ko^ IMAGE EVALUATION TEST TARGET (MT-3) 10 I I.I 11.25 1.4 11.6 '/3 <>% f >, ?v^ 07^ '/ J /S^ L<P ^ CIHM/ICMH Microfiche Series. CIHM/ICMH Collection de microfiches. Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions Institut Canadian de microreproductions historiques 1980 Technical Notes / Notes techniques The Institute has attempted to obtain the best original copy available for filming. Physical features of this copy which may alter any of the images in the reproduction are checked below. L'Institut a microfilm^ le mellleur exemplaire qu'il lui a 6t6 possible de se procurer. Certains d6fauts susceptibles de nuire d la quality de la reproduction sont not6s ci-dessous. D Coloured covers/ Couvertures de couleur D Coloured pages/ Pages de couleur D D Coloured maps/ Cartes g6ographiques en couleur Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ Pages ddcolordes, tachetdes ou piqu6es Tight binding (may cause shadows or distortion along interior margin)/ Reliure serrd (peut causer de I'ombre ou de la distortion le long de la marge intdrieure) D n Coloured plates/ Planches en couleur r~^ Show through/ Transparence Pages damaged/ Pages endommag6es D Additional comments/ Commentaires suppldmentaires Bibliographic Notes / Notes bibliographiques n Only edition available/ Seule Edition disponible Bound with other material/ Reli6 avec d'autres documents Cover title missing/ Le titre de couverture manque D D D Pagination incorrect/ Erreurs de pagination Pages missing/ Des pages manquent Maps missing/ Des cartes gdographiques manquent D Plates missing/ Des planches manquent n Additional commonts/ Commentaires suppldmentaires The images appearing here are the best quality possible considering the condition and legibility of the original copy and in keeping with the filming contract specifications. The last recorded frame on each microfiche shall contain the symbol —► (meaning CONTINUED"), or the symbol Y (meaning "END"), whichever applies. Les images suivantes ont 4t6 reproduites avec le plus grand soin, compte tenu de la condition et de la nettet6 de I'exemplalre film6, et en conformity avec les conditions du contrat de filmage. Un des symboles suivants apparaftra sur la der- nidre image de cheque microfiche, selon le cas: le symbols — ► signifie "A SUIVRE". ie symbole V signifie "FIN". The original copy was borrowed from, and filmed with, the Itind consent of the following institution: Library of the Public Archives of Canada Maps or plates too large to be entirely included in one exposure are filmed beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to right and top to bottom, as many frames as required. The following diagrams illustrate the method: L'exemplaire fiimd fut reproduit grdce d la g6n6rosit6 de I'dtablissement prdteur suivant : La bibiiothdque des Archives publiques du Canada Les cartes ou les planches trop grandes pour dtre reproduites en un seul clich6 sont film^es d partir de Tangle supdrieure gauche, de gauche i droite et de haut en bas, en prenant le nomore d'images n^cessaire. Le diagramme suivant illustre la m6thode : 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 6 HISTORY OF THE GENERAL PUBLIC HOSPITAL IN THE CITY OF SAINT JOHN, N. B. ^ BY WILLIAM BAYARD, M. D., Edin., Etc. May, 1896. X ^^i f^.;C PS m Offi(?eF| of the Institution, 1896. £/^i^ COMMISSIONERS. WILLIAM BAYAKI), Es.,, M. D, Edin, President. ROBERT W. CROOKSIIANK, Esq., Vice-President. M. W. Mahek, Esq. w. C. Rudman Allan, Esq. ThomasWalkeb, Esq., M.D., Edin. John McGoldbick, Esq. A. Chipman Smith, Esq. John Behryman, Esq., M.D., Edik. H. G. Aduy, M. D. I. OLIVE THOMAS, Secretary. W. R. ELLIS, Esq., M. D., Resident Physician and Superintendent. BERTHA B. CHESLEY, Matron. PHYSICIANS. Alban F. Emeby, Esq., M. D. Walter W. White, Esq., M. D. Murray M aclaben, Esq., M.D.,EniN. William Christie, Es^l, M. D. James Christie, Esq., M. D. T. D. W • lker, Esq., M. B., C. M., Edin. OCULISTS. M. F. Bruce, Esq., M. D. h. D. Fritz, Esq., M. D. CONSULTING PHYSICIANS. Thomas Walker, Esq., M. D., Edin. J. D. White, Esq., M. D. PATHOLOGIST. G. A. B. Addy', Esq., M. D. ^ OF THE General Public Hospital IN THE CITY OF SAINT JOHN. Prior to the year 1865 the City and County of Saint John, with a population of upwards of 30,000, possessed no hospital accommodation for the meclianic and the labourer suifering from disease or accident. The Poor House was his only refuge; and with laudable pride, he declineci to be classed as a pauper, preferring to be cared for at his humble home by friends; too often with the result tliat his little savings became exhausted, ultimately compelling him to accept that shelter which his pride induced him to ignore in the lirst instance. Indeed, there was no such hospital in the Province, and those living in the outlviui? districts — when requiring skilled medical and surgical assistance — became a burden upon their friends. This was not a proud position for the largest city in the Province, and one con- taining many persons of large wealth. Dr. W. Bayard's position, as physician in charge of the Poor House, and his connection with the Board of Health, taught him the imperative necessity for a hospital. He brought the subject before the community through the press, adducing various arguments in support of it; and having received promises by kind philanthropists for the sum of $10,000 for the purpose of erecting one, he felt sanguine that his scheme would be crowned by success. But when four of the most wealthy men in the city — one Hislovy of the General Public Hospital. tal of Saint eased no labourer )uso was leci to be I humble lis little him to ignore lospital itriets — ance — a proud Due con- e of the Health, 111. He jgh the it; and for the he felt success. y — one .1 of them the largest landowner — refused to assist, he aban- <loncd the idea of accomplishing his object by subscription, and concluded to carry out the project by imposing a tax upon the ratc-])aycrs. He felt Justitied in adopting this course because the burden would then fall proportionally upon oil, the rich man — who hud not the heart to give — would be compelled to furnish his proportion, while the man in the position to receive the most benetit JVom such an institution would contribute his mite. Accordingly, he employed the late George Blatch, Esq., tO frame a bill asking power from the Legislature to sell bonds for the sum of $50,000 to be appro[)riated towards the erection and the furnishing of the building. For the support, the bill asked that a tax of one dollar a year be placed upon the poll of every ratable male inhabitant of the City and County of St. John. All other expenses to fall upon the real and personal estate of the rate-payer. In other words, the real and persorud property holders were to furnish the building, pay the interest upon the money borrowed, their poll tax, and meet all extra demands ; while those most likely to use it were asked to pay one dollar per year towards its support — a small sum compared with the expected benetit to them. The word positive may properly be substituted for the word expected, for no reasoning mind can ignore the fact that positive benefit must accrue to those having the privilege of entree to such an institution. The idea of increased taxation alarmed those who did not, or would not, recognize the necessity for a hospital. They did not take into consideration the fact that its estab- lishment would necessarily lessen permanent pauperism, and thereby proportionally reduce the poor-rate. The bill met with the most determined opposition from the press. Many editors wrote most bitterly against the measure, appealing to prejudices, and attributing unworthy motives to its supporters. The Common Council — as a I 6 Ilislot'ij of the General Public Ifospital. body — was hostile to it, and HU|)[»orted its liostility by seiid- iiig u foimnitti'e of its inemiiors to Frodorietoii to prevent the ii}issui:;e of the bill. vVll this did not disoounige tlie lujiny believers in the riffhteousness of their cause. The bill was taken to Fred- ericton, and argned before the individual members of tlie Lei;islature, and with the able assistance of the Hon. John Robertson, Sir Leonard Tilley, K. J). Wilmot, John IT. Gray, Sir Albert Smith, aiul many others, it became law on tlie IHh day of April, ISOO. While the bill had passed, it did not grant all that was asked for. The Commissioners were given authority to sell bonds not to exceed ^28,()()0, and the poll-tax was reduced from one dollar to twenty-five cents. In view of the fact that the wages of the meclianic and the laborer has doubled since that period, while the expense of living has not increased, and the fact that their children are educated at the public expense, it was a mistake that the origiiud amount asked was not imposed upon them. • On the 3rd day of July, 1860, Hon. John Robertson, Dr. Wm. Bayard, Wm. II. Scovil, R. W. Crookshank, and John McLauchlin, Ksqs., were appointed Commissioners to carrv out the Act. On the loth day of August, 18()0, the first meeting of the Board was held, at which Hon. John Robertson was elected President; Dr. Wm. Bayard, Vice-President: and John Ansley, Secretary. In October of the same year tenders were asked for between two and three acres of ground in or near the city upon which to place the building. In December of the same 3'ear various tenders were con- sidered by the Board, and that of Joseph Fairweather was accepted, giving nearly three acres of land, with the absolute an' anconditional occupation of the roadways leading to it from Waterloo street and the City Road, for $9,650. Sub- sequently the land adjoining, and fronting on the City Road, History of the Geiwal Vublk llosjntal. 7 ANSIS piirt'lmwod t'roiii tlio estate of tlie lute Senator .loliu U(jl)crtHou for l!?2,0(IO, iiiuking in all the cost of the hind fn January, 1801, a seal was obtained for the Corpora- tion, and in July of the same year the late Mathevv Stead was enijtowered to nnike plans and specifications for the building, wiiich were adopted by the Board in December. The Commissioners finding that the $2H,(I0(» in hand woidd not complete the building, they asked power from the Legislature to sell bonds for ^20,000 more. Liberty was granted to borrow ^18,000, nud<ing in all $46,000, con- sequently they were eomi)elled to curtail the plans and build only the main building and the eastern wing. Subsequently the Province gave $8,000, and the estate of the late Kichard Sands $2,000 towards tiie under- taking. Tenders were jisked for the construction of the })ortion of the building named, with the understanding that it was to be completed early in i ear 1863. The tender of James (iuinton for $26, 3x. being the lowest, the con- tract was awarded to him. The excavations, drainage, heating apparatus, and plumbing, were not included in Quinton's contract. Those works added laro^elv to the e.vpenditure. ITl)on the removal of Senator John Robertson to Eng- land in 1868 he tendered his resignation as President of the Board of Commissioners. His loss was much felt, as he was an active, energetic, and influential member. Upon the resignation of Senator John Robertson in 1868, Dr. W. Bayard was appointed President of the Board, Wn.. H. A. Keans Vice-President, and R. W. Crookshank Treasurer. At the request of the Board, Dr. Bayard framed the by-laws of the institution, which were adopted in 1865. In June, 1865, the Hospital was opened for the reception 8 Histwy of the General Public Hospital. of patients, when the memhera of the medical staff were appointed, namely : LeBaron Botsfonl, M. D., Glas. ; Edwin Bayard, M. 1)., Ediii. ; T. W. Smith, M. D., Edin. ; J. T. Steeves, M. I)., New York ; G. E. S. Keator, M. D., New York; W. S. Harding, M. K. C. S., Eng. ; James Sinclair, M. D., House Surgeon ; Mrs. Mary Craig, Matron. The names of the Commissioners, Medical Staff, House Surgeons, Matrons, and Secretaries, who have heen con- nected with the institution since it was established, appear in the Appendix, together with other statistical information. In November, 1873, the Trustees of the Savings Bank in the City of St. John — with the consent of the Dominion Goverument — handed to the Commissioners of the Hospi- tal, for the support of that institution, the sum of |44,269.69, with the proviso that $42,000 of that sum " shall be invested in good and sufficient ]>ublic securities, bearing not less than six per cent, per annum, which interest shall he appropriated by them towards the support and maintenance of the Hos- pital." This was done, and the proceeds are in the Hospital box in the vault of the Bank of Nova Scotia, the President holding one key and the Treasurer the other. In the year 1872 an Act was passed by the Legislature authorizing the Commissioners of the Hospital to expend $6,000 in building a Hospital for Infectious Diseases upon the Hospital ground. The Board of Health having obtained tlie use of the old Military Hospital on the Barrack Ground for that purpose, the Act was not enforced until the year 1885, when the Common Council required the building to be removed from the locality upon which it stood. The Commissioners complying with the request, con- cluded to erect one as directed by the law. Two months History of the General Public Hospital. 9 staff were itf, House been coil- ed. appear brmation. ngs Bank Dominion he Ilospi- 44,269.69, e invested less than iropriated the Hos- Hospital President egislature o expend ises upon Df the old purpose, when the )ved from lest, con- 3 months after the work had been commenced, and when about $2,000 had been expended upon it, a cabal was inaugurated by Mayor Macgregor Grant, who, appealing to prt^judices, induced the various council boards to pass resolutions pro- testing against the undertaking. The CJommissioners were hounded to the bitter end b}' a memorial to the Legislature, having the Civic Seals attached to it. This misleading document was replete with false reasoning. Its author did not dare to place a copy of it in the hands of the Com- missioners before it was sent forward. Consequently the members of the Legislature were left in ignorance of the facts, and passed an Act placing the responsibility of the location of the Hospital upon the shoulders of the Com- missioners, thereby subjecting them to prosecution by an}' person holding land adjoining that selected as a site for it. The Legislature having previously declared that the "Hos- pital for Contagious Disease shall be placed on the ground of the General Public Hospital," no action can be taken against its location. Happily for the tax-payer, the Legis- tive Council did not ratify the Act, thereb}' saving to the community the $2,000 already spent, $3,000 or $4,000 tor land in some other locality, with the never-ending risk of prosecution. And now we have a Hospital for Contagious Diseases on the Hospital ground, always ready for the reception of suitable cases, in almost daily use, the cost of which was $6,000, and contrary to the declared opinion of our oppo- nents, the surrounding neighbourhood has not in any way been contaminated or prejudiced by it. A Nursing School was established in the year 1888, Dr. Bayard giving the opening address, and Commissioners Walker and Hetherington, together with the members of the medical staff, the lectures to the students upon the various subjects connected with their studies. The Commissioners feeling the disadvantage of requiring nurses to sleep and eat in the atmosphere of the sick, and 10 History of the General Public Hospital. having no available room in the institution to provide them with good atmospheric surroundings, and not having the means at their disposal to furnish such accommodation, they determined to appeal to philanthropists in aid of their object; also to assist them in carrying out a scheme for " District Nursing" in the city, a desideratum much needed. Knowing the ability and the untiring zeal of the wife of our Lieutenant Governor when engaged in a philanthropic object, and believing that if they could enlist her in their cause its success would be assured, consequently they ap- proached Lady Tilley, and nobly she responded. She, with the able assistance of verv manv ladies in this city, in the provincial towns, and many abroad, gave a building that will be a lasting monument of their good work, and illustrating their kind sympathy for a class who have embraced a calling with few attractions and many hardships, and when performing their various duties in a sick room faithfully and kindly, may be truly classed as " ministering angels," and who deserve all the fostering care that can be aiforded to them. Appreciating the value of this gift, the Commissioners read the following address to her : To Lady Tili-ey. Madam — The Commissioners of the General Public Hospital, in addition to the verbal thanks already extended to you by our President, desire to express to you more formally our appreciation of the great value to the Hospital, and to the community at large, of the Nurses' Home, recently presented to us by you. We would express to you our admiration of the zeal and untiring energy displayed by you, in bringing this charitable undertaking to such a successful completion, and we would, through you, thank all those who, under your leadership, have given so largely of both time and means to this noble enterprise. We sincerely pray that your ladyship's fondest anticipations may be more than fulfilled in the value of this delightful home to the hard-worked Hospital nurses, and that from this cheerful meeting place, there will go forth in I History of the General Public Hospital. 11 ovido thorn havino; the iiniodation, lid of their scheme for jcli needed, the wife of lilanthropic ler in their ly they ap- idies in this ad, gave a their good a class who and many duties in a ' cUxssed as iQ fostering iimissioners He Hospital, you by our appreciation lity at large, We would ring energy ng to such a nk all those nth time and y that your filled in the pital nurses, I go forth in years to come, a devoted band of Didrict Nurses, whose ministra- tions will prove a blessing to the place, and continue a lasting memorial to your efforts in behalf of the sick poor. M.ay you live long, and may your life be cheered by the refection of your good works. Signed by, W. Bayard, M. W. Maker, G. H. Clark, A. C. Smith, R. W. Crookshank, Thomas Walker, G. A. Hetherington, W. C. R. Allan. In all communities there are sick persons, who, for various reasons, cannot or will not obtain admission into hospitals, and wdio are too poor to employ skilled nurses. It is for such persons that District .Nurses are required. Dr. Bayard, in liis address to the nurses at the opening of the school in 1888, said: " They visit the houses of the indigent, or those wlio cannot aiford to pay for a nurse, wherever sickness exists, and attend to the various wants of the patient. I sincerely hope that from this Hospital, we may be able to afford a stafi' of nurses for that purpose. Only those who are daily brought in contact with the misery, accruing from the want of such nursing, can appreciate the necessit}' for it. Imagine a small child with hip disease and abscess, where ignorant handling would produce exquisite agony. The skilled nurse alone, knows how to move the small sulFerer so as not to jar the diseased limb. Another patient, bedridden and suft'ering from disease, requiring constant poulticing; the wife a helpless, nervous woman, with her room in confusion. In a few minutes the trained nurse has removed the crumbs from under him, replaced the cold, sloppy poultice with a warm tirm one, given him a warm cup of gruel, and made him comfortable. Or the sick young mother, in a dark and impure room, with a crying child at her side, too often drugged with ' sleepy stuff' to enable the mother to obtain the rest which nature demands. Here the nurse can teach the mother that infants ■■ 12 History of the General Public Hospital. thrive on light and air, not upon ' sleepy stuiF.' Each nurse could visit from ten to twelve such cases in a day, and return to the Hospital at night. " The road to the heart is oftener through the eye than the e;ir. I am quite sure if we could induce some of our kind friends, who are taking such an interest in this institution, to visit such cases as I have described, and see the misery that could bo relieved by such nursing, there would be no lack of lands for the support of it." There is accommodation in the Nurses' Home for six " district nurses,"' but the Commissioners have not authority to draw upon the funds of the Hospital to pay them. Con- secjuently an appeal has been made to the clergymen of the different denominations in the City, to establish a Hospital Sunday for that worthy object. The Commissioners propose to feed them in the Hospital, and they ask kind philan- thropists to furnish money to pay them. Dr. Thomas Walker is Treasurer of the Nurses' Fund, and will receive donations. The clergy of the Church of England in St. John have responded, giving one nurse, who has been on duty since December, 1894 — none of the others — but it is earnestly hoped that they may soon do so. The proposition is to divide the city into six districts, and detail a nurse for each district, whose duty shall be to seek out and aid those requiring her assistance; and when her district work will admit of it, she may obey the calls of those able to pay for the services of a trained nurse. Since the establishment of the Hospital up to the year 1883, the medical staif attended the sick gratuitously. At that time the work became so onerous, coupled with the difficulty of inducing experienced men to accept the situa- tion, the Commissioners felt justified in paying each member when employed $2 per day for one or more visits. The pay is nothing commensurate with the work, but it is as much as the funds of the institution can at present afford. i History of the General Public Hospital. 13 ■.' Each in a day, I eye than lie of our it in this 1, and see ng, there le for six authority m. Con- aen of the 1 Hospital rs propose d philan- ses' Fund, ;hurch of ne nurse, none of may soon districts, lall be to and when le calls of se. the year usly. At with the the situa- 1 member The pay as much i. Six physicians and surgeons, two oculists, two or more consultants, a dentist, and a house surgeon comprise the medical staff. Their duties have not been divided into medical and surgical, but it is hoped that in the near future this will be accomplished. They are educated men, who take large interest in their work, and ]>erfonn their various duties faithfully, scientifically and effectually, as is amply proved by their record of all the modern surgical operations. The}' are appointed annually, and it may be remarked that no capital operation is allowed to be performed — except under special emergency — without notification and consul- tation with the staff. In the year 1889 it was found that the accommodation for the sick was not sufficient for the demand upon it, conse- quently the Commissioners asked the Legislature to grant permission to sell bonds for the amount of $14,000 to com- plete and furnish the building by adding the western wing. This was done, and now we have a hospital with all modern conveniences, capable of receiving one hundred and ten patients, and affording each patient 1,800 cubic feet of air space. Also a " Hospital for Contagious Diseases," capable of receiving twenty-five patients, with a like air space. Therefore, we may claim that the City of Saint John has ample hospital accommodation for its present requirements, and at a smaller cost than that of anv other town with the same population. The yearly expenditure for the Hospital in Halifax, with few more patients, — sailon.- included — is between $38,000 and $39,000, and the one in Portland, Maine, with nearly the same number of patients, is about $34,000, while the yearly expenditure upon this institution is under $20,000. When deducting the provincial grant — the Savings Bank Bequest Fund — and the money received from pay patients, — sailors included — the rate-payer is not burdened to the extent of more than $12,000 yearly for this good work, and he may credit the institution with a reduction 14 History of the General Public Hospital. in his poor-rate. But he pays more than his share. For the provincial grant — as will be seen In* referring to the yearly reports — does not pay more than half the outlay for the patients from the different counties in the Province and the way-farers, in or passing through tlie city. The Commissioners have repeatedly brought this fact under the notice of the Government, contending that the gran^ from the Province should be largely increased. They were met by the contention that the " Savings Bank Bequest Fund'" was a gift from the Province. '■'•This is fallacious,'" for, after much personal persuasion, and through the able assistance of Judge Weldon and Canon Scovil, the money was obtained for the Hospital, as appears by the following correspondence : Saint John, September 1st, 1873. To the Chairman of Commissioners of the Public Hospital. Sir, — I am directed to enclose to you a copy of the resolution passed by the Trustees of the St. John Savings Bank, and to request the action of your Board in reference thereto at your earliest convenience. I am sir, yours respectfully, John Boyd. Moved by Rev. Canon Scovil, and seconded by Mr. Justice Weldon : Whereas, By the IGth Section of an Act, Chap. 6 of 34 Victoria, passed by the Dominion Parliament, April 14, 1871, the St. John Savings Bank, with its property, assets and liabilities, were trans- ferred to the Dominion of Canada, subject to a proper allowance for any surplus of such property in the settlement of account be- tween the Dominion and the Bank ; And whereas, On the adjustment of said account, the sura of forty-two thousand and seventy-nine dollars has been placed in the Bank of New Brunswick to the credit of the Trustees of the St. John Savings Bank, with the accumulated interest now amount- ing to the sum of forty-four thousand one hundred and eighty-two dollars and ninety-five cents ($44,132.95), to be disposed of as the History of the General Public Hospital. 16 hare. For iiu' to the ! outlay for ovince and it this fact \g that the ^ed. They Ilk Bequest fallacious,^' fh the able the money e following 1st, 1873. il. he resolution ink, and to eto at your HN Boyd. Mr. Justice 34 Victoria, ;he St. John were trans- er allowance account be- the sura of )laced in the stees of the low araount- i eighty-two sed of as the said Trustees, with the approbation of the Dominion Government, may think fit ; Therefore resolved, That the above sum of $44,182.95, to 16th of October, 1873, ^.ith any further interest till paid, be given, by tiiid with the consent of the Government, to the Commissioners of the General Hospital in the City of St. John, to be by them invested in good and sufficie/:t public securities hearing not less than six per cent, per annum, which interest alone shall be appropriated by them towards the support and maintenance of said Hospital, to enable the Commissioners to carry on their work mure efficiently ; Provided nevertheless, That the said Commissioners do first pay out of the said money, the sum of six hundred dollars per annum, in four equal qur^rterly payments, to the widow of Daniel Jordan, Esq., late cashier of the St. John Savings Bank, during the term of her natural life, the same to be paid to her from the time of Mr. Jordan's death. Conse(j[ueiitly forty-two thousand dollars of the above named sum was invested in public securities. It is therefore idle to claim that the money was a gift from this Province. If the Provincial grant is not increased, the Commission- ers will be driven to close the doors of the Hospital against the sick from the out counties. For it is obviously unfair that the people of this city and county should be burdened with the pa*uper sick of the Province. The Victoria General Hospital in Halifax, ^ova Scotia, is a provincial institution — owned, managed and supported bv the Provincial Government — yet it receives not double the number of patients from the out counties that this one does, the figures being for the Victoria 475 ; for this one 819. The foregoing should afford food for the considera- tion of our legislators. The Commissioners have done all in their power — the matter must now rest with the citizens. In consequence of complaints against the management of the Marine Hospital in this city, the Minister of Marine requested the Commissioners to receive the sick sailors arriving in this port into the Hospital, the Dominion Gov- 16 Hisf.ory of the General Public Hospital. ermnenf to pay >//??<7// cods per du}' for each ri)an, and all l)nrial exj)oiisos. This wns ii^sented to in February, 1893, giving to the Hospital in future about two hundred addi- tional patients yearly, for which rhe institiition will receive between ,^3,000 and $4,000 per annum. An " ambulance," for the purpose of conveying persons seriously injured, seriously ill, or laboring under contagious diseases, to the institution, is much required. The sufferers are compelled to get there as best they can, and these infected with contagious diseases are too often taken to the Infectious Hospital in coaches, which coaches are used im- mediately after, without disinfection of any kind. In May, 1894, D?\ Bayard brought this subject to the notice of the Mayor in the following letter: Gkorge Rohertson, Esq., Mayor of the City of Saint John. Mv Dear Sir — Allow me to bring to your notice, and to the body over which you preside, the fact that an ambulance is sadly recpiired in this city. There is no mode by which an individual having received such an injury as to make it imperative that he should be conveyed in a horizontal posture, or one so ill as to demand the same care, can be conveyed to his home, or to the Hospital. Such a want should not exist in a town the size of St. John. As an illustration, I may say to you that a short time since a gentleman fell down a stair-way, and received such an injury that to attempt to place him in a coach would have probably produced instant death. He was obliged to lie where he fell for an hour and a half before he could be moved to the Hospital, and then, at the risk of his life, on a rough express wagon. I have given Messrs. Price <fe Shaw plans of the most approved kind at present in use in London. Enclosed is their estimate for the cost — $885. It will be so constructed that it can carry con- tagious diseases, and can be thoroughly purified in half an hour, and there will be no risk of contagion to the driver. It will not require to be often used, and could be kept in the city stable, and a horse and driver furaished from there at little History of the Genei'cl Public JTo8j,>fal. 17 II, and all ary, 1893, Ired a(l<li- ill receive ig persons lontagious e sufferers xnd these ken to the 3 used im- ect to the , and to the nee is sadly individual ive that he 30 ill as to or to the size of St. ime since a injury that y produced in hour and then, at the st approved jstimate for carry con- ,lf an hour, kept in the ere at little cost ; whercaf, if the Con)iiiissioncrs of the Hospital furnisihed one, it would cost the city little short of ^1,000 a year, inasnuich as a horse and man must al\va}s be on hand with little to do. I have the honor to be. Yours very truly, W. Bayard. Dr. Bavard having received no answer to the above note, he cannot say what action has or will be taken upon it. The history of an institution is worthless if not full and true in every particular. I now approach the unpleasant part of my subject, and have to record the first scandal against ihe nos[>ital since its establishment. On the 27th February, 1C89, a num with a diseased eye was sent in, after the visiting hour of the oculist, by a member of the staff, who had been in attendance upon him for eiijht or ten days, assisted bv an oculist. Ilis disease was ulceration of the cornea, with pus in the anterior chamber (hypopyon). The day after admission the ulcer penetrated the abscess, and the matter was discharged. The next day lie left the Hospital, having been there about fifty hours, when he again went under the treatment of those who placed him there, and ultimately lost his eye. About a year after this he prosecuted the Commissioners, claiming that he h)st his eye in consequence of neglect. When the case came into court, the chief witnesses against the Commissioners were their paid employ^, Dr. Daniel, and a disappointed aspirant to the situation of oculist, Dr. Crawford. The trial resulted in a verdict for the plaintift' — damages, $500; costs, $500. While it is the duty of the oculist to visit his patients every other day, or oftener if necessary, he did not see this man as he should have done. The house surgeon was away on leave, and a friend acting in his place, which may have accounted for, though not excused, the neglect. But had Dr. Daniel dis- played the same zeal for his patient that he did at the trial, or the ordinary zeal that a medical man -attached to a 18 Histori/ of the General Piihlic Jfnsjutal. hosjtitrtl should (lisi»lu> towurdn it, he would have hccii the ocMiliftt, aud Hoc'ured hi.s 'ttt'udaiu'o u[)ou his [taticnt. Had ho doue 80, his patient ertaiuly would have reeeivod the l)eiietit of the treatmei lie uri^ed at the trial. IFe v/ould have prevented the slander upon an institution of which he was a paid meniher, and he would have saved the pocket of the tax-payer to the extent of $1,000. And it may he asked why he, or tlie oculist with him, did not perform the simple operation of opening; the ahseess hefore they sent the man to the Hospital ? The Commissioners claim that the disease in the man's eye was so far advanced when lie came to the Hospital that an operation would have hcen of no avail ; that to afford a prospect of success it should have heen done days hefore. They claim that it is iwprecedentcd to hold the governing hody of a hospital liahle for the malpractice or laches of a member of the medical staff. They can find no such case on record. They claim that the result of this trial has done irrepar- able injury to the institution, inasmuch Jis it has paved the way to litigation and prosecution, which no amount of vigilance and care on their part can prevent. They employ the best men they can obtain, and make rigid rules and regulations governing their conduct, but cannot alwjiys be at hand to see them enforced. Indeed it has already yielded fruit, for an action is now pending in the Supreme Court against the Commissioners at the instance of a woman who claims that she was discharged before she was well. A pauper comes to our door; we admit him, feed and care fur him, and wdien recovered we tell him to go. He likes his quarters, and says no. We discharge him, and as a return for what we have done he prosecutes us. This is small encouragement for the philanthropist. But it will continue ad infinitum unless such claimants are compelled by legislative enactment to furnish security for the costs. They have nothing to lose, and consequently embark into a HlMory of the General Public Ilospiial. 19 1 Hccn the nt. Usui eivod the lie would which ho [toekct of { be asked ;he simple [ the man the man's spital that to art'ord a 5 before, governing aches of a such case •ne irrepar- paved the imount of ley employ rules and always be idy yielded erne Court oman wlu) well. A I and care He likes , and as a ii. This is ^ut it will compelled the costs, jark into a 4 Hpeculative a'.'ti>>n. It will bo claimed that the interest of the poor man should be guarded. True; so should that of the giver. We have to record scandal No. 2. In July, 1H08 a statement ap|>eared in one of the newspapers, that Com- missioner Clark iiad taken samples of various . nds, and medicines from tiie Hosijit'il. The statement was of such a character :is to dennmd immediate investigation, which was made before a full Board. The acknowledgments of Mr. Clark, coupled with the evidence, made \i api)arent that he had taken samples. "". bile the amount taken was trivial, and not in the nature of stealing, still the mend)ers of the Board reluctantly came to the unanimous conclusion, that his usefulness as a com- missioner was destroyed, inasmuch as he could not prevent the employes of the Institution from doing the same thing, having been guilty himself. Consequently a resolution was passed, urgently requesting him to resign. He declined to do so, leaving no alternative but to place the resolution and evidence into the hands of the Municipal Council, as the appointing body. This was done, and the following is the answer received : Saint John, October 5th, 1893. Dear Sru, — With reference to your letter to the Warden, of date 29th August last, enclosing evidence taken before the Com- missioners of the General Public Hospital, in an investigation held by them, and their resolution thereon, requesting Mr. G. H. Clark, a commissioner of the Hospital, to resign. I beg to inform you that the same was laid before the October meeting of the Council of the Municipality, when a resolution was passed to refer the matter to a committee of the Council, " to investigate the same, and all matters connected with the Hospital and its management, and report to the Council." The committee consists of the Mayor, and Councillors Law, J. A. Chesley, O'Brien, Baxter, McLeod and Irvine. I am, dear sir, your obedient servant, W. Bayard, M. D., H. W. Frith, Secretary. President Hospital Board of Commissioners. 90 History of the General Public Hospital. The reHolutioii in a» extraonliimry owa to Huy the leant of it. A Board, after an impartuil iiiveHtiifatioii, finds one of itft mend)ers ^ujuilty of eonunittin^ a wronif, he its re<jueHtt'd to renign, he deelineH, the resolution and evidence forwarded to the parties appointing liini ; the anwer the Board re- ceives, is the a[)pointment of a (joniinitteo with a rovinjL^ eoniniission, "lo investigate all matters conncctal with the Hos- pital and its matuHjement." No charge was niade against the Board, none could be formulated. Had the Council declared that we had dealt harshly with Mr. Clark, or that the evi- dence did not justify the resolution, we must iiave bowed to that decision. Or had they decided the Clark matter, and then demanded the investigation, we should have had no cause of complaint, for we have always courted the fullest [(ublicity for our acts. But when they ^msed the resolu- tion upon the Clark matter, they did not treat the Com- missioners with the confidence that men in their position deserved. The .nembers of the committee claimed that a want of confidence was not intended — that may be so — but acts speak stronger than words, and no other construction can be put upon the act. And it may be asked, does not this act of the Council create an inducement for a Board to condone or cover tiu act of an erring member, rather than subject themselves to the treatment we have received ? Several meetings of the investigating committee were held at the Hospital. Every possible facility was afforded. Nothing could be found for the hidden hand to disapprove of, except that some of the Commissioners had suspected Mr. Clark, and did not place their suspicions before the Board. It did not enter their minds that it is an invidious act to make a charge against a brother member, the ground should be sure before it is made; and recent experience would not encourage a man in that procedure, even with the best proof at hand. We cannot help feeling that the hidden hand placed the investigating committee in an unenviable position when it History of the Ot,.jral Public Ifospitaf. 21 the loawt iiids one tHjucHted (rwiirdcd ►oard ro- ll roving ( (hf Ifos- uiiiHt the (lechired the evi- L)owed to tter, and ! had no le fullest resolu- lie Com- position }d that a so — but 3truction does not Board to her than ed? tee were itforded. ^approve uspected fore the nvldious ) ground perience 'en with iced the when it inihiced that body to call for the opinions of the niedieal men in the city regardini»: the management of the Hospital, none of whom were present at the investigation. Tt was apparent that the large majority di<l not approve of the call, for i»nt three out of the forty appeared at the meeting. 'I'he three ventilated their oitinions; two did not display their usual judgment. The vaporings of the other can be ac- counted for from the fact that he had been on the staff, and was left off for cause. That but three out of tiie fortv could be found to speak dis[»aragingly of the institution is largely in its favor. At this stage of the [)roceeding, Dr. Bayard placed his resignation as Commissioner in the b uids of Warden Mc- Lauelilan. That gentleman wrote him a kind letter rerpiest- ing its withdrawal. Below is the Doctor's answer, declining to do so : St. John, January 1, 1894. Dear Mr. McLauchlan — Nothing would give me greater pleasure than to grant a request coming from you, pjirticularly when it is couched in such kind and flattering terms as those conveyed in your note. When I placed my resignation as Hospital Commissioner in your hands, I felt it prudent to do so without note or comment. Your kind request makes it incumbent upon me to give you my reasons for so doing. When the resolution passed the County Council appointing a committee with a roving commission " to inquire into all matters regarding the management of the Hospital," I determined to resign ray position, but delayed doing so in order that I might assist my fellow-commissioners in affording every possible facility for investi- gation to the committee. That investigation, I believe, has been concluded, and I am now in a position to carry out my original intention. I came to this conclusion because I considered the act of the County Council a declaration of '* want of confidence in the Board over which I have the honor to preside." It has been claimed that it was not so intended by the Council. It may not have been 22 History of the Getifrnf Public Hospital. intended, but the fact remains : the investigation was ordered ; such an order necessarily carries suspicion with it. What was the suspicion? No cliarge was made; none couhl be formuhitcd by the committee. Then it may be asked, was it riglit or just that a body of gentlemen, performing a gratuitous work for the benefit of suft'ering humanity, should, without any apparent reason, l)e sub- ject to hostile criticism by the press — one writer going so far as to class them as freebooters and thieves — or that they should be com- pelled to defend their acts against irresponsible and disappointed medical men ? It is hard to trace the hidden hand moving in this matter. I am unwilling to believe that the action of the Hospital Board in the Clark matter is the cause. Yet, when looking for one, I can- not find another. If sucl. is the case, a dangerous principle has been established, inasmuch as it holds out an inducen)ent for a Board to condone or cover the act of an erring member. Had the Council passed a resolution that we had dealt harshly with Mr. Clark, or that the evidence did not justify our conclusion, we should have bowed to that decision. The acts of Mr. Clark were right, or they were wrong. After due consideration we came to the painful conclusion that they were wrong, and we feel that our deci- sion hii.s received scant consideration at the hands of the Council. 1 have personally requested njy brother Commissioners not to follow my example, for by so doing I believe the instituticm will be seriously injured. I do not say that honest men could not be obtained to fill their places ; but I do say that none could be ob- tained who know the various duties so well, or who have the welfare of the institution more at heart. It may be claimed that if the committee report favorably of the Commissioners, no harm is done. Not so ; we have been i»i the ])illory, and must necessarily come out swiled ; not in the eyes of those who know us, but in the eyes of those abroad who do not know us. I wish it to be understood that I have no fault to find with the investigating committee, the members of which treated us with the utmost courtesy. I have seen the Hospital rise from nothing to its present state of usefulness. I have taken more than common interest in it. I leave it with regret, not ia auger. I leave it as a matter of self- History of the General Public Hospital. 23 I ordered ; at was the ulatcd by just that a ! benefit of n, be sub- o far as to Id be com- lappointed matter. I Board in )ne, I can- nciple has lent for a Had the with Mr. lusion, we Jhirk were ame to the t our J'^ci- Council. ers not to Lution will uld not be II Id be ob- ;he welfare vorably of )oen in the he eyes of ho do not cl with the d Ma with Bsent state it in it. I ter of self- respect. And, sir, after the pcnis^al of my reason^*, I believe you will agree with me that 1 have just cause for so doing. I have the honor to remain, Yours very sincerely, W. Bayard. C. McLanchlan, Esq., Warden County Council. The following is the report of the oomiiiittee : To the Warden and Council of the Municipality of the City and County of St, John. The special committee of Council, appointed in October last under the following resolution, viz. : That the communication and evidence sent up to this Council, by the Commissioneis of the General Public Hospital, respecting certain charges made against Commissioner George H. Clark, " be referred to a committee of seven for investigation, together with all matters connected with the Hospital and its management," such committee to report thereon, beg now to report as follows : The committee have held several meetings, at three of which ^he President and other members of the Hospital Board of Com- missi(>iiers were present, and at two of which Mr. Clark was present. They have heard all the evidence produced before them, and the statements of Mr. Clark hin)self; several of the Commissioners, Including the President, have been heard, and at the last meeting of the committee ojjportunity was given for the attendance of medi- cal men not on the staff of the Hospital or connected therewith, when they were ikvored with the views of several physicians as to the general tManage;<ient of the Hosp'.tal, and the committee having also had fuii consideration of all matters referred to them, arrived at the following conclusions: First. They agree with the resolution of the Commissioners that . while Mr. Clark, in the matters charged against him, acted with no idea or intention of wrong-doing, his usefulness uS a commissioner is destroyed. The committee regret that Mr. Clark did not, as requested by the Board of Commissioners, tender his resignation, but he has not seen fit to do so, the committee feel compelled to reconmiend that the Council remove him from office. 24 History of the General Public Hospital. Second, It appeared in evidence during the investigation of the committee, that certain of the commissioners had for several years been acquainted with some of the acts now charged against Mr. Clark, and the committee cannot but regret that these acts were not at the time brought before the Commissioners of the Hospital for action. [Third. This section has not been adopted, having been ordered to lie on the table.] Fourth. In view of the large number of non-paying patients treated in tLe Hospital who come from all parts cf the Province yutside of this city and county, the committee are strongly of ojiinion that the aii'uiai grunt from the Government should be increased, an-l they r 3commend that the Council should join with the Commissioners in a renewed application to the Government to increase the same. Fifth. The committee submit here.vith a record '^^ +hcir pro- ceedings, and of the evidence taken before them, as jlished in the columns of The Sun. Sixth. In conclusion the committee beg to say that, during this investigation, and the visits of the committee to the Hospital in connection therewith, they have had the hearty co-operation of the President and all the Commissioners ; have been readily and frankly afforded full information upon all matters of inquiry, and given every opportunity to examine for themselves the Hospital buildings, the officials employed, and the patients under treatment. The committee recommend that a copy of this report be for- warded to the Commissioners. Respectfully submitted. Signed by Thomas W. Peters, J. McLeod, John Irvine, John B. M. Baxter, H. W. Frith, Secretary. A. L. Law, John A. Chesley, K. O'Brien. St. John, January 16, 1894. On the 16th of January, 1894, G. R. Vincent, Esq.,* oftered the following resolution regarding Dr. Bayard's resignation : Whereas, Wra. Bayard, Esq., M. D., was in July, 1860, ap- pointed a Commissioner of the General Public Hospital, and was History of the General Public Hospital. 26 Ltion of the veral years igainst Mr. e acts were le Hospital ien ordered iig patients le Province strongly of should be d join with ernment to ♦heir pro- jiished in during this Hospital in ltion of the md frankly and given buildings, »ort be for- ER, ecretary. Bnt, Esq.,' Bayard's 1860, ap- I, and was immediately thereafter elected chairman of the commission of the said Hospital, the onerous duties of which he has faithfully and honestly discharged, to the entire satisfaction of this Council, and the public at largo ; And whereas. This Council recognizes and fully appreciates the successful efforts of Dr. Bayard on behalf of the institution, and his deep devotion to its interests, for which he has labored for more than a third of a century, and which, under his management, has been gradually enlarged and fully equipped, until it ban attained its present magnificent proportions and usefulness, standing as it does to-day, a nionument to the indomitable energy of Dr. Bayard, and a credit to the City and County of St. John ; And whereas, During all these years of faithful and successful management, and the accomplishment of so much under most try- ing circi'.P'stances, this Council has learned to look upon Dr. Bayard as the father of the institution ; And ivhereas. This Council desires to express regret, that any misunderstanding resulted from the passage of a resolution, at the last meeting of the Board, relating to Hospital matters, and to as- sure Pr. Bayard that no reflection was intended to be cast on him ; but on the contrary, the Council always had and still has, the utmost confidence in his honesty, integrity and ability, to discharge the duties of commissioner and chairman, which he has so long discharged at great personal sacrifice, and without fee or reward. Therefore resolved, That this Council do not now accept Dr. Bayard's resignation as such Conmiissioner, but earnestly request him to withdraw the same, and that a copy of this resolution be fowarded by the secretary to him under the corporate seal. This resolution did not please the hidden hand, conse- quently Dr. Bayard received the following : At a meeting of the Council of the Municipality of the City and County of Saint John, held at the Court House, in the City of Saint John, on Tuesday, 16th January, A. D. 1894 — Read a letter from Dr. William Bayard to the Warden, request- ing him to place Dr. Bayard's resignation as member of the Board of Hospital Commissioners before the County Council ; " Wheretcpon resolved, That this Council do not now accepjt Dr. Bayard's resignation as such Commissioner, but earnestly request 26 History of the General Public Hospital. him to withdraw the same, and that a copy of this resolution be forwarded to him by the secretary under the corporate seal." True extract from the minutes. In testimony where jf I have hereunto set the seal of the said Municipality this 17th day of January, A. D. 1894. [Seal] (Signed) H. W. Frith, Secretary. This resolution is in keeping with many that have pre- ceded it from the municipal authorities of the day since the commencement of Dr. Bayard's efforts to establish a hospital in this city. The members of the Hospital Board liave occasionally found themselves compelled to differ from the civic authorities upon points connected with the manage- ment of the institution. This was done under the firm conviction that they were acting for the best interest of all concerned, not with the wish or intention of ignoring public opinion. ])r. Bayard asks neither praise nor thanks for anvthing he has done ; but when kind words are offered, and refused, it displays the existing feeling towards him by the majority of the Council. To Mr. Vincent, and those who supported him in the kind expressions offered, he owes a debt of gratitude; to those who refused them, he leaves to the enjoyment of their triumph. As a[)pears by the following letter to Warden McLauchlan from Dr. Bayard, that he has withdrawn his resignation, thereby sulvjccting himself to be made use of a little longer. But it is evident from its wording, that the withdrawal was in consequence of the expressed wish — by resolutions — of his l)rother commissioners and the members of the medical staff: Charles McLauchlan, Esq., Warden of the County Council. Dear Sir — I have the honor to acknowledge the receipt of a resolution passed by the County Council declining to accept my resignation as a member of the Hospital Board of Commissioners, and " urgently requesting me to withdraw the same." ssMMt?--" imrvm- ■.■f^ f % History of the General Public Hospital. 27 solution be eal." •f jf I have ;y this 17th :ITH, secretary. have pre- y since the a hospital oard have r from the e manage- r the lirm erest of all ring public thanks for ire offered, I'd 8 him by and those id, he owes he leaves cLauchlan esignation, ttle longer, rlrawal was ntions — of he medical ■% receipt of a accept my mmissioners, In answer, I have to say that unanimous resolutions having been passed by the Board of Commissioners and tlie members of the medical staff of the institution, strongly urging me to retain my position at the Board, induce me to obey the expressed wish of the Municipal Council, I consequently withdraw the same. I have the honor to be. Yours truly, W. Bayard. St. John, xMarch 26, 1894. It appears that there is no rest for the Hospital Com- missioners, for, on the 25th of May, 1894, the following communication was received from the County Secretary : [Memorandum.] The following is a true copy of Section 3 of the Report of the Special Committee of the Council of the Municipality appointed in October last under the following resolution : "That the communication and evidence sent up to this Council, by the Commissioners of the General Public Hospital, respecting certain charges made against Commissioner George H. Clark, 'be referred to a committee of seven for investigation, together with all matters connected with the Hospital and its management,' such committee to report thereon." Section 3. While as the result of inquiry into the general man- agement of the Hospital, the committee are satisfied that the affairs of the Hospital are carefully conducted, and that a vast deal of unremunerated time and labor are bestowed upon them by the President and all the Commissioners, the committee would recom- mend the following changes as improvements on the present system, that is to say : That paying patients shall be allowed to have the attenaar.c*^ in the Hospital of their own physicians ; and That the purchasing of supplies, ti duty of which is now thrown on a single commissioner during the month which he takes in rotation with his fellow-commissioners, should be made the busi- ness of some responsible official paid by the institution. The report containing the above section was submitted to the Council at a meeting held on the 16th day of January last past, ■;i#iW/*'J 28 History of the General Puhfio Ilosiyital. and the whole of said report was adopted except the third section, which was by resolution laid on the table. That at a meeting of the said Council, held on the 8th day of May instant, the said section was taken ofi'the table and considered, and the following resolution passed : Resolved, That so much of the report as relates to the attend- ance of physicians on their private patients be adopted, and that the Commissioners be recommended to intrust the purchased sup- plies to an official, if it can be done without increasing the expenses of the institution. (. ^ Vincent, [Seal] County Secretary. St. John, N. B., May 25th, A. D. 1894. Govereiied by the by-laws of the Hospital, a large majority of the articles required for the institution are obtained by tender; others cannot be so obtained — the Commissioner of the month, with the sanction of the Board, purchases them, but he cannot individually spend more than $20 during his month, without such sanction given before or at the next board meeting. The members of the Muni- cipal Council are well aware of these facts. Then it may he asked, why the above resolution was passed ? with its extraordinary proviso : " If it can be done without increas- ing the expenses of the institution." Is it done to cast suspicion upon the integrity of the Commissioners ? For I am unwilling to believe that any member expects that a man can be found who will do this work for nothing ; or if found, will not pay himself. Personally I have no interest in the matter, never having purchased ten cents worth of provisions for the institution, but I assume equal responsi- bility. The Commissioners do not covet the work, but as they are responsible, they prefer to trust those they know, rather than one they do not know, hence the following answer : At a meeting of the Commissioners, January 11, 1895 — Resolved, That the Commissioners cannot recommend any change in the purchase of supplies for the Hospital, as they do not consider 1 Hisiwy of the General Public Hospital, 29 hird section, e 8th day of [1 considered, 3 the attcnd- ;ed, and that rehased sup- the expenses CENT, ty Secretary. large 111, a titution are tained — the r the Board, d more than i;iven before [f the Muni- hien it may d? with its out increas- oiie to cast ers ? For I )ects that a hing ; or if no interest its worth of al responsi- vork, but as they know, le following i95 — id any change not consider I I it would be in the interest of the Hospital, and could not be done without a very considerable extra expense. At the same meeting, the question of allowing paying patients to have the attendance in the Hospital of their own physicians was discussed, when the following resolution was passed : That the Commissioners of the General Public Hospital cannot recommend that any change be made in the present medical man- agement of the Hospital, as we do not believe it would be conducive to the best interest of the institution, and would, we believe, add very largely to the cost of management. This did not please the hidden hand, as appears by the following resolution : At a meeting of the Council of the City and County of St. John, held at the Court House, in the City of St. John, on Tuesday, the 15th day of January, A. D. 1895, the following resolution was " Whereas, This Municipal Council having heard read the com- munication from the Commissioners of the Public Hospital, in which they decline to accede to the request of this Council that private paying patients should have the privilege of being attended by their own physicians whether on the staff of the Hospital or not ; "Inhere/ore resolved, That the Commissioners of the General Public Hospital be requested to try the experiment, and that a committee of this Council be appointed to confer with the Commis- sioners on the subject." The Warden appoints the following councillors on such com- mittee : McRobbie, Catherwood, Daniel, Christie, Baxter, Lee and Dunn. I hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and correct extract from the minutes of the Council of the Municipality of the City and County of St. John, embodying the resolution in regard to ^ Hospital matters, passed at the meeting of said Council on the fifteenth day of January, 1895. (Signed) Geo. R. Vincent, Secretary. H 30 Hhtory of ihe General Public Hospital. Acceding to the rc(|Ut'8t, tlie Coinniissionors met the committee named, sit the ofKce of the Municipulity, on the 2l8t of March instant, and, after a prolonged discussion, the matter was left as it stood hefore. At a meeting of the Hospital Commissioners, on the 3rd of May, 1895, tiie following resolution was passed : The Commissioners having, on the 21st of March, met with a committee of the Municipal Council for the purpose of further considering a request of the said Council, that pay patients at the Hospital be allowed, if required, to have the service of their own physicians outside of the Hospital staff, and having heard the arguments of the connnittee of the Council regarding the matter, are still of the opinion that it would not be in the general interest of the Hospital to make any change in this department, and that the secretary write to the secretary of the municipality to this effect." The idea of making the Hospital a hoarding-house for the patients of every doctor ii> the city ha., been pursued with a determination worthy of a better cause. In April last, at the instance of Dr. Berryman, a petition urging this measure — signed by half of the medical men in the city — was placed before the Board of Commissioners, but the arguments in support of it were not such as to induce them to rescind their former decision. Our answer is, that room does not exist in the institution for such patients without excluding the poor, for whom alone the Hospital was established. It is incidental to all hospitals to have a few rooms for accident or emergency, but it never was contemplated that they should be open to all. It is idle to contend that the wealthy should be admit- ted because they contribute to its support. They contribute to the support of many institutions, but I have not heard of their demanding admission to anv. Xo ! this movement is for the benefit of the petitioners, who, having failed to establish a private hospital for their patients, come forward and ask the rate-payer to furnish one for them. Appreciat- ing their wish to obtain rooms, skilled nursing, continued ■9, I Hintortj of the General Public Hospital. 31 .TH mot the ilitv, on the discussion, «, on the 3rd ed : h, met with a 86 of further )atient8 at the of their own ig heard the g the matter, nieral intereBt lent, and that to this effect." iig-house for een pursued ,n, a petition nedical men nmissioners, such as to e institution for whom iental to all emergency, be open to d be admit- y contribute not heard of novement is ig failed to )me forward Appreciat- ^, continued medical and surgical supervision, medical and surgical in- struments, api»liances, etc., I feel, as a Commissioner dis- bursing pul)lic money, I have not the right to grant ^"ich privileges at tlie expense of the rate-payer. We have been asked to try the experiment ; we answer, we have no right to try experiments with the public funds. The word exi)eriment implies a risk. If we lose — of which vfe have little doubt — what then? Again, it may be asked, have the petitioners take : into consideration the risk of placing their patients — when it can be avoided — in the atmosphere of a hospital that has been in constant occupation for thirty years. They should know, that with all the care possible, the air of such hos- pital cannot be made so pure as a private house with proper sanitary surroundings that has not been made a receptacle for the sick; the safety of their patients should be their first consideration. It is more than probable that the other half of the profession who refused to sign the petition, had this risk in their minds. It has been claimed, that by granting this petition, it would prevent persons from going abroad to seek surgical f aid ; daily experience proves such a claim to be fallacious. Hospitals are institutions that should commend them- selves to the sympathy of all classes. To the poor, for whom alone they are established, and to the rich, who see the result of their good work — a form of charity, to which, every individual should be proud and glad to contribute his mite. For I hold, that no man — whatever his prejudices may be — can pass through the wards of one, without being impressed with the care and comfort extended towards each and every sufferer who receives the daily, and I may say the hourly attention of the experienced physician, with the kind and gentle aid of the skilled nurse. And as the road to the heart is oftener through the eye than the ear, we solicit the visits of all to this one. 32 History of the General Vublk Hosjiital, While tlie large majority accept thcKC giftH with grati- tude, there is another class who deinand this charity as a right, and would not be satisfied it' "Angel Gabriel" aj)- peared and ininistered to their wants. This class is largely composed of persons wlio, having deceived the (/oniniis- sioners regarding their poverty, occupy the beds ot'the poor at the expense of the rate-itayer. Again, the "out-door departments" of all hospitals are widly abused. Tt is claimed that in London nearly 2,000,000 visits are paid yearly to the various hosi>itals by ajtjOicants for advice and medicine, one-half of whom are not fit sub- jects for such charity, being well able to pay for that which they obtain. This abuse has so alarmingly reduced the voluntary contributions to those institutions that the autho- rities are making strong efforts to remedy the evil. This evil does not exist in the same proportion in St. John, bu: W3 are approaching it. The Commissioners find it difficult io discriminate, and the waiting-room at the Hos- pital is often occupied by persons who would feel insulted if classed as paupers, and who would not dare to ask such charity from any other source. I do not wish to convey the impression that such charity should not be afforded. Better to give to two undeserving, than to withhold from one who really deserves it. It would fill pages to name each individual who has contributed valuable articles for the comfort of the sick and afflicted in this institution; also, the lady visitors who, by their presence and kind sympathy, have done so much to- wards relieving the misery of the sick bed. To one and all we here tender our sincere thanks. (a/. 'ts with grati- I charity as a Gabriel" ap- lass i.s largely the C/ommis- Is of the poor iiospitals are irly 2,000,000 by a I ►plica I its c not fit Hub- )r that which reduced the at the aiitho- ivil. ortion in St. issioners lind 1 at the IIos- el insulted if to ask such convey the ied. Better om one who APPENDIX. lal who has the sick and ors who, by so much to- one and all TRAINING SCHOOL IN CONNECTION WITH General Public Hospital. The followincr ladies, 32 in number, have fulfilled all the requirements to entitle them to their diploma. In addition to having two years' practical care of the sick in the general and private wards of the Hospital, they have passed a satis- factory examination, both written and oral, on the following subjects : Topographical Anatomy, Physiology, Administra- tion of Anresthetics, Materia Medica, Theory and Practice of Medical and Surgical Xursing, Obstetrical Nursing, Gynecol- ogical Nursing, Care of Patients after Surgical Operations on the Eye and Ear, Care of Patients after Special Operations : Miss Janet Bacon Digby, N. S. H. Evylene Drury Montreal, P. Q. Eliza P. Hegnn Charlotte Street. City. J. Bryce Murdoch G. P. Hospital, City. Alice Morris Fairville, N. B. Susan Patterson Waterloo Street, City. Jessie Sheraton Charlottetown, P. E. I. Emma Thomas Broad Street, City. Laura Boyce Fredericton, N. B. Miriam Perry St. John, West. Gertrude Powers Carmarthen Street. Mary McAllister Sussex, N. B. Mary Robertsoii Upper Loch Loraoud. Elizabeth Williams High Street, City. Kate Holt Duke Street, City. Bertha Chesley Douglas Avenue. Isabella Murdoch Milltown, N. B. Eva Coram Paradise Row, City. Annie Delaney Douglas Avenue, City. Daisy Hanson Lepreaux, N. B. .(36) 36 Miss Mrs, Miss (( (( <( (( <( 11 (C « Miss « it <( (I « <( << (( <( « Appendix. Ada Ferguson Princess Street, City. Agnes D. Carson G. P. Hospital, City. Minnie Armstrong Dorchester, N. B. Alice Kierstead BelleisJe, Kings Co. Letitia Robinson Union Street, City. Berth n Roxboroiigh St. John, West. Emma Mitchell Millidge Street, City. Leua Jones Douglas Avenue, City. Mi^rgaretta Morris Fairville, N. B. Ella Tait Dorchester, N. B. Ada Titus Titusville. Ella Betts St. oohn, North. PUPIL NUR8ES IN TRAINING. Gertrude Williams Douglas Avenue, City. Annie E. Fulton St. John, West. Lena Murray Orange Street, City. Annie Gillies Springfield, Kings Co. Annie Bell Paradise Row. Annie Racine 16 Elliott Row. Ada Burns Priuce William Stre^^t. Nellie Clark Carleton. Susie Wilson Waterloo Street. Plary McGourty Waterloo Street. Blanch Kellier Springfield, Kings Co. May Murphy 50 City Road. Minnie Melaney 34 Pitt Street. Melissa Browne St. Martins. DISTRICT NURSE. Ella Betts. Appendix. 37 Street, City, spital, City. iv, N. B. Kings Co. reet, City. West. Street, City. Avenue, City. N. B. r, N. B. North. L venue, City. West, reet, City, i, Kings Co. Jow. Row. illiara StrCw^t. Street. Street. i, Kings Co. oad. •eet. IS. TABLE OF ADMISSIONS AND DISCHARGES From 1865 to 1895. Year. 1865. 1866. 1867. 1868. 1869., 1870., 1871., 1872., 1873.. 1874.. 1875.. 1876.. 1877-.. 1878.. 1879.. 1880.. 1881.. 1882.. 1883.. 1884.. 1885.. 1886.. 1887.., 1888.., 1889.., 1890.., 1891... 1892.., 1893... 1894... 1895.. 73 3 Q n3 > o c 3 '135 231 272 268 330 333 285 344 436 '403 !432 I 420 442 513 383 373 372 383 338 335 360 358 373 468 511 578 672 598 758 716 745 229 i 67 295 1 87 295 309 376 369 435 450 472 102 113 143 109 108 106 101 85 9 151 35 157 56 162 38: 11 221 I 36 206: 31 196 34 231 12 3001 43 14 281 ; 42 I 2 310 49 1 2 296 45 11 342; 28 9 328; 67 24 223 51 i 29 196; 52! 29 196 1 57! 6 200 66! 10 185 661 29 209 37! 16 240 41 I 18 214 ! 57 I 25 21 14 22 38 33 26 63 24 44 o Q : :5 f2 u 3 s 10 4 2 20 5 11 8 7 3 5 5 8 9 8 7 3 2 4 2 2 • ■ • 1 2 8 1 4 1 4 2 1 2 1 16 24 7 26 3 6 7 18 29 24 15 11 13 16 8 8 25 11 26 25 12 19 15 16 7 6 17 16 20 24 18 22 15 23 11 ! 19 25 26 22 24 ! 32 16 18 22 23 26 30 20 24 10 15 31 27 43 29 38 46 38 be S3 S P3 23 30 25 36 28 23 22 36 33 41 40 37 30 29 37 38 50 49 19 29 25' 28 36 32 49 63 44 52 91 74 70 s P-l 3 o 242 217 264 412 484 324 1300 1137 885 1353 1640 1298 1176 817 795 815 38 Appendix. Money Received from the Legislative Grant. ^868 ..... $ 500 00 •i^69 1^000 00 ^S"<> 1,200 00 1^71 1,200 00 18"2 1,200 00 1^73 1,200 00 1^74 1^200 00 1^75 1,500 00 1876 1,500 00 1877 1,500 00 1878 1,500 00 1879 1,500 00 1880 1,500 00 1881 1,500 00 1882 1,500 00 1883 2,000 00 1884 2,000 00 1885 2,000 00 1886 2,000 00 1887 2,000 00 1888 2,000 00 1889 2,000 00 1890.... 3,000 00 1891 3,000 00 1892 3,000 00 1893 3,000 00 1894 3,000 00 1895 3,000 00 Money Received from the Savings Bank Fund. 18"4 St2,520 00 ! 1875 2,520 00 I 1876 2,520 00 1877 2,520 00 1878 2,520 00 1879 2,520 00 1880 2,520 00 1881 2,520 00 1882 2,520 00 1883 2,520 00 1884 2,520 00 1885 2,520 00 1886 2,520 00 1887 2,520 00 1888 2,520 00 1889 2,520 00 1890 2,520 00 1891 2,520 00 1892 2,520 00 1893 2,520 00 1894 2,520 00 1895 2,568 90 Appendix. 39 Receipts from Pay Patients. 1865 $ 258 52 1866 518 .5 1867 249 87 1868 167 96 1869 436 70 1870 290 95 1871 337 50 1872 337 75 1873 309 30 1874 236 00 1875 242 00 1876 768 25 1877 571 70 1878 572 62 1879 176 00 1880 138 78 1881 209 57 1882 540 64 1883 591 59 1884 649 74 1885 564 25 1886 353 28 1887 622 00 1888 1,368 62 1889 1,125 38 1890 1,035 42 1891 1,308 88 1892 1,367 70 1893 1,743 36 1894 1,438 82 1895 1,670 56 Received from the Dominion Government for Sick Sailors. 1893 $3,559 20 1894 2,788 00 1895 3,169 50 Paid Interest on Building. 1865 $2,558 14 1866 2,569 91 1867 2,671 53 1868 2,838 48 1869 2,708 60 1870 2,842 85 1871 2,828 63 1872 2,760 00 1873 2,760 00 1874 2.760 00 1875 2,760 00 1876 2,760 00 1877 2,760 00 1878 2,760 00 1879 2,760 00 1880 2,760 00 1881 2,760 00 1882 2.760 00 1883 2,760 00 1884 2,760 00 1885 2,910 00 1886 1,380 00 1887 1,356 00 1888 1,356 00 1889 1,356 00 1890 1,632 00 1891 1,756 00 1892 1,756 00 1893 1,766 00 1894 1,916 00 1895 1,916 00 40 Appendix. The following list comprises the Commissioners ap- pointed up to date : Appointed by the Municipality. 1860. Senator John Rob'^rtson. Wni. Bayard, M. D., Edin. Wm. H.'Scovil, Esq. Appointed by the Common Council. R. W. Crookshank, Esq. John McLaughlin, Esq. Substittites. 1865. Wm. H. A. Keans, Esq., vice Robertson. 1870. M. W. Maher, Esq., vice Scovil. 1876. J. R. Marshall, Esq., vice McLaughlin. G. H. Clark, Esq., vice Keans. 1881. T. Walker, M. D., Edin., vice Marshall. Appointed by the Government. 1882, Judge Walters. A. Chipman Smith, Esq. 8. Z. Earle, M. D. G. A. Barker, Esq. Substitutes. 1890. G. A. Hetherington, M. D., vice Barker. 1890. W. C. R. Allan, Esq., mie Earle. 1892. J. McGoldrick, Esq., vice Watters. 1894. J. Berryman, M. D., Edin., vice Clarke (appointed by the Common Council). 1896. A. G. Addy, M. D., vice Hetherington. The following list comprises the physicians and surgeons who have served the institution, and the dates of their appointments : 1865. LeBaron Botsford, M. D. Edwin Bayard, M. D. T. W. Smith, M. D. J. T. Steeves, M. D. G. E. S. Keator, M. D. W. S. Harding, M. R. C. S. L. I i •1 Appendix. 41 sioiiers ap- 1866. 1868. 1872. 1873. 1874. 1877. 1878. 1879. 1882. 1883. 1884. 1887. 1889. 1890. 1891. 1893. 1894. 1896. (appointed surgeons of their 1887. 1893. 1895. 1896. Situation it, as he had G. A. Hamilton, M. D. L. Maclaren, M. R. C. S. E. Dr. Baxter. S. Z. Earle, M. D. L. Allison, M. D. James Christie, M. D. W. T. Coleman, M. D., Oculist. J. D. White, M. D. T. Walker, M. D. T. W. Daniel, M. D. Boyle Travers, M. D. Wm. Christie, M. D. M. F. Bruce, M. D., Oculist. Murray Maclaren, M. D., Edin., etc. G. R. Crawford, M. D., Oculist. A. F. Emery, M. D. W. W. White, M. D. G. A. Hetherington, M. D., Pathologist. T. D. Walker, M. D. H. D. Fritz, M. D., Oculist. R. S. Robertson, M. D., Dentist. G. A. B. Addy, Pathologist. Staff on duty in 1896. James Christie. Wm. Christie. Murray Maclaren. A. F. Emery. W. W. White. T. D. Walker. M. F. Bruce, Oculist. H. D. Fritz, Oculist. Consulting Staff. Dr. T. Walker. Dr. J. D. White. Dr. J. Berrymau. Dr. A. G. Addy. offered to Dr. Bayard, but he refused to accept not served on the staff. 42 Appendix, Secretaries. 1860. John Ansley. 1867. Robert Seely. 1872. Dr. Barteaux. 1876. Dr. Hannington. 1878. Dr. Crookshank. 1882. T. F. Raymond. 1892. I. Olive Thomas. House Surgeons. Dr. J. Sinclair. Dr. Baxter. Dr. MeCurdy. Dr. Barteaux. Tir. Hannington. Dr. Crookshank. Dr. Crawford. Dr. Duncan. Dr. Emery. Dr. Esson. Br. G. A. B. Addy. Dr. W. A. Christie. Dr. Ellis. 1865. 1866. 1868. 1872. 1876. 1878. 1882. 1885. 1887. 1889. 1891. 1893. 1896. 1865. 1866. 1888. 1890. 1891. 1895. Matrons. Mrs. Mary Craig. Mrs. Higgins. Miss Julia Purdy. Miss J. B. Murdock. Miss E. P. Hegan. Miss B. B. Chesley. Appendix. 43 ST. JOHN TRAINING SCHOOL FOR NURSES IN CONNECTION WITH GENERAL PUBLIC HOSPITAL. The Government of the School to be the same as that of the Hospital ; the nurses being in the Hospital service, and to receive six dollars per month first year, and eight dollars second year. This is not to be considered wages, their instruction being considered as a full equivalent for their services. Application for positions as pupils to be made to the Resident Physician of the Hospital on the prescribed forms. Applicants, after approval by the Resident Physician and the Directors of the School, will be received for one month on trial. During this month they are boarded and lodged at the Hospital, but will receive no compensation in money. They will be under the authority of the Resident Physician and Directors, and subject to the Rules of the Hospital. Their fitness for the work, and the propriety of retaining or dismissing them at the end of the month of trial, will be determined by the Directors on the recommendation of the Resident Physician ; and the same authority may discharge them at any time for mis- conduct or inefficiency. The most desirable age for candidates is from twenty to thirty years. All Nurses before entering Training School must present a Seventh Grade School Certificate, or an equivalent, or else pass an Examination set by the Board of Examiners. When a pupil shall have completed the full term of two years and passed a satisfactory examination, she will receive a Diploma, certifying to her period of training, her proficiency and good character. Said Diploma will be signed by the President, the Resident Physician, the Matron, and the Examiners to be appointed by the Directors, and countersigned by the Secretary of the Commission, who will keep a record of all such Diplomas in a book for the purpose. 44 Appendix. The Directors reserve the right to terminate the connection of a pupil with the School for any reason they may deem sufficient. The course of instruction includes Clinical as well as Didactic Lectures on : 1. The dressing of burns, ulcers and wounds; the prepara- tion and application of fomentations and poultices; of cups and leeches, and minor dressings. 2. The administration of enemas, and the use of the catheter, and the giving of baths. 3. The principles of massage, with practical exercises. 4. The care of patients' rooms ; changing sheets while a patient is in bed. 5. The management of helpless patients; changing their clothing, giving baths in bed, and preventing bed- sores. 6. Bandaging; making bandages and rollers ; lining splints. 7. Ventilation ; antiseptic treatment of wounds. 8. How to treat emergencies, such as hemorrhage. 9. To observe accurately the state of secretions, expectora- tions, pulse, skin, appetite, temperature, sleep, irrup- tions, effect of diet, or stimulants, or medicine ; also, in the management of convalescents. This instruction is mainly given by the Superintendent and Matron. 10. The preparation, cooking, and serving of nutritious and appetizing food. Examinations will take place from time to time, relative chiefly to practical points. All pupils to be subject to the Rules of the Hospital in the same manner as those under pay. • The nurses are liable to be sent to nurse outside the Hospital ; all money received for such service to go to the benefit of the Training School in such manner as the. Directors may see fit. All nurses to be entitled to two weeks' vacation during the year without loss of pay, at such time as may be found convenient. All accepted as pupils after the month of trial must sign a written agreement to remain at the School for two years, and con- form to its Rules. connection of I sufficient. II as Didactic the prepara- nd poultices; s, ' the catheter, ercises. leets while a anging their venting bed- ining splints. ge. s, expectora- sleep, irrup- dicine; also, is instruction id Matron, itritious and ative chiefly in the same e Hospital ; nefit of the ee fit. ng the year en lent. Qust sign a fs, and con- Appmdix. 45 1 The full term of two years to mean a full course of twenty-four f months ; time lost by sickness or absence to be made up. I The Board of Directors shall consist of four Commissioners to I be elected annually at the Regular Meeting in May. The visiting I Commissioner shall be ex-officio a member of the Board of Directors. I Saint John, N. B., October 1, 1888. I THIS PAPER is to be filled out (in the Candidate's own handwnt- I ing) and sent to Resident Physictan, General Public Hospital, Saint John, N. B. 1. Name in full, and present address of candidate 2. Are you a single woman or widow ? 3. Your present occupation or em- ployment ? 4. Age last birthday, and place of birth? 5. Height and Weight? 6. Where educated? 7. Are you strong and healthy ? and have you always been so? 8. Have you any physical defect?.... 46 Appendix. 9. If a widow, have you children ? r How many? How are thoy ] provided for? ( 10. Where (if any) was your last situ- f ation ? How long were you in it ? / 11. The names' in full and addresses of two persons to be referred to. State how long each has known you. If previously employed, one of them must be the last employer. Neither one of them shall be a relative has known lue years lias known me years I declare the above statement to be correct. Signed Candidatt Date Appendix. 47 RECAPITULATION OP RECEIPTS AND EXPENDITURES FOR G. P. HOSPITAL. Dr. Received from Taxes for Hospital Support andlnterest 8329,091 70 " " Pay Patients and Sailors 29,263 46 " " Legislative Grant 51,500 00 " " Interest on Savings Bank Bequest Fund 53,922 90 $463,778 06 Cr. Paid for Hospital Support (including Furnishings) $366,865 88 " Interest on Bonds 72,190 23 $439,056 11 Balance on hand (Dec. 31st, 1895) ... 24,721 95 $463,778 06