k'l^ 
 
 
 IMAGE EVALUATION 
 TEST TARGET {MT-3) 
 
 /> 
 
 A 
 
 ^k- 
 
 
 -^^M% 
 
 ^ 
 
 A 
 
 < ^ 
 
 %^ 
 
 1.0 Sfi 
 
 IL 1125 
 
 II 
 
 Sf ■- III 
 
 us 
 
 US 
 
 ■ 4.0 
 
 2.2 
 
 2.0 
 
 1.8 
 
 
 1.25 1.4 1.6 
 
 
 ■* 6" 
 
 ► 
 
 ^Wm, " ^^'^ J» 
 
 ::^J' 
 
 ^v ^ 
 
 Photogr^hic 
 
 Sciences 
 
 Corporation 
 
 23 WEST MAIN STREET 
 
 WEBSTER, N.Y. MSSO 
 
 (716) 872-4503 
 

 CIHM/ICMH 
 
 Microfiche 
 
 Series. 
 
 CIHM/ICMH 
 Collection de 
 microfiches. 
 
 Canadiun Institute for Historical Microreproductions / Institut Canadian de microreproductions historiques 
 
Technical and Bibliographic Notas/iMotas tachniquas at bibliographiquaa 
 
 Tha Instituta has attamptad to obtain the best 
 original copy available for filming. Features of this 
 sopy which may be bibliographically unique, 
 which may alter any of the imagea in tha 
 reproduction, or which may significantly change 
 the usual method of filming, are checked below. 
 
 n 
 
 Coloured covers/ 
 Uouvarture de couiaur 
 
 n~| Covers damaged/ 
 
 Couverture endommagte 
 
 Covers restored and/or laminated/ 
 Couverture restaurie et/ou peillcui^e 
 
 I I Covej title missing/ 
 
 Ls titre de couverture manque 
 
 j I Coloured maps/ 
 
 Cartes g^ographiquas en couleur 
 
 □ Coloured Ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ 
 Encre de couleur (i.e. autre que bleue ou noire) 
 
 j I Coloured plates and/or illustrations/ 
 
 Planches et/ou illustrations an couieui- 
 
 Bound with other material/ 
 Relii avac d'autras documants 
 
 D 
 
 D 
 
 Tight binding may cause shadows or distortion 
 along interior margin/ 
 
 La re liure serrie peut causer da I'ombra ou da la 
 distorsion ie long de la marge int6ri«ure 
 
 Blank leaves added during restoration may 
 appear within the text. Whenever possible, these 
 have been omitted from filming/ 
 II se peut que certaines pages btsinches ajouties 
 lors d'une restauration apparaissem dans la taxte, 
 maia, lorsque ceia itait possible, gbs pages n'ont 
 pa£ M film^as. 
 
 L'Institut a microfilm* ie meilleur examplaira 
 qu'il lui a iti possible de se procurer. Les details 
 de cet exemplaira qui sont peut-dtre uniques du 
 point de vue bibliographique, qui peuvent modifier 
 une image reproduite, ou qui peuvent exiger una 
 modification dans la mAthoda normaie de fllmage 
 sont indiquAs ci-dessous. 
 
 n 
 
 n 
 n 
 
 D 
 
 n 
 n 
 
 Coloured pages/ 
 Pages de couleur 
 
 P^ges damaged/ 
 Pages endommagies 
 
 Pages restored and/or laminated/ 
 Pages restauries et/ou pelliculdes 
 
 Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ 
 Pages decolorizes, tachetdes ou piquees 
 
 Pages detached/ 
 Pages ditachies 
 
 Showthrough/ 
 Transparence 
 
 Quality of print varies/ 
 Quality inigala de I'impression 
 
 Includes supplementary material/ 
 Comprend du materiel supplementaira 
 
 Only edition available/ 
 Seule Edition disponible 
 
 Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata 
 slips, tissues, etc., have been refiimed to 
 ensure the best possible =mage/ 
 Les pages totalement ou partiellement 
 obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata, une pelure, 
 etc., ont 6ti fiimies i nouveau de fapon d 
 obtanir la mailieure image possible. 
 
 EZl 
 
 Additional comments:/ 
 Commentaires suppl^mantairas; 
 
 Wrinkled payes may film sliehtly out of focus. 
 
 This item is filmed at i.ie reduction ratio checked below/ 
 
 Ce document est film* au taux de reduction indiqu* ci-dessous. 
 
 ^OX 14X 18X 22X 
 
 26X 
 
 30X 
 
 12X 
 
 16X 
 
 20X 
 
 24X 
 
 28X 
 
 32X 
 
The copy filmed here hes been reproduced thanks 
 to the generosity of: 
 
 Mills IMemoriai Library 
 McMaster University 
 
 L'exemplaire fiimA fut reproduit grAce A la 
 gAnArositA de; 
 
 IMills IMemorial Library 
 McMaster University 
 
 Tha images appearing here are the best quality 
 possible considering thf« condition and legibility 
 of the original copy and in Iteeping with the 
 filming contract specifications. 
 
 Original copies in printed paper covers are filmed 
 beginning with the front cover and ending on 
 the last page with a printed or illustrated impres- 
 sion, or the bacic cover when appropriate. All 
 other original copies are filmed beginning on the 
 first page with a printed or illustrated impres- 
 sion, and ending on the last page with a printed 
 or illustrated impression. 
 
 The last recorded frame on each microfiche 
 shall contain the symbol -^ (meaning "CON- 
 TINUED"), or the symbol V (meaning "END"), 
 whichever applies. 
 
 Maps, plates, charts, etc., may be filmed at 
 different reduction ratios. Those too large to be 
 entirely included in one exposure are filmed 
 beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to 
 right and top to bottom, as many frames as 
 required. The following diagrams illustrate the 
 method: 
 
 Les Images suivantes ont 4t6 reproduites avec le 
 plus grand soin, compte tenu de la condition et 
 de la netteti de l'exemplaire f ilm6, et en 
 conformity avec les conditions' du contrat de 
 filmage. 
 
 Les exemplaires originaux dont la couvenure en 
 papier est imprimie sont filmte en commenpant 
 par le premier plat et en terminant sc!: par la 
 derniire page qui comporte une empreinte 
 d'impression ou d'illustration, soit par le second 
 plat, salon le cas. Tous ies autres exemplaires 
 originaux sont film^s en commenpant par la 
 premidre page qui comporte une empreirtte 
 d'impression ou d'illustration et en terminant par 
 la dernidre page qui comporte une telle 
 empreinte. 
 
 Un d<9s symboles suivants appara?tra sur ia 
 dernidre image de cheque microfiche, selon le 
 cas: le symbole — ► signifie "A SUIVRE", le 
 symbole V signifie "FIN". 
 
 Les cartes, planches, tableaux, etc., peuvent Atre 
 filmAs d des taux de reduction diffdrents. 
 Lorsque le document est trop grand pour Atre 
 reproduit en un seul clichA, il est filmA A partir 
 de I'angle supArteur gauche, de gauche A droite, 
 et de haut en has, en prenant le nomtre 
 d'imagas n^cessaire. Les diagrammes suivants 
 illustrent ia mAthode. 
 
 1 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 1 2 3 
 
 4 5 6 
 

 ^^mmA^T^m 
 
 OF 
 
 THE CONVERSION 
 
 OF 
 
 TO THE FAITH 
 
 OF THE 
 
 9 
 
 Catfjoltc/ 
 
 APOSTOLIC & ROMAN CHURCH, 
 
 ' •■ ■-""».« ->' ...-.> 
 
 AmiMt REJUTATMijW OJ TUB C^KAENT OJWSCTIONS 
 
 TO MANY ARTICLES OF CATHOLIC 
 
 FAITH AND DISCIJPLINE. 
 
 ONE LORD, ONE FAITH, ONE BAPTISM.-ifjpA. m i. 
 
 MONTREAL : 
 
 .JPRINTXD BY NAHUM MOWERt 
 
 u 
 
 •'»'■ .*. 
 
 '1 , ^ ' 
 
 »J» 
 
McMASTER UNIVERSITY UBRAHU 
 
TO THE BIGHT REVEREND 
 
 BISHOP OF BOSTON. 
 
 My dear Lord 4Nd Frijind, 
 
 I TAKE the liberty to inscribe my Pamphlet to 
 your Lordship. — To you it owes its existence ; for 
 to you (under God, J I owe my Conversion, 
 
 It would, perhaps, have a better claim to notice, 
 had Providence permitted me to prolong my pupil- 
 age and mature my Catholicity under such Gama- 
 liels as yourself; and the late beloved and ever la- 
 mented Doctor Matignon. 
 
 I PRAY God, that delaying your reward for the 
 good of mankind, he will protract the life of so di- 
 ligent a labourer in his Vineyard^that you may 
 long remain to instruct by your precept, and edify 
 by your example^;— in short, that the lapse of many 
 years may still fnd you a blessing to your Diocese 
 and an ornament to the American Republic / * 
 
 I am 
 
 My dear Lord and Friend, 
 
 Your affectionate grateful Servant, 
 
 THE AUTHOR, 
 
 JBoucherville, L, C,\ 
 Michaelmas, X 8g 1 . j 
 
FIRST, 
 
 OR 
 
 WHjENEVER a Citizen finds it a duty to 
 change his Rehgion, he owes it in deferei.ce to 
 public curiosity, so generally excited, to jmpait 
 the motives which prompt his secession from iiis 
 native communion. 
 
 I HASTEN to acquit myself of this obligation-^ 
 and I trust that my readers will recognizL- in 
 the following recital of my conversion to iho 
 Catholic Faith, every tiait of artless sincerity, dil- 
 igent research and cautious deliberation, which a 
 nrieasure connected with Salvation should so impe- 
 riously require. 
 
 I WAS born in Salem, Massachusetts, on the 
 20th of January, I77I, and was baptized by the 
 Reverend Mr. Gilchrist, the Rector of St. Peter's 
 Church. My family on both sides were Episco- 
 palians, and my maternal grandfather, the Rever- 
 end Aaron Cleveland, had been Rector of Halifax 
 in Nova-Scotia. 
 
 The war of the American Revolution coming 
 on, the Clergy of this persuasion, being generally 
 Royalists, emigrated, and the Churches were clo. 
 sed. During this interval, our family attended 
 Congregational worship in the meeting-house of 
 the late Reverend Doctor Barnard, 
 
I WAS introduced to an acquaintance with the 
 English Alphabet by Dame Chapman, a School- 
 mistress of the vicinity ; and as soon as X had 
 learned to read, the Catechism of the Westmin- 
 ster Divines was put into my hands. This is a 
 compendium of the Calvinistic doctrines then gen- 
 erally held in New-England : and this I repeated 
 periodically to our Pastor in the Meeting-house, 
 with other children of the Society. The peace of 
 1783 re-opened the Episcopal Churches ; and we 
 had for our new Incumbent, the late lieverend 
 Nathaniel Fisher, a very able Preacher, as is suffi- 
 ciently evinced by the posthumous volume of his 
 Sermons. 
 
 After attending a few preparatory Schools, in 
 January 1782, 1 was admitted into Phillips* Acad- 
 emy at Andover. This Institution was then in 
 high reputation, and under the care and tuition of 
 the Reverend EUphalet Pearson, a learned schol- 
 ar, and a rigid disciplinarian,— JCind and indul- 
 gent to the industrious Student ; to delinquents 
 his look pf displeasure was petrifaction, 
 
 Although Religion mingled with many of our 
 academical exercises, hitherto I had experienced 
 no very serious impressiops of this nature. While 
 at Andover I met with Bunj/an*s Fiigrim*s PrQ^ 
 gress. This was well calculated to inflan^e a youth- 
 ful imagination like mine. Hervey's Meditations 
 ^Iso fell in my way, and charmed me with their 
 glitter of style and pious enthusiasm. 
 
 I SOON afterward met with a work which has 
 never since been out of my reach— Young* s Night 
 Thoughts— io the reading of which I was recom- 
 mended by the advice and example of my mater- 
 nal grandmother, with whom " the Poet of the 
 Tombs" was a favourite and daily companion. 
 The perusal of this admirable volume impressed 
 
with the 
 a School. 
 as X had 
 iVestmin- 
 This is a 
 :hen gen- 
 repeated 
 ig- house, 
 peace of 
 and we 
 leverend 
 IS is sufH- 
 ne of his 
 
 :hools, in 
 >s* Acad- 
 then in 
 iuition of 
 ed schol- 
 id indul- 
 linquents 
 
 ly of our 
 lerienced 
 . While 
 n*s PrQ' 
 ! a youth- 
 editations 
 fiih their 
 
 hich has 
 ^'s Night 
 5 recpm- 
 ly mater- 
 it of the 
 npanion. 
 npresse^ 
 
 me deeply. It presented m6 with new and exalt- 
 ed views of the providence of God and the desti- 
 nation of Man. It diffused a soft and tender mel- 
 ancholy over my mind, and I aspired to Immor- 
 tality. 
 
 In July I78G, having passed the usual exaraina- 
 tions in the Classics, I was adm'tted into Harvard 
 University, the first literary Institution, in age and 
 renown, upon the American Continent. The 
 Presidency was then filled by the Reverend Jo- 
 seph Willard. Among my fellow-students at col- 
 lege was the celebrated John Quincy Adams, then 
 a senior-sophistic: and was, at that immature 
 age, a finished Scholar, Philosopher and Politician. 
 That distinguished orator in Congress, Josiah 
 Quincy, was my class-mate. 
 
 This was the aera of Daniel Shay's famous in- 
 surrection. The sound of the drum and fife in- 
 spired me with a thirst for military glory. Too 
 young, however, to enroll myself for war, I was 
 merely an impatient spectator of toils and dangers 
 which I could not share. My reading was conso- 
 nant with this ardor of mind, and letting the dust 
 gather upon books of every other description, Vol- 
 taire's History of Charles XII., whose exploits 
 engrossed every faculty of my soul, was ever wak- 
 m^, in my hand ; and sleeping, under my pillow. 
 Addison's Cato had already turned my head to 
 Stoicism. — I resolved to pass unmoved through all 
 the varyingscenesof life— undated by prosperity, 
 and undepressed by adversity. 
 
 My Mother falling sick and dying, I was with, 
 drawn from the University, before I had comple- 
 ted the year of my Freshmanship. I returned to 
 Salem, and after a few months solitary application 
 to miscellaneous studies, in April, 1788, 1 began 
 
the study of Physic, under the late Doctor Joshua 
 Fhiiiuar, u Practitioner of high reputation. 
 
 I NOW became a hard student. 1 lose eailv, 
 retired late, and addicssed myself to the elenicn- 
 taiy stihlies of the various branches of this profes- 
 sion, with indefatigable industry. A morbid sen- 
 sibility of heart, however, gave me an aversion to 
 the operations of Surgery. Of course, in this de- 
 partment, J made less proficiency. 
 
 1 WAS branded b} nature with a wild romanti- 
 city of character, and ready for any enterprize to 
 which the warmth and caprice of my temperament 
 might impel me. 1 was seized with a gust for 
 Travel ; and having finished my medical studies, 
 I embarked in December, 1790, for South-Caro- 
 lina. I arrived at Charleston on the first of Jan- 
 uary, 1791. 
 
 This was a scene of sufficient danger for the 
 immaturity of nineteen years* A warm climate 
 invites to luxury, and affluence furnishes the means. 
 Aware of the perils which surrounded me, I de- 
 tcriTuneU to be upon my guard. 1 kept much at 
 he mv ; and when unoccupied by the calls of my 
 p.K'fession, devoted my time to reading. Poetical 
 Coin|K)siiion, for which 1 had much taste, and was 
 Altered to luivc some talent, occasionally amused 
 nie. 1 also cultivated Music with much zeal and 
 some success. 
 
 I RE-OPENED Young, and he fortified my love of 
 abstraction and retirement. Blair's Sermons 1 al- 
 so read wiih profit and delight. My companions 
 were tew— and from my industrious seclusion from 
 the jgay world, 1 hoped to escape the snares which 
 had caught so many unwary youth. Alas ! I was 
 mistaken. Gradually enlarging my sphere of So- 
 ciety, I began to lose sight of those solid maxims 
 of piety and prudence which I had brought froxn 
 
9 
 
 New-E- ,'land. No longer had I relish for serious 
 lecture aud private prayer j and iu a short time 
 neglected public worship. 
 
 About this time the new Theatre was built in 
 Charleston, and opened under West and Bignall. 
 The dramatic mania spread far and wide. I 
 breathed the air of contagion, and found my way 
 to tlie stage. One essay cured me of my folly, 
 and I renounced at once and forever the sock and 
 buskin. 
 
 I RCMovED in July, 1793, to Savannah, in Geor- 
 gia, where, in February, 1794, 1 embarked for the 
 West4ndies.— 1 arrived at St. Martinis, and soon 
 afterward fixed myself in the Virgin Islands. 
 
 In this part of the world I met nothing calcu- 
 lated to renew the pious impressions of my early 
 years ; but much to make me forget them alto- 
 gether. There was a Methodist Mission in Tor- 
 tola, but seldom any other public worship. The 
 poor Africans were among the few who appeared 
 to have any sense of Religion. 
 
 Hitherto, although far from living up to the 
 standard of the Gospel, I had never been taught to 
 doubt the truth of Divine Revelation. It was now 
 my misfortune to add infidelity to my other follies, 
 and to have the whole fabric of my religious be- 
 lief overturned by a single blow. This was achiev- 
 ed by Thomas Paine's Age of Reason, I read 
 this book with undivided attention j and subscri- 
 bing to every position, I became a convert to De^ 
 ism. The Religion of Nature, in my estimation, 
 afforded sufficient sanctions for every purpose of 
 moral government ; and I considered all supernat- 
 ural Revelation superfluous, devised by priestcraft, 
 and addressed to the fears of men. 
 
 The war with France was now raging in gll • 
 parts of the globe, and every American heart psi. 
 
10 
 
 pitated ii) devotion to the French Republic. Ea- 
 ger to add my suffrage to that of my countrymeii, 
 1 sailed from St. Thomas for St. Domingo. Af- 
 ter a short residence at Port de Paix, where my 
 sole employment was composing and sinsing re- 
 pubhca?^ songs, I solicited and obtained 'from 
 Genera! Lavaux, a commission appointing me 
 Qfficier de Santi en Second on board of the Ran- 
 ger Coi'vette, in which in the month of Floreal 
 of the Sd year 1 sailed for France. 
 
 OxV my arrival at Brest, in Prairiai, I was assign- 
 ed employment successively in the Marine Hos- 
 pital of that Port, and in that of Pontanezen. In- 
 ternal dissensions had now in some degree subsi- 
 ded, and France began to breathe. Kobespierre 
 and the Mountain party harJ perished, and the axe 
 of the guiilotin was left to rust. 
 
 In the autumn of 1795, I was invited to Paris, 
 to join the commercial house o^ Dallarde, Swan 
 & Co. I took place m the Diligence for Rennis 
 the 24th Fractidor of the ;:Jd year. The Vendee 
 country was still the tlieatre of war and bloodshed. 
 We traversed it with an escort, through a thou- 
 sand dangers and escapes, and arrived the 10th 
 Vendemiaire of the 4th )'ear, at the French Cap> 
 ital. *^ 
 
 I HAD hardly began to recreate myself with the 
 novelties of this superb metropolis, when the lapse 
 of a few days exhibited one for which I was not 
 prepared. This was the sanguinary scene of the 
 13th Vendemiaire, an jEra which will be recorded 
 by the faithful historian, as equally tragical and, 
 disgraceful to the French nation. X^r on this ca- 
 lamitous day was fought that memorable battle 
 between the militia of the Sections of Paris, and 
 tMv, ^,,atMj wi tijc x>aiii;ijui v^uiivennon. liere 
 IBoiiaparte (who was entrusted with the defence 
 
 
11 
 
 blic. £a- 
 Lintrymeii, 
 ngo. Af- 
 vhere my 
 nging re- 
 led from 
 nting me 
 the Ran- 
 •f Floreal 
 
 as asslgn- 
 ine Hos- 
 zen. In- 
 ree subsi- 
 bespierre 
 d the axe 
 
 to Paris, 
 le. Swan 
 r Rennis 
 ! Vendee 
 oodshed. 
 I a thou- 
 the 10th 
 ich Cap- 
 
 with the 
 he lapse 
 was not 
 3 of the 
 c corded 
 cal and, 
 this ca- 
 J battle 
 ris, and 
 Here 
 defence 
 
 «f' the f!onvention) made his coup d*essai as a com- 
 mander, and was instrumental in the destruction 
 of more than eight thousand of his fellow men. 
 
 James Monroe, now President of the United 
 States, was at this time the American Ambassador 
 in France. Thomas Paine lived at his house. — 
 I soon became acquainted with him : and meet- 
 ing with the second part of his ^ge of Jieason, 
 was fortified in my disbelief of divine Kevelation, 
 
 I WAS still however, in some degree, under tlie 
 influence of virtuous habit, which had been early 
 fashioned by religious credence, though now ef- 
 faced from my mind. I was anxious to sustain a 
 good name by being in my narrow sphere a doeV 
 of good. I gave alms liberally out of my small 
 meanSf and innumerable w^ere'the services which 
 I rendered to the poor English prisoners. These 
 sentiments resembled that precious "leaven hid 
 in three measures of meal," Matthew xiii. 33. 
 
 In 1796, I was sent to the United States with 
 dispatches. I em.barked at Havre de Grace, the 
 24th Germinal of the 4th year, and arrived at 
 New A'ork the 10th Prairial. I went on to Phila- 
 delphia and delivered my dispatches. Citizen 
 Adet was then the French Minister. I re- visited 
 my relatives in Massachusetts, with whom having 
 passed the Summer, and deafened them with my 
 Jacobinical clamor. I returned in the Autumn to 
 France. I embarked at Salem the lOth Thumi- 
 dor, 4th year, and arrived at Bordeaux the 2d 
 Vendemiaire, 5th year. Desirous of seeing to 
 greater advantage the South of France during the 
 vintage, I proceeded to Paris on foot — descending 
 the Garonne to Blaye, Koyan, thro* Rochfort, 
 Rochelle, Nioit, Poictiers, Tours, &c.-— a journey 
 of between four a,nd five hundred miles. 1 arrived 
 the 8th Brumaire, 
 
 B 2 
 
■.^r-f.'-^i'i'sy^r'' 
 
 r 
 
 TiiROPmLANTHRorY now began to prevail in 
 France, and temples for the exercise of this spe- 
 
 nIL 't^Tl ""'^''^^P ^^'■^ ^P^ned in various 
 places. Had the views and sentiments of its pro- 
 jectors quadrated with the import of the word, thev 
 rl ^;f^%^een justly entitled to the gratitude of 
 Defsm '* '"^^^ ""^ ""^"^^'fied system of 
 
 I WISHED to make the campaign of the 5th 
 
 in?l' ^ . ^-'^^ ^^ ^^^^ ^ ^PP^^'^^ t« government 
 ior leave to jom the Army of Italy under Bona^ 
 
 parte : but was too Jate for an appointment. 
 
 In March, 1797, I was commissioned to go to 
 ^ngland, in order to recover the amount of tome 
 spoliations of American property upon the hieh 
 seas. Un my arrival in London, finding the re- 
 covery hopeless, I accepted an Assistancy in an 
 Acadenjy at Kennington, a village of the vicinity. 
 While here. I attended divine service regularly 
 
 Tpaf nf fl.''"f'*'? f^'^'^ 9"^^^^ ^^ Lambeth, the 
 seat of the Arch-bishop of Canterbury. Prayers 
 were also read morning and evening in the School 
 itoom In these exercises I assisted, and occa- 
 sionally preached a Sermon. All this, however, I 
 considered merely as a matter of routine, which 
 fideir^ ^"^ to awaHen me from the torpor of In- 
 
 HmI^k^ ^^^- ^^^^' ^^^"^ ^* Manchester, I was 
 drawn by curiosity to visit Fairfield, a village of 
 the Umtas Fratrum, or Moraviari Brethren, I 
 Mas delighted wi h the beautiful simplicity of their 
 worship, and felt a revival of pious emotions in my 
 iieart. I his prompted me to enter into corres- 
 pondence with the Reverend John Swertner, one 
 of heir ministers, in order to learn the peculiar 
 doctrines and discipline of this Sect, and with a 
 >iew to admittance into their Society, lie obli. 
 
 it 
 
 ¥. 
 
 -.-. ...W ww B a ..u i . ' M-.U. o^ -,^.,^^.^.,^^ 
 
18 
 
 prevail in 
 ; this spe- 
 in various 
 of its pro- 
 *'ord, they 
 atitude of 
 system of 
 
 f the 5th 
 vernment 
 ler Bona- 
 jnt. 
 
 to go to 
 t of some 
 
 the high 
 ig the re- 
 icy in an 
 
 vicinity* 
 regularly 
 beth, the 
 
 Prayers 
 e School 
 nd occa- 
 •wever, I 
 -, which 
 )r of In- 
 
 ^ed me with a candid exposition of their tenets 
 but I aid not find them satisfj 
 
 ?r, I was 
 illage of 
 hren. I 
 
 of their 
 ns in my 
 
 corres- 
 ^er, one 
 pecuh'ar 
 i with a 
 Lie ODii- 
 
 ed the desiijn no Airth 
 
 er. 
 
 ^actory, and I pursu- 
 
 o-~ — "-" ' ,-* 
 
 The Moravians address their prayers exclusive- 
 ly to Christ. This appeared to me a sort of im- 
 piety to tlie Father, and was a virtual denial of 
 his existence. I conceived it, moreover, contrary 
 to the express precept and example of our Saviour 
 himself, who commanded us when we pray, to say 
 " Our Father, &c." Their notions of Faith also 
 seemed to my apprehension, wild and incoherent. 
 IJjey do not indeed reject good works : but their 
 practice is certainly more favourable to them than 
 their doctrme. Many points too, of .lie Moravi- 
 an discipline, had in my mind an air of extrava- 
 gance. Their marriages I thought ill-assorted, 
 and the decision of every question by the Lot in 
 alrotestant Church, which declares that miia- 
 cles have ceased, seemed to the last degree, ab- 
 surd and inconsistent. 
 
 Having returned to London, I ^ot acquainted 
 with some members of the Society of Universa lists, 
 tounded by my countryman, the Keverend Elhan. 
 an Winchester, and addressed myself to the Rev- 
 erena Mr. Vidler for a sketch of their doctrines. 
 My much honored Father had indulged this be- 
 liet, and entertained that peculiarity of it profes- 
 sed by the Reverend John Murray, of Boston. 
 But I soon suspected that this ground was unten- 
 able by any who adhered to the plain text of Scrip- 
 ture, and was solely supported by some detached 
 passages, obscure and equivocal. I dropped the 
 Universahsts. There had now been for several 
 years m London a Society under the name of the 
 New Jerusalem, I heard such astonishing ac 
 counts of their doctrines, that mv rurincitT, ,... 
 strongly excited to learn them in detail. For iQ 
 
 
 ■^ „ 
 
u 
 
 I !! 
 
 purpose I addressed myself to the Reverend Jo- 
 seph Proud, their High Priest, who lent me sever- 
 al tracts, written by their founder, Baron Sweden- 
 borg. I was struck with the intrepidity of his un- 
 dertakirtg. Conjecture and hypothesis are out of 
 the question. All is pronounced to be fact. On 
 the bold assumption of immediate correspondence 
 with the Deity, this hardy Dogmatist had erected 
 a system of doctrines, unequalled for ingenuity of 
 contrivance. 1 went through much of this volum- 
 nious writer, and was for a while charmed with 
 the subtility of his deductions ; but finding the 
 whole scheme rest solely on the personal respon- 
 sibility of one who wrought no miracle in sup- 
 port of his pretensions, I took leave of him as an 
 entertaining madman, and classed his tale with 
 those of the Arabian Nights. 
 
 My next tour was among the Quakers* Their 
 modesty and simplicity had impressed me when a 
 hpy, and I loved the people without knowing their 
 doctrines. To learn them satisfactorily, I applied 
 to some of the most intelligent of the Society, and 
 attended their Meetings. Jf I was at first pleas- 
 ed with their plain and artless deportment, I was 
 soon dissatisfied with the nudity of their worship. 
 i examined with the eye of reason and with the 
 Scripture before me, their principal doctrine of ^ 
 Divine Light within, which was to lead us into all 
 truth. This was avowedly not the light of con- 
 science, and I knew no other. I had no doubt 
 indeed that conscience v»ras susceptible of, and re- 
 ceived at times, illumination from above : but it 
 still appeared to me incontrovertible that, clear or 
 cloudy, enlightened from heaven, or obscured by 
 the powers of darkness^ Conscience was our sole 
 interior^-^guide. Their definition of this favourite 
 
 «,- , ..J v.'v/...\.vi ».vr liivi «.» vliiJtiliVi-iVil iTAbli(^Ub a tiiilCi- 
 
 % 
 
 ■f 
 
 
verend Jo^ 
 ; me sever- 
 n JSweden- 
 of his un- 
 are out of 
 fact. On 
 spondence 
 id erected 
 genuity of 
 his volum- 
 rmed with 
 tiding the 
 lal respon- 
 le jn sup- 
 him as an 
 tale with 
 
 :s. Their 
 le when a 
 wing their 
 I applied 
 ciety, and 
 irst pleas- 
 ant, I was 
 • worship, 
 with the 
 trine of a 
 js into all 
 t of con- 
 no doubt 
 f, and re- 
 3 : but it 
 ;, clear or 
 5cured by 
 I our sole 
 favourite 
 
 b U> UlllCi-' 
 
 15 
 
 ence, and much too subtle for edification. I gradf. 
 ually withdrew from their coirespondence. 
 
 Still anxious and not disheartened in my pur- 
 suit, I began to attend the worship of a Society 
 of Unitaridns, then under the pastoral care of the 
 Reverend D. Disney, their Liturgy was model- 
 led after that of the Church of England—and their 
 doctrines appeared to me the simplest and most ra- 
 tional 1 had met with. The recognition of one 
 Supreme God, the Father of all— and of whom 
 all other beings, however elevated in the order of 
 nature or of grace, are but the creatures, had in my 
 estimation an air of grandeur, which engaged all 
 my attention. But as if I were doomed to be the 
 victim of a fastidious taste, and endlessly to roam 
 in quest of what I should never find, 1 soon dis- 
 covered in the simplest form of Christianity, the 
 most palpable inconsistencies. The Socinians pre- 
 tend that Reason is our sole guide, and the only 
 touchstone by which all doctrines, divine or hu- 
 man, shotld be tried,— and that whatever cannot 
 abide this test, should be rejected as false. In obe- 
 dience to this rule,^ they deny the virginity of 
 Blessed Mary, and the incarnation and Divinity 
 of Christ, But in disobedience to the same rule 
 they admit all the miracles of the Old and Ne#^ 
 Testaments. I left them unsatisfied. 
 
 In justice to myself; and to the honest zeal with^ 
 which I engaged in these tiresome expeditions ii 
 quest of truth, I must observe that I never ente/ 
 ed into connexion with any of these Societies. \ 
 postponed my adhesion to 'the momentof ultimate 
 conviction. 
 
 About this time I fell sick of a lingering fever 
 and passed several months in sufierinff aiid con' 
 T'j" ,"'^* iyuiiijj; my illness, i met wr!n Dod- 
 dridge s Rise and Progress oflieligion in Hie Soul, 
 
 vi*' 
 
It3 
 
 ! !i' 
 
 I ■ I ■ : ! 
 
 il I 
 
 lliii 
 
 This work IS of a high Calvinistical cast, and is 
 ^vritten with much pathos. 1 trembled at his pic 
 ture ot the impenitent sinner, and resolved that if 
 by divine mercy I should be restored to health, I 
 would solemnly dedicate myself to God. 
 
 My ardor now began to abate. 1 saw on every 
 side, hosts of Sects which claimed Divine Truth 
 as exclusively their own, while the Bible served 
 tnem a 1 as a vast armoury, whence they supplied 
 themselves with weapozis, and waged an intermin- 
 able war against each other. In short I met with 
 nothing but disappointment, and began to despair 
 ot hnding what 1 sought, in any Christian com- 
 munion. 
 
 .u ^i!^}^.^^ observed, that into my calculations 
 the tathohc Faith had never entered. 1 had in- 
 deed heard the Reverend John Thayer of Boston 
 preach once or twi' ^ in Salem when I was youncr. 
 I admired his eloquence, but was indifferent to lus 
 theme. I had occasionally too, while in London 
 frequented the Sardinian Ambassador's Chapel' 
 m Lincoln'sJnn-Fields; but 1 was attracted by 
 the music, and not by the Doctrine. I had imbi 
 bed in early life most of the Protestant prejudices 
 against Catholics, and never conceived that there 
 was any truth in their Church, but what they en- 
 joyed m common with all other Churches. In 
 other respects, I viewed it as a sink of idolatry 
 and corruption. 
 
 "1 NOW thought of taking leave of Christianity 
 altogether, and embracing Mahometanism, I was 
 acquainted with the leading tenets of the Koran, 
 and With a view to further' instruction, I wrote to 
 the Turkish Ambassador. I was answered by hi» 
 first Dratjoman, but so unmeaningly, that J was 
 ashameR>f my project, and abandoned it X^ie 
 
at his pic- 
 ved that if 
 
 health, I 
 
 • 
 
 V on every 
 ine Truth 
 jle served 
 r supplied 
 intermin- 
 met with 
 to despair 
 tian com- 
 
 Iculations 
 
 1 had in- 
 3f Boston 
 is young. 
 3nt to his 
 London, 
 
 Chapel, 
 acted by 
 lad imbi 
 rejudices 
 lat there 
 they en- 
 hes. In 
 idolatry 
 
 istianity 
 I was 
 Koran, 
 wrote to 
 1 by his 
 It J was 
 
 if 
 
 » 
 gulrdian of Israel, who never slumbers nor sleeps, 
 preserved me from this wicked temptation. 
 
 Having at length wandered till I was iairly be- 
 wildered among the ignes fatus of contending 
 ^ects, I resolved to loojc no farther, but retire 
 once more to the strong hold of Deism j and rest- 
 ing satisfied with the existence and perfections of 
 the Supreme Being and with my moral obliga- 
 tlonsi together with what hope of a future state 
 might be derived from analogy, desist from any 
 larther pursuit. ^ 
 
 On March 4th, l-J^gg. I was married in the 
 Uuirch of St. Dunstan's, Ste{>ney, to Miss Kings- 
 ley, of the Parish of St. George, in the East Mid- 
 dlesex; Snortly afterward I received an appoint- 
 ment upon the Hospital Staff of the Army, and 
 was sent to Yarmouth, to assist in the Hospital 
 hlled with sick and wounded Russians, after the 
 disastrous campaign of that year in Holland. 
 
 Notwithstanding my melancholy eclipse of 
 mmd with regard to the great truths of Christiani- 
 ty, books of devotion still continued to occupy my 
 leisure hours. Having met with Law's Serious 
 Call to a devout and Holy Life, I read it with great 
 care and delight. I followed his method of pray- 
 er for a considerable time—and the' I afterward 
 discontinued .this practice, his book still shares 
 many of my reading hours. 
 
 I LEFT Yarmouth in July, 1800, and served sue 
 cessively at York Hospital, in Chelsea, and at 
 Blatchington Barracks in Sus^, with the 95th 
 Kinle Corps. 
 
 Early in 1801, I was ordered on service to the 
 ^^st Indies. I sailed in the Packet from Fal- 
 mouth, March 7, and arrived April 11th at Bar- 
 badpes. During the passage, I lost a little Rov 
 my tirst born. I lamented his death with the 
 
 C 
 
I^ 
 
 
 Hv 
 
 il.i' 
 
 ih 
 
 acutest sorrow, and creation wore a gloom aronnrf 
 nie. Besides, it was my misery to « mourn like 
 those without hope." A future state was to me 
 proMemati^al, and upon this melancholy occasion. 
 ^ 1 wanted the benign influence of this belief to 
 clieer my despondency. I determined to re-con- 
 sider the evidence of divine Ueveiation. and eVen 
 to anricipate mj; final conviction, by -performing 
 wnthout J'aith the works of Faith.'' I according? 
 ly gave myjfelf up to religious readityg and prayer 
 earnestly mvoking the God of light and truth to 
 direct my way, and guide me to that haven of 
 tranquillity, of which my mind had been in lono- 
 and atixious searclr. - " 
 
 |uoM Barbadoes I sailed to Martinico ; thence 
 to 5t. Lucia, where I was charged with a Hospi- 
 tal of Invalids, by the late Sir George Provost 
 then a Brigadier General. ^ ^^rovost, 
 
 On ^my recal to Martinico, I met (for the first 
 time, tho' not a rare book) with Thomas A. Kem- 
 pis s Follmmg of Christ I was so pleasingly ed- 
 ified by this little volume, and so much impressed 
 with the holy delights of a religious life, that, in 
 order to have a nefarer survey of them, I introdu- 
 ced myselt to the Fathers of the Convent in St 
 Fierre, by whom I was received with courtesy' 
 and If t.-ned to with kindness. - ■ 
 
 Aftkr the restoration of Martinico to the 
 French at the peacfe of 1802, 1 proceeded on med- 
 ical duty to St. Christopher's. There was a mis- 
 sion ot the Moravian Brethren in this Island. Up- 
 on tne strength of my former acquaintance with I 
 some ot their Society in England, J cultivated the 
 friendship of the Ministers who conducted this 
 mission. I lived next door to their Chapel, and ' 
 enjoyed much of their company. This circum- 
 
19 
 
 >m arbnnrf 
 lourn like 
 vas to me 
 ' occasion, 
 
 belief to 
 to re-coti- 
 and eVen 
 plforming 
 ccording- 
 d prayer, 
 
 truth to 
 
 haven of 
 
 I in long 
 
 ; thence 
 a Hospi- 
 Provost, 
 
 the first 
 A. Kem- 
 ngly ed- 
 npressed 
 that, in 
 introdii- 
 tit in St. 
 oiirtesy, 
 
 to the 
 on med- 
 
 s a mi's- 
 
 ;ircum. 
 
 stance contributed to keep my religion* principles 
 alive. J, 
 
 Some of the worts of Doctor Priestley having 
 fallen into nay hands, I examined his evidences di 
 the truth of Revealed Religion with great atten- 
 tion. They threw much ligh't upon the subjeqi, 
 and dissipated many of my doubts. 
 
 During my long sickness in London, I had con- 
 templated, as already related, dedicating np^y self 
 •to God by a formal act. Several obstacies had 
 hitherto conspired to retard the execution of th^s 
 design, but, I now resolved to delay it no Ipnger. 
 I, accordingly drew up a Fomtt and having with 
 jtnuch care brought it to tlie perfection I wisl^ed, J. 
 t>orrawed the use qf the Moravian Chapel for th.e 
 occasion, and on the 1st of Janizary 1803, | ^n^ 
 tered it with a lighted candle before day, and hav- 
 ing read my solemn Covenant, I signed ^nd: sx?aJ- 
 ed it. 
 
 I HAD not been long in ^ this Island, befojQ I 
 projected and contributed t;o found a QhariUiible 
 JnSkitution for the relief of ppor and destitute chil- 
 dren. The history of this Est,ab|Ushm€nt has been 
 given to the public. The Comnfiittee of Superin- 
 tendence were solicitous that I should take charge 
 of it-—ai)d having persuaded n\^ to resign my ap- 
 pointment upon the Hospital Staff, 1 yielded to 
 their inclinations. I governed this Institution for 
 two years, and wa-s, I believe, under Di\'ine Pro- 
 vidence, the hun>ble means of rescuing many a 
 poor child from vice and misery, and bestowing 
 jon him the benefits of a virtuous education. 
 
 While in the e^^ercise of this charge, I met 
 with the Sermons of Massillop, which I read with 
 uncommon interest, J found in this inimitable 
 Preacher^ an unction which penetrated to the 
 mu% ^rom the moral of this eloquent Prelate, 
 
 C 2 
 
Ill 
 
 \'rM 
 
 m 
 
 Mji' 
 
 £0 
 
 Pofk^i- ■ ^. . ^ """ resolution to continiiP mir 
 
 .. £'"„s »"'" rr ''""'"-•■''■•J "» 
 
 Lf^t ^°"^^""S on madness. I hardly nraved 
 
 Her behalf R f .t" i""" ^"''^ "^ "'« ^""'heon 
 comrriHTr lu ^"® ^"'"^^ "•"<:'' had been 
 sufflc ent to cool my enthusiasm. I contrasted 
 
 the Gatho ,V P •..'°"l*'""y °f '^^ Professors of 
 ■ e^k^ndtJ-^A '"''^ -cheerfully submitted to 
 All iMa u '" ?«v°"on to their Religion _ 
 t^l^A "^^ ■'^y""'' '''« •■each of hypocrifv a^ 
 excued a powerful re-action in n.y ,^f„d ' ' ""' 
 
 inth/° f^^y P^';? ""y q"0'a of the general tax 
 
 "^s ' r,tTT°^ "''""'' ?''"™'"g fit^ of sic". 
 tl«7r . V,^^ ? **' '" '"eh a state of debility 
 Tn. > r^ '''''■§^'^ *° relinqnish my charge of he 
 
 Smate "f '"^ T^ "^ '"«' ''^^'th in ,^J „at ve 
 climate. E arrived at Boston in May. I Ll now 
 Iiappily the means of hr.n,,i„„ .u„ T...f "^" ."."f 
 
'' which he 
 he was so 
 either that 
 was not of 
 that M as- 
 ms of the 
 ion of the 
 itinue my 
 ^e should 
 
 ilated me 
 lent, wag 
 evolution, 
 was that 
 in it with 
 K prayed 
 bh'c- and 
 Pantheon 
 irs shew- 
 ad been 
 lore than 
 >ntrasted 
 5ic cour- 
 essors of 
 litted to 
 igion.—r 
 isy, and 
 
 eral tax 
 V^est In- 
 of sick- 
 lebility, 
 J of the 
 ^ native 
 ad now 
 I whicli 
 
 had long agitated my mind, to a decision. There 
 was in this town a Catholic Church, and Catholic 
 Priests to hear and answer my enquiries. I imme- 
 diately addressed myself to the Reverend Mr. 
 Cheverus, then the assistant Minister, but since 
 raised by his wonderful merit to the Episcopacy, 
 with the title of Bishop qf Boston, He received 
 me with great kindness, and introduced me to his 
 Colleague, the late Reverend Doctor Matignon. 
 I found m Mr. Ciieverus a man of uncommon zeal 
 and uncommon talents. He had acquired a critic- 
 al knowledge of the English language, and preach- 
 ed to the delight and edification ot all who heard 
 him. In Doctor Matignon I discovered a man of 
 equal zeal and extraordinary piety, mingled with 
 the most captivating suavity of manners. They 
 ^ lived in habits of friendship with the principal in- 
 habitants of Boston— and the various Protestant 
 Ministers of the neighbourhood were delight ' to 
 assist at the consecration of their new and beauti- 
 ful Church. 
 
 Among other works, Mr. Cheverus put into my 
 hands a httle book of which I had been long in 
 quest— Bossuet's Ka^osition of the doctrine (if the 
 Catholic Church in matters oj Controversy. This 
 celebrated writer, the famous historian Gibbon aa- 
 serts to have achieved his conversion, and he adds 
 by way of consolation, that he *^ surely fell by a 
 noble hand." 1 read this tract with much inter- 
 est, and found it luminous, candid and convin- 
 cing. To this succeeded many other pieces of a 
 similar description. • 
 
 I REMOVED to Salem, and continued my.corres. 
 pondence with Mr. Cheverus, at intervals, for four 
 years. I had read and reflected enough to aban, 
 dun all hope of finding satisfaction in anv Protes= 
 tant communion : but still my scruples with re- 
 
 
pifuid to the Catholic Faith were not resolved. 1 
 
 had detjernuncU to take nothing upon trust and 
 
 during our controversy, every article of CathoHc 
 doctrine passed the ordeal of a critical exanv 
 ination. I hai) not much dilliculty with regard to 
 the Sacrifice of'tfie Mans, and the Real Vrescnce (jf 
 Christ in the Eucharist — although I did not much 
 inMx the terra TransubstantiaUon. i had more 
 with regard to the existence of Purgatory ^ whi h 
 appeared to be of Pagan origin. The w vship aj- 
 80 oi Maryi and the Saints, as well as \\\v. vei era- 
 tion of Relics and Images struck mc< :-■ both irra- 
 tional and unscriptural. ;^ ,,..^ , 
 
 It is worthy of remark that one of the greatest 
 difltculties which I had to overcome was not of 
 Protestant growth. 'J^his was the doctrine- of the 
 Trinity. I saw no tenet in any system of religion 
 apparently more repugnant to reason xmd scrips 
 ture than this. 1 had applied to the best com- 
 mentators for relief, but they had all left the sub- 
 ject m my mind darkened with new obscurities. 
 This will ever be the case when men undertake to 
 measure Divinity by a scale of humanity, and to 
 sound depths unfathomable by the human under^ 
 standing. 
 
 On the other hand, there were anti.cathohc 
 tenets, whose belief I cherished with fond pertina- 
 x'ity. The principal of these was the doctrine, 
 which, however varied u^ ''.^'^rent appellations, is 
 essentially the same-?-! ic^an the Faic of Seneca 
 with the ancient Stoics—the Predestination of 
 President Edwards with the Calvinists— and the 
 Philosophical Necessity of Doctor Priestley with 
 the Socinians. I took leave of this dogma with 
 reluctance — and even since my conversion have 
 laboured, by pressing St. Austin into the service, 
 
 to iMpnrnnrijf^ f-hla latrorifo fonaf «T.'fU r^„*^U>»i:^:4.. 
 
 ~:s^-iv±:s g jUfi4 !_ ' j» '' M « 
 
f9 
 
 jsolved. i 
 trust — and 
 )f Catholic 
 ical cxani- 
 1 regard to 
 l^resence of 
 1 not mucli 
 
 had more 
 orj/f which 
 ^'cvship aj- 
 hn vei^era- 
 
 .both irra- 
 
 - ■■y .»■' 
 le greatest 
 vas not of 
 ineof the 
 >f religion 
 iiid scrip- 
 :>est com- 
 t the sub- 
 bscuritiea^ 
 lertake to 
 }% and to 
 ui uQderi> 
 
 i,-cathohe 
 I pertina^ 
 doctrine, 
 latioiis, is 
 f Seneca 
 nation of 
 -and the 
 :ley with 
 ^ma witli 
 ion have 
 5 service. 
 
 I NEED not recapitulate the arguments whicf^ 
 drculated between me and my Itatned correspon- 
 dent, in this most momentous of nil discussions^ 
 because th«^ substance of them will be incorpora- 
 ted with the following pages. Suffice it to observe^ 
 that after an obstinate contest I began to gi\'e 
 way ; and in a short time afterward announced 
 mv suiTender, and proposed to enter rlirectly into 
 ffcliowship with the CathoHc Church. This, how- 
 ever, was a more serious measure than I had ima- 
 gined. My correspondent desired 1 would take 
 more time, — and urged the necessity of some im- 
 portant preparatory steps. During this delay, new 
 scruples tormented me, which I Irankly imparted 
 to Mr. Cheverus, who answered them in the most 
 affectionate terms, which marked neither chagrin 
 nor disappointment. 
 
 The controversy, however, was soon to close. 
 I had exhausted every source of argument in my 
 power against the doctrines of the Catholic Church, 
 and I now saw that I could not, with any consis- 
 tency, reject them, if I professed myself a Chris- 
 tain. There still remained to me, nevertheless, 
 one resource — that of Dtism, and a steady d(?niai 
 of supernatural Revelation. But again to remove 
 from the pale of every visible Church, was a mel- 
 ancholy alternatrve, and I wished to avoid it. At 
 every step in this all-important enquiry, more and 
 more light was shed upon my path ; and at length ' 
 I perceived, that to resist any longer, were wilful 
 and unpardonable obstinacy. I accordingly ap- 
 prised my correspondent of my final conversion to ' 
 the Catholic Faith. After some preliminary in- 
 structions, followed by a general confession at the 
 feet of Mr. Cheverus, I made my first communion 
 ijni the Church of the Holy Cross in Boston, at the 
 Festival of i^ntecost, May i^lst, 1801). In this 
 
m^ 
 
 mtcresting ceremony I was accompanied by mf 
 \Vife. and Elizabeth King, a late pupil of the In- 
 
 wlsUmiils "" ^ ^''^^ ^'''"^^^' '''^^' ™^ ^'''"' ^^^' 
 Soo>^ afterward I was invited to settle in tower 
 Canada. Nothing could be more seasonable and 
 to my taste, than this overture. Accordingly hav- 
 ing made the necessary arrangements, I took leave 
 ot my friends, and departing with my family, ar- 
 lived on the iSth of June at Montreal. 
 
 J BiiouGHT and exhibited on my arrival, the fol- 
 lowing ve.y flattering testimonial, which Mr. Che- 
 verus had given me with his Valedictory Bles- 
 
 Sing. 
 
 Omnibus, &c. &c. 
 Ego infrd Scriptus in Nov^-Anglii Missionarius 
 Apostohcus testor dilectum Stephanum Cleveland 
 Ulyth, arta Medicum, inter Protestantes riatum et 
 educatum, divina juvante gratia, fidem Catholicam 
 sumina pictate amplexum fuisse. Die Pentecostis 
 Ultima, Pane vita3 primu vice refectus est. In 
 ftciei professione et sacramentorum paiticipatione 
 Socias habuit dilectam ipsius conjugem necnon et 
 pupillam ipsius tutelas commissam quae ipsius exem- 
 phs et documentis ad Sanctum Kcclesiam Caiholi- 
 cam suaviter et fortiter attracts sunt. Ilium abe- 
 untem sincero prosequi desiderio et ut charissimum 
 in Christo fratrem ut virum pictate et zelo religio- 
 nis msignem. Ecclesiarum Pastoribus et Omnibus 
 iibique Catholics fidei prolessoribus commenda- 
 tum velim. 
 
 Datam Bostonii in Nova-Aughi quarto Calen- 
 das Junii 1809. 
 
 Joannes Cheverus;, Sacerdos, 
 _ Idem testo/, 
 
 Francisci/s a. Matignon, Vic, Gen, 
 
ied hy my 
 of the In- 
 e from the 
 
 J in Lower 
 enable and 
 lingly hav- 
 took leave 
 family, ar- 
 
 al, the fol- 
 
 Mr. Che- 
 
 tory Bles- 
 
 ssionanus 
 Cleveland 
 natum et 
 atholicam 
 sntecostis 
 
 est. In 
 cipatione 
 lecnon et 
 ius exem- 
 
 Caxholi- 
 lum abe- 
 rissimum 
 o religio- 
 Omnibus 
 nmenda- 
 
 ) Calen- 
 
 erdos. 
 
 25 
 
 I COULD not offer an English version of this doc- 
 ument, without incurring the imputation of van- 
 ity. 
 
 In November of the same year, I established 
 myself in the practice of Physic at fioucher- 
 ville, a pleasant Village on the St Lawrence, 
 nine miles below Montreal. I was confirmed by 
 M. Plessis, Bishop of Quebec, August 30th, 1810, 
 and superadded to my own the holy name of Saint 
 Francis of Salis. I conclude this little biograph- 
 ical sketch by observing, that in obedience to the 
 injunction jf this eminent Saint to enter into the 
 Confraternity of the place where we live, I sought 
 and obtained admission into the Congregation of 
 the Blessed Virgin, at their Festival of August 
 $^5tli, 1814. 
 
 The present Tract, of which I invite the peru- 
 sal, has already passed through one edition. It 
 was favourably received and extensively circula- 
 ted. This honor has tempted me to renew my 
 labours ; with what success (as the matter is dif- 
 ferently methodized,) the event can alone deter- 
 mine. 
 
 In palliation of ite faulty, and in deprecation of 
 criticism, it will, I trust, be sufficient to state, 
 that my Pamphlet was composed amid the calls of 
 an importunate profession, in the languor of dis- 
 ease, and under the pressure of mijifbrtune :— cir- 
 cumstances which would, in the humane minds of 
 my readers atone, I am persuaded, for grievances 
 «f uglier hue, and of greater magnitude. 
 
 STEPHANUS SOLYMIENSIS. 
 Nov-Anglorum. 
 
-'1 
 
 tit li 
 
SECOND, 
 
 «m. 
 
 111 
 
 i 
 
 IGNORANCE, although very properly con- 
 trasted with Truth and Knowledge, is not howev- 
 er their worst enemy. There is a greater, and that 
 is Prejudice. 
 
 There is, it may be safely presumed, no quali- 
 ty of the human Mind, native or acquired, more 
 base in its origin — more rapid in its growth— more 
 active in its operations — more tragical in its ef- 
 fects — in short, more dissocial and cruel in its char- 
 acter, than Prejudice. As it is of the most ma- 
 lignant, so it is also of the most singular cast.— 
 Other vices and follies are limited in their nature, 
 and require proper recipients. Some assault the 
 rich ; others, the poor : — Some, the high ; others, 
 the low : — Some, the young ; others, the old :— 
 Some, the male sex ; others, the female. But Pre- 
 judice has no choice either of place or company^ 
 It finds access every where. — It penetrates the in* 
 most recesses of the mind. — It bursts every bar- 
 rier. — It surmounts every obstacle. — It is equally 
 
 and country— in an Indian. 
 D2 
 
 Mi 
 
 iiUUiU, 
 
 111 iuWU 
 
28 
 
 Wigwam, and in the Palace of an Emperor -All 
 
 prietv Ztrr't '' "'1^'°''' wUh m'l^^Tpl" 
 Pnety, that it has been called by an eminent no 
 
 been mn,? I ■" ^ ',""■".''• *'"'' ^^"""^^er reason, has 
 
 and Ifit I ^^.^ P"^*""' J" '-■'""" the number 
 
 Tiers whi h ;" "r*"'" • "'^ ""^ """•"'' °f ■"'""- 
 tiers wuch have been invented to blacken l.Pr 
 
 e^nce, would be a task beyond mv strenirth. So 
 lo-K Lave they been in circi.latio.,_propacated 
 
 with :a t'Z"""' ■"''""'■^'' """ •"-'- 
 
 witn such tenacious constaucv, that few even 
 among the most liberal and cam! d of our Protes 
 
 SeS:n'ron%r^ '"'' ''"T •'°'- -K-cIou.: prt 
 possessions on this score. On everv othpr cnKiLf 
 
 Cran ,'^iTr"'"'»8 >-°" "hlJ ate ta 
 haish and intolerant. Gross as are the i ntrutiK 
 
 tZdTtifj'^'r""''"^' "'°' ''etectedtd S 
 ed Need r rf T'' ""^y "^« >""' believ. 
 
 sand who hear the calumnies, there is scarrelv «.,« 
 who learns their refutali, n aIaV, sC'>r«-Iy one 
 «n«<! f,<,. „• 1 'y"'"'""- Ana it by sonic who 
 
 Sir ..T""'f,' «^<="!"^<"•. Catholic evidence 
 i-liould be casually and slightly inspected Pren 
 
 .«a that w th such fertility of mischief; that where 
 substance is wantipg. it can thrive iipon ou X 
 
 festait Rri '"'^^"'ne more to render onr Pro- 
 than a I 1^, !'i"'" ^''"°''? *? ^^""'•'''■c testimony. 
 "Names /aid ?r'"A "^ "'" ^"^'^^^^^ ""i'^J 
 
 ed. n^, „".' *!5"."°1"= Clunjch been condemn. 
 , -.—.. v^-^,a.ictnuence and without a hearing. 
 
iror — All 
 Hich pro- 
 linent po. 
 
 ason, has 
 perseci^ 
 3 number 
 of slan- 
 :ken her 
 \\y influ' 
 gth. So 
 opagated 
 lintairied 
 w, even 
 ' Protest 
 ious pre^ 
 subject, 
 (, blind, 
 jntrutha 
 and ex- 
 belie v- 
 a tlioii- 
 x^Iy one 
 mo who 
 vidence 
 Preju- 
 istort^^. 
 
 t where 
 
 sounds, 
 
 lest of- 
 
 'rucr/Lv, 
 
 n Pro- 
 
 iraony, 
 
 united. 
 
 orJd.'* 
 
 denin- 
 
 ?ar 
 
 jng. 
 
 29 
 
 Her eneniieii tmvc furnished brtth text and com. 
 meht^ry-^ahdh.r Creed and Discipline have^in 
 
 slnhaJ']?. I' rt "'t^^^°"^^ ^^^''^ a metamorpho" 
 s^s, that Catholics no longer recognize their own 
 
 Religion. In fine, the pencil of Malice has t7a^ 
 ced not a Portrait, but a Caricature. 
 
 iHis cucumstaiice nevertheless, stranffe as it 
 may seem, by that wbnderful Pro;idence^ wh^h 
 in the language of the Poet of the Seasons. ' 
 
 **From seminj^ ml, still cUuciqg ^ooaf," 
 
 has aided th6 best interests of Catholicity, and oc- 
 casioned many Conversions. For sincere enauT 
 m>s strapping the Catholic Church of this uTly 
 mask, are so struck with her native dign tv and 
 beau y^and the astonishing contrast between the 
 
 iieacfiery of which they have h therto been the 
 victuns, they fly to this'arK of truth and safety 
 and are happy to live and die in her Communion 
 Keconciled myself to the Religion ofourcZ* 
 mn Ancestors, /may be pardoneTrl ^sh the 
 same happiness to others. Vith these sen^ J,ents 
 andas a propei- sequel to th6 history of my Sr 
 
 trln^A^'TV/^^ ^'^'' ^" ^^^^^e o?tlie Dot 
 tunes to which I am a Convert, against the nonn 
 lar cavils, which the zealots of thf a^fare a^s^S ' 
 
 pThiri'T r' "^'^' '^ ''^ se^crnratd 
 
 pe^rhap3 to the destruction, of our weaker breth- 
 
 torv\n!f ''''"''"^ ""^ ?" P^f^^^^' the most satisfac. 
 
 CafhohV nrT''^ ^'7 ^^ '^' ^«^t""^s of the 
 catholic Church, may be found in the Profe- Jnn 
 
 tirt^'^^T^ ''''^ '''' Decrees of t&^^^^ 
 ^JT^J:'^'^^ ^^^ commonly called the " 
 
 The Council of Trent was assembled from all 
 
so 
 
 parts of Christendom, soon after that famous re- 
 volt from the Church, generally called the Ag^or- 
 mation, an event which deluged Europe with so 
 many calamities, and which she has still so much 
 reason to lament. It was one of the most numer- 
 ou,, as well as one of the most virtuous, wise and 
 learned Assen^blies ever convened in the Chris- 
 - tian world : and its object was the condemnation 
 of the recent Heresies of Luther and Calvin. 
 
 "I S. C. B., with a firm Faith, believe and pro- 
 fess all and every one of those things which are 
 contained in that Creed, which the Holy Roman 
 Church maketh use of: To Wit . ' 
 
 I BELIEVE in one God, the Father Almighty, 
 Maker of Heaven and Earth, and of all things 
 visible and invisible — And in one Lord Jesus 
 Christ, the only begotten Son of God, and born of 
 the Father before all ages— God of God, Light of 
 Light, True God of True God: begotten not 
 made ; consubstantial to the Father, by whom all 
 things were made : who for us Men, and for our 
 Salvation, came down from Heaven, and was in- 
 carnate by the Holy Ghost of the Virgin Mary, 
 and was made Man. Was crucified also for us 
 under Pontius Pilate : he suffered and was buri- 
 ed : and the third day he rose again, according to 
 the Scriptures ; he ascended into Heaven ; sits 
 at the right hand of the Father, and is to come 
 again with glory to judge both the living and the 
 dead, of whose Kingdom there shall be no end.— . 
 Anp in the Holy Ghost, the Lord and Giver of 
 Life, who proceedeth from the Father and the Son, 
 who begotten with the Father and the Son is ado- 
 red and glorified, who spake by the Prophets..— 
 
 And I believe On6 Holy Catholic and Apos- 
 tolic Church : I confess one Baptism for the re- 
 
 
 
 
 
 T 
 
 
 Kesurrec* 
 
famous re- 
 1 the b^i^T' 
 rope with so 
 ttill so much 
 nost nuDier- 
 us, wise and 
 1 the Chiis- 
 iidemnation 
 Calvin. 
 Jve and pro- 
 
 which are 
 [oly Roman 
 
 Almighty, 
 ' all things 
 Lord Jesus 
 and born of 
 •d, Light of 
 Jgotten not 
 y whom all 
 and for our 
 and was in- 
 rgin Mary, 
 
 also for us 
 d was buri- 
 :cording to 
 aven ; sits 
 
 is to come 
 ng and the 
 
 no end.— 
 d Giver of 
 id the Son, 
 5on is ado- 
 phets.-^ 
 and Apos- 
 for the re- 
 
 Hesurrec* 
 
 M 
 
 tion of the Dead, and the life of the world to 
 come. — 
 
 I MOST steadfastly admit and embrace all Apos- 
 tolical and Ecclesiastical Traditions, and all oth- 
 er Observances and Constitutions of the same 
 Church.— 
 
 I ALSO admit the Holy Scriptures, according to 
 the Sense which our Holy Mother the Church, 
 has held and does hold, to which it belongs to 
 judge of the true sense and interpretation of the 
 Scriptures : neither will I ever take and interpret 
 them otherwise than according to the unanimous 
 sense of the Fathers. — 
 
 I ALSO profess that there are truly and properly 
 Seven Sacraments of the New Law instituted by 
 ^esus Christ, and necessary for the Salvation of 
 Mankind : though not all for every one : to wit. 
 Baptism, Confirmation, The Eucharist, Penance, 
 Extreme Unction, Orders, and Matrimony: and 
 that they coafer Grace : and that of these, Bap- 
 tism, Confirmation and Orders cannot be reitera- 
 ted without Sacrilege. — 
 
 I ALSO receive and admit the received and ap- 
 proved Ceremonies of the Catholic Church, em- 
 ployed in the solemn administration of the afore- 
 said Sacraments.— 
 
 I EMBRACE and receive all and every one of the 
 things which have been defined and declared in 
 the Holy Council of Trent, concerning Original 
 Sin, and Satisfaction.-^ 
 
 I PROFESS likewise that in the Mass there is of- 
 fered to Uod, a true, proper and propitiatory Sac- 
 rifice for the living and the dead. — 
 
 And that in the Most Holy Sacrament of the 
 Eucharist, there is truly, really and substantially 
 the Body and JBlood, together with the Soul and 
 divinity of our Lord Jesus Christ : and that there 
 
'hi " 
 
 3i 
 
 S ""°. the Body and the ^^fne into the 
 ?«SSi::£^ the,Cath.«o Church, cX 
 
 amlthTM^"^",'^'' '.'•'' ther^f^'S Purgatory: 
 
 .h„ i ff ^ ^"1''* ""^*«"' detained- are helned W 
 the suffrage of the faithful.— ^ ^ 
 
 ,f,„ V '° ^^ honored and invocated : and that 
 Ihey offer prayers to Gqd for us, and that the/J 
 ft^.c8 are to be held in venemtion.- ' ' ' - 
 
 rf Sn^""'^ T/' *.'"" *'** ^""K^^ of Christ-, 
 othir s^^ ^' °5 *^°''' ever Virgin- and also of 
 o^herSa.n^, ought to be had and retained : an^ 
 
 I ALSO aiSrm that the Power of Tmliiraeii^I 
 was left by Christ to the Church ; and^K dj 
 .thenl ,s most beneficial to Christian peopr- 
 
 1 ACKNowLEDCE the HoIy, CathoKc, Apostolic 
 rfalfrZ ?"'"'' for the^Mother a d mS 
 to fh. r! ''' /"u ^ P'T'^e true obedience 
 t^ Pnn^i °/.>°^ !^°'"^' Successor to St, .Pe. 
 Chrisi!!! ^ ^^'^^^ ""'' Vic^rpf Jesus 
 
 nthli^'ff'^"^ ^undoubtedly receive and, profers all 
 thP S, '!?! ' '''''^"■'•*' '^^^"ed and declared by 
 the Sacred Canons and General Councils, and Oar 
 Ucularly by the Holy Cou.xil of Trent 1- ^ 
 thil? condemn, reject and anathematise all 
 thmgs eonttary thereto : and all Heresies which 
 matiid ''*' *=<""*'''"°ed. rejected and anathe. 
 
 * iwfs ■tvi JUff 
 
 do at this time freely profess and sio. 
 
 ■- n i r ii n ii m I i ,, i 
 
tance of thc^ 
 le into the 
 'hurch c»lls 
 
 iind alone, 
 and a true 
 
 Purgatory : 
 : lieljfied by 
 
 getter With 
 : and that 
 that tli^Jr 
 
 >f Christ-^ 
 ind also of 
 md : arid 
 > be giye^ 
 
 dulgehces 
 the use of 
 )Ie.— 
 Apostph'c 
 Mistress 
 jbedience 
 ' St. J?ei 
 Qi Jmis 
 
 >rofe?s all 
 :lared by 
 ,apd pal- 
 latise all 
 es which 
 anathe« 
 
 and sin** 
 
 cereiy hold the true Catholic Faith, without which 
 no one can be saved : and I promise most con- 
 stant y to retain and confess the same entire and 
 inviolable, with God's assistance, to the end of my 
 
 This and this only is the Catholic Faith. And 
 he >yho subscribes to its belief, and who leads a 
 hie in conformity to its dictates, is a Catholic 
 Christian and an heir of Salvation. 
 
 isjow let any dispassionate enquirer review thi« 
 
 Creec^with calmness and candor— with a spirit of 
 
 ove and meekness-and then ask himselt' what 
 
 there is m it to stagger his confidence and preclude 
 
 his assent ? And would he believe, if sober histow 
 
 Zf'v T """"'^ *'''/'^*' *^^^ ^" opposition to 
 this Faith, ancient and Apostolical as it is, should 
 
 ^ave engendered insurrections, wars and slaughter ; 
 and that in order to overcome it, and to substitute 
 the ravings and chimaeras of ambitious madmen, 
 .he Daemon of Schism and Heresy should have 
 with blood r ' ^"^ crimsoned whole lands 
 
 In the first place this Profession of Faith con- 
 tains all ike essential and necessary Articles of the 
 Christian Rehgzon, This our adversaries admit. 
 And should It be doubted for an instant, the hon- 
 est enquirer has only to examine the confessions 
 ot the various Protestant Communions, and he will 
 Unci that their Fundamental Articles are in exact 
 consent with the Nicene Creed, which makes the 
 first part of the Cathohc Profession of Faith. In- 
 Mm '^ ^^^" adopted in most Churches 'ver^ 
 
 ^ But to put this matter beyond all dispute, let 
 mm peruse a document which we quote from the 
 uukeof Brunswick's «*Fiffev Rpasnns » «n^ «>:.;«ij 
 t'ontams the Decision of the Faculty of Helrostadt, 
 
34 
 
 (a famous Lutheran University in Germany) and 
 he will be surprised with an illustrious testimony 
 of the purity of Catholic Doctrine. ^ 
 
 It appears* that the opinion of the Faculty of 
 Divinity in this University was asked on the fol- 
 lowing Question— «*Whether a Protestant Prin- 
 cesa, destined to marry a Catholic Prince, may 
 with a safe conscience embrace the Catlwlic Ke- 
 ligion.** 
 
 The Faculty begin their answer hy saying that 
 • the Question propounded cannot solidly be sol- 
 ved, without deciding first, whether or no the 
 Catholics are in Fundamental Errors, and such as 
 are opposite to Salvation?" "Our answer (say 
 they) is without hesitation in the Affirmative— i?/- 
 cause the Catholics are at the bottom of the same 
 Religion with w^/and have the necessary faith to 
 know God, in order to Salvation. For the foun- 
 dation of Religion and a Christian life is the be- 
 lief of God the Father, our Creator, of God the 
 Son, the Messiah ; who had been promised, and 
 has delivered us from Sin, Death, the Devil and 
 Hell : and of the Holy Ghost, who enlightens us. 
 We mpst also admit the ten Commandments of 
 God, which teach us our duty to God and to our 
 Neighbor : the Lord's Prayer, which instructs ns 
 how to pray : the practice of the Sacraments of 
 iJaptism and the Lord's Supper, according to 
 Christ's Institution and Command. Moreover, 
 we must acknowledge the power of the Keys' 
 and believe with therm that God has given in the 
 Church to the Apostles and their Successors in 
 Apostolical functions, the authority of declarine: 
 to penitents, that their ISins are forgiven ; and to 
 denounce to the impenitent, God's hatred against 
 them, and what iude-ments Hp nrpnnrf^c f/^r *K^rv. 
 and so eitl^er to remit or retain 6'/n*— and therefore 
 
35 
 
 ^miiny) and 
 testimony 
 
 « 
 Faculty of 
 m the fol- 
 tant Prin- 
 rince, may 
 Ulwlic lie- 
 saying that 
 dly be sol- 
 or no the 
 nd such as 
 iswer (say 
 itive — Be- 
 f the same 
 ry faith io 
 the foun- 
 ts the be* 
 God the 
 lised, and 
 )evil and 
 jhtens us. 
 iments of 
 nd to our 
 structs us 
 iments of 
 •rdin^ to 
 loreover, 
 he Keys^ 
 en in the 
 essors in 
 ieclaring 
 r and to 
 i against 
 
 /AT" *Kt»rv» 
 
 therefore 
 
 tt'tf somelimes repair to the Confession chair to re- 
 0eive Absolution of our Sins" 
 
 They proceed in a similar strain, and in one place 
 they say " Neither can it be denied, that the Roman 
 Church is a true Church, wherein the ministry of 
 God's word, and the use of the Sacraments sub- 
 sist, for if it were no more, or had not been a true 
 Church, all its members would be in a state of 
 damnation, and irrecoverably lost, which none 
 amongst us would dare to advance. Nay, Malanc- 
 thpn himself has maintained, that the Roman 
 Church did not cease being a true Church, because 
 the word of God was sufficiently taught in the di- 
 vers parts of the Catechism, which contains the 
 ten Commandments, the Creed, and tfie Lord's 
 Prayer, and in the service of Baptism, and the 
 Epistles and Gospels that are read on Sundays." 
 They finally decide the Question in this manner — 
 «* Having demonstrated that the foundation of 
 Religion subsists in the Roman Catholic Church, 
 so that one may be orthoddK and live and die well, 
 and obtain Salvation in it — it is easy to decide the 
 question propounded. The most serene Princess 
 may in consideration of her marriage, embrace the 
 Catholic Religion." 
 
 Can any thing be more satisfactory than all 
 this ? 
 
 It is matter for curious speculation, with what 
 anxiety the authors of this Document, by the man- 
 ner in which they speak of the power of the Keys — 
 Apostolical SuiCessfon-^Covfession — Remission of 
 Sins, S^c, labor to approximate their own Confes- 
 sion of Faith to the Catholic — aware that the Ar- 
 ticles wTiich the Reformers had rejected, were as* 
 well warranted by Scripture as those which they 
 retained. • 
 
 " When a man ('savs the crpflt. "Rnssnpt^ fivps-. 
 
 E 2 
 
56 
 
 fori model of doS ?i„^,°"'i'-''""^ ""'' ""'' 
 about to „,ake a crp'r/tion'^r^o; ^J,^ T^^ST 
 
 he always says something wh.ch he wm M L.'^"""' 
 and afterwarih Aiic ,»,♦ ® «""*-» ne would not say, 
 
 discussion of the sZr^ 1.^.^ '"T^l "^ *" » 
 this Profession of I'alth T "''"='' co-^Pose 
 
 -alysis and ^sS of' S" ttThir"' 
 
 urged aStrhlXter^rSVt^^^^^^^ 
 tendom, before th^ moi- c ^'^^^" <^r all Chris- 
 
 .e«w.« siKrtt"^L'd''o;7v'^r^^^^ 
 
 jonty of the Christian worid. Happy Vt T 
 
 believe, we will bestow Jfl ^'fi'^" do not 
 wluch they Jbelieve '''"^' "P°° «"« 
 
 cious boon' KlilZ-^« -'^ ^« P- 
 
87 
 
 This most subiinie and benevolent of all pur- 
 poses was to be accomplished by His Assumption 
 of our nature — by His Precepts, Example, Mira- 
 cles, I'assion, Death, Resurrection, Ascension and 
 perpetual Intercession. 
 
 The channel through which His Graces were to 
 be communicated to us, was a Church ; which, by 
 commemorating His Sacrifice on the Cross, and 
 applying His Sacraments to human exigency, was 
 predestined to secure Salvation to all true Peni- 
 tents who should be found in her bosom. 
 
 Now, it is obviously and most imperiously the 
 duty of every Soul living, to be associated to this 
 Church, wherever it he. But this is impossible, 
 unless it be known. Therefore, all Tradition, oral 
 and Scriptural, has assigned certain marks and fea- 
 tures to identify and distinguish it, which are aa 
 prominent and palpable as the King's head upon 
 the national coin. 
 
 She is One. She is Holy, She is Catholic ox 
 Universal She is Apostolical, 
 
 Among the thousand Sects, heteroclite and het- 
 erogeneous, engendered by the Reformation, cai^ 
 one be named which possesses these traits of the 
 true Church of Christ ?— -Certainly not. Many 
 boast them. But few possess any of these fea- 
 tures, and not a single one can challenge them 
 collectively. 
 
 The more accurately we survey the various 
 Protestant Communions at large throughout Eu- 
 rope and America, the -result will be the more un^ 
 propitious to these lofty pretensions. They all re- 
 pose with tranquil recumbence upon merely ficti- 
 tious titles to legitimacy. 
 
 ^^viNG thus evidently shewn where the true 
 Church of Christ is not, we will shortly exhibit 
 Wiiere she w. 
 
38 
 
 The first Article of controversy, relates to Jms 
 toheal and Ecclesiastical Traditions. ^ 
 
 iHE Catholic Cl^urch has been accused of im- 
 posing articles of faith and ruler of practice m 
 known to Christ and his Apostles, aKrwar." 
 lanted by either Reason or Scripture. 
 
 In answer to this objection, we may observe 
 that if our Protestant Brethren are opposed to Tra' 
 dition as suck they must take leave of Keli^rion 
 aItogether-.for all Religion is Traditional The 
 Patriarchal, Jewiali and Christian Covenants were 
 Revelations to those to whom they were immedi- 
 ately addressed, but are only traditional to their 
 postenty. * 
 
 Great stress has been laid upon the difference 
 between the Bible which our Protestant Brethren 
 call (and that truly) the Word of God, and other 
 Traditions, of which slie is the Guardian and 
 Irustee. 
 
 J^iiERE is however, no essential difference be- 
 tween them The whole is tradition and the whol^ 
 IS the Word of God— and these Traditions, wheth! 
 er written or unwritten, are equally entitled to our 
 homage and obedience. 
 
 The Traditions of the Catholic Church com- 
 prehend the Bible— the works of 'the ancient Fath- 
 ers-the ancient Liturgies-the ancient monu- 
 ments—the universal practice of the Church— the 
 condemnation of ancient Heresies— the acts of 
 Councils— and the customs of Rome. 
 
 When Christ established his Church, as the eter- 
 nal depository of his Religion, not a line of the 
 New Testament was yet in writing : nor during 
 his residence on earth, did he write a syllable him- 
 seJl. All his instructions were colloquial. It 
 pleased indeed the Holy Spirit, after the events 
 much preceded, accomnaniprl nnri f,^^l/.«r«J u:.. 
 
 ***^^^^m^ 
 
, 3^ 
 
 l)ivine Mission, to inspire the chosen Apostles to 
 record them, in order to aid the infant interests of 
 Christianity, by publishing to the world the most 
 remarkable traits in the history and character of 
 this divine Religion. But though these writings 
 embrace the essentials, they were never intended 
 to record the subordinate points of faith and prac- 
 tice. Still less were they designed to be their own 
 interpreters^ or to leave the awful truths which are 
 the subject of them to private interpretation 
 
 That umvritten Tradition is competent to the 
 preservation and application of every Precept, 
 moral and ceremonial, of revealed Religion, is suf- 
 ficiently evident from the circumstance that from 
 the Creation of the world to the sera of Moses, a 
 period of two thousand five hundred years, there 
 was no Scripture at <7//,— yet there was no com- 
 plaint, nor even apprehension, that the rule of 
 faith was imperfect or obscure. 
 
 It is remarkable hdw our Protestant Brethren 
 are obliged, in spite of their professions, to do jus- 
 tice to the Traditions of tlie Church and forget 
 their Bible, when these are in question. Why do 
 they observe the Jirst day of the week, for pur- 
 poses of worship, instead of the se^veiith, instituted 
 by Jehovah himself, on Mount Sinai, and pro- 
 claimed m thunder and in flame ? Why do they 
 
 l^l^'""'^ ^'K'^'''^ ' "^'^y *^° ^^^^y baptize by effusion!^ 
 V\ hy do they not practice pediiuvium or foot^wasi 
 mg, so emphatically commanded by our Saviour ? 
 Ihe truth is, and it is a splendid triumph for Cath- 
 olicity, that all these observances, the adoption of 
 some and the rejection of others, are derived from 
 tlie Catholic Church and are a homage to her Tra- 
 ditions.— See Deut. xxxii. 7. Ps. wiii. a fi r, ^ 
 
 L^""'' o''-?' ^ ^^''''' "■• 1^-"^'- 6. 2 TimVi; 
 X3.-1U 2.-111. 14. . 
 
46 
 
 The iiext article relates to the Holy Scriptures. 
 Its tenor is more than sufficient to shield Catholics 
 from holding them in cheap estimation. It is true 
 indeed that with filial obedience, the Children of 
 the Universal Church submit to her judgment and 
 her's alone, the true sense and interpretation of 
 these divine Oracles. Suspending farther eluci- 
 dation however of this matter for the present, we 
 will refer it to the moment when we shall examine 
 the Protestant Rule of Faith. 
 
 The next Article relates to the Sacraments, 
 Which are seven in number. 1 Baptism. Q. Con- 
 frmalion. 3 The Eucharist. 4 Penance. 5 
 EaUreme Unction. 6 Orders. 7 Matrimony. 
 
 1. ^^i'r/^'ii/.— Against the matter and form of 
 this Sacrament, ol. Protestant Brethren urge a va- 
 nety of objections. The Quakers declare that 
 Baptism of water is not of divine institution. The 
 Anabaptists, that the baptismof Infants is without 
 Scriptural authority. The Socinians and others, 
 that It is no Sacrament, and is not necessary to 
 Salvation. "^ 
 
 On the contrary, we alledge that Catholic Bap- 
 tism has all the three conditions of a true Sacra- 
 ment. — 1. It is an outward visible sign— 2. It has 
 the power of imparting Grace— 3. It is of divine 
 ordination. We say that Baptism is of water.— 
 See Acts viii. 36. 38.-X. 47- 48. We assert that 
 the Baptism of Infants is an Evangelical ordin- 
 ance. See Luke xviii. KJ. John iii. 5. We af- 
 firm that it is necessary to Salvation, and for proof 
 refer to the last named text. 
 
 2. Confirmation. — This ceremony our Protes- 
 tant Brethren insist is no Sacrament, and is of 
 modern invention. 
 
 On the contrary, we declare that it possesses, in 
 common with Baptism, tlie three essential requi- 
 
41 
 
 Sites of a true Sacrament, and as such has been 
 adnainistered from the age of the Apostles, aa ap. 
 pears most evidently in the pages of Tertullian and 
 the Fathers. See Acts viii. 15, 1 7.-xix. 6. 2 Con 
 i.21. 22. Heb. vi. 2. 
 
 3. Tn^ Holy Evchahist, — This Sacrament i« 
 feo intimately connected with the Sacrifice of the 
 Mass, that we will discuss them presently together. 
 
 4. Penance,-^*' This (says the excellent Bish- 
 op Cballoner) is a Sacrament, by which the Faiths 
 ful that have fallen into sins, confessing the same 
 with a true repentance and a sincere purpose of 
 making satisfaction, are absolved from their Sins 
 by the Minister of God." Three things are re- 
 quired on the part of the Sinner, in order to ob- 
 tain Forgiveness and Absolution— viz : Contri* 
 tion. Confession and Satisfaction. 
 
 This Sacrament is declared by our Protestant 
 
 Jirethren to be an imposition on the vorld that 
 
 it has no foundation in either Reason or Scripture, 
 but is the invention of a lat^ date, in ord^r, as 
 Thomas Paine says of national Churches, « to ter^ 
 rify and enslave Mankind, and to monopolize pow- 
 er and proiit." i- i— 
 
 Qn the contrary, we are of opinion that those 
 who declaim in this manner, forget their own na- 
 ture, and the world in which they live. 
 
 The state of Man is a state ef ruin. He emer- 
 ges into existence defiled with native and heredi- 
 tary Sin, and under sentence of eternal death : 
 from which nothing can redeem him but the bloo4 
 of our Saviour, the Lord Jesus Christ, and its ap- 
 pbcation through the medium of the Sacraments 
 Which he has established in his Church. Of these, 
 Penance is one of the most important. « Except 
 ye do Penance (says he) ye shall all likewise uer, 
 Jsh." Those who cavii" at this doctiine of *the 
 
 F 
 
4? 
 
 Catholic Church, do not sufficiently reflect npon 
 their condition. Some wonder that a benevolent 
 Deity should impose sufferings upon his poor crea- 
 tures for involuntary transgressions. Others in- 
 sist that Clirist has sufficiently satisfied for Sin. 
 To the first class of objectors we urge that Man 
 is not now, what he once wa. He is fallen from 
 u state ^of Innocence into one of Guilt. Guilt en- 
 tails misery. Reason and the whole ceconomv of 
 God's moral government teach us with sufficient 
 certainty, that Sin and suffering in this life are in- 
 timately connected, and that the one follows the 
 other, as its penalty and its corrective. We are 
 not only Delinquents in a Prison j but we are Pa- 
 tients in a Hospitah As well may a sick man 
 murmur that a different diet is prescribed for him, 
 from one for another in sound health, as for mor- 
 tals to complain of the regimen which infinite wis- 
 dom and goodness have ordained for the cure of 
 our spiritual maladies, and to ensure our restora- 
 tion to primsfeval felicity. Ho\^ natural then it is, 
 to co-operate with this kind intention of Provi- 
 dence, and impose upon ourselves voluntary pain, 
 whenever the ordinary effects of our frailty and 
 wickedness appear insufficient for pardon and re- 
 formation ! 
 
 It is not the broad but the narrow path which 
 leads to Heaven. As Christ our Saviour bore his 
 Cross, we must also bear our's. He tells us ex- 
 pressly that unless we suffer, we cannot hope to 
 reign with him. Consequently, not only all the 
 unforeseen afflictions and calamities of life are to 
 be cheerfully endured, but we must occasionally 
 seek them. Not only pains, involuntary and ac- 
 cidental — but voluntary and elective, must be suf- 
 fered. It is onlv throup-h trials and *r»^»"la*>f>n« 
 that the diade:m of the Saint is won. 
 
4^ 
 
 jflect npOH 
 benevolent 
 i poor crea- 
 Others in- 
 id for Sin. 
 
 that Man 
 alien from 
 
 Guilt en- 
 conomy of 
 [i sufficient 
 life are in- 
 bllows the 
 . We are 
 we are Pa- 
 sick man 
 d for him, 
 iS for mor- 
 ifinite wis- 
 lie cure of 
 ir restora- 
 then it is, 
 of Provi- 
 tary pain, 
 railty and 
 )n and re- 
 
 ath which 
 r bore his 
 is us ex- 
 hope to 
 ly all the 
 life are to 
 :asionally 
 r and ac- 
 St be suf. 
 
 ihiilatinnia 
 
 To the second class of objectors we will reply 
 anon. 
 
 Confession, which is a requisite and a condi- 
 tion of Penance, is, independently of its Divinity, 
 one of the most admirable institutions that was 
 ever conceivecj for the good of man. In every 
 age, in every land, and among every description 
 of people, the Church has had and still has, the 
 happiness to see thousands of Sinners appeal to 
 the sublime consolations of this duty, and not ap- 
 peal in vain. Absolution is never accorded the 
 Penitent, unless he fulfil the conditions requi- 
 red by the Institution. From this important du- 
 ty no Christian is exempted, It is equally obliga- 
 tory on the Clergy »s the Laity — and to see a 
 Priest of the highest rank, and Archbishop or a 
 Cardinal, approach the Tribunal of Penance and 
 humbly kneel at the feet of his Confessor, andsofl 
 tened by Contrition, divulge in his ear every Sin, 
 fault and inadvertency, and receive forgiveness at 
 his hands, is one of the most beautiful and edify- 
 ing spectacles which the Catholic Church affords. 
 If neither the Divinity of this hqly Institution, 
 nor the injunctions of the Church, nor the verdict 
 of the pious and penitent of all ages be satisfacto- 
 ry to the incredulous Protestant, let him listen to 
 the opinion of a Philosopher, who disbelieved Re- 
 velation. ^ 
 
 " Confession (says Voltaire in his Dictionary) 
 is highly beneficial— a strong curb to vice and of 
 very early institution. It was anciently practised 
 at the celebration of all the Mysteries of the 
 Churph ^ ;^nd we have imitated and sanctified so 
 devout an observance. It avails greatly, turning 
 resentment and hatred into forgiveness and friend- 
 ship. By it the petty rogues are induced to re- 
 store what they have stolen j"— and in his Age of 
 
 F^ 
 
44 
 
 Lewis the XV. I,e declares "tWfession is the 
 greatest of all restraints to human wickedness.*' 
 
 " O 6WEET balm of the wounded spirit ! (apos- 
 troplnzes the eldauent Pr. Milner.) *0 sovereign 
 restorative of the 8pul»9 life and yigor ! best known 
 to those who taithfully use thee and not unattested 
 by those who neglect and blaspheme thee !" 
 
 The b»>-^ pf llngland. Dr. Johnsop, says in a 
 ponvers* ,th his f'riepd Boswell upon Confes- 
 
 ?r?"'o" ^ ' ^^^ ^^^"^ ^^^ ^'^a^ Js a good thing. 
 Ihe Scripture says * Confess your faults one to an- 
 otherj^and the Priests confess as well as the Lai- 
 ty. 1 heii It mtist be considered, that their Abso- 
 lution IS only upon repentance, and often upon 
 penance also. You (the Protestants) think your 
 ems may be forgiven without penance, upon re- 
 pentanpe alone." See Numb, v. (j. 7. Mat.iii.6. 
 Actsxix. 18. James V. 16. , 
 
 Absolution has been pronounced "aleayeto 
 co^imit Sm." This calumny would have been 
 spared, if its inventors had duly weighed the con- 
 ditions on which pardon is granted to the cbnfes- 
 Buig J^mner. Confession alone is by no means a 
 sufhcient title to forgiveness. To this must be 
 ih "^^r^"^"^^°"' *»fl Satisfaction (if possible^ for 
 
 Thus sanctioned by Reason, as a power in the 
 liighest degree conducive to pufity of manners, 
 and consolatory to the poor fallen Sinner, so also 
 IS It supported by Scripture, as a power promised 
 and given to thef astors of the Church, See Matt. 
 XVI. lO.-xviii. 18. John XX. j. 23. 
 
 5. ^XTujsME UKCTioN.'^1i:his h'ds al| {he quali- 
 ties of a true Sacrament, and notwithstanding tfte 
 otyections of our Protestant Brethren, is of divine 
 .authoruy, and of Apostolical u^age. >e James 
 
as 
 
 0. Ilvir OK/yrii».— This wdinance >may be dis- 
 patched in as rev, words as the preceding. It has 
 equally all the featurels dt'-a true Sacrament, and is 
 e^jually hfippoited by Scripture. See Luke xxii. 19. 
 John XX. n, Acts-vi. O.-xiii. 8.-xiv. 4. 1 Tim. 
 iv. B. 2 Tim. i.e. 
 
 7' MytTHmoNY,'— tittle detafl is necessary to 
 shew that this Iiistlitution is likewise of Divine 
 origin, and is a true Sacramerit. 'See 'Gen. ii. 24. 
 Matt. 3(ix. 6. Mark x. 11. m, Luke xvi. 18. 
 J«»n- vii. ^. 3. 1 Cor. vii. 10. 11. '89. JEph. v. 
 SS. IThess. iv. 3. 4. 5. ^ 
 
 Such are the Sacramento of theCathdlic Chwch, 
 Divine m their institution and salutary in their ef- 
 fect. To abuse "their application or to abridge 
 their nirdber, is enuafly to profane -their charac- 
 \pr and to endanger Salvation. 
 
 •ii ^^^aJ^^^^ Article relates to the ^Ceremonies of 
 the Cdthohc Church, whidh we will nptice amonfe 
 oiir miscellaneous matter. 
 
 The succeeding Article, rdatJng to Ori^/W/ 
 Sin ;indJu^tiJicdtm, has been among our Protes- 
 tant^Brethren tfie subject of much complaint awd 
 misrepresentation. 
 
 TiiE Catholic Church is accused of deprecia- 
 ^ing the vdlue of the Sacrifice of our Blessed 
 Saviour Jesus Christ on the Gross, and of over, 
 rating dnd sdbstituting the merit of good works, 
 '^low it is impossible that any expressions should 
 be thbre cleur and pdinted*^more satisfactory in 
 themselves, and in morp, perfect consent with Rea- 
 son arid Scripture, than f hose used by ^heCoundl 
 ot Trertt upon this subject. 
 ^ We believe (say they) that our Sins Are freely 
 forgiven us by the Divine mercyfbr Jesus Christ^ 
 sake. '-— Sess. 6. ch fl. Th^v nHH «« w^ «^^«:j 
 
 to tfe justitied ^rii/w, because none of those acts 
 
46 
 
 which precede Justification, whether they bo o^ 
 faith or good works can merit his Grace** As to 
 the merit of good works, the Council of Trent de- 
 clares that " Eternal life ought to be proposed to 
 the Children of God, both as a Grace which h 
 mercifully promised to them by the mediation of 
 our Lord Jesus Christ, and as a recompence which 
 h faithfully rendered to their good works and mer- 
 its, by virtue of this promise." Again, " Although 
 we say that Holy Writ esteems good works so 
 much, Jhat Jesus Christ himself promises that a 
 glass of cold water given to the poor shall not 
 want its reward, and that the Apostle testifies how 
 a moment of light pain endured in this world, 
 shall produce an eternal weight of glory — neverthe- 
 less, God forbid that a Christian should trust and 
 glory in himself and not in the Lord, whose boun- 
 ty is so great to all men, that he will have those 
 gifts which he bestows upon them to be their mer- 
 its" Onpe more, " We who can do nothing of 
 purselyes, can do all things with Him who strength- 
 lens us, in such sort that njan has nothing of which 
 be may glory, nor for which he may confide in 
 himself; but all his confidence and glory is in Je- 
 sus Christ, in whom we live-fr-iq whoip we merit — 
 in whom we satisfy — bringing forth fruits worthy 
 of penance, which draw their virtue from Him, 
 ai)d by Him are offered lo his Father and apcept- 
 led of by his Father through Him." — So th^t, jt 
 ,^ppears clearly from these decisions of the Coun- 
 cil of Trent, *' That our Sins are pardoned us out 
 of pure mercy for the sake of Jesus Christ — that 
 we are indebted for that Justice which is in us by 
 the Holy Ghost to a liberality gratis bestowed ujp- 
 on us-r-and that all the good works we do are bu^ 
 $0 many gifts of his Grace." 
 
 Add to all this the Praver which the Catholic B 
 
they bo o^ 
 :e.*' As to 
 :>f Trent de- 
 proposed to 
 ze which h 
 nediation of 
 pence which 
 ks and mer- 
 " Although 
 3d works so 
 nises that a 
 r shall not 
 ;estifies how 
 this world, 
 — neverthe- 
 d trust and 
 jrhose boun- 
 have those 
 e their mer- 
 nothing of 
 10 strength- 
 ig of which 
 confide In 
 irv is in Je- 
 we merit — 
 Ljits worthy 
 fropn Him, 
 ,nd apcept- 
 -So th^t, jt 
 the Coun- 
 ted us out 
 hrist — that 
 is in us by 
 stowed up- 
 do are hh 
 
 p PafhhTih 
 
 I 
 
 49' 
 
 Church uses in her daily Sacrifice. — *« Vouchsafe^ 
 O God, to grant to us Sinners, thy Servants, who 
 hope in the multitude of thy mercies, some part 
 and Society with the blessed Apostles and Mar- 
 tyrs — into whose number we beseech Thee to be 
 pleased to receive us, not looking upon our Mer- 
 its, but graciously pardoning us in the name q/Je^ 
 sus Christ our Lord" 
 
 What more satisfactory explanation would the 
 I most obstinate disputant demand ? 
 
 The Church's doctrine on these points is abun* 
 dantly supported by Scripture. See Gen. iv. 7.- 
 xxii. 16. 17. 18. Ps. xvii. 11. 23. 24.-xviii. 8. 11. 
 Matt. v. 11. 12.-X. 42.-xvi. 27. 1 Cor. iii. 8. 
 2 Tim. iv. 8. 
 
 The following article relates to the Sacrijice of 
 the Holy Mass — in the language of the inspired 
 St. Frartcis of Sales— «« The most Holy, Sacred 
 and Sovereign Sacrifice of the Mass, the centre of 
 Christian Religion, the Heart of Devotion, thc^ 
 Soul of Piety, and an unspeakable Mystery : which 
 comprehends in it the bottomless depth of God's 
 Charity— and by which God, uniting Himself re- 
 ally to us, liberally communicates his Grace and 
 Favors," This sublime definition and eulogy would 
 be alone sufficient, it might be imagined, to silence 
 every cavil and gain every heart. But Prejudice 
 can convert nourishment into poison. 
 
 This Article likewise declares the Beal Presence 
 of our Lord Jesus Christ in the Most Holy Sacra, 
 ment of the Eucharist^ — which involves a Doctrine 
 that has afforded matter for more acrimony of cen- 
 sure and even levity of ridicule, than perhaps anj 
 other tenet of the Catholic Church. 
 
 She teaches, that the Eucharist is the true body 
 and blood of Christ, under the appearance of 
 Bread and Wine. These elements undergo the 
 
4i 
 
 most important and nairacqloqfi revolution tiiat Ai^ 
 mighty Pomer can eflect. Thiu wonderfia change, 
 the sole perqiiisitfe and charact^mtic of the truQ 
 Church and Ministry, is produced by tlie wfficia- 
 ting Priest, and tliis we call Transubstantiation. 
 
 Jt has been urged against this doctrine, that it 
 is not ortiy a miracle greater than all others, but 
 is of a very different nature^-^for \«hefeas the oth- 
 er Miracles recorded in Holy Writ were addressed 
 to the eyes and ears of men ; here on the contra- 
 ry, the senses are worse than useless ^ fof their 
 testimony directly contradicts tlie Miracle^ 
 
 In answer to this objection, let it be observed, 
 that \ve are not to dictate to our Divine Master, 
 in what manner to operate flis Miracles. We 
 haye no need of any remote arguments to prove, 
 however, that we have faculties of higlier authori- 
 ty than our ^senses ; and that many tri^ths in di- 
 rect contradiction to their testimony are supported 
 by the most invincible evidence. * For example, 
 the eye sees, as plainly as solar effulgence can ena- 
 ble it, that the Sun rises in the east, ascends to 
 the zenith, declines and sets in the west. Now 
 who does not know that this apprehension is a mis- 
 take ? Do men in general discover this by any 
 astronomical researches of their own ? No, They 
 trust to those of others, and prefer their authority 
 to that of their own senses. " Blessed are those 
 who have not seen (^sys our Lord and Saviour) 
 and yet have believed." 
 
 The doctrine of the Real Presence has ever been 
 thought so essential to Christianity, that among all 
 the Svhismatic CL arches which have separated 
 from Catholic unity, there is not one to he found 
 before the aera of the Reformation, which caUed 
 in question the presence of Christ in the Eucha- 
 
 Hniu nniir'K crLoira.* 4-k^^ir ^U-^«-» t-^ At£C — •-. 
 w^vr, M4vt--£^ =;v---.-wi Liicv »-fiyap *U \XllKii Ip 
 
 
 4- \r\£\^^ 
 
j 
 
 49 
 
 other points from Ih^ Catholic Church and from 
 each ofhor, they all itnited in this belief. The 
 perpetual consent ol tae Greek aiui 'all the Orien* 
 tal Churches, in this Article, has been demonstra- 
 ted and is acknowledged on all sides. And it is 
 not a little remarkable, that even the Church of 
 England, declares in her public Catechism, that 
 *• llie body and blood of Christ are verily and in^ 
 deed taken and received by the faithful in the 
 Lord's Supper." 
 
 As Keason is by no means hostile to this doc- 
 trine, so Scripture supports it with the whole 
 weight of its authority. Sec Matt. xxvi. 26.— 
 Mark xiv. 22. 24. Luke xxii. l{). John vi. 51. 
 ryZ. X Cor. x. lO.-xi. 24. 25. 27- 29. These 
 texts are clear and decisive, and leave no room for 
 cavil pr objection to any who believe the Gospel. 
 
 If It be asked, why the Catholic Church ihter- 
 p^ts these passages in the literal . sense, let the 
 gj%at rBpssuet reply in 'her behalf. " There is no 
 more;Teason to ask us why we fix ourselves to the 
 literal sense, than there is to ask a traveller why 
 lie follows the high road. It is their part, who 
 have recourse to the ^gurative sense, and who 
 take bye paths, to give a reason for what they do/' 
 Tne Holy Mass is the unbloody Sacrifice of the 
 
 • 1)ody and blood of Christ. As vet inactive, though 
 
 pesent in the Euctiaristic Sacrament, He is in tlie 
 
 Holy .M^sfi offered up tohis Eternal Father, as a 
 
 propitiatory Sacrifice for the Sins of tlie whole 
 
 ^vvorjfd. 
 
 '^Tiiis introduces one of the heaviest ebargeg 
 ^v/hich has ever been invented against the Catholic 
 'Church— that oi^ Idolatrij. It is rourrdly asserted 
 .that Catholics are the grossest Idolators, and wor- 
 ship brpad and wine as God ! ' ^^*^^- 
 
 What is Idolatry ? A Catholic child, who hai 
 
 • ' -.■ ,. Q 
 
CO 
 
 made his Hrst communion would ansWer<^" Idotu^ 
 try is rendering to the Creature the homage and 
 worship due alone to the Creator." If this defi- 
 nition be correct, it will require neither much ad- 
 dress, nor many words to clear Catholics from tliis 
 reproach. 
 
 It is not then the elements of bread and wine 
 which are worshipped in the most Holy Eucha- 
 rist — nor even these elements consecrated for re* 
 ligious purposes — but it is these elements, humble 
 as they are, converted, changed and Transubstan- 
 tiated into the body and blood, the real and true 
 body and blood of Christ, 
 
 Now it is hoped, that among our Protestant 
 Brethren, tiiere is no one who would have the im- 
 piety to assert that this worship ought not to be 
 rendered, provided this doctrine be true, and Jesus 
 Christ be really present on the Altar. Now would 
 this worsliip be Idolatrous, were even the doctrine 
 Jalse, It is the Lord Jesus Christ our Redeemer 
 whom Catholics adore. If they imagine Him io 
 a place where He is not, and by»mistake worship 
 Him in that place, surely as no indignity is inten- 
 ded, no Sin is committed. 
 
 ** There is no Idolatry in the Mass, (says Dr* 
 Johnson to his friend Boswell.) They believe 
 God to be there, and they worship Him.^ 
 
 It has been objected to the Sacrifice of the 
 Mass, that it pretends to be a renewed oblation 
 and propitiation of our Lord — thereby annulling 
 or diminishing the Sacrifice which He once offer- 
 Cil for our sins upon the Cross, 
 
 In answer to this objection, we say it is meant 
 to do neithei.-. The Sacrifice of the Mass is not 
 a new payment of the price of bur salvation, but 
 
 IS mPI'plv a rnmntPvnn'r/iti'nfi Skanrifipa or\r\Urirk/v ^t\ 
 
 Sinners the merits of i^Ihrist's Passion and Death. 
 
51 
 
 Nevertheless, although His blood is only shed mya. 
 tjcaljy, and his death only intervenes by representa- 
 tion,(to borrow the expressions of the great Bossuet) 
 yet it is a real .Sacrifice inasmuch as Jesus Christ 
 is really present in tne Eucharist, and is offered up 
 to His Eternal F?ither. In fine, " This Sacrifice is 
 instituted (says the Council of Trent) only to re- 
 present that which was once accomplished upon 
 the Cross ; to perpetuate the memory of it to the 
 end of the world ; and to apply to us the saving 
 virtue of it for the remission of those sini which 
 we commit every day." 
 
 It has been insisted that although Sacramental 
 Communion be as ancient as our Religion, yet the 
 Mass bears little or no resemblance to the primi*' 
 tive*rite; but is, on the contrary, new in name 
 and character. Now it appears from the most au- 
 thentic and ri^mote records, that this Sacrifice ever 
 bore the same name and exhibited the same shape 
 that it does at the present day, St, Ambrose 
 writes in the 4<th century-*-** I continued the office 
 '^I began to say Mass" L. i, Ep. 14. St. Leo 
 in the 5th writes**^** When the multitude is so 
 great that the Church cannot hold them all, let 
 there be no difficulty made to offer the Sacrifice 
 more than once. For some part of the people 
 must of necessity be deprived of their devotions, 
 if following the custom of saying Mass but once, 
 none can offer up the Sacrifice but they who come 
 early in the mprning." 
 
 Such is this wonderful ^nd propitiating Sacri- 
 ficp-r-the n^ysterious chain which connects Earth 
 with Heaven : repentant Man with his reconciled 
 Maker. «* Let a Person (says the eloquent Cha- 
 teaubriand) worthily appr6a(:h the Holy Sacrament 
 only once a month, and he must necessarily be* 
 Come one of the most virtuous on earth,*' 
 
52 
 
 Haviog ^aid thus mucR respecting the ftolv 
 JWass as a doclrhie, we wih hazard a single r^hiark 
 on It as a cerefnom, vt*;*'' 
 
 As a religious jiite m:M^i:m^iE 
 
 ot Worship, It is ni point of grandeur, be^ltv, ele- 
 ^^. a»?d pathos, one of the qiost iriterestife anil' 
 affecting spectacles, ever exhibited—and iiolhin^ 
 but Us fimuehc^ enfeebles oiir admiration^ ^ 
 
 It IS said there are things in the Masg which 
 g^^ye offence--.^ut to whom ^ Let the faculty of 
 Divinity in the Protestant University of ttehnstadt 
 answer. ,« Tq those only who are ighoraiit what 
 these ceremomfes signify j for there is none olf them, 
 but has a ^pod represention. As for tlie rest, tfe 
 Mass is a figure and represeptatioiri , of tlie most; 
 bitter Fusion and De^th of Jesu^ Christ/'' ' . 
 
 This ■Sacrifice is suffjci^ritly warraiit'ed by Smb: 
 ture. It was prefigured Gen. xiv, l8-«pfeaictea' 
 rs.cix.^. JTatt i. 10.11^ancl tesVituted by 
 Chmt Tiimseir, I.ute xxii, ){), 20. , See also 1' Coiv 
 X. 16, 18, \% 20. 21. Heb. xiii. 16. ' \ . 
 
 The Article following relates to the inte^% of 
 "*?^?<=^*'i«^e>\t unt^ler either kind alphe. ' ' 
 
 THfs has been the occasion ot^triuch ofeloqut 
 a»d aspersion. It i? thought to begreal presunip: 
 ti^oll in the Oatholic i*riesthood, to rec^eive tffe 
 Cornmumon in both kinds themselves and to dtmv 
 the Cup to the liiit^. / : -^^.^ t -^ 
 
 As this regulation appears impossibfe to be as- 
 cribed to any sinister motive, Ave nee^ not' iro /ar 
 to learn tfie reason of it. f. 
 
 The quirch has tau|fht iom tihe earliest ages 
 that tlie Sacrament is eniire, whether administered 
 in owe kind oi' ia both. One reason, out of rnany, 
 why theXup is withheld fi^om the tatty, is, le^st 
 the blood ot Christ, in the sliape of wine, slin/ilrl 
 
^2 1 
 
 PI 
 
 5B 
 
 be spilled, ^tJ great profanation and confusion en- 
 !fe6 in large Congregation«,^>»''^*^ ■ -'^ » 
 
 0*E fciird alone, as su^eieht for its intt^mioii as 
 a Sacrarttent, is justififed by the doctrine and prac- 
 tice of the Apoistle!); ^'^';v4^^'^ -t^^* '■ 
 
 In th^jir private Gtiaracter, thfe Clergy them- 
 selves *n^v^r receive the Eucharist but in one kind. 
 If they receivb it in* both ki^ids at the Altar, they 
 do it as dfl^biating' in thd person of Christ, whoot- 
 fers his body and Wood ik the Mass as a Sacrifice 
 for the siijs of Mankind. ' . ' 
 
 DtiV'JdWKSON observes on this subject-^" Catho- 
 lies may think that m what is merely ritual, devi- 
 ations from the primitive mode may be admitted 
 on the ground of convenience : and I think that 
 they are ^s well warranted to make this alteration, 
 as we (the Protestants) are to substitute .sjprmM^/^ 
 in the roojn of tHe ancient Baptism." • 
 
 We might add that this privation is no article 
 of Catholic Faith, but one merely of DimpUne ; 
 which tnay be abrogated by the Authority wiiich 
 ordaiwed it. >. i i 
 
 Communion in one kind as sufficient to salvation* 
 is satisfactorily certified by Scripture— See Luke 
 
 xxiv. 30, 31. John vi. 51. Acts ii. 42, 46 
 
 Rom. vi. 9. I. Cor. x. I7. 
 
 The next article relates to Ptirgaiorj^ arid. Prafy'. 
 ersfor the Dead, all which have been pronowncetl 
 unscriptural and absurd. 
 
 ^ They are neither— and the real doctrine of the 
 Catholic Church on this subject is of a nature to 
 silence and satisfy the most scrupulous. 
 
 She teaches us that the Saints and some few 
 others who have passed lives of singular piety and 
 virtue on earth, are at their death immediately re- 
 
 CGIVPfl infn rrl/Arv S\Ua inf/»»»*Ma ..« ..1.-.^ .-K^*. 4.I ^' 
 
 __- — ,„ ^.,,.^, f -,,-_, itiisj^iinrj tan iSJov, J-iiat iircic 
 
 are others, and but too rtany, whose guilt is so 
 
64, 
 
 great that in quitting their mortal bodies they are 
 cast into Hell. Finally she declares that there s^x^. 
 great numbers, who, not deserving of eternal pun* 
 ishment for their sins, nor yet so immaculate a$ 
 to go immediately to Heaven, are placed by Di^ 
 vine Justice in a middle state ; where their person- 
 al sufferings,^ united with the Prayers of the Faithr. 
 fu I on earth, may finally avail to procure thera 
 Pardon and Salvation, Upon this important and 
 consolatory belief is founded tli^ Catholic s^nd pi- 
 ous custom of praying for the Dead. A mtiltir 
 plicity of passages might be eited from the Greek 
 and Latin J athers, to proye the antiquity of this 
 salutary practice, Tertullian who wrote soon af- 
 ter the death of our Saviour, speaks tf it oflen» 
 and it is recognised as an Apostolical Tradition 
 in the most ancient Liturgies of all the Christian 
 Churclies before the Reformation-j-^as the Roman, 
 Greek, Syrian, Armenian, Nestorian, Egyptian, 
 Ethiopian, Indian, &c. &c. 
 
 ** Purgatory (says Dr. Johnson) is a very 
 harmless doctrine. They (the Catholics) are of 
 opinion that the generality of mankind are neither 
 so obstinately wicked as to deserve everlasting 
 punishment, nor so good as to merit being admit- 
 ted into the Society of Blessed Spirits ; and there- 
 fore that God js graciously pleased to allow of a 
 middi0 state, where they may be purified by cer* 
 tain degrees of suffering. There is nothing un- 
 reasonable in this."— rHe adds, " If it be onpe es. 
 tablished that there are souls in Purgatory, it is as 
 proper to pray for them, as for our bjrethven of 
 mankind who are yet in this life.*' Jn fact, this 
 tenet is so consonant with Reason as well as Scrip- 
 ture, that a vast number of intelligent Protestants 
 have avowed their belief in it. One of high rep- 
 utation observes in his Lectures : *^ With regard 
 
5s they are 
 t there £^re. 
 ernal pun*- 
 laculate as 
 5d by Dif 
 eir person- 
 the Fftithr. 
 :ure them 
 Drtant an4 
 liq £^nd pi- 
 
 A mtiltir 
 the Greek 
 lity of this 
 :e soon af- 
 f it often. 
 Tradition 
 
 Christian 
 e Roman^ 
 Egyptian, 
 
 s a very 
 cs) are of 
 re neither 
 verlasting" 
 ng admit, 
 md there- 
 Ilovr of a 
 I by cer- 
 hing uh- 
 ; onpe es. 
 y, it is as 
 ethren of 
 fact, this 
 as Scrip- 
 •otestants 
 high rep- 
 h regard 
 
 55 
 
 to the doctrine Of Purgatory though it may not be 
 founded either in lledson or Scripture, it is nofc 
 unnatural. — Who can bear the thought of dwell- 
 ing in everlasting torments? Yet who can say 
 that God, everlastingly just, may not inflict them ? 
 The mind of man seeks for some resource. It 
 finds one ow/^— in conceiving that some temporory 
 punishment after death may purify the soul from 
 its moral pollution, and make it at last acceptable 
 even to a Deity infinitely pure." As the Doc- 
 trine of Pufgatory and Prayers for the Dead is 
 sanctioned by good sense and remote antiquity, so 
 it has also the support of Scripture. These pray- 
 ers made and still make part of the Ritual of the 
 Jewish Synagogue- — see ir. Mace. xii. 4S, &c.-- 
 See also Malt. v. 25, 26, xii. S2, 36. i. Cor. iii. 
 13, 14. 15. J. Pet. iii. 18, 19, 20. Apoc. xxi. 
 27. 
 
 The next article relates to the Invocation of the 
 Saints — to which may be added that of the Bles- 
 sed Virgin Mary and of the Angels, 
 
 In this exercise, Catholics are accused of ren- 
 dering these glorified Persons divine worship, and 
 of being thereby guilty of Idolatry. 
 
 LEt it be then repeated for the millionth time^ 
 that Catholics do not worship them, at least in the 
 Protestant acceptation. They do indeed address 
 them in certain forms and with much solemnity : 
 but it is only to beseech them to add their Play- 
 ers to ours, and to intercede for us at the throne 
 of the Most High.—Catholics recognize no pow- 
 er in them to help us by their own immediate act. 
 They can assist us only by joining their supplica- 
 tions to ours. If our'Proiestant Brethren should 
 still insist that God has no need of their vicarious 
 Prayers, but is ever ready to hearken to the Peti- 
 t?ions of the humblest of his creatures, and that 
 
56 
 
 ilieir intercession is superfluous, as our Jlrorti Je-* 
 4SUS Christ is our sole Intercessor with the Father ^ 
 we can retort the objection^ and mk tlie.iu wliv 
 they soh'cit the prayers of ^ack other.? j^' the 
 Pjayers of' the JBlessed Virgin and of tl^e ^ngeis 
 land Siiints .cannot avail us» we may be very sure 
 that nothing can be expected from those of our 
 poor, sinful ^eliow creatures. 
 
 But that their Pra}|fiis can and do avail us, we 
 have the-express testimony of Scripture — ^See Luke 
 xvi. 9. I. Cor. xii. 8. and Apoc. v. 8. We have a 
 communion with them — Heb. xii. 22, 23. They 
 have power over nations — Apoc. ii. 26, 2.7-v. ,1 0. 
 They knovf what passes among us^ — ^Lul^e xv. 10- 
 j. Cor. xiii. 12. i. John iii. 2. They are with 
 Christ in Heaven before the Resurrection ~ii. Coi:. 
 y. 1, 6, 7, 8. Phil. i. 23, 24. Appc. iv. 4-vi. 9r- 
 vii. 9, 14,15. &c.-xiv. 2, 3, 4.-xix. 1, 4, 5, 6.-xx. 4. 
 The Prayers of God's Servants have greatinfluence 
 with Him— Ex. xxxii. 11, 14. i. I&ngs vii. 8^ 9, 
 10. Jobxlii, 7,8. Rom. xv. 30. %h. vi. 18, 
 
 19. I. Tiles. V. 25. Heb. xiii. 13. James v. 16. 
 The dignity of the Blessed Virgin Mary ap* 
 
 pears from Luke i. 28, 42, 43, 48. 
 
 Th£ Invocation of Angels appears from Gen. 
 xlviii. 15, 16. Osa. xii. 4. Apoc. i. 4. They 
 have been honored by the Servants of God—Jos. 
 V. 14, 15. They have a charge over us— Ex. xxiii. 
 
 20, 21. Ps. xcii. 12, &c. Matt, xviii. 10. Heb. 
 i. 14. They pray for us^— rZach. i. 1,2. They of- 
 fer up our Prayers — Apoc. yiii. 4. , ,* 
 
 The next Article relates to the use of Images^ 
 and declr ^s that honor and veneration are due to 
 ilnem. , - . • 
 
 l^EW tenets of the Catholic Church liave excited 
 
 .,i.,„ 
 
 auti 
 
 i1- 
 
 
 cuniroversy , laan uiij^^t 
 shalt not make to thyself any graven Iiipage,*' sav 
 
57 
 
 the divine Commandment — and it never ceases to 
 be quoted to cover Catholics with confusion. 
 
 Now, that the strict Protpstapt S|^nse is not that 
 of the Law of Moses, must be evident, on exam- 
 ination, to the most comn\pn apprehension ; unles? 
 we acknowledge that the Scriptui'e is inconsistent, 
 with itself. For Images were not only permitted 
 in the Jewish worship, but were absolutely cowi- 
 inanded by God himself — as appears from Ex. 
 XXV. 18, &c. Numb. xxi. 8. 9* They were plac- 
 ed on each side of the mercy seat in the Sanctuary 
 —Ex. xxxvii. 7. And in the Temple of Solo- 
 mon— ii. Chron. iii. 10. By Divine Command— 
 t. Chron. xxviii. 18, If), lielative honor to the 
 Images of Chrigt and his Saints authorised, Heb* 
 xi. 21. See also ii. Kings vi. \% 15, 14, 15, l6* 
 II. Chron. v. % &c. Ps. xcviii. 5. P\\\\. ii. 10. 
 
 *'* Our intention is tiot (says the admirable Bos- 
 suet) so much to honor tlie Image, as to honpr 
 the Apostle or Martyr in presence of the Image. 
 ** The honor we render to Images (says the Coun- 
 cil of Trent) has such ^ reference to those tliey 
 represent, that by means of those Images which 
 we kiss, and before which we kneel, we adore J^- 
 sus Christ, and honor the Saints, vvhose types they 
 are." This Council forbids us expressly "to be- 
 lieve any divinity in them, for which they ought 
 to be reverenced ; to demand any favor of them 
 or put any trust in them.*' To all this it may be 
 added, that the use of Images is no duty of posi- 
 tive obligation. The Council of Trent merely 
 says the practice is good and beneficial. If it be 
 asked how this practice is good and beneficial, we 
 answer, that it is most admirably calculated to an- 
 imate and enliven the pious affections. In every 
 Catholic familv are seen the Crucifix^ and nictures 
 of ihe Blessed Virgin and of the Saints. We 
 
 H 
 
 
 w L 
 
 -<■«-■ 
 
58 
 
 kneel in prayer before the Image of our cruciffed 
 Saviour, that our minds, impressed with the awful 
 ideas of his Passion and Death, may be extited to 
 fellow the precepts and example of the great Cap- 
 tain of our Salvation, and learn that ** we have Re- 
 demption through his blood.** 
 
 Hence may be inferred the utility of Images, 
 and the honor and respect which are paid to them 
 by all the members of the Catholic Church. 
 
 With regard to Relics, besides the motives to 
 their retention and respect in common with Ima- 
 ges ; there are particular reasons which urge the 
 Catholic Church to enjoin the veneration of RelicwS, 
 1. They have been the victims and living temples 
 of God. 2. They are pre-ordained to a happy 
 Resurrection. B, They have been and are daily 
 the Instruments of the power of God, for the work- 
 ing of innumerable miracles. 4. They serve to 
 encourage the Faithful to an imitation of their 
 virtues. 
 
 "Nothing is more evident (says the learned 
 Bishop Challoner,) from all kinds of monuments 
 of antiquity, than that the veneration of the Relics 
 of the Saints, is one of the most ancient things of 
 Christianity ; as may be seen in the writings of 
 the Holy Fathers, particularly St. Basil, St. Greg- 
 ory Nyssen, St. Gregory Nazianzen, St. Cyril, 
 St. John Chrysostom, St. Ambrose, St. Jerome, 
 St. Austin and Theodoret." See 2 Kings xiii. 21. 
 Matt. ix. 20. 21. Acts xix. 11. 12. 
 
 It is here incumbent upon me to observe, once 
 for all, that on this, as well as on every other point 
 in the controversy, I quote only the real doctrine of 
 the Catholic Church. It is to be regretted that in 
 practice many have departed from her precepts ; 
 and as some have fallen short of her injunctions, 
 so others have carried them to excess. Among 
 
09 
 
 other indiscretions, the use of Images and Relics 
 may sometimes have been perverted to purposes 
 of improper devotion, But tlie best things are h- 
 able to abuse, Of this truth, the Bible itself is a 
 melancholy example. 
 
 The next Article relates to Indulgences, which 
 are intimately connected with Penance, and in 
 like manner have been sadly misunderstood and 
 thoughtlessly censured. 
 
 «• By an Indulgence (says Bishop Ghalloner) we 
 mean no more than the releasing of true Penitents 
 from the debt of temporal punishment, which re- 
 mained due to their sins, after the sins themselves, 
 as to the guilt and eternal punishment, had been 
 already remitted by the Sacrament of Penance, by 
 a perfect contrition." 
 
 "The power to grant Indulgences (says the 
 Council of Trent) has been given to the Church 
 by Jesus Christ, and the use of them is beneficial 
 to Salvation." But the Council adds that " This 
 power ought to be retained, yet nevertheless used 
 with a moderation, lest Ecclesiastical discipline 
 should be weakened by an over-great facility." 
 
 «» When therefore (says the great Bossuet) the 
 Church imposes upon Sinners painful and labori- 
 ous works, and they undergo them with humility, 
 this is called Satisfaction ; and when, regarding 
 the fervor of Penitents, or some other good works 
 which she has prescribed them, she relaxes some 
 part of that pain which is due to them, this is cal- 
 led Indulgence" 
 
 That a debt of temporal punishment may re- 
 main after the guilt of it is removed, we may learn 
 from the royal Psalmist. It appears from the 
 Book of Samuel, that though Nathan assures Da- 
 vid that the Lord had put away his Sin, yet He 
 Ar^nr^.tnryaA orcctincf Wivn maTiv tpmnnral afnictlonSt 
 
60 
 
 frJ^l^^HT'^^ ^'■'^"^'"^ Indulgences i^ eviaoiifc 
 ii^rn Matt/ XVI 18. iy.<a„d the use of this pow. 
 er from S Cor. li, 6. 7. 9. 10. p w 
 
 The next Article relates to the identity of the 
 Church, aiid IS the most important ol' all, because 
 It IS the foundationv as well as the guarantee of 
 overy other Article of the Catholic he\iet\ U she 
 be a false Church, it matters little what doctrines 
 • She teaches; for where there is no Authority, 
 there can be no Obedience. But if; on the con! 
 traiy, fU momehtous question !) she be the true, 
 and o«/^ «rwe Church, of Christ, her voice fs con- 
 sequently the voice of God. " He tliat hath ears 
 to hear, let him hear.*' 
 
 .1 J"^ ^ftholic, Apostolic and Roman Church 
 
 ifT r ^^f'^, ^^'''''^'' ^"d c^a^'^s it exclusively. 
 It therefore^behoves All who seek Salvation, to 
 examine with all possible care and industry these 
 liigh pretensibnsr. ; Compared with the importance 
 ot this duty, all other avocations ai^ triflincr, and 
 tneir objects vain. ^ 
 
 ^ The titles by which the triie Church of Christ 
 IS to^be re^bgntxed, have already been noticed.— 
 itiJoWontylr^mainstotest by these criteria the 
 
 ^She is O/ze— She is Holj/.^She is Univers, l^ 
 ohe IS Apostolical 
 
 She is'Ow^.—Her Members agree in ow(? Faith- 
 are all m owe Communion—and are all imdev one 
 -wead. A Catholic of Rome subscribes the ?iame 
 Creed as a Catholic of Pekin. A Catholic of Vi- 
 •enna partakes the same Sacraments as a Catholic 
 ot Aleppo A Catholic of Paris acknowledges the 
 same Clnef as a-Catholic of Baltimore. She is the 
 same Society in the present century as she was in 
 
61 
 
 
 the very first, fiver onCf anfl imdiangeable iti 
 FaitU and Doctrine. 
 
 She is /:^o/y.— Her doctrines are derived from 
 Christ and his Apostles. Her Sacraments have 
 no tendency but to purify tlie lives of men. The 
 holiness of her Saints has l)een the admiration of 
 tlie world. 
 
 She is Unix)crsttl — This fact needs no special 
 proof, as it has never bfeen ^bntest?ed. Adorned 
 with this feattne, the Church assumes the title of 
 Catholic : which is tacitly at least, acknowledged 
 legitimate by Separatists of every' denomination, 
 ll^r Missionaries have carried the Cross of Christy 
 to every part of the habitable globe '; and have 
 prddaimed the glad tidings of the*C jspel from the 
 Equator to the Poles— ^among tlio Snows of Sibe- 
 ria and the burning Sands of Abbyssmia. 
 
 She is ^^^^Mcflf/.— That this Church is the 
 most ancient of all Churches, wHl not be quesi^ 
 tioned by ainy who have coififidence in History. 
 The succession of the Bishops of Rome may be 
 traced, step by stej), without the smallest inter- 
 ruption, from the present Pope to St. '*eter^ 
 that zealous Apostle whom our Lt)rd commission- 
 ed to be the Chief of \ih infant Church, in the 
 ever memorable words recorded by St. Matthew 
 xvi. 18. 
 
 Many and oft have been ber struggle* with the 
 powers of darkness in tb' shape of Schisms and 
 Heresies, which have disturbed her tranquillity. 
 But she has risen from the combat with victory in 
 her hand. Of these, eveiy age has been nnhap- 
 Jpily fruitful. Latterly, the secession of half Eu- 
 rope from her communion menaced her downfall — 
 which the events of the French Revolution were 
 supposed to leave no longer doUbtful. What con- 
 iident predictions were hazarded of ber utter des- 
 
 
m 
 
 tiHiction ! What declamatory threats of a speedy 
 extinction of the ** Man of Sin !" Finally, when 
 the French toofw Rome and imprisoned the Vicar 
 of Jesus Clirist, Epitaphs were written for depar- 
 ted Popery. But depression was not Ruin. God 
 has tried his Church witl> Adversity, and is now 
 raising her to new splendor. We have seeti Greek 
 and Protestant unite tp re-instate the fallen Pon- 
 tiff in his sovereignty, and to decorate with anoth- 
 er wreath of glory the Chair of St. Peter. 
 
 She is Apostolical, in the Scripturality, Unifor- 
 mity and Invariability pf her Doctrines. Precise- 
 ly those which she teaches at the present day are 
 co-eval with Christianity itself. As a proof, a 
 triumphant proof of this, allusion is made to them 
 in the writings of the earliest Fathers of the 
 Chureh — those holy Men, for whom our Protes- 
 tant Brethren profess to feel (and I believe sin- 
 cerely) the highest veneration :— -nor has any in- 
 vestigation been able satisfactorily to fix a later 
 date to a single Article of Cr^tholic Faith, Infi- 
 nite are the attempts which have been made in 
 nocturnal researches amopg the musty and man- 
 gled records of the middle ages, to controvert this 
 position, but in vain. Much of the clamor wjiich 
 has been excited against the Catholic Church on 
 this subject has arisen from an egregious mistake. 
 Articles of F^'th have been confounded with those 
 o^ Discipline, Over the latter, the Church has 
 the most absolute control ; over the former, none 
 at all. Her Discipline has varied in different ages ; 
 but h r Faith is immutable. 
 
 Among the liberal of our Protestant Brethren, 
 
 the Fathers of the Church have always obtained 
 
 credit and esteem. Let us hear their report on 
 
 this important subject. 
 
 . 5r. IftEiNCEUs, who lived in the second century, 
 
of 9. speedy 
 nally, when 
 I the Vicar 
 
 for depar- 
 luin. God 
 and is now 
 seen Greek 
 fallen Pon- 
 with anoth- 
 er. 
 
 ity, Unifor- 
 }, Precise- 
 »nt day are 
 
 a proof, a 
 ide to iherr\ 
 lers of the 
 our Protes- 
 believe sin- 
 has any in- 
 ) fix a later 
 'aith. Ipfi- 
 n made in 
 y and nian- 
 itrovert this 
 imur wjiich 
 
 Church on 
 js mistake. 
 I with those 
 I!hurch has 
 >rmer, none 
 ferent ages : 
 
 t Brethren, 
 ys obtained 
 ir report on 
 
 id century, 
 
 6^ 
 
 says ** The Founders of the Church delivered thd 
 Episcopacy and government of the Church to 
 Linus : who was succeeded by Anacletus, Cle* 
 nient, Evaristus*' — enumerating the others in suc- 
 cession down to the Chief who then ruled the 
 Church, and concluding with these words, " This 
 is a most full demonstration that the same lively 
 Faith, taught by the Apostles, is still even unto 
 this day, preserved in the Church and duly deliv- 
 ered." Tertullian, one of the earliest of the 
 Fathers, speaks thus, " Wliat I believe, I received 
 from tlie present Church, and the present from 
 the primitive : the primitive fiom the Apostles : 
 the Apostles from Christ." St. Cyprian, who liv- 
 ed in the third century, says " We know Corneli- 
 us the Bishop of Rome to have been elected by 
 Almighty God, and Christ our Lord, the Bishop 
 of the most holy Catholic Church : neither are we 
 ignorant, that there ought to be one God, one 
 Christ our Lord, one Holy Ghost, and one Bishop 
 in the Catholic Church." Lanctantius, who lived 
 in the fourth century, says " It is she alone, which, 
 as the ancient Fathers write, retains the true wor- 
 ship. She is the fountain of truth and the tem- 
 ple of God, into which whosoever shall not enter, 
 or out of which which whosoever shall depart, can 
 have no hope of everlasting life and Salvation." 
 
 In fact we should never cease if we continued 
 these quotations. The Unity and Indivisibility of 
 the Church, of which the Bishop of Rome is the 
 sovereign Pontiff, are their favorite and endless 
 topics. 
 
 We may also be permitted to adduce as one of 
 the most signal and decisive test of the true 
 Church, that she has the gifl of Miracles, Here 
 the Catholic Church shines with transcendent lus- 
 tre. Not a sect which has had the misfortune to 
 
secede from her communion, has ever nretendea 
 to this distinction. It follows irresistibly, thivt if 
 the Catholic Churcii has ever, in the most solitary 
 instance, been the instrument of a single Miracle, 
 the triumph is all her own. - 
 
 To controvert this stubborn pretension of the 
 Catholic Church, her adversaries boldly aver, that 
 Miracles once necessary, are no longer so, and 
 have therefore ceased. In what book or record, 
 or by what sentence and authority Miracles arc 
 declared to have ceased. Catholics have yet to 
 learn. If this assumption find any support in Ho- 
 ly Writ, let the specific texts be cited. 
 
 This appeal, however, to Scripture in a question 
 of Miracles, is altogetiier idle and superfluous. 
 A Miracle, so far from meeting any extriiisic evi- 
 dence to support it, is inteuded by its nature to 
 give evidence and support to other truths. The 
 doctrines of Scripture itself are founded upon Mir- 
 acles : and had not the Miracles been performed, 
 the- doctrines which they were destined to sanc- 
 tion, had never been proclaimed nor believed. 
 
 No hypothesis, however ingenious, can be ra^ 
 tionally opposed to a matter of fact. Has then a 
 Miracle ever been performed in the Catholic 
 Church ? Let faithful history answer, whose re- 
 fcords are full of the most exact details of miracu- 
 lous power exercised iji this Church, that the most 
 sceptical enquirer can desire. To cite merely a 
 catalogue of preservations and cures, together with 
 other immediate interpositions of Divine agency, 
 wrought through the instrumentality of living and 
 departed Saints of this Church, would fill yol- 
 
 umes. j./Yi 1 
 
 From this immense mass of matter, it is difficult 
 to select any particular examples for citation, when 
 the whole 'seems so equally adapted to the pur- 
 
G9 
 
 iretendeu 
 ly, tljivt if 
 St Rolitarj' 
 I Jtdiracie, 
 
 on of the 
 aver, that 
 If so, and 
 dT record, 
 racles arc 
 ;e yet to 
 >rt in Ho- 
 
 1 question 
 perfluous. 
 riiisic evi- 
 nature to 
 ;hs. The 
 jpon Mir- 
 erforraed, 
 d to sanc- 
 ieved. 
 2an be ra^ 
 [as then a 
 
 Catholic 
 whose re- 
 jf miracu- 
 t the most 
 
 merely a 
 ether with 
 
 2 agency, 
 living and 
 1 fill yol- 
 
 is difficult 
 
 ion, when 
 
 the pur- 
 
 t)09e. It is sufficient on this occasion to observe 
 that the Miracles of St. Austin, the Missionary to 
 whom Eng'and owes her Conversion from the dark- 
 ness of Paganism to the light of the Gospel — and 
 those of St. Francis Xavier, the Apostle of the In- 
 dies, have been acknowledged by the most judi- 
 cious and impartial Protestant Writers. 
 
 Let it be understood however, that this power 
 is not one which the Church can exercise at her 
 option. It is only imparted occasionally, and ne- 
 ver but for some signal purpose. 
 
 The preceding Positions established, no argu- 
 ment is necessary to prove that the Catholic Church 
 is infallible. Her infallibiHty is a direct and in- 
 disputable deduction from the Premises. 
 
 After recording the vei-dict of Reason, calio, 
 collected and dispassionate, in favor of the C$tho- 
 lic Church— let us see with what splended suffrage 
 Scripture ratifies this decision. 
 
 The Church of Christ is everlasting, Ps. xlviii. 
 8.-lxxi. <5. y.-lxxxviii. 3. 4. 29. tJG. 37.-cxxxi. 13. 
 14. Is. ix. 7.-liv. 9. lO.-lix. 20. 21.-lx. 15. 18.- 
 Ixii. 6. Jer. xxxi. 35. SO.-xxxiv. 17. Ezec. 
 xxxviii. 24. 26. Dan. ii. 44. Matt. xvi. 18.- 
 xxviii. 10. John xiv. 16. I7.— The Church is the 
 Kingdom of Christ, Dan. ii. 44. Luke i. 33. — 
 The City of the Great King, Ps. xlvii. 2. His 
 rest and his habitation forever, Ps. cxxxi. 13. 14. 
 The House of the living God, 1 Tim. iii. 15. The 
 fold of which Christ is the Shepherd, John x. 16. 
 The body of which Christ is the head, Eph. v. 23- 
 Cok i. 18. The spouse of which He is the Bride- 
 groom, Eph. V. 31. 32. Ever subject to Him and 
 ever faithful to Him-24. Ever loved and cher- 
 ished by Him, 25. 29. And joined to him by an 
 Indissoluble union, 31. 32. The Church is the 
 piiiar and ground of the truth, X Tim. iii. 35. — 
 
 I 
 
^ 
 
 God's Cdvenant mih her is an everlasting /!oV6- 
 nant of Peace, Ezec. xxxvii. 6^. Confirmed by a 
 solemn oath, never to be altered, like that made to 
 Noah, Is. liv. 9. A covenant like that of the day 
 and night to stand to all generations, Jer. xxxiii. 
 20. 21. God shall be her everlasting light, Is. Ix. 
 18. 19. Whosoever shall gather together against 
 her shall fall ; and the nation that will not serve 
 her shall perish. Is. Ix. 12. 15. 17. The Church 
 is al'rvays one, Cant. vi. 9. 10. John x. 16. Eph. 
 iv. 4. 5. Always visible. Is. ii. 2. 3. Mic. iv. 1. 2. 
 Matt. V. 14. Spread far and near, and teaching 
 many nations, Ps. ii. 8,-xxi. 27. Is. xlix. G.-Hv. 
 1. 2. 3. Dan. ii. 35. U. Mai. i. 1 1. 
 
 The last Article relates to the Sacred Canons of 
 the Church, and her General Councils, All these 
 are identified with the Church herself; and as she 
 is infallible in matters of Faith, so whatever eman- 
 ates from her Councils, must necessarily bear the 
 impression of her Infallibility. 
 
 Such are the principles upon which the Catho- 
 lic Church urges her claim to the proud pre-em- 
 inence of being that true Ckurch, predicted by the 
 Prophets of Israel, and in due time founded by 
 our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, and against 
 which *' the Gates of Hell shall never prevail." 
 
 Now, let me ask whether these tests be not sa- 
 tisfactoiy and decisive ? And whether there be 
 another Religious Society in the whole world, 
 which in support of the same pretensions can ad- 
 duce the same proofs, or any other of equal validi- 
 ty ? No surely. Can we then doubt for a mo« 
 ment that she is the true Churchy the Church with- 
 out spot or wrinkle, the pillar and ground of truth, 
 the cliaste virgin and beloved spouse of Jesus 
 
 rhn*st : 
 
 ** A ZEAL without Knowledge" has constantly 
 
67 
 
 i 
 
 ing /!oV6- 
 med by a 
 t made to 
 )f the day 
 er. xxxiii. 
 ;ht, Is. Ix. 
 er against 
 not serve 
 le Church 
 l(j. Eph. 
 c. iv. 1 . 2. 
 teaching 
 ix. G.-liv, 
 
 Canons of 
 All these 
 md as she 
 ^er eman- 
 r bear 'the 
 
 he Catho- 
 I pre-em* 
 led by the 
 jnded by 
 d against 
 -evail." 
 be not sa- 
 
 there be 
 le world, 
 IS can ad- 
 ual validi- 
 for a mo« 
 irch with- 
 I of truth, 
 
 of Jesus 
 
 constantly 
 
 nourished a mortal antipathy to the Pope ox Bish- 
 op of Rome, who has long been an eye sore to our 
 Protestant Brethren, who think he is worshipped 
 as a God ! 
 
 The Papacy is indeed an office of great trust 
 and dignity. And the same Divine Authority 
 which created, his elevation in the person of St. 
 Peter, still maintains him in his rank, as a regular 
 Descendant from the Prince of the Apostles, in 
 the line of Ecclesiastical succession. Why our 
 Lord and Saviour required such a Chief for the 
 government of his Church, and why he chose that 
 he should be invested with so much external gran- 
 deur, we are not to enquire, but refer it to His 
 Almighty and Sovei^ign Will. This eminent per^ 
 sonage has been very much calumniated, and bulky 
 tomes have been written to perpetuate the real or 
 supposed vices and intrigues of the Popes. But 
 true History tells another tale ; and we may safe- 
 ly challenge all Nations to exhibit a succession of 
 Sovereigns more pious, virtuous, wise and learned, 
 than those who now for eighteen Centuries have 
 filled the See of Rome. 
 
 So much for the Catholic Profession of Faith..^^ 
 We now proceed to notice sonie miscellaneous ob- 
 jections, which relate not to matters of Faith, but 
 merely to those o^ DiccipUne. 
 
 The Sign of' the Cross, so universal among Cath* 
 olics, is censured as superstitious. But a thou- 
 sand testimonies prove it to be as ancient as Chris- 
 tianity. ** At every step, (says Turtullian) at eve* 
 ry coming in and going out, when we put on onr 
 clothes or shoes, when we wash, when we sit dowa 
 to table, when we light a candle, when we go to 
 bed — whatsoever conversation employs us, we im- 
 print on our foreheads the Sign of the Cross, 
 
 The Catholic Church has been accused of a 
 
 12 
 
 •» 
 
splendor and magnificence in her general a^con, 
 omy and public worship, inconsistent with the 
 simphcity of the Gospel. "God (it is said) is a 
 ^mt, and they who worship Him, must worship 
 Him m spirit and in truth." , 
 
 It is not sufficiently considered that God was 
 not less a Spirit in ancient times than He is now. 
 And yet He not only approved, but instituted for 
 His chosen people a form of worship, the most 
 splendid and magnificent that the world had ever 
 seen. That the worship of the Apostles and pri^ 
 mitive Christians was simple and unadorned, is 
 freely granted. But this (as Soame Jenyns acute- 
 Jy remarks, in answer to the same objection res, 
 pectmg the service of the Church of England) 
 was perhaps rather their misfortune than their 
 cboace. During the first Persecutions they had no 
 pubhc worship at all Their ceremonies were per- 
 formed, and the bread of life was broken to them 
 in private^m the dark recesses of caves and grot, 
 toes; and wherever else they could escape the in, 
 spection and interference of the civil power. 
 _ " The malignant influence of Calvinism Csaya 
 Dr. Johnson) has blasted ceremony and decency 
 together." .,, ■ *^ 
 
 It is objected as an unedifying practice that the 
 public service of the Church is performed in LaU 
 tn; a language unknown to the people at laiL^e. 
 even in Catholic countries. 
 
 This objection is easily answered. A Umver. 
 sal Church requires a Universal Language. It re- 
 quires also a language fixed and permanent in its 
 construction, not varying and fluctuating, and em- 
 barrassed with different idioms and Provincialities. 
 1 he Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is daily pffered in ev- 
 
 !JIP^f!^_^^/^^^^"^^" ^T*^' Missions expose Ec. 
 c*e«astiv3 to frequent and remote changes of plac^. 
 
69 
 
 Were tb« public Service of the Church performedi 
 in the vernacular language of each nation, a for? 
 eign Missionary would be a stranger in every coun, 
 try but his own, ^nd would be unequal to the du, 
 ty imposed on him. But thp Mass and Vespers 
 being in Latins an ancient and stable language, » 
 Priest of the Catholic Church is at home in every 
 quarter of the globe. In the infancy of Christi- 
 4nity, the language of the Church and of the Peor 
 pie was tlie same. Jlome was, as it still is, the 
 seat of the chief Bishop ; and Latin was the Ian* 
 guage of Rome, This tongue was vitiated by the 
 incorporation of barbarous dialects introduced into 
 Italy by invasion and conquest. So that it is not 
 Uie Church which has adopted a foreign language, 
 but^^he People, The Church continued, preserve 
 ed and consecrated the Ancient vernacular tongue. 
 Besides, those who assist at the S?icrifice qf the 
 Mass, have nothing to do with what is called the 
 Ordinary of the Mass, which is entirely said by 
 the o^ciating Priest. This is not a pMbiic Litur* 
 gy. Every one of the congregation respects his 
 own private prayers; which adds much to th^ 
 beauty and solemnity of the Catholic worship. 
 
 This objection, whatever it be worth, is not exr 
 elusive. The Greeks, Armenians, and Oriental 
 Churches in general, celebrate their divine service 
 in a language not familiar to the commonv.people, 
 
 A CoNVENTiAL LiFE — has been taxed as nour- 
 ishing superstition — hostile to the best interest of 
 Society— rand destructive of population. 
 
 In answer to these allegations, in the first place, 
 let us never forget, that in a question of Salva^ 
 tion, no human interests should come in competir 
 tion with this most important of all concerns.-r- 
 " Unum est necessarium" savs our Lord and Sa, 
 viour— "One thing is needful."— And he is but a 
 
70 
 
 tepid Christian who can suffer this great dutv to be 
 arrested by any considerations of minor moment* 
 In the next place, we urge that it is a state of 
 life as ancient as Christianity^ and is sanctioned 
 by the counsels and practice of the pious of every 
 age. Let us hear the report of Eusebius, who 
 lived at the time of the first General Council. 
 
 "There have been instituted in the Church of 
 Christ (says he) two ways or manners of living. — 
 The one raised above the ordinary state of nature, 
 and common ways of living : reiects wedlock, pos- 
 sessions and worldly goods, and being wholly se- 
 parated and removed from the ordinary conversa- 
 tion of common life, is appropriated and devoted 
 solely to the worship and service of God, through 
 an exceeding degree of heavenly love. They who 
 are of this order of people, seem dead to the life 
 of this world ; and having their bodies only upon 
 earth, are in their minds and contemplations dwel- 
 ling in heaven. From whence, like many heavenly 
 inhabitants, they look down upon human life, ma- 
 king intercessions and oblations to Almighty God 
 for the whole race of mankind. And this is not 
 with the blood of beasts, or the fat and smoke and 
 burning of bodies ; but with the highest exercises 
 oftrue piety, with cleansed and purified hearts, 
 and with a whole form of life strictly devoted to 
 virtue. These are their sacrifices, which they are 
 continually offering unto God, implore his mercy 
 and favor for themselves and their fellow creatures.- 
 Christianity receives this as the most perfect man^ 
 ner of life." — The other is a secular life. 
 
 The Religious Orders take three vows — the 
 first, of Poverty'y the second, of Chastity ; the 
 third, of Obedience — all which find sufficient sanc- 
 tion in Scnpture : See Matt. xix. 12^ 21. &c. 
 
 That Monastic JfciStablishments atlect the popu- 
 
:lutv to be 
 
 momenU 
 a state of 
 auctioned 
 3 of every 
 >ius, who 
 jncil. 
 :hurch of 
 living. — 
 af nature, 
 lock, pos- 
 vholly se- 
 conversa- 
 devoted 
 , through 
 fhey who 
 o the ]if« 
 »nly upon 
 ons dwel- 
 heavenly 
 life, ma- 
 ^hty God 
 his is not 
 noke and 
 exercises 
 i hearts, 
 3voted to 
 they are 
 lis mercy 
 :reatures*- 
 ect man-r 
 
 )ws— the 
 tity ; the 
 ?nt sanc- 
 &c. 
 he popu- 
 
 latioii of a country has been denied and disproved 
 by many Protestant writer^^particularly by Da* 
 vid Hume, 
 
 The Celibacy or single life of the Regular and 
 Secular Clergy of the Catholic Church, our Pro* 
 testant Brethren hold to be obnoxious to equal 
 censure. 
 
 In answer to this we observe, that the duties 
 imposed on the Catholic Clergy are far more mul- 
 tifarious and weighty, than on any other order of 
 men perhaps in the world. If they be faithful to 
 their vocation, their whole time is absorbed in the 
 discharge of these obligations. Mass must be said 
 every morning — the sick must be visited — the 
 Sacraments must be adminiatered-^the Dead must 
 be interred — Confession; a never-ending duty, 
 levies a heavy tax of occupation. Add to all this, 
 that they are bound to recite their Breviary at the 
 Canonical hours, occurring seven times a day,^^ 
 They are exposed also to be sent as Missionaries 
 to the ends of the earth. Let the candid judge, 
 whether married men be competent to the dis- 
 charge of these various and momentous duties. 
 " " He that hath a Wife or Children (says Lord 
 Bacon) hath given hostages to fortune ; for they 
 are impediments to great enterprizes" — and else- 
 where — " A single life doth well with Churchmen; 
 for Charity will hardly water the ground, when it 
 must fill a pool." 
 
 Thus sanctioned by Reason, Religious Celibacy 
 has also the support of Scripture. Continency 
 proved possible, Matt. xix. 11. 1^. The vow 
 binding, Deut. xxiii. 21. The breach of the vow 
 damnable, 1 Tim. v. 12. The practice commend- 
 ed, 1. Cor, vii. 7. 8. 27. 37. 38. 40. For reasons 
 which oarticularlv affect the Clprorv. f\9. R^. R^ 
 
 The Catholic Church is tajted with uncharita^ 
 
 t1 
 
hkness in her opinions, and with cfuel^ in hef 
 conduct? d^ouncing as Heretics, All who. are 
 not oif her communion — and consigning them if in 
 her power, to tortures and death I It is true in* 
 deed that Catholics believe, and that upon Divine 
 Authority, that out 6J the Church there is no mlm* 
 Horn 
 
 Bt)t what is it, to be out of the Churcb—that 
 Cnly ark of salvation ? They who are not imme- 
 diately in her communhrti are not therefore, by a 
 necessary consequence^ out tyf ike CJmrch. Hear 
 the great St. Austin of Hippo—" They that de* 
 fend their sentence (though false and perverse) 
 With no stubborn stomach or obstinate heart ; es- 
 pecially if it be such as themsetvea broached not, 
 but received of their deceived parents 3 and do 
 seek the tluth warily and carefully s beiiig ready 
 to be reformed if they find it : Such are not to be 
 reputed Heretics J* 
 
 - « Not every one (says the Annotators to the 
 Rheims Testament) that erreth in Religion is a 
 Hereik, But he only that after the Church's de* 
 termination, wilfully and stubbornly standeth in 
 his fklsc opinion, not yielding to decrees of Coun- 
 cils, or the Chief Pastor of the Catholic Church/* 
 AoREEABLY to this doctrinc The Church excepts 
 from this denunciation, all Children who have re- 
 ceived Christian Baptism-^which alone, obviating 
 the effects of Original Sin, qualifies them with a 
 title to inherit the promises. She excepts also, all 
 who are in a state of invincible ignorance* — " Be- 
 cause (says the learned BellJu-min) wlierever there 
 is ifwincike ignorance^ united with a sincerity and 
 love of troth*— in mrtve of the dispositbiis of their 
 hearts, the Persons so circumstanced belong^to the 
 true church" Tki^ai two classes comprehend a 
 j^ooigious numOci' 01 Souis, who thuugh in a jslate 
 
i^ in lief 
 who are 
 .hendifid 
 is true in* 
 m Divine 
 no mlva* 
 
 •cb— that 
 ot imme-^ 
 bre, by a 
 h. Hear 
 ^ that de* 
 perverse) 
 eart ; es- 
 jhed not, 
 ; and do 
 tig ready 
 not to be 
 
 s to thei 
 gion is a 
 rch'iS de* 
 ndeth in 
 of Goun- 
 >hurch/* 
 I excepts 
 have re- 
 Aviating' 
 tk with a 
 also, all 
 r— "Be- 
 ^ei* there 
 rity and 
 
 I of their 
 igtothe 
 Bhend a 
 
 II a £late 
 
 f*rj" 
 
 •f exterior, separation from the visible Church, ata 
 nevertheless, inwardly united to her by charity. 
 
 Fob. purposes inscrutable to tiie human intellect^, 
 God has seen fit to keep in a condition of uncath* 
 olicity, many pious and virtuous aawefl as learned 
 Persons of various^ Sects, /their prejudices are 
 those of birth and education, and not of the heart* 
 
 The pretended persecuting spirit of the Cathou 
 he Churdi is exhibited«n vast relief in the muddy 
 details of Fox and other zealots : but it is difllcult 
 to substantiate their charges by any documents of 
 authentic History. 
 
 ^ On the contrary, we assert that the Catholic 
 ehurcb is of a^ tolerant character. " During the 
 space of eight hundred years (says W. E. Andrews^ 
 the sagacious Editor of the Londoti Orthodox 
 Journal,) in which the Catholic Church reigned 
 uncontrolled; and her Winisters were invested 
 with tlie plenitude of power^ not a drop of blood 
 was shed in support of her spiritual rights, nor a; 
 temporal law passed to punish those who dogma* 
 tised her doctrines." 
 
 A^TER all Ihesef deductiotl* hov^ev^r, that the 
 Representatives of the Catholic Church have in 
 many instances abused the power con^ded to them, 
 is nevertheless acknowledged and lamented.-^ 
 " Wherever there ai^e men (says Seneca) there are 
 f^lts.*'.-— The Church, though divinely commis- 
 sioned, is a /<Mwia« aW^/^— and human Societies 
 are necessarily imperfect, because Man is imper- 
 fect. The Protestant Sects, with no commission 
 whatever, have almost all persecuted in their turn* 
 Rousseau, a Protestant^ declares that " f he Refer, 
 mation was intolerant from its cradle, and its au* 
 tbors universally persecutors." It is acfaiowledg. 
 ed l^ another Protestant writer, that in the sinde 
 
 K 
 
 iM«««M^, liMO A%iCi^|aiCK>, 
 
74 
 
 burnt down no less than nine htmdred towns and 
 villages,, and murdered three hundred and seventy- 
 eight Priests and Religiovis persons, in the course 
 otone rebellion. The total number of Churches 
 in France which they burnt, was computed to be 
 no less than twenty thousand. The history of the 
 Reformation in England, though less sanguinary 
 than on the Continent, has caused many a Con- 
 version to the Catholic Faith. 
 
 But it is high time that all these complaints and 
 reflections were hushed forever. The wrong was 
 reciprocal. We are none of us answerable for tlie 
 misdeeds of our ance^.ors. God is love. '1 he 
 Religion of Christ is a Religion of love. Instead 
 then of bri^ndishing the lirebrands of religious con- 
 tention, and reproaching each other for the crimes 
 of our forefathers — crimes the offspring of a bar- 
 barous age— -and which in this we all equally la- 
 ment ; let us learn to love one another — to live 
 by faith and not by sight— and to pray and labor 
 for our mutual Salvation. 
 
 " Non est Religionid ReKgionem cogere." , 
 
 Another slander imputes great corruption of 
 manners to Catholics, aud boldly asserts that they 
 substitute devotion for morality-^thinking that a 
 few pater-nosters and ave-marias mumbled over, 
 are sufficient to atone for the most enormous of- 
 fences ; and that Catholic Priests are loose and 
 yinprfncipled. In answer to this charge, we boldly 
 insist, that if there be any thing in which the Ca- 
 tholic church is pre-eminent, it is in the rigid mO' 
 rality of her doctrine. What she preaches, she 
 fails not to practise. Her Clergy are in general 
 pious, just, and temperate; and her Laity are as 
 virtuous at least, it is presumed, as the membeiie 
 #1 other communioiis* 
 
75 
 
 owns and 
 id seventy- 
 the course 
 Churches 
 ted to be 
 )ry of the 
 ariguinary 
 ny a Con- 
 
 laints and 
 vrong was 
 lie for tlie 
 ve. The 
 Instead 
 i^ious con- 
 he crimes 
 of a bar- 
 ]ualiy la- 
 '— to live 
 md labor 
 
 uption of 
 that they 
 ng that a 
 )led over, 
 rmous of^ 
 loose and 
 we boldlj 
 h the Ca- 
 rigid mO' 
 ches, she 
 n general 
 ity are as 
 membeiw 
 
 It is true that a few of the Catholic Clergy* 
 (and 9tiU more Laymen) do not live up to their 
 profession. Some Ecclesiastics are proud, others 
 anjbitious— sQoie dissipated, others covetous, and 
 caring (as Massillon expresses it) more for thQ 
 Jleece than tlie Jhck, This is raatjter for regret, 
 but not for surprise. Did not our bjessed Lord 
 complain that one of his chosen twelve pisciple^ 
 was a DeviU If in the very infapcy of the, 
 Church, under the immediate inspection of our 
 Saviour himself, and anjong his own apostles, there 
 could lurk treason and murdev j wh^t wonder is i^ 
 that in so considerable a body ^s the Catholic Cler« 
 ^y, there should occur, sorpe examples of lamenta^ 
 ble defection ? But for oar consolation, if there 
 be here and there a Judas in the C^hojic Church, 
 90 there are Peters and Pauls— men iliu^tripMS for 
 piety and virtue, whose every thought f^nrf deed 
 are a splendid commentary on that ^09pe} whiclv 
 they are 9ent to proclaim. Look at the inniime? 
 rable band of Martyrs who have bled for the 
 Faith ! Look at the numerous Miasionaries, whp 
 traversing sea and land, have penetrated to the 
 deepest caverns of savage retreat, to announce the 
 glad tidings of a crupified Saviour ! Look at the 
 various Cpnvents all over Christendom ; which, 
 however calunjniated, exhibit the most sublime 
 virtues, and where the severity of the evangelical 
 law is pure and unmitigated ! There, thousands 
 of holy men consecrate thpir diys and nights to 
 Pevotion • There, thousand^ of faithful Virgins, 
 with their lamps trimmed and burning, employ 
 every hour of their life in offering pr^^^'crs of in- 
 tercession for a wicked world ! 
 
 Finally, the Clergy and Dignitaries of the Ca* 
 tholic Church have been traduced as foes to civil li^ 
 fceitp^i as well as to light and knowledge-^particilff 
 
 iwmiiM 
 
7tf 
 
 hdy Awpteyedtn keeping the cmrimon people i« ig. 
 noratice, and in witWiolding fjem them the BM» 
 fit Salvation. 
 
 > WfiRE t^iese tfeniendoa* charges founded in 
 tiuih, -they would lon^r ago have awihilated th^ 
 w^teosiofls, if not the vef y existence, of the €a. 
 itmic 0)urch.— But they are false. 
 
 All ^^he Rtpiblics m Europe havu been reared 
 *nd fostered i« the bosom of^the Catholic Churdh. 
 Magm Umia, the Wlwat k of Brkish fr^dora, 
 J^as the enterprise of ^atbolics. The House of 
 Commons, that sole democratic branch of t4^i€ Con- 
 Sntuti^, had the same origin. In the language 
 0* an Insh orator— "It ^as in tbe bosom of tbe 
 Catholic Church that our free Constitution feeeiv- 
 ?d Its l^uth. Catholics rooked its cradle. Catho- 
 lics watched its infancy, cherished its ehiiahood, 
 and matured its youth.** Literary works witbout 
 number have been written by authors o* ilxis com- 
 munion, i« support of the rights and liberties of 
 inankina. Among others, we may instance the il- 
 lustrious Sir Thomas More, who wiote the lHo- 
 m, or the scheme of a perfect Commooweakh s 
 ki whidh (says David Williams, a Deist) ** are 
 inorereal p inciples, real truths, md real facts, 
 than m all the systems of government, the codes 
 ,TJ,* ^"^ *^^ commentaries on laws in tlm whole 
 V t'^ This great man was so zealous a Catho. 
 •Ac, that be was put to death by Henry the eighth ; 
 becauge he would not renounce his allegiance to 
 the Soyer ign Fontiff, and recognize the suprema- 
 cyorthissanguinarj Tyrant in the Church. 
 
 Protestant writers of the lii^est reputation, 
 have been zealous to eulogize the Catholics, as 
 iovera of Freedom. None h|iv^ executed this in- 
 tention ^nore successfully than that wOhder of our 
 M^» And r»rt<4«» rvf TitolA¥>iJ tu,i,,v.,^„ ...u,. j__l 
 
?opIe m ig. 
 I the Biblft 
 
 >unddl if\ 
 wiated th€ 
 )f theCa- 
 
 eeii re»red 
 e Churdh. 
 \ freedom. 
 House of 
 r the Con- 
 I knguagQ 
 lom ot' th« 
 (Ml feeeiv- 
 . Catho- 
 *hHdhood, 
 :« without 
 41^8 "Com- 
 ^berties of 
 lee the li- 
 the Uio- 
 mweshh : 
 -Jst) ** are 
 eal facts, 
 the eodes 
 the whole 
 a Catho- 
 e eighth ; 
 giance to 
 sii|)rejna- 
 ch. 
 
 •piitatioti, 
 holies, as 
 d this in- 
 ier of ouf 
 
 Gaehdicity gplenAjJ jMsMoe, and that in « strain of 
 eloquence, unparaiieied perhaps in «ny ianguaf?e. 
 
 4yOo« at the Missions of Paiaguay. The Cath- 
 die -Church had prcgected the converf?ion of the 
 Aborigines o^* tbi^ extensive region to the Ohf is- 
 tiai- Faith. A few Jesuit^ undertook tik cciga»ti« 
 and ha»ardous enterprise. With a Cruahx in 
 their hand and a chaplet ^t their girdle, they ^^ac- 
 €d danger and death amid tlie pathless wilds of 
 Soubh America. They chewed the leaf of ll)« 
 forest for food, and slaked tlieir thirst with tlve 
 ram from heaven. Their lodging was among the 
 branches of trees— and tlieif si lumbers were hourly 
 interrupted by the roaring of lions, tygers and 
 panthers, and the hissing of serpants. Nothing, 
 however coi|ld appal these brov^ and indefatigable 
 men. yhe hostility of the Savages made up the 
 measure of their sutferings. But their zeal, pa- 
 tience, and trust in God, triumphed over every 
 obstacle j and conciliating tl>e barbarians l>y de- 
 grees, they founded a Colony—anil such a colony 
 ^s the world never yet saw. We say nothing of 
 tt as a rdigious^ but merely as a political establish* 
 flient, though in either yiew it excites equal won- 
 der and ments equal praiset. The republir of Ha- 
 te was no longer a dri im. In 'Paraguay /asre- 
 dlized a society the ha| inest, and a legislation the 
 most perfect, that Hfstory had yet presented t«^ 
 human admiration. Let those who stigmatize tl^e 
 Catholic Church in general, and tlie Jesuits in par- 
 tic'ar, as enemies to civil libtrty and the rights o£ 
 man, read the Relation of' the Missi. ns of Para- 
 |^ttay,'and thank ^God for the preservaaon of the 
 one and the restoration of ihi^ other { 
 
 It is equally false that the Catholic Clergy are 
 ^nemies to light and knowledge. They wlio love 
 f© cowtittst the learning of the iHieieirt i*ag^ns witih 
 
 
7» 
 
 I 
 
 that of modern Christians, will do well <o remem- 
 ber, that not a single line of any Greek or Roman 
 writer would have reached our times and inspec- 
 tion, had it not been for the care and vigilance qf 
 the Catholic Clergy. During and after the rava- 
 ges of the Goths, Vandals and northern barbari- 
 ans in the South of Europe, who laid all waste ; 
 Literature found an asylum in the Convents of 
 the Catholic Church — and if she has since come 
 forth with her treasures to delight and edify ihe 
 world, let those who afforded her so signal a pro- 
 tection, have their meed of praise. 
 
 Yet this is but a small part of the claim of Ca- 
 tholics. The revival of letters was the work of 
 Leo tenth— .not merely a Cathqlic, but a Papal 
 power— and Voltaire boasts that the Catholic 
 reign of Louis the fourteenth made a fourth sera 
 in literature ; and was more fertile in illustrious 
 men, than the other three— viz : those of Pericles, 
 Augustus, and Lqq tenth, though, so rppoyynied, 
 put together. 
 
 In every branch of sacred and prpfane learning 
 —in every art and in every science ; Catholics 
 have so greatly distinguished themselves, as tp 
 bear off the palm from every other society in the 
 universe. David Hume acknowledges that the 
 Catholics are the. most learned of all the Christian 
 denominations-r-and Lord Hutchinson, in a speech 
 in Parliament, says that " Catholicity has been the 
 belief of the most ej^tensive and enlightened na- 
 tions ; and of the most illustrious characters that 
 ever did honor to the name of man." Her two 
 Religious Orders of Jesuits and Benedictines alone 
 have done more for Letters, than all the learned 
 moen of the Reform united. 
 
 Scarcely a department of excellence can be 
 named which does not find a Catholic at the head 
 
remein« 
 )r Roman 
 d inspec- 
 ;ilance qf 
 the rava- 
 
 barbari* 
 ill waste ; 
 nvents of 
 nee come 
 edify the 
 lal a pro* 
 
 m of Ca- 
 ) work of 
 t a Papal 
 
 Catholic 
 »urth aera 
 Uustrious 
 
 Pericles, 
 jpowned, 
 
 learning 
 Catholics 
 Js, as tp 
 ty in the 
 that the 
 [Christian 
 a speech 
 been the 
 ned na- 
 ters that 
 Her two 
 les alone 
 
 1 learned 
 
 can be 
 the head 
 
 1% 
 
 df it. In such a galdxv of light and splendor, to 
 particularize any single star were a sort of pre- 
 sumption. Theology is udorned with the names 
 of all the Fathers of the Church from Tertullian 
 down to St. Thomas Aquinas and Bossuet. In 
 Philosophy, Descartes has divided the applause of 
 mankind with Newton. Mallebranche associates 
 with Locke in anatomizing the human intellect* 
 Tasso, Ariosto, Petrarch, Corneille, Dryden, Ka- 
 cine and Pope, have rivalled Homer and Virgil in 
 Song. Bourdalour and Massillon are names for 
 eloquence itself. In Music, Catholicity has pro* 
 duced Corelli, Geminiani and Arne. In Painting, 
 Raffaelle, Rubens, Michael Angello, Le Brun and 
 Poussin. 
 
 A Catholic first traversed the Atlantic ocean, 
 and the Indian seas. A Catholic first scaled the 
 heavens in an air balloon. In fine, most of the 
 inventionsi either of use or ornament, which have 
 appeared in modern time, owe their existence to 
 the knowledge and enginuity of Catholics. Yet 
 Catholics are denounced as enemies to human im- 
 provement l-^Risum Teneatis amki ? 
 
 As the Regular and Secular Clergy of the Ca- 
 tholic Church have been illustrious for Learning 
 themselves, so have they generally been industrious 
 in diffusing useful knowledge among the people. 
 
 Almost all the Universities, Colleges and 
 Schools in Europe, that are not of recent institu- 
 tion, were founded by the zeal and charity of Ca- 
 tholics. These establishments are much more 
 numerous in Catholic than in Protestant countries 
 — and infinitely superior in their government and 
 regulation. 
 
 That the Catholic Church withholds the Scrip, 
 tures from the common people, is likewise false 
 
 and oaliimniniifi T^iio incr>it«Arl "XT^l,,,^^ k^^ i i<. 
 
 i 
 
 "Ml 
 
ho€i> translated into all tl>€ knguages of the known 
 wwKK where tlie Catholic Faith ia professed. It 
 » true unU k was necessary^ tlm in the disuibu- 
 tioil of copies, mnong many where a spirit of cavil 
 iwAl contention was remly Ixy obli(jii€ interpretation 
 fo wros« the sense to their own tlestructioni the 
 Pastors of the Church, midcr so wei^^hty .. respon- 
 sihilily, harve shewn some reserve. Who can won- 
 der at t\m prndence, after what we have seen take 
 plade antong our Protestant Brethren, in whose 
 connnunion* an opposite line of conduct has muU 
 tipled opinions and divisions without end ? 
 
 itwiNu ihus anticipated and (we trust) obvia* 
 ted all current, and alnioj^t all possible, objections 
 to Catholic Faith and Discipline, we may conft* 
 dent[y affirm that this task is, nevertheless, alto- 
 gether gratuitous and snuerogatory. For if it bo 
 oiearly established, that the Csitholic Church is tlye 
 true Church of Christ J all discussions respecting 
 her tenets, is SuperHuous. Because if she be the 
 tru<5 Church, she is infallible, if infaUible, she 
 can impose ik) t^rtides oi^ cretlence, false or even 
 doiibtiul. The interenco is irresistible. 
 
 Let us never ceuse to insist, that the Catholic 
 Clmrcb unites every feature and qualification, 
 which Reason and Religion teach us to expect in 
 the true Church of Christ. Ofie in shape and 
 form— //o/y in cb.aracter — Cnmraal in extent^ — 
 MKl-Aposioikai in Faith and Doctrine, and in thtif 
 succession of her Pastors. 
 
 In all these traits (we repeat it) the Protestiknt 
 societies are evitiently {leficient. If then tiie Ca- 
 tholic Church be not the true Church of Christ, 
 tliere is and qan be ^ofie. Consequently,, they 
 who deny her authority, must take refuge iu De- 
 ism, and reject all Revcrtied Religion, 
 
 NoTW|THsxAN©iNG the disaordance of Uieic 
 
lie known 
 med. It 
 ' distiibu- 
 t o( cavil 
 pretatiuii 
 ;?tion, the 
 ♦* rcspon- 
 cati won* 
 iecn take 
 in wiiose 
 has mul* 
 ? 
 
 ;t) obvia-i 
 bjectioiwf 
 ay conii* 
 ess, a}to- 
 1' if it bo 
 ck is the 
 jspecting. 
 le be the 
 ibU}, she 
 t or even 
 
 Catholic 
 iHcationi 
 xp€Gl in 
 Ape and 
 ?xtent^ — 
 d in thd 
 
 otesti^nt 
 tiie Ca^ 
 f Christ, 
 ^y, they 
 Q ill De- 
 
 f tlieic 
 
 81 
 
 opinions, vet our Protestant Brethren insist, that 
 they have a standard of truth, and a rule of faith 
 to winch they appeal ou all occasions, and by 
 
 Ts the Sibl!"'"'''' '" ^' ^"'"'"'^ ^'""^^'^ This 
 of IWulb^'^' Chillingworth) is the Religion 
 
 On the contrary, Catholics maintain that the Bi. 
 ble. however inspired, is insufficient as a rule of 
 laiUi, and a giude to salvation. 
 
 Lkst this sentiment should be misunderstood, it 
 may be proper to state, that no people on the face 
 ) the earth, entertam a more profound veneratioa 
 or the Ho y Scriptures, than the Clergy and Lai- 
 tyof the Catholic Church. The solemnity and 
 genuflexions which are exacted in reading them 
 at Mass, are edifymg to all strangers whS occa- 
 sionally assist at this Sacriflce. One side of the 
 High Altar is called the Gospel side, and the oth- 
 o{ hat o the Ep^slie Nor are they less respect, 
 ed by Catholics individually. They are read with 
 great devotion ; and by many upon their knees. 
 
 1 HE Bible (says ChiUmgworth) is the tteligion 
 ot Protestants." . & ^ * 
 
 What is the Bible ? The Bible it will be an- 
 swered, is the History of the most remarkable 
 Dispensations of God to Man. It records a series 
 ot the most astonishing events, analogous to no- 
 thing w iich we, of the present age. have ever seen 
 or heard— events in constant contradiction to th« 
 usual routine of things, and in perpetual violaUon 
 ot the common laws of nature. 
 
 irM '^'''i" \^'^ ^"'^ ^^^"^^^ ^ha^ evidence does th« 
 Bible aliord in proof of the amazing and miracu- 
 lous trfinsactions which it relates ?— None wiiattv- 
 er. No book can authenticate itself —It mtst 
 then be believed nnnn pTtPWini t^kof. •...««., a„j 
 
^i 
 
 what is this ? — Tradition, So true is it that every 
 thing in Religion is traditional. 
 
 In the next place, through what channel ? Did 
 the first Reformers witness the events narrated in 
 Holy Writ, or even see them recorded ? — Certain- 
 Jy not. From whom did they receive the Bible ?- 
 From the Catholic Church. Consequently then 
 she is the regular channel of Tradition, is the sole 
 legitimate depository of the Scriptures, and can 
 alone prove their authenticity — and explain their 
 meaning. 
 
 The Founders of Protestantism rejected the 
 unwritten Traditions of the Cliurch, on the pre- 
 text that they were fabricated and false. If the 
 Catholic Church could with impunity have exe- 
 cuted such imposition as these on the Christian 
 world, could she not likewise have invented the 
 Bible itself? 
 
 Should our Protestant Brethren object that the 
 Old Testament has been also transmitted through 
 the channel of the Synagogue ; we might reply, 
 that not a Christian in existence believes it upon 
 this testimony. And had the Catholic Church 
 rejected the Jewish Records as she did the Jewish 
 Worship, not a Protestant at this day would have 
 received them. 
 
 With regard to the New Testament, should 
 our Protestant Brethren cite the Greek and Eas- 
 tern churches — and alledge that it has been e- 
 qually transmitted through their channel ; w« 
 might rejoin that both Greeks and Orientals have 
 separated from Catholic unity— and like the Pro- 
 testants, owe their Bible to C atholic Tradition. 
 
 Luther himself acknowledges all this, and sayg 
 " We are obliged to yield many things to the Pa- 
 pists — that mth them is the Word of God, whick 
 
93 
 
 ;hat every 
 
 el? Did 
 arrated in 
 -Certain. 
 ? Bible ?- 
 ntly then 
 s the sole 
 , and can 
 (lain their 
 
 icted the 
 1 the pre- 
 j. If the 
 have exe- 
 Christian 
 ented the 
 
 t that the 
 I through 
 jht reply, 
 IS it upon 
 : Church 
 le Jewish 
 )uld have 
 
 t, should 
 and £as- 
 been e- 
 lel ; we 
 tals have 
 the Pro- 
 lition. 
 and says 
 ) the Pa- 
 d, whick 
 
 we received from them : otherwise we should have 
 known nothing at all about it. * 
 
 These facts being admitted, what guarantee 
 have our Protestant Brethren, that the CathoIi« 
 Church is not the sole inventor of Christianity, and 
 that she has not herself forged the Records which 
 proclaim its establishment ? — Certainly none what- 
 ever. 
 
 AGAiN-r^Suppose the Bible true^ — of what num- 
 ber of books and what precise books does it cortJ 
 sist ?— 14; is itself silent upon the subject. Twen- 
 ty books at least, it has been calculated, are lost. 
 Among them are that of tJie Wars of the Lord-^ 
 See Numbers xxi. U^^that of Jehu the son of 
 Hanani, 2 Chron. xx, 34i.-^that of Nathan the Pro- 
 phet, 1 Chron. xxix. 29.r— that of the Prophecy of 
 Abijah, ^ Chron. ix. ^9,^that of tb- Vision of 
 Iddo the Seer, See ibid.— that of 3a'u.uel the Seer, 
 See 1 Chron. xxix. 29.-r--t!iai af Gad the Seer, 
 ibid.— that of Jasher.— The Fpistle of Paul to the 
 Laodiceans, See Col. iv. IG.— that of the Chroni- 
 cles of the Kings of Judah and Israel, and many 
 others—besides three thousand Proverbs by Solo- 
 mon, and fifteen hundred Canticles ! 
 
 Now we ask, who knows what these lost books 
 contained ; and whether they might not have con- 
 tained something, the knowledge of which is ab- 
 solutely necessary to Salvation ? ^ 
 
 Once more — Suppose this difficulty vanquished, 
 others arise not less obstinate and perplexing, and 
 the Protestant still holds 1ms faith by the most 
 precarious tenure. 
 
 *' The Bible (says Chillingworth) is the Religion 
 of Protestants." 
 
 But what Bible — that is, what copy, what edi- 
 tion ? The learned Dr. Mills computed that in 
 feis tim^, there were not less thaiji iUrttf thousand, 
 
readings of the New Testament. Cm we for ii 
 moment doubt that in these various rei^dings, there 
 IS matter enough to foEm as many sects, when we 
 see a hundred sects divide upon the same reading 
 ■^yiz ; that of the Bible printed in Use reisn of 
 King James the first ? ■ 
 
 If it be urged, that these variations are trifling 
 and accidental, neither subversive of sound doc- 
 trine, nor implying any treachery in the Transla- 
 tors : let us appeal to the sentiments of the Re- 
 formers and other Protestants themselves, whose 
 mutual complaints, sarcasms and abuse are un^ 
 paralleled in the annals of controversy. Whitaker 
 B'Ay?, ^' Forgery, I blush for the honor of Protes- 
 tantism, while I write it, seems to have been pe- 
 culiar to the Reformed, I look in vain for one of 
 these accursed outrages of imposition among tb^ 
 disciples of Popery.** 
 
 ZuiNGi^ius says to Luther—" Thou corruptest, 
 O Luther ! the divine word. Thou art an open 
 and bold perverter of the Sacred Scriptures. Al- 
 - though we have esteemed thee beyond measure, 
 yet we now blush at thy prophaneness." Luther 
 is not much in his debt, but calls him and his fol- 
 lowers " Asses, fools, antichrists and impostors.** 
 The Bible of the divines of Basil, Beza calls «• wic- 
 ked, and quite repugnant to the dictates of the 
 Holy Ghost.'* The Bible of Castalio, tiie same 
 Bejsa calls " Sacrilegious, wicked and pagan.** Of 
 the Bible of Beza himself, Castalio in his turn 
 says, " Indieed to mention all Beza*s corruptions 
 of the Scripture would fill a volume.** And Mo^ 
 linoeus says '* Beza changes entirely the text.**— 
 The Bible of Calvin, the same Molinoeus criticises 
 with egual severity, and says '^ Calvin makes the 
 t^xt of the Gospel leap up and down. He uses 
 vioknee to the letter V tbe Gospel and adds if 
 
we for ft 
 gs, there 
 ivhen we 
 reading 
 reign oi 
 
 5 trifling 
 ind doc- 
 Transla- 
 the Rcr 
 5, whose 
 are un^ 
 i^hitaker 
 ■ Protes- 
 jeen pe- 
 r one of 
 ong th« 
 
 riiptest, 
 an open 
 
 !S. Al- 
 leasure, 
 Luther 
 his fol- 
 ostors." 
 s *• wic- 
 s of the 
 Le same 
 1." Of 
 lis turn 
 uptions 
 uiMo- 
 ?xt."— 
 riticises 
 kes the 
 le uses 
 adds if 
 
 the text.- InLutlier's Dutch translation of the 
 New lestament only, there were found o/j^ //^ow, 
 sand Jour hundred heretical errors ' 
 
 merited or found any better quarter. 
 
 A Petition directed to King James the First, 
 comptams « That our translation of the Psalms 
 comprised m the Book of Common Prayer, doth 
 n addition subtraction and alteration, difer Irora 
 
 CT: P / ? ^^^^^^^^ corruptions wcr^ found 
 1\Z Tf «/a;2., and that by Protestant, ihem- 
 seives how many might be found fmm the be^in^ 
 mng of Genesis to the end of the Apucatmse, it ex. 
 amined by an impartial judge? ^ 
 
 Mb. Carlisle vouches "That the Enolish 
 ransto have^depraved the sense, ooscurecf the 
 truth deceived the ignorant; that in many place?. 
 tlftl' '\ Scriptures from the ri,.htinsel: 
 and that they shew themselves to love darkness 
 more than light-^falsehood more than truth >» 
 
 ihatthe English translation of the Bible is a 
 translation that takes ^way from the texts-that 
 adds to the texts, and that sometimes to the chan. 
 olnJ' ^^'""7"^, ^^' the meaning of the Holy 
 Ohost. For which cause, Protesumts of tender 
 
 trreto""'' "'''^' ^'""' '''"^^'^ ^^' subscribing 
 
 niy nand, a translation, which hath so maw/ omis^ 
 mm, many additions, which sometimes obscure 
 ^n^eumes pervert the sense: being sometimes 
 fe^^iieless, sometimes contrary." 
 
 This great evil of corrupting the Scripture, 
 being well considered by Mr. Bimighton, one of 
 fUe moat zealous sort of Prntpstanfc ^uw^^a u:^ 
 
80 
 
 to write an epistle to the Lords of the Council, 
 desiring them with all speed to procure a new 
 translation. Because (says he) that which is now 
 m England is full of errorsJ* And in his adver- 
 tisements of coruptions, he tells the Bishops " That 
 their public translation of the Scripture into En- 
 glish is such, that it perverts the text of the Old 
 Testament in eight hundred and forty eight places, 
 and that it causes millions of millions to reject the 
 New Testament, and run into eternal flames /** 
 
 Finally, the translators of the great English 
 Bible declare that " Among the numberless trans- 
 iations which are extant this day in Europe, there 
 is none 0/ them all of divine and infallible authority " 
 
 Thus it appears that the Bible is written in va- 
 rious and obsolete languages, translated and re- 
 translated over and over again, offering at length in- 
 numerable copies, obscure and interpolated. Who 
 has the sagacity, the patience, the time and the 
 opportunity to collate, examine and compare all 
 these copies, verse by verse, and erect a system of 
 faith upon his labor? 
 
 Nevertheless, every person, without exception, 
 who takes the Bible as his sole guide to salvation, 
 is absolutely bound to do this. And after all his 
 industry and research, it is at least a million chan- 
 ces to one that he mistakes in his doctrine and 
 that his soul is lost ! 
 
 We repeat it emphatically once and again, let 
 none imagine, from the color of this argument, that 
 Catholics do not entertain the most profound res^ 
 pect for this Divine Volume. They esteem it more 
 than all other writings whatever. But they do not 
 ascribe to it impossibilities. They know and they 
 never cease to urge that the Bible cannct be ifs 
 own interpreter. Books cannot speak. What 
 then is precisely, and without equivocationj it's use? 
 
Council, 
 J a new 
 h is now 
 is adver- 
 s " That 
 into En- 
 tile Old 
 ht places, 
 jject the 
 les r 
 
 English 
 jss trans- 
 36, there 
 thorityJ^ 
 m in va- 
 
 and re- 
 ength in- 
 1. Who 
 and the 
 ipare all 
 ystem of 
 
 :ception, 
 alvation, 
 2r ail his 
 on chan- 
 ine and 
 
 gain, let 
 ent, that 
 und resi- 
 lit more 
 y do not 
 md they 
 t be tfs 
 What 
 it's use? 
 
 S7 
 
 Simply this and this only. It is a Lcviv in the 
 hands of a Judge, excellent when applied : but 
 Absolutely incapable of self application. 
 
 God, who wills the salvation of man, who would 
 rescue him from sin and death, and raise him to a 
 state of immortal life and glory, has appointed three 
 powers which co-operate in this work of transcen- 
 dant love and mercy, viz i a LegUator, a Law, 
 and an Interpreter, The Legislator is the Al^ 
 fnight^ himself. The Law, is the Traditions of 
 the Church, whether written or unwritten. The 
 Interpreter is the Church. In this compound 
 agency, the last (I speak it with awe) is as neces- 
 sary as the first : and without whose cooperation 
 the second is absolutely useless. ' 
 
 To render this more clear and incontrovertible 
 let us suppose a code of laws framed for a country 
 which were to be obeyed without the intervention 
 and coercion of courts of justice. What would be 
 the consequence of this arrangement ? Exactly 
 what we see take place among our Protestant 
 -Brethren, with regard tc the laws of Scripture. 
 And as men who recognize no common authority 
 to explain and apply these laws, interpret them in 
 their own way, and of course differently : one 
 crying, this is the trurh according to Scripture 
 another that—So in a community where every re- 
 gulation was to be adjusted by private opinion 
 without judge or jury, every man offending or of- 
 lended, sinned against or sinning would interpret 
 the law in his own favor, to the multiplication of 
 crime and the oppression of innocence. 
 
 It would not be possible to govern a community. 
 It laws were left to arbitrary interpretation and 
 execution. The Church, founded by our Lord 
 and Saviour, is the grand tribunal, to which her 
 children are to refer in all tbeir soiritual conrmK, 
 
88 
 
 It she exacts the most implicit obedience, slie t^- 
 pays it with peace an security. 
 
 This principle of submission and subordination 
 so necessary to every society^ though formally 
 denied by our Protestant Brethren, who avow> 
 that the very essence of Protestantism is the ri^ht 
 q/ private judgmentf is nevertheless, virtually admit- 
 ted. Assemblies and Synods have been convened 
 in the several countries of the Reform to digest 
 and impose articles of faith. And though the 
 foundation of their revolt from the Church, rests 
 on the right of private judgment j yet among our 
 Protestant Brethren this right, which has been 
 claimed and maintained by rebellion and blood- 
 shed, is as much controlled by the decisions of 
 their Assemblies and Synods, as it is among Ca 
 thoiics by the decrees of the General Councils. 
 The Synod of Charenton in France in 1()4<4«, noti- 
 cing the error of the Independents, who teach that 
 " Every Church ought to be governed by her pro- 
 per laws, without any dependance upon any person 
 in ecclesiastical matters, and without any obligation 
 to acknowledge the authorhy of Conferences and 
 Synods, for her regulation and conduct," urge 
 on the contrary and with great animation, " That 
 this sect is as prtjudicial to the state, as to the 
 Church : and that it opens a door to all sorts of 
 irregularities and extravagances, that it takes 
 away all the means of applying any remedy to it, 
 and that if it took place, there might be as many 
 religions framed as parishes or particular assem- 
 blids" Rational as this decision is in itself, can 
 any thing be imagined more inconsistent and un- 
 becomnig, than such language in the mouths of 
 men, who had themselves renounced the autho- 
 rity of the universal Church ? 
 
 Among tlie various abuses of terms, their i« 
 
, she f d- 
 
 dination 
 formally 
 10 avow> 
 :he right 
 y admit- 
 onvened 
 y digest 
 ugh the 
 :h, reRts" 
 long our 
 as been 
 I blood- 
 sions of 
 3ng Ca 
 Councils. 
 4, noti- 
 ;acb that 
 lier pro- 
 y person 
 [)Hgaj,ion 
 Qces and 
 :," urge 
 , " That 
 to the 
 sorts of 
 it takes 
 dy to it, 
 
 r ossein- 
 lelf, can 
 and un- 
 louths of 
 le autho- 
 
 their i« 
 
 89 
 
 bond rtiore l)alpable than the word Church amontf 
 our seceding Brethren. They speak with great 
 confidence of the Protestant Church, in contradis- 
 tinction from the Cathohc. But where is this 
 Church ? No where. A vast variety of sects has 
 appeared within the last three centuries in Europe 
 and America, denominated Protestant : from 
 their protesting against the Church of Rome. But 
 they have no other bond of union whatever. Thev 
 are many of them bitter foes to each other, and 
 profess tenets of reciprocal contradiction. In 
 this chaos of ^eeds^amid this anarchy of sects 
 and opinionsi. it is true with mathematical certain- 
 ty, that all cannnot have truth on their side All 
 may be wrong, but all cannot be right. Yet alas ' 
 
 n7f \PP^^* ^"^ ^^^^ ^^™^ standard of truth— the 
 liibte : though no two sects and scarcely any two 
 men of this whole number can agree ia their in- 
 terpretation of its meaning, 
 
 Tpiusitis evident that out of the Catholic 
 Church, there is no certainty of faith and tto as- 
 surance of salvation, and many an example has 
 there been of a Catholic, after rejecting the an- 
 thority of his native Church, becoming Sn Atheist, 
 
 IHE Authors of the Encyclopcedia speak very 
 pertmenly on this subject. « The first step (say 
 they) which the curious ahd indocile CathohV 
 ^kes, when he begins to be dissatisfied ^?h h is 
 KehgioH IS to adopt the Protestant rule of inve 
 tigation, to constitute himself a judge of Relicrion 
 and become Protestant. Led on by this rufe Tn 
 the ardor of investigation, he soon begins to di^ 
 covei that the principles of Protestantism are f„ 
 coherent, and its doctrine unintelligible. S m 
 therefore, conducted by the same rule, he ^oen 
 
 forward, and becomes a Socinian. Soc niurnsm 
 he finds out has all th^ nprr.w;.:.. „ J7 " "*^*?'» 
 
 M 
 
90 
 
 Cencie^ of Protestantisrti, and he declares himself 
 a Deist. Well, still discontented, because still 
 parsued with difficuhiesr, he i? sen«il ly becomes a 
 tyrrhonian. Pyrrhonism h a state too drea(*^"ul 
 to eudure, and he concludes the series of his erroff 
 by linking into the dreadful abj ss of Atheram." 
 
 If all be true that is recorded, even by Protes- 
 tants themselves, the history of the Kefon* ^tion 
 is a satire upon itn n taie and pretensions. If 
 sound doctrine gained nothing by this Hevolty 
 there are abundant vouchers to prove that pine 
 morality gained as little. Even in jthe inlim^y of 
 this unhappy Sec ssion, when prudetiee and policy 
 ought at least to have sav« d appearances, what 
 was the character of Protestantism and Protes- 
 tants ? Let us listen to their own report.— Pare- 
 lus l-.berus, a learned Lutheran minister, utters 
 this bitter complaint — " Our whole evangelical 
 congregation abounds with so many divisions and 
 scandals, that it is nothing less than what it pre- 
 tends to be. If you look upon the evangelical 
 teachers themselves, you will see that some of them 
 are spurred on with vain glory and an invidious 
 zeal. Some of them raise unreasonable debates, 
 and then maintain them with unadvised heat. — 
 There are many of thr m who pull down by their 
 picked lives, what they had built up by the truth 
 of their doctrine. Which evi s as every one sees 
 with his own eyes, so has he great reason to doubt 
 whether our evangelical congregation be the true 
 Church, in which so many and such enormous 
 vices are discovered.*' 
 
 •Andrew DuDiTH, in his epistle to Beza, write* 
 as foMows — •* What sort of people are our Protes- 
 tants, struggling to and fro, and carried about with 
 every wind of doptrine, sometimes to this side, 
 sometimes to that ? You may perhaps know what 
 
91 
 
 himself 
 tse still 
 
 Jreac'^ul 
 is erroro 
 ram." 
 
 Protes- 
 rni^tion 
 ms. U 
 
 HevoUy 
 lat pure 
 Un^y of 
 l1 policy 
 .'9, what 
 
 Protes- 
 -^Pare- 
 ', utters 
 ngelical 
 ons and 
 t it pre- 
 ngelicat 
 ot' them 
 ividious 
 debates, 
 
 heat. — 
 by their 
 he truth 
 me sees 
 :^o doubt 
 the true 
 lortnoua 
 
 U write* 
 Protes- 
 )ut with 
 his side, 
 )w what 
 
 theii stentitnents in reli^ion are to-day : but you 
 can nerer certainly tell what they ,viU be to-rti^r- 
 row. In what article of religion do these churches 
 agree among themselves, whicii have cast off' the 
 Bishop f ^ome 5 Examine all from top to L t- 
 tom, ycm sh »" scarce find one thing affirmed oy 
 one is not immediately condemned by a- 
 
 nother lor wicked doctrine." 
 
 Luther himself in many places, complairtA of 
 his Followers growing worse and worse — ** And 
 men, (says he) are now more revengeful, covetous 
 and licentious than they were in the Papacy.;" 
 " Heretofore (he remarks in anotiier place) when 
 ' we wer< -^educed by the Pope, every body did 
 willing! V ,bllow ^ood 'works. And now no man 
 either sayeth or knowcfh any thing, but hnw to 
 get all to himself by exactions, pillage, theft, lying, 
 usury, &c." He eise\yhere declaims-r-'* Men are 
 become so extiavagant by the Gospel we have 
 
 f)reached to them, that they think every thing 
 awful that flatters their passions, and have lost all 
 fear of hell fire. There is hut one peasant in i\\Q 
 district of Wittemberg, who endeavours to instruct 
 his fkmily according to the word o)l God. All the 
 rest go st-aight to the Devil, The same Luther 
 acknowledges that under the Papacy are many 
 good things ; yea,' All that is good in Christianiti/. 
 ?« 1 say, moreover, (rejoins he) that under the Pa- 
 pacy is true Christianity f even the very kernel of 
 iPhristianityJ* 
 
 Melancthom says^* It is plain, that in these 
 countries, men*s whole concern almost is about 
 banquetting, drunkenness and carousing. And 
 so strangely barbarous is the people, that most 
 mien are persuaded that if they do but fast one 
 day, they must die the following night." 
 
 Galviit says, " of so many thousands, who re- 
 
IMAGE EVALUATION 
 TEST TARGET (MT.3) 
 
 1.0 
 
 I.I 
 
 m m 
 
 2.5 
 
 us 
 
 u 
 
 2.0 
 
 IL25 ■ 1.4 
 
 1.6 
 
 A" 
 
 Photographic 
 
 Sciences 
 Corporation 
 
 23 WEST MAIN STREET 
 
 WEBSTER, N.Y. 14580 
 
 (716) 872-<5c3 
 
 A 
 
 .^ 
 
 
 
 » 
 
 y. 
 
 f/j 
 
 
 <F 
 
 \ 
 
 iV 
 
 :\ 
 
 \ 
 
 
 % 
 
 
 .^ 
 
 ^ 
 
} 
 
 A' 
 
 
•' 
 
 m 
 
 Mouncjng Popery, seepdcd eagerly to embrace th« 
 Uospel, howfew have aipen^ed their lives ? Nay, 
 what else did the greater p^r| pretend to. but sha, 
 k,mg of the yoke of superstition^ to give themselves 
 more liberty to follow rU kind of lasciviousn^ss ? 
 In anoxher place—" Qf the few that hav^ separa- 
 ted themselves fro(n the tyranny of the Pop^ 
 the greatest part are rotten ^t he^rt. They ap- 
 pear outwardly to he full of zeal j but if you 
 search them to the bottom, you ;yil| jJacJ theii^ 
 lull of hypocrisy and deceit.'' ., 
 
 CAriTON, a tpinister of S^rasburg says in one of 
 o' V®"^*"^""" The multitude has entirely shaken 
 o^^the yoke, being trained up to libertinism. As 
 |t by pulhng down the pope's authority. W9 m. 
 lended to destroy the word qf God, th^ S^cra^ 
 nients, and the, whole ministry. They ev^n have 
 the impudence to tell us, ' I am syffici^ntly ip- 
 strycted in Scriptures— I can read— .a?id stand in 
 no need of your direction." 
 
 Jacob AxYdrjias says-^MThe Protestants give 
 
 due place to the preaching pf the word of God j 
 
 but no amendment of manners is found among 
 
 theni. On the contrary, we see them lead an a- 
 
 bominahle, voluptuous beastly life. Instead of 
 
 lasts they spend whole nights and days in revellings 
 
 and drunkennessi."— In another place he says, «« To 
 
 ^ake it plain to all the world that they are not 
 
 Papists, and place no confidence in good wo^ks ; 
 
 they take care to practise none. When they 
 
 pught to relieve the poor, they fleece and oppress 
 
 them. Oaths, blasphemies, and implications are 
 
 the;r usual prayers. So that Jesus Christ is nolt 
 
 so blasphemed among tjie Jurks as he is among 
 
 them. In a word—instead of humility, nothing 
 
 reigns among them but haughtiness, arrogance and 
 
 pnde } and this sorf of life is called evangelical," , 
 
)race th^ 
 J? Nay, 
 but sha« 
 em selves 
 ousn^ssp 
 p separa^ 
 e f ope, 
 rhey ap- 
 t if you 
 04 then^ 
 
 n one of 
 f shaken 
 3m. iVs 
 . W9i^, 
 
 ^^n have 
 ?ntly ip- 
 starid in 
 
 its give 
 ►fGodj 
 
 among 
 id an a- 
 tead of 
 veilings 
 Ks, " To 
 are not 
 wo^'Jks ; 
 ^ they 
 oppress 
 ons are 
 t is no|^ 
 
 among 
 nothing 
 ice and 
 li^ai," . 
 
 96 
 
 WoLFANGUs MuscDLus says— « OuF Gospellen 
 ^^re grown so unlike themselves, that whereas un- 
 der Popery, they were religious in their errors and 
 superstition j now, in the light of the known truth.^ 
 they are more profane, light, vain and teme- 
 rarious thijn the very children of -this world." In 
 another place he declares, « As to us Lutherans, 
 the matter stands thus ; If any one has a mind to 
 
 UaJ T . ^'^^^^ "™"^' drunkards, libertines, 
 liars, cheats and insurers— let him go to a town 
 where the Gospel is preached in its purity : and he 
 
 I'l \^\^lu^^^'^^ ^' ^^^ ^'"^ "™^y ^^ seen at noon 
 ii^y, that there is not so much insolence and wic- 
 kedness pracused among the Turks and infidels as 
 Among emngehcal people, where all the reins of 
 the Devil are let loose.'^ 
 
 thp^l^'T'^? Baiter confesses, f' That now was 
 ^he state of religion in England come to a stmnge 
 pass J because always in passing and had no et 
 Sr'!?'' f^/^bleof^Protfus, X cha^ 
 W ^ Tu^ ^".s^^Pes and forms, might be no 
 
 says. « What Jove or charity is th^ere among^^^^^^^ 
 When one calls anoUier Heretic and Anabaptist- 
 
 If P '^nfT- ""f' ^""^ ^^P^'^*' Hypocrite, Phari. 
 see?.^OfthisIam sure, that charity and virtue 
 were never less exercised; and that God among 
 SfS'^' ''''' "^'^' '' reverenced, Jionored or 
 
 Box perhaps the Keformers redeemed, by the 
 
 Ifl^ltrZu'^": "r '^^"''«««' the disorder 
 Of their Adherents. Let us then add the portraite 
 
«MH 
 
 which the Reforffiera draw of themselves and of 
 each pthen 
 
 ** Qum I>9us vuit perdere, prius detnenUt" 
 
 Luther says-—" I am burned with the flames 
 of my untamed lusts and the desire of fvomen, I, 
 who ought to be fervent in spi.it, am lost in im- 
 purity, in sloth, &c.*' In another i>iace he says, 
 ** Relying on the strong foundation of my learn- 
 ingf I yielded not in pride either to the Emperor j 
 King, or Devih-^XiOt not to the universe itself.** 
 
 " Luther (says Hospinian) is a man absolutely 
 furious ; accustomed to combat the trutk, not only 
 unjustly, but in contradiction to his own conscience,** 
 " Hie is (says OScolampadius) puffed up with ar- 
 rogance and pride, and seduced by Satan.". Zur 
 inglius says, ** Indeed so great is the power which 
 Satan possesses over Luther, that He seems to aim 
 at the possession of the ^hole man.*^ Calvin is 
 called by Beza, ^* a mere mad dog^r^a malevolent 
 man ; judging of men by t;he measure cf his love 
 or hatred for them." Valmersays also of Calvin, 
 •* He is violent and perverse: but so much the 
 better, since violence is necessary to promote our 
 Zuinghus is called by Luther *? A son of 
 
 cause. 
 
 Hell, an associate with Arius-— a man undeserving 
 to be prayed for,** Melanpthop is styled by Iflirir 
 cus and Armsdorf? " A shoe for every foot-^-^a 
 corrupter of the word of Gdd-^a Pelagian."— 
 Stanearus calls him " The northern Antichrist.'' 
 Melancthon testifies of Carlostadius, that he was 
 «* void of piety and humanity, and more of a Je^f 
 than a Christmn.'* Luther says of CEcolampadius, 
 " He! was beaten to death by the Devil.*' ' John 
 Knox, the ringleader of the Revolt in Scotland, is 
 stited by Whitaker "A deluded Idiot in his no- 
 tions— a wild raven in his speeches—- a son of viov 
 
^s and of 
 
 ;he flames 
 omen, I, 
 ost in im- 
 e he says, 
 my learn- 
 Emperor, 
 itself.'* 
 ibsolutely 
 
 not only 
 nscience*^ 
 I with ar- 
 il.". Zu- 
 ver which 
 ms to aim 
 
 Calvin 19 
 lalevplent 
 f his love 
 of Calvin, 
 much the 
 omoie our 
 ' A sor; of 
 td^servmg 
 ibyinirir 
 y foot-i*^a 
 agian.*'— - 
 itichrist.'' 
 at he was 
 
 of a JeTf 
 impadius, 
 ." John 
 lotland, is 
 in his no*i 
 on of vioi- 
 
 lence tied Barbarism— th^ religtoui sacheto o{ 
 religious Mohawks." Dn Johnson hoped that he 
 was buried in the highway, Barnet says, " The' 
 open lewdness in which many lived with^Ot shame 
 or remorse, gave gre^ occasjoq for their adversa- 
 ries to say, that they were in the right to assert 
 justification without works ^ since they Were to 
 every good work reprobate. Their gross and in- 
 satiable scrambling after the goc^s and wealth 
 that had been dedicated with; good designs, with- 
 out applying any part o. it to the promoting of 
 the Gospel, the instruction of youth, and the re^ 
 Jieviilg of ihe poor— made all people conclude that 
 it was for Robbery and not for Reformation, that 
 their zeal made them so active. The irregular 
 and immoral lives of many of the professors of the 
 Gospel, gave their enemies great advantage to sayl 
 that they ran away from Confession, Penancci 
 Fasting and Pfayer, only that they might be un- 
 der no restraint, but indulge t4iemselyes in a licen- 
 cious and dissolute course of life." Fletcher ot 
 Madiley says, " How few of our celebrated pulpits 
 where more has not been said^r sin than against 
 it. Even adultery and murder {sLCCording to theso 
 preachers) do not hurt the pleasant children of God: 
 but rather work for tJieir good, God sees no sin in 
 hlievers, whatever sin they cowtwi/."— Oh I jam 
 satis est. 
 
 The candid Protestant will see the pertinacy of 
 these Extracts-^and not suspect me of anv wish 
 to give pain. I would gladly have omitted them J 
 but I could not do justice to my subject, and ex- 
 hibit the advantages of Catholic union, without 
 depicting the miseries of Protestant disunion, dis- 
 sension and uncertainty. Far be it ftora me to 
 confound our Protestant Brethren of the present 
 i&y >»ith those who were guilty of these excesses^ 
 
:il 
 
 !Lct it be, however, ackhowledged, that the l^ml 
 of an infallible authority in matters of faith, wasr 
 titihappily the cause of them. The radical evil 
 still exists, and if it produce not such bitter fruits 
 as in former times j our Brethren of the Reform 
 owe it not to their doctrine, but to the general in- 
 fluence of civilization and refinement* 
 
 The sole, sure and safe remedy for all the dis- 
 orders engendered by the multiplication of sects, 
 and the diversity of opinions, is for all dissentient 
 Christians, of whatever communion, to return to 
 Catholic tfnityi The Church, a tender mother. 
 Opens her arms to receive with smiles and embraces 
 her wandering Children. She has never ceased 
 to pray for them in their estrangement, and longs 
 to reckon them once more among those of her 
 household. \ 
 
 That this is the only remedy for the evils of 
 the Reformation, and that this will prove effectual, 
 has been the deliberate sentiment of many Protes- 
 tants of high reputation. 
 
 Grotius (whose name is an hotior to Letters) 
 was clearly of opinion, that ** Protestants will ne- 
 ver be united with each other, until they are so 
 with those who adhere to the See of Rome : without 
 ^' hich, no common agreement can be expected.-— 
 .ie wishes therefore that the rupture now existing, 
 as well as the occasions of it, were removed. A- 
 mong the causes of which, the Supremacy of the 
 Fope^ according to the cannon cannot be reckoned, 
 as Melancthon confesses ; who even deems the Su- 
 premacy neaessar^ for the preservation of unity .-^ 
 Neither is this putting the Church at the Pope's 
 feet, but it is only the ancient and respectable order^ 
 of things restored again" 
 
 Leibnitz ^another illustrious name) gives his 
 opinion as follows—" As God is the God of order. 
 
the iirtini 
 aith, was? 
 dical evil 
 ter fruits 
 : Reform 
 meral in- 
 
 1 the dis> 
 of sects, 
 ssentient 
 return to 
 mother, 
 embraces 
 3r ceased 
 iDd longs 
 le of her 
 
 B evils of 
 efiectual, 
 y Protes- 
 
 Letters) 
 will ne- 
 sy are so 
 without 
 lected.— 
 existing, 
 jed» A- 
 c^ of the 
 eckoned, 
 s the Su- 
 ^unity*-'-^ 
 
 \Q PODC'S 
 
 A. 
 
 \ble order^ 
 
 gives his 
 of order. 
 
 97 
 
 and as the Church One, Catholic and Apostolic, un- 
 der a hierarchy embracing all tlie members, is from 
 God : It follows that in this body there is by Di- 
 vme Right, One Supreme Spiritual Magistrate, 
 acting within his own limits, having a dictatodal 
 authority, and the power of executing what is 
 necessary to discharge his duty for the advantaffe 
 ot the Church. Even should Borne, which is the 
 metropolis of the Christian world, be chosen the 
 seat and residence of this Power, from merely 
 human considerations ; really it is requisite in ev- 
 ery commonwealth and consequently in the Chris- 
 tian Church, that there be one supreme Magistracy • 
 whether it be determined to center all its authority 
 m one individual, or divide it between many. And 
 in the latter case, it is fit that one of the members 
 should have the authority of dictator or supreme 
 Magistrate, which is the same, though with a lim- 
 ited power." In another document he sighs for 
 the restoration of the ancient order of thin.rs— . 
 "which (he says emphatically) would bring back 
 to us the Golden Age," ^ 
 
 « There is (says St. Cyprian) but one God and 
 one Christ, and one Faith, and a People joined in 
 one solid body with the cement of concord This 
 unity cannot suffer a division, nor this one, body 
 bear to be disjointed. He cannot have Ood for 
 his Father, who has not the Church for his Mother, 
 It any one could escape the Deluge out of Noah's 
 Ark, he who is out of the Church ma/also escape." 
 IHE great ht. Austin thus addresses the Dis- 
 senters of his time—" If you think you have been 
 sufficiently tossed about, and wish to see an erici 
 to your anxieties, follow the rule of Catholic dis- 
 cipline, which came down to us through the Apos- 
 ties from Christ himself, and which shall descend 
 irom us to the latest posterity." 
 
 N r 
 
98 
 
 There aie two considerations, which duly 
 weighed, would no doubt facilitate the return of 
 our Protestant Brethren to the Catholic Church. 
 Ift tlie first place, the return of a Protestant to the;, 
 coAimunion of the universal Church cannot strict- 
 ly be called ^.Conversion. He does not join a 
 strange and foreign Church— be only returns to 
 the Church of his Forefathers.-**He is not convert 
 edf but merely reconciled. 
 
 In the next place, tliia return does not imply 
 absolutely a change qf doctrine. The convert still 
 retains the fundamental articles of his former be- 
 liefs—and only enlarges his creeds. Dr. Johnson 
 observes with his usual wisdom and penetration—- 
 *« A man who is converted from Protestantism to 
 Popery may be sincere. He parts with nothing. 
 He is only super-adding to what he already had." 
 
 These reflections are of the most consolatoiy 
 nature, and ought surely to influence tlie minds 
 of our Protestant Brethren to a measure fraught 
 with such transcendant advantage. Still perhaps 
 will they insist, that there are corruptions in the 
 Catholic Church.— Enough, and perhaps more 
 than enough has been advanced in refutation of 
 Uiis charge. But supposing for a moment, ^and 
 tlie concession costs us nothing) that in the long 
 lap«e of time the Catholic Church " covered with 
 the awful hoar of innumerable ages" may have 
 lost something of her primitive attraction and sim- 
 plicity; is this a reason for estrangement and re- 
 jection? — A^e the matron graces of Christ's 
 Spouse less engaging than were her bridal charms ? 
 Or (to try another simile) would an Heir leave a 
 venerable Palace, which bad descended to him 
 from the most remote ancestry, merely because, in, 
 the revolution of years^ a few cobwebs had col- 
 lected upon the walls? 
 
90 
 
 1 duly 
 turn of 
 Ihurch. 
 ; to Ui& 
 ; strict- 
 join a 
 urns to 
 'orwerU 
 
 t imply 
 ert still 
 ner be- 
 ohnson 
 ation-^ — 
 itism to 
 iothing. 
 jr had." 
 lolatoiy 
 3 minds 
 fraught 
 perhaps 
 s in the 
 18 more 
 ation of 
 It, ^and 
 he long 
 ed with 
 ay have 
 nd sim- 
 and re- 
 Christ's 
 charms? 
 leave a 
 to him 
 lause, in, 
 had col- 
 
 X HEBE close the subject.— There are in tho va- 
 rious- Protestant communions thousands of well 
 disposed persons, who only require to have the 
 substance of the controversy impartially laid before 
 them, to receive the truth in all its integrity. To 
 my fellow citizens of this description, I address 
 this humble attempt ; and affectionately request 
 them to weigh the arguments thus offered to their 
 consideration. Let them not forget that Religion 
 is the most important concern of mankind : and 
 that while all the Protestant sects unite in acknow- 
 ledging that Catholics may be saved ; the Catholic 
 Church, •' the city of God," and sole depository 
 of all truth, emphatically declares that out of 
 her pale, there is no salvation. O that we raay^ 
 all know in this our day the things which belong 
 to our peace, before thev be forever hidden from 
 our eyes. 
 
 HHSSSS 
 
 ■»' ! , ' rt ! 
 
 UNIVERSAL PRAYER, 
 
 Translated from the original Latin of the Sovereign Pontiffi, 
 
 In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holu 
 Ghost — Amen. *^ ^ 
 
 I believe in Thee, O Lord ! Rfay I believe more firmly. 
 I hrojie irr Thee, O Lord ! May I hope more safely. 
 I love Thee, O Lord ! May I love 1 hee more fervently. 
 I repent, O Lord ! May I repent more earneetly. 
 
 I adore Thee as my First Beginning. 
 I. desire Thee as my Last End. 
 I praise Thee as my Constant Benefactor. 
 I invoke Ihee as* my Merciful Defender. 
 
 Direct me by thy Wisdoi».— Restrain me by thy JMstice*— 
 Console me by Thy Pity* Protect me by tby Pow€r. 
 
 That I may be Thine according to my Baptism. I re» 
 noiHiCC the Devil and hia Works-^the World and iU Pomp»-^ 
 the Flesh and its Lustfw-Heresy and its Errors. 
 
 To Thee I consecrate my Thoughts, that they may be occu- 
 
BK' ..mrasfi^:" 
 
 100 
 
 pied with Thy Greatncsa; my Words, that ihey may proclaim 
 fhyGoodnew; my Actions, that they may be regulated by 
 Thy Law ; and my Sufferingi, that they may he.gubmisaive to 
 Thy Decrees. 
 
 1 will whatever Thou wiliest— because Thou wiliest, in the 
 manner Thou wiliest— and as much as 1 hou wiliest. v 
 
 May I Accept what Thou Approvast^ Reject what Tho\i 
 
 Hatest Shun what Thou Forbiddcst— and Observe what 
 
 TIiou Commandest. 
 
 To this end I beseech Thee — 
 to Enlighten my Understanding— to Inflame my Will— to 
 Purify my liody— and to Sanctify my Soul. 
 
 May I Bewail my ftist Offences— Surmount Future Temp- 
 tations—Correct vicious Propensities— and practice the Chris- 
 tian Virtues. 
 
 Inspire me, good God ! with a Love of Thee— a Hatred of 
 Myself a ieal for m v Neighbor — and a contempt for the World. 
 May I studiously Respect my Superiors — Condescend to my 
 Inferiors — /Assist my Friends — and Spare ray Foes. 
 
 May I vanquish Pleasure by Austerity— Avarice bj Liberal- 
 ity—Auger by ft^eekness- and Tepidity by Devotion. 
 
 Infuse in my heart, Fear without Despair— Confidence with- 
 out Presumption— Piety without Enthusiasm— and Joy without 
 Levity. 
 
 Render me also Prudent in Undertakings- Couragious in 
 Dangers — Patient in Adversity— and Humble in Prosperity. 
 
 Grant, O Lord, that I may be Recollected in my Prayers — 
 Sober in my Repasts— Diligent in my Employments — and con- 
 stant in my Resolutions. 
 
 May 1 80 govern my Senses, that I may Hear nothing In- 
 jurious—Speak nothing Licentious— See nothing Impure— and 
 do nothing Perverse. 
 
 May 1 be careful to maintain — 
 an Inward Innocence — an Outward Modesty — an Examplary 
 Conversation- and a Regular life. 
 
 May I assiduously watch to Subdue nature— to Cherish Thy 
 Grace — to Obey Thy Law — and to secure my Salvation. 
 
 May I learn from Thee 
 how Little what is Earthly— how Great what is Heavenly—.;, 
 how Short what is Temporal — and how Durable what is Eternal. 
 Grant that 1 may Anticipate Death — Fear Thy Judgments- 
 Escape Hell — and Obtain xieaven. 
 
 Finally, Grant Repentance to Sinners — Perseverance to the 
 Just — Peace to the Living — and Happiness to the Departed. 
 
 Through Christ our Mediator — Mary our Intercessor — the 
 Prayers of the Saints— and the Suffrages of the Church. — 
 
 AMEN. 
 
nay proclaim 
 regulated by 
 iUbmissive to 
 
 rillest, in the 
 
 t what Tho\i 
 bscTve what 
 
 ly Will— to 
 
 Jture Temp- 
 ;e the Chris- 
 
 a Hatred of 
 r the World, 
 scend to my 
 
 I 
 
 i bj Liberal- 
 ion. 
 
 idence with- 
 Joy without 
 
 ouragious in 
 rosperity. 
 y Prayers — 
 s — and con- 
 nothing In- 
 mpure — and 
 
 Examplary 
 
 ]!herish Thy 
 ation. 
 
 Heavenly— J 
 itisEterngl. 
 Lidgments— 
 
 mce to the 
 Departed, 
 ccssor — the 
 urch. —