IMAGE EVALUATION 
 TEST TARGET (MT-3) 
 
 // 
 
 
 S^ ^ /y,.. W 
 
 4t. 
 
 1.0 
 
 I.I 
 
 |50 '""^^ ! 
 
 ■IT IM III 
 lu _,^ ill 
 
 
 1|M 
 
 izo 
 1.8 
 
 
 1.25 
 
 1.4 1.6 
 
 
 
 t.ti 
 
 
 
 
 u 
 
 
 P^ 
 
 <^ 
 
 /a 
 
 ^l 
 
 
 °^ ;>> 
 
 
 u/^:< 
 
 -5$ 
 
 f 
 
 Photographic 
 
 Sciences 
 
 Corporation 
 
 23 WEST MAIN STREET 
 
 WEBSTER, N.Y. 14580 
 
 (716) 872-4503 
 
 ^^ 
 
 \ 
 
 iV 
 
 % 
 
 V 
 
 
 >\>, 
 
 ^ 
 
 >> 
 
 '^^^" 
 
 ^1.^ 
 
CIHM/ICMH 
 Microfiche 
 
 CIHIVI/ICMH 
 Collection de 
 microfiches. 
 
 Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions / Institut canadien de rnicroreproductions historiques 
 
 ►> 
 
Technical and Bibliographic Notes/Notes tachniques et bibliographiquas 
 
 The Institute has attempted to obtain the beat 
 original copy available for filming. Features of this 
 copy which may be bibliographically unique, 
 which may alter any of the images in the 
 reproduction, or which may significantly change 
 the usual method of filming, are checked below. 
 
 □ 
 
 D 
 D 
 D 
 
 n 
 □ 
 □ 
 
 Coloured covers/ 
 Couverture de couieur 
 
 Covers damaged/ 
 Couverture endommagde 
 
 Covers restored and/or laminated/ 
 Couverture restaur^e et/ou pellicul^e 
 
 Cover title missing/ 
 
 Le titre de couverture manque 
 
 Coloured maps/ 
 
 Cartes gAographiques on couieur 
 
 Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or blacM/ 
 Encre da couleut (i.e. autre que bleue ou noirel 
 
 Coloured plates and/or illustrations/ 
 Planches et/ou illustrations en couieur 
 
 Bound with other material/ 
 Relii avec d'autres documents 
 
 Tight binding may causa shadows o~ distortion 
 along interior margin/ 
 
 Lareliure serree peut causer de i'ombre ou de la 
 distorsion le long de la marge interieure 
 
 Blank leaves added during restoration may 
 appear within the text. Whenever possible, these 
 have been omitted from filming/ 
 II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajouties 
 lors d uie restauration apparaissant dans le texte, 
 mais, <orsque cela 6tait possible, ces pages n'ont 
 pas iti film^es. 
 
 L'Institut a micro'ilmd le meilleur exemplaire 
 qu'il lui a et^ possible de se procurer. Las details 
 de cet exemplaire qui sont peut-dtre uniques du 
 point de vue bibliographique, qui peuvent modifier 
 une image reproduite, ou qui peuvent exiger une 
 modification dans la mdthude normale de filmage 
 sont indiquAs ci-dessous. 
 
 □ Coloured pages/ 
 Pages de couieur 
 
 Q Pages damaged/ 
 Pages endommag^es 
 
 □ Pages restored and/or laminated/ 
 Pages restaur^es et/ou polliculdes 
 
 Pages discolou 
 Pages ddcolord 
 
 red. stained or foxed/ 
 6es, tachet^es ou piquees 
 
 Pages 
 
 Pages 
 
 Pages datachees 
 
 Showthrough 
 Transparence 
 
 Quality of prii 
 
 Quality inigale de ('impression 
 
 Includes suppierrmntary materi 
 Comprend du materiel supplementaire 
 
 Only edition available/ 
 Seule ddit:3n disponible 
 
 I I Pages detached/ 
 
 I "1 Showthrough/ 
 
 I I Quality of print varies/ 
 
 I I Includes suppierrmntary material/ 
 
 r~n Only edition available/ 
 
 Th« 
 to t» 
 
 Th« 
 
 POM 
 
 of tf 
 fiimi 
 
 Grig 
 begi 
 thai 
 sjon 
 othe 
 first 
 sion 
 or ill 
 
 Tha 
 shall 
 TIIMC 
 whic 
 
 Map) 
 diffai 
 antin 
 bagii 
 right 
 raqui 
 matti 
 
 D 
 
 Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata 
 slips, tissues, etc., have been refilmed to 
 ensure the best possible image/ 
 Les pages totalement ou partiellement 
 obscurcies pur un feuillet d'errata. une pelure, 
 etc , cnt it6 fWrr.ies i nouveau de facon a 
 obtenir la meilleure image possible. 
 
 Q 
 
 Additional comments:/ 
 Commentaires suppl^mentaires: 
 
 There are some creases in the middle of the pages. 
 
 This item is filmed at the r<nduction ratio cheuked below/ 
 
 Ce document est filmd au \aux de reduction indiqu^ ci-dessous. 
 
 10X 14X 18X 22X 
 
 26X 
 
 »X 
 
 I 
 
 / 
 
 12X 
 
 16X 
 
 20X 
 
 24X 
 
 28X 
 
 32X 
 
ills 
 
 du 
 
 difier 
 
 ine 
 
 lage 
 
 Th« copy filmed hers has been reproduced thanks 
 to the generosity of: 
 
 The Nova Scotia 
 Legislative Library 
 
 The images appearing here are the best quality 
 possible considering the condition snd legibility 
 of the original copy and in keeping with the 
 filming contract specifications. 
 
 Original copies in printed paper covers are filmed 
 beginning with the front cover and ending on 
 the last page with a printed or illustratad imprsa> 
 sion, or the back cover when appropriate. All 
 other original copies ar® filmed beginning on the 
 first page with a printed or illustrated impres- 
 sion, and anding on the last page with a printed 
 or illustrated impression. 
 
 The last r^dcorded frame on each microfiche 
 shall contain the symbol —•-(meaning "CON- 
 TINUED"), or the symbol V (meaning "END"), 
 whichever applies. 
 
 Maps, plates, charts, etc.. may be filmed at 
 different reduction ratios. Those too largo to b« 
 entirely included in one exposure are filmed 
 beginning in the upper left hand comer, left to 
 right and top to boncm, as many frames as 
 required. The following diagrams illustrate the 
 method: 
 
 L'ttxemplaire filmi fut reproduit grice i la 
 g^nirositi de: 
 
 The Nova Scotia 
 Legislative Library 
 
 Laa images suivantes ont Atii reproduites avec le 
 plus yrand soin. compta tenu de la condition at 
 da la nettet* de I'exemplaire fllm«, at an 
 conformity avec lea conditions du contrat de 
 f!imaga. 
 
 Laa exomplalrea originaux dont la couverture 9n 
 papier est imprim^ sor^t filmte en commencant 
 par le premier plat at an terminant soit par la 
 derniira page qui comporte une ampreinte 
 d'impression ou d'lllustration, soit par le second 
 plat, salon la eas. Touai tea autraa axamplairss 
 originaux sont filmte an commenqant par la 
 premiere page qui comporte une ampreinte 
 d'Impresaion ou d'lllustration at an terminant par 
 la demiire pag« qui comporte une telle 
 empreonta. 
 
 Un doe symboiea suivants apparaitra sur la 
 domlAre image do cheque microfiche, selon le 
 caa: lo symbole — *> signifie "A SUIVRE". le 
 symbolo V signifie "FIN". 
 
 Las cartes, planches, tableaux, etc., peuvent dtre 
 fiimte i doe taux do rMuction diff«rents. 
 Lorsquo lo document ast trop grand pour itre 
 reproduit en un soul c!ichA. il est film« i partir 
 do I'anglo supiriour gauche, de gauche i droita, 
 at do haut an baa. en pronant le nombre 
 d'images nteessaire. Les diagram mes suivants 
 illustrent la mithodo. 
 
 ata 
 
 !lure, 
 
 a 
 
 : 
 
 2X 
 
 1 2 G 
 
 1 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 4 
 
 5 
 
 6 
 
«-■- 
 
 J 
 
 • It.^as I 
 anythiug : 
 controveri 
 
 tuiia perha 
 th)9> P'-iulic 
 thJepeopU 
 effected I 
 a contest, 
 possibly ] 
 
 TfaeR* 
 taken the 
 eaysJ'frjt 
 VC8 more 
 ject," anc 
 fefidy ref 
 
 tory, and 
 4wny," w 
 it being i 
 •rhere thi 
 The in 
 wUch th 
 jtl^i merit 
 jB*rWttle c 
 taking i 
 V J{««4i' em 
 
 jm^Ke, to 
 chargaik 
 
 is within 
 in^^nti 
 
 te^tioiP 
 man setf 
 having ^ 
 informir 
 his oppo 
 J|^orp( 
 
 no»>%i 
 
 .... MrJB 
 
 voured 
 entirely 
 ;nad^a 
 iy b«n». 
 wrwwd 
 
r*^ 
 
 ^Mpipipppii IB,, I, I j>i:-.^e;#.- 
 
 .. ." iii i. 
 
 
 l&bfuwti^ atft J^lttou ilcalifenii 
 
 * »«« 
 
 Ibr^ 
 
 itA 
 
 :> n .ri' 
 
 t« rte Ici^bert of the Presbyteriaii Cburch of Not* Scotia: 
 
 'Viu'i'fiJ Wn.t 
 
 • It.^as not my- intention to havo \?rUtea 
 any th lug further in connexion with ihe late 
 controversy on the sul)jeqt of Pictou Academy, 
 ^,1 cansidered the dliief ofcjecj; I had in view, 
 v\Bia perhaps the only ope of real inteijest to 
 tiwpuuHc, had been secured by the action of 
 the people pf thjc Country, this having b?en 
 eJBFected I had no longer a desire to coDtinuP 
 a contest, which conld only be profitless, and 
 possibly perHonaL 
 
 The Rev. James Ross, has however again 
 taken the, Tield in the " N^ovascotian," as he 
 pays " vfrje^^ds were anxion? to make themsel- 
 ves more tkoroughly acqnaintjd with the sub- 
 ject," and as t^ ' Eastern Chronicle" had al- 
 ready refused ^ .veral coramunicatioas, he had 
 i^M^'-^0t^6&, "a simpltfBtat^ii&i of tl)& l»^tw3* 
 ' ^ry, and present condition of tbePictotiAca- 
 4wny," which he offers to the " Nov,*scotian' 
 it being read in " many sectionsof our Church 
 .F'here the Extern Chronicle is rarely seen. 
 The instructing his friends in a matter m 
 which they are so deeply interested, yet, with 
 tim merits of which, it would seem, they are 
 £o little conversant, is a very laudable under- 
 ' ' taking ; but I will presently show, from Mr. 
 ,M»S8' own writings, contrasted with the record- 
 ed fpiaims of tmse whose testimony, he is bound 
 hy (iVfry ob^-'jation of nature, of Jionour, and of 
 > jm^e, to re's^ect fmt he is no way fitted ^ dis- 
 charge the duty he. has undertaken. "Tlereis 
 .guUt in ignqrancp jjjf a man , when knjg^dgp 
 is within his Keach ; there is guilt in 
 injiJtiP'iti'^"' when truth and motive 
 higliest iu^^esj; hove pjaimed his sed 
 . tefttioifc^ Tfajra is, ?tiU greater gmt, . , 
 man sets himself up a^ api:SHoiastructt.,_ 
 having within his reach the means pf.<?orm;^ly 
 informing himself, does not avail hiXnlffti 
 his opportunitiea— -or having done so^w^eir 
 - "-— ---^ ™ui!oi.»^ /K the 
 
 tworpervprts fact8» and pubUs™,. ,hj'^ -■- 
 -i^ld as trutt8r.«n4er4tl!Q prestig«pf his Of,- 
 fi^ »ftd the san^ja of his name, what havp 
 noklSJiA slightest con^ction with T^j^h.}!^ 
 
 Mr. JU>«» and soiaf f^\i\» frienda nava; as- 
 serted, and fUll do m^ that Jl have M»ae«- 
 voured tomlalwd the pviblic, and that I w^' 
 ontir^y ignoramt of th^e 8a|)ject oa prhichjhad 
 
 iSrwwd i9 i^pport of my vipwf, wty mimit^ 
 
 wffich has Hot been recognised as the highest 
 and best, by Mr. Rps^ and his friends. Ih^TQ 
 not adduced the fitatementa of thb$ewHo^?W* 
 serf the Academy— t have hot expressed «hd 
 oplnionsof the Rev. Messrs McKcaw^ an^ 
 Fraser an<l' fheir supporters ; I have only cited 
 the hpguage o! D^.McCullcch and other warm 
 friend? of the Instttuflor. v.this course^ I will 
 BtiU pursue, for "'thank God' for books, th^ 
 bring us into connexion with the distant ana 
 the dead-they make the past, 'fesent ; the 
 distant near ;"— by reams ot authentic re'COJdP 
 (which I shall be happy to produce at ati£- 
 time to snch as may feel an interests them^ 
 I am now enabled to make the dead ftnd the 
 distant, speak. After 1 ^a^i fartished^y 
 («K6Sm»ttts, 'and given toy Yefei^Trcef, fi sttWi, 
 as I have formerly, done, leave it for you to 
 say, who has furnished the true history. 
 
 The first fact worthy of attention id ML 
 Ross' sinfple statement, is, the assertion th* 
 the Trustees, are emt)loying its ftinas Kx 
 purposes quite foreign to th6 dertgn or tHe 
 original contributors," which design was, to 
 provide the mearis (y inMruction in those btancH- 
 es of a liberal Vacation which are not taught 
 in the Province Grammar Schools, the Sut|- 
 scriptiona raised were for the purpose Of Car- 
 rying out this' object. «By whom t^hesd -B^b- 
 scriptionswcre raised* says Mr. Rosf,' smdfor 
 what purpose the Institttljlon was ibdiia«9, 
 Will appear from the preamble to the Act bjr 
 which ft was established"— he then takes tl^ 
 trouble to,cite the preamhle whereby it wotild 
 [flS^ear thdt Edward Mortimer and b«icriw^i> 
 We^byterians, and were desirous of Bdncatiiig 
 •their children in their own faith, jnd n ^ 
 "'evident beyond disputef ays .Mr.!Ross,-"Ri&t 
 m parties Who paid aiid contributed aiver£ 
 "turns pf mwiey, for the patpose of mnim$ 
 "^nd supposing Pictou Academf wefe Pto= 
 byterians residing in ?ictoti, and that oneWia 
 'the principal object contempkted by ^SJ™- 
 Tjlishment wjls to provide means of e^.tteatag 
 their children in the Presbyterian Reh^- > 
 ' My coinment on this, 13 that , it i^ »rf*her 
 eviderit nor beyond disjtotc, hilt the v?ry r«- 
 Ve -se I my proof lies now hefora WSvJJJJ;^ 
 .first pla<ie 1 pro^uee the Act of.m^^^^tn 
 lifitislU TMfntMvuhA, it is in tne. Mv*writing 
 
 SSf of M^ iii^lmor: It^tdias iW^r^wnw to 
 
mmmmm 
 
 i.iW'.l 
 
 %' 
 
 p 
 
 2 
 
 Preabykriani or Presbyterianim, on the con- One more quotation on thit point I shall 
 trarv it says, it i« " for the purpose of founding make for the special benefit of the Rev. Jamei 
 
 was a member, and in manifesiing their dis- 
 like to that Church, the unthinking or evil in- 
 clined part of them, did not make such dis- 
 tinctions as reason would have dictated. For 
 these reasons he had considered it his duty to 
 surrender up to the Presbytery his ministerial 
 charge, and he now wished it to he perfectly un- 
 derstood by the meeting, and by the community 
 geniraily^ that the Pictou Academy was a Pro- 
 
 knowledge thefact,*^ 
 *"' Fortunately he had it in his power to palli. 
 ate the injustice and illiberality of those clau- 
 ses by stating that the friends of the institu- 
 tion were altogether averse from their intro- 
 duction and that no religions p^uliarity was 
 ever introduced into the course of instruction. 
 A Catholic or Methodist, Episcopalian for 
 Baptist had equal access to all the knowledge 
 which could be obtained at the institution, and 
 
 - • ■ - - £V^ 
 
 yin^ial Institution connected with no particular' ,,„.v,.^ ^„^..^* ^^ ^^.^.^^^ ^„ ^..^ .^^,..^..^..,..^^ 
 
 principles of Religion. It was equally free to might pass through its classes without any en- 
 
 all classes and denominations of Christians, and quiry respecting his religious tenets. He 
 
 they could all derive equal advantages from it hoped soon to see an equal degree of liberality 
 
 if they Chose.'" in the admieBion to oflSc^s in the institation. 
 
 \ 
 
 Ross. Again there was an annual meeting 
 of the Trusteas in the Academy at Pictou on 
 the 1st Jany. 1827 an account of this meeting 
 was drawn up by Dr. McCulloch and was 
 published in the, Acadian Recorder of 27th 
 Jany. The Spe'eches were reported to the 
 same paper by Mr. Blanchard on the 24th 
 Febry. the printed papers and the original 
 manuscripts are now before me. The follow- 
 ing Resolution as moved by the Revd> Dun- 
 can Ross, is in the handwriting of Dr. Mc- 
 Culloch, 
 
 •* 1. That as the Pictou Academy was not 
 intended to be a Sectarian Seminary, and as 
 contrary to the wish of its Trustees, several 
 
 establishing and maintaining an Academy in 
 the district of Pictou," and expressly declares 
 ** that no Bvelaw, Rule, or Regulation, shall 
 be made by the said Trustees, by which any 
 Be.ligious d'itinctions .shall be set up." The 
 Presbyteriat ism was'all imposed in the Ac- 
 quoted by Mr. Ross, against the strongest, op- 
 position of tJjjUiBromoters of the Academy, and 
 when it was urged by'the p'-esent Master of 
 the Roll's as'a main cause of his opposition. 
 ^r. Archibald replied " it was quite suflBcier^t 
 that the aupportft-s \)f this Institution should 
 be libeHed out ofdoors, without their wishes 
 pv intention himgmisrepresented in that house; 
 
 it wa^ well known thnt the objectionable restric- .,.,....„.j ,„ ...^ ,.„„ ^. ..^ ^ .--, 
 
 tims had been forced upon Uiem ly the CounciHl denominations of Christians in the Province, 
 Judge Haliburtou a favourite authority with have been by the Act of incorporation exclu- 
 Mr. Ross and his friends, on the same debate ded from the oflBce of Trusteee or Teacher, 
 says, *' when the original bill was sent up to the Trustees consider its present constitutioa 
 the Council, it came down trammelled with as calculated to disaffect its friends, and injure 
 
 • every test, which gentlemen complains gave to its interests, and therefore they will at the ?.n- 
 it a sectarian cast^ Mr. Ross ought not tore- suing meeting of t.he Legislature, renew the.'r 
 . quire me to tell him, that year after year, the application to be relieved from restrictions. 
 Trustees petitioned for the removal of the ob- which by an infringement of natural rights, at- 
 noxious restriction— the drafts of the petition tach degradation to any deservifg class of Her 
 are ndW in« my possession and are all in the Majesty's subjects." 
 handwTOting of the late Dr. McCulloch ? From The effect of this resolution was enhanced 
 
 . .jng^J^Bi^pe, I make the following extract, by the mover, who spoke thus :—'' That the 
 
 • ' But your memorialists would respectfully Pictou Academy, originated among men of 
 • rep^ipSBnt, that by the unnecessary tests to the most liberal sentiment and whose strong- 
 which they are subjected, the Pictou Academy est opinion ..as that knowledge should be free 
 
 . labqors under disadvantages, which impede its as the light of Heaven. The unjust and mc- 
 aucefss, and counteract the very ends for which nopoliziug spirit of the laws of King's College 
 
 mti^a^ established." haa first produced the idea that a Seminary 
 
 , In* 1825 the proceedings of the Trustees of for all denominations of Nova Scotians might 
 1^ Academy at their annual meeting were be established with honor to the pnH<Tht.-;ned 
 published by the authoritj^ of the Board ; views and judicious conduct .>i the govern- , 
 . frofti the origfual minutes, which are in the ment, and also with immense utiHty to thege- 
 handwriting of the Laie Mr. Jotham Blanch- neral interests jf the province. Unfortunately 
 ^d, then Secretary of the Board, I co'^v as the scheme in its progress did not accord with 
 
 v follc^s,' Dr. McCulloch said. " Ther was the original plan. There were introduced into 
 
 '■ another .very powerful inducement whun he the charter, in oppositionto the wish tf the friends 
 had for making a total seperation of the Con- of the institution, restrictive clauses which have 
 gregation in which he laboured and the Aca- not only drawn an unmerited odvm vpon them 
 demy— there were other Congregations spring- but have proved highly injurious to its interests 
 ing up in the district not connected with the The clause to which he alluded were those which 
 Synod to which he belonged. The persons excluded any but Episcopalians or Presbgterians 
 composiog these, identified the Ac&iemy yrlth f rom the office of trustee or teacher. He had 
 him} and him with the Church of which he been questioned at Pictou and blushed to ac- 
 
 i 
 
 5^ -7-7 ^ 
 
I 
 
 'Mftm 
 
 ■MMMH 
 
 IH^.' 
 
 ,.., I, iiri*i 
 
 r ■ iw i 
 
 ^ 
 
 t I shall 
 
 i\. Jamei 
 
 meeting 
 
 'ictou ou 
 
 8 meeting 
 and was 
 • of 27th 
 d to the 
 the 24th 
 I original 
 16 follow- 
 vd, Dun- 
 Dr. Mc- 
 
 r was net 
 t, and as 
 I, several 
 Province, 
 »n exclu- 
 Teacher, 
 nstitutioa 
 ad injurA 
 it the ?n- 
 tiew the.'r 
 strictions, 
 ights, at' 
 IS of Her 
 
 enhanced 
 That th? 
 ; men of 
 3 strong- 
 Id be free 
 and mc- 
 's College 
 Seminary 
 ms might 
 lic»ht.-;oed 
 
 govern- t 
 tothege- 
 brtunatelu 
 ord with 
 uced into 
 hefriends 
 hick have 
 pon them 
 
 9 interests 
 ■)se which 
 ihgterians 
 
 He had 
 i to ac' 
 
 to palli. 
 ose clau- 
 
 institu- 
 sir intro- 
 irity was 
 itruction. 
 ah'an |or 
 lowledge 
 ition,and 
 ; any en- 
 ets. He 
 liberality 
 stitatioo. 
 
 m were nnjusl, unneces- In .he year ISIS, Mr. E^f^J^^ortim*. 
 
 •rre/.¥o«* ; but he knew deavered a.8pcech to the jirW rtud«ttt8 of tbtt 
 
 \ there wA..a sufflcienc; o? sens^ and liberality Pictou Academy, m^presen^^^^^^ 
 
 /I Tho exeltmivs clauses 
 [iteury, impolitic and i 
 
 ( sti 
 j this 
 
 =g^l.7tr^^«^e^;nd"heh-opedtheir appli- friends »« .^^^f J^e'lS^f i^^ 
 
 cation to government would enable them^to Trustee^ to bring the A^^^^ ^^^_ 
 
 exterminate such blots from ihQ otherwise rair ,on, .«« ?"^.*«^5?.^^ His re- 
 
 standing of the institution. ♦» mg raised in the I>'2^' ^^J^^i^^^^ it r 
 
 -TreqSest you in the meantio-e to reflect on cor^^^^ »P«^„^,^ " "^\ Kent twoda« toW* 
 
 this ; in my next letter I will show from the extract as °"7^C; J /P'^Vr^Jogu^^ dur- 
 
 same auth/rities, by whom the subscriptions ^^^^ «^- ^^^,^^^^^^^ and. 
 
 were r.ised. »^ng w ^^17^^^ ^^. a brothier Trustee, Jm. 
 
 Forman, Esq., we obtained '"'"le most hand- 
 some and liberal manner, from our friendig 
 the capital, donations amounting to nearly 
 £1000." 
 
 I remain faithfully Yours, 
 
 Wm. Jas. Andkmon. 
 Pictou, 1 6th March 1850. 
 
 LETVEB 2. 
 
 To 
 
 TUB Members of thk Presbyterian 
 
 CH0RCH OF NOTA SCOTIA. 
 
 From this preambk, says Mr. P.08S, " It is 
 evident beyond dispute, that the parties 
 
 WHO FAID A»D CONTRIBUTED divcrs SUMS Of 
 
 money, were Presbyterians residing in Pic- 
 tou, and that one and the principal object -- — ^^^ , ^. •„„ nhurch 
 which they contemplated by its establishment. From 1 Presbyterian Churcn 
 was to provide the means of educating their _ «* ^°J,^,JT5' tland 
 ehildrenin the Presbyterian Religion."- Froai 2 Kirk of Scojtland, 
 
 On referring to the two ortgSid subsei^- 
 tion lists, containing the suhscnptions men- 
 tionedbyMr. Mortimer.. I find *o^«Lto^ 
 one shews subscriptions a9»oo°''°5 *° ,*;„** 
 the subscribers with three or four exception-, 
 being members of the Presbyterian. Church of 
 Nova Scotia. Of this sum, there vrere collect- 
 ed but JE538 12s. 2d. as under : 
 
 In a previous part of his letter, Mr. Ross had- 
 cited Haliburton, to phew that Pictou Acade- 
 
 ! my was projected as early as 1304, for "me 
 purpose of affording to the childrtn of Di»- 
 8ENTER8, who wcrc excluded from the honours 
 of King's College, those Literary and Sci- 
 entific acquirements, which mighty qualify 
 them for the learned professions, but the 
 scheme was not carried out till 1816, when 
 Mr. Ross again tells us, "on this condition 
 subscriptions were raised, and a petition pre- 
 sented to the Legislature for a charter which 
 
 was obtained." ^ „ _ 
 
 As the above statements of Mr. Ross, ap- 
 pear contradictory, I shall endeavour to solve 
 the problem, by reference to less doubtful au- 
 thority. On turning to the Journals of the 
 House of Assembly, for Friday, 31st March, 
 1815, it will be found that Mr. Archibald la- 
 trodu.Ted the First Pictou Academy Bill, wnich 
 was postponed till next Session. On the 17th 
 April, 1816, Mr. Wells again brought m the 
 Bill, which passed its third reading, and was 
 sent to the Council on the 1st May, 1816. 
 
 3 Church of England, 
 
 4 » " Rome, 
 
 £500 
 
 30 
 
 5 
 
 ■ ^ 
 
 
 
 
 Id 
 
 o 
 
 
 
 j^m.4Si 4 
 
 Total, -7-^---.-^ 
 
 Tlie Halifax list amounted to £63^ ^. OT:. 
 -of which there were collected £5p7 Ks. oo, 
 as follows : from the Governor and CosncUj 
 £52 108. Od.— from the residents of tW.ToWft 
 £538 38 2d.— and the balance from stifaiM»™« 
 The uifl^erent Religious Denominations 
 tributed as under : 
 
 1 Church of Scotland, 
 
 2 •♦ " England, 
 
 3 " " Rome, 
 
 4 Methodists, , ,„ « 
 
 5 Presbyterian Church of N. o. 
 
 6 Baptists " " 
 
 7 QHakers " ^, 
 
 8 Sandimanians " 
 
 
 £277 
 
 255 
 
 26 Id 
 
 16 10' 
 
 13 10 
 
 5 10 
 
 2 
 
 1 
 
 
 
 Total, 
 
 £597 13 
 
 
 
 The analyses of the lists, "^^^^^^^i^J ^ 
 aid of a gentleman to whom the parties Sab- 
 
 "TrBiu'c^^yTM^ bU^^^^^ -ribing -e rV^^rfa^fwifh an^^- 
 
 moriil to tKing. presented in 1831) was gLt'suS £^00 ta«^^^^^^ 
 passed, without any allusion to Rehgwus pecu- J J"'"^ ,«J?J ^^ i^^^TrSS were enabled to 
 Lrities." How the peculiarities were mtro- «ur« t» 1819. ^^^^J^^}^^' ^^^ to import 
 Sd have been already explained . proceed ^^^f^ tl^« ^mWrng. an^ P|^_ 
 
 On the nth March, 1818, Lord Dalhousie through the apncy of Mr. t^mu , 
 sem downto the Hou'se of Assembly t^Mes- ^T^ A??rlVn meXs ° f CoundT^ho 
 sage, recommending a Grant to the Academy "^^J-O^f ° ^f J^.r^te-^ ol tbe Church 
 as it. appeared to him, » to promise advantages subscribed ^l^T'^'l'^^^^^^^,^ oi Scotland. 
 of EdLticn, highly valuable tQ thiKk k ?^^°tetf,^tTmself was pecuUarly at- 
 iaZ^ part of the Province." The Charter p^"? ^I?*^,'l°'^« ^S^%^^^^^ 
 fSr^ by Mr. Ross. wM not obUiuei tiU tach«d to the K. A ^o^f^ 5!°S;r.tood by an 
 iao"26th March, 1820. ' - - • -> ^^^ sawnPiBS, »»- ■.'. ■--•^'^ - 
 
■PK" 
 
 ....,,„. J 
 
 '■^v. 
 
 
 tf\ 
 
 \ '•■% 
 
 •1 
 * 
 
 
 
 '•' .*>, 
 
 * *■ 
 
 <> 
 
 t^» 
 
 4 
 
 m»> • m'^' which, WAS rcfld ""i 
 
 AKisar and that iinm7f,f,-,.T, "^^5 » *"''^' ^^™S the year 1826 and in subsequent 
 The fmner Me iaia^ced in ol^rtT^n^I^u' "(^^^^^^exton which tuv^ts suhsisted between 
 
 Teii9^'^i!upl£i:Zr-£:^^^^ TI. connexion .^.n subsisting between the 
 it necessaxT ha could name, iurllZuLh ffh ^i >t°" ^^^'^emy and the Presbyterian Church 
 latter cl£7wLetj^'^e^'^l"t^^^^ of Nova Scotia Dr McCulIoeh had publicl:;. 
 
 Institution in existence ; andihese he w^froud f^P^^^Tk ^"^. 'solemnly dednred to be as fol- 
 t»sgy, were the mos emrnent men iStha ^''^'- " ^^'.^''^^^^^^'^'i^emy is conneetedwitk 
 Produce fot worth and "Ss and official £^£«^«i^i!2^J^^^-aci^^ 
 standing." .PfojA&m^ And I believe the certificate 
 
 In the lettiTs of " On,:. ri^«„ j .. t S'^en to Mr. McCulloch, discloses the true 
 
 know eXof thaf Dr^ LS^^^^^ ^f''' '^'^' subscribers, and the objects they 
 
 chiefly StrumentaMn bringrS l^d^nviey^asparticularlr, mentioned in thl* 
 
 the "Glasgow Society "and I 8 rfPd1/«^^ ^""^rparfo/^/leeerfi/zcate, which is no ways 
 jectsmighfbeexSdbyL'S Ruet SooSh'' p f./*^' asseverations at D^.\ 
 foUows. "The design of the society beinl To fjS \ ^""^ ^^^ certificate was quite un- ■ 
 promote the interests o^ J/ ?./™V^a^ • necessary ; I have always been most ready to . 
 
 stz^SSf^ ty^hSf s Syt ist'Tr^' '''■' ;-"°"''^ "- ' 
 
 op^TTTTBelfiendror •Rpiio.i'nr, „^^ t-u i "l""" J''" '"^t Mr. A. P. Ross m his openins 
 
 Ross also allucl^to tb lg socK'b S prefers « t u IfT'^^ ^*?S""S" =V 
 to take the 2nd Rule as theexnositionof whl? .^. M ^''° ^'"^ f "i "^?°°^ be controverted, 
 it contemplated. ToSe Xt ^^ Sv ^^^ t^e secession body in addition to firs: 
 the bbject of its orgaLationt^d who terShe fT^f '^' Institution, likewisecontributed 
 ^artiis composingit, I shdl pToduce Se tea- ^T -^T' '"™ *« ''^ support than all other 
 flmbnyof its orign^tor Dr Sulloch a ^'^""'"'"''t'ons put together. From these 
 given V him at the annual meSffni827 ^T'' '* T ^^l'"°'u' ™™«i\ately under ite 
 Ind as recorded by the SecrS of the AcJ T"^^!""'"'' ^^^^^}'Shasa Eeligioussect,thej 
 demy. ^ue oecretary of the Aca- claimed no more right to its controul than 
 
 ' "rf-i.«;i i„* 1 u . T, . . o,>ty other Denomination in the Province " 
 
 polnteafofftrrteSl^^^^^^^ . On referring to the printed memorial ad- 
 
 EJinTthe sta fof thTlSt ?^^^^^ B^tl?/ ^T^i '° *'^"^ Scottish public in 1831. byDrs. 
 
 sSpubUc This he had ra« 1^^^^ S! Hall. Paxton, and Mitchell, on behalf of the 
 
 »tate«eL m Scotli iet ti?h?h; most ?a- fSv.t,'iT-'i ^"'^ *??^ ^*^' *''^' '* ^«« 
 
 Tdrable consideration from the hiSL^ifi™ !? a^lished "by the cordial cooperation of 
 
 ty authority S condTfr.^ if? • • ™; Sjgseotcrsof all classes in the Colony, con- 
 
 iJriS JUs-Te Sc%^ g^f^PTyerians from t he C hfeh of 
 
 8^g of tha UniversitlsVf SS^rg and Sfas: Sf« 1°.^ m 1*^"- ?'r T ' f ' T" ^ °^ ^ap- 
 gow-the leading Clergy of the ^arfous rli? ! '" S ^^^'^^odis s. both of whom are nume- 
 J?tousDenominat%us aU^^^^^^^ S. f t "^f ''*''^'°' This statement being 
 
 tSnCSralr5?3nP-?7"thos73 backed by tlie recommendations of the Wes- 
 
 then handed inSmd) In Gktr a ?o ^y^*^- g^'^f'^'-^^ce and Baptist associations of 
 c«TTwasformediustbaforpl,«l«ff«?^^ J?" ^J^^a Scotia m smm ; also by a certificate 
 
 aid ia Ih^SSiorof N X VK P^^^^^ ^ W?n?JfT "T^?" '''''' ^"^^'""^''^^ ^'"- 
 thislnstitution. Its office bearlr^^^of.^!* l^^amyat of Nova Scotia, rep resenting allJDgi 
 nj •■i'shiy resnactfthJi, nam., 'Kn^rortrnVVrr ' ^"^"^"^^g^ '"'^ ^° ^^^ *^<>»'^»«» reception of 
 
 u ot the cler- the memorial by all sects in Scotland ; and 
 
 
 ' respectable names, 
 
 01* rcTerrl 
 
 Dr. McCi 
 
 contains 
 
 Clergym< 
 
 alists & 9. 
 •"i were to 
 McCullo 
 scribed v 
 cation in 
 of Class 
 toJ?<you 
 
 ■To THB 
 
 In 18: 
 quiry ui 
 cific qu( 
 in rtien 
 teriau C 
 in?, »< - 
 
 •' ».h, 
 
 the:?;d« 
 
 ^revmt 
 
 rrJ, hiui 
 
 oi in!:t<i' 
 
 derived 
 
 are pre 
 
 tjosp el, 
 
 TSaiDee 
 
 the res 
 
 bu the i 
 
 fore, i 
 
 Acada 
 
 to theJ 
 
 Atl 
 1832, 
 Marcl 
 before 
 was ni 
 reciiof 
 
 'the S 
 b^eni 
 come 
 toth( 
 was I 
 gratn 
 In 
 .IficCi 
 
 ibe; 
 Ktfu 
 pasM 
 
 K^v* 
 
... * 
 
 oi> n-rerrlnf? to the list of namet handed in by Kay in Plctou. on the 2*'^ M»;«h; "^^l /fjf" 
 iVr i^loOulloch ivt the'publio meeting. I find ie gated Mr. A. P. Ross, to proceed to Halifax 
 ?onta n?Sname offfimost distinguished .8 their advocate befor. tl.e Counc.l. Mr. 
 ni««™«n «nd IftvmeT of the Kirk ofJjfiQk Ross was furnished with a brief, which among 
 F^^^ir/vnT^oo/lOhuVch-l^C^^^^ others, memorandums for his -uidancc, con- 
 
 S &' ^a a^nd I h^ T^fSt- t'^ISHf- tained one to this effect-The Rev. D. A. Fr,- 
 ^fS^to'a^P V to them, they would lilce Mr. ser, having on the previous Session, present*^ 
 Mcculloch's friends, Cmifv. that iht^, sub- a petition to ttte Assemblr.afflrmuig that U 
 ^^C^lXV^Zd^^sirttoadmncemraltdu. was a conscientious belef, "tjatthe .anxiety 
 Srin the Province and to famish a couth of the Old Trustees, ongmated chiefly in a de- 
 ofC^rASSiCALanJ Philosophical imtruction sire to have it converted into a fi-ectonan /«• 
 ?o SvouthtXaZia for the study of Theolo- stituiionfor the purpose oj tr'fmng up young 
 toj«youtasw"cra«.<*«v/ -.,.■'.,,, «,«,//, tkf. dutiex and callma of Antiburgher 
 
 «fV. 
 
 I remain very faithfully 
 
 Wm. Jas. Akdbrson. 
 
 LETTER 3. 
 
 To THB Members of the Pbesbttbrian 
 Church of Nova Scotia. 
 In 1827, when Judge Chipman held his en- 
 quiry unto the affairs of the Academy, a spe- 
 cific question (No. 3) was put to the Trustees, 
 in rtfercnco to the connection of the Presby- 
 teriau Ohv-cti of No- 'a Scotia with the Acade- 
 
 men to the duties and calling of Antiburgher 
 Clergymen— that this was iu oHginal detign^ 
 and was openly avowed by the Rev, Dr. Mc* 
 CuUoch, the Principafof the Academy." Iu 
 denial and explanation, Mr. Ross is requett- 
 ed to produce to the Council, the sUtcments 
 of Dr. McCulloch, as reported in the Nova* 
 scotian, and as I have given them above. . ^ 
 After the passage of the Bill of 1832, which 
 was for the benefit of "persons of all denomi- 
 nations of Christians^ without distinction of 
 sect,'* and' which introduced, in addition tQ 
 
 imy, av ^ ths-. Education of Theological t>tu- ^^^ Higher Branches formerly taught, "alUb« 
 .flntH. a iie rei)i7 is h. the hand-writmg of p4ement««7 branches usually taught in Gram- 
 i>i. i4cC alloch', as follows . ^lar Schools." and jn^ wh ich, was introducej ^ 
 
 •'» he T'-u-'te«.-s would fanher observe, that the re3trictiv^jc]ju§alnj:ejergncotfl, the tcftch :. 
 ths:?;dttcutioiv of these, is ro inducted, as to "In p oTDmnUV . , t he SynodoTthe Fresbyte- 
 P'-ev'j\tar. ime:'fc.'mLe with the ^..nds tnd gmt- -H^Dhurch of JNora Scotia, tooK the Subject 
 
 nJ. huiiness cf tiic jny-.muon. i'or 1 his branch of the Academy into their consideration, and 
 ox incuaotior , ib« r^echer's eraolunients are appointed the Hcrycrendo John WaddeH,Tha- 
 derived iti.' those among whom the stufl en^ mas, Trotter, Robert Douglas, and John Mc- 
 nrrnrcpan ng to'^'^jipCM ""^^ committee to propose an address 
 
 "ftosDeTE^Sntha^boological Library, which ««to the Congregations of the Presbyterian 
 "BMbeen provided for ♦heir improvement, is Church of Nora Scotia." The address •was 
 the result of rUnnt.inns ex press l y appropr tatecj printed under the authoriry of the Synod and 
 bu the donors to this use. The trustees there- widely circulated ; from it I make the follow- 
 *fJjr-5w^eorTHe"charge of perverting the ing selections. 
 
 Acttdmv to Sectarian purposes, which has been .' The Academy is not nob ever was a 
 
 -. -V Affainst them, would be understood as express- Sectarian Institotion, as its opponents have 
 
 ^^"^st&tingdtatni >art of the funds intrusted sometime a/^rmcd ; for it is alike open to att 
 
 tQ their management, has ever been devoted to denominations, and is conducted on the most 
 
 the benefit "f'^'^^f individual sKt MJmM" liberal and conciliatory principles ; and it u 
 
 ^ST^^^^iSSkdeb^te^^irS^^ for iMs very reason that we have patraniiedf 
 
 18M reported in th^ '^ Novascotian" 15th nnd for this very reason wepatrmUe it sttlj, 
 
 Sh 1M2 nace 87. Dr. McCu'lochstated TT* would be unworthy o tbe name of Pres- 
 
 £e the hK of aSUij, that " to byterjans, and of having the interests of Pres- 
 
 ^ZtL^^ Class taught under thedi- byterians entrusted to us, did wo not endea- 
 
 ^ \ ^-^ tfO^T^isiees ^^atthe public ex- vour to place Education on a liberal and re- 
 
 *^^ SS^l-f«JiS«T3?^S"'«'^em spectablefooUng, andjliffuse a taste as ex- 
 
 -r^Sy»^^^ young nien who had tensively as possible through that comnunity 
 
 bLstu&atthTAcadeSy, wishedtobe- of which Presbyterians torra an important 
 
 ^ - Sfi3 fr.r tb« ministrv—tbev applied part." " A 1 beral education is becomuip m. 
 
 a^^ of thfprr;^e^^^^ Supensable for ail those offices of .ower .n. 
 
 ww?5»2edto instruct them. He did so trust, which our continually mcreas.nR pop 
 
 gratuitously at his leisure. •• 
 
 In 1838, it was proposed te translate Dr. 
 IficCelloch. to Halifax, and take with him 
 iBBiiL of the grant to Pictou Academy. Dr. 
 ^IcCuUoch and his friends were ia favor of 
 rtw proposition } it was opposed by Mr. Mc- 
 KflDzie and bis friei^s— ia order to insurethe 
 passage of the.BiU. Dr. McCulloch and his 
 
 r^! J- «i.^ at *t,> lift.iai. nl* Htv "RrtKprk Ila- 
 
 k^ji^ 
 
 lation and advancing wealth, are duiiy multi- 
 plying and caliinft into existence ; unci if such 
 an Education is Blighted or desp'sed l.y aw/ 
 denomination, that denomination wi:atever 
 may he its numbers, musi soon take its sta- 
 tton in the rear ; and permit others to seize on 
 the front, together with the honour and ad- 
 vantage attached to it." " It is altogethor a 
 false idwi tliat the Acadeay is only • iocal 
 
 fs^sm 
 
1 
 
 \.r 
 
 X' 
 
 n 
 
 Irr nr Ko ; . ' Prtparations for the minis, 
 trv and «./ A 5 -^ ^^ *^° mother couu- 
 
 • ., ^""'"V^'KiAN OHCHCiioiT Nova SmTTi" k» 
 ieter lafrf//^'^' ^° theirTcSTh a/e 
 rian— ' , ig an address, worthy of enlightened 
 jnen in an enlightened age! and affords a 
 
 ■ frntuhT'""' '" certain publications 0? thS 
 I^tmesumup. I have proved; 
 
 • y.1^1' ?^ ^^^ ^'''»'"* of '^e original bill in the 
 handnrntmg of Mr. Mortimer, that Pictou 
 
 fetbe declarations of the RevS^ Sr mS' 
 
 &"' SnTh'V'-T T'^'''' Messrs.' Ar: 
 cniDald, Smith, Fairbanks and Haliburton . 
 
 .tamped Sf on hlS the' ^T^ff""'""' "«« 
 
 that e^iir&^BTS^g^lfSf^-'"'^ 
 «cribed by the friends o £r McCuZir'- ' 
 Scotland, who were members ^ff^so^frf f 
 
 ^m^cQuIioch, tp havQ Um fot(he,9sms 
 
 4th. By the Petitions of the Trustn-.. on ' 
 
 AC, up to 1832, and couched n the strono-n«^ 
 ^npuHge. .t is apparent that they viewedThe ^ 
 Religious rcatrictions, as invidioL, !Z'^,r. 
 
 prosperity or the Institution. 
 
 5th. By the Address of the Synod of the 
 Presbyterian Church of Nova slotia, to he 
 
 fsas^Thlr'r-'' '^''' -o"»exion. 'issued in 
 1 833-That after the removal of the Restric" 
 tions, and opening up of the Trust tf" per- 
 
 Stions' ' "«T' 'f"'""'. ^'^"e-"^ ^no- 
 minations ; ~0erthejntroduction of the Zoiver 
 
 byterian Church of Nova Scotia, recommend- 
 ed Pictou Academy to their Congregations 
 as most worthy of their support. canons. 
 
 Having now proved the correctness of everu 
 '.£pi' «^^«°«^^\V mein the letters o? 
 
 One Concerned ;" having also, I think, mado 
 U clear that the statementrof the Rev. jZes 
 Ross, are at variance with those made by his 
 father and the other friends of the Academy 
 
 h/fiC?r. '°i^e* I»/''t"t'on. both under 
 the firsf Act. and that of 1832, 1 shall in mv 
 
 _ P10.0U, ,'ar '"?K,'M.»wf 
 
 ■^ '■! „_ • III 
 
 I.ETTEB 4. 
 
 To THE Members of thk Pbe8Btteeia« 
 
 Church OP NoTA Scotia. \^ . 
 
 fbo S";^"'"'^- f ?«-„Kos«. in his third letter in 
 the "NovascoUan" of March 18th, >as thus 
 
 '^#^ 
 
 r«";,'\'^^''''"*^'' *° 'J'^ communication S 
 the Revd. Wm. McCulloch, published in the 
 
 Missionary Record, in March 1849 
 niot'l^^'*^''"^'' f "'ains the following state- 
 fhl^U T^'^'^'fy ^e werein a more favour. 
 
 wi h ^ P?' \^^-» '^''^^ existed in connexion 
 With our Church^an,f to a certain extent un- 
 der Its controni, an Institution, the Pictou 
 
 ;r*' rfi ™/;/'°.™ ^'^'''^ « s'ea'^y ^pp'r of weu 
 
 qualified Ministers might be obtained." For 
 <^?5 statement, he has been publicly denoun- 
 ced as asserting what he and every member 
 of the Synod knew to be untrue, and as en- 
 deavounng to oStain from simple-minded 
 Scotchmen, funds for our Seminary, by false- 
 fiood, fraud mi deception. Persons who at- 
 tempt to instruct the ignorant, and whd'b*e-- :3k•^' 
 trav such unaccountable ignorance, or which 
 ts Jar worse, who wilfully misrepresent the 
 tacts oft/ce case, soon find their proper level 
 in public estimation, and goon lol©' their 
 power to mjurc."] . , . , . 
 
 \ } 
 
 
jouDg inea 
 
 rusteci, an- 
 Mage cf tho 
 lie strongest 
 viewed tho "» 
 
 10U8 to tho 
 
 lod of tho 
 tia, to the 
 I. issued in 
 he Restric- 
 t to "per- 
 ous Deno- 
 
 '^stn ctive . 
 
 the Pres- 
 commend- 
 rregatioriB, 
 
 S3 of every 
 letters ot 
 .ink,madQ 
 3v. James 
 le by his 
 Academy. 
 Dth nnder 
 II in mj 
 preserjted 
 ' tho Law 
 
 BBSOX. 
 
 ITEBIAN 
 
 letter in 
 
 as thus 
 
 ition Qf 
 
 ia tho 
 
 ; state- 
 fa vour- 
 inexion 
 mt un- 
 
 Pictou 
 of well 
 ' For 
 enoun- 
 lember 
 as en- 
 lirided 
 falae- 
 lo.at- 
 hd:b*e-- 
 which 
 nt the 
 r level 
 
 their 
 
 >*Min( 
 
 '^/« 
 
 3l•^' 
 
 but the truth is, in his zeal, and just indigna- 
 tion, against "falsehood, fraud and decep- 
 tian," Mr. Ross has forgotten to give the 
 conclusion of tho paragraph which is as fol- 
 lows : 
 
 [" Under powerful opposition and legisla- 
 tive interference, that Institution, with its Li- 
 brary, Appai-atus, and Building, have passed 
 into other hands, and have been placed entire 
 
 Any one on reading this, would naturally Nov* bcotia, the otily rt ii ati t n . \yith tho «• 
 •uppMc. that Ml. Koss had here given tho cepf ion of 'ho trfcnsferenco of the Trust, bemff 
 truth, the whole truth, and nothing but tho on the clause in reference to tho t«achngof 
 truth that in fact, Mr. McCulloch W writ- Theology, which is based ^n^he Resolution / > 
 ten nothing more than the above quotation, drawn up by the Revd. JnaJilc^lay. ^nrf ; / 
 
 •^ •-. .^ ,.•__- ^.;„-^^ „.^, approved of by all the oldlrm^ 
 
 tees, Mr. Boss among the number. I refer i 
 for further information to the letter of rcsig- i 
 nation cf the old Board, which I hare alr©»djf ( 
 published. " ;''V""r-'' 
 
 2nd. That instead of introducing tt« Z,C'V/& 
 Branches at the expense oftheHigha\ the Trus- 
 tcas in arranging in Departmentl^e various 
 mto oiner nanas, anu nave oeeii p.nv;«u ^u...,.- branches which the Law introduced sS^^m: 
 \y beyond the coutroul of our Church by which nelled^themjojcac^ Ix^^S^ 
 
 the Institution was originated. By this meaiw the wriltenluggesmcsjurniahed ttm fcy "i«^«'r \ , 
 have we been deprived no^ onlyoftbo small Jas. Boss, who m J-efcref e to ,the i>owat . 
 amount contributed by the Government, but Branches- wrote thus-" ^l^^ ^■^'f^^^Z ^ 
 of all that had been raised by the friends of Branches-TYi^ Lower Bran6he8--/rw_W«i 
 Education, both in the Provinces and at home, most important-^lt is the most '«<'0"<^«*-;^ T, . 
 By this act, we are as a body not only e^clud- the one on which success principally <iff^' ' 
 ed from any direct interest in the Institution, The Trustees secured the sorvicea of ^ . J«» 
 but from the very nature of the Act, we aro Mr. Way, to teach^ Mathematics and. N^tvaj 
 prevented by what is due to ourselves, from PJ»iIosophy at a salary of £175 per annual ai^i 
 SesiriBg Pny such interest."] a fifth of the fees-Mr. Bell in iiis second J)e- 
 
 I leave you to comment on Mr. Ross's con- P-*£^ffiK,^X fo?^^^^^^^^ 
 
 atpiro/rrnn^^r "^.^T^ XL'lZ ^^^^^^^ 
 
 ducted the whole controversy. As regards 1^"?^^ ;jrMr f W KwaoHow Sia I 
 
 the assertions of Mr. McCulloch, Imay say Ist. ^JJ,?, J.^ Ju'por.monJ^^iraS^jraS- \ 
 
 That the W/amount comriuu^ea oy u^^ ^eTed intdSon to thercgular cours^a com- \ 
 
 aient, was ^JjSOO -£4,400 oj J^m^^^^ plete series of Lectures on if*t. History-em- . 
 
 drawn ^^er the passage of tic Act ^^^^^ V t/iree Professors for the Higher, om 
 
 which opened up the Trust to f ^^^J^'^' Master for the Lower, in uthe opinion of the 
 
 tions of Christuins"-restncted the teaching of ^'l"^/^,"^''^,*; ..„„*j„t;„^„„i/„ ,he L6wm 
 
 Theology— and made the Boman Catholic Jii- 
 
 shop, the colleague of Dr. McCulloch 
 
 That as all, the Tbeplogical L^br^r, „ — 
 
 once handelo verto the Syno dJythojEregest 
 
 2^^^T^''Sw^nSSilo man, a graduate ot«,scotcn..mver.uy ua.« 
 
 frStZ^a u7 iS^SS testifiedV the ability.^with which th. Masters 
 
 Rev. Jas. Ros?, "was introducing the Xidwor 
 Branches at the expense of the Higher." 
 Among others who hava' certifio(Jy^ the Rev. 
 Mr. Elliot who received his odupation at tha 
 University of Oxford, and the Rev. Mr. Herd- 
 man, a graduate of a, Scotch University hava 
 
 i 
 
 ! 
 
 the Church, mixed up 
 property. Dr. McCulloch having solemnly 
 declared to Judge Chipman, that tho Trustees 
 had m this respect, taken care " to prevent all 
 interference with the funds, and general busi- 
 ness of the Institution. 
 
 The Ilevd. Jas. Ross, in his letters in the 
 " ]\ovascotian," not only reports the charge 
 about the robberv of tho property, and that 
 
 profi- 
 
 havo performed their duties, and to the 
 ciency of their pu.jils. 
 
 Thirdly— None of the Trustees, have either 
 by word or deed shewn any } stility to the 
 establishment by the Synod c a Theologicil 
 Seminan/ , on the contrary, I uave reason to 
 know thai one and all of them entertain tha 
 aoom tne roDoerv ui lu. p..i.c...r, ..« ...«. opinions which I have ever f'^P-^ssed fud 
 the present Trustees have applied it " to pur- which I have published, that t% would htve 
 poses quite foreign to the design of the origi- failed in their duty if they had not exerted 
 nal contiibiitors," and thi;t 'Uhey have iniro- themselves to the utmost to establish aTheolo- 
 duced the Lower Branches at the expense o/ gical Seminary under the complete controul 
 
 " Education 'of their Church. 
 
 ■ Tft'^* 
 
 the Higher, so that a course 
 
 of 
 
 cannot bo obtained there, which will qualify 
 younr; men for entering upon the study cf 
 the ministry ;" but ho adds, "certain "f the 
 Trustees seem determined to destroy Ike Si/nod's 
 
 Seminary, root and branch." The answer to 
 all this is, 1st. That the Act of 1845, which 
 has been so much misrepresented, is substan- 
 tialhj the Act of 1832, which met the approval 
 - - ~ ■ .-.ffh^ p-ggbytcriau Cliurch of strura^ata: 
 
 i^JMVvfc 
 
 The sentiments of the Trus* 
 tecs arc in exact accordance with those ex- 
 pressed by the Resolutions of the Rev. Mr. 
 McKinlay's Congregation. " Entertaining 
 these views, thoy looked on the establishment 
 of a Theological Seminary at West River, 
 hs having a tendency beneficial to the Acade- 
 my, whifc they at the same time, had the con- 
 fident hope, that the Academy, might be in- 
 ai ia forwatdlBg th§ objects Qf tho 
 
%' 
 
 \ 
 
 
 8 
 
 * 
 
 r 
 
 ^amoncement of tlwse person.. ttMolkrL. ^"^ ^. 
 
 JiOMBTeanpoa their present ::mitedSe J?^i ,r^!' %"'' f "f '^ '^''^^ Jealo-" ca,e tL d l' ' 
 
 ^^ aiQ«K«P8, w well as a 8a.e.ruard aLa^n^t ^^1 ^ ''"^' guardians, ia what r.c maiJ 
 gefHHS^'#«gfr^^ &r'"',i'"'' they Jiould maiSftsT^ 
 
 !S?^?^^«' of seeking mstrnSriS ?^S'"^ ^' "^^"^ good work, and dl-oj 
 ''T^^*§#5^ °f »^° Church. ItSS «^ hr.n« ofT" *»d!»<^a^!on of the young, the J3 
 i.l<e,^$f>rPtfj that eventually the ffitSl J ^^ °^"i® ^°"'"« ago, will giin fo/theto'tC 
 
 «><riSv5ri«idf, iS- ^««'^''^er. instead of their jveighbours, is what every true mirn SS 
 ' ^°« 't''J. t*9 Trustees hav^ m^^- «« •*^«„'l. to freedom of thonf?ht. »nA th. „-v,k# .* I-sIj™ 
 
 •n 
 
 wpw Seminary at West Biver ; when Xy jndgemcnt-sbenll seek to mak^tho very «i! 
 ti^^^'T''^^^''^ ungenerously at?id^ej T^t^/ ^'^^TT' ^« active pow^ ia the i5^ 
 &Tjby 1^''"°'^' ^'^^y °o°»°nt«d S,afi*«r?ofthe ti^e, in rdelr.«ion atii . 
 
 fi^nK^^^^^ J.'^^^selvos, is proof positive 
 
 rillMk-f.,^"^ - vxcou m lao institutiou" ? ;^at tua^ BSye still a great deai'to ieain. m to 
 
 ^?. L^/>r«'««fe'' fii/ t**^ -• ii due to ''^f « «P«nt they are of. Conduct such M^h , 
 
 me^^J^rnd^iT,ngany such interest" f At T^ "^' "«'*« '"^'^ of those who have know. 
 
 Ktetin^ of the qfltfe Octobr . the R«v. Mr! f^^^P?''*^ <'^/ ^<^ «^f true religiob, but ft wTS 
 
 S& ««K£f"2?* to defend Mr. McOuI- !f,J tjem to doubt, 2^;Aer^er««clav«,We CA,^* 
 
 Jbrttepttbh<»tya^fjy8firstjfiiier--bal '*'^f %A«*« or 6e^< c^powyrt o/ C/^-istianZ^ 
 
 ^^l^V^'T^ ? l^'P"*^^^ 4«u,<S, -'•«''' "'Memanl^ feeling, in christians cf£SS^ 
 
 ' ■ ''.v .■'», 
 
 '^ '» r» i., ' \ 
 
 -■j*» 
 
 
 :'fci 
 
 
 
 I 
 
 
 \ 
 
 
isionsd not hy itt 
 'e«*t. Ineoncla- 
 triouf perasal of 
 
 Wch thflj and 
 ons — f - • 
 ire to K 
 should ' 
 iloiu I 
 
 the . 
 i what nc man 
 uld mauifeM a 
 vork, and d»y)i 
 young, thebtirt 
 «in fof them tbj 
 od man.*' 
 that goad nay 
 be kingdOflfi of 
 ) witness a,;,ate»t 
 y true mirn, wll! 
 rciCnoneHftfjBint, 
 i fn anf Agodifiii 
 
 right jfpriTaite 
 ike the very m* 
 'tr y^ the geeft- 
 ich-.aion abd a 
 srxent tad dc- 
 'Jiecryofiaft^ 
 iO are as deep* 
 andflpiritutlity 
 proof positiro 
 I to ieaia, ea to 
 let soch aa fhia 
 10 have know* 
 oh, but it wilt 
 I visible Church 
 f Cliristianity^ 
 ^ iDorld,incith 
 stianschariig.*^ 
 mia 
 
 
 •) 
 
 ( * 
 
 < 
 
 'T* . ■ 1 
 
 < 
 
 ;'.^ . - ,.