IMAGE EVALUATION TEST TARGET (MT-3) /^d. 4^ 1.0 1.1 11.25 I ■tt lii 12.2 S lis 12.0 ■ 1.8 ■MB V ^ % .■»* o Photographic Sciences Corpopalion 23 WIST MAIN STMIT WltSTIR.N.Y. MSIO (71*)t72-4S03 '^ CIHM/ICMH Microfiche Series. CIHIVI/ICMH Collection de microfiches. Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions / Institut Canadian de microreproductions historiquas Technical and Bibliographic Notas/Notaa tachniquas at bibliographiquas The Instituta haa attamptad to obtain tha bast original copy availabia for filming. Faaturas of this copy which may ba bibliographically uniqua, which may altar any of tha imagas in tha raproduction. or which may significantly changa tha usual mathod of filming, ara chacicad balow. nColourad covars/ Couvartura da coulaur I I Covars damagad/ D D D □ D Cuuvartura andommagte Covars rastorad and/or laminatad/ Couvartura rastaur6a at/ou palliculAa r~| Covar titia missing/ La titra de couvartura manqua Colourad maps/ Cartas giographiquas an coulaur □ Colourad ink (i.e. othar than blua or blaclt)/ Encra da coulaur (i.a. autra qua blaue ou noira) {~n Colourad platas and/or illustrations/ Planchas at/ou illustrations mn coulaur Bound with othar matarial/ Rail* avac d'autras documants Tight binding may causa shadows or distortion along intarior margin/ La re liura sarrie paut causar da I'ombra ou da la distortion la long da la marga intiriaura Blanit leavas addad during rastoration may appaar within tha taxt. Whanavar possibla. thasa hava baan omittad from filming/ II sa paut qua certainas pagas blanchas ajoutias lors d'una rastauration apparaissant dans la taxta. mais. lorsqua caia Atait possibla. cas pagas n'ont PAS At* filmtes. Additional commants:/ Commantairas supplAmantairas; L'Institut a microfilm* la maillaur axamplaira qu'il lui a itA possibla da sa procurar. Las details da cat axamplaira qui sont paut-^tra uniquas du point da vua bibliographiqua. qui pauvant modifier una imaga raproduita. ou qui pauvant axiger una modification dans la mAthoda normala da filmage sont indiquAs ci-dassous. r~~| Colourad pagas/ D This item is filmed at the reduction ratio checited below/ Ce document est film* au taux de reduction indiquA ci-dessous. Pagas da coulaur Pages damaged/ Pages endommagAes Pages restored and/oi Pagas restaurAes at/ou pelliculAes Pagas discoloured, stained or foxe< Pages dAcolorAes, tachetAes ou piquAes Pages detached/ Pages dAtachies Showthrough/ Transparence Quality of prin Quality inAgale de I'impression Includes supplementary materit Comprend du materiel supplAmentaire Only edition available/ Seule Edition disponible Pyj Pages damaged/ I I Pages restored and/or laminated/ r~p\ Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ I I Pages detached/ rri Showthrough/ I I Quality of print varies/ |~n Includes supplementary material/ I — I Only edition available/ T si T w b€ rif ra mi Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata slips, tissues, etc.. have been refilmed to ensure the best possible image/ Les pages totalement ou partiellement obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata. une pelure. etc., ont M filmAes A nouveau de fapon A obtanir la meilleure imaga possible. 10X 14X 18X 22X 36X aox J 12X 16X aox a4x 28X 32X Th« copy filmed h«r« haa bean raproducad thanka to tha ganaroalty of: Douglaa Library Quaan'a Univaraity L'axamplaira film* f ut raproduit grlea A la gtoAroait* da: Oougiat Library Quaan's Univaraity Tha imagaa appaaring hara ara tha baat quality poaalbia conaidaring tha condition and lagibllity of tha original copy and in kaaping wKh tha filnting contract apacif teationa. Original coplaa in printad papar covara ara fiimad beginning with tha front covar and anding on tha laat paga with a printad or liluatratad Impraa- aion, or tha back covar whan appropriata. Ail othar original coplaa ara fiimad beginning on tha firat paga with a printad or liluatratad Impraa- aion. and anding on tha laat paga with a printad or liluatratad impraaalon. Tha laat raeordad frama on aach microficha shall contain tha symbol ^^ (moaning "CON- TINUED"), or tha symbol V (moaning "END"), whichavar appiiaa. Laa imagaa auivantaa ont it* raprodultas avac la plua grand aoin, compta tanu da la condition at da la nattat* da l'axamplaira f llmA, at an conformiti avac laa conditiona du contrat da fllmaga. Laa axamplalras origlnaux dont la couvartura an papiar aat imprimia aont fiimia an commanqant par la pramiar plat at an tarmlnant aolt par la darnlAra paga qui comporta una amprainta d'Impraaalon ou d'llluatratlon. solt par la aacond plat, aalon la caa. Toua laa autraa axamplalras origlnaux aont filmic an commangant par la pramlira paga qui comporta una amprainta d'Impraaalon ou d'llluatratlon at an tarminant par la darniira paga qui comporta una talia amprainta. Un daa aymbolaa aulvants apparattra sur Im darniira imaga da chaqua microficha, salon la caa: la aymbola — »> algnifia "A SUIVRE", la aymbola ▼ algnifia "FIN". IVIaps, plataa, charts, ate, may ba fiimad at different reduction ratioa. Thoaa too large to be entirely included In one expoaure are filmed beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to right and top to bottom, as many framea as required. The following diegrama illuatrata the method: Lea cartea, planchea, tableaux, etc., peuvent Atre filmia A dee taux da rMuction diffirants. Lorsque le document est trop grand pour Atre reprodult en un aaul ciichi. ii eat fiimi i partir da i'angia aupiriaur gauche, de gauche i droite, et de haut an baa, an pranant la nombre d'imagea nicessaira. Lea diagrammea suivants iiiuatrent la mithode. 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 S 6 •♦ -l;*^* IMIMlMhl JLl ^^^^/| {""^^^ tketo wUdilto '^>. •.\*»i*«.«o hl^ Ihi^hii Immm ■llliMlillMlliMni1itin(Wf> ^koAKaMriiiiididmBliiiJNliata tli[&atlr*aiav ihi JMiV kMit mil tiT ihWi utian ilMia ■;,' p '/"^ 2 f^^ ■^1 ^ .Ji^ ■ Ai>i. •'.i, « « »i' ■^ ;• • 1 |: iS ■«»■- ■¥• .: .1. # I'' « stretohottt hiiMrm before tiie other hone in the feoood heat, apiwreMly tokeephimfeMk. ^do hir(i«r dadwe» t^^ ^piie i» ■ptflfH «^«e«* te naUiig this atatenwBt, wUebl UBiead^ to veriQr on wthfif required to do 10. ' I,BICHARD F i ! i |itta».a lne«iMr i^mk 9l manner aa pw w pl a d the eolw*' >y ti ^wi^g Mat wUaki,lnmr •fiinion^lw tMUiiav* daw M 11)11 Mavnnldaaiwup ! t I have nvliHMtian mJmimmJi^mM^ thJi ilfiwiwin tiMA thewrtdewe at the reqtmt of a flanili— in tealnia 0»ftal>«prl4iff!A«ah AAMUiB* ilNSON. ti'^ n' "i • Mm »i I III vnti . 1.v::-i-?/^ "^.i! ,)j.^.: ; •:' ' .!. do'didiie'tiati iaw tfto fibi tnii-i iTM diirtde; mi^iniiMmMM^(p »my k kim A %miuiktmo heap Unhaek. WILUAM ■»>«■ WWIHi ■liif»wly My >>jfeiidw iV hflwaioBtiw Khg^^ toaeeuree a|ilM|ft,tioie#nqf^ h th^aacoftd and third heafi^ nrfi hi eonqpap, njifilh Mr. llMMnaa. We atood near die diilanoe pofet I aaw M|. r^taithe kat heat, atrike the btaekboj lepealdllf inth|t]taBgi|al,i*^> ij^fllSy of eaehheat In the last forty or fiffy rods of the third hent, tte ealoured \>ay, w h^hnd been mme distnee behind Mr. M^iwtil^li^iiBtfM^igrii^ 1^^. J^j^ ^l|iifeiiMtoC|M,Airi^|)fitviWl'it«|ll ey|d«»tt|p|||«t(|t^^|);iq^ |^^B*^^^5-.^»^HP ^^^W^WI^^^^HRij^^ ^WFvW^ff^^^^B.»*^fl^ 'I' ^^ Ww JfffllrSfrnr ^^^ff^fl^Wr^ I alio state, that I waa not, in the feast, inteMMd ilijie it»^ 4 Jblftno- thiim^ at stake upen either of the h otawi and I do not remember of ever hair- ing seen either of than pnyious to the, race. ■^fitt^-y mrtiri^Lii! ' '•^ ■ -sir tiji»ilB ^a>.! «'•■; •..• »» .i,,"i f.U <' •M-V »;,' ^,i ;,',.!j{ ,,/?i1 . •>•■ ..,: I'-." ■ •> II ■"11!,'" •■■ri '^ni| | m • • ■ ' . ■ 'i? -i nt^ 4 Jitino. Dberofcverhav- o)isq[ gether, and Mr. »|iQi am)*!!*. fm^ to li a ia t b9«#. . < f ..^ /. JOHK BmTTBRWORT^. # Miiifif-iTlM ililt 9ii^Tbf fi^«t||t^t)if fliMna«Vi^^ attribu^4»«ia i«,lM9|iaft(^r (^,.|»^^9(^^ 8tatef^thftii«N||W1|Uudedto. ,. ..-^j^. .-^ I attended tba meetiog at your lequest ; and bfb|f |^^0)|ktlX|ff:,fou, Mr. TbMMKMi aaked, ** Wen yo» aMhe moe oiMfaft imi" " was ruu> ibrtittaMi/)"'' '^BW ]««'' Ml M^ 'tf^|lttMr iftWMite «> A^ Fam eMki^f IgMlMli'orlM^'Hlel STlMMMid^'i .driiliiR fel^ il4kltli»r WhM t eaii' ^vlMtinflirw'ik V%it'l'««Niitffly'ilaW iMil Y efen^i ' % ^ i»ik-tt mk Mitd > ^ln tlMJait liil t^irt lii ia fca €teMit» iwi im^i l iM i i l iii '|MMr;'l«tMr ilie »kl«^ MMrirtAig Wtl fi i MrM iii iitt 'iBj 8iMb«>«Mi9< tHkA N#iirii»f 4rk teempMc- heii^^ '^#lii^^lftf^ obaerved it, one aMh of «4«li%lt|ibM«oft,?* J Directly beta on the race.^ "I hadaoo0iHriD« you any -'ir- ; AltblNWli|[l«waU liueb nther »T«id i^.inteEfef«nee m, the aaatler of the I »< I y Met, yet, being wtuiicti witli yum miem Ib^M^MMtajfttRf t^Vs^ldft my Tti>i.l^, ,^^ . , ^^^ H!''^^^^ ' Sii^ have'taaabiliM the elBlbleht made h^iie iMiMtlkSlif^^ the pOnpUet pahiished hy thefts a&d IbMl they ha^ MKiMdM^ * '■ I krt* (iMbetwMu !■(( MMrMtirani ■nannB ufwnuN bb Nft •lu widi '« iQriMuw ito6ui8 J|IWil^ IVHUIMQ : ^' i. ■■; ^ ' :. -,•,■■.,'• J .■.'. miN) feltethiivl HitecoCMiiiiJIfr. Ni'ii»vtfct,...„ the X, - # irlMltofmylMliMMr* latatodlhiilfr. Pnorlooiiiliebiaflkboiyt^ th« MJtet iwl jMJlMilii Urn fti lii iimwii, wUoh ki ^y opiitepravrated thi lMi» o^Mlh ■■Hii' AtlA wteiif Ik* IhI liwt. I tlwilaleA tlwt Mr. P tioi Hte »il l <» h liii lt l » it» Mi i nil h Hi» bMut «Mi Irit bit aroi in poft, aod •!» ni«Bd kii iHridi put hia honeiotMflW ( I, WOnit. pJ^FOkot tM ToipMli^y of KingsUm, ButtWr, da declarf tlift I itw dw nm Mtppn Mf* Yai^r't hone mmI Mr. f liiiwy's, on the ITtbNorm^f ttl^llfwwilr* Prior ]W|fi|tli|aleft arm in Dte SJIicat, bafaia tha hla^ kgr, or iiia I«om% aom after they dtarted ; and in the tliir^ hao>> h a tH wa n tha ^iaiaiteo and irinrng po«t,lMirtbebfa|ckboyon com- bf «fi to Mr* Vfifiv^MdeovQMied to paas Mr. ttifn who reined hie horse's haad.bdbMthaoliwr, aoAiilthabiif couU not get part. Whenthisbe. fuitka hoTMi 1*P« neat ^ iipiiide af tha course, with the blaolc boy out- aide { birtiii Mhort tisM Mr. IMarbad worked againat the other hi meh fi way aa tobii||f them a emiaidariUa diatanea lowardF^ the ontside of thp course hy tht time they conw oppoaite the winaing posu HtSUnt DAVIS. W«AV jb| daela«|d hi tJM Ihnpioifig itati«mts caaM wittb ny own hmh^- diataobiMimtiontotha fe^aat e«tci^ ; pad whilo the Stowai^ wan y«( fit ihartM^ irpda up and IbU them (hat 1 M soen onftfar pfaiy>.ottd Icqiiested thap.jbra^Mrider a jaiigmont, wUeh t undarstoodlhay hR# liren hi favor of Mr. Yii^cr'M honie. Thaae fpntlemcQ d|d not see fit to alter tlviir da- . .^^kifM^ 4i^>* ^ I did not baaUate to elate to ony l>eraoo wkoit Ikippanad ik» converM with on tha subject, what I bod saeu jand on tU )tfU> Mr. CnitHaden, wbokad beenoneoftha Stewards, cametoHiehithB itfaet. Aa ioliAoik Mr. Mir, and ashed hmiv^ H^hat I bad said of *a raoa^ " I ni sig l hi j r w ji rt l iii l m Mir. Priori afaiiater as a tartJeman." VswMoh In|III|, Uitt whenl spoka of (ha' Mb«i I never «entsn>plil8«^ifr. P« ih as^MftfnfflTrrae«lfa«deT«rs«en." Iti^iUad ■f. 1 1 4 : I , i. / I* I MmI 1 did M( MeoBMt iMw itmM^nmU, biliMt|«wiMdrl6.i obwmltoii In u iii u a i»ih ll ta ii ail it« |i«l|ttM»WlMfci' dw of UMt day, b oidtr ttMt Iba niglit U piMMl at Ikk C^MvitaM^ mt)wMlNli that ha had takan |ho ophdoB of thw gjpa<|iiaaii, whoaa immb w lia did '• Bolhaaitate to n^MUm,** vlt. Mr. TlMiiM^, ll». MdiAiliy^, ind Mir. Gray, iad who wart«r«pifdoii, Ihatla Ac ]^#iint cMr, fta iMhklNa oTiotkay tiid GantfcnaB eoM aellla aapaiilea. tte «yeklfa|illill,1li»i^ IcauldlwthalpUiaoidaiooiOf dlhri^a^-tiiH hidc u M W Had Mf««aldr«f l^iaada alae. by «lkMa ad^rfea I hadVa«i i i 'n> i. WBr,twlMwI 1 i> W «il tfai tft^i^HWli^t wUekl danksd ; Wlhllif hi> rwtoliid any Millar aaMiMMi 1ha« iHMll copwHiiid I hadamidytivwihitt. I AaaMMathfiirlMbaraiMMMi la what alc|^^ IJanae. Mr. C. lutirwilbillvwv diSr Matiaf thdIkatriaMMf Iba bad had ib^ftingtd do fit the natter. ' Aa 4»fl^lMid MN bean fLvat) op, the Stoiiraidiiwafa tadoead to Matt Ml the aveniaf of the 19lh to rccooiider their fcnaar JudgHMat ; and aa 1 uaderMood thataafwpenoiw had been indMtriapa in aaldiif i^p^livthat IMini>da%imindlMc1^ Nik,la(leaMttllla|aaAi>k in«d(i|t9ipBa|iMtopM(MMax|ili|ned,lttotdir lo allell aaH|(l to JaMlhr the awaiUonlkid dMde. tKa Ibwaldi cadbuad thtfr fctiwi iijfelito; aSar ^iMtiifaf tofhe W;biill«idbed the odyctttJaM lodM^aMttljrM inlhM eJiiiiUMtioif-HBaBiely, todanMMlnaato*naMMdiiuitM^ tobeiiKaent,aa well toall impaitial penooa, tha^ 1 had dteaiwl«4)r4 inpion. plefa oTii^uitiea. Thu being iM;coin|4|iM* t cdM aoi wla te ^y^bow tte^kidiinlghtgo. .fr*T' '){ i QnliiBilwdtgnflhBMtb »fc. C?iKtiwdan oanni»>iH pUed tbaiMM tobt/rf^ Ihafi nHM ■-! liava Mottiaclio* it.wiibdMw Jihat | M.«aU« liitMid, #itlilii(faa toiyiniHi, larty yHiato apinia^ wwatitttlia mm i Wid that l^^lwda who had hwid tba^fa^afcutian weta alaa fliHy c B wH ia< d oi in p Bi aalaMi t bil, laddad. thai ill leonld do Ihad daiia» JMMWlifi I 'hidibatidtethedaciaiooofthaHlawartainp^ngtba atfOl bala.liM M it # «IIM HMBiJlrinMnMMt w, Bucnlnff , ind bUhwiilllllrMlh MRRM 1MB WMhI f » ladaeaAtoBMct idgmmt;aDdu I ikiiifitmMrtlMt tenMllkttt joMUy^ wkiiWiiikill ■i 4te«teligi4)r4 •it JaWMwhtft I Mr. C. w«n4 ftWi^ iod ntittIM agyii MiM Immm »ft«mwdi, with i written ptpw, to t|w PMwit that I " oofw eoMld«red tl># rie« ftir." the Stewwdi ktvinff dtotara^M } wUok b* mU Mr. P. wUMd m^ to lign} "' U«t hi kiiiokl ilk. Prior. btkMwl Mould iw fcr (IM kit tioii^ iffer bogglaf of no io ttte to tU oxciteHivil the buriooii had |wodoecd ; MiDo roqitooiia afid wry civil dwnjaior, firom ith no, he had aaver deviated, teiminated. and fat aome weeki heard little about it ; when on the 7lhlnel*t,the Mowinr aailuaoApC paper waa diaco^ vered, and put into mjgfhandaby aftieodiwbwaeoertained that it waa at firatahewnaboutaiMing^a/flooidjr.bHl hnd been ianiedao far bMOkaithi aAemooBofthe 19th i^. aboitljr after MrvC^nittenden'i interview with Mr. BriKoe and mvadf ; ||id a lew houra befem the nMeting of the Btewarda. at the aauM time notdoao. Henow wll mr inlhienre inputlinffi and alter bavi^; abaarvWl whicb,inaUhlafaii I now thought the a4Ur homaidlfr. leaBXhraaay ofbr.oraa inmiMr. 1 ttwi L«ii nraifMi " -t , r. Prior to writ oa Dr. •uipwia, Ibr M«inllMtlMor«satMii bhttar, iii«intl» Mr. Friw.ndkaiMtMwMa Mr.TMkw'* luAlrir. IwaitadMDr.t. MdlliaMawwwaa,I«dMaiTatlMt orHr.Frior, M« jodMy, wMMmt aflbetiim kit akMMtarM #' MlaMnrMrinvatetkMTeimuMtaMM. 1 Ml Dr. •. nd took tk* UoMomtetowauo* tho fbUowiof poiat, wlMMkor tho NMulnaedli iaor.«MMtaA,ona tfcoy woro ■ ■ ■■Iw n ei h r aCapla l Mi Ifcut Dr. 8. mw. ■HOB. iMMiw«k,a« BIr. Prior** UhanetoroeflAdiiitko Mtiimiaa of who dM Ml miMMtmA muk laMloaiotiMtioUa.— HMriM ania iroit- o4««tlMD|4ko OMwwfoa, that ho ootid Ml ko^tkoopMdoMortkoOoinSMMa, :M ho iMiaft ii* vofjMthM OB hM ehoiMtor •• o mriNMa-^^oMklotod (ho iMo Mfcir.-Httd honJioidhtefhotMr.P. Mid lUoaoMil^oawMoMMhood,— MOMWorwaiiiiroB tH tUo,i«lhorlhMDr. 8.ii9im,ieMr.P.p4nU(odteeallia(hlaito aewMuit, ho wotid taitoiMhtUpoastholowolmrodtoM«Toat«|V ■ooHiig. BDWnr COVWnENAT CRUTTENDBN. IhMotei Bwa, IdehciriVooi(^,(holoaFridaythoI9thNo«r. I ml Momti. ThoapMo. Priorand < Toiftor|hkC!lM^hmi«ot,tholanMrnMliM a liopor, whkh wao rilonriwdt haadod to ■Of OM whiah MiMited to bo a atateaMat Of MOM wterriows that oooamd botwooa Dr. Md Mr. Crattoadoa. ,IlthDoo.Un. TH08. HAMDCOCK. . Kow, I do confeaa, t waa dot a little aatoniihed on readihg thia awagfering declaration of Mr. Ciuttenden, after the veiy mild and alible tenor of bia coodnct in pnraon towarda me ; and I wrote a noie to Mr. Briicoe on the aubject, whoae reply ia u ieliowa. DBAa Sia, KingitoB, aad Doeoabor. 1880. wMaoas iBlhak ; no to dotail a«08T«n*UoB I waa Ih anwor toyoar aoto ofthit day. " l aqM rt Ing i . — MOO to, hr year dotiro, betwcon Mr. Crattoadon aad yoanOlLoa tho aftwaooa of the lak;" aadaifciaf , " whether I hoard tha ienb/«/«efto«4 ooatayad to you by tha fcf^ sa^^J^n 'fc'.«feii';.,0Bf J ^.r*^ v II I ■Him , < Mg » » i . Ha iiiSfe V ( no met." IlMT«tott>to,tlwtIwuproMBtihiifai/(^ei(4olf«rtk*fBtarTiawtowluehMB •llad*. U»t MrCratttBdM eooHMMMby toUiu nm « ibhU juttakMtha miNiiu-opMiMaKtli«nMlatflrrod«b7Mi(MarirM aawiifair om, th» chiuMtan argeaUMwui wd JDclny Midd IM M|Hit««t* |Mi Iktt llMM mOmmb w«« oTopiBiM, tint rack destnctiw cmild not ba umU ia ttit- 4I«m.** To tS« yaa replM, *tli^youeo«MBotkelpth«4'iioMoraaMnoBtlM^poi«^«*tf^ opinhiiS tbe friends yw ted eoMvUcdk fat yo« hM is eoquaOB wiilaB WMtail«n ■!« |Wh^ gronnd, w uaquMtionaUe tigbft ta Mate wtet yoa ted tfjim, wutent b«ag aeeooataUe to indftidHls, provided yae. 10,1880. Sia, f, . In reply to ynnr note of thi* moning I beg to elato, ttet on or a|out tte 19th of NoTember lait, Mr. Cnittendea anet me in tte ttrectf and aaid, te wished to eaecrtain ay opinion on a certain point, naasely " whetter any disiespeetral remarks nipde on an indi- vidual in his capacity as a JUdsr did not aStet hiaeharaeter as a gcntfcMw ; and whe^ tter the natter of sach renutriu eovid with propriety rcfnse to oMke reMration to the fierton wte eoueeired himself ii^initd." I immedianly rc|riicd, that I eowid aot perceire tte distinction ; as, in mj opinion, disrespectful words said of a rider mi^ dhet his charscteras a nntleman, in the estimation of the public I think Mr. Cmttendcn did not mention the names of tte parties concerned— ceitsialy^ not the cause of offence Neitter did I oonsolt with any person, relatire to tte subject, before w after expressing my opinion. I am. Sir, Your obedient SerraBt, , H C. "{HOMSOK. James Sampson, Esquire. 8ia, In answer to your note of this day reanesting to te ioforaied whether I was consnhad by Mr. Cmttendcn on a point in qaeition between you and Mr. Prior, I am to state, that Mr Cfttttenden a»ked me one day in the street, *in a very enriory manner, something touching the matter, and I recolleet saying to him in reply, that I thought it too nice a r>int to define in a moment, aud that Newmarket is tte place to decide sQch questions, did not tay tiiat Doetor Sampson was liable to make reparation to Mr. Prior on any point, as I knew nut tbe circumstance of the case. To Doctor Stetpson, \c^&e. he. Hn Dccemter, 1830. I am. Sir, Your most obedient, &c &c. &e. W.U.tJRAY. Br.l /' \ itcWMW to which VM Qny,whiUMnahw - aawiMr one, the To «r: 7«i repli«L piai«itoMr.Cntten. »«li»th«flpWMMIof mt I declare that wasMteoaTeyed ^heregfettedbiv- ot h«^ muridag to Kr. roora, Y BRI8C0E. i?r* »«y, and Macfar- d "who were una- on" to Mr. Prior, •ubjoinedaiuwert tea. Dee. 10,1889. oralmit thelfthof ahed to aaoertain my iriuii^oaaaiadi- ^tfoMM J aad whe^ «• nMratioB to the ^leoaldaot perceive hw mi(Malftcthia Maeeraed— certaialr^ UUvetothesubjcct, Mdieat Senraat. C. '{HOMSON. herlwueoarahed I am to f tate, that manner, gomething ragfat it too aieea de iDch quettioai. Frior OB any point, dient, '< tte. &e, W.H.tiRAV. An,— la answer (oyonr dea, aaliing me .o»e day oa Prior, aa arider, w«nuu.aa«« aflmMttva, ttMtfai Aat I did eAet Thk waa all that pai UaUWy to make repaiatioB i» iMBtlaaad* Dr. Sanqxoa, Ae. Jbc.Jc« . . KingitOB, Mth Dfccember, 1880. ifthia nenuag, I beg to tay, that I recollect Mr, Cmtteif leeet, whether I eooaidend aay wfleatioaa made on Mr. I character aa a gea tlea w a t o whi«h I auwored hi the wadentaad aaeh aiee diitiaethMi, or aomethiBg to that oa tha ooeaaioB. Thww wari aotkfaig Mid about year Fnor—nordo I recoOaal that your aame waa even . ., Tour TUT obadieatSehraat JAS. MACFARLjUIE. So much for the unammoui ofmioa of tjbree Gentlemen, that Doctor Sampaon could not shelter himself under the' plea ofrigb|t< toexpicM hia opinion about the unfairneag of a race, biit waa liable to make reparation to Mr. Prior for the same. So much for the grounds of the opinion which I had declared ; and so much for the merits of Mr. Edwin Courtenajr Crutten* den's declaration-<-lb«l in consequence of all this, he tcdd me to my beard I had related a/obeMld /; / Wbedttr Mr. Cmittenden hadreai)y been deputed by his principal !o con- vey such an wmUdem sort of message to me or not, it is hot for me to say, much less, to (pare. However, it would seem that Mr. C. in the genuine spirit of ancient chindry, did very soon recollect that he had omitted a most import- ant part of his duty as aftithful Hertdd, in not having proclaimed the defiance and the Ue togetb . r ; and so he retires to his peac^fvi chamber, and immedi- ately issues, for the gratification of his partft, this ultra-courageous bulletin of his exploits. Why these exploits were only performed on a sheet of foola- cap, Ithall leave to his own sensations to explain. Although this manifesto has eventually come to my view, I cannot think that it was ever written with an intention that 1 should see it. Three '.vceks had elapsed, before any of my immediate friends or myself, had the slightest knowledge of its existence ; which was discovered only by accident. However, only four hours had passed aller its production, when Mr. Cruttenden did take lis seat as Steward to judge, and as Secretary to take notes of'evidence, in a cause which he had thus sn violently prejudged; 4iMl forsooth, to s«e impartial justice done in an afiair, wherein he himself, acctMding to hit men account, had been so very active a performer. Hie re- puta^on, as well as that of his friend, both awaited the issue of Ats otcn deci- sion ; for on hie oum part he stood pledged for the truth of his accusation against me ; while, as related to Mr. Prior, it had been carefully ascertain- ed, that in his persQ|, the characters of " Gentleman" and " Jockey" stood '*;■, ''W^ - ■m: ...Mtu.-lt^'^A'im* II" m* u i^ "W*' finr Ifr. CiH»id|pj_.lWjfiMpcittNt Ibr ' tiMt tt if not ler tlMJ^iliiy jN4^^ l»v« tlni 1^ Jieii^£|liNil &A^ nMT^ M w. Hili pfW« o^dli . )Im li!«|b^ It tthiiii induced tbi^oi^ '*^" ■■■'iP 1r Tn mtnuMript of the above haa been in our hajide for publict^ (5r a whdAeibrtttight, and we have to apologue ibr the delay which bM* occur- red (hnNtgh the lieknew of JoGmeyroen. h ^ .. ^ llMBlOTOlMte. ■t^ w PJ: rnnMt ■ ■■ QMttwAm. iil, iMttiMDpanBd b«i^ coUd be ofiMi lo .• dosowMt, 'ftrp- It indncM tbiffbconi |«liiif totnurdi him. Btkn&p.-a lidfror. UeiMl mo iM dom- Mi IF «' >r pubUci^fbra which b^oceur- Hnam