IMAGE EVALUATION 
 TEST TARGET (MT-3) 
 
 ^^ 
 
 
 .■% --Kp Agar ^ 
 
 & 
 •% 
 
 ML/ 
 
 1.0 
 
 I.I 
 
 1.25 
 
 |50 ~^™ 
 
 1^ 
 
 22 
 2.0 
 
 11= 
 U III 1.6 
 
 V] 
 
 A- 
 
 
 fm 
 
 y 
 
 'A 
 
 ^ 
 
 /^ 
 
 Photographic 
 
 Sciences 
 Corporation 
 
 33 WEST MAIN STREET 
 
 WEBSTER, N.Y. 14580 
 
 (716) 872--.S03 
 
CIHM/ICMH 
 
 Microfiche 
 
 Series. 
 
 CIHIVI/ICMH 
 Collection de 
 microfiches. 
 
 Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions / Institut Canadian de microreproductions historiques 
 
Technical and Bibliographic Notes/Notes techniques et bibliographiques 
 
 The Institute has attempted to obtain the best 
 original copy available for filming. Features of this 
 copy which may be bibliographically unique, 
 which may alter any of the images in the 
 reproduction, or which may significantly change 
 the usual method of filming, are checked below. 
 
 L'Institut a microfilm^ le meilleur exemplaire 
 qu'il lui a 4t6 possible de se procurer. Les d6ta. "> 
 de cet exemplaire qui sont peut-dtre uniques du 
 point de vue bibliographique, qui peuvent modifier 
 u'AB image reproduite, ou qui peuvent exiger une 
 modification dans la mdthode normale de filmage 
 sont indiquds ci-dessous. 
 
 n 
 
 D 
 D 
 
 n 
 
 D 
 D 
 
 D 
 
 n 
 
 n 
 
 n 
 
 Coloured covers/ 
 Couverture de couleur 
 
 Covers damaged/ 
 Couverture endommagee 
 
 Covers restored and/or laminated/ 
 Couverture restaurde et/ou pellicul^e 
 
 Cover title missing/ 
 
 Le titre de couverture manque 
 
 Coloured maps/ 
 
 Cartes g^ographiques en couleur 
 
 Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ 
 Encre de couleur (i.e. autre que bleue ou noire) 
 
 Coloured plates and/or illustrations/ 
 Planches et/ou illustrations en couleur 
 
 Bound with other material/ 
 Reli6 avec d'autres documents 
 
 Tight binding may cause shadows or distortion 
 along interior margin/ 
 
 La reliure serree peut causer de I'ombre ou de la 
 distortion le long de la marge intdrieure 
 
 Blank leaves added during restoration may 
 appear within the text. Whenever possible, these 
 have been omitted from filming/ 
 II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajoutdes 
 lors d'une restauration apparaissent dans le texte, 
 mais, lorsque cela ^tait possible, ces pages n'ont 
 pas 6t6 filmdes. 
 
 Additional comments:/ 
 Commentaires suppl6mentaires; 
 
 □ Coloured pages/ 
 Pages de couleur 
 
 □ Pages damaged/ 
 Pages endommagdes 
 
 □ Pages restored and/or laminated/ 
 Pages restauries et/ou pelliculdes 
 
 I n Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ 
 
 D 
 D 
 D 
 
 Pages d^color^es, tachetdes ou piqu^es 
 
 Pages detached/ 
 Pages ddtachdes 
 
 Showthrough/ 
 Transparence 
 
 I I Pages detached/ 
 r~n Showthrough/ 
 
 I I Quality of print varies/ 
 
 Quality indgale de I'impression 
 
 Includes supplementary material/ 
 Comprend du materiel supplementaire 
 
 Only edition available/ 
 Seule Edition disponible 
 
 Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata 
 slips, tissues, etc., have been refilmed to 
 ensure the best possible image/ 
 Les pages totalement ou partiellement 
 obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata. une pelure. 
 etc., ont 6t6 filmies d nouveau de facon i 
 obtenir la meilleure image possible. 
 
 This item is filmed at the reduction ratio checked below/ 
 
 Ce document est film6 au tasix de reduction indiqu6 ci-dessous. 
 
 10X 
 
 
 
 
 14X 
 
 
 
 
 18X 
 
 
 
 
 22X 
 
 
 
 
 26X 
 
 
 
 
 30X 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 y 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 12X 
 
 16X 
 
 20X 
 
 24X 
 
 28X 
 
 32X 
 
The copy filmed here has been reproduced thanks 
 to the generosity of: 
 
 Library of the Public 
 Archives of Canada 
 
 The images appearing here are the best quality 
 possible considering the condition and legibility 
 of the original copy and in keeping with the 
 filming contract specifications. 
 
 Original copies in printed paper covers are filmed 
 beginning with the front cover and ending on 
 the last page with a printed or illustrated impres- 
 sion, or the back cover when appropriate. All 
 other original copies are filmed beginning on the 
 first page with a printed or illustrated impres- 
 sion, and ending on the last page with a printed 
 or illustrated impression. 
 
 The last recorded frame on each microfiche 
 shall contain the symbol ^^ (meaning "CON- 
 TIIMUED"), or the symbol V (meaning "END"), 
 whichever applies. 
 
 Maps, plates, charts, etc.. may be filmed at 
 different reduction ratios. Those too large to be 
 entirely included in one exposure are filmed 
 beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to 
 right and top to bottom, as many frames as 
 required. The following diagrams illustrate the 
 method: 
 
 L'exemplaire film6 fut reproduit grflce d la 
 ginirositA de: 
 
 La bibliothdque des Archives 
 publiques du Canada 
 
 Las images suivantes ont 6t6 reproduites avec le 
 plus grand soin, compte tenu de la condition et 
 de la nettet6 de l'exemplaire filmd, et en 
 conformity avec les conditions du contrat de 
 filmage. 
 
 Les exemplaires originaux dont la couverture en 
 papier est imprimis sont film6s en commen^ant 
 par le premier plat et en terminant soit par la 
 derniire page qui comporte une empreinte 
 d'impression ou d'illustration, soit par le second 
 plat, salon le cas. Tous les autres exemplaires 
 originaux sont film6s en commenpant par la 
 premiere page qui comporte une empreinte 
 d'impression ou d'illustration et en terminant par 
 la derniAre page qui comporte une telle 
 empreinte. 
 
 Un des symboles suivants apparaitra sur la 
 dernidre image de cheque microfiche, selon le 
 cas: le symbols — ► signifie "A SUIVRE ", le 
 symbols V signifie "FIN". 
 
 Les cartes, planches, tableaux, etc., peuvent dtre 
 film6s d des taux de reduction diffdrents. 
 Lorsque le document est trop grand pour dtre 
 reproduit en un seul cliche, il est filmi A partir 
 de Tangle supirieur gauche, de gauche d droite, 
 et de haut en bas, en prenant le nombre 
 d'images ndcessaire. Les diagrammes suivants 
 illustrent la mithode. 
 
 1 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 32X 
 
 1 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 4 
 
 5 
 
 6 
 
N 
 
FOR THE LEADER COMPAM, LIMITED. 
 
 ET AL 
 
 A SPEECH 
 
 BY 
 
 NiGiioidis Ficoojo r)a\"i5, \\.v.. 
 
 J)eliverecl in the Suprcinf (tonrt of the NorthWest IVnitorics. Hin Honour 
 Mr. Justice Richanlsou presidinf?, on the Tih .Tuly. \^\*\. 
 
 Thk Lkaukk Company (liiMnKD). I{k<;ina. 
 
 1 8 9 0. 
 
 :^' 
 
 A 
 
!•( 
 
 M 
 
 am J 
 uf tl 
 
 141 nil 
 
 Slijr 
 
 lint 
 clia 
 
 col: 
 
 (iiir 
 
 ,"\ . 
 
 f l 
 tint 
 thu 
 in ( 
 
 Tin 
 I'hi 
 
 ILII 
 
 of 
 fn. 
 'I'll 
 Li; 
 
 lil. 
 
 nil 
 
FOR I'lII-: Li.ADI'R Ci)MV.\X\ 
 
 A s 1 ' e: f: c h 
 
 \i\ 
 
 \ /a /()/,. IS I'l.oon D.w'i.w m.i 
 
 My Ldiil and ;^eiitloiiii'n of tho jury, I T 
 
 art KM t' (k-als 
 
 itli 
 
 Atkinson 
 
 am ^lail this caso lias CDnm licfoif a jury not as tlin publislu'r of a pajier, but aa 
 
 of tlitj Nmth-W I'st. I bclicvL' in trial liy prosidont of a Simday schonl. lUit I \\ill 
 
 jury. Yesterday morning' vvlicn you woro show you that tho position of a Sumhiy 
 
 i^oni.r iiiti. thi- box a fiioiul lianded nic a school toachor is a ])ul)lic one. Are we to 
 
 slip of paper intiuia;iM'.x that some of you be tuld,- and now especially would it, be 
 
 were lieforuieis and that one had a per- alisurd when the I'uble and reliL;ious 
 
 soii;ii preju<hce ai,'ainst me 
 
 i; 
 
 1 dill toachiii"' are beiu'' ilriven from "ur d; 
 
 0' 
 
 not ente? tani thcMiotidii fur a laonient of schotils— ar 
 
 (■ w. 
 
 to be toM tliat t 
 
 le eliai 
 
 elialleiii^inu any of ynu. i had perfect acter of the T*rcsideiit i f a Sunday school 
 eontidrnce tliat a juiy fairly clio.ien from is not a mMtf(>i' of pub'ic rMuci'in ' I will 
 
 ol 
 
 M- Noitli-West Settlers, 
 
 lit' ( ii'its (ir 
 
 lines, wi'ii 
 
 hcth 
 1.1 
 
 er couiitoH show 
 
 y..u 
 
 that 
 
 It 
 
 IS. 
 
 his 
 
 rue an hon- 
 
 'entliMiian is 
 
 still TresidcMit uf tl 
 
 e t \('rdiet. I am S'llislied there is ni>t the Su'idny .--ehonl, yet he eoines to ynu 
 
 one man a 
 
 monsist YOU who would all 
 
 ow aiut says 
 
 he! 
 
 las I'ceii so 
 
 damnilied that 
 
 the least personal foelini,' to iiitiuenee him wants slO,()0U. N"W in tiie tirsi place in 
 in deciilini; on the i.ssues you have lo try. reL''ud to that article we saj 
 
 U're ale three issues belnre yai. 
 
 The libellous. We sav it did not 
 
 If was not 
 touch him 
 
 riaintiir comes into Cnurt and Ijccan.-i 
 
 if in his means iif lis eliiioiiil. and this is 
 
 th 
 
 an ai 
 
 tide which appeared ill Tni: Li;.u>i:!; heart and core of a libel. \\ e s ly it wa' 
 
 of Au'.nist the (itli a.sks .-^KJ.UUO dam; 
 
 piivil 
 
 e''ed coMunei.t • n liim m i most im- 
 
 \V( 
 
 from Tni; l^KAUKii ( 'mnpany and Davin. portant public otiice, in rei:ai'd to which 
 
 Thesis last make a counter claim, Tin: his character is of vi!:il impiitan-^e 
 
 liKAhr.i; ('iim]iany ii^lO.OOO for libellinr^- it say a alandeier is imt tit f' 
 
 and Davin SiO,(J()0 for that the riaiiitill' tion. 
 
 such a piisi- 
 
 W 
 
 'y. y 
 
 libelle.l 
 |iul>lie 
 
 hini. 
 
 hold 
 mtempt 
 
 wvj 
 
 ami 
 
 iim 
 
 no to 
 
 HI saw him in that lio.\, 
 swears h" was leit .actuated by malice 
 
 h:it ?'e( 
 
 lb 
 
 ai,''iiost ine or auainsl I'lii' 
 
 ,i; villi: : but did 
 
yon not mark the scorn iind hato wliicli lu' 
 
 pourneil into the rc'iidinf4 of those articles f 
 
 Ami who b»)liaved most like a Chris- 
 
 lian— this h)ud professor x.r the man that 
 
 would not presume to make a profession ! 
 
 Libelled three years and a half, did we 
 
 once reply ! 
 
 'A IhouHHiul suns went i4own on I hut man's : 
 lie." 
 
 He called me a peiniy-a-liner and an 
 understrapper on eastern newspapers. 
 They tried to explain away penny-a-liner. 
 Hut I tell you, what you know, it is a term , 
 of contempt. But what does his own 
 counsel eay ? He tells you that 1 am the 
 first writer in Canada, or one of the tirst, 1 
 forget which. He says thi-ro was pro- 
 bably nut another man in the world 
 coul'' have written that article but 
 myself. Was it true then to say 1 
 was a penny-a-liner i His counsel tells 
 you I am an able speaker and a hard 
 hitter. What did his client, say of me ? 
 The ink is hardly dry yet on the paper, in 
 which he said 1 should be lost in the shadow 
 t>f a ministerial walking stick. Do you 
 think he believed that when he wrote it? 
 Well gentlemen I have known the mem- 
 bers of government under Grit and Tory 
 rule, and you know how goverrnnenta are 
 recruited, and do you think he believed 
 that >: Was it true ? I do not think you 
 will think it arrogant on my pait if I say 
 it would be a pretty big walking stick, 
 aye, and a pretty big minister too in 
 whose shadow I should bo lost. Was that 
 written believing it to be true or with the 
 malicious purpose of bringing me into 
 eontenipt ? What are ycju to think of 
 this man ? (ientlenien are we in Bedlam? 
 Is this a phantasmagoric dream ? Is the 
 whole a delusion ? 'I'he Judge sitting ' 
 there ; the Sheriff; the Clerk; the polica 
 Sergeant; you the jury; the two Q.C.'s, ; 
 with silk on their backs; Mr. Johnst<me 
 and myself Here is a man wIm has 
 
 hi' 1 libelling mo for three years and ft 
 half and there i.i one reply and ho rushes 
 into Court and says : "Please gentlemen 
 give me 810, (X)0:" (Laughtor.) Why, 
 it is a Hionstrons farce. If he can 
 claim 810.000 why should not I have 
 810, OCX). What about the paper. -Til K 
 Lkadkk which he calls a libellous sheet, a 
 paper in regard to which no instance can 
 be found where it did not stand up for the 
 interest of the North West > He says it 
 is a libellous sheet — is that true ? My 
 learned friend coi.gratulated the bar on 
 not d»>laying you. Certainly we have not 
 delayed you. But 1 must make this re- 
 mark in regard to them — you saw it your- 
 selves — they wished to close my mouth. 
 Were they afraid of the voice of a petty 
 creaturd who could be lost "in theshad:)W 
 of a ministerial walking stick?" Vou saw 
 how they tried to keep out 
 evidence. We had evidence bearing on 
 every point in the pleadings — and 
 why did we not produce it ''. Because 
 they did not daru to go into the inattera 
 contained in the pleadings. The fact is 
 this they found that their case had broken 
 down. You can fancy the conclave. The 
 two Q.C's with silk on their backs, — 
 Mr. Scott presumably one of the tirst 
 lawyers in the Territories, for he is the 
 government prosecutor, and his partner 
 newly Pledged, with his blushing honours 
 fresh upon him, (Laughter.) — and Mr. 
 Atkinson in tweed and they have discover- 
 ed they cannot win on the ni'^rits and one 
 or other says: "our only chance is to send 
 for Hagel." (Laughtei.) My learned friend 
 Mr. Scott is an able lawyer, but they 
 wanted a difierent man; they wanted a 
 man who could address a jury; and my 
 learned friend Mr. Hagel has the repu- 
 tation of being able to pull the wool over 
 the eyes of any jury in Canada. And 
 how does he do it '. Look at the actor he 
 is. Look how he read the article. Ytui 
 
5 
 
 yoara aiitl «■ 
 id lie rushes 
 kae f^untleinon 
 hter.) Why, 
 If he can 
 
 not I have 
 
 |)a|>er. -T)1K 
 lUous sheet, a 
 
 instance can 
 tnd up for the 
 He says it 
 true 'i My 
 th« bar <»n 
 y we have not 
 maiie this re- 
 >u saw it your- 
 le my mouth, 
 ice of a petty 
 "ill the shad )W 
 ckr You saw 
 keep out 
 oe bearinft on 
 plcadini;8— and 
 
 it ? Because 
 
 to the matters 
 
 The fact is 
 
 case hadl)n)ken 
 
 conclave. The 
 
 their backs, — 
 ne of tlie first 
 
 for he is the 
 ,iid his partner 
 tushin<4 ln)nours 
 .ter.)--and Mr. 
 :y have discover- 
 ! ni'^rits and one 
 lance is to send 
 ly learned friend 
 wyer, but they 
 
 they wanted a 
 jury; and my 
 )1 has the repu- 
 ill the wool over 
 I Canada, And 
 k at the actor he 
 the article. You 
 
 
 h;hv the way lie j)ictur('d .sniiio iiiiai{iiiary 
 creature under the frot or knoi' of iitjotliyr, 
 and how he piodded away a.s thouL;ii the 
 weapon was in hia hand. The f.ict is, lj» 
 would have made a irreit reputation on 
 the 8tai»o ; l»ut it waa mere act iuLj. You 
 marked tin- way he oniphasized that article 
 anil bronuht out uifauuii,'a neither you nor 
 any ordinary reader would ever have .seen 
 .\ ;»reat deal depends on how you road 
 anything. You renieuilier how our Lord 
 fed thouaaud.s with live barley loaves and 
 a few tiihes The sacred writer tells us 
 how they all sat dowti and they did eat 
 iiud were filled. Head that as an ordinary 
 man would reul U and you <,'et the idea 
 that- they had a yood meal. Now let me 
 emi>h.i.si/,e one word after tlie manutM' of 
 my friend Mr. llayel — "and they all sat 
 d:wii and they ilid eat,'' and you liave 
 thousands of yluttnns at once. (Lauj^hter.) 
 1 am very i;lad that my learned friend 
 (Mr. llai^el) quoted al such length from 
 t»ilL,'er in tlie scoii^- and bounds <if criti- 
 L'isiii, fo, it saves me the trouble of doiiis^ 
 iliis, and all he (|Uoted to you makes as 
 mucli for us as for the plaintilV. That 
 i.'reat authority says a newspaper has a 
 rijiht to comment sharply and fearlessly 
 oil matters of public interest --but he must 
 not e.xoeed. Did the plaintilf exceed when 
 lie discusaed me as a barrister, when he 
 called me a penny a-liner, and a bald 
 headed eagle f " True criticism," quoted 
 my learned friend, "deals only with audi 
 things as invite public attetition ; call for 
 public comment ; it does not follow a uiftn 
 into his private life or pry into his domes- 
 tic concerns." la the open and public de 
 meanour of a Sunday achool teacher ii 
 l)rivate or domeatio concern f But, ijentle- 
 men, do you remember what he aaid in an 
 article read in that box about aome sup- 
 jused couvensation of mine at a breakfast 
 table — when he attributed to me a re- 
 mark I never made in oider t* bring mo 
 
 into public odium '. The very lirst ami 
 worst article written ahout me was written 
 hefore I wia a candidate for jiarliament. 
 "Criticism, " says Odger. as ((uoted by my 
 learned friend, " never attacks the indi- 
 vidual but only the work ; in every case 
 the attack is on the man's act and not u|)on 
 the man himself." Was it my work he 
 attacked when he called me a cowardly 
 back-8tabbor, a libeller, the evil genius of 
 the North- West ( Evil genius of the 
 North-West 1 (Jentlemen, you all kiiosv 
 me for the last eight years. During that 
 time have 1 ever, before and since I have 
 been in jiarliament, have 1 ever i.eglected 
 to attend toanynian's private atl'aira, what- 
 ever his piditics '. You know that I have 
 done the business of you all at the land 
 otlice and in the Departments. I have 
 spent and been spent in your service— in 
 the service of the North-Weat. He says 
 1 made an unfjualitied pledge on disallow- 
 ance and after it was pointed out to him 
 i that 1 said in my address " With Sir John 
 Macdonald im any vote challengiiik; the 
 confidence of the country 1 will stand or 
 fall," he awore — this intelligent and cons- 
 cientious saint — ihat my voluntary [dedye 
 i was yet unt|ualitied. You saw the scorn 
 he threw into hia voice in reading that 
 address -because 1 held up a high jjoliticul 
 ideal before the North-West and he 
 continued until his counsel who saw it 
 was injuring him told him not 
 to inflect his voice. What has 
 TiiK Leaueu done '. Has it not been 
 forward to make suggestions for the wel- 
 fare and tight the battles of the Nort'i- 
 Weat' Yet this man who comes here and 
 befon* he knows anything about me libels 
 me, who has nc "er done anything for the 
 country, who devoted all his columns and 
 all hia energy to denouncim; Davin, and 
 who for the last four yi ars followed me 
 like a sleuth hound, he declares 1 am the 
 ' evil genius of the North We.st! I'lit if the 
 
ii 
 
 ulii|) i.H iiU'Vcl gently (ivcr liis ImcW In- 
 (imwIh iiii'l whiiii'rt iii.d siys "(u'litli- 
 iiu'ii, I .'iiii iiii iiijiiri''l iiiiiii, |iIiM.ir iiivi' iiic 
 Sin. 000." (LiiiiLfhkM'V (ii'iitlt'Mi. II, ! 
 iii;iy li.ivc tn put uii iiiy ^mvn -LMiii t'ic;irii 
 my liri'uil. I stinlii'il l,i\v in tin' licsr '^i-lm ,1 
 ill the wi. till tliut of tlic Mid.lU' 'I'-Mpl.- 
 Mtid Wl'HtlllillHl'r II ill. 1 ^^.l^^:lt ii;i''i;ii| 
 iiiitli'.i at ( >.s'.^i)(i(U' liiUl ; I am Mil aii\ iitM'c 
 
 nf t lie Tl'lTltiil ii'.s. N'nW Wi.sil IIIV Wnlks 
 
 as a [luljlic iiiaii lie oriticizcil wlifn In- said 
 i \»as II I'ailiiii! as a lauvff ^ TIk' vciy 
 <ih\ '>f a lilicl is til. it it slu'iiM ImiuIi ,i 
 mans liii.siiu'.s!-. Now «iiaf ilnl I il" ulnn 
 I caiiit." Iiack In I't^Liiiia and luiiiid tli ii tlic 
 Ivlitor (pf tlm IjC'.HKH ll.ld LiMiiinclltid IIII 
 till' printing' I'y t]\\H man nf cuds {<iv 
 iat\'S, ai^aiii.st wliicli imci'.-' he liad uaimd 
 Itny.s il, tilt' Sunday sclinul!' I apil 'l;!:'. d 
 Tliat ii'lati'd t.) lii.s lursincss ; it '.vas 
 ill im Hi.'iisi; a puldif mait.tr. Il')\v 
 did he tvcoivL' my apnl'^'y, ilu-; 
 saintly man '. .Vs a Cliiistiaii! N" : .\s 
 :i j^ontlt.'iiion '. Nn ; In- !■ 'iild 
 
 iKit it'ccivf it t,M!ifiiin.ilv. Hi- 
 
 DiiiimMitod nil it in a vai.i l;1 irimis, \\n\i almnt tlial iiiliK- C'liiritcnaiiei 
 
 iiiu' lit till' L' real est iiii'ii nf tin- ci^Iitci'iilli 
 loiitiiry, w(i>< ludd ; \)r. .InlinHnii wan liald; 
 Mr. ('amiiii.,' that j^rcut Ht.'ittuman, wa.i 
 litl I, and till' lixt Ih iii«lt'tinit(>. Tliisman, 
 the |ilaiiitill, (.''>iii|il,4ins that we call liiiii a 
 «<df. r>iit \vi' did. n t iIm ' iia'. T-nt 
 >ii|)j» i.s" V.I' dill. W'liiit is a liald lira ii'<l 
 y:f^\-'. A iiinl i>( pity, w ln.di kiils aii'i 
 
 Hnimt illll'.S .S;n ipS ni i ca I'l in| i . What Is I 
 
 Will: .' .\ lit', 1st i.f |iii'y nil fniir K u;s wliii-li 
 sniiMtiiiK'.s c its I'ati inn tnn .\iid yt't tld.s 
 man whn.sc aniinii.s a'.^ain.st im; vvas.>iu'ii that 
 liciMuld imt .sraii' .sp.ir" in hi.A 
 !• •Itl'iins tn di-i II i- N'nith \N'c.»! 
 
 maiti'is, .sn lull wa.-< his In.iin • f 
 ■' It.isiii ' '• I)a\in " " l),i\iii," c"ni.-.% 
 hi If l'(('aii.si' wnlf il l>rniit;ht III as an il- 
 Iilsliaiinii and Wiinls tt n thnn.s.uiil liddN'- 
 stitk^! ( 1/ iii'.^Iit(.r. ) Shnnid I imt he 
 ju.siilicil III oallin^'a mai , \\\n> cdltd m • 
 a liald hfaiKd vaLilf, an eh phiiii m ,i 
 hipp 'pntamus '. It' a man is callod wnji 
 and is iini likr mu, tlm lan:4nam( .^tiikc.-i 
 i) ick nil him wliii ii^-s n And wlm 
 
 wniild tiiink llu'i'i' «as anything nf tiu' 
 
 boastful way. and it was niit nf that 
 
 nil ( Ii UlLclitoi 
 
 ) T 
 
 W ICO 
 
 aciiist it 
 
 incnt that tliis mm iclc en iipl.diu' 1 nf arns '. 'in' nf liciiii; a h) pnci ilc ami ;icn.\aidly 
 ."My frieuil (jimtt'd < »d:{ci',s that " a rr 
 
 111' li'u^kstaliln 
 
 Will 
 
 111 I'liicn 
 
 Clitic never mdiilues in persnualiticH.'' pi'i-lty well-kiinwii in the Nnith W\ .si 
 
 Ls il a jiuisniiality tn call ii 
 (1 
 
 a liald- MnM nf ynii kimn- me, ami I dnn't thi 
 
 ])oariiiice 
 
 llaldnerts is a di'fect fmm the lijlit a man I li'jlr him tn Ids f, 
 
 And 
 
 ]ii>iiit (if view nf piisniial lieauty and .is fur cnwardici^ 1 am pretty wi II kmnvii 
 
 tlieie are imii v. Im.se feel 
 
 lIl'JS WdU 
 
 Id Iv thiMii;,dinnf ( '.ui.ad I and im man w Im i'\er 
 
 le man is 
 
 judges will! over sat mi tlie heiicli in Vaij.- attacked. This man ;iii|i','ar.s hefnre ymi 
 land, whom my friend li.a.s i|mited, vvas as .is a reiiL^inii.s teacher. I in.ike im prnfes 
 
 liald as a l.idiaid T.nll ; Alexander I 
 
 lieadi'deaLiie '.' (litiit^hter. ) Smiif n.en ue .iiy Imdy wnuld l>elieve 1 w luld dn ,tii\ - 
 veryaeiisitive nil the snliji'ci nf pcrs'iiial iji iliin,' h ■hind a man';! back. I think if 1 'i 
 
 w'nundt'd liy a refi'ionce tn their uiithatcli- knew me wmild iielieve thai tjiiiit tn he ' 
 
 i^d rnof, tli'i' Some of the ni.'i who have in me. .\rc not these words rellectinn.s I 
 
 done most for the world- the L;teat ones ou moral ch.aractt'r ^ ^'et what diil the 
 
 of the woild — have lieen hald: llismarck learned counsel icad^to ynu tiom Od'.'eis ' 
 
 ii.is hoen hald for mm e than half a en- That il is ii it liiiellou.-) tn attack or i i'licu'.e 
 
 tury ; C.isar was liald ; tiie late Chief a ii'.an's works, Imr it is a dilferent ihiiiL^ 
 
 • lilstice Cnckhiiiii, nne nf the irrnatcst wlicn the mnr.il cli,ir;'.cier of t 
 
 i\ 
 
 nl:e, Sinn. 
 
 uch. I 
 
 am Init a 
 
 f 
 
tin' fiulili'i'litll 
 mHuii vviiH liiiM; 
 rttiitc.Hiimii, «•>••< 
 ill". Tliis iiiiiii, 
 
 (li. •liii'. I -lit 
 rt ,1 li;il(l liiM 1<'"I 
 
 wlii.:li kills .iii'l 
 i.,li. \\ li:it i-^ >■ 
 
 f. iiir li 'J.> wliU'li 
 
 And yt't tliis 
 
 iiii! v\a-*.-iuii tli^>t 
 
 s|ii(" in liii 
 
 N.iitli \\>-i 
 
 liis lii;iin ' t' 
 
 l),i\iii," fniiii-s 
 iilit III as all il- 
 linlis.unl liiMli'- 
 linlllil I II"' '"• 
 
 vvliu CllUil III." 
 
 I f|. ji'i lilt "I' a 
 
 Kill IS Cillloil Woll 
 
 laii;;ii.i;^i' .>lrikivi 
 
 ji Ami wli" 
 
 iiiytliiii'j; "f tin' 
 
 le c.iii:iti'iiaiKM'{ 
 
 111! acriisiil 
 
 • ami ii (■H.vartUy 
 iil'i'iiiun, I ill!: 
 
 tin' '.^iiitll N\ I si. 
 iiul 1 (Im't tliihk 
 
 • 1 W'liiKl (In ,uiy- 
 lafk. I ihiiik if 1 
 (I l.i.s t'aci.'. Ami 
 iift'j Will k'Kiwii 
 nil man win) oviT 
 V thai taint to \'v 
 
 Wiil'ds M'lll'L'tinlls 
 
 Wit wiiiit 'iiil the 
 yiill tlDlii ( lil'.'t'is ' 
 
 II attack nr liJu'Lile 
 s a dillori-'iit tiling 
 :\c1cv iif tiie mall is 
 |i|r.'ara In.'i'nri' ymi 
 
 1 iiiaki' im |iriiti!s 
 eh. 1 mil l)Ut a 
 
 wiiiKir. Dill ymi lirai Imw lie swnrc in 
 I'lat Ifi.x I liat liu ciiulil imt ^ivi- an nn 
 i|iiaiit;i!il ' iKt ' iVH tu Hiietliiir aufiitititj 
 wrilttMi liy him was iiitomU-d i<v n"t to 
 liiiiin iiH' iiil'i itul)lic ciinti.!in|il ! W liat 
 i:< an iim|iialilii'd an '. Hid y<Mi nut lirir 
 liim aiiswrr ulii-n af-kcd wJii'tlu'i' iIhtc 
 wart ill-fiiiiliii!,' ill a uivon lutitio. *' ' Nit 
 ill fi!rliii'4 as I ntidcrstaiid it."'--NM' ill 
 I'oi'liii:,' an lit) iimU'istamls ill fi'idiiiL' ! Ilr 
 (.'ihiiMt '^'ivi' an iiiii|ualiticd 'no' : 1 1 ■ i * ji 
 I'l't'sbyteri in, Imt tlu-HO aiiswiTs winild 
 siU'U'i'st till" vvnrst fcatnrrs cvciy attrilmtcd 
 ti .li'.->niliHiii. My luariu'd fiiond tuld ymi 
 lli.'t wi! ODidd not sjiy : " Voij lilx'lli'd iis; 
 \vi' pan liln'l you." I'li' tlun'o is siicli i 
 thiii'i a.-t pr iMiL-il i'l'i. Now, '^I'liilonit'ii, 
 \\ii iMloi's ( >dL;iMs s ly ; (>ii pi'^i' 17"' lit' 
 l.iy.s it dow 11 ; 
 
 " KviTV man has i riidit to di'fi'iid I'i-t 
 " (il 11 acti'i' a.' liiist falso aH|i('iHiou. It I 
 " am a'tackrd in a nmvspipi'f I may wiiti' 
 ■ to that papor to roUiit tin; (iiai';,'t's and 
 '■ I may at tlio f<aim) timo rutort upon my 
 •• aHsail.ani wlu'ii such a rriort is a ni'ci's- 
 " sary part of my diii'ticr or fairly arisi's 
 '• oiii of till.' Liiai'Ltt's ho .ia.s made a'_;aiMst 
 '• nil". \ man who liimsiif i-oiiiiiicnci'd a 
 " a m \v.spa|ii'r war naiinot snh^oipitMitly 
 " conm to till' (.' nut as plaintitl', to fom- 
 " |i!ain thai he lias had tin- wor.st of tlu' 
 •• fray.- 
 
 \'_':iin on pau't' ~'-'>>^ ( )dL;>'r says : 
 " The pri'vi' Ills libels and slanders may 
 111- 111 ide tlie iiiattt r of a I'lanitir tiaiiii 
 even tlioiiLii not immediately connoe'ted 
 with the words on wliijh the plaintill' is 
 suiiiL?. 
 
 That retort in Tin: Lkvih:!; aiose 
 fairly out of t.lie way the plaintitl' received 
 11. ii' 111 inly apolo<j:y. Was it true what lie 
 St ited that wi' had accejited his oorreetionf 
 It WIS not. lie put ill the wi'iil " e.vist 
 t'd"- no t,'riinnd exi.sted for s.'vyin;,' he 
 he was a hypocrite. This woiild bo a 
 wholesale starement— a ;4i'iieral oertiticato 
 
 of liiaracter. We utterly refused to put 
 ill the word. Were liny true the stilto- 
 tiionts he made in e'.mmentini,' on oiir 
 a|iolii.iy ' Nm, gentlemen ymi will hase 
 seen that the plaintilt's couiisi 1 ha.i* he 
 liaveil as if they were cariyint; ii heavy 
 hat! a load ton hea\ v. They for_;iit yes- 
 teid.iy to prove puhlioation and it wa.s 
 only after sleepim^ over il last ni.;ht that 
 tiiey discover', tl their case was ilu•lllllp^'te, 
 ami they luive iiovi-r justilied imw ami 
 their case i.i iiicoinpleto still. Mr. 
 Se )tt is an experienced lawyer :- how 
 eime he to .s<i act ' The fact is as I .^uid 
 liefore they fof.ml there was no easo ; no 
 eh nice ; no hope hut tn sseiid 
 fill Ilau'ii : Whit is ilii^'ol ' A -^rual 
 actor A liii'ed adsi-eate. .Vnd, 
 
 ^eiitlomeii. if Mr. .lolinstone 
 
 anil myself hid tlioiiuh' "ur ease w.a.s 
 weak and feared— we aie only stull ;,'ii\viia 
 you know —the two i). t'.'.s with tiiiir 
 silk — uiy loarnod friend, Mr. Seoti an t 
 his pirinor, (Liiii^'hrer, ) well if ii\e 
 miinites iieiore tlii'y did it, \se hail si'iil 
 tor .Mr. Iliiu'ti, y' II \wiuld have 
 seen liiiii Ket into a ii.i.-i-ion in my regard: 
 he would h.ivi! read the lilniloiis articiv's 
 writ' n ;v.^ai;i.st mi' uir.i iiidi'^iiition and 
 fecliii^ ; he Would h;ive Jilaeed uu' on tho 
 i^rmnii and ih scrih.-d .some ima:;iiiary in- 
 dividual driving his speir l)eliw my iil.,< 
 i;itii my \itiU, and wmild hue 
 h-jil me up witli ^real pathos 
 ,is an olijecl for your commiser- 
 ation. (Laughter) lie would liavo des- 
 eriliel .Vtkinsoii piimiuelliiu; lau for fniir 
 years and lit! wouM have aski'd ynii uliicli 
 iif till! two showed the more ( hiistiaii 
 spirit ' (ientleiiien, I make im [n'ofession. 
 I am hut a siiiiiec. I am like the puldi- 
 can in the t. iiijile who stood afar oil' ami 
 dared not to liii. up so iiiuiii as his eyes 
 to heaven. This man like 'lie I'harisee 
 wrajis his 'garments tif Imliness ami sjiirit- 
 iial pride aroini'l him umI thanks 'loij he 
 
H 
 
 iiiint. UH iii!n r iiii'ii Mr i'\ I'll us ihiH |MH.r 
 HiiiiuM'. lint whiit iluuH I'll!' I< >nl Miiy ' 
 "I rtiy iiiit't V'Mi tim* tin- |iii'»Ikmii wi-af 
 Hwuy jiMtitiiiil Mit'.m' tli;iii tlio otinT ' 
 TliiH iimii in u roli)^Mi)U8 tiMKilior Is it n<-\ 
 a iihittDf fnr piililit u iititiitilit wliotluT he 
 is a hIiiii(1<ti'I' amt .i liliillt.-r <>v iiui ! S >\\ 
 my loariifil fiimiil tlinw liis vuir • vciy 
 1)^ iiiid tiicl t" iiiiiir»'.~>H yciii with tli* 
 \ iuw ill. it it WiiH a tet'iildi! tliiiiu tu CDiif 
 inunt nil tiiia inan'ri n-liui >ii8 clia'acfur, 
 >vliic!i lit! Hiiiil ill tills LMHo was a iii;itti>r 
 '" liiitwi'iMi liim iiikI ;iu! cliil'ln'ii. ' W Imt 
 alidUt till' paroiitH <'f tin; cliililifii ' What 
 aboiil the |iiil.ilif ^ What alfiil •■'ixl; 
 I Mill sliuw yoii accoi'iliiii^ to IiIh own 
 '.iiitlinriiy, ()(lj,'fr8, that Atlviii.stui ii a hi 
 niiIiJim;! (if t'liiiiiiicit. nil jiiiL;i' '>U'> wv 
 itiul : 
 
 '* I'Ih' vviiikiiij^ uf all piiKIlc liistif iti.m^*, 
 fiiicli as c'llIfiii'H, hn>|iitaU, as^iuiiis 
 lioiiitH, IS a uiatler nt |Mihlic iiiri'it-yt, ca- 
 Itcrially wlicr',' such iiistitutitms a|i|ii-al t<> 
 lilt) [Mililio f>ir .suiisori|>ii"iis." 
 
 1 think, it I iiMurml<t r ii^'hily 1 have 
 HulisiM'ilii'il siiiiiithiML' f'T that Smul.iy 
 siihonl I cfrtaiiiiy have fir tin- I'hiiich 
 and if I have iiui fur tlh> sulionl nthora 
 have. 
 
 A^aiii : " A liishop's unvoiiiincnt nf 
 his tlinci'so, a ruL-tui's iiiaiiat,'<'iiit'iit cif |ii.> 
 parish (ir of tlio iiainchial sflni.il aiv iiiat- 
 tiirs (if |iiil>lic iutorosl.' 
 
 la tiot tlio imuri^i"' aiul inaiiav'i'iiu'iit i>( 
 
 a Sunday schmil then (i|»i<n t'l |iiil>lii; 
 
 cnticisui '. Why we do not want auth(jr 
 
 itius — the thiiii,' is cuiiiiiKin hl'usi'. And 
 
 have we nil c.fiiid,' niistandiid ' What 
 
 does this honk siy? -" I5y their fruits ye 
 
 shall know them. " This luominent leli- 
 
 liidiis teacher ';eaciK's the lo chapter of 1st 
 
 l'(iriutiiiaii3 in which we are told that love 
 is above all thin<_'s. 
 
 " Tliouij;!! 1 speak with the touijues of 
 
 men and angels and hive not lovt; I am 
 
 bocfime as sounding hrass or a tinkliii" 
 
 eymltal. And thoULth I have llie ;.Mft of 
 ppphecy hikI undeistaiid all iiiysterit^H, 
 and idl kiiowlttd^'e, and tlioui^'li I have all 
 faith HO that I eoijlil n-inove moiintaiiiii 
 and havo not love, 1 am iiotliin>^'. And, 
 tlnHJuh I l»t«Htow' all my s^oodfl I i foed the 
 poor, and thoii<.^h 1 '^ivn my liody to he 
 hiiriH'd and have not love, it pidtiteth me 
 iiothim,' 
 
 And what does our Lord «aj ' I, ivoyour 
 Meii,dil)ours / Ves. And your friends' 
 Yes. Nay. more emphatically, l"ve your 
 etiemieH This man sa> in the same church 
 with me a few Sundays a<,'o, when the 
 llcv. Mr. ''armichaol prenehe;! on this 
 suhjeet ; alno when he ireiclied oil the 
 »Hth cha|.ter of iHaiah. VNhat did Mr. I'ar- 
 micliael i*ay '. That tin- .Ii'wish I'hurch. 
 in Isaiali's time, with itc priests and livilc", 
 its doctors and Sunday Synii<^ot,Mie teachers 
 was a " ma:,'iiihcent hyp «cii-ty, a sjilendid 
 insincerity;" and he .said the Cliiistiaii 
 church to-ilay was in diii^rr of lieiiu,' a 
 " mauniliceiit hypocrisy, a splemlid insin- 
 cerity. ' With t)i(! r.ilile sjieakinj,' thus, 
 and a Ministi'r of the fiosjiel speakiiii; 
 thus, aro we to take for Lirantt'd the 
 Christianity of every man who professes 
 himself a christian ^ How did this man 
 display love-the love of Christ ' What 
 example did he .set the children of that 
 school and this community '. How did he 
 minif(;st his Christian love to the poor 
 sinner who address's you ' How did lit* 
 try to lead iiu' from the heniiihted con- 
 dition in wliich he thinks 1 am '. He has 
 toldymifrom that box — liy determiiiin^'to 
 drive me from my .seat ; liy aimin'_r at my 
 life as a public man ; by pursuiiit,' me like 
 a sleuth hound for three years and ti half ; 
 Viy seekiiii,' to destroy me ; with what 
 weapons ? The w'.ipons of slander, of 
 caluny, of mlies. And if he thus fought, 
 li his character such as should beloiii.' to a 
 prominent ndi^'ious teacher ' Our Lord 
 !ias said it is impossible but 
 
 a || 
 
 tht 
 and 
 
 • pJ 
 fatf 
 asll 
 ] 
 
 HUl 
 
 kil 
 
 
f» 
 
 ;i\r tin- l^if' "f 
 
 nil myrttiTi*'"' 
 
 AC tiii'ii'itiiin" 
 tiling. Aiul, 
 
 ,n.lH I . tVo«l till! 
 „iy ImmIv t'» l'«' 
 it proliti'tli iin* 
 
 »;i} ' l/>voy<>iir 
 y,i\ir fiit'ii'lH ' 
 
 .•iiliy. l"vi" yniir 
 hcHimii'cJi'ir'li 
 
 .,.f(. wlll'll tll<! 
 
 rciii'lii"'. "U tlii'* 
 
 I m'k-Ih'iI "II tlio 
 
 ^l.i.t ilia Mr. I'nr- 
 
 .IcwihIi ilunvli. 
 
 ,IlCSt:^lllitl I'-vii"-', 
 
 ,i)iii,'"Uiif toaduTK 
 
 .misy. !i Hpli'iuU.l 
 
 ciid tlui Cliiirtti'in 
 
 ■, !i HpU'iuliil insiii- 
 .U> MpiMikiiii.' tlii\^-, 
 • ( i'.HiK'l spi-iikinn 
 
 for uriintotl thf 
 iiiii who ]trofi'Hsi>H 
 IdW (litl tliis niiui 
 
 ,,f Christ ' NVliiit 
 i' cliil'livn "f thiif 
 iiity '. II<|«' aid 111' 
 
 \n\V til tlU' pour 
 
 y.)U '' Hiiw (lidlu* 
 h« liiMii^zlUtMl coll 
 ,ka 1 iun ^ He lins 
 — By (ItUernimin^t'. 
 : by iiiiiiiiiir at my 
 by pursuiui; me lik«^ 
 ee si'.xTh and a half ; 
 oy nie ; witli what 
 inns of slander, of 
 ikI if iio thus fonf-'ht, 
 IS sill mid boh •lit' t<> a 
 teaiiluT ' Our Lord 
 impossible but 
 
 that aoiindalH shouUl ar 
 
 IHU 
 
 that by a fow lioiirn work a day 1 habitually 
 
 ia misconduct on tho part of Cliriut- I oarn«d uioro than tli 
 
 ians; but woo to that man by wlioni 
 th« oti'onio comes. And yet with that 
 Mible-that standard in our hands- 
 there ia to be no criticism ' My learned 
 friend told you I wrote that article in 
 II passion ; but if 90 it must have been an 
 tuipulsive act. There Cduld be no malice 
 if it was the fruit of passion. And was 
 there malice ? You know what malice is ; 
 it is a pansion that abides ; it controls a 
 man ; it overturns his judi<mont ; it rides 
 the will. I controlled the columns of the 
 most powerful paper in th« Territories. 
 Did I feel malice towards that man— do 
 you suppose if 1 did that 
 with the continual dropping 
 
 of his ((all of bitterness from week to week 
 — that I could hava kept my hands off 
 him ? No : I had no malice. But where 
 was tho evidence of malice ? In his paper, 
 where tliere was the weekly dropping of 
 six or seven articles — ther^ was the malice. 
 This man falsely said I had been a |ienny- 
 a-liner. Did Thk Lkahkr ever refer to 
 what he had been ? What matter what a 
 man's beginnini;s ? We must take him as 
 he is. He commenced life as a j)rinter's 
 devil -as a devil — and in the process of 
 Darwinian evolution he has evolved into 
 a printer, and tho evolution is goin^ on 
 through a Sunday school Superintendent, 
 and at some very far off day ho will doubt- 
 less e.nerge as a seraph. (Laughter). But 
 before that f.ngelic and super-essential 
 time comes he "will have to change very 
 much. (Lauifhter.) The learned counsel 
 referred ttt the Chinese Commission, and 
 (|Wotiiig his client, who mis-stating the 
 facts, said I got ^13i a day. I never 
 asked to be placed on that Crmimission. 
 1 was appointed without being con- 
 sul tod and tho salary was ^5 a day and 
 S.'i.oO as expenses. My friend Mr. Hagol 
 knew me in Toronto and when in Toronto 
 
 IIS, and a commission 
 takes up a man's whole time, the bulk of 
 the work falliiii< on tho Socretary. They 
 plead that I am a public man ' Hax a 
 public man no protection < lias he no 
 right, before the courts of his country '. 
 Is he like a wild bimst to whom no law is 
 to he given and who may l>u nhot at with 
 any iiUHsilos from behind a bush or clump { 
 Suppose .--• < of you were to duturmine to 
 run for the North-West Assemlily or for 
 tho Doininion Parliament, what justi- 
 tication would there bo for men iiieml- 
 aciously accusing you of faults you never 
 had and crimes you never committed ^ 
 And is ho not in a public position '. Am 
 I to be pursued for tiiree and u half years 
 and never reply '. Is the worm never to 
 turn >. Why did I not reply to him '. lie 
 was attacking mo with congenital ferocity. 
 My learned friend, his counsel, tells you 
 I am the Hrst writer in Canada. Well I 
 cannot say that his client is the Krst or 
 second or third or (ifth or tifteenth writer 
 in Canada, But any man who can hold a 
 pen can write mendacity and abuse. W liy 
 did I n(.>t reply to him '. Becaudo I held 
 him at naught. I cared not for him. He 
 could not excite anger, still Iosh inspire 
 malice. I will tell you a little story. 
 There was in my boyhood a groat large 
 St. Bernard dog in Cork and a litcle half- 
 bred terrier used to bark after him. Vuv 
 some threo years ho barked after him and 
 was never noticed. One day crossing St. 
 Patrick's bridge, which spans the Lee, the 
 St. Bernard thought the time of the petty 
 barker had come, and turning struck the 
 cur with his paw; kept liim there while he 
 lifted his hind leg over him; then taking 
 him by the skin of tho neck ho droppeil 
 him into the river. (Laughter) My 
 learned friend spoke very strongly on tho 
 sentence that but for the restraining in- 
 fluence of Christianity this man might 
 
\l) 
 
 li;i VI' It 111 III 
 
 III .1 I M iiiih.il i|< HI, .iii'i III' ,11 ^ 
 
 i| liiii |)M-,ii|.,ii 1 li,i;i |,i 1 1 
 
 III;; ;i 1 1, Mil III .^'tiihy 
 
 M 
 
 'lUlil ,UII, 
 
 \M,;it i. Ii.'.t 
 
 my |i'iiii .iiiility i|i:ii;li!ir!.',iii 
 
 lliiif ii, lliiit ' lit !•, :i I'l I ;iliyliM i.in. Iji W Ik'Ii I |i lllf :,ii|ni' i.iii- <Ihi- ciili C'.iiM! 
 
 l<-iu:lii t III" li'iK-t ) III rri-,.l<\ tiri;ii;i ,111 ;iii,l i'lcwai'l, ;iyi-, il .ynu '■■m ',"•* ii III. iirm |ii-i' 
 
 |iii'.",uiiialily I !ii', rinrtiiiH ", i ( 1 In- r. 1 1 ill',, I III I li.ip.M I ill' ill III III- v,-i!liii;.; I'l ri-.!iri:. Tn 'I'li Im 
 
 \ liat ;iii; I lii'd- ' 'I'liiil lli<; IhmM, ''I liiali v.'nU vv'l \^ n l.iln ill' iu;i llilli'; iilnl 
 
 I 1 lull 'i! adiiili'l li'i',, iiiiiiilii , lyiti"^ iiipl |ii|iiiiiH ,.|'i i|:il t.il.iiit'. iUO fi 
 
 :i II III I '1 1. 1-1 I'i \\ , ' I'l !i 1 , 1 1 1, 1 1 I 111- I III-.' ;i ■, I li.iA 1- I III- I 'iiiIhIi'Ii''' III III}' f'lli iw 
 
 ili-|ii|iiii It ', '.\ irLr'lii.-.-':-i ii'i iii.iii cm I, ii'ivs' i;"i/iii'i I In iiii-'Ip hiI liiiii r iii ,1 it ii;iiii'y I 
 
 Vnll !i;i\ I- ;ilMii-.il I i.i l!l'li.i|i| l;,i.'.'i'l :i \', 1 11 I -'l il i':',i ii I iIh'Ih null! :i',|iii: in.'i li w l|i i 
 
 j.'ii'.il ;iiiil hi/ly il I villi- I Im' ,'i.iii li'ii III ''I'll- i;\u M'.iliy l;il.i; r;iii- nt lliiii iiil ii . nl ; i:; 
 
 S,iilil:i l'i\ CI l;i.",l lir' l.'i -1. W'h.'il liid |,i hil'l li' ' ilnili'.', ;iiii| lln-ii jii-i l,;i|i.- ^l-i'lly 
 
 i.;iy nil hi i-ii,'.' ;i ri iiMiii,il 111 i.i;:ii-iiil !' i| iii i ii'iiljli 'vViiiiM I l.iy '''<••', i: llic |i i-liiiii",! 
 
 t li" |)i l-,iiii '■;ill t'.lln' ;.',illirvV :-; ' ''i'lii-M' i'lli'.V- 'r,iKi 'I'lli. l,i,',|iM: In'il-. ;it |l:i 
 
 l)i|l I'll' till- 'Ma':!! Ill 'i'lli '.'■,•. 1 Iv'ii-lriMl , m ,l i l' .ii . |l i,a, li':i-ii cilliil ;i llln-lliiii. 
 
 |',,i -;ti'.-. W li,il ill'l 'I II I. 1,1. \ iil.l: ;i,iy t ii,i.l . :.i-i-l ali<l ,111 lir.i|i|..i- 'it 1.. 1 -,'-hi .' iil't. I ■; 
 
 |:ir:li,iii| r. I.', ii-r (I'll ', II t .'.iv "I liiiii.^i-lt ' th.it tii|i ' y.ai l.iiiiW 'I'm. Li.Mii.l;, ami 
 
 'i'li,il till- inli' 'liii ■ linl .-i.iy III ,'iii liii-i; ' ,',li,i.l ll'i i;ill'.i'- li-il hi-' li l-i| i-li'lil yi--ii ■ 
 'Ilia! liii.i mill it ii'- I', illi'ii-iit iiiTit Mill lii'iv. It iia 1 lii-i-n ill- V'll I I inljn', in 
 
 iijic.ll ' \lii| 111 a lli.i.tti'r III l.icl !!'!(-. -1:1 iii lln: l.ilni' 1 , ami till- |ii-'i|iii- I.i 
 
 Mll'.'lll Ip- li'it ll.lVil I' ml 111 t||.- .X'.llil V\ I I, III ll;i- will,!.- ,\ii|i!! 
 
 ,1 ( I iiiiinal il'iil. ■ .Mi'lit 111- h'lt, l,a.\'. \\ ' it, aii'l tlia' ','. !i'-ii it c.iini- 
 
 j'liiii: ti) ,Si ' .11 V .Mi)!iiii .11 11 ' •'iiiilil I ii'ii I '1 1)1- ,1 i|i|i -.ti',!! Ii. t ',', I'l II .\iiii!i W'l-.Ht, iii- 
 
 li i\i' |ii '1 1 'i:i|' -' I It'll t ii- 1:11 .III III I) li -I ' -I i;.it I ail' I .1 iiy i.liiii 
 
 a "'1'- I I ii 
 
 III im-ii I , 
 
 .11 'Ii .1 1-1 1 
 
 flli-!'.'l .1 It, 
 
 'ill I'll; ait|i-.l''i ,i.:t nut. Ill tlii--.i- |,l'-/,(!iii-' 1 ' i'ir|iii.it I'll), a |iiililii: I'lliiii-r, 
 Ji'iiH'iiiii'-i !li--ii- 1 ', a "|im1 li' ,ii a! '^'.i.l-.i- ' Ii 
 'ii 'I'll 1. 111. \ 111. I: ,imi fur iii". ,M y li'ji'it 
 
 t. -,t.il-. 
 
 ii|i I III- 
 
 1, it li.i I m-\ i-( lit , III ,ii -■! il ha-, ,il-,'. .i\ 
 
 I |i 111 1.-, ,i,t :.l ikt; ; my [in it ,|i 11 ,t 
 
 l| Willi tl,(: ^.t•|,|, ll,:; t, 
 
 iiiii'-r, tl 
 
 my iitr l.'i 111 yair li 
 
 ili'l'. I lit ha ', iiii :iii II .S"llli \\i-!',t. 'llil -, ma II ', I ■,■■; 'I'll I, I 
 
 k a', I 
 
 li.ivi-; !i" ii,i", ii'it|iiii'_» ,ii .-il.il.i-. 11 
 
 1 1 V'lU -'IV" III III a 1,11 1 II 1 11:' 'I ii'i i"i-( 'ii- i|.) I ill 
 
 I \ hi, I: 
 
 •ill i| .Mr iJ.'i'ti nil a 'MM II i.i-.-a mhii, aiiil 
 il 1 ', lii:i I 1 1 li-;' I ,-tiii:'. I'l ,11 j iji. ii t il I ( a I ,!■ I 
 
 II ,ii i:i;i| 
 
 '!> Ill , .1 1 ill mil. . li I Pill 
 
 01 
 
 C'l'ii ',1- 1 111- am h-ii . lit I In i,p 1 1- 
 
 ' ■ aiii ;ui'l '.'ivi' th-- t -A'., 'h t' ii'l.iii 
 
 'lam:. v.'iiihI 'Ii:,!'.- ; Iml it 
 
 v. I . ,1 It," II III 
 
 I li"ii.i iM I il iii. II t I'ai'ii 111 I'll 
 
 i| I- ,\ 1! will ;/i-> .1.1 III I I 111" 111 1 t ■ I 1 1 .1 III 
 
 ir'.m .M 
 
 -111 'I'll- thi' I'llliiwiii" iii'iiiiiu',' /■||t-ii' Mr i 
 
 I iii-ii.im I II 
 
 ,Mi. '1,11 y .Ml. ( 
 
 l)iVlh |i.i|iilii| Willi III.', Ilic'i'l 1. '.I'l 1,1: \<f iiii.'.t .1- 
 
 n\ !■ lilt- |. a.'l In-/ \\ 1 1 . 
 
 I'lillm lit th 
 
 .ili'iii 
 
 i|i-r aiiilil iiiUi;!i I.III '111 1-1 /. I '.III it < ''iiliicll. \\ ii.il. i|'ii . .Ill nil '.iiiiii 'I II i| |i'l 
 
 \''lll "l\i- llllll .1 Vi'Mt li'l |l ,'. II 
 
 lli'l il 
 
 a ilillm' .'I im aiii'.niit ti 
 
 I: 
 
 v:ii^ .".iM III 
 
 111 t 1 1 1 1 1: 
 
 W 
 
 f iiiU'it. |i.iy It. 'i'/it II y'lii t hi If '/I' .ifi il ly ; hi l',iii>\ all .liimil it 
 
 I, V 1- I II I! 11 1,1 ' If r mil I i:iat ui 
 
 III- f-iiiiil 
 
 ',V.-ai In I I 
 
 'til. 'v\ 
 
 '.V 
 
 rl|. 
 
 'I'll'- |/. 'llllll- 
 "l\ I'll lllf t 
 
 V\'f-.'f III .\. ..1 
 
 1.1 'Mia li,i'.-.' ' li'-y II 
 
 .1 ''.li! him ' 'I'l 
 
 ii-y ,1 III . ii't I. lit 1 h.il 
 
 I-' l,l'.'lr-a 
 
 I, -at 
 
 'I Vf, that 'it 1 i-iii f --I, ' iir_' ' li.-m in 
 
 I'.u'i.i \',ill I' 
 
 Ml , I. Ill Ir-ll, 
 
 IhiWCil 111 :'i:l 
 
 •l:l 
 
 I '. I llf !il;_';ii . ' ]i' ..1,1 lull I hi' J. 
 
 llill'i li liM illlf ", III !i'll,|i' ,| t 
 
 I III- .111111 ri: I.) ji'.wil III .i i|"iii'.f t it ir !l|.-l( -.'.iti'li 
 
 il 'hat 'III), I, 
 
 I, 1 hi I' V. a , .1 
 
 ri llllll I \', '-all 
 
 Inlii-.-, Iiliill'iin hh 
 
 ht'. I \V|.', iliii t 
 
 \ h'li ',ih 
 
 Ml 
 
 l.'ll 
 
 'I 
 
 |i .'.ll.i'ili llii-y ''III rthil 'I III I.I \lil.i: lai'l .ill'. Ill lllf jinlicf _t 
 
1 1 
 
 I,,,'.. 1' "'" 
 
 y ,ii^''ll'll'V''- 
 
 .'■Ih.- <:t" '•' '■ 
 
 ,(. ii 111 Ml III 1>'-| 
 
 •.•.lire. '1'" 'l"i''" 
 ,,i;, Ihin". i'i"l 
 1-.. f'"' 
 
 ,,-.-<if Miy t'li"''" 
 ,t.,h .ii»i'">'"'.y ' 
 
 1 :,,,,,,.•. n.:ni v^il" 
 ,|,,.|i iiii'" '''■'■ '■• 
 
 ,M: til'' I' ■ !"■" •! 
 
 ,„,,. l,,..l. .' 1'^^ 
 
 ,..,11. .1 :i ilt.'-li"" ■ 
 
 ,t i..l'.'-l ''^*- '■'■ 
 
 ■lill, l.l.M'li'M •^"'' 
 I, t,l .-i/l'' .V" 
 
 ,i,.VMli 1 IM llir, II. 
 
 ;um1 ';.•■ i-'-'i'i'- "' 
 ,,l,..,, It •■ll"'^ 
 
 ;, .<.,,! iiiii' III , :i 
 
 ,; I. tl. .■,.•!■, V.-l, 
 
 I ,i m, ,,^.,1,11' tnr"., 
 ,,.,! il li:i'. .vl'.v..\:'. 
 ,. il;,; t..iipi'i\ '11'' 
 ,,, ,..;■, Till. I.IM'' '• 
 
 Mr II 
 
 T ' < iiMII Iriiirii, 
 
 I will l"l! ihtu |l. N'.'.v ;'i'litlriKili liiy !'';i|-ll<i I 
 
 , ..|Vt II I 
 
 :i ■lull, :'li'' 
 
 yciil till' ii:i»Mii 
 
 i'rui.il ' M r. I l.i!'"l) tp 'K' t" yiiii ai 
 
 il tl 
 
 Ml I hr'irl, <,> < ' I iln IImI 'A |,,I| (., Ill hlirJH ;i II IMl 1 1 1 1 i-i I In .,|,|y ■\\ \ "I X'Vll 
 
 t,.,,ii|i! my li'aiiicci rii(ii(|lii|t li In- iiiivi'l.H ;i;^aiiiHt iim- liiii yu Kim.u tiny wi'if ri,\\ 
 
 |l (,| till- lie. .Ill •\>- ll.ili'.t .I'lK Inr a rrply lllllll''! Il| 
 
 I 111! I', till' virv 'l,tv "f ' 
 
 |C I'lllll- 
 
 M 
 
 I. .loliii I 
 
 iiiit r,i|i ilh'U' 'Inn:'' ■"'■ iii''iii''iiii-iil 'I 'lii.-i ai'ii'iii 
 
 Vmii klinVV 
 
 mI 1)1)1 III till' |i|iirilli!.'M. 
 
 vvliiit lilH p.yHtriii lia'i 
 I 
 
 I, .••Ml. \ 
 
 1 1 1 1 1< 1 1 1 1 w 
 
 ,,i,l..,i.. ''I '11""'" "•''■ 
 l,,.t I' \'^' ■' /I'.'.'"'' 
 
 ,,,„ ,-,i,.' tP.,,1 M.. 
 i,.y Mr. <''>l'y' ""• 
 ,,;:- ^Mi.'l.nll.:. -t '1- 
 , .111 H.|..ui.|. 'II"! "•''■ 
 
 >1,. I;...,-, vwi^ •iitiii:' 
 ^ |.,l,, A all .i'"""' " ■ 
 
 ,h,. iarti,. \M..V '*"' 
 
 Tii.-y .11"-' ' '■'" '''^^' 
 
 ,;,rl al.'.ul 111" li"ll'-'' 
 ,„ al^.■-^'•'i '" '"^' '""■ 
 l',:i,ni'- '•■ '" ■■'I'!'"'' 
 ,at Tin. I-' ■ ''■'■"■' 
 
 ; M'tcr ..i'liii.. ;vr;'inii..iil tlial \\r\i- I ai wirii' (IM S.il.iiiiMii aiiil H|iMt 
 
 i Mr |);iviii ai-l '»li, \\.-il I ■.■.ill p.! . ic-.i a.' an afr'i-l aiiyl'iili ' I iImI Ii'^ ■.vniiiil 
 
 ? way fioiiillial. \ii'l n'lW .^nl li.|,."'ii I <ii,|,irii', \ li li'.il'..'li Im- |.'.ii-* .i'< 
 
 .>sil| ,..,11 yniii al I ..|it iMii In ilir a'T.!'"' a it:Fi.mi<i, li i .ii I v .c-il c anyllim:.^ 
 
 \ MVi-li liy ihl'. aiiit i! yiHi Will' tl. i-\aiii wliirli In- Inay llill;l\ tin- 
 
 ii,i. |,i;, ;..||i,iililn:, I liavi- ii'i (I'Hilil ym :■; ,viniini-iil '|. I'.'i iml a p; I'l ,'.!■ nl In- ■«tallH 
 
 ,.,,ii|,| till, I ilii. vin"i jifiiil in:' iijihialt.nl. inc. ' ;> iit li-nn-n I ha \ n li<-t ii 
 
 ( |,,i|..lit,..| ^ t'l I In- iininii'l|'alily i n j n I i-i| , ln-cniM- I li M ma ii'f', |ia | n r liaa ;."iiif 
 
 .,| i'mia^'.- 1.1 I'lalin , Ml iln- i-ilM-ial. Mc ;iiii'ili;: in-w it I Ni ^ a mi I v>a;.; t a , Ininy 
 
 i,,|,l llicMi I" i-|imliali. i!,.-ir jii.i "l.-l.tH. .li;.(ii:.Mm'.' 'I.'- ..Ilaii. ni tin Miuntry t" 
 
 Inil my liaiinil lininl .Ml lla:'i| !ay,i ., (F- H 'I , pai-.- ■ .r t !,. a,;;li t h. .||.aliin<- tlicir 
 
 I Ii,.|,. 1 , III, liarm III llil ( ami 'lial it u.i.. inlli'l!',. Tin- p.i |iit may liavi- h.-nii lli|iir 
 
 v-ty WM.n;.', Ill 11", til H.iy ilial In- ...!\r.,iil ml, ji n- p. '.|.|i v, In > u ■ aiM i i-'.'anl it an a 
 
 . I, ,111 In M,l, 11,.' |, 111. In- 'iiill!..!. \ni. hl.i-llmr. :.|n-nt ■.■."iil'i m.l n I,, r i i la- f . r ll . 
 
 I kimv. wliat am n-lit i'l.vt'.l saya ..li|..|l I |..\v .In..:.', In, In .w '-an .i ny man 1. m.w Imw 
 
 ' .ami an ii:.',ly I Inn;' '-.i ii I." I"ln:.l clnv.n I', mm-l! I liavn (...fu iii|iili-il in my f.'i-llii:^.^ 
 
 tl, ,...;,,. |,y .m-li .iij.ln-ml, ni . a... llmMn '.! I.y t li i,i [.• rj.i-t ii.i I mi,-, i ..),n-. a-iil a I imi ami 
 
 I ,,| ,„y |,..,n,,.ii 111.. ml. W In-ii .\ym in .il.n.a-; tl.n. 'irMnnial iLnv ..| .■alnniny. 
 
 Slial..-!(|.ran-.h ".M<-iiy Wim!!..! Wim!...! ;in'l !-,la.ml.t , tlmi nnlaiiin" aipply "I '-iivy, 
 
 , ,,,,,i,,,.|i,lii :,l|.alim.', ii'iii" tin l,ai: ,1; v.umI lia.ll'il, malic,, ami all iim liai •.tal.l<-iii.M^' 
 
 ..ml <-;il!ii," ;. i.|.,nli- a ! |..iil'-, nnin' llnm-.'d I lia v.- h' .nn-l inn-i< i n my nml In-l ii llfiliinn 
 
 I I'lut.i.l !'..'iy'i ■'< '(,ii\ .•\', tin- w 1.1- it <;ill n.fraiiicil fpnn r'l,.! im^ In.nn- I.i.m.ii:- in 
 
 " l.'al; Inli; a li.-'i Im tin- i.liiai,.-. W In-n \vlil.-li n-|.ln-i a|i|M.ai.-il t-i ,illa<-l<:i trniii 
 
 ,i y.iii .-all :<l,.-allli:' "i-i.ti',-. y lli" |! i.aiml.i ..I In-.i pa p.-i ( l.i-i-aii:..- I -.'.anti-.l t'l Hpaii- 
 
 * I. .-11. -I, ami y..ii lia.vi- In-.inl lln- i-.\'-ii ..•;. In-,|-pain. lirntNimn tin- -.•. In.l.- .-aHn nt 
 
 mail.-, liy my l.-arin-iMin-ml Imi- tin- a'lvn:.- I.rinn- y.ii. I nly 'ii yai .inin:' y.iir 
 
 1,, ,.,.[,ii,li.it... In "liavi- tin- m-r\.- In i-'pinl 'Inly, I !i.-i\ .- "m lal'-in'- ll'-'t y.n will 
 
 ,,it,..-' I'lil ivliat line:, tin- '.'/,,/„, 111. |. -ail in.ul. wiHi ynr ili-ippi .l.a' mn, .-iivi-.u y 
 
 in;.; )..nriial ..I In , p.uty .ay ' '"I'ln- jirn :ti-iirnl'.ii-, iinpiU. ma li,'iiaiit a,ml imn- 
 
 .-.•.•liint^H ar.- iiii<in.-,Ht n n.ii.ly 'li,Hlinin';.,i (|ar|..i|h at| nl; t nii a piil.ln- man ami nn a 
 
 Mr, Si-nlt , Wnll my I.'.i'i I ,iilmnl nnw-ipap.-r -.•.li-.-..- .-ml, wlm",.. ;inii ami 
 
 !|iiH I,, travi-llii,:; ..i|t .i.l.- tin- i.-.:ni<i. wlnmn, wal clr.vnr. I lia,; l.i .-ii l.nt li- iilin..,H I., 
 
 Ml. I>avin W.-l! my I.. f\ I v.mif ;", tin- .\niili W'-".^ . 
 
 ♦ '-. I' ■» -L