IMAGE EVALUATION TEST TARGET (MT-3) 1.0 I.I 1.25 «4i 1^ ■ 132 .i36 1.4 IIIM 2.0 1.6 V] ^ /}. VI e: ew r p> /y V M Photographic Sciences Corporation ^% iV ^ \ \ ^<6 V 6^ 23 WEST MAIN STREET WEBSTER, NY 14580 (716) 872-4503 CIHM/ICMH Microfiche Series. CIHM/ICMH Collection de microfiches. Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions / Institut canadien de microreproductions historiques Technical and Bibliographic Notes/Notes techniques et bibliographiques The Institute has attempted to obtain the best original copy available for filming. Features of this copy which may be bibliographically unique, which may alter any of the images in the reproduction, or which may significantly change the usual method of filming, are checked below. □ D D D Coloured covers/ Couverture de couleur I I Covers damaged/ Couverture endommagde Covers restored and/or laminated/ Couverture restaurde et/ou pellicul^e Cover title missing/ Le titre de couverture manque Coloured maps/ Cartes gdographiques en couleur Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ Encre de couleur (i.e. autre que bleue ou noire) Coloured plates and/or illustrations/ Planches et/ou illustrations en couleur D Bound with other material/ Be\\6 avec d'autres documents Tight binding may cause shadows or distortion along interior margin/ La reliure serr^e peut causer de I'ombre ou de la distortion le long de la marge int^rieure Blank leaves added during restoration may appear within the text. Whenever possible, these have been omitted from filming/ II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajout^es lors d'une restauration apparaissent dans le texte, mais, lorsque cela dtait possible, ces pages n'ont pas 6t6 film^es. Additional comments:/ Commentiires suppldmentaires: L'Institut a micirofilmd le meilleur exemplaire qu'il lui a 6t6 possible de se procurer. Les details de cet exemplaire qui sont peut-dtre uniques du point de vue bibliographique, qui peuvent modifier une image reproduite, ou qui peuvent exiger une modification dans la m^thode normale de filmage sont indiquds ci-dessous. □ Coloured pages/ Pages de couleur □ Pages damaged/ Pages endommagdes n Pages restored and/or laminated/ Pages restaur6es et/ou pelliculdes □ Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ Pages d6color§es, tachetdes ou piqu6es n r I Showthrough/ I I Quality of print varies/ I I Includes supplementary material/ I I Only edition available/ Pages detached/ Pages d^tach^es Showthroughy Transparence Quality of prir Quality in^gale de {'impression Includes supplementary materie Comprend du materiel supplementaire Only edition available/ Seule Edition disponible □ Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata slips, tissues, etc., have been refilmed to ensure the best possible image/ Les pages totalement ou partiellement obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata, une pelure, etc., ont 6t6 film^es d nouveau de fagon d obtenir la meilleure image possible. This item is filmed at the reduction ratio checked below/ Ce document est film^ au taux de reduction indiqud ci-dessous. 10X 14X 18X 22X 26X 30X t 12X 16X 20X 24X 28X 32X The copy filmed here has bean reproduced tharrkr to the generosity of: Library of the Public Archives of Canada L'exemplaire film6 fut reproduit grAce A la ginArositi de: La bibliothdque des Archives publiques du Canada The images appearing here are the best quality possible considering the condition and legibility of the original copy and in keeping with the filming contract specifications. Original copies in printed paper covers are filmed beginning with the front cover and ending on the last page with a printed or illustnted impres- sion, or the back cover when appropriate. All other original copies are filmed beginning on the first page with a printed or illustrated impres- sion, and ending on the last page with a printed or illustrated impression. The last recorded frame on each microfiche shall contain the symbol — ^ (meaning "CON- TINUED"), or the symbol V (meaning "END"), whichever applies. Les images suivantes ont 6t6 reproduites avec le plus grand soin, compte tenu de la condition at de la netteti de l'exemplaire filmd, et en conformity avec les conditions du contrat de filmage. Les exemplaires originaux dont la couverture en papier est imprimde sont filmis en commenqant par le premier plat et en terminant soit par la derniire page qui comporte une empreinte d'impression ou d'illustration, soit par le second plat, salon le cas. Tous les autres exemplaires originaux sont filmds en commengant par la premidre page qui comporte une empreinte d'impression ou d'illustration et en terminant par la dernidre page qui comporte une telle empreinte. Un des symboles suivants apparaitra sur la derniire image de cheque microfiche, selon le cas: le symbole ^^ signifie "A SUIVRE". le symbole V signifie "FIN". Maps, plates, charts, etc., may be filmed at different reduction ratios. Those too large to be entirely included in one exposure are filmed beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to right and top to bottom, as many frames as required. The following diagrams illustrate the method: Les cartes, planches, tableaux, etc., peuvent dtre film^s d des taux de reduction diff^rents. Lorsque le document est trop grand pour dtre reproduit en un seul clich6, il est film^ d partir de Tangle sup6rieur gauche, de gauche 6 droite, et de haut en bas, en prenant le nombre d'images ndcessaire. Les diagrammes suivants illustrent la m6thode. 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 6 RETURN (620) To ftii Order of the House of Commons, dated the Ist Jul}', 1891. for ii Copy of the Report of Thomas Monro, Government Enguu;er, upon the Mun- cheater Ship Canal. By order. J. A. CHArLEAU, Secrrtanj of SUde. Il KKPOIIT ON THE MAN(U1K,STKI{ SUIT CA.\AL. SouLANQKS Canal, FOnoinef.h's Office, CoTEAU Landino, 1 Uh May, 1801. Sm. — TJoferriii); to tho acoompanying extract from an Ordc'i- in CoiuKil duted 24t.l» Di'co?iiber, ISi'O, iind your IcLtor ot instructions daloil the VMh .lanuarv, ISDl, I bog to enclose herewith a Ueport einlioiiyiiii^ the result of my exaniitwuion of tho Manchester Sliip Canal, in the montli of Fehruaiy of thi.s year, lugeMier with some observations on tlic general subject of canal construction. Tressure .>f business has ])re\ente(l my submitting this documen' at an earlier (late; and, as you i re avvare, tho shij) canal iS of such vast e::tent as rendered it impossible to do more than accomplish a rapid ins])ection of its chiet points, in tlio limited tin)e at ni}- disposal. It is hoped, however, that the Report may bo of Home value in directing attention to sevcal matters connected with the construction of hydraulic works on which more extended discussion seems desirable. 1 am, sir, vour obedient servant, THO.MAS MOXRO, 3/; /ws^ C'.£:., <£c A. P. Rk.VDLEY. Esq., Secretary ot Railways and Canals, Ottawa. Extract from a certified co]n' of a Re|iort of a Committee of the Ilonounible the I'rivy C» on good-^ l>otween that city and Manchester. From the beginning of the enterjirise it has been considered by its promoters an established fact that, when the canal is opened for traffic, rates of freight and marine insurance on foreign consignments to Manchester will not exceed those to Liver])n()l ; and the saving thus otfocted will bo available for divisif)n between the Canal Company and the owners of cargoes. The probable proceeds from this source will, it is stated, provide remuner- ative rates for the company, and result in a saving of at least 50 per cent, (see ajtpendix) on the present average cost of transportation between the two cities. The importance of such a reduction cannot be over-estimated, especially in the present condition of trade. The very existence of numerous industries in tlie dis- tricts around Manchester is dependent upon cheap transportation, now that the rate of carriage bears, in many cases, such a disjiroportionate relation to the cost of the commodities themselves. It is said that the duos .it the ports of northern P^urope, and the canal and railway rates between these ports and the interior (esneciaily in Belgium) are so very much less than those which the trades of the Mancnester dis tricts have to pay, that all their industries are greati}- overweighted in the compe- tition which they have to meet; whereas tho ship canal, when built, will go far to place them in as good a po.sition as their continental rivals. Li brief, distance from the .seaboard is now exerci.sing a marked effect upon the prosperity of hitherto flourishing inland towns. l*rnximity to the coast means progress, whereas long railway cariiage to a shipping point, with its attendant cost, will practically |)ut a juanufacturing centre out of tho race in these days of fierce competition and narrow margins. Those statements aro irrefutable; and the magnitude of the interests involved in the construction of the work in question maj- be conjectured from tho fact that within ji radius of 45 miles from Manchester there is a population of nearly eight millions chiefly engaged in manufactures. The prospective traffic of the canal daring the secoml year after its being opened is estimated at about 4,500,000 tons, the revenue from which, would enable at least a four per cent, dividend to be paid on a capital of ,'J 10,000,000 and leave a considerable surplus for reserve or sinking fund. As might have been expected, this enterjjrise was strenuously opposed from its inception both b)- the iJovk Hoard and CorjKiration of Liverj)ool, and the various railway companies intert!sted. About £1.^)0,000 had to be spent by its piomotors before the Acts authorizir.g construction on the present plan were passed; and even now the works are hampered with conditions whieh have greatly increased the cost of the underlaking and may injuriously atfect the future operation of tho canal. If, however, the scheme is siu'cessfully carried out, it will afford a striking example of what a groat English manufacturing town can do, relying solely upon its own resources, and wholly without Governmental aid. Its construction will also afford another proof of the fact that no railway can compete with a canal of large dimensions in the cheap carriage of heavy goods. It is stated that even the Bridge- watei- Canal Cnavigated by barges of only about 50 tons) carries 00,000 tons of traffic per mile per annum, whilst the average of the railways of England and Wales is only 17,000 tons. It ))ays a larger divideml than any railway in the counlry, and has* been recently acquired by the .Manchester Ship Canal (-onipany at a cost of £l,'750,O0O. The Leeds and Liverpool Canal, worked independently of the railways, paj's an average dividend of over 18 per cent. place >t a of Tlio liistory c)f'tho inci,812,0(in. it was then stated tiial the cost of the works would not exceed ,€5,Tr)(i,000, and tiiat the sum of CS02,U.'!H should pay for all land and damages. The Biiilgewutei- Canal to be accjuired tor the sum above mentioned, the average not inconu' from this being set down at .C*!it,000 per annum. Forty thotisund sharolioldi'is slDwed what contidonce the public had in the scheme; and for the tirst thrci' years after tlie commencement of the works, the progros . made was almost unparalleled. But the death of the contractor, Mr. Thomas A. Walker, had an imme- diate etleet upon this rapid rate of progre.ss ; the works were not so vigorously ])ushed. although tlioy were to have lieon com|>lete'', under a heavy penalty, in throe veais. Then the rale of wages jidvanccd from liO to 25 per cent. — the winter frosts ot' 18M0 were phenomenally severe, and the heavy floods of Xovemlier did nuich damage The result of all this was, that, on the 24lb November, 18'J0, the directors decided lo take over the works upon certain conditions, and in this way avoid litigation with the trustees of the contractor's estate, as well us ])lace themselves in a position to carry on operations untrammelled by tlie existence of any contract wliatevcr. At a half yearly meeting of the shareholders, held in Manchester on the 4th February last, this action was unanimously approved; — although only generally known then for the tirst time. In readjusiing matters connected with Walker's contract (undor.str.od to have been originally for the sum of £5,750,000, with schedule prices attached) an addition to this amrmnt was granted, for extras and unfore.soen items, of £865,753, (see Appendix) whilst that expended for land and damages up to (late was found lo bo £1, 022,131)0 In short, the funds >vere confessedly oxliausted, and the announcemeht was authoritatively tnade that unless reliet were at once forthcoming, operations must soon entirely cease. An appeal for help was made to iie Corjioration of Manchester, which was promptly and cordially responded to. ICstimates were made by the engineers of the company, showing that the additional Mim re(|uire(l to complete was. say, £1,700,000 ; l)ul before extending the piomised aid the C\>rporation wisely had an independent enquiry made by their own engineer, which resulted in this amount being increased to about £2,500,000. Steps were taken to obtain tlio requisite permission from Parliament to advance the money. This power \vill be granted almost as a matter of course. Thus this immense imdertaking will probably lie completed at :. cost of about .jC12,500,Ot(0; or, say, 802,500,000 — a niuch larger sum than that hitherto expendeii on all the Canadian canals, which is shown in the last iie[»ort of the Department to have been, up to the .'{Oth of June, 18S9— 4J54,5'.>(;,]S8. There are, however, physical ilifBculties to be contended with in the operation of this canal, whicli may |)rove more formidable than those of financial origin already experienced. Indeed, of the Manchester Ship Camil,as a line of navigation .Miitable for ocean vea.sols, it may be said that it is an experiment on a gigantic scale — one which it is hoped may fully reali/.e the expoctatujus of its supporters — but stili an HXi)oriment, l>ecause there are eonditions met with whieh it is bolie\ ed do not exist elsewhere in the same degree on a first-class line of navigation. For example; the admis,sion of tidal fluctuations into the lower two-thirds of a lock canal must prove a source of trouble in the movements of the large class of vessels which it is intended to accommodate. It is also obvious thai the up])er or inland portion between Latr. Tho rnlv ofciirront which iiiiiHt oiiKHo tVdrii the p!insn;;t' of even ono-halT ot'Hiich a voliinif as this caiiin'l but titi HcnoiiM ovoii vvlioii tiio caiiai Ih complotoil to its full crosH-soctioii throiiichoiii ami all th(^ sliiii'cs arc in position. These didiciiltios will, of foiirHe. iio only of short duration and cx|)cricncci| at connidcraldo intervals; still, when combined with those of the tide, they will render the naviifation mmdi more diliicull than that of the Welhmd or St. F/iwr(Mice (finals, where eaeli is arran^^od to admit just as much water as is re(|uir(«l for satisfaetory operation unil no mcjre. 'I'ho tluetnations of the lakt^H and rivers do not soiifutsly interfere with their safe W(>rkinj^ atid the lower enlranf'os are not, ombariasscd by tho continuous oscillutions of ti(ieH. It may ho said, at this p(;ini, that the olfcctivo, rapid, ami safe navigation, through hicU canals, of vosM(d[i of 2,0lHJ tons is no longer a problem for solution in Canada. Tiie praeli'td experience possessed .)n thin point does not, however, exist in lOngland, where uji ti> the present lime, tliu largest mivigiition has been for bargot* oi about 800 tons — I'Ui by far the greater length of the aggregate of 8,000 miles '>f eanal, sailuiees will also lie used l"r tidal flow. Tbo canal pasM-.s Uuncorn under tbo viaduct of tlie London and Norlll-\Ve^t«rn Railway, and leave-i Ibe .Merhey by a deep cutting, appr^," where two .'.(ifoel "luices li:tvc been built lo enable tbo tiilal water to bo let into or oiit of the canal. liotwoen EaHlbani and Ijaiciil'ord, the miidmum width of the canal at bottom is I'JO feet The depth at me:4n high water in 2t; feet. The surface width varies with the side slopes. The locU sills are placed 2H feet below water level, to jillow ol a future deepening of the canal li}' dredging. At Latcliford there are two locks side by siile — the larger ont> being (JOO feet by (15 and the Minallor one 350 feet by 45. At Irlam, .seven and a-half miles above Latebford, similar locks arc nearly constrtu'ted, as well as at Marton, two miles above Irlani.and at Mode Wheel, thivc and a ijuaiter miles from Haitoii. These last -named loiivs torni the entiance lo ,he .Muncdiesler Docks, whiidi extend one and a quarter miles ahove .Mode Wii ol. The total rise from the onliiuii-y water level of thecaiuil at Eastham to the (looks al Manche.xter is )!(( feet (! inches. This rise, divided amongst four locks gives an average fif about 1") feet lA inches. All the lock gates aie constructed olgreenheart, a very hard wood iru|>oiteil from I>»Mnerara, which has been found by e.xperieneo to be exceeilingly oint above Laicdifonl where tlie canal leaves the riverand takes jin indepeiuient course inland. The railways are crossed over the canals by high levtd bridges. Of these there are five, viz: — Tho Jjondon it North- Western ; Tbo <terj. The (dear iieadway for liie railway iiridges i> 75 teet, which is tho height of tho underside of tlie Jtun- coi'ii viaduct over the water in the canal. Tho total length of railway diversions is eleven and a quarter miles, and the viaducts are mostly on the skew with openings varying from 2(i(j to i;{7 feet. In some cases a new lini' had to be fo; mud on each side of the canal to the mnv crossing. i''ioiu this it will lie observed thai the (pies- lion of railway divei'sion -A-as a formidable one to deal with, and added greatly to tho cost oi the undertaking. The embankments ol approach are very high ami swallowed up va>t quantities of material. There are two high level andsix swing road bridges between Kuncorn and JJarton. The spans ol' those bridges are in all case-^ not less than 12t) feet, the full navigable width (}f canal being retained. The minimum headway is the same as for the railway bridges. The swing luidges will be worked by hydraulic power, as well as the moveable aijUeluct which will eii.able boats to pass across the Ship flii Tin- liocljs at ^faiulii'tttrr will liav« all iirc:i of wati'i •^|^al•(^ nt 1 11 iid'OH , tin' ait-a (if i|iiay f*pac(' heinii' iri2 ai'iv. The lerijitli of p<)HU(l to bo ron- »*trinft'<| ofan area of "J.! ni-ies. At I'ariiiiLCton the cjnial is wi'lciicd out to allow btfaiixTK to lii^ oil t'itliiT hido ; and l>raiicli railways will he (Mii.Hinicitd will. Iiydiaii- lic coal ti)>!* to acC'oiiiiiKKJatc the iitidc. With tlio tiHo ot till- oloetric li^^lit the taiial can l>o navigated at night. It ia oxpoeted thai tlie whole length oi' the canal can bo travorued in uhonl ton (10) hour hecn tyund, mihI l.'tii.OtKt bricks poi- week have been made at th«' < ontractoi's l)i'i(d{- yard near 'riuiwall. Laiyf ([uanlitii's have alu) to !»«• bon^lit, as about 7(>,(Mi(t,(((H> will bo used on the canal. The gra-vel and sand ar»' being used iJor cunerete, of which l.li.'ittjiOO (a million and a quuiterj yjirdH aio rc(juired. r'oiicict"' has bot^ji useil wherever prarticablo in dock and lock walls. Tho copings and liollow (juoiiis are of < oriiish granite, while bard sandrttonc fiom quarries in Yoikuhiro, i>erbyHhiro and (Micfihire, and liineHtono from Walos, are used in other portions of the work. Tho lower portions ot llii> dock and kick walls are formed of concrete. At tho water level, granite or limi>sfonc fender cour.ses slightly projecting from the face of the wall ar/- iiiHoitcd to protect the <-onciete. Above this lovd the conciete wailh are laced with bri(d cubic yar Is, in addition to ^20,0(10 cubic yanls of masonry. I'Vir tin.' oxcavalion of the cMiiul nearly KMt sicaiii excavators of various tyjiea have been enii)loyed, (sonie of w.dch have been constructed in l-'ianceand (iei'iiiauy) am) to convey the earth lo tho spoil grounds and for other purposes there were em- ployed in ISi'O, 17 < small locoinotives : (J.liOO waggons and trucks; 'J2.'J miles of r.'iilway (4 feet .^A inches uaugc) having boon laid alongside of and in the bod I'f the canal. Tho rate ol i^xcavation has varioil from 'I to ) j million cubic yards pj'r month. As much as 2,400 cubic yards have boon o.veavated in ten hours by thetrciraan excavators, but their average work would bo less than 2,0(Hl yarils. Like the I'reiudi typo ot'oxcavalois. tlie}' tire land dre(lges suitable only tor soft hoil. The hiiiglisli exi'avatois have in good s(dl at times reached nearly 2,00(( cubic yards per day, but their average in all sorts would be about 7<'0 cultic yards. Tliey are, however, capable of excavating very lianl material, and even lock where powder is used ahead of the excavator. There were 1!)4 steam cranes, 182 portable i»nd other steam engines and 201' steam puiiii», employed upon the work.-, ai,d they c(mhumiil about lU.OOO tons ot coal per month. The deepest cutting is ne.-ir (lunconi, where for a short distance the depth is (lO feet. The largest cutting is at rjatchtoni, where foradistance ot" lA miles the depth aveiag' 8 5") feet. Tho slopes ot'the cuttings vary willi the nature of the soil iroiii 1 to I to 2 lo 1. In the rock cutting tho sides are nearly vettical. The total amliunl of excavation is alioiit 4t;,ll00.(l00 cubic yards; Ifl.OOO.OOn of which is .sandstone rock. The spoil Irom thct ("iintd is used in tilling up the river bends whi<.> as to make them available for use as shipyards and other purpose^. Of the ;{r) V miles of canal, 15 are curveil and 20A straight line. The sharpest curve is at Kuncorn. and has a radius of ;5(> chains (1,1180'). It is not considerecl necessary, for the |)Uiposos of this Report, to refer in iletail to the stntill navigations tributary to the .Shiji Canal, further than to say that they will provo m()8t valiml'lv fet'ilor.H to its inuli'. Xcillior in any |iartioiilar li-foronue r«(|uiif ttost of tli»> Canal, ami it i> saiil tliat tlif railway coinjianitH ( who wt>io all ainiii,' anlayoiHKtie to tin- (■I'lit'iiu'j iiinistt'd on tin- vai ioim worU-N conmM tot! witli iho (l«\iativ»ii li«'iii|f can it'll out in tin* most costly niaiiiinr. The vuiilucts ai'o |»nrici|ially laiilt oi hiick, aiil;iniing osiers, \c. The -nnd'^tone pitching ot' the slopes docfi not ajijiear to be of a clKiractor to resist jiormancntlv the wa-h of ocean steamers, if they shoidd perlorm the trip from Kasthain to ^fanchester in the time expected, viz., 10 hours. It will probably take lui an average threc-(|uarter8 of an hour for a Large sjiip to get thi-ough a loek and as there aio five cd' these, the speed at whi(di the Canal pai't (d' the voyage woidd have to be made woidd, even with tliel;irgo cros.ssection ot canal, cieate a wave that wouhl pndiably peel otf the pitching in many |)laces. The general impression given was thai the side slopes are 'oo steep lliroughout. As to the shifting of material, it is evident at a glance that jierteet organizatit>n existed for the exeiiition of thai important part of the svoik. The coiilracioi's ealue> was ih>', however, obtainable during the lime ot the wiiter's visit This will be readily ulidcrstood if the embarrassed state of the Company's affairs and the partial confusion conse- quent upon a sudden change of management arc taken into consideration. This remark also applies to the difficulty exjiericnced in trying to understand several iiinttcrs without ;in<.'h help tK is i' luilly !it!ordeil iicaps are formed, one of which, near " Slaidow (Jutting, ' ap])ears to reach an elevation of ubout 100 feet over canal bottom. Tliose features give ai; impression of magnitude botncwliat like that ])rodiiced on looking south tVom Allaidjiirg through Iho dcej) cut on the Welland Canal. The laie of prog. ess has been previously statiMl at an aver- age of about one million cubic yards [ler month, i'his, it is said, was kejjt up for a considerable period. The foice employed sonuUim's reached the large number of liO.OOO men and lioys. .Small villages of huts were erected for their accommodation ut convenient points along the Canal. It is now proposed to look more in iletail into various points of consii uetion which may be found useful in considering future j>lans connected with Ihe com- jjietion of our canal-. The numerous drawings accompan^'ing this I'epori show clearly the dimensions of several ot' the locks and sluices, and a description of the chief features of one set will siMve tor all the rest. All the lock.s and sluices on the canal are founded on red sandstone ri)ck. This is, of cmir.^e, a most im|.ortant pi>int, and n:u>i have larg-dy contributed to s.ive the works from more serious in.jury tlien they appear to bavesustained during the floods of last Xovemb(M'. The rock where it forms .he chamliei'-floor is ludlowed out into the ^haj)e ot an invert. In sev-vtil cas(>.s the walls were built betore tho central portion or core of ruck was excavated; this seiving. meanwiiile, as availnlde space on which to depo^it materials, make roads, and, generally speaking, to got ii'\r the work, and thus save a large anmunt of labour in hoi.sting. The walls throiigh'Hit are of concrete, with bri(dc facing above the level of the lower reach. They are not 0' x 15' or 120' x 45'; so that, in all, >ix ilitVcrent ing al>o generally ilone to the vessel, and sonielimeH to the I'eaches below. Bui with a breast wail, a-^ on fhi! .^nip (.'anal, the upper gales are out of danger, because a vessel may slriko the wall but cannot tniuh tic gates, which are, therefoie, .safe from the fruitful source of ilamage alluded to. There is no timber whatever in the foundation of the locks or retaining walls. The mitre sill platforms are of stone, and the g.a'.es shut auainst nui>sive sills of graniie. 15y the introduction of masonry inverts great stabiliiy ir> securt^d. It is not neces.sary to describe the brick facing of the locks above the rubbing coui'so of granite which is carried all round at about the level of the surface of tho lower reach. Such a method of construclion is entirely unsuited to our (diniatf — and a]jpoars liable to be destroyed if struck heavily by a vessel. It is j)resumed, liowever, that the plan has been ijrac'tically tested beftire being adopted in -mdi an important position. As a gent'ral thing it may be said that all the works connecteil with the locks, sluices and other struc.ures of the Manchesler .Ship (Vnal are execnted in an excellent and woi knianlike n\anner. Tho group of locks at. Easlbam (ihc 'limensions (jf which aie previoiisl\- given) is designed to meet tho special requirements of navigation at the .Merse}' entrance, where the syjijng tides rise to trom five to seven feet over ordinary level of the i-an:d, or about 21 feet. Diiringsiich times the gates will bo open, the lido being permiltetl to llow freely into thi' canal. At llood, the gates will be shut .and the water thus penned in, will, on the ebb, run out through tlie o])eniiigs marie hu' that pur|)oied in the unwateiing below floor level whilst a wbol" ileet nf ves-i-Is awaiti'd the re- opening ot navigation outside. It seems clear, tboiclore, tiiat tho plan of Iniving culverts in the side walls in the manner adopted on the Ship ('anal and numerous large works in b'ligland hrs a great many points to I'ecommenil it. It has been objected that in this climate the frost may be introduced by the.se ojienings into the 10 lifiiri oi' tliii walls and have a damaging effect on tlie muMMiry. It does not ajipear that tlii8 viyw can bo cstalilij^licd. Diirinjii llio nperalion ol' flio Canal, tlie ciilvt-rts are, of course, always full and d(» not require to !><■ emptied unless in case of accident or when the (janal is undergoing repairs in the spring, so that there is really no chance to damage the walls in thii way apprehended. It seems as if our own Canal experience so Car givi's suflicieni proof of the correctness of ihe^e views. Tlio lock gates on the Ship Canal (see i)lan8) are of gieat strength — veiw heavy "and costly. Indeed it would appear as if the same superabundance of sTrengtii which is geiu-rully seen in tln^ structures of thi.s canal culminated in the lock gates. They are framed and jmt together in large shcd^ oiectcd for the purpo>e. They are accurately fitted in all their parts, and the workmanship is of the \ery lie>t kiml. When completed in the shop, they are taken ai)art and transported to the works where they are set uj) iii place. This, of eoursc, adds to the cost, which i.-> very large. It is said that one leaf of the gates of the large lock, at Kastham, will cost as much as a complete set for ■< lock on the Wellaiid Canal, or about JL'."J,;)00. The grei'idieart is imported in logs from the West Indies, and there is considerable waste in framing iho timber. There is nothing in connection with the gates which atl'ords an example for construction in this country. In a recent discussion at the Institute nt' (.'ivil Engineers on the question of lock gates, it was remarked by a competent ••luihoi'ily that it was curious to observe how some engineers adopted iron and some wondeu lock gates. At the Ale.xaodia Docks, at Hull, wooden gates are employed; at the Barry Docks, iron gates. At Liverpool, wooden gates; at Havre there were formerly wooden gates across the liig entrance (lUO feet wide) of tlie Kurc Dock; but for the.->o iron gates have been siibsliiuted. Although, it seems as if the u'eneral verdict were in favour of wooden gales, it ap])cars strange that those on the ]M.an- ( hester .Shi]i Canal, which runs through a county of ii'on manufactures, should bo built of wood imported across the ocean at great expense. As to their beinu' less lial>le to damage than iron gatt's. it is to bofcartMl that if a large vessel strike cither, the result Vvould be about the same. <.)n the Welland and St. Livwrence Canals, the solid gates which Ijuvebeen sometime in use have given fair satisfaction, although a Weak form of construction. For high lifts, gates built on the |)lan of thixc nf the American Sault Sle. Maiie Canal have the materials scientitically distributeo to meet tlie strains; ami in practice they have given much satisfaction. The fiames are of oak sheeted with Norway pine, and strengthened with iron bolts and straps where necessary, so as tu combine lightness with strength. A leaf of the Lower lock irates weighs 7(! tons. A nuiditication of these gates to suit tlie circumstances of each case would form a vcrv good type for use in the comiilction of llie St. Lawience Caiuds. The machinery i'l'V operating the heavy gates and sluices of the Ship Canal is correspondingly heavy and expensive. Th<' ArnistKuig hydraulic apparatus, now being constructcil at lOasihain, is t)nly partly executed, and its ultimate cost eould not be obtained. This system is in use to a consiiieralile extent at the Liverjiool docks, where it is found to answer admirably. Itwassaid that the cost of buildii\g and ), and at the other four >.et> pmjjor- he extra sums gi'anled to the con- tractor by the arrangement of the 'J-lth November, ISHO, previously rcf'oireil to. an item of C;{t!,U>4 ajijiears for " additional work on the Armstrong eontraet." It seern.s proliable that the cost of buildings and machinery to operate all the lock gr.tes. &.Q., would beat least .C2r)(),(tlJ0. Tin; interest on this would be about 8U'J,.")('0 yearly, to which the cost of fuel, attendance and operutors on the loeiv must be added. This woukl jilace such a system quite beyond our means loi' an\lhing but an isolated luck like that at Sault Ste. Marie, The niachinery of the n(>w American lock there is esti- nuited to cost $1(10,000, and the annual ex|teniliture for operati-ai caimol be less than at Iht i)resent one, viz., over §)in,t)(lO. It seems, therefore, clear that the hydraulic system could not be juiiiciou^ly ailo|ited on a cuiuU with numerous locks, but ii i.i, proliable that machinery for the pur|)ose may soon be very much >imj)liried; and iioth its tirst cost and that of operation greatly reduce«l by the introduction of machinery at Kastham alone wy having tlie chains work fi-omatixe(i jioint in the lock wall as will be seen on examining ihe plans. At the yuult the driving power is thi'fall at the lock, as liiere is no need of economising water, such as exists on the Ship Canal. In rcferi-nce to this matter, it may h-' said tnat the most recent aj)|i!ieation of liydranlic power to the operation of gates is at Barry Docks, South Wales, where piston.; connected wit'a lams placed in recesses hchind tho gates are a])plicd to fixed points in their rear. These pistons, the stioke of which is over 20 feet, pu>h the gate -hut, or pull it open as reipiired, and this is ptuMormed with gieat stcadiu'-ss, oven when thoio is a very rough ^ca. This is a manifest improvement on the Oom[ili- cated system of sheaves and chains of the Arnistiong plan and lias received the warm approval of many distinguished Knglish engineers. I'^electric motors could he used to ell'ect the object somewhat afici- this fashion lock' gates of tho sizeof those on the St. Lawrence navigation coidd be worked with great ease and ex])eclition. Tlio-iibject is one well worthy of close attention. It has been previously observed that all the lock and dock w;ills are almost entirely built ofconerele, the amount of whieli u-^ed on tho Ship ('an;il will beaiiout l,2a(l,()0it cubic yards. Its jiroparalion is condiictt'd in a very simple and apparently quite elKcii'nl way, by ordinary laboui' for the most ])art ; but tin; .'^reale-l care is taken in the selection and treatment of the materials of which it is composed, and from which sucli very satisfactory results have been secured. As to tho cement — this has been obtained from variou- manufaciuror.-, but it is all subjecteil to the same tests. It would take too long to describe these in detail, iiut it may lie said that where so much depends upon the purity of the article, its quality is assureil by ibe mo>t rigid e.vaniination and trials, .\ cetnent must not only stand a certain maximum breakinii' strain at a dctinito period shortly after setting, but it must show a considerable increase of strength in time. For example, suppose an inch section breaks at the en, this nui-t also be tlK»roughly satisfactoiy. In brief, tho [uogress of science ami improved methodfi of manufacturi> have (dearly shown that risks of failure, hithertodeemed inseparable from the use of Portland cement concrete, are really attributable either to 'ho fad that tho C(>ment has been badly mailo, or that proper caio has imt been exercjhed in the jireparation ol' tho aggregate, to ensure which only ordinary jirecautions are reqtiireil. The greater part of the concrete used in the Shij) Canal is t'ormcd of gravel, >and and cement in the proportion ot ^ to ' by vol.mie. In the face work 4 to 1 is ntud. The aggregate is tlnn'oughly mixed on a platform — then a suHicieney ot clean water i> ailded throui^li th<' rose of a watoi'ing ))ot, anaiy to insure an e\'C(dlent jub. ,Miles of walls Hiade in (hi way were caretully examine I iiy the writer, and no (hange was visible in any part of them, although last wintei-'s frosts in Hngland weiv, as i- well kn^wn, exceptionally severe. There may, ot course, be positions in whi( b, for economical reasftns. rubble niasotiiy might bo piefeiablo to concrete ; but the manifest facility and cheapness with which a hydraulic wall can be built oj' this material — the ease with which it can be moulded into any required >hape, (bus Mjten avoldioi; i-.,..ily .niting — ;ind die fact that but a short training is required to enable an ordinai'v labourer to prepare it, are obviously strong arguments in favour ol its more general adoption on the hydraulic works of Canada. On the Ship Canal the filling culverts through tho lock 12 walls j)roviou8ly alluded to wore intended to have a lining of bricks throughout, but tlioy are now simply faced with richer concrete, and the brick lining has lioen dis- pensed with as iinnccossar}-. A nu)-:t iiisiructivi' example of the adoptii)ii of concrete as a building material in v the recent rcntiwal of a considiuablo portimi of the breakwater at Hutfalo Harbour, the woolen Huporstriicture of which bad been more or less destroyed by the violent gales so prevalent on Lake Krii'. The i|Uestioii of the advisability of abandoiung the old ini-thod of renewing wooden superstructures with thui'd in sti>ne or concrc-te. It tbcndbre becomes a matter of cotisideialde importance as to which is the better plan to adnpi. In tiie case in point, two modes were subniilted. One was to renew the superstructure with a hearting of concrete faced with cut stone. The other was to nudful examin- ation of the new concrete work was made aftei' the ice had left I>ake Krie, and thouub the preceding winter had been exceptionally severe, no damage was clone, and the surface of the concrete hail undergone no perccptibK' degradation. It was then recoiiiiueiided that the further use of masonry should cease; and as a matter of fact there were only 228 cubic yards of cut stone built, although it re(piired about 10,500 cubic yards of ccmcretc to renew 1,150 in length of superstructure. In this case, the cut stone cost nearly six times as much as the onerete, lait the j)rice of neither can bi' taken as a fair criterion for work done under ordinary ci^cum■^tances. Theie were many interruptions owing to its c\])osed jiosition, and the tVequent occurrence of stormy weatlier, besides the gxtra expense .attendant upon it being out of the reach of iMdin.ary means of ti'ansporl. The engineer lias recommeiide(i that a tuither length of 2,(ti)l» feel ol' pier lie renewed on the same plan which has proved quite satisfactory. The late (Jbief Engineer of Canah', ^Ir. Page, also had a test made of this material with a view to using it for the juirpose above described; but in a much more sheltered ])Osition. A length of some 4ll0 feel of the east pier at Port Dal- housic llarbiiur, the wooden superstructure of which w:is quite tlecayed, was rebuilt of Ci)ncrete, the cross-secti(uial dimensions of which are about IS feet b\ 5 feet. It lias resisted perfectly the action of frost and has in every way proved suitable for the intended purjiose. Means arc not at hand to get at the particular« of its pre- jjaration or cos', bui these can doubtless lie bud trom tlu' (jllicer in (diarge. It may be said, however, that the we of till' latter only wheie the lu'st results are require(l. Fnun the fiiregoing, it would a])))ear that extensive experience, h'Hli luiglish, Anuuii an and t'anadian, point to the conclusion that Portland cement concrete, if made of sound matindal . and with proper care, can be safely used in hvdraulic works and in expo.-,ed |)ositions in this (dimatc, and thai the question of its dur- ahilily bus ccused lo be a niaiter of doubt or conjecture. Another ]ioini in connection with the Manchester Ship Canal which meiits special mention is its sluices on Stoiuy's Patent, whi(di are introduced tbrouL;lc>ut in 18 lit' il ic li- lts ill llip lodcH ami weirs or wherever water liar- to In; controlled. The>e Mliiiccs aro an excellont invention, and may be lirietly described aw wrought iron shutters or doors inoviiifj vertieally in grooves formed in the masonry piers of the weirs, etc., — and carrieil on live rollers so arranged as to almost eliminate friction, so that with the use of the counterbalance they can be o))er:ited by band power with surprising ease. It is obvious to any one who has bad practical experience of the troubles aris- ing troin tlie use of sc-me of the existing valves on onr canals that simplicity of form is a great recommendaiion, for nowhere is this more valuable than in connection with the re.gulation and contrs-il>le to describe here. The great merits f)t lbi« invention are now universally recognized. The sluices aro especially adapted tor controlling large bodies of water, hut can also be as advantageously applied to the purposes of lock and culvert valves. It is obvious tliat there is a great advan- tage in bavinga eoiiii)letely unobst rueled opening secured in the wa}- .■e sluices with nioditlcal ions suitable to tbe circumstances of each pailiculai' case. The wisdom of adoptin,L:' ihem so geiieiallj' on the Ship Canal, will bo abundantly evident on examining the series of photogra]dis forwarded herewith, which were taken immediately after the last floods; and show what provision is necessary to ])i'ovorit disaster when the line of navigation is o])oneil for traffic. Attention is dra^'n to the accompan\-in,g printed tocte(l with lit-avv stone pitcliiiiu;. Tlie liottom of this ciilvoft. whoi'o it ])!ishcs luhlor tlio Siiip Ciinal. is I'liliy "td f'eot holow the sitifiico of the i^roiiii'l iuijoiriiiiLT. Tl)e iiiriteriiii excavatcil ii|)])oars to have been very sot^ clay atul considerable lronl)ie\\as oxperierceij in gettintr a jjroper toiimlation, especially ai HUi-h a depth below tide-water. The length of the sy|>h(jn is ;)(I0 feot. .\t periods of high water in the Morsoy the water will riisli through tlieso lubes into .he valley of the r'iver or creek, an(rrtowoiit with the reeeding tide. Tliisform of iidvert has been adopted In view of ilb etlieiiMu-y ami cheapness, The tubes cau, of course, resist pi'essuro in either direction, anil in that respect (aminigst others) have a manifest advantage over n.asonry arches. Steps have been taken to preserve the inside surfaces from the corro.^ive action of salt water. No dilHcuity is, how- ever, apprehended in connection with these tubes, allliough when (.nre tilb'd ihey will be dirticult to unwater; fior does there ap))oar to be any reasonable gi'ounds to m with water which had to be punrjcd out before opi>rations could be jvsuined. Below llu' locks at Ijalchford the water rose ujnvards of forty feet — and for miles the canal looked as if it were road}- for navigation. But notwithstanding liiese drawbacdvs, there is no rcasim why, if the necessary fun. Is are forthcoinitig in time as they doubtless will be, that the canal throughout sIkuiRI not be opened for ti'aflic next yeai'. There will probably be some trouble in excavating a cliannel of approach at the lower entrance and koe|iing it clear afterwards. Tlicie is much un- certainty about all such chuniuds, and those amongst the .shifting sandbanks of the estuary of the Mersey, are, it is said, constantly changing. The main shore lielow J'lastliiim is, however, rocky, and the chaniud cdio.-en for leading to 'be tMitrance to the canal, bus, it is understood, ]ir;'s<'rved its jiresent dimensions for a long period. It is dillicult, however, to understiind how large vessels will be able to safely cuter the Eastham locks when borne along on the tidal cuircnt to the mouth of the u cixnnl. but it is prosuincii thiit the exporionce gniiiod at the Liverpool docks, wliore vesHfls liiivo to enter quifUly tVotn the rivei- 'liiviiiLC higli water, will eniiltle ^liip captains to i,ui(Je tlieir crafts salelj in wliat seems to he a dangerous place. It ap- pears as if it would have been an exi:>cllen:, tiiiny to t'orm a huije basin jnst above the ^n-oiip of locks at Eastliam, where vessels cniild halt bt't'ore sinrtiiiu' uj) the canal. It is to be ho])ed, however, that ail tlie benetits expected to llow from tlie con^lnu•tion of this i^ioat Work will eventually be realized. The Ship Canal is ex- pected to bot^in business with a tutnia<Oj, l.H.'i.OOl tons of lieigbt passed llirough the lock, and its full capacity may lie rea« bed before the Canadian canal, now in pro- gres-i. can be built. The tonnage whivdi passes Detroit, repr(>sents the trade of Lal to which tlie laketratfic has grown, and the chea|)noss of water transport is suiHcientl}' evident from the fact that wheat is ij.dng can-led this noa-son from Chicago to Buifalo, a distance of about one thousand 'niles. at a rate of one cent per bushel. In conclusion, it may be said that the general impression formed of the .Man- chester Siiip Canal, is that of a magnificent lino of navigation, the works of which have been most substantially executed, but whose free operation will be somewhat trammelled by its having t(j act as the main Special thanks are ockH and strai<,'hleninL'' fanal at Barton 15t,Ui»0 I'Atras on Arnislronj; s contract 3(1,10-4 Klood sluices 11,048 Kxtra cost of materialn, concrete i^ li|>,(!SH Stone 10,T(!0 Siihstitutioii of hrick work fo.' masonry ruhijlc. (in,Si;{ 21(l.2(;i £8t]5^573 Land oxpenses i:i,022,:5itO (I-'xlraot tVi.'m speech of chairman at meeting of 4th February. ISIM, at Man- chester.) List of Firms ii'ho have supplied Exmcatdrs. Locomntives, Cranes, ii-c.,for Ike. irorks of t/ie Manchester Ship Canal. E.vcaraiors. — Knston, Proctor i*i Co., Sheal Iron Works, Lincoln. 1. II. Wilson iV Co., Sandhills, Liverpool. Wliitakcr 15ros., llorsforth, near .iOed.s. 7>oiiIct i*c Co., Rue Baineci .31 — Paris. Liibocker Machine Co., (icrinany. Pi ii .-'man Bros., lloldernt'ss Foundry, lliill. LocoiDotioes. — Manninsil <>f variou.«> Articlfs fiotn ox Ship, Livoipool tn Uiiil.viiy Station or (/Jina! Wlmil", Miiiu lii".tor. A.tkw,-2..cwt ... ,uui iri^c^e. 'At.^z.o,j ^\«::;ti:'i -::--! • ,..%,.. 'I'liUl ('(ittmi. \\\'<\ Sui;;ir, luavcM (Id iliiniKiif'l iillCDIl -.iud IllUllS. . . 'rinii'il iiicatH T. ii (itiiiii. wlii'iit ill micki*. KiM!t, iiniiiKi'S I'l'trolviiiii Tiill.m In 111 ore Tiinter 'lnwii Dui'ii. 3 ,S ti 2 I Hiirv-'f. -IllTlllKt'. (1. 1 3 I t( 1 10 I 2 'J *J 1 5 1 4 ^ ■> 1 2 .1 1 2 7 1 ! 1 4 H 3 1 3 I 7 1 1 H \ 4 \ 1) 2 -A I 1 1 ;< 1 2 1 1 1 9 : 1 1 1 1 <) I H 1 :( 1 :» 1 :« (1. 1 ;( 1 ;t 1 3 1 2 II 1 M 1 :< 1 3 1 2 '» 2 10 10 ll <) •» 10 10 (•) H !• i> i| •> 1 11 4 •> )') H 13 S IC. 5 17 11 12 2 15 17 .-) IH 2 it n ITi 14 5 IM li- »: 11 '.) 5 (2.) The cokt of bringing iho pumo ArticlcK to Miiiicln'stor by the Ship Cuniil iiu;lii(iii)g the Maximum (.'liargf-i in llif Hill. Arti'lfs [H r 20 ('wt. ^""'^'1'""'l f'ilaS i^Vharfago. Total jxtTiiii. Cf.tt^ni. \y.Kii SuKar, liiaves ... . . . . (in uiirefiiic'd H;ki)ii uiul liiiiiiK Tiiiiiril iiu-als Tra. (Jiaiii, wheat in «a<.'kj*. Fniit, oraiiKi'H PttroltMim Tallow Iron ore Timber s. (1. , 4 3 i 6 I 4 2 I 3 4 ! 8 5 6 10 3 8 5 4 7 4 2 2 1 3 » 1 1 o I i; II li 1 o I I) II It o li li li (i li I. .1. 1 1 '.I 1 li 1 1 1 II 2 o 1 n ,S s 111 1 2 'O A li s. ,1. 7 7 !l li s 4 11 i! 7 « I) X 7 4 10 I! 2 •. 11 f) 10 2 10 4 <) (3.) CoMi'AnisoN of tho Total Charges in No. 1 an'l No. 2, nhowint'- Total by (Janal.' Savings 1 • ! I 1 i 1 1 ~ ■ Se^ S3 5 H—- U i 5^ ^ M X s ■■3! s. d. I H. d. d. s. d. d. M. d. Pi..sHitcost... 13 8 lie 5 17 11 12 2 1.", Ii Co.> ;< u v> 1 1 ■l;i r, 9 7 I 5 1 I 8 10 8 ' 7 8 : 4 1 4 8 I i I I I e1 4^ Copy of Plan Ihandi'd to in at Manchester, SOth Jajiuaiuj, 181 Liverpool A 1 t Mm§ f ; »• ^r ^ XTi' handed to me hy Mr. E. Leader Williams, 0th January, 189 1. THOMAS M0:NR0, M. Inst. C. E. B- H m 1 IK A 1 Liverpool Mancheater iiverpool, "Warrington and Madoheater, Kailway S !H H IP' o o « > _X' o o X . L K V KL O F H I O H W A T K R Q_£ j:gUlNO CTlAl. SPF HOI O M JUL. C A N ,\ 1. Manohester; Ship Oaual Datum 2.1 rON BROOK i M m K f 1 H > c )UIN0CT1A1. SPRING TIDES 5 u n 2 K 2 U O u gUAV DOCKS i o M M DC z o tZ H u - < a is X — ^ 2 a ri ' IS - ^ ^ t H > d -> -J o 5< X 'J ^ !:: , S 8 d a ZJ 5z s « J. M a :;; < r.2 g u I i u z g Fi i^' S ? 2; S !^ ° £ ° z § 5 ? 2 2 H z p r-" X U> 3: >Z r< 2 4 * ^ a a a . ' u;-« 2« » i X 1 1 18 r 2 2 5E g ^ I LATCH FORD LOCKS i Z ' " " , X N 5. 6 1 -^4 ■ 1 1 NO 1 600 X RS '. FT IN 2 3SO X 45 ' RISE 10 n R 11 I N A R V W A T F. R _^ F V F T y \ - ' V- -— — — '■ ■ - O ' — — - >I|U- — ■ ■ . ^- - — — — — — _ — i S B 1 r o M OF 8 C ANA li 1 (0 «4 < 71; MILES ° O 9 S^iJ ' > ' T H I 2 F E F. T ^ / Vertical Scale for Section Scale for Plan and Horizontal Scale for Section £ 3 A- u J 8 n u u i J IRLAM LOCKS eoo X ns 360 X 4S ^f|}'ij:gyi}ii'j" Engineer's Offlce, Manchester Sh ,) Canul, Manohest&r, July, 1890. iAtilES MODE WHEEL LOCKS 'A \ii 0. c a •< o as o RISE 13 Q DOCKS M O o in y. u Q O QRUINARY WATER LEVEL, liUllO :l1 K < WAI. I'j MILES MINIMUM BOTTOM i () lAL LKNGTH TO V/ODLN S! WIDTH 170 FEET FOOTBRIDGE ^^s' . M ! 1 IS b