.>^. «> 
 
 IMAGE EVALUATION 
 TEST TARGET (MT-3) 
 
 #/ 
 
 
 ML// ^^7^^ M 
 
 1.0 If 1^ l&i 
 
 I.I 
 
 1.25 
 
 ut bi 122 
 
 If m 
 T IS 110 
 
 1.8 
 
 U ■1.6 
 
 U 
 
 V] 
 
 <p^ 
 
 A 
 
 ^^' ' c%;^ ^'^ 
 
 '^. 
 
 '^ .>^ 
 
 %:^».^'*'" 
 %.>? 
 
 
 °f2 
 
 M 
 
 Photographic 
 
 Sciences 
 Corporation 
 
 23 WEST MAIN STREET 
 
 WEBSTER, N.Y. 14580 
 
 (716) 872-4503 
 
 A 
 
CIHM/ICMH 
 
 Microfiche 
 
 Series. 
 
 CIHM/ICMH 
 Collection de 
 microfiches. 
 
 Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions / Institut Canadian de microreproductions historiques 
 
Technical and Bibliographic Notes/Notes tachniquas at bibliographiquas 
 
 The Institute has attempted to obtain the best 
 original copy available for filming. Features of this 
 copy which may be bibliographically unique, 
 which may alter any of the images in the 
 reproduction, or which may significantly change 
 the usual method of filming, are checked below. 
 
 
 
 D 
 
 D 
 
 □ 
 
 D 
 
 D 
 
 Coloured covers/ 
 Couverture de couleur 
 
 I I Covers damaged/ 
 
 Couverture endommag^e 
 
 Covers restored and/or laminated/ 
 Couverture restaur^e et/ou pelliculie 
 
 □ Cover title missing/ 
 Letit 
 
 titre de couverture manque 
 
 I I Coloured maps/ 
 
 Cartes g6ographiques en couleur 
 
 Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ 
 Encre de couleur (i.e. autre que bleue ou noire) 
 
 I I Coloured plates and/or illustrations/ 
 
 Planches et/ou illustrations en couleur 
 
 Bound with other material/ 
 Relid avec d'autres documents 
 
 Tight binding may cause shadows or distortion 
 along interior margin/ 
 
 Lareliure serr6e peut causer de I'ombre ou de la 
 distorsion le long de la marge int6rieure 
 
 Blank leaves added during restoration may 
 appear within the text. Whenever possible, these 
 have been omitted from filming/ 
 II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajouties 
 lors d'une restauration apparaissent dans ie texte, 
 mais, lorsque cela itait possible, ces pages n'ont 
 pas iti film^es. 
 
 Additional comments:/ 
 Commentaires suppldmentaires; 
 
 L'Institut a microfilm^ le meilleur exemplaire 
 qu'il lui a 6ti possible de se procurer. Les details 
 de cet exemplaire qui sont peut-dtre uniques du 
 point de vue bibliographique, qui peuvent modifier 
 une image reproduite, ou qui peuvent exiger une 
 modification dans la m^thode normale de filmage 
 sont indiqu6s ci-dessous. 
 
 I I Coloured pages/ 
 
 D 
 
 Pages de couleur 
 
 Pages damaged/ 
 Pages endommagies 
 
 Pages restored and/oi 
 
 Pages restaur^es et/ou pellicul^es 
 
 Pages discoloured, stained or foxe< 
 Pages ddcolories, tachet^es ou piqu6es 
 
 Pages detached/ 
 Pages d^tachdes 
 
 Showthrough/ 
 Transparence 
 
 Quality of prir 
 
 Qualiti inigale de I'impression 
 
 Includes supplementary materia 
 Comprend du materiel supplementaire 
 
 Only edition available/ 
 Seule Edition disponible 
 
 I — I Pages damaged/ 
 
 r~~| Pages restored and/or laminated/ 
 
 r~| Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ 
 
 I I Pages detached/ 
 
 r~~] Showthrough/ 
 
 r~~1 Quality of print varies/ 
 
 I I Includes supplementary material/ 
 
 r~n Only edition available/ 
 
 Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata 
 slips, tissues, etc., have been refilmed to 
 ensure the best possible image/ 
 Les pages totalement ou partiellement 
 obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata, une pelure, 
 etc., ont 4t^ filmdes d nouveau de facon d 
 obtenir la meilleure image possible. 
 
 This item is filmed at the reduction ratio checked below/ 
 
 Ce document est filmi au taux de reduction indiqud ci-dessous. 
 
 10X 14X 18X 22X 
 
 26X 
 
 SOX 
 
 y 
 
 12X 
 
 16X 
 
 20X 
 
 24X 
 
 28X 
 
 32X 
 
Th« copy filmed httro hat b««n reproduced thanks 
 to the generosity of: 
 
 IVIedical Library 
 IVIcGill University 
 IVIontreal 
 
 L'exemplaire fllmA fut reproduit grice A la 
 ginirositA de: 
 
 IMedical Library 
 McGiil University 
 Montreal 
 
 The imagee appearing here are the best quality 
 possible considering the condition and legibility 
 of the original copy and in Iceeping with the 
 filming contract specifications. 
 
 Lee imsges suivantes ont #ti reproduites avec le 
 plus grand soin, eompte tenu de la condition et 
 de la nettet4de I'exemplaire filmi, et en 
 conformity avec les conditions du contrat de 
 fllmage. 
 
 Original copies in printed paper covers are filmed 
 beginning with the front cover and ending on 
 the last page with a printed or Illustrated impres- 
 sion, or the bacic cover when appropriate. All 
 other original copies are filmed beginning on the 
 first page with a printed or illustrated impres- 
 sion, and ending on the last page with a printed 
 or illustrated impression. 
 
 Les exemplaires originaux dont la couverture en 
 papier est imprimte sont filmte en commenpant 
 par le premier plat et en terminant soit par la 
 dernlAre page qui comporte une empreinte 
 d'impression ou d'illustration, soit par le second 
 plet, selon le cas. Tous les autrM exemplaires 
 originaux sont filmte en commenpant par la 
 premlAre page qui comporte une empreinte 
 d'impression ou d'illustration et en terminant par 
 la derniAre page qui comporte une telle 
 empreinte. 
 
 The last recorded frame on each microfiche 
 shall contein the symbol -i»> (meaning "CON- 
 TINUED"), or the symbol y (meaning "END"), 
 whichever applies. 
 
 Un dee symbolee suivants apparaftra sur la 
 demlAre image de cheque microfiche, selon le 
 cas: le symbols — *> signifie "A SUIVRE". le 
 symbols ▼ kignifie "FIN". 
 
 Maps, plates, charts, etc., may be filmed at 
 different reduction ratios. Those too large to be 
 entirely included in one exposure are filmed 
 beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to 
 right and top to bottom, as many frames as 
 required. The following diagrams illustrate the 
 method: 
 
 Les cartes, planchei, tableaux, etc., peuvent Atre 
 filmto A des taux de rMuction diff Arents. 
 Lorsque le document est trop grand pour Atre 
 reproduit en un seul clichA, il esc film6 d partir 
 de Tangle sup4rieur gauche, de gauche h droite, 
 et de haut en bas, en prenant le nombre 
 d'images nAcessaire. Las diagrammes suivants 
 illustrent la mithode. 
 
 1 t 3 
 
 t 
 
 t 
 
 i 
 
 ♦ 
 
 • 
 
 • 
 
"Re 
 
 ^^V^ouoJ-Ousr-^ i *^( 
 
 INTRODUCTION TO THE DISCUSSION 
 
 ON THE 
 
 RELATION OF RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS 
 
 TO DISEASES OF THE 
 
 Nervous System, Tiil)erciilosis and Rheumatism 
 
 By JAIVIES STEWART, M.D., 
 
 Profkssou f)i- Mkuicink ami C'i.inu ai, AIkdicini;, Mcr.ii.i. I'mvursity ; 
 
 I'llYSICIAN r.) IIIK HdVAI, \ K T.)iaA HOSI'ITAI,. 
 
 1{i::munted fbo.i tiik Monimiiai. Mi.Dicai, Jdi-iiNAi,, IlEiicMnKii, 'n^.il. 
 
HI 1 1 ■ i m um 
 
 INTRODUCTION TO 
 
 THE DISCUSSION ON THE RELATION OF RHEUMATOID 
 
 ARTHRITIS TO DISEASES OF THE NERVOUS 
 
 SYSTEM, TUBERCULOSIS, AND RHEUMATISM. 
 
 II Y 
 
 Jamks Stkwakt, M.D., 
 
 Professor of Medicine and Clinical Medicine, McGill University; Physician to the 
 
 Royal Victoria Hospital, Montreal. 
 
 Rheumatism in its acute and sub-acute arthritic and general mani- 
 festations, is a very common disease in thi.s country ; while rheuma- 
 toid arthritis is comparatively rare. I have been unable to collect 
 any evidence as to its comparative frcrjuency in Canada and the 
 United States, and it is doubtful whethe • our inoro vigorous Canadian 
 climate especially predispo.ses to it or no^. It is well known that both 
 in the United States and Canada, gouty arthi Itis is extremely rare. 
 Of the few cases that I have met with, the great majority were in 
 people who had previously lived in England, and who had suffered 
 before coming to this country, or had a vciy strong gouty predisposi- 
 tion. 
 
 Owing to the kindness of many of my fellow practitioners in this 
 city and the surrounding country, I have had an opportunity of study- 
 ing during the past three and a half years in the wards of the Royal 
 Victoria Hospital upwards of 40 cases of rheumatoid arthritis. An 
 analysis of these cases is the chief foundation for the remarks that 
 follow. 
 
 The number is small as compared with the e.Kperience of many phy- 
 sicians in England and the continent of Europe, but as far as I know 
 it is the largest number that has been reported on from any one hos- 
 pital on this continent. 
 
Of the 40 cases, twenty were males and twenty fi;niales. IJfiUally 
 the proportion between males and females is al)out five to one. 
 
 There was a family history of some foi'in of ilicimiutif affection in 
 eight eases, oi" tul)ereulosis in livr. and of a neurojiatliict tcndmey 
 in four cases. Unfortunately, little stress for useful mc(lieal work 
 can he laid on tlu; famil}' history olitaineil from hospitid patients. 
 Even well to do and educated ]ieoi)le oft<'n ,i;ivi', although uncon- 
 sciously, misleadin<f inforniation on such matters. 
 
 As to the exeitiny- causes of rheumatoid aithritis the followini;' were 
 note<.l. There was a history (jt "(jnorrha'a in more than HO pel' cent, 
 of all cases oeeurrin<; in miili'S, and in three of the male oiu^es there- 
 was a histoi'v of 2 or more attacks of ironorrho'ii. In the fennde 
 j)atients, howevi-r, there wiis with the exception of oiir ease an entire 
 ab.sei'je of .symptoms pointing' to a [last j^enito-urinaiy disturbance. 
 For a lon<' time it has been iau<![ht that there is an intimate connection 
 betwi'en uterine disease and rlieumatoi<l arthritis. In fact a veiy 
 ingenious theory as to the nature of the disease has been built upon 
 this alleged connection. But next to gonorrlxea, exposure to cold 
 was considered as the most likely exciting cause. It appeared to be 
 the sole or chief cause in five of the forty cases, which mr.y account 
 for the fact that in Canada the disease is rather frecpiently met with 
 in lumbermen. The next most frerpient cause was worr/. It was 
 said to have lieen present in four cases. In all four casts the worry 
 was of an unusually severe and prolonged character. In three caseS 
 alcoholism was at least a predisposing factor. Three patients had had 
 subcutaneous absces.ses, two had had double otitis media, two influenza 
 and two tonsillitis. Typhoid fever, whooping cough and diphthci'ia 
 were each in one case considered as beinw the chief cause. 
 
 In several cases two or more of the above mentioned causes were 
 present, while in about 15 per cent, no cause could be ascertained. 
 It will be noticed that in fully 50 per cent, of the cases the patient had 
 previously had some infectious trouble, the most frequent being gon" 
 orrh(Ea, but only in two of the gonorrhceal cases was there a history 
 pointing to gonorrha^al rheumatism. In both cases the gonorrh(i?al 
 arthritis was confined to a single joint, but there afterwards developed 
 a polyai'ticular rheumatoid arthritis. It appears as if the infection of 
 one joint predisposed to a general joint affection. It is worthy of 
 note that three patients had recently had subcutaneous abscesses and 
 two a double otitis media. 
 
 I will now take up the consideration of the more immediate object 
 of this paper viz., a discus.sion of the relations existing between 
 nervous disease, tuberculosis, rheumatism and r}iPumatoid arthritis. 
 
3 
 
 I. The relation Itotweon rhojimatolil 'irtlirltis Hn<I ncrvims iliseoM. 
 
 Tliti peculiar joint artoctioii met with in cases of talx's dorsalis 
 first fully descrihed l»y Charcot, presents many features hoth clinical 
 and anatomical similar to those of rheumatoid arthritis. It was, I 
 believe Remak who first, in l.S(i:i, drew attention to this striking,' re- 
 semblance, and who sufj^jnreftt'.'d the possible spinal ori;^nn of rheumatoid 
 arthritis. Much has been written lately on the similarity. Tn the 
 <,'reat majority of stanihird medical works of the present day, the 
 favourite theory for the explanation of the disease is that it is bioufjlit 
 aliout by chanifes in the spinal cord. IJut \ -hen tlie whole subjt^ct is 
 carefully considered it is dilUcult to understuiid why such a view has 
 becfjine so popular. It certainly has no sullicient ground work to 
 entitle it to l)e generally accepted as a full and true explanation of 
 the nature of rheumatoid arthritis. The reasons usually advanced for 
 adopting the nervous origin of rheumatoid arthritis, are these : 
 
 1. The fact, that in certain diseases of the spinal cord, as tabes, 
 syringomyelia, progressive nuiscular atro|jhy, joint changes of a 
 somewhat similar character are met with. 
 
 2. The very frequent early and pronounced mu.scular atroi)hy oV»- 
 served in cases of rheinnatoid arthritis. 
 
 3. The history fre(|uently obtained of eau.sos, having a markerl 
 effect in lowering the resisting power of the central nervous system to 
 disease. 
 
 4. The frequent onset of rheumatoid arthi-itis with symptoms of a 
 nervous character, .symptoms pointing to a central or peripheral nerve 
 disturliance, and there can be no (juestion that in a certain proportion 
 of cases about the first symptoms complained of are tingling and numb- 
 ness in the extremitie.s. In 10 of my 40 cases such an onset was 
 described, and simultaneously with this perverted sensory disturbance 
 or soon subsequent to it, stiffness of the joints supervened. 
 
 The neihropathic arthropatlik's. In a number of well recognised 
 lesions of the central nervous system marked joint changes are 
 occasionally met with. They are probably more frequently seen in 
 syringomyelia than in tabes dorsalis. They are rare in progressive 
 muscular atrophy, hemiplegia anil ataxic paraplegia. 
 
 The joint changes in tabes may take the form of atrophy or hyper- 
 trophy of the structures entering into its formation, or there may be 
 atrophy of some parts and hypertrophy of others. Usually the onset 
 is very sudden and painless, and a characteristic feature is sudden 
 distension of one of the larger joints, the knee generally, from fluia 
 effused in the synovial sac. This effusion may disappear after a 
 time without permanently damaging the functions of the joint. 
 
Mori! frofniciitly .sij^ns of ilisorf^ani/ation In-eoinr' iip|>arfnt. The car- 
 tilai^t! is (Icstioycfl. Tin: licads of the Itoiics waste mid soinctiuH's 
 bony ovi'r^rro\vtl)SH])i'infj; from tin- eritls aiul tlu-y aiv also i.iot with in 
 the iK'ri-articuhir .structures. 
 
 Occa.sionally the liuih hecunies cnoriuously cnlarijed from the 
 exce.ssiv(( jirowth of lioiic, ami as sodn as the chaii'it's in the honts set in 
 there is no tendency to repair. Clinically tliere is little or no dif- 
 ference bt'tween the joint att'ections of tabes and syrini^om^clia. 
 Anatomically they also correspond. In a few ea.ses of tabes the Joints- 
 have lieen openeil early in the di.sease, and in se\eral ea.ses of 
 .syrine;()myelia. where s\ir;;ieal intctrferenoe was consideied necessary 
 I'arly in the disease, j^ood opportunities were pre.sentitl of a.seertain- 
 in|f the exact changes present in tlu; joint liefore the destructive pro- 
 cess b.ad made much nroeress. The cartilage is found to lie more or 
 less destroyeil and covered here and there with polypoid ^^nnvtlis. 
 In .several cases the ends of the bones weii; <lisea.sed, there being 
 usually a considerable increase in the cortical substance and a wast- 
 ing of the spongy .structure. The caps-ule is found gieatly expanded 
 from'tlie accumulation of the polypoid growths which vaiy much in 
 S' :e, the smaller ones being soft and vascular and the larger ones hard 
 in consistence and containing but little V)!ood. Bony plates are also 
 to be met with on the internal surface of th(; capsule. Tht; above 
 intracapsular changes are precisely like those met with in cases of 
 rheumatoid arthritis that have been operated on earl}' in this 
 disca.se. There hiis been for .some time a difference of opinion as 
 to th(! .structures lirst involved in rheumatoid arthritis, .some con- 
 tending that it first shows itself in the cartilage, while others 
 think that it ari.ses primarily in the .synovial membrane. Early 
 changes, however, are met with in both structures, which are inrlis- 
 tinguishable from those seen in syringomyelia and in tabes. In 
 nervous arthropathies effusion into the Joints is more common and 
 reaches a greater degree than it does in rheumatoid arthi'itis. The 
 destructive process reaches a greater degree and runs a much more 
 rapid course in the former than it does in the latter. The clinical 
 difference between the two is much greater than the anatomical. 
 Rheumatoid arthritis is attended by great pain, while the nervous 
 arthropathies usually run a painless course. The Vuuhs in the latter 
 can be bent in all directio • without causing any pain, the extreme 
 flexibility of the joints bein^, lUe to the .stretching of the ligaments and 
 other structures l)y the copious effusion into the joint. 
 
 Two different views are at present held as to the nature of the 
 nervous arthropathies, one being that they are brought or by inter- 
 
fereuce witli tlio function of the so-culled troiihie centnss for the Joints 
 in the spinal conl. Ft is ciiiiniud that tin; ili';^onorativo process in tahes 
 and syrinirouiyelia involves such parts in the spinal cord. The other 
 view, and one that is steadily i^aining Lfi'ound, is that owitis;' to the 
 lessened or disturhed si'iisation so fnMU'.eiitly met with in both tal)es 
 and syringomyelia, traumatic inthn'iices have much to do with setting 
 up the inHammatory action, and according to this view it is not neces- 
 sary to assume the presence in the cord of centres having a trophic 
 iuHu. nee (jver the joints, the <lestruetion of which Wrings al)out the 
 changes. In the great majority of eases of both tabetic and syringo- 
 myelic arthritis, a iiistory of a fall or injury is obtainable Tin re is 
 nothing special in the joint changes that could not Ite explained by 
 an inHanuuatory action excited l>y an injury. The clinical difference 
 is accounted for by the sensory disturlmnce in the joints, anil all 
 things considered, it appears mori consistent with ol)served fact to 
 explain the arthi'itis on the assumption of an injury than that it is 
 brought about i>y the involvement of certain deiinite parts of the 
 spinal cord. 
 
 The (jUestion of tlie cause and nature of the joint changes m tabes, 
 syringomyelia, etc, is still a mattei- of doubt. It is u)iwise to speak 
 too positively on this matter. There is, liowt'Ver, very strong ground 
 for taking the view that the joint changes in rheumatcnd arthritis are 
 not due to disease of the spinal cord. .ShouKl such changes be brought 
 about in that way, it is hardly conceivable that they should not 
 present evidence of not only microscopic, Init mucroscopic changes in 
 the spinal cord. In several cases the spinal cord has been c.vamiucd in 
 rheumatoid arthritis after dt;ath, and no abnormal appearances have 
 been discovered Folli in two cases saw some wasting of the cells of 
 the anterior coriiua, but elsewhere nothing. Changes in the peri- 
 pheral nerves have also been met with in a few cases, but neither the 
 slight changes descriljcd by Folli or the nerve changes are constant, 
 and, therefore, cannot be considered as .sufficient cai ''the joint 
 
 changes in rlu^umatoid arthriti.s. 
 
 It is difficult to explain the marked and comparatively early atrophy 
 of the muscles that occurs in rheumatoid arthritis. It does not 
 correspond clinically to that met with in anterior polio-myelitis_ 
 for we do not meet with any marked reaction of degeneration. The 
 electric reaction is often normal, and is rarely more than slightly 
 lowered. The view commonly held at present is that the wasting is 
 brought about in a reflex manner. This theory receives support from 
 the experiment of Raymond that division of the posterior spinal 
 roots prevents wasting from taking place in joint disease. It must 
 
(i 
 
 ixi rt'iiuMiilM'n'il that ntropliy of tlic muscles takes place in all t'uniis 
 '>r chronic arthritis, ami even in snliacute cases ; syphilitic and 
 tuherculous and ha-Mitiphilic arthritis are ire(|Uently attended l)y 
 atrophy. No matter what the canst! is then, it must he due in the first 
 place to some chani^e in the joint, and not to any supposed chaiif^es 
 in the spinal cord. It is in the first ])!ace an arthritic aU'ectioJi. 
 
 The fact that causes that are well known to i)rin^ ahout a lowered 
 resistin<^ ptnver of the nervous system are often prominent in rheuma- 
 toid arthi'itis does not directly prove the involvement of the nervous 
 sy.stem. .Such causes act as well on the jufeneral nutrition as on the 
 joints. 
 
 The not infre(|uent ))erverte<l sensory disturliance preceilinj^ the 
 <aiset of rlu'umatoid arthritis has lieeii advanced as tending to prov«! 
 the nervous orij.'-in of the rlisease. I have never heen able to ascer- 
 tain that there was an ohjt-ctive ilisturhance of sensation in rheuma- 
 toid arthritis. No matter how extreme the muscular atrophy, it is 
 not attended with any lo.ss of sen.sation. Sulijective disturhanct; of 
 sejisation is a fretpient symptom of many jfeneral conditions, due 
 {generally to auto-intoxication from the intestinal canal, and its fre- 
 (|uent presence in rheumatoid arthritis does not, as far as I can judge, 
 lend n)U(;h support to the neuropathic origin of this disea.se. 
 
 On the whole it must \n> considered that the evidence pointing to a 
 nervous origin of rheumatoid arthritis is very meagre. 
 
 II. T/ui Reldtion of Ji/i<niinat(ml Arthritis to Tuberculosis. — Pul- 
 monary and other forms of tuberculosis appear to be more frequent in 
 the families of sufferers from rheumatoid arthritis than they are in 
 other non-tuberculosis diseases. In the series of 40 reported cases such 
 a history was only obtained in three cases, a pi'oportion not greater, if 
 as great a.s, in people in good health. J^uller, in a report on 119 cases 
 of rheumatoid arthiitis, found a history of phthi.sis in 23 cases. 
 Charcot and sevei-al other observers have found tuberculosis of the 
 lungs and lymphatic glands not infrequent antecedents in their ex- 
 perience. \ few cases have been published where both disea.ses were 
 apparently present at the same time, one joint l)eing tuberculous, 
 while others resembled the joint lesions of rheumatoid arthritis. 
 There i.s, however, nothing in common l)etween the two diseases, 
 although in some respects there is a similarity between them. Tuber- 
 culosis is an infectious disease, prone to attack those who have an 
 inherited predisposition to it. There is every reason to Vtelieve that 
 rheumatoid arthritis is also of an infectious nature, nor is there any 
 doubt that there is an inheritance of what we call an arthritic 
 diathesis ; that is an inheritance which involves a tendency to intlam- 
 
Illation of iuiiits iitnl Hl.n)n.s stnictun's. Indiivctly, a tultL'ivuloiis tcii- 
 fleiicy may, l»y lowcriiij; tliu rt'sistaiicc, tcml to Itriiij,' alioiit a rluMiiiui- 
 toid artliritiH, and it is only in this si'iist-, as I understand it, that 
 thoi'«! is a coinu'ction Ix'twccn tlic two diseases. 
 
 III. The, RcldJioii af lihi'miinlit'id Arlhrilis to Aciiir, Siihiiridi' <ni(l 
 (!hn>n'ic liht'ii iniitiniii. — Is rheunmtoid arthritis a Fro(|n»!nt or an occa- 
 sional continuation or result ot" an attack of acute, sultacute or chronic 
 rheumatism ? This rjuestion is constantly heiuL; forced on ev(;ry 
 physician who sees much of this dist^ase. In a very considerahle 
 pro)K)rti(ai of ail cases a history of acute or suKaciite rheiimutism is 
 fortlu'omine', hut the vaj,fueness with which the word rheumatism is 
 ,t;'enerally emplo^'ed, renders the clinical hi.storyof such fuses far from 
 exact. Makin<ij a certain allowance for this, there can l)e no (|uestion 
 that a certain, even a very considerahle numlu'r of cases that are imlis- 
 tinnuishahh^ in the lieninninn' from acute rheumatism develop after- 
 wards, it may lie gradually or more or less suddenly, into rheumatoid 
 arthiitis. In four of my 40 cases of rheumatoid arthritis there was 
 a very clear history of acute rheumatism. In tun of the foui' cases, 
 there were found the physical siyns of ortranie disease of the heart. In 
 one, a female, aged 85, there was both mitral and aortic disease. She 
 was said to have had rln-umatic fevei' at 10 and sevei-al suhacute 
 rheumatic attacks subsequently. Whe.i under tib.servation in 1<S94, 
 she presented all the marked symptoms of a poly-articular rheunuitoid 
 arthritis. In a second, a female, age<l 70, was under observation dur- 
 ing the early stage of her illness, which clinically was not to be 
 distinguished fi-oin an ordinary attack of acute rheumntism. Early 
 the physical signs of mitral disease were discovered, and after several 
 I'elap.ses of the arthritis, the signs and symptoms of rheumatoid 
 arthritis gradually developed. There can, I think, be no (piestion 
 that in both of these cases we have a rheumatoid arthritis gradually- 
 developing as the result of I'cpeated acute rheumatic attacks. In 
 neither case was there a history pointing to an hereditary tendency 
 to rheumatism. 
 
 In thirteen cases, the onset resembled that of an ordinary subacute 
 rheumatism, pain and swelling of the joints being the first and only 
 prominent features of the early stage. The rule in such cases being 
 that after lasting a few days the intensity of the symptoms subside, 
 but only for a short time. Repeated attacks occur, till finally we have 
 a fully established case of rheumatoid arthritis. In twelve cases the 
 onset was very slow, with stiffness and swelling of one or more joints, 
 coming and going till finally the condition was one of undoubted 
 rheumatoid arthritis. In the great majority of the cases of chronic 
 
8 
 
 onset some time passed before the characteristic changes of rheuma- 
 toid arthritis were developed. 
 
 It will be observed that in a very large proportion of the cases the 
 beginnings of the disease were the same as in ordinary rheumatism. 
 In at least .30 per cent, the onset was either that of acute or sub- 
 acute rheumatism — the unavoidable inference being that a very 
 intimate connection exists between rheuniatoid arthritis and acute and 
 subacute rheumatism. How is it that the great majority of cases 
 of both acute and subacute rheumatism recover perfectly and that a 
 few cases do not, but eventually go on to destructive changes in 
 the joints. It is a well recognized fact that irrespective of the cardiac 
 changes neither acute nor subacute rheumatism are followed by any 
 permanent damage of the structures involved. 
 
 There is no recognised well marked dividing line between clu'onic 
 rheumatism and rheumatoid arthritis. 
 
 We meet with all jxjssible grades of ditierence from paroxysmal, 
 slight pain anil stiti'ness of one or more joints, up to cases in which 
 nearly all the joints of the body tirv practically useless from destruc- 
 tion of theii' tissues and the formation of new bony tissue. We 
 characterize the cases at one end of this scale as chronic rheumatism, 
 and at the othei- end as rheumatoid arthi'itis. But the naming of the 
 cases that we meet in the borderland between these two extremes is 
 a difficult matter. One and the same case may be called by com- 
 petent observers, chronic rheumatism or rheumatoid arthritis. This 
 goes to show that there is nothing distinctive about the clinical fea- 
 tures of these cases. It is only in marked types of rheumatoid 
 arthritis that a diagnosis is easily made, and one that would be 
 accepted universally. 
 
 In Germany and France it is the custom to call cases chronic 
 rheumatism which in England would be called rheumatoid arthritis. 
 There are no anatomical differences between boi'derland cases of 
 chronic rheumatism and rheumatoid arthritis. In both we find dis- 
 tension of till capsnlo from pcjlj'poid growths and the accumulation of 
 serum. 
 
 There are grounds f(jr hoping that the bacteriological examination 
 of the joints may help to clear up the difficulties suri'ounding the 
 nature of chronic rheumatism and rheumatoid arthi'itis. 
 
 As 3'et we have no absolute proof uf acute rheumatism being due 
 to a micro-organism ; there are strong reasons, however, for believing 
 that such is the ease. Riva, of Parma, in a recent paper has made 
 a very important contribution tending to prove the infectious nature 
 of this disease. Until comparatively recently thei'e was no evi- 
 
 I 
 
9 
 
 I 
 
 I 
 
 dence pointing to the microbic origin of rheumatoid arthritis, but 
 from the bacteriological researches of Schiiller of Berlin, Bannatyne 
 and Blaxall, and of Chaufford and Ramond, it is highly probable that 
 we have here to do with an infectious disease. The acute and subacute 
 poly-articular forms of rheumatoid arthritis have all the clinical 
 characters of an infection. Schiiller, who has practised arthrectomy in 
 many cases of rheumatoid arthritis,^has examined the tissues for jnicro- 
 organisms and has constantly ftiunda small bacillus present and occa- 
 sionally an agglomeration of micrococci. He has also made cultures 
 from the fluid in the joints removed by tapping. Ho found bacilli 
 develop on various media. The best stain is carbolised fuchsin. In- 
 noculation into the knee of a rabbit produced an arthritis resembling 
 that of chronic rheumatism, but withe at any changes in the carti- 
 lages or bones. 
 
 Drs. Bannatyne and VVohlmann, of Bath, working with Dr. Blaxall, 
 of London, have demonstrated the presence of an organism which is 
 said to be constant in its characteristics. It is a very small bacillus, 
 presenting marked polar .staining. It was found pre.seut in the 
 .synovial fluid in 24 out of 25 ca.ses examined. It was al.so found 
 in the blood in three out of Ave cases. A bacteriological examina- 
 tion was made of the synovial fluid from joints diseased from other 
 causes with a negative result as far as the special bacillus is con- 
 cerned. The observers have not succeeded by re-inoculation as yet 
 in producing the original disease in animals. 
 
 Ciiauftbrd and Ramond have still more recently found in the 
 synovial fluid in cases of rheumatoiil arthritis a diplo-bacillus. They 
 also found the same organism in the swollen lymphatic glands in the 
 neighbourhood of the <li.seased joints, Imt did not succeed in culti- 
 vating the bacillus. 
 
 Much work yet requires to be done in the bacteriology of this 
 disease before a true estimate can l)e made of the value of tlio 
 researches referred to. In some points they all lack in the extreme 
 care that such work demands, and before they can be accepted the 
 work must be i-epeated by diti'erent observei's. 
 
 Prof. Baumler, of Freiburg, the most recent writer on this subject, 
 considers that it is highly probable that the disease is of an infectious 
 nature. At the recent meeting in Berlin of the Congress for Internal 
 Medicine, he read a very able paper on the subject. 
 
 I will conclude with the following sunnnary of the chief points in 
 this discussion. 
 
 1. Rheumatoid arthritis is a disease prone to occur in people of a 
 rheumatic tendency, and who have suflered from sub-acute rheumatic 
 
10 
 
 attacks. The presence; of infectious disease of any kind tends to in- 
 crease this tendency, as does also the operation of all causes havinj^ a 
 depressing influenet! on the resisting power of the nervoxis system 
 (won-y, exposure to cold, and triiumatism.) 
 
 2. There is no shai-p dividing line between certain cases of chronic 
 rheuniatisni and the earlier stages of I'heuniatoid arthritis. 
 
 3. There is not sufficient evidence to support the views commonly 
 held, as to the nervous origin of rheumatoid arthritis. 
 
 '. There is no direct relationship between tuberculosis and rheu- 
 matoid arthritis. 
 
 5. The polyarticular forms of rheumatoid arthritis have clinically 
 the features of an infectious di.sease. 
 
 6. The result of recent investigations points ver^' strongly to its 
 infectious nature. 
 
 I have only a few words to say on the ti'eatment of the disease, 
 especially on the ti'eatment by super-heated air baths. 
 
 It is universally recognized that the medicinal treatm.'ut is very 
 unsatisfactory. Whethei- surgical interference will ever become 
 practically applicable is difficult to say. Tiiere appears to be a field 
 for surgery in these cases. .Schuller, of Bt'rlin, and other Gei'man 
 surgeons have published results which certainly tend to make one 
 think that much may be accomplished in this way. Something also 
 may be accomplished by the injection into the diseased joints of 
 various antiseptic agents. Reports hy Schuller and others on this 
 way of dealing with the disease are more or less .satisfactory. 
 
 At the present time the most universally applicable and successful 
 method of dealing with early rheumatoid arthritis is by means of 
 baths of various kinds. 
 
 The Scotch douche is in certain cases a veiy valuaVjle means. It 
 consists in the direct application of an alternating stream of hot and 
 cold water. It promotes the absorption of the exudations into the 
 joint, and it also relieves pain. 
 
 Dry baths are, however, generally more effective than moist ones 
 The dry sand bath has for a long time been used with more or less 
 success. But in my opinion the most valuable of all methods of 
 treatment is the use of baths of super-heated diy air, after the Taller- 
 man method. It has Vteen used in 20 cases of rheumatoid arthi-itis 
 in the Royal Victoria Hospital during the past nine months with 
 gratifying results. 
 
 The apparatus consists of a copper cylinder, of various shapes and 
 sizes. The usually employed model is sufficieutl}' long to admit a lower 
 limb to some inches above the knee. By means of valve taps the 
 
11 
 
 moisture from the limb is expelled, so tlmt the nir in the chamber is 
 kept dry. The temperature in the chambei- is kepo usually from 240° 
 to 300°. The first marked effect is copious per«piration all over the 
 body. The puLse is increased froui 1.5 to 30 Itcats, and th(! tempera- 
 ture is usually elevated from 1° to 2°. 
 
 In all we have treated twi'nty cases with the hot iiir bath. In 
 fourteen of the twenty cases pain in the affected joints was present 
 and of a severe character. In the great majority of the cases the 
 relief was marked even after the first bath, and after several baths 
 the patient, except on movement, was practically free from pain. As 
 a result of this relief, sleep, which usually befoi-o was greatly dis- 
 turbed, becomes possible. In addition there was .some apparent change 
 foi* the better in nutrition. In spite of losing daily mon? than a 
 pound in weight from the loss of fluid by perspiration, the patient 
 u.sually steadily gains in weight. Gains of from three to four pounds 
 weekly have been (juite common. As regards the effect on the 
 affected joint it is various, depending on the amount of effusion and 
 the degree of (i.vclii/losis. 
 
 Generally a considerable increase i" the molality follows after the 
 use of a few baths. 
 
 It cannot be expected that restitution can take place in advanced 
 cases, but befon; nmch actual destruction takes place, there is eveiy 
 reason to look for a decided check to the progressive character of the 
 disease. 
 
 Dr. Shingleton Smith (Bristol) (juestioned whether the term 
 rheumatism should ever be used in connection with the disease, and 
 he preferred the term rheumatoid arthritis to that now advocated in 
 Germany by Dr. B umler, chronic pol^'^articular i-heumatism. He 
 believed that the ordinary theories of the di.sease failed to give a satis- 
 factory explanation of its phenomena, that it had no connection 
 with tubercle, syphilis or nerve disease, and that probably it had little 
 connection with ordinary acute and chronic rheumatism. One fact 
 mentioned by Dr. Stewart, that 30 per cent, of the male cases had a 
 history of gonorrlxea, gives us a clue to a more satisfactory view of 
 the nature of the malady ; it has been abundantly shown that 
 gonorrhoeal rheumatism is due to infection from the urethra, and is a 
 form of pyiemic infection due to the gonococcus. Is it not probable 
 that rheumatoid ai'thritis is also due to some microbic infection, and 
 that the coccus described by Drs. Bannantyne and Wohlnian, of Bath 
 and cultivated bj' Dr. Blaxall, may be the real cause of the polyarthritis 
 in its early stages, whereas the subsequent phenomeua are only the 
 sequelae of the arthritis itself ? This theory gives us a more hopeful 
 
12 
 
 view of the possibility of a more successful treatment before the 
 incurable deformities and other s(U|Uol8e have occurred. 
 
 Dr. LiND.SAY (Belfast) would base his remarks on twelve; or thirteen 
 years of liospital practice in Belfast, where the disease was frequent- 
 He had seen nothing to justify the theory (jf any special connection 
 between rheumatoid arthritis and tuberculosis. He had been much 
 struck with the nervous symptoms present in rheumatoid arthritis, 
 especiall}' the atrophy of musch's. He was ii.<clined to suspect that 
 these .sj'mptoms were due to chanj^es in tht- peripheral nerves, po.ssibly 
 due to some toxic influence. He thought, there was a real and fre- 
 (|uent connection between rheumatoid arthritis and chronic articular 
 rheumatism. He had seen many cases where the former had super- 
 vened upon the latter, and had seen other cases in which he found it 
 quitv-^ impossible to draw^ the line between the two diseases. He 
 thought the two conditions presented considerable analogy as regards 
 their etiology. As regards treatment, he had not found much advan- 
 tage from the ordinary anti-rheumatic remedies. He thouglit cod-liver 
 C'il and a general tonic line of treatment offered the greatest prospect 
 of benefit. 
 
 Dr. A. Jacobi (New York), .said : In his very concise and compre- 
 hensive paper Dr. Htewart had omitted om.^ thing — namely, to tell us 
 what he meant or we are to mean by arthritis deformans or rheuma- 
 toid arthritis. We have been told about lioundai-y lines and gradual 
 transitions, but I have been unal)le to learn his opinion of thy patho- 
 logical anatomy. One thing is certain : it is not acute articular 
 rheumatism and not a sequela of it. The latter is an affection 
 (anatomically speaking) of the .synovial membranes, never of the 
 cartilage. Arthritis deformans is an affection (again anatomically 
 speaking) of the cartilage, which, w'hile fii'st e.xhibiting prolifei-ation, 
 terminates in atrophy and absolute lo.ss, and finally in circular hyper- 
 trophy and eburnation round the atrophic cartilage. From gout it 
 differs liy the absence of uratic deposits. I cannot tell what arthritis 
 deformans is : the pixvsence of cocci in a few cases does not prove the 
 latter to be the cause. It may be that in the future it will be best to 
 study the cases of arthritis deformans in childhood, where it may be 
 expected to be primary an<l uncomplicated. Two such cases in girls 
 of 10 and of 6 years were published here in Montreal by Dr. Nicholls ; 
 one was published by Dr. Koplik (girl of 7). In none was there acute 
 rheumatism or any rheumatism previously. As far as the latter is 
 concerned, we should :.'ot use the term except in acute rheumatism . 
 The best treatment had been in his hands arsenic in increasing doses, 
 continued months and m .nths with occasional interruptions, and the 
 iralvanic current. 
 
13 
 
 Dr. J. C. Wilson said : The use of tlie term rheumatism is a stumb- 
 ling block in the way o*^' our knowledge of diseases of the joints. It 
 .should be restricted to the disease known as acute rheumatism, or 
 better, as rheumatic fe\er. Such a restriction would clear the way 
 for a bcttel^abderstunding of the medical arthropathies There are 
 various foi-ms of joint di.seases, very different in tlieir clinical mani- 
 festation. s, which must be legarded as arthritis deformans. Many 
 cases in their early course progress by attacks ?resend)ling those of 
 subacute rheumatic fever. Tliese cases suggest a reseml)lance to that 
 disea.se which is only superlicial, bnt lend support to the view that 
 the di.sea.se may be of inicrobic origin. 
 
 Dr. FuKDiCHKJlv C. Slf.VTTiX'K (Boston ) .said : I risi; with some diffi- 
 dence, having unfortunately been prevented from hearing Dr. 
 Stewart, lait venture to touch briciti}' on .sevtM'al points. In the first 
 place, I cordially concui' in the opinion which .seems to be generally 
 held that our ignorance with reefard to this di.sease is lamentable 
 Pathologically- and therapeutically alike it is one of the opprobria of 
 medicine. Since the appearance of the observations of Smith and 
 Lindsay, Dr. J. E. Goldthwaite, of Boston, has been carefully studying 
 the fluid obtained from joints affected with arthritic deformans where 
 such could be had. Thus far he has not confirmed Smith and Lindsay s 
 observations, having found no organisms of any knid. Some eight 
 years ago my attention was forcibly arrested by an article in the 
 American Joitrrtal of Medical Sciences by Blake. He relates several 
 cases which seem to conclusi\ely show that stippuration, especially' if 
 concealed, may have the most intimate relation with arthritic disease, 
 non-rheumatic, .similar to arthritis deformans in .some I'espects. One 
 of these cases was that of a clergyman of middle age who became the 
 subject of severe, intractable, advancing arthritic disea.se. Blake found 
 a nasty condition of things beneath a toot'i plate, careful attention to 
 which was followed by complete recovery. Since then I have care- 
 fully sought for concealed suppuration in all cases of chronic and 
 obstinate arthritis which have come under my observation. I have 
 failed to find such save in one case — one of advanced and severe 
 arthritis deformans anfl psoriasi.s. In this patient I found a neglected 
 Riggs's disease. The teeth were thoroughly treated by a competent 
 dentist, and a very sharp acute exaet'rbation of the arthritis pi-omptiy 
 followed. There would .seem to be an analogy between Blake's cases 
 and those of gonorrhoeal synovitis. I trust that any gentleman whose 
 attention may have been called to this point will speak of it. 
 
 Dr. MooiiHOUSE said : I believe that there is an intimate relation- 
 ship between arthritis deformans and ordinary rheumatism, l)ut that 
 
14 
 
 the disease has advanced a stop farther in attacking the substance of 
 the synovial membranes and cartilages. I am (juite in accord with 
 ])r. Lindsay (Belfast) both as to cause and treatment, believing that 
 tonic treatment is the better plan, never having seen any benefit from 
 the ordinary antirheumatic treatment, tonics such aw^on, piinine, 
 arsenic, cod liver oil, etc. I do not think that any microscopical germ 
 has yet been di.scovered. 
 
 ])r. J. E. (iUAHA.M (Toronto) said: 'i'he <liagnosis lietween gout 
 and clu'onic rher.niatic arthritis has given me the greatest difficulty- 
 This, I suppo.--.', was not referred to by J)r. St(!wart, because the 
 differentiation between chronic rheumatism and arthritis deformans 
 is (|iiite sufficiently extensive for one discussion. 1 agree with I)r 
 Jacobi that we should have a clear idea of thc«pathology of the dis- 
 ease ; the hyperplasia and destruction of cartilage, and the eburnation 
 of the ends of bones are marked characteristics which differentiate 
 this disease from those affections of joints which are usually placed 
 under the head of chronic rheumatism. It is unfortunate that the 
 term "rheumatism" should be given to a number of joint affections 
 arising from causes altogeth(;r distinct from those of acute and .sub- 
 acute rheumatism. 1 have found arsenic one (;f the most valuable 
 remedies in the treatment of this very obstinate disease 
 
 Dr. G[HNKV (New York) expressed his inability to contribute to the 
 differential diagnosis between arthi-itis defoi'mans and I'heutnatism, or 
 even to the etiology and pathology. He failed to hear Dr. Stewart's 
 paper, but learning that this paper included a discussion of the treat- 
 ment by superheated dry air, believed that he ;night contribute his 
 experience which was in general t'.rms satisfactory. He had found 
 the hot-air treatment specially valuable immediately after surgical 
 means, such as breaking up adhesions or improving the position of 
 the limb. He called attention to the importance of protecting the 
 joint in examination by absolute immobilization, and of affording a 
 limited amount of protection on the subsidence of the exacerbation> 
 especially in the management of the knee, the ankle, and the elbow- 
 This he does by an appliance limiting the range of motion to that 
 allowed by Nature herself. He found valuable assistance in arsenic 
 and cod-liver oil. 
 
 Dr. Tyson (Philadelphia) thought the .subject thoroughly covered 
 by what had been said. Personally he inclined to the view that in a 
 certain number of cases the true rheumatic condition, or that gener- 
 ally conceded to be it, had at least a predisposing, and possibly through 
 its specific cause a direct causal relation to rheumatoid arthritis 
 However this may be, he considered that an infectious nature must 
 
^ 
 
 15 
 
 be concorlod in other cases, as attested by the large proportion (HO per 
 cent; in which there was previous presence of an infectious disease 
 reported liy Dr. Stewart. As to treatment, his e.xperience, like that 
 of others, luul liecii most uiisntisfiictory ; no cnics, hut simply pallia- 
 tion, followed in most cases hy relapsi'. His method of treatment has 
 invariably been by general rcstojative measures, amonif which he 
 included especially coddiver oil, arsenic, the bcht of food, and hyffiene. 
 Nbissage, too, he thouijjht was sometimes au ertieient palliative. 
 
 The Pkksidknt (Dr. Steplii'ii Maeken/ic) commenced by paying .1 
 tributes of res])ect to Dr. Stewart for his very alile handling of such a 
 ditticult subject as arthritis dei'ormaus. lie indieated that in his 
 (;xperience arthritis tlefoniians was a disciise distinct from rheumatism, 
 acute and chronic, and had nothing whatever to do with gout. Me 
 especially ilii'W attention to the class in which the |)iimary artlnitic 
 attack could not be <listinguislied from rheumntie fevei-, and recovery 
 took [ilace without any appreciable deformity of the joints, but which 
 subse(|Uently came under ob.sei'vation in an attack of ordinary and 
 undoubted subacute or chronic arthritis deformans. The late J )i-. H. 
 G. Sutton drew attenticm to the association of osti.'o-ai'thritis, rheu- 
 matism, and insanity in families. He also pointed out that though in 
 a considerable proportion of cases of arthritis deformans there was a 
 history of rheumatic fever, yet in not 1 per cent, of cases of arthritis 
 was heart di.scase found on post-mortem, examination. He (juit(! 
 agreed with .some previous speakers, especially Dr. J. C. Wilson, that 
 under the term arthritis di.'formans there was pi'ol)alily a number of 
 groups of cases which would ultimately be separated as clinical 
 entities.