.a5- 
 
 
 
 IJ^. 
 
 IMAGE EVALUATION 
 TEST TARGET (MT-3) 
 
 1.0 
 
 I.I 
 
 as, 
 
 ISi 
 
 lit 
 
 lit 
 
 ■ 23 
 
 3.2 
 
 M 12.0 
 
 
 1.25 III 1.4 
 
 1.8 
 
 1.6 
 
 ISOrnm 
 
 V 
 
 
 >1PPLIED^ IIVUGE . Inc 
 
 jss 1653 East Main street 
 
 ^^ i Rochester, NY 14609 USA 
 
 ^SS-^ Phone: 716/482-0300 
 
 JSr-.S== Fax: 716/288-5989 
 
 e 1993, Applied Image. Inc . All Rights Reserved 
 
 ^t 
 
 A 
 
 ^\' 
 
 # 
 
 ^\ 
 
 '« 
 
 

 if 
 
 CIHM 
 Microfiche 
 Series 
 (Monographs) 
 
 ICIMH 
 
 Collection de 
 microfiches 
 (monographies) 
 
 Canadian Instituta for Historical Microraproductions / Institut Canadian da microraproductions hittoriquas 
 
 O 
 
 \ 
 
Ttchnical and Bibliographic Nottt / Notts ttchniquit et bibliographiqucs 
 
 Thi 
 toi 
 
 The Institut* has atttmptad to obtain the bast original 
 copy available for filming. Foaturet of this copy which 
 may be bibliographically unique, which may alter any 
 of the images in the reproduction, or which may 
 significantly change the usual method of filming, are 
 checked below. 
 
 Coloured covers/ 
 Couverture de couleur 
 
 D 
 
 I I Covers damaged/ 
 
 Couverture endommag4e 
 
 Covers restored and/or laminated/ 
 Couverture resteurit et/ou pelliculAe 
 
 n 
 
 □ Cover title missing/ 
 Le 
 
 n 
 
 n 
 
 
 n 
 
 n 
 
 titre de couverture manque 
 
 Coloured maps/ 
 
 Cartes giographiques en couleur 
 
 Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ 
 Encre de couleur (i.e. autre que bleue ou noire) 
 
 Coloured plates and/or illustrations/ 
 Planches et/ou illustrations en couleur 
 
 Bound with other material/ 
 Relie avec d'autres documents 
 
 '• ight binding may cause shadows or distortion 
 along interior margin/ 
 La reliure serrte peut causer de I 'ombre ou de la 
 distorsion le long de la marge interieure 
 
 Blank leaves added during restoration may appear 
 within the text. Whenever possible, these have 
 been omitted from filming/ 
 II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajout^ 
 lors d'une resteuration apparaissent dans le texte, 
 mais, lorsque cela itait possible, ces pages n'ont 
 pas ete f ilmtes. 
 
 Additional comments:/ 
 Commentaires supplementaires: 
 
 L'Institut a microfilm* le meilleur exemplaire qu'il 
 lui a M possible de se procurer. Les details de cet 
 exemplaire qui sont p«ut-«tre uniques du point de vue 
 btbliographique, qui peuvent modifier unc image 
 reproduite. ou qui peuvent exiger une modification 
 dans la m^thode normale de f ilmage sont indiquis 
 ci-dessous. 
 
 □ Coloured pages/ 
 Pages de couleur 
 
 □ Pages damaged/ 
 Pages endommagtes 
 
 y I Pages restored and/or laminated/ 
 ilJ Pages restauries et/ou pelliculies 
 
 Pages discoloured, steined or foxed/ 
 Pages dUolotin, tacheties ou piquees 
 
 □ Pages deteched/ 
 Pages ditachies 
 
 QShowthrough/ 
 Transparence 
 
 Quality of print varies/ 
 Qualite in^le de I'impression 
 
 □ Continuous pagination/ 
 Pagmation continue 
 
 □ Includes index(es)/ 
 Comprend un (des) index 
 
 Title on header taken from:/ 
 Le titre de I'entAte provient: 
 
 Thi 
 poa 
 oft 
 filir 
 
 Ori( 
 b»g 
 th« 
 tior 
 othi 
 first 
 •Ion 
 orH 
 
 Tho 
 ohall 
 TINI 
 whic 
 
 Map 
 difft 
 ontir 
 bogii 
 right 
 roqui 
 mot^ 
 
 □ Title page of issue/ 
 Page de titre de la I 
 
 □ Caption of issue/ 
 Titre de depart de la 
 
 □ Masthead/ 
 Gener 
 
 ivraison 
 
 livraison 
 
 ique (periodiques) de la livraison 
 
 This Item is filmed at the reduction ratio checked below/ 
 
 Ce document est f ilme au taux de rMuction indiqui ci-dessous. 
 
 ^°* 14X 18X 
 
 12X 
 
 20X 
 
 22X 
 
 26X 
 
 7 
 
 30X 
 
 24 X 
 
 28 X 
 
 32 X 
 
^ 
 
 Th» copy ftlmvd h«r* hat b««n rtproduead thankt 
 to tho gonorosity of: 
 
 Library of tht National 
 Archival of Canada 
 
 Tho Imogos oppoaring hora oro tho boat quality 
 poaalbia conaldaring tha condition and lagibility 
 of tho originol copy and In kaoping with tha 
 fllmino contract apacif icatlona. 
 
 Original copioa in printed papar eovera ara fllmad 
 beginning iwlth tf«a front cover and ending on 
 tha laat page with a printed or llluatFatad Imprea- 
 aion. or tha back cover when eppropriata. All 
 other original coplea are filmed beginning on tho 
 firat page with a printed or lliuatratad imprea* 
 aion. and ending on the leat page with a printed 
 or Nfuatrated impreaaion. 
 
 The laat recorded frame on oech microfiche 
 ahaii contain the tymbol "-^ (meaning "CON- 
 TINUED"), or thoiymboi ▼ (meaning "END"), 
 whichever appiiaa. 
 
 Mapa. platea. charta. etc.. may be filmed at 
 different reduction ratioa. Thoae too large to be 
 entirely included in one expoaure »n filmed 
 beginning In the upper left hend comer, left to 
 right and top to bottom, at many framea at 
 required. The following diegramt llluttrata the 
 method: 
 
 L'exemplaira filmA fut raproduit grAc9 i la 
 gAnirotiti dt: 
 
 La biofiiothiqua dai Archival 
 nationalai du Canada 
 
 Let imeget tuivantat ont AtA raproduitet avtc la 
 plut grand toin. compta tanu da la condition at 
 da te nattat* da I axempiaira fiim«. at •n 
 conformity avac las conditiont du contrat da 
 flimaga. 
 
 Lea aaemplairat originaux dent la eouvartura an 
 papier eat lmprim«a tent filmte en commandant 
 par le premier plot et •n tarminant toit par it 
 demlAra page qui comporta una emprainta 
 d impreaaion eu d'llluttration, aoit par la tacond 
 plat, aelon le cot. Tout Km autret exempiairaa 
 originaux aont filmte an comman9ent par la 
 pramlAro page qui comporta une empreinte 
 dimpreaaion ou d ^lluttretion et en ferminant par 
 la darnlAre pege qui comporte une teila 
 empreinte. 
 
 Un dot tymbdea aulvantt apparattra aur la 
 darniire image da cheque microfiche, taion la 
 cat: la tymbeia -^ tignifia "A SUiVRE", la 
 aymbola ▼ tignifie "FIN". 
 
 Let cartea, planchat. tableaux, etc.. pauvent Atre 
 flimAt A dot taux da rAduetion diff Arantt. 
 Lortque le document ett trop grand pour Atra 
 raproduit en un teul cliehA. 11 ett filmA A portir 
 do I'angia tupArieur gauche, do geuche A droita. 
 et de haut en bat, en prenant la nombra 
 d'imaget nAcettaira. Let diegremmet tuivanta 
 illuttrent le mAthode. 
 
 1 2 3 
 
 4 5 6 
 
w 
 
 u . 
 
Welland Canal Commission, 
 
 ARGUMENT 
 
 (»!•' 
 
 J. C, RYKERT. Esq., 
 
 COUNSEL FOR MR. ELLIS, SUPT., ^ 
 
 HKK(.»KE 
 
 A. F. Wood, Esq,, Commissioner" 
 
 l.'lTHplbVKMHKK 18S9. 
 
'^.'^" ....' ™ ,. .'; -.,„:;;;;;: ,;::; r :;;""' '-r ■'■ 
 
 to Mr HvL-..it M,- , . ■ ''"*''■''"'*'»">'!<. on.t a Si, uinfs 
 
 ;™.fl :,u. ,■■",",:: :: ;^,r:; "'"' •";";■'""• •■""" '■■ " ■> 
 
 expense whrM wouM l',- eutiilf,! hv i> <.,. i i . .>. '"«i nnonifr th» 
 
 MR. -^I'^-'ALLl'M - -F c^ni'' i)roiiai'«(l 111 jr.ti, ti ., 
 
 THE COMMISSIONER-! .ould ... ,M ,o have v.nn h.l„ „. th. n.-r., ,r 
 'iifiiiiiing up. Ill "lie ni^>T»i ,)( 
 
 MR M<rM,Lr.M.-I IM uo. .on,. b»,o U., that ,.u,,.„„ , ,,„,„, ,, , ,. 
 
 THE COMMLSSIONI.:R-Vo„,. .t..t.,nK.nt .ou!d u..r ,. ..v,.i.„,. ,„,1 ..„„, 
 "..1v h. as explanatory, IV.m. you. .ta.nl,.oint of the evid.noe ^ 
 
 MR. MrCALLUM .-B,.r I want to «.t mv arKu.n.nt 
 
 MR. M.f.ALLlM- lor th.> binelit of the puhhr 
 
 .>iK. MCLALLLM— \ou have the evulcnci' m.l r ,..,.„» » 
 ...Id what 1 .ii,I pn.ve, an.i von .hall ,. th 1; vb the di. 'ir'7 "'' '° ''' 
 
 THE COMMISSIONER--, snppo. .„, o.L. t . , ' ^ ^uV. Hke t 
 ne a.(k..l in your pointing our p«rsoualJv s,u h po.„t. as you col,l . I? i , . . 
 vourevidcnoH, ,„d I w,ll t.ke notus; and ,f M R vkmVelsrto LP ^ ' ''^ 
 to any point, l.e thtnU ho ha. .nad. on hehair of 1, Jur s^M T' "'''°" 
 rha, ; hut I do not prop., to assume that e,,hor v ur a^u, e / 1 '^:' j" 
 
 a-guni.nt. IS goiuf? to he corrupt. I do not n,ean to ,JlT ^'''"' 
 
 a..^v.. „. th.. eviden,.. , propose to .j:,:ZZ:': Z^r "T "^, " ^" 
 ""'1e.-.tann why you .shouhi ir,aist upon its he.ng „, t yp.> ' " ''" '" 
 
 -MR. M.CALI,[-M~My un lerstan iinR wh.s that Mr' Holl,nH > 
 ^ereand take th- argument down. '""'^ """ «'""« '" t'*' 
 
 THE COMMISSIOVER-I did noi ,„tend fh., »», 
 ^alled upon to pay ^,00 si.nph th.t I „lh U b nlf^T'"""""' ^'^^''^ '"^ 
 
 t.v,.. I could get the l,e„..H, without thrStonL apt, •■'""■ "*^""""" '" 
 
 MR. McCALLFM Th- eviden,. ,s beforf vou an.l I , 
 —e, ....port. , ,„.,... „o n.h, ,0 .av von wd n. „ T ^"" 7." "'«'''• * 
 
 riih COMMiSSfONEK- This deeimoa of uum w« ,.«.,-h«d after l.ar. . , 
 • Md I wrot.. you immediately. " '*"''"*! '^•'■•• 
 
 MR. McCALLUM-1 got your letter yesterday. 
 
THF. rOMMlSSIONEK-I »vi.,t. y..n Kifoiiiiinff yon .jf tlm fmt tliiit the 
 «(ivi'rmiii-iit j,MVf iiif to uuili'i>f.iiiit tli.it in the ^niimiin^' up it i> u iii:it«»>r |.ii mv 
 nwii iiiiliviilinil |..r,r»n,il liciii'tit iii.i il I mi ai!liii.^ to takf tin iiH|.oii-,(l>ilitv of 
 
 <lirf.:tiii>,' Ml Hollaii.l to ri'|i.iii lli.' •ij;uiti.-iit tm mv l.i'ii*>lit, ;it i st m( Aioo, \t \, 
 
 nil ukIiI. 
 
 MR. .M< PALLl'M— \',nv wfU ; ymi (an mipi iij> th.if ninUd Von hm ;.. • 
 tho ivultiici ilii'iv an<l <lo not want iin a'-si^taiii' ^ ; Iml I «,intnl, in )UMti<c ii 
 mvself, iii.instire to this wlioU- cust , a- I think tin- Hiijiinifut ^liouM Iv time, mm! 
 if 1 li.i\-c nit ptovt'l \Ui.if 1 sav. ail ii;;lit. an'l f will not >,'o :\ st< |. Inttli.'i, \'m 
 '•III) ^i« on 
 
 .MI{. TiVKERT — .Ml. .rolmsiun uili take 'li.iwn tlif aiauiu'iit 
 
 MR .NIiC.\I..LL'M--i li.ivf no It-cliiiij iiIhuU iheniatli-i. 
 
 THE lO.MMl.SSluXEIi -Voip t..n- is imt pluasant. Vou mv I . an go on. 
 OtLouiHc I \vill j;o ■111. it I M'. lit. ^vitloiiif .i.s|;iii<r .■iiivInmIv s I'ciuii.^sion. | want to 
 tell you, lii'lmv you {,'0. I will li,i\e that tikeu itown m lypfwritinir, so ili it vom 
 will liavi- lu) u.viu-e 
 
 (Mr. .McCilhini ntiiv;- 
 
 MR. RVKF.nr I Mill soiry Mi. M(("alluni flii'v ma pa.-.nion. ] i\|„,i,l i 
 liavo iln; bi'iii III of his arj.'iinifnt -ami to ansui-i it. 
 
 THE COMMISSIONKlt I will write to Mr. MiCallnm t^lllll- hiin I uill h.r., 
 the art,'uiiicMit taken ilown in shorthand, ami wiittt;ii oni, , (Hinni-iiLing at J oVhuk. 
 
 AJ.iouruod till 'J 1'. M. 
 
 AFTER ADJOrRXMFXT 
 
 THE CO.MMISSIOXER— I .s(Mit a toiiiiniini.ation to Senator McCalliun, .stating 
 that, as hi' had siuh strong IVelinf.'n with irr^ivnc.' to liivino his ar;,'UMi"nt icpo.ud 
 i' typiuiiting. that I had dci id. d to < niploy .Mr, Johnst. o. an (Xpert, -.vho w.i, 
 } resHit, lor that piir}>o.-e, foi his bruclit, ami tot tho hcinfii ot'.Mr. Elli.s; and thai 
 hoped he would hf here at 2 o'(.lo. k to ;t;(. on « iih his iiifuinciit. f nnty statf 
 that I ivccivi-l a Itttd from .Mr. -McCalliHii, in whi' h Ik- dc. lines to pioec-d «itb 
 his argument. He thinks h... w.is not faiilv treitc I in fli.' matter. an>l d.-. lines t( 
 ^0 nil with it 
 
 THE rOM.MJrfSIONER — I m,iy state her.- that I intend to avail njvseli. h.toi, 
 I nmke out my report, hy j.pplyin;; to .Mi. V.u^i- \\,\ any information I niiy eon.sid.^i 
 ne-essny in rfteieiici to thi-s matter. WhciiHei I apply for anv inloiination l 
 think is of sudieient iinportamc I will send a copvofit hioc f.. voii, s" that v( 
 will know p.xactly th«.' (^in!stion an I icplv from luiii. in I I shill pidhihlx siipplv 
 Ml. MeCalhim with tin smiK.- tiling;. I rp>,'i(f very imieli tint Mr MiCillnn 
 shouhi have felt hurt at anythin.s 1 shoiiM have siid. fioin the fa( t tlint i,i\ (in!'- 
 olijf.^t in i-'fiisint; to have it in typ( \uitiiii; was siinplv t ?natter of iconumx .m. 
 saviiijf ,111 exp('ii.si» whieii f i'oiisideii'(i iimiei essaiy, and I had no i.hi th.it Mi 
 Mef'alhim was ,so excei'dinsfly anxion.s to ivacli the puhlii thioiiffh fh- tviiewiitin.' 
 
 And now I I all upon .Mr Ryk'it to proceed with .i!i\ ivniaiks in wislns i 
 mak( 111 (onneetion with this matte- 
 
 MR RYKERT- I reirret ev,..,.,!>, .,,!.■ (i,;.! m, v],., .,,11,,,,. „ i,,, j^ ,. ..,.,.j. ,,, , 
 makt" these charges in the S('natp. and who has lieon the cau.se ol tins ( oiiiinissi.,: 
 hcing issued to iiiako an in(|Uiiy luto the tnamtgeirient ot the Canal, should have ,, 
 
3 
 thelftst mimut .1erlin«d the oHVi- whirJi von m..!- i i,.. » u 
 r.".t...| ,„ h.li. II., I„„ MO ,H'I„ I , , , '"■"'','"'" ^" '""'" »"•' arKim..ntr«. 
 
 -y tnni.n.iiv. „.«, ,0,. i.Hv. ,,„ „, „„',,'', ;"•;• '";' ' ''""^ ' ^- 
 
 10................ ... ,,...,,„ „..„.,: .:.x :.:;."": : ""'■ ''•"■" ^"- 
 
 "■" • --'. I "". .i-'i '" i..., .......,.,„; ,,:'C ;';;;": '^\''' r ' 
 
 .1.0 i..,ft..„. .f ,i.e who),, „„„., „. ,i,/ ,';:;' ''"^•"■""-""" ' ■ «."-^ H. 
 
 V.H. t., ...ak.. tho.,. ..h..rv,»tio.... b,.,nn.r J ..,M.„i . . 1 ^"' '^ '*"' '" 
 
 "■'''^•'"-.lv..l .... i..s n.a., U..,.i,.,„ ,,,/•" '' '°"« — t''^"".-. 
 
 or ti.. g.,ti..:.,. ..n.h,c; . ; .;:t:; ,.:" : r' '"^^v" '"r "p°" ^'^^ '^"^ 
 
 -M.-.UO ,h«ul,l be ,e,.civ.l' ... „., . ' i,; ■' ''" ' ""' !" ^^''r' ""*"" -• "- 
 
 ^i-.. -.a to ,1.., tuk.... ... the evl,; .,;,;'' TT'" '" '"' '"^"^"»- 
 
 y.. ^.i g.. .t .....,., ,0 rL ,..,r r;^ ,;..^;: j;;;;::!^ '--^-^^ -^^^^^^ 
 
 .l'us.> ,.xi.„„|. how ,n..l ... what ,na..ne, the abut '' ' ' '"'^' " '"'^ 
 
 .Mv..,.i«-.ti„g „.,m,.rs ,„■ ,.Htvuaeva„.es tir .r '^^ «''^«'"' you.- .nquirv into 
 •'<|..Hy .su,.en,.t,.n,i..„s 1 ,:,.„«i,,,,,, ,„„ ,,,„,. ^^^ '^ '^^^ ■ EII.h o,- h.. 
 
 'l<H.bt y.,.. i,.okt..| „po,. i, i,. th.;, li,h, , ''"•>•' "•""^■'vr.l-aml I have no 
 
 the l„t„re imu,(,nu.m ot th,. .a„-.l ., ' ' i ' ""^^ ■^»8K'stio„8. as to 
 
 i.iea that Mr. MrCUlUun . on!,! 'av 1, u * *".'>n.enee,„ont F ba.) „o 
 
I 
 
 1 iiirii]itly , 'Ii.it if tlipv !i:uj inailf nii.Ht^ikvs timt ihflv arte<l mi their host Jii'lu'nctil, 
 
 .•ll|i| il \S:ix )illl(ly ,111 ilIOl III' illilffllU'llt I'lUl, It ■.I'fllli'il, tlolil tlic Very mmiiiihiiip 
 
 mtiit, iliif till' inmicd x'liatoi liail .JirtTinl liih altciiti.iii p.ii li'iiLiih auA i'«|i. iillv 
 to iiivcsti«afiiij,' siimll, tiitliiifj '■1imij;i>, in.itti m n'llimi'v imt ullii lin^' llic iii.m.iv'i 
 iiHiit (i( t' iin.il. iniifl'T" wlii'li h.iil l"i II .iisp'iM'ci lit \c,irs iiiro, nuriy nt tlifni l'\ 
 
 tllr ill [I II tllll'llt, .Itllj lllilttiM> III |l||V.ltr L'l II'VIIII '■. wall wllirl) V'lU, >ir. ll.lVi' llnl lliliji 
 
 wliitlevor til till . w i;li wliii li tin- (iov iimiiiil, I iii'iy -lay, iiiivt- iintliiii^ to iln, iii.iiiN 
 III' wliii'Ii )>avi' Ih'i.'Ii |i|i'm iiti'il t'l tlir f i«vi'i iiiiniit yi'ill < iigii Mini {iflKsi >l ovi r ill (HI li" t 
 ^tli-iKf. I Miy I imtiii'il In, III th< vciy loiiiihrinfiiieiit tlini that w.iv tin' iliill nl ili'- 
 Sciiutiii's I'bsi'i'Viif iiiii>. 
 
 Si>\\, wliat t!iH imblii. \\t* unximis Im in this j^iwit mniiiiry was tn kimw .il! 
 •ilioiit the ia.ui:ii;i'nii-iit of tiic catiiti ; aii'i I liavi- im •Imiht you nutirni. Irmii ili ' 
 voiy noiiiiiii'tK fimnt until tln' ilosf nt thi- invfuiigaiiun, mi tlic |iiirt iil iln- |ii(i,si'i u 
 lion, that mil lOii- sintjli' i|iiosiii)ii >v;i.i \>\V U> a witiif.ss iitioiit tli»' Uhuiiij^i'im-nt nl il." 
 laual ; iiot oiin sin^ilo i|iicsr.ioii whn .'i:<kril nt ;iiiy )ii ismi ('Xit^iit Mi. I'.iki', llii- kiiv 
 last pHi'soii wild, from his jmsiiimi, imirIii ik he itskfilito n\\r .in i'|iiiii(ii) ulmut >iii h 
 H ni.itli'i. Nut a .siiigli! witiii:sM wasiiski'il thf ijUcKtimi wiii'tlu'i ur imi thf cannl w.ih 
 wull or luopt'ily iniiiia<{Cii. That i|Uf>li(iii w.is i-ntiioly i^jnoH-.l. It wu.s within hi» 
 province to liuvn hiouvhr ixj't'it.s Juir. imii iifalnlitx !Ui<i iwiiiiiiiun, nl whom \m« 
 liavf jiliiity iti this couiitiy, liki' Mi W iltci Shaiih ami hUhts, \\li(> miiiil liam 
 tonic ami tL'^tili^ll with ri'ganl to t hi' iiian.ijjfim'ni ot the canal. Not one ul' iliiin 
 lian been hnnijht hero to qut^stion Mi. Kll'.s' iimiiagcim-iit ; but, on tiic cuntrai>, 
 ijnestion.s liavi' hci'ii aski'ij, ami opinions '^ouj^lit to he nbtaini'ii, t'roni persons who 
 hud fcfUngs of hostility towaiil- Mr. Kills, uihI who wi'if not at all i oiivci>:iiii 
 with tlio nianaj{i'nifint of the caicil. Nm^', .is I s.iid, tliu rountry had a li^dit to 
 expect that, and von Imd a lijrlit to c.\pi>ct tlmt, fioni tin- pio.'^ci.ution; you had a 
 right to know whtthc- or not, Irnni iIp' cxpiuiciio- of imn like Mr. Sh.inly iUid 
 olhciH, .Mr. Ellis conducted tlii> cmil ]iropi'ilv. '\'oii arc not called Upon imi 
 would the (ounliy th.mk you to mvotigatc a lot oi ..liarguM of a j^iuieU pci onai 
 churactci', wliuh had bctoi explotlcd _\cars agn. 
 
 Xow, aunthei thing must have stiuck you duiiiii.' tiie iiive-itiKation— th.it al! 
 tljer<B trivial idiarges biouglit ajcainst Mi. Elli>, aic of a stale i h.ir.n tir, dating l>.ek 
 to 1.880 and ISM, di.'wn to tlirec or lour years ago; hut not a singh emiuiry h.i-. 
 been made as legai'db tho niaiiagcniciit of the riiial ; not a >ingle euiiuirv his hien 
 mado about the troubles with olhfial.s in the last thit'e or four years ; but. I ^.i> 
 inuttiTS of an old character, which liave iin bearinj.' whatever on the management i4 
 the canal, liu'e been brought up. 1 am >oi'ry to say--and if the Seiiitor wcie hiii' 
 1 would make the same observation, although I would not wi^h to s:iy anytliiiif 
 rtflertiug upon Mr. McCalluin one way or the otiuu, or upon any peison, if I eouhi 
 avoid it — that there .nppear.s to be -^onn thing personal at the boitoin nf thi.-" matter, 
 and can come to uo other condu.sion when 1 look at tlie .-pii.-h whii h was rehiie.i 
 to you for invrstigalion. and which, 1 bi lie\i'. wa.s your naki'd iustru. tinii> 
 
 THE COMMlStSIOXEK-Yps. 
 
 Mil. RYKKRT— ^Vhcn that speech was referred to thi^ ("oiiin i^>iiiii loi invsii 
 gation, one could not fail to se,j that it was purely a privnte matter . ihal, underlyiii;,- 
 this w hole enijuiiy, tlieri' was a venom and spite mair.fcstfid against Mr. Doniare jiartir 
 ularly, because he would not employ Mr. Mossip. 
 
MlnMMluo„,.l,M...«.,l,a,K..,.h,,m...iIya.|,.«n. I ,.,..,...« ,o ...U. . 
 
 "•• '7 '"•":''" " "- l-^". -"' ^I V,.,. I...«lit,i. M.'m.p,,!,,, . . 
 
 "'"""' '" ';"'*"■« ""• '-""- '" -"•"«'•.«....>- M. EllM ,n .he s..„„ ,, 
 
 ^^lu.lusl..,l,n..^,,^ak..,hu.M„1.,„v.,,.ll ,s ,1,,.: ,. ,•,.«, ,.,. |,„ ,,„.„,„, , 
 ;....nK .,.,.,. ,,.....,,.,1 U,,.,.„. Mo^ip ,.,„„...,, .,„...,.,..,,,.....,,..;,,. 
 
 '"' '■■ ''' ''^"'^' '■' "..,. ,H.n.l,..r „„.., .,„ ,1,.. w..t!„„| , ,..„Hl. I .,,.„,. . 
 
 ""■•"> I"t'. '■■ .-!. I'll.s, Sup..,iu..n,|..,.r o,„... u„al. ..kin, hi,,, if h. > I,| 
 
 KH. flu. •u.u .„nf„.n,.,H .•.nplov.uru., an h. ha.| a 1h«.. ra„„!v ,.. ,„,„.,„ | 
 
 ""••• ''■•'»'"» '«"' '■""".V. l>s>. «,v„,^Mn.. Ih. „....o,M Khv h..'-.,ul.| ...t .uu.l,: 
 
 :;';!^„"""" '""',?." '•"'■••"- !->■,. ,.,,.1 .,„.,,..„ „m.,, .;.:'; 
 
 MrCllmn n.a. .•. pul,l„h..., in ,h,. ,Se,..t.. „ p„,ts .., U,,,t .lu,.. .N,,. Kll.s hn. .-u ^ 
 
 _ ...nplv ,hat h,. ,ll.i,.„,p., ,,.,1 «..n..r;.I l.oaring ,..,var,K h.s !..„. |„., h. ,.„ ,.. 
 
 •v., ..„.. (hat at las, „ 1,,..,,„„ ui.h.an.hl.. ,.„.l .ntohTalio M.. 1,,, ,„.,,, „ .j,,,, , 
 
 -a.ul Wie thoroughly a.v.ua.ute.l vtl, ,).. „,„k, „„i «.■ a.e anuou. „". k...,', 
 
 -huu; and a Ithou,-!, Ik has „ .v.d ...veal w«n.,„ps.„ ,1..,, ,..,,, ,h.v h.v ! , 
 
 I .av th.. wlK,l, ..,,n,.iat.un uf ,1mh .n.,,mv a.is.., „..„. ,|„. „„ ,„., M, ni„ 
 -uh ,.ot ...pl.,., a.Hl kuc.p in las ..,..ploy,.»..u, a ,.k.u na„,.l M..s,s.p, .h... ' . 
 M. McLal u,u .ay.s .k .. vou... ma., .,r «„o,l reputati,.,. an.l ...ha.v.,:,..;, .„.i ,,„ 
 jfisoi. an «l,ouh. h. ..u.plov,.,! J» ,lo^, ,eem to ..u. that Mr. M-Callun, „„. r h. ■ 
 
 .-.. .U.H.h.,1. .fa„y p.,so„ , o..l.i h. satisHe.l. h.-fo... h. .h,. ,, LUZ^lCX' 
 M...MP was „.-t a ...an ..I su, h a d.a.a, I. , a,„i ,epu,al,o„ an anv .uv, , „„.:,., , .; I,i 
 '■u^Vloy. .(ust lot. u.e po.ut out here that the.v Lave Wn callrd upo„ M, M.CaUnu 
 l"half tw...,ty w„„essc.H, U, tCMtily as to tho .-haracte.- ,.f .\f,. M,,,.,,, Th. ,- . ■. 
 . )g!,t ot ,hc.e who hav.. s«.n„ that h- wa. a,. agr....ahh. n.u.. to «...,-k m ith. hut five 
 
 n .. ,h.. ...ht have .wo.n thn- his .oputation for h. i..g of .. .,.,3„.H.„,„e .lisp Li 
 l>u ua. ^vdl.kuo^M. tlnouf,! ■. . -h. vilbK- of Poit nalI,ou..., wh-r. h. ,.s 1 
 
 h- ot iHT tuolv. w,tT,r.s.>. hav. unhe,sil..tu.gly sw..,,. th.at h,- was of a ,,..an..N.,„e 
 
 w.uM „o^ work w.th h„„ ur.,1,., any ■ i.- un.staua.s; but ,h,. ...n.r.l ,,«„cv,.m. 
 
 .t .- hanlly ar. ..saiy .or ..... to ,|„..,.t ^.n,r atu„.ti„„ . I„„ ,.„„ will li,..l ,he,„ .on 
 ..^..c.ng at, pa«,. ".N. an-i ..x,...n.linH awa> ,lou ,. ,o p,.,, „0,.. ,.,.,, ..„ .,„ « . ,h , 
 
 .-;m ",1! hav.> „.,M.rv.,l that, duri.,;; th„ .onauot ,.r,l,i. ..,„|„,,v ■, 1.,.,. „nn n' 
 
 -...•SS..S ..11.1 >,. M,. M..Callu.., hin.self hav. ..n ..nly , ,on H,,. .l^ „ Z h:' 
 
 ' :': '"'^ "'':•" --;'---tion. a,In,itto,i that U. .J, , ...all , ", ; 
 
 .>l ...... as..o,.„.,...l wa , pa.ti-.ularly as a wo..ki„g n.ao. Th. ,,.. p.^,,,; ., . 
 
 .. Ins (avor onlj ..p..ak f.o... thoi.- k-unvi..,!,.. .wM.in. ,.,,,.. M hv v,,Hi,,. vnh'i.. 
 '■■m, two to th..e.. weuks in th.-. ......rs,. .,f thrn. or fo.u s..,.,.. ■ ,1.;. ;.„„ . r . 
 
 -r... said h.- w..,.k..,, with hin. wa. .onn.hin, Hk.. Jt ;;::iX:iuZ 
 >....... .. rhn-e or Jour year. As ,a, as th.. prose-utiou . , .uc, ..e,l. Ly ^ 
 
 .nt,r.ly a.le.l to ,.,ak.. out any proof that M,. Mussip w.s a .n a wo.tl v. ^H. " 
 uodrbthty. or a n.a.. worthy of being etnployed upc. the ca..al. T.ke the ev ic . 
 
ai ' "';;'",;":• r- ' "•"'•— •• "'^ '--i. ....i ,i,„.« wh.. i,.v. i,...,. 
 
 I.U- U ... u urn, .... .lU u„M I.. iH. ,u«K-i.u,. „Hl, „„i ., M.u. „.,..« m,.-!, vi„|..,.. 
 1 « t,r«t ,,..>..„ .1.,. -,...k.. ,„..nulv u,..,. ,|,a, ,.„iMr u..« M, l,,iKv.tv. „l.o. :., ,.„,.. 
 
 ■■: • :"•*;■ ■ • ''••'^'■' ^''"' I-'"-'"" •■ ",. . „ ,.„. ,. V..,; ,,i...«..„t L... 
 
 ""' "" '""' "'•■•'■■• ""■"• « '^ • --itv to, ,. ■ II,.., ,,„„. ,f ,,,., ,, , ,; 
 
 »H.Vp, -In. s..V..;il> , ^Mf.lt .I..11! ilt tilli.s 
 
 , '''""• *"■' '^ '" '■' '•" '"'"pi- ■'• 'I,. ..,..1,.,.,. wiM, I. u,. |.,.v.. I.,.,M,.. M. So 
 
 ' '';"" '"; '';;'^"'"" "- -•«.vi..K <!.■.. v" '.,„,,, ,„ ti,. .»,„i.,.i,„.r,o,„,he 
 
 .M.k.h,...h;.i Mr M..»,,.«v.,,„,„i.i,n.tnllv„„«„,il,vot ,l,......,„i,!..,„,.,.| Mr KIli> .,„( 
 
 I.w ,l..puf.y M,,,. un,i.„.lu,t., an.l a „,,.,. «hu,., „ «. ., .,,., ,., |,.v..„„,ki„« «i,|. 
 
 ""'"''"'''">■""■ "'«>l..-w.,.,„„i,nuliyl,r I.h« ,l.-..o„l ,.„.„„;. tl... „.,•.. ,,.,.„„ 
 
 -.llN ny...K I.. .11..,! s„,k..,. i„.|u,i,.u „.,.. r,. L. l-v.^ .l,.-v „•..,•..,.„, M.ili,.,. nth 
 '•<""""'al..,| I,. ,l„. (;„v.., „„„.,„, „„l, ,|„.,...„n., .:n.sn.ui,.s,.l,o„l.n,.r.,.,..^>.i,.-t 
 a. .m.n,-,...M, „. «lu,.| v,.„, .,. ,, „,,,.. .■..i|,lo\M.v l.,h„ „ill kMnviHtl.,.,,,..,, 
 
 .l...u'w,.u.t|.,„ir,. ispoKMhi. ,„|,,.w.. V.M,.Mu-,ak..,| V.I,...,, or, .1,1 Mr \Iui, 
 
 vJ.VM,,!., Mmu. „ .^ruH.-unu w.ll k..<.«,. „. tins ..,„.,ntn,.n, , . livinjj i„ iN.r, 
 ,l)ill...„s„ |.,r .0 ,.r ;.o y,.ar.s.. .... v...,.loy..r .,f l,l,or . 1.^ suvs \u- w',.,,!.! „ot l.av.. ,„. 
 
 .U.U ,„.., :u ,P. ri„.., yon ,.,ay fak. Mr II,,rvoy S...'.., , ^,-ut\.mnu .U> 
 vmi,l„y.n^' l.l.or: iu- >;,y. " I ,|.. not want ,.. ..mi|.Iov s.f,.), ■, „,,,,■ V.„ „,av 
 
 follow ,t ou. .in,i t.k. ih,. .liU.r,.,, „...„ wl.o have |...,.„ ,„ll,.|, ,,,„., ^,.,„^ ,,.,,;,. 
 ^m,.lo\,...l Uuu ; ii,(.y all s.y. an,i In-ir t,.stin,ony universallv to the lact, that h. ,. 
 nut ;. ,.m,.vr limn to he .n.i.h.v,.,! ..1. the .anal. Th.-n we hav- P ...tain I arlin a 
 jrentleman also w.ll.kn.-wn in this ,.ou..tv : h. snys h.- is n nmn ),. wouM not Imve 
 
 Now. th-rc wi.son.Ml,.nf;«-hi.i, «tni-k n^... wh.ch I thought wa, v,rv nrhri 
 on the part of .Mr. .M. (Mlluni : that wa. an attemr-t upon his part to h.^t;,. upon 
 -Mr Dema.ethes,„n...tha, h. h.nd h,..„ ,,ui,t, „, ,,i„,, lanff„,«c al.out Sir .J .hn 
 Macion .1.1. whi, h ,1 h. ,v. r.. «niltv of usin«. .w,a« totally unworthv of hin. But 
 who.1 we come to ox .inmn vliat are the wor.ls use,i upon that „r.,.asio„ a. allcire.! 
 to have been u^e,l I,y Mr. Douiaie. nc. oniiiiK to Mr. Mossip". .tory, that he was a 
 Utrty son ol a hmh : w« have the nniver.sai to.tin.ony of everv witne..s tli..t that is 
 h„ooai,„onex-p,e..sio„: .vvrytnanthatha.. neen sworn, who h.a.« ,mv.„ to.stin.ony 
 wu regaul to lu,n, says that is his ,.o,„n.on expression, -.ou aro^. .lirty ..„ o, a 
 biteh. .N.w. Mr^ 1). ina... has ,n«t it fairly an.l s.p.nrely ; he ,h.ni..s ,t po.<.i,iv..lv 
 ..ys.t ,8 no sueh thin,. He .ays. -I have never taken part in an ele.-tion. ami 1 
 c..n personally bea. te.tu,e,.,y t„ that nivvell. R., h,a. alwaya trie.! to act impart- 
 . i'" ;■" ;7'^'-^" "-"'l'l''.V' '- to the hes, of his j,ni«n,ent, an.l I think vo„ .ill 
 .omo to hat eonclu«iou when v„h m.ke your report. But tint this Molsipv,, 
 dehhmtely telhng what is nor true m that .statement a.hnits of no -Jonbt. We Jo noi 
 rely alone u,..o,i T.emare ; wv h.ve . George ^y. Kead, a g.ntlen.at, well-known in the 
 vomtnnmty, ot f.stabhshml reputation, a man of honestv and integritv H. s.,v 
 -Mossip |.,hl h.ni .liMinetly h,. never hea.d Den.are make ihat observation, but th;' 
 lie had hear,l that itemare hail said so. 
 
 X,.w, theie ,s a wiines.s, who voluntarily wrote n.e a letter as soon as h.^ heard 
 Mr. MosMp s testuuony. an^i I aUo que^tioued *r. Mos.sip upon the point. So that 
 
'"■; ■ ' '" "■ "' ''•"• Ho;r, , Mill. ,, „ «..„rl..„.,.n «|,» „.,.-. !,«>,. ..v,,,...! ,. Kn.., 
 «''!•. M.|...-s,..,, ,.,„.,. v„u, muMi ..M . ,M,tl, t.lli..^. ,.„.,,. .-. „„.,. «h.. Im, ,1m. ..,„.r.. 
 c..,h.|..,„.r,. Mr 1.,.,,.., .,.,1.„1„. |".„.,..«l,.,|„.v,.,,.,r,ol..,,.„l.h. .u,U.- Hk 
 
 ''"""■""•'V';"^"'" ^'-'i'- t..„..iv „„.„ ,. . .,.,i,.v,.,., ,,,.,, „.u 
 
 -.•«to^ .n.ul.n.,I.M,.n.u. n.M.n,. f|... I:.t,.,nn,- ,„, n on ,|... .,.,...1, .,..|, ,1. ..-r.,,,.. •. „, ,„ 
 .h..>,.m.l„.,r „..,„,. „„. ,„,„n,.sta,.o>. ....ive unv (,.v.,. nr ,1k 1„.u.I.s oftl... 
 n.. r,.,n..„L I took ,.,, la. ,«.• li.s. ^«:^u,. it U ,hc lonu,l,.„ r f\. .-i,.,, 
 
 ' T' , " ""-'•"•^""""'' «""- -s u, la- ,1, „,,,.., : „„., , ,„, „, ,,^^^ „,., • 
 
 o .t .„ ,v,.nf V «■„.,.:.,,., ,.,,llo,l hy M, .\|,.,;.11,.„, b..,o to.ti„„.nv f, th. fr,. t ,l,.r 1... „ 
 a mill iiiiiii ti. In; (•m|i|"-'jc.l up.m th.' i.inil. 
 
 Xou- .,k«n ij. ronm.uoi. ui.h ,lu.t ,a>.,.. M,. MrCalluni. ib o..le. to .sl,ou ,l,ar 
 1.H .liam. ,.s ,„,vl.. out. ,1m. 0,1.,.,. UI.M,, ,M iK. .ays. ,vhilt. 1.,. ,i,...,.v„,. ,l,,„ 
 o.M,.,v..r.ro.v,vl.,.u.,,,,,vn.u,t.v,.n ,|,..y, h. Mngl.s ou, tl„ ,„„u. o, Wiiu,,,, 
 0.1. , .1. ..miinr |)..ly, ,. , „,,„ ,,,,,i„^, ,;.,.„^,^ ,^.,„, ^,^^^,^j J ^^^ |__ ^^ ^ 
 
 emp oy«. npon ,h.. , anal o.io ,l.y lon„r Th.- l.onoraM. ..ntkui.-n 1„... spe,'., « 
 Ml.., .I*al oi Ins t> .u. H>,1 the t.u.c o. the , onn.u=..on in i..ve.t.,,ati,.K th. .umUu.t 
 '■' th.. ni.u J.ily, .,..1 I ,h.,ik r.n „.us, ,.o,„e ,o tl.,. ,o,K.lus,on i.v .ht .in.. I 
 . .^>.thorow...,hurg.. whuh b.i ,.i,.d. „ U ti.t a. ..,a.,i; ..s,,.blH,i.,« .l,; 
 
 >1 . D. In nt t,,,..;, «. t. .,..ox.. at.:.i . l.u, thne i, o„o thing, l,.,von.l nil ,,uo„tion, 
 wl. h ,. p.-r.d .n tin. .n-.u.ry. that during tl,o ti,n» h. u at work h., i. not u u., « 
 
 hat , har,n.o.-. Mr. Kca.I has sworn that upon „n,. o, ,w„ ..ca.ion^ he n^- 
 ht lo . nto.xn.ate;J. Uhn, n.k.i by you to giv. un ..plan.fon .hont ,he wo,d 
 orunk o,. n.to.x.,Mt.d/'hocomd..otdoit; b„thrK.,esonto«,,y. 1 ,1,1 „o, 
 ^ d,Mh,,rg.. h.,n. although I knmv I on«ht t. d.soha.';;'. bin, if 1,„ wnre drunk I did 
 no lonsuler he wa.s so niu.h into.uatvd :ukI imapabie of ,l„chargin.. hisdytic. 
 t .|U ongh. to d.s, hn,^p. l,.n,.' I'.ut vhcn «e .on.a to .xn„..n.. ,nto the ,n!t,e 
 . mt e lurthor wo have tho wv..,.who!n,i„g te.sti.nony oi u lot of gLntl-incn ,,rr,oni 
 who hn.c worked with him. who all l.ar t.lin.ony to the nui.o .n ,„n , "^ du ' 
 t^.^ ,nan wh.h. upon tn. work, although it n.ay be his niisfortun.^ whil.- oU' ho 
 wo,k, toiiesonietnnesintoxirand; but, sir. I think von will .dv. ,.,.,d,.,.co to tlL 
 tostnnony of thcso .Hrte.ont gnutlcnen who h.vo !.«.„ .all.d upon th..s .nnnirv who 
 
 tho ,.st o, tl.cncn upon tho wo.k, a n„,n who could Ke-op up his .nd ui.h ,h. 
 othor ,n..n wo,k„ig on ,h.- .-..nal, .John Mun.d. nn. of ,hc .o.n.n.n. t....i,l, d to I ! 
 good ..huac.o,- and good conduct, and d.si.c to wo.k. ...d willi„g,eHH ,o do mctv- 
 tungaskedo, hwn; ,.nd also thu .a.t that uh.tev.., h. wa, askod to do l./d d 
 ethn-MUly: andwasasoho.-, industrious, an 1 h,..,;.work,ng n.an, and that he had 
 >.ev, r soH. hnn drn^k on duty, Mr. Lci.h spoak.s well of hi.n : and ul.so Mr 
 D-mar... It ha. be.n att,.nn.ted to Iv ma-lc out, and I ..hall aliuMu to :t sLortlv- 
 
 ....„k y.., v„! ,:au- no :.«;t,u;on ju coming to ihu ..onciu^ion that, so far as Dalv 
 IS concrrnc.d, ho wa. a n.an who cllicientiv diuha.-god his dut^. .n.l nood very hil 
 m comparison with Mr. Mossip. I u.cntioued VVrlliam Daly because hn Mn-di !,£ 
 
'u, ,^ ) c nan. alw.. .11 other., who have ),..„ ..,nph,y.,l. H„d ho is ,h. o.,. uho,., 
 .. .u.l.ntly .,„^h;.l „„, to ,„„v. .hargc U, ; l.,„ , think v.. will ,.o,u. „. 
 
 ^ .nh,..l u, .l,..luM.,n., A oss.p, au,l .v.using .okIv.. hi,,, ,.,n,,h,v,..ont an ' 1,„„., • 
 as..«..,.lsDalv, who .a. si,„l,.., .... .,v M,. M,.,.!...,,,; . tl,i„k vo,.;.i,| 
 
 who zealously a.,.i faithtullv disrhaip.,! his ,|,„\ ' 
 
 Anothor pom to whi.h J uish ,n .ii.v,, unn att,.„.io„ l„i,,l, is ,h,. ta.t th., 
 
 ".'•• ''''■'^""""'' ^""■' • '- -'■" -tiH. ,■,,,1 of ,i,„ ,„,,„;, , . 'h 
 
 .n.xu,.,.„st,..,,.,io,..ith,v,a„.; .,..1 in th. -a.lv pa.t of H i,; ,. " Z , 
 W.1 m.ol]e.t. . ohi„cto,l to that ki,„l of ..vi.len,.. h.J,... I k„..w i, wo M " ^ ^ 
 '» ti"; .;n.l .ha, M,-. Mill., .a. .,.,ga«e,i u,,o„ ....st.u,,,,,,,, ,hat ail th 's .^ 
 
 '-uplatuts w .„ h. ha,l ,.,a.l.. a.aius, M,. Mill,., ha,l relb,.„.. . ^eU ' ^ 
 
 >uu tr,uc M,. McCalh,,,,, v,.,-y !„„i,.aly, .v.-.y lat„.,„le, upoM his .nvi„4r vo,; th. 
 Uuna,. „uh„ „„, |„. „,,.,,| „^ ^,, ,„,.^„j,„„. ,„att«r that vu„ -onhi not dis,i„ 
 
 ;;a. ,..a,.a,in« the .pai. at any tnne ,ave ,ae any .a*:.^: ^ ;:X:E:7 
 apply i,[,on construction, and allowed it to be paid to,- l,v ,1, . , "^ '>t'""S ^u 
 
 ;• jh,,. «.,..„,<,. ,..« „..„ » „.,,, „-.,, r t;: ;l;.':;z ;?"''r 
 
 1601. , 1 kon furtluT o„, at ,,ag,, 16S2 ■■ tl„ tinR. .a, oareftlUv comi.ire.l ,f ,1„ ! 
 
 ■■!' :;r;; ""rr"" - "'"™ "■'■"" '^^^^.^^^: 
 
 maiKeddown. ^M''- t>eniare was .^mtc too particilai-.vith me at timn. ' T^ 
 page 1605 "kept the tun. of the .„.„ sepLate while t'L' o:ie pot o"," 
 I hat ai,pcars t. hav.> b.en oae of the g.eat \nwh,;u: of M,' AT P.n ' 
 
 the tlungs upon whi., h,- ..H.d ; that^u.d U.^.:Z:l,l, tt ^:;, ^Z:" 
 hall, and the band wa^on. Those sc-in to hav., h,...„ m i , ^, 
 
 was not justilied in making any arcn^^atioi, so t,,. „ fi '" 
 
 would attach any blan.e t^M.' ElMrT y U. "''f ^ ^Z;^'^^"-'^- -'-L 
 
 had nothing to do with it : that, while th ,• ml"- " '" ^ "'''''' 
 
 abontthoti.ncof the ,ncn. tha; it l>^.t^.^::J^'Z^^::T::^^^^^^ 
 l.sl.ed that M... l)en.a.e paid fo.. nothing on, of .epai wl i f .1 1 ' T 
 charged to th« constn.ction ; and that Mr Mille, ,,M V J'av« been 
 
 cunstrut.tioii, ' i -m app.joa tu 
 
 Tbe next point to which I shall refer b, ierty is that of the band hali It In 
 Mem to me it is hardly worth while- " ^''"'* 
 
1 lit' is tllli (llio ulllllll 
 
 . yni wjll .•oiuc to 
 • Wlis was |(i'rr'Vily 
 l<>yiiii,'iit any lnni;i^i ; 
 II. I think voii will 
 iiii M(.>,>i|i, (iii,( „„,. 
 
 ielh is fill" ta^'l iIi;h 
 luii'v. lias soiijt;!it to 
 I iiivi'<ti{^atioii, yoii 
 
 >^ it WdllM rollio mil 
 
 It all tlics.' (iitl,:rt'i)t 
 Since oiitirely to his 
 Jivestij^'atofl Lv you 
 :i liisyiviiigyou the 
 i Mr. Ellis and Atr. 
 oil louM not distill 
 ni to ask ijutsticri-,, 
 d ,vmi will sec now, 
 >':\, tliat .Mr .Mi'- 
 uiiith liail iKj light 
 i.s ilear and loticIu- 
 ikc didiijeiit altera 
 o control over him. 
 'c.(\ raising the lock 
 re in their capacity 
 inie or anything to 
 repair department 
 \-chaiig6(l." rParre 
 lUipared at the end 
 working was duly 
 times. •■. Then at 
 : on the lioutouii." 
 alluiii, and one of 
 tlie gui, the baiid- 
 ol' the houorablti 
 , I think, that he 
 concerned, whicli 
 ler and construe- 
 i« and .Mr Detriaie 
 ' iiiisapprelieiision 
 and cltarly estali- 
 shonld have been 
 f liand, Las at no 
 {lerlv applied to 
 
 tl Ijall. It doi^n 
 
 THE COMMISSION KR. , .,„.,, , ■;, ,,, ,,,, „,^,^ .,, ,.,,,„,^,^,^^ ^ 
 
 rLa;i'^U.;iS^t: --'M.U.....ban.,wa,,n.Uo. 
 
 M\i. RVKKUT -M, IS^,. h,,,,.,.!! >aid th.t he ,,„.M „„t ,,. ,i,at it wa, rea'lv 
 a liaiid w,-,Kon. W.ll, th-u, th,. ,1,.^, ..jia M.vn, ,, ^ * '""" *^a., ui.ly 
 
 •l.aract,r; M,. I,..,„..„ u ,s , hii^cd «i ' ' '""" '''"'"« 
 
 • . , 'iiaigH.l (Mil, li-iving, v,.iv inipioiM-ilv, taken uviv 
 l.overninent timi.ci, and raited it to Welland I ihink 1 1, „ I l 
 •xplanied to you by M,. Den.are and h,s ZL " "'" ^""^'^ '-"^ 
 
 If wa. also attempted to ta,siBn „ Ml. KIlis .son.ethu,^^ .v,o„. ,„ ,„,„,,„, , 
 
 ■n;,,,5^.:r::r:;;i;ji;;-,: :t:""^:;; --;;-;:::, 
 
 attempt M.ade to ..how ,o y.u, ,.i,, ,,nd u, the department at Ottaw . tiiit ' ,? 
 
 was not onlv u.nvorthy o, the .oti.idence o,' his en.pIoveiJt ' ' "T'" 
 
 «ett.„g ptcktu^s, and a u.iinbe, .f , hi,„s like that. x!,w: Mr ^^^ . " ^ t" 
 
 speech, relets to t,.,, ,.,.,, f ,.,,,„.,, ,,, , ,,„^,„.^^ is among .l«"'o,/"^ 
 
 im.k.ngs. -It looks as if he was getting a lot ot piekitigs " is o„ , '' /' """" 
 
 complaints. Wh..ther that refers to th.. ,nal and l.inZ; , „ , , "'" '""••'"'"• 
 
 -t !<' ■ ; but so far as that charge is tnade rh Oe ,■ • '^TT' ' ''" 
 
 Uovornment tor his „w,i pcrsor.tl use, a.id .ti/ J " T' "*''?"' ''" 
 -hat is ampiv and suHicientiy -net by the evide ^e f V t,uTTT ''""' 
 ilistinctly that Mr. Lntgley told him he did not know whe e I,. : '?r"";' 
 but. as a matter of fiut. it eomcs out in the evidence suorn to M d1 T"^ 
 self, at j«ge 1778, and by Mr. Hohnes, at page 17,^0, that Mr )e, i, ,"" 
 
 '" the house in the ..11 of 1^S5. when the id was jmte ;.;;'''" T 
 tl>e time, lieyond all .juestion, in ISS.".. At that time it w.s H ,, ^'^ '^' 
 
 .nd Dcnare occupied the ceti.rc l^-iiaing^ a^t^ I ^ ^'^ ^:i^;,^-^'^''y^■ 
 ;-i - '•■■il^'.^nn. was cotnpelled to keep hi. coal in a sh^d " : t t .';; J"^ 'J 
 tlmik vou wtll come to the conclusion that the,, is nothing in that e ,ar' ^ 
 
 U e conn; to another .jm^stion, wjiieh I do not monose t., ,„.,!, t 
 
 upon...I nioan in reterence to the rubber boot "l^Z I j^ hha t""!;"" 
 i.a)lv ilisposed of , tiiink the evidence of Mr. Page, and .h ' t ^ "h'*^ '''''' 
 H.nl Mr. Ellis and Mr. Miller, all go to .show that the tubhc. o . , "T' 
 
 ubieh should be investigated bv you. it apphes whollv to c^Z^o::,:T' 
 h.< been a large amount of valuable titne wasted in discussim' tint t l ' 
 
 ."• tl:e rubber boots. Mr. Page gives his reasons tor il :":d i Kc^rTu"""'" 
 -li-tinetly, at page i,^7ti .nd the following pages, that Mr Flli, 1 „ J ., ''' '*■*' 
 ever to do with it ; he accepts th. whole'^Ajibi i I L!^]^^ - .".what- 
 to the eonelusion, as 1 have, that that .nattJr should have be', "dtt f 'T 
 inveRtimtion. *"' """«o<i from the 
 
 igation. 
 leii ilie iie.xi i|iiestioii is that of the 
 
 made in the early part of this 
 
 Slew iKiitoon. There 
 
 was an a 
 
 this charge, alleging that tliey had deliberat 
 take timber aud to consunje 
 
 tigationtodragMr. Demare and Mv. Ell 
 
 ttempt 
 
 .V and wilfully allowed Mr. MiHe, 
 
 labor, which actually belonged to r«pair 
 
 18 into 
 
 to 
 
 '», on conetruc- 
 
In 
 
 tliili. tur wliii'li lie lii)iu..lt' I,., I r 
 
 torilv. M,.. M,ll..,. l,:,s ,.xH:nn..,l „. « ,oi; ., I TT T' r"''"'- 
 
 purpose, in ..,„,.Ho,. .,H, r,,.r n,a,.l,.,...y .n.l k.opi .,.„,.:"%:;;;"'"" 
 will soe that while n.on „„ ,,.,th ..pairs ,,,.1 ..onstrn. i.,;; .1 L it tlm n '"" 
 iher. might hiv- ],...„ som« ,sh.nv of r.,.,,,, for .,,in<^ hi , "" 
 
 - .■ons,nK.„on .hen thoy .... a.tnallv wor .' ^f, t;'' "'"' j"' r'"'"' 
 
 t^enator should havo invsti^.r-.l that .nartP „ 1 li' ^".^- "-' 1"«""'" 
 
 .weartl,oi..ti,„ewa.pai,Un,.a, tl. c^kl L: t I "" '"'" """I "'' 
 
 imv-c. boon tol.l that the,, wa. oth-r work o, 'm f'"' '•^""■m..„mo,- shoul,l 
 
 Mr. Marshall ar,d oth.rs in tl . cmplov, ,T„t o i . i ° ""'^■"'^""'''••' ^^^ 
 
 I think yon will havo no hos.tat,o,; in Z: ^' t 'I'^.X^ir'S:;'"""' """" t 
 th^ ponto,., there i. r.n a tittle o, ovidenc. t. show Z'^^" A El" "' U 
 Den.are has aetod itrpropcrly, or that a„v „.onev wl i^.h , eH ' .^ '"^ "'f'-'- 
 
 The next matter is about the new lai.thorns. That i< i nntter wl,; i 
 not sent here to investigate, n. .eems to ,ne. 1 do not th n th r I ' "" 7"" 
 minimized their work to that extent th-.r til- . Government ha. 
 
 ..l^dieney or the poliev ot one!^^;;:;,.;';:: i:!! ^^ -;:^;: :;;^;';;;:- tl. 
 «:n-n.gwhetherala„thornora certa.n kind shall be ^t^V'TV 
 beneath the di.nitv of a eo„,missiouer to .on-e here and e:tt ^.H eth r I l^ if 
 exercsed proper judgment in ehoosin. the kind of lamp, to use Vn „ i 
 you want a eoal oil lamp ; you mioht .av vou want , ll \-\ ""^''" ''■'■ 
 
 a railway, or you mi.hf pr;.r oneTof Z IZZ^Z'ZZ "v^^f "• T 
 take that view of the matter. I like the old-fash.oned 2 „ luh? a H " 
 
 .ome™L- n:i^;r::^!r;^a:r t?:!:-;^;;:::^^' ^'^;r^'""r ^"^^' '-''- 
 
 are very suitable for the work : and tl ^ o . '"''■"'' "'" ''''"'^' ^''^-^ 
 
 .ot I^-H;^;:^K. upon to dee.de. lLZX^:i:Z "^ ""^ "'" " ' '^'^ 
 
 . a r^i^r'^'o L'it:::: "''' ^""'^'^'^■'^"' "^""' ^'^" ^-"" '-'■ "-- --. 
 
 The next matter is the clover seed on the ,anal w)n,.i, . 
 to e-KBrcise bift own judirment as to u-hnf „••,. »i i . r.!i:- •.•.!: 
 
ag". Mr;Pai;i!,'xplaiiis, 
 .' .'ilioiit ii lii.fi.ii till 
 \<- li.is "vidciMjyil.^.siiv.l 
 I' Wiinti'd fli.it |Miiit(...,, 
 ii'iiic. and tli:ir h<; u.i , 
 ■ I "ill i^\\(: him rli( 
 'lone a((nidi!)f; to that 
 it' VDii will n.'olloi't, ■■' 
 
 '■Xillaillc illld itr to Sf't; 
 
 'I'liiis it i|uite .s,iiisf:ic. 
 >hr,\yu rljiit tljelc. \v:i- 
 ■Mi'. KIlis lor r.cifaiM 
 ir tooh, So tli.'it yo»i 
 il-'ed nil that jioniooi , 
 ■Iii:'.-f men liiid woilu-n 
 '"It I say tlic- Icainou 
 liavc ai^witaini'd tho 
 II lonifi forwafd and 
 i.'oniiuissi.inoi- shouli-, 
 'Mitsido tlio loiiirai't, 
 "g biiiiriintciidul by 
 acting undtT iciiairs, 
 ion tliar, n^ regard's 
 lur .Ml. Ellis or Mr. 
 "■operly bolciigcl to 
 
 ittnr wliii'li you were 
 the Government ha,? 
 to on.fuiro into the 
 
 •1 gi'^at puldir; work 
 ' "ot. I think it is 
 V whether .Mr. KlhV 
 INI'. You might sav 
 
 like a roiuluctor on 
 Von and I nii_:jl,t 
 "r "ith a caihllf, to 
 ntiit on, 
 
 vidcnoe that, while 
 ic'r,« wjio think the} 
 s one whi. h I eould 
 
 iji havf iinvcr ,£;iv 
 
 en 
 
 !-''.'iiis n Very trivial 
 o"- Mr. Ellis was 
 'I to put upon the 
 )0 Mr. Pa^o says: 
 I was trying to lind 
 
 11 
 
 -nut -ho best ,^n. I (o, th.l.niks I, |..M,u.ssarytohavesom.lhiMo„,-,h.. l,i„d 
 
 •■ lor the ,vt,nwa>h.->th.. bank, awas,' S,, ,l,at thai .s another nutter d..|„.nd..n, 
 ^ Ml-M Mr Kills „u„ ,j„.!u.,p 111, aii.l It apiH.a,. to l,,,. ,„„ with the apvioea! of Mr 
 
 Ii.l;'' at llir 111,,,., but it turn.d ,,:,t iiii.satl-^i'aetoi ,-, 
 
 Then, a,-, repaid, ll,.. trees on i|„. .-aiial. on vUii,.|, .,„,.„ ,,,,.>s wa> laid bv» \1, 
 
 ^'■•'■^'lluui, ,t tu,„> out thai a LiCm- v,a« r.^ived Ironi Mr. Bradiev. of l-bruary 
 ;'■';•,"'''■ ';•'":'■''■'' '' I-''-' '-'^^ "' • 'i''""''-- The letter is put',,,, wh,-,,. M," 
 
 l.i-.,dl.\ authonze.s .Mr. Klli.s to ex,HM,d 81,000 tor thai pi.rpos, \ou \li 
 M.Callun, made a «reat deal olTiis.s about that, and .iuiiii^^ the eoui,e of the inves' 
 n-afiou mad- a remark in ivr.ren.e ,o ih. manner in ^^ hhh he had ..,d hold of 
 that evnene,. : and 1 .as M,-uek with the .,b„ rvati.n made by vonr.ollfwhi.^h ^^a. 
 ''I'l'i";^ '!•-•> 1 "'»,k, to the whole o. this inquiry. The la„..M-v von usid, sir. was 
 m,t, I th.iik, ,,uif,. .tioi,^^ enoii,i,d, ; it vnight have b«en .st.ll .trons^o,- in view ,dtl,e 
 <'!"""•", .V""l''v.n|.o;, ,hat ,lass of te.stimony. Now. 1 ju.st t.iok th.- libertv „| 
 .e.t,.od,ng honi page 137 what yon said in loll.ence to the anony„.„ns letter; uiion 
 ■Ml. MeCalhim eompb.uied that he ivceivcl a good deal ol hi.s inhmnaUon thro„.|. 
 ..ionymous i.tters, you expressed your disapprobation of .uch mean, of altaekit 
 
 ■•'■■ '■'•'"■"■•">- "\ ;' P^'>'iu^ .-llH.rr, and eonsid.i^d that too mueh credence .should m.t 
 >.H. giv..n to ,.y,demeoo,aim.d ,n that way ft struek n,e verx foidblv at that 
 tune, and I take the libe.-ty of quoting your language in rele.emo to thrs enquiry 
 genera ll}'. ■• 
 
 TIJH COMMISSIONER-I trtay say, u, addition to that, that ,he snb.s.qnent 
 -videiue wh,d, )i.a,s -levcvd itself Jia. eonfirme.l that opinion i„ iny own mind 
 vvith velerenco to that class of information received in that way 
 
 M H. RYKEKT-.Vow, the next matter alluded to was Mr. Ellis anu the boat 
 h<u,se. It seems to mo that it is a very silly and foolish ehar-'o 
 THE COMMrsSKXVER-I do not think you need go tnt^o that 
 mi IlYkEUT-Then the question about loafers and loungers, 1 do not think 
 you have anything to adjudicate upon in that ^ 
 
 THE COMMISSIONEK-No. 
 
 .MR. EYKEKT-Mr. Page has said that that is a very proper order. You hav« 
 read the order: tt speaks for it.self. The order was for the purpose of preventing. 
 Mr. Elh. .a5s, a lot ol peoj.le congregating at the lock-hou^es. and .ontinuallv 
 bleeding and circulating scaiiilal. ^ 
 
 Then the matte, about ioei;-ton.lers and using vacant land ; I think sir von 
 u.e pretty ^vell versod in that, and know all about that yourself. You'know'the 
 i.a.son why it was d-uie. The lock-tciders were allowe.l the privilege of using the 
 vacant land n,,on condition that they would keep it free from thi;tles and weeds 
 and upon tliat condition alone they were allowed ,o use that land ; so tliat a« fa,- a^ 
 that is cone-ined, there is nothing in the charge. An attempt was made tJ make 
 ..ut that lemare and oth-rs had been t.'atlieking in that, but I do not think the 
 evikuife will warrant that conclusion. 
 
 Xow. the mattei about that receipt, which Mr. Huston and Mr, Smilie snoke 
 ol. 11, reference to the Steamer Haskell, was. I think, satisfaetorih e,pi,.i„, j to 
 .^..u tnat, while the otlicial documents shuw that the ,ecei,,t was SJ3. the production • 
 ol the receipt shows It was only $3, The person in making the copy for the printer 
 
 was §3 airmiot Slii, as indicated. ^ 
 
1" i- al.,.u.lon.,l l.y Mr. M,.,Calluui after a .l.orr ti.n.. ^ 
 
 T^r T ' "^' r^' -'•'' ^/M;..'il:i.;:;:;^;:;;'z■:;;;;z:'■:;. 
 
 o In. nu..st.«at.o„, so ,..• as charges oC that nature an, ,uu,nn.A to .hn,., J, , 
 usBii, wufiie, III Ills exaniiiiatiaii t i', si-toiid tin... 1,., ^ („n 
 
 .t alf '"'„";,' "'"""■"'«»""' "■! "■■■ 'ii'-l' '..„» t„ 1,. „.„ ,„,,,l,v ,„■„„■„,„„„.,„ 
 at ali. it was a raattor of uecessity. ■ ^ ^t'liniitii' 
 
 Then, another rclleetion was sought to he r;^t „>,,, ,i ,■ 
 was e..,loyo,l uhon .here was a gr.at .rcsh.t hor. some v.-ars . t.^i^^^ 
 
 liight, 111 or.h;r to prevent dan-cr and tioi.Me to U,,. canal ■ ih.t tl„. n,.. ". 
 .son,eihin« in the .ha,,e ol' refreshment, and they -Tt 't , T 
 
 which wa. charged a. uork done U"^ "^ ^ ^^r, '?" ='f "' '^^« ^' '^S^'' 
 
 return It as It was; but Mr 0'\..ill w,> . n . i , '"'"'•> '"'" '"">. a>"" 
 
 ~t k.".wa„,.,|„„g„,„Ub„„°„ " '"■"•■1-"- 'I""- Al .,,)•,.„„ I,. ,1,J 
 
 business man may enable vo.' 'o mak. certain s.^r T^ "VFnonce as a 
 
 beneficial to him and also to tne c :^;C ';:'CZ Ur S-^"' "'"'' '' 
 en>ployee,. sliouM have the stigma atV el ^.i/^ Jet "■"■"•'"'■ ','' 
 weighed or measured, or that they h.vu tlmLh tl i '^ ''aye improperly 
 
 den^uaca the Government, 1 thi k s ; U^ ^^^ the.rcareles.iess or ne,li,enc., 
 to be as go.>d a system, as far a« check, i "uc rnec? s .t TI' • T T"' 
 Mr. Walton. agentle„.„ inspired w.t/a„ un.i: ^ e H ,' ^^^t, ^i^^ 
 
Use f,ho evidence entiroly 
 
 Ic I'll 'lllt\. 'I'lial yci'iii,-. 
 
 '"lit -Mr. Smiflj and Mi 
 
 it lines sct'in to lilt! tli;ii 
 
 ii|iiin I lie iiijmfatioii <,r 
 Jim ill i^hnvji<- (if a gioji 
 I tVoiii l)r^;iiiiiliii/ If. cm! 
 
 lllC.'lllO.I, tu .llillnjo Jiiii, 
 
 fit vcKetalik's for a m1i.iI, 
 iifiirlo Siiiitir,,rvi(li'iir, 
 fully <'oiitr,i.li(;tt'i| hi.-, 
 'I'belioi; aiiil you, >h. 
 11 1'tli't/tnally ilis]i(i,se <.i 
 ii;ti'il hio tnvincr stato 
 1 "itii tVit/iulb niitsidi' 
 
 1 liaiill\ ..■nlii,. l„ till- 
 
 ill tfiitlickiiiR wirh the 
 
 voithv or-iiiyooiniiieni 
 
 Li.iviinni; It i-mployou:. 
 you that Mr. OXeiH 
 '•ears ago, wiwn it \va> 
 miiilmr tun during tli;^ 
 hat tlie 111(11 rtquin:d 
 iw-galioii ke;,' of higcr, 
 II? i«tunieti tor that, 
 thing. It would hav. 
 arely and fairly, and 
 Jans of making ihoac 
 s, H large amount ol 
 or. At any rate he did 
 
 ircf'uliy youivself, and 
 • ma tier uf till- hooks 
 ■ books— and I wouM 
 'i; beeau.se, on hehall 
 the eharacter of the 
 : uiaking his entries 
 long e\}icrieneo as a 
 hinj that would bi 
 r. Ellis, or any of liis 
 liey have imiuopcrly 
 ;ssne.ss or negligeiicr, 
 Hitrary, tliere seein- 
 be obtained. Now, 
 ; against Ur. Ellis, 
 
 l'"Xlu;"ll;u''"'" "\-'-th.^arn,ter to weigh the iron. I sontotimoH 
 I uugh It «l,en It eon.es in at four oHoik. 1 know the work I have ordned and 
 
 •;:;;::: rt7;'k "" ''" ' ' -"""^^ ^^ -ightomot. whe„ , L: 
 
 I>n.t.a la, job, I k.Knv .nvrv ,,„und of ,„„. there .. in it and the cost of it I 
 
 Hi I i.he k oil th. ,,„.,,,. ,, Hiey , oine uito the yard." Now, there is a ...ntlenian 
 I ^luu^ o, a e.„.in ,.,,,„., of this woik, Mi. Vanderbu.gh, whose ev^ene " 
 "t perhai. «.s conelus.ve on that point as .t might have been, from the fact t 
 he «as not alway.s n. the yard, ..ys ti.at nh Miever anythi.ig ... ne in whil ■ wa 
 heri. ,.e properly weighed i, and examined it, and eheeked die aeeount ev • luh 
 
 hen he was no, th-re he left Mr. Holmes or .Mr. De.naro there. We 1 e , ■ 
 
 :K>.e w, no>.es. both of wh,„„ testi.y to tl„. laet thar everv dollar's wo -. n 
 ..ken into that yard was either weighed or measured hv whoever handled t A 
 
 >1, ,ns M,h.„ee, and the mann. r in -hieh he explained the J^i.smes. about the 
 """■■';; ' ^'- •;"■'".-'■ •" -'-••' '.^ -l-olished .h,. .videneeof Cnlp, who!, .her 
 -^ iully one-hall, a.el then omM-nth, and th.-u two.,im,s of m t rial i , l^" 
 . «erap iron ^^.nt right ,,..1. as new material. Then e,.. niav take Mr. Dei ^ 
 - -..r and^.n,th.sev.denee: and you mu.st eome to the eoneli.ion that, o fir 
 .. tha eheek ,« coneenie , there has h..,.,. a .beek upon everything going ut am 
 
 •■ - hingeonnng in; whether it ,s in that lensed shape that .^mhl l^ sa s^ 
 
 .1 to a stranger coming li,.re, ] am no. prepared to say. 1 think, probablv with 
 .^our giea .pidgment in those matters, as the employer of laboi. ai I eniplo^. o 
 --'-• oi people 1.1 dillerent eapaeities, that yon niav, peihaps. be a. r nn k 
 ■-^--<— '"'hat point, whieh may be valuable; but, I think von w.I 
 
 ■mECOMMlSSIOXKIU-Imavsayhere that T think th. „uestio,. of pai,. 
 > ttl, d Usell. I do not think there is any need of going into an a.gu„.,.nt -n hat 
 
 1 o.ay just s.iy It turned first u, the ,nalitv of ,he paint ; the ^..st. , w, t 
 
 raised as to the titn,..s of ,i„ p..,>„„ j,, paint, but the ,,ualitv of the' ,1,1 • 
 
 ■'7-"-7-?!"'V ''-^'■^••-'-'^''-'b..otheniana;m..t. ,; ,^^^^^^^^ 
 
 not upon the,p,ali,y ofthe paint, but upon the „.. it *■ t" ^^'"ds tu, ncd, 
 
 ,-.pird'''' "'''''""""■" "'■ '"'" '"■"' ^'^"'""" ^ ' ^'""'^ ''- "- -tistaetonly 
 
 TlIK COMM ISSIOXKK - If we believe-as we must believe-the tLstimonv of 
 Ml' foster, there is no -luestion of doubt, stimonv of 
 
 MK. in-KKKT -Mr. Foster is a man of unblemishe.l reputation in th. eitv 
 .>bu,si. won! will go as far as anybody's. • ' 
 
 And Mr. Ellis ,u,d holidiu-s : it seems m m. ,t „ hardlv wo,,h while ^avin. 
 H.yrh.ng alio,,, that. Mr. I'agiMn h.s ,,„aint and ,|ui,.t wav s,.em. „,, " ' ^ 
 
 ^' '■' -.'">■ ^ '-Hday, thongl, ,„. „,,,„' takes a holUv bimsid, " '"'" 
 
 • niKrOMMISSlONKi; - I .an se,. nothing wrong in Mr. Ellis' holidav. in 
 
 iii'i:;;'^:;:" ^-••- '''''''''■'■■''---''■■'"•'.'■ -o. number ofy,..: 
 
14 
 
 MR. RVKERT -Th.n rhut mattor ..f RHis an.l Mio travnllin- oT,,6nsr<, sl-o 
 
 I'll ii'iim-.'i 
 
 Ml. Mrr„| 
 
 ms tr 
 
 .'jS^OO. I iv.iiit t.( |wiiiir our t 
 
 .'lltllOlli'l! I 
 
 It' I IISC" 
 
 th^ 
 
 find tli.il iij Mr. Klli 
 
 ilori^ tlic 
 
 <> vmi t. 
 
 .^' HCC'tinit lie l.w 
 
 VnU 
 
 '•x:mnu.; .till 
 
 11-^ 
 
 i''aiiiil. itiiili.thcr ixiM'iniif , t,, ul 
 
 iiui'sfi.iii ,il„,iit il 
 i> olli, ill rc|iiiit. you Ul 
 ■d i|u;irtc.i, .tiiil t.ln; lior.^c lni 
 
 Tlii'V ill.' III! p.i.s'.s, ,| hy til,' Au'liroi- fn'ii.ial 
 
 iii'ii 
 
 Ml. M.0,,11 
 
 1111 tak 
 
 will liii.i, 
 will 
 
 111 (.111- part of it. Kills ;:?i'ftiii;,r his $75 ., 
 
 tinl oil tllP SIUIIO |llC4c 111 tll.ll i„ 
 
 ''■Xi'(.|itloh 
 
 fl 
 
 ic^ SI Tiitiiiv an. 
 
 lint, tor livriv, Foster ami otiiurs 
 
 lowaiicc, ,iiiil liil.iu that tli 
 
 tli< 
 
 vi,!,'iiaitio of the Anilitoi-JU-iirral, wh 
 
 So that that has st.ooi| ih.' f 
 
 est 
 
 o say, i'S|.i'(;ially ii|>on oin sid,. of politi. 
 
 man to hi' alji>' t 
 
 Now, iir.vjt the Vaiiderhur;,' inatfr. Vou 1 
 not pr..|.aif.(l n. justify Mi. Vaii.lHil.mv' n, rl 
 
 iliicth 
 
 Mill that 
 
 Iv i'.\|i!aiM('ti J 
 
 tor ; I think li<' \v;i 
 
 oiifTinally hy Mr. Win,'. Tin 
 
 s sonunvjiat iri('>;ulav 111 that 
 
 larLfiM;,' toi trips th;if hi' .li,i 
 
 Hot 
 
 laf was allowirii to l;,i 
 
 iMIt ll|. 
 
 -piainiisitc, likt! in..nih.is of P.irliauu'iit wh. 
 things '.I fh.it kiihl, uhiih ail' luoktMl 
 
 »'is t.'uiploy. 
 .'IT ; it was hioknl upon as 
 
 p.issts iip.iii laiiwavs. 
 
 ami oth. 
 
 a ri;'hl to In 
 
 into 
 
 pai. 
 
 ami thr i,'o\('riiiiii'iii shouhl pav. Id 
 
 iip.-n as ]>. r,|,i,sit,s. II,' .;on.si.h'r(.,| he h, 
 
 .iiiy .ithcr pi'ison's ,ir, cunt in that 
 III'; I do not know, pi'iliap.^ I ndiiht ivf 
 
 Wore iniich 
 
 in ih 
 
 at all about that. 11 
 
 rt'sp.'i ^. 
 .tl 
 
 n.)t SI'.' any inv.'st).,'ati 
 
 jH'ili.aps that may b,- rlii- on 
 
 I'l' to 
 
 i.'i persons 
 
 ir s.iinc fiositiou, it [ 
 
 ni„'lit'r 11 
 
 IS., to di 
 
 I'l' 
 
 ..■r.' wl 
 
 Tlifii about Ilnini' and tiii' \i 
 
 c nwcais .iistiii.i,. Mt. Kills ha. 
 
 I'Ui Ml. Kills kuL'w iiothiiu 
 iiothiiiKat all to do with ii. 
 
 bv .Mr. EUi 
 
 H 
 
 af,Mra-st bridge, fliat uas satistl 
 
 I'lolllv .lis 
 
 ,'lir to pay. Mr. Di 
 
 mm: say.i JU' was ba.llv tr.'af.jd and uia,,h. t.i pay for 1 
 
 iiiaro has sworn thai the a 
 
 noi'L' than h 
 
 fiiriiishtHl to llunii', and he .li.l n.it t.iki 
 
 I'l'ouiit, was niado out in ditail 
 
 inv t'X.L'^iiioii to It. At anv 
 
 110 (oinjilaiiit to this .lepai'tnu iit. wh.iv hr had hi.-, i.nii d 
 
 r.iti.'. 
 
 lij iiia' 
 
 Thin tlu'ic is the Met 
 
 w. a iii'oai'l 
 
 inioia .'a.se, whirh is a trilliiiu matt.'r, whh) 
 d it 
 
 uistnuati.iiis Mii-owu out that Mr. Ellis 
 have hvH dioppo.l bv Mr. McOallmn 
 
 logulati.ius, mid it was not hdlowpd bv Mr. MoCall 
 
 1 appears t. 
 mil : uiil>. 
 
 lad tri'itod liim nufairly. That 
 
 Biid^'c ,it Lo, k 10. Til 
 
 that; and, instead of men b.-in/,; employed t 
 it apj-«ars they were simply, durinj,' . oiistnut 
 
 eie ajipears to have liepii soiiii- iiidihiiit... 
 
 'I'Videiuo abuii' 
 
 lo wiUK one .lay ami undo it tiuMiexi. 
 ion, -aisi.JKthe bri.l;.;,, t,, ^.t the lev, ' 
 
 H feet: Hud they had t.. rui.s.' it up a ..rtain h.'ight. so that tl 
 
 nii.Ieineath the hiidj,'e .)ii tlm alnitmmi 
 
 1.' mi'ii .'ouh 
 
 Is. 
 
 Then the s.-.ni 
 that he paid for i'\ 
 
 Si. till re is 
 
 Rii 
 
 :,i,''ir. 
 
 IJraill 
 
 nothing in that. 
 
 i«y swears distimilv ami Ir 
 
 tor the governiiipiit about that ti 
 
 eiythinjj; done upon th.ii. It 
 
 nij;ht tl 
 
 iil'l'Mi 'ii.'tt 1 
 
 le w.i.s worl 
 
 thi li 
 
 that has b.'.ri referi 
 
 Hit. a! any rat.', he swears distiin'tlv that 
 
 1 II 
 
 wl t.i her,' that he ili.l tl 
 
 ink, 
 
 IL- UOI 
 
 Then th 
 
 npoii that poiu' 
 
 'ill 
 
 liml litth' troiih 
 
 d it 
 
 wa'- 
 
 tl 
 
 .'.\t I'ase is that of Willi nn A.--. 
 
 ■h,,i 
 
 lere is ii" i|i 
 in,:; the servi. 
 
 mbt .Mr. Kills has vielde.i i.i tlr 
 
 d Ih. 
 
 1 1! 
 
 le intiu.'llre (il 
 
 •'Utsii 
 
 a v.ry 'dil man. 
 
 Ill 
 
 Ihl 
 
 'i' 
 
 .an I for 
 
 ■as.'-i wl]. i. 
 in rewai.i 
 
 1.1. 
 
 a;iniethin<; like .'ifi m 10 
 
 ;,'i'ow n iiilmii an. 
 
 ,1 
 
 II' .llS.'ll.llJ 
 
 Mum 
 
 I fl 
 
 'hi- .-itv- 
 
 ii'on rnK;ii^'d ill t[i.' .h'jiart 
 '■ ""-^ ■! 111'-.-' ii'-:"i io tha! .fhir. an.l h. 
 il his ilntiim At th 
 '.ho ft'!f that Mr. Wiiham A- 
 
 men 
 
 soni" ie.,i-m(iuii at tlui h.in.N of th,- i 
 
 II li'i|Ui'sf of 
 'Heij was .h 
 
 a ;aii; 
 -ierviii:.' 
 
 the matt.'r, i.iok up.m himself to aliow thi- man half 
 
 iivi mill. .lit. Ml. Kllis. alt.r 
 
 ■iiiisKlerin 
 
 IV, ami .li.arn;*. it to repair 
 
 iW, til 
 
 Si;..' fli.at 
 
 hv.'il. ha.i 
 
 .1 
 
 |ii-t .,r 1,1 
 ll.l 1 
 
 la 
 
 partiiiB 
 |.'\fr.'inpnt 
 
 N( 
 
 IM.ink 
 
 alter 
 not J 
 
 H.' .1 
 
 ellK" 
 
 Irliink 
 .silting 
 Ibri. 
 
 yoi 
 
 or 
 
 at fJie till 
 I r.i me lliii 
 
 .Mr. Smyi 
 Itaon.' fled 
 U^uiyvh Wl 
 I knows til. 
 ur the \ 
 
 la.l f.) 
 
 time 
 
 irh. h 
 
 md 
 
 lessil 
 
 bi'liev.. it. 
 
 Then 
 
 hi-'<;iriiiintr 
 
 ha- i.ome I 
 
 • ^.ild thi 
 7 •JO, -'r, 
 ■ linn I.. I 
 ill the ri'sl 
 Then 
 
 lliE 
 MR 1 
 
 oiifi.m . 
 X,.w, 
 
 IS .•.line : 
 '!i i( he wo 
 ii» w.iiild i; 
 
olliiit; oTiioDscs st'oms t' 
 till' i|iii'8ri'iii ;ii)oiit il, 
 ^ iillic i il ir|i.iir VDii \\\] 
 
 I'tlM, .ilid tin: liiii-sc ]\],, 
 • lIl'Uli takrs f.xri|Pti(il; 
 
 ■■■ pau'' III th.-it lioiik y.. 
 ■I-, .iimI ImIdu that rill I 
 i.it hii.s .stood III,. f,..st , . 
 
 i-'ll is siiilicllillij; fijl ail', 
 
 lillly ('.SlibniiiMi, J ;iii 
 '■^ tli;if h.. did iM)t p,i'. 
 
 Imt li,' 
 
 "•■i--> oiiipkivi 
 
 «'i^ looked upi)!) as 
 >"ii railways, and utlu 
 
 111' roll.sidcl'cd In: ll;;. 
 
 >' '''I' any iuvi'sti;,'atiri 
 s that may be tin- oi,;. 
 till hi;,dit:r iiji hun- wlm 
 II- Ellis know iiotliij., 
 ii« at all to do with il. 
 itislacUiiily di.sjHjscd ■; 
 ' pay f>)r inorc than h, 
 rnad(! out in diiuil -mi.. 
 Ai any ratu. hj nias- 
 
 d.li.'i', nhiili ajipcai's t- 
 -^li-. -MoCalliiin ; uu\\ 
 faii'ly. Tliat sirins t.. 
 
 hdiliitr .;'vidi'lli'e aboir 
 
 iind undo it (ln> next. 
 
 '>ii'l|:« to ^i.'t tho lev, 
 
 it rill' ni.'ll rnidd wni k 
 
 ; ill that. 
 
 he oiiirlit to know 
 that hi.' uav \M-iikio_ 
 I'ai.s distiiii'ily that ,, 
 iii'l it wa-- j.aid toi 1.-, 
 
 P ol thovc pasos w'l' I ■ 
 'i'li' pi-ojd' in It-war.' 
 I'd in t^ii' lii'partnii'i;' 
 
 lit! I'fllcc. and III. ill ; 
 
 u it'i|Uc6t ol a !ai:, 
 AsHidl wa.s di'.serviii;.: 
 
 li.s. atti.r 'oiisiderin:, 
 I'hai'^'f it to icpaii'.s 
 
 iiiw, as far as that gofis, T point out f 
 "iw. that ho iiad iii>vci' lucn paid t' 
 
 15 
 
 O V 
 
 f^it, sir, and produrr the dooutnoiit.'* h 
 
 101 |i to 
 
 lor as ,1 
 
 111? that t>ositi 
 
 position, and arfinc in fliat fajiaiitv. Mr, .\,,soll 
 
 oiiiuioii nifsisHiitrci ; fliat \\hili 
 
 ly month as n i omiiion iahon'i Uy Mr, \v, 
 
 '•< luimi' had hoi'u attach 
 
 I'll, 
 
 had hi'Pii atraihoij. first to tho I) 
 
 111 ; not with th« vifw of 
 
 ininilli. li^i 
 
 L'ov "iiiini;n 
 
 t. hut it 
 
 It IS till' liioM 
 
 i^ri'iniii},' till' piyr.ii.nt oi kr 
 
 '"• »VV Ml liiKWir. l.v Mr Rod 
 and, n.'Xi to th, ,\,,updiKt list. 
 
 |!i~t or last list 
 
 '■oiiv.Miji.iit \ia\ ti' I haii 
 
 pinu it hid iVom tli 
 
 I'l 1 
 
 Dining into tin. ortii.o. Mr, K 
 
 law l)..|.n bi'ttor. ai y.n siijijiasti d. 
 
 lis hi 
 
 a lalioror upon the tiist 
 
 idojM' that, and r think, hIi, it 
 
 '.iilini'nt and htati'd how th(> hu't 
 
 il' Mr. Kllis had at 
 
 h 
 
 onni wviiti'ii to th 
 
 |.i;ri'inpiit of tbi- canal I Miink is .sa 
 
 Now, the noxt niattiir wp 1 
 Ilk, si 
 
 yill^' a j,'ood deal 
 
 <iy thai rh.it aHoited V. 
 
 fhink, sir, von niii.st havo 
 
 liitvc to coiisidci is that of •'.SmiHi .\; ])^^^ 
 
 'inn; ro il 
 
 liur 
 
 nian- 
 
 .mil I 
 
 l.iiid after hcariii.!.; .Sinvtli's tostin 
 
 i^oiii liision, alter lio.ning Phel'iKs tost 
 
 Iwi- not tcUiii" the tiiitii 
 
 louy in oi)|Msiii..n to .Mr. Dj. 
 
 inioiiv, 
 
 [lie denied ever liavint; .spoken to ,Mi, I'hi.' 
 
 caiiiij here and deliheratelv si 
 
 •r, that Mr. Disln 
 
 that he ha'l pm-chascd 
 
 M 
 
 slated xrh.if 
 
 l.s stitelliini. 
 
 till 
 
 nil k'i I 
 
 Ifhiiik yon eanie to the conclusion that, ev 
 
 linisi'lf, turned out to bi 
 
 "■.I'l not true. 
 
 '■■ n ho was tirsi 
 luitriin ; and I 
 
 Islatiiig what w.as correer ; at anv rate, Snivt 
 
 eii u|>ou hi.s own testinioin, ji 
 
 brie 
 
 or that he sold him the privilege, for all t 
 
 1 denies ]iositiv,.|v he i. 
 
 11! '.\a.s not 
 
 iiin the 
 
 lid I 
 
 at the time ho s.ays ho invoked the bh 
 
 inii- to come, ol riirnishing wat 
 
 I til me that he was siraiuiiig his i 
 
 '^■<iiiK of the .Mmii'htv 
 
 «!■, 
 
 iin 
 
 urination pnlty far. At ai 
 
 Mr. Smyth and by Mr. Phelps, both reliable wit 
 
 ipo" liini. It seem 
 ly rati,' it uas met Ic 
 
 I more ciedence to them than Mr. Disher. It 
 Kiiiyth would a,i;ri'e to luinish him with all tl 
 kiiow.s rheie are niillioii.s of hor.s<'-power ^ 
 
 iicsseM, 
 
 id 1 think 
 
 1 so impiob.ibli. 
 
 .vou will "ivf 
 
 le Water hi wajiti 
 
 ui'l unlikely that Mi 
 
 wiiei: 
 
 ,-ijr rl 
 
 lie water 
 
 Kll 
 
 ;oin.!,' to wasti 
 
 What 
 
 I'Celvboi 
 
 IS had the power. Smith had to do as t 
 
 Jiowei h.id .Smvth 
 
 111 to do was to keep too much from 1,'oiiif,' over. 
 I rime; and the idea ol saying he was goiiij; t 
 till iiiessiitif.of the Alinii^'htv, 
 
 It 
 
 '"■ «''is told, and all h 
 ,^"dii^' to Waste all th 
 
 ,1,' to y;ive hiin so iimeh wai 
 
 a perfect fai( 
 
 and I 
 
 ei, and iiivoki 
 
 believe It. 
 
 not think vo 
 
 iig 
 11 will 
 
 Then there is aiiothei- ti 
 
 n ial cliai'ire : ami tin 
 
 .^uiniiii; to fasten soinethiiiL' 
 
 iig upon ,1. (i. Itemaiv and .1. |{ 
 
 re .seems to be an attempt from the 
 
 forward and sworn that .Mr. Snivth «ot t 
 
 Sin\rl 
 
 'Sum 
 
 all i-.\|ilodeil by Ml Hastings 
 
 lilee stii 
 
 I'l M 
 
 r Mnv 
 
 th. 
 
 who swears positivelv th.it thsv 
 
 an 
 
 ^'>, 
 
 ' recollei 
 
 ■t 'I'l 
 
 lionias 
 
 Hasti 
 
 Imii fill them. 
 
 ; p.iid fi 
 in''.s took sour 
 
 lor Ins v|, 
 were hi 
 
 ■p: 
 
 pel -on 
 That 
 
 So von must ronie to th 
 
 || I hem by him. .Smvi 
 stmie steps to mv |i|,-i 
 
 s own, am 
 
 1 s"eais, 
 
 .ml I 
 
 111 Hie ivst of the ih 
 
 l■OI|^'|ll^||,||. 
 
 ir^'es to whiei 
 
 I h 
 
 tli 1 1 
 
 ave ri.'feried so f.i 
 
 thai (1 
 
 pai. 
 
 Ill IS 111 
 
 Then a trivial ehiircje af;ain about Mi, .■<nivt 
 
 I II niiii 
 
 lor an afternoon. 
 
 ■Mr Wilk 
 
 in>'iii ai hi.s 
 
 rilE COMMISSIOXKK I think that 
 
 MR KVKEK. 'V 
 
 IS ll.'lldlv 
 
 '"'■iitioii III 11 
 
 a pailful iif p!a«tei. lb 
 
 I'l lulls ch.irp'. 
 
 le senator. 
 
 iwever it ^eeiiiid to ati 
 
 ■.i"t the 
 
 Vi 
 
 ■hii 1, 
 
 wi I mill, to ini'ilb..'! !n,-i!!ei. th.it i.f 
 forward here, and delibiiateh ^wm 
 
 Ah! 
 
 II' ;■ ,1 
 
 nd .Ml 
 
 "oiild lend hi 
 
 II that .Ml .Sill VI 
 
 m a certain amount of i 
 
 ■'Uiuii Ahbey 
 !• upon condition 
 
 noiiev lui 
 
 ii» u.'uld increase the pav for his horse. 
 
 W 
 
 •' specltic tilll. 
 
 ell, now. the \>h„U. boi 
 
 stilted that 
 
 I'lm ib knocked 
 
]lU } 
 
 IS 
 
 out of that case when we ascertain the fart rhaf !,« «... i 
 
 dollar a.ui i, half and flmt n«, fi > ' ''°^'' P'"* f""" t^'* ^>0"« 
 
 .n.i that up to rhatr ;;:;:; r"' r' ''' '"" ^"^ >-^*" ^-^-^ ^'>- 
 
 least, not L- n.anv ; ar ! / o's Jr 'I'T, ""' ;"''''"-^'' "P"" ''" --'• 
 -utra.licts Abbev alt^Kh.r h . i J !",""' ^' '^". '' ■'"^' ^"- ^'">- 
 
 look. s.r, at the ..it/;;:; i„ : ::;nrnH ':;" ^'"^";.""^ """-^- ^- 
 
 Smyth swears thn same thi„<. i, is .,„ , . ' """""^' ''^ ^'H ''^"••>f >' 
 
 dollar was ko,:t by Mr, Sn ■ h Vrr..nr J'"' "*"■'■ ''""" '"""^ ^ "'" ^ -'«' ' 
 
 Smyth. an.l I .„. satisli,:,] ho .'tWi , u. , s n ""': ""'-^ '"'* ^^ *'' 
 
 against Sn.y.h nh.ch n.u«t ,,. „. , : ^^ „ ")j" , ''^" ^^ -'""- "''-. 
 Booth, Mr. Bra,lley. and Mr^Kyan uJ t ,,., ^ t''^ ' Tt""' ''' 
 documents show it-was SI. r,0. ' ''""^'^^-and the othei. 
 
 X<nr we ..onre to the ,,uesti..M .,| ,],, ro.r of rhe stone u the „» 
 and ti.jt of on. friend ,le,hu li.atle who sn , ,, ,. T ^^" -"'^'-■'■"'"«'t '("arn 
 • Wen uttetnpted to ^.e shown U ! ^ o J: '' "'" '" '" ^'''•''^- '' '^ ^ 
 
 erntnent wa. paying a verv lat^ge p,i.. 2 ' "'"; 'T" T """"' "''^^ "" «"^ " ' 
 -hat it i« worth. If that we,t ,ue . ^ I'r '""• "'"' '""'^'^ '"■^°>"' ^ 
 
 «tmnce about that; but what ar. t'he ^ i; "u^' f' '" '"''''•"« --"o- 
 
 .l«liberatcly swears tha- he .ould ,,„,,rv the s, • \ ' ''""''" ^"'''''''^ «'"' 
 deliver it at Shriner. bridge J ,^ Z d ' V". '" rT'''''' ''''"^' '^"' 
 statement that it w-ts not Tone .r i "'"■" '"' ^^'^'^ "'"l^ing th.v 
 
 ti.at my predietnm;:;;;^: ';;;::: ::,r^^'?'"^^ 
 
 Callum, swears that the priee pa.,1 to out " " ""■" "'"' ''' '"• ^'' ' 
 15 years-.,Vo,n 1. to U, yearsithat th i !^ i" ^ Z TT ^ ''''^ ''^ ^'" '«^' 
 Btone of that .ualtty was ^..00 to ^5.^a if t \ '''V IV'T'"^ ^""" *''' 
 ollrontery to stand up here and swear he eouhl .1, . ' , ' , , ^ " "^ I"" ^'"' 
 subscque.tt evidence, is shown to ho a ,,.dess m ^ "..r • ;'''''"'-'' '''^'''^' ''■ 
 ho eould .p,a>,v i, for .*i a eurd. I s v i i ' / ""' ""'•'^.'"' ^''"^ 
 
 evidence, San,uel Bovd, Hetnv Carter u.d 1 „' 'I '" ""' '''" ^"''■^'■'l"en> 
 
 g^tting no nn,re than a f.,r priJe „:' li;; ^ e ". tlt^^V'""' '"" ''"*''' "-■ 
 useless and played out long ago; a„d „,.,, u lllX Z:Z^T' ''^^^^ 
 Uuahty, tit fo. any purpo.se at ..11, under anv eirenm f ee V 1 ,?' ''""'^' 
 
 ?5 to $r,.,0 a cord. Tl.,.,, ,,,|i,s ,.,, given e'^ "'" """''' ''"^^' ^" !-"> 
 
 I-*^^ ^-'''> '"■ ^ '^ that u, eonstStatio ^^uTlCXo^ ""V'""'- '' 
 
 their mimls the.^ uould close i, „,, |„>,,.„,,, .„ ' \T ' Ottawa they made up 
 
 oftheexpen.se. ' " "" ' '""''' '"" "^'"•.^ *' '", on acronn' 
 
 Then, with n lerenceto Rohejt Simn-ou • I ,lo „ , 
 ^efernng ,o that. Sin,,.,,, has eotuphZ: ' ' j„ i ^Z^, '' '^ "-'^ ^''"''^ 
 
 Mo,.ri,son at the a,u..duet : and we have show,,' I J' I ', '"'"'"'■' "'" ^'' 
 
 j.ulgmen,. As \1,-. M,.Call,„„ .o„|d say ii- ••|,o t""'« t'M'^»ss a prop,., 
 
 rather hug... ' ' '" '"'" ' ^""" .^•""•■^" pio|,ensities we,, 
 
 Then(he,e !,Ms!,^.,.„;,trivi,.l ,i,a,g,. .•,,ja,„s, \i, kik, :„ 
 stone monuments. *" '''.'' '" ^"'""vtion with ,^om„ 
 
 I I 
 
nly paid for the hors« 
 eeii for yarn ht-foip tli!) 
 ^•yftii upon fbp csnal, 
 all a .lay. Mr. Sniyti 
 3 that SCOW; f|i,,t, ho ha; 
 I'xMit this niniiP3. . Hi- 
 
 n'Xliiii^'at all about it 
 '11)11 iH.'fwven Mi. Siiiyd' 
 |||;ti hark; not a slug!- 
 '!< ii' 188;j I think, .sii. 
 "''■" liiiriy met by M. 
 that is auotJitii ehai^i 
 ' In Mr. Wahon, M, 
 
 hoiy(s--an(l the oth.'i,< 
 
 th('f,'ovuniint'iit, ijuarn 
 If I'l' tliu tabic. It h;.. 
 Of other, that the Go\ 
 t'liic. a)).l niucli hfvoihi 
 I ill making a rtnion 
 •l ionics forward an.l 
 oveinnjcnr (jiiarry aif 
 •11 hi' \va^ making' th.v 
 ; and the lesult show- 
 i('.s.s lalloil by Mr. M( 
 lii-t! ; that for the Ia>t 
 I the average price f,.- 
 ^\.iiton has the cooi 
 'I :' 4'iarry, which, b; 
 i'lilt to work in, thai 
 'I'l'l the aubsequeni 
 «h,.tt- That Battle wa- 
 •oveinnient quarry i- 
 stoiie of any averag.- 
 '11 "on Id liave to pay 
 ill IT was elosi'd. A' 
 Otiaw,, th(\ inadenj. 
 nrv ii oil on aeeoiuT 
 
 ■*■■ It is Worth whil,' 
 Hie londuet of M, 
 '^'^■''ly, that he was :< 
 iines to ()a,ssa propn 
 "" propensities weiv 
 
 iineetion with .^oniM 
 
 an a> alte„d by the .inploy.vs of (be ^ov, ,m ,„. M,, ,, N, n .w, L ,o ,1,.. 
 
 a.iil Mr. ^n,3, b swears ,o,|H.. an,,, bin,, ,„,d(,bink von will, on,, " 
 
 sioii ibeir IS lioibm^ m ih.K , baig,.. 
 
 Now, astotho wall at llol,l,.r., | ,|,ink iIm^ 
 ihiit 
 
 nii:("UMMlS.Slo.VEH -Ol, ve-. 
 
 AiK.HVKmn; i ,...,;. ..nVm'tb u -o ,be ,,..,. wbi,,, ... ,b,.. „„., 
 
 :::';r;:t'::;!;:orb; :,;;:;!;::;:;;;;,.';;:;•';■:•'■, •■'--'-'^ •'"' 
 
 Tl-n, keeping the ra,. .Lar ot i,, ; M, x,,,,,;, ,.,, ^^^,„.„ , 
 
 I reeled the .statement towards the end • he savs "tl„ <• 
 
 11 breaking the „ ,.,...': T' . ^''" •■-■•■•■■'"""' --■-.■ ^P-'nt one 
 
 I" the roiiilii 
 
 '■ll<e liillM .iti.-ly y,,ii ii, to 
 
 "eentin breikiM,r ,l„ i ., •-'•■--J-. ""^ '■o\ernnMnl never ^p..nt one 
 
 I '...111/ 111 uieaking tin; h;e on tho.s,' yiici< T L-.,.,t ti, . 
 "\1IT,.... -1 • . '"o,s, laii,. J Kept them open at niv own exiiciis,, 
 
 ■M:.::,:i,:r;::,;';'r''i-.xr;:::r:;Tr'"™r "'"■"•"■* 
 
 llioint di,l not amount to anvtliin.. Mr Mr « ' ' '" "" ""* 
 
 ,,,, "vuun^. .HI. .Heiiitt .sweais to the sam., thin,'. 
 
 •'-nnnent. uv ';;,:,,:,::. ^^ ^^^^^^ 
 
 Ml WoodruJi; Mr Ho,lwell ' '''^ '''''' ■^''' '^■■'>-^''l'''ni,t..,,deMt of ,b,, ,,„al, 
 
 "-'• '" < - conclusion .1,,; c, ' i""*" ^''''"' ''^' "'• ""''"'• ■V"" •""•^' 
 
 '-" that second It n '''""r" "" ' ' """' '"" ^"■''"^' '"">'"' "' '"-'" 
 
 ".'^ ...ills .n,;tr u :;a :': r^';;::^- ' '"•' •" t'" ^^^*^' '" ^"^ -""^ '"• 
 
 Merritts evidet.ce at , J ' ,«2 '^ "' " '^«''•^ ""''ry that should be done. Mr. 
 
 i till, ai p.ige .062, I thuik bears t lat out coniidetciv At., v 
 .iisnex-piaine.l that, and Mr Vecloi, \i, i- "' '''"il'ittM\. .Mi, > orris 
 
 eiiiplovinent of Mr Hodwell ' ■ '"f ''''"''"■ "^"^"•■^ ^'"'^ "''"" '-. the 
 
 >''<^«'. ^vith reference to .stone masons and Mr llustin.'s- M,. t.-ir . 
 tliat he made a bargain with Mr H . ,; ' ' ^'^ »%"' • Mi. hllis has shown 
 
 n.n.i.h,nasonsatwSr s ,. tnf' ^' if ' "' '""''"'" ^" "''^ '^"^■' *" 
 
 H'-ting the repairs c rid..::: .' ) ? '^. T^T ""' "'r'^'"^" "' """■ 
 
 •^^i.'iO per day for each mason Those w.n ' ""•' "^''"■'' '" l''^>' '""' 
 
 i'-s usually paid at that tine, d n ^ I, "'"'V--- '''^o- vveiv the 
 
 ---^'•^-••-'-.-Motn...rikd^^ 
 
n!i)!i 
 
 aiii 
 
 if^iMiiisiMf ro scr tliiit tl 
 
 18 
 
 IfV 
 
 tl 
 
 I'Vidnii 1 
 
 tl 
 
 M'lilits W.iltcin's I'VJ. 
 
 I''IK'<' Clltili'l 
 
 "ii- 'liity vr.iiMilv [ tliiiik Mi. Elli 
 
 Us nuMllHIlt ,1I1,| iltt.'l|,|,f,j,l to luitcii til 
 
 'IV hr 
 
 iits ul 
 
 an.v I It., «•(■ liiu.' Mr, JIiistiii„''s cvid 
 son ; mill «<• Iliac tluir sintijiM 
 Ml. Il;,sti, 
 tli.'it I, nil. I 
 111 bill . 
 
 >ii Mr. Klli. I 
 
 'llM li iv.> r.,iUi- t..|«;iii| 
 
 aiiiiiii iiii.|i'i.-.taii.|. .\i 
 
 'll.'.- tint ll. ,.||,,,l,,y..,| Wilkiiis,,,, ,„|,| Tl, 
 
 iiii.l u.. li.iv,. .Ml. l;i,|,|| 
 
 •III. I |.. iSllll-i ill . liKlf., 
 
 Ill uhi.li thcv Miv (I 
 
 r\ ill, 'II 
 
 'I III. II 
 
 III 111. 
 
 I. ii.il ..r ..lit 
 
 i-y uvi.. .'iriploy,.,! I. 
 •"I.I l!..^',i Ml!!,.,-, ,.vi,|.|„ 
 wh.ii (li..y liiiiiisl, skill,. 
 
 I'l'IINOII. ,11,. I ( iliiiik .,,, 
 Vdli tin.'.' (.1 loiir III, I, t. 
 
 ;uiilii;j 
 
 1" 
 
 •iiiiU' ii|"'ii tii.'ii 
 
 ll. 
 
 It 
 
 11. u III yoiil iiwii l.ii iiM,-. t 
 
 M.llnl 
 
 i;il 
 
 \\..|-| 
 
 hiiv. 
 
 .III. fi)iiiv.ileiit lor it. Tl 
 
 vtu ttill 
 
 ti(;crilii.' I 
 li.'il I-i the UMiii 
 
 pi.ii.sililc I'nr ( 
 
 ..III..C (I 
 
 iar|i.'iiifi>, uijl ||,,t 
 
 II' ^aiii.' mill 
 
 .III,.- 1,1 ll 
 
 liiiij 
 
 II' ■■iiinliisiiiii tliri'.' i 
 
 ;lll> 
 
 III.' II. 'XI iii.ittur 
 
 rHi':(UM.\ii.>^.>;roNKi.' - I 
 
 -< iioiliiiif^ wroii;; ill 1 1 
 N I 111' iii|ii('.|ii, t ,iiiil til., li-lav. 
 
 I lliii 
 
 liiok.il 
 
 lliiltti I .i! V. 1" 
 
 ll I. 
 
 at til" iiiueiitii.ii ol tli. 
 i[i.)it 
 
 ll'.l tl. tliut ili;i|>;.. I 
 
 ill 
 
 tll.lt, Jiiis.sil.ly, th U Ilik'liI 1 
 
 ivc iiii[i.)itaii.:(\ It iliil afi|W!iir to in 
 
 vult iiic with r,.r,.||.ia,. t,, til..,! (1, 
 
 I'l-t ■*■!) tlii- 
 
 it it W;is 
 
 11' till- rliiiiuos w.'iit 
 
 javo liMu (I u.iiil 
 
 01 
 
 liuaiiii.' the wli 
 
 (:Vil< 
 
 1 1'Uaoimbl 
 
 I'lKl: ill 1. r.,l..||,f! tl. til.lt, I tlllll.k- 1 
 
 piopoi ..'ili..i..i|..y thi'i'e ; but aft. 
 
 tl 
 
 e ilLirt,'!. miiiiitaiiifi 
 
 [ 
 
 U-'li.' 
 
 le (iviilfn..^ th.U f c'liulrl ii.,t 
 
 ii'inarkeil to rli 
 
 I'l' 111) siu 
 
 he siiM no, liu \v 
 
 iis.suiiiL' lie was aiixii)ii,s to 
 
 U' 
 
 Xlli'! II 
 
 of tllO.sr ill I 
 
 IIS not. I c'lii s.'.' Ill) possible I'l'Duml for il 
 
 triii.'il St'iiatoi .'It ( 
 
 I.'OIIVI, t Wlfllnllt |V,|..,0||, ;,1|, 
 
 is riiiplov, with nut emk'in oi 
 .fl 
 
 ability, ti) ili.sifli.'ii-^ri; thi'lr iluty. 
 MR. RVKERT-I tliii;k 
 ti'stiiriuiiy. 
 
 largiiij,' Ml. Elli.s, „i an 
 iiif,', at li'ast to tliL' vi'iy b.'.'il of t! 
 
 :ii'ii 
 
 voii iiiii.st havi' Ih'l'Ii ,<j,itislii'il witli M 
 
 Ol llSOIj 
 
 'Aa.s. 
 
 THE COM MISSION ER-VV.,. I 
 MR. RYKERT- All 1 Captain lUrv>y li 
 festeil by Morrison, tliat if ho erre.] at all it « 
 
 Town, who .swore, as to tlu. zciil 
 
 THE ro.MMISSlONEK -V,,: (l,,it if i 
 
 as on bfhalf of tlii' (. 
 
 iiiaiii 
 
 'o^'oniriR-nr. 
 
 I" .'ii'r.j at all it 
 
 bt'li.ilf of till- liovirriiiHiiil. 
 MR. RYKERT- Xow 
 
 was ov.T.Mutioii 
 
 riv 
 
 anil 
 
 p;ii1 o 
 
 thi 
 
 Wf L'onif to anotlifi niattii i 
 
 invi'sti.i,'atioii Mr. Howm- w 
 
 N l.'lati.iii to tcinlci 
 
 in Sti'vpiisson's t-viilf 
 
 asmlli'il; and in hi.«t 
 
 In til 
 
 lii'e 
 
 favored a I'ert.iiii .stovi 
 stove.* ; ainl from \'tuir ii 
 
 ileal 
 
 It pag.! HM, they butli triei! to .show that .Mr. 1 
 I. Catharines in re.speet to tin- fnrni.sh 
 
 I'stinioiiy ill p:igi':i,sl 
 
 ;ii:- 
 
 er HI ,S 
 
 wa.s justified in paisuiiij,' that I'uitl 
 respect. If tin; h'tter were to eonvev tl 
 it, you iiiu.st conie to th 
 
 .s.r\'atioii ill lefi'ienee to a letter of Mr. Mi'Cl 
 
 li'arv s, ; 
 
 fell 
 
 to get this eontraet; but you i 
 making that ehargi- was tl 
 saetion. Mr. Hi 
 
 Vour icinarks were perl'i'itly loriirt. in th; 
 le ineaniiirr „i iiiterpiel.Tti.ni llist juit iipo] 
 1-011,1; was ilnne, in ok!. 
 le "flitleniai 
 
 toneliisioii that sonii'thing w 
 lid not know, iioi .|id lanti.npate, that, tl 
 
 le '.'ery pi'isoii mIi'i wa.s ''iiilty o 
 
 rooki'.lncss in the trai 
 
 w.se I'OiPe.s forwai'.l and swears ho loiiM not t.-nder for the M-aseott 
 
 stove, lieeainje Mr. Lloyd bail the sole privilege of .sidlin- 
 
 ties of Lincoln and Wellan.l froin tl 
 Lloyd's testini 
 
 those stoves in the r, 
 
 ie inanufaet 
 the manager, tli.'it Mr. H 
 
 urer. It tiiriis out from Arthi 
 
 rhe Oovemment ; hut lie went to Lloyd 
 
 0>V.S" I 
 
 ■ouh 
 
 not .sell the sti 
 
 thrill \on tfind.r, and y.ju will p.,y i,ie tlo- oxtra d 
 
 and said, "I will tender a doll 
 
 ar liifrht 
 
 honest iransaitii 
 
 to; 
 
 '11, and I think How.se had better not 1 
 
 ollar." N 
 
 ow, that uas not 
 
 itJmojiy. i think there is nothing in thai, so tar as Mr. Ellis i 
 
 lave eonie ami given us tha 
 Colieerned ; le 
 
l.v, r flunk Ml. Elli. 
 
 iM h iVi' I'liiuc ruiUiird ,ir 
 i.ililii"! illii|i'r,-,fui|.|. .\i 
 I Wilkiiisni, .111(1 '|"|i,iiii| 
 
 V tli"y Wvtv ,'it||.Ioyc,| I, 
 »{■«, I- Mjllri'., ..vi.liliM 
 
 tli'\v riiiiiisli skilli.; 
 Ii''ii n..ilv. If si.iimIs t 
 
 I ^ll|lcill«T-, uill II, ,f M II, 
 
 <y till' .saiiii iiiiliss III, 
 
 l<<if<;\iU!i: ;l||.| I tlij,,; 
 ll.-ll l>'-;|pr,', 
 
 ""III. I |l|,t. .i:,y tin, ; 
 Iff tl. tll.lt, tll.lt. it was , 
 
 • tin- ( liaiijfd.s w,-iit 01 
 
 t.i-ii;y there ; liiit alf. 
 
 tlit-'iv eai! In; no .suri 
 
 st'iiatur at the .lo.^.; „• 
 'ii f without na.suii. in i 
 iiKin^' Ml. F.lii.s, m mi'. 
 
 the viTv best of thiii 
 
 islii'd with Muirisoii'J 
 
 re, as to the zoal maiii- 
 the l-itn-oriiriK-nr. 
 it was (.iv,'i..autiijii d 
 
 tioii to tf'ii'icr.s. Ill tj, 
 -ti'stinioiiyat |iagM:{><l 
 ' .shou tiiat Ml. Klli 
 f to till- furnishing ,' 
 Ii. M.(J|,aiy's. J fell I 
 iMlri'lly ,-,)iic,t in th;r 
 'U'lntiiui lirst jmt njioi;! 
 ,1; was lionc, in .pkI, ■ 1 
 ti', that, tliv g« ntli>niai 
 
 *loklMili(.,S.s ill IIk; ti'iii; 
 
 i'udci- ioi till. .M.iscoit. 
 isf stov,'.s ill the i-,im. 
 urn's out IVoni Aithi:. 
 I mU soil the stovr-s |. 
 Miller a dollar liight 
 Xow, rhat was not, a : j 
 )niu ami given us tlia 
 
 Ellis is CullreilK'd ; 1|. 
 
 A tiinit the tenders for nine Mr Hmt... ,. , , 
 
 h. fen.lend for pi,. «, ; „j, ^ ,, , '" ' ; " ''■•^^"" 'I.V a-l ,l,.,ih,,,„.,,, „.at 
 
 Hou,..sav.. page 381 ^Wi 1 n 1 '' . ' ^^^ " »" ""'"^^ « <"ot. Mi. 
 l-re and ..tate.s, and J ni„d , e ,1 . ' l"" '"■'"** *'^''' ^''^=^'""''' ' "'"- 
 
 -'- '.is i.u..„ „:',L' r ::::::•" ; ';^; f-' --• --:- ;'.i<i- ^ 
 
 "as American pipe; Mr. IMuse .,av.s h.^ ask I ,1 , r ""•' '""'\ " "'"^ '"^ 
 
 -i.l Hiovdid no, ,u fha, tin. main L.^^' ",',:" l^^^'''^: ^"' '''^^'^^'^ 
 lakfn; Imt In- ask-d f„, H„. 4.,,, • . -'*'"»•''*. ttitietor. , Howse was nii.s 
 
 *"<'"''»•'* f'f he r,uestion of tinilwr; von aske,l Ml l-'lii .. ,. , 
 
 'Irew out from h.rn what .xan.u,atK.n the e ^ I^ .n . I " '"" "■ "^' 
 
 .vourself, from Mr. Ellis' evafnin.tion ,1 f . " •^" "'''" s't'Mie.l 
 
 tenders were nronerlv .ot ^^0 e ■ ''"' '"' '" " ''"''"'' "">' '""' ^'-' "•^• 
 
 -aore than the one suggested .hould t^ t!:^ tSL !:;:::";;; "::;; 'T'''' 
 no such thing; at page I'l?!) he siv^ ih.f m . ^ , ' ^""t'ai'y that it is 
 
 «o .,..« .hiJ „„. 1,.: .: 4 ,:,' V ,,:'",,:,'; .' ';;■"','," "* '■■"'" *"" '•• 
 
 liim al alii lie >.avs he harm,, ,i„l.', , "•"""■ '"■" ■"'■ "«ll»" "I'VIT .ou.sulu'.l 
 
 hiin^ H;„i,,;-::h;.rt, ;;,:;rt ':,;''"' "^^ ..ikii..„8„.o 
 
 hiaadvh.,o„ a „»„„,,,,,,,.,„ „, 7 ' ' '."' '"'" '" "i'I"~ «I»n .«r. Elli. 
 
 ■..,» .n hi. ,a,.. wr:,^r:;t;r.^'r ;;::::«r .!;t -' ■°'^"- 
 
 arch over a culvert, he niitrht as w.-ll tilt f throwing an 
 
 ;:;*•:■ '■'»" - ■ - -" '■■-■• - -■»;i;:' in:rr,,:;'.;:; 
 
 Now, then, we come to the very celebrated matter.- - 
 
 .....irg'tri!'''""™'-' """ " '•" "■ »™-™shi,> i„v..«„a,.„ ... 
 
 MR. SVKKRT.-Tl,ath.h,s.. ,,„„„„„, 
 
 i!::;,;":;;' r;,:";:: '';,:r:':f ;:,',"'•■'■ :'""'• " - • '»«- ■■'•■ ■"-« 
 
 .-hicl, h. ,il.,,|aj„| ,„v.,.al ,i„„, ,,„,i „„ ,„ , '°".° ' ', '^" «">"8'. t.m|.e,. 
 
 I- .a. .,.„„„ ,„i«.t.„ ,vhe,. he ,„.,M , , ; ■ , .,,^:;:;t'r "'°"' '"« 
 
 '"'e^- /!'< uganift tlie long enquiry 
 
!(j !ii 
 
 I tliiiik 
 
 in ili.it , liiif. 
 
 2fl 
 
 iliM ,\c.iiH_' Ml-. ('liirk.''H iliMth W!i> 
 
 *^ill '■' ■ I" the .'iili.'llisinii til, It 
 
 < fiiivil \n til.' KiiK hiT.it; ttniK'-l dcwii 
 
 il ^^■l^. ridt. .IM>4 lli.U llrt'lc is rintllil' 
 
 THKCOMMlssioMll; N,, 
 
 Ml{. ItVKKliT ,\l ,.iiv iHlf tl nl.i h, i.| 
 
 Ncai- Mtfcr il 
 
 'I'l 
 
 n -I |(,tllii-* wciv .liourieil. 
 
 I IS to w.i.', hot piilili.-ili.'il tiir t\ 
 
 !i-' iii'xf |M.iiii is til,' .JKiif,'.' iillii.i.<| t.i M. ,,(!, II .111,1 >,, r,,.|iii.'lv l.\ Il 
 
 • K'l" I'lllll'"! ill l>i'll|;||(''.s liDiLsc. Tli;ll 
 
 Air. r. Iiriiiiiiit, .Ml. C.iin.ll, ,ii„| |),.|iiiin liim.vH 
 TMK ro.M.MlssiONKH V,..s. 
 
 I.S '■.\|plfM|ri|, J llillik. Iiv III.' . vi.|. 
 
 I" M'li;il( 
 
 nil 
 
 Ml(. la KKI.'T I'l 
 
 fllU llist illU'sl 
 
 i.if is ii>> siirli tiling as >,"'tliii,i,' f\i< -;,.,. and II 
 
 PU'SII..,, v„|, ,,ut «,.,s, •• It is sihiply IvrallS,- I ,ii,| „„t ;,|r,.|„l tu II : I, 
 lor Ills J{,'|.s, u||;|t,.tll il III.IV III'. 
 
 iMillii I i|iiislii.ii, aliniii KIlis aiKJ till' gas. In i| 
 I'l' fliis i'ii.|iiii V it CI 
 
 \ 
 
 iw, wi I on,!' (i 
 
 iMt ill .'viij.'iin. that .Mr. Kij 
 
 ;k ii'i 
 
 111' iiiiii|iaii\ , 
 
 II 
 
 M' ' .11 IV [111 
 llCl' ■'.'IS ,1, ,111,1,., I I, ill, In 
 
 i^^-Jt, .lllll tJKlt Klli.^ ,li,| |„,t u,.t liis ( 
 
 'III'' iiin ill < \itK:iiii' that III! I'liiuiai't hd't I 
 
 (I't lllcl) .sji'll,.,! II 
 
 'iitr.ii'l \\a> .sif;ii"tl witli lli" linv.ri 
 
 Civi' «"•■« until l.'iM ; tlial at tl 
 
 ni'iiicy I'i'i' aliiiiiiii. vi/,, ?>r>.<Mj() ,.\,.iy li.ili vr.ii'; a 
 
 iini'iit tln-y ajjiiT'l to |,iy ,i i I'lf 
 
 'It' tiiiic tin 
 '■ill .'iiiiiiiiiit M 
 
 iimI .Mr. I'.llis l.ail iiotliiift,' to .say .ilioui .ilt, lin^ tl 
 'I'lii' i.liM'i v.iiiiiiis, I think, .iir, uni 
 
 .s|iiM ill,, iiiiiiunt was niuiitioiicl. 
 
 ir allitililit 
 
 iiiirca.siji'' 01 n iliii'iiu 
 
 yell at tint time uill apiiiy now, V 
 
 sai.l lit p..,-,' ion am! I ,..,.1, t h.li' Inn ,|..,,f,' |,,„„ this, l.,',au,M I 'think 
 
 on 
 
 to the 1001 of Tlu' whol, matUii ; .iinl 1 ilo not think voii liav 
 
 «' 
 
 your viiiws now tVom wliat voii Ih 
 
 I' iiiiy ii'.i.son to t'haiigi 
 
 Ihi' ol'j,''tioji o!' Ml'. Kvk.'il i., .Mini. t,,i' t 
 
 im'ssci! • yon suiil, •' 1 think tlial toadi'x 
 
 I'd 
 
 ■ liav, 
 
 n<i ri.i;lit tl. Ill i:i,it^f.;,'i| l;,.}',,!,, ijiis Coniinissi 
 
 K.Koii; that Ml. Kllis ]iriv.iU' alliiii 
 
 tain tliciii, unl 
 
 I'.ss it i.s slii>wn that ihcv ai 
 
 ' ami othrr i-vi.l 
 to the .stri' t rnii'.s of cvhIi'ih'c a.s hcloi. 
 
 oil, Inn liav,' I any ri^ht fouiiii 
 a roiiid'cting link lictw.'uii .Mr. Elli-^ 
 
 ' fii'il tli.if aii\' [iiiviiic iiiatti 
 ' thing th'ir ,i.tn;,ll\ aH'ii't^ il 
 
 '•III'.' ol .-orMiiit [ii.i, tin ,,. 1 ,1,) not pi'ojm.s,.. to hohl Mr. .M.'Calli 
 a louit; at the same tiim' I inii.',t hf satis 
 
 T I 'roll" 
 
 ht M|i Im-Idh' inc is a coniiiTtiiis; link with .soi' 
 
 ic iiiatii'is iiii'lt'i- ronsidi-rati. 
 
 III. 
 
 Tl 
 
 you sav. •■siijiposiii.t,' the ^a.s w-.ti' tunii'd <in th 
 
 ii'iiat page .12i». 
 
 it, ami it conM not hi' shown that tin- .sa 
 
 anal, ami Mr. Kills had ordt 
 
 ' H'i'v HI'. I .'aiiimt .sc- aii\ wroiisj in tiiining it il"\ i, •; ,i T 
 ' '•oinj.wiy-slionhl hi lali' I upon to I.uin gas wImi' th.H 
 ' it ,an ))<■ shown that the piihli • intcri'st was ii,;,. 
 ' that Mr. Kllis liaii i.'.'ii',,,! hi,- 
 
 vinp of that gas injun.'d tlic publi' 
 
 tniiot .si'i' why the gii 
 
 * M" noccssity 
 il 
 
 II 
 
 ga.s iKv in iiiik't ti 
 
 ' thru I shoiilil .SI',' till' n li'vani'V ofliis ('\iil 
 
 !'• 'Or mg down the gas, au' 
 in.jiiro ihi' piil'lii' intcifsts 
 
 Tliosr oti.si'rvatio 
 
 \ iik'in'c 
 
 s.-onied to he pi'ttiiuiit at flK'tiiiii', and I think 1 
 
 in I'Hlliiig your attt'iition to lluni: tlii- ^i^ing of tree "a.s wa 
 
 tlii'i 
 
 part, and thi' acoiptatiro ot' th 
 
 (.' .sanic a nialtii of iiri 
 
 'Ui, t. say th.iri' is any loirupt hargain, I think v 
 
 'II jiistitic 
 .s a in.itlrrof ju.lxMiit'iit o 
 idcnci' on .Mr. Kllis' pifrt 
 
 not . rri'i't. 
 
 •Ill will I'OII)'' to till' 
 
 roiit'insion 1^^ 
 
 V"ict we 1 
 rtli uliili 
 
 I -Vi' till' ( 
 
 luii.stion of stopping v.'s.sds in rlit' ranals. It is lianll 
 
 i"r to it, hcausc it is r.splaim'd thoroughly hy Mr. Di'iuan 
 
 TH K ( O.M M I.S.SJOXKK— Yes 
 
 .MR. UVKi';i;T^-TIierc is the complaint of Mr. Carti-r whii.l 
 
 aif- vi's.sels lit'inL' '■to 
 
 ppi 
 
 loi'k 
 
 Il was made aboir 
 if. ; it was fully invt'stigated ; and I put in tl.f 
 
KU(t W'y.\)i tiiiiM'l iliiwii, 
 i< lliiii ilri'iv is iiiitliiii;' 
 
 i.|M.tr tl.ei..oi, i,.i„|., i.y M, |.,„„„ „^^ 
 
 111'- ('Kill llJ.ticll f||;,f, „>; f. 
 
 II ai -.11 
 
 «1 
 
 '•t •J,..ilH. So ilmi I tliii.k 
 
 MKitfi'i'of .jihi^iii,.),! (Ill Ml. !■; 
 
 f'I'lIlK Vl'hM'lM it, tj,., 
 
 ymi Hill niiii. r. 
 
 '" |''ti» ; Ih iimk.'M a nilr that 
 
 laiml 1^ .,,|,ri llird it, JM Nillt|.|< 
 
 ■^ lint |.ul.li>l...,l |.,r t^^.. ■ '""""? '•'•'•'■•'111 winds; ,„„| j,' , |„, |„„,^ ,,.,,,,„|^ ^_,^^_^ ^^ 
 
 VtHM'.S tllll 
 
 ■'•liii^'lv l.\ III.. M.|,,ii(. 
 
 ink, U\ ill,. I \ j.lriirl' .. 
 
 [H»; atii) the jinsw.-i t.. 
 it ,'itfciiil tip il : h.. ji.i\v 
 
 I'iS. Ill till. Lilly [111 
 
 11' {,';is .111 iii.liil liiiii l,v 
 ■ait tiail liii-ii si;r||,.(| j], 
 tliat al till' liiijf til. 
 I riitaiii aiiioiiiit i.i 
 iMiiuiit wa.'^ Miuiitiuia-ii, 
 iiHTfa.iiiij,' 01 inliiriti;.: 
 uiil iiiijily how. Villi 
 lii'caii.si I tliiiilx it ^vv> 
 !■• any ii'a.-.iiii to cli.iii^'. 
 tliiiilv tliat to a )lc>;i'(i 
 V. HI lis ]iiivato iilliiii 
 ^l• I any rislif to ciiiii 
 ink liMw.'cii .Mr. Elliv 
 to lioiil Ml. Mi'Culitiii. 
 i tiiii'' I nni.st lie s.iti^ 
 I'ltiiiK lirilv with .soim' 
 . ' Then- , It [lagc ]i'ii. 
 Ml. Klli.s lijiil iiiili'i'cM 
 as iiijtiM'il tile jmblii • 
 iiiliot .SCO wliy till' gu- 
 ll" iii!(.'C8,sity inr if. 1 1 
 iiig ilowii tlu'ijiis, ami 
 
 the imlilir iliti'icsts, 
 
 I I tliiiik i am justilii". 
 
 Iiatt<'l'll|jll,|.^r|,n.||t 111, 
 
 CI! on .Mf. JCIlis' [i:fit . 
 
 f to t)ic coiit'liisioii i;- 
 
 liinals. It is harin\ 
 y .Mr. Dciiiarc. 
 
 hii'h was made ukui- 
 .1 ; and 1 jjut in t,li> 
 
 li •<a(is(ii.ii. if, is ...ftaiiily not Mr. K 
 
 lOsc nil.s, 111,1 III,, t 
 
 .Ml Dtiiiarc w. 
 
 •|iiiii 
 
 '""■ ' 'liliil; III! ,A|il.iiiali. 
 
 llut (lie inu»tcr nl tlic .Mm , M 
 
 ili-r.icloiy „„ ,|,,„ ,,„j,n -,,|,^,j| ,,_,,„.,,,, I 
 
 ||"||| thai That «a- I 
 
 iiii'd .oiniiliiiii,.,! Ill ,li|.i^ 
 
 .\iiii<ii,.( 
 
 I' jiajjc •-',•.'00, si 
 
 •Illy ami lliiiioii;f|||y iinctigui, ,| \ 
 
 III' /llMl -fi, ,. 
 
 !>; -a 111 
 
 I ,„l 
 
 *Ms tdJiiij,' cntiiviv what 
 
 ■"wiii^f ,l,aii.\, i.rt.M ,1 li,„-,,„^| 
 
 l^ll llH.^ll.r. til 
 
 tl 
 
 !•• ia|itaiii ill i|iaii'i., h 
 
 wis niitiiic. ,111.1 tliat tl 
 
 "11 >wll III, 
 
 n •! Il Mi, 
 
 ii|>i)ii .Mr. .\iiiisl 
 
 III iiiailc 1 
 
 ic OH mi III till .\| 
 
 .» i iii-'ii'iii;, 
 
 MiM , 
 
 lo Mil h ,111 
 
 V|il;iilii'.| liy Ml. 1 1 
 
 rone's viviil iiiia;,'iii,itii 
 
 nil'lr III 
 
 i|il,iiiit, 
 
 \' Il iiii|i 
 
 Now, tnki tilt; iiiittci- ,,r ,|, 
 
 iiiK, I ihiiik 
 
 I'liiai'i- 
 
 it lia.-. 1 1, 
 
 TIJK O^MMI.S.SKJXKK \\ 
 ■MH. i;VKKftT-.\ 
 
 "W, wc comi; to a iiior, 
 
 iml that is the trcatiiiciit. oi rln ,.ui|i| 
 
 'Molls lii.im I, „( |7, 
 
 SI1-, Il 
 
 ivitI 
 
 lis «cni;iai tmitnmiit towanls iho„ in 1 
 'C-aiiii<,' ohaiactcr which is allcj-cl, i( th u I 
 
 I'loM'cs liy Ml Kills am' tl 
 
 II' casi , 
 I, .SI' iimi(.|. 
 
 limps ; 
 
 , ir. 
 
 iHili'imtysiii,ciint(imlcfit.s, then I tl,ii,i. 
 
 iiH nii|iloMin.|ii Is 1,1 rli.ii 
 
 '■(••'Il his haliir, ,im| fill- h,.,i,,. „| 
 
 muii III 
 
 IJiit when it (oiii.'s to iiivcstigatii,;,rti 
 w.is iliHiharKcii, F think 
 
 yon aril jiistitioii in inv 
 
 ^'llii;i|iicstioii why J;,nii., I 
 
 ^iiv'iitiiii' tl 
 
 •■ III,. 
 
 '"il""l'-'i ly tivatcl. .11 harshlv li,at,,,j 
 
 t IsoIlUiil,. nry.illr lildvilic..; I„ 
 
 •I'a.ii.-y, or.iiiv |„ 
 
 nil. 
 
 Kht 
 
 li' lie h.'iil 
 
 '■•HiNi'. il .Mr. IJi 
 
 aiiicv w 
 
 ''•• y-i-xm for the (iovirninciit icinstat 
 
 ilOt lllslli 
 
 'lit it is ciitiii'lv oiitsi Ic tl 
 111 ii|i|iortiinity of having,' i 
 Hraiilcv sni.iis', at 
 
 111,1,' hiiii. 
 
 'Iniic luni, tlnii I 
 
 "!■ llivcstif,'atii,^. ,1, 
 
 !•• I'lovUK'o ,.rv„n, ,,,„,„„ ^._ i,e^.,j„^,. J, 
 
 c iiiatti 
 
 licir 
 
 •"'il'l.iuits investigate, I, ami tiu-v i 
 
 le^e geiitleiiii'ii h. 
 
 oiniiuttee. 
 
 '1' not. " Saw, I sav il 
 
 '^"' -'l;i, 'l ii.ly .lemamle.l 
 noiv whi'tlicr .Mr. |.;|| 
 
 lave lii.f 
 
 not k 
 
 .■ui iiivisii..',iii„„ tIiiom,.|i th 
 
 ■Mr. KIlis is ar 
 
 IX not lair lo 
 
 Is Wolll 
 
 Xe.U, 
 
 •oiiiitalilf. (or having' ilischaim'd 
 
 eoine lieiv ..ifti., dij, ].|| 
 
 iii\est,|.'ate 
 
 "'I' '■" to ("liarlcs Cdllici 
 
 geii a man who .Ij,! 
 
 ■-1' ot time a I 
 lol ii.rl'i.ii 
 
 II Ill- 
 
 was <!;if>atcr (han the oil 
 Dem; 
 
 xi'ase, anil I {|,i„k i,, | 
 
 ciice. 
 
 11'- i'.l>e I he iiiii 
 
 tics eviil'ii ,.. ami .Mr. Mi||,., 
 
 Al the time I thoii^-ht.si,: hiit, after I 
 
 l<iM tli,it insnlioriliiiatioii i.^ tl 
 
 I'viileiiie, ami w\ 
 
 |lll||Js!i.||l;||| 
 
 leariic^ Me. 
 
 irk.s, I think 
 
 le mill of ■! .r|,..,t 
 
 I'll uassaiil.aml lookin-'at thi 
 
 wlieif I man 
 
 if troiililc ami 
 
 Niipennr in a n,rc:ir jmhlic u 
 entirely fion, i|,,.,t |„,,„ 
 
 A<iiill\ of insiil.iir.liiKit 
 
 '■vil in all iml.li,. 
 
 ink, that tl 
 
 i"ii, •■iml refuses to- ol 
 
 leill.stati 
 
 ihiiik 
 
 l>ut, ,ti anv lit, 
 
 ley are jnstil 
 
 ie\ Ills 
 
 Ml- mii'ht 
 
 It has been si 
 
 "•'' '" lclie\il|H themsclv. 
 
 idllt It. 
 
 lav.- kciit 
 
 lowii .Mr. (v,||, 
 
 er will |„ 
 
 I'l away, without makiiir- a fuss 
 
 T 
 
 ili.Sehai'fje 
 
 ••.\|iiiliti. 
 
 :i,.iii w ■ miMc lo ,\li-\:inii,.|- .St(.\\ait'.s 
 
 Il llolli I, IS 
 
 II. ,11)1 
 
 'n.ittei. Mr. ,\1 
 
 I"""""'"' ^vork. Mr. Kills thought that 1 
 
 e.\aiii|.-i- .Sti.w,u-( 
 
 Wa.^ iiof 
 
 liil not ol.ev i 
 
 lis Onlfl.s s;ltisl' 
 
 l'«";l"llmn. But Mr. KHi^ s.ays he .liil not ilisi liarr^- 1 
 
 icionlv 
 
 lifiiii that kiml ol 
 M r. Stewart ti; 
 
 rk at wlii-h }| 
 
 urn aU(i.',,| 
 
 e was tlioi 
 
 "■ 'I'll not act with 
 therolbi'. he 
 
 "I', I'lll .Mllllll 
 
 III' 
 
 woulil not .say so. At aii\ 
 ■1 ilay or two. 
 
 say « h'-ther In- was ilischai-L'eil fr 
 
 1 ,-iiy,ii,rcii ; ami uhiii J 
 
 rom till 
 
 i.ite,.we know this.tliat .Mi. K 
 
 'erniam-ni ciniil,, 
 lis n-iiislaiiil li 
 
 I'ly 
 
 pressed 
 yilieilt, he 
 
 ill! "itiiiii 
 
T)u.„ tl,..,v ,s ,l„. ,.,,.. ,,! M:uti,. XMur; he ,nak.s :t .■oa.plaint tl,at ,T„l,n M 
 
 ..■x>M„. ,i .> .M Llhs ,.,■ l,y M,, .s,n„l,. P,.,J,,,,,,, ica Wgorou.s r.,le wo.v n.lo,,t...| 
 u,n„ ,h,. l„u..l ,lK, NV,.1I„„1 .■.„,.,]. . I,.u,e .n.n,l......,no...k-U.,„lc.r,s, Ini.Igo ton ,. 
 
 ''';, :■;;■'>;. ;;"■';■'•'«■"• •■""•'--■. -"' ^^^\^<-^- tm,!,....,,. on wi.i.h ...odit i« giv.„. o., 
 
 wl, ,„„ ,.v . ..,.,,,. I ,,:„ i, a , ,.M.,n, uhi.h shouM be pu, a s,..,. ,...' Tben-'i. .., 
 
 a g...... u, h,,,,,l,l ,„..r. , uiunn,. ul,„ i. .upbuuin^ of tl„a. Tl„. Divi^.o, 
 
 CouH .sh.lln,,.b:u«,.sn,,.,l..^.i„., ,„., M,,., tb..y will ,„„ ,„„, ,i,..i,- au.on - 
 
 iuak,. a ,,no, „„„„b ...bout . lar,v ,,u„ily ,o M.,.l.,„t. .,,-1 all th-,.. ,n„l :,rcalK,il , , 
 gu, on i>M,iiiisiii!,' t., |iiiy a ,b,|b,i a niuntli. 
 
 .I"ln. I'lark,.'. ,-,,>,. ua^ Inlly nu,.ti.at,.,|, au.l I think Vnu >mus( .■,.,„.- to tb 
 
 .e un.ht „. t,. tlH. ,!,..l, . .„„ u,„thy oC en.ploy,,,.,.,. Mv U,Lio ,ce t H 
 |U|., ...... ..n h.p,,.s t,, .. s.k. h. ^ 
 
 Then a.s to E,l\v,ii',l Sinilcy's carte. H,. i^ „„,. nf t),B 1„ ct .;, , 
 
 .1,0 »„,, „„. ,,,. „.. ,„„ ,„„„, , „.„,„^. 4,::::;J":;r^; :;:,;:,: "r::; 
 
 foi' that roaaoii li,>. was i,i'oi,.»i.ly di.suh.u.gi.l. ' 
 
 W., ro„u. t„ ,hc. .a... 01 W. L s,.uth. lie, trind to ,nako out a frrh-vanrn .,,,,1 
 ho e„t.n.ly huk.,1 He .h,l ..ot sat.ly yo,. th^re was auythu.K wtonf ^ l'^: 
 
 ■ ;IS. """" •■ """' '^ '""'""■^^'•' '"""^'^•- ^'-^ '- -- ^»'^y 01' 
 
 Tlu-o w,. bn. Vohu.y.M.n,,, who -uiue. h,..,v ami makes u loug .noutU abou- 
 ...ng d...h u.g,..,,, 1,., had be.,, .epeatodl^ war,..d abo,,t ,hunke.„.esl Su .ti; yo" 
 do not iii-opose to investigate lliat matte.- I ^^ '' 
 
 THJ-: ((AMMISSIOXKR-Xo, Idonot. • 
 
 MK. RYKEliT- Rvan wa. ,li.eba.g,ni to, d.unk.mn^.s, and taken on db 
 |;lK.god .ga.n and taken on: ev,.,.v .■on..e..ion granted to him, fc-r the Lk^n. 
 t».n,lv, a., yet he be, a.ne so „,to.xieated they -onh, not keo,, lim any >1> 
 '■-not „nd..-stand ubv M,, MeCallnm .i,ould blow hot and eohi, H ,- Zki.re 
 ahont ,..o.- e,,,.. l,en,:u,. being dis.-ha.ged, an,l then in the .^^J^^^t 
 uas nor l,t to be .n the e,n,,|oyn.ent I ,lo not know what he ,nea..> bv fhu 
 
 THK COMMISSIOXE.: A, any .ate, it was established he wa.'a good u.an 
 MJI. UYKKIIT - Thon.a. Ha.tley, anothe,' untb.tnnate vict.n. ot intemperance 
 a n,an whose e,lnea„on shows he is entitled to a bette, positio.. ; vet a" t^ 
 cazed h„n so that be ,s not able to d.seharge bin duty, and had to be\|is,S 
 
 A.,d n„w we ,o,ne to another ela..s of eases, the incivility ofe.nployees ' Mr 
 Unme has .on,pl,-nn,.d about the nnfortnnate lockdeader. b.in^ asl,..,, ...d .,11 tb", 
 
 tcnle.s upon , e very lo,.k he eon.plains o,; ana othe. luck, within a range ft„r 
 or h^ e lock. 1 hej hav all swo. ,t that Hume state, what 1. positively unlru M • 
 
iilllpl.iilit tli;it .Tiiliii R. 
 was i,„ ihkIu,. influoiicu 
 Ji"U.s iiiio woiv adopttMl 
 ''-•iiiler.-i, liii.lgo teiiil.T'i, 
 ■sly imiiiiiig licavy liilU 
 
 ■ iiirh crodit is given on 
 lines lui jiaynient, tjn^v 
 
 ' ^1"!' to. TLfiv is not 
 
 of that. Thr Division 
 
 III |iiiy tjiiii u((onnt? 
 
 'II' llli'.jll.igi-, fjicy will 
 
 lilt. Htiil iiiwilliiweil t.. 
 yoii niii.s( .-Lnu! to tin; 
 
 itS()|-,jJ,eily,]iij(.|,;„.^y,,. 
 
 i'lrker who h.-id )iis leg 
 'J'i'iity .■jii(K'nntuiidont 
 V lixjierience is, that 
 -idv to turn Dut and 
 
 diveis wc havo upon 
 hotoiuus abii^ivo, and 
 
 out a griovaiion, and 
 
 ■ >noiig. Wc did uot 
 that tlieio was a sub 
 at he was guilty of 
 
 s u long muutli aboui 
 ikeniiess. Surely you 
 
 and taknn on, dis 
 n, for the .sakeof hi.s 
 him any longer. I 
 il He roniplaiired 
 ' inixt lireath said li.:; 
 Means hy that, 
 he wa.-5 a good man. 
 ini of intemjieranoe, 
 lion ; yet liijuor h.ts 
 to he tlismissisd. 
 of employees. AJr 
 asleep, and all that 
 videnee of the lock 
 hin a range of lour 
 itively ujitnie. Mr. 
 
 lit 
 
 I!o-).v lias mnlf some .■ouiplaii.t- 
 
 '" ''I'll- ^Vhru !,.■ is asked !o 
 u-r made any . (uuplaint aiiout it, he will 
 
 i';< 
 
 omjilains aliout the lo-k-t.-nders he 
 
 Mienuon who Ihl^v 
 
 were, and 
 
 iiig umivil 
 
 " iii'u he i,s a 
 
 nia 
 
 Coinini.ssi 
 
 iiipliin! : ir th.-refure ,1. 
 
 not ^!i\ u)i:it lock I. lid 
 
 sKeil I 
 
 fh 
 
 oil, an 
 
 tl say thai six or 
 
 ' ii'if lie in Jii 
 
 '■I'; iiiid a hoils h< 
 
 IS nioiitii now |(, ,.,11,1 
 
 i-iiiK's. and ni.,kea emnpLuiil ahoin it „.iu 
 THK CO.MMIS.SIOXHI; . x„ 
 
 ■ipt.iiii .Saiiiiii ii|.|l.; 
 
 seven years a;<o some lo.k tend 
 
 eri-a 
 
 lied 
 
 'lefi.re the 
 liini ahiisive 
 
 MR ItVKiORr ( 
 
 )i 
 
 si nee, 
 ! fur. 
 
 casing tlial 
 At any rati , 
 Then the casf 
 I think, Mr. ( 
 
 after a lapse of live vca 
 
 rs, and ><wi.'ars I 
 
 siuiilai eoiiiplaiiit ; .ind u |, 
 
 e»er sill, 
 
 Ik'Ii. 
 
 he has li. 
 
 it 
 of S 
 
 I'll well treated. 
 
 ■111 I roiiii!e on, 
 I 
 
 Ji'i) a man 
 aiei Hon,, 
 
 aious that f 
 
 Jierrv Caitn - 1 
 
 "• maiiatjeiiient of (he eanal lias I 
 
 ''^ 'io| look 1,0 me to I 
 
 le 
 
 onimissioiit 
 
 'viiifv of ih 
 
 ma I 
 
 eiii 
 
 and ot 
 
 ler.s has li 
 
 Hii that a in. 
 
 live n;|'erre(l to that, 
 mne to ihe .-oil,. I 
 oyees is coiieeiiied, the universal test 
 
 ifeii safisf.aelorv. 
 
 lei. \-f)M milsf 
 
 iision that, so I 
 
 'ir .i.s til,! 
 
 lie civi 
 
 iiiiony of fuij.ow 
 
 te.il) 
 
 Xow, another gnat nime, the 
 irs here, with all ihe .lignitv and 
 
 " ''lid ol.ligiiig lot ol nien do not ivis, 
 iiidWlily of Mr. Ellis. Mr. \V. X. 
 
 ners 
 
 "I the Conservative Assoeiatic 
 
 ii'sponsihility atta. lied to 1 
 
 Currant 
 
 [.Skinner's Corncis, an 
 
 'II of Ihe 'I 
 
 liim, bednc'i;) 
 
 ;a jio 
 
 'dm out of the oil 
 jnun he wanted to havi 
 lisi ; and In 
 ills iriends in. .Mr. K 
 
 I, ami insists upon Mr. EUi.s anno 
 
 owiiship of (Jrowland, 
 
 'sition ; ami he .says Mr Ellis treated liini wit! 
 
 ppointing anyliodv 
 
 lairman 
 he.idijuaitris at 
 and eviTvliodv to 
 
 iee, and ,a varii^iv 
 
 oi otiu 
 
 1 a great want of civilit 
 
 i-'rthing.s. He .says Ir 
 
 I'U'loyed on the eanal, a list in li 
 
 y, ordi'fed 
 '■<"m- with ,1 li.st of. 
 
 •ante.i Mr Ellis to at onee f 
 
 here let mu roll 
 
 ha sai 
 
 d -If 
 
 urn out other m 
 
 i>* month, lint 
 
 len on t 
 
 voii eonie 
 
 i|i' eaiia 
 
 !i written 
 
 an 
 
 Slide f 
 
 lark this is one of the eases in LsM Mi. b 
 
 hvw eommissioned by Mi. Jhmt 
 
 (1 init 
 
 in 
 
 or--'It you bring Mr. Bunting's lette 
 
 :iiis 1 
 
 ig 
 
 li.as I. 
 
 made, 1 will put. down the n 
 
 |l"isitively using the expression C 
 
 anie, and attend to it 
 
 I', indieating he w 
 
 'ants an 
 
 nil 
 
 "ver saw you befon 
 
 ent speaks of H 
 
 III proper time 
 
 '"' respoii- 
 appointnienf 
 
 liiit 
 
 le.nies 
 
 man got very wrath v. I 
 
 iind u IS no use your eoniim' t 
 
 :iy^ipago-JI:jl; '•! .said '1 
 
 authority. 
 
 would not h 
 
 ■SS. 
 
 o me on that busim 
 :ive recognized him without Bnntin./s 
 
 Tl 
 
 lie 
 
 No^v 
 
 Hl:llit\ 
 
 WC eoinc to aiiotlii.>r 
 
 inl 
 
 us own e.stimation— a man 
 
 elebraled eharacter, a gentleman of d 
 
 iiairinan ol 
 
 the O 
 
 .Mil), 
 
 'High. 1 would like t 
 
 Miseivative Assofialion 
 
 'ipyiuf^a lugh position in the com 
 
 listingnished 
 itunnity, 
 
 "Ut it whieh stumns i( as 1) 
 
 pi.iiiit that Mr. Ellis, al 
 
 point out his ov 
 ling untruthful, f 
 
 tlie (■ounty of Wellaiid, Jol 
 
 idem . 
 
 beeau.se tlnn 
 
 loiliee 
 
 and wanted him to appoin 
 
 have already gut .im; of yt 
 
 lout the year LSSl, Ind thi.- 
 t a man name.l Ualb 
 
 11 the lirst pjai 
 
 is .somethi 
 
 '*:■ he make 
 
 111! 
 
 ng 
 
 row 
 
 with him Jf 
 
 !s a eoni- 
 
 i-dati 
 
 laith. .Mr. i;i| 
 
 "Il 
 
 V>lli 
 
 ilir 
 
 1 i,.: 
 
 ' ippointi 
 
 and now 
 
 onie and 
 
 Vis .ippoinfed; and 
 
 '■ went to his 
 is .say.s "7011 
 
 ogiiize uni; f want .Mr. Biuit 
 
 lor a third c 
 
 you h.nc il,s 
 
 .inoiher 
 
 o he ;i 
 
 lie he swe 
 
 iiig's aiithoritv for that. 
 
 lipoiiited. I eannot 
 
 His this thing took place 111 ISSI, voti 1, 
 
 I Mr. Ibinting was not a uiemb 
 
 now. 
 
 le th 
 
 'erin 1«,S1; 1 
 
 >l> \i.ll wil 
 
 •iii, as a matter 
 
 (hat 
 
 iig mixed up from beginning to end 
 
 e ceased in ISH'2. \l, 
 
 niii..uiite.s the fan, ,ii,d a very inii 
 
 bill, 
 
 it any i,it. 
 
 h^'olL 
 
 ■ouiitrv should 1 
 
 kuo 
 
 w. that he is Ch 
 
 :iml he demands tint his relati 
 position on the Welland Canal, and tl 
 
 urtanl faet, whieh wc 
 airman of the (,'01 
 
 01 record 
 has got th 
 imns il! t! 
 
 ought lo ki 
 
 ere 
 
 now, and 
 
 ves, his cousins am! I 
 
 iservilivf As.soeiatioi 
 
 11 ol 
 
 Is I'nils, 'hoidd 
 
 ic- liovernment should pay tribute to 
 
 his 
 
Tr^ 
 
 ml 
 
 1i! 
 
 if I 
 
 ii!' 
 
 ill 
 
 Ml 
 
 .lili 
 
 !J 
 
 liiiiiily irlalK.iis: .iini liucmsc Mi'. KHif, ,.) 
 
 Mr M-l),.iiMi;l 
 ollirc. I tliiiil 
 
 I ,UHfS llllll (he li( 
 
 \<iii, -.ii', vv,Mi|,! ,1,, il 
 
 loii.sc, to t.-ll liiui tlicic are i 
 
 ID varaiicic 
 
 mil -Mr. Kllis thnafriis tn kick lull, out of th 
 
 liati- hcpii iiii|)(irf,iiiicil in tli,. mii 
 
 "■ same lliiiiiT r lliiiik V 
 
 II- \\av. 
 
 ' nrivil u liiT,. till II wiMe a Hi 
 
 1 tliiiik ill N.ntli llasi 
 
 oil, sir, as iimiiil 
 
 llihcr 
 
 111^':^ vacaiicif's Ii 
 
 ave (fxi'iri.scil y,,iii- ,lisi-inlii)ii in iIIIjuk d 
 icrc was a va.anc\, ami yon t.,i,| him || 
 
 ytisaiiii ami i.i,.' apiilirants lot )]„. ,.,„silin, 
 
 I,- ami VI 
 
 u' I'lisiiioii ; ami ila man wciv i,, f,.|i 
 
 111' \\as Mot. 
 
 I'll! Inin i.llf ul ;,„ui iillin. vi'iy i|iiiH<iy. Ami I tl,i„k .)„) 
 
 iri'iiuil i:ii|,ii.|,i.|l>. Ninv, Ml, j.;|]i., ,|, .„],,„ ,|„. ,^|„,| 
 (Mini' Imiv. ami lirlil.i.i iirly s\\,-ai' Ihat ikal 
 
 iliil lie ri'iicalcil it, you 
 II Mrnoiiai'li w:, 
 
 WOllI 
 
 lifcaiisc 111- 1, lij.^,.,! I,, |.|||j| 
 
 '■■"■ •■! "H't. |i,i liiiii in issii f|,.,i; 
 
 '■ tliiiii,': ami i\,r that man (, 
 ■iiiinioMlv uas inaintaiiiiiil l.v .Mt. Kjl; 
 
 \V liisoun ic.-inmmy, uIumi: In.' says that in l>,sj 
 
 ■sif, i.s ,1,'ivon flic li,j 
 
 ;ati'i| a riaii 
 auaidi'il ihis 
 
 tmir til ri.inic al. 
 
 M aixain -t fin' (Jov.'i' 
 
 iii'l l^s:{ |)|,.,t ,M|, J.; 
 
 imii'iii. ami. in 
 
 lis UlVijstl 
 
 lorimi >ta(i'ni.'iils that Mr. lOHis 
 
 'lilM.silion li.tinTi^j.ortoi' Mr. .Miinn. 
 
 SI' III 10 niM ai-fcsor(;„vcrinm-nt laml lor a' 
 
 •■' "omuial sum. \VI„,i in- Mat.s tjiat, In- giv,-.s tli,. hV .„ ,11 ,,; 
 
 man .'jliJtii) .and I he n 
 
 111! Iii'.-ilal 
 
 IS was in lMisrilir,\- to hiin, it 
 
 iim 111 USUI!,' .,ri.iim l.niLriiai'c I 
 
 IS not true. 
 
 iivaii^c I 
 
 I'dinc to a imhlic olli.'fi' ,inil .-,av '•'»'iiii 1 
 
 say It i.s not li'rht | 
 
 tl 
 
 icMois no iva.sun lor it. 1 say th.iv shuuM 1 
 
 lavc ^'ot to lio .so ami so," wUvd if 
 
 "I' a man 
 
 if turns 
 
 tilUli 
 
 11' soim^ I 
 
 .So lar as ti 
 
 ii'Sf iwo i^'iitlijiiR'n ai 
 
 '•iii'liision that Mr. l']!) 
 
 'iiii'ini'il. 1 ti 
 
 iiiiliio|iii : whiln .Mi'Doiiai'li, w 
 
 is has siiown a \vy\ ,:],.ar sheet: 
 
 lici'k |iut to that sort 
 link you must i-oiir- to tl 
 
 conir hi'ir showing' a iooliiii; ami 
 till- lui'.sL'iit tiiim, amicr tin' cin niiisf 
 
 mm the cviiiiaiiai sli 
 
 lie liiis done iiotli 
 
 nws is- 11 liail-teiii|ii^red i 
 
 111;.' 
 nan, ha 
 
 iiiinosity whi.h lie ought not to have .iisi.layed 
 
 X 
 
 tiw, wr roine to the !e;,'ular ijiai'^'es. 1 think I 
 i.lenral i li;,iu,.s wlii.h Mr. .MeCallum has ihiown in 1 
 
 l-.olst 
 
 erinii; i 
 
 t iqi. Tl 
 
 111, ii\ wav of 
 
 liiii>!;,'s made l.v .Mr. SlrC 
 
 \-oliimiiious (diararter. In the tirst i.Iaee h< 
 
 iiive 1,'one through fho inci 
 
 ase an 
 ijuite 
 
 Hssistint; liis 
 
 ilium in the .Senate are of 
 
 J'or luel was 
 
 im iirreii. am 
 
 I In 
 
 liiugea that a verv la 
 
 l-iTu with thosu in I.s7ti 
 
 / 1) and I >S( 
 
 tune; and in his ol)..(er\atioiis li.d 
 
 mtiasrs th.. anioaiit expended in the years 18 
 i" ; ami .also with those of 1884 dowii t 
 
 an iiirre.ase, uml. r t 
 
 ii-e tin- Senate he |iroeeeds a.s I'olh; 
 
 me tl 
 
 II' iiK'si'iit man iLiviiient of tlr 
 
 I'fte e.vpemliti 
 1)9 a 
 
 >' jnesen: 
 There i 
 
 th 
 
 loijsam 
 
 ■lit. Mr. |';ili.s, in 1, 
 
 I'll, ill this item of fueJ, ah 
 
 iayinj^ the fuel for the Wellaml C 
 
 s delenee, trie.s ti 
 
 Iboii 
 
 tlu' Weh.ind Ciiial .sloh' fill i lor tlu' ( 
 
 Ilia! was stolen lorinerlv; that tl 
 
 exiilaiii tile itierease 
 
 ■red I til 
 
 tl 
 
 . emnirnt of the 
 
 le employees 
 
 nil-- fi 
 
 epuiitrv. 
 
 ■ wliole , la.ss .i| |.,'o]i|( in i] 
 
 'einplove.'s of the eaiial, that 
 
 •ilislike 111 attark tl 
 ' .soim h'l 
 
 "■ ■'" olli.'ci of the (;o\i'rnineiit ol ihi; I), 
 
 It 
 
 is not a vei 
 
 ei! "ay ; for ) 
 
 million to slaiiiKi 
 
 tliev ail 
 
 M-iitnre to sav, for tl 
 
 ^is iiomsi as III,, majority of mankiir 
 
 !•■ sii|ieriiii, rnk'nf l.ehiml his hai.k ; lor tl 
 
 t.'ls to III,- |li'[iartlm'i,l, .'isking lor e.vpl. 
 
 lat reason J 
 
 wroi 
 
 lai.l III |i,r,' till lloi 
 
 iiiHtion. .Mr. El 
 
 IS reply wil 
 
 .So thai you uill see that tl 
 
 he I 
 
 is full 
 
 le gr.ivaiiien of the ej, 
 
 las e.vpejidi d a mneh lariri'r amount in fuel tl 
 
 \ iX|iiaiij.'d. Ihal tliel 
 
 t.) do without h 
 
 e 111", cr \\ IS .'in .illowaii' e In 
 
 iari,'e against Air. Kllis is th, 
 as expemled formerly. Tli 
 'fore for if. 'md the men ha 
 
 VV 
 
 e i^i.1 on fuitki'r .iii 
 
 ,,,,,,. , . "' ^'•'' ""'' ""■ ^'■'"'■'niMif made l,y Mr. KIlis about lock 
 
 temlers stealing w I is imply jusiilled l,y the .videme. The evidence is vei > 
 
 «tron^ upon that point. Tlieiv is tl,,. evidence of Mr. Smith ; thi'ie is the evideP, 
 
Ill tlicrc iii'c ijc) vinaiicii-.. 
 
 IIS (n kirk I11II1 out of til' 
 
 i>k you, sir, as iiminlic] 
 I H.'istiii;^:, vaciiiicifis liav 
 01 llif posilimi,. ami yoi, 
 ir a iii.'iii wciv to tell \-i> , 
 ill' n'pcad'il it, you uoiil., 
 ilili .Mcl)oiia.i,'li ua., lint 
 '^: and loi- that man I, 
 
 iiiaiiitaiiKii! liy M,, l]]\, 
 . sir, is jriveii tj,,. ij,. (.. 
 i lli'-t .Mr. i.:ilis iiiv,;>ti 
 
 tlifiuj.ort of .\|r. Muiiic 
 'Covenniiciit lami Cor ai 
 
 ll'' gives ti„- li,. •,,;>!! ill' 
 
 If is not true. , liav. 
 is not i-iglit fur a ,Tmn 1 
 iii so," w iu'i) it turns ,, 
 <'i'k jiiit to tliat sort . ; 
 
 ll< you ilUlst IIUIIL' to til 
 
 ; ill' lias (loiK! nothiii;_' I 
 liail-toniiMiriMl man, ha 
 nut to liavc (Jisjiiaycil a. 
 
 ^'oni' tliiougli the inci 
 ol assisting iiis r.'a.s(; an ' 
 lie Sfnatc aip of i|uiti- 
 L vi'iy large exiicmlitti! 
 I ill lliu ywir.- 1809 air: 
 <84 down to thi> |iies(!ii 
 as lollow.!: "Then' i- 
 I this item olluej, aboL 
 explain the inerease 1. 
 ; that the employees 11 
 Hitry. [t is not a vei . 
 Dominion to slandti , 
 lie to say, for th. 
 ajority of mankind. I 
 '1- tiiat reason 1 wroi 
 Ir, Kills" reply uill 1, 
 
 s'ainst Mr. KIHh is tli.t 
 liiided formerly. Th. 
 >i it. and the men ha^ 
 
 • Air. Elii.s about loek 
 The evidouee i.s vei > 
 : there is the oviden. 
 
 'I' .laiiies Bradley ; there i.s fl 
 
 i5 
 
 1111 ri. Hmdl 
 
 ey : and there is t 
 ailed in ivbuttal ; all tl 
 
 le evidelK 
 
 le evid 
 
 ■<■' I'f Captain Scott, 
 
 ''ii'-'' «if other peo])le ; tl 
 
 and the eriden, e of Abrt 
 
 tilideis U( 
 
 ii'se \viliie.s.st 
 
 eiu was John Neill. 
 
 le III 111,. 
 
 'limine' them to ji.iy tribiit,; to t 
 
 ''■'''il "'■ g'-ning wood from the 
 
 ■s rome (oiward ami .swe.ar that th 
 
 Uiillld lint 
 
 lloWed to t.lk. 
 
 Iiuni III that ivspeet 
 
 seows as they I'anie al 
 
 iiid freiiueiitly, when tl 
 
 ong. 
 
 ilie paities. Captain .S.-olt swrirs f,, tl 
 
 ""••'I. fli-yuouM take it without the"km.wled 
 
 lie same tliiiif 
 
 and 
 
 ■.top[)ed 
 
 me. to sWeai thai the lock 
 
 [ « llhoiit eoiisi'iit . ,1, il 
 "iiifliision that .Mr. K 
 Ml. .MeCalluin referred. 
 
 lendii 
 
 Ml. as far as fh.at is 
 
 '■" l"-'-itiv('ly, and A. H, Br.i.ll 
 'II'''' a dozen witne.s.ses, i| v 
 ■s "'I'l. in the hibif of taK 
 
 ley 
 
 g« of 
 
 '•y sweats to 
 
 "11 hid not 
 
 lis was .amply instilled i. 
 
 ""■•■'""'I- I think you will 
 
 I makiiif' rl 
 
 mg wood with or 
 ■oniB to the 
 
 lit statement, to whieh 
 
 !'■ maiji-r ol' 
 
 We (.-ome to tl 
 illioi ity." 
 liii'^iMutions iip,,n that iioint? When .Mr. 1' 
 
 i.'it n.'e,.ssaril 
 
 •s|ieiidiiig a large 
 
 y in\-ol\-os tl 
 
 '"""iini of „„ V witl 
 
 <|iiestioii of uh.it 
 
 eiUt 
 
 iit Mr. Kllis' instruet 
 
 aav V. 
 
 as a.skei 
 
 mlv when tl 
 
 lon.s were, he eonld not fell; h 
 
 tl 
 
 "'"re Mr. Kl 
 
 K' 'iiuvtion if he |;n 
 
 I" repair.s aii. 
 
 la roe. 
 
 ■ when le- dl> 
 
 was ivadv i, 
 
 •says, --.Mr. Ell 
 
 is 1 onsults 
 
 'lo it. 
 
 -ningoi (pie.stions that woiil.l till 
 ■ I'lideavored to a 
 'di'iits consulted nie, and 
 
 i.is advi.sfd with me vet 
 
 ' advise htm on ,inv 
 
 y olten. IJ 
 
 subject 
 
 a she.t of paper when I 
 
 L- geiierallv 
 
 lailne 
 
 ill tl 
 
 II' construction ol 
 
 •'■^"vrthem, and do th',' best I couhl about it. So 
 >iiii tunes they did not. I 
 
 lad a 
 wars 
 
 im! I al 
 nie superiiitcn- 
 
 '"■« works; and what tlmv .-an k 
 
 am very much e 
 
 ngaged now 
 
 iK-n, page 140si ••Did not e.v 
 
 .\ii estimate is in 
 
 amine into t 
 
 •■''1' away I'toni me t 
 
 lev 
 
 W 
 
 lien th.al is 
 
 I'le and submitted to i.h„ .Minister. I 
 
 le small accoiiiit.s 1 
 
 Ol' itpaii 
 
 done It is sent t 
 
 mwn to the .same, and I 
 
 " !>ai'liatnent. In large it 
 
 am consulted about it. 
 
 Allowance is made for e.vtraord 
 
 the best 1 can. All 
 
 •«!■ Items my afttmtion i.s 
 
 superintendent 
 
 :)Mes tl 
 
 K-y exercise tlieii 
 
 inary lejiaiis in case of 
 
 "wn judgment. 
 
 s make estimate 
 i'nierg,.n.y. f„ sm.alh 
 
 e ipiestion arises about tl 
 
 :Hlildi 
 
 i.-Tc. ill his eviden.'e in ret. 
 'dM'Ut linllding .lock at, I 
 
 'i''nce to the dock. 
 
 ig of the (look at I' 
 
 Hie. iSonie 
 
 '"It Colborue. (fad 
 
 ''.vs: "Mr. Klli.s ,lid not 
 
 '"I't (-'olborm-. Ml 
 
 \ 
 
 say it is good, an. lot 
 
 lers 
 
 >\y. II turns out in evid 
 
 not. 1 
 
 an opportunitv of 
 
 '■oiisult n 
 
 I lied lot of niiui ai.ii 
 
 t'M.'e. that the t 
 
 'l.uv ,sav it 
 
 si!oiiig what 
 
 »as 
 
 IL'tl 
 
 ' 'u ; ,in.l th.\ seem to 
 ii''v u.i not like ih.- .lock 1 
 
 airil, 
 mak 
 
 ig owners a 
 
 '•an I'll iitiliwii.-- 
 '■'■ 'I'/'arenlly a dissutis 
 
 "'"'liave a privilege for ^vhieh thev onl 
 
 '11 tl 
 
 e more fuss thai 
 
 ili'iii, .Mr. I 'art. 
 
 ii' east side of th.. ,;inal. I 
 
 y I»ay S30 a 
 ' '"'v other persons on the canal. 
 
 I' lav. It 
 
 '!■ sa_\s Ih.'v do 111,1 Jik,, j,_ .|||j ^[ 
 
 "-•'•aiise it is not 
 
 -t"i III, 
 
 Ml, K 
 
 mu-r uas laiili t 
 
 lis sa\'; 
 
 tl 
 
 " aiisw,.r 111 .ir.i.scofa st.irm 1 
 
 '""ig.'i storm it is a bad 
 
 ley will iralurillv 
 
 III, iieiaii; 
 
 lonveniont 
 
 jdace 
 
 It in ciis 
 
 ol a stoiiii 
 
 Tl 
 
 go oil into th 
 
 'I', in .'a; 
 
 •'• of a 
 
 i.'iltl 
 
 ie«s sa\s, wlo'iiev.'i tl 
 
 "V ^wll stay in,M.le if t 
 
 'V ill ih.'li,' ; thev will not ;. 
 
 ' k should be longer. H,- i: 
 I'l my fault with it. It ,ill 
 
 le is a storm they g. 
 
 ;o out where the d 
 
 iii'i'l 11" "thiT faiiil. rt it 
 
 '' 'anal. 
 'i.'v ran I 
 
 I'l'-y will not 
 
 lOSSlll|\ ,i,, 
 
 ' and lay in th.. |,,.>k il 
 
 .Ml 
 
 .Ml 
 
 •.111- 
 
 goe,-. to show it 
 'llle to tht 
 
 '5iit .Mr. Carl 
 \^tii'' longer he ufiiiiil 
 
 i''y go ,ind 
 C'l says tile 
 
 IS a matter of judgment on t! 
 
 •'lions purposes, tor the purpo.v.. ,.f unload 
 ||"ii|i.i,ses, which \ou will 
 [the ,.,ason all through, i.s very'small 
 
 I'age liOl.S. H 
 
 c'>iicliision it is necessary (o 1 
 'uig Vessels at the elevat 
 
 not 
 
 le part 
 
 aave it f, 
 
 e savs: 
 
 I lit' rough weath 
 
 ■"'. and for otl 
 
 t'l, tak 
 
 'ler 
 iug 
 
I I 
 
 26 
 
 '• iH'Xt ,ii,.stio„ „.. ,o,„o to t.n.lw ,l,u |,.,„| i., th, Imihling „f tl,,- Cust 
 
 lli'iisc ulnl f'ost oil 
 
 "N 
 
 not williin youi' jiruviiKO to riii 
 
 •>", sii', ii|,oii that [M-iiit, I v.'iituro t 
 
 on, 
 
 t)i(i (jovcrmiifiit 
 
 i''i/i 
 
 \ 
 
 oil :il 
 
 jjletf 
 
 wts rijrlit 
 
 o siiliiiiit tliut it 
 '■ not .iillpil upon licic to say wli.,t!: 
 
 •il a lo(i;r (iiiH. bi'lorc ilii 
 
 '"■ vM'iiig 111 i.aviiig ior;i piiWi.- uoik .vl 
 
 ilcli «;!'• 
 
 at Foil Co]>ionib was iMoctod I'oi' tl 
 
 '■ii'imiy r„mw'ur,:\. M,, Page .s.iv.s thf mst^.m li 
 
 ]lCM 
 
 as lai- liai 
 
 ys It was iic.cssaiy to liavf that bnihli 
 
 piiiiiosi' olt!ikiiif{ thi- i.iai'fi of one torn dr 
 
 as Afuv, 1S,S7. 
 
 :)inl «.• liii,! thit tlic riovon 
 
 of the colhMtor'.s olli. 
 utiini of, Mr. MiCalhi 
 
 iilvaiirfil ih." sum of 81, 000. 
 "■iistoiij housk- at Port Coll 
 
 lllU'll! 
 
 his; thi.>y knew it was, ^ 
 
 Ills, at paj;.. L'lia ; so that 1 1 
 
 111 a.voiiiii of tlie.'odstnirti. 
 '"11),., \,.n will (hill it ill tl 
 
 :«ui^ on. It \v;is takni ovf;r hv 
 
 'ill •'■llllih'lit \'iMr .-.ij/i'd iif 
 
 liliMrv ilK 
 
 h« found at paj^c 2.S1'J. Mr. P 
 
 liini that that has hecii taki 
 
 thoir coiitr.d ; w that a.s long ago as 1887, hui;/ bol 
 
 viT liy tho Pulilj,. W 
 
 I'ldi'l- ill roiilK il, uliirh 
 
 osc.s oidt-i-in-.-oiiiiril (,, ^\),.. i,;||i,„ ,,,| 
 
 111^ 
 
 orks r»f|iur) lilt lit. 
 
 iiiak 
 
 iiig tliese chaigus, thu (j'oV(,rniiicrit 
 
 >r.; Mr. MiCillinn tlioui. 
 
 for, .md ratilii.'d it. 
 
 ;new tl 
 
 aiHl 
 
 took it over 
 
 hull 
 
 had 
 
 of the pioviiKT of this ..'nqiiiry t( 
 uoiiie to that eonnlu.sion oi 
 long hcfoin this cuiiuiry 
 
 as a public woik. .So [ 
 
 I'H frci.tcd'.Tu 
 
 vT," It b 
 
 (I investigate that 
 
 cjitirely outsii 
 
 I loo 
 
 ikii 
 
 matier, .■ind 1 thi 
 
 ig at tin- i. 
 
 wa.s iiKstiiiitei 
 
 Xow, wf pouiy to a branch ol cases, snch 
 
 a variety of oth 
 
 that Mr. Ellis ^n'tod 
 
 repair.s. In tho lit^it plan-, in ru 
 
 or matters, with regard to wh 
 
 dlieh ~:h.'.\v that it « 
 
 as the l-ejiaii.-. to the 
 
 UK you wi' 
 as paid to 
 
 olii 
 
 111 the interests of the piiblie .serv 
 
 i<-'i< I think y,. 
 
 ice in niakiuff 
 
 Mr. MeCalhuii has tak. 
 
 leivnee In the repair.s in the eaiial of! 
 
 ail' 
 
 tllo.- 
 
 T) 
 
 ■a exeeptioii, you will tind that Mr. P 
 
 lu repairs were necessary. It is desii'al>le for 
 
 lice, to wiiic! 
 ;ige say.s, at page Mil 
 
 'about that. It 
 
 •Th 
 
 ill a pretty bad state. It 
 
 hifn to consult the Deiiart 
 
 le eorner wa.s falling down, and Mr, Ell 
 
 «;is iieee.ssary to repair the build 
 
 IS made 
 
 tl 
 
 men; 
 
 ling 
 
 le repair,- 
 
 :!'!'": !,' ^';"".^l\"' '"'"'''*" "J"'"' '■' 1'"^ '"' ^'^' ■■'i'l'H-'<! ro the D 
 
 ^ •''•'pail', nii'i 'i^ked for authority to eini 
 
 Mi. K 
 
 ha 
 
 ing out the faet of the waiU of 
 
 paitiiient, poi 
 
 aii'i 
 
 make the ireressarv 
 
 and got permission for that purj 
 an architect for that purpose. X 
 was over six years ag.). The (im 
 is nece.ssai'y. 
 
 THE COMMISSIONER- I 
 
 provements tlial he Imd i 
 
 III 
 
 "Van arehiteii 
 
 lade up his laiiid to i 
 
 io,se, 
 
 ow, I he ( 
 erniueiit 
 
 n'U .see the letter sliows 1 
 
 'ei'oiiinieiii 
 
 le asks to emidi 
 oveiiiinent knew all about tliat. Th; 
 las apjiroved of it, and .Mr. p,.,ge savs 
 
 mav say 
 
 ai'proved of by tlie Department eertainly 
 
 re at onee that repairs n 
 
 tigation 
 
 To ir 
 
 tile Government had done t! 
 
 vestigate a matter of that kind 
 
 lo not eonie within tin 
 
 aie 
 
 MK. JIVKEKT-W 
 1 
 
 llomselv(!s, 
 eome to the celebrated watt 
 
 Would be taking etcept 
 
 seope of my invc: 
 
 ptioll to wli;i 
 
 that you have le.t hatl the pleasure ol iuspee 
 
 ■I works at Port Daij 
 
 Air. Ellis, say tl 
 
 y they Were nei.-e.ssary. 
 uninsured, ami they are obligetl to have 
 Works are 
 
 A laii 
 
 (ing: Mr. JJemare, and Mr. .Mil} 
 
 IIUI.'-I 
 
 er, aie 
 
 amount of valiiabli 
 
 a wateh tl 
 
 loperty is tliei> 
 
 I tlieii,' a! 
 
 kept for the q)urpose of proteeting the buih 
 •e shows, notwithstanding the evMeuee of M 
 
 he time ; ami these wat- 
 
 lllllgS 111 
 
 ease o 
 
 r. Wood 
 
 Den 
 
 who have shown feelings of hostility towards Mr. 
 s«ear that the water works answer the inirpo.so for wliich tl 
 you vNill decide that is a wise c.xponditure, M, 
 them work, ile had an opportunity of seeing them over and 
 
 f tir< 
 Hid .Mr, E. 
 
 lare- an ! t!i 
 
 Tl 
 Igraft- 
 
 <'■ witue.ssfH 
 
 ley aie intendi.'fl, 1. thii 
 
 P 
 
 age <iid not 
 
 over 
 
 again. 
 
Iiiiildiijg of llio CuHtoti. 
 luiv to .siilfinit tlint it ; 
 iijiiiii litic to say wlifttlii 
 ilii- work vvliicli was con 
 gt' s.ivs tlif ciisU'iii Inu! 
 plfiic ol one fiirii (low 
 111 til it till' riuvoriiiiicii! 
 '''luiii of rhi' i-otistnirti,,i 
 ^''■u will (Iml it ill til, 
 
 lllll'llt V.'ll' .-^'i/l-ll of ;l' 
 
 I'l ill rolllKil, ulliill \vi' 
 
 ii'il to Air. Ell!.--, toiliii. 
 larlimiit, '(ihl ik.i, uikI. 
 1. M'Cnlluni tlionj,'lit ■■ 
 ;i.l Incn frpotfd'niHl paj. 
 say it is oiitin'ly outsiil 
 ^1', .'iinl 1 tliink you wi'i 
 ■ '"' that it was ['aid {■ 
 
 Now, tlic liuil.l 
 rwl 
 
 tigs at Port D; 
 
 rwlifliiiiiif^. i„ i;n„r ,,rt|,rif | 
 
 lllloll.sir ; f i|,i,,k 
 
 it'll' roasoii uli\ 
 • $-d,l)(tO o,|,| 
 
 'I'lii^' 111.' l„-i 
 
 l'<'d tlli'lii lliiji,. .|, 
 
 you <vill .,av 1 1, at t\ 
 
 location 
 
 Ah. Ti 
 
 :o' I'Viilfii, 
 
 " llir'\" I lie ti.1,1,,.1 iVoli, l,„li 1). 
 
 fill till 
 
 •d 1 
 
 >\Ml.sll('lid g:u, 
 
 'II tl 
 
 IIS 0|,iliio|i Uy jKiyii), 
 
 'ic Mi'w .'aiial, to Port 
 
 TFIK i;oM.\Ussi()Vi,;i{ 
 liMtatioii ill -^ayiii^r at t|,j.^ ^, 
 
 ■ivc liirlliri ar^'iii,i,.|jt I'll tl, 
 
 IVolM til- 
 
 ••K'-, tlnl if f 
 
 <.'\ I'lciin, addiK cd, I w, 
 
 .U'lV I, 
 
 'Ifi'ldi' ul|i:ri; |< 
 
 .\1H. RVKEP.T Tlo.y iKid to I.,, b 
 
 I'M I'iM'taiiily i,|it thoiii at Port 11 
 
 iiialtL-r, r havi' 
 
 pill tin: I'll 
 
 i'^yil'Ka h. ;r,. sluirof 
 
 ilii.Ti' is 
 
 allioii.Mi' 
 
 lli'-:i Ilii'i'i 
 
 '!ii,"'.l to repair llo- oatis. Tl, 
 
 lllrkl 
 
 V It was I', 
 
 'II' and i,Llli,liL'ri 
 
 W 
 
 111 
 
 IliMl tl 
 
 I'lViiit;- III,, ,ia|[' 
 "as an ai'cnhnt to tlni Haskell'. 
 
 " ||iii'stioii ah,, lit III It. j'l 
 I'Vi-iy iiioiitli, ami tl 
 
 no 
 
 ,f\ 
 
 'in.' pontoon, ,ii,d tin- 
 
 '•.\ an- Miiar the fsial.'lisl 
 
 guti's arc I'ari'ii; 
 
 ailrl sri! I 
 
 y an- tak 
 
 lini'llt ; til 
 
 ■I i'l'op.'r pusiiioi, lor till- ,„.^;i, 
 I'oinc to tiic- Inidgij at tli 
 
 "ii to tlu! Work 
 
 lOW 
 
 ! away, the ^'alf.s are .ill 
 I gati-saif taken down 
 
 W 
 
 1 1 real' 
 
 and .so 1,11. 
 
 s and Impaired iuiiniiiUatel 
 
 |iii'l!isioii that the ( 
 
 <• Woolen liii'ti 
 
 • "iiginal map will show 
 
 ■overnuient had iki otl 
 
 "■y ; ami I tl 
 ii'i •ilieriiat 
 
 'ink \oii \\i)i 
 
 IVl 
 
 I'h; t' 
 
 "^•'^ It "-as; fory.'ai 
 
 hut iC) I 
 
 illd pill 
 
 '>iti>- to the 
 i" tii„v did. 
 
 > go through hi.s private prop.iity, and 
 
 ■s and years .Mr. Dishr-r allow.id il 
 
 'toiy. the wat 
 trouble a 
 
 ■ I'ower of will,.], is le.-isrd 
 
 go across the biidge int 
 
 ' iij,'ht to shut 
 iVii'cc the (iovi'ii. 
 
 To.-ehctueenyou.i-Mr. Dishei 
 
 'V the C 
 
 o the woolen 
 overniiient to certain gentleini 
 
 lUIn o 
 
 "11, and, through mv inter 
 
 an 4 Air. Ell 
 
 ii-Samlheatoiireclainiei 
 
 idl,'e, 
 lli'ioi 
 
 \ 
 
 iiii'iiL oir thai 
 
 ow, th 
 
 " evidynce is oveiwliellii 
 
 yioUMil, ,unl thev w 
 
 •volition, did cause that to bi 
 
 IS c.xpeiidituie. In th,. (],..st ,,j 
 
 iliig in lav'.ror that b 
 
 ■ 113 compelled to biiiM 
 
 o be (lone, 
 
 a new 
 
 <v » no way to read, that exce,,t by this brid 
 
 place, thf! Govoriiinent l.id to 
 
 leing a proper and 
 ivach that iiow 
 
 ih 
 
 dory ha. 
 
 waste weir oji (iov 
 
 ig'.'; ami you will see the b 
 
 .'lu.nent pioperty. The proi'rieto, of 
 
 power 
 ifidg.' i.- 
 
 li Pheljis say ' H, 
 hears he worked witlrtl, 
 
 tight to go then. ; the Government 
 
 the woolt 
 
 «ays tho Govp 
 
 ■ up the bridge and hui] 
 
 le Oovernmniit f 
 
 ■ument did work fher 
 
 had coutrol of it. What d 
 
 a new o 
 
 "!■ years ami years; he worked 
 
 ■e; and Roger .Mill.. 
 
 .ne.-: 
 
 bvi'inmeiit w.,rkin 
 
 Itistiod himself that tl 
 
 ig over and over 
 
 !iat was on 
 
 I"-'- Jolin b. Smyth says h 
 again upun that bridge 
 
 ujioii that 
 
 livatc property, an.l that he had to t 
 
 private property; that th 
 
 e recollerts w-ll tl 
 ■^'"1 Mr. Ellis w. 
 
 rh'en 
 
 lomo to th 
 
 ■"• 111 order to fully nn.lei stand 
 
 mild 
 
 'rati'd Riord 
 
 wa- 11 
 
 't, as .Mr. .Mct.'alj 
 
 I tl 
 
 'I'll -Mggesled, t( 
 
 oronio Jf.r,-/, [f,, showed \ 
 
 a jiroper bridge. 
 Ion's i'OM.I. AVel), ii,at r 
 'link \ou will coine to tl 
 I'lease Riiii.loii that 
 
 ^ original road 
 
 "as 
 
 on 
 
 !«(.■ 
 
 aquires an insj 
 I' coneliisi.'ii tliat 
 
 llli'd this a tl.' 
 
 .iliiiit 
 
 "iii'v had been ex]; 
 
 '■iii|Uiry. 
 
 IS animus bcaus,- the Mail ] 
 
 Was i.lone. or t 
 
 liad 
 
 leli. 
 
 ve.'ir; 
 
 and y 
 you sent to invest igate that' It 
 
 Hf thought he wouhl hit them back 
 
 o I'leasK 
 very [iroperlv 
 
 «ar,sago, a,{;ay back in ]*?;], (or tl 
 
 and show that 
 
 ■i.le years ago Ijetw, 
 
 lor life: I say tl 
 
 '11 .lohn Riordon 
 
 ''('I'lns to nil. 
 
 not. I ,lor 
 
 ol care if I 
 
 I'lik the testi 
 
 y that vou an 
 
 and Air. Ellis, by whiih h 
 
 i''ir beiielii. 
 laigain wai> 
 
 :nioii 
 
 t called ujion t 
 
 e would -et hi 
 
 llll/.ed 
 
 iiy tl 
 
 for the 
 
 lie iicoi'l 
 
 .\ of all would be to th 
 
 investigate that 
 
 It- 1)1 
 
 .\r, 
 
 I'lir 
 
 li'i for 1 lai'fj,' a 
 
 ■pose of iiuloadiii 
 
 rritton, .ui,I there 
 
 e cllbet that that sli( 
 
 liou ; i,ut I 
 
 wa.s no otin 
 
 ' ^^■as ,-i Useful on 
 
 ig vessel.s. Surely tl 
 
 rf. Mr. R 
 
 ge anioiint of rent, have a ricrht tc 
 
 y the (, 
 
 ^ayofgoingtoRio 
 
 rdon's 
 
 overnmeiit, when thcv t 
 
 loidon did not touch those bank, 
 
 give him facililics t 
 
 ilX 
 
 o go into his 
 
 at aJl; they belonged to th 
 
m 
 
 n!i 
 
 ! I 
 
 I ! !• 
 
 S8 
 
 <l:iiii 
 
 >v,>i'nniotii. Why .a1„.ii1i1 Iw ni.'dillc with 
 MiMitiii 
 
 S,). 
 
 I tliiiik. 
 
 thtMii 
 
 It svcMilil caii.'ic 
 
 vim wil 
 
 OHIO 1. 1 til 
 
 ii great (It 
 
 I'liiirlusioii thill it w 
 
 •IS il I 01' 
 
 M>\V Wii 
 
 Hill' III till- woik 
 
 TIII;C()M,M|SSK)NKK | 
 
 it Mr. I)t'iii,ii«'.s il 
 
 tliat vi'i' 
 
 link that ha.s I 
 
 "•••II txj.LiiiKMJ; ( tliiiik t Hwh 
 
 :r.sl, 
 
 MK ItVKKHT Th.. nrxt 
 
 aiHJ All 
 
 iiihiirj,' Kia 
 
 .1. 1 
 
 i|ii«'stioii is that lit Si 
 
 iiiiiur ,s 
 
 l)ii(lgi 
 
 ipon OovormiHiit |,r..|,.Tt> ; i|,at thr ma 
 
 wish to |.(.iiil <iiit to yoi! tliat that road. 
 
 ;«, oil ii„. 1 1, 
 
 as it now I'xis 
 
 ihnrg, for Ihi- groad-r |Miition of tlic uav, i 
 
 Alia 
 
 tliat was imrcly upon (;ov 
 |io.s.si'ii.sion of thai n 
 
 IS it originally ran hct 
 
 u-.'iMi Thorohl 
 
 iriiiiR'iit jiropcrty; anil when tl 
 
 ui upon tho spoil hank of tl 
 
 IIJ l.'UI, 
 
 purely a privati' ruail. 'I') 
 
 iind l.rii|-v thrv hail 
 
 II' roail 
 
 niissionii, 
 veiiieiii 
 
 Thisi 
 
 If oiij-inal voa.l iinis to ih 
 
 I'oinjiariy 
 noie right to it than I had, Ft 
 
 west. (Plan shown to C 
 
 It 
 
 sa road whi.h th. ,anal people had made along their hank t 
 
 MS been shown .Shrii 
 
 heeii for the water raised in th 
 
 •r s Civi'k was a very narii 
 
 or 
 
 iwereek; and if it had 
 
 would ha\ 
 
 eost very miirh. fhi' evideme si 
 
 wh. 
 
 '• r..,|iiiivd there would lunv h.vu a small enlvert, whi 
 
 1 a bai;k-watcr there, that all iT 
 
 deviated 
 
 ri 
 
 There 
 entirel 
 
 !'• lOiid fornierlv ran to tl 
 
 • eoiicliisivrly thai the i(]ad has 1 
 
 would not 
 
 was a 
 
 le east ; the (io\ei 
 
 leen altered 
 
 eoniieetl'iM 
 
 het 
 
 ween the old an 
 
 ninent changed the 
 
 that 
 
 y upon ihueriinieiit 
 
 e.xpeiiditure. Mr. Hills lias- 
 
 I'l'op-rly; and I sav Mr. Ef 
 
 d the new eanal ; and th 
 
 here and stated that reiiionst 
 
 Jieople ill the Town and Townshii. of Tl 
 
 explained how it was dor 
 laiii'e was n 
 
 is wasjiislilied in mak 
 
 Dr. h 
 
 ergUtiOIl llH 
 
 fovernnieiit teaui 
 
 llOI'll 
 
 ini 
 
 tl 
 
 le rana 
 
 a I 
 
 id, I 
 
 the hridge had been destroved hv ( 
 
 le to him over and over again li 
 is an iinjiortant work, ii.sed \< 
 
 It 
 
 leiiig ii|inii (.'oviiniiient 
 
 Govern nieiit teams in h 
 
 npon the ilovernineiit to niakr the ivpaiis I, 
 and 1 think his testiniouv wil 
 
 pii'inrty. t 
 hai hridsre. 
 
 Iiev f, 
 
 . 'It,! 
 Ml. 1' 
 
 lie lereni'i 
 
 - thai, in < lujsullation wit! 
 thing to ^ay, "Let .Mr. Hll 
 
 11 
 
 jtistilied 
 VrgiLson 
 
 in ra!!i" 
 swi>;i] • 
 
 -ly you as h,.i„g u„i likely to be impearl. 
 
 'n Ileiiiy I'op,., .Mr. l'op,> s,,id, wh.a't was tl 
 
 i>Miied that, and 1 I 
 
 is build th.' briiltje out of h 
 
 l-estei 
 
 ia\ e no obiei'tioi 
 
 upon inn, his attention I 
 
 Ah. !•: 
 
 (leing called to the dan 
 
 'propria tio 
 
 le uatn 
 K 
 
 n, as long 
 
 person.- pa.s.sing o\er it aloncr the eanal. kiiowin.. 
 using ihe canal, felt that 
 Fergu.soii and .Mr. Hllis. and you will 
 money expended has not been wa> 
 
 mat til 
 
 I' was liei'essarv. 
 
 lis, fi'iding the responsib 
 
 iridg. 
 y p,.i. 
 
 ig^rous state of rhe I 
 
 uiilge was iis.'d 1 
 
 -HI hav.' till 
 
 ■OltlH 
 
 to II 
 
 e.\planatioii.s of ^i 
 
 ited. 
 
 coiiclnsion. I rhink, thai 
 
 As regains the weigh sralc 
 
 till y wi'i'c usi lul : In 
 
 do not .--ec 1 1 
 
 .said h,. tlci'dit till 
 
 ■■'t St. Catharines, I think Mr. i'.i.n' has st 
 
 ati 
 
 \ Were ii' 
 
 .\f 
 
 lis was ail obiectionable cvih iid 
 
 112, he H 
 
 li V- 
 
 Itllle 
 
 conelu.-ion it wis a w i 
 
 N 
 
 se eX|ienditnii 
 
 think vnii will 
 
 oliie lul 
 
 ow, wr coiiii' to another hr 
 
 Work tor oiitsid.' paiiir 
 stigma upon .Mr. KJlj 
 
 ;iicli of li 
 
 II 
 
 While there h 
 
 laf 1- 
 
 allowiiu 
 
 Ml 
 
 Deiiiari 
 
 I'lliplo'.ei" 
 
 '"•'•I' 'lu ai tempt made to fasten 
 
 Jiersons ill the 111 
 
 nniciil of il 
 
 •Mr. Smith and .Mr. 1), 
 
 exploded. Let 
 days tiiat they 
 
 filial. 1 thinl 
 
 iiiil 
 
 ine Jiist say here that 
 
 k yon wil 
 e\i'li sujiposinjr (], 
 
 aced t! 
 
 lis you wil 
 
 and allowing the full -pay that tl 
 
 1 lot of,, 
 iceli enl ■ 
 men have woiki.-d 
 
 ^.i\ that ha.s I 
 
 li'V 
 
 lid 
 
 lli.it in I 
 
 jet 
 
 I I 
 
 allowing them the full t 
 
 in >.'ars, (he tul.il aimu 
 
 ia\'e eiiuii; 
 
 nie, altliongh they ai.' paid by tl 
 
 .lilt o| these I 
 
 men s w.ij- 
 year, arnount.s ti 
 
29 
 
 w.mM niuse a great dm: ■"'■"■>iis Mim of ,«ns • That i. thecxtpnt of fh. 
 
 sioii tli;il 'it u.ns 
 
 iiicil; I think I uinl. 
 
 Ml, I'llis, ;ir, 
 illli 
 
 iiiig t.. Mr. MrCillii, 
 
 'X|iiiiiiiriir( whi 
 
 li iviii h.' I li.ii'i'fMl 
 
 SilVS 
 
 If I 
 
 allies for 11. vsoir. I 
 
 h;i(| lint 
 
 11 s (,U!| v.Lsi.Mi ol th.' stoiy. Just hx.k at it. 
 
 I't-i! Udikiii;,', I w(,ul(l h.ivu h, 
 
 or.s Iui(Il;v, 
 
 nil Iht' 
 
 T 
 
 iHf , 
 
 Kills' hiiihliin,', and was (•iiira<'-(;(l 
 
 w.is ..'iiiployed hy tli.; u-,,,, ,;».! 1 ,■! 
 
 'II niiikin^r ipjftiin 
 I 
 
 iiKa<{(;(l two or Hum. wtok.> 
 111'', aii.i ii c, lines to .$40. Th-' luwt i.s H 
 
 l">i' 10 ,i;'n IImI sU|M.rilll('M.l 
 
 I h 
 
 iivi' taken ti 
 
 liii.*m..V). William Hllint 
 
 I, oil.. |,,:|,| of 
 
 lit 10.1(1, as it now exis, 
 ly ran het\v...eii 'rhoiohl 
 tlio spoil bank of tht> ua 
 Ml tilt' road eoiii|iaii\ ' 
 it to it than I had. It 
 
 " hia.l.s of^^Tavel. |i) renf.s. .r.,|ill I 
 i'l-, H) eelil.^-. . I. ,1,11 ,S 
 ik, I 
 .hd 
 
 eiltins; worke.l n w,.rk : f 1 
 i'elei I'avl 
 
 ;iav(.|. ■_'(! , ,.ntx 
 
 '■ihv, 
 
 l.'vv I. ..a. I 
 
 .11 ."^I'Xli'll. two d.i 
 
 10 .S.I hi. if \, 
 
 vs, .?2 
 
 11 "ill roeollnet, ahoMi t 
 
 I I 
 
 th 
 
 le out 
 ia\ e ^'iveii 
 
 "II, h..i(luif,' 
 
 Live taken that lo he |\ 
 
 a ihiy; although 1 
 
 le w.l.s ih>in.' oth 
 
 lip 111 lour or live ininiit, 
 
 iv" iiiiiiulis h.fon 
 
 ••ix. Wnw 
 
 Mr. II. 
 
 "-'""I- •^- !■"■ Iii.^ rim... .M;„ti,i .\i,.( 
 
 •mil Ih.le w.'le lwelv(. loads, I 
 
 or li\(. III.. II 
 
 have .-iveii I 
 
 <t. iPk 
 
 ill shown to ( 
 
 'r,<;ia\..l ill I.S.K], ;i,„| to.,k 
 
 orniiek ,s\\e.i 
 
 mil 
 
 r.s le 
 
 It t.i Klli.s 
 
 le along their hank for . 
 now creek; and if it had 
 ^k-water there, that all i' 
 
 Ml will .see I 
 
 hut K 
 
 si'\-en 
 
 low mar he 
 
 ■tUe.l I;.- uorked ■■i7k diiy.-.. If,. ^.|j,| 
 
 house ; hi; would not k. 
 il 
 
 cam., to t 
 Mr. \|, 
 
 I- llev.l .lUii,.,! th" h. 
 
 '"' "I'llis- Then l'li,,i|,.,s liii]. 
 
 II 
 
 •p lia.-k uli..thi.r I 
 
 ■rev would he loM 1,,- 
 
 e n..|il tlii.|i 
 
 ;\\as .'Oilier fl 
 
 It, whi.di wouhl not uM"' '""' '"""'■■' f'"- "''"•>'• ''""■ I"' "oike.l h,r Mr. Kljis v,,,s ,il 
 
 I' road has hccn alten 
 eriiinont cluiiiged tlic r. 
 
 '1 lie sav.s li. 
 
 I (I .'.I I 
 
 iiii ijuile as niii.-h lui ,.iil prev 
 
 'I lii'I : hill hi. eolll,., 
 il'oiil tluv.. w led. ..lavs: 
 
 iiiirei 
 
 soil.liiix. .'-;s. Ilaiiiiltoii I'ag,.. t 
 
 lolls Sllp.rilitelldelils. 1 
 
 allow him 
 
 •iiiial; and thai ■""''■"■"■ ' ''^'ve taken the whole of h 
 
 w.. ii.ir. 
 
 ;vs. (It. a win;,' iion : ]' 
 
 li.sw;isJiistilie(liniiiak!B "" '''''H'llor, cleuniiiL;' i he j,l,„.o ajt,.,. Si. ( 
 
 i.-s pay, .say .>!.!0. .lohii .Se.vt 
 
 loiiias 
 "II. at 8'.'. 
 
 H. Dr. F: 
 
 •r^'U'ion lm,s 
 
 ■w and Walton, workiii'' haif 
 
 [>vor and ovnr ajjain hy 
 portant work, ii.se.l hy 
 oveiiiuient teams in Ini 
 
 •l(ii,'i 
 
 iiity, !i<.i..-)0. Makiii.' !:^r 
 
 •I .lav d 
 
 'our^'es festival, s;i; an.l Will 
 
 ""II 111 the hospit.il, ,1 
 
 Now, I 
 
 want to point out this to v 
 
 111 ten ye.irs, the otl'eliee ehai'ired a;;; 
 
 lain 
 "111,^' an aei of 
 
 |\e ma. 
 
 IV Upon the side of this list th.'it tl 
 
 iiid yon will .se 
 
 liiist Air, H 
 
 U.S. 
 
 It j'lisritiei 
 
 Il in fn]\\ 
 
 "rii th.it they w,.re pahl hy .Mr. hlllis. The I 
 
 e li hy tl 
 le ,1,'ieat m.ijoiity of fj 
 
 II' ""iiinients I 
 ivse men lia\.. 
 
 Ml. I't'igiison sweai 
 Mot likidy to heinipea. Il 
 ■aid, what was th.. ijatn 
 ppiopriati.iii, as lung ,. 
 feeling the respoii.sihir 
 lis stat(. of the lipid", ■ 
 
 -tniete-l p.,i.sitiv..ly not to a! 
 
 Ill reie (. t 
 
 "W a man's time h 
 
 " I"' di.'iwn is rh.it all tie 
 
 oiviiieii all .say that tl 
 or aiiv work for Mr. Kll 
 
 H'V Welu 
 
 ihar Klli, left 
 
 money for them in th,. .,ii 
 
 ■■se men were pai,| l.v .\1,.. KIlj,, ,s 
 
 is: so th 
 
 them, we .aiiiiot (h.eide which 
 
 Us say: 
 
 i.^.e m.aii a siiii,'h> 
 
 s: '1 paid for all this : I told the f 
 
 he: Si) that if K 
 i;e it w.is, ami when it 
 
 ollle ol tl 
 
 ll.s left th 
 
 Hut, 
 
 was. 
 
 i>.m 
 
 e nioil.'V 
 
 at anv 
 
 lioiirol wag.storaiiv tim 
 
 oreillen Ull.li.l I 
 
 lie Uol t.) all 
 
 dg, 
 
 >riilce was IIS 
 
 ,y p, 
 
 uk yoi! will ...me to tl 
 
 •■ I'll work outside of 1 1„;( 
 
 o\\ a 
 
 the e.\planation.s of v| 
 lii-^ioii. I rhink, thai 
 
 "'•'1. Now, tak(. all t 
 
 le i()li.:Jnsi,ui lle.fi 
 
 lias 'heeii no ;||, 
 
 •overnimiit. 
 
 iL'se men that liav.. worked 
 
 Ir. I'age has stated 
 
 I "It sod, you iiiiist say that the time of tl 
 Ml. Kllis. 
 
 Now, as to this malte ■ of fioiidwells. It 
 
 lesi. mei, 
 
 there, w 
 h.is not 
 
 I""' of I hat kin. I | 
 
 ler 
 
 1" ll.lVe |,,.|,|..,| 
 
 ,'ra\'» 
 
 ■" iiii|irop..rlv U.S.., 
 
 112, he .sa 
 
 'weil that man to.,i;o otf f 
 
 '■i|'l"':ii> th.it .Ml Kll 
 
 link you will I'ome tn i 
 
 I'll w.is rifjht ..i wroiif,' is n.,) f, 
 |i' doinir very little wnil. 
 
 "!■ im ' (en days uh.ii I 
 
 II' w.is ..lit il 
 
 I me (, 
 
 -.i\ 
 
 '11' Mr. Kllis 1 1 
 
 loi tw.i \i,.ars, 
 ' '■■""I' : "hetluT 
 
 !<, he wasjiislili..,|. 
 
 lOlli'llt. 
 
 allow ine- i.mphr, 
 fust 
 
 liii .iloii^' with him hir a short t 
 
 line. 
 
 I d. 
 
 ii''-mpeiint..|id,.ni ,,f (j,, 
 
 as (hat 
 
 Mian 
 
 up! liiaile 
 
 Cli 
 
 .s(. . asi.s wi'ii 
 
 hi 
 
 not think thai 
 
 m.ih ill taking 
 
 Dell 
 
 and a lot of o: 
 
 Willi men in the 
 
 i>" a ground tor cen.sming Mr. Kllis fori 
 
 wen an a. eumnlntion of 
 
 iploynient of the ( 
 
 laviiig iinne,.(.,s,„,,i)v i,it 
 
 ■ l\ thai has heen (.|ili|. 
 
 '-' iiK'ii have woikcd ^ 
 
 lid get I 
 
 lilt of these men 
 
 tl 
 
 Hiineee.s,sary manner. It h,is heer .stated hy .Mr. J,, 
 
 • overuiiient. ,111. i iiti 
 
 i/e.l th,.!:' lal 
 
 ■i oth 
 
 r.s, that Mr. E 
 
 li.ive eiiuii 
 
 ■'^o, I think yon will coin.« ti 
 
 lis p:ii,l for ..vervth 
 
 iiigsent to 1 
 
 w 
 
 I thi. conclusion. 1 
 
 Hill. .\|r. Salvin, .Mr. c 
 lis jilaro. 
 
 S W.i.. 
 
 ill. from a fair standpoint, that Mr. E\ 
 
 H> year, amounts ti 
 
 Il Ills owxi piir 
 
 purposes. 
 
 ion. Jooking at everyth 
 i.s has nor iis,..| that 1;,1„ 
 
 er- 
 mr in 
 lesliey 
 
 now 
 
 iig, as I k 
 >r on the <.anjil 
 

 I 
 
 ! I 
 
 I 
 
 8 nil ^ i- 
 
 i 
 
 
 irir: 
 
 TV, '''° 
 
 .1... ™:::r^::',°:;::,:i::" ""«"« - >- --- ^. - -« - ■ 
 
 THK CO.MMISSIOXKR Ves. 
 
 THK co',';l',!;.,„«;';r ";:" '"•'" "■ ■"■• ■ - "■"" »"■ >■■"•■.•. 
 
 ::.:w,r,:r;;,x,:;r '■""'■' "■'''• •'■' '-■--■'■ 
 
 I ii... ,,. „.g,„.h ,|,„ ,„M„,, ,„„,„,j.^ i, ^,, 1^ _^ 
 
 ■1;.).. I.... ,. .„„„, ,„„ ,„ „vM,,„, .i,..ti„„,.„.,„,,,,.,;i„ , ;,*','■;. : 
 
 I :. ■■... . ' ■■'imi.d, .»ii, .\|, („i|||ini strove ( ,tv in nn,) .l..,- .iii< 
 
 '^:^ ; t^': :^:,^r ■ "' ^" ^'^"' '^'" ^^^"'^ "•' --- i-'^'-'^^t ^ ^ 
 
 THE COM MISSION ER-V,.. ' 
 
 a l.,s ot the cases, a,.,l I have put th. number of hour. u}k>u ,ay li.t and th. v. ■ 
 
 n", r;ssr;^8r"^'"'^'"v ^"' ''"' ^'" «'"'^>'-''-orti,i;;;;;'tr 
 
 m 18»2 1S8.5, lo84, y.ar,s a>wl years a^'o ; that in a nu.nh,.., of th.se .uses tlu ,„• 
 pa.l to, th,. ... of th.. annor ; la.t wh.r. th., ,|i,l ,.,„ pav fV„ , u e " I t 
 J^ was h..aus. th,. vessols ... i,j,„., .,. n,e .anal. L .Un.k u .^ he i 
 Dehan.., .Invou upon ,t by th. ..,.,1. yu. Ellis Ion, ,h. .Uvn., appar ^' i, 
 'nak.„« a ..ha,p^ Mr. N.elo,. «ot the ,livi,„ apparatus ,or th. H ^ ', „: 
 -Jonr ays, and Mr Ellis^thou.ht it not nccssary to .har,e ,;. ,,ha "r ' 1 
 ^ illp, no , har^T ; she struck the pier au,l was loakiu" ['1,,^ U,.!-.]! l-,, L ' I 
 shoe on the toe I „o not know the t.hn.oa, .xpre^Iiou":,,,!" .^^^ ^^ J I 
 ^.ort tune. A eharge is n.,le that the Silcox «o, the use of the divn ^ t, l- ij 
 
 e«; Uwas shown that the nn.ney was paid direct to the L>epartn,e T 
 
 Man.towoe Mruck the w,n^onlo,k nun,!., 1.; only en.a^e^ . L' 1 o ^ • ' . 
 Elhs d,d no. eha,ge lor tha,. Th. ... P. Heal st.n.ka loifand a Lr " H 
 .or t^ree and a half hou.s. Then the Mo.ewood knoel.., .„' he. ■ i 'J 
 
 n U can I, away baek ,n 1884 ; M. ,1. r,un,.,ings, in 1887, th. .an,, wav ; 
 ^^ K.ng, also the s.n,. way ; and the Hentl.y :- .. .....not find auv t,a..' o 
 
 M--. De,na.-e ,sea,.hed and eould not find it. You will .s.. tha ,1 iv ' 
 appautus was „.., perhaps altogether a week or ten days in the'ias, To. ^^.. 
 M .E!hss.ys: -I ,n,i .„, ,, ,,,„,,,,, ,,,., ^^^„,^, J ^,,^ .^ ^ 3- 
 
 o see hes. n.en who were navigating the eanal, who .e.eived an injnrv Xtl, 
 through the.r own ca.elessuess, or so.nething wrong in the .ani ^ , 
 
31 
 
 fiiiaif, it liasbfien slio . ■■"Raiiist. u win;:,' \vh1I--I thoiiglit it was not .-id 
 
 hoiifriit If was not ^iilvisal.lc, 
 
 thf r 
 
 lit with .Ml. .Mi||,>,-. 
 
 "I .Ml-. Miller; .some 
 loliii.>,oii ami .loliii D(. 
 Kicliuc a liitliir I'loiii i 
 
 !• work Wlli(!ll W:ts ),;, 
 
 il liHVc |.Hic| 1(11 hiiii,-. 
 
 lat IJir only tiiargn th, 
 lencu .siy.^ Uvo (Iiiv>. . 
 ny lato, we will say tu 
 y ill tin; inteii St <it' > 
 ill thi' il.'im, till' i.x! 
 
 lly answered, 
 six, "allowing part; 
 'lay in and day out 
 ■riornicd, but he faili 
 ivitlidutauthoiitv : ,i 
 
 I liavti enuiniTat' . 
 my liat, ami the yeai 
 of thi.- work was doi, 
 )!' tlit'.^e cuse.s tlii; uf . 
 
 I lie iisrt lit' the ariii'- 
 ick ii|Mjn the |iier, tl- 
 ing dinuratu.s witlioii| 
 
 the Benson, for thiir 
 foi tliat. The Lea 
 [Ia.<kell knocked t'i.| 
 
 that oeoupiod a vrrv 
 
 tlie (living apjiaratr.J 
 e Depaitniont. T!' 
 nd a few hours ; y, 
 and a diver was thi:-| 
 ler luddt'i ; oecupl- I 
 nc hour, some inji; 
 le .same \\:iy ■ .nul jl 
 
 d any traec of at li.f 
 Ml', that the divi. : 
 the last 7 or >^ ve;!' . 
 it Was .HI inju.'st: 
 1 an injury, wliefl 
 L' lanal, or runtii!;! 
 
 think 
 
 lilway ; thoiij,'l]f it was li..t.|.M i 
 
 you will I nine to fl 
 
 vi,sahle to make a eharpe for that." 
 
 •oii-i.lerint; th.' ..onpetition with th'j Kii^ Canal 
 
 II'' .'[iparatiis and not*eliar-" f 
 
 (J [I'll. I I 
 
 liaiK"' iiiadi' liv Mr. .Mef 
 
 I" fjiH lii>i in that th 
 
 or 
 
 !■'■ wa ■ not ivallv-iiiv f 
 
 oundation for 
 
 IlllUIII. 
 
 Till II "Tiuilii 
 
 '■"'" f'"' l"""')oM ■• W. h;iv.. h.id thai -vplallio,!. A I 
 
 tin ponto.iii" has ,ilso l.ciui explallK'd 
 Thill wi' Imvm the awful eriun' ot taki 
 
 'Spiki 
 
 Itiin .riiuii'nl. Hut paid |i 
 
 r. Mr I) 
 
 n;,' -.'irt pick'ts, valii.M 
 
 It 81 r.O, from th. 
 
 ml to MrCliviiv ,<: (' 
 
 ''■iiiaic uaiiti'i 
 
 iiid hmiid rlnv hud 
 
 soliir llllllhi'i 10 |V,.t Ion 
 
 H' 
 
 ot taki tl 
 
 tioiii' linl I'j ,in.l I I |, 
 
 "11' iiiil'.-<- they (hai-id for only Klf.',.t, whirh il 
 
 I. Hid Di'iiian 
 
 III' riit "Il two fri't, and till. I 
 
 iiniyiuf,' thriii liuun- undi'r tl 
 
 Hc'Ts wn-i. pil,.,| II,, in ()„. yard: and 
 
 u:v ajjii-fil (i 
 
 men wen 
 
 .1 .1 few hoards theie t 
 
 ii'ir anus; an.i om. dav .Mr. K 
 
 th 
 
 o inaki' a side\\alk to his li 
 
 lis aske.l if there 
 
 iKc tnosi 
 
 l"h'le to foiiu'l 
 
 piekets, worth .«il.;',0; .md 1 
 
 irn: ,ind fhoiicjht it was no I 
 
 a eharge uiion that. 
 
 'lo not think you will ruusidr 
 
 Mere 
 larni 
 
 nli-r 1. worth 
 
 hen the scow used hv FFiitclii 
 
 iison. 
 
 il- 'li'i not; think it worth whil,, diargin^' for the .^a 
 If vdraulic jacks were paid for by Mr. .Muir. 
 
 lor two d.iys u.sed by Hutton. Mr. Deniarc h, 
 
 hat «a- ii.^ci |',„ a >Iiort tin; 
 
 and .Ml 
 
 ly; th.at thatHcow was lavi 
 
 ni^ up in Tl 
 
 cxplaine.l that s.ttisfa.' 
 
 Ibiiii;; II down f( 
 
 loronl 11. ar the ijuari'v; thcv 
 
 k'liii intcc no loss he nii'dit bi 
 
 )r repairs; and he tidd .Mr. Mutton if 1 
 
 in-' di 
 
 V I ajMiot say there w.as aiivthi 
 
 le would biin.L,' it dow; 
 wn .1 tiw stone in it, and he brou'dii it d 
 
 llh.'it. 
 
 i'emenl lor tin; rubber factory; n 
 
 Iij; wron,!.,' in that re.siieel. 
 
 wcri! ''oiiii' to 
 
 1 ami 
 own. 
 
 cement was uaed; that i,s tlic best 
 
 Then the only thing which 
 
 I'l iii.'^artion is the la. I that h<- did .ill 
 |li"iii the yard and put tle^ni in his \' 
 
 seems to have sturk to Dell 
 
 '^w the melt to take tour or (i 
 
 lest answer o 
 
 throughout the whole 
 
 tlici'i who has bi-eii a faithful 
 
 in. Now that is th' 
 
 ve oi' six plank 
 
 U 
 
 ;'rvant hii many \i a 
 
 ■nnie to be attached ti 
 
 '■ "'inc to another important matter, uhi, 1 
 
 Is on the canal, 
 
 uid n.ii letiirncl jn jnoper tine Tl 
 
 I IS in relerellee ti 
 
 'W, .Mr, Diuiii, in the hist placi , has [ 
 
 lit 1.- one of the charges Mr. .Met: 
 
 'Honeys reieived 
 
 Ilium iii.ik 
 
 l\..'lll., hi 
 
 tore Ml. Klli.>' time, of 
 
 lointed out that ihi 
 
 Iki.ep the inoiiiv in tl 
 
 the superintendents, when the I, 
 
 piyticn had 
 
 lieeii, for 
 
 1 no record kept id' then 
 [111' lias invaiialily put in 
 
 M'lr own poeket, ami tiia!;e the ret 
 
 iii'.s were paid in, ti 
 
 Sincr .Ml. Kills I 
 
 tini at the curl of the 
 
 veai, 
 
 orf (■ 
 hvl 
 
 ?y in his pocket ; the iilol 
 
 ':'■- li"'n in the rontinl nt ti 
 
 le canal 
 
 line, liy till' collector; tie 
 
 "■V uas collected at lock 7. 
 
 liui to Mr La 
 
 nioii.v was sent to Mr. KIlis 
 
 lit w 
 
 wreiice, ami entered in tie' book, tl 
 
 IS paid for, and tlim hamlcl to Mr. l)i 
 
 le lea.son for it, 
 
 and handed 
 what 
 
 th 
 
 '■ m< Ill the money ton. hed Mr. Dii 
 
 liiiclei .in\- ciieunistances; h.- 
 
 ^^ the payniastei ol the laiial. fi 
 
 not, the money ueiit in, and Dunn .savs it 
 
 i"";"i'l l"it into I he .site. I contend 
 
 le- ame lesponsible for it 
 
 lit siij.po.s,. he did, or 
 
 nn s hands I,,. ( 
 
 [iii^'.mce, if men wei. 
 
 as useful to h.ive that 
 
 iiisfad of making the poor feUow.s 
 |tliciii to .sell tledr time to shark 
 '• the envelope out ,uid hand the 
 
 in})loyed upon the canal five or six i lavs h 
 
 moiiev I- 
 
 or 
 
 «aif for their i 
 
 r special work, 
 
 "'■ocy. and instead ot 
 
 s aioumt to\M 
 
 in tl 
 
 I. as has hei.ii often 
 
 "Olii'l lis 
 
 IS nioiiev. If .Ml. Dm 
 
 com iiel ling 
 )ne, he would 
 
 Mune (,| this iiimseli; or .Mr. Klii.-. 
 
 Ill was short of mom 
 
 u anyone else. It was al 
 
 Ways 
 

 In.. - , 
 
 I! 
 
 i I 
 
 n 
 
 ii 
 
 Mill I 
 
 iiii 
 
 go 
 
 •Kl . -<> .l.> tha.. I M,y rha, Mr. Ellis has .lo,„. , .ow than his ,.n.,l, .,...,.• 1,„ 
 
 ">^.s i- , an.l I „.v,t,. you u, look af then,, H„ .ays th. a,.,-,..,. tt,„ t,k ■ . 
 
 '•n;.s n,„l , wa. .,ntnv,i in th,. l„„.k what ti.y we.. n....iv.l lo,-, an^l tluV. 
 
 l::;^.:^■'■'''''•■'';.^'^'r''-■ «'■:-"■ "„.tn,ayh. a, „op,...M,in;o:: 
 
 . n, an.... ha,, a..nnu.at...,, a.^ 
 
 Canal lu.^ulattons. A, th- .....1, i, says: -Su.h .lau.a.,. „. he ..sti,„a.,.,ri,v ,|, 
 .su,„.nn.,.n,l..nt ,>( th... .anal, an,l at on.,, pahl ov... to th,. ,..-..,.,„■ ,.Lnu., . 
 
 ^ 1 .^ «1. to m.„..n yo,. „,., M... Whit,.... has si L l,.,«..,nh.. .„ , : 
 
 an. . >m;: th.s ha. .o,,,.. .s,.,.,.iall.v u„,|..,. th.- Kail.avs a,.l Cu.als l),.,„u..n..„ 
 
 niStr.lt!t.O.,S hav.. h..,.|| ,riv,.|| Ihit .l„.v vl,..ll I II . '■ ■ "''"" "'l''""ii"| 
 
 ^^^ THKCOMMlSSIOXfc:,;^., think tha, i. an a,...., .. „, .hat onght , 
 
 ko.„f '; ^^^^'-'^"^r ^'"^";^'"^ l"-^ ""f l'^^^<' that looseness ahour itru,..! Ellis ha- 
 t:^l:wt. """""' ^"""' """'■ "^'^ n.. not.. o;a...Uv.yUolla,. hash. . 
 
 THE C0M.M1,«^SI0XER-I .1.. ..ot thi,.k y.,,, n..a .o ...to that 
 
 ThatT'" Z'^'^^^^f r'^;'"'" r^>^'' ""^ «-- ^ -'-.t ,.c.,ly to o..der ol' tho Hon.s,.. 
 I hat has hee.i expla.ii,.,! satistai>torily, I thi.ik. * 
 
 THE COM MISSIONEi;-Y..s. 
 ■ MR. HYKEHT -X..w. w,- .o,,,,. to anoth... h.an.'h of th,. .-as,: .'That M. 
 
 MI.s ,s a..l„t,a..y i,. his „..a,...e,.t of .........s of v.ss.ls, .idaini...^ wi,ho,.t 
 
 ....son . finnl t„g „«..,.,. ^00. h.-canso h. ,,,„.stion.,i hi> n,a«aK,.,.,o;;t." \ow" |, • 
 
 « th-, U1..SO, ,„.,.a„:,, uh,.th,., prop....iyo,.in,p,..,,„|y, hav.. ,1.. no „,,,„.,,, 
 
 tho tnh„nal wi.e.o ,h..y ha,| a n.^ht to app,.al. V„„ know, si., if „ nru, i L 
 
 u.U.rop..,.,y Ellis has ,ot to a,...„n.,t h,. tha, ..,-. „., „^kos . ,.rt 1,. 
 
 Government an,l tl... ,„ .„ 1,,. .nak,.s ,h.. rcpor, to th. .i„vo..,.n,...t i,'is onts 1 
 
 of 1..S ,,ur.s,h.t.on, a..,l, i,' a.,yho,iy has „, ,.fn.„l it„ i, i. „,„ ,;„v......n,..,t ,ts,., 
 
 K..^ ';;■"- '';■•-. -"> -^^^l ■!-- l.,. say ' ■' I-hat / was i,. h.k .. a..,l was ins,.l„ : 
 J.y th. loc-k.t.,, ,.,.s, ah„..,l l,y ,!,. i.,.K.,..n.l....s, an,| I was l,n..l,,..,.„s. I ,|, - 
 
 .mth.ng. A,„| h. ..v,.lo..,.osh.,ws..o.,.h,siv,.lv. h..yn,„| alU,„.stion^ thr.vi.i.,. 
 of N.. .olas Hay ..„ an,i WilHan. H..i,! ,ha, ,his ...an a.,,',, „k.. a hla,.k; . u 
 
 •"""f"" "f "'"• i ^ '- ''^f >" ""-■ '-"- an,l ,h.... is th,. i..po,., s.„t in ' ! ,: 
 
 ago. wh..h .s th. host .vi,i.n.. of th.. fa,, that Ellis ,i.„.,| hi.,, U. that: an.l "n.iv 
 altor a lapse ol hn.r o.Jiv. y.a.s. I.. ..on„.,s a,.,l .nak..s th. .on.plai.,,. J,. ,,i,, „„, 
 nrake a ...nphunt at the t.....^ h.. .lid not ,o to th. o,ti... an.i ,l..na...i:,. invosfi,.,: 
 tion. AMi.n h. .am.! to the .anal ..ili... M,. pn;. ,„,,. ,,:,,, ,.,,,, ^, . " 
 
 ■"7,t' "^ ' '■;■ " "...."■. ... o„;,„ ;,.:„„:, ';;::; : : ::;;,,"*;,:::■■ 
 
 •nJ I think yo,, „,11 com, ,„ ,l„. ™,„.|„„„„ „M >,,.s |,,„|,,,.|y a„,.„,l,.J il 
 
•- t(i v\liyf oiK'lit I 
 
 brouglit to buar iiiKii 
 
 W 
 
 Thc« there is Captain Jamas Saurin ; m kuow what he was fined for fo. 
 ur.g,.anryarth.a,,n«clnct^ Ho ,ay, h. came to Mr. EUi., an.l that M. klH 
 
 ..a(«,nu.n r,u.tc cool.v. a„,i ,orne an^.y wonls „..„od . and Mr. Rlli, told him to 
 lcive the o»uc. or soo.cthing like that ; h„t.l,o a,!,nus Id.ns.ll that, at the u- f 
 , 'i-c .^."Pln.n, ,na,le, a,a..t hi.n. 1,. lo.,t h. tunpcr -.vith Mr. Morri on at u V It" 
 U was hnea, and only deta.ne.l a .short tin. i„ th. aq„oduc. at ti,., .in K;- 
 
 Mcd., and mad., no ..nplaint ,o Or.awa Ros. .-ay.s h. u.ado a .orni-la n. .o D 
 Ferguson, and l.at Dr F.rgn.on .sold hin. ; did not act .trai«ht with him Whe„ 
 , .nan su.ura that l.tor. .you, ..poci.lly with your knowlod^e of .-hnt .mmb r „f 
 ,.rh,unent have to .. .so„u.r.n,c. I th>nk yon w,ll con. u, the conclu^o,: " , J 
 .Ma.ght ; I do not th.nk ha .. .apabl. of acting otherwi.. Mr Saurin's J w 
 '■■^wfiKHfed in the .same way. * 
 
 Caj,tain McCoppen comes hon- w.th a icng n.outl,. Savs h. was fined ai Of, 
 «.. when I said .0 hin. -Pid you ,.v tha, monev- l.said "No. I cSno mv •"■ 
 .nd he un out lauglan, Capta.n Lark.n pa.d ,. Wh v did h ,ay it ^ B II 
 (jt violated the rules of the -timl Wh^' r^^< t 1 • (.>"■' necausn 
 
 .. Off With 3500 fine, for the iage^lone. ' '"^''" """' ''"' "''^" «'''' '^ 
 
 Then Captain IIutiie'.s case— ' 
 
 S^ <;?'™'3SI0XER-Y» need not .pe.l, of ,h.,. 
 
 Then number thirteon, I think vou will bowl out 
 THE COMMIS.SION'ER-Yes. 
 
 . wit'outf jltn '"^ '""■' "'"^^"' '''■' '-^ "^■^'*"^ "• -'^ ^''^y — ^ not par 
 
 THE COMMISSIONER-And it thr ev.d.nc. produr.d h... a. to ST, D.m«r • 
 
 .ffKionrv is to b.> r.li,,d on, h. d.-.^crvc. th. money. 
 
 MR. RVIvRRT Wr com., now to M... mo.^t .soriou.. . ha.g.-. of all ■ "Allowed 
 
 ■v.,„. ,. now into th. , .nal f.om Uke Ene. in .fanua.y las,, though ho ha ' l" v 
 
 o. ,n.„ ,0 piovnu .,, causing an r.timat.d dam.gc of .?2.5,000/ Well Vow "ir ■ 
 
 ■M-.. .bH, point, I ,],. not wish ,0 pass ,u,v nllo.tio,. upon .Mr. (>,«., ,, ,„ o: [' 
 
 '-. rarv, I hav. .,.ont,do,.. iu ,i„ ,n., ..bi,ity . and I do not bd.L ha M P t' 
 
 ;.;- .^. not bian. .L El. . that;;,:.- ^:;'";:;;::Lt;r ^'t' Zci^z 
 ;--r:;tt :^:n:r:r:^^:::-:-;rTr"fr 
 
 ;; rhat any po.itiv. .n.t.u.t.on. w... g..,, , ,,,1 ..'^ti; J ,^,^ , ^^^ ^'- 
 ^^op.log.s t ere, and it was f,. h„„ to givr th.. instructions. T 1 I ; le ■ 
 opened, and thev were ordered to he .losed in ,88.0. • Now. vou w .1 .f. that n 
 Mr. Page« report sent fo you. ot wbi,h I bave a eonv bn dn.= n.f r 
 
 ........ ..in, ,i„„ . .k„„.^c ,..0. .,. .„ . „ ;.;::!;, :i;.,t^ :z'z ;:„■ r^ 
 
 Mr V)) V ♦>, u . • ^^.iuJdrine.s. tney got scared about a htt e sometimB* 
 
 Mr Ell s.thoiigh,^ It neces^aiy to guard the Welland Canal, and he wrote to OtZ!' 
 .nd made a r.por. .-.pon it, and a gonticman wa. sent here to Lptrt up^o^ 
 
iijll 
 
 A, I I Yi 
 
 if 
 
 matter; l,o .ou.ultod ^r.■ Elli.. nn,l r.^JLuvh-.l tl.n cr.tr, to h. .1 ,. 
 
 by tl.e l.tter tl..t M,. ri.,n.,,,s,„. was «o,kij,, M,,.,. ; ,„■! ,1... „I „',. .f H . " ,. 
 EUis „„,, Mr. Tho„„,.a . .. ...ay, ..nn.,!,,,; I nun.ot :„lli^ .^^ ' ' , 
 
 l..l«. -, n,..I .xcmsod .upcn.su,,, ov, it ,h,o,,;,l, .^r,, Tho,n,Ho,. ; m', Ellis -., ' 
 
 .lor , n M . T!,o,„p.,on. tl... re,,!.,,,, en^inec. Tliev. wl.cn u.mr.k.te.l u-ii' L 
 placc,l.ln.,..,,ly«a cv you. ch;.,g.; ,ac.nti,n., you .ill U, J.l.a J t<^ (, t 
 
 Bcc, ,vlnlc th. letter oftl,.. ICth ,.f F-.W..,. ..lorl tu rh./^m. X ,.t^ .^l:; 
 Mo,, at t at tijne. 3n,I tie ic. .tt. tho. i. not one wur.l abonl .^.^ -ic ^ ^ 
 a t r n,„ .lose ornav,,,,ti„n ; nu.l Mr. Pag«. in ni.= ..viacn.c. ..y ].? vcr ' 
 such ,n,t..uot.on.s lu; ..y. : "The „nc. wero oponoa, an.l tl.v were orZ t^.' 
 clo,,ea m 1 o cluru,,, the Fenian scare." Ho goes on to sa^ "The la L 1 
 •'gat., .houM be cloHod, 3t.,nn or no storm, at the clu.e of n vh,. io„ ■ I'.d . 
 J.>nk there ,s no .louht about th.t : l,o..a,.o. if an accident happens uruth^n; 
 o.day tle.o .. not the moan, ofstoppin., the water until the iolo o L I « En 
 lowered. The turn le «ate. are ru that. po.mion th.at they >.„not he raised I v 
 pn m a letter u. reference to that, .h.e .Mr. Ellis .Ira.., -.ttent.on to 1 a f. t 
 letter i. ,>i Aprd .30th, 183.1. I an. not ref^.ting upon Mr. Pa,e at all • , L 
 
 an omts^on up... the parr, of .somebody, Mr. Elli., a.s you wdl see. a 10,;': 
 iS .. a-sked the n.paKu,ent to give hin. instruction., about the tntnb e '^.t ' a K • 
 Colborn., and also at Port Robinson ; and ho sav«, in that let lor, "Tunrble nto 
 ; provided at Port Colborno. an,!. I believe, at Port Robin.son ; bur t J^;^. ^ 
 
 no prov..,.,n to r,a,se a.ul lou-er tlK.e at neauent interval, as there shon b" 
 keep them Iron. aecu,nulat.on« of nrud and in goo.l ^rorkin, onl.-r. un' I .houV 
 ; bo Klad to h:.vo th. authority to have prope, appliances put up at one b 1 
 : purpose. Now. Mr. Page a.lnnt. that if the ,.te. had been dosed, Jtl 1 " 
 amount ol ,lan,a,^ would neee.s.avily have been done. Then I aske.I h ,.. ahout h 
 Btop logs Mr. Page says there were .rr,.n,emonr. there lo, putting in hT t^ 
 logs ; but y.K. wdl .00 from the in.tru. tiou. that Mr. Ellis had r,o autho tv to • 
 in a.khnonal .top log., Th« evidence i.s that the water went four feet ov hi t ' 
 au.l. even suj.posmg t.Kjt Mr. Elli. had put on r-v , feet nrore. the water wo , W S' 
 have gone over that. Then, at page 2J '5, Mi Ellis save ■ -'T „nu . '™""^ ^^'^ 
 "instrueuous iVom Mr. Page or ^u.bod else ^ t in ■!^ZZ^T1 ""' 
 Then, on March 7th. 1885, Mr. Bradley wntos .s loll w. -T 2yt mu St' 
 ;;of the .th in.unt. I an. drroeted to .nf;nm you that it i. .!; £ -^J ^ha^ f 
 • etop-Iogs, at t e north end .f ,he ...e^v.y r. Port Colborne, should be m.^„ s t 
 'in the event of such ,,enoa., injury oc.u, ring to .ome of the ininoriant wo t 
 •: that part of the Wellan.l Canal, a. to r.nUer this eour.e nece:!:^ j; sul^tr!: 
 
ll oM : 111 II' 
 
 lit til It uiie .^rt III' tli. 
 !.aii h.' fiTv\y 'i lo^c ; 
 I. iiii! -Ui ii a iiiiin; 
 I'l' U]i tlif Siljiply ! 
 i"!i ; Ijoi.iiusc ymi ■ 
 
 Mr. l\\!ir, tliiit .\; 
 
 I'f wijti w:is tli lil.ii 
 I' ''iitiielv ill 1,1, ,,v, 
 .'•"on ; Mr. Ellis ;i,i 
 II i!'toi' tliat to ^fi 
 ii'-tiinrcd, uinlci hi 
 '1 toni[il,..toil, will I , 
 iKiascil to jillow tl.. 
 saiijo." So, yoiiui' 
 
 ••It tliO J^Mte.H llitlfitl. 
 
 kufiliiijfjthuraclode': 
 s.i.V-s lio never i^.tv, 
 ' were orJeroil to l.- 
 ■. "Tholactis, tl. 
 avi.!<ation." And I 
 iiTis u|iou tbe caiiv 
 lolo of L.ik« Erie '■ 
 i lie raised. I Imvr 
 on to tiiat fact; tl... 
 
 ■it all; it has Ut.. 
 
 SCO, as long ago u;- 
 imhk cfatesat I'or- 
 
 "Tumble g.itec! ar 
 'lit ibcro lias beci. 
 ;Ji'jre shuiiM be t.: 
 nliT, ami I dlion!. 
 ' at Oiiro tor tha: 
 losed, (hilt a lar^-- 
 kpil liiiii about tb 
 ting in other stop 
 
 authority to jur. 
 feet ovcT the top, 
 
 1 water would stil: 
 ever recuiriMj an\ 
 tional =.toji.log.-. 
 ilily to your lotte: 
 li'^irable that fl. 
 i;u be imtin, save 
 lonaiit works oi; 
 y. In such evetj:. 
 
 in^o,.(„.,,.; ;„ -•■',.-^'W'-iM, „ntuiil!y, b,. th.. rno.mun. n,!op(.,|.'' Soth.it 
 
 • ml ....e t\m n mvn- waa iu ro„ron>pI,mV,„ ,„ ,,„ that. Mr. Pi,«c h,,| ,m.r 
 
 ■'-'..' h,.\ an npportiuatv of ...i,,,, th. .t.nn „,, to tha, ],. i.|., TIuto n.vor wa, 
 
 ..n occasion lor ,t b.fore thi.. H,, ,ay.4 ih... stop.jo.^ u,.„. h,.|lt 
 
 ii«i»ial plan. Ill answdr to niv rjue.stion, he sari : 
 
 ae oriliiig t') thi 
 Xo spci'i.il iiititiiirtioiij wpio 
 
 ,..^ on any furt her than tl- objo.t , onton,plat«.l wu. in kee,, tl.o ..rater out, and if 
 ^ h.y wnr« not h,,h . ,^„„h ,h.v ahouM K, ,.ut nu. Th.y Uhl an.n.r the -nipn.. 
 '.p to .I.u.uary 9th. No trouble ninne tho norlcs were ron.pl:..,! until Mien Tl... 
 wat.r was n«v.r hi«l,..r (or thirty yoarr Thny .o,. l.,;r tho ov,,,. h.-i^ht thov 
 w.,. M.hrn ^ons,n:,.,.,l ; ,,„| I „„po„. t]., ,,,,„, ,,^„, ,^,„^.^ ,;^^^,, ,^^.^^ ,.^;;^ ^ ^ 
 
 "'.i" 'I'r- -Ti'^n, in iv^.-i. Mr. Kllis wrote the Dinurtnu-nt ..bout th. Fenian. • 
 ■ .aul th..v w,.,v .„in, t„ blov „,, tli,. ranal. He was ordered in Feb, uarv, 1^S5 to 
 .^ut tha 1, . and ..h.,r the R.ue.., a,.,; tlioy wen> to put in the .t.>p.I„,, "that were 
 .bcre. riiat was iu ,.85, and yet the letter .lys to put in „o n.o,. .top-io^n I 
 o not .ay ,t . r,dte.t,n« n,ou Mr. Pa«e ; I look up,..i Mr. P.,. a. a uio.t' eminent 
 ^1, n .1 .ook upon In-u ,,s ,u uUni.ato triend. aud I would not .itt.uipt to ca.st auv 
 .Uo..t on upon b.a. >..n- .onld I. b.ea.ue L. . a «eutienian of di.sti..,;.i,.h.,d .dn,i " 
 Kco-M.ued all over tin. 0,-ntiuent. but the b.st men uro liablu to mak. ,ui.takeV 
 .lr^ra-,..ay.it wiMho ru,.st e.xceptionai stoim know,, for th- la,t f.r, wears' 
 but wl„.„ wi. ,„u,e to e.^a,ni^e tho qnc3t>on about what damage has been duue" Mr' 
 
 lvVr,""r 7"!''' """ 'r° *''">^'''"''^'''^ 'la.na«e.veuif,he.a,c.shad'bee,; 
 ; o^ed. and I think tlier. ,s uo doubt whatever that tho v,i,..r would hav. ,i,.u, .vw. 
 iftheKuti-. wa.o.elo,cd. to ti,u .„„„. height over the stone wo.k ,dong the ranal 
 -•er the stone Kicn,,, and that u would have w.ashed the banks; because it ia in 
 .vu once h.,e tuat ther. wc.e sto ms of the year before that, and two vea,> b.dbrc 
 rhat, whce tl... wuu.r r... two or three feet over the ttoue an.l washed'th. Ivuikn 
 •ae water i:ou„„g iVo.u Ldu.- Erie, and it ha., been in the habir of doin« that If 
 •r.ere rs any lault t,,. b. ..:,„nd it was in not havi„g that b,i,di enou.di. Dia that thi>- 
 .'.as an esecpt,o,r,l storn. ad,n,t,. .,i ,„. ,loubt whatever, that thei^e was a wind 
 • .0WU..1J and wbwievur 'h. wu,d -I.e. blow upon the ranal, and the water ri.es, it 
 V , sues the oauks eon,i,.,u,l,y. So tnat when it i. said the whole dama;-.. wa.s caused 
 -•• thrs I think ,t IS an e„i„.. uu.nake. The .videnco .how. that f.r the Ur..t time 
 >n tUnty vear. ba.k, at any rat., that the water opene.l the lock-gatc at Port 
 •lutlaud. where the.e i.. a drop of eight feet into the lake. So vou L it was ar. 
 -:.'ept,o,ial storm, vuich no perso.i could .nmi^d again..t. M,'. .Secord says that wh-n 
 .: -cut to bed at n o'clock he had no rcasou to believe the.e wonl.fbe a ..v er 
 
 ^W' Z e ' " "T' "r •'" "" " '''' '' '' ''••'• ^-^ ^^'' ^"'« to blame , 
 . a,it , It se ,„8 to me that ihis is outside of your cncjuirv. Iu ti,. lirst place, vou 
 
 ::: sr^'r.?"^'. " '^'..i:''^^ ^^'^ '"-'^ i^-d ins judgment ui,^t-"f 
 
 ^Li^fjH'' r''"''" '^' ^I'v"' "hoiiy;,bw,;;:'u;;rhe'w,;;iidhaveso 
 
 .epo ted to the (government, and they would have uu-L- Mr. EUi., p^v the penaltv 
 font, I he Government are seized of all tho.se la.ts, .audi 
 '■:?araiue the m.itler liiUy, they wili come to the conelu.« 
 -iijle, and that it i,s ni. 
 
 run satisfied if they 
 , , -'^iun Mr. Ellis i.- not lespon- 
 
 will rnn p t , t. T ''"'" "''''''' ^'° '''"''' ""' ^""^''^'M'-'te. So I think vou 
 
 wdl co,ne to the conelu.sion it is not a c.iso in which wo can 
 
 ... • . X. .,,,. T-. . - -••• ni'iki' anv complaint 
 
 ^.aumt Mr. £.li,s, Tno Govornment were in po.ssession of all the fac^., and rouki 
 vass an opiniou upon ,t U they cho.se to do so. Hut I referred to the evidlnce put 
 to show M.-. P,age must be mistaken with, regard to giving instruetious ; an 1 I lo 
 
'111?, 
 
 I ] 
 
 i I 
 
 jl 
 
 i U. 
 
 knw 1 '.?''" '''"'''" "'■• ■^''- 'V- •'ays h. know, notlnngof hie ou ^ 
 
 I ;!• \ ■, ' ''' '"' '"■''^'" '"^ '■"1"'" t'-'-'f *^ «•""''! '-^^t S-25.000 UVlrn 
 
 00 hatt heo.-..hna,v ga.Ksotn.e,, ...ploycl year alter vear, with tho .vc.p . 
 tuo additional ..en. have h.en .n.ploy.d wUh other work alon. tb^^Tau' 
 
 ha other w..,. a. .,..,..,, do,, alou, .i.h this : .o that th. da.na,;,;^ ^'2 
 unucd. It has b..n Mu.wu ,l.a a laV^e a,„o„nr of ,„at..rial .L n,to tU- cuur 
 every year ho.n wasi:.. : and wi.u th. host heave, the bank. Th t ho^ 
 
 oxraordiuary aet.on upon the end.ankn.en,. Vear alt«r year a hu- ' l.o^^t . 
 
 > ai altu yt.u >. i ,,y „ ,, ,,„, ,^^„, ,^, ,tt,i|,„,, ,|, t,,;^ damaKe to on. .ton, 
 he ..tn.KUe was nude, and :he eros...et,.„. taken, son. tin.e alteftlL 2, i 
 
 place , .. u IS utt-riy nn,,oss,ble to say hou nn,eh is attributable to this, 
 
 NoSN, w.. ..o.ne to the general nianaKeineut of the .a.ial. I Omk I do n, 
 n^n-e to put .n any evideuee l.elore y.u of the eniei.,,,.. „■ u. lock e « V 
 
 ha e-the evnlenee ol tug-owners, tu^-eaptain., and ot],er gentIon,en wl ^ J, 
 ut,U.,ng t^he eanal and they invariably eon,e to the eonciu.io ' and . , ^ J ' 
 hat the loek.tender. have done their best to get thetn through th,' 'in IV 
 
 he cvulenee o Captain iiawder.ly, Captain Ar.n.tron,, Captain Sa.,r C, ta ' 
 
 ..in. .heir v... th.ngh. s„ \ Hn-^r^^rir tirL: ^ir^^^^^^^^^ 
 
 .anal ha. been uli.e.ently n.anaged by the loek-tender. a. .ar a, thev are!^ ^n ' 
 
 ;^ --"--;v to n,en.nh.gherposU.ou.. along the eunal. I do tot hi k 
 need ,,ay much about the n.auageUK.nt ol Mr D.uure : ht. nuu.ageu ent I a ha 
 gueii.uuae .atrsiaeiion. He eouies hue nin\ .„ i i '"^.^''U'ent ,o la. hu= 
 
 with a .ertiheate ol character iron:./ P. ti,! 7 ZiT^ T T'' ''"'^'" 
 
 ^jervu.g n.n, a capuui nun, b.th eucgeti.. and skUied.' V^,,. .^ T ' 
 tlha bear.s lestini.my m the ^aiue direetion u,.! I i i, i ' "^'^■'^•^■l -^J' 
 So.clusi.n that. ., ,ar a. he ,s eunee^! J hJ , t^ T TT '" '^' 
 
 ,pou hitn and charged hi -ith having 'l^i^'^^^,!^;::: Z^^^^t 
 
 own private nu)n,,se.. craiusi il>. ;..f.,..„„.., ,>■ ., ' . "^"^ ^'"'*' '"» '"^ 
 
 e V. as nii.stakeii and 
 
 own private puri^.e., .gain.t the iutere.st« of the government h 
 uot justilied Hi making the charge 
 
 With rjjgard to Mr S.uyth'. uiatiagotnuut, we leave tiic ..xord of M,- Suntl 
 who IS uu old and valuable -ervaiu on the caiiui W - 1 .v ,1, . ■ • ' 
 
 n... who are not .oittical inend. of t:" ' h^l^^ t: '.^"^ 
 ^a CaptaL. .Norri. aud .Ir. Xo^lo.. Hohe.c C.ultct';:ar;: ^l^ to^^: 
 
oppose. ,0 ,„„ ,,oht„n!!v. wl,o have ccne lu.,,. volunr.Mlv au,) ho,,.- fo.tin.c.v t,. 
 .H .n. oa,c,o„,.v .„ the .na„.ge,„«..t of th. ..„at h se.„s t,. „.e vou T . ^ 
 on,,.,h„..o,„..lns,o„tha.,,),.tHn,ythl,a.a.te,l,„ th« ,.„...]... int^.^.r .„i , 
 
 ■l^'initv s„j,..,„„,.„,l„,„. h,, ,ii,.,,,,.j,„, ,,i, ,,„ti,, f,i,h,ully ;„,l well 
 
 As ,.ga,.ls the ,.,u„.ge,.,c„t of th. ...k.) hy M.-. ]£lli«, r do „c, th„.k that vu„ 
 
 >.n. ,.o„t to :, .s.„gK. .(.twuent ,„ th. ..v„le,H,. whi.l, will ..3,-,a,.t vo„ in .o.nhiKto 
 
 ..yoclK.,-,..o„cu.,„. ,1M„ tha, M,. Ellis l,a. ..anag.l the c-alweli. m" Si 
 
 : :;;f ;;: u'?,r'"r" ' "r r^^'"^^ '"" ^^ '^ *^'^ ^«--^>- ■^' "- --^ 
 
 mei.t. M . ,\r..C.ll,„„ I,.., stu,ho„sly avoided asking a .ine.stior, as to whetJie. he 
 ■nnj-age, the .„., .. ,, „, ,,,, ea,,tai„ Ko.s. Captain Lnin, Captain M ^pp^i 
 •nd C pta„, H„n,e all have p,.ivate g.ievanees of thei,- ow,,. Xot L s-'n^le ,, a, 
 
 ::^ :t ;:t\;: ;7'';v'^":;' r^-^ ^ '-'^ thatobs^v^tiiin! 
 
 T • '" " "' '^ ■■'^'^ '''' ^l"^^'"""" '^^ ^" ^'"^ n>anagem.nt of the 
 attacU.g tlH ,na„ag.,n.„t ,.t the ,anal, t,L.,e arc dozens of .nen within vour 
 t. ^ou .an go back aud ,:xa„„„e ,„t,> the ,nanagen,ent of the canal f „• the pa8t 
 
 ; tn;;;'^:'.;;;;::;" t "1""^ """^^ " ^'^^ "^ ^^^" -'^-^^^ -^ ^ ^^s. 
 
 .0 ,1; to\ n '■'' ''•""• l^"""^"^'"^'>-«'"'-''"^ and it .ill ,.en.ai„ as a 
 
 n o.u„ne, t to M. Llh. .nanagement lor all time to co.ne. We havo the evidenee 
 
 :; r;: z:;;"/t'^^'' '""''^ -' '"^^ ^- '-' ^-^^ i^'-t^- ^ genial t 
 
 ; , I' 'i''f'>^ "' ^ l^"K'.' out..-,'p>-,se in .Are,ritt,.n, the paper tmll; he testiir^g as 
 ^t u, efh,.:ent u,a„age.nent of the .anal. We hav. the toslunouv ^Av^^' 
 
 -ko .say. no ,nan has over eon,plained of hi. u,anago,ue„t, M,-. Pa.e ,J^eZ 
 car .,0 cotnpla,nt.s of M,.. Eili. n,anageu,c„t." He .ays that at pa^e ui' itok 
 
 upon that a. „npo,tant tcsti,nony. M'o have Alexande,. Mui,. who has bl a m 
 
 ong Relor,,u.r who has no friendly f.eli„gs towards this Govert^unt ; , 21 ul 
 
 0. o .Mr S n,tl, and Mr, Den.a.e, Then we have Mr. Baldwin, tna.ager oftho 
 Ogdeu.bu,g Iransportation Li„e, . gen,h.„,,n who controls a la,.g aTJuJt o" 
 tnUhc con,.ng th.ough the -anal; he says Ellis 1ms done mne], o Lukretl 
 -al : he ha. .nanaged it etheieiuly : he want, to «oc no cha„ge. Thl r^e^ 
 
 r,.sia. ut o the Hefoian Assoe.at.o,, I do n.,t k„ow whether that is an liono.able 
 
 I a.e 0, not ; I aur not in the .ee.ets of that o.gani.at.ou at all ; but j'lgir '^ 
 .uy owt, organ,.at,on. I ^vouId thtnk that it wa. not vcrv h.crat ve at a", r u, H 
 
 W.itthous, ot ron.n o. vos^el-owuer, und other persons who have a .i^^ht to l<now 
 
 ,1 nu, a ,,, 1, Jciboii wlio saya his whole imorcst foi a life time has bet., 
 
 rapped up .„ the oaual : he draw, a con.parison between Ellis and his d c' 'nl 
 
 ud .ays there .s a .na.-ked distinction in favor of M... Ellis; and then \^72 
 
 U«t.wrtu,.,.Mr. Xcelon. aud his testimony is valuable, to . All thL , it 
 
>hi 
 
 ;! I'll 
 
 esUfy. to he goo.l managen.ont of M.. Ell,. So vo., ,„„m <.ome to th,- < on.ln.sio., 
 he canal ha, t.ean efficently mana^e.l hy Mv. Klli. It i. true that little thil 
 have cro,pe. up .r« aud there; In.t look at ,he gigantic uorlc whi.h is «oin, o?, 
 He h bee. hero tor ton years : and what can you say against Mr. Ellis ? He has 
 Kot 249 pu.kets; that is all ho ha. put .u his pocket and that not paid for by the 
 -vornment ; he, ha. had sod bronght to his house, aud a few loads of gravel ;" and 
 
 or two occasions, but his .^hole interest has been i. favor of the canal L th.e 
 
 AT.d the last poiut is the testimonial to Mr Ellis. I pointed out to vou. and 1 
 now show you that M. Conway, the n.ana.er o, the canal at Lachine, the genera 
 superintendent that he has ha,l a testin.onial giv,,n to bin, repeatedlv, and that 
 too, wub the knowledge of the Government,, giv.n to him in a j.ubli; place con,' 
 ...ented upoo by the merchants of Montreal i,i the Board of Tr.de, and public 
 ):itone y giveu to it; and yet there has been no ,en.onst,ance. It is a n,atter of 
 
 •til to vn 'pr'^'lT" T'^"^ '^"'' ^^"''^^' '^"^ '° ''y ♦^'•■'^ ^">' "«ti»'^"ial 
 Th T A T ' ? '■ "' " ^''"'""^ "'"'''"•^'''•' ''^' ''-''y '"■ "--^lution, Ifke that of 
 the fhorold Township, or otherwise, is given in consequence of a .service to a class 
 in the community, I think is not justitied. 
 
 But Mr. Ellis, when he came here, was in au unfortunate position. I do net 
 know that you are here to expose his private aflairs, 
 THE COMMISSIOXER-No. 
 
 MR. RYKERT-He came heroin an unfortunate position; aud if thev gav. 
 hi,ii a U^stimouial, It was uot lor the purpose of making hi,n giv. the.n a .^uidpro 
 qao. He has acted m the public iuterest, and I think the testimonials have had uo 
 derogutory etie.ct on the public iut«rest. And, with these remarks, I submit with 
 ail conhdeuce, that, after a careful review of the matter, you will repo, t that the 
 whole investigation, lioin beginning to end. was prompt..! by malice, bv a personal 
 ?pit9, lu the uiterests of a man named Mossip, who ^^ as totally unwJrthv of auy 
 truet being reposed iu him. I make those observations because Mr. McCalluni 
 charges that this niau was unjustly disu,is6cd. .\ow, we have shown he i. a man 
 totally unworthy of the conh.leuce of anybody, unworthy of being employed; aud 
 all the chaiges, from beginning to end, are based entirely upon the evidcuce of dis 
 aj.pointed men, who have been turned out of office because they disobeyed orders or 
 for. drunkenness, or for the violation of some rules, which were la^cessary to' be 
 enlorced lu order to have elhcieut management on the canal. So I think you will 
 come to the conclusion that the whole thing, Irom beginning to end, is a trivolous 
 and vexaliouD en.,uiry ; aud I w..uld u,-ge uj.on you strongly, if I l,e permitted to do 
 so, to make such a report to the Government as will satisfy them that there waa no 
 ground ior the enquiry ; that while you make your suggestions, as I know you will 
 do, about the management of the g.'eat ,mblic woik, I think yuu must come to the 
 conclusion that no portion of the repo.t will be able to fasten upon Mr Elli. auv 
 stigma 01- any chai'ge that he has acted in dereliction of bis duty 
 
 THE COMMLSSIOXEK-I wi,.h to just say, at the close ot'this invcMigation, 
 Ln^'Tfi'-'i , I ''"°''^"' '"'H>«^"""^^v of doing it. and 1 wish it taken 
 
 dQ^^n. that 1 have been exceedingly gratified at the courtesy that has been extended 
 .to me personally by the partie. conducting the case, by Senator MeCallum on the 
 
 liiii. 
 
fi till- couohisioii 
 at little thuifT^ 
 liiili is f^oiu^ nil 
 Ellis ? He has 
 I paid fill" by tlirt 
 of ^Tavel ; ami 
 ffineut upon onc- 
 ? canal and tlic 
 
 It to you, and I 
 ne, tlie gcnoial 
 idly, and that, 
 blic placo. com- 
 ide, and public 
 is a matter of 
 my testimonial 
 on, like tliat of 
 ivico to a class 
 
 39 
 
 I think, ui ,, vury .a.efu] mann-T I .hall nrobablv HuA it , ' "' ' ■''"^'^ ""■'• 
 
 '■iMium.'.^ in connection ^vith this matter in rprird .„ .h« O" • i 
 
 I do net 
 
 I if they gavo 
 leni a :^uid pro 
 ■h have had uu 
 I sulimit, with 
 spoil that the 
 
 by a personal 
 worthy of any 
 Ir. iicCiUmu 
 n he is a man 
 mployud ; and 
 iilcucf of ditj. 
 jyed orders, or 
 lucRssiiry to ba 
 link you wjU 
 
 is a frivolou.s 
 -Tmittod to do 
 thuro was no 
 now you will 
 >t tome to the 
 Ur. Ellia any 
 
 invcftifration, 
 wish it taken 
 icen uxtouded 
 dlum on th9