REVISION •) OF THE CANADIAN TARIFF, BY J. C. LANGELIER. ^ MONT R E A L • •JAZKTTE PRINTING HOUSE, CORNER ST. FRANCOIS XAVIER AND CRAIG STREETS. 1872. ^ ' Ifc « *,••- «' * - • I . ♦ • ■ • • « • • ' PRELIMINARY REMARKS. These notes were originally prepared to be published in the papers; but some circumstances havin;j; prevented their publication tlirough the press, it was thouglit advisable to make a panii>hlet of them. So defective as the style in which they are written may be, their subject is not less pregnant with facts and suggestions which nnist draw the attention of all those who take some interest in the commercial and industrial policy of the Dominion. Such is the onlw excuse for their jtublication. Montreal, April IStli, 1ST2. i -i II E V 1 S 1 O N or TiiK CANADIAN TARIFF. Tho great fvetit of 18G7 cfinHidcrably moililii'd tilt! (.oiidition of Canadian fconoiny, by abulishiuK the cUMtoDJH dutiis wlii
  • ; a powerful impulse to Canndia!i coinuierie and indiihtry : in the interior, hh well as the exterior, comniereial opt;rati(>ns t' ' k con- siderable proportionB. Duriiiir ii • year which esi)ireil on the liOtli of June, 1870, we imported for $7-1,814,33!), and exported for $7;!, 573, 190 ; so that our total toDimerce amounted to S;i4S,387,820. The cuBtoras brought to the Government $'.),4''>2 a40, and the tonna^t! of all our Canadian ports was 11,415,820 tons. These fii{ure8 show i)lainly tho commer- cial importance which Confederation has ^;iven to this country. During; the year which expired on the 30th of June, 18C7, we imported for $50,048,987, ami exported for '?)8,48t),143, making the amount of our com- merce $107,535,130. '1 he customs gave a revenue of $7,023,327, and the tonnage at all ports did not exceed 9,883,187 tons. During the three years comprised with- in these two periods, that is to say, from the first of July, 1807, to the first of July, 1870, our commerce was increased $40,- 852,anjing the report for the year 18 70. the (V niniissit>iier of Customs writes to the Ihn. Mr, Tilley, (hat " independently of our splendid and nnnuT- '• ous llour mills, nnd of our vast es- " tablishnii'iits for the falricatiou of all " kinds of wooden articles, it is but "just to siiy that the manufactures of Canada " are distinguished, more by th'ir divtr.-ity, '•than by the extent of their a hievemeuts." •' There are" he adds, " a few manufrtcfuiies "which, as regaids numbers and devtlop- " ment, produce more than is net cssary to " supply the Canadian market." To have been within the truth, Mr, I'l'ti- chette should Imve written that our manu- factures Were very far from siiflitient to sup- ply the Canadian market. We have spinners of wool and cotton, and at the same time we imported during the year of width Mr. Bouchette speaks, $8",2£8,588 worth of woollens, and of cotttm gccds, $7,399,- 992 worth : we also have large estab- lishments where are made all manner of aiticles in iron, from the locomotive to the finest tack ; notwithstanding this we import- ed during the year 1870, $5,703,143 worth of these goods i we also imported of articles in copper antl brass $326,980, and of glassware $553,300 worth, while we have, ei-pecially at Montreal, establishments wIiitc articles of this description are made quite us well as in forei^'n countries. Where shall we find the cause of this anomaly? In our tarilf, whit li dots not give a sufiit'ient prottcticn against foreign competition, especially auainst english competition. We have all tho necessary eltments for the creation of a con- siderable industry, a market of ft iir niillions of people, bkillid and im xpen^ive labour, raw material, motive power, and capital ; but all these advantages are nlative, and dis- appear when we havt^'o enter into tumpeti- tion with english mantitacturevs, who have all these advantages, aud enormous capital, 6 on wLitli tlioy pny but a comparativfly nom- inal intt'ri.-Kt, with<>ut coiitititi^ that tlicir fabrics huvt! tliiit hiijuriority wliirh loiijj ex|)i"rii.'ri(;e has (KvclopwI. Mow ran thf propriftor of t\ ('iinailian fstablinbiui'iit sus- tain, witlioiit iirott'ction, thu couipctitioii Willi inu'lis'i iridiistiy wli^n the latter payw but au interest of two or tlireo \>vr cent on money; wliieli liern we (iiunot obtain willi- nut paying' an interest of hjvcu or eight per cent? Moreover, Coiileileiution wave to our mar- ket Ko Ku(hiuil, where they have had husiness rela- tions established for many years. It is with so fjreiit dillii'iilty that a wliole orKaui/.'itioii is chauifi-d ! Those wlio beliijve in the future of our industry have not yet had time sulli- ciently to examine the vast field which opens i before them. ' It is by introducing into our tarifT tlie i modifications rendereil necessary by our cir- oumstanees, that we shall surmount all these ' difiiculties ; it is by protecting our capitalists that wo shall lay the foundations of an in- dustry truly national, an industry which has every opportunity soon to take magnificent proportions, and considerably to augment j the riches of Canada. For the moment it is i urgent to facilitate the establishment of manufacturies in all the little centres ofj trade ; it is there that our workine: popula- 1 lion sliould find the employment which it is \ forced to seek in a foreign country. When | we shall have obtained this hap])y result our Canaaians will not depart from the soil i which possesses all their all'ections, and the immigrants who ordinarily traverse the ' country to go to our neighbors, will gladly accept here the work which they were going to ask from the Americans. Then our popti- lation like that of the United States will increase in an extraordinary manner, and the works of colonization will go on sponta- neously, without the sacrifices which the government wjuld perhaps make to advance it. But before indicating the ni'.difi'.ations which we think it neces-ary to make in our fiscal laws, it will be well to form a just idea of our financial position, and to point out clearly the principles which should govern the augmentation or diminution of the duties levied on the importation of certain mer- chandise. For thi.s reason we shall endeavor to give on this point all the information de- sirable. Admitting first of all that Canada, especially the Province of Quebec, contrary to the general o])iuion, is naturally a manufactur- ing country, that is to say, that it is a coun- try whose climate, geogiaphical position, and the aptitude of Its inhaliitints are more, fa- vourable to manufacturing industry than toag- ricullure. Possessing nianufaetiiring i)r)werH capable of development at sniull cost, labor as intelligent us itiexpensive, the raw ma- terial rerjiiired to supply the largest manu- factories, the neeess '.rv capitiil for the work- ing of vast est'iblishments, and a iniirket of foiw millions of consunii'rs, we could supjiort manufaetnn s capablt^ of giving eniplojnunt to thousands of working people. < »n the other haiiniont, woiilil suppoit a riuinirouR| workiiiK population, nml om- railw'n>H and rive-H would rtinltr ixtrunfly i-any the tranH- portation of our wcalih. We only Im k , immufai turuH to roniplcto all that const!-; tiiten a rich aiid iiult-pctiik'nt pcopk". Hut to have tlivHo mariufiKtiircn it is iw-\ coHcary to nsHurf tln'iu of muicHH by protiit-' in>? tliciii. Now hire a ditUcuIty prcRints; iiHi'lf wljicli ))iUf*t bf ovonoiu". The people j will nctcHHarily oppoKi' the iiic rtnsoof ccrtttin duliiH ; and as all things arc conniH tcil in till! cfoiiciiny of a country, wi- shall lose all the iidvantiigcrt rcHiiltiiif,' fruni the low price; f I 68 the it.tTease of expenditure, estimated at $.! 460,.',! 40. Ill distrihuting these numerous i iiptmta over the diffi'rent sources of revenue, a^'coutit should bo taken of certain interests which require to be watched over. Tli'! uvire clearly to iriikc these di'tinctionH. we may divide merchandiz ', subject to fiscal charges, into three classes: — 1st, arti- cles of liixijry and fancy gorwls : 2iid, the neccsdaries of Mf.', and ,'ird, those things comprisid in the above tw<» elapses, that we can advantageously manufa( turv in this country. As to luxuries aii'l fancy goods, high duties may be imposed unon th'^m without in^-rtas- ing in any ttawa, Mr. Robert Wilkes, of Toronto, suggested the imposition of a million dnllars on landed property, and of one hundred and twenty-five thousand dollars on the transfer of land. It is unnecebsary to say thiit this paper displayed on the part of its aulhor a great deal more of imagination than of com- mon sense; and that the members of tlcj Board of Trade were very far from wishing to adopt his couclu'iions. We remarked before that articles which could be advantageously manufactured in this country sliould be taxed, which wouhi support our manufacturers in entering ir/o competition with foreigners. Amongst these articles there are some of which we have the raw material, such as woolen good.", ironware, glassware, etc., etc, and others of which we can import the raw ma- terial at as small a cost as the English manufaturers, such as cotton. To encourage the production of thcsa arti- 8 clcsinthe country ifl at the gAinc tltno to encourage Iho dtvcloiiiuent of our uutural rcHourct'S. To show the |iiantity of raw niattrial which wo should I - ,duct>, and the advance- ment which would take place in our manu- facturer, if we had a tariff which would p'-r- mit U8 to manufacture these articles, we will give a table Hhowing the value of merchan- dise imported, the percentage of duty upon them, the tariff to which tliey are Buhject, and on the other side the value of th(! raw ma- terial entering into the conntruction of these articles ^hich we have exported. \Vo will take for a ba8is of this table the figures given in the "Movement of Commerce for 18G9-7()" ; the amount of importation having steadily increased since that tinv, these fiEures will give to th(^ comparison a foun- dation of which it will he imposnilile to contest the correctness. Here is the table ; — [See Table I.] As may be seen by this table, wo im- ported in that year for $i:.,H82,.'')Hm ot ordinary mcrcliiindisi', and exported during the same period for $'^8,096,3012 of raw material em- ployed in the manufacture of these goods, which brought to the Government but $-,- 990,50,"). lieeumiug all these details in a few words we will give the rules upon which the re- vision of the tariff should be based. 1st. Reduce so for as possible the duties on the necessaries of life. 2ijd. Increase the duties on those articles imported which can advantageously be manu- factured in this country, at all events, those of which we produce the raw material. 3id. Place very heavy duties on luxuries and fancy goods. It is in the ap])lication ot these rules that wo suggest the proposed cbanKes in the ta- riff indicated in the following table, taken from the "Movements of Trade for 18G9- 70." The table gives the actual ttirilV, the duties which it yielded in 1870, the value of the merchandise irapoited, the tariff pro- posed, the duties which it will give,(i!jd also the increase of revenue which would result from it ; [See Tiil.le II.] Such should be the Canadian tariff to ena- ble us to meet all the exigencies of our po- sition. In the projiosition which we have made, the duties on importations will not affect the necessaries of life, const quently the pi ice of labour will not be affected, and it will favour the creation and development of certain manufactures, the raw material for which will be admitted free of duty, while articles which we produce have a high duty attached to them. These changt;s are also required by the necessities of the public lervice, and we have endeavoured to draw jirolit from the position of alTairs which creates this neces- «ity, by giving to the chaiigts a tendency to protect our manufactures. I If these changfs produce the good results which we have reason to expect, from the industrial point of view, the increase of cus- toms receipts will not in al! probability reach the figure at which we place it. Thus if we import but for $0,000,000 of woolens, instead of for $ < $ 9,848.27 S. D Ic^-ft 19,696.54 44,448 9,848.27 9,405.68 <( 15c. 4P'gal 26,961.20 30.061 10,503.05 55,372.77 u 1.00c. ^ft 115,000.00 151,401 59,628.00 7,766.00 (i 60c. ^ minot. .. 11,649.00 30,095 3,883.00 15,983.77 u 20c. ^-gal 21,310.80 32,603 5,327,01 4,038.07 (I 20c. 34,674 ) 3,220 )| 20,315 )' 7,593 )! 40,437 )'■ 34,134 ) 2,192 ) 38,639 ) 57,852 5 3,535 >' 251 ) 8Cr.,478 51 33,001 )' 2,272 S 6,263 5 220,583 1 1,861.20 8,811.60 1,688.70 643.30 1,520.35 4,654.40 8,712.35 462.75 2,082.45 406.35 136.10 432.85 1,371.40 365.85 126,95 642.45 599.30 530.35 789.65 1,712.00 140.60 808.30 20.00 34.75 12,654.95 799.45 2,659.90 3,558.10 54.80 9,557.70 377.30 16.70 4,125.00 1,042.00 69U5 173.50 346.25 194.80 2,802.30 56,700.03 3,753.65 45,864.10 5,800.35 1,342.15 69.15 492.35 934.35 1,733.35 161.00 1,010.75 379.65 2,021.85 . 1,706.70 109.60 1,931.95 2,892.60 176.75 1 12.55 -10,273.40 1,650.05 110.60 312.65 11,024.15 269,374.6* )! 5,288,281 1 259,374.60 • 11,601, 104.0( )| 20,697,324 2,138,164.10 11,860,478.6( )j 25,985,605 i 1 2,397,5.38.20 1 9 Green Coflee per lb . 03 j ColTeo, dry, ground or roasted .04 Chicory raw or green, or all other roots i and vegetables employed as coffee . . 0.03 Chicary dry, roasted or ground 0.04 Fish salted or smoked, when not im- ported from the British North Ameri- can Provinces 0.01 Fruits preserved in lUandy or other spirits, per gftl 1.20 Hops, per lb 0.01 Lard and Tallow 0.01 Malt, per bushel 0.60 Oils, viz: Coal and Kerosene, distilled, purified, and refined 0.20 Naphtha, Benzole, and Refined Petro- leum 0.15 Products of Petroleum, Coal, Shale, and Lignite, not otherwise speci- fied 0.15 Crude Petroleum . 08 Eice 0.01 Soap, common O.OI Starch 0.02 Salt, except Salt imported from the United Kingdom, or any British Pos- sessions, or for the use of the Sea and Gulf Fisheries, which shall be [ free of duty, per bushel of 56 lbs 0.05 Spirits and Strong Waters, viz : Spirits and Strong waters, not hav- ing been sweetened or mixed with any article so that the degree of strength thereof cannot be ascer- tained by Syke's Hydrometer, for every gallon of the strength of proof by such Hydrometer, and so in proportion for any greater or less strength than the strength of proof, and for every greater or less quantity than a gallon, namely : — Brandy, per gallon 1.20 Geneva, Gin, including Old Tom, per gallon 1.10 Spirits, Alcohol, Whiskey, Rye, and other articles of the same kind, unenumerated, per gallon 0. 90 Rum, per gallon 1 .00 Rum-Shruh, Cordials, Scheidam Sch- napps, Bitters, and unenumerated articles of like kind, per gallons. . 1.50 Cologne Water and Perfumed Spirits not in flasks, per gallon 1 .50 Cologne Water and Perfumed Spirits when in bottles 1 . 50 Unenumerated Spirits and Strong Waters 1.50 Spirits and strong 'waters imported into Canada, mixed with any ingre- dient or ingredients, and although thereby coming under the denomi- nation of Proprietary Medicines, Tinctures, Essences, Extracts, or any other denomination, shall be nevertheless deemed "Spirits or Strong Waters," and subject to duty aa such 0.00 Molasses, employed for refining, or for the manufacture of Sugar, per lOOlbs. . 73 SKCTIOK B. Articles submitted to a »)ierijle and ad valorem duly : Sugar : — All sugar equal to, or above No. 9, Dutch Standard, twenty-five centum ad fdlorem, and a specific duty of one cent per lb. Below No. 9 Dutch Standard, twenty-five per centum ad valorem, and a specific duty of three-fourths of one cent per lb. Cane Juice, Syrup of Sugar or of Sugar Cane, Syrup of Molasses or of Sorghum, Melado, Concentrated Melado, or Con- centrated Molasses, twenty-five per centum ad valorem, and a specific duty of five-eighths of one cent per lb. Ale, Beer and Porter, thirty per centum ad valorem, and a specific duty oi five cents per gallon in casks, and eleven cents per gallon in bottles (5 quart and 10 pint bottles to be held to contain a gallon.) i Tea — Black, ten per centum ad valorem, and I a specific duty of three cents and one half I of a cent per lb. I Tea — Green, including Japan twenty per I centum ad valorem, and a specific duty of seven cents per lb. ' Tobacco, manufactured, except Cigars, and including SnutV, twenty-five per cent, ad valorem, and a specific duty of twenty cents per lb. Wines of all kinds' including Ginger, Orange, Lemon, Goo8el>erry, Strawberry, Raspberry, Elder, and Currant Wines, thirty-five per centum ad valorem, and a specific duty of ten cents per gallon (5 quart and 10 pint bottles to be held to contain a gallon.) SECTION C. Articles Subject to a Duty of 50 per cent, ad valorem. Perfumes, not elsewhere specified. Perfumed and Famy Soaps. Playing Cards. Patent Medicines or Preparations, of which the recepics and ingredients are kef t secret, for the relict and cure of diseases. SECTION D. Artic'es Subject to a Duty of 25 per cent, ad valorem. Unmanufactured Tobacco. Molasses, not employed for refining or for the manufacture of sugar. Bagatelle Boards, and Billiard Tables and Furnishings. Blacking. Brooms and Brushes of all kinds. Cabinet Ware and Furniture. Carpets and Hearth Rugs. Carriages. Coach and Harness Furniture. Chandeliers, Girondoles, and Gas Fittings. Cider. Clothing or Wearing Apparel, made by hand or sewing-machine. Cocoa and Chocolate, 10 Drugs, not clsewhero specified. Fancy (ioods. Fireworkrt. (riins, lliHeB and FirearmH of all kindrt. UlaHB and Glassware of all kinds. Article) suhjected to a duty of 'Zb per cent, ad valorem. (ilaasware. Hat Plush. Iron and hardware, — Cutlt;ry of all kinds. Spades, Shovels, Axes, Hoes, Kakcs, Forks, and Edge Tools, Scythes, and Snaths. Spikes, Nails, Taks, Hrads, ami Springs. Stoves and all other Iron Castings. Other Hardware, .lewellery and Watches. Manufactures of India Ilubber. > or (iutha-l'ercha. Manufacturers of Brass or Copper. Musical Instruments. Stationery. Steam Engines — not elsewhere enumerated. SECTION E. Articles submitted to a duly of 20 jper cent, ad valorem. Cotton Goods. Paper. Locomotives and Cars. Machines not elsewhere specified. Manufactures of Marble. Woollens. SECTION F. Ancles tubmided to a duty of 10 i>er cent ad valorem. Busts, Statues and Statuettes. Sole and Upper Leather. Animals except those imported for breeding. Fruit of all kinds ; Hay, Straw, Bran, Seed Grain — not classed as Cereals — Vegetables, including Potatoes, Garden stulV, Plants, Trees and Shrubs. Books, Periodical Publications, Pamphlets, Prints, not being Foreign re-prints of Eng- lish works, subject to the Copyright lawf^, nor Blank Account Book,nor Memorandum or Drawing Books, or re-prints of Canadian Books, nor leaves of printed Music. SECTION G. Articles Subject to a Duty of 1i per cent, ad valorem. Iron : — Do in bars, Block, or Pig or Sheets. Canada Plates, and Tin. Plates — Heated and Pressed. Types. SECTION H. Articles Subject to a Duty of 5 per cent, ad valorem. Dralvings and Paintings. Gems and Medals. Acids — Alum, Antimony and Argol. Bark, Berries, Drugs, Nuts, Vegetables, and Woods used chiefly in dyeing. P.leaching Powders and Borax. Colors and other Articles not elsewhere spr. cified. Cream of Tartar in Crystals. Lead— l!ed and White— dry. Nitre, Sal Ammoniac, Sal Soda, Saltpetre, Soda Ash, Soda Caustic, Nitrate, and Siii. cate ot Soda. Oils — Cocoanut, Pine, and Palm, in thcii natural state. Roots — Medicinal — in their natural state. Vitriol — blue. Whiting or Whitening. Zinc — white, dry. Ashes — Pot, Pearl, and Soda. Biscuit, and Bread from tircat Britain and P. N. A. Provinces. Bolting Cloth. Bookbinders' Tools and Implements. Cotton Candle Wick. Cement — Marine and Hydraulic — unground. Church Bells and Communion Plate. Cocoa Paste. Fire Kngines, Steam, imported by IMunicipal Corporations. Gold Beaters' Brim Moulds and Skin.';, (iold, Silver and Platers' Leaf. IIoop Skirt Manufacture — Articles for. Junk and(»akum. Lithographic Stones. Lumber — Plank, and Sawed Mahogany, Rosewood, Walnut, Cherry, and Chestnut, and Pitch Pine. Machinery, when used in the original con- struction of Mills or Factories. Nails — Composition of Sheathing and Coni- l)08ition Spikes. Oil Cake. Printers' Implements, viz. — Presses, Electro- type and Stereotype Blocks and Ink. Straw Plaits, Tuscan and Grass, fancy. Veneering of Wood or Ivory. Wire Cloth, of Brass or Copper. Copper — Pig, Bar, Rod, Bolt and Sheet, and Sheathing, except for covering ships. Locomotive Engine Frames, Axles, Crank.'--, iloop Iron or Steel for Tires, bent and welded. Crank Axles, Piston Hods, Guidn and Slide Bars, Crank Pins, and Connect- ing Rods. Railroad Bars and Frogs, Wrought Iron or Steel Chairs, and Fish Plates and Car Axles. Tubes and Piping, of Brass, Copper, or Iron- drawn. Wire, of Brass or Copper, round or flat. Cocoa — Bean and Shell. Corkwood and Bark. I'-ggs. Emery. Firewood. Fish Bait. Grease and Grease Scraps. Gum — Copal. Hay. Moss, for 1 holstery purpose.^. Osiers or 'W illow, for Basket Makers. Trees, Plants and Shrubs, Bulb.i and Koota, Turpentine, other than Spirits of. Whale Oil. 11 Wood, I'nmanufactured ordinniy. All articlcH not mentioned above to be ad- mitted duty Irte. >r({. w I to the canals a double tonnage capacity, this ;is,i;>r).'jo , tonnage at the present rate will at least in- crease the tolls 25 per cent. Now to resume the different increases. 7 27 1.1.112.71 17 v.ti.m Total fioni pxels .,$a,G01,16!i.51 Pl'BUC WORKS. Ciinal tolls ft22,lIfi.P0 Hr'iit, of water powers lt).s.)ii.!il Kliil.saiul IXHiius H2.7H4.(i;i Wlurves ^.i'-*''!' Roads and brUlj^es 0>!"< i^ Tot:il from I'ulillc Works $,51.'!..'>nii. 15 Ptami.s l,fn,27rt.03 C'iler^-' '■■■es (>j,l75.(io •1,201. 94 r- 25 per cent. 6I,17S. 12=26 Milking a total rovemio of $1,410,S15.74 On these different sources of revenue we have to create an increase of $1,035.- ]S8 44. But it is quite as natural that these duties should, as in the case of the customs' dutiej!, bear heaviest upon those articles which arc least necessary to life. It is for this reason tliat spirits, which, far from being Duty on spirits $5-5 1,701. 00 35 percent. Duty on fermented II- fpiors Do do malt Do luaiuifactured to- bacco 1 fs.im. 04 .= 24 Do tobacco leaf 7,025. 04 -Z5 Do petroleum !',175.8'»^ 5 luspeeMon 17,liM.80_10 Warebouses i;i,ll2.71 = 10 Canal tolls SI,lKS.Sf)=20 Hli(l,)S'Mul booms ia.5i0.81=20 Railroads, Ae ini,.oyefnment, as we count upon manufacturing industries taking unex- pecttftl. J)r0portlo'i}6f. , 'When our manufac- < lianges : r.rewor's fiioenses, from.. §50.00 to $75.00 .50 p. c. 'l\)iiiieco Manufacturer's.. 50.00 " ion 00 loo p.o. 1 lisiillors .- 250.00 " 275.00 27 p.c. The receipts from railroads, and "from ofher ]iublie works sliould be increassd. lf)y"$lfe_4,- 2'."3 00, and the revenue from otlier sources in the following proportion: . .■. ;•. ; : "f 12 turers can no longer content thomaolvoB with the local markut, they will bo in a posi- tion easily to Kupport foniKti comiu^tition. Ah LaH been the euHe with bootH ami Rhoefl, HO will it bo with our other nianufitctiiriMl j)rodiictH ; in a few years we bIihII be able to manufacture at a less price than any other country. i And now, wu pray all men who think about tho industrial question, or the future of their country, to examine this feeble at- tempt. The criticiHrns made upon it can but throw further light upon the great question of Industry, which encloses tho secret of our future national existence. Lot tho Govern- ment raise tho tariff, and we shall see before us an era of prosperity worthy of our patriotic aspirations. cm: I I I S 1 ■ -'I ♦f 1 • I. . I. r« t n* >( ) I ' ^^ 1 T .-'1 'i; ' ■>. 1 ''••,* J!,u;n> r>»» )>• ,t,t. .,1 f" *Z~».t;t fU'Mf* •i'ilil't 1 • • > I t < t t \ 1 I- 1 , • ft * 'I