^ s^^ ^X< IMAGE EVALUATION TEST TARGET (MT-3) 1.0 12.5 I.I ■^ 1^ 12.2 S? us. 12.0 1.8 !!.25 li — 1.4 1.6 ^ 6" .,, ^ ;0 Ptptographic Sdenues Corporation 33 WEST MAIN STREET WEBSTER, NY. 14580 (716) 872-4503 ^S iV ^ \\^ '1^ % V .e^ \ ^\ >. -^^% ^ CIHM/ICMH Microfiche Series. CIHM/ICMH Collection de microfiches. Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions / InsMtut Canadian de microreproductions historiques Is Wk< Tachnicai and Bibliographic Notes/Notes ifachniques et bibiiographiquaa The Institute has attempted to obtain the best original copy available for filming. Features of this copy which may be bibliographically unique, which may alter any of the images in the reproduction, or which may significantly change the usual method of filming, are checked Leiow. □ Coloured covers/ Couverture de couleur I — I Covers damaged/ Couverture endommagde □ Covers restored and/or laminated/ Couverture rrstaur^ et/ou pelliculAe I I Cover title missing/ n D D n D Le titre de couverture manque Coloured maps/ Cartes giographiques en couleur Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ Encre de couleur {ha. autre que bleue ou noire) Coloured pfatos and/or illustrations/ Planches et/ou illustrations en couleur Bound with other material/ Relii avac d'autras documents Tight binding may causa shadows or distortion along interior margin/ La re liure serrAe peut causer de I'ombre ou de la distorsion le long de la marge int^rieure Blank leaves added during restoration may appear within the text. Whenever possible, these have been omitted from filming/ II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajout^es tors d'une restauration apparaissent dans ie texte, mais, torsque cela itait possible, ces pages n'ont pas iti film^es. Additional comments:/ Commentaires suppldmentaires: L'Institut a microfilm^ le meilk'ir exemplaire qu'il lui a iti possible de se procurer. Les details de cet exemplaire t^ui 3ont peut-Atre uniques du point de vue bibliographique, qui peuvent modifier une image reproduite, ou qui peuvent exiger une modification dans !a miithode normale de fiimage 3ont indiqu6s ci-da.isous. [~n Coloured pages/ Pages de couleur Pages damaged/ Pages endommagies Pages restored and/oi Pages restauries et/ou pelliculdes ^ages discoloured, stained or foxe< Pages ddcolor^es, tacheties ou piqudes [~~| Pages damaged/ r~~l Pages restored and/or laminated/ r~~U''^ages discoloured, stained or foxed/ □Pages detached/ Pages ddtachies r^T^ Showthrough/ uTlJ Transparence □ Quality of print varies/ Qualiti in^gale de {'impression □ Includes supplementary material/ Comprend du material supplementaire r*n Only edition available/ D Seule Edition disponible Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata slips, tissues, etc.. have been refilmed to ensure the best possible image/ Les pages totalement ou partieilement obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata, un'^ pelure. etc., ont iti filmies d nouveau de fapc.n d obtenir la meiMeure image possible. This item is filmed at the reduction ratio checked below/ Ce document est film6 au taux de rtiduction indiqui ci-dessous. 10X 14X lax 22X 26X 30X / 12X i6X 20X 24X 28X 32X Th« copy filmed har« has been reproducad thanks to tha ganerosity of: Archives of Ontario Toronto Tha imagas appaaring liars ara tha bast quality possibia considaring tha condition and legibility of tha origiinai copy and in keeping with the filming contract specifications. L'sxemplaire filmi fut reproduit grice i la gtnirositi de: Archives of Ontario Toronto Lea images suivantes ont tti reproduites avec ie plus grand soin. compta tanu de la condition st da la nattat* d^ rexamplaire filmi, at en conformity avec \»i conditions du contrat de fflmage. Original copies in printed paper covers are filmed beginning with the front cover and ending on the last page with a printed or illustrated impres* sion, or the back cover when appropriate. All other original copies are filmed beginning on tne first page with a printed or illustrated impres* sion. and ending on the last page with a printed or illustrated impression. The last recorded frame on each microfiche shall contain the symbol «^ (meaning "CON- TINUED"), or the symbol V (meaning "END"), whichever applies. Las exemp^aires originaux dont la couverture en papier est imprimte sont fiimis en uommenpant par Ie premier plat et en terminant soit par la derniAre page qui comporte una ampreinte d'lmpression ou d'illustration. soit par Ie second plat, aaion Ie cas. Tous les arjtres axempiaires originaux sont filmfo en cummen^ant par la premiire page qui comporte une empreinte d'lmpression ou d'illustration et en terminunt par la derniire page qui comporte une telle empreinte. Un des symboles suivants apparaitra sur la demiAre image de cheque microfiche, seion Ie cas: la symbols — »> signifie "A SUiVRE", Ie symbols V signifie "FIN". Maps, plates, charts, etc.. mey be filmed at different reduction ratios. Those too large to be entirely included in one exposure are filmed beginning in the upper left hand comer, left to right and top to bottom, as many frames as required. The following diagrams illustrate the method: Les cartes, planches, tableaux, etc., peuvent itre fiimta d des taux de reduction diffirents. Lorsque Ie document est trop grand pour dtre reproduit en un seul cliche, il est filmi i partir de Tangle suoirieur gauche, de gauche i droite. et de haut en bas, en prenant Ie nombre d'images nicessaire. Les diagramrrtes suivants illustrent la mithode. 1 2 3 4 5 6 l%Jn-i 2^0 THOUGHTS ON THE KEBUILDING ii^' OF ®l)e €atl)ck*al €l}xxxt\) o( Ql 3famc5, BY THE LORD BISHOP OF TORONTO. Printed for private circulation only. 1 / l)l TORONTO: PRINTED AT THE DIOCESAN PRESS, MD C CO L. I I. TO THE PARISHIONERS OF St. iamcs'a JJarifil), Toronto. My Dear Brethren,— It is to be regretted, that, after the unfortunate destruction of the Cathedral of St. James, by fire, last April, measures were not more speedily taken to rebuild a new Church, worthy of this rising city; because the delay and frequent meetings of the Vestry on the subject have pro- duced differences of opinion, and something of irritation. Now, a want of unanimity in this matter is very much to be deplored; more especially, as all the parishioners have the same object in view, and are equally anxious to do every thing in their power for its accomplishment. Permiit me, therefore, to submit a few seasonable words, in the hope ot restoring harmony ; for till this be done, we shall not be m a position to make the great and united effort necessary to rebuild a church, which may remain through ages a monu- ment to our piety, and an ornament to the city of loronto. 1. From the first agea. Christians have had places set apart, with prayers and sacerdotal benedictions, for burying their dead, called Dormitories, or sleeping places; tor they considered death a sleep till the resurrection. There were, however, no dormitories or burying places within the cities or villages during the first three centuries of the Christian era. In this respect, the Roman law was exceedingly strict, and prohibited the burying in cities to every rank and station whatsoever. Now, as Christians obeyed implicitly the law ft n i I under which they lived in all things, innocent and indifferent, they neither did nor could, diirin<^ this period, bury their dead in or around t'leir churches ; because the churches were all within towns and cities. Their burying'-places were, therfore, without the cities, — being either monuments erected above ground, or more frequently caves, vaults, and cata- combs in the fields under ground. In times of persecution, these cemeteries, or vaults, and caves, were also used as places of vVjOrship, in which Christians could meet in greater safety. 2. The laws against burying in cities and in churches continued in force under tlie Christian as well as the Paijan Emperors for several ages after Constantine the Great. Every city and village had a burial-place without the gates, or near the entrance ; and so it continued till about the sixth and seventh centuries, when some relaxations beofan to be introduced. Hrst, churches were built on the graves of the martyrs ; next, Kings and Emperors and eminent men began occasionally to be buried in the porches of churches ; and at length, and after a 'ong interval, people were allowed to be interred close to the church or under its walls, but not within the church ; then, leave was given to bury Kings, Bishops, and founders of churches, within the church; and in the ninth century the whole matter was left to the discretion of the Bishops. Still, public opinion, as well as the law, were against burying in churches or cities ; and, being considered injurious to health, it made slow progress. But in the thirteenth century, when it came to be believed that it was of great benefit to the soul to be buried in or near the church, the dying became eager to gain this privilege, and at length it was generally conceded. 3. A return to ancient usage is reviving ; and in most of the large towns in Europe the people are at present pro- hibited from burying within the walls, and compelled to have cemeteries in the fields or adjacent country without the cities. 4. But, although burying-places were compelled in an- cient times to be without the cities, they were protected from robbery, violence, and indignity, by severe laws and canons. The old Roman law was particularly severe in punishing injuries and abuses offered to the bodies, monuments, and sepulchres of the dead. They were considered sacred things, ■^^p I \ tion. ThisXev^i, )erors, because 6if to the coVetpus, and the penalty was death or tra««por^ continued under Christian Kings aif^ I'. the temptation which the cemetries offt ^ ,^. ,. and superstitious : the former were e^&er ^c possess theiDT. selves of the splendid ornaments deposite^J v.'itl|^tl»e bodies of' the rich; the latter to obtain relics, whidh weri^t^considereU, by the weak and ignorant, of infinite value. 1*^, 5. In regard to the consecration of burial-grourt^much misconception appears to exist, in the minds of grea*i|pum- bers of well-disposed and intelligent persons. We have |^en that many ages elapsed before burial-grounds were estab^ lished around churches, as they are at present; and, conse^ , quently, the custom of consecrating them is not of ancient date Christian churches were indeed devoted to God, and consecrated for holy purposes, from the beginnings because authorised by Scripture, but not churchyards, which have not Scriptural but only Ecclesiastical warrant; nor are there any instances of the consecration of burial-grounds or church- yards till long after they had been made the depositories ot the d-ad,— and then consecration was gradually adopted, and more especially because it began to be believed that they would derive a more perfect security by setting them apart with a holy service, than they had hitherto possessed from the civil and canon law. 6. Consecration adds the sanction and influence of reli- gion to the penalty of the law, in separating by a visible and holy Service a portion of ground around the church of every parish, for ever, in which to inter the bodies of the congre- eation. This is done by the bishop, so far as in him Hea, and by law he can. He separates the assigned portion ot land by holy prayer and benediction from all common and profane uses whatsoever, and dedicates and consecrates the same for a burial-ground, or place of sepulchre, for the interment of the dead ; and that the same ought so to remain by this lus definite sentence and final decree. 7 Such is the purport of the sentence of consecration, in regard to churchyards ; and it is subject to three important limitations. First: the civil law of the ^a^d, which may forbid, as the authorities of this city have lately forbidden (on account of the health of the inhabitants) any further ^ 6 interments in tlie churchyard ; and the same prohibition has been recently adopted in London, and will soon be in all the principal cities and towns of the Mother Country. 8. Second : so far as in us lies. This limitation accords with the law, so far as that no burials can take place when the civil law prohibits them. But it comes into action, whether the civil law operates or not, so soon as the bishop is convinced that farther interments may injure the living, by creatinjr or promotint^ disease. The third limitation re- gards the rights of the church, which is the principal object in all churcnyards ; and to her requirements and necessities every thing else must give way. Tlie churchyard is merely an appendage to the church; and its consecration is nOt equal in authority to the consecration of the church : hence, when the interests of the church itself are concerned, the churchyard may be dispensed with, or removed to another location. In fact, it is so dispensed with, when it can no longer be used as a place of interment. 9. Although consecration of burial-grounds be in strict accordance with all the better and holier feelings of our nature,— and is taught us by the example of God's servants in all ages, who assigned peculiar places where the bodies of the saints may rest in peace, and be preserved fiom all indignities, while their souls are safely kept in die hands of their Creator, — we must take heed not to carry our good feelings, or the effects of such consecration, to a superstitious or pernicious extent, or detm it equal to the consecration of a church. It is therefore no indignity, much less a desecra- tion, to remove dead bodies with decent care and reverence from'i locality found inconvenient to one more becoming. No one thought it a desecration ov indignity to remove Gen. Brock's body from one of the bastions of Fort George, to place it below the monument on the Queenston Heights, erected to his honour. Nor have I and others been guilty of an act of desecration in removing the bodies of our dead from St. James's churchyard, to the new cemetery. It ecame our duty to do so, the moment it ceased legally to b^j a burial-ground. * 10. In England there are at least ten thousand parishes. Each parish has its church, and many of them have had K: r^m churches more than a thousanu years. During that longf period these churches have, no doubt, been several times re- newed and enlarcred, &s they fell into decay, and the popuht* tion increased ; but did any one ever dream that because the parish church was to be renewed or enlarged, or its site changed to another more eligible part of the church-yard, where it might cover many graves, and require the removal of many bodies, that this was desecrating such bodies? Cer- tainly not: the church is the first thing to be considered. — K Besides, most men d^^sire the church to cover their graves, and when this cannot be done, to remove them with pious reverence to another part of the burial-ground is perfectly consistent with the most solemn consecration. Were it other- wise, no new church could ever be built or enlarged; for parishes have, in general, no other site than the churchy ' To the re- building or enlarging of a parish church, there* . as the most important and necessary parochial object, £ other thing connected with the churchyard must yield, this the site or church plot was originally given. The bu.^ ing of the dead is a secondary object, and must not he allowed to hinder or stand in the way of providing, in a becoming manner, for public worship— nor, I believe, has it ever been made a question in any parish. It would, indeed, be an in- dignity to the dead, as well as the living, to permit graves to obstruct the building or enlargement of churches. Such a thought can never be entertained, even for a moment, by a sincere and well-informed Christian. Hence : 11. When the law prohibits the inhabitants of a parish from burying any longer in tloir churchyard, it is found that the parishioners hasten to remove the bodies of their friends to a fitter place ; and if there be any that are unable to do so, they should be assisted by the parochial authorities, for it is found by experience that when a churchyard ceases to be a place of interment, it is less carefully attended to, — the graves are trampled upon, and becoire flat, — the head- stones are defnced, and the tombs fall into ruin. Now, it will not be contended that those who have with reverent care re- moved their beloved ones from a churchyard where burying is no longer allow«d, to another cemetery more safe and con- venient, have less affection for their dead than some of their neighbours, who leave their dead exposed, as they may be, to < f \ 8 the chance of indignity. On the contrary, their aflfection is shewn in a more rational and becoming manner : all their dead are again brought together, and deposited in ground which promises, from its locality, never again to be disturbed. 12 These general principles and limitations apply to the pre'sent state of the parish of St. Jame.. At the more early meetings of the Vestry, after tl.e destruction of the ca- thedral by fire, it was found that twelve o. fifteen tnousand pounds would be required to build a new church worthy ot the rity, and that about five thousand only were in hand.— Now, it is quite true that the difference, viz., nine or ten thousand pounds, could be raised by the congregation ; but it 19 equally true that, in the present times, it could not be raised without much difficulty, for the parishioners have had already to build two churches, both of which have been des- troyed, at an expense of not less, I believe, than twenty thousand pounds. This naturally induced the \estry to look around for help. Tiiey saw that by leasing some lots the required sum might be raised, and altnough every member of the vestr- wished to retain the land, they came to the con- clusion, thoigh with great reluctance, that there was no other alternative ; and as it was doubtful whether a proper title could be given, they were at the trouble of procuring an Act to settle that point. 13. Since then, a plan for rebuilding the chuich, on another part of the burial-ground, has been adopted by a great majority, the cost of which io estimated at nearly fifteen Thousand pounds : but in the meantime a cry «f dese /ation has been got up, as if it were sacrilege to disturb a single grave for any purpose whatever, however necessary and holy, Ind the parish 18 threatened with a continuance of the great evil it now suffers, in being without any place ofP"Wic wor- ship. Now if this cry were well founded, it would be entitled to grave consideration, and, associated as it may be in some sincere hearts, with tender feelings and affections it deserves kind treatment and full evidence that it is founded m error and misconception. What the Vestry proposes to do has been done through all Christendom in every age, and is at tms moment in daily practice. First, respecting the site of the cortemplated church, which may, it is believed, be placed to [Wj9 9 more advantat^e in the middle of the square, it is only re- quired to do what, sooner or later, must be done in every parisli where a church is tj be built or enlarged, viz., remove a few bodies witii decent reverence to the cemetery, or to anotl.er part of the present church- -^rd. Second, in regard to the land to be leased ; if it be devoted, or, what is the same thinir, its proceeds be devoted to rebuilding the church, which is a bettf"* and holier purpose than thaC of becoming a depository for >\ie dead, it is altogether a mistake that the ground is thereby desecrated and an act oi sacrilege com- mitted. Look at ihe city of London : all the churches had at first burial-grounds around them ; but the city grew, and necessity compelled relaxations, from time to time, or enact- ments for the b nefit of the living, till, in many instances, nothing is left but the bare church, witness, for instance, St. Clement Da»»es in the Strand, and St. Martin's i ' the Fields. Yet no charge of desecration has ever been made, because during the piocess every thing was done with reve- rence and decency, and to constitute sacrilege there must be neglect, irreverence or intentional indignity. The cathedral of St. Paul covers the whole of the ancient burying-ground and nobody complains, for, though it be a natural feeling to respect the dead, the rights of the living must neither be neglected nor sacrificed. 14. The subject, therefore, of re-building the church, as contemplated by the vestry of St. James's Church, in what- ever light it be correctly viewed, involves no case of desecra- tion or of sacrilege. If built upon the middle of the square the bodies can be piously removed, as daily happens iu other places. All desire the ground to be preserved, if there be a possibility of building the church otherwise. But if ic be found impossible, from inability or disinclination, the ground' may be leased without any apprehension of desecration, for, to speak of desecration when the land is thus devoted to the glory ot God, is totally to misunderstand the meaning of the word. 15. Once more: some persons think that there is no occasion to be at any great expence in erecting a church, — For they argue, that God may be as sincerely worshipped in a building of clay or of timber, as in the most gorgeous a 10 cathedral. Now this may not only be true, but proper, when the people are poor and unable to build any thin^ better, but it involves a great error when sought to be applied to a community like this. The uniform practice of Christians through the whole period of Ecclesiastical history, has not only been to build according to their ability, but not unfre- quently according to their faith. And that this is their duty is manifest from Scriptural example and the annals of the Church. Solomon's Temple was built exceedingly rich and magnif cent, at the immediate command of God, and Chris- tians iidving this all-prevailing authority before them, have frequently in their churches and cathedrals surpassed the Temple itself as far in size, beauty, and costliness, as their (endowments of divine gifts and privileges in spirit and in truth, go beyond those of the Jewish people. Often have they built God's holy sanctuary like high places, not merely from their own resources, but from faith in their children. Hence many of the most renowned churches were more than one hundred years in building, and exhauswd the means of several genera- tions. The first promoters had little regard to cost, they gave freely what God had given them, ar 1 expected their successors to do the same, till the building was completed. If this be seldom done in the present age, it is because our faith has waxed feeble. 16. In regard to the restoration of the Church of St. James, it will not do to make it of less dimensions, because in that case it would not accommodate and reunite the congre- gation, — nor ought it to be so plain and destitute of architec- tural beauty as the one we have lost. If our means are at present insufficient for its completion, why not build a portion of the magnificent plan that has been adopted, and in a few years do something more, and trust in faith as our Fathers did, that our children will finish, what we have begun ? 17. The writer of these remarks is enti: 'cd to a hearing, and therefore to recommend them to the serious perusal of every one of the parishioners of the parish of St. James. He was against devoting the ground along King-street, to rebuild the church or cathedral, and offered to be one of thirty or forty to erect it, but was not supported. He was then com- pelled to yield to the conviction, that in the present circum- 11 stances and state of mind of the pr.rishioners, the rebuilding of the church cannot be accomplished without the assistance to be derived from ^ the proceeds of the ground. Had he supposed that to put it to this sacred use was a desecration he would not have consented; but it is no desecration of this or of any ground to be devoted to the building up of the House of God. Contrast the magnificent buildings which now replace those along King-street destroyed by the fire, with the ruins of the cathedral, and ask with the Prophet, "Is it time for "you to dwell in your ceiled houses, and this house lie waste ? " Were every member of the congregation to reflect seriously on this, the means of rebuilding would not be long wanting. 18. In fine: let the Vestry consider the whole matter calmly and (l.spassionately, and if the Church can be built and the ground preserved— let it be so. But if this cannot be done, devoce the rents of the ground to the sacred purpose of rebuilding the House of God, that we may again worship therein ; for, in doing so, there is no desecration. I remain, my dear Brethren, Your affectionate Diocesan, John Toronto. ,- *,