IMAGE EVALUATION TEST TARGET (MT-3) '^ A 1.0 I.I 1.25 In •- IM ||||| 2j_ !.4 1.6 6" ■- ^ ^. V] <^^ # c?^ %^ v// / Photographic Sciences Corporation 23 WEST MAIN STREET WE3STER,N.Y. 14S80 (716) 872-4503 # 9rs/ Couverture de couleur I — I Covers damaged/ Couver'iure endommag^e □ Covers restored and/or laminated/ Couverture restaurie et/ou pelHculAe □ Cover title missing/ Le titre de couverture manque I — I Coloured maps/ d Cartes giographiques en couleur Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ Encre de couleur (i.e. autre que bleue ou noire) Coloured plates and/or illustrations/ I ^1 Planches et/ou illustiations en couleur Sound with other material/ ReJif £ivec d'autres documents Tight binding may causa shadows or distortion alcng interior margin/ La re liure serree peut cuasttr de I'ombro ou de la distorsion le long de la marge intirieure Blank leaves added during restoration may appear within the text. Whenever possible, these have b6en omitted from filming/ II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajouties lors d'une restauration apparaissent dans le texte, mais, lorsque cela Atait possible, ces pages n'ont pas iti ^ilm^es. L'Institut a microfilm^ le meilleur exemplaire qu'il lui a 6ti possible de se procurer. Les details de cet exemplaire qui sont peut-dtre uniques du point de vue bibliographique, qui peuvert modifier une image reproduite, ou qui peuvent exiger une modification dans la m^thode normale de fHmage sont indiquAs cidessous. □ Cctoured pages/ Pages de couleur □ Pages damaged/ Pages endommagies D D Pages restored and/or laminated/ Pages restaur^es et/ou pelliculies Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ 'v ! Pages dicolor^es, tacheties ou piquees Pages detached/ Pages ditachees Showthrough/ Transparence Quality of prir Quality inigale de I'impression Includes suppltimentary materii Comprend du materiel supplementaire r~n Pages detached/ FT] Showthrough/ [ I Quality of print varies/ n~| Includes suppltimentary material/ Only edition available/ Seule Edition disponible Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata slips, tissues, etc.. have been refilmed to ensure the best possible image/ Les pages totaiament ou partiellement obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata. une pelure, etc.. cnt iti filmies i nouveau de facon i obtanir la meiMeure image possible. T tc T P o fi O bi t^ si ot fii si oi T» sh Tl w M di er be rl« rei m( Additional comments:/ Commentaires supplAmentaires; Pagination ii at follows : [103] - [127] p. This item is filmed at the reduction ratio checked balow/ Ce document est film( meaning "CON- TINUED"), or the symbol V (meaning "END"), whichever applies. Maps, plates, charts, etc., may be filmed at different reduction ratios. Those too large to be entirely included in one exposure are filmed beginning in tlie upper left hand corner, left to right and top to bottom, as many frames as required. The following diagrams illustrate the method: L'exemplaire film6 fut reproduit grAce A la g«n6roslt6 de: La bibliothdque des Archives publiques du Canada Les images suivantes ont iti reproduites avec le plus grand soin, compte tenu de la condition et de la nattet* de l'exemplaire fiSm«, et en conformity avec les conditions du contrat de filmage. Les exemplalres originaux dont la couverture en papier est imprlmte sont filmte en commenpant par le premier plat et en terminant soit par la derniire page qui comporte une empreinte d'impression ou d'illustratlon, soit par le second plat, selon le cas. Tous les autres exemplalres originaux sont film6s en comment ant par la premiere page qui comporte une empreinte d'impression ou d'illustration et en terminant par la dernlAre page qui comporte une telle empreinte. Un des symboles suivants apparaftra sur la dernlAre image de cheque microfiche, selon le cas: le uymbole — ► signifie "A SUIVRE", le symbols y signifie "FIN". Les cartes, planches, tableaux, etc., peuvent Atre filmAs d des taux de rMuction difftrents. Lorsque le document est trop grand pour Atre reproduit en un seul clich«, 11 est filmA A partir de i'angle supArieur gauche, de gauche A droite, et de haut en bas, en prenant le nombre d'images nicessalra. Les diagrammes suivants illustrent la mAthode. 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 6 \Ui/t^. l/t^u wmm No iililiPffPiipnpipp' ^w w~ ^^^T^m J ON THE COLONIES: A PAPER READ BEFORE THE STATISTICAL SOCIETY, Uth MABOH, 1872. BY ARCHIBALD HAMILTON, ESQ. •J- -*-• ^4^« U.4,^£ek,iZcL iUniiil (!iivl<»itt:il LONDON ! HARRISON AND SONS, ST. MARTIN'S LANE. |)rin<«r« lit (L^rbiwara to il«r Pajwtjj. 1872. #• I • ■♦^>!/ •• ( ■ • \ -■•- ' ,iv. -■ - -.'j / • • •'';;.-■■'„; A ■■■ ■ cV^A ;• ■'::'" S' \ - 1 ■' ^ ■ •> » - -" ' ■"^'' ■ , V *4 ■■ ■.- [ '. .-■- ;'*.{»^-', ■-^ « * J « •* ON THE COLONIES: A PAPER READ BEFORE THE STATISTICAL SOCIETY, lOth MABCH, 1872. BY ARCHIBALD IIAMIITOX, ESQ. LONDON : HATIRTSON AND SONS, ST. MAETIN'S LANTi. |)nntcrs iit Orbiuiinj to ¥)fr rtlnjestt). 1872. I II I\ A V VI Ol sel ha wl: ge we th( am int ser CO] thf gO( fro i-at the has Mi to chi Co rence to colonial matters, it so happens that the permanent staff of the Colonial Office is, for all practicid jmrjKJses, almost fi-ee froni any check or control. Tlie waste lands have been handed over, unfortunately with- out any reservation ; full control over their own aftaii's has very properly been conceded to the North American and Australian 108 HAMir;T(jN — Oil the Co follies. [Mar, colonies, but with no tlioiiglit as to how tlie inipevial connection is to continue ; and at the present time the Cape colonists ai-e in vain solicited to accept responsible government. At the same time the chief object of the Colonial OfHce, without regard to varying- circumstances in each case, has bet>n to witht^raw British troops from the colonics, and, at all hazards, reduce their cost to the British Exchequer; so that our relations with the colonies have at leuf^h become so attenuated, that a very slight strain with any one of them will suffice to break the tie ; and it is oidy too probable that the separation of one, would be the signal for others to assume independence, or, it may be, to seek some other protection. Before resigning ourselves to this, it sui'ely Mould be well that such a vital question should be examincLl to the bottom, and be thoroughly discussed in all its manifold bearings, so that we should deliberately satisfy ourselves whether it is in reality a matter of such little consequenct>, that our connection Avith the colonies should be maintained ; or whether it woidil not be Aviser rather to seek for some means whereby we could draw them closer to us than ever. II. — Ej'ports (aid for by exports from this country. Is'ow, on all such indirect operations, the amounts of our exports in payment, if they could be traced out Avith any degree of accuracy, should be ]ilaced to the credit of the colonies, rather than to the countries supplying the rcmgh gootls. ■khiy. The exj)orting merchant's ])rotit or conuuissiou is a benefit acci'uiiiL;- to this countrv which must ntjt be omitted. Taking these iii'iiis together, it will be admitted by every (me convei'sant with the siU)ject, that they far (Uitweigh the cost of raw materials In our home manufactures sent to the colonies; and that 1 am, tiu-refore, well within, the mark in claiming credit for the colonies to the full extent of our honu; produce exported to them; and thiit the anu)unt shoidd be taken as so much added to the earuiugs ov aggregate income of the United Kingdom, M 110 Hamilton — On the Colonics. [Mar. I liave stilted that tlie total to our clopendcncifs for 1871 amounted to 51,000,000/., but sliall eonhne lujselt' to our colonies proper, viz., North Auiericaii, Australian, and South African, togetlier Avitli our tropical settlements in the West Indies, Mauri- tius, Ceylon, and the Straits; and with these 1 have contrasted our ti-ade with the princi])al tbreigu countries. 1 leave out of consider- atitni our Indian Possessions, since these cannot be regarded as colonies, and because I take for granted that our supremacy in that country Avill be upheld by the strong hand so long as v/e retain the jower ; neither for the present shall I concern myself with our laval and military stations, such as ^lalta, Gibraltar, Bermuda, 'long K(mg, &c., which are maintained for inijierial purposes. In Appendix, Table A, Avil! be found the exports of British produce for thirty years from 1840 to iKt)',) inclusive, reduced for the sake of convenience to cpiinqueimial averages. 1 commence Avith 1810, so as to include a period of live years prior to our final adoption of free trade, when reciprocity in discriminating duties between the home country and the colonics Avas abolished. An examination of the table will show that, taking averages of ten years, our exports of home produce have increased in the following ratio : — Nortli Anicrii-aii Colonics .... Aufiti'iilin and >ii'\v Zealand Ci\\)o and Xatal Wt'»t. Inches Jhiiiritius Ceylon Straits and Singapore United States Franee Spain and I'ortiigid ... Gernmnv and Austria Italv ." Eiissia IFollund IJelirium .Brazil China with lloiig Kong. ih-jO to '[mo, Inciciist' per (,'tiit. ii|K)ii ItiKl to IhW. 49 509 '44 1 1 deer. 54 90 48 147 67 61 56 37 7 deer. 4- 25 52 18G() to lH(i9, Iiici-t^iisc per Cent. U|)Oii Ih.'iO to IhaU. 63 39 45 41 22 111 97 3 deer. 131 Gl 65 77 105 r>7 77 49 167 In A))ptndix. Table !i, 1 have taken out the consumption of Bi-itish ])roiluce by the several colonies and foreign countries above uiuned. For the populiition 1 lake the years of census, but for the exports 1 have averaged three years, viz., the year of census with the preceding and succeeding years, so as to obtain a fair result, 1872.] Hamilton — On the Colonial. Ill free from special ciroumstancos which might attach to single years ; and in Di-der still further to elucidate the matter I have, in Table C, ascertained the pro])ortion which British produce bears to the total inip(U'fs of the same ])laccs ; for this purpose I have taken an average of the three vcars, ISGt-GO, being the latest uniform period for which I can obtain a comparison. Tlie results of Tables B and arc shortly stated below. It will be observed that the figures are gix^atly in favour of the colonies proper, as might be expected with infant communities, occupied chiefly in the production of raw produce. This applies to the United States, for the samo reason, though in a lesser degree ; while the tropical settlements rank next to the cohniies pi'oper. Consumption of British Produce per Ile:iil. Proportion of Britisli Produce to Tutiil IiiiiMirts. North American Colonic!) Australia mil New Zealand ,-, , 1 XT i 1 /total population (Jape and JNatal< , .^ ' ^ ^ L wlute „ West Indies Mauritius Ceylon \ Straits United States Franco Spain Portugal Gei'many (Prussia, Hamburg, and Austria) Itiily .' RuLssia Holland* Eelgiunif Brazil £ .V. d. 1 S 8 8 lo 3 2 ^) 4 8 12 2 2 8 7 I 14 7 Small European populiition 12 6 2 10 6 4 16 1 1 1 1 10 I 4 1 1 I T 10 Per cut. 42 47 69 43 .30 3G 21 31 9 18 Not ascertainable 17 17 10 8 Not aseertainablft * A proportion of this no doubt belongs to Oermany, being for goods in transit, and the British produce is not distinguishable. t Belgium proliably shows in excess for the same reason. But it is alleged that onr trade Avith the colonies would not be iffected, were they at once to be declared independent States ; and Mr. Goldwin Smith has argued tliat it would rather be increased thereby. He appeals to the example of the United States in support of this opinion, but overlooks the totally different circum- stances tinder which our trade with the colonies is now carried on, as ompared with the jealous monopoly which existed wdien the United States became independent. I need scarcely recall Lord Chatham's well-known declaration, that " the colonists had no right 11-2 Hamii.tox — Oil iho Cnhr.iie.*. [Mnr. •' to nianufactTiro even ii iiiiil for a lioi'sc-slioe." They were honnd to buy f'voin the niotlicr connfry wliatcvcr tlicy ooiisnniiHl, and to sell to Ikt wliaiovor tlicy prodiicMl. It was not in conscquenco of tli(>ii' separation that our trade wiili llie United Stales subsequently incrensed ; but it was l)eeanse, toii'etlier willi independence, tliey estabbslii'il {'vow '•oninier;'i,tl rebiliiuis w itii oIIht countries as well as witli ourselves. iTow, as our colonies already enjoy tlie advanta^'es of tree trade to tlie fullest extent, except so far as it may be siinted by taritfs of tlieir own Imposition, and as they also enjoy the :nost absolute control of tlieir (>\vn alfairs, it is manifest that ther(> are no ;4T(ninds for expectinn- a rapitl inci'ease in theii- tr.'ide, such as followed on the indep(nidence of the I'nited Stat(\s. On the contrary, thonub the colonial trade min'lit not at iirst be materially alfected, provid"d always that separation took ])Iace in a friendly spirit, thei'e is too much reason to fear that the i-itio of increase would not be sus- tained, and might altoc'cthei' disa])]iear, The maxim that "the trade loilows the flag" is supported by the examples of our con([Kei'ed coloriies, viz. : — In Canada there are about one million, or nearly one-third of the ])opnlation, of Fi'ench (h'sceni, living much apart in Lower Canada, and retaining 1 heir language and ciistouis to a remarkable extent; and although dui-ing the last thirty vears then' have been no discri- minating coloinal ilnties between British atid French produce, the ini|)ortatii.'ns for the year 1^(,>(> were respectively as follows : — £ British prodiico 5,000, coo lO'i'llc'll ,, i^COOv Similai'ly. as regards the Ca])e of Cood llopt>, where tlu> l"]uro])eau poptdation numhered about tSo.ooo, of whom t svo-th.iv(ls are of Dutch extra'-tion. s]>eakiiig their own language and adhering totheir own manners anil customs with exti'aordinai v lenacitv — takinn- an average of the years 1S() |.-( '>('>. the importations slimd thus — lirili-h )iru(Jucc |ii'i' annum i,7Cio.occ DiUcli ]nx)ihicc direct tll.ODO Throun'li I'liitt'd Kiniidoiu in lionil 20,000 ■ 1^1,000 Again, if we examine (he reftirns fi'oni ^raiiriiius, where the Creole ]iopidation is still csseidially l''rencli. 1 1," tigui'cs stand as follows, tai^iiiL;' an avera^'e of the vears ISlil-lid: — - liri(i>-h ])i'(i(hic(' \H'\' ainunu 'ii^,oco l''i'<'nfli ,, ^i,i,coo It is b) be observed, howev(>r, tliid of (he lader no li'ss tliaii ilCi.oool. consist el of wines ami brandy, (he win" biu'iig a S])ei.ial I ■V i t * 1872.] Hamilton' — Ou ihe Coloniest. 113 K i •? it production of Fi-ance, and peculiurly suited to the climate and taste cf the ]>eoplo. Convorsoly, no one can douht, had we retained possession of Java, that onv ti-ado with tlmt island would now be ten times what it is. Let us next i.onsider in Avhat maimor our trade with the colonies is influenced by their connection with the home country. It is a matt(M' of e\('ry day experience that yotin<]^ nu'n of tlie middle or commercial clnss prefer the colonies, \vh-]i looking around for a tield. in which to push their way in the world. Tn the coltmies they settle among friends and relations, wheiv Kuo-lish law and Kng'li.sh ideas and customs prevail ; nnd it is by this class more especially that our commerce is extended. They rendily enier into business corre- spond(Mice Avith their friends at home, and become the channel through which llritish ciipitnl is more freely end)!U'k(Hl in the colonies than in foreign countries. Agiiin, colonists more frequently intermarry with ])(>ople at home than Avith foi'eigners. I have been assured on competent iiiithority that marriages between Canadians and their American neigh bonrs, arc not much moi-e fre(|uent than marriages between ourselves and French or Germans. MoreoA'er, most of us have relatives settled in the various colonies; no that, in addition to siniilnrity of tastes and general sympalhy Avith the oldeounlry, there are innumerable ])ei'sonid and family ties Avhich secure to us a comiu.'ind of the colniiiid trade, such as is not elsewhere obtained. In fact, it is an aggregate of wlint, in individual cases, is called trade connection, oi- "good-will.'' I thiids, thei-eforc, it is rensonnble to conclude, that were our con- nection with the CI denies severed, though otir trade might not bo immediately diminished, still the steady increase it has shoAvn for so many yciirs Avould be lessened, or might even become sti.tionary —as. liming always I hut the separation took place amicably, and that the colonies became iiidojtendent States. ]iut let us suppose Ave part Avith feelings of discontent, as is only too probable Avith more than oni^ colony, and that they either seek protection from scmie other State, or enter int(» reeipi'ociil treat ies to cur ])rejndice : the result would of cinirse 1k' vciy ditl'ereiit. The truth is, we ciiinot afford to run the risk of our trade being diminished. Considering that our population is increasijig at the rate of i,ooo jier day, surely it is only ivasonable (hat Ave .should striAH! to increase, rather than run the risk of curtailing (mr means of subsistence. Tlu' evils of ])au|ierisni and the pri'ssure of pooi-'s rates arc alrea(l\ sutlicient ly appalling. In the coinviiencenicnt of 1871 tlu're \\vvv in the United Kingdom no less than 1,280,000 j)au|)(M's of all sorts, receiving relief at a cost of 8.300,000/. iVnd ail exaiiiinatioi, of the returns of ^'poor's rates and jiatiperism" Avill show that, during 1S71, tli(>re has been a steady decreaso, vol,. XXW. I'AKT I,. I ^z 114 Hamit.tox — On flie Colonies. [Mar. especially duvi no- the latter lialf of the year ; pi'oving mmiistakably the influence of the returning pi'osperity of onr export trade ; just as the contrary effect is to be traced in the dei)res.sion which followed on the commercial ci'isis of IHOfj. I repeat, there foi'e, that we cannot afford to tamper with our relations with the colonies, whicli, relatively to their population, are cci'taiuly our best customers. in — SJii]>iin>i'i. In Appendix, Table D. will 1)e found a statement of the tonijage employed in the trade of the several colo:iies and foreign states, together with the proportion thereof which consists of British tonnag(!. I have taken an average of three years where possible, and it will be seen that the colonial percentages greatly exceed the others. I leave the subjoined iigures to speak IVir themselves, viz. : — North American Colonies, of total tonnage 80 per cent, is British; Ansti'alia 93, Ciipe and Natal 85, West Indies 60, Mauri- tius 74, Ceylon 87, and Straits 58 percent. ; whereas of the foreign States, the percentage of the United States is 47, France 36, Hause Towns 36, Italy 23, Russia 34, Holland 49, and Belgiuiu 55. I would only further rcmai'k that, were the colonies independent, rhese figures might be altered seriously to our ju'ejudice by the adoption of navigation laws. IV. — Ciiloiiifii.'^ ii-]jt) T?i'lnrn. Apart from the direct and immediate benefit derived from our colonial trade, we must also consider the effect upon ourselves as well as upon the colonies, of the Avealthy colonists who return to end their days at home, and spend their fortunes in the old country. This cannot be reduced to an estimate, but, whatever benefit may result to us from this source, it is manifestly due to our connexion with tlu^ colonies. I had imagined that, on the whole, this was rather a pi'aise- wortliy, or, at all events, a harmless class of citizens. But Mr. Thorold Rogei's, in an essay recently |)ublisheil by the Cobden Club, seems iit a loss for terms sulliciently scornful in alluding to them. \i' it he true that "luiviiig become great capitalists "they are eager to blot oul the nitniory of the cradle in which *' their fortiuies were nursed," and " hurry back to their old home, " in oi-dei- that i hey may achieve social rank," surely the same thing may be said of Manchester, the cra505 1,3C1,771 08S.I-23 .. other colonies aud nl.ices 1()0,771 To tho United States ^ic,865 196,075 2.5IO,!in5 t.l.72,ti72 Grand totals i 5 6, 940 7,013,(]37 It niay be admitted, therefore, if we arc content to leave emigration to run its course, unaided and undirected, that it would not be much affected by the independence of the colonies ; always excepting tlu^ 'uiddlo or commercial classes, who, as already remarked, go chiefly to colonies. Th(; bulk of the Irish emigrants go to the Unifed States, where they not only adil to the strength of our rivals, but bear with them a feeling of animosity against us so bittei', that the necessity of securing the Irish vote is the main source of all our trotibles with our kinsmen in America. Nov, it. is a strange fact that the Irish who settle in the eoloiiii's become comparatively loyal subjects; and it should, therefore, be tlu^ object of the Colonial Office, if possible, to divert some jiortion of the Irish emigratio to the colonies, instead of lookirg on helplessly while it flows to the United States. Nay, more, would if not be well to devise such a systematic emi- gration, as would diminish the poor rates aud relievo the struggle 1 '> 1 u 5 'I 116 Hamilton — On the Cnlmici^. [Mar. for existence at Inme, by reraovinc^ labour from where it is too often supt-i-abundant and wages low ;* to tlic colonies, where employment is abundant, wages are high, and food clieap ? Wo should thus by one and the same operation lesson the competition for employment at home, and create moi-e woi'k for those who remain behind ; as the emigrant to the colonics at once becomes a large consumer of home produce. Unfortunately, the Colonial OfUce has pnrfed with all control over ilie waste lands, without considering tliat the people of this country liad an interest therein, ami that for their benefit, jointly with that of the colonists, the waste lands should have been held in trust. Negociations mic'ht nevertheless be entered into with the colonies for a systematic emigration, and our share of the expense would assuredly be well laid out. Befoi'c quitting the subject of einigratlon 1 would refer to a diagram in Tal)lo F, Avhich I bor''ow from ^Iv. Eddy, representing on a chess board the proportionate area of Great Britain and her dependencies, ihus: — Orcat Britain and Tivlaml oofiipy i square. Tlie colonics 41. „ India and other dejicndeneies S ,, VI. — Aih-iiiif(Vfi\tnrn are by far thelai-gest i)ur('hascrs of their ])r()(luce. j'litli sides ]n'ofit by these operations: peo])le in the colonies as well as at home !ir(> employed, and earn wages and profits thereby. The colonists possess all the privileges of British subjects, being citizens of no nu'an city, which surely is an advantage as comparecl with tlie citizensliip of small separate states. J5ut there are also what sonu' may consider nior(> tangible advantag(>s, viz., that tlio coloin"es enj.>y betti-i' cr(>dit in eonse(|iienee (if llu> ('(.nnection, and are able to borrow money on belter terms fov their jtnblic improvements. Further, as has beiMi ali'(vealth, commercial cntcr})rise, and a first-rate poAver. How difterent if we suppose them dependencies of Russia, Spain, Italy, or even France. VII. — Cod of the Colonies. Ever since the Parliamentary Committee of 18(31, it has been the policy of our Government to throw the colonies on their own resources lor military defence; but without discrimination as to their varying circumstances and antecedents. In Appendix, Table E, will be found a summary of the cost of the colonies to the imperial exchequer from the year 1853 to 1808, which I have continued by a liberal estimate to the year 1871 inclusive, bi'ing ninelecni years in all, I may remark, however, that the parliamentary returns on which Table E is based a]ipear to be open to question. For in.stance, the sum of 2.990,509/. is chiirged during the nineteen years for gaols, police, and military in Western Australia and Tasmania; but this expense was chieHy, if not altogether, incurred because those colonies were penal settlements, and it must therefore be ascribed to an imperial, and not to a co'ouial ])urpo,se. There is also hicluded in the naval charges I'or the earlier years, the cost of transport of convicts, which is equally A'oid of justification. I have been unable to test the other items ; but thetruih is, the returns in question were drawn up, not with v view to recover the money from the colonies, but nu'n-ly fo show the expense this country incurs by reason of, or ou account oi' tlie colonics. The returns have nevei-, therefore, been properly coi'irctcd ; but to them, in a great measure, is due the general impression that the colonics are very costly possessions. Neverthe- less. 1 acci'pt the I'cturns as renderi-d. And how stand the facts? Tht> exports u\' lirii isli jirnduce, during tiie nineteen years in ques- tion, con irast wit li the siippo.scd cost of the colon ii>s. as follows, viz.: — Tiiliil Oust, iMuli to InTI. I'.x polls lit' lii-itisli I'i'iiiUicc, Ih.iS to IhTl. Noi'tli AnuM'ii'im coKmii^s iVuslfaliii and N('W Ztuilinul £ 13,107,000 10,^158,000 7 /> 7 9,000 i, 13^,000 1,374,000 if- 1,000 107,S2S,000 21 1-,(>S!),0(K) ;u.7r)(!,(i()0 .Ii»,i>:;2.0(i0 1^1 tiuril 1 lis tt.lOl.O'Mt ( \'\loU ...■ 12,7( »;<,()( M) SiiigaiiDi'i' uiul Slruits 2r),i(»8,()0U 4;,,8 10,000 JuO,7U8.(K)0 w 118 Hamilton — On the Culvitics. [Mar. Now, I must repeat once raoi-e, tliat tlie amount of the exports of lionie produce constituted in reality so nnieli of our ap'ii'regate income; nnd it lias been variously estimated tliat in tin's country we are taxed from lo per cent, to as hiuii as 20 ]ier cent, on our incomes. I take the lowest estimate, and it follows that the Treasury has, during the nineteen years in question, obtained a revenue of 45.000,000/. in consequence of the colonial trade, while the expendi- ture has not exceeded 43,800,000/. I cannot but regret the present habit of regarding the cost of the colonies exclusively from the Trea.sury point of view, as though her ]\rajesty's Go\ ernment were dri^-ing a ti-aJe in colonies, and as if the result should be judged by the protit and loss shown on the Treasury balance-sheet. Even tried l)y this test, it will be seen that the colonies have not been burdensome to the imperial exchequer, while they have added four hundred and fifty millions to the earuino-g of the people of this country. It would be useless to re-open the discussions as to Caffre and Maori wars : riglitly or wrongly, the Colonial Office has determined to withdraw our troops from the Cape and Xew Zenland. and has also, it is to be presumed, relinquished all idea of interfering with the colonists in their relations with, the natives. Had that course alwavs been followed, we should have been saved a great deal of trouble and some money ; the colonists Avould have been spared a great deal of irritation; it is doubtful whether the Maoris would not at this day have been in much the same condition : but the Caifres have ttn- doiibtedly beiielitted by our benevolent interference in their behalf. It is more to tlie purpose to eonsidei' how the Treasury is atlected, now that our troops have been almost wholly withdrawn I'rom the principal colonies. The figures for the vear l^n are these: — Cusr for l"-?!. K\]i(irts of omt' I'lijiliicc, l^Tl. Kortli Ame/'ican colonies | Australia and >i"i"\v Zealand | Capo and >'atal j AVest Indies , ^Mauritius I t'eylon | IStraits ' £• m.^zo .-..;.>. OCO I'''^,3co 35r. 9C0 7 ^.fco ;.;,4co 3^^^cc• t i: 8 29('.,O0O (i 03 1,000 *> ]!lS.(iOO ') ;»io,ooo ■jo;i,o(io '.'2S.O0U 1 [t3d.U0() I. i 14. L'o..s;ji.ooo 80 that for the year 1^71 the Treasury has derive.l at lea.st 2.5N0.000/. from the eolonial ti'ade. and t'xpeiidi'd l.ioo.coo/. \nx\ it may bi' uri^vd. in reply, that our liade with foreign States does not entail so much cost as is here shown. What 1 contend for "I'^"--] HxisnLiO};~0,i the Colonies. 119 is that tlic colonics arc no actual bm-clon to the Ti-easury, as is very generally assumed ;* and, as a set-off for the cost, we enjoy a decided l)reference in the colonial trade, because of tlieir dependency. But neither is foreign trade carried on free of expense to the Treasury : the cost of the diplomatic and consular services may be ascribed to it, as well as the charge for cruisers to protect our lia<''. Again, let us take the Australian colonies as a group, including New Zealand Avith its Maori wars, of which we have heard so much, and not excluding the two penal settlements above mentioned, and we find the following results : — £ ]\meteen years exports of liomo produce 214,680,000 „ cost to exchequer io/jcs'.cco „ revenue on the exports 21,468,000 Since 1840, it will be seen, from Table A, that om- exports of home produce to the Australian colonies have reached the satis- factory total of 238,376,000/. ; all, be it remembered, so much added to the earnings of the people of this country. Surely, then, in the fiice of such I'csults, instead of discussing the " colonial question," we should rather be taking thought that the great Australian continent is not as yet even frinstic nuuiafacturos, ecjuivalout to their customs duties OP. imports, forgetting that it is only a i'vw years since that principle was adopted in this country ; besides whicli the circum- stances are totally ditl'erent, since we levy customs duties on one or two articles only, which could be produced in this country, even in the form of substitutes, as beer for wine, &c., whei'cas the colonial duties are levied upon the entire variety of imjiorted articles, ren- dering excise duties out of the cpiestion. Neither is direct taxation applicable to sparsely ])eopled countries like the colonies, such taxes would not in many districts repay the cost of collection ; and surely they do Avell to avoid the income tax, with all its inherent injustice. Considering that the colonies import so large a proportion of what they constime, it is obvious that the necessary revenue can be most easily and fairly raised throiigh the customs. The objection as yet applies chiefly to Canada, and in a lesser degree to Australia, as these are the only colonies which have reached the stage where manufactures might commence, even if unprotected. In ^^'auada the duties are 15 per cent., and in Australia they are chiefly 5 per vvni.. rising in .some cases to 7 and 10 per cent, (n] vahn' m. I a})[)i'ehend the ])roper view to take of colonial tariii's is this: that so long as the colonies continue members of the empire, tlu^y are identified with the policy of fret; trade, so far at least as to avoid discriminating duties ; but, if independent, no one can foresee what reciprocity treaties and restrictive turilfs they might adopt. IX. — Li case of War. There is still one other a.spect in which oiu* colonies and possessions should be carefully regarded, but on which I must touch very briefly, viz., their value in case of war. We take a just pride in the steady increase* of our population. Notwithstanding that we have sent forth 7,000.000 of emigrants since 1H1.\ our numbers have increased frt);u 19,208,000 in 181-i> to 31,048,397 in bsn. Hut we must not ovei'iook one! result of this gratifying increase of strength, viz., that we can no loiigm" I'aise sulHcient food at home for our (hxily wants. Taking an avei'age of three years, ending ISTi), I find that we now re(|uire foi'cign sup[)!ies of the i)rini(! necessaries of life, as cattle, sheep, meat, Ijiittcr. cheese, corn, I'ice, <'ggs, fish, and potatoes, to the valiu' of 58.500,000/. per annum ; while to these may be added ai'ticles of .secondary iKU-essity, as sugar, tea, and cofiee, to the value of 30,100,000/. pi'i' annum. These articles of daily consumption are procured in exchange for our exports, and it is obvious that when war comes it is now simply 1872.] Hamilton — On the Colonies. 121 a matter of life and death to maintain our supremacy at sea. If our foreign and colonial commerce, with all its wide ramifications and numerous channels, cannot be efficiently protected at sea, what will be the result ? Our supplies of food will fall off, and our export trade will be reduced, so that tlie necessaries of life will become scarce and dear at the very time when the means of earning a living will be lessened; we shall, in fact, be reduced to the condition of a besieged city. Happily for us, the carrying trade is undergoing a great change by the substitution of steamers for sailing ships, partly owing to the Suez Canal, but more es])ecially to recent improvemt. .s and the greater economy of fuel ; this change is going on with astonishiu"- rapidity; the proportion of tonnage built in 1871, and on the stocks being built on 81st December last, was 611,700 tons, steamers, to 107,000 tons, sailing vessels ; so that in a few years the great bulk of our trade will be carried in steamers, which, in case of war, Avould diminish the risk of capture; while vvith our great wealth and unequalled facilities, our fleet of steam, men-of-war ought to give us more than ever the undisputed command of the sea. But supplies of coal for our mercantile and Royal Navy have become a matter of absolute necessity, as well as poi-ts in which iron vessels can be docked ; without which their etficiency would be much impaired ; for this purpose, and as fortified depots of coal, our naval and military stations have now become of vital importance. Instead of scrutinising in a niggardly spirit the cost of maintaining such places as Gibraltar, Malta, and Aden, Bermuda, Hong Koungthened ; but I may be excused for remarking that it can only be on a footing of perfect equality; and that the pi'csent time, when by means of the telegraph we shall shortly be brought, as it were, into contact with our fellow-country- men at the antipodes, is surely not the occasion on which to look upon separation as inevitable. Let us imagine, for a moment, how two centuries hence our dealings Avith this momentous question will be regarded. Will it be recorded how a great opportunity was lost r — how our public men were engrossed by party strife, and our Parliament absorbeil in local bills and temporary concerns — until a crisis coming upon us, unex- pected and unprepaivd, our empire suddenly broke up and drifted away in fragments ? Or, shall the record be that our statesmen, vra it was too late, aroused them to the task r* — how they were seconded by an awakened Parliament, and encouraged by the people at home as well as by the patriotism of the colonists ; and how, fechug the advantage of mutual support, the ties that bound them to the old country were drawn closer, as the colonies waxed stronger — until the whole became welded into one homogeneous enqtire, such as the world had not yet seen ? An empire inhabited by a people scrupulous in respecting the rights of others, yet resolute to n>aintain th(>ir own ; with no ambition to encroach on the territory of their neighbours, but whose glory it was to subJue the wilderness: and who, by their achieve- ments in scien.ce, their devotion t(j peace, and 'heir love of liberty, of justice, and of truth, marked an epoch in the history of mankind. rnitcd 1 I'ranciv. Spuiii ill <^T('1'111J111 Italy .. Kiissia.. Hi'li;iiiii; lirazil .. t'liiiiii ill 1872.] Hamilton — On the Colonies. 12? APPENDIX. Table A. — Quinquennial Avemf/es of Kv/)ort.'i of British Produce to the undermentioned British J'ossL'SHions and Forei(jn CountricK. rdnOS oiuiiled.l I.M(i-M. 1815-4!}. 1850-51. 1855-59. Yearly A\ciii^e. Yearly Avira^'e. Increase per Cent. Yearly •Vvcrajjc. Increase per Cent. Yearly Avernjre. Increase per Cent. >"ort]i Amoriean colonics Australia ami New Zoa- 1 land / Cnpe and Xatal £ 2,585, 1,24(5, 119, 2,530, 285, 18 1, 578, £ 2 87'> 1,50(5, 597, 2,027, 250, 201, 405, I I 26 20 deci". 10 „ I I 20 deer. £ 4,200, 7,215, 919, 1,9(52, 320, 254, 584, 46 361 59 3 deer. 25 25 26 £ 3,(522, 9,903, 1.527, 2.08i>, 511, 483, 9()5, 14 deer. 37 61 West Indies 7 60 Mauritius Ccvlon 90 65 Straits St'ttlonionts Total 7,833, 7,987, -t 15,18 1, 94 19.100, 1 » "^^ United Slates 5.772, 2.733, 1,5W, (i.732, 2.181, 1.821, 3.459. I.IMO, 2,2!tS, 1 "•' 1 I, — 1, 9,297, 2,207, 1'778, 7,001, '' 31" 1.8 1:'., 3,271. 1.190. 2, l(i5, 1,735, 61 19 deer. I « 4 f) 5 (Irer. V / 4^ 18.178, 2,594, 2,113, 8.501), 2,(i98, 1.025. 4,0 11, 1,195, 3,111. 1,798, 96 36 I 2 44 (Icrr. -4 26 4 19,053, 5,655, 3,292, 12,801, 3,M4, 2.305, 5,50 1, 1,081, 4 122, 2,050, :; France I 18 Spain and Portuf^al (lermany and Austria .... Italv 3^> 50 28 Eus.^ia Holland 131 36 41 i} 48 ndj^iuni Erazd China and Hongkong .... Total 28.871, 33,105. 15 15.()25, 38 00,57(5, 33 1800-04. ls(:5-()'.». 1870. Yearly Avcr:eie. Increase per l-'ent. Ye.irly Averaiie. Increase per Cent. 1871. North American colonies Australia and New Zea- 1 land / Cain; and Natal West Indies £ 5,200, 11,311, 1.953, 3,1.50, 55(5, 727, 1,287, 45 15 28 51 '9 50 £ 7,480, 12,417, 1,031, 2,509, ■102, 833, 1,754, 4- 9 16 deer. 18 „ 17 .' I ^ 3'" 0,801, 9,902, 1,807, 3,3(i2, 483, !t07, 2,332, £ 8,296, 10,035, 2,198, 2,940, C03, ^lauritius Ccvlon 9-8, '•935. Straits Settlements Total 21,280, 27,1 Ki, 25,054, 26,8 ;<;, rnited States 14,521, 8,01(5, 5.028, 1 1,379, 5.100, 2,7S0, (;,303, 1.955, •1,592, 1,380, 24 (leer. 4- 53 I 2 5 7 18 16 16 I I 21,522, 10,9! 15, 4.175, 20,8.-)8, 5,473, 4,117, !t.5l3, 3.1.53, 0,178, 7,511, 4.S 3 7 I 7 deer. 45 1 49 CO 61 71 28,335, 11,615, 1,015, 22.034, 5,207, 0,9!>3, 11,222, 4,170, 5,3.53, 9,515, 34'--9, 18, c6 1, I'Viuiee Spaiu ami I'drtuifal 6,554, 14''--' 6,287, Kussia Ilolhind lii'luiuni lirazil 6,-.; I I , Cliiiia and Hongkong .... 9:404, Total (57.150, 1 1 !)3.558, 39 109,185, I ?';,o27. 124 Hamilton — Ok the Colonics. [Mar. Table Vi.—Comvmption of Britii// I'rodvve per Head of Popidatiun, in till' iniiliu'iiii'iiti'ii)iil ('ol<)iiii'!< Kiid F,4.c;6,i6i 38,067,094 16,301,851 3,987,867 59,250,280 24.273,776 -5>5-7,9i5 7 3.92c. ceo 77,cc8,448 3,628,467 4.529,560 4,839,094 7/'77.8oo 10,045,000 Imports of 15riti>M I'rnduce, ol '^ Vcura. t 3.11(M»00 ;i.s(i:}.noo 5,28y,000 2.1ii6,000 10,781,000 11,801,000 1.761,000 1,761,000 2,017.000 2,62'J,000 275,000 536,000 416,000 13,742.000 17.761,000 21,798,000 2,387,000 7,785,000 ll,iy 1,000 2,445,000 2,053,000 20,566,000 5,133.000 5,353,000 3.110.000 2,537,OUO 10,1U3,000 1. 708.000 2,871,000 4,313.000 5,289,000 Per Head. £ s. d. 1 5 2 I "3 • 1 5 8 411 5 8 10 3 678 2 6 4 8 12 2 239 2 « 7 I 10 5 I 14 7 I 5 9 12 - u 4 12 10 1 4 4 2 6 - 2 I 10 4 6 11 4 3 4 2 - n - 7 2 16 z - 7 f' -1110 -11 2 - 10 6 * Suuie proportion of this belongs to Germany lor goods in transit. yofe. — The imports are taken at an average of tl:ree years, viz., the year of eeiisus with the war before and the year after. 1R72.] Hamilton — On the Cohnion 125 Tablk C — Proportion ^rjn'ch British Prndnce hpnrs to the Total Imports into the imdi'rmentioned Colonies and Foreign Countries. Taken frf)m Colonial and Foreign Returns. North Amerinan colonies ... Australia and New Zealand Cape and Natal West Indies Mauritius Ceylon Singapore and Straits United States France Spain Italy Russia Holland* Belgium Cirnss T(it;il of Tnipnrts for Hfil-fifi, rX UullioU illld S|ll'OiL'. 43,r)r)3,ono ns,88i»,(100 7,710.000 15,807.000 fi,200.000 1 0.571.000 25,577,000 195,700.000 431,108.000 45,145.000 121.350,000 80,204.000 121,139.000 102,029,000 Grosa Inipmn of British Produce for l«fll-66. £ i9,;o9,ooo 46,705,000 5,283.000 6.805,000 1,870,000 3,815,000 5,315,000 64,543,000 38,221,000 8,037,000 20,764,000 14,293,000 11,840,000 12,250,000 Perrentaae of British Produce. 42 47 09 43 30 30 21 31 9 18 17 17 10 8 A proportion due to Crcrinany for goods in tran=it. Table D. — Tonnape Empioi/ed in 'he Trade of the following Colonies and Foreign States, vv'th the Proportion of Briti'^h Tonnage. Total Tonnage Entered and Cleared. North American colo- "1 nies J Australia and New \ Zealand j Ca]H' and Natal West Indies and Guiana Mauritius Ceylon Straits Settlements "I and Singapore J United States France Hanso Towns (Ilam- 1 burg, Bremen, Lu- > beck) J Italy Russia Holland Belgium Tliree Yeirs taken for .Avcraee. Annual Averaiie of Total Tonna'ie. 1805-00-08 1800-08 '00 08 '00 08 '00-f)8 '00- (» '00-08 1800-08 '00-08 1805-07 1808 1800-07 '0(5 07 '00-08 6,2i3>049 4,318,097 552,918 1,768,753 528,189 1,208,568 1,496,542 15,862,597 12,796,694 5,634,568 7,269.501 2,852.245 4,012,246 2,478,962 Annuid Avcraire of British Toiinai'e. 4,995,107 3,992.239 408,109 1,051,030 389,985 1,053,082 873,434 7, 13 1.059 4,013,792 2,017,508 1,050.900 800,935 1,957,901 1,3(!0,I14 Percentage of British Tons. 80 93 85 60 74 87 47 36 36 23 34 49 55 Tons or Lasts. Tons Tons Lasts Tons 12(5 Hamilton — On the Colonies. M,i Table E. — Abstract of the Co>>t of the imdormentmied Colonies and Settlements at the E.vpense of the British Exchequer^ from the Year 1853 to 1871. Norlli Australia Cape and SiuL'apore 1 Years. Aniericaii Colonics. and New ZualniuL 1 Naial. West Indies. Manritms. Ceylon. and SI raits. Total. t i^ ;t' s: .C £ £ £ 1853 51 6, 190 559,485 6(12.227 5V3. 71c 130,710 146,825 — 2.549.177 'ot 315,956 5 7.:,z6z 608,100 .^03,109 126,076 115,170 — 2,241,072 1855 260,577 473,809 620,800 5<4'.^7r 130,627 117,?2,T _ 2,126,519 '5G 551t,522 44^,580 1,106,070 467,014 15 1 ,083 125,498 — 2,8£;6,<;67 '57 422,313 4-.v4'''.'^ 682,015 .^51.7.^7 7 1.881 119,279 — -,-73.7iO '58 35it,()75 .V^o,993 527,750 385,102 65,731. 80,176 — 1,749.430 '5'J 392,03(i 316,415 435,828 .^yy,7C9 08,0(;2 61,872 — 1,703,9-i 18G0 36S.!126 SSOA^'> 513,376 391,846 118.875 8;, 686 2.o';7,i;8 '61 008,271 64. , li I 450,73s 3^.^979 141!, "26 '''7,^30 — -.^'99.365 '62 1,012,303 586,861 387,111 39.v45- 133,6x0 7i,c;s — 2,584,492 '63 850,862 1,108,255 ■I20,20() 366,649 137,515 122,876 — 3,015,393 '61. 852,002 i>.U7-9.';6 328,513 362,071 135,020 84-577 28 3,140,176 '65 881,313 1,171,881 366,056 i}l>i^'^ 110,005 ^5r:,^o — { .1,897,905 1866 1,103,580 ^'.^ .1)3 1 1 3 17.867 38.';.53- 110,270 22,808 1,120 2, "70 ^,,"^06 '67 1,270.082 359,ioi 377,32 1 3,^9.397 122,110 35.*^45 12,386 -.537. '^ '- '68 1,003,300 290,914 286,2 15 350,9^9 73,516 -345c 36,781 2,155,165 11,356,037 9,846,839 8,070,561- 6,741,923 1,011,557 i>303,597 50,215 39,290,732 1869* "1 efitimiite J 1,003,300 290,914 286,2 15 35o>9-9 73,546 -3-450 36,781 2,155,165 1870*.... 1 e.^tiiuiite J 431,968 290,914 165,033 ^94.747 73,516 -3.450 36,781 1.3 1 9.439 1871*... \ estimate j 221,075 229,714 168,257 291,489 73,516 -3-450 36,781 1,045,212 Total... 13,107,180 10,658,381 8,600,000 7,679,088 2,132,105 1 i>3 73)947 1()0,(;58 43,810,548 * i860 talii-ii saiuo made .'or dill'ereiu'c in \\ as 1868. 1870 and 1871 saiiio 10 inilitai'v o.-^tiiualt's iur tliosc yo Koiu-nd t'X]H'ii.-ies a.s 1868, but ullowauce HARRISON AND SONa, I'llINTKUa IN OUDINAHV TO UKU MAJE8T".', HT. MAUTIN'* I,ANE. Table F. — Extracted from Mr. 0. W. Eddy's Tables of British Commerce. 09 1 H CTi M VJ o n iz; rt 1^ fe n o iz; o K r^ Pi ;s pq ^ fl S i3 H r-.2 H go 125 2^ o a^ o ■ r 3J i .=1 . o P4 jZ c 2 O - < 5 o z < _l Hi o mi O Q " 3 < S 1 I He ^ It CO ^ e w -^ o o e ^ r« ?H ^ ti o 0) « UJ a^ •« ■HI M M z 19 M O - "1* _J ^ -^ O o = a o ^ 3 ,^ CK) I- < UJ O « CK ^ ^ 9 o Pm 1 i od o « 03 1^ w Eh O <1 H Ph GREAT BRITAIN AND IRELAND H P LLl o z Ul o z UJ Q. UJ G q: UJ X f- o Q Z < < 5 Ci M if a Si TJi o t 19 'o a S 19 c» (0 « .3 13 O o ■s I* "3 fr- CJ o u ^ ti a "* o » ^ M r= H S nv,,l