«p 
 
 , 
 
 
 •; 
 
 
 1 
 
 t 
 
 
 >, 
 
 •^ 
 
 1 • 
 
 **- 
 
 ' * 
 
 ,t 
 
 
 ■ 
 
 -% 
 
 , 
 
 * 
 * 
 
 
 f 
 
 ■••' 
 
 » ■ 
 f 
 
 
 V^ 
 
 V 
 
 ,* 
 
 •'T: 
 
 CIHM 
 
 Series ' 
 (Monographs) 
 
 ■Wi' 
 
 ■^. •■ ■ 
 
 ICMH 
 Collection de 
 
 (monographies) 
 
 ^ 
 
 v ■ 
 
 ,,'■■'■. T^ ■ ■ . ■ ■ - ■■ ■ 
 
 . <^ CarMdian Inatitut* for Historical Microraproductions / Institut Canadian da microraproductions hiatorlquaa 
 
 "'■'■:^ 'ji- 
 
TMteiMMl and ttbltotrafrtiM NotM / NolM MchnMiyM •! b<blMifraphM|WM 
 
 Tha ImtitwM hm ctMrnplMt Id olM*l«i tiM bMf orifinat 
 copy cvMlabl* for ftlminf . f MtwrM of itiH eopy iwfiicfi 
 iMv ta MMietrapdiMNv imi^«m. vvtitdi ni«v alMt Mty 
 of ifM tmafM tn ttM rcprodwetton. •» wittah may 
 ««mftcw«tiv chanfi th« UMMl HMtlMd of ftimlnt. art . 
 
 1/ 
 
 1/ 
 
 Colowrwf covtn/ 
 Cou««f tura da coulaur 
 
 Cotart d a wiapd/ 
 Couwaf twrt aiMlomiiM|Aa 
 
 ECovari radofiad and/or laminaiad/ 
 CouvarMra railaurAa at/ov palliculAa 
 
 • ' ■ =W ■ ■ . . ■ ■ 
 
 , " ■ _, . . -^ . ■ 
 
 I I La titra da eouvartura maiMiiM ' 
 
 □ CoMrad tntput , , .' - "r 
 
 Cat tat fl«o«raphiqiia« an eoulMir 
 
 D 
 
 CokNirad ink (i.a. ott«ar than blua or Mack)/ 
 Encra da coulaur (i.a. autra qua Maua 6t» noiral' 
 
 □ CokMirad plata* and/or iiluitrationt/ 
 Planettai af /ou illustrations an coulaur 
 
 n 
 
 
 n 
 
 Bound witfi otkar matarial/ 
 Rali4 avac d'autras documanti 
 
 tifht bindfnc may cause iNdowrs or dif tortion 
 ■along intarior margin/ 
 
 La raliura sarrte paut causar da l^ombra ou da la 
 distorsion la long da la marga intiriaura 
 
 Blank laavas addad during rastoration may appaar 
 
 wittiin tfia taxt. WlMnavar possiMa. ttiasa hava 
 
 bafn omittad from filming/ 
 
 II sa paut qua ca^tainas pagas blanchas ajoutM 
 
 lors d'una rastauration apparaissant dans la texta, 
 
 mais, lorsqua cala ttait possiMa. cas pagas n'ont 
 
 pasMfilmAas. 
 
 □ Additional eommants:/ 
 Commantairaf suppl4mantairas: 
 
 This ilam is filmad at tha raduction ratio chackad balow/ 
 ' Ca documarit #st filmiau taux da rMuction indiqui ci-dassout. 
 
 IPX 14X ^ix 
 
 L'lmHtut a mlcrofilm4 la maillaur cHamplctr* qu'il 
 Im4 a 4l* poMiMa da la procurer Las dAta«U da cat 
 axamptatra qui sont pa«i«4tr« uruquat du potnt dt «ua 
 Wbliognphiqua. qui pauvant modif lar una Imafi 
 raproduita. ou qut pauvant axigar una modification 
 darts la m4tfioda normala da f itmaga sont indiqu4« 
 ct-dassout. . »-^,- ■ .■• • ■ , 
 
 dColourad pafH/ 
 Pagas da coulaur 
 
 □ Pagas damaga d / 
 PagM andommagaas 
 
 □ Pagn rattorad and/or limmatad/ 
 Pagas rastaurias at/ou palliculAas '-^ 
 
 Q 
 
 Pagas ditcelourad. slainad or fexad/ 
 Pagn dicolerAas. tadiaiAas pu piqw^ 
 
 □ Pagas datachad/ 
 Pagas d«tach«as 
 
 HShowthrough/ 
 Transparanca 
 
 Quality of print varias/ 
 
 Quality intgala da I'imprftsion 
 
 □ Cofi 
 Pagi 
 
 Continuous pagination/ 
 lination continua 
 
 □ Includas indax(as)/ 
 Cpmprand un (das) indax 
 .■■**'. 
 
 Titia on haadar takan from:/ 
 La titra da I'an-tita pro«iant: 
 
 □ Title paga of istua/ 
 Paga da titra da la livraison 
 
 □ Caption of issua/ 
 Tjtra da depart da la livraison 
 
 □ Masthaad/ 
 Giniriqua (piriodiquas) da la livraison 
 
 22X 
 
 -2tX- 
 
 JOJL 
 
 ; 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 v_ 
 
 ' 
 
 
 
 •, 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Th« copy film«d h«r« haa iMMn r«produo«d Iharilct 
 to th« ganaroaity ofs ., . 
 
 AnfN«n CtHifch of ewMdi J 
 
 iMMral tVMtf AraM«M 
 
 M 
 
 Th«Tmagaa appaarino hara mrm tha 4>aat quality 
 potalbia consldarlng tha condition and lafllblllty 
 of tha original copy and In kaaping with tha 
 filming contract apacif Icationa. 
 
 Original coplaa In printad papar covara ara fllmtd , 
 baginning with tha front covar and aridlng on 1 
 tha laat p«ga with a printad or illuatratad Impraa/ 
 alon. or tha back covar wh#n appropriate : All 
 othar origirMi coplaa Ara flimad baginning on tha 
 firat paga viHth a printad or illuatratad ImprM' 
 ••ion. and anding on tha laat paga with a printad 
 or illuatratad Impraaaioni. ■ ^- ■-. 
 
 ■;.,;;,•■•■<;■'..■ ■ ■ ■•: . ' . /'.-'■ 
 
 Tha laat racordad frama on dich nilcroflcha ^ 
 ahall contain tha aymbol-^ (moaning "CON- 
 TtNUED"). or tha aymbol V (movning "END"), 
 whichavar appiioa. 
 
 -'■.■:: '■:':^ -T •:■• ■ ;^.■/■ :.:':;■■■•■•■ 
 Maps, plitia, eharta, ate., may b4 flimad it 
 diffarant raduotion ratioa. Thoaa too larga to ba 
 antlraiy Includad In ona axpotura ara filmad 
 baginnipg in tha uppar laft hand cornar. laft to 
 right and top to bottom, aa many framaMa 
 raquirad. Tha folldwing diagrama illuatrata tha 
 mathod: / 
 
 .\ 
 
 ..y\. 
 
 ■ ■ . ■ ■ . . ■• • 
 
 m^^t\'- ' 
 
 ^.-.■^■- , . 
 
 ■ %.- ■ f ■ 
 — 4 
 
 } 2. : 
 
 -:::3' 
 
 L'aMamplaira fllm4 fut raprodult grAca i la 
 g4n4roalt4 da: , 
 
 Ahfttpan CtNireli of Canada 
 f OMMTti tvMMl AnMvai 
 
 ;Laa Imagaa aulvantaa ont 4t« raprodultaa avac'la 
 plua grand aoln. compta tonu da la condition at 
 da la nattat4 da I'axamplaira fllm4. at an 
 oonformit* avao laa conditiona du contrat 4» 
 flimaga. 
 
 Laa axamplalraa orlginauH dont la couvartura fii 
 papiar aat ImprlmAa aont filmAa an commandant 
 par la pramiar plat at mn tarmlnant aoit par la 
 darnlAra paga qui comporta una amprainto 
 d'Impraaaion ou d'iiluatratlon. aoit par la aaco^d 
 plat, aalon la oaa. Toualaa autraa aiiampiairaa 
 orlgihauM aont f ilm4a mn commandant par la ! 
 pramlAra paga qui com^ort« una ampralnta 
 d'Impraaaion ou d'llluiftratidh alf an tarmlnant par 
 la darnlAra paga qui comporta una talla 
 ampralnta. ^ 
 
 ■ •' ■ ■ - ■ ■ ,; , ^/ . • 'r. 
 
 Un daa aymbolaa aulvanta apparattra aur \m *■' ' ' 
 darnlAra Imaga da chaqua microflcha. aalop If 
 caa: la aymbola — *> aignifia "A SUiVRE", la 
 aymbola V ai^nifia "FIN". 
 
 Laa cartaa, planohaa, tabloaux, ate. pauvaht Atra 
 fiimia k daa tauM da rMuction dlffAranta. 
 Loraqua la documantaattrop' grand pour Atra 
 raprodult an un aaul clidhA. II aat fllmA A partir 
 da I'angia aupAriaur gaucha. da gaucha A droita, 
 at da haut an baa. an prahant la nombra 
 d'Imagaa nAcaaaaira. Laa ttiagrammaa aulvanta 
 iiluatrant la mAthoda. 
 
 * 
 
 '".■*' J ■ . • ■ ■ 
 
 "^v:;^i':;;"7 
 
 
 :'■: 3' ■■■ 
 
 
 /■?::,h':f': r-'-_[-: 
 
 ■■.,.. •4. ■.■• 
 
 ;'- '5 /.■ 
 
 6 
 
 ^ __._ _____ i ._" 
 
 r ■ ;■- /• 
 
 
 - 
 
 
 • « ' . — / 
 
 ■^ / 
 
, I ;■/■ 
 
 -\ 
 
 / 
 
 MKVOCOrV. HfOUITION TKT CHAtT 
 
 (ANSI and ISO TIST CHART N«. 2) 
 
 1.0 zm^M 
 
 I.I 
 
 1.25 
 
 !,?*. 
 
 1.4 
 
 j.6 
 
 » J » 
 
 ' '"•••if 
 
 ;'. 
 
 ••#1 
 
 .I/i .:,.._,.._ 
 
 /APPLIED IIVHGE I, 
 
 nc 
 
 1693 East Main StrMt 
 Ri»ch«tt«r. N«w York 14609 
 (716) 482 - 0300 - Phone 
 (716) ?8a- 3989 -Fox 
 
 Wi 
 
 ■"i -M 
 
■) ' 
 
 ■•\ 
 
 CUITIQUE 
 
 ON 
 
 akciidea(con MAiisirs 
 
 EXPLANATIONS. 
 
 **f$l>rak 111 to wii* mtn t juttgt yt what t n»jf,'*»-l Cor. : 10 ot), U ▼. , 
 
 $;VETIAL weoki linoil ft puniphlot apponnitl conUining 
 •* Explanfttioim by Archd«ac<m Marnh," atul it ir ft. 
 niattisr of durpriw) that no fnvlher «tat©inont \\wik ap- 
 poared. Thg charpjen aiitl G<nirit«r-oharii(ja th«r«iii aro of a 
 ■oleum natuM, aiul having r«foronc« to tho ohAraotura of men 
 holtiiiiK poaitioiii in the Hacred Ministry of tho Church of (^A>d, 
 it would be criminal indeed to allow the ** aoverity of tilenco " 
 to glow Over chargtvi which are ao detrimental to the Church** 
 welfare, aa well as to the honor of Clod and Ilia Christ. The 
 Laitv are deeply concerned with the mattor,-<4i it will bo im-. 
 possible for them to respect men in tho position of clergynion, 
 • whilst charges so destructive to moral and religious f(ood rest 
 upon them : moreover, all tho Clergy, for their charactora will be 
 eitimatod, in some decree ^at least, by tho positions of those 
 who aro concerned. *. ^ 
 
 The " Explanations " receiving no answer will bo considered 
 satiefaotory, and that efforts have been made to injure a most 
 useful servant of tho Church, or if refuted, will make it incuin- 
 bent upon those who have cliargod tho Archdeacon, to bring him 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 t 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 i 
 
 *. 
 
 
 
 , , 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 .,. 
 
 
 ..^Za^ 
 
 ■..■,. *.• 
 
 ^ 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 \ * ■' 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 , 
 
 
 
 . .■ • 
 
 ^ 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 •s . 
 
 
 
 ' 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 •■ '-■ .'r- 
 
 a. ... 
 
 ','_■■ 
 
 
 . • >> 
 
 t. • , 
 
 _ ■ .'k •. 
 
 
 '. '^ ■ , ■ " : 
 
 ■;■ . ■. . ',. 
 
 'M- 
 
 
 
 • 
 
 *■ »» 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
/^ 
 
 > 
 
 I . ■ H CIITIQUI. 
 
 to Iriil; for • mwi who la guilty of •' dnpllcUy ind anoopUun •» 
 •o M to Imi unfll for * pli*« •! th« C«»iifioil Bo*r«l of lluroii 
 C«»II«'K«, i»n«i whom th« llinh.ip of k ohuroh oannot h«>iii»tl)f w 
 g»r(l M » fU ptiMOn to oontiimu ah ArohclMc«m on AOootini of 
 hb oh«r»ol«r,- iuoh a p«»rion, ll U oloar, owiiiot «i«roia«» th« 
 work of th« Ministry mnon«*t hit |MW»pU for thttr tpirittiMl 
 b«n«flt Th« Hynotl h^ dtioiiUnX this, by providing Ounona on 
 aiioipUn0 to oorruot th» livni «»f Ihomj who ditgriwd, or bring 
 dishonor up<>n thgir holy o»Uing. It wouM U hypoori«y to nmy 
 thiit out c»f pity to lh« Archd«iiwon th*»y wi«hod to ovorlouk Muuh 
 griovoiw ofTonooa, •fl«r thj foumo th«y h»v« puriu«d : tuoh 
 ^wisdom if •>oao«iihl«" could not b« ornditwd m "puru." If, 
 on th« othwr hand, tlm ohargw cannot bo iuntninod. tho vdrdlot 
 from without will bo timt hi« traduour*, having buon guilty of 
 •n ftggrarat«d oflTonoti, otight not to go un\.uniahod. Probably 
 thoy may rett upon thoir otUoial potitioni for support; auoh 
 protoniiion* will not b« aco«pt«d, for p«opl« do not boli«ivo that 
 any oflloo can justify tho holder in committing an act of In- 
 juitioo against an«»thor : if so, tho aocuior would haro to acoopt 
 whatovor ho would mote out to tho accused. Tho oaao is ono 
 which fully justiftos and calls f«)r criticism. It is a vain thing 
 to say that public mon and public institutions should not bo 
 criticised, for herein depends the public safety : by criticism, 
 uprightness and integrity are upheld, whilst deception and 
 fraud are unmasked. Criticism should be generous, it i« true, 
 but generosity has truth for ita mall oharaotoristio. Not only 
 should public men and iwiblic institutions be criticised, but they 
 ■hould bo able to fccarf criticism : above all, the Church of 
 Christ whose foundation is " Divine Truth," should bo able to 
 challenge searching investigation ; \hoso who hold high <»ffloe, 
 and who are not byikny means fed upon " pulse," should be s<» 
 under divine love, that fi Mg f ro »P. woul d fi nd no pUoe^ the 
 
> 
 
 iceptlufi " 
 }f llurtiii 
 itttlly ra* 
 ooutini of 
 sroim iht) 
 •pirittinl 
 bttoiit on 
 ur bring 
 iiy to nay 
 luuk Muuh ^ 
 irtd : tuoh 
 iru." If, 
 lu vordiot 
 Kititty of 
 Frobftbly 
 >rt ; auoh 
 littvo that 
 Kit of in* 
 tu aooopt 
 lo it one 
 min thini( 
 lid not be 
 oritioUm, 
 )tion and 
 t In true, 
 Not only 
 , but they 
 3hiiroh of 
 M) able to 
 igh ofHoe, 
 >nld be so 
 )Uoe; tho 
 
 CtlTlQWi. S 
 
 l«tllmriny boriio to thtiir oltariKittirt thoiiUI In),—** Wi» •hall not 
 find any o«oa«ion again«t thU Danbt, aiMpI wn find It i^tainat 
 him aoprntnlnK Iha law t»f hit God." Tho niatUtr eontainad In 
 tha **BipUnationt" hat gono b«youd thoau niorti Immmliataly 
 ooneamad, and b«ootne the proiKirty of " our ownohurah p«Ki|>la 
 and thoto who taka an Intartat In ih« niatlor." % * 
 
 W« oannot In Juttiee patt over notloln^ bri«fly tint career of, 
 Arehdeaeon Murtli, and in doing to we are impreMo<l with tha 
 wordt of Hulottion :— >*' Lei another man praiie thee, and nol 
 thine own mouth: • iiranger, and nol thina own ^^•.**^ 
 
 The Arohdoaeon wat ordained in the year 1840, and It now a 
 Priott of HO yutr't nttnding in tho Minlttry of the Churoh of 
 Gtigtand. fie hat filled varioiit potitiont in the ('hiiroh, from 
 a itruggling mitniooary to that whiah he now holdti with tuoh 
 acjooptability m to have the hi«hutt tettim<my given to hit great 
 worth At the Synod, of 1873, the following retoluiiou wiUbe 
 found on thd- mintitet, and wat oontidered to deteMn that it 
 met with the highett approval :— Moved by Judge Wilton, t«o« 
 onded by Dr. Ooverntun, Uotolved :— **That thit SJrnod, while 
 warmly congratulating tho Venerable Archdeacon Marth cm hit 
 recent appointment to the high occletiattioal ofHce of Arch- 
 deacon, cannot permit him to retire from the office of Clerical 
 Secretary of thin Kynod, without expro»ting their hi| h apprecia* 
 tion of hit long and valuable torvicot in the faithful ditcharge 
 of the oneroui and imp(»rtant dutiet connected with thit oflice. 
 Hit unwearied attention to the numorout detaili of hit official 
 dutiet, hit prompt attention tu all corrotpondenee, whether 
 asking for information or written on tho butinott either of the 
 Church Society, or of the Synod, hit unwearied oourioty and 
 kindnett both to hit Clerical and Lay brethren, have won for 
 him the alfeptiun aad.reBpeoi of overy member of tail Synod ', 
 
 ■I . 
 
mi 
 
 4 CtlTtQUI. 
 
 And mi rtliHna r»<nti ihviMi i>llla«M h«i onrTica with him our b«*l 
 wi»hM for hl» (ul»ir« h*|>|>iii«MMi miH wntfurv, Aliil oii# ttMfiittl 
 ptM^wn IhAt il tu*y plttAMi Aliiiiifhiy iUnX lo thciwtr Uuwn on 
 oar ?«ii«ribl« fri«m«l Mi4 birtUlkiff, Arohcle*c<in M^nh, lib 
 e)ioi<}Mt hl«MitiK». an«l *<» ot«>«n with tnoiMM hit futitrv Ub<mn 
 in Ihii vtiieyurd «f uuf l)i%1ii« MMlor.'* 
 
 Thia rwolulion (KitiiliiK fn»m lh« Hymnl »f thii Church U ftry 
 •igtiifloAtii, At thai lim« h« hiul »h>«ii 24 yf urt in thn Minitlry , 
 Atul •ubjvct to thn t«it of A diacunvitiK public : h« «M to 
 hotiorvd and wip«ctifd, wh«th©r in partichiAl or dii^wwn work^ 
 lot hit OhHttitn int««ritr and ut«ifttln«it, that without— at all 
 Imow—any prutturo in hit favor, th(» iibov*i rvtotution waa 
 patatd by tho highutt bixly in tho DioooMan Chuioh, ooni|Hi««d 
 of f«pr«t«tntaliv« ohurohiiM»n frt»ui «K»»ry part of tho l>io««M<}. 
 A man who, if wfiualUxl, ttand* unmirpiMMi«<l in thit, «>r any 
 othor Dioc«t«» of tho Douiinion for r«al odniinittrativa ability ; 
 a man of aumoiont mhul lo \m uiiattuuiing, unpr»t«nding, uir- 
 obtruiivu; a man ut|M)ctally fritndly to thu pmirDf oUirgy ; ft 
 man, t«i truttud by tho OU»ruy and Laity nt iu bo put on all im- 
 portant oommittotit of tho church by ovurwh«.min« numb«r«, 
 if not by an unanimout v«*t«, when they had tho election; amXn 
 who, at thu latt Dioconan Hpiacitpal Election obtained a highly 
 reipectablo and large minority of Clerical antl Uy vote* J and 
 MOW the Church it ttartlotl and MJiockod by the chargot which 
 have been preferroti tt«»intt hiui by the Bithop of Huron and 
 eight others who form a dote corporation (two of whom aro 
 beyond the conflnet of the Dioccto and irretpohtiblo except t() 
 the civil power) -oharget no lett grave than '•duplicity and 
 deception." It it true that out of tho remaining six membert, 
 tho three latt on \\w list may bo regarded at " pretumptuout," 
 when compared with thit venerable servant of the Church, 
 whiltt of tho other three who have been prof etted friendt for 
 
 
#- 
 
 Mmittl 
 
 lown on 
 why Uw 
 t lab«»iini 
 
 h U f^ 
 
 I VM to ■ 
 
 l—M »ll 
 
 Uon wM 
 i(>m|Miiiv<l 
 
 • or Miy 
 AbUily i 
 
 ling, urn 
 jlurgy J ft 
 m All im- 
 iiuiiibonif 
 III; aiiiXti 
 
 ft hiK^ly 
 ttit; AJid 
 ut which 
 iirc»n and 
 rhoiii ftro 
 
 ioity and 
 inuinburi, 
 uptuoui," 
 Church, 
 riundi fur 
 
 thirty Of forty y««t. *m» a.«i not iftihiawr aui.imtl hU own 
 l»#«l»W. Il*r» Ihnii Wf haif« th« llUli"|» «»l Hufiiii aiKl Iwo 
 ** ftgtttl" nMti bfl* vi>> :— Dmmi il4K»iiMir ftitd Ar(}liitiNM}«»ii lUlwood. 
 Tlift olMrgM hftft arlaan In eonn«ef Irm with two l«ti«»r« |»«b« 
 Ilth«d In ft elt) n«wi|m|»««r cftil«d th« Ihrmtd, and ilgncd r«. 
 •p««tlviily, •« Chiirchwi.niwi" ••!«» ••Churchmftn '* In r«Nidtng 
 th« •• KiplaniHoiii," •«»«»« w>l«Ht r«?gird Archdeacon Manh aa 
 nrrinK hy i.lontifylnii hlnnwlf In any way with •© w#ak a nian aa 
 Df. 'HchuUu i whvfi tho latltr came and aliowod him th« •platJa 
 nf«C^wrchwoinan/* lift illottWM •>«••■"«, Sftfft •»un««ll«a 
 him to altwna to hit own kualnina. At fof ibo l«itt«r [^U, any 
 man. woman oi child, had a moral Hght to Indita of t«»bliah i| : 
 for If HnUmuth I^ica'8oho«»lHunmCollege-«>r the Church, 
 oannot iUnd th«'t«it of iiich ft wild and ««mmiinat« comjioaition, 
 4h«n tluiy niuit U w«iak Indcad, and uncU»a«»nrinic of nii|wet. 
 The lottftr of *• Churchman " haa tho m«rit of " manlinwaa," and 
 it la iurprUInu that th« Arohdt?acon ihould write conccminn it, 
 ** I did not, and do not approvn withur c»f ita MtntimunU or Ita 
 tone," wh«n no ono knowt Iwttcr than h«, that it cc.ntaina 
 •impl«, unvami»hod truth. But h« infoniunl hia readora that 
 !i« ha<i biwn ** futhiiUUm by hi* m«dical attondant to attempt 
 annwcrioii any luttert." Hi« «.iroring t*. lutign hia Archdeaconry 
 and not take part in Kynod for two yeara, but which he lo 
 properly withdrew, evidenced •evoro mental depreaaion ; and 
 no wonder that a man lo ieniiitive, should b« unnerved by what 
 he termed, ** tho malicioui and peraiitent attempta to oruah him 
 down." However, we leave the two letteri leit we ihould be 
 guilty of the charge that like the College Council, wo gave them 
 an amount of attenti«)n beyond their doaervinga. 
 
 *We paaa on to the leitera of the Biahop, of May tith and Juno 
 ICth., and the extract from the minutca of tho Council, dated 
 
 f 
 
 
 
m- :■ ' 
 
 ■ .■#. 
 
 C ■ t ■ '\ ■ . CRITIQUI. ;. " ■.; 
 
 Juno 14th. WoJonoi iutond to wado thr«)Ugh th« inccmaU- 
 Unoiut which oharacterisw thf» d<»ouiiioiili, but briutly louoh 
 Upon a fw ittliont pointf. *Mtmt readere cannot h»vo failed to 
 notice the itrikinK •imilarity in tho ttylt of coiuiKmition which 
 porvadflB thow) documents, but it wouhl b« phooliing to enter- 
 tain the idea that one perion in<lited theni. But thouijh the 
 •tyle might be aimilar, there is a striking difforenoo "between tho 
 modus operandi to convict the Archdeacon. On p»«e 10, th*> 
 Bishop writes, " ' I can no longer rely upon his tldelity or 
 loyalty to myaelj, or on tho faithful porformanoo of his duties 
 as Archd«aoou. So long as lus hostility was directed against 
 me personally, I b(>re it patiently, and abstained froui noticing 
 it, but sinco his attacks included my loyM Clergy and Liity, 
 and our eduoatioaal institutions,- siloncj and forbJjiranoo cease 
 to be charity ,' etc. j etc. No>y read this from p»;^o 42, which 
 the Bishop and his loyal Clergtf and Ltity sign h-^** We wotild, 
 therefore, distinctly staie that , we admit tho ri^ht of the exercise 
 of private judgment upon all matters, and of the expression of 
 •i^ch opinions in the public iwess or otherwise. But the con- 
 tents of the said letter, or tho Hubjeet animadverte'l upon there- 
 ini^Jid not in the least degree kiixt^ir into the question before the 
 Council, nor had it anything to do witli the decision arrived at. '* 
 Wlit is the use of going oh, for tha BUhop and the Council 
 could not have thought such c )ntradict')rv matter wrould ever 
 meet the public gaza. But onae. m .re at page 43, they assert 
 that the Archdeacon desired Dr. Schulte to show " Church wo- 
 man's " letter to the Djan, and point out to him what the 
 j^Mft/tVopmio/i.wason theaubjjot to which it related. These 
 gentlemen, anxious for the welfare of the students, ask, "Was 
 this the act of an lionest man?" How melancholy to think 
 they do not know, that one person, though of the weaker sex, 
 may be. the honoat and truthful exponent of public opinion, aa 
 
 ~!:3ie0^^^-.','. 
 
 [•t7.^'~ M,uSiv^;^£^ ' 
 
 'hsA^B^. 
 
 - " ■■ ■'■ ■ - " ■■ ■ " ' '•■•«■■ ■» " ...i'.i .m. ^ . I .--. TOI.,... , .*i » ,.» „ , . . t 
 
4 
 
 ino(m«{i- 
 \y ItMioh 
 failed to 
 [)n which 
 to outor- 
 ough tho 
 vvouii tho 
 ) 10, tho 
 lUolity or 
 ui dutiti* 
 1 at{aiii»t 
 \ notioiii}{ 
 id Liity, 
 100 ooaao 
 ,2, whioh 
 e would, 
 exeroiso 
 'osaiou of 
 
 tho con- 
 on there- 
 tofore the 
 rived at. " 
 ) Oonnoil 
 )uld ever 
 ,ey assert 
 )hurohwo- 
 what the 
 d. These 
 sk, **\V(is 
 
 to think 
 )aker sex, 
 pinion, aa 
 
 CRltlQUi. 7 
 
 wull aa a thoiiiand. This, however, waa said to ho taken from 
 a private letter written to Dr. Hhtilte. What are the people 
 to think I Hivt where were Ool. Hhanley, Ool. Gsowaki and 
 V, 0. Blake i They are aaid to he iiiun ot character, and mem- 
 \i on of the [toard. Where were thoy J It iaaiich an important 
 queation that we aak again—" Where were they I Were M«y 
 notinedl" © 
 
 Wo must not forgot to notice t)ie Bishop'a <fwp«n«aWow. Tho 
 Archdeacon could effect an exchange with a clergyman of good 
 atanding in any other Dioceae. To eiToct thia, tho Biahop of 
 Huron would have to give a man whi^m he, and other ioyal 
 mou, had charged with "duplicity and deception "-a teatimo- 
 nial of '*good life and converaation. " After thia, how dan 
 tho Biahop oonaiatently maintftin the charge of " duplicity and do- 
 «sjptioa" againat Archdeacon Marsh?- The profouild and irra-- 
 aistible reaaoning of St. Paul might not he inapplicable here. 
 " Behold, thou art called a Jew, aud roateat in the iaw, and 
 makeat thy boaat of God, and knowtjat Uia will, and approveat 
 the things that are more excollont, being inatructed out of the 
 law ', and art confident that thou thyself art a guide of the 
 blind, a light of them which are in darknosa, an inatructor pf 
 the fooliah, a teacher of babes, which hast the form of knowl- 
 ledge and of the truth in tho lav. Thou therefore which 
 tea chest another, teaohest thou not thyself? Thou that 
 preaoheat a man should liot steal, dost thou steal? Thou that 
 sayest a man should not commit adul^i^ry, dost thou commit 
 adultery ? Thou that abhorrest idols, dfist thou commit sacri- 
 lege i Thou that makeat thy boast of the law, through break- 
 int< the law di8honou|;est thou God ? For the name of God ia 
 blasphemed among thb Gentilea through you, as it ia written." 
 (Romans 2 ch., 17-24.) 
 
ulf 
 
 • , CtlTIQOE. 
 
 We will not dwell upon the wordi ao iuRaMo lo Hio cht^w- 
 t«r of Noro, a well known Roman Kinp«ror, and wliich w«ro 
 laid to hay« h«»'n addr«M«d t<» a Liiyinan <.f tlio Church of 
 England, by the Hiiihop of Huron, that " wtr« ho a olurnynian 
 he would not allow him to Bay H, wtird ;" without controvoray 
 il ia Rome's apirit ; it belongs ta the City of the beven II ills. 
 
 Archdoacon Marsh asuorts thut the Bishop treated him with 
 "scorn," and insultud him when oxpo|Iir « him. The Council 
 declare, " he performed the painful duty with the numt marked 
 consideration and courteBy." 
 
 There miKht be consideration shown by holding the meeting 
 in a *' drawing room," when any unbianed person must bo 
 assured that the expulsion <»f Archdeacon Marsh was fully de- 
 termined, but it is unroasonablo to talk about " courtesy r^'^ 
 But who will believe this? It is a general practice amongst 
 men of the world without professed piety, when they have to 
 dismiss a person from office, to suggest to him the propriety of 
 "resigning." Those who know human nature will easily 
 understand what a fav<»rable opportunity was presented to 
 gratify a wrathful rpirit. We ^Ire satisfied that the calm, dis- 
 passionate reader, will regard this "drawing room " entertain- 
 ment, unworthy of true Christian manliness, and that the 
 Council took a omel advantage of the Aifohdeacon. 
 
 We do not suppose that Dr. Schulte'a letters were written 
 upon a material rack, but evidently under the potent influence 
 of mental agony. On page 29 it reads :—" Your Lordship will 
 remember that I took from the very first the wholtj. blame to 
 myself, and thought that my apology was satisfactory to the 
 Council, and thought there the matter would end. '^le whole 
 affair is truly disagreeable and distasteful to me. I hate to 
 
 I- 
 
9 oha^nc- 
 ich wore 
 hurch (»f 
 uriiyiuAn 
 trovuray 
 i)U ililU. 
 
 tiin with 
 Council 
 it inarkud 
 
 ) mooting 
 
 nuist bo 
 
 fully de- 
 
 iourtoBy,"- 
 
 ami>ni{Bt 
 
 I have to 
 
 Dpriety of 
 
 ill easily 
 
 dented to 
 
 calm, dis- 
 
 entertain- 
 
 that the 
 
 re written 
 I influence 
 ■dflhip will 
 . blame to 
 ^ry to the 
 'Pie whole 
 I hate to 
 
 • ■ ^ * ■ ' ' .^ " ■ ■ ' ' . ' 
 
 • •KITMn'f'.. • 9 
 
 IwpUcftto Archf1c»(icon Mnmb, who lm« bocn kiiwl to mo ever 
 Rinco t came »o thin Dtocoiin. I wotiM rather that y<)u *ih<»nld 
 a^lc biiiipolf ab( nf th(i nmttrr lutntainiMl in your hotter." Ono 
 HpplioHtion <f the '•innohino" n«>t Imudk miflloii'iit, thn Dr. 
 writeii thui f»n i-oro IJr»,--V* I tnutt iit»»o thut muthor Iho Arch- 
 dtai'on nor any ono oliio outnidv of my Houro i<i roRponaihlo for 
 writintr tho lotfttr : it waa written innooontly, without nny in- 
 Hliju'iition, on tho impulio of the momunt, and without any 
 intontion of hurting? tho foolingu t)f any one." After th«Hrt 
 pfatomontH, what d*» tho otht'tR lunonnt (•> ? Mnny an IrujulHi'tor 
 hm obfamrd frr ni bin victim far Iphr truth, W« thon hoar 
 nbotit tho Vrtc /Vcat? nrd Ihvnhi, aftor whioli wo aro cdifuul (f)- 
 by Brmo of tho doJn^'S and «»yinf:B of that obspcuuimB Chn-ic, 
 
 '•Can<»n Innin." . 
 
 « 
 
 - liot ufl now coneidor whet the BiHhnp nlpct laid. Whon 
 
 seconding tlin rcnolntion to oxpcl Arch«1oicon Mafflh ho gavo a» 
 
 a r(^niK>n, "that ho bad alwuyn coneidrrrd liim Rinoofo until re« 
 
 rentfj/, wbon n circuinHtanco cnme fohtH knowlod^jfO which proved 
 
 bis wart of sincrrify." Yet on i)rt/?o 44 tho tlion Arcbdoacrm 
 
 /Swoatmnn nfHrrlB tho rraBcn to Kavoboon " that theconnoction 
 
 of Archdtnoon Murnh with tho publication of "Churrih wo- ' 
 
 man's " letter wns tho culn^inntion of long ro'itititml opposition 
 
 on the part of tho Archdea<'on, '.' This |yfnntlQU)an, howovor, on 
 
 pnoo 67 writoB that tho rcaaoh waa on account of Homo matter 
 
 f>f potty onvy which had been enj^ondcro'J in hi.t ownhfinom con- 
 
 cernint? tho " Dominion" and •'Evan'joHcal" newapapora, but 
 
 which bo flatly contradicts, by ft'iortitvj: if. was ** oppogition to 
 
 tho Bi8ho[» f.f Hui:(»n. " No nood to prove ** duplicity " here." 
 
 Truly, "envy is as rottonncng of tho bones." • 
 
 By "Dran Boomer" poraiittin^' the mooting f.^r such 
 spocial" bj3in33* to bi hald in his dr*win^' room, the -^ 
 
 I* 
 
 •v 
 
 <( 
 
 ^ 
 
' r 
 
 5?gpyjf^ 
 
 ■Bj?B^j'-'^|»3t5r^s^^lF«3r^«si7^^^.3£a?^^ 
 
 '•»» • 
 
 .f 
 
 to 
 
 CRlTIQUfc 
 
 u,>im.i« of the Council U apparortt. H«w molanohdy to loo • 
 „mn who .huuia «njoy gmiural r..p«ot, ullowmg )xxm*M to bo 
 placed in auch a pomtum. Clianty, wu tni.l, will ^.ut it down ^ 
 to tho infirmity of ago. 
 
 Th« c«ur.o i.ur.uml by Mr. Cronyn will not b« rogurd^d with 
 envy by any who valuo .olf ro-poct, for when taking tho ofhoo 
 of Chanconorhohadnw<.m-that ho would to tUo utmo.t o 
 hi. aadorHtandn.« deal uprightly in hi. olUoo ;-'^l»""^ /""i;"*^^ 
 of favor or reward." Yot in -ondiug Archdeacon M*"»» » 
 notico of tho Hpocial n.ootlng, hold h^k tho - buauio.. to bo 
 -brought boforo it, although tho rule of tho Council rouuirod it. 
 It wan an oniinoun ouiiMion. 
 
 It may not be unprofitablo to roviow briplly thoso mombor. of 
 
 ^Huron ColWo Council. whc«,o nanion woro appended to the do<5U- 
 
 • mont. and for which, each one i« rcponniblo, whether ho had 
 
 anything to do with tho cunceiving, inditing, or couipoBing of 
 
 it, or not. 
 
 I. HUUON. 
 
 ! 
 
 A. SWEATMAN. 
 
 The "aecondor" of the resolution : since loft tho Diocoao. 
 We leave tho voice of cousciouco to spoak to hun. 
 
 H. J. GRASETT. > 
 
 A man remarkable for the coldness of his nature, and for 
 bein« barren of human sympathy. Ho " specially 'V came to a ^ 
 - special meeting," and *' moved " the resolution. Ho does not 
 Zfc6 in tho Diocese. 
 
 • U. BOOMER. 
 
 The legitimate demand which ago has for evdry conridoration, 
 
 will suffice. ••^ 
 
 .JfJl^M.^i^K'^U.fe 2 
 
 ■•^-*^m^ma 
 
 ^ BJi i B iiiiiti iii i inrii i iM i iii ii ■ '»!^i 
 
 ! 
 

 
 ■ -m,- 
 
 r to MO ft 
 
 ilf to bu 
 it duwii 
 
 dad with 
 ;hu otiiuu 
 
 itlliOHt of 
 
 t ruHpuct 
 Marsh a 
 • " to bo 
 L^uirud it. 
 
 uiuburd of 
 the doqu- 
 r ho httd 
 iposing of 
 
 DIOOOBO. 
 
 e, and for . 
 oaiao to a 
 le docB not 
 
 itldoration, 
 
 i y CRiriQUK. 
 
 FJW. SANDYS. 
 
 ' II 
 
 ^ An iitifortunatu m(^n, dfturvtiiK oomtuiiii^rniion m inttch at 
 coiidutii nation. ^ 
 
 K. L ELLWOOU. 
 A very hnrinlulTa (/Jd K<!nfli)niftn, i! loft alone. For 3() yoarti, 
 ho and Archdoacon Mamh Wi-ro un Jt>nAthau and David. Ho 
 i« Buid to ImTO siKnud the dociunvnt nhich iMrtortoil hu waa 
 preMfut at a tKovtitig, whon ho wan abatnt. (Pag<i40.) . 
 
 J. P. IltNCIvS. 
 
 Thifl uontlcman, it appears, tuHtitiod to the sulmtanco of a con- 
 vorHaii^ai at a nicuting, althou>;h hn w:ui nol thuro. (Pago 41). ) It 
 would lount ho wan not in the habit of attending. " gonoral '* 
 niuotings. ViXxaXconstraintdWim toboatthu "npucial" mooting { 
 Will ho bo good enough to toll tlio« public / ^ , . 
 
 Many will rooognizo the f()ll»)wing aa tho "Synodioal" lan- 
 guago of "Canon InnoH." O.i th3 G )ltoj;o Council niattor it 
 . will be interesting, as ho can spv)ak with authority. " There is 
 no language too forcible, no satire too bitter, and no hand too 
 rough, to tear aside the sugar coating with whi^h thtae gentle- 
 men have dishonorably cout'^d their pill." His proper place 
 would bo the . witness box. 
 
 ■:■■•■'"/■ " 'v. CRONYN. 
 
 Solicitor, Bursar, Seorotary, Chancellor. Xoo many ofhcea 
 for owe individual. 
 
 Antony. (For Brutus, ii an honorable man; __ 
 So are //i£y all,'all Aono/*a6/e men,) » 
 
 
 
\- 
 
 It 
 
 CRITIQUK. 
 
 N. B. Thoio oMMpoio th(Y ju(!M<«aof whom it liui hi'(»n fttatid, 
 Uuiy tttt(tiiiiitf!(i to biHMt (ho dmrnutor of a rlrrgyiiiivii, wIk in thii 
 Church hold* in mtrvrii for iiWuiy ynAfM «>( honoriiMo Hr? ici*, 
 »iul to wrvolc thu pimco hiuI hnpiiimiM of bin fniiiily- Ardxii'A- 
 oon MarMh will b(« juatiftcd hy nil iiirii at upriKhMiunn mikI in- 
 t4;grity,,i|ioul(I htifci>l coiiMtmiiKid to Appfml to Cn^tittni' Court. 
 If ho be not yuiUy his Aoountm will, whon driven, bo ^^ad 
 to fiAy, '*Thin man ini^ht hnvo been ToloMNodf if bi> hml not np- 
 poiilnd to Cji'Hiir." ■■ ^ 
 
 UEVERKND J. B. HICHAHDHON. 
 
 Thin KPntlonian in not a njrnibt>r of ///r (-Miincil, but h© hIiowb 
 hii hand atraiuHt Archd4>aoon Marsh, and ia diniinKHiHlicd 
 (1 ©xtinguiihwl) by ijringing up the roar, Jlo waa Oiori^rtl Sec- 
 retary to the Synod, and ontruntod \tith oonVinunicafionM' nd- 
 droHScd to that, thu nuwt Suprenio EooloHitMtioal body of tho 
 Church within tho Piooubu. It in onrturtud by Arohdoacoii 
 Marah, that uii u numtbur of thu Syaud, tiu aunt Itiia a com- 
 mUnioation for that trody whun it mut, but liko thu othor 
 " special businons ut thu Council, it wua " kupt back." Mr. 
 RichardBon hafl'[)lncod himdulf in an unfortunate puslti.in. Aa 
 tho Socrotar^') and rucoiviuK aa Htich, a coiutnunication for tho 
 Synod, his duty was cloar : no individual, uhutovor liia olliou, 
 should have buen allowed to turn him from thu path of duty. 
 This Kontloman haa boon but two years iu the Diocif), and it 
 is curtain ho did not niurit tho JilHoo on acount .')f length of 
 Sorvioo iu tho Diocoao, whilst Itis uufitnuss in uatablilhol by dis- 
 houostly kuoping back a doquruont beloiiuting to tho Synod. It 
 must bo seen thuroby, that ho was not meroly guilty of dorolio- 
 tion of duty, — not ainiply of showing disroupoot to tho Synod, 
 h^it having rooeived a oomtiiunic.itiou in sacrad trust, ho whs 
 guilty by withholding it, of violating that tru^t, and therefore of 
 
 4 
 
' *fy "• '" 
 
 I 
 
 will III tllM 
 
 Arclulfii- 
 I nikI in- 
 ••' Court. 
 , bo k1ii<) 
 [\ nut A| • 
 
 ho Mhiiwii 
 iiit^uiHhc'd 
 ri^ftl Sec- 
 
 flOHM" ftll- 
 
 ly nf tho 
 •ohdoucoii 
 II tv oohi- 
 tho othor 
 i/' Mr. 
 tim. As 
 m for tho 
 iiH olti^io, 
 of duty. 
 ), find it 
 tingth of 
 '3l by dis- 
 jTiiod. It 
 >f dorolio- 
 e Synod, 
 
 ,, ho WHS 
 
 itrcforo of 
 
 « 
 
 cmTiijifr.. 
 
 N" 
 
 n 
 
 kn offidftl fr»ud, Worojiny HticroUry Ut commit luoh » browh 
 (if trtMt in oimntfction with » dvil institution ho would hu 
 ^immtrily diwuiHW d, i»nd liftblo to progteutioti. If »fl oflicial 
 w»mhi i<m p Imck'witf dtwumont, tho iiimo olrmont «»f ohanictur 
 would •iifllco to kcM»p bftok othi-m. It would bu no oxodpu !<►? 
 Mr. Richaninon to iiiy ho w»n th.» liiwhop'* n«»min©o, or thf>» 
 th« cninniitico for preparinn tho Synod OirouUr hml •b»olvod 
 him ; ni«»«t, if not nil «'f whom, iiumbor with thoio wl|f> now 
 t»i)j«»y • uioiit iinfortuiiftto fiotorii-ty an mouibori of llunm Cnl- 
 l«tKU ^ottooil Theaotof Mr, Uiohanlnon wm on * par with 
 that of aoo^hor dorgynian whf), boiiig appointod a RortHjnoor .cf 
 .votes uiidor tho ballot, loft otFa uiombor who had buou olootej. 
 It would bo woU for thou* Clor^'yinon to rclloot up »n tho inoaH' 
 tngof the toxt of Hcripturo, or bettor atill, to proaoh frotn % 
 for tixpuriunou would aid thoin : 
 
 *' Bo iuro -your flin will find you out.'*. 
 
 It in hanlly c<mcoival>lo that such a stato of things can oiist 
 ill tho (yhurch. Tho only romody will bo found in estimating 
 tho worth <»f men by their tfhararter, and not by their office. 
 
 iJy makin)( tho Hynod indopendimt, and soourinj? to every 
 Clergyman a reunonable living for his wife and family froo fron; 
 undue Episcopal influence, or of parasitical supporters. 
 
 Hy the L-iity proving thoniselvos independent, manly, ChriS' 
 tain mOmbors of the Synod. ' 
 
 tiy tho Synod exercising its right in diaponaing the patronage 
 of the CKurch in connection with the Iliahop. 
 
 Tho patronage belongs to the Synod, and is a^sacred tru"t : 
 it should not bo placed under tho control of any man : if pro* 
 perly administered it can be made to aubaorvo a good purpose ; 
 if abused, it becomoo an Dvil. % 
 
 rl» "1 I 
 
 1 
 
.(' •■ 
 
 14 ' CRItlgtfR. 
 
 U II not limii for tho Hyn<Kl l«> Inlcu up tli« ttifttUtr, aitd itoi 
 Allow M}hm)Ia t<t iiiturforu with thu wtifk of Ui« Churuh. Th« 
 lltlltiiuth Iiii»Iii»«' Heh(M»l !• not nntbr tho JiirMk^tior* i»f Ihu 
 Church, hut a private ^mt«)rpHiii of Dr. lluUmuth ; it hM noth* 
 Ing to do with thu rtdation in whioh h» atAuda to tlitt Churoh am 
 Biihop. Ilowuvur oomniurulAhlu it tuny ho for Aiiy |M}rN4»n !<» 
 etigago in a U'gitiniAto cnlliug, utpvciAlly thut of iKluoAtion, it 
 coaava to \w comuumdahlo whvn it intorfurna with higher 
 dutitta ; hutwotiu thia iiiatitution of a«oular luariting and tho 
 Churoh of Uod thoro ia a inarvolloua diatA}ict), hut tho protuin- 
 ono« givt«n it would acriu to uaurp th« wttrlc «>f tho Holy 
 Mintatry, uiid uiuku thjtt Churvh auhaidiary to ita tnturuata. 
 
 ' Wh< n ft person ia oKoaen to iho offloo w hioh haa Jht ovtr- 
 
 ■ight of tho Churoh, it ia not for him to hcomne ontAuglod with 
 aocular niattcra ; And an incnnui of hotwoiui four and five tlioua 
 and dollara por annuni paid aununlly out of tho TrouMury of tho 
 Churoh, ia to oimhlu hint to duvoto hiuiaolf, not only pliyMicully, 
 but alao niontally, to thu work of tho Churoh. If othura who 
 work in tho Miniittry tiru uxpuctod to givo ull their tiuio and 
 onorgiua to thuir work on auvon or oi^dtt huiidnxl clollarn per 
 annuni— niun who, m culture, attAinuiontH and piuty aro, in 
 many caaua, not a whit hohind atiy ououpaut of thu Kpiicopatu, 
 how much more should hu givo hiuiaulf to Iuh work as a good 
 Boldior of tho Cross, and as an uxampio to othurs. 
 
 During Bishop Oronyn's tint'), wu had not tlasu ditliouUios, 
 but this turrible scandal which has ooinu upon thu Church, is to 
 be traced tu an institution with which Iho Church Iiuh nothing 
 to do. If the high and holy iiituruHts of tho Church of (Jod aro 
 to bo made subservient to a secular school, tho sooner that 
 ■ohool is given up tho bettor. 
 
 Aa for Uuron College where young men are trained to fill 
 
( , 
 
 illtd tioi 
 rck. Thtf 
 i>r« i»f tho 
 linM ii<ith« 
 !litiroh Ml 
 |M}rN4»ii |t> 
 OiilUm, it 
 h higher 
 
 Allll thtt 
 
 > pt'umitf 
 
 ruitf. 
 
 Uio ovtr- 
 kIocI with 
 ivo thoui 
 iry <>( tho 
 
 liyMically, 
 hem who 
 
 tllllO UI1<1 
 
 >ltarH por 
 Y MO, in 
 ;)iiOo|>atu, 
 a a good 
 
 itUoiiUiua, 
 itrch, is to 
 t iiotliiiig 
 •f Ood aro 
 oiior that 
 
 lod to fill 
 
 I 
 
 i'iiru)i?iu ^ I 1$ 
 
 IMJtillutui III thii Church, nud Mliich it thuroby a Church fiiHlIn* 
 tiim, ft nhottld Ik) tuhjtiot lt» thu HyitiMl i for if th« 
 Cbtirch ■ r^rt^tiiitAtivt) btdy la iit>t fit tagovrni ih« Church in 
 nil it* br«iiohi*«, it ihould not uxiiil. 
 
 B€t|>«ot(iig th<i«A nt«tiitKif«i of thu roiiiivil nho hiiv0 f«>me to 
 proitiiiiAiitly ht*for<) (ho ptildi^, mid in n iitntiiiur which hni to 
 MvtiidMlixvd the Church, how cmi tfity lH>^/«iid fm>pgt punioiit 
 to dirttct the ttftudiiiitf t»f iiiornHty tiud rulitfion, whon tht'y^x* 
 yullfd Archdeacon Mon'h im luring iwfii; ^mX yut, «('htl«t hraiid* 
 ing him im u tftcfittr mtd douhlt-mhulti tiiun, thoy tuicit nt» ' 
 honornhli) Mid lugitiniato iitci>ii lu prevent him mitiittcring to » 
 congr 'gation : a tiiiniiitry which cutitiot bu othurwito thiin 
 injurioiift to tlie Chiurchf uud u furthur ■c niid rt l t*t rvUgiou,^ ML 
 tiit'ir clmrgi'ii be Out : if nittim, thun thuy urc. guilty of thu 
 ci'iiiicK likid to hiM chnrgu. I^ut thiwc iiiun go into tliu witiiumi 
 box Aiid tuMtify utuUtr mith, " thu truth »iid notiiing but thu 
 truth," which hoiiuiit, godly niun would bo wilting to do, and 
 Mhiohonly will cUur thcin of guilt in tho public mind. 'l'«^ 
 talk about not doing what in htdy and right for fitar tho Church 
 would iutrcr, nill not do ; pbopb uru tired of Much cant ; they 
 want a religion which in honoHt. Thu Church of Cliiiat iiuilor ! 
 Uod huH Maid, " The gutim of hull hIuUI not pruvail a;{ain«t it/' 
 The iHAuo is cirar. It' Archdeacon Marsh be guilt) of thi) 
 cluugts laid agailiat him, he is not fit to be in hia ponitioii : if 
 the charges be fulee, tlxoao who preferred them are not fit to bo 
 in Ihcim. 
 
 4l 
 
 t ., 
 
 
 § Maiina rut vi't'i tun^ rt p/ti'((hin'l» 
 
/■ 
 
 / 
 
i^'>' 
 
 ' .' \* 
 
 
 
/* 
 
 f 
 
 § 
 
 i''^^ 
 
 
 
 
 
" 
 
 ■ ,, ,.- -" ■-. -. ".V ■ .i - 
 
 .; ■ . - ■' 
 
 ,. ',- , ;. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 ■• ■■■: ^.-..■- 
 
 '* 
 
 • 
 
 '■''■>, ■. 
 
 • 
 
 !■=. 
 
 ;V 
 
 
 
 ■; '. .-; - ■-■■.' •'- •\". ;' 
 
 ■ ■ *■ 
 
 
 ;^ ■ 
 
 
 ;. ■ -m::^- 
 
 1 
 
 • 
 
 " ' 
 
 
 
 
 •" ■■■■■.' 
 
Vs 
 
 \ 
 
 J_ i_ 
 
 %St*"