IMAGE EVALUATION TEST TARGET (MT-3) ?< ^ // :/- £o f/. 1.0 I.I 1.25 |150 2.5 iiiiii 2.0 1.8 1.4 IIIIII.6 %i V5 >^ / S. ^ '/ Photographic Sciences Corporation V (meaning "CON- TINUED"), or the symbol V (meaning "END"), whichever applies. Un des symboles suivants apparaltra sur la darnlAre Image de cheque microfiche, seion le cas: le symbols — ► signifie "A SUiVRE", le symboie V signifie "FIN". Maps, plates, charts, etc., may be filmed at different reduction ratios. Those too large to be entirely included in one exposure are filmed beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to right and top to bottom, as many frames as required. The following diagrams illustrate the method: Les cartes, planches, tableaux, etc., peuvent Atre flimte A des taux de reduction difftrents. Lorsque le document est trop grand pour Atre reprodult en un seul clichA, il est fiimi A psrtir de I'angle supArieur gauche, de gauche A droite, et de haut en bas, en prenant le nombre d'images nAcessaire. Les diagrammes suivants illustrent la mAthode. errata to I palure, on A n 32X 12 3 f 2 3 4 5 6 T CA c> \ V t R Link in the Chain A SHIP CANAL BETWEEN LAKE ST. CLAIR AND LAKE ERIE. hhtboit; \VM. (GRAHAM PRINTING CO. 11^^ TABLE 'OF CONTENTS. Introductory, . . Report of the Deep Water Way Commission. Detroit River a Difficult and Dangerous Route. Is the Construction of a Bridge at Detroit Practicable? Approxiniate Estimates. Compared with other Canals. Rapid Increase of Tonnage and Gain to Commerce, The Canal a Winter Refuge. A Transfer and Coaling Point, Klectrically Lrighted, . Military Advantages, A Link in the Chain. Growth of Canadian Commerce, Report of Chief Engineer, Report of Consulting Engineer, Charter. .... Address at the Cleveland Convention by Jas. Fisher, Q. C, M. P. P., Manitoba. 5 9 II r6 17 19 19 30 22 22 23 ?4 25 32 39 55 MAPS AND PLATES. The Great Lakes, Deep Water Commission Map. Detroit River Route, . Canal Bridges, Topographical Map, I'AliK • • 5 Opposite page lO 11 (t 3' It u 3« 54 95" IXTKODIXTOKV Traffic on the Gkfat Lakhs. I'ACiK 5 lO 3' 3« 54 When the I'Vench voyajj^eurs ])a(lie, has a narrow neck, and although the present course around it is over 92 miles, the distance across this neck is but a little over 13 miles, making the actual distance to be saved by a canal across this neck 79 miles. The cost of excavating such a canal would be comi)aratively small, as the land is level east and west, and rises gradually from a low marsh on the borders of Lake St. Clair to about 50 feet at Lake Erie, excepting a narrow sand ridge just north of the lake which rises about eighteen feet higher. It has been proved by numerous auger borings that the stratum of blue clay which forms the greater portion of this peninsula is for the whole dis- tance across from one hundred to one hundred and thirty feet in thickness, without rock or b(nilders. ( )nly earth excavation therefore will be needed. The canal will be in direct continuation of the course from the end of the cut at the St. Clair l-'lats to its entrance. It will be crossed by four existing railroads, which will necessitate that number of drawbridges, and three other bridges will be retpiired by connnon roads. As the difTerence in level between the two lakes is only three feet, no locks will be retpured. but there will be a guanl gate at the St. Clair end. for use during construction, and after- wards when repairs are necessary. The entrance from Lake St. Clair is shallow, and to obtain a 21 -foot channel through the lake, three miles of dredging will be necessary. Here also the material is blue clay. At the Lake Erie end less than half a mile of dredg- ing will be needed to reach deep water. At this enil it is proposed to construct a harbor of refuge, which has long been needed, so that vessels may find jjrotcction from the storms of Lake ICrie at all times. This canal will be of the p^reatest benefit to navijjators. for by usin^r it they will not only avoid the (Ianjj;ero»is and difficult passage of the Detroit River, and the islands and shoals at the west end of Lake ICrie. but they will also actually save from fifteen to twenty hours in the round trip. The time occupied by the larger freight vessels in the trip from i'.uffalo to Chicago or Duluth and return is from ten to twelve days, and they make about 20 trips in a season. \ essels of aver- age speed would save 300 hours in a season by this shorter route, and thus be able to make an additional trip. Ki:i'()Ui" oi" i)i-:i:i' waii-.k'W.w com mission. J.\N1-AKY, iHc;;. Ill iXt^) C'onmTss passi'il an act autlinriziii!^ tlu' IVcsitk-nt tu appoint .' coniniission of tlinr persons, who shonhl nu'i't with a similar ooininission to ho appointi-d l»y tlu' ( ioviTnor-( ii'tu'ral of tanatla, to consi^liT and n-port npon tlu- f«.'asil)ility of a 5;. as fnr- nishecl hy Lient. J. I'.. I'avananj^h. Corps of Limincers. ['. .S. A. ( Lt.tter of l'"el)rnary il, |K<>(), Detroit, .\iiih.), in comparison witli Lake l'"rie for the same periocl. The mean elevation of L.ike h'rie for June and July, iH<)5, was .vi.*^)! feet above mean title at New ^'ork City, or ().J6 foot above standard low water. VUv standanl low water slope for the Detroit River was found by sub- tracting' o.jG foot from the .i;auf.;e readings. The mean i^aiis^e readin}.js and the standard low water are ^j^iveii in the following table: 10 AFfaii (Jaiij^c Staiidan! Koadiiijr. June Low- Locality, and July. i8(>5. Water. Gros:;e Pointc, Lake St. Clair 574.5^ S74-2t'^ '^^'t'*"'^ 574-IO 57.VX4 ''•"t-nton 5;2.8r) 572.60 ^•''""altar 57i.«o 571.54 Lake Erie, Cleveland 57' -61 57 '-^t The maps and profiles on a reduced scale of the St. Clair and l'>ie Ship Canal illustrate the proposed channel fcr shorienin.i;- the distance on the throuj^h route and avoidin.i^ the difficulties in the navig-ation of the Detroit River and the west end of Lake- Erie. They were compiled from the followiii!:; material: Sketch (with profile) of the Detroit River pas.saj,^' .'ind the St. Clair and Erie .Ship Canal, by D. I'arrand Henry, Chief Engineer. Chart of Lake St Clair, by C S. Lake Survey. Chart of Lakes Erie and Ontario, hv 1 Ivdro^rapliic ( )rfice. U. S. N." . ., .> ■ ■r- -' 'f ,.*'' - 4 " K^mm Pi^UjyJkt^ MTmUM'C^ g^^TCH MAP^AND PROp^^^ SAIMT CLAIR AND ERIE SHIP CANAL from dais, liy D. FARRAND HENRY Tr^actcr anA Chief Engineer SCAUCB H«rl*enUl: statute MilM Vertical: Feet J»»/g. 7fttf» IVmim^emmmU^.mJUjBmmt, 11 DKTkOlT RIVKR A Dll'FIClLT AND I)A.\(;I<:K(JLS kOLTK. The Detroit River, or more ])roperly the straits coiineetinjj^ Lakes St. Clair and lirie, althouj^h tortuous and full of islands, was of sufficient depth for navigation l)y the early vessels which followed the canoes and hatteaus, and wliich did not draw to exceed y feet; but the current was swift, and when the wind was with it, sail vessels could not beat up stream, and often waited for days at certain bends, nota])ly Sandwich Point, just below Detroit, for a favorable wind. Th-- ■ never attempted to run the crooked and narrow channels ■ nie;htfall, and it was no uncommon sig^ht to see an hundrvjci sail anchored below a bend, waiting for wind or daylight. When steam supplanted sails, time became more of an object, and many lighthouses were built to aid in passing the more dan- gerous j)laces, and ranges established, so that the channels could be run by night or day. Xor do the shoals and narrow i)assages comprise all of the dangers to navigation on this river. At Detroit, where it is very deep and half a mile wide, several lines of ferries, both for the transfer of pas.sengers and of cars, are constantly crossing. There are excursion l)oats to tlie park, islands and other resorts; boats engaged in local traffic between the city and near-by towns; while the river is dotted with yachts of all descriptions and small boats without number, to avoid all of which often taxes the sea- manship and nerve of the best cai)tains on the through craft, espe- cially when the steamers have one or more barges in tow. As the channels between the other Lakes were deepened to accommodate the growing traffic, which called for vessels of deeper draft, the water in many reaches was found scant, and improvements were demanded, and from time to time nuich work lias been done on the river and is still in ])rogress. 'I'he folio wing- table shows the crookedness of this route. 12 TABLE OF COURSES AND DISTANCES Dktkoit Rivr.R Rj)i tk kkom iiik Lowkk T.roiiT at tiik St. Ci.aik Ki.ATs n» Oi'i'o.siTK TIIK Km) ok tiik Siiii- Canai. In Lakk Krik. ColKSK TO nKARI\(;s, DiSTANC K, Points. , Mtr.Ks. Grosse Pte. Slioal S. \V Windmill Point \V. S. \V.... Helk' Isle Lifj;ht .S. \V. J^ .S.. Along Helle Ish- \V. S. \V.... Opposite Detroit \V. ■*, S \V. S. VV.... " " S. W. 1.. W Ri •r Roiif:;c S. \V. I)v S. S. \V. l)y S. ■■', S. .S. W. '., S Hi'iul of Ki<:;liiiiij; Isliiiui... (jrassy Islaiul S. ■*, V. Wvaiulolie S. W. l)v W. i, \V. Mammy juily Kifjlit South Head of Grosse Isle S. W. Jj .S.. Opposite River Caiiiird Lit s. s. !•: Stony Islanil s. hv ¥. Lime Kiln S. S. K S. I)v K Kiln Crossinji; Soiitl I S. S. \V Opposite Amherstlmrfjli S. liv K. Jy K Alonp: Hois Hlanc Islaiul S. J, W S. l)y K S. \V l)v S. 1., S. S. I., W Opjjosite Mar Point S. W Bar Point Six S. :t, S.. MIS s !■■ S. I.v hv S. l'. S.. '., S. Entrance to Li Opposite Colli Pte. Pelt Eiitr Total '?'•-• ^'^^ I '.J -I ter Reef K. S. K t '4 JO ei- '. K. hy S. 1 K. N. K.. .J S e Ship Canal ^ — From the lower liffht St. Clair Flats throiifih the Shiji Canal to deej) water, Lake Krie, S. I"). '.4 S.. ^j miles. 13 Tlic (Irossc Pointc slioal at the t'litraticc to tlu- river in Lake St. Clair is a sand and mud flat, fonncd by deposition of silt from the St. Clair River and the "l'"lats," and is constantly increasiiifj. The head of i'elle Isle is a boulder flat, only avoided by a shaq) turn at Windmill Point, and another at the head of the islaiul. At Sandwich Point are two sharp turns, and along I'ijjfhting^ Island the channel is narrow and tortuous. Near Grosse Isle are Ikdlards reef and Stony Island, both rocky shoals. Then conies the Lime Kiln crossing, long a terror to vessel men, and not much better even now that a cut has been made through it. h'or, though the chamiel is 400 feet wide, there is a bend at each end, and a swift current through it. The narrow channel near llois lUanc Island and the shoals near liar Point follow, and then Lake Lrie is entered, where we find Colchester reef and the shoals between I'oint Pelee and Pelee Island on the course to P.ufifalo and Cleveland, and a little to the south are the reefs around the I len and Chickens and other groU])s of islands. .'Mthough nuich work has been done towards deepening these shoals, still the narrow channels formed are very dangerous, and the long steamers now being built (many much over 400 feet in length) find the abrupt turns difficult to make, especially at night, when they have to run by lighted ranges, and accidents often occur when vessels are meeting or jjassing in the narrow channels. Much time i^ also lost, as they are obliged to run under check through a large jjart of the river. After the improvements? now in progress are completed, giving a 21 -foot diamiel through Cnited States waters, there will still remain the shoals at the mouth of the river, which will have to be deepened by the Cana- dian (iovernment. being entirely in its territory, and even when the passage of the river is made as ])erfect as possible it will still be hazardous and difficult to navigate and not to be compared with the straight and short route through the canal. X'essels ground on the shoals every year, causing nnich delay to the traffic and damage to themselves. In i8(;3 a vessel struck the rocky sides at the Lime Kiln cn)ss- ing and sunk. Another following was drawn to her by the cur- rent, and swinging around, blocked the passage for 48 hours. It was estimated that the cost of detention and repairs that vear amounted to nearlv $2,000,000. In 181)4 the "Northwest," a 14 large passenger steamer, struck on one of the shoals near Bar I'oint. and remained there for over twenty hours. In 1895 a record was kept for ahout two months of the acci- dents occurrinji^ in this passaj^e. the following being a copy: At Grosse Pointe. Sept. 5 — Str. Kearsarge and Sch. Juniata. 16 — Str. City of Berlin. 19 — Whalehack \'o. 117. 22 — Str. I'Vontenac. 23 — Schr. Howgood. Oct. 5— Str. Bruce. 7— Str. W. 15. Morley. 1 1 — Barge Kitty l'"al)er and consort; Str. Lachlan. I 1 — Strs. Pontiac and Thompson (whalehack). 11) — l>arges Whitney and Wayne. Str. Rugel. 20 — Str. Tacoma and Sch. Parker. 24 — Str. Cleo. W. Williams. At Head of Belle Isle. Sept. 9 — Str. Jas. I'ish. • At Mghting Island. Sept. 5 — Str. Keystone. At Lime Kiln Crossing. Sept. 21 — Str. Adriatic. 30 — Str. flelen and Str. ( )gdens1)urg. At Ballards Reef. Oct. 22 — Strs. Waldo and Avery. 25 — Strs. Simon G. Murphy and Sam Magee. At Amhcrsthurg. Sept. 20 — Str. R. P. Fitzgerald. 15 At Bar Point, Sept. 3 — Str. Cofiinburg. 17 — Str. City of X't'iiict'. 24 — Str. keuheii Doud. 28 — iJar^c City of Cleveland. At Colchester Reef. Oct. 22 — Str. \'ega. Str. Escanaba. At Point Pelee. Sept. 25 — Str. Topeka. Oct. 16 — Sell. C. L.Johnson. Some of the above were only detained a short time, while others were not f^ot off for one or more days, and many had to be dcjcked before they could ccjntinue their trip. The cost to vessels and insurance companies durinj^ these two months was not ascertained, but it nuist have been very heavy. Many other vessels were detained and lost much time in slowly picking their way past the vessels aground, often having to come to anchor until the latter could be lightened off. Another important point for consideration is the change in the water level at the mouth of thej river due to the force and direction of the wind. We have no continuous records at that point, but we know that an easterly wind often so raises the water in the trumpet-sha])ed mouth of the river that tlie current opposite Detroit is reversed, with apparently nearly as strong a flow as the natural current, which indicates a rise of the water level at the mouth of four or five feet. In the same manner a westerly wind depresses the level at this Mnnt, though not to the same degree. At lUiffalo, at the other end of Lake Erie, where the conditions are somewhat similar, the recorded extreme difference between high and low water is thirteen feet, but as the periodical fluctua- tions, extending through a series of years, amounts to four or five feet, the local change, due mainly to the direction of the wind, may be taken at eight or nine feet. We can, therefore, safely i i 16 c'Stiniatc that the (k'i)R'Ssinn of thi water k-vcl .oi 1,737 *-'• y^li^- excavation canal $3,802,347 488,000 c. yds., excavation gars i.jy,6oo 2,066,722 c. yds., dredging canal 310,008 1.408,600 c. yds., dredging Lake St. Clair. . 210,290 406,000 c. yds., dredging Lake Erie 60,900 $4,481,145 Harbor, Lake I<:rit'. cril). 7cxj feet, at $50. , . $.^5.(xx) picTs. 3.700 fc'ct. at $16 5,^,j(xj Docks at jfars and hridj^cs So.ooo Koad alonj,'^ canal. 10 miles io.(xxj 4 railroad hrid^'-es. stipcrstriK-ttirc Sso.otx) piers and abutments 60,000 1 lO.OOlJ 3 liij,dnvay bridjj^es. superstructure $27,000 piers and abutments 23,000 5o,o(X) Cluard j,rate at north end 61 ,(xx) IClectric 1 Mant. Lamps and wiring'- $8.o(X) Power house, euf^ines, etc lo.^oo 1 )vnani( is 3.000 Conductor, 18 miles 42.000 7 bridge motors iH.cxxd 81.500 Land damages, i .600 acres at $50 Ho.ooo luigineering and contingencies, 10 per cent 501.784 $5.5i().62(; THE LVCOME. The tolls being placed at the proposed rate of three cents i)er registered ton. would amount to $660,000 for the 22.cxx),ooo tons assumed to pass thnntgh the canal. Toll on 22,000,000 tons, at 3c $660,000 Interest on $8,000,000 bonds at 5 per cent $400,000 ( )perating expenses 50,000 Maintenance 50,000 500,000 Net income . .' $160,000 Equal to 8. per cent on $2,000,000, the amount of the Canal Company's capital stock. 19 COM I 'A Ri: I) WITH ()THi:r f.wAi.s. rill- St. Clair and ICric Shi)) Canal will he 72 firt \vic) per ton. The L'orinth Canal is 37 miles lonjf, with a hottom width of 72 feet, and a depth of 26 1-4 feet, and cost .S4.{)57,(xx) per mile. The .\ortli Sea and I'laltic Canal has a lenjj^th of 61 1-2 miles (I its prism is such that a war vessel havinj.^ a width of 7 J feet d drawinjj^ 26 feet can safely pass throuj.jli. It cost $f) 10.^)88 ])er mile. The N'orth Holland Canal is 16 miles lonjj. with a depth of 23 feet. It has a hottom width of Hi) feet and at the surface 1S7 feet. It cost nearly $i.cxxj.o, IJ. 14 and now K) feet. When, therefore, the 21-foot deep water channel is completed, the increase will be more raj. id than durinj^" past years. 'rhron,!.;h the I )etroit River passes almost the entire traffic of the lakes, the only notable e,\cei)tion b.'inj^- that between Lake Superior and the ports on Lake .Michi,y;an. In iS()() the tonnajj^e retfisterec 1 at .\ merican ])orts passing' throu h the Detroit River both ways was Ji .r)K4.(X)() tons, in iSc)^ it was J^.oi)!.''^!^") tons, and in 1X1)3 26. iO^.och) tons. In i(S()(j this will ci'rtainb increase to _?().( )(X).( XX) tons. ( )f this tonnage about one-tenth enti-rs and clears at ihe ])ort of l)(.'troit. so tliat it will be well within bounds to assumi' that 2().(xx),(H)() t; ns will prefer to pass tlu-oujuh the canal, rather than take the difficult and danj^crous mute throui^h tiie river, liut the additional tri]) whicli the use of the canal will allow will add about ten ])er cent to this tonnaiie. and as the canal can be coni- l)leted and in operation within two years from the time the work- is connnenced. we may safel\ estimate that the registered toii- naiL^e which will then pass throuj^h the canal will amount to at least 22.ooo.O(X) tons. .\s the carr\ iiu ca pacily of the lakt' steaim-rs is jj^enerally liftv percent, in excess of thi'ir re,L;istered tonna^^v, and as on the other hand the up loads are lighter than the down, it will be fair to assume that tlu' freight in l>otli directions is e(|ual to the les^is- tered tomiaj.;e. The average freit^lit charj^es amount to nine- tenths of a mill per t mill per ton-iiiilc $1 ,5(')4.j(X) Toll oil 22,(XT(i.o, and purchasers for all sorts of L^'irden ami farm pro(hu-e. .Maimfaclories would also be estal)lisheo that of the cost of shipment from Duluth to Liverpool about i>ue-half is paid between lUiffalo and New N'ork. This canal is a very important link in the direct route, and when constructed a Canadian Heet can be loaded with the produce of that ^reat Northwest territory at Port .Arthur, and carr\ it directly throujLih to Montreal without leavinj;' Canadian watt'rs, and the farnuT would receive the difference in frei.n'ht charj^es, for the price lie i^ets is the Liverpool price less the cost of trau'-port. Lven now this canal would be of j^reat benefit to C'anadiau shipping;', for nearly all such vessels have to pass throu,y;h tlie Detroit River, there beiuL;- only two or three lines of a few steamers on the Cpper Lakes. AS A CAR FKRRY ROIJTK. al. and •y IC'S. lilt is .1 a •oal ut;li lUT lu- ll i\\ f. )r Vt-T, tlu' There are many points on opposite sides of the lakes where railroad lines converge, where the distance across is much shorter and easier than following the railroad lines around the shore. Steamer lines have been established at many of these points to transport passengers and perishable freight, but the cost of unloading and loading heavy freight is more than the saving in railroad rates. Of late years, however, car ferries have been put on some of these routes, so that all freight can be transported without break- ing bulk, and passengers do not have to change cars. The first of these lines was established about ihirty years ago, at Detroit, and in winter the ferries force a passage through the ice without very much detention. Then a line was put on at the Straits of Mackinac, where they are about five miles wide. Generally the winter crossing is regularly made, but in exceptional seasons the ice is broken up by the wind and the cakes so piled on each other that for a time- no boat can force its way through. Later lines were established on Lake Michigan, and although they often have great difficulty in forcing their way through the ice floes, which are moved by the wind from one part of the lake to another, they have been (juite successful. Last year a line was established on Lake Ivrie, from Port Dover, Canada, to ports on the south shore. This line is located too far east, and, .so far, has had little success as a winter route. The more westerly portion of the lake is, however, admirably adapted for a car ferry route. For the first ,^o miles east of the Detroit river the lake is shoal and studded with islands Beyond this it is over 50 miles wide, and much deeper. The ice floes, which are formed in shallow water and carried out into the open lake by the wind, are driven l)y an easterly wind to and among the islands, and held fast, so that when the wind changes to the west only so much of the ice as can break away from the islands is carried into the open lake. As the ])revailing winds during the winter are westerly, there is almost always oiieii water for many miles east of the islands, and the great bulk of the ice is forced into the narrower eastern end of the lake. Thus a winter passage across this jwrtion of the lake is very feasible, as it would be only necessar\' to keep an open passage through the shore ice. A car ferry, therefore, between, say Cleveland and the canal, would make the passage almost as easily in winter as in summer. r^ 25 KKi'oRT oi.-ciiiKi.- I':\(;i\i.:kk. St Ci.air axd Krik Ship C \ai. 'I'o the IVfsident and Directors St. Clair and l-ric Sliip (.'anal. jannary i^tli, i,S(/). (icntlcnion: Fifty u.a,sa«„ vc.sds „„ ,|,, i,,K-.s „,,, .,„,„ „„, ,„„ „„.,.,, •■< f-. .In,f,. s„ ,l,a, „,,, ,,a,| li„u. ,n,„l,U. i„ passing- ,l,n,„„l, ' ': ""■" '■""""■""« l-'^-^' I-:'-"- »i.l. Ih. .„.|,c.r laK.s. Sailin,. .« Is uc-a. s„„K.„„K.s .u-arlv a „„„„l, ,„aki„,. „,.. ,„„ ,,.,„„ I."tfal„ „, I Incasfu, a,„l sU.aMUTs ..fu-n i™ ,lavs ,„■ ,„.„■, 1,,,, i, ;;;»-■- Into a. o,,,,,,..,i,„,,H,, ,,,,„,,,,,,,, ;,,,,^^.,,^_,,; <)i tlU' lony;- trip. ' Then i;uftdo.acvdand.anclI).tr..it were little nn.^^ a«cs, an.l Unca,., only a nnlitary post, the first fnrrous uere e^,, tnrne n, the fe^ \\u Ith of Lake Supenor haar I'oint shoals, nnich dreaded by navij^ators. The western end of Lake ICrie contains many islands, near and amont;" which are shoals, the last one on our jjro.y'ress east beinjjf between I'oint I'elee and an island of the sanu' name, and throu.Q;h this i)assa,u:e all the eastern bountl vessels have to pass. 27 St. Clair and Kkik Shii' Canai, X (iw, It IS to avoid a II tl K- (lanu'tTs ot tins route, as woll as to shorten the (hstancc. that the St. Clair and I'.rie Ship Lanal is projected. Starting' from the southeastern corner of Lake St. Clair, it crosses the peninsula and enters Lake ICrie 26 miles east of I'oint IVlee, the last of the ie. 32 miles, a savinq' in distance of 7<) miles. As steam- ers have to run under check throujj;-h part of the river, the fastest cannot averaj^e over ten miles an hour, and as they would make about five miles an hour throuj.i[h the canal, the savin.y in time for the fast steamers would be six and a half hotu's, or thirteen hours for the rounie ports. As the jjfain of one or two trips a season would add nearly 10 per cent to the tonnajj^e jjassinjj;' Detroit, or say j,cxxj.(xxj tons, and as there will he a certain increase before the canal is finished, it is safe to say that 22.o(X).ooo rej^istered tons will pass throut^h the canal in a season. This does not include the Canadian tonnage. .\s lake vessels, when loaded, carry about 50 j)er cent more than their rej^jistered tonnage, we can consideV the above tonnaj;e as the amount of frei}.,dit carried, and as the saving of distance was shown to be about 79 mik's. the ton miles saved would be 1 .73S.(XX),ooo. The avera,y;e freijLj;ht rate on the lakes is estimated at o.o4--'^' 'i^ the net savinjj;' for the sea.son, app(jrtioned pro rata anionjj;' the different vessels. To this must be added the profit on the e.xtra trij), or trips, given in the last section, so that there would seem to be a strong financial inducement to use the canal, liesides, the insur- ce rates on such vessels would doubtless be lowered, as those an m coinpaiiii's would savt- the losses on tin- shoals of tlu" Detroit Kivtr route. "In these times of close eompetitiou the slij^litest ehaiij^e in the cost of transi)ortation may revolutionize trade.' Fl'TlRE OK THK CaN.\L. The eonmieree of the ( ireat Lakes has increased with wonder- ful rapidity in the past few years, (ieneral ( ). .\1. I'oe. in a rejjort on the deep water channel in iS()i, speakinj.,^ of this c<»mmerce. says: "( live it a chamiel practicall\- na\i}4ai)le on a ilraft of jo feet, and it needs no prophet to ])re(lict a wonderful j^rowth, but only a prophet could tell its de^jfree. I'or nearly .^5 years 1 liave watched this increase, hut neither I, nor anyone else within my knowlediji^e, has been able to expand in ideas at the same rate. The wildest expectations of one year seem absurdly tame the next." i'his is largely due to the growth of the (ireat West, but more to the improvement in the connectin.i; rivers. h'very increase in depth has been followed by a ^reat increase in toiuiaj4;e and the ccjustruction of larj^er vessels. .Nearly all of the newer craft rival ocean vessels in size. A four hundred-footer is no longer a wonder, for a larjj^e number are now far beyond that mark. In the past ten years the re,tjistered toimajje ])assinj.j throuj^'h the Detroit River has increased over 44 per cent, and if ("on^'ress does not withhold the appro])riations, in two or three years the Dee]) Water Channel of 21 feet will be completed. This will j^ive a ji^reat impetus to vessel buildinjj^, and it would hardly be a.stonishin^-. in view of the past, if ten years hence 40,- (xx),(xx) registered tons were passin}.^ Detroit either throuj.,di the river or the canal. The maj^nitude of the lake commerce is almost unknown, even to those luost interested. The ton-mileajj^e of the lakes is over one-(|uartcr of the ton-mileage ol all the railroads of the L'nited States. The tonnaj.je of the lakes is one-third the amount of all the other tonnage of the United States, both coastwise on both sides of the continent, and foreign. The amount passing through the Detroit River in the season of 8 months is between three and four tiiues greater than that passing through the Suez Canal in if J le 11 :r k\ in HKETen or THE Detroit river passage STCUIR^^oERiESHIPCAf ^ ^ N, H._Th(" (lotted MneK rHows route of v 0"' pi' ^-; -^ \ H SKETCH OFTBfi \ > \ 1 ^ FROIT RIVER P>\SSAGE ^iR'*o Erie Ship Canal (loltfd lines shown rouU' of vpkkcIs 15' V ^ ^ ^ ^ ^% % •:.\' 31 the whole year. It is {h)uhle the entrances and clearances of the port of New York, and exceeds the combined entrances and clear- ances of the ports of Liverpool and London. 1 will not repeat my estimates of cost here — sufifice to sav that I consider them ample for the proper construction of the canal, and that the gross income of $660,000 given above will pav the interest on the $8,000,000 bonds, or $400,000, allow $100,000 for maintenance and repairs, and leave a net income of $160,000 a year. 1 am, Yours respectfully, D. FARRAXD HEXRY, Member Am. Soc. C. E., Chief Engineer. 82 REPORT OF CONSTRUCTING ENGINEER. Report of John Bogart, C E. Member Atnerican Society of Civil Engineers, etc. November ist, 1895. JOHN BOGART, Civil Engineer. 50 Wall St., New York. In accordance witli our recjuest, I have visited and inspected the location of the proposed St. Clair and Erie Ship Canal for conecting Lake Erie and Lake St. Clair. I was accompanied by Henry A. Olney, Es{|., and D. l-'arrand Henry, Es(|., C. E. With nie also was Herbert Stewart. Es(|., the well-known cie, work upon which is now in ])rogress by the I'nited States government, in order to secure a de])th of 21 feet and a width of 800 feet. I'rom the mtnith of the Detroit River, at the western end of Lake Erie, the greater portion of the traffic passes through Lake Erie, either to lUiffalo or the west end of the Wel- land Canal ; and in the latter case, through the Welland Canal to Lake Ontario and by the St. Lawrence River to Montreal, Que- bec, and the tide-water of the Atlantic ( )cean. The traffic which goes to liuflfalo is there transferred either to railways or to the boats in the l'>ie Canal, in either case reaching tide-water of the Atlantic by \ew York or other of the ports of the L'nited States. Time and Distance Saved. The proposed canal will shorten the distance for all this traffic seventy-nine iji)) miles, and will give straight and direct sailing courses for thirty-two miles in it and in Lake St. Clair, as com- pared with 1 1 1 u'.iles, the greater portion of which is in a difficult and tortuous chamiel and the ra])id current of the Detroit River. The saving in time will thus probably be considerably greater than the saving in distance. This new channel of commerce would be available for and valuable to all of the traffic of the ( jreat Lakes going either easterly or westerly, except that portion which would have freight for the City of Detroit, or ports on the Detroit 84 River, and the statistics show that not more than ten per cent, of the total traffic tonches at ports on the Detroit River. In other words, ninety per cent, of the traffic is through business which could be more economically carried through the St. Clair and Erie Ship Canal. ToK.iAGE Passing Through the Detroit River. The amount of this lousiness for a series of years since 1880, is shown by the following statement of the number of vessels ajid the tonnage, exclusive of Canadian vessels clearing from Can- adian p> Its, ,:!:ch passed through the Detroit River; this is compiled tio u !u- oflicial returns of the United States govern- ment officers: Year>. V. of Vessels. Registered Tonnage. 1880 ;^\j2i 20,235,249 1881 35,888 17,572,240 1882 35,199 17,872,182 1883 40.385 17,695,174 1884 38,742 18,045.949 1885 34,921 16,777,826 1886 38,261 18,968.065 1887 38,125 18,864,250 1888 31.404 19,099.060 1899 32-415 19.646,000 1890 35,640 21,684.000 1891 34.-25I 22.160.000 1892 33,860 24,785.000 1893 33,165 23,o<;i,889 1894 34,800 26,120,000 This latter is double the entrances and clearances at the Port of New York, exceeds the combined entrances and clearances of the great seaports of London and Liverpool, and is about three times the tonnage passing through the Suez Canal. The proposed canal will have ample capacity to accommodate more than this business, and this business is substantially concen- trated in the months during which the navigation of the canal 35 would be free from ice; in fact, a very small proportion of the through traffic between the West and the East is carried diiring the severe winter months, because during those months neither the Erie Canal nor the Canadian canals can be operated on account of obstruction bv ice. No Lockage Necessary. In this proposed canal there will be no locks. It is intended that a guard-gate shall be placed at the northern entrance t(j tho canal as a precaution, but the difference of elevation between Lake St. Clair and Lake Erie being only three feet there would be no objectionable current through the length of this canal. The guard-gate is provided for, however, both for the reason above stated and in accordance with the law of the Dominion. It is intended to provide for electric lighting of the entire length of the canal, so that vessels can pass in either direction, both day and night; and the width and (le])th give am])le room for such continuous passage. The capacity to take care of all possible traffic is undoubted. The canal lies entirely within the Province of Ontario, Domin- ion of Canada, and there are therefore no international complica- tions to be anticipated in connection with its use. I am informed that the laws which have been enacted in Canada in connection with this enter])rise provide every safeguard for its uno])structed use. Topographical Features. I have made a careful personal examination along the whole line of the proposed canal and find that the maps and profiles submitted by the officers of the comi)any correctly show the physical features. The distance between the waters of the two lakes, as shown on the map and profile, is 70,872 feet, or nearly 13 423-ioooth miles. The ptans propose dredging in Lake St. Clair 23.700 feet (about 4 488-ioooth miles) in addition to the above. The deep water oi Lake Erie is- reached 1,740 feet (about 3-ioth mile) from the shore. The total length of the works of excavatit)n and dredging will then be about 18 211-ioooth miles. The land on the hne of the canal is at the level of the water of the lake at the Lake St. Clair end of the canal. The surface then rises j^radually and with much regularity to within a short dis- tance of Lake Erie, where it attains a niaxinnini elevation of about 60 feet a])(jve the waters of Lake St. Clair. The depth of the water in the canal beinj^r 21 feet, the maximum depth of excavation will thus he 81 feet at the highest point, near Lake Erie. The land terminates at Lake Erie in a high, steep blufT, which seems to have withstood the elements for many years, maintaining this steep slope. The plans propose that the excavated material shall (except at the extreme ends of the canal) be jiiled on either side of the excavation in synmietrical embankments. The charter of the canal ]>ermits the ac(|uirement of land to the width of i.ooo feet. Witii this width .secured, the length to which the excavated ma- terial is to be carried is thus fairly defined. At the Lake l'>ie end of the canal, where, for a short distance, the excavation is very deep, the Engineer of the canal considers it might be more economical to load the material into vessels and dum]i it into deep water, which occurs here not very far from the shore. The excavation of al)()Ut 4 miles at the St. Clair end is designed to be made bv dredging, and the material to be carried out to dee]) water. h'our lines of railway cross the line of the proposed canal. Draw-bridges nuist be provided for each. The maps also show a num])er of roads crossing the line of the canal. Provision is made in the estimates for sufficient bridges for these roads. Proposed Pl.\ns ok Canal. At the Lake h's'w end the plans show a small harbor, or basin, 1,900 feet long and 600 feet in width, ft)rmed by timber crib work and end)ankment from the canal excavatic^n. 1 think the canal can be constructed in general accowlance with the plans presented. They provide for a channel from lake to lake, with a width at bottom of 72 feet, and a depth of water of 21 feet. The slope of the banks to four feet above the water line is 2 to i . Above this there is a level berme of 3 feet in width 37 on bf)th sides of the canal, and the excavation is then continued on n slope of one and one-half horizontal to one vertical, uj) to the surface of the ground. T have considered the various items of an estimate of cost for this con.struction and have included in such estimate land dam- ajT^es. hridses, both for the railroads and common roads, guard- gates, bank ])rotection. dredging in both Lake St. Clair and Lake Erie, a small harbor at the Lake Erie end of the canal, the exca- vation of the canal, and a reasonable amount for contingencies. In my opinion the sum of $5,800,000 will construct the canal and its bridges and i)Ut the work in condition for operation and for innnediate use by all the commerce of the (Ireat Lakes. Advantage ok a Direct Course- The total lengdi of the canal from Lakr> St. Clair to Lake l*>ie will be 14 miles, and there will be, in addition, 4 miles of dredg- ing, most of which will be in Lake St. Clair; tlie total length of the work under consideration is thus 18 miles. In the use of this artificial channel the vessels will leave the present course of navigation at a ])oint in Lake St. Clair 18 miles northerly from the southern shore of that lake, at the point of entrance into the canal. The distance from this point of depar- ture from the present course of navigation to a point in Lake Erie, which is 200 miles from the City of lUiffalo, will be 32 miles. The distance from the same point of departure by way of Lake St. Clair, the Detroit River and the western jjortion of Lake Erie to a point also 200 miles from the City of iUiffalo. will be 1 1 1 miles. The actual saving in distance is therefore, as has been above .stateie. Referring more ])articularly to the engineering features of this undertaking. I have to say iti conclusion, that the i)roject is entirely feasible, that I believe that the work can be done for the amount estimated, and that the canal and its approaches, thus 88 constructed, will provide ample, safe a.id cfftrtual means of transit for eonnnerce. and tl.at the annual cost of maintenance will be small. I enclose herewith maps which show the (ireat Lakes and their connection with tide-water, both through the Dominion of Can- ada and through the I'nited States, and also the line of the canal, and of the navigation through the lakes and the Detroit River which is now ftjllowed. I have the honor to be, \ery respectfully. (Signed) JC)H\ P.OGART. Consulting Engineer. il ^= ^^Ze vcct toTV ^ iik-> W'wm r/Z/POUG// J?. /p. n/?/IWSf'y9N Sr Cl j^//? & £/?/£ S///P C/iN/ii — /SfccUje ^j"= /-O' -^JSZevcLtto mssusimsi •^JJZe vcLttoTi^ — ScccZe ^g-/'0"— ^•//rJiU vsac 30-0' * i *a«ga^ig'.^-!t^i.--v^jiygie»^ wmmm^9>^'*>''''-*^*»ji^''^^ Lj ;.j .J ij Sr.CA/J//F & £/?/£ S/^/P C/JNML -^ SfiaZeJ6s-/-0'=- An Act 1 WHE incorpor; hereinaft the said vice and ada, dec^ I. Tl "canal c requires, of the c Act; (a.) in this i (b.) ships, passing lakes ( ic.) wares, passing 2. hereb\ 3- Michi of Or C. Bi and ( togetl pany poratj CotnJ 39 An Act to Incorporate the St. Clair and Erie Ship Canal Com- pany. WHEREAS, a petition has been presented praying' for the incorporation of a company for the pnrposes and with the powers hereinafter set forth, and it is expedient to grant the i)rayer of the said petition: Therefore Her Majesty, by and with the ad- vice and consent of the Senate and House of Commons of Can- ada, declares and enacts as follows: — 1. The word "canal" wherever used in this Act shall mean "canal or navigation," and shall, unless the context (Otherwise requires, include every kind of work necessary or done in respect of the canal for the purpose of carr\'ing out the objects of this Act; (a.) The word "land" wherever used in The Raihavy Act or in this Act, shall include land covered or partly covered by water; (b.) The word "vessel" shall mean and include any steam- ships, boats or craft, barges, boats, rafts, or vessels navigating or passing through the canal hereby authorized, or l)lying UjKjn the lakes or rivers connecting therewith ; (c.) The word "goods" shall mean and include any goods, wares, merchandise and connnodities of whatsoever description passing through the canal hereby authorized. 2. The works hereinafter authorized to be constructed are hereby declared to be works for the general advantage of Canada. 3. I). I''arrand Henry, of the City of Detroit, in the State of Michigan; David Tisdale, of the Town of Sinicoe, in the IVovince of Ontario; Hervey A. ( )lney. of Tilbury. Ontario. Canada; W. C. Baxter, of the City of Minneapolis, in the State of .Minnesota; and C. A. Youmans. of Xeillsville. in the State of Wisconsin: together with such persons as become shareholders in the Com- pany hereby incorj^orated, are hereby constituted a body cor- porate, under the name of "The St. Clair and Erie Ship Canal Company." hereinafter called "the Company." 40 4- TIh' head office of the Company shall be at the City of Toronto, in the Province of ( )ntario. or at such other i)lace in C"ana(la as the Company from time to time by by-law determines. 5. The capital stock of the Company shall be two million dollars, divided into shares of one hundred dollars each, and may be called up from time to time by the directors as they deem necessary. 6. The persons named in the third section of this Act shall be the provisional directors of the Company. 7. So soon as five hundred thousand dollars of the amount of the capital stock have been subscribed and fifty thousand dollars on such subscribed stock paid into one of the chartered banks in Canada, the provisional directors or a majority of them shall call a jj^eneral meetinj,^ of the shareholders to be held at the said City of Toronto or at such other i)lace in Canada as the pro- visional directors calling such meeting determine, for the ])ur- pose of electing the first directors of the Company and of trans- acting any other business that may ])e done at a shareholders' meeting; and notice in writing signetl by or on behalf of the provisional directors or a majority of them calling such meeting, of the date and i)Iace of holding the same, mailed, postage ])re- ])aid. to the post office address of each shareholder not less than ten days previous to the calling of such meeting, shall be deemed sufficient notice of such meeting. 8. The Company may — ((/.) Lay out. construct, maintain and o])erate a canal from some point on Lake St. Clair, in the Township of \orth Tilbury, in the County of Essex, or in the Tovvnshi]) of luist Tilbury or of West Dover, in the County of Kent, to some point on Lake Erie between Point Pelee and Rondeau Marbor. of such dimen- sions as to make and con.stitute a navigable channel of any depth not less than eighteen feet and of any width not less than seventy- two feet at the bottom of the said channel; (b.) Construct, erect, maintain, and o])erate by anv kind of motive power all such locks, dams, tcnv paths, branches, basins. feeders to sui)ply water from the said lakes, or from any rivers, creeks, reservoirs, cuttings, apparatus, appliances and machinery 41 as may he (Icsirahlc or necessary for tlie construction and opera- tion of the said canal ; (c.) I*2nte» upon and tal- and supporting', usin^-, workinjjf and main- taining^ the .sy.stem of connnunication by tele,t;ra])h and telephone and electric lines or wires, and may stretch wires and other tele- j^raphic and telephonic and electric contrivances thereon: and, as often as the Company, their at^^ents. ofificers or workmen think ])roper. may break up and open any part of the said public roads, hijj^hvvays. streets, bridj'i'es, watercourses, navitjable and non-navi- ji^able waters and other like ])laces. subject, however, to the fol- lowing provisions, that is to say:— (a.) The Company shall not interfere with the i)ublic rit:;-ht of travelling" on or using such public roads, higlnva\s, streets, bridges or watercourses, and other like ])laces. and shall not do anv unnecessarv damage, nor in any way obstruct tlie entrance to any door or gateway or free access to any building: (b.) The Com])any shall not affix any wire less than twenty- two feet above the surface of the street or road, nor erect more than one line of jioles along any street or road without the con- sent of the municipal council having jurisdiction over the roads or streets of the municipality; (c.) In all nnmicipalities the poles shall be as nearly as jjossi- ble .straight and penH-ndicular, and shall, in cities, be ])ainted. if so re(|uired by any by-law of the council: ((/.) Whcinever, in case of fire, it becomes necessary for its extinction or in the preservation of property, that the poles or 44 wires should he cut, the cuttinj^ under such circumstances of the poles or any of the wires of tlie Company, under the direction of the chief ent:;'ineer or otiier officer in charjife of the fire brij^ade, shall not entitle the C(jmpany to demand or to claim compensa- tion for any damage thereby incurred; (('.) The Company shall be res]M)nsible for all damage which their agents, servants or workmen cause to individuals or ])roj)- erty in constructing, carrying out or maintaining any of the said works in this or the next ]ireceding section authorized; (/".) The Company shall not cut down or nnitilate any shade, fruit or ornamental tree ; (g.) In all munici])alities the opening up of streets for die erection of poles, or for carrying the wires under ground, shall be subject to the direction and approval of such engineer or other official as the council ai)points, and shall be done in such maimer as the council directs: the council may also direct and designate the places where the poles are to be erected in such municipality; and tlie surface of die street shall in all cases be restored as far as i)ossible to its former condition by and at the expense of the Company ; (7i.) Xo Act of I'arliaiiient re(|uiring the Company, in case efficient means are devised for carrying telegraph or telephone wires under ground, tn adopt such means, and abrogating the right given by this section to continue carrying lines on poles through cities, ttnvns, or incorporated villages, shall be deemed an infringement of the ])rivileges granted by this Act, and the Com])aiiy shall not be entitled to damages thcrefo'": (/.) Xo person shall labour upon tlu' work of erecting or re- pairing any line or instniment of the Coiii])any. witliout having conspicuously attached to his dress a medal or badgi- on which shall l)e legibly inscribed the name of the Company and a number by which he can be readily identified; (/'.) Xothing herein contained sliall be deemed to authorize the Company, their servants, workmen or agents, to enter upon any private property for the purpose of erecting, maintaining or reiiairing any i»f tlieir works, without the previous assent of the owner or occupant of the property for tiie time being; 45 rv- I I'll l)Cl' li/A' |)on ov Itho (A'.) If in the removal of liuildings. or if in the i)uhhc right of traveHng on or using any puhhc road, highway or street, it becomes necessary that the said wires or ])oles be temporarily removed, it sh-'ll be the duty of the Company, at its own expense, ujKjn reasonable notice in writing from any person recjuiring the same, to remove such wires or jjoles, and in default of the Coni- ])any so doing, it shall be lawful for any such person to remove the same at the expense of the Com])any, doing no unnecessary damage thereby; such notice may be given at the head office of the Company or to any agent or ofificer of the Com])any in the nnmicipality wherein such wires or ptjles are recpiired to be le- moved, or in the case of a municipality wherein there is no such- agent or officer of the Company then either at the said head office or to any agent or officer of the Company in the nearest or any adjt)ining municipality to that in which such wires or poles re(|uire to be removed. 11. The Company may enter into arrangements with any other telegrai)h or telephone company for the exchange and transmission of messages, or for the working in wliole or in ])art of the lines of the Company. 12. The Company shall make due ])rovision for, take care and dispose of, all water and drainage, to tb.e extent to which it dis- turbs or interferes therewith, whether fn.Jin artificial drain.-;, nat- ural streams or watercourses, which drains, natural .streams or watercourses the said canal crosses, touches or interferes with and which are in existence at the time of the construction of the said canal. 2. All subsequent ([uestions, dis])utes or comi)laints as to the construction of new dmins and as to the alteration, enlargement and change of existing drains and of natural streams or water- courses, and as to who shall make such alteration, enlargement and change, ami by whom the expense thereof sh;dl be paid, and also anv complaint or dispute as to the manner or sufficiency of the comi)liance with the provisions of the next preceding sub- section, shall be entpiired into, heard and determined by the Railway Connnittee of the Privy C"ouncil in the same manner as is provided for other matters to be encpiired into, heard and determined bv the said Connnittee under The RailMiy Act. ISF'3? mmmmm 46 13. When the Company and the owners or occupants of priv- vate property entered upon cannot agree as to the compensation for lands required for the construction or maintenance of any \v(jrk audiorized under this Act, or for damages to lands injured thereby, the matter shall be settled in the same manner as is pro- vided for obtaining title and fixing compensation under The Raik\.'ay Act so far as the same may be applicable; 2. In this section and in sections eight and ten the expression "lands" means the lands the ac(|uiring, taking or using of which is incident to the exercise of the pcjwers given by this Act, and includes real i)roperty, messuages, lands, tenements and heredita- ments of any tenure. 14. In case oi any accident re(juiring immediate repair on the saitl canal or any part thereof, the Company, their agents or workmen may enter upon the adjoining land (not being an orchard or garden) and dig for. work, get and carry away and use all such gravel, stone, earth, clay or odier materials as may be necessary for the repair of the accident aforesaid, doing as little damage as may be to such land and making com])ensation there- for; and in case of dispute or difference regarding the amount to be so paid, the same sliall be decided by arbitration as provided in 77/f' Raih^'ay Act: but l)efore entering ui)on any land for the purposes aforesaid, the Comjiany shall, in case the consent of the owner is not obtained thereto, pay into the oflfice of one of the superior courts for the Province of Ontario, such sum with interest thereon for six months as is fixed, on the cx-partc appli- cation of the Company, by a judge of the county court in which such lands are situate. 15. The Company may open, cut and direct such ponds and l)asins for the laying up and turning of vessels using the said canal, and at such ])oints thereon as they deem expedient, and may also build and erect such dry docks, slips and machinery connected therewith for the hauling out and rei)airing of vessels as they think proper, and may lease or hire the same on such terms as they deem expedient, or may o])erate the same by their servaiUs or agents, as the Company shall decide from time to time. i V 47 V |o i6. Tlio Company shall at each and every place where the said canal crosses any railway, hij^hway, or puhlic road (nnlcss exempted from the provisions of this section, as far as any high- way or public n)ad is concerned, by the municipality having jurisdiction over such highway or public road) construct and maintain to the satisfaction of the Governor in Council bridges for ])assage over the said canal, so that the public thoroughfare or railway may be as little imjjeded as reasonably may be; and the Company shall not ui making the said canal cut througli or interrupt the jiassage on any highway or public road until they have made a convenient road past their works for the use of the l)ublic; and for every day on which they shall neglect to comply with the recjuirenients of this section the Company shall incur a penalty of one hundred dollars. 17. The land, ground nr property to be taken or used without the consent of the pro])rietors for the said canal and works, and tlfe ditches, drains and fences to separate the same from the ad- joining lands, shall not together exceed one thousand feel in breadth, except in places where basins and other works are recpiired to be cut or made as necessary parts of the canal as shown on the i)lan to be approved as hereinafter provided by the Ciovernor in Council. 18. Ik'fore the Company breaks ground or commences the construction of the canal or any of the works hereby autliorized, the i)lans, locations, dimensions, and all necessary i)articulars of the canal and other works, including a guard lock or gate at tlie Lake .St. Clair entrance of the said canal, shall be submitted to and receive the a])i)roval of the ( Invernor in Council. 19. The annual general meeting of the shareholders shall be held on the first Tuesday in I'ebruary in each year. 20. At the first meeting of shareholders, and at each annual meeting, the subscribers for capital stock assembled who liave l)aid all calls due on their shares shall choose five i)ersons to be directors of the Company, each of whom shall hold at least twenty shares of the capital stock of the Company, tiie majority of whom shall form a quorum, and one or more of whom may be paid directors of the Company. 2. The directors elected at the first meeting of shareholders shall hold office only until the first annual meeting of the Com- pany. 21. In addition to the general powers to make by-laws under The Railway Act, the Company may, subject to the approval of the Governor in Council, make by-laws, rules or regulations for the following purjjoses, that is to say: (a.) For regulating the speed at which, and the mode by which, vessels using the Company's works are to be propelled; (b.) VoT regulating the hours of arrival and departure of such vessels ; , * (r.) For regulating the loading or unloading of such vessels and the draught thereof: (rf.) P\:»r preventing the smoking of tobacco upon the works, the bringing into (jr upon the i)r<)perty of the Company of dan- gerous or deleterious substances, and for the i)ro])er care and preservati(jn of the Company's property: (('.) I 'or regulating the travelling and transportation upon and the using and the working of the canal : if.) For regulating the conduct of the officers, servants, and employes of the Company; (g.) For the maintaining, preserving and using the canal and all other works hereljy authorized to be constructed or connected tlierewith, and for the governing of all persons and vessels i)ass- ing through the said canal; and (//.) For providing for the due management of the affairs of the Company in all respects. 22. The Company m. - issue and pledge or dispose of bonds, debentures or .' 2"]. The C()nii)aiiy shall not make or jjivc any secret special toll, rate, rebate, drawback, or concession to any person; and the Company shall on the demand of any i)erson make known to iiini any special rate, rebate, drawback or concession given to any one. 28. In case of denial or neglect of payment on demand of any such tolls or any part thereof, the same shall be recoverable in any court of competent jurisdiction ; and the agents or ser- vants of the Company may seize the vessel or goods for or with respect to which such tolls are payable, and may detain the same until payment thereof, and in the meantime the said vessel or goods shall be at the risk of the owners therecjf. 2(> If the t(jlls are not paid within six weeks from the time of such detainer the Company may sell by public auction the vessel or the whole or any j^art of such goods, and out of the moneys arising from such sale retain the tolls ])ayable and all reasonable charges and exjjenses of such seizure, detention and sale, and shall deliver the suri)lus. if any, or die vessel or such of the goods as remain unsold, to the person entitled thereto. 30. If anv vessel or goods remain in the possession of the Company unclaimed for the space of twelve nu)nths, the Com- l)any may thereafter and on giving public notice thereof by ad- vertisement for six weeks in the ofificial gazette of the province in which such vessel or g(jods are, and in such other newspa])er as it deems necessary, sell such vessel or goods by public auction at a time and ])lace which shall be mentioned in such advertise- ment, and out of the proceeds thereof pay such t(jlls and all rea- sonable charges for keeping, storing, advertising and selling such vessel or goods, and the balance of the proceeds, if any, shall be kept by the Company for a further period of three months to be paid over to any person entitled thereto. 31. In default of such balance being claimed before the expi- ration of the time last aforesaid, it shall be paid over to the Min- ister of I'inance and Receiver General for the public uses of Canada until claimed by the person entitled thereto. 32. In all cases where there is a fraction of a mile in the dis- tance which vessels, rafts, goods, wares, merchandise or other connnodities or passengers shall be conveyed or transported on I ; m. } the said canal, such fraction shall, in ascertaining the said rates, be deemed and considered as a \vlK)le mile; and in all cases where there is a fraction of a ton in the weight of any such goods, wares, merchandise and other commodities, a proportion of the said rates shall he demanded and taken by the Company calcu- lated upon the number of cpiarters of a ton contained therein; and in all cases where there is a fraction of a quarter of a ton, such fraction shall be deemed and considered as a whole (puirter of a ton. 33. Every vessel using the said canal shall have her draught of water legibly marked, in figures of not less than si.x inches long, frcim V I •■ ,.^^ ' .attiiaftWfefe;;j ^ >atf;:tU'-'- ' > ' - f§i > V 9k£TCm or /f/mjf040 Bfft09£ .gj ii j wM \^ , «.■.*■ . '*"•'• . .%,,.;^ :• > /''VWi ^ ' .Tr« V^' % ^^ &^> ^; !l'l M'N^i, , ll mw.. -%:m ' •^^^•r^''%:vr:-*: .<*:ili ■.*• '.I < ^ / ? J ^.-•... •■"f !l ,1 4 «i . 5/ <» s 1 »•••* ■>. ; \l /' 4 S 1 1 1 ^••. ^ ■» '•^^'^•■i•■/ir?V■Ji.',i;.-' N v., ,,•,!•• fe}r..'i:.3,X(i:tji ,, ,1 1 ^ I €:'-^| I: W i ^ If - ^ ^ >r-- .ill.' M,':U, ;>iM '/^?it im I iNuJ;* p; liij ^^i pLA Surveyed and drai direction ' 740 Bftt{»£ Surveyed and drawn Mnder Ihe direction si D. Tare AND HEKRYM..Am.SocCJE.. / 44- ccjnstriK of this t within : grantea so muc 45- conferr of sect 46. incons three t eig-hty hundr teeii. ( hundr inclus one 1 inchif dred and : hund to t\v six t andjf auth of tl- pow is aj 2. OCC ..iiiiidMltMMna 00 \oLUME AND XALn-L OF C( ).MM i:kck ruir.r'iARv TO AX EXLAR(JED WATERWAY SYSTEM. James Fisher, O. ('., M. V. P., Winiiipe^^, Canada. F^irst Annual Convention of the International Deep \\'ater\va\ s Association, Cleveland. Sept. 24, 25, 26. i8(j5. In furtherance of the iini>ortant object for which XI-.' Interna- tional Dee]) Waterways Association was created, it was scarcely necessary, perhaps, that anyone should have been charged with the task of preparing- a paper discussing- the volume and value of the conmierce tributary to an enlar^rd waterway in connection with the 5^reat lakes route. If there is one subject more than another in the interesting prog-ranuiie before us ujxin which not only members of this association, but the ])ul)lic at lari;c, are already pretty fully informed, it i>^ surely this one. Thanks to the activity anfl enterprise of an omuiscient press, everywhere circu- lated and universally read, the means of knowledjrc ui)tin this subject are always at our dis])osal. Day after d ■ the newspa])ers and other jjcriodicals furnish us with iacts and tiiiures bearinjj;' upon the growth of commerce due to the past enlargement "f the water channels. Tliese facts and figures .ire put up Uressive form that the wi -lum of ihe brightt'st minds r;ui suggest. ( )ur blue books and i)ublic rep(>rt> suppl\ tliem in full (ktail. Our trade returns and conunercial bulletms are ladi'u with state- ments brimfull of information on the subject as instructive a> it is complete and accurate. I'.xpert statisticians and learnid political eciiuomists present us every il;i\ w'tli stateiuiMUs classifying in I'verv varii't\ the iruits of our soil and the products n* our indus- tries. The\ exhibit the growth of our farming interests; the develo])- nient of out mines; the product of our lisheries: and tlu' \ield of oiu- forests, as well a.^ the otitcome of our extensive maiuilactories. 'j'hev chronicle for our edification the movement of .ill these pro- 56 ducts, and the cost thereof, by sea and lancl, over lake and rail. They furnish us with, comparative statements of results in the i)ur- suit of each department of industry under every conceivable con- dition. They de inculcates, fail to obey the fiat of the persuasive gentleman from Superior, wiio is indeed the very life and >oul of our growing movement, the "i'lower" of our association? I undertook the task, tlirrtforc. realizing", however, thai al all e\ents it in\olved no original researcii or painstaking iinestig;)- tioii on my part, but simply a fi'w hom-s" delvitig into tiie maga- zines and books and ;i wholesale appn>p, i.'tion of the labor of others. It is not my purpose to submit any long ;nta\ of figiuvs or to l)ro(luce elaboratt' statistics touching the i'\lent of iln' commerce of tile lake region am! its connection>. i will simpK mentioti a tew salient facts, of a general character, touching its growth, and call attention to somr significant teatnres in coimection tiu'reuith, and with the conditions of that legion. that may serve to empha- size the great importaiici' not oid\ of enlarging the chann<'ls leading from tlu' lakes to the sea. i)Ut of I'ventually extending a system of canals farther imo the interior. 67 When one looks at the enormous movement of commerce on this continent, and' niaieoples, the most ijnji^ressive communities, and the most intellij^ent artisans and workers on the face of the wide earth. The product of all the industries carried on by a population so larg-e and of such a character, is necessarily greater than that of an e(|ual number of less i)rog-ressive peo])les. The wants of sucli a peoi)le. too, where civilization has attained its hifjhest form and where wealth has lar_ti;-ely accunnilated. are e(|ually tjreat in com- parison with less favored countries. Alto.y;ether, the conditions in this country, on both sides of the boundary, are such as to create an extraordinary movement of connnerce for domestic purposes alone. The foreign connnerce is also proportionatelx- large. rerliai>s we do not realize die extent, for instance, to which our two coun- tries sui)])lv the markets of the great consuming nation of tlie world— ( ireat Tiritain. Canada. 1 may say. 's a very heavy exporter to the mother land. .And in the four years from i8()0 to iX<,3 inclusive, the imports of the I'nited Kingdo.'V from the Cmted ."States alone, ecjualled those fr(»i'i I'rai'ce. (iirmany, Rus- sia, Italy, China and I'.razil all put together. They exceeded li\ nearly l^),oo().ooo the imports in the same \ear Iroin ;ill thr I'.ritish possessions in the norld, ( anad.'i inchuK'd. As the vcar> roll on. I'.ritain pin-chases from our two countries more atid more. Comparing her imports for thi' four \ears nameplicablr. o| course, to the entire country. Ihil they arr appliuiblv in particu- 58 lar to the region wliose products and supplies are in such great part carried over the lakes. There is a further important fact, one which applies especially to the lake region. It is that the greatest develoi)ment of trade, in the future, both in the I'nited States and Canada, nuist be in the region tributary to the lakes and their coiuiections. It is in the region tributary to die great lakes. The conunerce of all parts of the two countries will no doubt greatly increase in the future as in the past. lUU we may look for the greatest increase of all in the region on both sides of the boundary tributary to till,' lakes and their connections. It is in this region that we have seen production and traffic increase at ho phenomenal a rat'j within the past two decades. And yet production th.ere is still in its infancy. The records of that period serve to give us a faint idea of what the traffic will be at the end of anodier ten years. How short has been the time since the great northwest was an unknown wilderness! The red man but recently held imdisputed sway over the districts where now the magnificent fields of yellow grain furnish a siglit such as can he seen in no other ])art of the world. The hunters who a few years ago chased the buffalo on the prairie, are still ali\e to iierd the cattle gra-^ing on the same grounds. Michigan but a short time since was one of the states of the far west: Chicago was first reached by a vessel fnjm the 'ower lakes in 1834. The boats that passed the cily of Cleveland, down to a period less than si.xty years ago, were engaged, noi in sliipping the products of the great west to the eastern market, but the car- rying provisions to the newl\ formed settlements beyond Detroit. The fir.st cargo of grain from Lake Michigan reached Huffnlo in iM^f). The lake trade soon developed, however, and Michigan ceased to be a border state. The settlers in Indiana and Illinois were the pioneers t)f a period a few years kiter, ;nid soon a few plucky atlventnrers made their way iiUo Iowa and Wisconsin, their frit-nds whom the\' left behind ctnnmitting tluni to the care of heaven and their tmsty nuiskets against the attacks of the savages around their new homes. The present *reneration has seen the occupation and developmeiU to some extent of the Hakot.'is an 3,820,382 1893 23,091,889 3,659,292 As long ago as i88(), a -cording to an estimate published b\ tin: late (r'o. H. Ely, the entire freight passing through the Det.oit river was more than three times the foreign trade of the port of New York; it exceeded the aggregate foreign trade of all the 62 sca]i()rts of the I'liitcd States by io,ocx3,ooo tons, aiul it exceeded by over 3,000,000 tons the total foreipi and coastwise trade of Liverjiool and London combined. The wheat received at Mon- treal in 1893 by the Lachine canal and St. Lawrence river, was about 7,000.000 bushels as against less than 130,000 bushels broug-ht in by all the railways. These facts j^ive us some idea of the past development of the lake and river traffic, and it does not surprise us to be told that the entire commerce of the j^reat lakes, American and Canadian, is tc|ual to 25 ]X'r cent, (jf that carried by all the railroads (jf the American union. What is that conunerce going to be in a com- paratively few years, when the present population of the great northwest shall be doubled, trebled, or (juadrupled, when all the productive prairie lands shall be brought under cultivation, when all the rich ranges shall be stocked with cattle, and when the rich mining districts on the Canadian side may be as fully developed as those on the south shore of Lake Superior? Col. ( ). M. I'oe, chief engineer of the Sault canal, writing, early in January of i8(ji, his report urging the com])letion of the twen- ty-fo(jt channel from the head of the lakes to lUiffalo, after describing the wonderful exi)ansion of the lake traffic up to that period, used the following language, which can aptly be used to-day in support of a demand for the extension of such a channel, and even of a deeper one to the Atlantic ocean: "Surely such a commerce deserves every aid ami encouragement that can be given U) it. (Jive it a channel practically navigable upijn a draught of twenty feet and it needs no pr(jphet to ])redict a won- derful growth, but only a prcjpb.et could foretell its degree. For neariy thirty-five \ears 1 have watched its increase, but neither I nor anyone else within my knowledge has been able to exi)an(l in ideas at the same rate. The wildest expectations of one vear seem absurdly tame the next." And so it is still. Let the 20-foot channel of the lakes be extended from the foot of L^ake Erie to the Atlantic, and com- merce will receive an impetus that will give results as startling as the unparalleled progress of the past. And it will result in a great development of the rich northwest on both sides of the line. I care not in wliat direction ycni may reach in the first place to Lake ( )ntario— whether it be by the Welland. deepened to 20 r/ H3 f/ feet, or by a new channel thron.^h the state of Xew Yuck. The result, in either case, will he the same. I. as a Canadian, may have a preference for the Welland ; but that would only be in so far as I could be convinced that it really afforded the best nnte. If a new channel can be opened to as i,n)()(l advantaj:^e. and at less cost. then let the new channel be opened, and let both countries join in the work. Canada's e.\])enditure in the past can be considered in fixinjr the amount which she should contribute. I care not, again, whether we are to reach the salt water 1)\ the St. Lawrence, or by a new n)ute from Oswej^o to All)anv. or whether we j^et to the Hudson by Cauj^^hnawag-a. All that this ccmvenvion should, in my judgment ask, is. that by one or other route the two countries should unite in ])roviding a deep channel. It is for us. at the .same time, to elicit and make known the fullest information that can be obtained, showing the advantages and disadvantages of each several route. Let us have a full discussion, right here, of every consideration that favors one route or other, in order that the governments and the people of the two nations may be well informed, lint this convention is not. nor is this associatiim. an executive bodv hav- ing power to act. 15e it ours to agitate, and to educate and inform the public as to the advantages of the scheme generally, and as to the merits of each individual route. With the national executives of the respective nations nuist be left the responsibility of propounding, and with the congress and parliament the respon- sibility of ratifying in the end the .scheme that on the whole mav commend itself to the public. What I take leave to urge is this: We are seeking an improvement in the natural water channels. It is an international waterway .supplied by nature for the material good of the two nations from the head of the lake to the ocean. One nation has no greater right over it than has the other. Mven the use of the St. Lawrence, where its course is within Canadian soil, has by soleiun treaty been assinrd to citizens of the Cm'ted States on exactly e(|ual terms with Canadians, and that fore\cr. 1 say. then, let the two nations unite, c^n proper terms and uikUt reasonable conditions, in the complexion of the work; and let the chatuiel, when completed, be for the use. absolutely free fr 112 I.I •^ I |40 25 12.2 IM 1.8 1-25 1.4 III 1.6 6" ► V] <^ /}. /:. V /A Hiotographic Sciences Corporation 33 WEST MAIN STREET WEBSTER, NY. 14580 (716) 873-4503 ,\ (V ^ o ;\ s:<9 6^ \ «;*; from year to year. lUit it is in tlir iiortliwcstcrly of those states, tributary to tlie upper lakes, tliat we shall witness the .ucreatest },''ro\\th in the next twenty \ears. Wisconsin is still a new state, with a vast amount of rich land still unoultivatt'd. and she is capa- ble of extendinj^ her varied industries many fold. In Minnesota, b)\\a. Nebraska, and the Dakotas but a fraction of the lands have been broujj^ht into a ])ro(luctive condition. W'Ih) can estimate the expansion of the conunerce <»f the north- west when these fj^reat territories shall be occu])ied by lari;e popu- lations, when all their arable lands shall be broujifht uiuler cultiva- tion and their varied industries shall be developed? And what a factor in the development of those industries will be the o])enim.;' of a canal from the head of the lakes to the headwaters of the extent and the un])aralleled richness of that retjion. and that h.'is j^ivi'U a tboui^ht to its natural advantages in respect of water cliaiuuls. capable of I)einiL;' utilized and im])roved. can fail to appreciate llu' boundless possibilities of de\elopuieut in iliat country llirou|L;!i an extension of watirways? I have said that in the nortiiwest above all \\c arc to look for the chief develop- ments of conunerce in tile future. What that develo])ment may be we can form some faint conce])tiiin nf 1)\ a stuily of the past. The wliole countrx. I repeat, is in its infanc). l.ook at ihe .yrouth of the i^real cities nf tJU' lakes betwci'u iSSo and iSijo. boundini.;' up from a po])uI;ition oi i,^(K),oik) to over ^.^oo.ooo. Look at tin.' ^feat towns and cities urowin^ uji thr th.it contribute In this tr;itlic. In the \mi'r- ican Itiion apart from W'w N ork and IVun>v Ivania there are sixteen .yi'eat states that are t" a l.irye exteiU dipendeiU on the lake route for transportation of their products. They are all states in which population is incrca>iiiL; and industri^'>^ extendinj;' .Mississippi and to the l\eil l\i\ir. brinyiujH' canal traffic to the twin cities of Mimiesota and to the ,L;raiu lields of I )akola. If we cannot hope in tlu' umnediate future to see step> taken to such ;m end wt' max at least i^ive serious thou.niil to tiie feasibility of such a .schenii', and furnish information that may enlighten tin- publi'- on llu' (|uestion. And let me adil a wortl or two about the j^Tcat expansion in production and commerce that we are sure to witness in the}j^reat and rich north west of Canada. To the capabilities of that coun- f »)7 try ill tlie way of siistainiii.y;' a j^n-at populatidii and (k-vt'Iopins;- a most (.'xtendcd trade, considfrahlo attrntion lias lati'lv hi-cn paid. Sutihicc' it to say lu-ri' that in the ])r()viiK(.' of .\lanitol>a aloiu", now containing' k-ss than j^.cxjo fanners, where six or eii^ht \ears aj^o wc had to import beef and butter and other provisions for tin settlers, we now have jj^^reat herds of stock, and a larije export trad,' of fat cattle to the h'nj^-lish markets is now jjfoin^ on ever\ season, and increasinj;' largely each successive vear. Ten \ears a^o Wf were practically without creameries oi- chei'se factories, which now we have in every district of the province. We ha\e iust wit nesse3 about I4,(xk),()(m). aiul in iSSX ;dii,nt (i,(KK),- (XX) buslu'ls. The ]»rovince is in the \er\ earliest infanc\ of it> l^touiIi; not one-tenth of its rich arable lan are uiidir cultivati^ in c\tenl. To ihi wi'st and northwest of .Manitoba extends tlu- j^reat ( anadian teiri- tory, rich beyond description in prairie and iirazinu' laml. a ciiun try destined in the futm-e to be the home of million>. We do not mind making" the acoura!.^f more rai)id -ettknieni i>« the j^rt'at cost of transportation to ;ind from the marki't> of tin- world. The (|uestion of chea])er transportation i-^ llic (|Uestion of (juestions for the Canadian as will as the Aniericni northwest. Solve that ])rol)leni and the adxanta.ue to the country, as well a- the ex|tansion of its commerce, will be mar\ilon>. It has all tlu' otlu'r conditions that wdl insure sue!; a result. A thousaml luiks be\ond tlu' boimdarx of .Manitoba, further to tlu' northwest, the wheat rej^ion coiuinno. Throuiih this threat rcLjion of .Manitob.i and the tt'rrilories run the Red, the Saskatchewan, the .\ssini boine, the (Jn' .\ppelk', and other stri'ams. It is feasible to con noct this conntrv bv a water channel with the i.;feat lakes — in other words, can canal coimection be opened up between the head of the lakes and the Ked river? That is the problem facing- Xorth Dakota and northern .Mimiesota as well as the Canadian north- ()8 i west. It is a problem upon which this cunvcntiou cannot, per- haps, jj^ive full information. l)in it is a (piestion that can be dis- cussed, and on wiiich we can procure information. We should impress upon the ^governments of the two nati(jns that, at least, the country should be examined, and a survey made with a view to judg-e as to the feasibility and cost of such an undertakings. One canal to the Red river mij^ht serve both coun- tries. The route ji^entrally considered most feasible on the Cana- dian side is by the Lake of the Woods. That lake and the Rainy river furnish already the re(|uired navifi^ation for a distance of 150 miles from the west shore of lUiffalo bay at the international boundary easterly to I'ort h'rancis, also on the boundary. Were the canal at l-'ort l-Vancis. on which a laru^e sum of money was ex]XMided 20 years ago. completed, and it is .said that $250,000 would do so. the entire distance from the west coast of the Lake of the Woods to within 40 miles of Lake Superior would be navigable, save only a number of portages not aggregating more than eight miles. To that extent a channel woulcl have to be opened, at considerable cost, no doubt, but at a cost which would be fully justified in view of the advantages secured. The most serious difficulty is met with in the 40 miles next to Lake Superior, where the great fall of land takes place. There, too, we have water conununication all the way, but the fall has to be overcome. How far can modern appliances and engineer- ing skill overcome that obstacle at a cost commensurate with the benefits to be derived from the opening of the chaimel? The country between the Lake of the Woods and the RcA river is one that offers no particular obstacle,^ to the o])ening of a water v'hamiel. A number of gentlemen iiUerested in bringing saw-logs from Lake of the Woods to the Rvil river have already secured a charter from the .Manitoba legislature for the opening of a canal for that purpose. ( )ne |)roposal was to use the channel of the Rt)sseau river, whose headwaters are within twenty miles of the Lake of the Wottds, and which runs to the Red river partly through Minnesota and partly through .Manitoba. The land between the headwaters of the Rosseau and the Lake t)f the Woods is chiefly muskeg, and there is a run of water all the way. The character of the soil throughout the whole distance is such as to inaki' construction easv. ^It' A 69 r have discussed the (|uesti()ii with men of en^^nneerinjf skill cc.nipetent. as I am net. to pass jud^nnent on the (|uestion. and their opinion is that the problem of conneotinjr the great lakes with Re practical results will be. .Snrely this convention would be taking a wise step, and will be working to a good end. if by any actioii of ours we succeed in at least directing pul)lic attention to th. importance of such an enterprise, and if we can impress upon tin- respective governments the desirability (.f taking nii-ans to have such survey and inspection made as will test the feasibility and cost of the work.