IMAGE EVALUATION TEST TARGET (MT-3) / o o s>>^. W' fe w. 1.0 LI <- ^mm IIM 2.2 1.8 1.25 1.4 1'-^ ■^ 6" — ► ^/# <^^ -9; ?S' c% <^^ > vj"- >; W Photographic Sciences Corporation 4^ A^ %< « ^^ V ?i? 6^ 'X^ 23 WEST MAIN STREET WEBSTER. NY 14S80 (716) 872-4503 c< CIHM/ICMH Microfiche Series. CIHM/ICMH Collection de microfiches. Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions / Institut Canadian de microreproductions historiques Technical and Bibliographic Notes/Notes techniques et bibliographiques The Institute has attempted to obtain the best original copy available for filming. Features of this copy which may be bibliographically unique, which may alter any of the images in the reproduction, or which may significantly change the usual method of filming, are checked below. L'Institut a microfilme ie meilleur exemplaire qu'il lui a ete possible de se procurer Les details de cet exemplaire qui sont peut-etre uniques du point de vuo bibliographique. qui peuvent modifier une image reproduite. ou qui peuvent exiger une modification dans la m^thode normale de filmage sont indiqu^s ci-dessous. (~~I Coloured covers/ I I Couverture de couieur Covers damaged/ Couverture endommagee Covers restored and/or laminated/ Couverture restaur^e et/ou pelliculee □ Cover title missin, Le titre de couverture manque □ Coloured maps/ Cartes gAographiques en couieur Dr. o Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ ere de couieur (i.e. autre que bleue ou noire) □ Coloured plates and/or illustrations/ Planches et/ou illustrations en couieur □ Boun< Rail* Bound with other material/ avec d'autres documents Tight binding may cause shadows or distortion along interior margin/ Lareliure serree peut causer de I'ombre ou de la distorsion le long de la marge interieure Blank leaves added during restoration may appear within the text. Whenever possible, these have been omitted from filming/ II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajouties lors d une restauration apparaissent dans le texte, mais, lorsque cela ^tait possible, ces pages n'ont pas m film^es. □ Coloured pages/ Pages de couieur Pages damaged/ Pages endommagees n Pages restored and/or laminated/ Pages restaurees et/ou pelliculees Pages discoloured stained or foxed/ Pages decolorees, tachet^es ou piquees Pages detached/ Pages detachees Showthrough/ Transparence Quality of print varies/ Qualite m^gale de I'impression n D □ Includes supplementary material/ Comp n iprend du materiel supplementaire I I Only edition available/ Seule Edition disponible Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata slips, tissues, etc.. have been refilmed to ensure the best possible image/ Les pages totalement ou partiellement obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata. une pelure. etc . cnt ^te fllm^es A nouveau de facon a obtenir la meilleure image possible n Additional comments:/ Commentaires supplementaires This Item is filmed at the reduction ratio checked below/ Ce document est filme au taux de reduction indiqu^ ci-dessous. 10X 14X 18X 22X 26X 30X 1 I I I ( 12X 16X 20X 24X 28X 32X The copy filmed h«r« has b««n r«produc*d thanks to tha gansrosity of: Harold Campbell Vaughan Memorial Library Acadia University. L'axampiairs film* fut raproduit grlca h la qinirotiti da: Harold Campbell Vaughan Memorial Library Acadia University. Tha Jmagas appaaring hara ara tha bast quality possibia considaring tha condition and lagibility of tha original copy and in kaaping with tha filming contract specifications. Original copies In printed paper covers are filmed beginning with the front cover and ending on the laat page with a prnted or illustrated impres- sion, or the back cover when appropriate. All other original copies are filmed beginning on the first page with a printed or illuatrated imprea- sion, and ending on the last page with a printed or illustrated impreaaion. Tha laat recorded frame on each microfiche shall contain the symbol '^^ (meaning "CON- TINUED"), or the symbol V (meaning "END"), whichever appiiea. Maps, plataa, charts, etc., may be filmed at different reduction ratioa. Thoae too large to be entirety included in one expoaure are filmed beginning in the upper left hand comer, left to right and top to bottom, as many framea aa required. The following diagrama illustrate the method: l.ae imagea suivantea ont At* raproduites avec le plus grand soin, compta tanu de la condition at da la nettet* de I'exemplaira film*, at »n conformit* avec les conditions du contrst de filmage. Lae exempiairae originaux dont la couvartura en papier est imprim*e sont fiimto an commenpant par le premier plat at an tarminant soit par la derni*re page qui comporte une amprainte d'lmpreasion ou d'illustration, soit par la second plat, saion le cas. Tous las autras axamplairas originaux sont film*s an commenpant par la premiere page qui comporte une ampreinte d'impreaaion ou d'liluatration at an tarminant par la darnlAre page qui comporte une telle empreinte. Un dee symboiee suivants apparaitra sur la demi*re image de cheque microfiche, selon la caa: le symbols — » signifie "A SUIVRe". le symbols ▼ signifie "FIN". Lea cartaa. planches, tableoux, ate. . peuvent dtra filmte * dee taux de reduction diff*rants. Lorsque le document est trop grand pour *tra raproduit en un seul clich*. il est film* * partir da Tangle sup*rieur gauche, de gauche ^ droite, et de haut en baa, en prenant le nombra d'images n*cessaira. Las diagrammes suivants illuatrant la m*thode. 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 6 "1^ ■> it ■'■^5?!' ., - '*;*«hk» ^i.. > *_©'i^ : ■ll COLLECTION O F .4 uH,' THE y^^ ^ .^..- ^ Publications relating to the Impeachmcntf ^^ ** * * o F T H E J U D G E S / OF HIS-MAJESTSY'S SUPREME COURTOt, ft* © F T H E V* « Province of Nova-Scotia, :v * ^^* J " ^^ -^, *!i '^t^y \ t K ■4«« Kb K .^ I ; I To the P If i // fnn\ HE ■ former 1 thol principal Advantage of a State of Society above tSat nf w,. • v . J? er Sre fixed Rules and Laws to regulate tTe Con ?,/^nf ^^ *'""' '*» '^^ '" "^JR^ Men, and Tribunals confti.uted to enforce obedience fr "^^v '"^"^^^ ^" ^'^'^'^w' '--■ :^yr. \^. -."'- "^ -«i°". CabtraVn^fo^ret?, a^e rSr^fv'eZ-r Xif ■g>»« fome and adapted to the Geniu»and a umtCces of its S^^^ . '^'"'^='>'" Rood, whole! partially adminiftcred, tno^e who compofe U,at Societv m.!f h " ' """^ ^'* faithfully and ini- Su.nmit of t'nt Happmef. which Civil Gov rnmenwa^"^--^^^^^^ to have attained th« Country fo favoured. Peace, good Order and aT'earf^fsuh^' <^ ^ Z"'^"''*'^ '° P'°="^*- •" » pervade every Rank of Citizens and to ext nd to the mlft dift.'^l^r '"' "-'"^ ^''' "« <■«" '<» other Hatvl, when the Laws are in their Principles or lenH' !r"''' °* "^« '"'«'«= •• O" the of the suhjea, or are „,aae fu: f.rvient to tl e^P^ ^oTes ot a fcw^TtheT''^ '° '""^ "^PP'"^--* wuh vvh.ch they a,e admimilered, the Defijn of a^rlawVh .' ^r u 'K"°'"=«"« "r Part.a'ity • nd Difcorxtent w>ll be heard fro.T^ every Ouartr -JfrMl ^ f"bverted, and Murmuring the Controverfy ,rif,ng fr,m the Repre'fe^tatTo- ;17:h^^^^^^^ th« GoYsrnor, reJut.ve to the irregular Ad iiiniftration of l.^rt- °^.'^^'^ / '" «'* £xccllency the firft and U(\ Importance to the good Peopk o Thi, p/" ^''* '",/'\'= =>"P'-f'ne Court, is of the Public may have the Opportunity of deliheLcviv rt""' , .^"''"" '^'* "•««' »"d t^at ed all the Publications on b^oth Sides^he Sert oT 'b ' wh '^1'"' "p' r"'"'"''"" "^^ ""''' '^°"«^- c,de, whether we have been treated with tha " aimef^ Tnd c\ J'^ ^''^"^ ^'" ''« ^""''led to de- ther t.e I'roceedings of the Ceuncil have be n fuch a, can^,,^^ VT ''f '"''''"'' '"' '"'^ ^»'«- to .he CompUints o, the Reprefentative, of the Peoule con- -^ T^ ' refpeftful Attentio,» or m any Uevere o. the h,ghcft Coa'f.de.at'on a7d oudl y'S-.^fi^ '"'r "=« T '' '^^^ '' '" -roVi.l.„" Talk, beca.fe ,t cxpoicd a Series of ITanf .elicn hit evinc H c v ^'"'T''- " ^""^ ^ >'-"'"' ency ,n thole who had be-n called to Office 0^:10 fi,f>" ''' ■' '^^'^''^ "'• J"comK- >f any longer per^.ttcd, w.thout inquiry o^No i e w;^! r ve.'. '"^^ 7 Government, and which. whKh naturally luccced .he Lofs of >ub!.c Vi-tuc ..vl V , 7 ki^^ ^^ ' P'""^""'' "'"'"<= ^v.ls duel of the Judges we did no' ft.nd a! ,ne in Op'rion The'^^""°?: ^^''('^''''"S the Con- Knowledge .o.th. Prad.c.of the Cou.t arta--d'd h rathe Ve ^Tr't^"'"^ "''"'"'•■ "'^•""- M.t^jea corroborated mod at C-.c Fact, and Opin n ve ^ . 'l'^^^'"? ^'^^-I'^dly .,pon t;.j ot cjual .f not of cre.U.T Moment. M.i-,r Kc a - ?,;;""'' '""^ "..ntiorcd manv .-.tur., h. owed the Public. )t was „o n the in r C J, m> -e f.^ T ' '=°"''^i°"'"'^'«'of Uu.y' the 1 .me by the Attorney. Cieneral th t K^ r "^•^'^^^"'^' ' e'hmonies, not d.fputed ac Hu ixcsli.ncy th: Lieut nant Jo 'a o . '^ ''""^^ '''''' ''''■'■'''^ ^'^'^' ^'-^^ '"Howin,- .Addrefs t^ .*%. r o Ip -) ^ iO Vf O THE PUBLIC. EXCELLENCY p A^ R R, Efq; 'Uc. b'f. TO HIS JOHN , P.,,,,... a.J Commander ,n C>-^fj'';;;:l;':^';,,j,^,. The Humble AooaEss^of;Hen^^^^^^^ M„v // pi'^'frr-- ^^"'^T:. Leva. ^v..^cas u. i^=p-'r""r^j;^^x: '-v ^r ptafe ycur cxic^'^r..., c„v,cas the Reprefentatues "■ - j,^.„<.y upon .. ■ .lys mnft dutiful at^rf Loyal ^"7'^"' '".^e to aiiartw y»«« ^f '' ",inR tha a Subjea c« the "tmo^ ^^^ |i--^,^„^ j,^^ On thisOround it is»]^'= ,_ Ariminiftration in t)m>.e oi v>,e bee Leave to iu_^_^^ ,r,i^ their Cai>.e«.>. p^,.^^ „,.a». th>o;n_r^.-;;. ^,.^j,„f Hi^ M^i^"^,: ;;-;;, , ^vcjudi por aiKi . --. = ■; ^ ot His i.xveu<....; - ••- -' ; ^B» TO THE PUBLIC. 4 1 th.it he had been nnwirily led into the Adoption of it by feme Petfon who was determined, ti he had Influence fnflicient, to bring the whole Proceeding into Contempt. His Majcfty's Council have fince refufed us the Opportuity of fubflantia tin; the Teftimony we gsve before the Houfe— h».Te undertaken to try the [udgec without examining a fmgle Wit- ncfs— and on the fole Credit of their own AflTertions have not only acquiiteo them but have endeavored fo far as their Credit would go with the Public, to (aften on us the Im- putation of bringing forward falfe and fc;>ndaious Charges againA faid fudges : And not con- t.-nt with this flagrant Aft of Injuftice, they have not rtopped here, but when conflrained by the Principles of Self-defence and a Regard to our Reputations with our Fellow- Citizens, to come forward in our own Vindication, tliofe Judges, who by accepting fuch a Mode o£ Trial had d«ftroyed all the little Remains of Confidence a Part of the Community yet had ia them, have deprived as of the Profeflions to which we were bred, in which we were eflablilhed, and had, as we flatter ourfelves, conduftcd with Integrity and Honor. It lias been fuggefted by fome, that it is true we originally rtood in the Light of Witneflfes : But that by coming forward with a Memori'l to the Governor on the Subjeft we made our- felves Principals, by taking up a Matter which belonged to the Houfe only. But whoever con- fiders that the Judges and their Friends, had from very improper Motives, impreflVd the Public with 'he Opinion that the Addrefs of the Houfe was procured by our Application and ground- ed folsly on our Teftimony, that the King's Reprefentative exprefly informed us that he wa» taught to believe that to be the Cafe and that thi Council were about to try them only on our Information, muft fee the Impropriety of our fufTering him to art under that Deception, and whoever confiders the Importance of the Subjert, muft alfo fee the Propriety of our not truftinj to a verbal Communication of it which might have been either mifapprehended or forgotton : Befides the exprefs Objeem which was then fecretly concerted, but has fince in fome Degree been laid open to the Public. Add to this that the fame new made Counfellor had di- reitly coritr.try to the Truth of Fails, and his own Knowledge, declared that the Member wlio made the Motion in th? Houfe of Alfembly for an Enquiry into the Condudl of the Judges had •xprefly ftatcd that he mide it at our Inflance, that the Houfe in their Addreii »&ed in Confsquence of our Information only, and that he had given his Opinion oa the Merits of ths '.Jueflion in the moll decided Terms. Could we under thofe Circum- ftinces do lefs thm flate fuch of thofe Faftj to the Governor as we thought material ? Where we not bound to do it for our own fakes i" WouM it net have been faid, and with Juf- tice, that the Council were milled, and that we had by our Ccndudl countenanced tlie Impofi- tion, had wefutfered them to proceed without giving the Information contained in our Memo- rial ? And (hould we not have been treated by the Council in the fame Manner we have been, i£ we had never interfered ' For to fuppofethat our Memorial induced them to decide differently, from what they would have done, is at once admitting them to liaveadlod from the mod unbe- co ning Motives. Thus f.tr every Man of Senfe and Candor, we hope, will juflify our Condurt. The next Step we took w^s, after th; Council had fulminated their woile than inquifitorial Senrence of Cofidemndiion againft us, which appears to have liad lor ito Ot>jcifl, as much the Di-rtruiflioa of our Charaifltis as falvinc; the Reputation of thj Judi;ci : Couid we, in Judice to ourfi-lvrj, futTer thjt to paf» unnoticed, when we had the Mcansof Pef;.r.ci and i'rcf.rv.ition in our I'ow. tr ' To h.ive hcfitated for a Moment in co:nhating it, would have IjCtn to have .ntquiefced iii th"! fuilice of tl)e7r Cenfuij. And could we i'o Ids on iliar Occaiicn than j.i'^liTi ; ur Mtinj- rial to the Governor, with our Remarki on t\vi Coniutl of tl.i Council ' V. h^.i Mr. Plowj's eane forward with and puhlifhed his Letter lo v.vi Govcrnoi cjuk: ws avoid tcnviilip'^ liiai r » tlio Fallhoodj it containe.l .' When an ancnynious Writer undt.r t e S'^rnaturc of I'lain liuiii appeared the Cha".ipion of t'le Council and judges, were we net juHi.*i;c! in rltfctirg and tx- pot'inr ths Falacv of his Produtlicns ' And ai to t'le Mannrr in which we haNt; c ir:v '"! on ti i Controverfy, we have endeavored not to foiTr the Ci'-jtne:'>. of tlie Irijurtiie and Injuiy v:a hive received fo far to excite our Rtf.nt.neot as to drav fron us .iny Exprefl'ions which ccu.'d fccdsemed hanli orillibcial ; tven the Icurriicui r.nd unmanncrlj Author weluveha. I Cecals n ( "V- y\ T O T M E P U B L I C. to comba, ^^•e flatter ourfclvc. has been treated ^.th muJ. more Decency '•""J'« '''^Ys'Ti or h!d a Ri.lu to cxpc.1. And a. to the Objcrtion that wr have t-^k'n or. ,. vvj-^' -;•;'= BuQnef* ot tt.e Houlcof AifemMy' The Statement here g.ven of our '-°"'*" * ^";' ^^"'""d' J>" a prove. hat we have not interfered luahcr than our own Repu.at.on. were ^'^,";""''' ' »';f Tvc^ Man, who think, for a Mon.ent on the Subject, n.ult *^c'cnt.bie ''>^''"/,;^^'<^' ;";;.',; tcnT. U ^v:, improper, could p.mly sv,c(l a Bulmef, out .. the >l>nf; ^'^; ^ f' '''^ "> p properly belonged to that Body, or could m any Manner :^Ui ihc.r Ot^hgatiuns lo take >t up ""ThfZircl"Men, if in Power, wllUnyo their F.lcnds ; and the worft of Aftion, if per- peuatcd /yVclfT^fth.tnefcription, willbejulUhed or palliated by ' '«; l;,^P«"'^-^ '",^^ 5le ccnary : 1 his wc find ha» been the Cale in the prefent Lo,.trovcrfy ; the moft P^^^ble Cround7n which the Conduft of the Councl ha. be.n dcf.nC.ed, and wluch .''-;^'""'« De- cree the f°mbiance .f Virtue and Benevolence, is thn-'l h..t ,t ..hard to dtpr.ve Men of the>r Subf ence. in an advanced ■nn)e of L.fe , and ti.e private V.rtues of one ot theGc^tlernen are r™ca ly held up to V.ew, by I'lain IVuth, to take hold more cffedualiy on the l'»J^^"»-- C ike .hefe'feMon. fa^l to inte.ert the Mi.d ; and ^. hen Men. un.ler the }^^^ "^ ^ch Feelines are fuddenly led to countenance Adions which -re wrong, liom Tendeuief. to SeASs?wcinvolun-a,ily prV.fe the amiable WeaUneL by wh.ch th.y are overcome Put ilei would thefe ConlHl=ra,icn> end, if once Court, of >ft.ce Huuld becon.e -"" .""^ by iuch Votive, > A Speaker VN ho was the moll capaMc of inierclUng the I'ad.ons. wouk. aUay» b ,' e to fucceed, a^ul luilice would be cr,cd out of Court. But .1 the Counol were ac- tuated by Mot.veJof Humanhy in adjudicate, on the Judges .t '^ "'■w';*'e.rl th v hate th- Influence of that amiable Virtue in adjudicating on th<- Cafe of t .e W.tne.res , they have, with ut Remorfc, confined them to Inf. my, and, by their Advce to '- '/J^^' ^V' as .ppcar. by Wu A^fvver to the Addref. of many rcfpec>ab e '"'••'';'^^"'^' '.'^^Jl^j;;'; ;^^^. *e.y hcarnly approved the fubfequent violent ConduCl of the l"'^8"--T " '"^^ °"'^''^'^^!' '": *irely ou ot- t!ie Cuhnef,,-do th. Council d.f.over any i eeling tor Mr. NVatfon, sheriff of C.unberland, compelled to pay a large Sum of Money, lor no other Realon, t..an """''-^g^" Order of that fame C'ourt, wluch he was obliged to execute > Or do they feel any I h,ng or tie Kins'o Subjcfts in generaj, whofc Live, and Properties are from Year to Year ^~'\'»J^^ Vr.carioti^, by the ignorant or partial Deeinon, ef thofe Men ' it'^v"'"^ ' \ T a J hi a Matter at fuel. Magnitude, the pnvate Keliofii ot imi.v.duaU Ihould take the>ead,mfU.ad 1 ht 1 ri.ods of the CourcU and the Judges, luive taken the very unjuf\.f^able L'^^ty of re- prefennng a large I a.t of th.. ( on.n.un.ty, who have f..vo,ed u. w.tU the,r Countenance, as f: ^ir u and tuftuknt, and have g.ven vc'y broad Mir.t. that tlx.r l.,tent.on was the Suoverl.on c. th.Kin.'s Govemmeft in tl i.Vrovlnce. "l he A.thor of 1 lain 1 ruth ParfcuUrly .nf^^n - ates, t'-atllep-efent Unea.uul. ar.le f.om a ^phit ot ■•'^P"''''":''''" "^^^ '"'P;''""" "''j KenVaint of nu,n.rehicalC.overnmei,t. Had that Idea been Ipcrf d by a M^'' w'>o ^^^ ""'f°^"^: )y leen .-.n Advo.are for the di^ ire Ri^ht of Kmg^, anrt whole Conduft had been af^reeable to h,^ Princphs, it mii'ht have been borne vv:th lome Deer e of I at.ence : but svbcn .t proceeCs tun, a Nian « ho has never iluwn auy Attachn:- nt to -ny Gcvernn ent, but v hat was funded en Intereit, and v. ho .. well known to have fohct.d to be .-.dmltud as a C.t,zen of a '''»-':'•«- at.d Repuhl c, while earning on a War with t! cir natural ard liege Sovx.e.gn-.t cannot la.* to ■. xcite the honelt IrdivPat.on cf every I over ot lus K.ng and the Br.t.Jh Govern.-nem. ■1 he Truth IS, ti.e reaf Auihoi- of that mali;;rant Publication by his (hameful and unprmci- r!edCo.Vu«h.-. etteeeda Meafuredif^rae.Uil in itiolf, brcl ly injurious to us and jult.y ^■armin,' to every t'.inkin< Man in .he Lou..try, and to oove. himlelt from th.; Oriiun- he me- lits fo.' his Ini^iui'y he' has e.-deavored to la.len on llw n.oll h.ber i.nd ration;.! 1 art ol the Comm niiy, the Im.ut.tion •. I c n- tLibul-.nt a.ul taCilous. This Charge was never mxle tyour uth..rlor tlie Puriole^f alieol.n^ us .roLM-Caule in this Province ; '.or it .s well K.io.vn l.f.ethit the Ley .1, th. (.r.lcrly, the I. uulfnou. ard the .voft opul .U ''ar'"' "'^;,'- ' '"- mrni.y. w h tl.or they be Old or New >e:tieis, Lnivcrl..ly r.p.obati: the iV.al.u-es Lately adoi tea ,ef e.'t;octle luc-gs-. 1^- t- iiows, that the 1 eO|.le ^re ala.n.ec', and viryjulMy loo, to find that 1 orVons ill i i -h Ctli^c ar;- 1 ..i.ly en. u;h b- th to decide in Aatt'.rs ot the hiijhell Moment not only auu'nft t'.r: Rules of fubilantial judlee, but agalnft eve-.y A pi raranee ■ f it. Rtj utatiin is a • .,0.1 nJ3ll leople aie- t.-.,acioj» of, it is 'he lall '1 hinx even a b.d Man pves up, it is thue- f( .-e a ine-1 nch' ly t iiriiniltanee to ft-e a l.'eleription of Mm whole C ha.h.?"lers cutht to te i ot .nly ih.llv but devoid ot Sufpici. n, and who have I'owcri of (> muoh Co nlecjUeiKe coiTmntti ■.! t • t'leli ( lurv.c, voluntarily icli.iq.i'.lliin* .ill i'leteniions to (.1,-racUi and tiling ihtir Authen- r, I., I '.iiv I'urK.i'v'S tf ori.a:'. CiMtifu.it.ttio.i or Revcni/.' ■»" 1 mm TO THE PUBLIC. »ii In thii Controverfy we have fomrtimes k»« ^ur j the I'crfon. wl.ofe Ch.raflers u'cy Sd Rufh •'^''* '° ^*^ T*''"?* ^^'^^ "'»<^ ?'*« I^*'" to the f auit ought not to reft on us if Ven will do h,'!'I!J " ^"" ^^^ '»'"=' ^^ conceive thtm b,d Men, there can be no Bread, eif.e of I,,,,- ^^'"? "° °"« '• to bl..me for callin? j-rcper Name*. *"'"' °' -'""'" »<■ Chanty in cailiug Thing, by their When it is confidered that we are Men of B r r t. occupy our whole Time, and that n.oft of our f'!!!!. »'I.'f°^ "^'''"^ "^""^ ^""y ("""icientto >.ehope Allowances w,ll be mad by the ioKnuo^^^^ ""^ ^»"''' "*P"'<='^. *Pr"r euher ia jh. Style <,r Arrangement of Ch.SubjS. ''"'^"^ '°' '"^ ''''•'^' ^'»«*' *"'/ J. STERNS, W. TAYLOR. a- '&n m '' il'i/ri J^ C (^( C A i^ ■J--/ fc 2_.. c- /i^i. L/C t^ / c6io / yj / ^t'^y\ k/c^ v^- r / I / // } 1 irjsjptnLTrL 'h i'-cpyr'^a2Z~ CT-Z-g. '/^TKlUil. ■ Uur-c / c ^ EXTRACTS from the PROCEEDINGS V W '> O F His M AJESTTs COUNCIL, ll.-r.fjx, 'be lij} February, lySS. HI S Excellency the Li.uttnam GjTf" '■ IsiH l>efore the Council an Addrcf'. preMMted le hiin fioni ilij Mtiif^ of AlFcn hly ot" tlic nil December, Dating, 1 hat v.ompUint« had been ImH biiore tlie Hctie of the improptr and irrejalar Adii ii,ilti_tion of JuHire in the sl- prenit Court, nnd i eq ' i e (Imp, that tnquiiy tni^jlil be nunle inio the C'l ndud ol the JullUes of J .h acccmpanied faid \ddrtf$, and u refer' d to, as th= I'roofb, on which tlie fame wa-j founded ; and alfo the Anf\vers thtrcio m.i.le by thi [uftice* cf (oid Court to Hii Excellency j On all which hedetired the Confidtrati m and Advice ol the Courjil. Wh ch feveral I'ap^ra b^-ini; read, it was ac-rfcd, that th? Council would go into a paiticuUr Conlideration oi the whole Matter on ThuruUy the iStli, ^ Tlvrftiiiy I'itb February, I788. His Majefty'3 Council Ssving maturely confidered the Adoref.. j-H-ciented to Hi» I xcellency the Lieut njiit Oo-jiincr from thr Houfe of Airenibly, of thezirt rf DtcemI tr, together with the Allegations which accornparied it, and the Anfweis of the Jullices thereto ; Do unanimcuny »irce. th.t. tire Allegftions miHe by faid Attornies in the Hoiifc of Aflcmbly againA the Con • dufl in Office, of the fufticcs •f the Supreme Court, are jrciirdlefs and fcandalcut ; and, that the jufUces ot faid Court have by their Anfwer* thereto, luily acquitted themfelves of all Im- putation of Mal-*-ondutt in Office. 1 he Council having alfo read and confidered a Memorinl, prefented to His Excellency on the 19th Inftant, by McfT rs 5rii/:i and 7 jy/sr-, on the Subieif^ of the liclore mentioned Acculacions made by ♦'h^m ; and which His F.xceHency ^vss pleai'cd alfo to lay beloie them, the Council Were tharcoii of Upinion, that laid .Memorial is altogether undefoiving cf his Ixcellency's Notice. .\nd Whether the Prayer cf it is net reafonable and fuch a one" as Whether the hire Air-.-riior.s cf t'-- !'a, tic .iccufcd, unfupported by any Species of i;vidence, i, furticicrt to fallen upon us the lmiut-l li of bringing forward fcandalous Uinr;es, without C.iound or Uund .tim, . i,i ,ho,t ■i Icne-h the Anathema of the Council appears to be pointed at us, zni aimed at th. Delhuiimn of Xr Characters, we fubmit it to the Public whether the Ctrlure dies not equally fail en i^,- \'c prefcntative Body of the People, who unuaimouny agreed, upon the Eviderce before them' that there was Reafcn to fufpedl the faid |u.tices ot '.nproierjA lrrc.„!.r .-^V 'w," :! c« "' Whether the above Frial of -he faid juftices. ,r it .-., ILlUdc.., is fuch'a -Jn.;! :i ho Vcu'c of AfTcmbly requeued .n their Addrefs ' Whether we have been tren.d wi,), ,! fai ne^ ",'' Candor we were intitled to u^ mt.cj]-., called up n hv a Pran.h of ih- I rrill ,iu ■ •.;.:;, mons we were bound to obey, efpec.ally, when wc repeatedly declared to the CeN-/:',rr Tlv ,■ '• wree ready ,0 fubftantiate every Part of our Telfmony. and only req,: Oe .,?,■■ 'uri V^ doing It > And whether it does not appear tl, u the Cruncii li.iv/tti. 1 -he Wr ,•'.!; ' i luft.ces, rather than the J.iMiccs rhemfelves ^ Confcous rf the Ifri-htneil r^ .„■ in- V and Condu^ in the whole TranfiOion, we O.ould have been h ..Vy^^ , uv i^d bc'or • il^ Hh' !-c our rcftimony given toth. Ho.fe ..f ArTem-.l-, ard tl„ lud^ie^ ArJlw^r:: ' 'l^^H^h th': boll 5 ,.' ', t I 4 \ , ...- ,, .lU.ucn to h. ecr „t .uhjcch . , ,,, ,o fay any lli.^R FROM THE ,, ^ c r O T I A GAZETTE:, "^ "^ " ' To the PRINTER. Thurulay bft< T "a'-'H^ «^^''^^ \''"'.' '"' or -c Tan'l will by '-ore > ""^f^^"; ' -^^t la-ing heard the S= ■S^^fcvvhofe.lth.n.dv^^j.-e;^^;^^,^,, hcH. ^„,, eve.y ^ e ud. ment ot it, i^ncl to place tlie ^^ ^ ^,^^^. i^gper .« a ^ ^, b ^^^ abridged ; no a ..oubt buttlut eve y 1 c non '" ^f j^ ,vh.oh h>. M^f 'J ' j^j the Ar.iweri given by "^'J i -Vo a copy ot ther own ' j;^"^°^J^' „,« ,ud^c«, vvh.C 1 g^'^f^'^,,, educed towrw '■• .; the Caies on wh.cU ttey >'•> ' ^" '^„. n,ade by thorn m the Houie wu ^ ,^^^ ^^^„ 1 , ,:^ r confciueut a.'d, 1.1 iTf^/ t , , fj i^jlc A.> -' <-r^ "I i „t them aniwcr tor tu^m op.n.onso.the uver,lj. or let th:ir Sikncc m-.u _t .^ ^^,„^^ ^'^^ ^f^y certain that le've, il th.y,th--M .- ^.^^^^^ ^,, ^•i-r,,^'':^^ rido no: believe r^ '^ "^ ,^ rwo othe,., ,r ict th:ir ^"^" ,•-■"- . „ut luppoUos tne ;-; ^ ^ain that a, i am t5 [ 5 ] Drowning Men catch at every Thing j and fometimcs accelerate tlirlr' neftiuciioii l.-"} tfu* ?agernel* to lay hold of what cannot poflibly ferve them. The Authors ot the ' A^jpeal niuit re:! their L ai.le on the immutable Laws of 'I ruth and Jurtice. If the Cafts thty*ha>if cijed ai- either failc in Foint of Faft, or frivolous and irrelevant, the Accufation muft fall totii-j CfouiMl, and ,ts Authors with it, although they Ihould be able to prcvc that their i ale had deceUed r.Ot four Gent'emen only but four hundred. • , There arc two | nncipal liuellions on which the Meritt of the Appeal will be bcfl confidereJ ■. l(\. Who are the Authors of the Accufations of the Judjei : Or in other Wordt,^ whofeTel'- timony was the Addrefs of the Houfc founded ? idly. Are the Cafes, cited by Mclf rs Surm and TjyLr before the Houfc, fairly flated, ar.cl do they prove the Char;e-i made by tlii;m. It is Imniatciia! to coniider whether MeflTrs. Srerm and Taylor are to be viewed in the Light of WitnelTes, called before the Houfe of Aflfenibly to give Evidence, or whether they wtrc nor Volunteers on the Occalion ; bccaufe their Crime is not tliat they have giren TelliTony, but in having tertified falfely or impertintntly. I believe, however, if it were n^celfary, it rould be cafilv proved that the Accufation wa3 concerted at Mr. ifr.-rm'i Houfe, and the Manner of bring- ing it forward in the Afleiijiy^, as wJl a$ the Mode in whxh it was to be fupported, there fettled and agreed on. In Or er to determine the fir,1 Que'iion, little more will be necclTary than to look into the JournalSi,of the Houfe, and its Addrefs to the Governor. The Affgnibly met the 25th of October, and after it had been fitting more than a Month, and after one or two fruidefi Attempts had been made to cenfure the Judges, ft'.ajoT M l/eiif^e. Mem- ber for D'lgbf, moved, t at the Houfe flioul.t refolve itfeif into a Committee on the InveiVgaiioa of Fafts, which, he faid, had occafioned Dilfatisfatlions in the Province relative t ■ the Admini- ftrntion of Juitice in the Supreme Court, This Motion was agreed 10, and, at the Inflance of the Maker of it, the Cle.k was rielired to rcqueft MelT'rs. ^nm: and Tay/r, Attormcs cf that Court, to attend the Committee the next Day. Mr. h^^i, another Attorn. y, v^as alfo defirtd to atttnH, but W.1S njt examined. Mr. Stcrm, as the leading Acculer, was hril called in, and entertained the Committee for fe.eral Hours, as wdl on that as tl.e Day foUowin,;, witli a Hif- tory of CaCes tried in the ^uprsme Court to prove the Ma'-conduft in Office of th; Judges, and their Want of Inte^rty ; after his P.xaniin ition was hnilhcd, th.- Acco'jnt he had given w.is read to him, and he was delircd to put hts Name to it, which he did. J he Commitf e, \v(ay of the Bufmtfs, and impatient from the length of Tin e be(lov.-ed on it, defireJ Mr. Tnyii' might be requerted to pu^ what he had to allcdge upon Paper, snd to bring it to the > cmmi'-- tee, which he did, and on the 3Cthof November they reported to t'le Houfe the I xaminations ol' MeJT'rs Sterm and Taylor, "at the Narrath't of the I'.u^i ff-.y hjd ini^-ni^aifil,'" and wliich they fuhmitiod without any Judgment or refolution whatever thereon. Anotlvcr Motion was thcii made by Major M. Hedge, that a Committee diould be appointed to pr.-pare an Addrefs to his Ex- cellency the Litut,'ia>'t-Go-vermr on the Subjeft, and to rtqutft he would .'dopt fuch Meafurrs thereon as he fhould think juft and right. The Addrefs was accordingly prepared, in which the Houfe fay, tl»at Complaints had been bid before them cf the improper and irieguh-r .f dmini-. ftration in Office of his Majefty's luftices of the Supreme Court, &c. ^'' the Pro':fl ^f -.vh'nb, a- *' they have teen offered to us, loefubmit ts yur E>:ce!'ciicy, (Sfc." And Copies of the Alltpa'i- cns of MelF'ri Stems and Tayhr, the I'roofs alluded to, were prefentca with the Addrcl-, and no o;her Paper or Teftimony whj.ever. 1 have been the more particul.u in rtl.uing thefe CIrciimftancfs, which are conl d alnoftve-r- b^tim front the Journals of the Houfe, becaufe 1 wifh " a candirt Public" to li^e hew ve-^y apt thefe .Attornies are to mi(l.ite Fafts, and to feize, pcrf.is nut tufa!, rn ary Pretext 10 h d,,; themfelve. Can Mr. Ijyls, fay he was ret iuliy heard by the Committee, when he drew up the .Statement marie by him at his Leifure, and deliver;! it in as all he had to fay on the Subjea > it Mr. Srnrs was not jjcrniitted to f.ater.U ttie C:v^^ !'.• in- tended when he was before the Committ-e, he hnd fiirely Oppoi tunity -to inlLrt \r :'.vi Mcnor ..1 which he and Mr. 'l.iyLr prcfentcd to the Cocernor, any Cai- or F.id wl.i, ri I ,,.i bcore he i> •muted by him. Be this ak it may, th.ir wli^le (.lar^'e a^-aiinl the JuJj.s rhojll iij-.v he .0..- liiieicd u [ 6 ] rtJered a; marfs ; an.1 to p-o .a it, 'm tlie T.»r.guage of the Council, grounjllcf, .vi,-! T jnjjl. ui, Uuli be the jul>jeil of a' otiitr letter fipm I'LAiN ll'-L'TH. Halitax, Mj'cb II, i;S8. FOR THE HALIFAX JOURNAL. Mr. Howr, Ai y.u L^ti'j- fublijhid M.Jps. Stfrt; anj TjyLr's Mmoii.u', y.u arc diji} ;d t3 fuhD.f) tl:if.!fy (J' a Litter tt his Exi.iiit»cy lb-, (j^tverr.ur. S I R, Halifax, iebrujiy zX, i;? HA'.'IN'C read the Memorial of MefTrJ. Sterni and Taylor, prefcntcd to your Fxcellency on Monday, i beg Leave to make a ftw Kemarks on tliofe I'arts oi ir m which they Iiave t iou;ht , roper to introduce my Name. . am but little acqu in-ed with Mr. Taylor, and do not recollet'l to have converfed with hin>, at any inie, on t!ie Conduit ;n Office of the judges of the Supreme Couit j fo that he can have no . uiencL' to quote my Sayings or Oi>inions. ith Mr. Sterns 1 have *• l-cretof'.re" lived in Habits of Intimacy, and have been often ptftered bv hiin w th ^urgtllions, that the Judges were coi ruptly partial in tlie Decifion of Caufes brought betor.; then ; but i have no Recolleifliun of having ufed the Kxprerti ns againll ther.i, ftattd by t!i Nieiiic.rlal.ftt, or in 'eed any ot like import. I perfcdlty rccollcd>, and fo fhould Mr. Sti.rn?, t' . in I ur iunfid?ntlal Conveifations on t!;e Suhjcft, 1 always declared, 1 did not believe the judijv.- wee >o rupt, or i« any Degree criminally partial ; and until I was convinced tliey were 10, 1 would r.ot be ome their Accufer, cr ngagein any Attempt to remove them. When ih'.- Bu finer v^ as broui-ht for war- n a fecret Committee of the Houfc of Aflenibly, and whe ., inft ad oi efta' IKbing .iny Colour of Guilt againll them, a String of garbled Law Cafts a"d p.irtLiI statements oi 1'roi.eedings bef< re thtm, were adduced as Proofs of their Want of In- tt.nty, a d ol th-ir M.-1 adminiiUatien cf juflicc, 1 was fhockcd at the Condud of their x- cuicri, Ar\A dtdured to loma Mcinbers of the Houfe, that I thought the Judges were cruelly tr at d, that i had not a L oubt of thtlr Innocence, and jvculd, if rcquefted, molt willingly ad- voeitc their Caufc before any 'liibunal in which 1 could be ferviceable to them. i h.ft are Ifill my ientiin. nts ; but their Caufe requiiet no Advocate ; for the Futility of th« CI ar II is o' vious on theiace of them, and the Anfwers of the Judges form fo clear and fatis- l'..ctory a i< futation of Cuilt, that, 1 think, no wcU-infoi mcd unprejudiced Perfon can, for a Ni^m'.nt entertain Doubts of it. if c^. . t ons of a criminal Nature had been, or could be fairly fubrtantiated againfl them, thae is n': ftian in tiK rrorinct who would be moie delirous than myfclf to effeft their Removal ; but, i^x.,ifit as I am of their Innocence, 1 think it my Duty to afford tiicm all t!ie Aid in my Pow <-, and t coun eraif a Hefign, the apparent Objtd ot which is to bear down, by the pow- er ul ir of Fadion ard populai l^rcjudice, reipcdable Men, confpicuous for Moderation ard Jiu:Tian ty in the Jifcha ge of tHeir Duty, and who, paced in difficult ituations, have for ma- ny i'c.r» nlitd Omc s i-f the finl lmpjrt.ince in the Government with general K.cputa;ion and Lll-e n. > h.it tlieMemcr'a'ifls meanbytiie "manifefl a.-.d avowed Partiality of the Judges towards me, "a a r.u:iiliorer, ' lam at a Lofs to ccnjedure ; unlefs it is that they have paid more Attention to 1. im.o 5 decent y ijr.;<.d by me kt the Bar, than the lurbuler.t Haran^utiof Mr. Sterns. As for *'r. .j)l r, liC lias argued only one Caufc, I think, before the Court, and the Lofs of that lecms to have dcllioyed ihe Sh reol I'rdciOandino; he wa>. thought to polftf.. . (hould n t ti4vc troubled your Fxcellency with thii Dftaii, hid 1 not obkrved, that Accu- fcs Ic! ■ m la 1 to fuggeft, tlwt the f;lcnt Contcnijit of indignant Innocence is ccrioberaiivc of tiiJ i-aluinn.ej tliey have circulttcd. ' 1 have tl.e Ho- or to be, with the greafeft Refped, \ o'jr txcLllfncv"; nicll obedimr >ervant, s. S. BLOWER S. Ti Hit Ex:c!'tni-y the LiEv TIN AN r-Govir.N OS. FROM 'f^-' '-^ r 7 ] :r -« - •d*- TF R O M T M R HALIFAX JOURNAL. To the PUBLIC. APUIVlIC \TI0\ mide "ts Appc^r.incc in Mr. Henry's Paper of Tucfdiy (aft, ontTie^iiH* )'.f\ ol the late Trial .ind AC)uittil ol the Juftices of His Majefly'j .-iiiprenic curt, u .• tht ii>;ii.ituic of riaTn I'rutli, in wiiith the ri;.ii Author is a« clearly to be diiciivcred as ij ii ..d tinned liis Name to every Sentence it conrans. 1 hat unfairnefi and equivocat on whiLh Mrk every I'art of the i.'onduf> of a certain Gentleman liigh in (Jthcc in this I'rovince are fo coif. i. cuoui ill this I'erformancs a-, to leave no Room for u< or ttic Public to doubt v» ho is its ■. ur'^or, or that h;; inieht, with mucli in, irc propriety, have take.a the Signature of I'Jain fallhood, than the one he has alFunud. As he liai rtcp'd forth the avowed Champion of the Council and the Juftices, we thin'< our- felves w.. antid in prefumuig he has the r Authinty for bringing them tefore the I nbunal of the Public, and (hall therefore take the Lihcrty of examining the (.'ondiift of bothwith a IJeiree of Fre!jdox wj before piirpofely avoided, our Objett then being only to fet our ownOonducV in fuch a Light as to enable the Public to c'^Cide impartially between us and the other rarties con- cerncd in this Tranfaclion, or in the cxjant Phrafe of our Author, to place the saddle on the right Horfc. The great Objea before the Public is to determine. Whether there hath cxifted probable Caufe for fufpeftinp the Juftices of His Majcllys Supreme Court of malrerfation in Office i' And whe- ther the Decifion of the Council hath removed, or ought to remove that Imputation ? Our Author has overlooked thefe Obje'fs ';ntirely, and feenis only intent on tiaducinf cur Charafters, and endaevo'ing to prove, that the Juftices were accufed by us, and not by the Houfe of Aflembly. His Production bcinp too contemptible to merit a particular Anfvvcr, to every Part, we (hall contetit ourftlves with giving to the Public a (hcrt Account of the Origin of the late Proceedings of the Houfe of AiremSly rtfpefiing the Admimftration of Juftice, in the su- preme Court, To far as thev an; within our Knowled^iC, recapitulating the Mcafures taken by the Council in Confequence of it, and remarkin; on fome few Things contained in this Publication. For a Ion : Time paft great Uifcontents have fublifted at the Par, and in the Country at lar^e, with the Adminiftration of [ uftise in the Supreme Court : All the Gentlemen of the Law with whom we have converfed, and we have converfed with moft of thofe in any exte' t of Practice, have agreed fome Remedy was neceflary for the Evil, but no one thoug,ht proper to fttp forward as the Champion cf the i'ub'ic on the Occafion, forefeeinjr the Difficulty which would attend it : r.ut to fuch a Height dd th; OilTatiifaftion arife during the Sitting of faid Court in uly laft, tliat fcv-ral of the Mcn-.ber, of the Houfe of Affcmbly communicated with us, of their own mere Motjon, long before the laft Seflion of that Houfe, on the Subjcft, and informed us oftlie r in- tention to move for tlie Knquiry which was afterwards inftituteJ in the Houfe : Wc arc re .dy to own, that the Propofal niclour moft hearty Approbation t That we then thought a'd do ^ ftlll think, it was a Meafiire liii>h'y necelfary lor the general VVe'fare of the Province, and tliat if we had been Members of that Koufe, we fhould moft certainly e ther have brought ; or-.vard cr fupportod the Motion which was m ide by the Honorable .ind worthy iV ember f:er.i L-i^by, whole upright and independent Conduit in his Legillative Capacity, docs him thehig e('. Ciedit. But wiien Mr. Plain Truth alferti, t'lat the Accufation was conceited -t the Houfeof Mr. turns, an 1 the Mode of conducing it ajieed on there, he has moft egregioufty deviated Ironi tae Line of I'lain Triith r.nd Fac>, and fuft.tuted Conjecture and lallhod in their ftcad. This Relatijn we have thought proper to lay before the i'ublic, notbecaulo weconcelve it vsry nureri.ll who firft originated the Accufation of the judge., but becaufr v/e are perfectly willing to have t\-erj P.irt of cur Conduit in this rra'-'"i£Uon l.-iid open to the- Wold. Ho.vever our Autl.or in hi^ Zc.!, feems not to have ua!iy fufieied their, ro !;t c". tht; 'I^i <1 ; and all this they ^^ tr: : ,»or:c with.-.ut :v:- at'f.rf.v.i;: to ctr\y ilic Tiut'-. v". "', *4i^ [ 8 1 H en th" contrary, It i. An Art cf ti.e Hcufe of ArTembly, it was impoff.ble for the Council f* V.\e lutjH f..i ili'y had taken cur Tclt.mony apainft tl.e Judges, lor the I'urp (c uf hav.nj thcr. h. il y condemned, or a> qu.t.cd on .t, a. ,he fame «.s tak-n prWatciy, n.i on ua.h, and lit , out the Judge, having .n Opportunity of crcU-examlnrng the VS.tne.lts. ip.'ced '"^X n-u.t Tae k.^own,wLver were the Accufcr., tl.al Evidence t,.Ucn m th>. Manrcr could not he fuch ..* any Vritilh .u.ot« ovght to be tried upon. This ,s a D.lemma f .om wh.ch cur Author, >.ith all hi» Inienuhy and icrgiverfauon, v.M not be able lo extricate lumulf or h>s Fnends. Our^utt4*decl.iTc.. iKh.st.ken Pain* to inform himfc f of the I adf. and C.rcum(»ance. .*hich .ave RiTc to our AUdrcf> to -h. I'ublic : We have no Doubt but he ,s perfectly acquaint - Td wmrthem, a„d we only w.h he was a. well di.pe fed a, ^.l'' ^^-'f ' ^l^'.;''"*;;; . .e^fi;^" fa't. invr them ; we have no Doubt but he was know.ng to the who.e Tranfaaicn m the firft^>«'^» ot it an^ that he early difcovered the back Way through wh.ch he MUendcd to conduft 1.. F.i nds frfe fr, m InvC.gation and tnquiry. Tty .... an Inuccuracy .n the Addref. c. 1^ Houfe in refcnng to our iel^imony as the I'roofs on wh.ch they procee.'ed. The 1 n.t i ol rX,l "ndl ain Irut. we havenol.oubt knew it, that Meffrs. Un.a.keand Harcfay gave . Kir intVrnVatt^n and Opinion, in their Places, as Members of the Houfe; their Tcft.mony iherTere could not^ave been rcHuced to Writing. After we were examined, an Addreis was agreed on in" one of thofe Gentlemen appointed of the Committee to craw u up ; alter '^ -»;^'i":P'«^ ♦ urf nte< to, and accepted by the Houfe, that Cenilemati, as we are informed, propcled .hat H; r eft mcn%.ould be reduced to Wriunp to accompany it : But .t bt.ng towards the c.ofe o t eSemons7and the Houfe in a hu,r>, it was dcemeo by them """'^"*^-*7 ,*° 'flud Tr u^ e hole Ikntlcmen promifing to auend and give their l v.dcrce .n the 1 rul of t le Jud- wU ?r AutI or the Lft Tit.'e to th- igna.urehc has alTumed, he would have told thefc fad" a d not Jave:;,deavored to miH^.a the Public, by palming on them Fidion in the Place ""^Thet'rt w.th wpich the following Sentence is Introduced, deferves ^'^.^'^''^^ Author fay^ " 1 Ihall not conlider wi,h ^^ h.c Degreeof Truth thefe falfe Accufers havv .ntr.duced the Names » nnd i"nio' sof the fcver.l Gentlemen mentioned in th.ir Memorial ; let th.m an'wer for " "iv -n Iv" °iA^e tSnU proper, or let their Silence manifert the thorough Contempt .n w .ch " ev hold the Authors of the Appeal and their Allegation.." There is n»thmg new m this dc5wtrw..t.p.m.a^a:.ted^ -r^hltS'^ f ^^"^s na.d in the ^-l w^ fa^ ^o^d^any Mar. l^... „ne Mon^ent to ':^^.^^^'^r'^^^^^ t^.tTa immunity w..' Contempt. The Public ::t-:; ?^;;.=i;^" ":tf. w.e. -Viir £s^r:S^w i;:^ vl-^ l:nt:-:gii:ec;;!:^tn'::;th:pubhc,tw:;^^ ly l>il to . .e-fe' ot ^ha.Tie. Fre-domof the Frefs which no Man cf In- Atier .dmlt inmhe llkffir.ss ^7'"='^ ^''^^/'^^ '"^X em^ud. to deny our Author proceeds to .. Poubt b,.t f-.it every I'erfon m theLomn.unuy x -^ '^,^^^^,^ ,,,^^.^ entertained." Will l.aUfati^fiedtl.efuohc, --.1 e.her th^ toun^ ^^ ^^ ^^^^ ^^^.^^^ ^^^^^^^^^ very imperfect N.anncr .n ''■■'■''=', ^'^ , \^^" ^^^,,7 .^yw"^ only fceking for Information, not Ym- ciown, would have convinced t.K- Hubhe hat «-'^y ^^ = "J obtained from the Clerk of d.nc„.. our writer ';'.ry, Clii.l" lulticc of India, did (h y proceed to 1 rial upon the mere Charje* and AII^»tioa^ ' U not a folcmn Jrial to take place ? Are not Witneires lo be examined on both %\ail ; \vl ere both Parfle, will have an Opportunity of crof*. examining thcin > By w' ich mrrrs the vvl:'>l« Fadtj will ci-meout, and fuch a Uecilion take place ^it-the Honor and Uiinity ^f the Natunrc- tate of our Minds en this Occalion. Mr. Blower; reprefentj the Magiftrate : we the fekn ; and what is very extraor- dinjiry about this worrhy MasjKlrate is, that when the Bone' ; tirft flicwn him, lie did not ap- prehtnd any Forgery ; it really ap;>eared to liim to be tlie hand Writir.g of the Perfun under whofc Kamtir appeared : And here as it toocftcn the Cafe with Magitlrates of hil Dtfcription, 1e made the poor Man thinlfchimfelf quite fecure, and that he had no furti cr Uilficulty to ap- rrt-licrH. Thi next News the .Man h.'ars, is That he is to be hanged fi;r forgery, and tiiat the J> ty ol Execution is named. He complains to tlieMajirtrate — he charges him with aflingwitli d:;phcity : the Magiilrate replies, the I'eifon whofe Name is to the Bond, has been with me, irij u'ciiics the Signiture to be his Hand-writing, and though he by that Denial gets ri(* of the Cbligat;,:..! li; woulil othervirife be under to pay it, yet as that is fie Cafe you ftand conviiSedof l-o!j;t'y, I would advifcyou to make a peaceable Exit. '1 he poor Man pleads the Laws of his Co;,.i£r/, \?!i;ch f-^rbid that any one (hould be condemned unheard j avers he can prove, by Wit - ni.;\s tt-|;o law the Pond executed, thai it is the Aft and Deed of the Perfon whofe Name isfub- i; l.od to ir ; but i- is to no riirpofe, he is told Judgment is pronoonced, and that Execution niu'i M,l!a\vs of Truih and Juflice." This is whatwc hare ever wilhcd, and it is not our Fault that a dark and left handed Road lr '.Kl.bv.ur, for diverting the Courfi of the Water whichturned his Mill ; he attended to the poo,- Man's Accufation, ind examined his while Cafe ; punilhed the Villainy of the Judges, iraJc the rich Man return the Water into its former Chauael, and obliged him to compcnfate lie injured Wilier for all thj Damages he had fultained. T he Que'^ion here did not turn on t'.:iz i o.nr, Who wts the ,\ cufcr ?" the Kinj did not take the fimple Affertioni of the lartie* f Mr. 'I aylor and m>fc-;f, having made iti Appearance .a Mr Hcwe s Paper of tlic nth InlUnt ; ia which, from Tefen of Memory, orfomeotlier LauU, you have ma ^e 'ome e.ieg.ou. MiiUkes ; i (hall t.ke the Liberty of pointing thtm o"'. ^'"l a-iimadvurtina; on fucti Tart, of it as ara calculated and mitndcd to miilead, lO a Bufmel, oi the ftrH Importance to this Piovince, as well as fi my o'.vn Ch.iraacr It is fue »' vv^ have h^y.tcf.re iived in the Hab.ts of i.Ki.na.y,- and I moll fince.ely L'.men« that a IXfer-ion • f your Principle*, and a Sciies of improper Conduit, (hould ha»e ohhgert me lo withdraw that good Opinicn of, and warm AHf.aion I had for you when 1 coniidered you as * H'ld l'":"rlly'l<^tl!fundatn under which you had moft f.lemnly inliHed, and become rcuter only, 1 Ihoul-^ ha.c fudcred you to pafsunnotic.d, without even expofing l'""'' Ircache- ^ ; hut when you have nut only defer-ed )0 ir Colour., but entered into 'j'^^'^^';-^^ ^^ » ^^^'^f, Men whole iiir-ctples and .'onduft you have hcretoiore umtorn.ly condemned, you cannot think it lutd ;t Jcu^^e treated a« a c'o^mon Encaiy while in the Field, and as a Uefcrterwhtn \oj lill into tt.e i lands oivoui former I neiids. , , . . ■ • * yIu fay '• you h.ve been oite,. pedered by me with Suggeftions that tlie J"<^«=y'"f. ^-f^; i' ;4 pa'ri..nn t!,e Leciiion .f Caufcs brought before the.n, but that >^u ^^^e no Recollefl.on " of iuvin? ufed the Expr.ihcns againlt them llate^ by ths MemoriahUs, or .ndeed any .f L.«3 " l^r^ot undertake to dct.r:.ine what wa. the ft.te of your Mind, v-'^^^^^T'thnfoJe -'on' v.rfed on t' e iul.j.a of li.e )uO:<.s ot the uo-e.ne Court, but 1 verily btheve, 'hat tl.o le on- v! Lio.s were as oltei. ir.rodu.td by you as my.elt, r.n>l th.t you wa. ^^^^^ t'fl'f.^^'lH^^^^ ^^^. ns, vx.ept or. r.coliea <,n of them, .:tter you 1 :A thought ttt to change Sides and ,,.« : Kr./mth; m,.l n.anieful Attempts on the .eput.t.on :>nd Hon..r of 'h%Man <.u h,.d fo- ki.inU pied.Hd yoi.rlJ.i to :uai;crt : 1 hen you wa. do.iutlefs / ,>W with the H... tha. your Ou > in..l in theCoun'i-ef Cu,.b..lan.l, eve: lir^ce the l.iu.recli.n ti.ere inthe Vear 17:^ >^-l"^h >.u^.e- r^ [ 1 1 ] J L. •^rcd they hid done In a partial and fhameful Manner, and 'ihnt they I'url aj-ji 175 taken I'm Sid; ot tlitf Kebiii againit the Kinvj'i Loyal iiil^jeOs : But that they li«d re^tr btcn al'K tia cttefl any I liinf( againll them while tlis late Ch.it Jofiict livtd, who had | r( tuietl a l laulr to lir iolerted in tht- Adl, which gave him a Controul over their 1 roLCcHings, and wIkj conllan;!/ while a Ive relided their Attempti araintl them. 1 then ohftrv(,d, ih.u 1 tlii;i;rht :1 « Country in central in a mort dei>lor.ible Situation as to the Admin iilrat ion of J u 'I ice, ^v<\ It w3» ikfnut\ of the liar particularly to endeavor to reform it. In whuh, you net only ai.v,ui.f<,cd, l-ut declared, yi>u thouiht It tne Duty of every one ti) do it ; tliat the Cou ntiy wiula be ruimd unlc(\ fome t hani^e fhould tike Place, and averred your Readinefj to afTitl in | ricur.ng a Kemov;! r,t the |iiilicei of the .>upreme Court from O/hce, but faid you would not be th*; firrt Mover cf the I'lUlinefs on Account of your being an Officer of (Jovernmcnt. 1 thtn tt Id y':u, that no one would probably wirti to (tep forward the ollcnfible Man on the Occafion, as he would be fu!C ta brinic on himi'elf the Vungeanceof a Set ef Men, who would leave Nothing untried to etieft his Ruin ; that he would, when the Matter came to a Trial, probably be dtfcrted by many who wilhed bim Succcfs ; and that I even fufpefted you would prc^ve a Utfaulter on fuch an Occa. ♦ion— which yju folemnly pledged yourlejf you would not. Vou laid, yc\i did not think it pro. J .'r to move in the Bulincf* under the prefmt Clovirnmtnt, as the judges would be abetted by a Set of i'eople who had the Par of the prtfcnt Governor, and would lupjiort them tlirojfh thick and thin; but that Lord Uoichelter, you believed to be a fair Man, and that you would, oa^ Lis .\rrival in the Province, come forward, give your Opinion that the Judges of the Supreme Court were un^t for, incompetent to, and ought to be removed from their Oiices : 1 hat you v/ould declare it as your Opinion, that they determined Matters vihich came btfore them on very improper Motivei) in ftiort, that they judgsd Men, not Caufea : But that you would not undertake to fay that they took Bribes, for that you in I- aft did not believe they would ever put thJHnfelvei in the Power of any Individual, fo far as to .iccpt one. 'I hit, hit, is, upon my Ho- nor, the SuTrtance of the Communications between us, which 1 refer to in the before-men- tioned Mempriil, to the bert of my KnowKd^'e. Recpllrcticn and Btlicf; thtre may be fome triHIn?Circum(>ancei in which I may be not corrrrt — as to every 1 King material, 1 will under- take to be pofitive. This Tranfafii^n, not private (onfider.tial ttti-vtrfatU.n, I communicated tQi Mr. Aplin, who called on you on the fame Suhjea— held a finiilar Con'v;rfatitn with you ref|>ea. inj it, at he aftcrwardt informed me, and received fioni you the fame foiemn Aiairance— Mr. Aplin it not hei^ at prefeot, to add {his Peciaration to mine, in Contirfation of tliit .Statement. Indeed if yoor Letter and tljit Aiifwer, weie 10 fall into the Hand* ot thofe reopj* only, who have known the repeated Inftances of tquivocatum of which yru have been guilty Jince you have been in this Place, I fhould have left the Public to have tried us, in the f. mi Manner you have concurred in trying th's Judges, on the Credit of our own Alfertians; but at tkc Papers may fall into the Hands of fome I'eople, who may be ignorant of our refpei'live Cha- raifters, I fubjoin a Letter from Mr. Andrew M'Oill, of this Place Merchant, on this SuSjeft, which rerifle* every Circumftance averred in our Memorial, not admitted in ycjr Letter to the Governor, and all the material Partt I have here related. We will now fee how far your own Letter contains in it'df, Evidence of the Faftt afr;rtoii'.M;.i?, .'.uJ to Ir;,;^^: 'jn :/-'.' v^.'o «to lilt tti.nk witn p tr.l/un Tld rcr j ^-.'inc'ii. Vtii iViy, " V. h'.-n t e tufnufi wa. hiuuj^lit for-'-aiH i:\ i ; cci^A Ci m nilttc 'f tin II .ul"'. o£, ♦' .■iJ:vr..tiy, "l > l>cn, i;i(»t.i(l of clhiblilhing »ny Colour of C'jilt ^./jiiifl tli-'tii, a ilrini; '■"f " 4.irb;ii! Law C.if'js and |'nrt.;il stat'.-inem. of I'roctcdlnitj l>tloi c t'lein, w^re :i li'.i-cd a Froo.'i " ot til i, Wan' of Intcvrity, and ot tlieir \ial-;.Hnuiii(fr.Uion of juilicj, 1 o is Ihock.d at : t'x •' ^^oniluri of tlitir Accufcr>, and declared to (cine Metnheri of tli<; Houlc, th:;t I tliouulu flif *' Ja'.'.:.c^ wevc cruelly tiea:ed — tint 1 lud r( t a 1 cabt of their Innocence, »nd ^voul^, if rcjuifl. ;. •iioft Willingly ad^ofdtc their Caufe bcf. re any i ribunal m which 1 could be fcrvneabl? t'um. ' Had you known the Mejn nj of li.e uncouth Word vou here mtkt ulu c(, )o': c- :i n!y wou'd rot have put it in the HI ice it occupies : But a.i 1 have fonieiliing ot more Con- i.(|i'ence in Hand than rr.ere verbal CritLifm, 1 (hail proceed to afk you why you (at in foemrk i< itnce in the Secret Committee, arvd never opened your Lips in V inilicaiion ot the Honor ir... Utpjtation of the Judges, when )ou pretended you was (hocked at the Condudl ot thiir Accu- r.-i J ,' Whei I was aiked by tlie coinmittee, what were the Sentinner.ts of the Cicntlenu'ii of tic I. iw, refpef>in5 the C onduf> of the Supreme Couit > 1 aiifwered, that .ill tlu fc -witli wIm i . I had convcHld, and tli.it I had converfed with all who weie in I'raflice as ItarriOcrs, m nn, ' - ■ 3'f.- cf Cm nence, were of the fame Op nioii with myfclf ; that all thofe whowcic Mtn.!r:is o;, til.'.' Houfe in particular, had communicated to nic the fame sentiments refpcifing tbcin, as 1 tiicii com. nunicatcd to the Committee : '1 his 1 pronounced emph.itically, anJ iec|U'.(UJ t!ic di'i.snv n t>t the Profeirion prefcat to corrc; faying, you had not bean confulted before the Bulinefs was brought torward in ths Houlc : To which 1 anfwered, it was a Matter that originated with the Members of the Houfe, 'n which i: cy cinlul ed fudi Perfons as they thought proper. And then, to complete your (huffling, you did the Accufa-ion had gone further than you ever intended ; that your Uetign was to accufc ti cm of Incompetency not I'artiility. At that Time you had a different Opinion of the String of garbled Law Cafes, which were adduced before the Committee, from what you cotiimunicaiw to e 'lovemor. 1 then afked you, whether any HcrCon of common Underrtanding could liraw a ly other Ccnclufions frorp thu Infiances 1 had cited belore the Houfe than I had dore ? Whe. ther their Errors in thofe Caufes could be imputtd to ignorance- ? To which you anlwered, their Ignorance was fo gr fi. that you could account for any Thing on that .Score. Vou then fjort- ed no fuch Idea, rcfpefting thofe Caufes, as you have (ince in this your fhameful t'piftls. Vou then did, and now do know, that there was not more than one of the Cafes cited by aie befors the Committee, the Particulars of which were taken down, which were not proved before you and the Reft of the Committee, either by authentic I'apert, under the Seal of the supremeCourt, the Hand of the Clerk, or the concurrent Teftimony cf one or more WitnilTes, wlw where Membtri of the Houfe. Notwithflanding this, you have jcined with the Re(\ of His Majtfty's Council, in the moll explicit Declarations, that the Allegations made to the Houfe of Aflembly were groundlefs and fcandalous. Had you merely jomod with them in that Decree, and net exerted the fpecious and plaulible Talents ycu podels, to deceive Others, who wire better difpofed thanyourlelf, and to brinp them into a Meafure which never can turn to the Credit of the Au- thors of it, I Ihould have looked on you as much lefs criminal tlian I do at prefent.— That you have done this, I am warranted to fuppofe, by your own ConfetTion, for you Cny " Satis. *' fied as yuj arc of the Innocence of the Judges, you think it your Duty to afford them all " the Aid in your Power, to counteract a Delign, the apparent Objeft of which is, to bear •' down, by the powerful Aid of Faction refpeftable Men, confpicuous for their Moderation •' and Humanity, &c."' How far you are direfted in your general Conduct, or in this particu. K-r Inftance, by a Senfe of Dui^ and the Dictates of Confcience, 1 leave the World to judge : JL'utto me, I confefs it a};pears a little fingular, to find you in your Letter bearing Date a 'Week before the foknin and impartial Tiial of the Juftice* came on, peremptorily deciding, that they were % wrrv :wM:t ; .,:t'^; Cli.:,|<;es .luJc a^alnrt tliem, when you could have no K:nowlc(''.e rf fl,,, Drfsicr, l-'ii throvjuli t'lc f.rivate Com.nun;cati)n^ of the t'arti.s actuf d 4.1! iha-'v 1 VI. to fr. ai s Jiulgeo.i their Conduc), (hould explicitly proniife them cv!:,y Aid in \Lr\'^l'l' «r. 'Uc-irrrnU ThU Conduft brings to my recolledion.'a C.ufc 01 grcj Conf Vu"" , ' r n V ..„f. I V. i ccrrtincd,foi>nafter my Arrivalin thisjrrovlncc ■ l'; on the I'a- cr l,ci i ( h 1^ I .;, Pc.u(3l,ItoM theoldCentUiiianvvhoconfult'edme.thattheCaufe had'ht'cnmil'^^n!!!!!!'^ .n-l a,ua i.cvi ,.oly l-elort: To which he rtpl.ed, '• nevermind ,t Man. I am (url „f he ., I'lh, 1 have gor a Pra.nife c) it from a Majority of thofc who aie to decide on it ■• I co ,M ■T- .,.,ce.v '.ly Alicnilh.nentat thi. Intelligence, whsn the old Gcntkm^n very cool'v obf-rv.! ' u -t he -H.l not like that Mode of foliciting Caofcs better than 1 dia mvldf, but that ,'oth;.. " " c-.y .rt.Jd be done in thi, Place without ..." However, you .uay no\ have pron.rd ,7. 5.TI,, , you ajpartntly have engaged your Voice before the Trial come on, ai d h.ve .h.J ?;-v, n , I'rctencc to turbulent Men to inf.nuate, that you arc not I'roof aRainft the DrivltlA 7 \yjn .-..1.1 .-<• highly improper for me to exhibit to the Wi-rld through the Channel of a New L l>or, t V ) afts en which that Alfertion is founded, but I offer to produce them before ^n?' • I-.:^»! «• ! .; hub a Rinht to decide on the Subjcft, and was ready to hava adduced thp,v. „ c 1..:. ,.f tl c Munor.aJ, before the Governor and bound, if I had been required vl h ''■ C>v , H= n to «,l.n.i that there has been fomething like particular Attention to you 01 the pr/, o! t.,0 Louu, hut modeltly impute it to your own d^cnt Condu^, contrafled w,th my uihu >r>'l H.ira.i,;i.;... Had you contented yourfelf with founding vour own Praife wit our r,fl.;^' S».nft h>m. Mr. Blowers then faid, he might have pledged hmfelfLt not in rh.^^^^ ''^'' unde, ftood Mr. Stern, had reprcfented-7 hat he had tcld^Mr Srns he could net T^"'' '''' Clvarge of taking Bribes againf\ them-but that on the Arriva of Lord Dorehefter \T^ '"".l joinina Keprefent»tiontoendeavourtoefFedlthcirR-mov 1 ^ora uorehelttr, he would Mr. Blowers then mentioned that he would «ever attempt 'to c'o.k th- Incomr,.-.n- ►■ of then, m particular, but that hehad not been confulted m bringing forwa SthTu.a'^ T T"' the Houfe, and would not move in the Bufmefs at prefent. ''^■^wa.d the i.l,ai ^.^i bcloic I ;«m, Sir, your moft obedient, humbi.- Servant, ^^ — ___^ A- M'GILL Mr.H!.?. ^ ^ " ^ HALIFAX J O U R N A L ri^.fe ,0 ,njcr, in your „m ?a^cr tb, fM^;„. LaUr adSrrJJcd U TAr . ZJ/,.^,,-,, ,,,/^,, „ ,■// ^y. s I R, ^'""' **"' "iaylor: HAViNG read your Letter publifhed in tiiis Paper of the inh Inft-.nr ,„»»,. c i.- o. . Mcmorul prcfentcd by Mr. Stem, and ■nyMf^'to II Ex^^dl^nc'rLleuuntf tofert* Parr, I ! - - > I I I // A/t [ '4 ] IS I), come necnmy f^r ntc to,,S|*»V.', tli^t il t Crnvci iti. O'l .4. 'J 111 tint A.c.u. n.tl itlieflm ; y ii, n ixpicrtv UM to li.ivr Ic^^t'l f>> M'- Stun*. r»rr, ■••'le-iifi 1 an', mtrtloncd, it clB^t'l h> Mr. bttint. I rni..i..i^i i^^ie c incvivc li.t y'l ur mrixUiciTig my Ninic m tlut Ltucr, wa» ncrelv lot 'l.o 1 O'-i.oie . i .>../ J m : i< I y u coul.l i o li .vc htrn i.-r. i.irt from my wlioii: tLU.fua, tliat I lu.e .. en lv> iH iro.n b...,iii.ig nl an/ Acq aiiUsnce wih ynu, that I li.i\c nudiix- toJor- qu.tcl >•«> T .s ;„ r I r f; r>r-M, wIhlIi hsvc , lifitl m little I (tiiti»tion. Iiuletd, l;»H I k'i- i< 1 ca ea . ■ It.r '!> ' 11 ot l!n:,n I ;hoii ■! not h ive qii'.frd tliem on tlie 1 1 cl< nt OccalK-n ; be- e ft r V4 II t .1 v' r, s ) id (. tvi.rtatiri n/. hawtrn v:b, and foinc l'eo(ile, Alio \^erc nil V I .i- (H.111 t d .1! I me. iTi i'u till' ii-;li Mil rti^rcL-i.tation have hccn indu. cd to fuii)ior.-, tli .: 1 .i.d .(..1 ctij ted hy Hu|ii.,«-Ml Relent. n-nt »3iinlt )ou ; it vv.i^ alfo imnei-citarv I. r mc t.i«)i y 1 I'l ■.-oiMJi t uoj ct, you h.ivlnj; more fully commmucattd your Opinion ot tlio • oni .c;, ot tl'.c Supreme Court, to Mr. Aplin and Mr. btcini. a> li.> h vo 111 riu-d mc, tlian you ever did to me, and hecjufe 1 fuppofcd you >(vould l.^v. Ltci. >J.lcri on a> a V> iineis on the Trial o' laid jullitei. Ihowtvcr, new declare, tlui hv A,^ ac.i.ie. tal Converfation with you on the Su^jift, duiinj? the feti.re* oi the ^uptemc Co.rt'ii.;, 1. I m> ftr.n i -■56, after the i rial of an txchan/e Csule, aijainll a Gentleman ot Vim, .i,y u leproh.vtd the general Loi.dufl of the |ud*?c»cf the Suprem: Court as fhamitu- r i •„. r.i.t an I p.ut.al. ) mention tlu-fc CircumiUnccs by Way of recalling it to your recol- Ud'oK. How you will reconcile ynur former upiniun, with your Letter to the (.ovoinor anU y t C-niclinCcU'cil. 1 c .nnot conceive. th> uyh 1 know you to he an Adept in reconcilma cont -r.ctu-» to >ourfelf : You will be much deceived if you fuppotc ihcy are fo caJily recon ■' cinr, 'i^fay but Mr. ^terns and m>f;lf hive arted candidly towards you. Previou •v our Me,iii.r,al, we informed you of -ur Intentions by Letter, a Copy of which i Previoul « V.u did Pot dei-n to notice it ; But rilied uponycur liittrtll to have It i. however a sort of Anathema tlial will not injure u», nor anlwer C.l to I11-- 1 i>ii ir t » Ctl.V.Tl' in er' d at u t h rof Il d n u'l in council. ^TaanScH- fa-i fi^rf with t'le profe(r.onsl Bufincf* 1 have done (ince my admilTioii at the Fa. , .ml .m i,.p,.y m tl.o Co, fi .ence of my Frienda, from whom I ^ave received flatterms 1 n., u a^e nent a,ll u,.p -rt. l he Number of Caufcs 1 hwe argued could be of htlle Conle- ciu n e t tho uoverno; ■ Vcu have, however, miftaken them .n your Letter to l;^';"- ^huhcr f o.n .eiigi. or oth.rw.fs is imm.tci.l. Ard it i, aifo immateiMl. whether a con c.oufDef. of th lu.pr^Vriety ot your Ccndud in the Caule you allude to, tr my Senfments, thereon com- rniMii' ,'i'd^o y u,has n adc fuCh an unpleaiant imptUHon on your M.nd as to occ.fion the.lh- bi-r.*. and uni:>.ni.emanly ConcUilion ut your Lctt'tr, 1 am, Sir, your mod humble Scivant, Hal.fux, March 17, iT^S. The iicn. c>. b. Bi.owiRS, Ifq; W. TAYLOR. S rbtfji.oiu-.'.z '■' fi' ^'■•'•-'- «• "^ '"-''■ !"" '" ^^'■- ^^^-"'"^ "'•'■'■"^"^ " ''''"''• \. ahout to pre.;.nt a N'-oria! to^f.i, Kxccllency OovemcrFarr. ^^^^^^^^^^ W rU- cits you, and w.ll probably atted your Reputation and Honor. Wc thert.cr f in vou that ,v/a e' dilp.lcd to appri/e you of its Content. ,. you ;=^°°'J,- ^/j;" f '^^^,';;;.' a.f.a .n.e ..t ^our Otftcc, w,t'. it immediately, or if you w.ll call ^' ' \"= "*^,'; ' ' j^Vs^rec \, . .i.oul 1 I. .ve given you lonser Notice of this Bulineb, hut tli« bubjett ot it has been a Secret to ua lUi very lately. _ , , ^ W'C are, Sir, your humble Servants FROM THE NOVA-SCOTIA GAZETTE. To the PRINTER. HAVING proved. 1 truft, to th= Satisfaftlon of e^ery candid Mind, ^^at Meflrs. 5«r« and T-yc., notwit'iaandins v^'hat they f,y to the '^-""^y' ^j'^^.'" ,''„^,^''\^,\;"i;V o. t' e fudges before the Adembly-That it xvas on the Allegations "^''^^jy 'J^' and th.fc' only the Motion was made fo r an Addrefs to the Governor, »"d «hat with ■» -^^^y^-^J^ mitt.d ih« leftimony of thcfc Attorniw as the Procf* on which u vra» founded, and no other Z^/ yen ij. ^:i •» »- - '^r '• t 'S J k«pcr or Documrnr wlMtc-fci ; ami t'ut tlxivforc His M-jjerty'* CoiiiiLil, If ili'> Infl hfu> of (..■•ifiimi< tiic J'J'J^c* ii ti.t .M id'l red llie afsun 4n> ctticr lirourd til 111 tlicy have done ; I ftull now ^)i >-ccil to exa. 11,11c thi; C4fc» cited by Mcif; i. i .^wi and V./y/", liei'ore tlij I'l imiiiitee 01 ilic HtniR. Hitheit J tlit-f* AtJoiaiK, l.av« app.aic,} ilk; Partners in IniqiM-y jlT ci:ifH <■ r Mirhif-f, Tr%- tly to l)4ck, or 10 anijwer for cich other *i ihoulil Lill fuit tticir 'uri)of. — ut it ii now 1 nne tJ uiicoaple tliem, nd to confidcr ilic Alk<.itlons m.i c hy i. ich dillin^ly aid ((.[uratrly. 1 (hail lie-in witti Mr. Smm. I lie fii l\ (^u.-rtion .Ikcd liim in tlm (. inmnipr, v.,j, •' H^be. th r bf ba.i hern a P rafilijitcr ir, ilf S:tprc>nf Cwf Jl, jtiy T:-rt f ' ihc »nf'wcr i» * 1 r Y ji \ it^ii up- TCJ'./i — He i> next alVuJ a cuiious <^ciU>in, " U'i.tio tu'in^ ttjl T ire le i.J htei peij.cily ja- iiifi J zi.':ii tht Pr,cr,, liniri r.f i[, C u I." Hcanfwersno; and lie niigtit have atid- d. n. r the Couit with hi^. Vhc \\txHi\itA\<^n\i, ^^ I: wl It jKfcul.ir Inpjr.f iL'Ji li Jjf.iti Ji..'. f" \n- rtead of aiifwering «hii tiutllion dirediy and faiily, lie anlwcrs, " In m.try /«/?jn,yi, i-Kt could net itl.itt j.'i ; ir ^cntul th, Judfcs Ju! n t jf,fi,^r to i.i.'e Jufl. e .i/;t'jyi in i-'itiu, JiJ in ii • 0/ inn «•<■.» ti.l .ompci.int tJtbe A.i,Hf,firaiuii of Juft../." Thi* Anlvcr bjiiig evafive, and o ly a licprtiiion of tliis Attoi ncy't Opinion, wliich waj as w ell known before ; lie i« »i.'a n alkcH, " In ii'l at In. jUn.ctivai ht paiti,:uljr!'f Jijnti^fi d T" and lie ilicn nahvtri,"' TLji iLc Huls '/F,j.^.~f bur f 1 ffn (IriHiy adi tied to a^iitn/l j int, tuljo ■iv--ri n t t'.if'jur ,ii<, an,! reiixcd cr. ■^t' f alt' ni i Ir/l^mf, it "JWJl laHitrnid fume 'I'lmu a^o fo' j riuiiH tf (wb fc Niim, b, tiwi n t rtiAuU) iibt-n be ivat ft ft in J Caufe tn tut OiffSii'-n that tb< D' fndjnt bad n.t bi:-..' firvfd ■iviti a C^py eft' e Account. He ittjip.d tl at tterf 10 Ji r-/ Ruii tf C'jurt leifttirmg tl; D: f"i lr)i:r 1 1 hr Urtcd ii-'ib J C^f>y '-ft be A .'.imr, and rt ut bi: DeJii- rjlr.n luJi fujfi^init. Tbej (meaning I fu|>pofc the |ut1^Ci) admitted 1! c Oje&r.n^ ,'r.d [-ut the Cauft »vir uponit. Ht jftirtUJrdi, '.'It the jum. Dj/, mjdt tbi' j'jiitf Ohjeffioii, lo'en fjr a Dtfirdjrt, -.vhni ivji oieriuUd, and beivji 'iidc'd topru^ed :n tbt Ciufi en t'e Partiflbe D fendtft. ' — in this Cafs this impartial \Vitncf> has ft rjot the Namca ot t'l-j I'aitiei, and has oinittid to '>ate the I \w» when it was decided, and the Place where : or to fay, if it wis a Cuuf- tritdfummjnly or not t yer he cannot be i(;norant that the [udges are authoiiZvd by a Lav of th^ Province t > try 'aufc* where the Debt or Uaniage does not exceed ,£10. in a fummary Way, and ro eive )udg nent ac- cordin< to Law or lujuity, that is, according to tlieir Confciences \ nor ia he iijnora it, t'^at Iher* ii a general Rule of the Court, th:ir where a Man is fui d on an open Account, t'le I laintitf 'i>aM ferve .le Deftnilant w ith a Copy of hi> Account a reafonahic i iiiie hefoie 1 ri.il, but fiat where the Account coniiils of only one, or a very few Jt.-ins, jr, I the Declaration futficiently expltins the Nature of th; Ucm .nd, that the Court in luch Cafes t'nnks it reafsnahle lodifpenf.- with the general Ruh, in Favor of Juilice, and fr the Fxpcdiiion of '^ auf.s ; and the (^ueition limply i», will) (hall judge of the reifonahien.fi cf enforcing or riifpen(:ng wkli this Rule of Fraftice, the |u.1gc> cm the Bench or a forward Attorney brawling for his Fee. Mr. i>terni is next aflccd, " Fr^m zvLir iniituulji Irfunces bad ki C^yfe to fufpcfi e!-rx (meaninjt the Judges) "wanted Integrity ?" 'I'o which he aofwiirs, *' 1 bat m a Cavff /r/iiCti j^bt.cr Mop ant Samuel M'.l\ tte Court infl'-ucled tbc y-.i y, that a Partiti'.n jf tic T'-iurJh.p of Anna^'Jii, made witfy- D'ed or H'l it., tojs gjjd and fiifi :,nt, and i^ii.'d ii,t be dijiurhed j a'ld I" a (ui jeqtient Caufe, in tubiib A'lner Mj> luai P'.uintiff and JljrK Kint icai Difcndart, tbe Cou-^t ir.Ji,tiSi'd tbe jfu'^, that tut Pri~ pr,;t.r% t,f Ar.:ap'.l\i lutic "Tenjnti in Cjmittcn, a.ini uiar lf''i,iinjr, -zuas of nj C i',-iuen:e qi Avail." Here again we find this impartial Witncfil OTiittinf to expl.iin the Nature of the twoCaufes. If the fint was tjeftment, in which the 1 i- tlc to a 1 r.i>flof Land or Mcifua^c, ilependin.^ on Mrtcs ^nd Poi.nd- bttwcen PtPi'rietors Of the Townlhip, \va^ 10 be tried, the Court were warranted in adrnittir.g any >Vriting almoft as Evi- dence of an old I'artition ainonj; tlic Pioprieiori ; and In the other Caufe, if it Was l"re<'pafa by one Propiieior a^ainft a mere Stranjtr tt^r a toniou. Pntry on his Land, it wa« nugatory to go inrothe Plaintiffs Pitlf , becaufe hi, PoiTcllion was fullicient to maintain the ->flioii. As 10 the Severity of the Chief- f utUcf, which he comp'ains ot, 1 doubt not he defcrved it ; ard it is only to berenr-ttcd that it has not bee:i more frequently exerted againtt him ; the Province would not then have been troubled wi'h thefc irivoiou. Complaints. '] DC next Inllancc cited by him, is a Cafe httween C u/ins ard IVatfn, in which he tells a long 13:6 of hi* havin^' cxcepterl to the 0|.i on oi t!ie Couit, and ot his Ihiwinc the i.xcep- tions to [ulUce Brentor, and ol his Jerylnj th.-m to be conedl, and ol hi* then applying to the Sol'iU'.r Oenei al and Major ZJ.", /,.f, andof t!ie iart r s certifvinp it to be, in his (,'pli>ion, Coricfl', and of Mr. Brcnton'a then inftriinj a lew Worls, v ilch Mr. ifi;Kj th.nks were immatcr'al, and giviu; it back toliiin. He thtn quotesa Ciuie between P .hd and .Sw.r/i, another btiween C fUft »nf9H7H"";- '"";r• ■■;■; rJ 'u'r/J.nTa°oS'S\ tariff o, no,\..ini Iciri Mo„=,o„ Ex«.,io„, - T A >he Court here have re.ufed to follow the Innovat'on in thu R.fpeft made at Kou.., The ntxt cafe c>t>^ by Mr. kcnn - ^^^ J^^ J:" •. E^^/^e too he omits to mention '.1,. '^ f > hV^cuiTVoco j-e^ The t-ourt here is aated to have agreed vvuh Mr .S.v,., m oted, .t .. ^; *^j;^',,'°y ;h..;h.>vlng rcfufed th. Plaint.ff Leave to daVutc the Ug,.hty cf tlw vv ""^T: et nllruau" t lurv to con.ider It a, a Kr.vfui Road ; that may be eanly account- Way, the) yet mil. uCtu.t.,ur) netvvUhilandini; he -as denied Li erty to produce w '" ;^' '^^r^r. Uh ' ^'al '^ "t 00. care to talk a great Deal en the .^uhjed to ril^'^'aSrri^k^th^.^ and ther:fo:c the Chief jua.efoun 1rv.'.i r / , ,U,u',l n't h,- Jurarrtd. 1'oc C:uit deterred tsann^ tti iii^n « %• Tiuth in tliii Cafe was, tint tJi: ltd (or Contempt, in not ohtyinj; an Oidtr of Court, until he qr are ca^ hgned by the Chief Juilice, or, if that C rk'.\'^""'' ''>"^/>=-^-^ .^n,(Vuu iu:l.c., and the P,,r,ies or th.ir AUorni;. go to the he . oort found cftabJ.:>,*d, a> 1 a.n intortTK/l, w!i;:n they came iato Office, and whicb, 1 think , 2^^V , ^ ^^ ' """"'"^ '-'*'''^ *^' ''''''•'' *^ '"> Knowledge, compia nt-d ct bet. r;, jj i^ ^ten^d With no mco.iTcniance to tbe Soitois, and it expedites the Budnefs of the Court. It ii^^ay deprive an Atturney fond oi oppofing the judgmtnts of the Court, ol fo.ne Oppo, tunit.es w 1 ,h w '' t"^ « «» tiic K»rt.jfvte«ts, vkicfa be talks of in ttie next AsUwer. 1 he lart »iuell.« .tit to hj.r, in, " ITt.H;,- tbn, are re ;r,j( D,Uo,:,^!s brevaXm. amcvt the '^f ,"^.f ':^ ^'f^'"" C-'^' 'rejclaut re^ydci, th^ he c.h. c^t, th^ir Opir,.„ n u^r^U of Jy IVa^bt ■m,to Jur>e: „ ^ewtr^ snjm,0..f,he GeraUr^v of thr C.unUy^ **f p*,tuuiariy tU cJ.tlJcn cftht That Difcx-Btentj have tor iom-. Time patt fubiirtec', n« only agaLnft tlie luQlces cfthe Su- pcemel.ourt, but »ga;nft Jmolt tvwy Oificer of GovernnitBt in thcProviace, is very true ■ and It II *Mo « tru^^ tijat extraordinary Paios bave been taken to create and encourage fuch Uifcon- tems by faaious, idle or »bltiou« Men, ntIio wifh to bsc*»e of cciviDquence in .t, and covet the f-lacej vjhicfaare ccctipiod by others : but it is hoped that tJu; Virtut)us and tlie Cood thcOr- «eily and the l^y J among us. h .i»e njt been, nor w,i.l U induced to concern theniftlves with then..— 1 iiB cofi^Kteut, t^ut if hich frivolous Charges and Mifrcprefentations, as we have now !r'i.*'\^'"*"\"' *^'''^ ""^ t^t-P^tation of tl.c [uilkes of the Supreme Court, no Man Clin tie lah;. I he Ccmftitut.oQ of our Governannt is unciceptiooably go^, and the Admir.i. »t*u«« ot n as m.M »fid ienicnt, to all Ranks of t'cople, as the veriell Republican can wuh Y'^'Ta tUT'''*^^"' ^" ^''"*' "^ ^<'<^'--ty' 'i'->'- v^l'o ai* endeavouring to dillurb it, and let us Cor,Jider Mifrepnsfentatioo and Scurrility a. i^,t Indication* of a bad Cauf.-. J h«vc tAiw, up lo much of your Paper that 1 rami defer the Confideration of Mr. r./y/^'i ieffiiHony to another Opprnumty. ^ PLAIN TRUTH. FROM THE H A L F F A X JOURNAL. To >m P U B L I C. I rmufthe obvious to every Peif m vrho l;.u tak- luheTroubleof lookingintothe Conauf* of the luUicti o! tlie supreme Couir, and th- >r Kri.nds, on the Occaiion of the late Impcathmctit. ■««i4t ihcjr hi^vt a|>4Jcaie4l much in;ie an.Moj. t . fix ihe Accufuiicn of thctu on Mr. f,».!or an! i^ ' .ii>fclf, ; [ iS J Wk ih li 'f? 1 I .1 r-il Stnie of tl>t V,crci,! ' t ' Arfdrefs, and out ol ^^'y"^";."^. .„ „,oundl>.-f5 and lean- rurther In.l..nccs or I'.oo • ^^ \;^,^,,,,Tcs to be <^'5"-y^'=^;,,^;^*=^f, ,,,,ich never ^^ .11 do e.tUr dalous, and tje S^-, ^^^ ..,„s. This U . ^^^^-^Xl^^. to escape even the n.oft care- fpeaUl" ot the ^V''-'^- reTc^nfcq'n.e to this Comn.un.ty dcOnn^ ^^^^^^ publications nHly -o run hin, down, o, at «^' p^rf^its. ^ , ,e the Committee of ^^"S '^ ""'^ htv Vxn fully conuT^itted to NN r • ■. |^^ .^^,, ,iiey h.id been "--'t^ly ^;»'_;^^^^^.^;,i i^ ,,,„,,rfy wa3^--^— -^^ , ,,,,. A/^^'V;;;^^^'^ To whichitwas anf^crcd s;";-i"^-^^^^tS-eSec^^::^ in h nei.,..r.vc , the ^-"'^/',',^,i^ol C.uit v.^chrcquired he^er '-^ ^Ue I'Uintirtcontained l,,,dh«vnn^?i.ti'r.tQ,c^^^^_ ,: c ; f;o..r till th-«- ^-^, , ,;;;; th.u.ht ana 1^1;;^--:-' ; ::;;,;, ■, to .hicn tiu^ ^^"^ :iwAnf*«r, •''•'" P'-"' Ineulartoany M«'i "» ^^"'*'"; , u, u's and have <^c ti.tti *jthCvrolvh«-o-^' , ^' til I fie Committee. A 1 no.v clccl prene Court. As to tlic're rcf, ■■ [ 19 1 s to the Rule of Court, which our Aut' or r ys I -tlutnoruchKul.d,.,hexirt;;,H;ath;;:;rt;dn c;.r:ri.it (, rt of this i 'arajraph, [the pentlt;m.inly ncc J was a !'ra« KHO' t'oiiL'i in t; ">rovc I Herfons oJ hij own "ThH^rill^^I^lf^l^^S h- Op^;; to the Court on ail Occa^ons wi.h D.::r" "'- and 'he other bttween Abner Mor<>\rTA *"A*' ''"^ ^''^"" •^''"" ^'°''^'= '■•"'' ^'T""^! ^!orf Ejectment, brought in the S,^ Mortc and Arad Kent ; tl.e fuli w.u .n Adi.., of T-cfpaf, vl ■'lamtiti-. whofe Int.rcft it was'^in that A H I^ f '"'^ '". ='"'"^""- ' ^ '^ "'' ^'^""^^l '■-'■' t!,^ by the I'ropriaors of it 6/70 in^» ,,^M ^^- P™"' ""' " '^'^''""^" '"^^^' °' ''id ■i'"wr,/ivp ;aw to create . Tenan;yT„7ev; ,?"" e' clt '^r' ^^i""'' -^ ""^--' -^^ ilTn^i.nt i'n Part,t,o.. n.ade by ,hn Writn, v« V.i ij / « /'"'^ ^ '"'S'=' 'n'l'"«=c1 the Ju,y, th.t the- which never could h. ^ t.'.efam.AbnerM. = b?oue,u h^ l^'" ' '';",'■' '^r'"'^ '''^ ^''^ '" ^''-- '^"'-"^ fo l^ - ' nf Land and carrying away tl"e^Hav ,o^n '?" c i refp.fs again.l Arad Kent, U r entering h .' '" the firrt ln Ktm w. .n P ' I "^'^ " '^ *"* "^"' ^"^ ^■^rrled .way thj f- t:y the iitl. ; both th,7and rll,' o r'' "'"^ '° '"^"^'<^ -^'^"^^ f^'''-'^ ^'t-Wi,Ti th. Divil.cn n,ar!e Cou. t on the former Tria Xn^e S hlrt" "' "'f ''"' ^''^"=' ' ''""' ""^ ^P-i«" "' ^^^ that he would not fuffer me^n r^tl > Ch.tf jubce treated me wiih great feverity, and dccl ir.-d And in this Inftance, , . Court i I uTed'thr,"'""' ?' '"? '"' Co.rt, Vithout^'thcr L ' x pr-etors of the Town/h d of Ap, r u -'"'^' """ ^'"^ '■""« I'artitlon made by tl e Pro" declln.J ' "'^" requelied tlicm to certify tl, ^ it w i f ; *', , '' ^""^ '' ""-- ?r";e court, whicf wL'^:;;!;.^i^rf,^;, sr::;: Tiuft r'^ii-^^ ^^^''^' - "-'p-'- '«w Words, whirh 1 now think i^nnmcnalhav^^^^^^^ "'' "'>' ^"^ -^t-'-.-n,, ,,. ''' "-"'"^- --^ fr-eas the Opinion of the t.urt. '^ '"'^'^ '^ '■"" ^-''". •'•'J i,.'ve a b:uk in o;^tS^'het^^^^ti^^:;;!.S;^^^ -> to relate them « large ot. a futuu uic^i;: n r:''' "iV f "" ""'^■' "'^^ ' ""-" ^'^""^^ V.'.-.tfon, [ -0 ] •V W.tf.n thcr.rt;.^.!.-, of v/>lc^ I rn.Il ''<=''•'«;/. ';'=,':,-7 J,;.; Id iron. ...n.a.n .nd. lar'xsFamilv, iilter Clirke a.cn-nt. ici mierior Court, for the Ltuntyoi c"! h. .rd a^lnfV f.ld Clarke -f ^-';'^"";;fj,",'^"J." o7£^ 'f'^^ ♦■ otl ers. vv.re f.t on foot and commenced ^"''""'J'^' „< ri>e Harties, and to elude laiu le car, icu ^^ ^j^^ contrary, to f*"""^ *' ^ cetifiderau«n mighn * :,„. of U,rv=.r .787, .boa, «;..• ""'"' '^.'''.'J;',", m" Lvjirgtheft "««""<■" ,4air.anl.,sf.dAaioracainlthuTi,bcca.fc .nnot.cvyng roducvd : He further fa) s, .,M.-;altnan,hrfcwl.chwc-.cth.Orou.dcf ,. l-'^^^^^^^^^^^^ rcr. 'iitno...ir,d.rnM)c-,iiu.rcr. ^^*^--^^""\' ^,,n„ ,i,e whole An:ount ot the udgmcnt ^v'r .'.h > had heloreflcrmlya.ljudgcd tohetr^.icut , ^^ ^^ JudgmeiU for ) , , ■" Timof the RtcovL-.y o. ihol. l.d.mcrt,, [^^^^^ .^ ^,.,,i„, ^^d not bear Intereft . ,; . o, wT, n they have r.fa.cd to give >;[-;J ^ .", „^,^,";',' ^e i ,me p-cfix.d '- 1';^";^"^^ In.-.c ■'ce of them, even vvh.re, hey ^vpef^•.^^^^ ,urv, they would fct »f"*« «'^^ ^ ', . f ', ard n.ve dclaved to nic .hat .t I po '' a i cri ^ ^, .^ Ln Mtto a narrow C'^^'f ^' ,''^.^ V , i/ o:> t:.at Acccurt. In (ho.t. to r.dujC .h>5 U.n^ 'Y'* ^^,,^ ^.,3 ^^,„cly under their 'u remc Cotnth.s punUhed an '''^>-'- f^'^^XrU a tS D cretion fcr not obeymg th m V c, Mrooi and co.M have been hncd .nd "^ ^ *^^[^^'' ',-,g^,\.„„ ,,.ev had folcn.nSy de-er.n.n.d t^ [ 21 1 Bti-.?, notw.tlirt.nding they deny Intereft on all ct'crOceafions. even for P.-hts which ./or*, from the lending o» Money, unlcfs the Lender had taken becunty exprelly l.,r the l,,te.c(l ' And .11 ihu.hey have done Without (uttering tt,c Defend.nt to hj*e a Trul by jury, th.- known .nd d.,:lmg Hr.v.lege ot tnRlimmcn, which not only the fudges, but evcy Vcomln lu the Country, or ehild m our htrem, knows to he lus Birth-riKht. Our Writer Uvs, that 1 cou d kum nothing of th.sCaufe but what I learned from the Defendant. U I'lam' Truth i. /ea y the I cr (on 1 fuppofe h.m to be, he Utww* that I have in my Hcircflion the wl.o'e Kt.ord' cltliclroued.ngsoft'iel.ouitinthatCaufe, tojeti er with the Order woich wa. krved oii Watlon all wh.ch 1 lubrn'tted 'o him, before the Bill was filed in Chancery for the Rcli.-f ot' the poor Man, anH at '- he .ppeared as much (hocked, as he pretend, he was, at the String Of g, .bled „aw . afe, - cd bco.c the Committee : 1 hii Re.,ord and Order 1 exhibited tu th« Body, when 1 wa . .,o:r f x,..n, nation before ihem, have them now in my HofreiJ-o.. ,m>i am ready lo (liew them to any l-erion who has a Curiofuv to fee the,n. 'I he .-revanca.ion of J lain 1 ruth ,n his Remarks on this Ca(e, is (handful inde.d-he has entirely omitted, in h,. Mitementof.t the Or>ter of Court, wnich I have above recited; has palled over (lightly, the C,rcumrt«nce<.f the Courts givii.g Judgment in Chief, ard ^IT (Tiiig Damai^es, without ever tiyin;,'the ,.aulc bya iuiy ; and ha. artfully enr'eavored to draw the Attention of the Public o C ircunmanuts which he kn.w to be entirely immaterial. Ht (ays, the Court ccmidcred the l.au(e to be ,y A. Natu,, of an A«ion on a Judgment : 1 f*y, they mi^ht .» well have confi^ercd |t a. an ndictment for Murder, for it was an Artion of Trefpafi, on theCafe, exorefly (o na.oed by the Plaintiff ,n the P,o:ee ling, : So that had our Judpo both been as i«nc. .nt, as the fuu. pofed Author ot h lam Truth fometime fince declared one of thorn To be, tiat he did not know one Law ! loceeding (rom another, unlcfs by the Intlorfement on it ; they murt have knovn that tne Action in Queftion, was not an A«ion upon a Judgment. The Cafe of Kerrin and Bonnel I related at large though it ii not taken dawn, the Committee exprefly diredm^. thatcnjytlie I itlc ihould be n eiitioned, that I mi«lit be calltdcnfcr thel'ar- ticular-,«n a future tJciion. Our Autho s Idea., as a Writer, differ materially from his 0,.i- nion. a. a ud^e : Here he fays, no Fact or Circumftance is mentioned, by which an inditferenc Fn-toncould(ormajud,*,#,r.,,r StTJ'^a f;r'°r>"V"'°'""'a?";^'^'"'* Circun.ftances enough in it, to oGeia.e this, with tlHf rcit of the Cafes, groundlefs and fcandalogs, without calling on the Witntffes to ex- plain, what our Author ha;, now found to be ablolutely incxplicaHe. The Rem irks on the Caufe of chambers and Shaw are too ( rile to tkfcrve an Answer, as •re thofc on the Cafe ot Mtlfenger to proft(rtonal Men, with wh»m our Writer a\vA fall into the molt abjrft I ontempt, either for his want of Knowledge or C»ndor. He fays, the Cour' did right in icfufing to hoar Me(ren^ on the utiAMj iravclici, who is never able to Hifcorer from whom Ik rtceivts the fatal V\ourd The villainous Inimuat: -as, rn»tth..(e PcojWe who have ^iven their Opini'-fis 'rtr-.i-'Tine t|,o ludgrs, were artuated by a wil]i to ohtiiln thc-r \ l^cei, ne^'er coj'rf hiv- i-vi ctttk,! fr n . rjy Man whof,- Hcnrt ;» not a. Mack ,ii Erehun, and wh© would i»ott-.i«r.icll c«nimii tlie viicil A^i- ■i . 11 ! rrs to ^nfure h'.s .wn 'civirccnunt •. I do rot apprcl.tn-H tli.,t my Pcii,-!., v.^ o Vrows irc .irl the cdtc 01 my Bulincfc, will even tor .i Mom.nt give C'xd.t to it ; tor, u i. well known tliat mv p.cfeoibituation Is t ir pcrlcr.lle, in I'oint of tinolu.m-rt, to tia-: alary ot a Julhcort the ^upre:•nL• Court. Arid 1 now dcdaic. t'latctn the l.i^h Ofli.e, ihf Author ot rlam liuth ;» fLproiV.I to be in qu.ll ot. and t'le I'unu.t of whicli ,i... brought liim into the p.Llcnt ircytn- cahL- Labyrinth, could not temt.t me to leave the piivatt- Walkb ot my I'luttliion, where I l,a\e tx.^eritnctd lioin a generous 1 uMic, a^uj-port, wluch lu-\b squ .ikd my V.i.t,c-, an l lar excced- el'my 1- xi.e-i>,it;o:t , or Mirit. i.iu.illy without 'i.-und or Keal n as his loreioing -u^.;^c(ti- on, is tilt '.'ajfe v.di.cli I'lain Truth ah-j^n^ tor the . Contents which p cvail in the Country, re- fp-ainj; the Conduct ol the lud^-c? :— 1 hole Difconicnt-. are rot of rtcait U'ii,in, they have Ion- cxilled in thi, Ciinitry— I i und thcnt here on my fiiil .Arrival in tlv- I rovince, in ti,« YcaV 17^1 : It i^ true they fuhlided, in fome Uegres, alter the Arnva! ol tlie Kite Chiel Jullice fr. m F.ni^land : but were aijain revived M hi-. Uenth, which happened about tv/o Vtars alter : >\nd this rlain Truth know, to have been the Caie, as he dues, that thole v.entlcmen, who vhen called on, gave th.ir Opinion on the Adminill.i'.tion of Jul\ice in the Supreme I oun, are rot \,en who de'ptnd on a Faaion for their Confqucnce in Society, and have never fought it by any indiredl or imprcptr Means. 1 no V again declare tL>the Public, that all the Fafli I related before the Committse, except the fill mentioned, weic conhrnied at the rime of my txaminaticn. by the Tctiimony ot two or more Witneifes, Memb.r- of the Houfe, or by auth'-ntic Papers by me produced to them ; and that 1 am leidy, not.vitlirtanding the Decreeof the Council, to rlik my Reputation on the '1 rutli of, and my AHllty to prove them ; and I now challenge any Perlon whofe Reputat.ort cr Inter-il is concerned in this important Tranfadion, to lubmit the whole Caic to the cx.imi- natior of any Man or Number of Men of Reputation and Abilities, who are Lawyers, or let tl-,c Judrvs be brouRh: to a Trial before the Chief Juilice of Canada, the Chief Juftice of New- Brunwick, cr any one of the lurtices of tlu Supreme Court of that Province, oy the Chief juilice of Cape Breton, who clearly are the only Peiions in the King's Dominions in Anierica, cc^mpctent to try them, and if they do not upon a fair and full Hearing pronounce, that the Ca- f., 1 adduced before the Committee are well lupported, «nd that 1 am juftihed in the Opimort I gave of them, by the fac>s on which 1 founded it, 1 will do, what th': Author of Plain I rutli ought long hacc to have done, I will abdicate Society— hide my Face from the Reach of the Kmnan E^e, and in Solitude fpend tlie rell»f my Life in Cont rition and Repentance. If they tludcfuch anEnquiry, the Scribbling of our Author, the C l.,mour of a Party, cr even the Ue- cifionof the Council, w. 11 not and ou«ht not to injure my R.-putdtion with the Candid, con- vince the Public that iuttice has been done, or that fuch an Invtlfigation has taken Place, at ought roj.itnfy ail c^^.nuJ. STERNS. H.i!:f.ix,x6rh March, 1-88. • I' FROM THE fj O V A - S C O T I A GAZETTE. ro the P R 1 N T E R, I SHALL now proceed to confider the Tellimony cf Mr.T.n^r, as laid before the Committee of the Houfj of A:Tcmhly. I have already obfcivtd, that Jhe was not perlonally examined, as Mr. Sicrri was, but delivered what he had to allcd-e, in Writing. He begins with laying, that, " ,/ TIMS al'.ut C7,,lu,: ALt.th! '-,;.>, fin.e i, had been aJmittid fj itc Prj^lUc f the Luzu m ttis Fr.z ina; dunn^ ifhuh Pn iJ, b's Bu/h:rh had r.ainn forest, ncr -a'di l>e able re g:-je Jo r,.uihl>i_h> ma- »:.« dj theCenthmen of the Barof!u:{er/ar.iiir^ ; but that in Oiedume fj tie Dhtethns of the Committee r:.:df kr'.tvn to i'lifi, he did, -with regret, decUue^ that f'r:m the Ohf.ri'Jt'mt! he / ,;■/ tee,: ejpabk cfnuiking, i'e rcr/ldcred thfyuds:^! bothlirrrifetefttandPa'tljf, a'd aitogilh-r urevi.tl to ile Admir.-.jirati'.n <,j y^ftAt. This i-.xordium, which weais the Appearance cf Candour and Moderation, would Lave entitled Mr. Tay/^r to feme Excufe, if the Violence of his fubfequent Conduft had not con- tradicted it. As a I'toof of the Incompetency and Partial. ty cf the Judges, he proceeds to fay, 'J hat •' he had ♦n'.idi them un a Tna! in E'ieame,'t, luhen the Lejllr :fthe Piah:t:f •■« deduciig hi: 1 itle hat prned hlmjef to be a Natite if Germany, ar.d nfd.r.g^ there ; to refufe granlir.g^ a j^'or.ju.t en M:tio'n,'hut fnffered a t'erd.el to be ^nrn in /.irr cf fi'.d ponigner, in d.refi Vklutif,n of the Laivs of the Land." It is unlucky for Mr. 'TayLr, that the Caufe, ^ere ci.cd, proves the KevciTe of the PiofClition, lie meant to caabliHi by it, lor the kJk. L 'J J P^^^'''^»si^'^^':t:!::'n.ui^^^^ and m.1e tl,. ro recover.-, Cha-td lr,r,rcH cnly, .,^ every M^v•^V M V ^J"*'"^"' '^ ari.l,uou> u.t Dutch Town to ttK- )).f..^d.nt, gJ^SUU , c' .,«' ""V '''^^'';'"f '" '>'« ' «!>- fa NouC-i, re.u.n. to quit I'.fl-.in.n, 1 jc^.r, ft wa '•'b-Lj t i, a', "''^ '"= ''"Wm, over l>,s ( e-n.and cultomei PofitiveneC, iofulcd cr, tnc Court or -^1' ''';"' ""'' ■• r. 6V..„.., vv.tl. h,s .c- Courf. of the Tri.,,' that the Uib t^^an ni a 'tit o7 ''''.'""'" it appeared, ,n ,l,e Court h3ing of Opinion, that the Uutllum o? ai "'"^ "■'" '" ^<^>many. Hu- the the Kartie., fo xlireflcd the Ju y and i. y"!,'' ''S« r' " i ' ''m''"^"^ '° "'•'^ '"^^ l^^'-^- a fuppofcd Fromife made by the Coileaor of rhp r„,> 'V"-u' ;■;"■'■ "/ "" • ■^'■"> a' o, » ths Conduft of the Judges, -.vho n've. Va e an. n "r"^ l"*^ ''' '"'"=5 t^s Caufe againft r.,/- we,e defirousif m.kin, a fair Tria of T ^n^.'T^" .^.^^P^-^^'ng -t. .f v.e.Jr,. Su.l and this of ad the Caufc.cit.d, atfjrd^d the heft n '"'i'^"'^'''' «■• Cnretmcy of t.he ludges. in.tted, and an KFue of l.av^ tcndV-t'^ the beft Opportun.r> of doin.; it ; for the > afls were ad- peaicJ in the Record, and every one'conv rf nV""-' ''.'• ! J"dgmtnt weul 1 th-relore ha^e ap. i-rom .t tojud,efor'iii,.rdf.f'.rAb t V'-itv" '"^'^ "^^^^ ^^'« defeat their Purpofc, uh.ch is not to prove in fuft'rn^ ''''.V°"/'- ''"' ^''^^ ^^^'l' d would !cf. A.ru:n,.tions and ....luialou. A Kl a^e t'l \v'/' "^'' ^''•'" *'^''' '^°'''- ^^^ """l- »nd their wh.ie , ale is eanly conf. ed wfi ', t e '''7 "j' ^' ' '^ '" ' "^'^'''^ ''^*^" ^^ '^^^^f vs. AV,«.„, ar.d four <,thcr Defendant :,wl,ic',s!ri-H'K '/'"' "^' '"'^ ''^^" ^"^^'"^ "^ ^"">' rnent ,iven a,^air.ll the Hcfcndants, a e t^e . ^ C u / " ' ^ ' ^'i r'"'^ ^"''^ Ve dift and ,udg. very certain h.- ha, be^-n Defendant only L, lie a'n" fll'", "'V '''-^' "'' '"'J ^^<^ ^' '' '« Tr.al ot tl-.e Caufe, brcug!,t by .V/^;,., ,| at f ^ '• '" ''''' '''^■*>* '-°""P">i'ed (mce the wards him, treated him with undue ''evtritv ''''' '"^ "''^'^ "'^ imputation ot Partiality to- The next Allfgation tnade by Mr. T^v/v'is- ri, f u , . , , 1 .■ '/,' vr — V '"'^ '-'"■'■^i'"' '.^'.'^ « ^....y f, t:f"^V- '"• ■^^'"'.^■'■■'' '''•"^'''" ^/'/-- C.:,.^^ and alur be he I vf.v: — |(,; xfv -..-w -■■, .,,,u aiiTioit eve re l.\e^.— Mil, ,\rtion vvai brouviit ai'ainiV t ol v i ,> . - - -■• Quart.rMa'lerofth. ^,VJ, to one of the liMmy";o'."r ''*''■ "^"^^^ "'"'^ «'^''"' ^y "'• Oi^c.r, and Men of th.. !A. wa, a, pr i d b- .ore the ; *"'=* '° ""'^ ''"" »'^'^" ''^ '^^ '■°'°- fced, that an,, fou. Authority wa-, .^y-n by linn Id", ^i"' '''°"^'''' "'^' "'^ ^^^1°"=' de- / K'v.n hi hun, and was adnf^d to bni.j the Suit againd ths (juart«^ »• H I H ] »u»rter-Ma'\tr f.i> irhoiYI ROodBVllWOU IdjhA been given, ana an In furm-^untable DifHoulty -.rt ^,i» I sie cure irquci\td a I'l" d. lie pei!'il>-'< li jyvivcr in bnii>;inpit ag-ioftti.e Colonel, jnd at Innuy Refill ua ^1 lury anil IcrvL- a the llVue viith Noticto 1 1 lUltt at ierm 1 he ljelci.d;4nt » fcl was i'^ <• ' r. they had ari ly l.xi>eC>(tio n oi Cuao.n HoufeWocunients a dotherlroohl.om Artnua td he >''0»i Irt have btenasdeiiiou^ o fore tntiU- nc (;hi-c^ Oil to the Notice a tthe lime it was fa-rnala.th.l'Unilff*^^,f^-i delivered, but attetwaid- on he ihcie- I a Motion wot h:,'ve the fpecial |ury i ai ii»^ » "*■* • .. . ».„ «,iw told a Mun*'" " * ' lr.clc,andth=payhxed he >. oM^.^^^ _^^^ ,^^,„ Id expe< ,„, to h:.vc "^-^ /P;^ -"^'/^^^ Ve to the next Term, the '7^';;,^'^ -7-, ordccdthe great t-^l'^' ■- ''''VU',*';. of tl«: tadt. alledged tor it. , ^^ "7n«)omicn* clihe V» .tne<1e. ^,«d, without any \'^ V;;^J,;;"; counfel, to confent. that ''^?,^".7°"; '".'oof, in the Caux-, Oft.r v»as rr^ado Ly 'hJ 1-^'-"'^*";,' ^ before a Wagiftrate, and be nled as 1 r ^^^ ^^^ .ttendin,, '>'-''l,^^' ^^K tl^ V S:,£ v^n-ve themfeWes ^-■;'=f l^^^f^^S^'Ju wa« made b) th« aod uicd at the In.l, ="'*''''^,;, other Ground of CompUmt, -« "«>''*;^\ ,^pettati.n of ,onr," requited ; a; f ^^^''^^ ^^^ 'b, ° •» F«^l^n,ieht were demanded) were miu <. paoeis had not ar- (;oods, (for wluch l^nymen, and fj^'l*"^^^.,,! -,„ the Drf^"«'-'*^='''''i';e on' nuance cnttr- ,,e had advifei his ^'-:"! J';J',:„t "befo .The next Term ; .''"''/'^"f-P^^; ^'ce " .r.r-.. Uid to ed the preceed.ng Day w».or ^^^^, ^^ ,nf„\ on Af^^'^^^t" J^^ts Counfel, entitled to M.irr.. Stnr, ^"'^^''J' "-''"'h. Wrf.rro- Central, who was the Of'T^^^^y^^^ ,„ indulge him, K»vc rife to the Charge a?*'^" '7 ... ■ ^he Memonal to the Litut. o-^-^' ^ ,, v n^ r- ,. ; ,. > Priftit oner, waicU ituaiea m wt Fv.-f^.-i.Bi fjt?" ff rJ^r ci;.- tUr, .. h, ccr^^'^^dp-- "- ^"'^I'i/", Jj at Cher T,«fi, '^^-'^/.f ■'.v; of the Supreme Court* decidci butitwouldbeM.d .nd^*1 « ^^^ fay., tSat Kf' P/V "^,^L^^id have them re- The TJi! AlIcKi r ^s ] :ion M, T!,.i I'll* (.'«f« ot C nlmtr it-'ft'^c L' Jin i :ha rijed """"-..s'lia-n, «• Win-lfor 'y- -'».■, />»», '«-■•-' f« I'll I #K. ^'ull outia^toufly b *''V''K " '^'' ^« 'y « ^^tj h^u f, f,-^. IJ Cir^M in 5upf.c;rt ot thil a a. had i„.,.„„,t „.,, i;:;;; "Z^'li^^ ^"ili''"^"^ ""''"^ th. o;,ts ;v I rueity , , hi, mack' had h fcfidccl ut^, en <5ril Cok ccu.'atioti. 'i his .Via « bU.:k Sljve, 11 WJt gfllCiaMy crrmjiUlllcd of *5, n the Expiration of the l^itw ii til ffu> C„/n ths, i>j^, cMttnrt attnbm,, ,, altij-attr ,» M thcChar«(f»er ol«he |ud>{e» PLAIN TRUTH. "liHtad them .n a Bufin«f, of the firft ImpoMni ti ?. . ,?'"'\«=^'«lent Intentions to deceive and pove, whatlwill undertake to f«hrk^ow??oh^ I. r'™"""- 'T*''' Writer endeavcrs to Ek. ^'^?" ^'°"' ">• ^hojt J'foceedinrirf rt^HLrl ""' ''"Bn«e with Mr. Sterns and Member* of hu M.jefty, council, by^trf MeS^""??.*'^^'^'^'^' '* '^"o^" b/ one of th. Inhabitant, of theTown and ConntrJ Had the Ch.r °1 h ^ "*'"'^' "'* »>> many'rcfpc-aabl. sJIh ' '.S?"""'' ''»^« undertaken to divide r' ?///"" »'"'"''"*'"* ^"^ f'^wdalou,, aihi* fhe r '"'? ''^'^ '^°"'*"« ^f"C»' would have afforded th^"''"^" f "'^* * ^^'^ ■"»*« P"blic Iny.ai :x^' '4 ul ths Riciiel^ Mnpnituile .'rfUy cru iciiiittc !) ive on t 1 aiulunja:llt'en muU the Vt'ic lulticcsof tlie Supreme Court o.i [ ^6 ] bren dtcmed a fufficitnt I'loof of clieir Condud ol Ins M jjelb'i Council appear,^ Innocence ' ffcw rri%ni- IdImvc no( only on their own Detlarati.in, n, ol tli.ir Innocence, bu lie fame fiimfy (iround p ,d proceeded to llipn..^ti/iiheCl.ararter,c f the Witncllci, \\liic!i I tr-jrt, aie at Will venture to » to alTca their lUputal Itaa 35 Koc^d as thole of the jcculc when they allured the Cover d : Can or ou-ht fuch a Decilion 1 tlicir readinefs to come l.rw iri' and to fubltantuie their Chai);cs, and prayed for the Oi;po he OtpottunUy of doinp it > I tin Liglit —this hvaCion of open Enquiry d 1 rill, mult alcne convince ever I le ir of y Man of Seiife anv!ilch is always ^-d a5-n« ^i'lohn Valentine Kagel, as Heir ilivin?there, anatnat ii-naua ui^^.'v -. with a Numncr 01 u'l.^w, i-,,,,), i,-i MtlertCaU'. lU knew that it AMsro. . . h, r for an Vltit.- .n !>= » note; that f.li.l. c.^ VTerm*-or YfHri rhat Nagcl was lu.n^lo., b.^t tor a ,<,.^,„cc m the Kir.t's L)o- thl:^aren.ut,,h.dac,.^^ .t os.-h.14.; mlsi.ons ts)r t^'.e j :,ti. 5 r ■!• ■ ' . Court on the Occalion - afte t°,Vunla;rn.fs he has been .ul'.ty and --'v,.l. with eve,7 .Man who can undcrlland l„. qu.bhne .n th r - 1 ] [ . -... bon, .. Merchant o!M';^;«";"J'i';'i' now « it .,lw.,y, ,, .,:,., Ll an "rr iiiSWiiil iiillilPpiiii iiii^iiiiipii ^s tor thf Caufe mentioned by our Authi- Vf c • leidantj, uwis t.-H .,„r / ""^ Aurtio. of St.un ^js nrt AV-.... , , «s noticed by Mr P/^ ., r, ,a .. ^ ' '"** *^' T^r.mji, . .„,i v, . , . fcioufnefs of h,s u,>f nr r Ifl . • V' •'^"''■■■^■'' "^ ^^hich, 1 hare :o la/ • ' V'Cl ''"""■' ' ^ "' •""■' 't';,nj to !,avc o(nfi. I *m rea4y tt> cc 1 Ul ill ibis l..'*u(- .ill lli»t u Mud oI Honor iwg'.t w (eel wl'O > confcious of i.uihIci 1 »m rea4y te crr'tfv :liit rit Iriuiticc toi.j; <;one liii c.innt. nytlilnj; rr.orc clni I (ttl o* ih; Ofcaln n. Au i ii lo hiidh-i lnlmi;a- t.o-s. th"v 4't »•, v.L- .nd tfr-^xd cf luiSi x. tin /.ml.cr l.i.nCflf, it 1< well kiwwn ihJt I il- \v«.. liiink iiul »cl I r gi)l'.lt, an.i am aliojciLer iiu^i-iMc oi him^ inrt.Kncot !'■ ' ''''*''''" fofei lie Ingctlh. and. 1 fliuer an it It, t'lai iny I l-.*rA<»er u too \»*ii KUi-iiihtd to bi ilUiUd I y .«iiy J hini< an .•>nnr.)ineu» Sinbifr CJii fay t > oiy l).f*dv»nt5»:i. L>)u-lly umleUiving 'it >iitciiiicn .. his LKtl»in»tjon rtlVettir^ Mr. ^ttrnsinc! iiiyl'l!. >->-r Cturaetcrs b.ivebfcn lluni- toUy i!.j5*viz«d,withcm our h4vin|{t,.»a-inof)v.ortiinily cl lu,.t>criiiif!ilKni in any otlicrw-iy th»n the rui'lit I iinii, in vvIikIi v.* 1..iv< connned ourftlvjs «o a b.^re Rf!itu n ot Fatt*; am. if we bavt, ,11 luilice to ouriflve;, btr«n rtduced «o tU« unpkaUtu Ncc. miy cf wcuiulmg the tciJl- ir.ss ot aiv" «^ fr briiy cl" nnn, N»e Ifuil tlw (eaflUU I'ul.lic ^1(1 .ur.buW it to tin: biluMion c'lfunmn Nifc'i luvtpijccki ii^in, uid i>i)ltD liu.l».nition in >i» : A' !oi pj) own Pait, I have al- va,^ .'I'.ii.iliiU'l aliitndly Dlfpoiilioii towaidi Inch of l.ib Majeily'i Servants who dikhars,e »..e Dum* c.rtjt.;ir Appointments *U'» Ab.liiy, Fnkii'y and Hon...; Ai. for tl.ofe cf an oj.po- (iie Ci'.irat>cr, 1 huU them in «qu^\ Conmmpt vyith llir Caluoinics ol cur Author. I he ori- ;i..-'»' Hfue in Apr.ll erm, li-, wlicD my Clifit ^tiut, who had ir»n/»aed the Bufincfswlth the Oalcndant, attended the .'u.ruTitAuit V ulj his\Mtcv,rei ii<,m iJkCidapd oi tape- Bretun, eupcOingtheCaiifi would have t, c . icci. bri.ot,ht 10 IiiiJ. Mr. blowers, M^hg was of Counfel fpr the UcferdaiU, applied to i.K ill tlieCourfi; o( ihtTtrni, to know ii 1 iniai>l«dio bring tiMt Caul«on ; I told l.im, th. t I fully i r.tnd. 1 i:. 10 wiiiLtt ht rtphcU, it wa* mineujUry I o* ok- to urge lorairial, tor thcCcuit lu.fproniUtdluiBthty would not fcr;e himioa '1 rial that Tinn. 1 hij Declaration e^'^'-.'^'y (iKvvcd that Ut lia.i h«ld imprep«r Cen.iiiuivcaiion» with the judges, or elfe that Uc had btcn Huiiiy of iiaducini lluir Cl>»raaer». 1 »tttrwurdi moved f.ar the Court to fix a Day to h^ir the favfv', in whch Mouon 1 ^i* lurporttd by Mr. Sterns, u'ho wiu concerned with me for t .e Ihilntittk, aivl oi»^ol«d by Mr. Blow»r», on the Part of the Defendant, who the Court m- duK'ed \vilhll»v g.iglef^andir.g ovor,witlioiit th«(*fuil Affidavit for a Co:i'.inuaiue, or ^ny lej.ii JUilcn wt.itevu bwing tivtn. In ti.e July Ttrni following, Sttut attended a frcond I imu ^Mil» hii Witnid** frwiii C.»p«-Bi«tcn, not djubtinR but thtiCaufc would then have been biou,.;ht t ) Trial. 1, on the tt. it U.iy of tlie T«ini, infjrawJ Mr- Ulowers of my Intentions ot trying the ( aiii»- Ht Caid, h» lv».d • rtteived iha I ap«r« that he Ivid expeaed, but that, nolwithfland- l.i<, Ik; w.-uld not Wetp y loftger cut of a Tnii : A Kind of Language he conf^anOy niakci ulc of, an<1 wMcb i» i, d. v« ot a con/cioufnefi cf his Influence with thcCourt. On calling; < vti the e..uf«» it wa» not.a fur T.ia! by .fpc^ial Jury j the Uay wa. aftejwards fixed on for ilic 'In.l iheicof, and the I'antlojtikc Jury, bttwten the Partios, was ttc firil mrl« euta«d It urocdby ilie Sheriff into Uic I. Ufks Ofbcu of any thit rom. 1 he caufe, howsver, went off to ii-.a'-.iio in icrothir ufir.cu.Mr.Blcwcis iipnfuiin^ that it vtas aCaule of confequencc,vvhich would take up a w.b«le Uay, and aj/otinj jjoiuivtly to try it oo'iuejday, the lall Day of the ■leri). l.a r.iooday, hivinj llruck the I'anel on tho Part of my Clients, I har.dtd it to r.:r. HiowtotofttiWeoHthc Part of tlic Defendant, which lt« abf. luitly rcfufcd doing : 1 then moved thei> 01 rt to ordn tlieCaufe 10 be perenaptoiily brougjit on tlie iu.xt Day. Mr. Clowers oppoie^t tho Mvion. and prayed icra Continuance upja live fule Hcaloa of its being inconve- TKi.t f..r h*ni to try H.e t. aule at tha 1 nwc j upon wbich the Court ordei ;d a further Con- tinuance 01 the Criulc, vvi'.Scut hl» afhining acy other Reafon, witbout diiedtmg the ufi-al .-.tn- d'.vit, and diructly coi trary to the wtU known and ^Itabliflied Kul« of the Court.— 1 he next l.ay i ca.ne in with, wh.t .\:r. Pl.iin 1 ruth is )'k..ltd to icrri., in argry Pttltiou frcm iny Cli- «.' -.16 i I conleU it favourtd 3^ much of An^er as v.;iS ncceifary to Ititw, la moderate 'rtn"5 tii; Ihifiiipgot t!it Dcf-n.lai.t'i Ccunf^^l in thjC.ufc, aad t!ie lnduis: iir.pioi ric v tii^reof in fuch iiointed Tcinu, as to induce Judge Ercnton to ai.d, by wi-/ (i exijlaiVtion, I'lut the Couit tell theinfclvji inclined (o ir.duli,c the Attorney Gtntral ht,c<\ti. Ik wai a pulMi.; Ulbcer^aod had the Crown Bwlinefs 10 attend to : ('n v hich Mr. .Sterns c'jfcivs,"l i" Co„;„ ™ "'•"""> ">'. "»■ J»™M.rr!oRS°.r,oMf,1r"" '"r'"P'"™.i">l.i'ln.l»J Conf.i„„„ o( „„., , t,„ alTccd * "• """' '"■""■■" "'. " <>" "..uS ;;£--"f -i '™" '" ''- "■' ' c™. ,„. Cafe Of ^unn.nphau,, o,'' Windfor. 'J he Fart L Lfn,' ^H w ^f""' "' " '"-'' ' -^"^'1 the real Author of >^ldin Truth i/un„ ^ ? . '=°'^'"'"P"''I'-- ■m-'^ tai,cftr*,nvf a Syc^pi, rr ^ ,ul guided l.twc=n th^i'u^V^f'rVd.^^son'tl'o"/'""-'^'-'' ' "■-•A'^'e^", thorha.done, have »ukned the Charge onMrrW!,^'''' ''' '"' ''-^^- ^ '"c wh.t our Au- When it is tonfjd.'itdthat 111 I Z. .l^r |)c(ch.imps ;n particular. -.11 have „. other 'frt-.a, hut fo rr .0 h hh"n r"n ^T '"""^"^ ^'■-'^-"' 1 -dudL . I '"'^'- f-ublica. ,^^ \ »irS^'" "-^yt^ X % tt ]f k (■'■■ ''\ /%f C /va Icjr- l'^^ a^ ^ -^^^f ///'(^? tf J^yy-^ '■'f ^ V| mm wpm ^^^1 ^ t 31 1 FROM THE HALIFAX JOURNAL. To the PUBLIC. THE grand Reqiiifites wliich ousht to be found in every we'! conftituted Oovernmenf, at effential to the Hippinefs of tlie Peoplt, are Wifdom. Goodncfs and I'ower : Wildo.n, to difcern t'le reil Intereil of tlw Co n nunity; (Jo idnefi, to enleivar al^vay^ topr-fjrve t!iat re^l In- te.'cdj and Strengtiior Po,ver, toe irry tlii.K.nowled ji an I int«ntioii i.ito execution. If ilovern- m'^nt is unfortunately rcpofcil in facli I'erfons as do no.: polIVfj tlicfj f^jjlines, tiie F.l.-ffings of Civil Society arc in a great mtafurcfiullratcd, and a univerlal DifTitisf action mutl tnfue ths Lofs of Confidence in thofc who arc appointed to the txocutionof the l.avs and ihe dilUibuti( n of hiitice. Ihe Rritiih (.'cnflitution is, in all it"s IVi't , heiter calculatid to promote the Hap- pir.efj of its various Members, than any other Syflcm v^•hicu human Wifdom hath yet dtvife i, or prohai->ly ever will ; for though foaiCiimji Fadtion and Venality may creep in and influ.nce the .Meafures of its niini(\erial and executive Officers, the Virtue of the I'eople, who generally polfcfs a futfi'-.ient Dcijree of I'atiiotifm to enable th.-m to form a juit Lftimate of their j:em is rar,:ly withlield from thwfc whofe ;;ondurt is direifled hy .Motivei of CanCor and Humanity ; and tliough 1 nitances may happen of th.-ir fuilaining a partial temporary tvil, they generally rife fupenoi to the intluvnce of artful deligning Men, and ultimately receive the Plaudits of their Fellow Subjedls, for their perfeve- Iranct: and Firinncfs in bringing to public View fuch Meafures as are either dangerous in their [Ert'eifs, or have a 'tendency to lefTcn the Reputation of Government. To excite unnectlfiry Fears and jeaioufies in the Minds of the I'eople is highly criminal ; but Occurrences may and fom*times do l;appen, when it is ^equally criminal to de filent, m ire efp^cialiy when the t'lrft Rights of the Subjetl are invaded by unwarrantable Disiranchifements, and a fair impartial Hnquiry eluded by every Artifice which Influence can fuftjjell.— Confcioua Innocence needs no Subterfuge, in the Moment oi the feveretl Trial, infpired vvilli Confidence, defies theclofeft Invefligation, and never Ihrinks from the mall rigid Inquiry. We have long heard of Complaints reipiclini; the Adminitlration of |ufiice in the Supreme Court of the Province, and however difficult it may be for People in general to afcertain with 'any Dtgree of Preeifion the Truth of them \ it is a melancholy Confideration that there fhould be even the PolTibility of a Pretext for fuch Complaints, becaiife it has a Tendency tJ locfeu tht Reins of Government, hy deflroying that Confidence whicii not only gives l.ncrgy to the Laws, but is the moft effeftual Karrier againft Anarchy and l.icentioufiiefs. Our Public Situ- ation is much to be lamented, but we have this Coiifolation, that an adequate Reiredy is within our Reach, we are oniy wanting in GoojKij'i to apply that Remetiy, which, it is devoutly to be wiihed, may be etl'cdcd through that ly^jaorn wln.Ujiilterno theital Ir.tercftof the Community. It is true that the General Alfembly, at their 1 ill SeiTion, in a Commiiteeot the whole Houfe, went into the Invc(lijati;>n of Facistha have occafiont I tliofe Diiuti^fatlions, and under a fe- rious Impreirio.i, from thi Informatii'n they hid rtceive.i, addrefled his Excellency the Lieu- tenant Ciovcinjr upon the Subjetl, requ;iiin.; that lie would take tliC fime int) Coniideration, and adopt fuch Meafures tUereon as he nii^lit think jull aiut light. Ihe Language of th.^t .\i- drefb was fuited to the Solemnity of t'.ie Uccalion, an 1 iiLnilelled tliehiah Senfethry had of the Trull repofed in them by the People ; for tliey cxpieily dccL.re tohis F.xccilency, that the mag- ritude of the Oojecl was fucii, that tliey were- eom^jeiltd to laciilice even the I eel njjs of Iiu- m.ir.ity, rather than bet:3y an inat^ntion to thofe Coiu-rrs, vvliich (lio'.jld evi.r claim the firil and null w.itchfui Ke the cl'...reil I vid.iHC <'f the Wifdom and Dw'libcr.ition of the Repiefentativcs of tlie People. 'Ihe iloiile, without any Ccnfliudicn or Comment i;pontlie Inlormarioii t'ler had received, furthe: tl :;ii what wa» cxpr^lVivj of tlcii I"). licitude lor a full Invelliratioii of tins fcri^ius BiUinel', UiUai.iicd I'loof*, as tie Giouiuio i fan tnquir), which th -y rcqicilod nukilit be iiiilituted in liicli a M.'.niier that a lair ind i.iipariial Tr a I (hould ta!» ,,1,-iif- T>,,i-_ /■ ^ ... i^ i r .t t - ex. est, .n 1 wh t have t'.t- Pu . '^^'^'"''^ •'' ' -"J. Aiiui.nco v,lut h.d the Hculc a v^'^:S'..tr n, n,.i, .nd A n i tL .,ah h^' T^ ''^ "''•^n^'-cal and ir:.,, a.:.blc. that the In- co,u-,d., tl,- .',oce.V,„:Vt" e , W,l-; ^'T:'*'!'; '^' '^'^ comma lo,,. 1 fhail theruore o. en. . r.wn, or fc^.^one o, ,^^"' t: .^'7, [". '.^ ,^''^'" Z^"'' ^^I' "-" -f the Law Servants c. ri.nglv, though uiih .4 D t™ ". , ,' -V "^ ^r. d d.rcfl.d thl, Buf.ncfs, and treat icac Court, ^^ ere fum,r.orcd;nd exam; dl?.,... '^'^'^y^" °» "'-' Attornlc. of the Supreme be ., .e regular th ,t . r Oepo t o^ ' „ .^'""1^ ^'!,*'' "' ^■''^^' ^'^°'' 'l-^'"- c..„celving it to fuJ,aothen,,cln.ormari'n iouTdwa^^^^^^^^^ ''. l'^'>' ^'^■'"^" "'^'^ '" P'^ruK of to t:.. wovemor, „od of the Ne«m tv 'irt tv "^^."^P^^"^"'*^'"" ^^ thrir Fears aud App^henfion, '^hich would ,ivet^eFarue^SVaL?!^?' '^'Z'^'' ^'""^ "^ Trial or Invemgation if innocent. U i^ prob^b here mav h.-K ' ' «.^ Opportunity of acquitting themfelve,, rn^nt of this nuane ■-, a. Art des „T?rn r ► ' ^'"' "^ /•"'"" ""^ ^"^'^od in the Arran^^e- Impe.fed.or, it wa- unhe om',^/ che hr« "'"f r? "^^ ^P-^^ific^Hy exhibited, but of this v.m.nc-r.t t. av,>il themfclverThat tl l^T ,T °^.l"'?"^ ^viftalning the h.gheit Offices in Go- oftheH.'u..,.ndcorrobe;aSi„m^^^^ f''" ''"'"^^ ey adduced at the Bar fcveral other Membe, of eHoufT and h.,,"'' '" ' ''^ '"'' ^''"' ^"''^'^ """* ral, .rcfuch .friking I'roof^. of tSealde hh', " T ^°"'.^^'^''^ed by the Attorney Jenc- their ful f.quent Conduft and tl - Zell nH s 7^. "'";'■ "«'^*' "'^t 't is now nccelTary to attend to Tra.fH«,on in fuel, a 1 r.,1n , 3, f fl " h^ ! -vr ' ^.'"^"if'^rted to ,Iace this int.^e.Ung bunal uiKonnedied w!,h t^l'^ ies c^ '. !r^^^ D.fnu.fuion might beeaabliftud befcrea Tn! Habits of th.clo^lUt;^!cl!nH'f°'^f'',^^^^^^ of the Secretary of ''p"ov?n"?h'rr^ = O.fcovering by the'communication. Council, and folely upon t°o Oninicn .lIUll V'^T!^' ^"^ ^" '^^' '^'''^^ before his Majeily's n-.orala, well as poiurcalVVa?arrs conl/n ."f '' ^^ '^.='" '"^ "'^ """'"'=' » ^^S^^^ fo'r their Memorial to tlx Governor ft tin^rn.'n'' '"""' '"'''" """P^-^ed Dilemma, to prefer a Oround. on wrich the'.A 1^^ "h'ad a 'X^^^^^^^^ Allegations were not tffe only givtn, upon ih- Jnouirv otThAir * ''''"^-'^ '''^ Lxcellency, and that Evidence would alfo by Ncwton^fqVci^eif f^conn -f "f':''l''^'"'^^'^''"'''y°^ '''= J"'-'?^^ t° the Hon. Henry I.-q; ^^r.-.hS'c:^'^:^:^:^^:^;;:^^';^^^^^^'^^ !'-^ality .0 widf the Hon. S. S. Blo.^rs' e X 34 1 • ITROM THE HALIFAX JOURNAL. To th, FraholJers and othtr lnhabtt»nU of the Pfvinc of No^a-Scolia. TS!*'''^ ",";,''' Rc-rcf'-ation -.He bytheCencral AflembJy, « their '.ft Seff.on to hi. Excellency the U.utcn.nt-Gov.. nor rdattye to the Admm^^^^^^ t. Conienoence of p.eme Court of the J^royince , the Proceedmg. of Hm '^»J«'\y * "l^^^^^'JdV^^'e.tment wc have ?ho.-. RcHrercntations, and the ver^ oppreffive .njunou nd unmcut^^^^^^ __^^^ experknced, f»r having endeavored to br.ng forw.IkL^^^^^ Authority of Govern- «r difpofed to render a ready and '^'"'"S. 0''«^'"«;,,Vu^,^trm.y pe^ f^ff" » partial „ent, than the Inhabitants °f ^'^''-^/"''••^f "t cSinatTon which has too long and too temporarv Evil, from ihc Influence of a '»/"f ^°"* ^^.^^^^^^^^ ,nd Injuries aiB- fatally governed almoft every publ.c ^*"^";^*„' ^^ 'J/' ^^/^toy th.rinfluence and thereby re- t::^^^:^\:^^^ i;in":o=r"/hc S o^. Ju^^- Men ofAbiHties, Honor "iVthe'pac^ctre embar. for Great- Britain P-7'- -^.'^^'-/^^itnre'w'; rntll'uln^o/fh: our Leave of thisCoun.ry, and publ.cly to «'<"°^^'^''Kr,'^'/"*!;"i, r„ Defcription. very honorable I^clarations and ..(Tur.nces we l^ve rece.ved from^^^^^ ^ P^^^^, of People of their entire Approbation of oar Condu« Such r*""^°"^ , ^..J, ^,,1,,, Publicdcmand our war^eiin-nks, and ^r ^ '^je oarWve ne^. to^^^^^^^ ^^^.^^^ ^^^^^^ t normity. We are with real and unteigned Regard, ' Gentlemen, Ycur moft faithfi-.l and obedient Snvanti, g ^. pR ^ s. , , I. «9 ^'- TAYLOR. '-^. '^->^4^i^ '-f^ ^^^^1 -■***.. V y^y^