^ J-^ ^ IMAGE EVALUATION TEST TARGET (MT-3) m A^ LO I.I 2.5 ■- IIIIIM *- Ih III 2.2 **" BiA mil 1.8 1.25 1.4 1.6 ^ 6" - >■ ^1 ^^> .>' 7^^ ^# .'^ .^ >^ C//^: Photographic Sciences Corporation 23 WEST MAIN STREET WEBSTER, NY. 14580 (716) 873-4503 CIHM/ICMH Microfiche CIHIVI/ICMH Collection de microfiches. Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions / Institut canadien de microreproductions historiques Technical and Bibliographic Notes/Notes techniques et bibliographiques The Institute has attempted to obtain the best original copy available for filming. Features of this copy which may be bibliographically unique, which may alter any of the images in the reproduction, or which may significantly change thn usual meiihod of filming, are checked belo^. L'Institut a microfilma le meilleur exemplaire qu'il lui a et^ possible de se procurer. Les details de cat exemplaire qui sont peut-^tre jniques du point de vue bibliographique, qui peuvent modifier una image reproduite, ou qui peuvent exiger une modification dans la mdthode normale de filmage sont indiqu^s ci-dessous. / D Coloured covers/ Couvarture de coulaur I I Covers damaged/ Couverture endommagee Covers rostored and/or laminated/ Couverture restaur^e et-'ou pellicul^e □ Cover title missing/ Le titre de couvertura nianqua I I Coloured maps/ n y Cartes giograohiques en coulaur D Coloured pages/ Pages de couleur Pages damaged/ Pages endommag^es Pages restored and/or laminated/ Pages restaurees et/ou pelliculees Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ Pages ddcolorees, tachetdes ou piquees Pages detached/ Pages ddtachees D Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ Encre de couleur (i.e. autre que bleue ou noire) / □ Coloured plates and/or illustrations/ Plan< n irhes et/ou illustrations en couleur Bound with other material/ RaliA avec d'autres documents Tight binding may cause shadows or distortion along interior marc in/ Lareliure serree peut causer de I'ombre ou de la iiistorsion le long de la marge intdrieure Blank leaves added during restoration may appear within the text. Whenever possible, these have been omitted from filming/ II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajouties lors d'une restauration apparaissent dans le texte, mais, lorsque cela 6tait possible, ces pages n'ont pas iti film^es. D D D n Showthrough/ Transparence Quality of print varies/ Quality indgale de I'impression Includes supplementary material/ Comprend du materiel supplementaire Only edition available/ Seule Edition disponible Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata slips, tissues, etc.. have been refilmed to ensure the best possible image/ Les pages totalement ou partiellement obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata. une pelu.-e, etc., cnt 6t6 film^es A nouveau de facon a obtenir la meilleure image possible. Q Additional comments:/ "^ ' Commentaires supplementaires: Pagination is as follows : 245 - 256 p. This item is filmed at the reduction -atio checked below/ Ce document est filmd au taux de reduction indiqu^ ci-dessous. 10X 14X 18X 22X 26X 30X J 12X 16X 20X 24X 28X 32X Th« copy filmed hare has baan raproducad thanks to tha ganarosity of: Library, Geological Survey of Canada Tha imagas appaaring hara ara tha bast quality possibia considaring tha condition and lagibiiiry of tha original copy and in Icaaping with tha filming contract spacificationa. L'axamplaira filmA fut raproduit grdca d la g^nirositi da: Bibliothdque. Commission Gtologique du Canada Laa imagaa suivantaa ont At6 reproduitas avac la plua grand soin. compts tar\u da la condition at da la nattat* da I'axamplaire fUmi, at an conformity avac laa conditiona du contrat da filmaga. Original copiaa in printad papar covars aro filmad beginning with tha front covar and anding on tha last paga with a printad or illustratad impraa- sion, or the back cover .vhan appropriate. All othpr original copiaa are filmed beginning on the first page with a printed or illuatratad imprea- sion, and anding on the last paga with a printad or illustratad impresaion. The laa; recorded frame on each microfiche shall contain the symbol «^ (meaning "CON- TINUED"!, or the symbol V (meaning "END"), whichever appliea. Laa axemplairea originaux dont la couvarture an papier eat imprim^ sont fllmto en commandant par la premie^ plat at an terminant soit par la darniire page qui comporta une amprainta d'impraasion ou d'illustration, soit par la second plat, salon le cas. Tous lea autres axemplairas originaun sont filmte on commandant par la premiere page qui comporte une smpreinte d'impression ou d'illustration at an terminant par la derniire paga qui comporte une telle ampreinta. Un dea symboles sutvants apparaitra sur la demiira image da cheque microfiche, selon le caa: le symbols — •- signifie "A SUIVRE", le symbole V signifie "FIN". Mapa, platea, charts, t tc, may be filmed at different reduction ratioa. Those too large to be entirely included in one exposure are filmed beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to right and top to bottom, as many framea aa required. The following diagrama illustrate the method: Las cartea. pianches. tableaux, etc., pauvent dtra fllm^a i das taux da r^uction diffirents. Lorsque le document est trop grand pour dtre reproduit on un seui cliche, ii eat film^ ^ partir da Tangle supirieur gauche, de gauche ^ droite. et de haut en baa. 9n prenant le nombre d'Images nteeasaire. Lea diagram ^es suivants iilustrent la mithodb. 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 6 B^•/ m^\ BULLETIN OF THE GEOLOGIC SOCIETY ( ^ If? VCL. 4, PP. 24». o '' OF AMERICA X,i"braTy , Department of Geology. THE F/UNAS OF THE SHASTA AND CiiXCO FORMATIONS BY T. W. STANTON ^ ■ ROCHESTER rUBLISHED BY THE SOCIETY June, 1893 I J II -^ v>. . r \ f, ftl BULLETIN OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF AMERICA Vol. 4, pp. 24t>-2S6 June 8, i893 TIJE FAUNAS OP THE SHASTA AND CHICO FORMATIONS RY T. W. STANTON {Read before the Society December ,W, JSD2) CONTENTS Historical Review 245 Earliest I-iterature 24."> Views of W. ]\r. (iabi) 240 Tiie Tojon Controvei^y 24('> Work of the Canadian Geological Survey 248 Wliitc's Classification of the California Cretaceous 24'.) Relation of Sliastii and C'hico Faui:as 24!) Identity of Faunas indicMited 24il Local liists of l)otli Faunas from northern California 250 Original Localities of (Uiico Fossils 2."):i Faunas of (iueeu C'liariolte and Nanainio l'\irniations 2.").T Correlation of (iueen Charlotte l'^:)nnatioa witii the Shasta 2.'i:i Correlation of Nanaiino Ik'ds with the Ch.ico 2.")4 The Sliusta-Chico Fauna compared with the Fauna of the Blackdown Beds . . 254 Ccfiiclusions 255 Historical Rrview. Earliest Literature, — The earliest publislied opinion concerning the age of the beds now known a.s the Chico formation seems to l)e that of l)r J. B. Tr sk,* who described Ammonites ehicoen-iis and Barulites chicocnsis in ]8.5(j. On account of the modern aspect of the fossils associated with those si)ecies lie referred the strata containing tliem to the upper Eocene. Shortly afterward Professor J. S. Newberry f discussed the same beds, *Proc. Cftl. Ai'dd. Nat. Sci., vol. i, IR.IO, p. 85. t I'iii'iHc R. R. Reports, vol. vi, pt. 2 f lsr.7 ?], pp. 24, 'J.'. Tho titlo-pdgo honrs tlio diitn IS-)."!, luit tlioro is intoniul evidi'iioo that the voliuiie whs not piililishod bofiiie 1X57. XXXVU-Bui.L. Gkoi. Soc. Am., Vol.. 4, ISHL'. (245) 240 T. \V. STANTON' — srrA>,T.V AND flllOO FATNAS. and, wliile iidniittiiii,' the proHonco of modern types of niolluskH, consid- ered lliiit tlie eepliiilopods were .stronger evidence of tlieir Cretaeeous iigc. lie also statod that he liad obtained a eolleetion of fossils from Xanaimo, Vaneouyer island, that proved the Crotaeoous n0 species of fossils whi(!h he referred to the Cretaceous. In the introduction some general statements concerning the elassilication and correlation of the California Cretaceous Avcre given hy Professor .1. 1). Whitney,*; the state geoh)gist, on the authority of Mr (;al)h. All the Cretaceous" beds on the I'acitie coast were assigned to two divisions (.1 and />'). which were to- gether supi)ose(l to represent the Upper Chalk or Whitt; Chalk of Furope and the Fort Pierre and Fox Hills groups of the upper .Missouri, although the Cretaceous of the latter region .seemed to have no species in conunon with the California strata. T/ie lejoa Coutmrer.vj.—Thv. puhlieation of this volume precipitated a discission between Messrs Cial)b, Conrad and others as to the age of *Tnuis. Albuny In.ititut-, vul. iv, l«r)S-'fi4, pp. ;!r,-49. t Hull. V. S. G<'ol. Siirv. 'l\n., vol. ii, IsTfi, pp. ;(r,i-.i7i. ri'I.e siiinc opinion is express.;.! in l>rof..ssoi- .Meeli's li.st woi'lc, U. S. (ieol. Siirv. Terr vol i.x hivert. Paleontology, J). XXV. ' ' ii Trims. St. Louis Aeiiil. Si'i,, vol. i, ls.">s, pp. ]-j.'i-i ■.',-,. IH^iiiirf. .Joiir. (ieol. So.:. 1^)1111., vol. xvji, Isiil, pp. IJS-l:!.;, 11 I'llleolltoloKV of Cill., vol. i, 18ti4, p. xix. •: ... • ; • •• • •*. •;.!.• . • • • ...•••• • • .••••.♦•. • ••• • •••• •••••• • •••• KOCKNIC KACIKS ol' 'I'lIK TK.ION. 21' division '•/)'," now known as tlu; .'I'ojiTii lorniiition, Mr ("ourad asH(irtiii>^ tliat it is E«»((iif and Mr (ial)l) as stromiously maintaining its Crotacoous a was rciiiirded as proof of its Tertiary aj^t- ; while on the other hand, (he |iri'senee of an annnonitc (Annii()i)!fi!.i ji'finUs) ami the apparently close fauna! and strati^'raphie connection with the Cretaceous lieds heneatli were helievcd to prove its ( 'retaeeons aj^e. According to Mr (lalili'st statement in oiu; of his controversial articles, 2'') species of the 107 in division II an; found in the uinh'rlying heds. When his list of connnon siiecies is criti<'ally examinecl, however, it is seen that, with the exception of the Aiiniiniiltc'^ and perhaps two o: three others, they all lielong to genera that have live(l iVom tiie Ci'etac^eous or earlier to the present f-ne without undergoing much cliangi!. I'rofessor Angelo iieil- prin :|; ' is given a "areful review of all the jiuiilished evidence hearing on this (luestion, ano in preparing it he has studied a large jiart of Mr (!al»h\s (trigin-d collections of ( 'alifornia, fossils. His article is a strong argument for the Koceiie age o!' the Tcjon and incidentally it throws consideral)le douht on the accuracy of Mr (iahh's statements concerning the sju'cies that occur in iioth the Chico and tlu; Tejon. I'rofessor Jules ^farcouj^ and l)r ('. A. White || have also referred the Tejon, or division />, to the Koeeiic, and tins view is now generally accepted. While admitting its 'I'crtiary age,l)oth Dr White*' and l)r(i. F. i>eckcr,-i"!'- after studying the suhject in the field, have stated their lielief that in southern California the Tejon, is oidy the upper i)art of an unbroken sevies, the Chico-Tijon, in which the sedimentation as well as the life was continuous from the Cretaceous into the Tertiary. In the second volume (tf the Paleontology of Califori, ,1, published in ]S()1), Professor Whitney jt again sunnuarized Mr (iabl»'s latest views on the classitication of the Cretaceous. Division /> is named the Tejou and considered to l)e the proltable etjuivalent of the >hiestricht beds. Division .1 is scfjaratcd into three groups: the Martinez grouj», which is (h)ul)tfully sc[>arated from the one next l)elow; the Chico group, which ♦Cimnicrw iirtii'los iiro in Am. .Jour. (jOUcIi., vol. i, ISWi, pp. :i62-:iii;7, p.:io.'. t I'roc. Ai'ikI. N;it. Si'i. I'liilii., issi!, p|i. Iti.VJI I : roiitrilmlioiis to Tortiiu-y Uool. uiid I';ilooiil. of llio Uiiitod States, I88», pp. 1ol'-1I7. ii Hull. Soo. (((''ol. lie Krimc'o, tome xi, l.ss.l, pp. tl7-l:!.->. II Bull. 15, tl. S. Gool. Survey. l,sS:i, pp. 11-17; Bull, "il, 1S8',I, pp. 11-11; Mull. 8li, 18111, p. 193. II Soo rul'oroiR'os just vtivon. ** Bull. 1!), U. S. Oi'ol. Siirv., 1S.S,-). tt Piigfs xiii iukI xiv. -'■18 T. W. STANTON— SHASTA AND CIIICO KAUNAS. ..s .orrdaU,. with th. Cppn- Chalk or |,.>w..r Chalk an.l, it is thou-^ht tht,,MNMaiin;.l„.,!su( \ aiinrnvrr Ishm.l ; an.l the Shasta -,•..„„ ,„■„- v.s..,nally ,unu.l „, indu.!.. a s.-ries of h..ls of ,,i„,,....t a,,.; h V '•■"• A;---'l...« to Whitney - it contains lossils, sec.n.inr.lv n,.rl t- ".^' a,es h.,,,, the (la.Ht to the Neeonnan, i.u.h.sive. ' ' vj' "one . .,s lossiis an. known to exten.l upwani into the Chi^o^roup'' U^-; / . Cun,nl.,a il.^Hira; S,,rrn,~\n 1S7I the ,eolo,ieal snrvev . ula .e,an the work n. British Cohnnhia whieh has eonlnhuteil Ulsl;;: ■;'''' '''';'h"'''"'^ <-"=aionsortheI'aeinccoaHt. t I. i. >..n. the s..ope ol this pap..,- to eonsider the .lelaih-l -...h.-M,. ;oonptMHM.tlH.(',vtne™onN^uw.o soip and Dr (ieor;re .M. Dawson.f • "Meet on \ aiwonver -slan.! an.l of ahont i:;,0()() feet on (^een Char- otte .slan.ls The mvortol,rato fossils Iron, hoth these areas have he . -nl... an.l Inl-y ,hs..uss...l hy ^r.•.r. F. Whiteav.-s.: The nn .trecento' the ii; ; / ■ ^^^'^'V';''''^'-'""^^^' i'^l'^'xl-^ «oction is the e.,uivalent .,f Mital.)nnat,.,n, an.l that the san.e hon..,n is represonte.l in the .-• lH.m ,,a.-t o, N j.n...n,ve.- islan.l an.l at sevenU h.ealiUes ..n the ^u ' - ••^"1 ••' '"t..h(..lnn.h:a; that the he.ls of the Xanain.o an.l Con.ox eoa u . s on the ..as,..n. c.oast of Vane.,uver islan.l are n.ore re.H,nt an.l i . .I.^' y the C h.eo .,rn.at..>n, an.l that non., of these he.ls are . , l.ler • n HM , I>rev,.,usly M,- ^^•|.iteaves ha.l expresso.l the opinion iMt the Shasta l.,rinat.nn an.l Its e.iuivalents in I!ritish('.,lnn.hiash..ni(l IH. s..parat...l nit,, tw.. f.>nnati..ns, refernno- tl... ol.ler he.ls, whi,.h are espeeja ly ehara..ten.e.l hy an ahnn.lanee of . I „..//., to the Neconuan ■".. tlu npperport.on to the (lanlt; hnt a.l.liti.nml coUoethMis showed su.^ a hlen.hn, ol tl. .aunas that they e.>nl.l not he separat.xl and U^ \ lew was aliandoiied. 118 l.s7:i--7:i, pp. ,iL<-!i,'. ' "'III,.!,!,,,! \„ iv,.,- ;n„l(;,i,,.M .•JiMi-lctt.. Ish.n.ls: ll,i,l., .Vr"'"''.'""''""""'""'''"" ^"•""<■|'^"•^'lt,.|,sla,„ls: ll,i,l ls7,s ' , „„ I hiM- • o„ r , L'.'il hxuiiunalii.M (j| the. iii.i'tlirrii I'.irt ,>,' \-.,. ., , ' ' • '. I'p. '-"H I. ; . )ii ^ („.,,l,,ni- I-P. I-.MT M; ..n .iu- .JJ^^-t^^^u^TZ ,' '""■ ''""'■ "'■"'■ ""■"•>' '■"-'^'' ■^'<"' ^^- ■■ A.n..r •.s,..,voi.v::';:i;- ';;;: ;:^^:,; '^ "o..n,w.st..n. ..o,., ..r .i. n.,,,.,,;..,, .„• ,.p. M-«.,, and Con,, to .;,„.a,|i.„ V^l^^, ^l l^"' ''"'' '"" ''""""' '"'■ '' "^'*- ^^ '^ iisK (jk i>ir,i,i:us <(>r,i,K<'Ti<»NH. 219 Wliilr'x (HitMlJiriilinii.Dj'lhc ('aHjuriilii Cnidrroii-s. — lh- (.'. \. White, wlin.st! work on tliu ('rctiut'oii.s of ('aliloriiiii lius iiliviuly been rd'crrfil (n, jilso rocdjiiiizod two divirtions in tlio SliiiHtii, towhinh ho niivotho h)C!il niuncH, KnoxvilU' iinil Iforsotown hods, !iltlioiii.'li ho Itoliovod thoni to l»o (liwoly roliitod ; and several species of the II(>rs<'to\vn fauna were afterward f<»uiid assoeiate(l in the; same strata witii Anrrlln, tiie characttM'istie fossil of tho Kno.willo l»eds, near Iliddles, Orejjon/^- It may theroforo he re<.::ardod hh ostaltlished that tho KnoxvilUi hods siiould not he eonsidorod distinct from the remainder of tin; Shasta formation, althon,i,di tliey ni; y usually he recognized hy the ;;reat ahuMdanc<' of Aiifillu, a fossil that Hoeins not to ran;^o into tin; upper jtart of tho series. Tho firout apparent did'oroneo in the faunae of tho Shasta and theChico formations at tht; localities studied hy him led Dr White to helievo that there is a break between these two formaiions, ropresontin'i a ^reat timo- hiatus.t althouji;h thoy aro apparently eonformahlo. 'i'lie list of species assijiuod to ea(Oi formation hy Mr (iabh also seomcid to justify this belief, bui the sei[Uel will show that tho strati^'raphic position and the vertical raii;;o of many of the spooios wore very imperfeetly known until (^uito rooontly. Ki:i,ATIO.\ Ol'' SUASTA AND ChIi'O KaUNAS. filanlili/ of l'iiii)iii-< indlcjitcd. — Various mombors of tho United States (!eoloi,dcal Survey working: in Califoriiia and ()re.t;-on during,' tin; last few years have from time to time ma\ iiml S2. t Kor (lescri|itl(iM ul'tlie );eiil(i>ry ol'tliis region iiii'l Curtlier iliai-'llssjoll of tile |>illeoi|loloi.'y see Mr l»iller'« (iiiper, tlii.-i voliinie, i>\>. ■^n't-S.il. L':.o T. W STANTON—SIIAHTA AM. cMlrc, Kai-nah. ; •""'•'■"< tM.ruons won, soon t., Ik, in,.x,,li..aMv nu.x..,|. M, „i, u? , ' - -...M.s„,,..s,...| that tlH. two lUunaH wcr. ,..;.,. dos.lv r v J Li 111;;:;:;::'' '"''^^ ^..I.l s..,.son NFr ) I..,. ,.,,, ...,„.i,,,,,,,, ,,,,■, „^ ,„,^,,^. at ^.^X.w • I "..aou . ||.,.s,. (.,ss,ls, wlMrh |.,v,. m-..„Mv 1.,...,. st,„Ii...| ,ravo :::c:;;::i;::;i:r:j:;;:t;^^^^^^^^^^ u (I '*A)nmo,n'fi:s /injf)„ininl, (iiil.l». '^AiiniioiiitrH hrcirrri, '* '^•I>lphiclii)iri-(i.'< Inrin^ Annjf(irtnt.s(/) llnivhis, '^liilcm n ififi iinprrssii.1, LioriniH pinirldhnii, " *Lmuiti(i (irrl/diHi, '• (ryrndes. Fiisitu ar(Ui(.% (Jahl). ''^Anlmiiiijn;! nurhii, (Jahli (?) .SVv//,„7V^ ((//m/(«/.s (/j), Jj'url)., Wl, it- caves. Arfnoiiiiia califnrnini, (ial)I). ('ill III id. fl\iiii/irii/d rdrid, (iaiil). '■^'Uiiiriiaclld pa/Ild^ '> 'I'Pdiiiiji.Ki Cdiit-nilrird, '* f('iirii/l;ii( (riniai/d, '' tAc)H(((/o/( rdiii:niirririi>iis, Mwk. \7Vi(/oiii(i /ripiit'OHlatd, CJahb. i' Triijnnia leann, " Trii/Diild. '\l'irin< oprrcnli/iinnis, (;alilj. •(■'/'//'■^/.-i annulata (dal.I.) = CdnUmn {Ltiiu'ainlliim) duimldlinn. fCorhn/d fnid-ii, (ial.l.. ■\-Mi/ti/ii.i (ptdilratii.'i, (ial)li(?) Mildhix Idiircolatus, Sowcrhy. •|-ArJr< traiidiiddd, (lalil). y'/riird,Hi/,i lin-iijatd, W'liitoavcs. jTi'llliid /iiijl'iiuiiiiiidiid, (laltl). \' Tell i lid iiidt/irir.soiili, " '\Mdrtrd, d.-ihhiinur!, " fC/iiDiie niridiis^ " jMcrh'd nulitUd, " jMi'ckiii /ifjr/.y, '\Mi'rkid -iil/d, UhijndKmcllii. (I * Sfl)s( of tllO llM'llliticM Ill('llli.ilw..l , '--;,,« ,„.a.. ,, ,,.«,. „„, .:n;:;::;;,:i,;:: ^ " "" ""■ ^''■"■" ■"^"' •■""="■ * ^^ j. a omor. *t riic spiM'ji.s ln'loiminif to '\f.. (;.,i.i,'„ wi . i- l'"H/.„n. '-^ ^"- "" ""'^■'■* l'^'^- -'"' '"•'•n posirivcly ,.s.ijt,u.,l to ..itl,..,- .■*]!■ (,i;|lil]'s UU1IK'11"I;UU1V js || i M'.l, in luust o.so« without rovi.ion, Ihro.igiioMt this imj^t. nil i Hirr.KN CIIKKK AV'> ONO ('(yr.r.Kf'TIONS. 251 Of tlic ^.<> sjH'cicM in this lint, tlic I*iilfniit(tln;.'y oi" i'njilnrniii jrivoH S as coiiiiii^' tVoiM the Siiii.slu lui'l is t'ntiu tiic Chico, wliilo '2 uftlic otiiors ani tloiilitfiilly rot'orrod U) tlit! loniitT iiml 2 to the iuttor. At least 12 of tlu^so spocjcs arc also tTprcscnted by i lahh. Nemodnii rinironn'mislx. Meek. (Uicnlliva Iniiinilii, (iahh. I'ictni iiitcrciiliforiiiix, " This collection a(Ms two Shasta and two Chico species to the Ilorsetown and Texas spring's list. ;\t and ahout Ono, Calii'ornia, mostly within a mile of the vilhij^'c, the followinj; species wero ohtained: AniiitiHilli'.'i hnli'.'^i, Tx'ask. . I /((//(()/( /Vrs hreirrri, (iahh. A iiniKiii !!(:■< /KilfiiKiinii'i '' ^iiiiiiiDnltc-i iriiioiiill, " Mtirtcxiti claii.'id, (iahh. Tnrmis plniim, " Plinniini/n l;irl(/(ilii, ^\'hiteaveH. 'JVii/iiiiia IcdiKi, (iahh. Amtiinaltc.'i {Phtjlloccrds) nuiioxm, Tri'/onid !i'(iiitri>ve loi'alities. f'rri, a, I'aclu'eo pass, Siskiyou mountains and 'J'uscan si)rings. The other live local itic', viz, Chieo creek. Cow creek, Folsom, Pence's and Texas Flat, yielded a greater proportion of species not contained in Mr Diller's ('ollecti(Mis from Shasta county, hut there are several well marked llorsetown species reported from each (jf these localities; and they are all so intimately related to the other Chico localities hy means of species held in <(immon with one or more of tliem that they cannot he regarded as helonixing to another fauna. The Martinez jiroup of (lahb has long since heen abandoned as insep- aral)le from the Chico; and, as Mr Diller has shown in his [laper on the Cretaceous and early Tertiar}"^ deposits of this regicjn,"'^ the Wallala for- mation probably also I)elongs in the same series. FaU nAS ok (ilKKN CUAUmTTK AM) NaNAIMO FoiiMATlONS. Cofirldtidii iif (^ncca ('ItarloUc FiiruuidDn ifitli the Shasln. — The correla- tion of the (iuecii Charlotte formation (divisions (', D and A'of Dr Daw- son's section) with the Shasta has already been mentioned in speaking of Mr W'hiteaves' woi'k. The additions now made to the llorsetown fauna materially increase tlu' mimliei'of species that occur in both tin; Shasta and tiuecn Charlotte formations, it should l)e stated, however, that several genera of annnonites found on (iueen Charlotte islands and not yet seen ill the Sliast;i suggest a somewhat earlier period for the bed in which tiny occur. It would simplily the matter if it could be proved that these aiiimouites came from a lower horizon. It is worthy of note *.\llti', p|i. ■-'(I.VliJI. .SN.XVIII -litl.!.. LiKUl.. Sw. .\.M., Vol.. I, ISSJ, 251 T. W. ST.\NT„X-s„.,sTA ASM. ."IHCO KArXA^ ill tills coiiiicclion tliat 11 <'nii(!(iii,rii('|i;ir|oUcs«.c( '(' upper slijilcs Mild saiiilst l'>ll,('l>lltilill /; imrci'.f aspodesthat is,.liarn,.U.risti,.ortlic('olora.l nioiiiitaii ill 1' I r(3j,'ion aii.l is m,t I ones, ,,!• division ./ '/'".s irrohlnudtlcKs, Schloth., ^<> t'oriiiatioii in tlu' ]{ 11 rope, Kiion-n to mnge IjiglaT than tlio 'J voc uroiiiaii iilTl N '/' "/' A'a//^/ iiiaiiiii l.cd> on \' ///('> Hcds u-lth the C/i ICO. -Th correlation of tli CIMI iH'i'tJoii with tl mniuver islan.l with the (^hieo formation, tat '<• facts ;drea(iyf,Mveii,iiiinl '■.vreiat,.,i(othe(iueenCharl.,ttt,ronnat ••'lid I tiiink tiiatii < plies that (hese hed ion (lian has been Cal ili'i'iiia, \'an ■"""Panson of tlie faunas (oui.d in the ti I'eiationship. 'J'hc j <'<'uver aiMl (^ueen Charl otte, will i/W' ken in s are more silpltosed, iree re'dons. elusion are tiiat son "•""■'I'al facts that seem to h ■vi(h'iiee of tl lis on V Afoiifi aneouvei- island ai IK' ol the species of //,„■»///, opposed to this ooii- ■'■ la ppareiitly closely related t ■-'' and of liiorcrnwiis found '='l<'nnationofX,hraska,(oi;,nuloandeI ■•^■J-non, and that the plants found in the .\ '•eot upper Cfetaeeous types. '<> (Species in the e coiitenii.oraneously in diireivnt explained by ,su])posin,i.' that tli« f ii-ea, but they would also 1 0( •cans separated by a lonu lunas conti- proved that they were not strictly eonte 'c equally well ex].lained if it eould nijioraneous. I'ow.x JJkds. ♦.So.. Dr C. A. Wliitu's .sl:,u.im.nr,„i U 'i^'oiNi i„ umi:. 1^, r.s.(f..ui.sm-v.,|,|,.j7-,,. COKHKLATION WITH KUIJOI'KAN KKl'OSiTS. 255 (ViKHiiiUiiiui. Of tliu 1(1 wiiucies li-iU'vil 'hy Sowcrl)}' as (•(.niiiij:; iVoiii lU:u'k(louii,iit least 2:], or ono-luilf of tliu ontiro luiinlior, arc represented ill the Slia.sta-C'hico fauna \>\ closely related species. Tiiese include such well niarkeiijrii Cdiiicd. }fj/lllii.'i I'lJcnliiJtiM. I Mi/tilii--i liacU(h)wn heds, if it had heen found in the western part of the United States, would he referred to the Sliasta formation and ahout to +lie horizon of the llorsetown Ixids. Whether the Chico heds al)ove the fossil-hearing Horsetown horizon rc{»resent all the rest of the upper Cretaceous remains to l>e deternnned. The close relationship of their fauna to that of the underlying lieds which has l)een compared with the (iault and t'enomanian, and its distinct- ness from the upper Cretaceous faunas enst of the Itocky mountains representing the Turonian and Senonian of ]Mn-oi)e seem to favor the view tliat a large part of the upper Cretaceous series is ahsent from tlie I'licifK' coast. CoNCI.l'SlONS. In view :)f all these facts, it seems to me that the exact rehdionslni> of the Chico and Tejon formatioiu. and the c.Ktent to which their faunas are connected must still l)e regarded as an dpen (|ucstion that can l)e solved only, if at all, after exhaustive collections have heen made from lK)th formations and thoroughly studied. 25(; T. VV. STANTON — SHASTA ANO CIKCO FAUNAS. 'Vhv, spccilic ('(Miclusions rouchcMl may tlius be suininarizud : There is no fkuiial break any where in the entire series of strata that have been referred to the Shasta and Chieo formations, (,'ertain i)ortions of the series are eliara(;t(!rized l)y the almndanee of particular species, e. g., Ancdld in tlie lower Ijeds and several species and jfenera of ammonites in the Horsetown division; but these sub-faunas are so bound together l)y connecting species that they caiuiot be regarded as really distinct, and I have therefore adojited Mr Diller's suggestion and called the wJiole the iShasta-Chico fauna. The age of this fauna, or at least of tin; i>ortion found in the Horsetown beds, seems to be not more recent than the Cenonianian. 'A !h '\ I IS le .■-,-^ '\M