^i^^\
<>
.. ^^%
^^.Vt>^^a
V]
<^
//y.
"el
*> ,>^
'^1/
>
(?
/
IMAGE EVALUATION
TEST TARGET (MT-3)
1.0 [fi
2.8
I.I
Mi 1^
Si: 1^
1.25
1.4
M
IIIIM
III 2.0
1.6
; :
€^. <^\ ^\
^■^T«."'^5>
%^\, 'v>
&?
^.
^
! ;
CIHM/ICMH
Microfiche
Series.
CIHM/ICMH
Collection de
microfiches.
Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions Institut canadien de microreproductions historiques
1980
Technical Notes / Notes techniques
The Institute has attempted to obtain the best
original copy available for filming. Physical
features of this copy which may alter any of the
images in the reproduction are checked below.
n
Coloured covers/
Couvertures de couleur
Coloured maps/
Cartes g^ographiques en
L'Institut a microfilmd le meilleur exemplaire
qu'il lui a 6t6 possible de se procurer. Certains
ddfauts susceptibles de nuire d la quality de la
reproduction sont notds ci-dessous.
ouleur
D
D
Coloured pages/
Pages de couleur
Coloured plates/
Planches en couleur
Th
po
of
filr
Th
coi
or
api
Th
filr
ins
Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/
Pages d^color^es, tachetdes ou piqu^es
Tight binding (may cause shadows or
distortion along interior margin)/
Reliure serrd (peut causer de I'ombre ou
de la distortion le long de la marge
intdrieure)
D
D
Show through/
Transparence
Pages damaged/
Pages endommagdes
M£
in (
upi
boi
fol
D
Additional comments/
Commentaires suppl^mentaires
Bibliographic Notes / Notes bibliographiques
Only edition available/
Seule Edition disponible
Bound with other material/
Relid avec d'autres documents
Cover title missing/
Le titre de couverture manque
Plates missing/
Des planches manquent
D
D
D
Pagination incorrect/
Erreurs de pagination
Pages missing/
Des pages manquent
Maps missing/
Des cartes g^ographiques manquent
D
Additional comments/
Commentaires suppldmentaires
The images appearing here are the best quality
possible considering the condition and legibility
of the original copy and in keeping with the
filming contract specifications.
The last recorded frame on each microfiche shall
contain the symbol —*> (meaning CONTINUED"),
or the symbol V (meaning "END"), whichever
applies.
Les images suivantes ont 6t6 reproduites avec le
plus grand soin, compte tenu de la condition et
de la nettetd de I'exemplaire filmd, et en
conformity avec les conditions du contrat de
filmage.
Un des symbotes suivants apparaitra sur la der-
nidre image dn cheque microfiche, selon le cas:
le symbole — ► signifie "A SUIVRE", le symbole
V signifie "FIN".
The original copy was borrowed from, and
filmed w
in-
terest must more or less have passed
away ; but it has this in favor, that it is
not a hackneyed subject, nor am 1 aware
that anyone has attempted a description of
the capture and destruction of the steamer
Caroline except Sir Francis Bond Head,
and then only cursorily, in his narrative of
events during his administration as Lieut-
enant Govarnor of Upper Canada. Nov.%
as the Caroline will live in history, it
seems a duty on my part to give a faithful
and authentic account of an event which
has been much exaggerated and misrepre-
sented.
When the report reached England it was
reported that a vessel had been sent over
tlie Falls of Niagara burning, and with 160
human beings on board. This remaining
uncontradicted, was believed for some
time, and I, of course, looked upon as a
monster in human shape ; whilst the truth
was, in my anxiety to ascertain there was
not a living soul on board before we
turned the vessel adrift, that 1 very near-
ly sacrificed my own life in endeavor-
ing to prove this, as will be seen here-
after.
1 shall, therefore, take upon myself to
draw up an account of the transaction in
its true colors, which, coming from me,
the principal actor in the drama, will carry
with it an air of authenticity which will
perhaps be its greatest value. I also em-
brace this opportunity of making public a
correspondence which I have carried on
with the heads of the department of her
majesty's government, for the very severe
pecaniary losses I sustained in being
obliged to abandon a country in which all
my wealth and all my hopea were contain-
ed. For, bad I remained in Canada up to
the present time, the value of my property
would have been m3re than double what
it was when I left in 1842.
I may be asked what object I have in
publishing this narrative at the present
time. This I scarcely know myself. There
may be two or three reasons. One is a
desire that a faithful and true record of so
remarkable an event as the sending the
Caroline over the Falls of Niagara may be
handed down to posterity in an authentic
ehap^. X ^a^not be acg an act of
9«»-Iy sixty
ho had 8uf-
5ountry too
from the
their lord-
g from the
& O/SMwmA.-
'hu8 ended
!• with an
•oyal navy
a, as they
raval Bio-
"ay story.
>mmander
^ing, dur-
had been
fche want
o chance,
© spring
Canada
make
home,
of June,
J6ided to
y of Ox.
nilton, a
emity of
ntage of
ids from
a fine
on com-
I had
id built
stabloM
got 200
which I
used to
'faction
n fact
ade up
lainder
will
Qortals
for fu.
honor
i from
imber-
untry,
as the
olony,
in my
e will
upted
i^^hen^
rebel-
gov-
ernment, I felt I could do no less than vol-
unteer to come forward and assist to put
down the rebellion, and accordingly, about
the middle of December, I s^ouldereJ a
musket and started oflf to join Col. Sir
Allan Macnab, who had the command
of the whole militia force is that part of
the colony, and was then on hie march
from Hamilton to Scotland, a district
where the rebels had musteie i in con-
sider.'ible force. I joined Sir Allan a few
miles from Hamilton, and we halted at
Braniford for night. At daybreak the
nexc morning we started for Scotland,
about twelve miles distance, with a vcy
respectable force of militia and volunteers;
but on our arrival there we found the re-
bels had left about halt an hour, having
been informed of Our approach, and scat-
terel themHolves in all directions, some
to the woods, some to their homen, and
the leaders, Dr. Duncombo and others, to
the United States. We ncoured the coun-
try for sixty or seventy miles around, but
baw no more of them, and a few days af-
ter brought ua news that the rebels had
made head again oi. the American side of
the River Niagara, under Mackenzie and
othore', and that they had actually taken
po98' HHion of Navy i^lann, a dependency of
her majesty, about half a mile from the
Canadian shore. 'I'hither we followed
them with the force under Sir Allan
Macnab considerably increased by volun-
teers on the march, and about Dec 20 we
arrived at Chippewa, a village a short dis
tance from the falls of Niagara The
rebels were fast collecting on the island,
and by the 5th were suppo.sed to muster
700 or 800 men. Our bu.-iineS8 was to
dislodge them from their position, and for
this purpose, amongst other preparations,
a body of men was told off to act as a
navy brigade, of which I, as the senior
navy officer, assumed the command. We
hired three lake schooners for the service,
putting a gnn on board each of them, and
were fitting them out to cany troops to
the island; but the principal part of the
landing was to be effected by boats and
craft belonging to the river navigation.
On Dec. 29, aboat four o'clock in the
afternoon, Sir Allan Macnab and myself
were standing together upon the look-out,
when, with the aid of a telescope, we ob-
served a steam- vessel standing across the
river, from Fort Schloseer to Navy island,
full of men and with one or two field pieces
on the deck. This was her first appear-
ance. Sir Allan said, "This won't do. I
say; Drew, do you think you can cut that
vessel out?" **0h, yet," I said, "nothing
easier, but it must be done at night."
"Well, then," said he, "go and do it."
These were literally all the orders I ever
received to take the Carmine; and although
I^had eaid hastily there is nothing easier,
yet m reality it was a service of such ex-
treme danger, that it may well be ques-
tioned whether anyone could be justified
in undertaking. In giving the order to
laku the Cuiullue, Sir Allan Macnab, of
course, considered it|was|my duty to judgeof
the practicability of the scheme as belong-
ging to my profession. It was not a busi-
ness to hesitate, or scarcely to think upon;
it had to be done, and the only question
was how to do it.
The current wa^ reported in the charts
to be running at the rate of seven miles an
hour at that part of the river where we
should have to cross, which was not half a
mile distant from the mighty Falls of Nia-
gara. We had nothing but a few small
boats about twelve feet long, each pulling
four oars, to trust to; we had to keep fear-
fully close to the rapid to prevent the
boats b'^ing seen from Navy Island, fiom
whence they would have given the alarm.
Numerous other difficulties might have
been started so as to make the attempt
appear impracti'.ible; but I determined
not to let one of them enter my head. I
had resolvec' to make the attempt, and
that nothing should stop me, well remem-
bering that most of the dashing things of
the late war were accomplished in this
way.
The first thing to be done was to call for
volunteers. "Here we are, sir," cried a
hundred voices; "what have we to do ?"
"Follow me" was all they could get out of
me, as Sir Allan and I had determined the
secret should be strictly between us, for,
hid our intentions been suffered to tran-
spire, one hour would have carried the
intelligence across the river to the Ameri-
cans, when we should have been opposed
by thousands, but so well was the secret
kept that the men knew not where they
were going nor what they had to do until
they were actually embarked in the boats
and had left the shore-
Amonst so many volunteers there was a
difficulty in making a selection; but this
they settled between themselves, it being
an indispensable condition that each should
be able to pull a good oar, which narrowed
the number to be selected from, and we had
no difficulty. The interval between four
\
o'clock, when the determination was come
to, and half- past seven at ni^ht, the time
proposed for startinjf, was taken up in
preparation Time dra^(;eel on todiouely.
It was necessary to give the men in the
steamer not. only timo to got to bed, but
to tleep; the moon, too, was nhining too
brif^htly for our purpose, and we had to
wau. to lot it go down for fear of di^cov
ery; the neglect of any uf these piecau-
tions would have marred our enterprise
The sroamer was secured under Fort
Schlofsor for the night. There was u
little dirt'erence of opinion hatwoon Sir
Allan McNab and myself as what we
ehould do with the vessel when we had
taken her; he wanted her brought over to
Chijp%WH, but I was altogether against it.
I opposed it simply upon the ground
that it she was in possesi-ion the Amer-
icans would never rest until nhe was given
up, but if burnt there was the end of her;
our purpose would be answered, and the
country ^aved from a great embarrassment.
At last half past eleven o'clock arrived,
and we started upon our perilous expedi-
tion. We received three cheers from the
assembled multitude on the shora, and off
we went. I had arranged with Sir Allan
Macnab that, as soon as h" saw a bright
light burning on the other side, he was to
make a blazing fire on the spon from
whence we ftarted,to serve a** a beacon to
gu.do us on our way back
We pulled a litt'e up along shore, and I
called the boats around me to tell t,lie men
the service they were going upon, and gave
the otiicers all the precautions I con.-idered
necessary —namely that th^y were not to
go too near Navy i.«land, for fear of being
seen; that they were to keep as clo-^e to me
as pos.«ible, and on no account to go abend
of me; that they were to endeavor to strike
the opposite shore some distance above
Fort Schlosser, where the steamer was
moored, and there wait for each o her. I
also said that if any of them disliked the
service they were going upon, which was
one full of danger, to .>eing
ablg to expend half an hour here unsoen
was a great event for u-t, to allow it to be-
come darker, as everythitig depended upon
our being able to search the vessel uiineen.
At last I judged it dark enough, and we
dropped silently down upon our prey liter
ally without moving an oar until we wore
close alongside hor. Tnese were anxious
moments for mer knowing how hazardous
it is to climb a vessel's s-ide and m ike good
a footing up >n the deck without being
knocked on the head. However, in
this, as in everything else, fortune
favored us. When within a boat's length
of the vessel, one of the watch (who had
apparently just awoke out of a sleep) cried
out, "Boat, ahoy! boat, ahoy! Give us the
countersign." I answered, in a low tone
of voice, "Silence, sileme! don't^ make a
noise, and I'll give you the countersign
when we get on board." I then mounted
the vessel's side, which I had some diffi-
culty In doing for want of a ladder, and
when fairly on deck I drew my sword, and
found three men lounging over the star-
board gangway unarmed, and quite un-
concerned. I said to them, "Now I want
this vessel and you had better go ashore at
once." She was lying alongside a wharf to
which she was secured. I waved my sword
over their heads to make them go, and I
do not think that until this moment they
fairly understood their position. They
then moved leisurely over to the port side,
I LhitiKing they were going on shore ; but
as they saw none of my party on deck but
myself they took up their hre arms, which
it nppoared. had been left on that side of
the deck, and the foremost man firod his
loaded musket at me. Not- more than a
yard from him, how the ball missod mo I
do not know; but he was too close to take
aim, and it pai-sed me. I thought this an
act of treachery, and that I need show him
no mercy, so with the full swing of my
arm 1 gave him a cut with mj sword over
the left temple, and he dropped at my
feet. In another second one of the men
put a pistol close to my face and pulled
the tritrger. ITortunately ir flashed in the
pan or I should not have been here to tell
the story Why I was so lenient with
this man I do not know, for he deserved
death by my hand as much as the other,
but I merely gave him a sabre cut on the
inside of the right arm, which made him
drop hir pistol, and he was unarmed.
The other man I disarmed and drove them
both over the side; but as they did not
seem to move as fast as I thought they
they ought, I gave them about an inch or
two of the [)Oint of my sword, which quick-
ened their pace wonderfully.
All this did not appear to have taken up
more than a minute of time, and we were
in complete possession of the after part of
the vessel Thre-J of the boats boarded
forward, where there was a good deal of
firing going on, and as the quarter deck
was clear I mounted the paddle box
and s?avt) orders for the firing to cease
immediately, fearing from the darkness of
the night we might take friends for foes;
and Lieut. MacCorraick had already received
a desperate wound
The vessel was now entirely in our
possession, and, to guard against an attack
from the shore, I directed Lieut. Elmsley
to head a small party as an advanced guard,
to warn us should any attack be meditated.
We then aroused everybody out of their
beds and sent them on shore, a consider-
able number of persons having been sleep-
ing on board. After this the vessel was set
on fire in four different places, and soon
began to burn. The next thing was to cast
her off from the jetty, which at one time I
feared we should have had great difficulty
in doing, as she was made fast with chains
6
under the water, or rather under ice— for
this was the middle of a Canadian winter,
where water freezes to the thickness of a
foot in a very short time; but a young
gentleman of the nariie of Sullivan, under-
standing the difficulty, seizod hold of an
axe, jumped down upon the ice, and in a
short time cleared the v.nain and set the
vessel adrift.
This done, and the vessel n flames fore
and aft, I ordered everyone to the boats,
which became the more neccFsary as the
enemy had opened a fire of musketry from
the shore, and some shot came disagreeably
near to me standing on the paddle-box.
The order was eoon obeyed, for it was ako
getting too hot to stand upon tl\e deck. I
did not giv3 any particular orc^ers to the
officer of my own baat; but I intended to
be the last person out of the vtpsel, and
naturally thought they would wfcit for me,
and, when jnst ready to embarl;, I saw a
man coming up the fore hatchway. I went
forward to ascertain whether it was likely
anyone else was down below; but '.he man
said it was not possible, for it was so hot
he could not have lived there .mother
minute. I then went to get into tha boat,
when to my horror I found that every boat
had leit the vessel. I cannot describe my
feelings at that moment, nor shall 1 ever
forget the sensation that came over me;
the vessel in flames and fast drifting down
the stream. I looked around and could
just see one boat in the di-tance; another
minute would have been fatal to mo. I
hailed her to come back, calling as loud
as I could that they had left me behind;
fortunj,tely ihev heard me, and returned
and took me and the man on board.
Having accomplished our object, we
had only to And our way safely back; and
when we rounded the point of the island
before named we saw a tremendous blazing
fire on the Canadinn shore, not only
enough to guide us, but almost to light
us on our way back. It was almost wel-
come, for by this time it had become quite
dark. Not caring about discovery now,
and as little for shot from Navy island, we
kept much closer to it, and felt safe in so
doing. We landed between two and three
o'clock in the morning at the spot f.om
whence we started, and found hosts of
j)eople to receive us with good hearty
British cheers. Sir Allan Macnab was
particularly cordial in his welcome, and
candidly acknowledged he never expected
to eee me again, tut that our success had
far exceeded his most sanguine expecta-
tions.
By this time the burning vessel was fast
approaching the Canadian shore, and not
far distant. Of all themarvels attending
this novel expedition, the course which the
steamer took of her own accord was the
most wonderful. When free from the
wharf s t Fort Schlosser, her natural course
would have been to follow the stream,
which would have taken her along the
American shore and over the American
falls ; but she acted as if she were aware
she had changed owners and navigated
herself right across the rikrer, clearing the
rapids above Goat island, and went as
fairly over the centre of the British falls of
Niagara as if she had been placed there on
purpose.
There were hundreds of people on the
banks of the river to witness the splendid
sight, for it was perfectly beautiful, and
the descent took place within a quarter of
an hour after our landing; &nd no human
ingenuity could have accomplished what
the vessel had so easily done for herself.
My first care after landing was to look
after the wounded and have them attended
to. The 'moat serious casualty was that of
Lieut. MacCormick, R. N., who was shot
through the wrist besides other wounds in
his body, from which, although he received
the best possible medical attendance, he
never recovered, and to my great regret,
died some days afterwards from the effects
of the wounds; there wero also some flesh
wounds amongst the young men, bub noth-
ing serious.
On tha ryart of the enemy wo were also
forturate, for certainly there were not
more than two killed, and four or five
wounded; less than this could hardly have
been expected.
I will hero mention a circumstance
which happened in the early part of the
encounter, and which might have brought
me to grief, had I not been on my guard.
In ray boat was a man named Zealand, a
ino specimen of an old British sailor, who
had served on the lakes under Sir James
Yeo in the late American war. The
Caroline had a raised cabin on the
quarterdeck; with a gangway on each
side between it and the bulwark and round
the stern; it was here, on the port-side,
that the arms were deposited. When I
had disposed of the three men, as before
related, I thought it prudent to go round
'jhis gangway to see whether there was
i.nybody lurking behind to take us in the
re
bd
■ XT^X-r^ '!■, -..W.WJH ' , I A-,
1© expecta.
N was fast
^> and not
attending
'Which the
' was the
from the
|ura; course
76 stream,
^long the
•American
ere aware
[navigated
■^""ng the
, went as
ph falls of
there on
e on the
splendid
iful. and
uarter of
o human
>ed what
herself.
to look
fctended
(hat of
ivas shot
3unds in
received
mce, he
regret,
> effects
ne flesh
It noth-
fe also
re not
)r five
y have
'tance
f the
3Ught
uard.
nd, a
who
ames
The
the
each
>iind
lide,
n I
fore
und
w&a
the
rear; and when returning along the star-
board-side I met a man rushing along,
sword in hand, who made a slashing cut
at my head without the least ceremony.
The night was dark, so that ^ little mis-
take of this kind was pardonable, and
fortunately I suspected it was one
of my own men; I parried the
blow and very successfully pinned
his cutlaps with mine against the
cabin bulk-head, eo that he could not move
it. This gave me time to look in his face,
and I at once made out who it was. "Hol-
loa, Zealand !" said I, "what are vou
about ?" "Oh ! I beg your pardon, sir; I
didn't know it was you." It was, however,
a fortunate discovery, and we parted good
friends.
Having out off the supplies of the rebels
by the destruction of the steamboat, our
nexD business was to drive them ofiF the
island; and to this we turned our whole
attention. We had a large militia force at
Chippewa and the neighborhood at this
time, all eager to do something. I have
before mentioned we had three schooners,
which, together with the boats and barges
we had, were capable of embarking a large
number of men; but we judged that about
500 men would be sufficient to take the
island, and accordingly that number was
told off for the service. I never saw a finer
spirit exhibited in any body of men in my
lifd, though they were only settlers in the
backwoods, who had left their farms to
put down the rebellion. The officers, tco,
were very fine fellows, and were ready to
lead theii men in any attack. I am sorry I
cannot mention their names, but in the
lapse of time I have forgott"in them.
Whilst the preparations were going on,
and the day before our intended landing,
which it was understood would be princi-
pally in boats, I heard a man say to his
comrades : "But what shall we do if a
shot strikes our boat ? We muse either
be drowned or go over the falls." This led
me to do what I have ever considered a
very foolish thing. I got a four-onred gig
and pulled up the stream round the head
of the island, within pistol-shot, with the
avowed intention of selecting a proper
place to land, but really to place the boat
under fire of the enemy's field- pieces, to
provo how difficult it was to hit a boat
moving fast through the wvter. I clearly
saw the spot to land, and immediatf (v
put the boat's head around to return,
when they began a fire of musketry, and
shortly afterwards with field pieces. The
firing was not good at first, but improved,
and the shot came nearer every time, then
ceased for two or three minutes, when I
thought we were all safe; but presently
another shot came whizzing past, admir-
ably aimed, making ducks and drakes in
the water, and just cleared the gunwale of
the boat, passing between me and strokes
man. The firing of this shot was evident-
ly by a more experienced hand, and 1
learnt afterwards it was from an amateur
a young American from West Point, a
miscreant who had not even the excuse ot
having joined the rebels, but for mere
amusement was trying to sink a boat and
possibly to sacrifice the lives of the crew.
Had I been able to get hold of his name 1
would have handed it down to posterity as
that of a sanguinary ruffian. They had not
another chance of tiring, so we got safe into
(Jhippawa creek, and I hoped my purpose
was answered.
Our plans for the morrow, when we in-
tended to make our landing, were widely
known. Nor could it be otherwise , but it
was not of so much consequence as the se
cret of the Caroline, because, the rebels
being in large numbers on tlie island, we
naturally thought that they would have
had the courage to have waited to receive
us ; whereas some of their friends told
them what was going forward, and they de-
camped in the night, landing upon Grand
island, and from thence made their way to
the American side ; thereby saving us a
greatdeal of trouble and possibly a great
many valuable lives ; so that when we
landed there was not a soul to be eetn.
Here our work was finished, and there was
an end uf the rebellion for the present.
Shortly alter this the militia and volun-
teers returned to their homes, a regiment
of the line taking the duty upon the Iron
tiei, whilst I was left to arrange about the
schooners and boats, and to wind up the
affairs of the nav^l brigade, who were ad
mitted by all hands to have done their
duty.
The Americans were astounded at what
had taken place, and did not imagine there
was energy enough in the colony co have
conceived such things as the taking of
their steamer and driving the rebels Irom
Navy iiland, but thought they had noth-
ing to do but pour into Canada as they
had previously done into Texas, and annex
it; but they found their mistake, and be-
gan to look at home.
They held large meetings at Buffalo, a
frontier town ao the head ot River Niagara,
1"^
8
to discuss the outrage of the Caroline, and
a report was spread that Capt. Drew was
to land with 1,000 men by night and burn
the town. They organized a large body of
men as a volunteer force to protect the
city, and turned out a guard of 500 men
every night to be ready to receive me; they
offered a reward of $500 to anyone who
would assassinate me. This was done by
public advertisement in one of their papers.
They »lso did me the very great honor
to hang me in effigy, and pa'd me
the same compliment annually on Decem-
ber 20th, for several years after-
wards. This was a mighty sum for any
rascal to obtain upon such easy terms, and
the &vst atbempb to assassinate me was
made a few days afterwards 1 was stay-
ing in the village of Chippawa, at the
house of gentlem*n named Cummins,
when in the middle of a certain day, the
maid servant came to her mistress to ask
leave to go home. Mrs. Cummins 8%id, "I
can't let you go, for Capt. Drew is staying
with us and you will be wanted." The
girl then said, "Well, minoress, if you
won't give me leave, I'll take it, for I am
not going to stay here to be murdered."
And go she did, withoat giving any fur-
ther reason, except that the house was
going to be attacked that night. Mr.
Cummins and I talked it over, and coul '
not make out what it meant, and after
dinner we went into the village to
learn if there were any reports about, bub
could hear of nothing, so we agreed to
take no notice of wh;it the girl had said;
and about seven o'clock 1 went to bed:
but not 60 Mr. Cummins, for he sat up. I
felt the more secure, as there were two
companies of troops close at hand, and
within hail of the hou?e. However, about
midnight a considerable body of armed
men surrounded the house, and walked on
the veranda, the floor of which being old
and rickety, made a considerable noise,
the dogs began to bark, and Mr. Cummins
called to me to get up, as the house was
attacked; after which he called out of the
window, "Turn out the guard, turn out
the gu-ird!" I got up, and before I began
to dress I saw a man climbing up
one of the posts of the veranda
opposite the window which opened into
my room. I seized hold of my sword,
which the ruffian saw, and down he drop-
ped, the 'sight of it was enough for him,
and I never slept without baring it in my
room. The guards were soon upon the
alert, and formed; they were heard by the
scoundrels, who got frightened and re-
treated. This visit was meant for me,
and showed how good their information
was to know the room in which I was
sleeping. This band of ruffians, about
fifty in number, had landed in boats from
the American shore just above Navy is-
land, and, being foiled in their attempt
upon my life, determined they would have
blood, and on their return to their boats
stopped at the house of a gentleman by
the name of Usher, a captain of militia,
who had distinguished himself on the
frontier. They knocked at his door, and,
unsuspicious, he went himself to open it,
when without a word they shot him dead.
I remained upon duty on the frontier for
about six or eight weeks after this, not
feeling very comfortable; for though I had
many friends around the neighborhood,
people did not like to take me into their
houses, particularly to sleep, fearing an-
other attack would be made upon me.
Therefore, having nothing to detain me, I
wound up the affairs of the naval bri-
gade and returned to my family ab Wood-
stock.
Here I was not suffered to enjoy mysalf
for more than a few months, for in the lat-
ter end of the year 1838 the rebels were
organizing another outbreak, which came
to open violence in Lower Canada, but was
soon put down by Gen. Sir John Colborne.
In the upper province they were more
war\ and took more time to perfect their
schemes; they were known to be busy in
the United States, meaning to make the
winter the .season for their operations.
Capt Sandom, the naval officer in com-
mand on the lakes, commissioned two or
three sailing schooners for service on Lake
Erie, and the Canadian government chart-
ered two fine steamars from the Americans,
to be fitted out as men-of- *^ar, and I was
appointed by the admiralty to assume the
command upon that lake.
The steamers were brought to the Grand
river, situated at the lower extremity of
the lake, to be equipped and manned ; the
crew consisting of lake seamen and about
200 militiamen, there being no man of-
war's men available for the service, nor
could I prevail upon the lieutenant-gov-
ernor to let me have any regular troops to
serve as marines. Having completed
our e(iuipment, we started about the lat-
ter end of November for Amherstburg, the
western part of the province, which I
intended to make my headquarters during
the winter, but we had nat s.oauieu more
than about thirty or forty miles before
we were stopped by the ice, the lake having
frozen during the previous night. We tried
to steam through, it, but found the ice
impenetrable, and therefore had no
alternative but to return to the Grand
river, where we remained nntil the spring.
During the winter the rebels made a
landing at Windsor, crossing the river from
Detroi '), and were very ably dealt with by
Col. Prince, a militia officer and magistrate
in that part of the country, who proved
himself a most suitable substitute for me,
and did the work much better than I could
have ione it, for he put an end to the
whole aflfair in a few hours. Things were
going on quietly with us at the Grand
river, when an incident occurred to en-
liven the scene by the arrival of a scound-
rel from BuflFalo on a pretended mission to
me. He was a most daring and impudent
fellow. He crossed over from the Ameri-
can side to Niagara, and made his way to
Col. Estcourt, then commanding on the
frontier, and asked him where I was to be
found, as he had something of great im-
porta.jce to communicate to me relative to
an intended landing of the rebels in Can-
ada. The colonel at once told him where
I was and wrote a note to me, of which he
made the man the bearer; and thinking
communication was
importance, begged
him know of it
to be so. The man
made his way to the Grand river, where I
was then, put his horse up at a small
tavern, came on board the sleamer and
asked to see me. The first lieucenant
brought him into the cabin, when he said
he had something most important to com-
municate to me. I begged the lieutenant
to wait, but the man intimated chat what
he had tu say must not be in the hearing
o fa third person. I replied that there could
be no secrets between me and my first
lieu tenant and that I had rather he were
present. The man then said, if I had no
cotiftdence in him there was an end of the
ma tter, and he would go- I thought it
very odd, and rather unwillingly I request-
ed the lieutenant to leave the
cabin. The man then presented
the letter from Col. Estcourt,
which lulled my suspicion and I
asked him to relate what he had to say.
He began talking a parcel of nonsense
about the rebellion and what had passed,
but no thing about what was to come. I
bore with him for some time, when he
the expected
something of
I would let
should it prove
said, "I am quite sure we are overheard
here, and I propose we should go on shore
and walk down the river, where we shall
be out of hearing of everybody, and then
Ml tell you what I have to say." I accord-
ingly landed, and with the man walked
along the bank of the river towards the
lake; but still notliing revealed. We had
got nearly to the rive's mouth and at
least a quarter of a mile from the steamer
when I curned to go back. Had we con-
tinued on we munt have made a sharp
turn to the right along the lake-shore,
where a dense wood would most eflfectually
have shut us out from the sight of the
steamer. So the fellow said, "Oh, sir, I
thought we were going to walk on where
we could not be interrupted." "No," I
said, "we will return: if you have any-
thing to say you have had plenty of time
to have done so, and I expect it's all hca-
bug." "Oh, sir, if that's it, I see you have
no confidence in me, and we'll part." I
was glad to find we were getting pretty
close to the vessel, for my suspicions we'-e
excited, and I thought I had had a lucky
escape, but in reality the man had com-
mitted no act for which I could detain him,
whatever I luay have thought of his inten-
tions. I therefore returned on board the
steamer and he to the tavern for his horse.
Some of the officers had their sus-
piciouvs of this man from the beginning,
and went to the tavern to have a look at
him, when, as he was mounting his horse,
with one foot in the stirrup, they saw the
handle of a great horse pistol protruding
from his siHe-coat pocket Off he gallop
ed, and, entering a wood, was soon out of
sight. The officers wanted me to send
after him and have him brought back, but
this 1 declined, a» we could prove nothing
against him. It was, however, well known
afterwards that he was the leader of the
gang that attacked ivlr. Cummin's house at
Chippawa, and murdered Capt. Usher.
Here was a very narrow escape; and had
1 oily continued along the lake shore in
stead of turning back, the pistol or the
bowie knife would have done its work, and
earned for the ruffian |500 This was my
second escape from assassinatiDn, and most
thankful was I for it; but thare is another
yet to come.
In the spring of the year 1839 it was
well known that there was to be another
landing of rebels in Upper Canada, and
upon a larger scale than hitherto; it was
therefore necessary to be preparing
accordingly. Lieut. -Gov. Sir George Ar-
10
thur Buinmoned me down to Toronto to
have a conference with him; I therefore
waited upon his excellency at the gov
arnment iiouae, and was ushered into a
room, where I found Sir George and
Col. Booth, commanding the Forty-
third regiment, then stationed at Nia
gara. The governor, aftor a little prelim-
ary conversation, said, "I b^ve desired to
see you two gentlemen to ask you to under-
take, jomtly, a piece of service of the utmost
consequence to the country. I need not
toll you that I am perfectly tired of the
frequent landing of tho Americans in Upper
Canada, and I have come to the determin-
ation, should another landing take place,
to retaliate and take possession of Fort
Niagara, which I think can easily be
accomplished, as there are but few troops
there at present." But sir," I said,
"had you not better communicate with
Capt. Sandom ? He commands the naval
force on the lakes, and I am only his
second." "No," said the governor ; "I
know you, bijt I do not know Capr. San-
dom ;tif you will not undertake it, I shall
give it up." I immediatoly said, "That
shall not be, sir ; 1 will do anything you
desire, and stand the consequences." Then
he 8 »id, "I have already told you what is
required tc be done, and leave you to carry
out the details. I must tell you that what
is intended is only known to my exclusive
council, and had therefore better be kept
strictly secret. You shall have my auth-
ority to go to any expense in preparation
that may be necessary, and I will inform
you at the earliest moment when you will
be required to aci>, which will be the
moment the Americans effect another land
ing in any part of Upper Canada, and the
sooner the preparations are completed the
bettor. I will not detain you further, but
leave you to settle your own plans, hav-
ing perfect confidence in you both, and
feeling sure that the work will be well
done."
It was quito a pleasure to have to co-
operate with such an officer as Col. Boo*^h;
and our plans were soon arranged. He
desired to have the whole regiment trans-
ported across the river at one time, if pos-
sible, and landed within 200 yards of Fort
Niagara. This fort is situated on the left
bank of the River Niagara, at the entrance
from Lake Ontario, and commands the
river. I immediatoly made arrangements
with the Niagara dock company, a building
establishment in the neighborhood, to
build two roomy flat bottomed boats, with
shovel noses, capable of carrying each 150
men with their arma and accountrements.
This they were not long in doing, and all
was soon ready, only waiting for the word
of command, the intontion being to land
one- half the regiment at first, and the other
half would follow in a quarter of an hour.
Had the order to land been given, the work
would have been well done; for never in
mj life did I see a finer body of men than
the Forty -third were at that time. But the
expectod did not take place; the rebels
altered their minds, and our services were
not requires.
After this I returned to Lake Erie, and
in the month of x\ugust was superseded
from my command, the rebellion, in fact,
having ended here Thus terminated my
public services in the colony, and I rejoin-
ed my family at Woodstock.
Here I hoped to find rest and enjoyment,
and that I should have been allowed to re-
main at my happy home in the backwoods
for the remainder of my life; but the hand
of the assassins followed me even here. I
had only been a few months home when a
good honest English yeoman, living on the
backwoods about ten miles off, rode in from
his farm and asked to see me. He said,
"Capt. Drew, I have come in to warn you
of your danger, and to beg you will nou
leave your house for two or three weeks to
come, as two of my neighbors have lefc
their house this morning, and have taken
an oath they will not return until they have
shot you." "Oh," I said, "tell me who
they are and I will get up a party and go
and meet them." "Oh, sir," he said, "that
won't do; it might save your life, buti it
would cost me mine' I cannot tell you
their names, but you know you can believe
me; so pray take warning, and do not go
out until these men have returned, of
which I will give you the earliest notice." I
felt that if I was to be under the constant
apprehension of being murdered, existence
was not worth having; and I went on
much in my usual way —not, however,
remaining in the woods alone, as was my
habit when the men went into dinner, but
returning with them as they left work.
This went on for some days, and nothing
happened to cause alarm, and I was begin-
ning to disregard the warnin;; that had
been given m^; but when ten days had
elapsed I allowed the men to go into din-
ner and I remained out in the woods alone.
In a short time I heard the report of a rifle,
and at the sam? Ime a ball struck the
stump of a tree not half a yard from where
. ^
11
I was Btanding. I made a tremendou8
halloaing, which must have frightened the
Bcoundrel, who, perhape, thought I was
shouting to someone in night, as he did
not fire again, and I got safely into the
house. Twii days afterwards my friend
came in from the woods to tell me his
neighbors had returned -not, however,
knowing what had happened; but as nu
proof could be brought, I took no notice of
the matter.
This was the third attempt on my life
from which I felt that nothing but the in-
ter position of Providence had saved me,
and having a wife and a large family of
small children, I felt I ought not to disre-
gard the last warning, so I at once made
up my mind to leave the country. At this
time, in consequence of the late rebellion,
property in Canada was scarcely saleable
at any price. I therefore so d mine for what
it would fetch. I return d to England in
the spring of the year 1842, and have been
a poor man ever since.
It not only remains for me to mention
the rewaids and honors which were be-
stowed upon me for the destruction of
the Caroline; they were highly compli-
mentary, but nothing substantial. I re-
ceived the thanks of the two houses of the
provincial parliament, and a sword of one
hundred guineas value was voted to me by
the house of assembly. I was made com-
modore dl the provincial marine of Upper
Canada, an office especially created for me
by an act of the legislature: but it tvas
merely honorary, and with no emolument
attached to it. A petition from the gov-
ernor in council was forwarded to her
majesty, praying that her majesty would
be pleased to ronfer upon me some special
mark of her royal favor for my services
to the province of Upper Canada. The
only pecuniary emolument 1 have ever re-
ceived from the colony was the pay of a
major of militia for three or four months
during the operations on the frontier in
common with the rest of the navy officers
employed, who each received pay accord-
ing to their relative rank, but which did
not meet the expenses they were put to for
lodging and subi-istence at the taverns
where they put up. Our object was not
a money rewat d, and all were fully com-
pensated by the inward satisfaction of
having served their country in a moment
of danger. It was admitted that the
emigrants of the previous seven years (of
which these officers as well as myself form-
ed a part) had saved the col ny in the late
crisis. The only substantial reward I ever
got was the promotion from commander
to captain in the year 1843. when 1 had
been nineteen ye&n a commander, and five
years and a half after the events which
have here been related.
[
^\
i
If
..The Cutting Out of the Caroline..
And Other Reminiscences of i837-'38.
TO THE READER"
Having received several requests for
r-opies of my narrative of "The Cutting out
of tliG Caroline, " witli which I could not
comply; and having through the kindness of
my friend, Mr. (ieorge H. Mills, of Hamil-
ton, President of the \Yi«(ntworth Historical
Society, procured from the Hamilton Spec-
tator, Admiral Drew's account of it. I have
been induced to re])ublisii my own, because
I could accompany it with so full and reli-
able a statement from the highest authority.
That it was a most perilous enterprise,
from whatsoever standj)oint looked at, is
made clear from the Admiral's words, and
in norespcct wasit moieso, thanas an inter-
national one.
The Jamieson raid in South Africa revives
the memory of this bold assault upon tht-
territory of a friendly state; and my friend,
ex-Governor Robinson, in writing recently
for copy of my paper, — which I could not
send him, says : "It was greatly worse than
Dr. Jamieson's raid, and all of you should
have been sent (as he seems to have been),
to lOngland to be tried for making war on a
friendly nation."
This, in all probability would have follow-
ed, but that the Kritish (iovernment at once
assumed the responsibility of the act, and
among other important results saved Alex-
ander McLeod, the Deputy-SheriflF of the
Niagara district, from being hanged as an
alleged participator in the affair.
Finding that my humble contribution may
safely re-appear under the aegis of the Ad-
miral's flag, I make no further excuse for its
republication, justasitappeared eleven years
ago.
R. S. WOODS.
Sius, It seems to be the thing, just now.
to recall the leading events of the country
by way of "Personal Recollections." The
report of ex-Mayor Harmon, of Detroit, on
tlie battle of VVindaor, and the interesting
account in your paper of the great naval
duel between the Alabama and the Kear-
sage, in which one of our Chatham lioys,
William (Jouin, was a hero, and the still
later very interesting account by James
Dougall, Esq., of the battle of Wind.sor,
have led me to rec 11 some of my recollec-
tions of a memorable event that took place
during the reliellion of 1S.S7, and I venture
to make my contril)ution to that eventful
period by giving you the ))articulars of the
Caroline expedition and some other incidents
of the time. I was not on the western fron-
tier at all during the troubles, and can,
therefore, say nothing about them up here.
Besides, your recent article on the necessity
for a more com])rehensive Extradition
treaty l)etween the States and Canada re-
minds me that the destruction of the Caro-
line was the occasion of that treaty ; and
the en(juiry just made in the Dominion Par-
liament as to the intention of the Govern-
ment to recognize in some way the services
of the men who were engaged in putting
down the rebellion of 'o7, suggests this as
an appropriate time for one's statements.
THE CUTTIN(J OUT. '
This steamer was "cut out" on the night
of the 29th of December, 1837, at Schlosser,
on the Niagara River, in the State of New
York. She had been built for salt water
sailing, was copper-bottomed, and "a de-
cent little craft," as her owner described
her, and had been brought thro' the rivers
and the Welland Canal to Buffalo, whence
she set out in December, 1837, to do the
piratical M'ork of William Lyon McKenzie
and the patriots and rebels with him on
Navy Island.
The cause, character and consequences of
that ex])edition are scarcely known to those
of the present day — sucli histories as I have
seen making scant reference to it.
Most of the actors in the enterprise,
(Quorum pars tui,
have, I fear, passed away, or left Canada ;
but I am led to think that my recollections
of that event will not be without interest to
many of your i laders, even at tliis late day.
The primary object was to prevent the
rebels, patriots,and American sympathizers,
brigands or pirates, as they were called,
from receiving further aid from the States.
The second was to show the American (gov-
ernment that, if it could not control its own
people, and keep them from coming into our
territory with arms, we would do it for
them.
It was a work of great danger, owing to
the very rapid current of the Niagara river,
our ignorance of the force on the steamer,
and the darkness of the night, Sch'.oaser be-
ing only two miles above the Falls. I re-
member it being said that the breaking of an
oar that night would be the loss of the boat
and her crew.
THE OOUP DB MAIN.
If not a coup d' etat, it was a coup do
main that led to serious consequences, and
gave rise to some important questions. The
rebel camp on Navy Island was soon broken
up ; a fierce state of feeling throughout t^e
States, from Maine to Louisiana, aroused.
The two governments of Great Britain anil
the United States were brought face to face
on the question of international rip' t,8 and
obligations. Then came various .cts of
public violence by American subjecis, such
as the attempts at invasion at Maiden,
Windsor and Prescott, blowing up Brock's
monument, the cutting out and burning of
steamer Sir Robert Peel ; the shooting of
Usher, and the threats to shoot Sir Allan
McNab, and every ont engaged in the
work ; the trial of McLeod for murder, at
Utica, in 1841 ; the Act of Congress of the
10th of March, 18S8. "for the precise
■•purpose of more effectually restrainirjg
"military enterprises from the United States
"into the British Provinces, by authorizing
"the use of more sure and decisive preven-
"tive means ; " and the further Act of Con-
gress aflfecting the rights of the Federal and
State Courts, and declaring that, if such
cases should arise thereafter, they should
immediately be transferred to the Courts of
the United States, and tho' last, not least,
to the Extradition Treaty, in 1842, between
Great Britain and the United States.
The world of that day had not received
the fiery baptism in International Law,
State rights and Foreign Enlistment Acts,
that it has since got through the great civil
war of our neighbors, with its scintillations
in the way of the Alabama, St. Albans, eto. ;
but the correspondencpi between Mr. Web-
ster, the Secretary of State in the Cabinet
of President Harrision, and Mr. Fox, the
British Minister at Washington, shows a
very critical state in the diplomatic rela-
tions of the two countries ; and there is no
floubt that if McLeod had not been released
war would have been the immediate result,
and the ports of New York and Boston and
other harbors would have been made famil-
iar witii cutting out operations. Indeed, it
was on the floor of the Senate of the United
States charged against Mr. Webster, that,
as Secretary of State, in writing to the
(governor of the State of New York, on the
subject of McLeod's trial, he had supported
his arguments by saying if McLeod was not
released the city of New Y'ork would be laid
in ashes.
I hardly need tell your readers that a
cutting out process like this is a naval one,
conducted with great secrecy, consisting of
one or more boats, with mufHed oars, men
armed with cutla- ses, pistols and boarding
pikes, attacking, under cover of night, a
hostile ship lying in port, and effecting her
capture or destruction. This torpedo age
will somewhat change the character of these
visits, but while making them more de-
structive, will rob them of much of their
old prestige, where personal courage and
cool determination were the (jualities most
required in the attacking party
Our party consisted of seven boat?, with
nine men each, the boat being the ordinary
"yawl" of the schooners and steamers then
in port. I cannot do better than give the
words of Sir Allan in his evidence in
McLeod's trial : "A body of ntilitia was
assembled at Chippewa, in the month of
December, 1837, and January 1838, to the
number of between 2,000 and 3,000, to re-
pel an expected invasion from rebels and
American brigands assembled on Navy Is-
land, and on the American Shore, near
Schlosser. They were ordered out by the
Lieut. -Governor, Sir F. B. Head. I as-
sumed command of the forces there by his
directions. I remember the last time when
the aroline came down previous to her de-
struction. From information I had receiv-
ed I had every reason to believe she came
for the express purpose of assisting the re-
bels on Navy Island with men, arms, am-
munition, provisions, stores, etc. To as-
certain that fact I sent officers with in-
structions to watch the movements of the
boat and report the same to me. These
gentlemen told me they saw her land a
3
\
cannon, several men armed and eijuipped
as soldiers, and that she had droppud her
anchor under the east side of Navy Island.
Upon the inforniatinn I had previously re-
ceived from highly respectalile sources in
Buttalo, together with the report of these
gentlemen, I detei mined to destroy her
that night. 1 entrusted the command of
the expedition for the, purpose to Captain
A. Drew, R N. I ordered the expedition,
and first communicated it to Capt. Drew on
the beach when the men eml)arked. A
short time previous to the embarkation
Capt. Drew was ordered to take and de-
stroy the Caroline wherever he could find
her. Seven boats were ecjuipped and left
the shore but I do not know the number
of men in each boat. '1 he last five words
of that order, "whenever he could find her,"
nearly fired the continent as well as the
Caroline.
As indicated by Sir Allan's testimony
there was great secrecy in the movement,
and it was supposed the steamer would be
found al Navy Island instead of the Ameri-
can shore. I belonged to a company of vol-
unteers which was organized in King street,
Hamilton, on our way down, and christened
by Sir Allan with his usual love ot a joke,
"The Elegant Extracts," as it was composed
of young gentlen n, chiefly from London,
Woodstock, Hamilton and other places
some 35 strong.
CALL FOB VOLUNTEERS.
Upon our company that night a call was
made for as many volunteers as would go in
for some work. The invitation was very
generally accepted. We were furnished with
a cutlass and pistol. I remember saying to
the otficer who gave me the latter, "Had
you not better give me another V" to which
he replied, "when you have used that you'll
find you don't want another." The pistol
was a single barrel and flint lock.
By nine o'clock we were at the beach,
having no idea of our destination.
An incident occurred here that I may be
pardoned for mentioning. Hearing that my
friend John Askin, of London, the eldest
son of the late Col. Askin, and brother of
our late friend. Dr. Askin of this place, and
one of our company had corne down to the
beach after the boats had got their comple-
ments, I foolishly said 1 would give him
my seat and get one in another boat, having
no idea of the strict rules of the service at a
time like this. After trying to get into an-
other boat without success, I went to Col.
McNab and Capt. Drew, who were stand-
ing under the trees on Chippewa Creek
and explained my position. Sir Allan's
answer was thoroughly characteristic of
him, for at fifteen years of age he was an en-
sign and engaged in the defence of the fort
at York, when it was blown up in 1813 :
"Why, you d d young scamp, if you
want to be shot, give my compliments to
Capt. Beer, and tell him to take you in. "
This was more easily said than done, how-
ever, but by the aid of my friends I got in-
to the boat quietly and lay on a pde of wet
sand with my knees to my chin until we
reached the final point of tfeparture, a mile
or so up the river where the last orders were
to be given to the officers in command. In
due time wc i cached our rendezvous, but
two of the boats failed to put in an appear-
ance, although we waited for them some
time near a warehouse, not far from the
steamer Only five boats were present, or
some 45 men in all. These were command-
ed by Captains Drew, II. N , Harris, R. N.,
(the father of Messrs. Edward and (ieorge
B. Harris, of London), Beer, R, N., McCor-
mick, R. N. , and Zeaand. I can only re-
call a few names of those present Hamil-
ton, O'Reilly, Frederick (cleverly, John A.
Eraser, A. W. Schweigner, John (iordon,
and W. S. Light. My old friend, Capt. J.
W. Taylor, of the Lake Shore, Raleigh, says
he was one of the number, and the captain,
as one of the most expert and daringseamen,
would find himself at home in this night's
work
America's pretence.
The Americans always claimed that the
steamer was not hostilely engaged and not
)re[)ared for a visit such as ours. So far
rom this being the case, as we approached
ler bow we were challenged by a sentry de-
manding : '*Who goes theie?" and on our
keeping quiet, he repeated the question, say-
ing : "Answer or I'll fire, " and he soon did
fire into us. In support of this I give an ex-
tract from the evidence of Oilman Appleby
of the steamer, at McLeod's trial : " There
were 33 men on board, 10 of whom com-
posed the crew, none of whom were armed ;
the first shot was from the river side near
the bow of the boat ; heard like two guns,
but could not be positive, the next report
was that of a gun fired on board the boat. "
Then one Stewart says, "When we first saw
the boats they were nearly abreast the bow
of the steamer, and out in the stream. I
told Capt. Kennedy that he had better call
them (the people on board), up from the
lower cabin. The boats were headed towards
the steamer. Capt. Kennedy called them
from below. A few minutes before a man
4
]>y tliu naiiiu of Nidiola came un hoard uiid
remained on deck ; he hailed then", asking
wlio comes there, or something like it, that
the answer was 'friends.' 'J'hey appeared
then to spring on tlieir oars ; tlu; houls were
four or Hve rods off. This witne-s proves
the cluilhmge, hut suppresses the fact of
Nichols tiring.
The crews of our hoats hoarded
fore and aft, and on hoth sides. Captain
Stephen Mc("ormick, K. N., was hadly
wounded, and 1 supjmrted him for some
time hefore his removal from the steamer.
He was given a pension of £100 a year for
this. Strange to say, when the trial was
made to set the boat on fire nothing would
burn, and for some little time the material
taken by Capt. Drew for the purpose known
as a "carcass," vvas forgotten, but on being
brought forward it soon did its work.
The story of any person being on the
steamer when she went over the Falls was
not believed by any of us. Even Durfee
was not killed on the boat, but on the land,
and the evidence of the prosecution showed
that the shot was from the land side. I
saw no one on her when we left, and the
evidence given on McLeod's trial shows that
Capt. Drew and his men were anxious to let
the men get ashore and sinij)!}' capture the
boat, which was tied to the Jock. One lwc(!n Kuropean nations, altliougli
HiBcu a«l«|)te(l hy many of tliuin, and Mr.
Wtibater saya of it, " 1 undcrtftke to huv
that tii« article for the extradition of of-
feaderv has l>een of more vahie to tliiu coun-
try, and it i« of more valiic to tlie progreas
of uiTiiix tion, the caHse of liuinanity, and
the gn»d underatanding between nations
than can he readily computed," I ouglit to
May, while thia trial settled the important
international dirticultiea, it also aetthsd the
inout momentuoua quescion of vvliat (^onnt i-
tutes the genua "dead-head,"' ao well known
at the present day. One of tiie witnesaea,
wh* had been on the Caroline that day,
descrihea himself as a dead head, and e\-
Elaiaa to the Court tiuit he did not ])ay fare,
ut turned in and gave a lift as occasion
reuuired.
The expansion of the criminal code since
1842 shewa the necessity of having the
basis of the Extradition 'IVeaty extended
80 as to protect both the United Slates and
Canada from the villaina who escape from
either side and find asylums here and there.
'Bke treaty originally provided for tlie sur-
reiider of seven olasses of ofTtmdera, viz.,
persona ckarged with murder, or assault
wi til intent to comndt muider, piracy, ai -
Bon, robbery, forgery, or the utterance of
forged paper. No change has aiu ;e l)een
naade in the critr.ps for whicli extradition
caa be had under it ; but this should no
longer be delayed, and I am glad to see
that the disposition of both (Jovernments is
greatly to extend the liyt of offences, and
the mode of procedure, as has been done by
statute in England aud Canada.
The United States authorities, as re-
marked by Cliief Justice Hagarty not long
ago, have always surrendered offenders
promptly and without legal quibbling, and
la this we should follow their good example,
and prevent our border towns from becom-
iag harbors of refuge tor the criminals of
either couatry. But ought we to stop with
an expanded extradition treaty' ? Do the
tinaee not demand something more ? VVhy
sh«nld not the Governments of the day,
American, European and Asiatic form one
great international confraternity, with a
view to the suppression and surrender, not
of the ordinary oriminals only, but the ex-
tj"aordiuary ones as well, found in the ranks
of the dynamiters. Socialists, Anarchists,
Nihilists, etc. ?
The Edmunds' Bill, as introduced into the
Senate of the United States within an hour
after the report had reached Washington of
the dynamite attempts upon the British
Houae of Commons and the Tower of Lon-
don, is the key note to the legialation, and
all honor is due to that gentleman for the
bold and noble step thus taken liy him.
And it is encouraging to sec; that Senator
Hayard who ao prominently idcntititMl him-
aelf with tiiia measure in the Senate, iiaa
been niade Secretary of State in ['resident
Chiveland's cabinet. Wiiy should the
United States the refuge of all tlie people
of the world - who.-e portaU are thrown
open to oppressed humanity rnal machines and exi)loaives that the
Koaaas and Mosts choose to hurl against the
innocent and helpless of the world? It is an
outrage upon the liberties of a country such
as the United States, and I am persuaded
the moral sense of that great people will in
due time |)rovide a means foi' the aupprea-
sion of auch practice, and co-operate to the
fullest extent with otiier governments in the
extermination of these devils incarnate, and
their fiend, 'i work.
OPKN WINTER.
And now, having done with the iniimrtant
evt-nts coniietted with the i aroline, let us
recall some of the lighter incidents of that
day. The winter was o])en till rel)ruary,
though there luul been sleighing just before
Xmas, as we went from Oxford to Chippewa
in sleighs. rho.se were not the days of
MacAdam or plank as a lule, altliougli
Yonge street was partly macadamized, and
a part of the road between Hamilton and
Ancaster. I've seen twelve yoke of oxen
drawing a 24-pouiider on wheels, and liter-
ally wading through the mud, i-ivalling
(irip's celebrated cartoon on the Winnipeg
streets
It was ao mild that for a week at the
beginning of January four or five of us were
blockaded in the house of the Hon Gilbert
McMicken at Queenston, owing to the depth
of mud and cut up as the only road was by
the military operations going on. But our
worthy host was a neutral, or as our friends
on the other side would say, a copperhead in
those days, and we had no scruples about
quartering upon his well-filled larder;
although from that day to this Canada has
had no more loyal subject than Mr. Mc-
Micken. Our hostess was my good cousin,
and lo this day I have visions of her splen-
did pies and tarts so generously given us
with everything else that was good
By the way I see that this worthy couple
have just been keeping their golden wed-
ding in Winnipeg, and are both in the full
enjoyment of health, and the many bless-
ings with which they are favored, and I sin-
(
corelv hopt! they may yet l)o (iflrinitted to
Hec many happy ruturua of thia graciouH
anniverHary
THK "ROSE."
For Home dayH too wo were on a schooner
in the Niu^^'ara Kiver, the "Kose," (/apiain
(irah.im, H. N., al)()ve Navy iHland, and a
rough time wo iiad of it ; straw for our beds
in the hohl of tiio sliip and cartouch boxes
for our piUows. UmU'r a "wpring cable"
wo iiaod to got opposite the Lsiand and ox-
duinge HJKitH with the l)atteriesi, but nobody
that I remember was iiurt on our good ship.
Kilh'd Armstrongs and Henry - Mai tinis were
not the go in those days. Before the evac-
uation of the Island many of us, dissatisfied
with wiiat was consideted too inactive a
state of things on tlie frontier, left for liome,
ffiid (,'ol. .McNab liad been relieved of his
command, when the Island was taken poss-
ession of Ity our men on the I4tli (»f January.
'I'liis closed my campdigning life, but one
recalls witli a sluidder the rough experiences
and exposure of the young volunteer— the
f'-alher bod soldier wholly unprepared for
war's rough nutios I may instance some
of those. I was anumg the first volunteers
in the City of Hamilton under Coi. Mac-
Nab and one of the 0(1 men of (iore who
went down that nigiir bv tiio s, imer "(4ore"
and saved Toronto. How we were welcom-
ed. ''A man of Gore" was a countersign
anywhere and gave us a passe partout
thiougiiout this city. That night I went on
guard at tlie city hall where I found the
Hon Chief Justice Robinson and The Hon.
r. Justici: Macaulay, both underarms and
doing eg.
Now, witii our Intercolonial and Canada
Pacific railways, those troops could leave
England and be at Vancouver in less time
than it took to get from Halifax to Quebec.
Here at once we see the spinal colui.m of
Imperial Federation What may wt not
expect when we see the grand portage be-
tween Asia and Europe covered by our ( an-
adian railway 2,898 miles long,' bringing
Vancouver within 12 days run from Eng-
land, and enabling troops from England to
reach Calcutta in nearly as possible the same
time as troops from England via the Suez
Canal. And if from any cause, polit cal or
physical, the canal were closed, and the
Cape had to be doubled, then many days
shorter than by that route. And what of
the splendid conmierce of the east and west?
When Liverpool will find itself ten days
nearer Hong Kong, and 22 days nearer Yo-
kohama, than by the Suez Canal. And as
compared with the American Pacific road,
Yokohama will be 1,100 miles nearer Liver-
pool by ours.
In a I'ew months hence we shall see the
representatives at Ottawa from British
Columbia as near the seat of (Government as
those from Toronto to (Quebec were in 1854 :
and, wiihin a shorter time than I will ven-
ture to predict, we shall see the col-
onial representat'.ves sitting in a Federal
^
.and
toij
in^
Ad
po\
abil
the!
meil
of if
devi
9
3
1
Council in London, and in closer communi-
cation with their homes than Scotland's
representatives were 40 yaars ago.
Here is the progress of events, here the
developemeat of the federation germ.
THE MORAL.
But my recollections would be of little
value did I not draw the moral — present the
])ractical thought — that thought is this—
Hold to Canada as an intkgral part of
THE Empire. Be strong in loyal attach-
ment to the Crown, and determined to do
what in you lies to perfect the bond between
the mother country and the colonies. The
dethronement of England, with all her pre-
sent troubles, has not yet taken place. Be-
hind the throne is a greater than Pitt, or
Disraeli or Gladstone. Slie has her destiny
yet to fulfill. Towards this every Canadian,
young or old, may contribute.
History repeats itself continually. In
looking back at the leading events in our
history I am amazed to see ho*v small events
and almost individual efforts have worked
great results. Owing to Sir Francis Head
having sent all the regular troops to Lower
Canada, Upper Canada in 1837 was nearly
lost to Bi'itain. The timely arrival at To-
ronto that night of Col. McNab in the
steamer "Gore," with his 56 men, gave
fresh courage to the loyal party, alarmed
the rebels and saved the city for the niglit
and until reinforcements could come from
other ([uarters ; then the destruction of the
Caroline and Col. Prince's summary punish-
ment of the invaders saved Canada at that
critical period.
Then look back at the war of 1812-15.
Upon how slight a thread did British su-
prema'y then seem to hang when exposed
to a hostile frontier of 2,0u0 miles, and a
people whose bitterness to us was that of
our own cousins. See what the prompt
acfciim of a tJrock could do in the expulsion
of I lie enemy from the western peninsula
and the capture of Detroit And so atQueens-
ton Heights, Chauteauguay, etc. Look-
ing further back, but for the combination of
American and French forces at Yorktown
in 1781 ours might yet be the 13 I'^.nglish
colonies and all the splendour of their devel-
opement into the great nation they are now;
and looking still further back to the con-
quest of Quebec by Wolfe in Sept., 1759,
we see the fall of the French on this conti-
nent ; and but for that victory thai day
there might have been no United States of
America, for the 13 colonies with British
power on this continent would in all prob-
ability have been forever driven back into
the sea.
Motives are great forces. Let the young
men and young maidens — the future mothers
of loyalists— learn the precious lesson of
devotion to our country. Learn to be true —
True as the dial to the sun.
Althouijh h be not shone upon!
PATRIOTISM.
Let no prospect of social or pecuniary ad-
vantages seduce them from their native
land. It is large enough and rich enough
for all, and is a land more favored with po-
litical, educational, commercial, social and
christian influences than any other section
of the world in proportion to its poptdatioii.
Why is it that every American youth is
radiant with patriotism ? Beciuse as a
native born he may become the President of
the great Republic, and the more humble
his birth and life the better his prospects.
Here is a motive power, and what is the re-
sult? A nation of ardent, intelligent
patriots, ready for any sacrifice for the good
of their country, and God knows that no
nation in the history of the world has ever
made so gieat a sacrifice for truth and liber-
ty as this. And they are prepared to make
further sacrifices for their liberties as a
christian people. The old puritan fires are
yet there and they will flash up yet in de-
fence of trutli and right.
Where ie the political prophet who can
foretell the effect of that Bible incident at
the inauguration of Mr. Cleveland, when he
was sworn into the high dignity of Presi-
dent of sixty millions of freemen upon the
Bible which his good mother gave him when
he left home ? What a harvest of Bibles
will yet be put into the sacks of the youth
of America. What an influence for good
will that good Christian mother have
wrought throughout the world in that gift !
that more Bibles were given by the moth-
ers of America and Canada to their sons as
they leave home ! Then would there be
more patriots —more Clevelands Garfields
— Washingtons Havelocks— Gordons and
Gladstones !
But as the young American looks forward
to the Presidency let the young men of Ca-
nada look forward to being the worthy suc-
cessors of Sir John A. Maiidonald and other
distinguished colonists— Sir John being
now pronounced by Blackwood's Magazine
the foremost colonial statesman, and who,
as a member of the Privy Council of Eng-
gland, may yet come to enjoy this distinc-
tion among Imperial statesmen. Let the
young Canadian feel that he has a future
before him that would make him the Pre-
mier of England, with her empire of 300,-
00(',000 of subjects; and may he feel that
every energy of his life shall be given to
her unity and supremacy, and his last
prayer be England forever.
'Tis a glorious charter, deny it who can, *
That is breathed in the words I'm an Englishman.'
Yours truly,
R. S. Woods.
|