IMAGE EVALUATION 
 TEST TARGET (MT-3) 
 
 1.0 If 
 
 
 iii 
 
 i^ 12.2 
 
 I.I 
 
 SB." 
 
 US 
 
 u 
 
 MS 1110 
 
 la. 
 
 L2I IIIIIM III 1.6 
 
 
 Photographic 
 
 Sciences 
 Corporation 
 
 fe 
 
 // 
 
 
 fer ^. 
 
 fV 
 
 iV 
 
 «^o^ 
 
 ^\ 
 
 4> 
 
 ^ 
 
 .V 
 
 ^\ 
 
 
 6^ 
 
 <# 
 
 %' 
 
 23 WEST MAIN STREET 
 
 WEBSTER, N.Y. 14580 
 
 (716) 872-4503 
 
 <* 
 
 ^ 
 
 S' 
 
.^r 
 
 '^<^ 
 
 AW* 
 
 .^ 
 
 K<i^ 
 
 CiHM 
 Microfiche 
 Series 
 (Monographs) 
 
 ICMH 
 
 Collection de 
 microfiches 
 (monographies) 
 
 Canadian lnstitir<:e for Historical Microreproductions / institut canadien de microreproductions historiques 
 
Technical and Bibliographic Notes / Notes techniques et bibliographiques 
 
 The Institute has attempted to obtain the best original 
 copy available for filming. Faatures of this copy which 
 may be bibliographically unique, which may alter any 
 of the images in the reproduction, or which may 
 significantly change the usual method of filming, are 
 checked below. 
 
 D 
 
 Coloured covers/ 
 Couverture de couleur 
 
 Covers damaged/ 
 Couverture endommagea 
 
 □ Covers restored and/or laminated/ 
 Couverture restauree et/ou pelliculee 
 
 
 Cover title missing/ 
 
 Le titre de couverture manque 
 
 Coloured maps/ 
 
 Caites geographiques en couleur 
 
 L'Institut a microfilm^ le meilleur exemplaire qu'il 
 lui a eie possible de se procurer. Les details de cet 
 exemplaire qui sont peut-£tre uniques du point de vue 
 bibliofraphique, qui peuvent mor^ifier une image 
 rpproduite. ou qui peuvent eriger une modification 
 dans la methods, normale de f ilmage sont indiques 
 ci-dessous. 
 
 □ Coloured pages/ 
 Pages de couleur 
 
 □ Pages damaged/ 
 Pages endommagees 
 
 □ Pages 
 Pages 
 
 restored and/or laminated/ 
 Pages restaurees et/ou pellicul^s 
 
 Q Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ 
 Pages decolorees, tachetees ou piquees 
 
 Pages detached/ 
 Pages detachees 
 
 □ Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ 
 Encre de couleur (i.e. 
 
 n 
 
 n 
 
 n 
 
 autre que bleu' u noire) 
 
 Coloured plates and/or illustrations/ 
 Planches st/ou illustrations en couleur 
 
 Bound with other material/ 
 Relie avec d'autres documents 
 
 Tight binding may cause shadows or distortion 
 along interior margin/ 
 
 La reliure serree peut causer de I'ombre ou de la 
 distorsion le long de la marge interieure 
 
 Blunk leaves added during restoration may appear 
 within the text. Whenever possible, these have 
 been omitted from filming/ 
 II ss peut que certaints pages blanches ajoutees 
 lors d'une restauration apparaissent dans le texte, 
 mais, lorsque cela etait possible, ces pages n'ont 
 pas ete filmees. 
 
 Additional comments:/ 
 Commentaires supplementaires: 
 
 Showthrough/ 
 Transparence 
 
 preiision 
 
 
 
 □ Ouality of print varies/ 
 Qualite inegale de Timpresisi 
 
 □ Continuous pagination/ 
 Pagination continue 
 
 □ Inclu 
 Comi 
 
 des index(es)/ 
 Comprend un (des) index 
 
 Title on header taken from:/ 
 Le titre de I'en-tSte provienf 
 
 issue/ 
 
 la livraison 
 
 □ Title page of iss 
 Pago de titre de 
 
 □ Caption of issue/ 
 Titre de depart de la li 
 
 vraison 
 
 □ Masthead/ 
 Gener 
 
 ique (peri<>diques) de la livraison 
 
 This Item is filmed at the reduction ratio checked below/ 
 
 Ce document est filme au taux de reductjr ...dique ci-dessous. 
 
 10X Uv igx 
 
 2rx 
 
 "7 
 
 26 X 
 
 30X 
 
 12X 
 
 16X 
 
 20X 
 
 24X 
 
 28X 
 
 32 X 
 
J'il 
 
 :et 
 ie vue 
 
 ion 
 
 The copy filmed here has been reproduced thanks 
 to the generosity of: 
 
 National Library of Canada 
 
 The images appearing here are the best quality 
 possible considering the condition and legibility 
 of the original copy and in keeping with the 
 filming contract specifications. 
 
 Original copies in printed paper covers are filmed 
 beginning with the front cover and ending on 
 the last page with a printed or illustrated impres- 
 sion, or the back cover when appropriate. All 
 other original copies are filmed beginning on the 
 first page with a printed or illustrated impres- 
 sion, and ending on the last page with a printed 
 or illustrated impression. 
 
 The last recorded frame on each microfiche 
 shall contain the symbol —^' (meaning "CON- 
 TINUED"), or the symbol V (meaning "END"), 
 whichever applies. 
 
 Maps, plotes, charts, etc., may be filmed at 
 different reduction ratios. Those too large to be 
 entirely included iii one exposure are filmed 
 beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to 
 right and top to bottom, as many frames as 
 required. The following diagrams illustrate :he 
 method: 
 
 L'exemplaire film^ fut reproduit grdce it la 
 gdndrositd de: 
 
 Bibliothdque nationale du Canada 
 
 Les images suivantes ont 6t6 reproduites avec Ie 
 plus grand soin, compte tenu de la condition et 
 de la nettetd de l'exemplaire film^, et en 
 conformity avec les conditions du contrat de 
 filmage. 
 
 Les exemplaires originaux dont la couverture en 
 papier est imprim6e sont filmds en commenpant 
 par Ie premier plat et en terminant soit par la 
 dernidre page qui comporte une empreinte 
 d'impression ou d'illustration, soit par Ie second 
 plat, selon Ie cas. Tous les autres exemplaires 
 originaux sont film^s en commengant par la 
 premidre page qui comporte une empreinte 
 d'impression ou d'illustration et en terminant par 
 la dernidre page qui comporte une telle 
 empreinte. 
 
 Un des symboles suivants apparaitra sur la 
 dernidre image de cheque microfiche, selon Ie 
 cas: Ie symbole —»► signifie "A SUIVRE", Ie 
 symbole V signifie "[MN". 
 
 Les cartes, planches, tableaux, etc., peuvent dtre 
 filmds d des taux de reduction diff6rents. 
 Lorsque Ie document est trop grand pour etre 
 reproduit en un seul clichd, il est film6 d partir 
 de Tangle sup^rieur gauche, de gauche d droite, 
 et de haut en bas, en prenant Ie nombre 
 d'images ndcessaire. Les diagrammes suivants 
 illustrent la mdthode. 
 
 1 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 22X 
 
 1 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 4 
 
 5 
 
 6 
 
IS ALCOHOL FOOD? 
 
 BY W. II. WITHROW, M,A.. 
 
 An extraordinary popular delusion prevails among many other- 
 wise sensible people, that wine, spirits, and especially malt liquors, 
 are exceedingly nourishing to the system, and are, tlierefore, 
 healthful and beiif'.ficial as articles of diet. In corroboration of 
 this idea, its advocates point to the rosy and rubicund appearance 
 and Falstaffian proportions of many wine, beer, or porter drinkers, 
 and refer to the frequently meagre solid diet of those who use 
 ardent spirits. These persons appear to assume that the true 
 ideal of manly health and vigour is not the finely moulded, lithe 
 and graceful Apollo, but the obese and drunken Silenus. 
 
 Like many popular fallacies, this theory of the nutritive character 
 of alcoholic liquors will not bear the test of scientific investiga- 
 tion. The deposition of fat, which its advocates regard as a proof 
 of nutrition and health, is actually a condition of pltysical degene- 
 ration and disease. " A general corpulence of the body," says Dr.. 
 Carpenter, of London University, " can be by no means admitted 
 as an indication of healthy nutrition ; indeed it must be regarded 
 as very much the reverse." The abstemiousness from food of many 
 spirit drinkers is at the expense of their bodily tissues, as their 
 maciated appearance, their "lean and hungry -ok," fully 
 testifies. 
 
 The fact is, pure alcohol contains not one particle of nutritive- 
 material for the human body, and even in malt liquor the amount 
 is practically inappreciable, almost infinitesimal. " Tliere is more 
 food," says that eminent analytical chemist. Baron Von Liebig, 
 in one bushel of barley than in twelve thousand gallons of malt, 
 liquor." Or, to put it otherwise, according to the same authority 
 
Is Alcohol Food? 
 
 tf a ir,an consume daily eight or ten quarts of the best Bavarian 
 teer, he will obtain from it, in the course of twelve months no 
 more nutriment than is contained in a five pound loaf of bread. 
 
 "spirits";::'*! "''"' " '^^ "^'''''^ °^' ^°'^^" --t« that 
 not evPn 1 I^^-°P°^tionate amount of nutritious matter, do 
 
 not even bear comparison with sugared water. Alcohol, their 
 essential element, and the most important substance in wine or 
 beer. IS not transformed into any blood constituent. It does not 
 therefore deserve the name of an alimentary principle" The' 
 des^nation. therefore, of Licensed VictuaU.l, Lumrd bv t 
 vendors of spirits is as flagrant a misnomer as can be concdved. 
 
 of ^he rr" f% '""'. ''"'^^ '^^'^ ^^ ^^^^^"'^ '^'^ the nature 
 of the process of fermentation, which destroys the albuminous, or 
 flesh-forming principle in the grain, or other substance subjected 
 Its action "Fermentation," says Liebig. "is nothing el e but 
 the putrefaction of a substance containing no nitrogen It 
 
 begms ^vyth^ chemical action, which is opposed to a vital on^ 
 . -Lite IS opposed to putrefaction. . . . Fermenf-itinn 
 and putrefaction are stages of the return [of organic matt to 
 less comp ex formations." Hence alcohol can be"formed f m the 
 most loathsome and putrescent substances, even from caTrion 
 flesh. In he latter case, however, the presence of nitrogen ^ives 
 an mtolerable odour to the product. A scheme has actually been 
 proiected for the manufacture of alcohol from the sewage of he 
 city of Chicago. ® 
 
 Animal life is maintained, almost exclusively, upon orc^anic 
 mater stored up in vegetable formations or inVer aniS 
 But alcohol, says Liebig, cannot be evolved from vegetable 
 matter till after vinous fermentation sets in. which, he asiC 
 ts death or decomposition, and the process of disintegration to 
 the inorganic elements. 
 
 Alcohol is not food in any sense, moreover, because it is not assi- 
 milable mo any of the tissues of the body, intonerve,brain, muscle, 
 or bone. It passes out of the body," says Dr. Story, "just as it 
 goes in, un-.hanged, undigested alcohol." Dr. J. K. Chamber 
 physician to H. n. H. the Prince of Wales, asserts the same thing.' 
 ^ It IS clear, he says, "that we must cease to regard alcohol as 
 in any sense an aUment, inasmuch as it goes out [of the body] as 
 
 
 < 
 ( 
 
 E 
 
 i 
 I 
 
 a 
 t 
 
 31 
 
la Alcohol Food? 
 
 3 
 
 at went m, and does not, so far as we know, leave any of its sub- 
 ^ stances behind it." Dr. Markham, editor of tlie British Medical 
 
 .fi. Jmcrnal, states that alcohol "is, to all intents, a foreign agent 
 
 which the body gets rid of as soon as it can ; . . . and none 
 of It, so far as we know, is assimilated, or serves for the purpose 
 of nutrition. It is, therefore, not a food in the eye of science" 
 Dr. Rush aserts, "There is neither strengtli nor nourishment in 
 spirituous liquors; if they produce vigour in the body it is 
 transient and is speedily followed by fatigue." Dr. Eeale, physician 
 to King s College Hospital, says. "Alcohol does not act as food- 
 it does not nourish tissues. " Dr. Mussey says, "It is not capable' 
 ot being converted into food, and of becoming part of the livin- 
 organs." The great French work, "On the role of alcohol in 
 the organism," by Professors Lallemand, Perrinand Duroy shows 
 a "strong demarkation between alcohol and food." It demonstrates 
 that It "comes out of the body in totality, tlirough breath, skin 
 and kidneys; and tliat no derivatives of alcohol are to be found 
 m tlie blood and secretions." Professor Miller, of Edinburgh in- 
 quires, " Can alcohol nourish or repair the waste of tissue ^"''"Wot 
 at all," he replies. " It contains no sufficient chemical constitution 
 tor that end; andbesidesit is conveyed uiichanged (i. e. un<li-ested) 
 into the blood." I am aware that Dr. Hammond, of I^ew York and 
 two or three other pliysicians, of some authority, maintain tli'at a 
 sviall proportion of alcohol is assimilated in the body • but the 
 overwhelming balance of testimony is against this conclusion 
 
 But some assert that if not food, alcohol is, at least, its equiva- 
 lent, force, enabling men to do what otherwise they could not do 
 To this Professor Miller responds, "Alcohol is not force itself but 
 only the excitant of force; and its invariable effect is while pro 
 ducing an increased expenditure of force for a time, to brin^ the 
 supply of that force to an untimely close." He sums up thus"' « It 
 is not food in any sense appreciable to common sense. It cannot 
 nourish or give strength; it can only stimulate. It cannot «ive 
 working power; it can only hurry the expenditure of what vou 
 already have ; and further, it hampers and opposes you in -ettin- 
 ^thatstoi^ renewed. . . . The best authorities," he concludes 
 place alcohol, not in the materia alimentaria, but in the materia 
 medica; ranking it not as a nutritious but as a narcotic article 
 
Ja Alcohol Food ? 
 
 and consequently a poison." Liebig asserts that "beer, wine^. 
 spirits, &c., furnish no element capable of entering into the com- 
 position of blood, muscular fibre, or any part which is the seat of 
 vital principle. . . . Their use " he says, " is attended by an 
 inward loss of power. . . . Spirits by their action on the 
 nerves of the drinker make up power at the expense of hia 
 tody; he draws a bill on his health which must always be 
 renewed \ ... lie consumes his capital instead of his interest, 
 and the result is the inevitable bankruptcy of his body." Like 
 the spur in the side of the flagging steed, alcohol impels to in- 
 creased effort at the time, but at the cost of the more terrible 
 reaction afterward. 
 
 That alcohol is not assimilable with the human system is cor- 
 roborated by the fact that it is found unchanged, in considerable 
 quantities in the brain of habitual drunkards, and may be detected 
 in the blood, bile, and other secretions. Drs. Kirk, Hare, Cook, 
 Ogden, Percy and others bear testimony to this fact. The fluid 
 burned readily, with the characteristic blue, lambent flame of 
 alcohol. Dr. Percy actually distilled from the brain of a drunkard 
 alcohol which dissolved camphor and burned freely. 
 
 The same unassimilated substance is strongly perceived in the 
 breath of the confirmed inebriate. Indeed a very large portion of 
 the imbibed alcohol passes oft' in this way. Dr. Eudolf Massing, 
 of Germany, has recently prepared a new test for alcohol, which 
 conspicuously shows its presence in the breath of the drunkard. 
 A red solution of sulphuric acid and bichromate of potash in a 
 test tube is changed to an emerald green by a very small quantity 
 of alcohol. The breath of a sober man will produce no effect on 
 this solution ; that of a drunkard will turn it instantly green. 
 
 " Cases have occurred," says Dr. Sewell, "in which the breath 
 of a drunkard has been so highly charged with alcohol as to 
 render it actually inflammable at the touch of a taper." Over 
 fifty such cases are recorded in the medical journals, in which the 
 bodies of habitual drunkards were thus consumed. They become 
 so saturated with alcoholic spirit as to become living volcanoes,, 
 which, when by accident ignited, burn with inextinguishable 
 flame, leaving only a loathsome residuum of greasy and fetid soot. 
 Dickens describes the horrible death of Krook, in " Bleak House,'" 
 
 i 
 
Is Alcohol Food? 6 
 
 ^s occurring in this way. The Reviewers strongly questioned the 
 possibility of the occurrence, but the novelist cited irrefragable 
 medical testimony in its support. It is also recognized in the 
 statistical nosology of the General Registrar's office under the 
 name of Catacausis Ehriosa, and though rare, its possibility can- 
 not be questioned. 
 
 These multiplied evidences all demonstrate that alcohol always 
 acts as a foreign and unassimilable substance in the human body ; 
 that it passes out by the various excretory organs undigested and 
 unchanged; and that, wherever it lodges, it still retains its 
 spirituous, acrid, and irritating character. It cannot therefore be 
 food for the body, nor supply the waste of aiip of its tissues. 
 
 But we are frequently told that, if not actually food, alcoholic 
 liquors assist greatly in the digestion of food, and thus, like salt, 
 are a valuable adjunct to other articles, and enable us to derive 
 greater benefit from them. Now this comparison is the most un- 
 fortunate that could possibly be made. " For," says Dr. Carpenter, 
 " salt is not a mere casual adjunct to our necessary food, but is 
 itself an indispensable ingredient in our diet. It is contained in 
 large proportion in the blood, and in every fluid secreted from it, 
 and enters into the composition of most of the tissues. , . . 
 Now, all that salt is" he continups " alcohol is not. It is not one 
 of the proper components of th. . ood or of the tissues, and its 
 presence in the circulation is entirely abnormal" 
 
 The remarkable effect of alcohol on animal tissue out of the body, 
 in hardening and toughening its fibre, would suggest the a priori 
 probability, that it would retard rather than aid digestioa It is 
 found to produce the same effects in the stomach, both on the 
 coats of that organ and on whatever it may contain. This has 
 been demonstrated by actual experiment. Dr. Figg, of Edin- 
 burgh, gave the same quantity of meat to two dogs. He then 
 forced an ounce and a half of spirit down the throat°of one of the 
 dogs. In three hours he killed them both. In the stomach of 
 the dog that drank the spirit the meat was found just as he ate it 
 —undigested. The other dog's stomach was empty,— the meat 
 having been all properly digested. Spirituous liquors have been 
 known to protract the digestion of food in the human stomach as 
 long as eight and forty hours. 
 
6 
 
 Is Alcohol Food? 
 
 Alcoliol prevents digestion also in another way. That process 
 is effected by the action of the salivary, gastric and pancreatic 
 fluids on the food. The peculiar principle, however, on which 
 digestion depends is j^q^sin, a powerful solvent of organic matter. 
 Now the gastric juice will not digest alcohol, but is itself neutral- 
 ized thereby. Alcohol is one of the most powerful solvents known, 
 being strong enough to dissolve sulphur, iodine, ammonia, potash, 
 camphor, resin, and all the organic vegetable alkalies. When 
 taken into the stomach it instantly changes the pepsin from its 
 soluble and active form to a solid, inert precipitate, which has no- 
 effect whatever on the food in the stomach. Alcohol is thus a 
 prompt and powerful antagonist to the digestive process. " It 
 also," says Orhlla, " coagulates the albuminous portion of the con- 
 tents of the stomach, and this coagulated albumen passes out of 
 the stomach almost unchanged." 
 
 To these facts Trofessors Miller, and Youmans, and Drs. 
 Thompson, Gregory, Figg, Sewell, Story and others bear testimony. 
 Dr. Munroe, of Hull Medical School, strikingly illustrated this 
 remarkable effect of alcohol by an ingenious and interesting 
 experiment. He mixed some bread and meat in two vials with 
 some gastric juice, but to one he added a little pale ale. He set both 
 vials in a box of warm sand, which he kept about the tempera- 
 ture of a healthy stomach, occasionally shaking the box to imitate 
 the motion of the stomach. In the vial without tlie ale the food 
 was digested in from six to eight hours. In the vial with the ale 
 it would not dissolve at all, though kept warm for several days. 
 
 The continual neutralizing of the gastric juice— the true diges- 
 tive fluid — by the use of alcohol, overtaxes the glands by which it 
 is supplied in the effort to secrete the quantity necessary for 
 digestion, till chronic dyspepsia is produced. And who are so 
 subject to that complaint, which saps the very foundations of life, 
 as confirmed dram drinkers ? This characteristic effect of alco- 
 holic liquors is well described in the old convivial song of 
 Bishop Stett, in the play of " Gammer Gurton's Needle," — the 
 earliest specimen of the British drama, — 
 
 " I cannot eat but little meat. 
 
 My stomach is not good ; 
 But sure I think that I can drink 
 
 With him that wears a hood. 
 
 
Is Alcohol Foodf 
 
 J 
 
 I love no roast, but a nut brown toa»t, 
 
 And a crab laid on the Hro ; 
 And little bread shall do me stead ; 
 
 Much bread I nought desire." 
 
 We have seen that alcoholic liquors not only cainiot aid, but 
 that they actually prevent digestion, and that they injure tho 
 tone of the entire digestive apparatus. Neither do they* increase 
 the power of endurance of fatigue, as is often asserted, but rather 
 diminish it, as is a!)undantly proved by the testimony of those 
 who have had to perform the severest labour under circumstances 
 of the greatest physical hardship. 
 
 Dr. Carpenter has examined tliis subject very thoroughly, and 
 presents ample evidence of the fallacy of the popular notions 
 upon it. He quotes, among many otlier examples, the circum- 
 stances of a vessel that sprang u leak at sea, and was kept afloat for 
 twelve weeks by the unceasing efforts of the passengers and crew. 
 At first they partook of spirits, but their strength failed so rapidly 
 that, by the captain's orders, coffee and cocoa were substituted, 
 "when," says the Dr., "their vigour returned ; their fatigue 
 diminished ; and after twelve weeks' incessant and severe labour 
 (witli no interval longer than four hours), the ship was brought 
 into port witli all on board of her in as good condition as ever 
 they were in their lives."* He also received the voluntary testi- 
 mony of thirty-four men engaged in the most laborious oper- 
 afi'^g, furnace and foundry-men, glass-blowers, etc., "that they 
 w ire able to perform their toil with greater ease and satisfaction 
 when abstaining from li(iuor than when they drank moderately 
 of it." A teetotal glass-blower, publicly stated at a meeting 
 at Exeter Hall, that he liad "worked sixty hours at a 
 stretch, without ever lying down, at his exhaustive labour, a feat 
 which he had never been able to accomplish wliile using spiri- 
 tuous liquors." A member of a Glasgow fire brigade statics that 
 he sustained seventy-three hours' continued exertion at a fire, 
 with no other beverage than coffee and ginger-beer, while his 
 spirit-drinking comrades "were beat, and fell avv.ay," The 
 superior efficacy of total abstinence in promoting bodily vi<Tour 
 was uniformly demonstrated in competitive trials between two sets 
 * Physiology of Temperance, p. 121. 
 
 "i 
 
8 
 
 I« Alcohol Food t 
 
 of lalioiintrs (iiij^nped in very divei-se but arduous toil,— mowers, 
 harvesters, Inick-nmkers, miners, iron-workers, railway-navvies 
 and the like, — the one set practising total ahstinenoe, whilst the 
 other relied on the assistance of alcoholic liquors.* The same 
 truth is corroborated by the noble physi(iue and athletic power of 
 the boatmen, porters, and water-carriers of Constantinople, said 
 to be strongest and finest set of men in Europe. The Moham- 
 medan populations of the East, generally, who are all aljstainers 
 on religious principle from wine or fermented liquor, are charac- 
 terized by their fine developnient and muscular energy. In compe- 
 titions of strength between the most athletic grenadiers of the Bri- 
 tish service, and the water drinkers of the Himalayas, the latter 
 were uniforn)ly victorious, their average strength, according to J. S. 
 Buckinghan), the oriental traveller, being one and three-quarter 
 times that of the strongest Europeans. The extraordinary endu- 
 rance of fatigue of the New Zealand Maories, the Cape Caffers, 
 the North American Indians, and of the Guachos of the South 
 American pampas, who all drink water exclusively, i)rove, at least, 
 the entire compatibility of total abstinence with perfect physical 
 health and vigour. 
 
 Military experience also proves that the prolonged and often 
 severe hardships of a soldier's life are better endured without 
 liquor than with it. During Sir John Moore's retreat from 
 Corunna, notwithstanding the depressing circumstances under 
 which this march was performed, the army was found to improve 
 in health and vigour, as soon as the usual allowance of spirits 
 was unattainable. The Duke of Wellington, during the Penin- 
 sular War, feared more for his men from barrels of wine than 
 from batteries of cannon, and sent a body of troops to destroy a 
 large magazine of wine which lay on his line of march. 
 
 Probably no troops ever performed more laborious work than 
 those that in 1870 proceeded by the Dawson Road to Red River 
 merous and often steep portages. Yet all this fatigue was suc- 
 dragging their heavy boats, stores, and war-material over nu- 
 cessfully undergone with the absolute prohibition of intoxicating 
 liquors and the substitution therefor of tea ad libitum. 
 
 " Since it has been proved," says the gallant Havelock, referring 
 
 * Carpenter, Physiology of Temperance, pp. 121, 122. 
 
la Alcohol Food f 
 
 9 
 
 forced marches 
 
 to the capture of Ghuznee, " that troops can m 
 ot forty miles, and storm a fortress in seventy-five minutos, with- 
 ont tlie aid of rum, behavinjr after success with a forl.ennmce and 
 humanity unparalleled in histoiy— not the slightest insult being 
 offered to one of the fem.'iles fouml in the Zenana— let it not 
 henceforth be arj^ued that distilled opirits are an indispensable 
 portion of a soldier's ration." 
 
 Copious evidence of this nature, both from the naval and mill- 
 
 tary service, was given before the Parliamentary Committee for 
 
 the Suppression of Intemperance. The superiority of Cromwell's 
 
 grave and temperate Ironsides over the drunken and roystering 
 
 <;avaliers is corroborative of the proposition here maintained. 
 
 We may learn, even from the prize ring, thiit the highest degree 
 of bodily vigour is inconsistent with even a moderate indulgence 
 m alcoholic liquors, This was also the experience of the andent 
 -athletes of the Isthmian games. 
 
 " Qui studet optatam cursu contingere motam, 
 Multa tulit, fecitque puer : sudavifc et alait ; 
 Abstinuit venere, et vino." 
 
 Homer also uukea Hector reject the entreaty of "royal 
 Hecuba " : — 
 
 " Stay till I brinK the cup with Bacchus crowned, 
 Then with a plenteous draught refresh thy soul. 
 Spent as thou art with long laborious fight." 
 •| Far hence be Bacchus' gifts, " the chief rejoined, 
 •• Inflaming wine, pernicious to mankind. 
 Unnerves the limbs, and dulls the noble mind." 
 
 Milton thus represents the wisdom of abstinence from wine in 
 the drama of " Samson Agonistes." 
 
 " OAorwa.— Desire of wine and all delicious drinks, 
 Which many a famous warrior overturns, 
 Thou couldst repress. . . 
 Samson.~l drank from the clear, milky juice, allaying 
 
 Thirst, and refreshed ; nor envied them the grape 
 Whose heads that turbulent liquor filled with fumes. 
 Cams. O JT-adneas, to think use of strongest wines 
 
 And strongest drinks our chief support in health, 
 When God, with these forbidden, made choice to rear 
 His mighty champion, strong above compare, 
 Whose drink was only from the liquid brook." 
 
10 
 
 Is Alcohol Food ? 
 
 There has long been a prevalent idea among the professional 
 classes, that a " moderate " use of fermented or spirituous liquors 
 conduces to intellectual vigour, and enables them better to endure 
 the mental strain they have to undergo. But this opinion, too, dis- 
 appears before the crucial test of actual experience. Those who 
 indulge in wine or spirit drinking mistake the transient stimulation 
 of the faculties for an increase of mental power, not considering 
 that the subsequent reaction and depression are all the greater for 
 the previous excitement. When men have sought the aid of these 
 delusive supports, it has often failed them utterly after a short 
 time. Hartley Coleridge, Mozart, Burns, Byron, E. A. Poe, and 
 many other gifted sons of genius, who had recourse to alcoholic 
 stimulus for the excitement of their powers, all died at an early 
 age, " as if," says Dr. Carpenter, " in consequence of the prema- 
 ture exhaustion of their nervous energy." 
 
 S. C. Plall, the well-known author, and editor of the Art- 
 Journal, gave his testimony as follows : " He lived by the labour 
 of his brain, and could testify that since he became a teetotaler^ 
 he had an increase of intellectual power. He was better in body 
 and mind, and was able to work three times longer than ever he 
 could while he indulged, even moderately, in the use of strong 
 drinks." 
 
 Few men have performed greater public labours than the late 
 Mr. Cobden. He says : " No one has more faith than I have in 
 the truth of the teetotal doctrine, both in a physical and moral 
 point of view. I have acted upon the principle that fermented 
 or distilled drinks are useless for sustaining our strength, for the 
 more work I have had to do, the more I have resorted to the 
 
 pump and the teapot From what I have seen of the 
 
 House," he continues, " I must say that I have the belief that 
 the men who are the most temperate are the men who bear the 
 fatigue of the House best." The late Col. Thompson and Mr. 
 Bright, those indefatigable workers in the public service, were 
 both practical teetotalers. John Howard, the illustrious philan- 
 thropist, notwithstanding his constitutional weakness, seemed to 
 bear a charmed life amid plague and pestilence, and the extraor- 
 dinary fatigues of his extensive travels, the result, doubtless, of 
 his abstemious diet. Some dried biscuit and a cup of milk or 
 
Is Alcohol Food? 
 
 II 
 
 cold water was his usual fare. Locke, also, attributed his pro- 
 longed life and labours to his entire abstinence from alcoholic 
 liquors. The testimony of great numbers of the clergy phy- 
 sicians and lawyers, lecturers, and other public speakers, who 
 once thought that alcoholic stimulants were necessary for the 
 sustenance and repair of their physical and mental powers, but 
 discovered that total abstinence was much more conducive to 
 that object, might also be cited. 
 
 Another purpose to be served by food is that of sustaining the 
 temperature of the body. Many articles of diet, which do not 
 contain much actual nutriment, are valuable for maintaining the 
 vital t. Spirituous liquors, it is asserted, are especially 
 adapted for that purpose. The immediate sense of warmth which 
 IS felt on their imbibition, favours the popular apprehension ; and 
 the large amount of carbon in their chemical composition— about 
 fifty-two per cent, in pure alcohol— gives a sort of quasi proba- 
 bility^ to the presumption. That presumption, however, is 
 fallacious. Tlie true and normal supporters of combustion— 
 which is really the process which takes place in the lungs, as well 
 asm the capillaries— are the sugar, starch, and fetty substances of 
 the food we eat. According to the estimate of Leibig, two hundred 
 and sixty-six parts of spirits of the strengtii of ordinary brandy 
 are required to generate the same amount of heat as a hundred 
 parts of fot would produce ; " so that weight for weight," says 
 Prof Carpenter, who has examined this subject exhaustively 
 "the heat-producing power of proof spirit, considered simply as a 
 chemical agent, is actually less than starch or sugar;"* com- 
 pared with fat, it is only as one to two and a half 
 
 Moreover, when alcohol is in the blood it prevents the com- 
 bustion of the proper fuel for maintaining the animal heat. The 
 effete material is not removed from the blood, as by the process 
 of respiration when uninterrupted by the presence of alcohol it 
 always is, and these impurities are retained in the system to the 
 great injury of the whole vital economy. After the first tran- 
 sient effect in quickening the circulation has ceased, the general 
 temperature of the body is lowered, so that for the very purpose 
 for which alcohol is so highly recommended, it is an actual injury 
 * Physiolgy of Temperance, p. 136. 
 
12 
 
 Is Alcohol Foodf 
 
 instead of a benefit. Ammonia and cam^phor possess similar 
 stimulating powers, yet no one thinks them appropriate articles of 
 diet on that account ; and there is no more reason why alcohol 
 should be so considered. The experiments of Dr. Prout on this 
 •subject show, " that alcohol enormously depresses the combustion 
 of carbon in the system during its existence in the body," and 
 therefore lessens the amount of animal heat generated. " The 
 supposition," says Dr. Lees, " that alcohol is necessary in cold 
 ■climates is erroneous, and contrary alike to common experience 
 and scientific experiment." 
 
 The result of wide and varied experience fully confirms these 
 conclusions, based on scientific data. The unvarying testimony 
 of arctic explorers, whale-fishers, fur-traders and trappers, and of 
 the inhabitants of high northern latitudes, of Alpine guides and 
 others exposed to extreme and long-continued cold, demonstrates 
 not only the inutility, but the absolute injuriousness of alcohol 
 as a generator of animal heat, and the vast superiority of an 
 oleaginous diet for that purpose. 
 
 Sir J. Eichardson mentions as a proof of his power of resisting 
 cold, which he attributed to his entire abstinence from spirits, 
 that, though advanced in years, he was enabled to go into the 
 open air at a temperature of 50° below zero without an over- 
 coat. 
 
 Sir John Ross says of his northern expedition : " I was twenty 
 years older than any of the officers or crew, and thirty years older 
 than all excepting three, yet I could stand the cold and endure 
 fatigue better than any of them, who all made use of tobacco 
 and spirits." " He who will make the corresponding experiments," 
 says the same commander, " on two equal boats' crews, rowing in 
 a heavy sea, will soon be convinced that the water-drinkers will 
 far outdo the others." The free use of ardent spirits is one of 
 the chief causes of the failure of so many Arctic expeditions, and 
 when the men drank nothing but water, they endured the rigour 
 of the climate with impunity. A Danish crew of sixty men 
 were winter-bound in Hudson's Bay. Before spring, fifty-eight of 
 them died. An English crew, under the same circumstances, lost 
 only two men. The former had an ample supply of ardent 
 spirits ; the latter had none. 
 
1 
 
 i 
 
 la Alcohol Food? jj 
 
 U^HBtration of the depressing effect of alcoholic liquors on the 
 bodjy powers The crews of two ice-locked vessels were fled 
 
 order to take refuge m that to which he belonged. The one had 
 only he,r usual rations of fat pork and biscuil The other ha^ 
 m addition a supply of brandy. The whole of the fl,.t e^w 
 
 TXT'- ''^ """'^ " '"' '^""""^ p-'*^^ f™» -1" -d 
 
 spmts from the north-west fur country, and the hardy Canadian 
 voyageurs, or coureurs rfe boi. in these desolate wilds as well a^ 
 the Indians and half-breeds, wiU endure the intensest =;id on tl^efr 
 generous rations of pemmican, and the bears' meat or blvej 
 tails they may obtain on the route 
 
 Can°ad'atX°'M""/f ""'" ^'«"- *^" «ovemor-Ge„eral of 
 
 int feet ^r ''""''^' ■'' ^"y'' ^ " =" '' " "''^' i'>'«=^'^=t- 
 
 ing fact, both m a moral and hygienic view, that for some years 
 
 a^osf u"the'°? 'TV7' ''""' "8"°"^'y e..cluded from 
 Z^l \, "' °' ""= lumbei-men ; and that uotwith- 
 
 ttandmg the exposure of the men to cold in the winter, and to 
 
 sIusLo;."'™- *' '''^' "' '"^ ^•^f--"' !>- "een entirely 
 
 The setting in of a Canadian winter, or any "cold snap" of 
 
 ranr™'"'-"""?"^ ""^"^^'1 -'"--eral instaifces of 
 death from exposure of poor wretches enfeebled and almost 
 devitahzed by habits of inebriation. 
 
 Baron Larrey, the great French surgeon, says that "durin. 
 Napoleons retreat from Moscow, those soldiers who indulged "n 
 the use of intoxicating liquors sank under the elfects of cold 
 almost in battalions; but their fate was not shared by those of 
 their comrades who abstained from those liquors." Marshal 
 Gjouchy says that "he was kept alive for days on coffee whil 
 
 time the Eussuin soldiers, on a winter march, have ration^ of oU 
 aerved out instead of spirits, experience having shown t 
 superiority as a generator of heat. The Esquimaux who liv^ 
 
14 
 
 Is Alcohol Food? 
 
 Dr. Hooker, a medical officer under Sir J. Ross, says : " Ardent 
 spirit never did me an atom of good. It does harm ; the ex- 
 tremities are not warmed by it . . . you are colder and more 
 fatigued a quarter or half an hour after it, than you would have 
 heen without it." 
 
 Such testimonies might be multiplied indefinitely, but 
 sufficient evidence has been adduced to show that " for enabling 
 the body to resist the continued influence of severe cold, alcoholic 
 liquors are far inferior in potency to solid food, especially of the 
 oleaginous kind;"* and that after tlie temporary stimulation of 
 the circulation that they produce has subsided, " the cold is felt 
 with augmented severity, and its action on the system is propor- 
 tionately injurious." 
 
 It is also maintained that among the many fancied virtues of 
 alcohol, is that of enabling the system to endure the effects of 
 intense and long-continued heat, whether climatic or artificial. 
 Indeed, it seems in the opinion of its admirers to be a universal 
 panacea, adapted to the most contrary circumstances and produc- 
 tive of the most contrary effects. It enables one to endure the 
 ligours of cold, it diminishes the effects of heat. It is a whole- 
 so°me corrective of too dry an atmosphere. It is an antidote to 
 the ill effects of wet. It is necessary to ward off the effects of 
 malaria on the Gold Coast. It is also necessary in the breezy sana- 
 toria in the hill country of India. It is required by those who 
 are in health to keep them so, and by those who are ill for their 
 recovery. It is prescribed for fevers and for colds, in cases of 
 exhaustion and of surfeit alike. It is part of the outfit of the 
 whaler in Baffin's Bay and of the ivory-trader in Timbuctoo. 
 Their spirit rations are served out to the British sailors when 
 sweltering between decks off the Slave Coast, as well as when 
 rounding°Cape Horn ; and to the British soldiers at Aden— the 
 hottest place on earth— as well as in midwinter to the garrisons 
 at Vancouver's Island or Quebec; and it is thought equally 
 necessary for them all. But neither the Esquimaux in the snow 
 huts of Nova Zembla, nor the naked negroes of Senegal use these 
 wondrous beverages, yet are superior in health and vigour to the 
 Europeans who enjoy its fictitious aid. The first maintains his 
 
 • Carpenter's Physiology of Temperance, p, 144. 
 
 ;f ■• 
 
Is Alcohol Food? 
 
 15 
 
 i> 
 
 
 temperature on an appropriate diet of whale's blubber, the second 
 keeps cool on melons and rice ; but the Englisliman, with a sub- 
 lime indifference to circumstances, continues to imbibe his 
 brandy, London stout, and Barclay's XXX, in every variety of 
 •climate, till he often falls a victim to his defiance of the laws of 
 health and common sense. It is said that a favourite beverage 
 in Jamaica is rum, flavoured with cayenne pepper ! We find, as 
 a consequence, that the planters die in scores from sunstroke. 
 About as suitable to the climate, this, as that described by a 
 Yankee in reply to the Cockney inquiry—" Do they drink hale in 
 your country ?" " Drink hail !" said Jonatlian, unaccustomed to 
 the aspirate, but not to be outdone by an Englishman, " We drink 
 thunder and lightnin" !" 
 
 A vast and varied experience has shown that instead of bein" 
 beneficial in any or all of those diverse circumstances, alcoholic 
 liquors are always and everywhere injurious. But they are 
 especially injurious to those living or labouring in elevated 
 temperatures. It has been thought absolutely necessary, when 
 the body is pouring out water in perspiration, to pour in alcohol 
 in order to keep up the supply. But this, really, is adding fuel to 
 the flames; and is increasing the amount of injurious material in 
 the blood, which the system is trying to get rid of througli the 
 pores. Tlius the blood is poisoned, the nervous and muscular 
 •energy is enfeebled, the appetite is impaired, and a state of 
 physical collapse is induced. 
 
 Dr. Carpenter has accumulated a vast body of proof of the 
 insufficiency of alcoholic liquors to sustain bodily vigour under 
 the enuurance of extreme and continued heat, or of great vicissi- 
 tudes of temperature. The experience of men in performing exces- 
 sive labour in an elevated temperature— steamship stokers, anchor 
 forgers, glass-blowers, and others similarly engaged— confirms this 
 theoretic opinion. 
 
 The testimony of oriental and tropical travellers and explorers, 
 of missionaries, of military and naval commanders, all conspire 
 in proof of the proposition that these liquors do not sustain 
 •either the mental or the physical powers under extremes or 
 striking vicissitudes of temperature. 
 
 Sir John Ross, to whose Arctic experiences we have referred 
 
16 
 
 la Alcohol Food? 
 
 H 
 
 says of exposure to heat : « On my last voyage to Honduras all 
 the sailors, twelve in number, died, and I was the only person 
 that went out in the ship who came home alive, which I attribute 
 entirely to my abstaining from the use of spirituous liquors." 
 " Eum," says Dr. Bell, speaking of its use in the West Indies 
 always diminishes the strength of the body, and renders man 
 more susceptible to disease, and unfit for any service in which 
 vigour or activity is required. As well might we throw oil into 
 a burniug house to extinguish the flames, as pour ardent spirits 
 into the stomach, to lessen the eflect of a hot sun upon the skin " 
 " I have served." says the veteran Governor of Gambia " in all 
 the West India colonies, and in Africa, and I never knew a dram- 
 drinker long-lived, healthy, or always equal to the duties he was 
 called upon to perform." 
 
 "Wherever," says an eminent medical authority, "in con- 
 conformity with their absurd national customs, European residents 
 m tropical countries continue to indulge in their usual alcoholic 
 beverages, they speedily fall victims to the climate or become 
 invalided." Small wonder that the Indian nabobs, who persist 
 in using curry powder and brandy and water, return to En-land 
 If they return at all, as yeUow as their own guineas \nd 
 with a temper as irascible as that of Nana Sahib himself 
 
 We liave thus seen that neither as food proper, for furnishincr 
 nourishment to the animal tissue, nor as an aid to digestion nor 
 as fuel for sustaining vital heat, do alcoholic liquors possess the 
 qualities popularly attributed to them. We have seen that they do 
 not aid in the least degree in the formation of bone, muscle, blood 
 brain, nerve, nor any tissue or substance of the human body but 
 are an absolute injury to all its parts ; and that they neutralize 
 and destroy the digestive fluids, and thus instead of aiding 
 actually hinder and prevent digestion. We have also seen that" 
 so far from increasing the power of resisting extreme cold or'heat 
 they depress the bodily powers, and render them less capable of " 
 such resistance. 
 
 Toronto : Published at the Methodist Book Roo^aTsOKing Street EmT