STANDARD TIME FOR THK United States of America, CANADA AND MEXICO. ►•♦- Special attention to the subject referred to in the accom- pamjing documents is respectfully requested BY THK AMERICAN SOCIETY OF CIVIL ENGINEERS, 127 East Twenty-Thibd Stbeet, NEW YORK. Should the Person receiving this be unable to send a roply, he will confer a great favor by transmitting the circular to some person who may be able to do so. <~'0 American Society of Civil Engineers. COMMITTEE ON STANDARD TIME. SANDFORD FLEMING, Esq., Ottawa, Ex-Chief Engineer .of the Northern Railway of Canada, The Inter-C!olo- nial liaihvay, and The Canadian Pacific Railway, Chairman. CHARLES PAINE, Esq., New Yobk, General Manager New York, West Shore and Buflfalo Railroad. THEODORE N. ELY, Esq., Altoona, Pa., Superintendent of Motive Power, Pennsylvania Railroad. J. M. TOUCEY, Esq., New York, General Superintendent New York Central and Hudson River Railroad. Professor J. E. HILGARD, Washington, Superintendent United States Coast and Geodetic Survey. Professor T. EGLESTON, New York, School of Mines, Columbia College. General T. G. ELLIS, C. E., Hartford, Conn. New York, March Lst, 1882. At the Annual Meeting of the American Society of Civil Engi- neers, held at New York, on the 18th ultimo, resolutions were passed directing that a general invitation be extended to all persons and associations specially interested in the subject of Standard Time, to co-operate with the Society in an effort to effect a satisfactory and speedy settlement of this important public question. The Committee on Standard Time has been requested to give effect to the wishes of the Society in this behalf. Accordingly the Committee seeks for the desired co-operation and solicits a general expression of opinion from persons engaged in connection with the Railways and Telegraphs of the country, and from all others specially interested in the question through- out the United States, Canada and Mexico. The Committee respt otfully directs the attention of all con- cerned to the accompanying documents elucidating the subject. The Committee cordially invites replies to the series of questions which accompany this. To all opinions with which the committee may be favored due weight will be attached. After the receipt of replies a Convention, duly called, will meet at Washington, for the purpose of determining the Time System which it would be advisable to adopt. The President of the So- ciety has been authorized to invite other Societies interested, the several State governments, the governments of Canada and Mexico, and the various departments of the general government at Wash- ington, to send representatives to the Convention. Replies are requested to be sent without delay (i^«]iMiiMi|«hMing addressed ^ ^ JOHN BOGART, Secretary A. 8. C. E,, 127 East Twbnty-Thibd Stbest, NEW YORK. SPECIAL KOTE. As authorized and requested by the Society at the Annual Meeting, the Committee has issued a series of questions on a separate sheet, with the view of eliciting an expression of opinio?i froa as many per- sons as possible. Some of the questions require explanations, but the Committee finds it difficult to narrow explanaxions to limits suffi- ciently small to be read by men whose time is sevcjrely taxed. The Com- mittee, however, hopes that such men may favor them with replies, at least to the leading questions. To other persons who have more leisure and who may desire to consider the wider range of the subject and ex- amine every point under discussion, the following documents are ap- pended to the resolutions adopted by the Society and the report of the Committee. The details of the scheme for Regulating Time, referred to in the sheet of questions, will be found in Appendix No. 4, to which particular attention is invited : No. 1. Communication read at the Convention of the American So- ciety of Civil Engineers, at Montreal, June, 1881 (page 9). No. 2. Extracts from an address read before the Association for the Beform and Codification of the Law of Nations, at Cologne, Prussia, August, 1881 (page 15). No. 3. Extracts from an address read at the International Geographi- cal Congress, at Venice, Italy, in September, 1881 (page 23). No. 4. Cosmopolitan scheme for regulating time with accompanying diagram, (page 28). STANDARD TIME. Resolutions adopted at the Annwil Meeting of the American Society of OivU Engineers. January IHth, 1882. Resolved, That the report of the Special Committee on Standard Time be accepted, and that the Committee is hereby requested to take such steps as it may consider necessary to obtain information to enable it to report definitely at a future meeting. Resolved, That the authority is hereby given to the Committee to co- operate with other associations in furtherance of this important subject. Resolved, That authority is hereby granted to the President of this Society to invite other Societies interested, and that representatives of State Governments, representatives of the Dominion of Canada, the Republic of Mexico and the various Departments of the General Gov- ernment at Washington, be invited to meet in a convention as set forth in the report. 6 STANDARD TIME REPORT OF THE SPECIAL COMMITTEE. House op the Societt, ) New Yokk, January 17tb, 1882. \ The Committee appointed to consider the paper on Standard Time, for Railway and other purposes, read at the Montreal Convention, June, 1881, beg leave to report : The Committee have examined the question referred to them, and fully recognize its great public importance. Practically it resolves itself into a proposition to reform our general time system. But diffi- culties of a peculiar nature present themselves. The Committee does not considpv the problem insolvable ; but from its character it is clear that no single association, and that no one individual can solve it. Every member of society is interested in it, and it becomes necessary to consult many interests in order that general concurrence in any change be obtained. Since the subject was brought under the notice of the Society in June last it has been taken into consideration by other associations : by the American Association for the Advancement of Science, at Cincin- nati ; by the American Metrological Society, in New York ; by the Asso- ciation for the Reform and Codification of the Law of Nations, at Cologne, Prussia ; by the International Geographical Congress, at Venice, Italy. The members of the Committee have, since their appointment, con- ferred individually with many persons. They find it admitted on all sides that standard time lor general use throughout the country is tiT<*ently demanded, and that the time has arrived when action should be taken. To apprehend that the question is one of importance, it is only nec- essary to glance at the existing conilition of our time service. Mistakes in the hour of the day are frecpient. In every State— in every city or town— discrepancies are met ^hich produce great aggregate inconven- ience. Thousands of engagements are broken. Innumerable disap- pointments and losses result. In some cases loss of life is caused, and generally in consec^uencie of defects in oiir time system, difficulties more or less serious constantly are exporiencod. These difficulties are not confined to this country. They are ex- perienced in all civilized e oousidered that the initiation of such a time system as the age demands properly falls within the province of the people of America, it becomes the more necessary that we shonld make earnest eftbrts to ascertain not simply what best will meet the reqiiireraents of the hour, but what will prove most generally beneficial to our own and succeeding generations throughout the world. The Committee holds it expedient to obtain an expression of opinion on the various points which present themselves, from as large a number of practical and scientific men as possible. They consider it essential to have the views of those who have been and are now engaged in con- nection with the great lines of transportation in every State, and Prov- ince between the two Oceans. Accordingly the Committee begs leave to recommend that such papers on Standard Time as it may consider necessary to set forth the sub- ject, be printed, and, all who are prominently connected with Railway and Telegraph enterprises, or are in any way interested in the consider- ation of the question in the United States, in Canada, and in Mexico, be cordially invited to send replies to the series of questions which have been prepared, with the view of obtaining all shades of opinion. The Committee more particularly draw attention to propositions 13 to 20 in the scheme which accompanies this. (See page 28.) It has been held by those who have given attention to the subject that no scheme of time reform can be considered complete without pro- vision for the ultimate removal of a defect familiar to many. The Com- mittee accordingly direct attention to the suggestions submitted under the heading "Division of the day into hours." (See page 31.) ' The Committee respectfully recommend that authority be granted by the Society to invite the co-operation of other scientific associations, and that of other bodies in the furtherance of this important object, and that all such Societies and government departments interested be invited in the name of the Society to attend a general convention to meet at New York or Washington on a day hereafter to be named, for the pur- pose of determining the Time System advisable to adopt. SANDFORD FLEMING, Chairman. 9 APPENDIX No. 1. Paper read before the Coni-ention of the American Society of Civil Engineers held at Montreal, Cmmda, June 15fh, 1881. CCXXXf. (Vol. X.— December, 1881.) ON UNIFORM STANDARD TIME, FOR RAILWAYS, TELEGRAPHS AND CIVIL PURPOSES GENERALLY. By Sandford FiiEMiNo, M. A. C. E. The question which I have been requested to bring under the notice of the Convention, although not strictly of an engineering character, from its nature cannot fail to be of interest to the members of the Ameri- can Society of Civil Engineers, many of whom have taken a prominent part in establishing the great lines of communication on this continent. To the large number of its members connected with the administration and development of the gigantic railway system extending between the two oceans, which in length are but little less than 100,000 mUes, the subject becomes one of vital importance. The occasion strikes me as peculiarly appropriate for submitting for your consideration the subject to which, with your permission, I will briefly refer. The Society meets for the first time beyond the limits of the United States, to find in the Dominion of Canada a cordial welcome. Many of its members, in attending this Convention, must have travelled long distances, and have experienced, in one way or another, some of the difficulties it is proposed should be removed. The definition of civil time and its scientific determination for railway, telegraph and all ordinary purposes, is a problem to which a solution is imperatively demanded by the present condition of civilization. 10, \r,^-yr;-y%./:^^ The question has been examined by the American Metrological Society, New York ; the Imperial Academy of Science, St. Petersburg ; the Boyal Society, London, England ; the Canadian Institute, Toronto, and other scientific bodies. Its importance has been fully admitted, and expressions of opinion have been obtained as to the means of overcoming the difficulties which are experienced. The citizens of the United States, and the subjects of Her Majesty, the Queen, occupy together the greater portion of North America. The most friendly relations exist between us, for, in the main, we are substantially one people, living under diflferent Governments, with laws and customs essentially identical. On all sides we are s^^tisfied to remain separated by our political affinities, having distinct theories and beliefs with respect to systems of government. But science, like every noble virtue, knows no national boundary. In this brief note I can recognize none. In alluding to matters which equally concern the United States and Canada, I shall refer simply to this country or to this continent. As the continent extends across 105 degrees of longitude, an indivi- dual at the western limit finds himself seven hours of recorded time be- hind another individual at the extreme eastern side at the same moment of absolute time. Much of the intervening country is but thinly settled, but railways and telegraphs traverse from ocean to ocean, and we have every gradation of difference of time between the extreme limit of seven hours. According to the system of notation which we have inherited from past centuries, every spot of earth between the Atlantic and the Pacific is entitled to have its own local time. Should each locality stand on its dignity, it may insist upon its railway and its other affairs being governed by the time derived from its own meridian. The smaller and less important localities, howevor, as a rule, have found it ( onvenient to adopt the time of the nearest city. The railways have laid down special standards which vary, as has been held expedient by eich separate management. In the whole country there is, so far, an irregular acknowledgment of more than one hundred of these artificial and arbi- trary standards of time. The consequences of this system are unsatis- factory. They are felt by every traveller, and in an age and in a country w!ien all, more or less, travel, the aggregate inconvenience and confusion is very great, and it will be enormously multiplied as time rolls on. If the system already results in difficulties to trouble our daily life, and to 11 '■^■'■''::'^^-:ro--;-^ lead to embarrassments which often occapy onr courts of law, which, indeed, too often are the cause of loss of life, what will be the conse- quences in a few years, when population will be immensely increased and travel and traffic indefinitely multiplied, if no effort be made to effect a change ? The societies I have mentioned, after careful examination, have united in the opinion that a satisfactory change cannot be made too soon, and they have adopted resolutions pointing to a general uniformity and thorough accuracy in time reckoning. They believe that the course they have recommended will greatly facilitate the daily transactions of busi- ness men, greatly increase the safety of the travelling public, and im- mensely benefit the whole community. It is proposed that the community unite in an effort to simplify the system now in use by reducing the number of time standards to a mini- mum by substituting for an indefinite number of irregularly established and purely local standards a few main or, as they may be termed, conti- nental standards, each one having a fixed and well known relation to all the others. It is proposed to have these standards established and main- tained by governmental authority ; to have them regulated with precision through a common central observatory, and through these standards it is proposed to keep every town, city, railway and steamboat clock throughout the land as nearly as practicable in perfect agreement. The plan of arrangements favored by the Metrological Society,New York, and the Canadian Institute, Toronto, is to have the standards so establish- ed that they will be exactly one hour apart ; that is to say, while it would be nine o'clock at one standard it would be eight o'clock at the next to the west, seven o'clock at the following, and so on, by steps of exactly one hour. There would be no difference in the minutes and smaller divisions of time. If the time be ten minutes or thirty minutes past the hour at any one point, it would at the same instant, in absolute time, be ten minutes or thirty minutes past some hour at every point. The hours themselves only would differ, and they would differ only in designation according as the localities were east or west. At the same instant of absolute time every clock in the country would strike either one hour or another ; the minute and second hands would always and everywhere be in perfect agreement. It may be known to gentlemen present that the officers of the United States Signal Service have evinced a deep interest in the question, and in 12 the efforts to establish uniformity, accuracy and simplicity of system throughout the country, General Hazen, Chief Signal Officer, Wash- ington, has expressed his earnest desire to contribute toward the public dissemination of standard time. He considers it eminently proper that the department over which ho presides should, as far as practicable, assist in a work in which the whole community is interested, and he offers the active co-operation of the Signal Service in every part of the United States, in the maintenance of accurate standard time and giving it to the public by dropping time balls at all important stations. Mr. Oarpmael, Chief Director of the Meteorological Department of Canada, would similarly co-operate in every practicable way. There would, therefore, be no difficulty in giving effect to a scheme of intro- ducing uniformity of time-reckoning .throughout North America, so soon as the railway and telegraph authorities and the general public express concurrence. It is proposed : 1. That the exact time should be determined astro- nomically at a central observatory. 2. That every town of any importance should have a public time signal station. 3. That arrangements be made for placing each station in electrical connection with the central obser- vatory at a certain hour every day. 4. That each station be furnished with automatical apparatus for making the proper signal, either by drop- ping a time ball or by firing a gun at the proper moment. 5. That all the public and railway clocks in each and every locality be controlled electrically from the public time signal station. I think it may fairly be claimed that no peoples are more progressive or more ready to adopt any needed change or manifest improvement than those who live in North America. And as there is no country except Russia where a greater necessity is presented, or a better field offered for the introduction of a comprehensive system of uniformity in time reck- oning, it is more than probable that in this country the change will first be made. As there can be little doubt that other countries will in due time follow the example of America, it is desirable that we should inaugurate a system which will readily commend itself by its appropriateness and simplicity. One that will have the best prospect of being ultimately adopted throughout the world. If we admit the principle that in a question of this kind it is not expedient to limit our view to any city or state or province, but to embrace in our system the whole of the con- lb tinent, it seems to follow that we should take a still broader riew, and endeavor to apply the principle to all countries. Steam and electricity are rapidly altering the conditions of life everywhere, they are girdling the globe and bringing all countries nearer together. We get our unit measure of time from the earth's revolutions, it is, therefore, common property, and nothing can be more cosmopolitan in its nature. It is perfectly obvious to my mind that a system of uniform time which would be good for this country should be equally good for all countries on the face of the globe. These views have mel with the ready acquiescence of all who have given them careful consideration, and the system recommended by the several scientific bodies for adoption on this continent, commends itself as a scheme which all nations may, with advantage to themselves and to general interests, accept. The American Metrological Society and the Canadian Institute have each papsed resolutions substantially as follows : "Lesolved, That uniformity of time throughout the United States and Canada is demanded by the progress of events, and that a general system by which time may be reckoned in a uniform and accurate man* ner by the people of all nations throughout the globe is of the highest importance. "Resolved, That a great service will be rendered to the world by directing the public mind to the subject, and by securing the general adoption of a well conceived system of uniformity, and that the Society is hereby authorized to co-operate with other bodies in recommending a comprehensive scheme based on the following propositions : "1. Twenty -four standard meridians (one every 15 degrees of longi- tude) to be established around the globe for reckoning sectional or local time. " 2. One of the 24 standards to be selected as a time zero or initial meridian for reckoning cosmopolitan time. " 3. The time zero to coincide with the prime meridian to be com- mon to all nations for computing longitude. "4. The twenty-four standard meridians to be designated by names^ or by letters of the alphabet, or by degrees of longitude, numbered from the prime meridian westerly. 14 ' Now, considering the fact that, for our own Continent of America the time actually kept at any place is usually purely conventional, and is not the true local time of the place itself, considering that this is also true in England, and is, probably, to a great extent true of the Continent of Europe, and considering that identity of the conventional with the local time is unimportant when the standard of time actually used is understood, it has seemed to us that by the adoption of a system accord- ing to which all time-keepers throughout the world might be made to agree as to the minute and second, and to differ only, as longitudes differ, in regard to the hour, all the confusion which exists in conse- quence of the present variety of time-standards might be wholly elimi- nated, to the great benefit of the people of all civilized lands. The adoption of this system would involve the recognition of twenty-four fixed meridians, distant from each other by a constant difference of fifteen degrees of longitude, and determined in position by some one of the number distinguished as the prime or zero meridian. The moment of the passage of the mean sun over each of these meridians is to be regarded as the hour of mean noon for that meridian, and for all places which are nearer to it than they are to any other. Thus the largest difference which can occur between conventional time and true local time will be thirty minutes, and the hour will change at a line half-way distant between any two meridians. The system here described was proposed originally for the United States by Professor Cleveland Abbe, of the United States Signal Service (as mentioned above), in a report to the American Metrological Society, and also (without concert with Professor Abbe) by Sandford Fleming, Esq., late Chief -Engineer of the Canadian Pacific Bail way, and now titular Chancellor of Queen's University, at Kingston, Ont., in a paper read by him before the Canadian Institute, and since published. In these papers it was proposed to adopt, for the American Continent, five meridians, of which the central one should be situated bit hours west of 18 Oreonwioh, and should pass almont centrally tkrongh the City of New OrleanH. The time of this meridian, being that prevailing through the principal Stutari> Time, Mkriuian U. Cnlifornia. Nevada. Oregon. Wasliington T. Br. ColuinbiH. Vancouver Island. Idaho. Utah. Arizona. STANUAnD TiMK, Mkridian T, Mexico. Texas. KnnMUS. Colorado. Nel)raa|{a. Wyoming. Dakota. Montana. Munitobn. Saskatchewan. Kcewadin. Standaki) Timk, Mkriuian 8* Louiniana. Mis!-i»i. Alabama. AvkatmaH. Tennessee. Missouri. Kentucky. Illinois. Indiana. I own. Minnesota. Wisconsin. Michigan. Standard T(hr, Meridian It. Florida. eorgia. ' S. Carolina. N. Carolina. Virginia. Ohio. Maryland. Delaware. Pennsylvania. New Jersey. New York. Rhode Island. Connecticut. Maosachusetts. Vermont. New llampshirs, Maine. ^,„ , Ontario. Quebec. New Brunswick. Prince Ed w'd rid Nova Scotia. 21. Reference to the diagram will show that the four meridians, U, T, S and R, at intervals each from the other of one hour, would effec- tively regulate the time of day throughout the whole extent of the Uni- ted States, Canada and Mexico. But the number of standards can be increased or reduced without interference with the harmony, and cosmo- politan application of the general scheme. Theories have been advanced, still further to reduce the number of standards. If two st to the east of the Prime Meridian proposed for all nations. It would pass through Lake Superior and the Mississippi Valley to the Gulf of Mexico, It would be generallj central, and would best suit the great body of the population. The Division of the Day into Houbs. 22. The present division of the day into halves, and these halves into twelve hours, each series of twelve hours being numbered identically, 89 leads to error and inconvenicnco. This division necessitates the use of the expressions ante meridian and post meridian, or forenoon and afternoon, or the contractions a. m. and p. m., to identify the particular half day to which any hour belongs. In railway time tables the expres- sions ordinarily used to specify the half day ure liable to be omitted, misplaced or misiinderstood. The consequence is that innumerable mistakes are made and uncertainty freqiiently arises. The halving of the day and the use of dual numberd to denote the hours is a very old practice, but it confers no single benefit ; and, beyond its claim to antiquity, has nothing whatever to recommend it. While it will doubtless be extremely diiHcult to do away with the custom so firmly established by long usage, it is nevertheless important to ascer* tain what change would be most advantageous, and what modifications, if any, would be most likely sooner or later to meet with general accept- anoe. Two alternative plans have been suggested. Firstly. — To have only one series of hours in the day, extending frora midnight to midnight, and numbered from one to twenty-four without interruption. Secondly. — To number the hours between midnight and noon (one to twelve) precisely as at present, and to denote the hours between noon and midnight by letters of the alphabet. y Both propositions would obviate the necessity of adding words of explanation, or otherwise specifying, whether the hours were forenoon or afternoon. The first would be extremely simple. The second would have the advantage of distinguishing the forenoon from the afternoon hours by the character of the symbols employed to denote them. The hours of the first half of the day would be known by numerals, of the second half by letters. The second plan would have other advantages to recommend it. The employment of cosmic time letters to denote the hours from noon to midnight, in local reckoning, would make the designation of the afternoon hours everywhere concurrent. According to the scheme herein submitted there would be, be- tween the Atlantic and Pacific coasts, four standard time meridians, R, 8, T and U. (See Fig. 4.) The relative time of the day for a few hours before and after noon under these several meridians would be as given in the table appended. An examination will show that under plan number two the noon letter in every instance would agree with the 33 C5 2 S> s 2 fl c5 S e ;i P ^ M >• N • > p ■5 - Q -it a ^ OJ . •*lOtOt-«C>0,H « CO <« in (0 •-* IH iH rl fH i-l i-l << m •i CO ^ to (0 fc* Q 9; •«1 sS' rH t— ( I-» -D 1 ■SS2 g m °° 'uoouejoj IM 'aooajdfjv 03 a;>M 10 t- 00 •-' rH tH d CO ^ 10 __ ^'^^o^ tH fH -«1 ... H a cJ C3 S 1 < N V5 • 3 P H § g 1-^ 3 s vj ca , t- 00 o> >-l e«i CO H* 10 t^* 00 Q •*^ r-« f-4 FH % •«J 55 ij i I< •*> £3 50 S a S a, • •noonajoj t- 00 e> •-• IN •H 'Qoonjauv rt « w •* 10 e> d ci el 0) d l> « 0> -4 f-1 »H Si » E* P ^ M >x N 9^ n a , 3 C ^H u , t- w e» .-1 (N n -^ in to t* (c a o ^ r-l rH rt IS ««1 'A r5 OQ ■f a • g.sS S 00 •nooaojoj aooajaijy t- 00 1-1 s iH e^ CO s e 0; Of OS OD E^ t) ^ H ^ n' " 1 1 84 letter by which the standard meridian of the locality would be known. Advancing Avesterly, local time would become one hour slower from meridian to meridian, as indicated by the numerals which denote the forenoon hours ; while the afternoon letters would everywhere be in perfect agreement. The time of New York would be regulated by Standard R, Chicago by Standard S, Denver by Standard T, and San Francisco by Standard U, each standard differing by steps of one hour, yet at any given hour in the afternoon, say at W, it wotild bo TF o'clock at the same moment in absolute time from the Atlantic to the Pacific. K. FIQ. I. /^rojecfion on thf xuggestfi fithrmij Straii. • ir Pnnfic Initial J^eniitan DlAOKAMS T(i ; COSMOPOLITAN SCHEME I FIG. 2. frnffCfttin ^0" \Vf.ilf'/ri rrnm thf zrro T(i ACCOMIANY FOR REGULATING TIME. ovrf* FIQ. 3. f'rojertim \ Mil" U',tl,r/i/ Irnin thi- i'rn TUT I l„iri FIQ, 4 I'rojretinn 270" Wftlrrlii trvm t/u zrru