LOUISBOURG: AK HISTORICAL SKETCH. BV JOSEPH PLIMiSOLL HOWARDS. Read before the Nova Scotia Historical Society, 27th November, 1894. .^K. HALIFAX : NOVA ("COriA PKIXTINO COMl'ANV, •V* V*w oV^ >^->r<.«' V4. UKW more romantic ami strau<5e episodes exist in North American annals than the story of this fortress of He Royalc. A colony and government removed to a lonely spot on the shore of a vast uninhabited island ; a city, a naval depot, and a citadel of enormous strength spring- ing up there under the flag of the most powerful militjiry nation in Europe, and resulting in an armed metropolis whicli menaced all the Atlantic coast, became one of the trade-centres of the continent, and formed one of the great bulwarks of French power in America. Suddenly and almost ignominiously it changes masters ; all its costly works, buildings, and armament become the property of Great Britain. In a year or two, with ecjual suddenness and grefiter ignominy, it reverts to France, and for a few years more holds a dominant position. Again it falls ; and its captors expunge the entire establishment from the face of the earth ; searccly is one stone left above another. Its inhabitants drift elsewhere, and in a few years it is apparently forgotten as if it never had been. All this within half a century — a man's short life. But it has left deep marks on the pages of the history of North America ; and while in a sense less purely Canadian than continental, it has been left chiefly to Canadian writers to tell its story with amplitude of detail. The value of these histories is enhanced in that they give us the annals of all Cape Breton from its discovery down to recent dates ; yet this very comprehensiveness leaves room for a sketch confined to the fortress which made the island famous. Such I have endeavored to portray in the following pages. Prior to that treaty which may be termed the legal beginning of Anglo- Acadian history — signed at Utrecht in 1713, Louisbourg under that name did not exist. The bay or harbour was known to the French as Havre a I'Anglais — to the English as English Harbour. An early 4 LOUISBOL'HCi : AN IIISTOKICAI. SKKTCII. tnivollur, Capt. Ltiigli, lias left a vi-ry interesting account of liis voj'age along these slior;^'< in 1597, and refers tf> the hay as Port Ingleese or English P(»rt. Of thesi; early days there is little known in connection with the [dace. Pontgrave, the conipanion of DeMonts in his memor- able voyage of 16(H, landed there on his arrival on this side and biiilt a boat : so far as we know this was the first vessel built by Kuropeans on what is now Nova Scotian soil. A quarter of a century elapses liefore we again hear of I'Havre si 1' Anglais, and this lime it is true to its name. British colours had temporarily supplanted those of France over all Acadie and Cape IJreton, thanks to the enterjjrise of a certain Captain Argall. He, in the summer of 1613, set out from the newly settled village of Jamestown in Virginia, and, in the informal method of those days, attacked and beat off the few French tluin in this colony, and proclaimetl the whole country as belonging to 15ritain. Fight years later a grant of all Acadie, Cape Breton, and part of Canada, was made by King James the first to Sir William Alexander, Secretary of State for Scotland. That astute nobleman divided his huge grant into lots and sold as many as possible to gentlemen anxious to go in for coloniza- tion work on a large scale. Among the purchasers was Lord Ochiltree, a Scottish nobleman, son of the Earl of Arran. With a following of 60 emigrants he sailed for Cape lireton in the spring of 1629, and settled his little colony within a few miles of English Harbour ; tlu-y erected a small fort and began to clear the land. Hut their residence there was a short one. A Captain Daniel, in the service of the King of France, had, or imagined he had, a grievance against my Lord Ochiltree for alleged interference with French tishernK^n ; and, without warning or explanation, landed a strong party on the 18th Sept. of that year, (1G29,) took the little fort liy assault, razed it to the ground, and deported the entire settlement, their arms, ammunition and stores — first to the harbour of Ste Anne, near by, then across the Atlantic — some to England, others to France. So bold a deed, in times of nominal peace between the two Crowns, created no little excitement, and voluminous charges and counter-statements were promptly forthcoming. But the Stuarts ruled England in those days, and French influence had great weight ; and it does not ai)pear that any of the settlers so suddenly and unceremoniously thrust back on their native sliores received redress. By treaty signed on 29th March, 1632, Cape Breton was restored to France ; but for more than three-quarters of a century thereafter, English LOUI8UOURO : AN IIISTOIIICAL HKETCH. 5 llftrbour reniained uiulistiirbe:ance in August, 1713. She had a double duty to perform — a mission of survey and of colonization, and carried among her company officials and settlers for the new colony ; chief among these being M. de Ste. Ovide de Brouillan, a naval officer, and Major L'Hcrmite of the Engineers. In the name of the King I.OUISBOUUO : AN HWTOUICAI. SKKTCH. they fornmlly took poHscssion of tl»« isliuitl ; mul, as incMlotcriiiiiicd Ity the Home authorities, re-nametl it l\v Royalo In fact a general rceliristeniiig of all tlie chief harhours of the island very Hoon took place, preceding their aotual aettlenieiit. The harhoiir of Ste. Anne became I'ort I)aii|ihin ; St. IVter's became Port Toulouse ; and Havre a I'Anglais, Louishourg. Of all these changes the latter alone survives ; hut its single greatness outweighs the lapse of the other three. The brilliant period of active P'rench ruh^ in Americu, and the valour of the New England inilili;'. and of liritish linesmen and blue-jackets cannot be forgotten while the name of Louisbourg lives. As to the most suitable harbnur t(t fortify and build up into a naval capital tiiere had lieen a market! ditt'erence of opinion, the Governor of Plaisance — backed uj) by no less a personage than the Viceroy of New Fiance — favoring Ste. Anne's ; but the excellence of the harbour of Louisbourg, the depth of water at the entrance, and its com|mrative freedom from ice, carried the day, and that place was definitely chosen as the metropolis of the island province. To Louisbourg the immin others ofe(pial note, but the foregoing all appear as having Ijeen in active correspondence with the authorities in France. Of the life and doings at Louisbourg during the.se early years there is little which is worth recording iJuildiug went on steadily, if not with remarkable speed. Supplies of various sorts were sent out from France, and from the French colonies, and all ch'ef business matters were regu- lated from Versailles. Cut off, to a very great extent, from the French po8.sessions in Canada, the Louisboiirg government and peojde were to an unusual degree dependent on the mother country. Every petty detail of civic and colonial life was reported at length to Paris, and full instructions as to the necessary action were sent out liy the Council of Marine. Immigrants from France came in Itut slowly, especially during the Hrst few years ; the sunny climate of New Orleans — at this period being laid out for settlement — proving a more tempting bait to warmth-loving Frenchmen than the cool summers and icy winters of lie Royale. Strong efforts were made by the local authorities to induce the Acadians to leave the now English province of Xova Scotia and cast in their lot with their compatrints in the new island iirovince ; but the Acadians, not framed in the sternly-heroic mould, were loath to leave their fertile farms and niarshlands. They noted the leniency with which their new masters 9 ^ouI^«^l>L'K(! : an histokical sketch. treated them hh regards tli«'ir all<.'gianc>', and showed their worldly wisdom in remaining as long m* pos8il)le French suhjectH on Ih'itiflh territory. A few went to lie Royale, and more to the fertile lands of He St. Jenn ; but the great majority remained at home, in the hojie, we may Hii|>j)OHe, of developments whieh would at one and the same time enable them to retain their nationality, appease their rulers, satisfy their consciences, and till their pockets. M. de Cnstabelle, the energetic and capable governor of Ilt> Koyale, died in 1717. His last days appear to have been clouded over with a .sense of wrong, or, at least, of lack of appreciation of his services, for his latest reports to the; Ministry deal with the troubles of his r/yiuif, and of his jiersonal expenditure in the interests of the government, and he ])rays "for justice." He died in France, having gone over in 1716. M. de Ste. f )vide de Brouillan, the King's Lieutenant, .seems to have taken charge during the (iovernor's ab.sence, and eventually succeeded him ; M. de Beaucour arriving at Louisbourg from Francf' was of short duration. He died at Louisl)ourg in May, 1740, eight months after his arrival ; and M. Dmpiesnel reigned in his stead. De Forant is worthy of special mention in that he becpieatheil an endowment or fonndatioii sufficient to defray the board and tuition of eight pupils, daughters of officers, at the chief convent of the town. This is probably the first act of the .sort that took place in any part of the province — certainly the first of which [ have been able to Hnd any trace. The new Governor, an appointive from France, reached Louisbourg early in Noveniher. He would seem to have been .somewhat of a iion vivnnf, as his first letter to the Home authorities is an application for more money to defray .lebts contracted " in the discharge of the duties of his office." It is easy to infer what tradesmen constituted his chief creditors. We are not informed if this very frank reipiest was granted, but presume that it was ; if not, his colleague, M. l>igot, no doubt got him out of the .scrape by methods ])eculiarly hi-! own Duquesnel ruled for four years only, and, like his predecessor, he died in office. During the winter preceding his death (1744) an appointment was made, of interest in view of after events ; the King's Lieutenant, .M. de liourville, retired, and was succeeded by Major Duchamlton who commanded the LOUISBOUKG : AN HISTOHUAI. SKBTCH. 11 garrison (lurin<^ the oveniful siego of 1745. Duqnosiiol died just in time to spare iiiniself tiie trials of tlie bombardment, ami tlie iiumiliation of tJie surnMider. The slindow of the cloud which burst on Louisl)ourg in 1745 seemed to have liung over the town for at least the three preteeding years. Requests anil complaints are common in all the corres[)ondence exchanged between (tovernor and Minister; but between 1742 and 1745 they gathered weight. They were too numerous and coiudied in too phiin language to iiave any source but in a sense of actual deficiencies and urgent recjuirements. Sucli plira^es as : " The desperate state of tlie colony;" " The pressing needs of the colony ; " '' The sad conilition of the colony;" "Distress increasing;" "Famine increasing;" '•Tilings are in a deplorable condilion," need no comment or explanation. Desertion seenis to have been rife Letter after letter mentitins the arrival of recruits, and yet tiie complaint is ever going forwanl, " We want more troops." "The fortifications are undergarrisoned," and the like. Absence from duty is freijueiitly mentioned, and it is evident tliat the free and open life of the woods possessed charms to the French .soldier of that day which UISB(JURG: an HISTOUICAL SKETCH. entire winter; and Dncliamboii, the Commandant, in writing to France ami to Quebec early in April, expressed his wish that the whole garrison should be sent back to France and new regiments sent out. In one particular his wish was granted. The troops did return to France that summer, but in a manner very ditteront from that proposed by the gallant Major. Put I anticipate. The business, growth, and general civic life of Louisbourg during these yeans can be briefly told. Fish was the chief, in fact almost the only staple of native production ; the trade in this was large and profitable. Several merchants owned as many as 40 or 50 vessels, each with a crew of three or four men, wliose pay depended on the quantity of their catch. But fearful and wonderful were the restrictions on trade in those days. Only vessels from France or from the French colonies were permitted to trade freely and bring in what goods they chose ; imports from New England were by law strictly limited to provisions, cattle, timber, and such goods as could not be produced in the mother country and her West Indian colonies. For outward or return cargoes vessels under the British flag were dependent on the unsold portion of the shij)ments of sugar, molasses and similar products whicli constituted the cargoes of ve.ssels hailing from the French West Indian ports. English skippers were strictly forbidden to take away witii them any specie ; all they sold must be taken out in merchandise. Dry goods, clothing and general hou.sehold and personal eff"ects were supposed to come from France, and from France alone. To add to the detriment to business in general, and to their own traders in particular, the New England laws had, since 1686, forbidden trade of any sort with Cape Breton or any other French dependency. But as a matter of fact many Yankee ski[)i)ers, thus repressed and yet determined on business, quieted their sensitive consciences by balancing matters in breaking the laws of both nations. They not only traded with Louisbourg, but brought in contraband goods, which were smuggled with little difficulty, the customs otticers of that port being generally o])en to persuasion of a financial character. Not only so, but whole cargoes of codfish itself, the great and only Cape Breton staple, were brought over from the English colonies, sold to West Indian merchant.?, and trans- ferred to their vessels in Louisbourg harbour under cover of night, or in some other port in broad daylight. False bills of lading and similar docu- ments were freely used. The English-cured cod was inferior in quality to the Cape Breton article, but could be sold at a much lower figure. LOUISBOURG : AX MIHTORICAl- SKETCH. 13 TliiiTL' wui'o otlier iuUiresting feiitiu'«.-! of the comiuerce of the port, but limited space forbids me to enlarge on the subject. Knowing that no depenilence could lie placed on Cape Breton as the sole source of food supply for the garrison and townsfolk of Louisbourg, it had been from an early date the policy of the government to encourage settlers, both from France and from the French residents of now English Acadia, to take up land in the fertile island of St. John. The fir-st came in 1719, and from that date to the downfall of French rule in America, the population showed a steady although small increase, amounting in 1758 to about 4,000 souls. Port-la-joie — now Charlottetown — was made the capitid, an officer being stationed there as commandant with a garrison of about 60 men, under the orders of the Governor of Cape Breton. The supplies from this island helped to eke out the stores reciuired for Louisbourg. In neither island did the population increase as rapidly as was wished. As alreatly noted, few Acadians came to Cape Breton ; and the measure which had most effect in augnietiting the number of re.sidents was one which legally ordained that every vessel which sailed from Franiie for tlie island should carry a certain number of men known as " mija[iiU" who had agreed to remain there at least three years. Most of these men stuyed permanently, and many of them rose to i)ositions of importance in the mercantile life of the town. It may be here noted that while very few of the A(;adians came to Cape Breton, to again live under their old Hag, they seem to have taken excellent care to use Louisbourg as a means of self-em ichment, De Heauharnois and Hoc(piart, respectively Governor ami Intendant of Canada in 1745, in writing to the Honu^ Ministry, state, " They (the Acailians) are "extremely covetous of specie. Since the settlement of lie Royale "they have drawn from Loui.sbourg, by means of their trade in cattle, " and all the other provisions, almcjst all the specie the King annually " sent out ; it never makes its appearance again, they are particularly " careful to conceal it." Neither as settlers, soldiers, or tradesmen did these vaccillating and unfortunate neutrals prove of \\\\\v\\ value in upholding i\\Q fleui--^ on this continent. Matters ecclesiastical were of considerable importance in Louisbourg. Six missionary [iriests of the Becdllet oriler, six brothers of the Chari- table Confraternity, ami .several nuns, were thought neces.sary to attend to the siiiritual, charitable, medical, and educational needs of the town. These were paid l>y the King, and the remuneration was not meagre. Each priest received 500 livres per aniunn, and the sum of 1000 livres 14 LOUISBOURG : AN HISTORICAL SKETCH. was alloweil for their luaintuuance ; they had also three country veA- deiices in ditlerent parts of the ishiml. The hospital was the finest civic building in Louisbourg ; it had a grant of 3,000 livres for general expenses and 600 livres for medicines, as well as an allowance for each patient. Of the character of the clerics I'iclion gives a poor account, and states that much of their time and attention was devoted to inciting the Indian to attacks on English settlements ; his remarks on their duties and behaviour are rather amusing. He speaks in high terms of the nuns, (xovernor de IJronillan seems also to h ive been dis- satisfied with the clergy of his day, — which was many years before Pichon came on the scei,e, — as we find him in 1726 complaining bitterly about the Brothers of Charity who, he says, devote their whole time to trade, instead of attending to the patients in the hospital. In another letter he objects to the appointment of Canon Fournel as cure of Louis- bourg, which had just been made by the orders of the Bishop of (^hiebec, who held spiritual jurisdiction over He Royale. This protest was repeated a couple of years later, and indicates that there must have been a very pretty and long drawn-out rjuarrel between the head of the state and the head of the church in the little capital. As a rule, the official corres- pondence has little or no reference to ecclesiastical matters. There was only one church in the town (with the exception of a small chapel attached to the hospital), and it was built, strange to say, in the centre of the King's bastion, inside the defensive works, and little more than one hundred yards from the crest of the glacis. The nunnery and hos- pital were both in the town proper. The government of Louisbourg was essentially a military one ; but the authority was divided. The Governor (subject however, to the Viceroy of Canada) controlled all purely military matters, and those relating to the Indians of the island ; while the Commissioner or Inten- dant had sole direction of the juiy and subsistence of the troops as well as the administration of justice, and the hospitals. Tliis division of authority in a place so far from Paris or Quebec, led at times to serious trouble. Governor and Commissary did not see eye to eye on all occasions, and the result was not edifying. Of the lesser lights, there were a King's Lieutenant, an Attorney General, a Secretary, a Tipstalf, and four or five Counsellors, usually chosen from among the merchants of the town ; these, with Governor and Commi-ssary, constituted the Supreme Council, of which the latter was i)resident. The civil aI in Louisbourg for several years, and his jtolicy and habits may have set the fashion to many. Xatuially, matters connected with trade and shipping, Avith import and ex|)ort, attracted the chief attention of the civil authorities ; but there were other objects on which they h .d of necessity to bestow much thought, and often vigorous action. l\ominent among these was *,e liquor traffic. From the earlier years of the settlement, ordinances regulating the sale of spirits wore ])romulgated, and were continually being amended as abuses became noticeable, or as the rulers and con- trollers of this business thought best to ordain. Not a little of the correspondence with the Ministry at Versailles was devoted to the sub- ject, and it is evident that generous indulgence in the flowing bowl was the order of the day year in and year out. Louisbourg was first and foremost a military and naval .station, and the soldier and sailor of that day were no less partial to conviviality than are their successors. Owing to the large trade done with France and the West India Islands, brandy, rum, and the like were amazingly cheap ; and knowing this, and the utter stagnation of the place for half the year, it is small wonder that intemperance was rampant, and that its devotees often gave trouble to the lords who ruled the town. For even at its best it must have been a dull little city, this Louisbourg, and a place where petty jealousies and petty gossip were bound to exist, and to influence both official and private life. Away at the extreme north- east corner of a vast continent, in which war and savage life were still dominant, isolated by dense forests and stormy waters from those of their kith and kin in America, and completely shut out from the stirring life of France and Europe, service in Louisbourg must have been tedious and irksome to both soldier and civilian, and when is added lack of food and supplies, it cannot be wondered at that some of the humbler class of its defemlers sought a freer and more adventuresome iiie in the woods. But whether the suft'erings and straits which the little colony had at times to endure i-esulted from neglect on the part of France, or from the faults of its own rulers and i)eople, it is difficult to determine. Probably both were to blame. All correspondence and authorities indicate that the officials of the colony were, as a whole, greedy for emolument and 16 U)UI8BOUH(J : AX HISTOUICAL SKKIOH. decorations,— a trait incompatible with good govcniing qualities. On the other hand, the treatment acconh-d by France to her Louisbourg subjects, presents a strange medley of alternate surfeit and starvation. Millions were lavished on fortifications, while the troops who were to man them could often scarcely obtain the necessaries of life. Store- houses, wliarves, and civic l)uildings were evolved at vast expense, while the garri.son (until the last few years) was a meagre one,— in sharp con- trast to the number of officials who ruled in bolh town and fortress, But while none can deny that the Mother Country was both in honour and duty bound to be ever generous, we must not forget that during almost the entire period in which Louisbourg existed as a fortress, France was in the throes of war and of commercial distress, and had pressing need of every .soldier and of every shilling. Startling events had followed each other in rapid succession, and the interest of those in power had of necessity been closely fixed on European and domestic occurrences. Although, as we have .seen, the Treaty of Utrecht was signed in April, 1713, war had been prolonged for another year. Al)so- lute peace had existed for only a few months when Louis XIV flieil, and all the excitement and change consequent on the jK-cession of new ruler.s nionopoli.sed public attention. Under the regency which followed, a startling an.i unprecedented series t)f financial measures were adopted ; and the exciteni^nt thus occasioned had scarcely subsided before France was again at war, this time with Spain. Concurrently with these events, the vast bubiile of speculation fi.thereil by the Scottish adven- turer, Law, had been sv/elling V)eyond all Ixnind.s of reason ; it burst in 1720, and the disastrous consequ lice;; permeated the kingdom, ruining thousands of families, and leaving the financial condition of the country in utter chaos. Peace was declared in l'"21, and the Regent and his successor Louis XV, were able to devote a few years attention to domestic troubles : but in 1733 the sword was again drawn, and, with few intermissions, remained unsheathed fc," fifteen years. It will be [ seen, therefore, that Franc(! and her rulers had much to do at home, which palliates her sins of omission in the garri.soning and victualling of > her Cape Breton seaport. ThrijUghoul all, the pe( jile of that seiqwrt were true to their colours, and never wavereil in tiieir loyalty. Save the occasional desertion of soldiers often harshly treated, often insidficiently fed, we read of no neglect of duty, no dalliance with the jtower which ruled the adjacent |)rovinces, and which held at least a nominal sway over the still nearer colony of Nova Scotia. The mutiny of 1744 was a revolt against gross inju.«tice, and was wholly free from treasonable intent. I.OUISBOURO : AN inSTORICAI. SKETCH. 17 IT. The lirst thirty VL'iir.s of the lifn of Louisbourg formed, as we have seen, a period of steady growth and of comparative quint, and were unmarked by the occurrence of any great event. But a startling change wa.< at hand. This fortress and naval station, of enormous strength, well armed and equipped, and the very embodiment of all martial jjonip and circumstance, had attained its great power and influence during a time of comjiarative peace ; now, by a strange mockery, it was to lose its renown and fnil in its purpose when first confronted with the reality of war ; equally strange, that to such a fortress so unlooked-for a fate should come at the hands of raw and undisciplined militia. Such was the outcnn>e of the New England expedition against Louislioiu'g in 1745. To briefly sketcli the fortunes of this enterprise must ])e our next task. Prior to attempting this, it might be of interest to have a look at the town and barbo>U' as they appeared in the spring of 1745. Api)roaching the place from the sea we come to the entrance, a sheet of watc-r about one-third of a mile in width, cleaving the rugged shores and leading into the harbour. Passing through, the high blutt" on the right was crowned with a lighthouse, which did noble work in its day in warning the mariner from its dangerous shore. To the left was a bunch of rocky knolls and islands, the largest of which, — alxnit 150 yards long by 60 M'ide, — was strongly fcjrtified with a work knovyn as the Island Battery. Behind it and still further to the left, was the sharp point of land which formed the apex of the triangle on which the town and fortress were built. Passing on, the visitor would And ''hat his craft had entered a beautiful body of water, two miles in length and about half a mile in breadth, with a depth varying from 18 to 36 feet. In from lighthouse Point, on the east shore of the harbour, was a careening wharf, where ships of the largest class could be treated ; while on the other side, but further north, extended a row of buildings containing naval stores. ()n the west side, directly opposite to and facing the entrance, w-as a strong defensive work called the Grand oi Royal Battery, armed with twenty -eight 42 pounders and two 18 pounders. As already mentioned, the town proper occupied the greater part of a triangular-shaped jiiece of ground which lay between the sea and the south-western end of the harbour. It covered an area of about 100 acres, and its site was elevated several feet above the level of the land 2 « o OQ M o Em O CO a? o H >< U H at o b Q SB < H U H Eh O iz; < I.OUISBOURd : AN HISToRICAIi HKETCH. 19 to the west and north, whidi was, as u rule, low antl swamiiy. ^^^ founders, possil^Iy from un|tleasaut experience of tortuous lanes in cities in the Old World, and in Quebec in the; New, laid out Louishourg in a regular and precise manner. Six wide streets ran oast and west, seven ran north and south ; the houses, as a rule, wore of wood, but with stone foundations. The fortress of Louisbourg was one of enorniou« strength ; nothing to etjual it had ever been seen on this continent, and it was aptly termed the Dunkirk of Ameriia,— a simile which, a century and a half ago, was e i'c.n face, lu'twccMi the I'rinci'as and Hrouillan hastions, a palisade and ditch heing the sole defences ; hut in front, shoals, rocky islands, and a continuous heavy surf formed an effectual harrier against hostile attack from this cpiartor. Here it may he mentioned that all writers on the subject have stated that the fortifications were not begun >nitil 1720, seven years after the foundation of the place. This statement must be taken with consider- able (pialitication. Louisbourg was by no means without fortificuntions for the first six or seven years of its existence ; n.iturally one of the very lirtit steps taken was to (;rect defensive works ; and the official correspon- dence and nqiorts from Governor to Minister-* as early as 1715, contain fre((uent reference; to the fortifications, and the progress which was being made on them. Whether tlie.si" works were part of the great system which eventually surroumled the town, or merely of a temporary nature, it is tlifhcult now to s])eak with absolute certainty. The fact that a mculal was struck, l)eariiig the words, " LunovicoHUROUM Funha- TUM Kt Munitum, MDCCXX," lends colour to the latter su}»|)osition ; but the above inscription may have referred to the citadel, and the centr.d and dominating work which surrounded it ; or the word ' fun- datum ' may have l)een used in the .sense of " making secure," a rendering common enough in old days. He this as it may, both record and reason inilicate that fortifications were begun certainly not later than 1715, and also fail to give any ground to the suitposition that the works existing in 1720 were then sup[)lanted by a new system. So .startling and costly a change would undoubtedly have left many traces in the contemporary ofticial letters, reports, and memoranda. The period when they may be fairly considered as completed is also an uncertain one, but a .study of the communications and reports .sent home would indicate that about 17.'i3 the main defensive works were practically finished. True it is that tlie official "correspondence, even as late as 1744, shows that there still remained w(trk to be done ; but it is .safe to con- clude that much of this additional work was tlie result of after-thought, and of the new ideas that suggested themselves from time to time to the chief engineer of the day. As an outcome of one of the many odd phases of human nature, it has been the almost invariable rule in fort- resses and strong defensive works, that each incoming governor, com- mandant, or chief engineer should deem it his bounden duty to suggest LnCISHOUIUi : AX HIHTOUICAt, HKKTCH. -1 nlttTiitioiis and iiilditii)iis, — dftpii very '■oiisitlcnililt! <>iu'h, — to the nrij;iiml plan ; this not ncccssarilv tci ini|ily ii^'nurancf or lack of curt' on tlio part of his itrcih-ccsHors, hut to show to liis snpcrior oHicer that he has u mind and ideas of his own, antl that he is fully up to date in his profes- sion, -in a word, that he is a vahuilile man. Apart from this, it seems iiKlisputalile that for nil practical purposes, the fortifications of I.ouis- liour^' weie conipletod many years hefore tht; arrival of tin; New Kn^'land Armada. As early as 172(S the (Jovernor, de iiroiiillan, in a despatch to the Minister of Marine, states that the fortihcalions are almost linished, and in Otitober, 173.3, he re|)orts that they are completed. Six years later de iirouillan was succeeded hy de Forant, who reported oHicially a few weeks after his arrival : " We have found tlio " fortifications in <,'ood condition, c()nsiderin<,' the fact that in this climate " mortar will ni>t hold when exposed t:t the air ; and this is so well *' known that settlers who have the means to do so, face their house.s " with hoards. M. Verrier has done well in ^'etting the battlenuMits "and remainder of the new enciente faced in that way." Further cor- respondence speaks of more work being nc(;e.ssary ; b>it su<"h undoubtedly had referen(;e to repairs, or additions decided on after the completion of the main defemtes. As to the exact armament of the various works in the spring of 1745, tlnn-e is a wide ditlerence of opinion among the authorities on the subject. The chief fortifications, enclosing the town, had embrasures for 148 guns ; but by what .seems to have l)een extraor- dinary carele.ssne.s.s, there was not much more than half that number of cannon in position. The Royal batttery, on the west side tif the harbour, mounted 18 forty-two-pounders and 2 eighteen-poundcrs ; while the Island battery, which commanded the entrance, had by at-tual count immediately after the surrender, 26 heavy guns aniil)le. Hit, numbers were small— barely ttne- third of those of his opponents ; l)ut his defence was vigorous and whole-hearted. The French commander did his utmost to induce. Mnsearene to ca|tilulate, and swore -that ii formidable naval force was en muff' to take part in the attack ; but the negotiations failed, and, not long afterward.H, the siege came to an inglorious end, Duvivier and bis troops making their way back U) Louisbourg, his expedition an utter failure. His naval auxiliaries did not materialize, and he received ])ractically no aid from the Acadian settlers. Small and insignificant as had been the.se events of the campaign of 1744, they engendered a feeling of marked unrest in the neighboring English colonies ; and especially was this felt in Massachusetts and its capital. A force of .')00 men was organised for frontier defence ; l>ut these, scattered throughout the i)rovince in small detachments, would have been able to render but little aid had Hoston been attacked, an event which might be looked for .so long as the fortress of Loui.slourg existed. And now the (question of the possibility of the removal of this formidable menace began to creep into the brains of some of the bolder of the i)rovincials. We have already .seen that in 1733, Governor Cosby, of the province of New York, in .sending home his r-iport of the visit of a deputation from Louisbourg to purchase food s. jiplie.s, had hinted at the pos.sibility of the capture of that much dreaded fortress. It is more than probable that his veiled suggestions met with no response from their lordships, for there the matter ended. Eight years later his successor in office, Lieutenant-Governor Clarke — a man who had been for almost half a century connected officially with the provincii — devoted one of his lettca-s to the Duke of Newcastle to the subject cf " how we may dispossess the French of the footing they have got on the back of all the Engli.sh colonies on this continent." Here appears the first definite proposal for the capture of the Cape Breton fortress. To ipiote the plain and business-like statement of the veteran governor : 24 LOUISnoL'HG : AN H18T0H1CAI. SKETCH. "To tlu! Northward of the Lake, viz : in Canada and at tlie Ls'and " of Breton the French are stroii<,'or hoth in men anil Fortitications, so " that a mucli greater force will he required to siihdue them ; the " harl)our of I/)uishour<,' at Ih'eton is strongly fortifved and the entrance "defended hv a ilattery of fifty guns, there is de|ith of water snllicient '■ for the higest ships, and the harbor is capahle of containing a very " large fleet ; its situation gives them all the advantages, they cmii wish " for, it secures their own navigation to Qiujbec, and gives them hut too " great opftortunities t() annoy and interrupt our Fishery ; in the Winter " they have few men upon the Island except their garrisons, hut are " secured by the cold, the snow and ice. In sununer they are strength- " ened by the great numbers of men employed in tlieir fishery ; the " only tin)e therefore to attempt with most advantage the taking of the " ]>laco will Ite at the hriaking up of the winter, and before their shi]is " come from France, and this may be done ; for if His Majesty's ships to " he appointed for that service winter at IJoston, they may block up the " harl)or of Louishourg before! any ships from France can arrive there, " and His Majesty's troops may land when the least opposition can be " given them, and for this expedition I am pursuaded that four or five " thousand men may be raised in New England, if the ( )ihcers, as they " wen! for the exjK'dition against the Spaniards he appointed in these '' provinces, but then I presume it will Ite necessary they be disciplined " Ijefore they end)ark, so that if the orders and commissions he sent " over the summer hefore, and a sufficient number of subalterns to " teacli them their exercise, they may l)efore the ensuing spring be fit " for service, hut I presume some veterans from I'lngland will he "absolutely necessary to join the Americans, under the command of an " experienced (ieneral If we take Cape Breton and have constantly " there and at Placentia in those months wherein those seas are »avig- " able, a sufficient number of ships of war to guard our Fishery, they " may intercept the French Ships hound to or from Canada, and thereby " rediic(> that Country to great necessity, and their communicition with " Messasippi being cut off by the means pro[)osed that country will " become an easier corKiuest." Governor Clarke's jjroposal was a shrewd and sensible one, and it fairly well outlines the plan of the expedition which followed. 'I'wo years later he returned to the charge, for in a report sent home in the spring of 1743, entitled, "State of the British Provinces with respect to the French who surround them," he says : " If ever it he thought adviseable to attempt again to take Canada, " the dispossessing the French of their mastery on the Lake and of the " Fort at the Crown point, will greatly facilitate the Enterprize, but " before we begin the work, I j)resume to think we ought to take Caj»e " Breton, a Place well fortifyed, and from whence the French can annoy " our Fishery at Newfoundland, and guard their ov.n navigation to and " from Canada. That place is such a Thorn in the sides of the New l,OUISBOURG : AX HISTOKICAI. SKETCH. 25 *' England jicople, that it.s verj' jirobablo a large body of men may be " raised there to assist in any siicli design. Anil if proper Ofticers are *' .sent from England in the Sniumer to exercise them, they may by the *' ensuing spring be well disciplined, as all their Youth are expert in the " u.se of tire arms, from the unrestrained liberty of Fowling, which " obtains in all the Province-s and I conceive the Spring is the most ^' proper season to attack the place before the Men f>f VViirr and Fishing " Yessells come frcnn France, for in the Winter they have few men *' excejjt the Garrisons, and Boston being a ]iroper Port for our Fleet to " harbour in the Winter, we may bloi.k up the Harbour of 15reton " before the ships from France can come \\]wn the coast." It will be noted that these primary representations of the great desirability of the reduction of Louisbouig came from New York ; the next i)lea emanated from an otHcial of the province of Massachusetts Bay, Judge of His Majesty's Court of Yioe-Atlmiralty for that province and for New Hampshire His pio])OPal is dated from his lodgings in Cecil-street, London, the 9th of April, 1744, but was not published until July of the following year, when it appeared in pamphlet form, entitled, "The lmj)ortance of Cape Jireton to the British Nation, " humbly represented by Robert Auckmuty, Judge, vVc, in New ?]ngland. " N. B. Upon the plan laid down in this representation, the island was *' taken by Commodore Wairen and General Pep])erill on the 14th of "June, 1745." Auckmuty 's proposal also apiieared in the Unith' man's Maijaziue oi that month (July). It suggests an expedition similar in general design to that which set out, and states that there would likely be little or no objection on the part of the provincial governments to bear their sli^re of the burden ; to u.se his own language, " Having " experienced the Iiiyalty of the Ma.ssachusetts for twenty-seven years, " 1 presume to engage they will cheerfully furnish their complenuMit." All the foregoing proposals for the expedition were, be it noted, written by civilians, not soldiers ; and to this fact it may po.«sibly be due that they appear to have evoked no responsive echo in those to whom they were addres.sed. They were for P^nglish eyes alone ; and to the Phiglishman of that day Cape Breton was practically a myth. ( )n the minds of the King's Ministers, colonial matters and colonial troubles sat lightly, and we can well imagine were at this time (juite eclip.sed by the checquered events occurring nearer home. AYar with Spain had been declared in 1739, furced by the merchants and trading clas.ses who had for years felt the strong hand of S})anish re|)ression on their business, and even on their rights, in the South American trade. Unknown to Walpole, England's First Minister, a compact for mutual 26 I/JUISBOURU : AN HISTORICAIi SKETCH. aiil existed between Spain and France; and tlie latter sotm joined forces against Britain. The combination was a strong one and had the best of it during the earlier years of the war ; anil Walpole, who had strenu- ously supported a peace policy, was forced to resign office early in 1742. For a year or two Lord Carteret (afterwards f^arl (Iranville) directed foreign att'airs. and during his regime th(.' decisive victory at iJettingen brightened English hopes In 17-14 nothing of great moment was effected by the naval and military forces, and during that year and tiie following winter and s|)riiig ])ublic attention w,is absorbed in politics, a change of ministry occurring in November. We may safely conclude that even those residents of England who were aware of the existence of such a place as Louisbourg, selilom allowed the subject of its rela- tion to their Am(;rican dependencies to pre.sent itself over-frequently to their minds. Little did either Ministry or people think that during that winter there was being evolved, far off i!i New England, a project, the result of which would have no small eH'ect on old-world policy. We have seen that the small post at Can.so had been taken by an expedition from Louisbourg early in 1744. The British garrison had been brought to that fortress as prisoners of war, but subsequently were sent to lioston ; and, after their arrival there, it would have been more than strange had not their chief topic of conversation been about their residence in the French citadel. The idea of an attack on the fortress was freely discussed, and the benefits to be derived from its capture were enlarged upon ; but no action was taken until about the end of 1744, when it entered into the mind of a New Hamp.shire geutleman-trader, William Vaughan by name, that the much dreaded Louisbourg could perhaps be captured by an expedition, chiefly if not wholly from the New England colonies. Vaughan was a man in the prime of life, well educated, and of good social position ; he had irrepressible energy, and when embarked on an undertaking i)ut forth more than ordinary deter- mination to accomplish his ends. In the latter trait he was fully etpialled by the then governor of iMassachusetts Bay, William Shirley, an Englishman, trained to the law, but with an uncommon interest in military matters, and no small conceit of his as yet undeveloped ability in this line. To Shirley, Vaughan propounded his pl.in ; it was as a sjtark to the train, and the tire ran swiftly. Nothing could have pleased the Governor better than to father such a propo.sal, and without delay he called together the (ieneral Court of Ma.ssachu.setts — the little Parlia- LOUISBOURG : AN HISTORICAL SKETCH. 27 ment wliich liold sway over the colony — niul, after swearing ihe mem hers to absolute secrecy, lie laid befcre them the proposal for an attack on the C'i])e IJreton cajntal, o'ld asked their authorization of the neces- sary ways and means. It was a startling suggestion to the quiet and peace-loving legislators who conijosed the Court, and, with the j)rospect before them of j)robable great loss in money and men, it is not sur- prising that after several days deliberation they rejected the scheme. But in the meantime the news had leaked out — possibly, as Pepperrell's biographer tells us, thro igh the religious fervor of one of the members of the Court whose prayers for Divine guidance in this momentous question were so loud as to be overheard. Shirley and another well- wisher to the scheme, James Gibson, drew uj) a petition to the Assembly praying that they reconsider their decision, and had it signed by a large number of >«ew England merchants, to whose trade I.ouisbourg had been a deadly enemy. This carried great weight. Vaughan and Shirley put forth all their energy and powers of persuasion. The Assembly reconsidered their decision, .'>nd finally, by a majority of one, authorised the expedition. This all-important preliminary settled, recruiting was briskly gone on with, and the neighbouring provinces were promptly called on for aid in men and shipping. Shirley no doubt was sanguine that hearty and generous responses would follow his appeal ; but if so he was quickly undeceived. Each colony was jealous of its neighbour, and the patiiotism of each was of the most narrow type ; — domiiuited by self- interest it was confined to provincial limits and existed solely for provincial ends. The sj)irit of Imperialism which now runs so .strongly through Greater Biitain had no counter-part in the British America of 1745. Although France was the common enemy, and Louisbourg the common menace, only three provinces — New Hamp- shire, Connecticut and Khode Island— could be induced to ptomise to give substantial aid in men to the expediticn. New Hampshire guaran- teed a regiment of five hundred men, of whom one hundred and fifty were to be paid by Massachu.setts ; Connecticut, soldiers to the num- ber of five hundred and sixteen, on condition that one of her officers should be second in command. Rhode Island, at first generous enough to jiromise one hundred and fifty fighting men, subsequently decided to limit her help to an armed vessel. New York, the richest of all the provinces, was naturally looked to for a measure of assistance befitting her premier position ; but in spite of the earnest ett'orts of Governor 28 LOUISBOURO : AN HISTOKICAI. SKETCH. Clinton, the Assenibl}' — wlin as a whoh; were singularly lackini,' in patriotism and public spirit — would only vote the ))altry sum of £3000, after debating the question for a fortnight. The governor, justly incensed at this and other evasions of duty, dismis.sed them to their homes ; and then busily applied himself to aid the New England troops by forwarding them ten pieces of cannon — a nuist useful and timely gift. The new A.ssembly did not meet until the ^oth of June, and would then only increase the grant to £aOOO. The energetic governor subsequently raised by subscription £l'000 for provisions for the New England men, as much more for clothing, and £900 for gunpowder. But all's well that ends well ; and as the Ilritish Govern tnent subse- quently repaid the entire cost of the expedition, the meagre measure of aid given to Mas.sachusetts in this patriotic enterprise made no jiracti cal ditterence to her treasury. The command of the whole expedition was given to William Pepperell, a merchant of Kittery, then a part of Massachusetts. The choice was an excellent one in every way. He had little or no martial training, but was by no means deficient in courage : he had tact, a quiet temper, and above all, a fund of good common sense. As a citizen- soldier he could better handle a newly raised army of like nature than could one trained to the letter of strictest discipline, and to the com- mand of veterans. Pepperell was at thi« time in his forty-ninth year. Within seven weeks the little army was recruited, and all necessary preparations for the expedition completed. The call for active service against the French had nmt with a ready response from the hardy yeomen of Mas.sachusetls, those from Maine (then a part of the first- named province) being especially eager, in oli'ering their services. There was apparently no age limit, nor was a medical examination deemed necessary ; .seeming good health and vigour, ami fieedom from physical defects, comprised the tpialifications for acceptance. Each man was to receive pay at the rate of twenty-five shillings provincial currencv a month, but supplieil hi^ own arms and uniform, of which a scarlet coat or tunic formed part. When completed, the force compri.sed eight regi- ments from Massachusetts, commanded respectively by Colonels Brad.'^treet, Waldo, 1) wight, Moulton, Willard, Hale, Richmond and Gorham. Colonel Ihiir was in command of the Connecticut regiment, while the New Hampshire battalion was led Ijy Cohinel (iorham. General Wo'cott of (vonnecticut was second-in-command of the whole force. The total strength was 4070 men, 3250 of whom were from Massachusetts, 516 from Coniu^iticut, and 30+ from New Hampshire. LOLISBt)UReen <[uietly l)ut powcM'fully at work adding force to the crusade. While drawing his main strength from New England, in men, money and ships, Shirley had not been forgetful of other potent strings to his l)ow. I>y a happy measure of foresight — one which turned out to V)e that on which the final success of the attack hinged — he had, in the fall of 1744, written to the I)uke of N(!wcastle to say that .some of the King's ships would probably lie required on the New England and Nova Scotian coast to protect the fisheries from French attack ; whereupon the Duke of Medford, First Lord of the Ailmiralty, instrucled Commodore Peter Warren — then in chief command of the North Anu;ricau squaibon — to .sail for lioston ami act with Shirley in the furtherance of IJritish interests. Despatch vessels were very slow sailers in those days, and before these instruc- tions reached Warren he had received word direct from Shirley, convey- ing the startling news of the New England expedition, and a.sking for more assistance. As the ])roject tlid not have the King's sanction, Warren declined to help; but on receipt of the instructions frreparations for a warm rece[)tion to these unasked and unwelcome visitors'! To the discretlit of the governor, Duchambon, the answer must be a negative one. Severril historians of tlie campaign have stated that the garrison was entirely ignorant of the e.xistence of the expedition until the ships were visible ; but this .seems difficult to credit, from the fact of the long wait at Caiiso, the skirmishes there with French and Indians (some of whom would assuredly have sent word to the town) and the appearance of the war-vessels in front of the X ,-.1 'n'l(i.^,i(jf V(jj/;'!;'i?im/T^ 'Hi*! V i a ? g>5 ii^ L. ""m§m CO o s o o« M CO CO Q < o CO o (4 o o i LOUISUOURO : AN HISTOBICAIi SKETCH. 88 fortress for so many days previously. In fact a certain unit[iio paiupliletL /^ ^/i^ (" Lettre d'uno liabitat de Loui.^hourg ") quoted by Parkiuan, states that/ ' ' the {garrison had lieard of the proposed expedition, hut judged the! news too iniprol)abU; to he true. Duohauihon — shariiijj; in the thorough contempt in whicli French officers held militia— doubtless pooh-ixjoheil the whole atfair, and laughed at the idea of such men taking such a for- tress. Deyond having stationed a detachment of forty nuin on the shore of the bay to watch for and resist a landing, the French com- mandant appears to have made absolutely no jjreparitions to meet the incoming wave, although so big and vehement in its hostility to France. But he was rudely startled from any sense of comparative security which he may have entertained, by the appearance, on the morning of the 30th of A])ril, of a vast cloud of transports under British colours, their decks crowded with scarlet-clad foenien ; and he hastily s(mt out eighty men under command of a trusty officer, to prevent the landing of the invade'-s. Here PepperroH's rough-and-ready commcn .sense was more than a match for the formal methods of the French commander. He made the ])retence of attemi)ting to land a few boat-loads of men at a place called Flat Point, about three miles from the town ; but recalled them to the Hag- ship and then suddenly sent them off at hot .speed to F'reshwater Bay, a little inlet about a mile and a half to the westward. The French ran to intercept them, but the boats reached the appointed spot first ; and the !New Englanders hastily landing, dashed at their enemies, killed six, took as many jiri-soncrs, and drove the rest headlong into the town. Morpain, the French commander, was one of those captured. First blood had now been shed, and the invading Britons, raw militia though they were, had shown no signs of funk — in fact ([uite the reverse. So far everything had re.sultcul in their favour. A host of other boats of the fleet, all crowded with men, followed close in the wake of the attacking party, and soon secureil their footing on shore Two thousand men were landed that day, followed on the morrow by the remainder of the force. Once established they quickly made them- selves at home and, after spending a night in the open with little or no shelter, they moved towards the town and pitched their tents on the banks of a little stream near ¥lat Point, about two miles from the walls of the fortress. Much latitude appears to have been given by Pepperrell to his regimental commanlers, for it is on record that at least one of these officers formed his encampment considerably nearer the town than did the rest of the army ; but his tents were soon a mark for thtj enemy's gunners, and he and his men had to beat a hasty retreat. 3 84 LOUISHOUKO : AN HIHTOHIfAI- MKETCII. Tlio liritish gtMu nil lost no time in nsploss dflay. With him, probably in the cajJiK-ity of a slatl'-otHcer, was Vaiiyhan, the ori<,'inator o the exiieilitioii and ont' of its most zealous otfictTs. To !iim wa? (intrusted the playing of tiic first rard in tluf giime now bej^inning ; and he played it uncommonly well. As soon as the troojis were landed he was desp.itched by Pepperrell at the head of a party of four hundred men, towards the nortli-east end of the harbour, to gain information and to do all possible (himag(.' to the enemy. With an audaeity of which oidy militia would l)e capable, the detachment, when on the high ground opposite the town, halteil and gave three duiers ; they then ]troceeded to their destination, avoiding the Royal battery i-ii nniti: (which, as we have Ijefore noted, was a strong and heavily-nrmed work on the iinrth shore) and burnt all the naval storehouses which were tlotted alo'-g the bank of the north-eact harbour. A dense smoke arose, which, wafted into the Royal battery, added to the fears of its garrison. Thierry, tlie commanding officer, had already recommended to I)uchambon that the battery be aljandonetl, the cannon spiked, and tht; works Ijlown u[). This advice the governor had determined to follow, except the demoli- tion of the works, to which the King's engineer, Verrier, had olijected. In a sensele.ss panic, Thierry and his men now hurried over to the town, spiking the guns it is true, but leaving a most valuable lot of ordnance stores intact. IJut all tliis was then unknown to Vaughan and his detachment. They spent the night in the neighboui hood of the burning storehouses, and in the morning were returning to camp in an irregular manner when Vaughan, with a party of sixteen men, while passing the battery noticed its apparent ab.sence of life ; struck by this, he stopped, and bribed a friendly Indian to reconnoitre. The work was empty. Vaughan and his handful of men ran in and took possession, and with- out delay sent a. messenger to General I'epperrell stating that they liad entered the Royal battery, and were waiting for a reinforcement and a flag. To make temporary amends for the latter, one of the men, William Tufts by name, doffed his red coat, gripped it with his teeth, and, with reckless bravado, climbed the flag-staH' and made fast the scarlet symbol at the to]>. AVhen the gunners in the town .saw the improvised bunting tlu-y hurled at it a shower of shot but to no e'ftect. Seeing but a small party of the invaders in po.s.se.ssion, a French detach- ment of a hundred men was hastily sent to re-occupy the battery, their main ol>ject, doubtless, being to bring off' the valuable stores which had been left there ; lint Vaughan and his handful of men ran down to the LOUISHoUHli : AN IlISTtJlUCAr- HKKTCH. 35 beiutli, and in tho most coiiriij^i'oiis iniimicr stood there tiriii;,' on the honts. Ill tlie iiiuaiitiiiie IV-ppent'll liad hurried oH' a iviiifoireiiieiit whicii caiiK! lo Viiuj^'haii's assistamo at this critical juncture, and tho Freuchnion returned to the shelter of th<'ir fortress. It is iinpoHsillo to overestimate the value of this aey a gmg of two hundred soldiers. The base of the artillery attack was a clum[i of hills which lay due north of the town ; and here on the 4th of May, the besiegers opened fire fntin a battery of four light i)ieees of c union and three mortars, two of which were, however, found useless. < )n the 7th, ten coehorns were placed in jMisition at a s|)ot 900 yards from tho town ; and within a few days, this battery was striMigthened by tho accession of eight 22-pr. guns, and by those from the battery which had been fir.-t arected. The tire from this, and from tlie Royal battery, was most destructive ; the shot tore through the walls, knocked over houses, and caught tlie citadel and King's bastion in flank. Five hundred men manned these b.itteries ; and all ammunition, stores and provisions for their use had to be trans[iorted through the knee-deep mud from the camp at liead-(iuarter.s, two miles distant, (lovernor Shirley — but a theorist in military matters — had expected the immediate capitulation of the fortress, having planned (on paper) for its complete surprise. This may account in jiart for the woeful lack of stores, which was one of the Teatuies of the expedition ; but the ignorance of its leaders on all mat- ters — except courage and pluck — which constitute military elHciency, 30 LOUIHIIOUIUI : AN lltHTOUICAL KKICTCH. was lit) tloubt iii.iiiily ri's|>(tnsible for the (U'Hiii'Ucit'H which uxistcHl — ileficiiMicieH wliich rcHultiMl in a vast deal of nicknesp, iniu-h loss of life, and, but for weather extraordinarily favourable, inif^ht have brouj^ht ftbout the utter failure of the expedition. For the iiieii lacked tentf, extra clothiii<,', often even necessury food ; and in spite of their mwon- (lueral)le H|»irit, an epideniii; of sickness cimi},' to the camp, as luiiny (18 Hftoen hundred men Ixfin^ down at one tin)e. lUit Pepperrell and his militia-men stuck to their j^uns, tired them 80 constantly (and, possibly, so injudiciously) during the day that many of them burst, and, \inder cover of ni<^ht and foj,', toiled anil strove at bringing? fresh batteries into play closer to the city walls. ( )n the Kith, the coehoruH auvl two other mortars were jaishcd forward to a point about 440 yards from the west <,'at<.' of the town ; and, on the next day an advanced battery was planted at a distance of only 2oO yards from the west gate. This was armed with 18 and 42 pounders, draggeil at night by s([uads of men from the Royal battery, two miles tlistant by road. On tiie 20th, more heavy guns were put in position on a piece of rising ground opposite the west gate, across the hnrliour. This last was kiiiiwn as Titcomb's battery, from the otHcer of that name in com- mand. From morning till night these groups of cannon kept hammerinf* away at the F'rench fortifications, and also did a vast deal of damage to the buildings of the town itself. There was a great scarcity of experi- enced gunners among the New Fhigland men, and many and disastrous were the accidents which happened ; the bursting of cannon was of daily occurrence, and almost as many men were disabled from this cause as from the fire of the enemy. With the excej)tion of the ten guns given by New York, those which had been brought over proved in many instances worse than useless. F'rom the very beginning of the siege the two commantVrs, Warren and Pe])perrell, acted in close concert. The former appears to have been an excellent type of the naval oflicer of that day — brave, imijul- sive, strong in his convictions, and inclined to he overbearing in his demeanour towards soldiers and civilians. Had a fiery and hot-tempered warrior been in command of the New Fhiglaiul forces, it is more than l)robable that continual clashing would have ensued l)etween the two chiefs, with the result of serious harm to the service on wliich they were employed ; but as it was, Pepperrell's calmness, good natuie and good sense enabled him to discuss and plan arrangements with Warr(?li in the most amicable manner, and to ignore those ebullitions of ai)parent i.dL'iMUouiKi : AN msrouicAi, hketoh. 87 tt'inpt'i' which at tiiiu's cinpiu'tl out in the corrt'siioiKh'iu'i' of the iiiipii- tioiit coiniiio(h)ic!. Ilotli wtTi! htyal ami (Mithiisiastic iWitons and equally zi'alous for tho siiocoss of HIh Maji'wty's arms. The t\v(t coiniiinmleis, alike uiitiaiiied in the somewlint tedious methods of military en^'ineering, and with little sympathy for the slow formalities of a methodical siege, were lient on bringing matters to a crisis with least possihh; delay. The hattery on the island at the entrance to the harl)our— a heavily-armed and well-defendetl work — was a /"/»' iinir to "Warren, eager to work his ships into the port and assLst in the honi- bardment ; and three or four days aft<'r th»! landing a joint attack on this hattery was talked of, to come oH" as soon as IVpperrell's guns were in jiosition. On the 7th, the ilritish lead(;r summoned the town to surrender — an invitation which was promptly declined by Duchambon ; following which, Warren uiged a night attack on the island, ami on three successive evenings preparations were made for the assault ; on each occasion rough weather prevented the embarkation. The storming of the town itself was decided on for the night of the 9tli ; but soon after the decision, more jiruilent thoughts prevailed, and the attack was jio.stponed. The energies of the New Kngland men were then con- centrated on the bombardment and on the work of pushing their batteries closer to the town — work most laborious and demanding all the avail- ul)Ie strength of the little army. lioth Warren and Pejiperrell had before this written lor more men and stores, the former to the govern- ments of tile southern coloidt s, the latter to Shirley. Eighteen trans- ports were sent io Uoston to liring the expected reinforcenu-nts, but failed to return during the period of the siege. Up to this time tho chief work tiud honcmrs of the campaign had fallen to the share of the land forces ; to Warren's .^([uadron, hitiierto confined to a passive and uneventful blockade, the oi)portunity now came to take a more active share in hostilities. On the 19lh of Mfty they saw a large man-of-war under French colours, making for the entrance to the harl'our. This waf the ]'ii/i/ai>f, a sixty-four gun vessel, commanded by the Marquis de la Maison Forte, and carrying stores and munitions of war for the beleagured garrison. Intercepted and atticked by the Uritish f ruisers she nnule a brave tight ; but, single-handed, she had small chance of success, and finally had to strike her Hag after a loss of eighty men. Her cargo proved a most welcome addition to the commissariat and ordnance stores of the besiegers, tiie latter of which at this time was at a low ebb. Pepperrell's stock of powder and heavy 38 LOUISBOUKG : AN IIISTOHICAL SKETCH. shot was, ill fact, entirely finished long Iwfore tli« end of ^Fay, and his necessities were theri^after supplied by the naval authorities. Warren began to receive accessions to his little fleet, which, at the beginning of June, stood as fallows : Superb, 40 guns Cupt. Soniers. FMIiam, 40 n n Durell. Lauweton, 40 m i, (Jalmadv. Mermaid, 40 <\ t Douglas. Priw'pss Mart/, GO n n Eilwards, Hector, 40 .i ., Cornewall. Viijilaiit, 64 h n Montague. In addition to these there were the Provincial cruisers which have been, already mentioned. The whole Hotilla was now kept on the qui rire in the expectation of attack from a strong French sipiadron which had been fitted out at Brest, and of which the VKjilant was supposed to have been the fore- runner. This intensified tiie fiery commodotii's anxiety to gain possession of Louisbourg prior to possible reverses by sea or by land ; for rumouns were current that a strong expedition of French and Indians were on the way to attack the New England troops in rear. The fact that more than one-third of the latter wcru unfit for duty by reason of sickne.'^s did not make the prospect more du'ering ; and Warren vehemently urged on Pe))perrell the necessity for an assault on the town, sending him (on the 24th of May) a proposition embudying full details. These were not agreeal)le to Pe])perr('irs officers, and the storming of the place was therefore deferred ; but .'i immediate attack on the island battery had been deciiled on, and • ii.'dniglit on tlu; L'Gth about three hundred men put oil' in small boats ti. make the assaidt. This appears to have been informally and irregularly arranged, and was far le.ss (;reditable ta those who planned it than to those wlu> took part in its dangers. The latter seem to have electted their own officers for the occasion — a thing in itself flagrantly subversive of discipline — and, under command of a man nanieil Brooks, pulled quietly for tlie island. The l)oats reached its shores safely, but found a very contracted landing place. When about one-half of the party had been safely diseml)arked, they had the imprudence to give three loud cheers ; the French garrison sprang to arms and opened a heavy and effective fire on their a.s.sailants and on the crowded mass of boats waiting to land their living cargoes. The rear vessels sheered oti" and got out of range as ipiickly as possible ; and LOUISBOURU : AN HISl'oRICAl. SKKTCH. 39 althoii<,'li the men on shore maile n hold dash for the ramparts and even succeeded in planting scaling ladders against the walls, they were i)rac- tically at the mercy of tiieir opponents. They made a plucky tight of it till daybreak, and then surrendered at discretion. Their total lo.ss in killed, wounded, and pri.sonera was one hundred and eighty-nine men. The effects of tho.se three hasty cheers made a sad hole in the little English army. This reverse was a startling lesson in discipline to the besiegers ; Vjut instead of disheartening, it nerved them to new efforts. ( Jorham's regiment hud been encamped at Lighthouse I'oint, at the eastern end of the entrance to the harl)our, and directly opposite to the island battery. It was now iletermined to put heavy guns in position at this point, and to endeavom' to crush out tlie effectiveness of the French work by artillery tire. Strong working parties wen; forthwith employed on the duty (if transporting heavy cannon and mortars from the, main attack to this position ; l)Ut the work was necessarily slow and most laboriou.*, and it was the 11th of June before any guns were ready to open tire. For their reception and defence (iorham and his men had built a strong battery, with embrasures directly flanking the line of French cannon on the island. Kvery shot told ; and the island battery, which had so long dividerning the accepted theories of slow and laborious attack — worked forward their batteries in a manner which almost .savored of bravado, and which, as in the strife of line against column of later days, startled their machiiuvtrained opponents. No aid 40 LouisnouRo : an historical sketch. came to the hosioged from their allies in the vicinity. The New Eng- Iftnd troojis Imtl made several forays on the neighbouring settlements, burnt hou.ses, l)arns and boats, and established fi)r them.y the writers of that day to Warren and his tars, and to their share in the successful consummation of the enterprise, although we know how essential it was ; almost the whole praise Wiis bestowed on the provincial troops and their leader. Rewards and honours were piomi)tIy forth- coming, and tukens of public joy were, as in America, immediately shown. Captain ^fontague, who carried to London the official account of the surrender, received from the Admiralty a jiresent of five hundred guineas ; salutes weri; tired from the Tower as soon as the intel- ligence had been received, while at night the city was ablaze with bonfires and illuminations. Warren was promoted to the rank of Rear- Admira!, and Pepperrell had the honour of being appointed a Haronet of Great Britain, and was also given the King's commission to rai.se and command a regiment of the line. To Shirley a similar commission was granted. LOUISUOURO : AN HISTOKICAL SKETCH. 46 Louishourj,' was now under British colours, and held by a l^ritish- Anierican garrison. Almost immediately aftt-r the surrender heavy wet weather set in, and the site of the late besiej^ers' camp became an uninhabitable swamp. Here was a singular instance of tlie extraordinary good luck which attended the exjtedition, for had the rain come earlier, or had the surrender been delayed, it would have been almost impossiI)le for Pepperrell to have maintained his ground. In th<} best of weather a very large proportion of liis men were unfit for duty, and heavy rains would have been absolutely fatal to the continued manning of his works and batteries. And yet the winning of the town brought fresh trouljles to the simple and impecunious New England men. 15y the greater number of these Louisbourg was .supposed to be a city of vast wealth, and visions of the glittering booty which would be theirs if successful had doubtless been ^.strong incentive in their stead fa.stne.ss. Hut there was little gold and silver and precious stones in the Cape Ih'eton capital ; and what there was must remain in the hands of its lawful owners. It was galling to the once expectant Xew Knglanders to have to mount guard over the houses of the vanqnished foe ; but, alas, such was their duty immediately after the surrender. They broke loose at times, however, from the restraints of discipline. As a contemporary chronicler (([uoted by Parkman) puts it : " A great Noys and hubbub a mongst ye Soldiers a bout yc Plunder ; Som Cursing som a Swarein ;" and it is recorded by one of their generals that on a Sunday when Father Moody was holding service there was " exce.ssive stealing in every part of the town." This feeling of lack of sufficient recompen.se for their services was intensiKed at a later date when rich harvests of spoil came to the men of the fleet, who liad endured little toil in the siege, and had suH'ered practically no loss. In the attack on Louisbourg, as has often been the case, the glory fell to the share of the aimy ; the gold and silver to the navy. The famous French fortress was now transformed into a bustling Uritish garrison town and naval depot. The .scarlet uniforms of the landsmen and the blue jackets of the tars dotted the streets ; but hard work was the order of the ointed governor l\v the Home authoiities, but Pepperrell remained in command of the provincials ; thus a joint control was exercised over the fortunes of the town and its garri.sou. It was no sinecure ; the duties involved considerable labour, and calleretoii to France was looked at with the utmost disfavour both in England and the British colonies in Anjerica ; and especially galling to national pride was that clau.se which provided that two English noblemen should be sent to France on the conclusion of the treaty to remain there as hostages until the surrender of Louisbourg should be completed. Even the Pretender Prince, then a defeatetl and di.sappointed exile, had enough British pride to say : " If ever I mount the throne of my ancestors, Euro[ie shall see me use uiy utmost endeavours to force France in her turn to send hcstages to England." The ett'cct of Britain's brilliant naval victories was more than counterbalanced by the excellent general- ship of the famous Marshal 8axe in Flanders, and the disastrous alliance in which Hanoverian policy had entangled British troops. The English ministry of that day was deplorably weak, and French diplomacy scored a brilliant triumph ; Cape Breton, so gallantly won, wa.« the sacrifice offered on the Gailic altar. With peace came the repayment to the American colonies of the total expenses they had incurred in the expedition against Louisbourg. The division was as follows : £ .s (f To Ma.ssachusetts Bay imUi) 2 7 New Hampshire KKioii 18 4 Connecticut 2HS(5:i 10 1 Rhode I.sland m:i2 12 10 James Gibson, (an ofticer in the Pro- vincial army who bail served with- out pay or allowance) 547 15 £2:^749 2.S 10(1 This sum was paid over in hard cash, silver and copper, sent to Boston in H. M. S. Mermaid. It proveil to be financial salvation to 4 so LOUIMHOL'RO : AN IIISTOKICAI. rtKKTCH. MassiuiliUHottH. Tliat iHDviiau was in debt tn ilic cxtciit of two niillion liuunds currency ; niul as one jtojiml stt'ilin^' was worth duvt'ti pouiiils of the old tenor curreney, and thirty shillings of the new, tlie inovineial ruh'rs were able to buy in ahnost the entin; del)t. Hack to Louisbourg duly came tlie Fren';l» in tht; early summer of 1749. M. Deshorbiers was the new governor, and he l)rought with hini tlie two larj^est ships in the French navy, and twenty t!ans|iorts carryinj^ the new garrison. Hero he found IJritish red-(;oats .still in po88e.wsion, their shipiiing not having arrivfd ; and, anxious no doubt to .»ritisli, and published a valua1)le and interesting book on Cape Breton, now of considerable rarity. Raymond was a capable othcer, and spent 100,000 livres in ojjening a road from Louisbourg to Port Toulouse, — a work for which he was severely censured by the authorities at homo. In November of the same year he reported the discovery of coal near La Uaie Kspagnol, (Sydney), and wished to form a fortified .settlement there without delay. He was evidently of an arbitrary temper, was continually quarrelling with the connnissary, and in 1753 was recalled at his own request. To succeed him M. d'Aillel)out came out from France in Decem- ber ; but his reign did not exceed twejve months, and M. de Druconr was installed as governor at the end of 1754. During the?e years few matters worthy of special mention occurred in the town. In Acadia the war — if such it can be called — was being carried on, and items concerning its varied fortunes occupied a large share of the ofhcial corres[)ondence. Louisbourg still called loudly for recruits, provisions, arms and stores of all kinds, indicating either a culpable degree of neglect on the jiart of the Home authorities, or a high degree of elhciency on the [lart of the English men-of-war cruising on the station, in ca[)turing French supi)ly vessels biiund for the port ; and, from the correspondence, it would seem that this was the real cause of the dearth. The peace between the two p.owers had been to a large extent a nominal one so far as America wus concerned ; petty acts of hostility — 62 I.OUlSBOUItO : AN HISTOUICAI, SKKTCII. resulting' in tlic; !i<,'j^n'^fato in tlii' Id^^s of niiniy lives — occurnul almost continuoUHly, ;in(l i\w. rciiowiil of warlike operations on a lar^u scale, was folt by all to be ii certainty in tlie near fiiMire. in tlie sprin*,' of 175r> matters came to a crisis, ami altiiouf,'li war bad not been oUieially (bu-lared, botb France and P^ngland sent laij^e armaments across tlie Atlantic. Certain vessels from eacb fleet came across eacb otber, — a fi;,'lit followcnl, and two of tbe Frencli sbips were, early in .Inne, captnred and taken into Halifax. Tliia was tantanionnt to a declaration of war, and bostili- ties on a larf^e and lively scale followed in ([iii'-k su(;('ession. I'artof tbe Frencli flotilla was for Louisl)our<,', and tbe <,Mrrison tbereby received a large addition to its stren<,,'tb. ( bi IIk^ "Jlst tbe residents of tbe town were startled by tbe a])pearan(!e of tbe wbole iSrilisb s([iiadron wbicb drew up oj^posite tbe entrance in tiglitl\:j,* array, and for tbe next ten days cruised along tbe (Jape Breton coast, prewnting all (communication between Louisbourg aivl tbe outside world. On tbe 1st of. Inly, tbey reappeared l)e,i'oK, e town, ancbored in order of battle, and ajiiJarently made ])r(;parati()ns for an assault ; but in tbe nigbt vanisbed as >uddeidy aa tbey bad come. Tliat summer was a most eventful one in Nova Scotian bistory ; Fort [leausejour was taken, and tbe Acadiaiis, still as a body opposing Knglisb rule, were expelleil from tln^ (country ; l>ut Louisbourg remaineJ inidisturbed. In September, tbe King, evidently uneasy as to tbe security of tbe town, sent out anotber frigate to aid in its defence ; and at tbe .same time assunsil tin; governor " Tbat wbatever "occurs in Canada, Louisbourg requires tlie greatest attention, and be is " disposed to l)estow s'ldi upon it." Tbus, douI)ly fortilied l)y royal deed and word, tbe olllcials waited witb contid(Mice fresb dev(dopments. 'l"be almost unncces.sary oflicial declarations of war were made early in tbe following summer ; by Kngland on tbe IStb of May, by France on tbe 9tb of .Inne. Long before tin's tbe rival lleets bad been making ready, and Louisbourg was not forgotten by eitber party ; and in tluc formal instructions given in April to Admiral .lobn Hyng — afterwards tbe sca])(^goat for tbe sins of a weak ministry — tbat luifortunate ofHcer was din.'cled to assist in strengtbening tbe force wbi(di was to operate on tbe Cape lireton coast. Hut tbe Fienidi were well prepared, and altbougb twice attackeil by a strong s(iuadron uniUn- Commodore Hohnes, tlu^y, altbougb deflated, were enabled to avoid any serious disaster ; on(^ sbip of war and one storesbip being tbeir only loss. Tbese vessels — carrying about six buiidreil and lifty men, and a large quantity of stores — were taken into Halifax. I.OIJISBOURG : AN IllHTOIUOAL SKETCH. 53 TIk^ control of Itiitisli iutiMosts in Aiiicricii was now vested in tlio Ivii'I of London, an oHiccr wliosc conduct of tlu! war l»a.s met with criticism mainly of iin unfavoiiriildi' niitiirc. l»,v some writiM-s In- liiis hccii (condemned in the most nnsparin;^' terms ; from other? he lias received a certnin measure of defence. A ialjorod argument of forty-live piintod pages was pnhlisiied in his hehalf early in 17.')8, in which the writer — to his own siitisfaction in any ca.se — ac(|uitted the nohli; call of all imj)ut(!d errors in judgment and tardines-s in action, One thing in clear, aiii! that is that his ell'orts were nn(|Uestiuned failures. He was a man of ordinary |iiirts ; whiles tliat cam|iaign to have heen a success, called for a leader lirilliimt in conception, (|uiclv in action, and abounding in tact. In these ((ualities Lord I^oudon was singularly deficitMit. In the fall of 1700 he propcrsed to th(! ministry a plan of campaign for the following summer, which had for its lir.st and main object, the reduction of L'Hiisbourg. This met with their concurrence ; but their l)art of tlie programme, the despatch of a large Heet and a powerful military force to (;o-oj)enit(^ with Loudon, w.is performed in so dilatory a manner, that it was not initil the fifth of May that the licet left England. It reached Halifnx (the pre-arranged rendezvous) early in July, where its commander, Vicc-.\dmiral llolhourne, found Loudon with about .'^Ik thousand troo|is just iirrived from New York. The combined forces now luunbered at least eleven thousand men, and twenty-two sliips- of-\var were in the harbour icidy to c(»nvey them to immediate! attack on the Cape I'.icton capitnl. l!ut the worthy commander-in-chief was seized with sudden fear that his men were ihsulliciently drilled, and that tin; com- missariat stones rtMpiiied ri'pK'iii.-iiing ; a brilliant .series of sham lights and other manu'uvres was indulged in, and much time and care ilevoted to planting large ([uantiti^s of vegetaliles to grace the me.s.s-taliles. This work occupied all hands fully until the 1st of August, when it was thought to be time to go en with the main object of their (expedition ; the troojis were leisurely embarked, and all was ready, when on the 4th, a .scliooner arrivi'd from Newfoundland with news that the enemy had got together in Louisbiung harbour a Heet of twenty-three; large! vesst!l.>j, and that the foi tress was garrisoiicil by a forct! of not less than seven thousand men. To the Kiiil of Loudon this was most alarming intelli- gence. His most active brigiulier. Lord Charles Hay, had been placed under arrest a few tlays liei'ore for having stated that the commander-in- chief's policy had resulted in "keeping the .soldiers' courage at bay, aixl " expending the n.itiou's wea'th in making sham-lights an.i planting 54 LouisBouno : an hihtohical sketch. " ciibhages "; and liis lordship's right-hand iimii now was Major-General James Abercroniby — notorious, if not immortal, for the way in which lie conducted the siege of Ticonderoga, and tlie cami)aign of 1758. A council-of-war was held, and it was decided to give up the enterprise. Loudon left some of the troops to garrison Halifa.x, sent off detachments to Forts Cumberland and Annapolis, and returned to New York with the remainder. l>ut the attempt was not wholly al)andoned. Admiral Holbourne made a reconnaissance in force towar.Is Louisbourg ; and on his return to Halifax, finding that a reinforcement of four ships-of-the line had just arrived, determined tocrui.se ott' the Cape llreton coast, and try to tempt tlie French admiral to come out and risk an engagement. He returned, but the Fren(;hman declined the invitation, and remained snugly sheltered in the harbour ; and on the night of the 24th of Sep- tember a furious gale burst on the liritisli fleet, wrecked one ship, dismasted and injured oth.i.,, and scattered the rest of the squadron. Some vessels .sailed direct to England, others to Halifax. Throughout all these threats of attack and ponderous demonstrations against their peace, the authorities and residents of Louisbourg appear to have been cahn, aniitish loss in killed and wounded during the siege was five hundred and twenty-four ofiiocrs and men, one hundred and sevonty-two having been killed and three hundred and lifty-two wounded. Of the French army, about tiiree hundred and thirty were killed and wouns and steadfastness have been immorta'ized l)y Najiier. But the French ilefenders showed ecpial bravery and eijual powers of endurance ; while the energies of their naval forces .^eemcd paralyzed by the vigour and dashing courage f)f the seanien who fought under St. George's Cross. As was the case half a century later, the Ihitons blockadeil their oppouents in port, or went in and fought them ship by shij), or cruised ab'iut the coast seeking their adversaries. The records of naval history, our patriotism, and our pride of race unite in giving force to the claim that the best men won ; and their winning did much towards giving us the Canada of to-day.