IMAGE EVALUATION
TEST TARGET (Mi -3)
//
^.*S
i.O
■50 ~^^
2.5
2.2
1.1 l."^ lys
IL25 III 1.4
— A"
1.6
"^
I^otographic
Sdences
Corporation
33 WIST MA^I STRKT
WEBSTH,N.Y. I45S0
(716)872-4503
^>^
'4^
^ .!^
^.
iiT^'^
^
CIHM/ICMH
Microfiche
Series.
CIHIVI/ICIVIH
Collection de
microfiches.
Canadian Institute for Historical IVIicroreproductions / Institut Canadian de microreproductions historiques
T«chnic«i and Bibliographic Notaa/Notas tachniquaa at bibliograpliiquaa
Tha Inatituta haa attamptad to obtain tha boat
original copy availabia for filming. Paaturaa of thia
copy which may ba bibliographically uniqua,
which may altar any of tha imagaa in tha
raproduction. or which may aignificantiy ehango
tha uauai mathod of filming, aro ehackad baiow.
□ Colourad covara/
Couvartura da eoulaur
pn Covara damagad/
Couvartura andommag4a
n Covara raatorad and/or laminatad/
Couvartura raatauria at/ou pailieulAa
□ Covar titia miaaing/
La titra da couvartura manqua
□ Colourad mapa/
Cartaa gAographiquaa an eoulaur
D
Colourad inic (i.a. othar than blua or black)/
Encra da eoulaur H.9. autra qua blaua ou noiral
r~| Colourad plataa and/or illuatrationa/
D
D
n
D
Planchaa at/ou illuatrationa an eoulaur
Bound with othar matariai/
RalM avac d'autraa doeumanta
Tight binding may eauaa ahadowa or diatortlon
along intarior margin/
Larvliura aarria paut eauaar da I'ombra ou da la
diatorakMi l« long da la marga intiriMira
Blank laavaa addad during raatoration may
appaar within tho taxt. Whanavar poaalbla. thaaa
hava baan omittad from filming/
11 aa paut qua cartainaa pagaa blanchaa aJoutAaa
lora d'una raatauration apparaiaaant dana la taxta.
mala, loraqua eala itait poaalbla, eaa pagaa n'ont
paa «t« fiimiaa.
Additional commanta:/
Commantairaa tupplAmantairaa;
L'Inatitut a microfilm* la maillaur axamplaira
qu'il lui a itA poaalbla da sa procurar. Laa ditaila
da eat axamplaira qui sent paut-Atra uniquaa du
point da vua bibliograrL . '1^^ '^* ^'' ^
HAMILTON & PORT DOYER RAILWAY.
•♦•
REPORT
OF THE
PRESIDENT AND DIRECTORS
TO THE
SHAREHOLDERS.
PBINTBD AT THE " SPECTATOR OFFICE, COURT HOUSE SQUARE.
,..>^ ,y?.t>
c-
sr
s-^
ft ' ^
:,j
^_c,"i^o,\^.(^^
HAMILTON & PORT DOVER RAILWAY.
DIRECTORS' REPORT
TO THE SHAREHOLDERS AND THE CITIZENS OF HAMILTON AND
THE PUBLIC, GENERALLY, INTERESTED IN THE LINE.
Shortly after the election of the present Board of Directors,
on the 11th day of June last, they issued an address to the citizens
of Hamilton, and other Municipalities interested in the construc-
tion of the Hamilton ane Port Dover Railway, in which they set
out the prominent features of the Line, and the advantages which its
construction promised to this City and the Country through which
it will pass. The appeal then made for public aid to a work
which, in the opinion of the Directors, promised such important
advantages to this City in particular, as well as the people on the
line, was immediately responded to by a unanimous vote of the
then City Council of £50,000, to be invested in the Company's
Stock, which vote was, with but one dissenting voice, confirmed
by the rate-payers at the public meeting called for that purpose.
The Village of Caledonia, following the example of our City,
subscribed £10,000, under the Municipal Loan Fund Act, which
however, being exhausted, that Municipality )C obliged to change;
and a new by-law iu< » (j piuu ewt4wfe«> ( the rate-paye^ Jfor that
purpose. A^tu /tA^t-J /tc^-^^^-x^-e^tC -rt^LT^a^iuZ^^Z e^
The Township Council of Walpole, also voted for subscribing
£15,000 to the Capital Stock of the Company, which, however,
was not confirmed by the rate-payers, owing to the divisions which
existed among them on account of the uncertainty of the route,
which the line might tal'e through their township. Since the
location of the line, the directors have assurances that a majority
of rate-payers will redeem the character of their Municipality, by
a liberal grant towards a work in which they have a deeper in-
\
t^
r
terest, if possible, than any on the line. In addition to the Mu-
nicipal subsciptions alluded to, there has been £33,800 of private
Stock subscribed, which amount the Directors still hope to in-
crease considerably. To this may be added £60,800 agreed to be
taken by the contractors, Messrs. Moore, Pierson & Co.
The progress which the Directors made at the commence-
ment in obtaining subscriptions to the Stock of the Company was
such as, in their judgment, warranted them in employing the ser-
vices of a competent Engineer, to make surveys and report upon
the best route for the location of the line. They accordingly en-
gaged John L. Hodge, Esq., a gentleman who has had much ex-
perience in locating and constructing Railways, both in Britain and
this Country, where he has been several years engaged in his pro-
fession as Civil Engineer. Mr. II. was at first ordered i^ survey
two routes — one by Caledonia and the other by Cayuga ; and sub-
sequently a third via Waterford and Simrae. The great length
of the latter line over the others, however, precluded the Directors
from entertaining it as a feasible route.
The leading facts contained in Mr. Hodge's report will be
iound embodied in the present statement of the Directors.
The cost of these several surveys, together with £1,300 paid
to R. G. Benedict, Esq., for a survey made by him under a former
Board of Directors, amounts to £2,702 lOs 2d. The Directors
have in addition to this sum, expended (chiefly in purchasing right
of way, and land for the purposes of the Railway,) £2,862 Is
which also includes printing. Parliamentary, and Office expenses
and salaries, and makes a total expenditure of £5,565 Os 2d.
The late period at which Mr. Hodge was able to complete
the several surv^s referred to, and the fact that the Company's
charter would expire in th^aaen th- ef" A pril, unless £50,000 were
expended by that time, prevented the Directors froiia taking any
further active measures for endeavoring to put the Stock list on
such a footing, as to warrant the commencement of the work, un-
til an Act of the Legislature should be obtained to extend the time
for such outlay. This Act, the Directors are happy to say, receiv-
ed the Royal assent on Friday, the 16th instant, and they are now
enabled to re-commence operations. But before doing so, they have
deemed it proper to submit a full statement of their proceedings
up to this time, as well as to lay before the Shareholders and the
8
B Mu-
rivato
to in-
itobe
nence-
ly was
he ser-
upon
gly en-
uch ex-
am and
lis pro-
survey
nd sub-
length
irectors
will be
00 paid
1 former
directors
ing right
J,862 Is
expenses
2d.
Bomplete
•mpany's
DOO were
iking any
ek list on
work, un-
i the time
ly, receiv-
Y are now
they have
'oceedings
rs and the
public interested, a recapitulation of the arguments in favor of the
line.
In the month of January, the Directors having received com-
plete plans and specifications from their Engineer, and feeling
that unless they had somf) substantial reasons to offer to the Leg-
islature in favor of the extension of their Charter, as well as to be
prepared for an early commencement of the work, unanimously
resolved upon letting the construction of the whole Line to some
thoroughly practical and responsible firm of Contractors. They
accordingly advertised for tenders, and ten different parties made
offers for doing the work. After mature consideration, and tho-
roughly weighing the character, responsibility and practical expe-
rience of those who tendered, as well as the prices specified, the
Board decided, with only one dissenting voice to award the con.
tract to Messrs. Moore, Pierson & Co., already so favourably
known in this city ; the tender of these gentlemen being the lowest
but two, of thos ejhat were admissable. The following extract
from the contract entered into will show the nature and extent of
the work to be performed by the contractors. "And it is h*iveby
declared, that iul'^ pass
squires a
s as that
1 cargo of
mer, and
afloat on
evening,
ay seem
nent, by
V^e may,
parts of
lishment
►nnection
rt Dover
I, as well
vantages
the two
lie Lake
he latter
n of that
of Penn-
•plies of
ine, the
ompany
it is this
;
13
class of business that contributes most largely to the growth and
wealth of towns and cities. The carriage of passengers through
a country adds but little to the general wealth, although it is
valuable as a means of profit to Railways.
" There is no reason, however, to doubt that this line will have
a large passenger as well as freight traffic. It is a universal law
of commerce, that the movement of passengers is always more or
less influenced by the general course of trade. If Hamilton be-
comes the entrep6t f >r Southern Canada and the Shores of Lake
Erie, those who conduct the business of the various localities will
necessarily be frequently drawn here, and our business men will
have constant occasion to visit the sources of business. Thus,
in addition to local, we may count upon a large through passenger
traffic."
As it has been doubted whether any considerable amount of
freight can be profitably transhipped and passed over by Railway
from one Lake to the other, a few facts may be adduced, which
will place the subject within the comprehension of every person
who will take the trouble to examine it. The most important
articles of transit are grains of various kinds. These, it has been
ascertained, can be raised by steam or water elevators from the
holds of vessels, and discharged in bulk into grain cars at a cost of
less than one-Jith of a cent per bushel. This is what the Directors are
assured by persons engaged in the business, is the actual result of
the Steam Elevators used at Chicago and other places. An Engine
capable of raising from the holds of vessels 100,000 bushels per
day, it is estimated, can be worked at a cost of $25 per day,
this would leave tL75 to apply on labor to feed the Elevators in use • ^^ /-,
and for incidentfllexpenses. The actual charge made by the Steam f /^
Elevator Companies at Chicago, for raising grain, is half a cent per /
bushel, which includes five days' storage and the Companies' profits,
which are said to be large. This profit would, in the case of the
Hamilton and Port Dover Railway, constitute a part of that Com-
pany's profit. Let us see what it would actually cost to unload at
Port Dover, and reshlp at Hamilton, a cargo of say 10,000 bush-
els of wheat or com.
Elevating into Warehouse, at 1 -5th of a cent
per bushel £5
Loading and discharging Cars by Schutes, at
same cost 5
Total cost of transhipment iJlO
14
If the same cargo were taken through the Welland Canal, the
figures would stand thus, computing the wheat at 37 bushels per
ton.
Canal Tolls on 270 tons Wheat, at 2s 3d per ton,£ 33 15
5 days Interest on cargo valued at £2,500, 2 5
Cost of towage, (average,) say 10
6 days expenses of Vessel, (always calculated
and added to charge on freight,) at £9 per
day, 64
£100
Deduct expense of transhipment to and from
Railway, 10
Leaving in favor of latter, £9J
i I t
Equal to 3 3-5 cents a bushel, which would, of itself, constitute
a sum sufficient to pay the cost of transit deterioration of rolling
Stock, and leave a handsome profit to the Company, and which
might probably be reduced after a large business has been estab-
lished.
It will be seen by these statistics, which every one acquaint-
ed with the forwarding business on the Lakes, can verify as a
pretty close approximation to the truth, that so far as the trans-
port of grain is concerned, the Hamilton & Port Dover Railway
will be able to compete with the Welland Canal, even if the tolls
were entirely abolished. There is no doubt but that flour, coal,
and many other kinds of freight, may also be profitably carried
over the Railway, if only proper appliances are adopted to save
labour in removing it from the holds of vessels to the trains of
cars, and vice versa, especially during the seasons when the canal
is most overtasked. The following tables will give some idea
of the magnitude of the grain trade carried on through the
Welland and Erie Canals, which the Railway may profitably com-
pete for at prices as low, or lower, than the cost and charges above
enumerated for barely passing the Canal.
Canal, the
usbels per
33 15
2 5
10
54
00
10
;9j
constitute
I of rolling
and which
leen estab-
i acquaint-
erify as a
the trans-
r Railway
f the tolls
lour, coal,
ly carried
d to save
i trains of
the canal
some idea
ough the
ably com-
ges above
15
Statement of the quantity of the following articles passed through
the Welland Canal during the years 1854 & 1855—-
1854. 1855.
Wheat, Tons, 76,961 166,620
Corn, " 113,463 115,148
Flour, " 40,022 27,828
Oats, « 10,371 5,776
Total, 240,697 315,271
Total traffic. . .767,210 849,333
Statement of the quantity, in bushels of Wheat and Flour shipped
at Buffalo and Oswego by Canal, from 1835 to 1856, inclu-
sive, the Mour being reckoned at Jive bushels to the barrel.
Year. Buffalo. Oswego. Total.
1835 672,427 669,067 1,341,393
1836 999,980 585,559 1,585,538
1837 1,084,475 340,036 1,424,510
1838 2,321,217 440,200 2,761,417
1839 2,405,849 658,160 3,064,000
1840 4,081,265 665,389 4,746,604
1841 4,450,565 735,249 5,185,814
1842 4,500,265 643,157 5,143,422
1843 6,104,064 1,154,909 7,258,973
1844 6,042,004 1,895,494 7,937,498
1845 4,946,451 2,016,487 6,980,928
1846 10,069,734 2,790,036 12,859,770
1847 15,533,117 3,766,001 19,099,118
1848 10,182,790 3,874,430 14,057,270
1849 9,115,040 5,104,997 14,057,270
1850 8,226,847 5,575,742 13,802,589
1851 9,199,762 6,116,868 15,317,533
1852 9,554,851 7,315,424 16,870,276
1853 8,250,638 8,783,293 17,083,931
1854 4,252,307 1,861,265 7,113,672
1855 7,633,531 4,691,662 12,325,193
It is only a few years since the enlargement of the Welland
Canal was completed. At that time it was supposed that its ca-
pacity for business was such as to meet the in^teasing wants of
the Western trade, for half a century. This capacity it has alrea-
dy been ascertained, is unequal to the demand for transit, and both
the Welland and Erie Canals, with the two great lines of Rail-
way through the State of New York, are taxed very nearly to their
utmost. In view of these facts, it is evident that, as the transit
16
ill
business betv^een the East and the West is every year increasing
in an accelerated ratio, there must be new channels opened to
meat the future requirements of this vast commerce. It would be
difficult to project a better avenue for sharing this most profitable
business than the one which will be afforded by the Hamilton &
Port Dover Railway, and which will at the «ame time possess so
many other sources of business in addition to that of opening a
new and easy transit between the two Lakes. If this Railway
proves as successful in competing for the trade of Lake Erie as its
friends believe it will, and the facts seem to verify, it will be the
means of raising both Hamilton and Dover to rank amongst the
most important shipping ports on the Lakes ; and a double track
will be required in less than three yeais after it is opened, to do
the business that will present itself.
ESTIMATED PROFIT.
It is no doubt a difficult matter to estimate the probable
profit that may be expected to result from a railway, drawing
business from so many sources as those enumerated. The history
of railways nowhere presents a parallel case of a short line having
so splendid a field for local business, and at the same time, forming
so many promising railway and water connections. Neither in
the old, or in the new world, do two other such lakes as Erie and
Ontario, teeming with so vast a commerce, seeking transit from
one to the other, exist.
With regard to the local business, it has been shown, that
after the line has been open long enough to develope this source
of traffic, say 5 years, at least £80,000 a year may be counted upon
from it. The Great Western working expenses are estimated at 60
per cent of the gross receipts. As the heavy freight trains on the
Hamilton and Port Dover Railway will be moved upon a down
grade and the light ones up, there is no reason to believe that the
working expenses of this line will be greater for the first two or
^c«-6 three years. T^j^^^henliiWoul^give £40,000 a year of profit, equal
Jlcuu^^,jf^4^ *® ®'8^* P®'^ °*"^' upon'dE600,000.
If it be assumed that the business that will be drawn from all
the other sources enumcBAted only equal the local traffic, instead
of, as will probably Wthe case, greatly exceeding it, and taking
the ratio of increase/predicated upon the two years' operations of
'^.
^-^^^-'^-^i^O-t^
11
the Great Western, the earnings for the first five years would be
as follows, taking the working expenses at 55 per cent of the gross
receipts.
Earnings Gross Working Leaving Percentage on
per Mile, Earnings. Expenses, with profit. Cost £600,000.
1st Tear, £1,512 £60,480 56 per cent. £80,000 6
2ad " 2,16« 86,640 " 38,988 7f
S'd " 2,824 112,960 " 60,834 10
4th " 3,480 139,200 " 62,640 12^
5th " 4,136 205,440 " 74,448 15
The expenses attending the operating of railways must neces-
sarily vary according to the description of business, and the more
or less favorable gradients of the line. In the case of the Hamilton
and Port Dover Railway, the great bulk of the freight will be moved
over the down grade towards Lake Ontario. On the New York
and Erie line 77 per cent of the freight goes East, against 23 going
West. It may therefore be assumed that the Hamilton and Port
Dover line will be an economical one to operate, and that the
working expenses and wear and tear of machinery and permanent
way together, will at no time exceed 55 per cent of the
gross receipts. The arguments which have been adduced, and
which the Directors trust have been presented in a perfectly intel-
ligible form, must afford convincing evidence that it will prove not
only profitable as an investment, but of incalculable value to the
interests of this City and all the localities interested.
The Directors closed their report last year with an allusion
to the effects produced upon the value of Real Estate in this City,
by the opening of the Great Western Railway. It will no doubt
be highly gratifying to the friends of our Railway interests to learn
that, the increase in the assessed value of property for the last
year has been fairly maintained, although the recent assessment
has been made during a period of unusual monetary pressure.
TABLE.
Shewing the assessed annual value of property in the City of
Hamilton, before the commencement and since tie opening of the
Great Western Railway, and shewing also the reilftive increase.
1849. (Before Great Western Railway was commenced,) £ 60,726
1860. do do 61,614:
Increase in one year. 860
1864. (Year of the opening,) 16*7,000
1865. (After Great Western was opened one year,) 190,000
Increase in one year. 8*7,000
1866. (Assessment just taken,) 220,000
Increase over 1866 £ 30,000
18
' i
It will bo seen by the above that the ratio of increase in the
assessed annual value of the City from 1849 to 1860 was about
one per cent, whilst from 1864 to 1856 it was 22, from 1856 to
1856 the increase has been 16, and from 1840 to 1860 no less than
360 per cent. As the annual value is computed at the rate of
c/ 6 per cent fi\ the gross assessed value, it will be seen that^
^/ the increase of last year /h the annual value of real estate in
Hamilton, (being £30,000,) represents an increase on the actual
value, of £600,000, a sum estimated to bo sufficient to build
and equip the whole of the Hamilton and Port Dover Rail-
way. The £220,000 (assessment for this year,) represents
about £3,606,000 as the gross assessed value for the whole City,
^^ which is, probably, more than a million of pounds below its ac-
)( ^Iti^ tual intrinsic value. It will, t hy^w , be seen that the City pos-
sesses ample ability to aid this enterprise to the extent necessary
to insure its completion. The Directors, therefore, appeal to the
public spirit and enterprise of all parties interested, and especial-
ly to the citizens of Hamilton, who will be most of all benefited,
to aid them in carrying forward the work. They must reflect
upon what the effect of delay will bo. Let the Southern Kailway
be built and the Buffalo and Lake Huron Line finished, and set
a-going, and the trade of the finest part of Canada will set in, in
another direction, from which it will be no easy matter hereafter
to divert it into our market. We shall, then, be cut off, and become
isolated from the most promising elements of future greatness. —
The Directors conceive that it is no longer a matter of choice, but
one of urgent necessity, to complete this work without further de-
lay. Hamilton will then take the lead of all other Cities in point of
Commerce in Upper Canada, and the consequent rise in the value of
I property may confidently be estimated at four or five times the cost
of the Line.
ALLAN N. MACNAB, President.
HUGH C. BAKER, Vice-President.
G. W. BURTON,
R. P. STREET,
M. W. BROWN^
J. T. GILKISON,
JAMES LITTLE,
w. p McLaren,
JOHN BROWN,
Directors.
crease in the
was about
om 185fi to
' no less than
the rate of
e seen that
lal estate in
1 the actual
nt to build
)ovcr Rail-
represents
whole City,
elow its ac-
le City pos-
it necessary
)peal to the
id especial-
I benefited,
nust reflect
rn Kail way
ed, and set
II set in, in
[• hereafter
ind become
reatness. —
shoice, but
further de-
in point of
ie value of
es the cost