IMAGE EVALUATION TEST TARGET (MT-3) :^, 1.0 I.I 1.25 2.8 M 120 14 III 1.6 V] (^ / 'c^l ^ "^^ ^'>/ W ^ ' // y ^ ?^ Photographic Sciences Corporation 23 WEST MAIN STREET WEBSTER, N.Y. 14580 (716) 872-4503 # iV '^^ :\ \ ,.'"'« »* ^\^ <>\ ^\ cv % ^^ <> ^'^^ ^i> ^^^ * '% i^A Q.r CIHM/ICMH Microfiche Series. CIHM/ICMH Collection de microfiches. Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions / Institut canadien de microreproductions historiques Tachntcal and Bibliographic Notes/Notes techniques et bibliographiques The Institute has attempted to obtain the best original copy available for filming. Features of this copy which may be hibliographically unique, which may alter any of the images in the reproduction, or which may significantly change the usual method of filming, are checked below. L'Institut a microfilm^ le meilleur exemplaire quit lui a ate possible de se procurer. Les details de cet exemplaire qui sont peut-dtre uniques du point de vue bibliograpiiique, qui peuvent modifier une image reproduite. ou qui peuvent exiger une modification dans la m^thode normale de filmage sont indiqu^s ci-dessous. a D D D n n Coloured covers/ Couverture de couleur I I Covers damaged/ Couverture endommag^e Covers restored and/or laminated/ Couverture restaurde at/ou pelliculde □ Cover title missing/ Le tit itre de couverture manque Coloured maps/ Cartes giographiques en couleur Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ Encre de couleur (i.e. autre que bleue ou noire) □ Coloured plates and/or illustrations/ Plant iches et/ou illustrations en couleur Bound with other material/ Relii avec d'autres documents Tight binding may cause shadows or distortion along interior margin/ Lareliure serree peut causer de I'cmbre ou de la distorsion le long de la marge interieure Blank leaves added during restoration may appear within the text. Whenever possible, these have been omitted from filming/ II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajoutdes lors d'une restauration apparaissent dans le texte, mais. iorsque cela 4tait possible, ces pages n'ont pas 6xi filmdes. r~7] Coloured pages/ D G E D 1/ D D Pages de couleur Pages damaged/ Pages endommag^es Pages restored and/or laminated/ Pages restaurees et/ou pelliculees Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ Pages ddcolorees, tachet^es ou piquees Pages detached/ Pages detachees Showthrough/ Transparence Quality of print varies/ Qualite in^gale de i'impression r~~| Includes supplementary material/ Comprend du materiel supplementaire Only edition available/ Seule Edition disponible Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata slips, tissues, etc., have been refilmed to ensure the best possible image/ Les pages totalement ou partiellement obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata, une pelure, etc.. cnt 6te film^es A nouveau de facon a obtenir la meilleure image possible. Additional comments:/ Commentaires supptementaires; Docket title page is bound in as last page in book but filmed as first page on fiche. This item is filmed at the reduction ratio checked below/ Ce document est film^ au taux de reduction indiqu^ ci-dessous. 10X 14X 18X 22X 26X 30X / 12X 1SX 2iX iP>f< ^OA 32X ils lu lifier ne age The copy fiimad hare has been reproduced thanks to the generosity of: Seminary of Quebec Library The images appearing here are the best quality possible considering the condition and legibility of the original copy and in keeping with the filming contract specifications. Original copies in printed paper covers are filmed beginning with the front cover and ending on the last page with a printed or illustrated impres- sion, or the back cover when appropriate. Ail other original copies are filmed beginning on the first page with a printed or illustrated impres- sion, and ending on the last page with a printed or illustrated impression. L'exempiaire filmi fut reproduit grice d la gin^rositi de: Siminaire de Quebec Bibllothdque Les images suivantes ont iti reproduites avec ie plus grand soin, compte tenu de la condition at de la nettet6 de l'exempiaire fiimd, et en conformity avac les conditions du contrat de flimage. Les exemplaires orlginaux dont la couverture en papier est imprimis sont fiimis en commen^ant par Ie premier plat et en terminant soit par la dernidre page qui comporte une empreinte d'impresslon ou d'illustration, soit par Ie second plat, salon Ie cas. Tous les autres exemplaires orlginaux sont filmds an commandant par la premiere page qui ccmporte une empreinte d'impresslon ou d'illustration et en terminant par la dernlAre page qui comporte une telle empreinte. The last recorded frame on each microfiche shall contain the symbol —^-(meaning "CON- TINUED "), or the symbol V (meaning "END"), whichever/ applies. Un des symboles sulvants apparaitra sur la dernlAre image de cheque microfiche, selon Ie cas: Ie symbols -^> signifle "A SUIVRE ", Ie symbols V signifie "FIN ". ita lure. he. 1 ;a Maps, plates, charts, etc., may be filmed at different reduction ratios. Those too large to be entirely included In one exposure are filmed beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to right and top to bottom, as many frames as required. The following diagrams illustrate the method: 1 2 3 Les cartes, planches, tableaux, etc.. peuvent dtre fllmte d des taux de reduction diffdrents. Lorsque Ie document est trop grand pour dtre reproduit en un seul cliche, 11 est filmi A partir de Tangle supArieur gauche, de gauche d droite, et de haut en baa. en prenant \g nombre d'images nicessaire. Les diagrammes sulvants illustrent la mithode. 1 2 3 4 5 6 I ^ ■S I M « o ? -^^ a o a o « 3. 9 If ■A ■ — ■ >^, I i s rii'ivi IiiSTIl t^ ( ; [rrjnviN'CF, Ok Canada, > n tilt €tinf tit^^ Stndi* APPEAL SIDfe THOMAS CASSOX, [Plaintiff in the Court beloip,) ApPEr.LANT; ANDREW THOMPSON, . , ; {Defendant in tin: Court helmv,) I Reshondent. This appeal is from a final jiidgmenl in the Court below, whereby the Re.„on,k-nt . ^m condomntMl u, pay the Appellant the 8u,n of £64 12.s. 1 Id, which the Apindlant . c<,n,end.s ,« much le.sB than he is entiUcd to rccovrr. The points upon which th, parti,-. ■r.rter are not nunH-ron, ,ut are rendered somewhat embarrassing by the neces ity for fulcuialions ot considerable extent and intricacy. -""'y Jor The deelarntion allege, the following facts as the basis of the Appellant's elain \he3dRr 'rV'"'/''Vr '"''" ^™^^^"" ^°'" ""^ «^fcndan't'Lot N . ■ 7„ the 3rd Ra,,^^ „( tarnham, for £J50, payable by an.ma." instalments of £25 each com mene.ng on >f.n-e„,l>er Is, 18,5, with interest to be computed from NovemberT '184" and that for seenrMy of these paymer^ts the said lot was hypothecated. ' Ihat ihe late John Casson by a will made in November 1848 consiitntP,! hi. ,. t Datne Mary Aery, his universal usufructuary legatee, and that t e pr I fl « J :'- belonged ,0 h.m at h.s death and formed part of the estate so devised ,0 h^renuZ^ rljher'nrf """ '''"'' '" '"^ '"''-'^^'^ ^" --'''--^- "^ ^ --thly ^L'^ vion Tv "t "' "" 'T "^ ""' ''''^ "■""''■'^^^' ""= ^^''""'^ "f" ""^ instalments which had ore r t ^Xr:ia:m:rs;;r "•" ""^^'' -^-^ --'^ > -^ ^^-^^ =;j:^r^;ij:t,r^ ~ of e,hib;i-v;;yr:j-;:r- " Le dofendeur pour exception peremptoi.e a eet.e action all^gue : Que pendant 'anneemil-huit-cent-trente-sept, il aurait acheto du nommfi John Casson, mentionne en la declaration en cetie cause n^^m ,1., i \ "omme John " pour une somme de £150 courant. ' ^ " '^'^'^^^nd.ur, une terre "Que sur et en deduction du prix de eette terre, il aurait avant le Icr Janvier H4I paye au d,. John Casson diverscs sommes de den'iers, en extinction des inX" , ' «' capital, ce qu. est eonslatf par certains re,uis A. Ini aecordfis nar le.lit ! r '^ pendant les annees .839 et ,840, ci-produL et auxqulitlt IJf^rfi ' ''"""' qu'tl stgna ou cju'.l fit signer par ,uel.,a'un par lui autorise e, parcc V.t ui u in ' accorde au Do cndeur, le dit Joh., Casson declara que la bdat^ce 1^1 "" ;; due^par le DeA.deur .tait une somme de 380 piales .gale , £0 , .::::JZ::X '. ca^^;;;": t^:^ ''- ^^^"^ '^^'^'^""'^"^ '^^^^^ --- ^^^p^y-au dit John w h ! " oourant cliaciue, le premier ilcsqueln dcvnit se fiiire le ler novenibre 1845, nvec iiiK'-r^^l " annnollement sur tout le capilul A compter du Icrnovembre 1843, elle Difoiidfurprit " possessioii state dansl'inventaire prodiiil en cette cause, el que le 20 deeembre 1851, il aiirait *' paye une somme de £49 18s. 3Jd.courant, sur et a compte de la dile somme de £182 " 19s., (lit cours il la dile dame Aery (cedanle du Demandeur) (pii lui uurait aeoorde quit- " taiice de cette somme par acte rei^u dans le dit district, devant inailre Clement et son «■' confrere, notaires publics, copie de laqiiclle quitlance est deja produite en cette cause " et que par tel acte de quittance du 20 deeembre 1851, il fut declare |)ar la dite dame " Aery, taut en son propre et prive nom (pie comme legataire de feu sou epoux au profit '' du Defendeur acceptant, que la somme de £4!) 18s. 3Jd. (lui lui etait ainsi payee par " le Defendeur, I'etait sur et en deduction de la dite somme de£l82 193. dit cours, porl6 " dans le dit invcotaire, el que la dile dame Aery par la dite quittance du 20 deeembre " 185\, a reeonnu que la seule somme qui lui fut due, le 20 deeembre 1851, avant d'a- " voir ref'ii Ies £49 18s. 3.Jd. par le Del'endeur, sur lout le prix de vente porli"; dans I'acte " du 29 inai 1813, etait la somme de £182 19s. dit cours, avec interfit du 14 avril 1851. " Qu'a l'(}po(jue on la dile dame Aery a accorde au Di''fendeur la dite quittance du " 20 deeembre 1351, la seule somme qui etait alors exigible sur Ies £182 19s. dil cours, " portfis dans I'inventaire elait celle de £7 19s., balance sur £25, pour un terme i\v paie- " inent eeliii au ler novembre 1851, avec intt'-rfit sur Ics £182 19s. dit cours a compter du " 14 avril 1851, au ler novembre de la m6me aunfie, lequel interftt s'elcvait a la somme " de £5 9s. 9d., formanl reunies ces deux iommosculle de £13 8s. 9(1. dit cours, et par " consi'qiient la somme de £49 18s. 3 Jd. dout le Defendeur a eu quittance le 20 deeembre " 1851, a ('teint la dit(! somme de £13 8s. 4d. pour tout ce (]ui etait drt le ler novenibre " 1851, et le surplus de I'argent paye a cette epoque la a du 6tre applique surle capital «♦ qui n'(''tait pas exigible, et que h Defendeur d'apr^s son coutrat avail la faculte(l'ac- " quitter avant son tchtance. ^■l M ':iri«HP«iiimiiii' n " Quf Ic Icr novombre 1851, la seiile somine qui etaii diio et exifjibic en capital et " inti^r^l, .sur le prix de voiite du 29 inai 18 JJ, t-iait bi soinm- de £52 IIh. 6d. couranf, " El le dit Delcndfin- ulli'gue : " Qiioi(iii'ilntfuir(!devubleauDi'mandouri|nndt!laba!;uioe, ilaci-pondantle1erinar8 " couratit 1855, par 1(! niiiiiiltsrode mailre VincebiUe ut son confrere, iiotaircH publics, ofFttrt " et fail oft'rir an dit Dfinundciir, nm sculmnpnt la snsdilc balance !\liiiduc,avec I'intu- " riJt (Id sur icclle, h cortipter du k-r noveinbre dernier, jiisqu'au dit jour, lermarscou- " rant, mais encore quelque cliose au-dela, savoir, une somme de JC50 17(i. 6d. courani, " pour rnontant de la susdite balance et pour les interfils accrus sur i"elle jusqu'au dit " jour, ler Mars courant, el de plus par le iiiinislero des dits notaires, le dit Defendeur " aurait la el alors, le dit jour, Ic^r Mars eourant, otl'ert ct fail olTrir au Dernandeur upp " somme de £3 15s. couraiit, pour les frais m au fonds en fait, or denial of the rights claimed by the Appellant was pleaded by the Respondent. To the exception the Appellant replied by special answer, in eflect as follows- That on the Mil. of April 1851, the date of the last payment previous to the making of the inventory, and after deduction of that payment, .here was aue to the .state Casson m principal and interest £200 18s. UJd. which at the date ol the inventory, (the 4th June, 1851) amounted to £203 3s. Gd. That tlie t^iry in the inve;. ,,ry was erroneous, inasmuch as the payments made previous to its , xvhi.h it wa. tLoI all It in Z, .,h« vvas ...u.rly i,„.a,,ablc of nmkinK "r of v-rilyi,.. ...h .alcnhrC ' "' ll..illh,-prin.,,,|,.sofi.npui...ion adopted by .he Re.pond.-nt in iii, ralcniH.lon. :«;';::i:,«:'™ - -""" '- •"'"■' •■ -"> '■■•■"-■ ■ ''■" '"""" T|k< App..|l,.nl also fded a R(;neral nnawer to .ho cxrrpii,,,,. liif tails ol ihi. case, which are not dlspnlcd, are an follows • On Ih. iJOll, day of I)econ.bor, 1837, .ho R.-sponden. pnr..ha,ed from .ho late- fohn Cn..on (..rron,..m.ly called Tho.nas in th. deed.) a lu, of' 1,.,,,, f.„ £1 "o 1; sj' t^ we ve annna .n..al,nen,s of i:,2 .0. each, co.n.uencing on .I,,'. ,s. of Ja,', rV ,83 ' wnh , he pr.vd,.,-., ho..vever, of pay in,, .he price at an earlier date if l.e .hough" t'? ' Hav.ng made .undry payment, on account of .hin pnrcha.. money, a .e.,i;„H „, ..r account ,ook place between the Respondent and the late John cJon oh, March, B.i-., by wh.eh the balance then due was established at £07 r,J cL.ev bearing interest. currtney .h. n?i" 'W' f ';' "■'''■ "" '^'^''P""^'-"' r>"rchnsed from John Casson the farm for he price of wh,c ... p.e.ent action is brought, upon the terms airea.ly adver.e Ho n the reeiial of the declaration in the court below. ""^c'le.. to in He continued from tim. to time to m«l,e payments to John Casson, af.er hi, death o his widow, and also to he .Appellant, .he da.cs and amounts of M , ;tn s In May, IS.Jl, John Casi tuary lei,'atee, his executors n nor the Respondent were pai » on having died and left his widow, his universal usufru..- 1 ade an mven.ory of his es.ate, to which neiiher the vv idow J , ■ '"'"'""'''"''''■' '"ventorv, it was staled ilmi ilu. ..,.,,..„. due t e es,a.e by ,l,e R^sponyen. on ,he ,4,h April, /sS., was i; H , ' ' tI: ^ " as af.erwards handed over [o ,he widow as usufructuary, by .he Lxecu.or and si e transferred her rights to the AJipellant " " *'^^"w», and slie proplnir""""" "'■'' "' "!' '*""•"''"" "P"''^'^ "^ •^■"'- -- "P- "- A>llawl„g 1st. That .he result of a proper i.npu.a.ion of the payments made to ,he Cas.ons upon he purchase money ol ,he two f.r.ns ano in.eres.. w-odd be ,he re.luetion f . J Appellanis demand to ihe sum of £53 1 Is. Gd. "^"I'ciion o. .Hc 2nd That the cn.ry in .he inven.ory is eorrec, and .ha. by adopting it ns a start ing point, the resni. would be llie same. ^ The Appellant aeeep.s the issues thus offered and trusis to be able to shew • l.t. limt .he calculations by which the Respondent arrives a. the '.alance of £52 lis. 6d. are erroneous in principle, and ; 2nd. That the entry in the inventory was based upon similar calculations and therefore pro|)or.ionably iiicorrccl. ■"■»""., ana The following is .he s.a.emen. fyled by the Respondent wiih his exception. ■• Aery! Dr " " '" '"'"'"" """"""' "P'^^'-'"""S •'""" Casson and Mary • 1S41 J,,n„„rj- .,l_To haUnce of capital .!„o .hi, day on r-rcl,.... of Farm in mi,. X07 '. 1851, Noveaib. I..t_To mtere.t on balance f,«,„ 1st January 1S4I, ,, f,', ,:, " ■1354,.Vovemb.lst_To 10 ,„.,al„,.nU on th price of farm bo»,;ht 29.1. May 1843 " hcfor,. I). Morison, Xot -y J'ublic, ' jm o "To interest on .CCo amonnt of capital from Ist November I'eVa' 'to " " Ist Xovembi'r 1831 ' , . ' 3.11 XI 77 18 6 481 & ■ 1804, Xovemb. Ut-Amount in capital and interest due and which might be claimed, «5« 18 6 ciu;i)iT. ''M.,nio. ,„.i.l l,y Thom«,„ and interci allowed on ,ame, „p ,o U November " lSo4, HM por rt'<'«'ij)ii). ' ' ' ''"»'-'nDcr " lH4a, M«rrh loth, palil " iiilercil lu lit November lHa4, ''"'^ '^ ' " 1843, May, im, p.ilil 10 » J " IntiTi St In lit .November 1H54,......,,". 10 " 1844, I'thnwry iiiih, ]Ki|J '"' ^IH,. ■■•'■■'■■■ ■.... " '" ' " 1845, tVbnmry 14lli, iiiiiil _" U 3 5 " Interest to lit .November lHf)4, * ' ' " IHli), Ki.hr.mry 24lh, imiil ......'. " * ' " Intiircsltr, |3| November 18,14 .,'.'.' '" ' "* " 1R47, Mnrch Uiti, p,il,l it * * " Interiat to lit Novc.Tiher 1834, ., 48 8 " 1M4H, Msreb HUi, paid ?^ ' "* " rnlercst to l»t November 18a4 .. '" '* " " 1848, Juno lilih, pa;.i '.'.'.'.'.'.'..'. '■* '* * " Inler'jst to Isl November 1854 .",,. '** " " " 18 tl', March a;inl, imiil '23 " Intereat to l»l November lHr.4 ^^ " * " 184!), Miiy Slh, paid .'.'.",".'.' '" " *• " Interest lo l«t .November 1H54 12 8 " ISflO, M.ir<:h t;th, pnhl .'.'.'.'.'.'.' "' '" " "Intmist to l»l November 1834,.!!!. MOO " 18B0, Juno IStli, imid !."!!!!.'." , " '" ' " Interest to 1st November 1854 . "'' " " " 18M, Miirel, 3r(l, p,ii,l .'!!!!!." 8 9 " Interest to Isi November 1884 .. ^' ' ° " 1881, April loth, pHi.i ■ !!!!!!!!! * '" "' " Interest lu 1st November 1884 .. "" ' * " 1881, October Dlb, paid, ■' " '" « " Interest to 1st November 1884 !!!!!!! " '** ' " 18,11, DicemlMT Otii, paid '...!!!!!! ^ ' ' " Interest to isl November 1884 *" '* ^* 8 U — eofl 7 i> " 1884, 1st Novomb„„..„, of inu.n.s, Mor. uritu. .1 V ■ 1843, March lOtli, paid ■■"crest on X8 15,. id. (^monnVimpi-i^d 'i^.^^a,];,: pri;;^,;".; Ihe'lVtNo^'lVs.;, ^'i '' \ inicrevs, oxceoding thdr arnolnTr' 1„ ^""^^^''''''l'''^':' P^y"''^"'^ ^vcrt■ ma.le, when other words, .hey're it^V^^ uLr, :=".''. '"'r'J '^ '^'"*'^'^^' "'^"" "'^''" = °^ *" .he two farms. """°" P"*'^' '' '" '^ '"«''« "P°" ">« Purchase money of !/ »{>■ On I'xaininiilion (if ihf (hcda in <|u.'nll<)ii il will Ih' rmintl lliiil tin- iiiirclM-*!' money •lipululfd for In the; mx paid, will nliew, iliut when xonio of dm piiynienin were ruidc, liitereMt w.ih due and p;iyal)le under bodi deeds, Init tio prineipal under (he deed of 1HI;1; when others were inuile, Ihe ninoniil of inleri'sl due and pajidile iind"r both de<'ds, w iih llie prl'ieipal iitnler thai of 1837, tixceeded sue!) poyinenU, arid no prineipal was Ihen due tinder llie deed of 1843 , and at olher dain* of pnyii onl, both interest und principal w«r« due and piiy- ublu under bolli deeds, This premised, ilu! A|)pelliinl contends for the following rules of impuliit'on : — 1st. Thai ihe iiileresl pMyiible iindi'r the died of 1838, should he- fir-it i-xlinijiiished. 2nd. That the payineiils choiild next be applied to the iiilenul, payiilile uiuler Ihu deed of 1813. 3rd. That any prineipal iieliially p liable under Ihe deed of 1837, shoiilil be next extiii>,'iiislied. ■lib. That the |>riiieipal due uiuler Ihe deed of 1813, ^ll(>lll(l be last extinguished. The Court below adopted llit- rules of impuialion e.oiiteiuled for by the Appellant, cxce|)t Ihul they orderecf that Ihe principal under the deed of 18J7 should bo exiin^juished bi'fore any itnpiitation was made even upon the iiilere»| due on the debt of 1813, and so far as llm eniineialion of llie.-e rules exl('iidH, the lirsl proposition of the Appellant is fully borne out by Ihe .liidgment. Il is eouehi^d in these terms : " The Conn considering' that the paymenls made by Ihu Defendant in this cause " should be iinpuled firstly in extineti-m of llio interest duo by the Defendant under the " deed of sale of date the 20lh day of r."e;-,nlier 1837, secondly towards thi^ capital dm' " under the .said deed, thirdly in exiinelion of the interest due undi'r the dc 1 of wile of " dale Ihe twenty ninih day of May, 18 »3, ami lastly on account of Ihe capital due iinrler " llic said last mentioned deed of sale ; and considering that it appears by the inventory " of Ihe estate of the late .lohn Casson that on the I ItU April, 18.5!. there was due to his "estate the sum of £192 19s. cy., which should be adopted as the jioinl from which " such imputations should commence ; and con>iilrrinf,' thai the Defendant liatli esta- " blished the payment to the s,u(' Dame Mary Aery, of the sum of £19 18s 3Jd. cy., •' oil the JOth December 1831 ; and considering that Ihe I'lainlill' hath cslabli.^hed that he " is the proprietor r« miij'niit of the amount due by the said Defend. ml under ine said " deed of sal(* of date May 39lh 1813; and considering also that there was due by the " Defendant to Ihc IMainlifl', at the date of the inslilulion of the present action the sum " of £01 UN. lljd. cy., a^ the balani'c of liio said amount due and payalile lo the said " Plainiill by the said Defendant, after deduction of Ihc said sum of £ 19 |8s. S^d. cy., " and of the inHinlinenIs thereof which had not matured at the date of the institution of " the present action, from the .iinoimt mentioned in the s.iid invcii'ory and after adjiist- " ment of interest, and that the lender of the Defendant was therefore insnllieienl ; dolh " condemn the Defendant lo pay and satisfy lo the IMaintiH" the said sum of £64 12». " 1 1 Jd. current money of this Province of Canada, due for the causes, matters, and things " mentioned and set forth in the declaration of the I'lainlill in this cause fyled, with iii- " tcrcsl thereon from the 1st Novciiilier 18.51, until paid and costs of suit." For Ihe pur|)osc of exhibiting the results of the mode of imputation suggested by the Appellant, and of that fixed by this Judgment of the Court below ; the Apjicllant has caused two slalemcnis lo be carefully prepared, shi-wing every calculation in detail, and cxhibiling both the amount re.dly due by the Respondent at the dale of the Inven- tory of the Kstalc of .John Casson, and that whieti he owed at ihe date of the inslilulion ol the action in the (,'ourt below. One of these stalemeiits forming Appendix A is con- structed upon tho.se principles of imputation which the Appellant considers correct ; and the other. Appendix H, upon those established by the Court below. The dales of Ihe payments and their amounts have been taken from \\n- Kespondent's exhibit K, filed with his exception and referred to in it; though in doing so the Apju'llant admits the 2nd and ith items of the credit side of that exhibit, which are open to some objection. 1 The or.Iy .liiiiigi! miitl.' in ilic RiKjjonili'ni'ii own »lal(rnpnt of hlii pnymcnls, is by the alturulion of ihc Jmc, Oih OcIoIht 1851, to tlu; iriic diiif, !)ili 0|Kii(lix A, il npix-iirs tliul llic Hinoiinl .In.- on tlic Ui NovrniL , 18CI, inslead of bt in^ only J:m 1 1». (M,, u" prctcnd.-.l l.y the ltf..|M.iiilrnl, reiiily uinounird lo £130 1 1«. ard iin L-xiuuiniilion ot ApjX'ndix H. .hIh'wi an indi'bii'dm-M at lliu iwtno duli; of JiMH lis. Od. I'licHf rtoiiltM lire obtained from ilia vory maint! iluta, an those iniide iidc of by liiu IU>r.pnndfnt in hi-, ciilcululionn, and whichever of them may bn conJiiihTt'd oorrvct," it U iniiiiiff!.! thiit Ihc princi|)lf!i of itiipnliiti.m he hac ndopifd iirc ino.Mt gliiriiiKly crron.-oiii. III! must Ihrrcfort- fail in supluininjf th.- prelfn»i«n» euunciatod in tin; first purl of hid I'xct'piion. A siniiiiir con<:hi«ion tho Appfllunt oubmitg must nccoHsurlly folhiw an examination ol the M-oond prcicnsion of the Ufsponilcnt, viz : that tin- nmoiint rnl.T.-d in llm Inventory of Ciiomm'H KHtalc! ax then due, it corn-nt , and thaf, on credit beinf? ^ivt^n liim for tli« num of £19 IHs. 3.'.is,e,„ with the fir.,, inasmuch as il aclu.owledged as correc, that whid, its own previous dec . ration proved to be wrong. In other words the judgment of the Court below, cslablishcl rules of .mpntulion which c.mclusively showed the iuventory to be grossly iiirorreei, and ihen in effect dclared i. to b.. right. This could not huJo been !"""'''■; \"7' '" " '''ili'.V ^^''- -"-'I ''.V -I." .ni.-taken imprcsion of the Court belowjhal Ihe payments u.id. . discussion, were made suhsequem u, the dale r „,, Inventory, instead of before il. If this error had nol found its way to die mud- of ,|.e member, ol the Court below, there would probably have been litiie need of the present appeal. It is phiin, however, th.l llie Appellani f,as „„, now to eonlend agai,., miy decision o the Court b.low, establishing the infallibilily of the Inventory ; but on llie n lary here is a nr prcsump.ion from .he judgment, that it was the opinion o( The Appelhm, iherefore eoefideully submits i„ this connection, that an entry in the in shewn by statements A and B with that entry; and whichever of thos a^, :„ ^ ^ be adopted as eorreel, the inventory x.ill be found lo be wrong lo a lar.^e ex n" Bm the Appellant succeeded in causing ,o be produced and (110^ as nitoCti the very calculations upon which ^,1 Notar; based ...: enll^l;;::;,:;'; win ■. ii>entti. invi. Jl^lrcli 10, . . Dciliiut.. 1843. May 1, Dciliict.. 181 1. liHlniic tnton;!.!,!,!.. '■ ,f"'''™' '''"', •lnt,r.-A iiM|«iUlj Tctnl Inlemt Amount .Hay ISH £ fi 13 I n. £ s. 1). « IS £ B. I). .\on«. liril, ..f I'lVVIIlClltH. rii'i.tl*. jm.vuKiil ». £ K. D. None. £ 8. n. 6 19 i." s. I 1-2 14 1 None. u ,'"• a 10 l'ro|)orilon of liu.viiiciili to Im imiiut',il on tiio prlndjuil. £ 3 8. 15 D. 1 3 14 10 Ki Amount ini|)utiible on prinoipal of deed on837 Amount due under deed of 1,SJ7 ' tiO u u Balance to be imputed on principal of deed of 1843,. Therefore deduct it from timl princiimi , . " . . I Dniance of |,rineipal due llii.^ dav. .Mi'v », . Interest to date, .' . j Total Ocduct cash on accouni,. . . 42 13 II 30 34 12 13 7i 3.-|0 II 337 li 4^ 1! l-i I i Balance of principal, ■March U, ... I Interest lo date 33;) \H :.; VI r, n 327 13 :,i Ifi f. 4 .lune 1.1 Total, iDcduct cash on ncoouni '' '■'** 18 Si; I , 2.-1 I Balance of principal, Interest to date, \ 319 18 9j " ...|Total, • i 1 '■ • • • iDcduct cash on acooudl,. ^-5 5 24 u " ••. Balance of ca|iitul ' <1clober9,.. Interest 1,1 date, 301 5 .1 15 10 1831. Mnreh 3, .\pril 1."), . Total, Deduct cash on accouni 307 10 13 10 Balance of capital, ilntcrosl to date 294 lU 10 I " fl 4i . jTotal, — , . 'Deduct cash on accoTini 301 n ;• I I .11 r> n ■ I Balance of rapiial, Interest to dale, , ' 270 (1 ■!; 1 1 18 3; Total, '. Deduct cash on accouni ' 272 4 1; 31 .', Balance due tliia day, ' ■ !X'240 19 I) t rnsullicicnt lo cover interest by X3 Os. 3d. • Insufflcient to cover interest !.., X'27 49. 7d. IJffi^jXSl.. .;:aii.'3i. ,v!ffSf'^Lrr?».j«ji 10 Tho entry in the inventory, tliorcforo. niuler (liis niclluKl of iinpiitiition, is Inrorrert to tlie extent of .£58 On. (id., or nearly one-lourtli of the entire (lel)t. Tiie biilanee due the 1st November, 1854, is sliewn as follows : — £ s. (I. lf.'>l. April in, Amount of oii|iilal duo ns nbuvc 240 in li Uccr. .'10, luU'rcsl lo dull', 10 Ci 2 " Total dup, 2."tl -l 8 " Dodui't nrnount of {lisclmrf;;!', 49 ir ,ij " niil.ilU'C of rapitnl 201 li 4 j 1854. Kovr. 1, Iiitercsl to dale :\r) 4 7.' Deduct 4 instalniouts not matured, each .I'S.*), 2.1t; 11 100 li I f Amoiinl lefuvcnible in pri-.SL'nt ncUdii, XKiG 1 1 APPENDIX n. Showing amount dun at the date of the Inventory, 4(h June, 18-31, accordinj; to the rnli^s of imputation fixed by the Court below. £ s. d. 1841, .lanuury 1, Rulanre settlid as lieing due inidpr deed of 18n7 97 n 1842, March 10, Interest lo dale I'.i o Total duo lot 4 Cash on ncpount 12 14 1 Capital due 1843, May 1, Inlerest to date. 91 9 11 C 5 2 Tttlal due f>7 15 ] Deduct Cash on aeooiint jo Capital duo g^ ]5 j 1844, Fehruury 2i!, Interest lo date 4 7 9 Total due 92 2 10 Deduct CuiSh on account 17 10 Capital due 184r>, February 14, Interest to date 74 12 10 4 2 Total due 78 13 Deduct Cash on account 4 o !) Capital duo £1 1 12s. lod , Interest .'Is. fid 74 hi 3 184G, February 24, Interest on £14 12s. lod. to date 4 12 OJ Total due 7., « 3J Deduct cash on account r,,) f mi Capital duo 29 6 184T, March 12, Interest to dale \ m o Total due 311 ly 7 Cush extinguishinit Principal and Interest, duo under deed of 18,1" 48 8 Leaving to be imputed on the interest, duo under the deed of 1H4:I 17 n 5 Interest on X.'l.'iU purchase money, under deeil nf IHIM, from the 1st .N'ovemher, 1843 to dale 70 12 g Halaucc of inlerest, duo on deed of 1843 53 1 3 1848, March «, Interest on X3."i0 to Unto 20 15 5 Total interest due 73 jc g Deduct cash on accouttt 37 jo Ilalanco of interest due • at; (j g June 10, InleroBt on i'350 lo date 5 16 1 Total interest due 42 j g Deduct cash on account ja 15 -S^i- 11 Italnnce of interest due 21 R o 18-111, March 2.1, Interest on Xa.lO to dntc ' .'.".,'.!!!!.'. jg Tutalintereat 30 9 101 uain extinguishing interest „. Lcnvini; ii Imliinec to impute on principal of 'm'To iT Amount '^"ti<"'. i« therefore ineorrect, to the .X eut of ,i- s 5s 1, . ,.„nv,u.y, or a little more tha.i „„e-|l,th of thoentire debt The balance .li.e the Ist Novetnber, 1S54, is shewn us follow.s : 1B51, April 15, Ainounl of capital due un.i-;r >Uv dicl