IMAGE EVALUATION 
 TEST TARGET (MT-3) 
 
 /. 
 
 ^o 
 
 V 
 
 ^ 
 
 
 
 fe 
 
 5r wi/s 
 
 1.0 
 
 I.I 
 
 ■- lilllM 
 
 2.2 
 
 III 1.8 
 
 
 1.25 
 
 1.4 
 
 1.6 
 
 
 .4 6" — 
 
 
 ► 
 
 <^ 
 
 ^ 
 
 /}. 
 
 
 
 I 
 
 
 '/ 
 
 Photographic 
 
 Sdences 
 
 CorpuiBtiun 
 
 23 WEST MAIN STREET 
 
 WEBSTER, N.Y. 14580 
 
 (716) 872-4503 
 
CIHM/ICMH 
 
 Microfiche 
 
 Series. 
 
 CIHM/ICMH 
 Collection de 
 microfiches. 
 
 Canadian Institute for Histortca! Microreproductions / Institut canadien de microreproductions historiques 
 
Technical and Bibliographic Notes/Notes techniques et bibiiographiques 
 
 The Institute has attempted to obtain the hest 
 original copy available for filming. Features of this 
 copy which may be bibliographically unique, 
 which may alter any of the images in the 
 reproduction, or which may significantly change 
 the usual method ot filming, are checked below. 
 
 n 
 n 
 
 Coloured covers/ 
 Couverture de couleur 
 
 Covers damaged/ 
 Couverture endommagde 
 
 Covers restored and/or laminated/ 
 Couverture restaurde et/ou peliicul^e 
 
 Cover title missinig/ 
 
 Le titre de couveirture manque 
 
 Coloured maps/ 
 
 Cartes gdographiques en couleur 
 
 Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black)/ 
 Encre de couleur (i.e. autre que blaue ou noire) 
 
 Coloured plates and/or illustrations/ 
 Planches et/ou illustrations en couleur 
 
 I ~y Bound with other material/ 
 \2l\ Relid avec d'autres documents 
 
 D 
 
 D 
 
 Tight binding may cause shadows or distortion 
 along interior margin/ 
 
 Lareliure serri^e peut causer de I'ombre ou de la 
 distortion le long de la marge intdrieure 
 
 Blank leaves added during restoration may 
 appear within the text. Whenever possible, these 
 have been omitted from filming/ 
 II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajoutdes 
 lors d'une restauration apparalssent dans le texte, 
 mais, lorsque cela 6tait possible, ces pages n'ont 
 pas dt6 filmdes. 
 
 L'Institut a microfilmd le meilleur e;templaire 
 qu'il lui a dt6 possible de se procurer. Les Jdtails 
 de cet exemplaire qui sont peut-dtre uniques du 
 point de vue bibliographique, qui peuvent modifier 
 une image reproduite, ou qui peuvent exiger une 
 modification dans la m^thcde normaie de filmage 
 sont indiquds ci-dessous. 
 
 D 
 D 
 
 n 
 
 Coloured pages/ 
 Pages de couleur 
 
 Pages damaged/ 
 Pages endommagdes 
 
 Pages restored and/or laminated/ 
 Pages restaurdes et/ou peliiculdes 
 
 r~]]/p Pages discoloured, stained or foxed/ 
 I ^\ Pages ddcolordes, tachetdes ou piqudes 
 
 Tho 
 to tl 
 
 The 
 
 POS! 
 Of tl 
 
 film 
 
 Grig 
 
 beg 
 
 the 
 
 sior 
 
 oth< 
 
 first 
 
 sior 
 
 or il 
 
 D 
 
 Pages detached/ 
 Pages ddtachdes 
 
 I V'Showthrough/ 
 LJ^ Transparence 
 
 I I Quality of print varies/ 
 
 Quality indgale de I'impression 
 
 Includes supplementary material/ 
 Comprend du materiel suppl^mentaire 
 
 Only edition available/ 
 Seule Edition disponible 
 
 The 
 sha 
 TIN 
 whi 
 
 Mai 
 diff 
 enti 
 beg 
 righ 
 reqi 
 met 
 
 D 
 
 Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata 
 slips, tissues, etc., have been refilmed to 
 ensure the best possible image/ 
 Les pages totalement ou partiellement 
 obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata, une pelure, 
 etc., ont 6t6 filmdes d nouveau de faqon h 
 obtenir la meilleure image possible. 
 
 \1 
 
 Additional comments:/ 
 Commentaires suppldmentaires; 
 
 Docket title is bound as last page but filmed as first pa«?e on fiche, 
 Creases in the pages may result in distortion of sone text. 
 
 This item is filmed at the reduction ratio checked below/ 
 
 Ce document est fllm6 au taux de reduction indiqud ci-dessous. 
 
 10X 14X 18X 22X 
 
 26X 
 
 30X 
 
 T71 
 
 12X 
 
 16X 
 
 20X 
 
 24X 
 
 28X 
 
 32X 
 
Tho copy filmed here has been reproduced thanks 
 to the generosity of: 
 
 Metropolitan Toronto Library 
 Canadian History Department 
 
 The images appearing here are the best quality 
 possible considering the condition and legibility 
 of the original copy and in keeping with the 
 filming contract specifications. 
 
 Original copies in printed paper covers are filmed 
 beginning with the front cover and ending on 
 the last page with a printed or illustrated impres- 
 sion, or the back cover when appropriate. Ail 
 other original copies are filmed beginning on the 
 first page with a printed or illustrated impres- 
 sion, and ending on the last page with a printed 
 or illustrated impression. 
 
 L'exemplaire film6 fut reproduit grfice d la 
 g6n6rosit6 de: 
 
 Metropolitan Toronto Library 
 Canadian History Department 
 
 Les images suivantes ont dtd reproduites avec le 
 plus grand soin. compte tenu de la condition et 
 de la netteti de l'exemplaire filmd, et en 
 conformity avec les conditions du contrat de 
 filmage. 
 
 Les exemplaires originaux dont la couverture en 
 papier est imprim^e sont film^s en commenpant 
 par le premier plat et en terminant soit par la 
 dernidre page qui comporte une empreinte 
 d'impression ou d'illustration, soit par le second 
 plat, salon le cas. Tous Iss autres exemplaires 
 originaux sont filmds en commenpant par la 
 premidre page qui comporte une empreinte 
 d'impre'jsion ou d'illustration et en terminant par 
 la dernidre page qui comporte une telle 
 empreinte. 
 
 The last recorded frame on each microfiche 
 shall contain the symbol —^ (meaning "CON- 
 TINUED"), or the symbol V (meaning "END"), 
 whichever applies. 
 
 Maps, plates, charts, etc., may be filmed at 
 different reduction ratios. Those too large to be 
 entirely included in one exposure are filmed 
 beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to 
 right and top to bottom, as many frames as 
 required. The following diagrams illustrate the 
 method: 
 
 Un des symboles suivants apparaitra sur la 
 dernidre image de cheque microfiche, selon le 
 cas: le symbole — ► signifie "A SUIVRE", le 
 symbole V signifie "FIN". 
 
 Les cartes, planches, tableaux, etc., peuvent 6tre 
 filmds d des taux de reduction diff6rents. 
 Lorsque le document est trop grand pour dtre 
 reproduit en un seul clichd, il est filmd d partir 
 de Tangle supdrieur gauche, de gauche d droite, 
 et de haut en bas, en prenant le nombro 
 d'images n^cessaire. Les diagrammes suivants 
 illustrent la mdthode. 
 
 T71 
 
 32X 
 
 1 2 3 
 
 1 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 4 
 
 i 
 
 5 
 
 6 
 
o 
 > 
 
 o 
 
 53 
 
 ^ 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 N- 
 
 
 
 
 Wl 
 
 
 V 
 
 
 
 
 !>3 
 
 
 
 
 3 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 >» 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 *i* 
 
 
 'X 
 
 3 
 ^ 
 
 
 -/; 
 
 o 
 
 
 
 
 IS 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 s 
 
 r 
 
 r 
 
 c 
 
 r- 
 
 PI 
 
 r 
 
 
 
 1-^ 
 
 5^ 
 
 c 
 2 
 
 X 
 
 5 
 
 
 
 2 
 
 r 
 
 r; 
 
 > 
 
 
 
 - 
 
 - 
 
 r 
 
 .J 
 
 
 ■^ 
 
 
 >r 
 
 S 
 
 . ._ 
 
 
 
 u 
 
 R 
 
 
 w 
 
 •0 
 
 ►d 
 
 «^ 
 
 ^ 
 
 
 
 »** 
 
 ^x 
 
 n 
 
 Pv 
 
 >• 
 
 > 
 
 r" 
 
 ■ a 
 
 3_ 
 
 
 M 
 
 r 1 
 
 H 
 
 C 
 
 
 f 
 
 
 v. 
 
 ^■ 
 
 
 C 
 
 P3 
 
 Mm 
 
 > 
 
 o 
 
 2 
 
 
 
 s/ 
 
 
 r-" 
 
 O 
 
 > 
 
 
 
 
 
 ■ O 
 
 2. 
 
 
 
 C« 
 
 r 
 r 
 
 c 
 > 
 
 "-J 
 X 
 
 w 
 
 s 
 
 
 v^~,-« 
 
 ^ 
 
 ^> 
 
 
 -> 
 
 >^ 
 
 
 a: 
 
 o 
 
 w 
 
 n 
 
 ■0 
 
 c 
 
 B 
 H 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 ST 
 
 
 
 
 o 
 
 C 
 
 
 
 
 
 *• 
 
 
 
 
 ■^ 
 
 •n 
 
 
 ,^;;t<^«BI^»Jag^-^<^-^g^iWr^W-v-a«gflKaLa^^ 
 
WAK;i'V..lai2 
 
IN THE PIMVY COl \ni.. 
 
 IN AN AIM'EAL FROM TFIE COITRT OF APPEAL OF TFIE 
 PROVINCE OF IJi'PER CANADA. 
 
 
 GRANT POWELL. ELIZABETH I'OW'ELL. and SAAU'EL ) 
 
 PETERS JARVIS. the Executors of WILLI AM Va.tei.i.ants; 
 DUMMER POWELL, (liaas,,! ; V 
 
 SIMON WASHRURN. tlu> A.lministrntor. with tho Will J 
 
 annexed otJAMES MONK, deceased. ,- HKspovnKNT. 
 
 CASE 
 
 OF THE H ESI' ON O E N T. 
 
 ^ In the vcar isofl, .Fames Mo„k cmmonced an Action oC Dd.t in the fo.nt .,C Ki„,A „.,. 
 
 Bench, ot the Province of Upper Canada, a^^ainst William Dunnner Powell, to reco^er i •<• »• 1 >!- < ,„.a,la 
 sum of money, and niterest thereon, due to him. ....<■.>.. 
 
 Actiiiii <if I)i III, 
 M.iiik c. I'OMI II.' 
 
 The proceedings in that Court are similar in fbrm to ,!,.. oi.l pro.re.Iin.^s hv Mill in 
 the Conrt of Queen's Ik-nch. in Kngland, and the Declaration .•untamed several" Co.mts 
 
 It Ks set ont at length in the Appendix, No. ,. pa.^e ,0.) .hi.h is the tran.npt of tlu' x,„„ ,, , , • 
 
 Record >n the Conrt of Appeal of Upper Canada, from which Court this Appeal ishron.dit. ^^- j^"^' ' '"^"- 
 
 The rirst Count was upon a Judgment obtained hv Mr. .Monk, a-ains, M, Powell In i. i 
 
 theCoun of O,mmo. Pleas, ofthcProvinceofLowerC'anad: ..n the .7,h\!f X::l: '''" 
 
 ,<)K where n- Mr. Monk recovered against Mr. Powell CM.f. r,s. •>,,. ,.„rrencv ol Low..- 
 ( anada, with interest thereon, from the 1st of April, 17M», until actual payment. 
 
 The second Count was upon a Boml, or single R,||, ,„uler Seal, heariii.r ,|at.. the -th 
 o. Apnl, ,78!.. wherehy Mr. l-owell acknowle.lged that he had re<.e.ed tn.m Mr. mU 
 H /'■;;;" M.n, he promised and hound himself to pay, with iawti.l „„.,.., ,, 
 
 the rate ot £(). per cent, from the 1st of April, 17,S(). 
 
 The third Count was upon an Instrument or Agreement in writing, dated the '-th of 
 April, .7Sf,, In winch Mr. Powell acknowledged that he had leeeivedfat his ow.^ r:;!.:;! 
 
Appoixlix, Nil I. 
 
 I'llilS. 
 
 Kqilirntioii. 
 Apiiemlix, No. 1, 
 
 (G.) 
 
 fh)iii Mr. Monk ttl ». ,"..<.•.'</.. vsliich hi' pniniiscd, and olihm-d hiniMlt to pus, witli lawful 
 intirt^t thcicoii, at llii' rati- of tti. \wr tviit. from tin- 1st of .\pril, 17H<». 
 
 Tin- foinlli, litHi, and sixth « oinifs wito ri'spcctivilv for nioiU'V li'iit, nioncv had and 
 recfivfd, and npoii an Account stated. 
 
 pag,. 7, To this Dcchiratioii, Mr Powell pleaded — 
 
 First. As to the tirst, third, foiuth, tilth, and sixth ("ounts,— //// dilicf. 
 
 Hrvuiidlji. As to the second Count, That the writing ohligatoiy, tlierein-iiientioncd, 
 was not his deed. 
 
 Tliirdlij. As to the tirst Count, That after the recovery of tiie .ludgiuent therein- 
 nieiitioned, Mr. Monk, on the ','7th December, 17!tl., for olitaininu,- satisfaction tiiercof, 
 causeil to be sued out a Writ of Kxccutioii at;ainst tiie good' and chattels, and (in case the 
 same should not be sulHcieiit to satisfy the debt, interest^ and costs,) against the lands and 
 tenements of Mr. Powell, directed to the Sheritf of the district of Montreal; and upon 
 which the .Sherirt'causeil to be made the said debt, interest, and costs. 
 
 Fourthli/ and Flf)lih/. As to the first and second Counts, respectively, — payment. 
 
 Si.iili/i/. As to the third, fourth, titMi, and sixth Coiuits, a period of limitation, — That 
 the causes of action therein-mentioned diil not accrue within six years; and, 
 
 Seventhly. As to the whole Declaration,-— a set ott". 
 
 Mr. Monk, l)v his replication, joined issue upon tiie first and second Picas, and 
 traversed the third, vi/. — Tliat he did not cause to he sued out the said Writ of Execution, 
 n(n- did tiie .Sheriff' cause to be made tiie said debt, interest, and costs, in manner, &c.; and 
 he also traversed the other Picas, respectively, in the form usually made use of in the 
 Courts at Westminster. 
 
 The following is a Copy of the Replication:— 
 
 p.igp 8. 
 
 " And tiie said James Monk, as to the said Pleas of the said William, by iiim firstly 
 and secondly above pleailed, and whereof he hath put himself upon the country, doth 
 the like. And the said James, as to the said Plea of the said William, by him above 
 pleaded, saith, that he the saiil James Monk, by reason of any tiling by him the said 
 William in tiiat Plea allegeil, ought not to be barred from having and maintaining liis 
 aforesaid action thereof, against him the said William, because he saith that he the said 
 James did not cause to be sued out of the said Court, in that Plea mentioned, the said 
 supposed Writ of Execution, in that Plea mentioned; nor did the said Sherifi", in that Plea 
 also mentioned, cause to be made the said debt, interest, and costs of Suit, in form aforesaid, 
 recovered, or any part thereof, in manner and form as tlie said W^illiam hath above, in his 
 last-meiitioned Plea, alleged; and this he prays may be iiKpiired of by the coi-ntry, &c. 
 
 " And the said James, as to the Pica of him the said William, by him fourthly above 
 pleaiied, saith, that he the said James, by reason of any tiling by the said William in tiiat 
 Plea alleged, ought not to be barred from having and maintaining his aforesaid action 
 thereof, against him the said William, because he saith that the said William did not i)ay 
 to him the said .Fames the said debt, interest and costs aforesaid, in form aforesaid 
 recovered, in manner and form as the said William hath above, in his said Plea in that 
 behalf alleged; and this he, the said James, prays may be inquired of by the country, &c. 
 
I 
 
 I 
 
 9 
 
 plfadi'd, siitli, tliat he till' sai.l JaiiK'., I.\ rw 
 
 I'lia alli'jriil ^r|,t i„,t to l>,. I,i,i,.,l th.in huv 
 
 I'*"!! ot am thiiit; Uy tli,. ,ai.l \Vil|,an, ,„ ilui 
 
 ";: ami niaiiitaiiiiiii,' li:> atliio.iul aiti.i! 
 
 toKctlu.,- w.th all .,„.,..., .l,u. ,lK.a.o„. acvordu., ,o ,1,. ,;„„. a„.l ..,.;..•, ,., ,1... .aul I u. 
 ol. ...a.-.n . ,„ .nan.u.r an.l ,onu a. tia- sai.l Willia.n ha.h abuv. in ,l.a, I'La all.,...! n. ,l.a' 
 bfiiaK; an.l this l.e j.rays n.ay l,e in<,uin..l „f l,y the onnfrv. 
 
 " An.1 .1,0 sai.| .lames as to tlu- sai.l I'La .,t Inn. ,1... sa,.l W,llia,M, l.v l,„n Mx.hlv 
 
 n ,lu.roo a,a,nst l.„n; Invause, 1. sa, . ,1,. saul s.^-al . a use of ac,H.„. ,„ „,. sa. 
 c. on. .„. ac..n..to hin, ,1. sa... ,,a,n.. ...Inn s. u.-rs ,...,i..v .lu- ..h,,.,..,; ^ 
 
 H : '-^ ;-,™"'I -'-' a^-s, the sa,.. Mm..,.,, to wi,. at York as aforesaid. i„ the 
 
 l^^^d sa, h. tha, he the sa,.l Ja„,es. by reason of any thin, by ,h.. sa,.l Uill,a„; ,n that 
 lea alleged, .n,,,l,t not to be ba.Te.l fro,n l.avin. an.l ,„a„„a„„n,. his a.or.sai.l Aet,o„ 
 tl,e,..,f a.a„,st I,,,,,, beeanse. he says that he the sai.l Ja,nes was n.,t no,- ,s ,n.l..bte.l to the 
 sa,d \\ , ,a,u ,„ n,a,„,er .,,.1 tbrn. as the sai.l Millian. hath abov e in his s„.l last I'l... in tha. 
 bchaH allegcl. a„.l ,h,s he ,he sai.l Ja.nes p.-ays n,ay be in.pn.v.l .,f by ,h.. ..onnt.y. .V. " 
 
 The Cause ca„K> on to be t,ie.l at the .Sitti„fr.s ,„■ ,he (-...nt a.i.T H,la,y Ter.n. IS-ti 
 when a V e,-.bet was o„„d ,b,- Monk (the plaintiff) „po,. all the ,ss„es. IM. 'x; ,o ^ ' .^d' 
 lWs.O,te M„ll.,„. .n,,i..t to the opinion of, he Co,,,-. ,n Han.o on ..;,,ai,; p.is 
 
 The ti.llowi„g Irulo,se,ne„t was „,a.le in the nsnal fi.rn, on ,h.. Xisi IVins lUror.l bv , , 
 the p,-oi.er ofteer at N,si IVins, afte,- the finding .,f iJa. J„rv n-l..r».m..„, .,„ tl,.. 
 
 " Veniict tor the Plaintiff; seven hnn.he.l an.l fbrtv ponn.Is. seven shillings JBS^^ 
 an.l n,ne pence tine., fa.things .lebt, an.l one :shilii„g .L.n.ages. subject ( Q- ) 
 
 to the ..],n,i.,n of the Co.irt ab.,ve on p.,in,s ,eserv...l." 
 
 (Signe.l) " I.. 1>. SiiKi.wo.),), J." 
 
 The points ,-eserve.l at Nisi IVius f;,r the opinion of the C.,,,,, in Bane,, were n,ne in 
 n„,nbe,-, and ai-e as fbll.)w: 
 
 The ti,-st was-That the Jn.lgment pro.lnce.l in support of the first Count was voi.l 
 upon the face of ,t, and thereibre insufficient to sustain the H,st Cnnt. 
 
 The secon.l was That if the Jn.lg.nent be not voi.l on the face of ,t. it is un .r 
 
 d una under the Laws of Lower Cana.la; v,..-Tl,e Onbnance an.l Statutes of he 
 
 :z';;.: : ^^^.^ -'«-[ -; ---- "" p-h...,i.>n of the c.,, pmne., bv au,;i ■ 
 
 >n that 1 ,o^,nce. and ,f so vo,.l. the hrst Count founde.l thereon co.ld „..t be sustaine.l. ' 
 
 The thi,d was-That it app..a,ed .„, the .ac.. of the .v.len.-e pro.lu.v.l th.t the 
 I"st.u„.e„t ..eclare.. on the secon.l Count was th.. .an,e upon wh,.,, ' Ju.t,';;: 1 
 
 N... I, |.,K.. W. 
 
 (H.) 
 
 Piiini- l(i>iTV(il. 
 Al'liiiiilix, 
 
 No. -J. |«i;:r L'H. 
 
I 
 
 iitit;iiiuil, «lii(li .lii(|._riiiiiil «a^ iiiinvt'i^f.l, .iiiil tliai it w.i> (■(iii->'(|iiiiitl\ im'ip'il in ilic 
 lli>flnT si'«'lirit\, Mild idiild Milt lie |p|()ilii(iil III ^ll|l|l(l|■| ot'llic »i((ill(l (oiillt. 
 
 'I'lir tiiiiitli— 'I'liai ii aii|Haii'(l nil the t'aci of tlu' i\ iiliiici', thai iiimIci tlic ,liiili;nu'nt 
 ill I.iiuir Canada which thf DiCiiidaiit maiiitaiiii'd to he iircfiidar, the real Kstatc of the 
 Dcli'iuhiiil ii|i(iii whii-h the Di'ht was (irifriiially si-ciired, iKwoll uh upon siifh othiT ffUrts a-* 
 the Dflriidant poHsi'ssi'd at tlii' tiiiic, or >.hoiild licconu' ])ossi'sst'd of, was si'i/cd in I'xi'cntioii, 
 and lii'iiifi i'\|io>t'd In thf Sliciitl at |inl)hc auction, was sold and conveyed to the I'laiiititl' 
 as the piircliaser at micIi aiiilioii, and that Mich Iraii^fcr niii^t I)c taken to he a satisfaction 
 of 'he delit and a liar to rt'co\erv ii|ioii the M'colid Count. 
 
 Tile fifth — That it appeared on the lace of the e\ ideiice that the Instiiniiellt lii'cliired 
 on ill the third Count, was the ^anii' on which .IiidLliiieiit was \et iinre\crsed, and that such 
 InstriiiiKiit was tliercfiire iiieiji:ed in the .(uilj^nieiit, and coiihl not he iiiodiiced to entitle 
 the I'laiiitill'to recoM'i on the thud Count. 
 
 The ^i\th— That I'laintitrs iii;lil to reco\ci upon the third Count, was hariid li\ the 
 traiisler of till' Defendilllt's property in execution upon tln' .Iiidu'inent, as conteiiiled with 
 rei^ard to the second ('ouiil, 
 
 1'hese\entli — That the liisli uimiit jirodiiced by the I'lailltitt' in support of the third 
 Count, was the same Instriiini'iil upon which the I'laiiitifV relied in sujiport of the second 
 Count, and which the Deleiidant admitted upon the issue on that Count to he his bond, as 
 stated; and that if, therefore, coulil not be received as evidence of |)ar()le afjreement under 
 ti." third Count. 
 
 The eijfhth — That no admissible evidence was uixiii to jirovi' an ackiiowledjjmcnt of a 
 debt within six years, and timf the I'laiiitirt's recovery upon the third, tiinrth, iiftli, and 
 sixth Counts, was, theii'fore, barred by the I'lea of the .Statute of Limitations. 
 
 .\nd till' ninth — 'I'liat if the evidence adduced was admissible to prove an imdertakinj; 
 within six vears, ne\ ertheless the I'laintifVliaviiiir replied nclin inirt'ril, an.l not a subseipieiit 
 undertaking specially, did not support his issue by such proof. 
 
 4 
 
 l'"\i<li'iir(' iilliidi-il til ill 
 till' I*iiintt* ri'siTvi'ii. 
 
 The e\ idence alluded to in the points reserved, were certain Exhibits which are set 
 at 111 the .•\ppendix, viz. — 
 
 A|iiMiiilix, No. •-', p. 1(). The Bond executed bv the Appellant to the Respondent, dated the '.'7th of April, 17^9. 
 
 (A.) 
 
 Appiiiilix. Nil. ■-', ]). 17. The proceedings in the (^)urt of Common Pleas of Lower Canada, on the i)art of the 
 
 (U.) Itespondent in Xovember Term, 17!»l'. 
 
 Appi'iiilix, No. -J, The .ludgment of the said Coiiit, dated '-'7fh of Xoveniber, 17!»K whereby the Court 
 
 paiii' l;<. (K.) ordered the Deleiidant to pay to the I'laintirt" the sum of .£11,'$ .J.v. '.W. current money of 
 
 pagr 17. ( C.) *''^' '''■<>\'"f*^> with the interest u))on this suni from the 1st day of April, I78!), until payment, 
 
 .^ ^-j . and costs of Suit. T3iit inasmuch as it ajjpeared by the Sheritrs return, that the service of 
 
 '"'*"" ' ^ "^'^ the said Writ was made by leaving a co])y of the same and of the Declaration annexed, at 
 
 (Uv) (i^v) the last domicile and jjlace of residence of the said Defendant, It is ordered that before 
 
 execution issue in consequence of the said Judgment, the riaiiitiff do give good and 
 
 sufficient security, to be approved by the Court, to refund to the Defendant or his legal 
 
 Ueinesentatixes, as much as the Defendant a])])eariitg by himself or his legal attorney 
 
 within a year and a day from that date, might be able to set aside, and reverse of the said 
 
 .ludgment, upon a reconsideration of the merits thereof. 
 
5 
 
 I'lii- S.'iiiiitN yixfii III |Hir>ii,iiic.' <il 111. ■ villi .liiilu'iiimt. il.iic.l ■.'t'lili.ii DitcihIht, I7'H. 
 
 'I'lu' Writ of Kxcriitioli mi llii> >;ii.l .liidirini'iil, diit.'il ..'Till of Dit.muIht, \'<,n, ;mil 
 the liuloiM'iiU'iit tluridri ..(' tlii' Naiiic ilalc. to Irvv t.Jt!*. 1(1,. ll,/„ aiul iiitin>i fmin llic 
 7tli of NoviMiilu'i-, I7S!), till|>ayiiuiit; the I'laiiitirt', on llu' sai.l 7tli o) \.n,inl.,r. I7S!». 
 having: ii'ci'ivcti CT'J. S.«. .((/. in pui ,,f th,. ,;,|,1 piiiuipal mum. 
 
 Tlif Ki'tmii tl-Tcto, ailil the |)n)civiliiiir^ in the Cinirl upon the •.M>\ Hfliiiii, 
 wluiiln, athr d^po^iiij; of an iiittiloiiiton claim ■mI ii|i to tlir |)iopiit\, >ii/cil t>\ <irtain 
 tliir.l pailii^, till' Mini oC Cll'i. l-.v. s,/. «as .lirirttil to In' paid l)v llii' SluTilf to tlio 
 I'laintirt'towanls the satisfaction of lii> lUl.t, iiiiiri^t. and tosts, savinjj to tlic I'luintilV his 
 itTonrsf a^'ainst the Di'fcndant for tlii' ivsuhif of \i\> diinaiiil. 
 
 \|i|»imIh. Nil. ■.', |i !•>. 
 
 (F.) 
 
 \p|N li>||\. V... •.'. |1. •Jll. 
 
 \|>|u'iiilit. Nil. 1'. 
 I'li:.- -.'ii .111.1 l'I. 
 
 (II and I.) 
 (N iiiid O.) 
 
 In till' lollowiiig EastiT 'IVini a iiilc was ohtaiiud on luhalt Ol ilic Dil'iiidaiit 
 (I'owill) in the Court in Itanio, caJiinj; ii|)onilii' l'laintill'(Monk) to show caiisi- wli\ tho 
 vi'idic't ahoM'-iiR'ntioiKd, ri'iiikrcd lor linn, should not iif sit aside, and a iionsiiit iiitin-d 
 upon tin.' |)oints ivscrvod at the trial, with li-avi- to move afti-rwards t'or a n.w trial, should 
 the o|.iiii()ii of tho Court be with tlii' I'iaintirt'on tiiosc points, on ||n. i:roiind of th,. xirdict 
 being (.■ontrarv to evidi'iice. 
 
 The rule was arnued in the same Terni, and in the tiillow.ntr Triintv ■l\riii was 
 discharifed by tlu' Court. 
 
 In Mieliaelmas Term .Judgment was given tiir the I'laiiititl' for Ins debt, damages, and 
 costs; which .ludg-nelit was duly entered aiul dockelted as of that term. 
 
 The following is a cojjy of the .Iiidgmeiit, as entered on tiic record, and of the 
 Meinorandmn of the Docket thereof: 
 
 .\|.piiiiln. V.i. :.', |i. •_>!>. 
 
 (S.) 
 
 l.M-1 .i| April, IS'Jii. 
 Milium 111 •! I n.iil,. till' 
 \ < rilii't, ami In iiitir a 
 
 N'llllsllll III! (Ill' |Mli||tll 
 
 rr« i»iil, or fur a mw 
 trial. 
 
 .\|.|'iiiilix. Nil. ••', (1. .'Jtl. 
 
 (T and V.) 
 
 ■JKlll 1,1 .llllll', iMli),. 
 
 .•|l>lli"lNi)vrniliir, IHL'li. 
 A|i[i<iiili\, Nil. I, |i. II. 
 
 (I.) 
 
 " And thereupon all and singuhir the premises being seen, and bv the Court of our 
 .said Lord the King, befi.re the King himself, now lieiv fuliv understood, ami mature 
 delilieratiou being thereupon had, IT I.S CONSIDKKKI) by the same Court, that the 
 said .lames do recover against the sai.l William his said de!)t 'and his damages aforesaid, 
 to one shilling, by the .lury aforesaid in li.rm ati)resaid assessed; and ak,, forty-four 
 l)oun,ls, eighteen shillings and ten pence, for his costs and charges bv the Court of our 
 said Lord the King, now here adjudged of increase to the said .fames, and with Ins 
 as.sent; which said damages, costs, and charges, in the whole amount to li.rtv-tbur pounds, 
 nineteen shillings and four pence- And let the said William Powell, inasmuch as he halli 
 denied his deed, be taken, &c.; and as to the sum of Ibur thousaii.l si.x JMin.lied and 
 seventy-seven pounds, three shillings and eight pence farthing, parcel of the said sum 
 aliove demanded, let the said William Dunimer Powell be acjuitted, and -o thereof; 
 without day, &c." 
 
 ".Judgment signed, entered, and docketted, the 30th d.iy of Xovenil)pr, 
 fH'.>(i, as of Michaelmas Term, in the 7th year of the reign of 
 King George the Fourth." 
 
 (.Signed) "Cii.\KLKs C. .Sm.m.i,, 
 
 "Clerk of the Crown." 
 
 In the beginning of the year I8Q7, Powell applie.l to the Court of Appeal of ilie 
 Province of Upper Canada, for a Writ of Appeal upon the al)o\e .Jiidgmei.f. 
 
 The Writ of Appeal fi.r this Province is in the same fbnn as the onlinary Writ of 
 Error, upon a .Judgment 111 the I'lnglish Courts at Westminster; but Powell applied that m 
 
 FJ 
 
 \|>|iiiiili\, Nil. I, page -J 
 
 (A.) 
 
 \-i lit laijuarv, I«a7. 
 
ulilitiiiii III lilt' MKitlci ciiiiMliu-il III i;.c coiiiMioii liimi, the Ciiiirl iuiow slimilil Ik> ri'(|iiiri'it 
 III SI Mil Willi till' Ki'ciinl, " ((// ////• iiriiiiiinl puiiirx nin/ iirnivfiliiiirx fiuniil in l/ir Hi inn/ ur 
 Urfrixhrs iif'llit: Court." 
 
 ['\um the .1th of March in that Mar, tln'Coiiit of Api)i'al, athr ilrliluratiim, rofiiHi'il to 
 |K'rmit a W'lil of .\|)|Mal to isiiu' m ilic limn |i|()|iom'iI; ami tli("vu|ioii I'owi'il MU'd out a 
 .\|p|MrMlix, \m. I, |M).- •-'. Wiit of A|i|i('al ill llif iiMia! fiiiiii, (ill I'ait, an oriliiiai\ Writ ot' Krror) which was tcsU'il 
 ( ■•• ) iipoii till' fitli of Mairli, IS'.',, anil uliini ililf on llii' '.'inl of April in the same year. 
 
 .\|i|Hiiilix, Nil. I, |iiip:i. No return was cNcr niailc to this Wrii, ami iipoii the ','.iil of ,Iainiar\, I.S.Ul, ai! 
 
 (U.) a|)|)li( atioii was niailc liy tlii' Di'ffinlanl I'owill to the Coiirl i.i' ,\]i|u'al, recitinj; the 
 
 A|>,.li™ti,,nti,ilii(;,>nri l),.t;.||,luiil's a|ipluati..n tin- the liist proposeil Wril of Appeal; the refusal of the Court 
 
 III A|i|imll>i ilin rt( null ' ' ' ' . 
 
 I)il.m,i..ii riil\ iill D.jiii- of Appe.il In iiiinpiy \Mlli that appliialion; the secoiiil Writ of Appeal in ihe usual lorni, 
 
 "hn'h r'.hulpmMr«'a^ "'"' ''''" ''"' •'"''-^- "'' 'I"' <'"'"' "'' ^""r^'^ "'"<li ''•"' 'I'" ^^'i'< 'lu' -aid Writ of Appeal to 
 
 timmlrii. them ill lliat liehaK lin . cleil, nor hail llie) done any thinn- thereupon, and prayiiifj; tliiit the 
 
 ( 'oiH I of Appeal slioiild eon mil the ( 'oiirt lielow to eertity to theiii, (the ( "oiirl of Appeal,) 
 
 " (/// fi-ii/iiiff mill ilniiniii'iifs ii'iiiniiii/ifi- in tliiir riixlni/i/ iijinii irliii'/i tlif siiiil Jiii/iriiii'/if 
 
 inis ri'iidi'ii'il." 
 
 i.'7ili iir,laiiii:ir\. ,>*:w. The Court of Apjieal, atU'r deliberation, irfiisril to issue .siieli eoinniand, and thereupon 
 
 I I'lii'a!!!'.' '■''''''''' "iioiher Writ in the usual iJinn of an alias writ was sued out by I'owell, directed to the 
 
 Aiipciulix. No. l.|p;igc t. llu'ii .Iiidj^es of the Court cf Kinjj;'s JJeiich, wiiicli, after recitini; the toriner Writ, and that 
 
 ( ll. ) lii'tiiie any return was made, the Chiet" .lusliee to whom it wa.> luecled had ceased to be 
 
 Chiet .Justice; and that it was prayed by I'owi'll, thai an alias writ miiiiit issue directed to 
 
 the tlu'ii .Indies. The writ proceeded in the tiirm ot' a Writ ot' Krror, to conunand the 
 
 Coiiil below to send up the l{ecori! and proeeeilinj;s, &c., to the Court ot' Appeal. This 
 
 Writ was lested liie ','nd of April, 1S'.>7, and made returnable on the'-'.sth of .January, IS.iO, 
 
 Appinilix, No. I. Cpoii till' day prescribed, the Court below made tliiir return in llie usual form. 'I'he 
 
 D.'il.-ir.-ition, |i.')(^ hj.) jJecord returned is in all respects similar to a lli'cord of the Mnolish Court at Westminster; 
 
 I'liiis p. 7( jr.") coiilaininu, an entry of the I'leadiiifis — the award of the .Jury I'roeess — the entry of the 
 
 lliplicaiion. p.H^Ci. ) *^ 'anse of Nisi I'rins — the return of the I'oslea — and the .Jiid<>inent. 
 
 IWia, p. l<i(H.) 
 
 .Iiiilpnrnt, p. 11(1.) 
 
 Appi'iidiN, No. I, p. 1 1. 
 
 (J.) 
 
 Upon the J Itli of Aufiust, l.H.'it), Powell assigned reasons of Appeal: they are several 
 in niiinbcr. 
 
 'I'he tirst is the Common Assignment of Errors: namely, — 'J'hat in the Record and 
 I'roceedings, and also in the giving the .Judgment, there was manifest error in this, to wit, 
 that the Ueciaration and tiie matter therein contained, were not sufficient in law for the 
 said .James Monk to have or maintain his action thereof, against the said William Dninmer 
 I'owell; and that there was also error in this, that by the liecord aforesaid, it appeared that 
 .Judgment had been given for the said .James Monk, against the said William Duinnier 
 rowell, whereas by the Law of the Land, .Judgment ought to have been given for the said 
 William Dunnner I'owell, against the said .Janus Monk. 
 
 i 
 
 Secondly, — That there was also error in this, to wit. That the said .ludgnicnt of the 
 Court of King's Bench was erroneous, illegal, and unjust, inasmuch, that the Action was by 
 Hill against the Chief .Justice, comiirising divers Counts, none of which contained just cau.se 
 of Action. 
 
 Thirdly, — That there was also error in this, to wit. That the first Count was upon a 
 !''oreign .Judgment of the Court of Common Pleas, at Montreal, beiring date more than 
 thirty years before, and in ])art executed in the year l~[)5, by .Sheriffs sale, in execution of 
 the real Estate of the Ajjpellant. 
 
l-"oiirlhl>.— 'I'liat iluT.'W!isii|so frn.r i.. this. i.MMt, TImI lli, •.cc-.n,! C.iMit in Ui. -...ul 
 Hill »y:is ,.ii th.' ...i.if \Mitini.'..l.lii:;,t..n. wli.fli Ini.l hwii oaiicflU.I In th, ^;,i.l .lii.lpivnt ol 
 the t'diirt at Moiiiiviil, ami uas tlKTvUnf no just cansf ot' Aciioi.. 
 
 Fimily.— 1 iiat fhcrv wm-< aUn v,,i>r in tin., to wit. That tlu- tliir.l Coimi in th, ,ai.l 
 Hill, was iii>oi. a not., of han.l lor tHJ .'«. •.',/.. h.-ariii- .lat.> iho :iu\ .lay of April. ITS't. 
 ami laiuvlhd on flic ..'7tli day of April. 17H!I, by pa-siiii; lu.foiv iiotary'-piililu' I'apiman. 
 at Montival. a writing; ohli^atoi for tlir amount of tlu- -.aiii iiotf. wl.m-hv tlu' >«ii.l note 
 was li-allv ami virtually nine flU'.i, altlioiiirl, framlnl, ntly rctaincil l.y th,- Hispon.l, it. ami 
 tliuii iisi-d as a ileinaiul for its amount. 
 
 Sixthly,— That tlu'ic was also error in this, to «it. That llu' toiirtli Count ii. the said 
 Hill, was thr aicoiint of nioniis paid and icct'iN d. an.! sitmits ri'iid.r.d l.rfori- thi> .Jr.l <.f 
 April, l/Sf), at which tiiiic the said account wasscttlcil, and the lialaiuv, £H.t r,.s. '>ri. paid 
 by t' same not, ,,f hand lor that sum, wliici' was on the '.'Ttli .lay of April, I7S!I. caiu'cllcd 
 an.l icmlcri.l void by the execution before notary, of a v ritiii^' obligatory tbr the amount 
 e.;,!. .aleiil to a bond and iiioit,t;a-:e, heiiiM; the same b.iml <,r writinj: obliiratoi v in the ^e.'oml 
 Count .if the Mill, on which the .liidpiu'Ut then app.ah.l from, was ^n^u bv the Court of 
 King's Hunch ajiaiiist law and erroiu sl\, ami which oinrht to be reveisc.l. " 
 
 I-astly,— That tlicrc was also error iii this, to wit. That it was agreed b.'tw.rii the 
 P' rties, ami sanctioiK.I by the Court, that any ver.lict tobe rcceive.l from the .liirv, sh.Mihl 
 
 be subject to certain points of law to be arpied betbre the ,fu.ljres. and the opini," I ili.^ 
 
 Court had upon their Ic-al etfect, accordiiif,' to which le-al opiMi.>n the xcrdut of il... .lurv 
 was tobe rcceive.l or rcjcctcl. That the sai.l I.-miiI points were ar-u.'il before lie Court, and 
 the opinion of the Court was then severally proiioiimcl .rniiiroiislN , an.l . ontrarv to .ii.' law 
 of the land, ami thereuiioii the ver.lict .if the jury, ernineoiislv and ille^r;dU. was conhrme.l 
 by the .fiidfrment of the Court from whence Appeal was ma.l.-." Ami th.' Appellant prave.l in 
 the usual f.,rm of the c.)uclusi.,n of an Assijrnmeiit of Errors, that the .Jml-meiit afotesai.l (i.r 
 the errors ah.rcsaul, ami ..ther errors in the Hec.r.l. ami pro.e.,iiiiirs af.resai.l mi-rh, |„. 
 reversed, anniille.l, an.l alt.vether liehl tbr i.otliiiijr, an.l that he nii-lit be restoivd. cVe. 
 
 On .he loth of December, a su^rjrestion was ma.le t.. the Court that Monk was .lead. A,,p.n,liv. N„. i ,, ,n 
 (m fact he ha.l died uii.in or ab.iiil the loth of November. IS'.'t).) an.l the Court .irdere.l ^'w-^'"'<< "f <l'"tl, ..f' 
 that unless answer to the said Reasons of Appeal were tile.l within (i.ur davs. the Court """' 
 woiil.l pr..cee.l r.r pnrtr; an,' the (■.•iirt .lirecte.l, that Notice tlier..,f slionl.l be .uiv..,i to 
 Monk's Administrator, and a further day was pvcn until the i7th ..f D.rcmb.r. 
 
 Uimn this .lay it appear...! that \<.tice ha.l been pven to ,Sim..n Washburn, the a s N„ i ,, n 
 
 A.lnmiistrator ot Monk, and the present itesp.mdent, but he .lid not appear, ..r aii-w.r the '''"" >•"*'" "' ^^-l- 
 said reasons. '"'"'■ 
 
 yP"" t'l^' '^l^t of Dcremher, another application was ma.le to the Co„r. of App.al on A,,, ,„l,x. N„. 1. ,,. la 
 
 behalf ..t I. .well, viz.: That theju.ljrcs of the Court below, he .liivcte.l to cans,, tlu return ^''i'''"" '" • ••"^' '•' 
 
 or the said Writ of Appeal to be amemle.l, by semliii^ up tlierewi.h, or atiaclu.l there.... nZi'^: Zui!^]:,, 
 
 /he on^nial pap,n.« nnd >/onn,wnfs/ih:,/ „t Nisi Prim, nml lh,-n „n Ih,- files „n,l in nnssess.o,, "^'cinal .lu.uni.nt, til.,! 
 of that Court, with the points reserved at NiH I'rius. subject to wlu.li the Verdict was given. '" ""' 
 
 The Court t(.ok time t.. .leliberate. 
 
 Ou the 7tli ..f .January, l.S.iV. the Court refused the above ajipluation. 
 
 On the same day, the Court of Appeal affirmed the .(u.lgmeut. an.l the cntrv t',er..ot; 
 upon recor.l. is as f..llows: 
 
 \|i|iiri(lii. Nil. 1. |i. la. 
 Ilii Ciiiirt iifuii-it till 
 •'i)']ilioatiiir>. 
 
 "And hereupon, as well the Rec.rd an.l lV.,.<.e.li.igs aforesai.l. an.l th.. .Imlpment \,,,,„„|„, Si,. 
 
 !.■). 
 
B 
 
 j;i\i'ii III liiiiii ;it'()ii'>aiil a^ llii' maltt'i> at'oioaiil, l)\ the •■aid William Diminui I'dwill aliovi- 
 lor ri'usoiis ol' A])|)t'al assigned, (hut witlioiit rt'ti'icnci' U> tlu' points ri'sfixtd at Nisi I'liiis 
 aforesaid,} Iji'iiif:; si'on and l)y tlif said Court oC A|i|ii'al here riill\ understood, and iiiatun- 
 (lelil)erati(.'ii beinji thereiipoti had, it a])|)eais to the said Court of Appeals here, that there 
 is no error eitlier in ;he Record anil Proeeeihiijjs aforesaid, or in ttiviiijr the Jiidgmeiit 
 aforesaid. T 1 1 K K K l''( ) U K IT IS CONSIDKIU:!) that the .liidjrnient aforesaid in form 
 aforesaid f^iven, he in all thiiiffs aifirined and stand in foree and effect, the several matters 
 aljove as rea-oiis of said Ap|)eal in anywise notwithstaiidiiifj;. And the said William Diimmer 
 Powell ii: luiTcy, &i ." 
 
 Anniiiiiix, No. I, p. 1-1. Upon the ','.ird of' Fehriiain, in the same year, an Appeal was made on helialf of 
 
 Appeal allouTjl. Powell to Mis late Most Hxcellent Majesty in Council, and the same was allowed hy the 
 
 said Court of Appeal of Upper Canada. 
 
 It appears, from a certified copy of the Proceed! iij;'s in the Court of A|)|)eal in Canada, 
 not heini; matter of record, transmitti'd aloiiu with the transcrij)t, that an application was 
 made on helialf of Powell, that in addition to the ordinary transcript oftlie Record, all the 
 ])rocee(lini;s had in the Cause, or with reference to it, from the conimeiicement to the con- 
 clusion, incliuliiif^ the entries from the Minute Rook, should he certified iinik'r the Great 
 Seal and transmitted to His Majesty in Council. The Court however irfusct/ In i/i'jiart 
 from Low ntid Uxn^r, <ni<l th'tcrmined t/inl nothing tiiii/d lie certified as the Record under 
 the Greiif Snil, e.rrept the Record of the Jiidfiiiieiif of that Court ujtoii the Record sent up 
 to Iheiii. Rut ilie Court, at the siiffj^estion of Counsel, instructed the Clerk that there 
 would he no ohjection to his fJiiviiif;- to the Appellant a certified copy of all the ])roceediiifrs, 
 whether the same were properly matters of' Record or not, namely, of any motions or api)li- 
 eations whether granted or refused, and of any collateral or interlocutory proceeding had 
 111 that Court on the Case. 
 
 Such certified copy was aecoi-dingly given by the clerk, lint there is noihiiig in It 
 material to the merits. 
 
 It has heen already stated that Mr. Monk is dead, and Mr. Simc'i Washhiirn, the 
 Respondent, is liis Administrator with the Will annexed. 
 
 Mr. Powell has also died since the Ajipeal; and his executors. Grant Powell, Elizabeth 
 Powell, and Samuel Peters ,Iar\is, have obtained lea\e to prosecute the same. 
 
 It is submitted with the utmost confidence, that the Judgment oftlie Court of Appeal 
 is perfectly correct. The jurisdiction of that Court is obviously that of' a Court of Krror, 
 and it is of first principles that a Court of' Error cannot look beyond the Record. In the 
 present case, no error of any kind appears upon the fiice of the Record: it seems to be 
 correct in every particular, bf(tli of form and substance. 
 
 As to tlu' points reserved at Nisi Priiis, (if it were competent for the Court to entertain 
 fliiiii, ) there would be little difficulty in showing that Monk (the Plaintifif'below) was entitled 
 to the .liulgiiient of' the Court, which he obtained upon t'lem. Not one of them go to the 
 merits of the case — they are all founded u|ion supposed technical difficiilties, for which, 
 when they come to be examined, there is not any foundation; and it seems to be admitted 
 'hat tlie nionev sued for and iccom led by Monk, was really due, and had never been paid. 
 
 Rut it is not competent for any Court of Vjipeal to entertain these points. The form 
 of proceeding of taking a verdict for a Plaintifl', and giving the Defendant leave to move to 
 enter a Xonsiiii, is of ordinary occurrence in the Courts at Westminster, from whence no 
 doubt it was adopted by the Court or' King's Reiicli, in Upper Canada. This practice is 
 
9 
 
 . iiiii|iMi:iti\.l\ lit iiKidcni oiiiiiii, :iiul \s;i> iiilioiliiccd loi tin- i'\|iiis> piiipn-f i)t saving; t(i 
 Miitors fill' cNiM'iisi- ntri'ssarily iiifiim>il b_v piiitiiiM; |ioiiit> ot'hiw upon tlif UrcDrd. ni imU-r 
 to trivf jurisilirtion to a Court of Krmrs, aiul it> ol.'uTt \\a> to avoid tlu- ikitnmIn ofijoiiif,' 
 to a Coiiil ot Appeal at all. 
 
 It i> not ohiiiiatorv upon i-iiy suitor to adopt tins lonn of liavipu points of law (Ifc-idcd— 
 it IS I'lUiroly a niattiT of a,<:iciMiK'nt from wliiili I'itlu'r party may dissi nt ; hut wIku fiitiTcil 
 into, its sul)slau(v is, tiiat the parties au'ri'c to suhiuit tlu' matters of law in lontiovcrsy 
 l)otwwu thiiu, to the .luduiiu'nl of tin- Court in wliiili llu' suit was .,rii,ri,i'il/i/ hro; nht, and 
 to hv hound l)y tlu'ir decision. 'I'liat tlniv was such an ai.Tci'nu'nt in tlie presi lU casi-, is 
 distinctl\ slated l>y tile orininal Appellant himself in the last reason of ApjKal. or allei;ed 
 special error assiuiu>d; and it would he ot'tlie most obvious injustice that one partv sliouh'. 
 he permitted to depart from an aureee • of this kin<l, ini ■ which he himsdf xohinlarily 
 entered, merelv hecaiisc the result was (luieierit d-om what he expected. 
 
 Inasmiicii, theretore, as m ilic present case, all the proceediu.us iii the wax ot' Appeal 
 are not only jjirouiulless and futile of themselves, hut ill opposition t.i the a^'reemeiit 
 voluntarily entered into hy the original Hespondent JiiniscK'; ii is liojied that the .luduimnt 
 of the Court helow will he aUirined, and the I{espondenl adjudged to hi entitled to interest 
 upon the dehl for the very lon^- jieriiKl which has elapsed dminir ihe procee<liims, and the 
 present Appeal disinis^rd wuh costs forllie liillowing- Reason, (amouf;- others:) 
 
 'J hat no error or <letiiult .)f an\ kind appears in aiiv ot' the proceedmiis, 
 and the .ludpnent of the Court of Appeal, anirmiiiji- the ,liid;;iueiil of 
 the Court helow, was jusl and riLiht.