^^'^^ VICTORIA UWVERS/rr 
 
 \^S -LIBRARY 
 
 '^ A CANADIAN SCHEME 
 
 OF 
 
 AGORESSION 
 
 UPON 
 
 AMERICAN COMMERCE, 
 
 AND HOW IT SHOULD BE TREATED. 
 
 BY 
 
 JOSEPH MMMO, Jr. 
 
 lA{ 
 
 May, 1889 
 
 
 WASHINGTON, D. C. 
 Gibson Bros., Prinikrs and Bookbin^E'^s 
 
 18S9. 
 
 

INTRODUCTORY REMARKS. 
 
 The chief object had in view in the preparation of this 
 article has been to present the constantly growing and 
 now clearly developed necessity for a thorough rectifica- 
 tion of our commercial relations with Canada, if not, in- 
 deed, for a radical change of policy regarding our Canadian 
 relationships generally. 
 
 The almost absolute freedom of restraint which marked 
 the beginning of the " transit trade " has been found to be 
 in important particulars incompatible with a pioper ad- 
 ministration of our Interstate Commerce Act. The rail- 
 road political policy maintained by Canada during the last 
 twenty years has shut railroad extension by American 
 companies out of the Dominion, while Canadian companies 
 have been enabled under the provisions of general rail- 
 road laws of our border States and by persistent entreaty 
 at the doors of State legislative halls to gain every year 
 some new favor. By dint of almost unremit^^ed begging, 
 the Treasury Department has also been coaxed into the 
 granting of favors to Canadian railroads, until dutiable 
 goods may be transported through Canada with even less 
 restraint of our customs regulations than is imposed upon 
 American railroads. The whole situation of afi'airs lacks 
 those essential elements of reciprocity, which should 
 always cliaracterize international arrangements, both of 
 treaty and of comity. 
 
 The Treaty of Washington, by a blunder or a fraud, 
 gives to Canadian railroad companies the right to trans- 
 port goods from one point in the United States, tli rough 
 Canadian territory, to another point in the United States, 
 without payment of duty, but omits to give to American 
 
railroad companies the reciprocal right of transporting 
 goods from one point in Canada, through the United States, 
 to another point in Canada, without payment of duty. 
 
 For several years past the Dominion government has 
 granted a rebate of 18 cents a ton on grain passing through 
 the Wolland Canal in favor of export via Montreal, al- 
 though the practice is held in this country to be clearly in 
 violation of Art. XXYII of the Treaty of AVashington. 
 Although Canadians are constantly shipping merchandise 
 across the territory of the United States, even to the value 
 of $40,000,000 a year, free of duty, the Dominion govern- 
 ment still refuses to allow American fishermen to ship pro- 
 ducts of the sea fisheries across Canadian territory free of 
 duty. But the most vexatious and injurious disturbance 
 of the natural interaction of commercial forces has arisen 
 from the eonstriiction of the Canadian Pacific Railway, by 
 means of a governmental subsidy of over two hundred 
 million dollars, in connection with heavily subsidized 
 steamer lines across the Atlantic and the Pacific, which 
 steamers receive additional British Admiralty subsidies in 
 consideration of the fact that they are so constructed as to 
 be available as armed cruisers. These warlike features of 
 a political scheme for turning trade out of the natural 
 channels are accentuated by a formidable British military 
 establishment on the Pacific coast. 
 
 The uncertainties which characterize our Canadian re- 
 lationships and the audacious and persistent course of 
 the Dominion government in taking advantage of such 
 uncei-tainties and of using the full force of its political 
 power in the direction of diverting American commerce 
 has led the United States Senate to assign to two of its 
 committees, within the limits of their respective spheres, 
 the duty of investigating and reporting upon our Cana- 
 dian relationships. The awakened sense of our people 
 in regard to this matter has also thrown a weight of re- 
 sponsibility upon the present administration of the Gov- 
 ernment. i'> ) 
 
The nation is now confronted bj conditions at the North 
 which far outweigh any possible American interests which 
 may be involved in the internecine struggles of unenlight- 
 ened and barbarous people upon isles of the sea with which 
 our commercial and political relationships are of compara- 
 tively insignificant value. 
 
 Any line of policy which fails to guard the commercial 
 and political interests of the United States against Cana- 
 dian encroachment or which does not fully and fittingly 
 respond to every act of aggression on the part of the 
 Dominion government will be lacking in prescience and 
 in courage. 
 
A CANADIAN SCHEME OF AGGBESSION. 
 
 A most audacious proposition has within a few days 
 been made by the Canadian Pacific Railway officials. 
 The managers of that line, built for political purposes 
 inimical to the United States, and with the object of 
 diverting American commerce from American steamer 
 lines, American seaports, and American railroads, have 
 come up here and asked that the Secretary of the Treas- 
 ury shall so exei^cise his discretion in the conduct of the 
 *' transit trade " as to place their road upon terms of per- 
 fect equality with American lines, or, in other words, en- 
 able it to establish connections for tapping American 
 transportation lines and diverting commerce from Ameri- 
 can cities. It is proposed, in this connection, briefly to 
 consider the true character of this new and glaring in- 
 stance of Canadian presumptuousness. 
 
 The (Canadian Pacific Railway is a political and military 
 enterprise, conceived and carried to execution for the pur- 
 pose of accomplishing the following objects : 
 
 ' ' \ 
 
 First. Politically to unite the four disconnected blocks of 
 inhabited territory comprising the Dominion of 
 Canada. 
 
 Second. To cause these foiir sections of the Dominion to 
 trade among themselves instead -of trading with 
 the United States. 
 
 Third. To suppress the growth in Canada of a sentiment 
 favorable to annexation to the United States. 
 
 Fourth. To divert as much as possible of the internal and 
 foreign commerce of the United States from 
 American transportation lines and American 
 cities. 
 
 Fifth. To serve as a line of military communication be- 
 tween the different parts of the Dominion. 
 
7 
 
 Sixth. To promote the scheme of British Imperial Con- 
 federation, to which the leaders of the Dominion 
 Government are devoted. 
 
 These several objects were fully discussed throughout 
 the Dominion when the proposition to construct the road 
 was under consideration, and an appreciation of their po- 
 litical importance led to the accomplishment of the enter- 
 prise. 
 
 Sir John A. Macdonald, the Premier of Canada, aijd 
 chief promoter of the Canadian Pacific Railway, declared 
 a year ago to the editor of the Pall Mall Gazette that his 
 chief aim was to establish a strong government on this conti- 
 nent, hased upon monarchial principles^ and, at the same 
 time, he expressed his ardent espousal of the cause of 
 British Imperial Confederation — the Canadian Pacific 
 Railway being the chief instrumentality for the accom- 
 plishment of both those objects. 
 
 In order to carry out its gigantic political and military 
 scheme, inimical to the interests of the United States, the 
 Canadian government has incurred expenditures whereby 
 its debt has been increased from $96,896,666, in 1868, to 
 $284,513,842 in 1888. In a word, the Dominion govern- 
 ment, for the accomplishment of this object, has imposed 
 upon the people of Canada, with their consent, a burden 
 of debt proportionally as great as that assumed by the 
 loyal people of the United States in order to preserve our 
 Union. 
 
 The political character of the Canadian Pacific Railway 
 is indicated by the fact that it has received from the Do- 
 minion government the following subsidies : 
 
 Cash and concessions which became available 
 
 as cash $105,000,000 
 
 Bonds and stock guaranteed by the Dominion 
 
 government 110,000,000 
 
 Total subsidy $215,000,000 
 
President Van Home of the C«anadian Pacific Railway 
 WHS compelled to own up to this entire subsidy before the 
 Interstate Commerce Committee of the United States 
 Senate at its last session in New York. 
 
 Recently there has appeared a statement, which I have 
 not yet been able to verify, that during its late session the 
 Dominion parliament appropriated $53,0U0,000 for rail- 
 wav subsidies. 
 
 The total cost of the Canadian Pacific Railway, with its 
 equipment, plant, <tc., &c., was, however, only $165,000,- 
 000. The total stock, bonds, and liabilities of the road 
 amount to only $121,000,000. 
 
 The enormous subsidy granted to this Company so 
 greatly in excess of the cost or capital of the road has 
 enabled it to enter upon bold schemes for the capture of 
 American commerce. This it has done and is now doing. 
 
 A steamer line has been established on the Pacific with 
 a subsidy of 1300,000 a year as against |16,75C paid by 
 the United States Government for the carriage of our 
 Asiatic mails. Besides, the Dominion government has 
 just granted a subsidy of $500,000 a year to an Atlantic 
 steamer line to operate from St. Johns, N. B., or Halifax, 
 upon the completion of fclie Canadian Pacific line soon to 
 be opened across the State of Maine. 
 
 These steamers on the Atlantic and the Pacific will also 
 receive " Admiralty " subsidies from the British govern- 
 ment, in consideration of which fact they are all to be so 
 constructed as to he, available as armed cruisers in the event 
 of vmr. .\ , ; . , : ^- ■ _ ., ;. ■ -, . -.' , ._ ..._ ,. :..:.,..;^,_ 
 
 The i)olitical and military character of the Canadian 
 Pacific enterprise is also clearly indicated by the formida- 
 ble fortress and naval station within sight of our shores at 
 Esquimalt, on the Island of Vancouver. A prominent 
 officer of the British Navy declares that this establish- 
 ment " holds a pistol at the' head of San Francisco." The 
 following press despatch of the 28th inst. seems to indicate 
 the present significance of this naval station : 
 
9 
 
 IS THIS A MENACE? 
 
 Victoria, B. C, May 28. — The entire Britisli fleet now 
 at Esquinuilt, consisting of the war ships Swiftsiire, Am- 
 phion, and Icarus, have received orders to proceed to 
 Behring Sea. Thoy will sail June 10. 
 
 Alreadv the United States Government has been forced to 
 take the preliminary steps toward the erection of a naval 
 and military station at the entrance to Puget Sound, which 
 is now totally unprotected against attack. Surely it is 
 time for us to awake out of sleep. 
 
 The commercial and political attitude of the Canadian 
 Pacific Railway towards the United States is quite the re- 
 verse of that of the Grand Trunk Railwav, The latter has 
 received from the Dominion government only $25,607,393, 
 its total cost having been $247,507,306, whereas the Cana- 
 dian Pacific has received aid from the Dominion govern- 
 ment to the amount of $215,000,000, its cost having been 
 only $105,000,000. Again, the Grand Trunk carries a 
 large amount of American produce through Canada and 
 to Montreal for export, but it also brings to American 
 lines and to American seaports, chiefly New York, Boston, 
 and Portland, Maine, a large amoimt of traflic. Through 
 these ports Canadian commerce, to the amount of about 
 $40,000,000 a year, is carried on. But the Canadian 
 Pacific is reaching out for all the American commerce it 
 can get, and it proposes to wheel it through the forests of 
 Maine over its rail line in that State, subsidized at the rate 
 of $180,000 a year, and connecting with a steamer line to 
 Europe, subsidized to the amount of $500,000 a year, thus 
 cutting off* New York, Boston, and Portland, and their 
 tril)utory railroads, from the benefits they enjoy of the 
 " transit trade " through the Grand Trunk and its connec- 
 tions in this country. 
 
 On the West our Asiatic commerce is also being cut off" 
 from San Francisco and from our trans-continental rail- 
 roads by the sheer force of Canadian and British subsidy, 
 
10 "^ 
 
 amounting for the one railroad to more tlian four times as 
 much as the total amount of aid granted by the United 
 States Government to all our trans continental railroads. 
 
 But if Canada, with a population of less than six mil- 
 lions, can afford to pay nearly ten millions of dollars a year 
 interest on a debt of $284,513,841 , contracted mainly for the 
 purpose of preventing her own citizens from trading with 
 the United States and of capturing a large part of the in- 
 ternal and foreign commerce of the United States, surely 
 the United States with more than ten times the popula- 
 tion, and probal)ly twenty times the wealth ; and, hopefully, 
 an equal degree of patriotism, ought to be able to defend 
 itself Against Canadian aggression. 
 
 The present proposition to place the Canadian Pacilic ^ 
 in our international traffic arrangements on the same plane 
 with our American lines is manifestly absurd. 
 
 The whole Canadian Pacific Railway scheme, with its 
 Esquimault fortress and its subsidized steamer line 
 " armed cruiser " appurtenances, vividly call to mind one 
 of the strongest points made by our forefathers in their 
 grand indictment of the King of Great Britain in 1776, 
 viz.", that he had " given his assent to legislation for cutting 
 off our trade with all parts of the world." This is just 
 what Canada, in her own peculiar way and to the extent 
 of her power, is now doing. The present proposition tliat 
 the United States Government shall aid Canada in work- 
 ing her sweet will in diverting tlie internal and foreign 
 commerce of this country is enough to make the lilood of 
 every true American boil with indignation. It would be 
 much more sensible and patriotic for us to devise some 
 plan of discrimination against Canadian and British ag- 
 gression. That is an obvious duty of the hour. 
 
 The assertion that the Canadian Pacific line is shorter 
 and, therefore, a cheaper route than any one of the Amer- 
 ican lines, is utterly false and absurd. The (vanadiaii Pa- 
 cific is simply a British slugger in American commerce, 
 driving traffic out of its natural channels by the sheer force 
 
11 
 
 of subsidy. It has very appropriately been termed the 
 Canadian Government on wheels. To call it " a mere com- 
 mercial enterprise " is a solecism of the baldest character. 
 In the face of the facts just stated the Canadian Pacific 
 
 officials have the audacity to come up here to AVashington 
 * 
 
 and ask the Secretary of the Treasury to use his discre- 
 tionary power over the " transit trade " in order that they 
 may be enabled to loot upon the internal and foreign com- 
 merce of the United States. The time is especially un- 
 favorable for such an attempt in view of the difficulties 
 which are being met in carrying out the provisions of our 
 Interstate Commerce Act, on account of the unrestrained 
 condition of the Canadian roads and their disposition to 
 take advantage of their extra-territorial opportunities for 
 depredating upon the American roads. Even now the 
 Grand Trunk is violating a clearly expressed agreement 
 with the American lines. The " cut " in its favor thus se- 
 cured may lead to a railroad war and the demoralization of 
 commerce. 
 
 The inopportunity of the present petition of the Cana- 
 dian Pacific is also marked by the fact that only a few 
 weeks ago the Dominion government renewed its " Order 
 in Council " allowing a rebate or discrimination of 18 cents 
 a ton in tolls on all American grain shipped to Montreal, 
 which action the Hon. Nelson Dingley, jr., of Maine, on 
 the floor of the House of Representatives, showed a year 
 ago to be clearly and flagitiously in violation of Art. XXVII 
 of the Treaty of Washington. The Dominion government 
 may expect to be called to account for this infraction of 
 Treaty agreements before its alter ego, the Canadian Pa- 
 cific Railway, becomes the beneficiary of privilege from this 
 Government. 
 
 The whole story of Canadian aggression upon American 
 commerce may be told in a few words. From the time 
 when the Wellaud and St. Lawrence Canals were opened 
 the United States has adopted a policy of perfect recipro- 
 
13 
 
 city of transportation facilities toward Canada, in what is 
 commonly known as " the transit trade." Passage through 
 either country has been allowed without an}' impediment 
 of customs duties, over lines partly in one country and 
 partly in the other, and forming direct routes of trans- 
 portation between the West and the seaboard. If railroad 
 construction in the two countries had been left to the inter- 
 action of commercial forces, that policy might have been 
 permitted to go on undisturbed. But the Dominion gov- 
 ernment has seen fit to throw the full force of its political 
 and financial power into the struggle and given it an en- 
 tirel}^ new character. Besides, the Dominion government 
 has all along taken large advantage and small advantage 
 of every opportunity to encroach upon the commercial in- 
 terests of the United States by discriminations in favor of 
 the people and the transportation lines of Canada. That 
 government obstinately refuses to allow citizens of the / 
 United States to go to the relief of American vessels in Cana- 
 dian waters — a right of common humanity — and it also per- 
 sistently refuses to allow fish caught by American fishermen 
 on the high seas, to be transported free of duty across 
 her territory, while Canadians are, every year, shipping 
 millions of merchandise across our territory free of duty. 
 The story is one of international relationships between a 
 small country whose foreign policy is shrewdly commer- 
 cial and a large country whose foreign policy is ingen- 
 uously political. At last we are confronted by a po- 
 litico-military policy regarding the conduct of commerce, 
 such as character- as the commercial relations existing 
 between contiguous countries in Europe. Our Northern 
 neighbor has thus forced us to the consideration of a new 
 line of international policy which shall provide adtjquate 
 securities for the honor, the dignity, and the interest of 
 
 the United States. 
 
 JOSEPH NIMMO, Jr. 
 Washington, D. C, 
 
 . May 31, 1881). 
 
 
 ^■^^- *-