CIHM Microfiche (l\/lonographs) ICIVIH Collection de microfiches (monographies) Canadian Institute for Historical Microreproductions / Institut Canadian de microreproductions historiques Technical and Bibliographic Notes / Notes techniques et bibliographiques les The Institute has attempted to obtain the best original copy available for filming. Features of this copy which may be bibliographically unique, which may alter any of the images in the reproduction, or which may significantly change the usual method of filming are checked below. I A Coloured covers / D D D D D D Q D d Couverture de couleur Covers damaged / Couverture endommagde Covers restored and/or laminated / Couverture restaur^e et/ou pellicul^e Covfei title missing / Le titre de couverture manque Coloured maps / Cartes g§ographiques en couleur Coloured ink (i.e. other than blue or black) / Encre de couleur (i.e. autre que bleue ou noire) Coloured plates and/or illustrations / Planches et/ou illustrations en couleur Bound with other material / Reli6 avec d'autres documents Only edition available / Seule Edition disponible Tight binding may cause shadows or distortion along interior margin / La reliure serr6e peut causer de I'ombre ou de la distorsion le long de la marge int6rieure. Blank leaves added during restorations may appear within the text. Whenever possible, these have been omitted from filming / II se peut que certaines pages blanches ajout§es lors d'une restauration apparaissent dans le texte, mais, lorsque cela 6tait possible, ces pages n'ont pas 6t6 film6es. L'Institut a microfilm6 le meilleur exemplaire qu'il lui a 6t6 possible de se procurer. Les d6tails de cet exem- plaire qui sont peut-§tre uniques du point de vue bibli- ographique, qui peuvent modifier une image reprcduite, ou qui peuvent exiger une modification dans la m6tho- de normale de filmage sont indiqu6s ci-dessous. |y| Coloured pages / Pages de couleur Pages damaged / Pages endommag6es D D Pages restored and/or laminated / Pages restaur6es et/ou pellicul6es Pages discoloured, stained or foxed / Pages d6color6es, tachet6es ou piqu6es I Pages detached / Pages d6tach6es I / Showthrough / Transparence □ Quality of print varies / Quality inegale de I'impression □ Includes supplementary matehal / Comprend du materiel supplemental re Pages wholly or partially obscured by errata slips, tissues, etc., have been refilmed to ensure the best possible image / Les pages totalement ou partiellement obscurcies par un feuillet d'errata, une pelure, etc., ont 6t6 film6es a nouveau de fa?on a obtenir la meilleure image possible. I I Opposing pages with varying colouration or ' — ' discolourations are filmed twice to ensure the best possible image / Les pages s'opposant ayant des colorations variables ou des decolorations sont film^es deux fois afin d'obtenir la meilleure image possible. Additional comments / Commentaires suppl6mentaires: Includes text in French. P This item is f iimed at the reduction ratio checl(ed below / Ce document est filmd au taux de reduction indiqu^ ci-dessous. lOx 14x 18x 22x 26x 30x / 12x 16x 20x 24x 28x 32v The copy filmed here has been reproduced thanks to the generosity of: La Bibliothdque de la Ville de Montreal L'exemplaire film6 fut reproduit grSce d la g6n6rosit6 de: La Bibliotheque de la Ville de Montreal The images appearing here are the best quality possible considering the condition and legibility of the original copy and in keeping with the filming contract specifications. Original copies in printed paper covers are filmed beginning with the front cover and ending on the last page with a printed or illustrated impres- sion, or the back cover when appropriate. All other original copies are filmed beginning on the first page with a printed or illustrated impres- sion, and ending on the last page with a printed or illustrated impression. The last recorded frame on each microfiche shall contain the symbol —►(meaning "CON- TINUED"), or the symbol V (rraaning "END"), whichever applies. Maps, plates, charts, etc., may be filmed at different reduction ratios. Those too large to be entirely included in one exposure are filmed beginning in the upper left hand corner, left to right and top to bottom, as many frames as required. The following diagrams illustrate the method: Les images suivantes ont 6X6 reproduites avec le plus grand soin, compte tenu de la condition et de la nettetd de l'exemplaire filmd, et en conformit6 avec les conditions du contrat de filmage. Les exemplaires originaux dont la couverture en papier est imprim6e sont film^s en commenpant per le premier plat et en terminant soit par la dernidre page qui comporte une empreinte d'impression ou d'illustration, soit par le second plat, selon le cas. Tous les autres exemplaires originaux sont film6s en commengant par la premidre page qui comporte une empreinte d'impression ou d'illustration et en terminant par la dernidre page qui comporte une telle empreinte. Un des symboles suivants apparaitra sur la derni6re image de cheque microfiche, selon le cas: le symbole —►signifie "A SUIVRE", le symbole V signifie "FIN". Les cartes, planches* tableaux, etc., peuvent Stre filmSs d des taux de reduction diffdrents. Lorsque le document est trop grand pour etre reproduit en un seul clichd, il est film§ d partir de i'angle sup^rieur gauche, de gauche h droite, et de haut en bas, en prenant le nombre d'images n6cessaire. Les diagrammes suivants illustrent la m^thode. 1 0I3TR1 ^- /I/ DISTRICT OF QUEBEC. ^.. 3iitlip|ii{ipriarffaiiri. Q^^ fi^fy '/ effjfircc/i /tunarea a/fti ft//// un/r. WILIJAM P.ROWN. of llic Parish of IJcaupoiL Trader and ^lillcr. IMaiuliff. fs. r.AinilOI.OMKNV CONRAD AKJl STIS (ilUV. of till' said Parish of Hcaiiport, in Ihc District of <}ui>h('c, Es(|nin>, A cmimt out the iiitontions of a Lortaiu i ••'rlociitoryjuilg- i iHoiit, IssiumI %j»_Ia llir ^aill Cniirt, on the oijrhteonth ihiv of Al-il, ono thoii.-aiid c'mlit hiiiiilnilamltiriv'M \cii.afUThaviiij; lii'cii (hilv luuni'il and sworn, in eouforiiiity with Ihr ro(|iii>itiiiii-i'flhc si'Ml,iu'i-'i."(l in pivseni-c oflho imrtii^s, and after due iintifuMtiiiiMo thL'iii to iljaf rlffct, OH the tliinl day of duly, of the same year, and tlienoe with all due llili^■enee, aeeoi'dinji' to adjournen'.eut, I'lom to time to the execution of the duties iiniio>t-d on them hy the ?aid inleiloiMitory judL^mont. The said ExpeiMs after much time lost, since the issuing of the said judgment, in tVuitless endeavours, to hetiually sworn on aceount ot the reiieated olijections on one side, and the other to their nomination which neecssimtetl the lU'esenee of the said Kxperts, at the Court House for several days in sueeession : iiroeeeded at hist and as aforesaid. Firstly, to infor^u themselves thoroughly of the dulies they had lo iiorforni as eontaim'(l in the said Judgment and of the hest mode of carrying out the same. Tlu' survey of the lU'eUiise-; was next (U'o. -ceiled with, in conjunction with a most careful examimiliou of the river lieauiKirt. its present ami former hcil, and of the natural « and arlilicial olistnictious to the tiow of the water therein, ijetweeu the high road at the hrldire and tin.' iMiildiiigdcsiLMiated hy the witnesses in this cause as the wooden store. ^ It was'ahofc.und heccssii'iy hy the Experts for the tluu'ongh investigation of some of the points al i-sue lo survey and level the said river to a distance lower down than the .said W(joden sioic, partlv alsli with the view of eounecting again with the main road hy liiu's in reai or to the west of the old Dislilh'ry lUnldiug I'herehy completing the circuit and insuring and proving the acciir.icy ol' the' survey. "With the view ol' examining the volume and eoiirseof tlic water coming from the interior, during the spring Hoods as thereunto reipiired liy the said jmlgment, the said Experts also suiveyed part of the channel ahove the high r.iad a, the hriilge. Unriug the survey of the premises and previous to and after the said survey, and at every -eas'ou of the year, the said Experts ilid examine the respective level- of the ordinary and high tides, the numnei' iu whicli the said tides covered tlie bed and himks of the said river "and the several wharves adjoining thereto and the depths to whieli they did s,i cover them. Xlso atnl (Ui each oc<'asion and at all seasons of the year iis at'oivsaiil, the depth towliicli the'watcA- rose on tlie mill wheel ami the duratioiiand freiiucncy oftlu' stoppage thereofiinder the ahove named eireumstanees. In a word the said Experts have c.inriuued their exatuiiuitiou of the premises and iheir observations on the tides ntid fresheto, etc., almost constantly since the sjjring of eighteen hundred and iifty eight, up to the pro- scut tiuie. 'S^n- have they spared any pains to ai rive at just conclusions on matters of buc]) r importiiiioo, Br) those iiivolviiil in tlic prosoiit suit. Tlio eiiid E\|"'its Imvo never liCHitntud, wlieii nnccHiftry to 1)0 on tlio !;ronii(l, eitlior iit live in the inornini;, or at ten ut ni;;lit, tor tlie MOecsHiuv olisiTVations oftiie tiili'H, A;o. Tlicemiui te on tlu^ rtlo|iiiiii?e ol'tiie mill wheel was next |iiiieiiei|eil with, as i" horisiMl liy the Kuiil jinlifMient iind the Hiiiuc hronijlil their hcst al)ilitieH lo hear I'n ttie siiliject und maturely cUdiheraled, are liUinldy id' opinion that. (.l/i-H'i'c III Claim: Xn. 1, n/ liilcrlijculor)/ Jiidi/mail.) 'I'he plan No. 1 nnneNod to this reiiort, prejiared hy th(! Kxinu'ts tiiemsclves t'rom actual Kurvey ot the premises, is a correct representation of the present lied of the river UeauiMirt as it apjiears in its norni.d slate, in the summer season. As to the liirmcr bed (d'liie lieauport river, il'liy tliat expression ho meant the lied of the said river, inimeiliately preceedini; the constrnetion^ ^0(; and hy anollier made in 17li2. The plan of ism;, orthat part of it whiidi refers to the hcl ot'tlic river at that time, has hcen Iraust'ciVd hy the ICxperts, to ]dans \o. 4 and ,') hereunto anmjxcd, the lirst of whicli shows how the channel of ISiKi was situated at that tinu', with rci;iiril to the present channel, the other, the relation of the two said channels, tocrelher with the hi'di tide t the hijih tide scales on those to inform channel, the other, the relation of the two said channels, tojjelhei lines of ISiJiI, to the position of the iircscnt huildin^Ljs ami wharves. The plans with a mere hul|) of a ]iair of dividers, will enahle the llonoralile ,(ui themselves on every point thereof. As to the natural and arliticial ohslrui^tious to the thnv ol' the waters in the river lieauport, it may he said that any curve in a riviu' is a mitural olistruction to the straii^ht course which such river would take it' siicli curve did not exist. •cars a nat\iral ohstruetion of that kind from X to V, cm mir plan No. 1 !i reunto Tnere o annexed. Tiio ])oiiit of land 1' ot the foot of tail race ftiid the small hank T \', hehiiid the utono .storo may also he considered asslii^htly ohstriu'timr the natural How of the water, iiiul tlioso ohstrue- tion ' are |iarlly mitural ami partly artificial. For instance the point 1' is partly formed naturally iiy the river itself which takes a hend at ahout that point and causes an eddv in ficishct time and an ohstruetion, which, to sonu' extent, retards the llnw of the waterand causes it, on account id' its diminished velocity to deposit materials pniviously held in suspension, hv the rapid current (sec appiMidix II of this lieport j stones of a certain size may also have hccn accuiiiulatcd there from the same causes. The same point I' iiniy he eonsjdi'rcd arliticial also as aliovc stated, to a certain extent, in as much as it js partly fcirined hy the materials taken t'riuii the tail race, the said materials hcinj; therein deposited hy the same cause which in freshet time Indps to throw up the accumulation at I* as to the small hank T \' hehind the stone store, it must also he considered as partly natural and Jiartly artiticial. The saiiL l>ank is composed, towards the to|i, of stones deposited there, at various times (see appendix (j of this report) and of stones which have fallen there on occasions hen part of the walls of the said store have been ilemolished and rebuilt. The under jiart id' the said hank T \' may be considered iiatiirel inasmuch as it is asscrtiMl by one of the I'efendant's own witnesses (No 4 of appendix (i continued) that previous to the stones heinif thrown there, there was a natural hank wide enough for the workmen to stand on as on a scaH'olding to rebuild the wall. It is true that several of the Defendant's witnesses say, that previously to the stones having been thrown behind the stmie store, the river ran idongside (lelongde)of the said store. The expreH.-ion "alongside" is materially inoditied however hy the same witnesses one of which (\o 2 of the same appendix (J continued) " dc ne sais jias si A rendroitou sont tomhees l(:s vidanges, il y avail de luterre .seche." (Another No 3 of the same appendix) " d'ai seulomeiit vu couler la riviere en iirriere rlcs vidaiiges" (outside ot the stone.s etc.) A third (No 5 of the same appendix) " Je ne dis pas que (,a fuisuit ^a dans lea basses eaux" Ill llii> .siiriu! wuv it iiiny 1)0 interred tliftt tho other witnosHCH, wliosny tiie tail laco or rivi-r iiMcil to niii iiioiiir^ifio tiiu store (lid not iiii'iui tlmt the river alisoiiitelv touched tlio .-lore, selves Iroiii r tiie rivei t'oriner lieil imiiediiili'ly ilf'rt Hiiles_J ters of the 1 on uliieli ■oiijjii soiiie iiled hy the > eliailiiel is :ly ii.ssci-ted c'l'el'iMieu to Itilt of this •liidiriiieiil. ninieili;itel\ ly, us nun lliiit tnicfs, villi II lofer- liee for the e to treat ol' tary. Nov\ Jieriod, the de ill \~\>2. U', has lici'ii t of whieii llie pre.-eiit e hii;h tide L's on those ^ to infoiia to tlie tlou s a natural d not exist. 1 iieiviiiito BtoiK! store loscohstriie- rtly foniii'il an vt]i\y ill rand eausos siis|H'nsi()ii so have lieeii ed artitieial le materials cause which r heliind the . The saiiL L'e ainiendi.\ if tile walls 1 hank T \' VII wiinesbest ', there was > rehnild the ' the Btoiies -') of the said le witnesses droit oil soiit 10 ajiiioiulix) stones etc.) basses uuux" hilt that if ran near it, it will hu deiiioiistrated however in the sei|iiel of the report, that it is of little importance us rcLrards the points iit issue in the present unit, whether or not there / was any natural hank at T \', or at 1', jirevioiis to the stones and riilihish, [haviiii; liccii di;- y' losited, and acciiiniihvted thereon. As to the stones allet;<'d to have lieen put alolij; the foot ol/ he I'laintitf's wharf, it inatlers little how they pit there, and still less what effect they ina_C-'1 lave had or inav still have iipmi the tlow of the waters hetwei'ii the two wharves, their fpmn-7t I I tity lieinj; two iiisii;iiifieant to |iiddin'e any elfci't capaMc of hcinj; a)ipreeiated. Wilhani Austin who surveyed the premises for the Defendant siiys (N'o 1 appendix (i continued) •• a portion niiirht have escaped from hetween the timheis of the wharf and lalleii to the \ liase thereof. Those stones however unlike those at T \' are hardly above the surface of the lowest siinilner waters, and are jiist similar to llioso whieli lino the whole IiimI of the cliaiinel, from the hridire downwards and may Jiossihly have hc'eii thrown there to protc'cl I he foot of the I'laiiititf s wharf or I iron '.'lit down liy freshets or from hoth causes com hi nod. A Hl'i'at deal of evidence has been adduced 1)V I'efendant as to the stones behind the stone store and tliosout 1' tlieetreet of such evidence lioing to distract attention from bis wharf ot Is.'ii, which, as it will be shown heri'after, is the only real obstrnetion in tin' rivi'r. The wh.irf ol ll<.')2 is not an obstruction to the How of the waters under rirdinary einumstances nor for the best part of the vear, but merely as will hereafter bo shewn, dnrim; the combined action of ice and fri'shets III thesprini; of tliu year and only occasionally in the sninmer season, by freshets alone, when those last are groat eiioilgh to produce uii appreciable elfect. [Aii.iii'o- la Cfiiusc Ao. 2 ij' Jiikrliicdtitiy Jwli/nutil.) The said Experts liir the purpose of determiiiinir by a series of observations the siilH- cieiiey, or insnlliciciicy of the passage or outlet tor the tlow of the water in the said ri\i>r did particularly examine, the volnine and course of the water coining from the interior during ihc spriiiglloods, but i ill connected with the ebb and How of the tidi', and to efh'ct a Jiart of this e\ainiiialion, they did select as much as possilile^the days and tinics of the day in \vhich uilliin the above nieiilioned e.\tent, and during the spring lloods. the level and course of the water was the least atfcclcd by the tide and when tlio greatest How did pass through the arch and feeder of the leill, as well when the mill w-as working, as w hen it was not working. The said ohservatioiis have torced upon the .said Kx|icrts the eonclusioii that the '• said outlet" / supposed to mean the narrov.'est space, between tln^ Del'eiidant's wliarf of lSu2 and the stone (, store at the point 'S' or that still narrower at the point Z as that s|iace c.visted at that time of building the said wharl' of l.S.")2, is sutlicient under all ordinary eircuinstances, that is, so long as the river is in its normal stale during tlie summer, liill and winter inonths, but abso- lutely iiisiitlicient during the spring freshets in conneetioii with the action roxin\ation be arrived nt, even then. Tho Honorable Judges in writing the interlocutory do not seem to have considered the ob- sti'uctiou complained of by the I'luiutitl" in its relation to tho action of the ice during tho I , "I'Vill^ ,1- ho INI hll ll ll.i Wlll'll urrlliw III ll,r illirilllii'Ill, llllll \rl {I 1 1 1 -llHiilrllc'S 111 lln' oinK'i m.iiiilv cli'in"i'U, iiiul I'lir iIh' hm-I tiiur, mi "iirli ni'tioii nl' l.ii' U-o. 'i\< in'iiki' iIim iiiiitli'r c li'iir mill cviili'iit it liiii^l In' lUMli'i-iliiml tlml tin' r'HrliiiM- nl' tlic cliiiiiiul \\ iiliT in llii' iiiitlci \\^l•^^/.l^^ M\i'i' iliiriinr tlid colli iiiiiiitli-i lit liir wiiitrr. mill turin-* a Iniiliri' nl ii'i' "Vcr it. 'I'lii' ii-c liiiiliTf lliii< riiriiii'd ihirUriis with the .-imw tlml rail" ii|hiii ii. Tlu' liii,'li tiilr* linf •i\ iT llif tiiiil ii'c lii'iilyi' iiifiti'inl I r iiiijrr it. iIh' icr lirint; ton ti,u:li;i\ jiiliiiiicil ln'tuct'iMlii' WlllirVl-, to lloill OM I'i-C with till' lilll'. 'I'llC ^llo\V IlllOSf till' iff' lll'I'lJlllilliJ lllfffllV ii in'i-iiiiiilfil Willi wilier, mill Irff/.inu' iiirniii inhN. to ihf lliifUiif-s of tlic iff liriil^ro uiiil to it< '.iliiliiy ; A s|iiiff I'fiiiiiiiiiiiir f'ti^liiiillv lif low it till tlif oiitiiow ol tlif wiilfi- tVoiii till' iiiilli'iiff. lor lit tliiit -iM-ioii 111' tlif yi'nr tlifrf lifiiiL' Imt wnlff fiioiiirli liir oiif or two nm ol stoiifs (iiiil null,, to M|iiii'f, it is nil tiikfii into till' mill, iiihI |i:i>-.fil out tlirinn.'li llif tull-i'iiff. Vfiy lill'i ir any foiiiiiii; ilowMllif iiiitiinil fluuiiifl iIii'oiil'Ii tlif ciilvfi't or affli iimlfi' tlif tilfiiliiUi) iMnl. Wiii'ii a lif.ivy rain ortliaw offiirs as soiiif liiiifH liappfiis uvfii in FfluMiiiiy. it will lif iiinlfr-'looil tliat tlif wiili'i' foiniiiv' down tlif river l!faii|iort, not liiivini; <|iaff i'non!.'li to tlow oil' ilii'iiuirli till- fontruftfil (lassiijrf iiiiilfr llif iff in tin.- (iiitlft at \ , iiinst ol nfff»ity mil over tlif iff in tlif >aiil out let (iliis is provfilhy tlif ilf |iosiis olsainl ami irravfl to lif foiiml nil tlif snrlaff of thii iff as we oiiiNf Ivfs havf wiliifs-fil in sfve nil offa>ioiis| vliif li al tliatsfiisonis too linn toyii'lil in any way to any iirfssnrii I'mni lifiifiitli whifli tliflifslifl ainl water niiirJit eXfl'fise nil it. ll'llie ii the said iff in llif onllft lie eoliffived t' 'ai i.fVfra! I'let in thickness, wliicli it always isalionl that lime nl' the year, it «lll rfadily he a|iiireliciiilcd ilmi any I'rcsliet water rrotiiraiii or soft weatlifrat ihal sfiison mnst pass ovi-r the ice, in Ihf ontlct. and llifivhy ho eonsiderahly liiorf ei'valfd llian it would he il' no ice f xisled : the extra elevation ol' tin' siirl'ace of the water at such tinn' luini; fi|iial to the tliifkiifss ot ih. iff, it has to pass iivf;'. OnMieh an ofiasion, as that alio\f ilfsirilifd. whiih nfiiciail^ liii|ipens once or more diiriiij; each yfiir, il will he iMMiffivfd that llie mill h liff I i-i iikcly to he siihinerjffd in pMporlion to the depth of the water sn llnwiiiu' over the ice in lln- outlet. For instaiicf with u thifkiifss of only thief \'ri-\ of iff and simw iiillie niiilfi. tlif Vfiy least that can he allowed, and with a depth ollhicf led ol fif-hfl walir llmviiii; liver tlif said iff the water wheel would he siihiiier^cd at Icasl luo feel, proporlioiially inorc aefordiii;.' to an anirinfiitfd tliifknes.-. nf iff and extra dipih of water tiowiiii;- ovfr ii. W'lifii liif r-nft Wfathfr comes on in the spriiii;-, .-a\ almiii the mniiili nf Man. I'l'.-n, ilif iif liiid;.'!' ill Ihf onllft ^' i- workfd n|inii l.y llif ^nn. frmii aliii\f, and iVni., hfiieath, it is worn away and imllfd li,\ llif wiinif r ualri~, uhifli at thai -fa-nn lif:;'iii to How from ihf int.rior nl lie i-niiiiir\. 'I'lif Innl^v nf icf ilariliy hcfninf- irr.idnally thiniifr and weaker towards the cenlie and In i;iii> in ^ink ai that pnint altei liavinjf irackfil idoni; its axial liiif. In lliis>lalf ilmiuiil he -iippn-fd thai the next hii;h tide or frcsln't would lloat il, hiitlhis does not ofcnr liil laUr in the sfason. 'I'lif u\ n li.ilvesof the ice liridj;e tlioinjh ^inkiiifr towards the fciilre, siill adhfiv lirinly to ihf .nl- jniiiini: wharves mid the inter'lice m li^.^uie alon^- the cfhiif. Iifinimv tillfd wiil, ualfraiid freezes a'.'ain diirini;' ihf ni^hl. r// ^^^<:^^^i^SS§g^^ i^*^ Il will linw lif eniiffixfil lli;it lindfl' Siifli I'i ff II lii-l a lif f >. ihf iff liiid;;.' hoi-l lie fVfii morf dillifull to r.ii^f or llnni. ihaii in it- iionnal fondilinn • iiifi- tlif t»n liiilvf- ihcTfiif oiif llifii iili-iilnlf ly in thf po>ilioii nf an iinirl fd aivh nr nf two fd::-f- li\f I al llfir l.a-f- and alMllliim- a;;aiiist cafh othfi. iii their fduifs, as indifiiled in tlf diaiiiain in the inaivin, where 1) (J represents the luo halvo of the ice hridiro lO, the water riinniiiir lifiieatli il, '• F" the freshet water runiiini; nvcr it,aiid .\ I! the two wharves of I'lainlilf and the Deffiidant. Nor is the dia<;raiii diavMi from mere theory, Imt was sketfheil on the preliiises on or ahoiil the leiilii of Marcli last. Tlic exlcnl'of the iiisiillicif ney of the onllet. may now he coiisidci'i'd in the follnwiiif- li>rlif. If the wharf of IS.')-J did not exist, the iff in the outlet al V and down to Z, liaviii- 1111 Vfi'lifal wall to aiiiit a^'.ainsl. .unld .'usily lie lloati d li\ llif l'rf>hit nr lidf walfi. r .1 llcil'llCN III llii' Til iiiiiki' Ihii I wuti'i' ill till' oT iri' iivi'f it. Iiii,'li tiil("« riKi' •ll liltWl'l'll till' lit lIllTcllv il, lll'llliTi: IIM'I I" viiirr IViMii till' ■ or tvvii I'lili III II till' tail-nii'i-, iii'cli niiiU'l' tin- I ill Fi'lifiiiii'v, liiiviiiu: quiri' III \, iiiiiHt III II mill irruvi'l 1(1 i~iiiii-, ill till' outlet, I'll : till' I'Xtiii irklicss (it tllr llirll XclUTllllv licl'l H liUl'lv lui Wt! ill till' ill llio iiUlli'l. Willi'l' llinvilis; I'limially iiini'i' Aim;' (ivcr ii. iili i.r Man-!. n\i\ mill I'l'iill, ll llial ^I'li-i'M IrliV IlL'CiilIll-- at |i(iiiil iilli'i 1 lilt' IK'Xt lliull ■oil. The lUii ilv t" llic ail ■,' lillnl Ulll, wliii'li wiiul.l tliiu iiii,-..* iiMilcrit mid r.ii,,' u, ,. ,, ,,,|||,| nut tln'ii In' jaiiiiu'd in a, n,,w IlllplM'llH. it Wi.illil 111' llii'li' ciiliji'ililii. til Htulc ll, »lialili»tmiii' (lie uliai-'l lit' IHrc' hIiiiuIiI ho rcMiiivcil towanls tlm D.'tcinlaiit'.^ *iilu t.i [iivviiit tin' iiImivc imn ofiii' IVoiii lu'ciiriii" : liiit it li-itiilil iii'f iltii III I' I'li/i II i I'll tit Ik.i i.iit I... ..I. ..> 1... • t! I'l . >• 1.1'. .1 .. ..'"* 'A V irr l'liili;i- lal I'liliilllinii 111' ail ilivi-i'l U'li iillicl-. :i! 'M'lllS ihl' lUli wali'f riiiiiiiiin liimraiii ilrawii Mill III' Mai'cli lllf lilHilwilltr ll) Z, liaviii;/ iir liilr watn. ■^ ■; ,', •■■■••'■■ ■"■' ; ,.,..- -I,, u 11. (PicMiu iMi' iiiMivc jiiiii (ll ii'i' iniiii iirciinii'': mt It wi.iilil |iriil.alily ii'i|iiii'(' In li" |.iil Imi. k at lia.l tlflv li'ct fnf tin. imnioin, tliu nuiUt ,ilaii liiiwiiviT lu'iiii; iiiiiluiiliti'illy In ri'iimvi' it ulii'iri'iliir. Ft is ni'xt linw.visr to im ■ stalili'liiil liiiw ol'ti'ii, iliiiiiiir tlu' vi'ui' till' almvi' naiin'ii in^iilllciciuiv Miall oi'ciir. It in iiii|iiii.ilili' ti. iiMtiililMli Willi iiiiii'li |ii'i',i,i,m tho ti'('i|iiincv and iliii'iitinii ol' tlic luid iii-iitrn'ii'iiiy diiriiii,' the vi'ar, .Ml tliiit i an lir said nn tliat imiiit. is that, tluTo is cvidcticti III' till' null liiiviiii,' liccn stopiii'd IVuiii oiil' to tlir lav-i in -.iircisr.iiin -iiici. tliu wliaif of Ix.VJwas limit. (S('(. »|,p('i,dix () ,i|' this r.poir.) A ciivuinstaiic, whiih In Appendix N is'i-sciti'd l.y !• witiK'^^i's iii'vir ll, havn occin'cd i.n'vi.iiis to tin' i^rciiiim uf ilie said wharf, and that the in-iilli'ii'iiry III' 111.' imtl. It at Vis likdv to oeeiir iiioi'd or less (V,.m 1,1- lirfiri' till' niidilli' iif.Maivh to the lii'tfiniiiiiL' id' May in each vear mid (ii'easiiiiiailv dniiii" the reiiiainini,' seasons. It miist not he siippo-ed that iii-iillii'ieiiev always (leciirs in the precise way indieated in the dcsenpiion iiinl dia-iani ahove iiieiitioiii'il. On tho eontraiv It may happen ami has jiappeiied to uiir kiio« jcdire and frmii oiii' pcisuiial ohservutioii when the n-e has lieeii alnin-i alliii.'elher liMkcii up hiit ianihii'il loifilher in siidi wiivas to I'linii a hai'iiei' to the iiii..sii,'e i.f the walei'. 'I'he caii-e (.i'lln- in-iit)i.ieiicv as alreadv \|atei| ,„„ l„ i.um utl„r ll„n, tin: ,vh.trf uf \n:,- Imill I,., ih l>. fn..!,,,,!. Tlie piw^i.^e posiliuii of ihat ol.staele IS laid down on i.iii' iilaii Xo. 1. The olMlailcs 1.11 the I'laiiititrs niile, and their relative iinportaiiei' have idroady heen eomnienled uli. in imr answer to the tirst elaiise of llwinterloiMilmy in aii-;wcriiii; which, it wa- iiii| ihle t'oriH not to anticipate to soine e.\ti'lit oiu- an-'Wei's to particular |i.iiauiaplis of the Mili.c.|iicni dan-es. j.ldM'-i /• t,i ( lo'l^, X,. 4 .,/' /i,l,fl,„-fil„iy.) The i)li..tnietioiis ahiive nieiiiioiicil cause a riso of the water in t'n-liet time iiideiiendent- ly of the tide, within that part of the extent ilhiive nlioiic : ahove the points .'^ and V rcspcciivelv in the plan marked .\ (Ware's plan i as aUo iii,i;,.ate.l hy the saiiio h'ttersoiiour plan No. 1 hei'i'iinlo annexed. W hen mu-Ii rise of ihe water does occur, it of eoiirso in- creases to some extent when the tide water meets the river water diiriiii'- the spriii" llonds That inerease escapes mid tlows off in the Mime wav, of iicces-itv ainf tliroii.'h the saiiii' outlet as the river water, and the water so raised has and iniivt 'have the etfed alone as wed as III addilion to the tide water ol'stiippiii;; the workiiiu- of the wheel of the I'laintiU's mill hy siihnicririiiu: it hcyoiid its iisiial exposure to the tide previous to tiie said ohsiri'ietions ■ and like i.li-crvations, and examinations, have also huun made at periods, days, uiid huurs ,>l liiilh ihehiirh and spriiie; tides. {.\iisiri r III Cldin'i: Xti. ."» cf //(^ /An •;/-;•'/. ) Kroiii the ahove nieiilioneil causes there is a ilill'crenee in the usual stoppae-o of the wheel. The imtllie of the stoppa^'c (ilwe well iiiiilerslaiid what is meant hy tlnTiiiU'scion) IS that the mill wheel is so sto|,pci| from licii,i,r siiliiiicri^cd in water licvrnd a certain depth or exposure, after which the machiiii ly lairs two miicli to (hi its work' edicietillv and has timilly to he stopped to prevent any injuiy oeciuiiiLr to the maehinerv, nnil to the 'wheel hy driving; tlir.iii;.'li hack water. The cxee.s of il„" -toppas;c. as eomiiar'ed with the •stoiiicii^- produced hy natural causes may he inferred directly from what has already heen said Tn answer to clause .No. :J of the iiileru.ciitory ; for since the insnllicieney of tho I'lssni'e at V was llierein considered, an. I eslahlished only inasmuch as it ean-ed the \va»el.s to ris(f emiii.di to Hood the wheel heyoiid its nsmil -. vp,.-.iiiv. ii follow, as a e.'iitrarv pronosition that, when siieh insullicieiiey (lid oris likely t cur so did the mill wheel :-ti'.p and is likely to stoii miller similar eirciinistanccs. To scpiiraie ihe elfcct i.ro.luced hy tide waters i'rom tliut proiluceil hy tieshels, mid liive to each its icl.itive propnition of ini'portanci; is almost imi,os >il,l('to perlorm. W hen it is stated however from our own ohserviitions, sloi.pai'cs liavu occurred independent of the tides, and at hours of the day at which tho tide must h'lvo heen low, and that >tiippa-es of from one to three da'vs duration have also oeciirmi a> asserted, in the evidein c .xlracls from which are civcn in appendix (» 'ind ll they have not occurred, may occur and are likely to occur for day's 'to ,i;-clher trom iihout the tifteculli of March to the bciriiiniiii; of May uiid oc- casionally also duriiii; the rcmainiiiL;- seaxui.-, of the year.' In tho case o'f Ircshets ■ while on the other hand the Uniial sloppa.iie from lii^li tides aloiio never exceed' six hours on an avcraije diiriii- any one day, and that circiinistance occurs only tor a low days 111 a montlij. Mic llonorahle .luil,i;vs will lorin u ^'ood idea them.solvos of th'u total prohahle amount ot extra slo|ipae;o durini; any one year. {Aiimh-r til Llatd-i: No n/ Jiilirhculori/.) _ As Hetnonts for our conclusions wo did ('arefiilly and particularly examine and ascer tain tho level or tall of the water ijotwocn the lower or iiiidor (lortion of tho mill wheel 'ind the level ot the Water of the river opposite the point Y, in our plan, to-ciher y.'itii the le.i.ser or f^reiiter dillerenco of level hctweeii tho lowe.sl point of the wiioel uiul tho ton or surliioo of tho wharves of both parties. The ivMilt of our examiiialion is imlicateU iu our plau ^ t, r N,, I al ■..cti..!, thiM,,.^!. I . . u!,.,l ,,mW ^iil r.ir,.,lu»i, tl,.. |HMI,I VJ.yvvlil.'liltn|.|MW* thai III,' Hililar,. ,,l'll,r.l,:uM,rlu.,l,Tut Y Hluil- UnriMIll ■..„t,MllM.ll( ll M.f l.-t . ...I I.MIf llfh..* l„.ri.ivll..Miihl.T.i.l til,' mill uii.'-l. Tlu. t.... or 111.' I'luHinir'^ wimil ..i,i,„.ii.. t,.il,>' point / il..f I Ni-I "|.|.n.it.' till- l">ial V win.'li Wu-v ■ i!,.' -l t m.m i^ .. ' l-i mIm'V" Hi" Ullll*l>llK' I'l 'III' Kllill lllill »llliiiI -.■.•tioi.n on III.' hiiiiio phlll No. I. 'I'll.' ''IllllllH'l W.lt.'l' i" •'lll.Wll ill ill'' -.•V.'I'.ll ■.I'l'lloll" IIH it I'Milt Ml Its normal ,'',.ii".iili..ii in ili.' -.iiiniii.'r ■..•ii>oii. 'I'll.' ivlali 'I'liiiif.'.! I.v tli.' iiit.'i;l..i'iitoi-v. ol' tli,« wliai'v.'* ol li'.tli |iifli.'s t'lli' wal.f of 111.' liv.'i' nt l..w iinMinni or Inifli wuli'r vmII ailniil ..r iw.i aiiMV.T.s n,« «.■ .■iiiiioi .a\ u li.'lli.rl.y livrc \* m.-aiil in llii-. I'lmi', II,,' riv.r ll..aiil...n oi' III.' liv, r r'a(i|..ifl, may lie. ii.lmit ol' iiiii.li iliirilvni'rol'o|.ini,.ii. M. I'Mwanl Ili'laU-i'-nii in .'Xinii'l No H. .Nl'l'i'iiilix l^. n-.'fN lli.it on .ill. .'ii^ioii till' lVi'i.lii't wal.f ro^.'l.iT or s I'.'.'t. in lli>' riviT li"an|.orl. A .l.'t.lli 111 ti'oiii .'.1.1 7 l.'.'t niiu-lil 111. 11 |ii'rliiiiivli,' tak.n a» liiyli »*iitiati' llial onliiiarv lii"li till.'* r.'ii.'li.'- ali.iill II-* t'ai'iislh.' "•o,„l.'ii stoi ..ri' ..r l.->. 'I'li.' In'iu'lil to wlii.'li .'.nlinarv lii'.'li ti.l.' ri".". Ii.'ili'/ irl I 11 T.. 1 will tli.T. I'or.' '-In.w tlial ll..' La-.' ..I 111.' I'lainlitl"- wharf at Oaii.l of tin' D.'f.'ii.laiil'- uhai.. ■ at /, ami Hm.' i'.'"|i,'.lisi'ly. (tlii'iv h.'insj liut litll.' .liU'.ivni'.' li.'lwi'.'ii till' r.'-|..'.'llv.'l.v.'U ..f ih..-.' |...!iil-i ahoiil II l.'.'i ahov.' low water ill 111.' .*it. I.iiwr.'iii'.'. a r.-iilt of "lii.'li ».• al-o urriv.'il liy h'V.'lliii'.' ■low'ii to M. Lawr.'i,,.' low wal.'r mark. .Imliiinir from |'iVN.-iit ni'i'.aram.'i' nn.l iii.U.l ly iln' .'vi.l.i.. .■ ol wmii' ol III.' witm— .'-. it woiilil a|.|i.ar that III.' Ii.'f.ii.hinr^ wh.irfol l>..:i lunl l.r.'ii Innlt iiil.i .l.'.'i. wat.'r fi-.im lllll.' Ii.'low \ .|.nvii to amrl.' n.'Xl h.'low Y. -.im'.' Illi.'r.' h at |.i-.-.,'nl from :; to :! I'.'i'l il.'|.tli of w.it.'r al.ni'.' it h.'lw,'.-ii ;lio-,' poliit-. 'I'h.' m.'ii w lio l.nilt lli.' -am uharl" how.'Vi'r. Mat.' in tln'ir I'Vi.l.'ii.'.' ihal it w,i> m.t hiiilt int.. iIm' . Iiaiin.'l Iml on lli,; liaiikth.'r.'of. ll i- h.ii'.'lv |i(.--il.l.' lli.i' tin' foot ..f l!i.' Lmk. on whi.-li tin' -aiil wli.irl i--lal.'.l t.i li.ivo lun'ii Iniill, may'hav.' h.'.'ii i.'ra.linilly ahr.i.h'-l ami wa^li.'.l away hy ll,.' .•nrr.'iil ,-imji' Ki.1. \\\ that ii imiiorla'ii in tin' .•\ lil.'ii.'.' ii.-arinu' "n tin' |.,i-ilion oflhc -li I wli.ilf of 1^■"•J in rolalion t.. th.'lMiik In.tw.'.'ii X Mii.l /, .111 whi.'li it i- hnilt will h.' f-ni I in •• aiiin'mliN^ |i. -.111111111. '.1." Nolliiii',' -ali-fai'lorv <-an In- l.'.irnt a- lo lli.' fo-ilion ,,f il;,' l'.,iiiiUll .-, wli.nl with i-.'u'.inl lo 111.' I'.nik .111 whi.'h i't i-*liiiill. tin' I'vi.l- m lli.il |. 'im I'-'i i-' Iw.i .■oiiir.i- iili.'t.irv' It lia|.ii.'ii-*liow.'V,-r a- wa-< alr.'ailv -lat.'.l llial il,.- io|, ..f lii.- .ni-imil hank on ll,.' liainlill'sM.I.'i-still vi-ihh' ami iirovcsifaiiylliin-, lliiil ili'' I 'IVmliir - " l.ai I i- hnill iii-iil.' of tlu' foot of llio oriiiinal >lo|..' ..f tin' lialik on hi- -i.h'. 'I'll.' I.i|. .'I lln' .-l..|»- "l' "I'l l..ink iHiit tiin.'f.'.'l from I'h.'onl.'r fa.-.' ..f tin' Mii.l "lunl ami tin' wharl iN. ll h.-imf ah.mi I, '11 f.'L'f hiu'li wonhl imik.' llic -lola' awrairi'iihoilt on.' I" om- ..r al an am:l.-"i f. - . .N.'W il i" \v,;ll Umiwii that III,! miliiral slop.' ofor.linary ,'arlli i-^ a- Mat a^ .1 l,i I, l.-inlini: l.j pl'ovo that thii fool of till' l.ank ,,r -l..|i''on th,' I'laintiirs m.Ii' |.irimrl.\ ,\l,-ii.l,;.l ah. ml 1 ..r o |,-ot h.'voml tho |.i-.'-.'iit wharf, tin' invsiimplion tli.-ivl'..r,' li.'in^' thai tin: riainlitl .-< wharl from till' -Ion.' -l,ir.' .lowii lo within -om.' l.-.-i .'f III.' |.'.int () is l.iiill imM'.' iiilaml ih.iii it. i„i,.htliav.' I II. 'I'll.' K.'^li.rls iiiiisl tak.' ih.- lih.rly M r.-h-r tin- lloiiorahh' .lii.lj.'.'.-* t.i iinuiv important rcmark.s whi.-h th.-v hav,' llmii-iil n tli.'il' ilmy t., ..Ih-r al lli.' .n.l ol llii-^ r.'ii.>'rl an t., tin' . .niirn-tiim' .-vi.l.-ii.',' a.Mii.'.'.l hy lln- p.irth's on s.ni I llu- ni.i--l imponanl point- al is-n.- with th.' vi.w of ,-\plainiii,i;lh,' .litt'i'iriil ,iiciim-.laii. ,- nmh'r whi.li lli.- -I'Vcial wiliu'--.'-pa.->' l.i .-.-.'ap.,' without any iiupf'lim.'iit to th.' mill wli.'.'l. 'I'li,' K.^pcrt^ liavimi ass,-rl,-.l in .-hm.su No :i, that th,; wharl is iin ohstrm-tioii iimstlv on a.-.'onnt of th,' a,-tion .'f lln: i.'C in tho siirin.i; livsh,'t.s, will imw pi',i,'L't'il to ^ll,■w h.iw t'h,- >anu'oli-lriuli.iiu'onhl not o,-,-iir if llio wharl wi-ro ix'liiovi'il. llu' liaukut thi'ihaiiin'l al Y li.-in^-aliont thr.',' f.'.t an.l a half, ahovc the siirfaco of ,-haiiii.l walL'i', it iniirht ll.: .supposi',1 that tlu' i.'.: lirhlu'..' ovor the .sai.l ,-liaiin,-l woiilil h.. loiiii.:.l, iw it now foniH l,L'tw.'.-ii Iho wharf of IS.VJ, iiml lliesUm,' store ami I'laiiiliH "s wharl. ll is pi-ohuhlc however tliat il w.nil.l imt la' so .sine,' the iee m.t liaviii- a verllual .-iirlaee to alni' iii'ain.st .iiil.l easilv ho i'ai-,'.laii,l ll'iale.l hy tin; wal.-r whi.-h it woiiUI cerlainly ,lo in all case.stit h.-iim- a l.uovaiit ,snhstaii,:e) when ai lii.eity to ,1,. mi. I'.iit . Acn if the lei^ .'oi'hl h.' h.>iani,:n.'.l ii7tlie o'lth't ami th.' fr.'.sliet waler, ma.l.' to ll.iw ov.r il. il will l"- ilire.-tly iimh'r- Hloo.l thai th.' fresh.-t water liavin,;; llieii a mmli iiml.'r -pa.'.' L' Mow ov.-r i-.nil.l never ohtaiii uny thill!..; like lhe.l.'|illi to whieii it now aeeiimiilater, in ill,' lire.seul narrow ..utlol. \S',' .aiim.l si\ Ihal on llie -hi.' .'llh.' i U'l'.-ii.iani ami in lli. • oar ..f ami witiiin iii.s wharf ereete.l in 'l><-"il., any nia'l.-earlh iloe- appear mi a- to prevent n.s at once Ir.mi 7 I'liill' llhln'* Mill' til ill" ;||p..Vi' Ihi' II lAtl'Ilt i* III' lllllll DM till' MIIIIIC >i«H ill il-« I'lliinitiiMX, hiirli Wiitil' ihin vn*i\ III llir rivi'f liliiivr liii'li- , may I"'. |.ln'lli|i\ *l- ■iiii|iiiil, A ii|iiirl livii- (vliiirM^ I' I hIiiIi' iIiiiI ■ liriL'lit In lia-i' III' llii' llii'lc liiiiiir illlilVC l.ivv uuii ll. Si. I'Viilil.ir lit I lirrh lllllll ■ M |>|i-rlil mill llii' ^iiiii I lull nil llli.' I, III' i< -iiili-il ■urriMil .-iuci' infill' l^.■l2 •• iHi;ii'iii|iN lill 'n vvliiirl' hvu riilillM- iil liaiik III! liilt' \> liiiill .liijir nr nlil lirilur lllliilll I : . Niiw il I. Irllilillir I" I illiiillt 1 HI ■'< Ililt'M ull.lll IMnl lliall il ' .IlldllCH ti> I'Mll 111' llli-^ st iiii|Mirliiiit ■ll lllC M'M'lIll tiiiiial cli-^a- ;,it i-i liiiilt vi'i' III 1 laii^i' ml I'Xi^l I III' till' .-Inpi; 111' willidiit aiiv lat tint wliiii't' 111-*, will now I'liiiiVfii. Tlio I! 1)1' cIkiiiih'I Id III' rmiiii'il. wliarl'. 1 1 i- lll'ari' 111 iilm' Illy iln ill all ! ice run 1(1 In' irt'ctly iiinli'i'- , iiL'Vcl' (ililaiii tlct. Ill witiiiii i;i.-^ al iiiiL'i; li'iiiu iilmTvinif ilic •lute 111 llu' pliiri' iix it wimjil ln'. It it Mi'i'.'HKiify liinvi>vi T tn roiiiui^k llmi Miiiili'-i'iiitli I'Xti'iid- 111 ll I'l'W I'l'i't licliiw lliii iiiiiht \ (Miliiii till! itaiil wimrl'. It U iijio |iii-.-ilili' uvi' niniiiil '•iiy |ii'iiliiili|i') tliut niiiiu' I'lirih imiy liiivn ln'i'ii i|ii|iiiHiti'il iiiiiiirdiiiti'ly III till' I'l'iii' 111 till' niiid wliail III IH.VJ, uliii'li \siiiili| (.'ivr tlic liuiik, mi wliicli liir Kaid wliurt' {■a Imilt, ilii' a|i|ii'ai'i'ii f liriiii; huiin'Wliai liiu'lii'l' lliaii iit tlii' tiim' tlin wliiii'l' wiis liiiill. 'riH'fc a|i|ii'ai'-<, iiiiiiii'diuti'ly lii'liiiid Iln- wli.irl', aiiil lii'tvvi'i'ii \ and V. it I'lTfuiii Miipi'i't'lt'- vatinii iiK it iiiiii|iii-"'d ni' till! niiili n'liinvi'd Iriiiii tin' nil ii|ii(il liy tlin wlmrf, iiii'l llil'iiwn ii|i lii'liiiid it. 'I'liii sii|ii!rrli'vatiiiii a|iiii'.ir-< tu in to Im iiliniil a li ut iiioro nr Ii'hh ill iliii'kiii'f«. Till' a|i|ii'aii'iiri' ill' ilii' li.iiik, il iiinif lii' iuii. What arc • iillcd ^prilla■ lidi-i arc kiiuwii to occur nl c\('ry new and lull iiiuuii. ThiMc tides ucciir twice a day. dnrinir I'uiir ur live ihiys. It iiii;.'lil ilicrcfmc lie staled that the I li'l'einlanr^ wharf ul' !.>•.■>;.' as well as •diiic part uf the I'laiiiliti's wharf liiwai'ils the puiiil l>. anl lie' wlnile nf the luw ttruillid in the fear of the », lid wharf uf ix.'rj urc siilijeri tu I.e ll.iii.|c,| mure ur less t'ur cis;lit ur ten days during each iiimilh ur diiriiii: I'ruiii 111 lu -.'il tides inureur less. .\s to the Iciiirth ofliinctur wliieli wharf III, IV lie IliiiiiU'd, li..' Imiirhl uf water drnwii iipmi it, in the ri'speetivc sct'timi indie. iliii.' sii 'h ,wharl' will irive an c i-,\ -'liiiiiu:!. '.y iin ri'ly alluwiiiL,' I'rmn liftecii to twenty niiniiles t'ur every I'uul ut' rise ur tall ahuvc -iieli wharves. Fur iiistanci! in the «L'ctioli thi'uiiili puiiil S' nil unr planN'ii.l. '. ^ ic a depili uf I'uiir f.'cl of water U .shewn duriiij; a vcrv lii'.'h lid'', il is piulialile lliiil | I ((mild he lluudcd ailusrclher tur alimit two hmirn and n'liire ur le-> e\ ideiitly in rdiiiu; lu iim lii'i'.;lil uf any parliciilar tide. Thu iiianii III whiiii the 111.' s^.iicr would hive cuveiel the hiinl. uii wliidi tlm Dcli'ndaiit'.s wharf in creeled, is ahsulutcly the saiim ns nniler pi'eseiii liiciinislaincs, il' we well ninlcrHtuod tlio iiicannii: of the (iilcsiiun. The aiiiieM'd I'i.m N'u. 7 ,-lmws a liird's eyi view ut' tin.' aiei-ar I n'c uf the pi'.'ini-es in dispii e diiriii.r an urdinary hi'.;li tide and licf' re the wharf ut |s!'i:i is tluodcd, at which lime llm s.iid w li.ii f licituincs iiivisihio ctcepts usu breaker henuath ihe -nrlace. (.|„..»',C A, r/i/iM, .\ .. 7 .,1' lnl.,/n.,fl.,ri/) The I'Apeil.. having e.vaniiiicd liy cuniieiri -.in anl t'ruiii Hcieiitilic data tlic si^titional area ul' the present mitlct al the punit \' and duwn tu / mi the one hand, and the conihi- iied si'i'limial areas ut' tlm mill race and ar.'h ur eiilvcrl nndcr the liridLce n\' the turnpike ruad mi tin* other hand, are of opinimi that under all ordinary cireuinslanecs and even dtliiiiLf >uiall ii-'«ln't uiiaccuinpanied hy the prcscin'c ul'ice in llie river, tin! said millet at Y !••} Hiitli- liciit for the p 11 piisc uf discliaru;iin.' all the water emiiin'.;'ilinvii ihe Iteaiipurt rlverainl passinj; parllv lhruu;rh tin' mill and mill race, and partly Ihrmiuh the said arch of thu liriili.'e. It will ill' uliscrved mi the" scclimial hridite " thai the arehway or culvert is now much higher than it was at the time we iiiadc the survey in 1S.')T. The cuiicliisiaiis almve arrivod ut arc true as well when tlm mill i~ wurkiiiir. as when it is not wurkiin;. lu our opinimi nil canal, ehaniiel ur pa,~a^c existed in the year \^'>i. at the timo of the constriicliun uf Ihe hcfcndeiit's wliarl al Ihe place >A' its ereeiimi fruiii \ dowui to 'A (the trees and slumps of trce.s existed all almu; Ihe hank heliiud the wliarf I'ruiii X to Y heiin; pri'lly L;uud evidence uf ihemselves of the trillii uf this assertimi) and if such a chajinol passai^e or canal did exist, a circiiiiislance uf which we can liuvo no douht in view ot" tUo evideime adduced uu the .suliject (.Vppendi.x .\) it must .so havi! existed at ahout tlni point X ora little above thai point. Itruwii's prul.'st uLCainst (iiijry Imildinu; his wharl]|ul' IS.'il and the reasons there .clfurth ai;ainst, the ereetiun uf llie said wharf (K.xlract No. IT Alipendi.x (i) fender il more ill.;.' pi'ubable lliat the former chaiiiml was cut of and ohliterated, lor t ho must jiart by the uiid wharf of l.><.'il. The chanin'l marked out on Ware's [ilaii (I'laiutitF'rt exhibit .\| liy .Michael .Scott who funuerly had the mill and must have known tho proiierty well if prolonged would cut the wharl'ui' Ls.jl a good many feet above tho point X. It is true that most u\: tho witnesses, wln'u called upon to trace out on tho Haid plan, (I'laintiirs exhibit .\) the supposed eastern channel have each of tlieiu Iriiceil oiio in ii, dif- !i!ft'ntdii'e'..'tio!!. leudini.' to sliew as the l>c!'end;i.iil has ii.riruoil that tin! fact nf the witiuis.soH not agreeing a.s to vvheio the supposed elianiiel was, proves iheiv. to have uevur been ouo; but k^ 8 when tliins< iiro v'kmvoiI in ii more iliHiiitiTOstoil llirlit ills cnsy f'iiiin:,'li to oxiilain all di.s- ori'iiiiiicii's. Louis All!,'.'!-, I'of instiiiico, the I'hiiiititr's iiiilli'i-, who is iiii old iiiiil i-iMpoctablo man, ami lia-; known lli.' mill and |ii'cnii-rand and tlieii r.Mpn-sted to trace it out on the plaii^ have in- dicaleil tho said island in a way bearimr not the least resemblance nor proportion to the verbal description jriven and dimensions assiLnicd. shewim,' clearly as above st^ocd. that tho fact of no chanuol (.'Ver haviuir exi-fd in the precise po^-iiion. pointed uiit by the wituosscs, is no proof that such a channel did not exist e|s,'wlicre. The initiirel indications thou,!.'h sliu'ht, of the existonco of the channel at some former time are still to be mmui, iind it will^ be'remarked bv an inspection of the si'ction, ihrmiiih Y and '/., tlait there is a ilepressioni'f thoirround ahiiijrthe wharf A U, and the bank of stoni's I! (J X. If in c..iinection with those iKiturel indications it he surmised why the wharf A 15 was built in it- pioeiit |iosition ami direction, instead of runniuj; up I'roin A towards Z the lloimr;iblc .Indices uill (aided by the evidence ■)( /•. n/, lU'extracts iheretrom, by us selected and to bo found in Appendix A) beable to form their roferenco to the wharf built in IS.'il and expressions in the eviile'nce to ilie etlcel that " I'mi .v'<,v/ ((/7)vt. In iiict, thu mere cntlint,' oil of tho ea>ti'rn channel, unjn>tilialile as il may have been, could iievor liuvo arisou to tlie bed of the present channel, but not so" high as not be overlloweil by frcshi'ts and by all the _ high tides of tho first anil third (piarters of the moon. In answer to the ivmaining Jiart of this clause, as to the aclion of the said wharf in forming an eddy above, it and causing ae<'uniulations of gravel etc, in the tail race, wo take tho liberty to' refer the llonnrahlo .liidges to our remarks on the ?amc .subject in anwer to clau.-'e Xo o of the Iiiterl.,.rut..ry .ludgment since, if we did imswor tlieso ,)nestioiis at this part of oiir re|iort il would be bin a mere repotition ot what wo have already suid in answer to the said clau.se Xo. :!. i Iihiiii all (li^^- iiil ri'H|)0('tiil)k! tiai'tMl (lilt on (> tlio wharfof (lilt liy Alitor. ■Icmiu'l to 1)1! tlio wiiil [iliiii. to us oil tlio AioMsly til lll(^ • licil uilli our xist('(|, 1)11' not 11 iiidiciitcil by lion (loun to- liH clmniii'l on that Aiiiicr (iin ■I on tlic iilan i|iKMitly tnici'd itlior cliaiiin.'ls I (if il |>liiii or liny Kikli iilan niics !i Iviiow- ■li lli(> irniiiliK; (■ alili- to triK-c who traced out ■ at till' time of ■lilH'lltcil, SOIlll' I'l ui'iit around ■alihli; way on ir with tho s to tlio di- I'laii have in- i|»iilioii to the 'lali'd. that tho the witnesses, i-iliiiiis tli(iii,i;h I'll, and it will a ilc|iri'ssioii of iiiiiicctioii with icM'iit position s will (aided hy II Aiipcndix A) Il r (if the river I -iili>laiiliiited . a clianiiel only er Jieauport, in II. Thai water mill niee down mill rai'o or will now 1111- the north east lani'es it would it a" liaisseiir." wharf iiuilt in ', 7)/-(/ ,h: lN,"il ilions indicates, i| X. K. chaiiiiel. iy not (ieullU'd l'. Ill fact, tlie iiiilil never iiave lined free t^iiace f of l^o•J so that ! said wharf of the hed of tli(^ the hitrli tides it' this clause, as rcuiiiulations of s to our remarks since, if we (lit! .'le reiietition ot [Auaira- to ('Imue Au. 'J of JiitirlouKlvn/.} Tlin ctroct of the course of tho water in the existiiii,' state of tho river ill relation to the dei^raihitions of tiio river liaiiUs may lie eonsiderod in^ the lol- lowintr liifht. 'riiu How of the water from the hridjro down airaiust the wharf of ISo^ iiiiiy to a certain extent have the elfeet of ealiiej; away llic liank heiieath it as wo liave alri'ady noticed in the former part of this report. The said wharf however is well ela|ilioarded, down to the bed of the river and not much dainajre can aeeruo to tho Defemlant froiu that cause, li appears rather iirohahle that the course of tho channel hetween X and \ was more concave towards tho Uefeiiilanfs side, previous to tho erection of his wharf hetween those points in 18,rJ. for the current seems to r-trike fiirlit into the wharf hetween those two iioints as if it would iro straiirht on if tho said wharf were not there. What renders this prohahle is the ureat del'tli of watiu' alon.i:sitle the said wharf lictween Xaiid \' as eoiiiparod with the other parts of the channel teiidinijlo show that the wharfof l>i;VJ. was huilt into the channel at that part of its loinrth. It is possihle, however, as already clause Xo. y, that the bank on which the said wharf may liav some extent oaten awav or abraded by tlh' current at that siiot stated ill answer to lieeii erected has been, to since tho erection of the sai('l wharf, and the l)efciidaiit is pro'bably not wronir in asserliiii; that the point of stones and rubbish 1' {rradually aiiirnieiiteil from year to year by tiic oleaiiiiii;s out from the tail race, which are from lime to time di-posited the'n'on, ii'iay huVe been and still bo iiislriimental in driviii',' the current towards his (the Defandantsi wharf and by so doinj; .irjve the wharf itself the appeanince of havim; oiieroached upon lueseiit channel, belwedi X and V, to a greater distaliec', than it has (huie. The eiirreiit after delloctiiiir at X or a little below X is ne.\t directed towards tho stone store, where it iniprin,;;-cs ai;aiiist the bank T V and necessarily eats awav the earthly jiarticles of the said bank, layin-- bare the stones of which it is partly eoiii'po.sed. In the remainder of the clianmi iVo'ni V to A and below Z down t.' (.) the dcjrra- dati' ■ and abrasion of tho bank ivro of so sli:;lit a nature as to be _ unworthy of note. We (.iiinot look upon tho ovidcnce udiiiicecl by the Defendant in this cause, rclati\cly, to the dei.'iadatioiis ot' the banks on his side of the river caused, as lie asserts, by tho I'laliitilf's wharf and the stones at the foot of the said wharf and behind the stone store, in aiiv other li^dit. than that of a desire on his part (a very natural and pluu.^ible one' ol course) to distract the attention of tho Court and of the Hxperls from ihe^ real and only im- portant obstruction in the river lieaniiort, to a few stones producing' an etl'eet upon the llow of the river of no relative iin|iiirtaiiee whatsoever, a> already slated in our answer to clause :; of the Jndi,'mont. (.Ui.ct, at tho base of the wharf ami but tifleen and a-lialf feet at llic top of the vaiiic h tlieivforo appears that from the efi'ect of the ice within the said wharf ol' l^'rZ or from the wearing away of tiio bank, beneath the wharl'at Z, or by tho-e two causes combined, tho piis.sage between tho two wharves at the said [Hiint Z has been reduced by several feet, say live feet and a lialf aecordini; to Fletcher and Austin's plans. The eti'ect we consider is mainly duo to tlie ice, between the inside of the wharf of lH,c', and the Defendants bank of stones at (I! tj X) and wharf 15 A. The action ol' tho ice may be considered to take place aa follows. The sheet of ice between Zand 1! on being torcod up every inontli or even twice a u.oiitli and for sever.il tides in succession at every new and full moon, and necessarily fractured by the iiroeess on account oftiie resistancoat the edges by friction against the said wharves ; tho water in the tissures feezes again as the tide ebbs, and the ex|iaiision so jiroduced (for water unlike all other lliiids, and by a kind dispensation of I'rovideneo e\[iaiids in becoming a solid) produeos its ellect in imikinirroom for itself by luisliiiig before it tho objects which otter the least resistanco which of course is tho ease with tho wharf of 1802, a.s compared with that of tiioro solid construction at A. li. The elfect incident on a single operation of the kind mentioned may be but the fraction of an inch : yet when repeated twice a day for several days in each month, and for several months in each year, ami multiplied again by a aeries of years (from IS'.:! to is'i'.i), it can be understood luiw units may bo farmed, and many of them by tho reiieated addition of so many fractions. — It might bo urged that tho ioo between Z and the opposite wharf should have a tciideucy to act upon the wharf of 10 \r IS.VJ ill ii ciiiitrnn- ilirrriimi I'lit il liii- ;ilrr;i(ly lucii ri'iniiiki'il iii;it for uihsI dfllir wijitrr till' ico is tlicrc iiMiiiM'd in mill nimlilc to risi' with tlic tiiUv mid if it iliil, its (■(K'ct im llii> wiiiirf (if LS'ili would oiiiy lie to tli;it ul' tlio ice within tlu^ wiid wliiirf iii llu' |ihi|iiii'|iii|i ,i| tlu; rcspoctivo l)i\':idlli-i 111' liotli, Anotln'i' rirriiin-itinii'i' whirh nivcs mi iiiidiH- intl iicc Ik till' ioo within the whiirt isthiit it rciiiiiiiis tlu'iv miil iic-ts as uhovc iiioiilioiicd for s'v -ocks lifter that, lirtwi'i'ii tin' wharves is hrokcii ii|) and parlly ilissolvcil. It iiiav !i. ijiorto state here that it has ocenri'i'd to the defendant lately that his wharf is in realit»' , irt'iiolit, to t!ie I'laintilf rather than the contrary, sinee as In' says it causes thi^ iee in tin outlet to hreiik np sir »■.,/,•« earlier than it would do. .Vow to say iKiliiiirof tin; six weeks aliov" men tioned it is an iindoiihted (iiet that iee always hrea'vs n|> earlier in the vieinitv of wharves than il does elsewliere. The eansi' is the non eondiielini; powers nf the wood' the wharvcH are linilt ot, and the relieitimi of the -siiiis rays from the wharves to the iee, and ireiieral eoneeiilratiiin of heat in any imlosed and niic.\po>ed phiee. We innst fivelv admit tliiy heiielii tliereliy eont'errod on the I'laiiitilK to he iiieahnlalple tlioiii;h not so miieli 'on aeeoimt ol' its j;roat im[iortaiiei! as of the eontrmy ipialily. It niiuht prohalily under the cirenni- staiiees of the cases lie made out an injury to the riaintill rather than a lieiielit to him as it is prohlematieal whetlier it would not lie lietlerfor the ieo to remain slalionarv in the outlet nnlil the lower iee had moved away, than to lireak np and cause jams as it has done and is likely to do under similar ciivuinstanees. — The channel and tail-race as laid dinvniii said I'hiinlilf's exhihit .\ are not at all correct nor do tlioy purport to he so and we cannot help rciiiarkin>rat this jnnctiiiv that an immense nia-s of evidence has hceii adiincd |i\- tl,,. I'cfcndaiil in this casi' to prove Ware's plan to he incorrect, and woiijde^s ; lor let it he leincmherel that Ware surveyed the premises on the "ill of April, at a season when the river must have liccn still covered with ice as he hinisclf states in his <'\ic|eiice (exiract :i appcinlix I'). J.et it he also reniemhered that the title of the said plan i>. •• riaii of tjir iieauport mills exhihiliiii: cerlain wiiarves ereeled hy .Mr. (;iii,rv survevi^l inli .\pril. Is.'i;!," and that Ware when sayinir in his evidence tliat the [ilan cxhiliiled a cnnr,/ view of the lo- cality could only he supposed to mean that the plan was corr^'ci inasmueli as il piirp.irle.l to he hy its title. .Nlcssrs. Fletcher ami .\nsliii holh state thai Ware's plan is ineoi'reet inainnich a> anioiiL; other thiiiirs the arch at the lirid:,'0 is represented lo he sixteen feet while it \< in reality Inil twelve feet .seven inches. .Some people rather iinfortiinalely take a ph.'asnre in tindiiiir an i.'rror in the work of a '•"hl'ri'iu of ihi: same profe^ion ami are too ipiick al comin"- to conehisions often erroneous. Xow we do >tate as a f.ni that the sixteen feet .-il ih" liridj,'e on Ware's |i!an do not indicate nor are tiny inleiid.'d |o indicale the width of the arch lull the distance between the wharves of lie parlies al that point and if .Messrs. Klelcher an I Austin had heeii a little more careful in their examination of Wares plan lliev would havi^ mide theuiselves aw. irc of their error ; there heiiiij an unini^la'ce.ilile proof (if ih' fact on the said plan even tlioui^h s[n;etacles were rec[uired to delect il. Secondly. — The only remark we .-honld have made uiih rcirard to l''letcli,'r's iilan (l)efcndaiit's Ivxhioil 14) is thai already allud d lo in conneclion with the distance lietween the wharves al 'A. It is however important to notice that the heiu'ht ol' the wliail' on ihe in-ide at near Z is much i,'realer than wrillen on Fletcher's plan. I'rohahlv the heiielii in ((Uestion was taken hitrher n|i towards V and written loo fai' down on the plan! The heclion throujrh / on our plan No. 1, shews how very low tin' hank is al that point. Thirdly.— .\s to Austin's plan I Kxlii hit N*o. Mof |),.fi.) the only remark worth niakiii:;- in- depeiidenll\ of that already made as to llie di-lancc at Z helwecn' the two wharves i> "linu the point I' at the time Aiislin survi'yed il does not appear to liave I n a hank of the piv^ sent mairniliide hut a mere reef a little ahove the siirfa''e and separated from the main land hy a small channel ; hetweeii the main ciiaiinel and Ihe tail race. 'I'hat point I' is mm joiiii'd to llie m.iinland in Ihe normal stale of the water in the channel and is as alrea.K explained ahoiit luo fi'et ahove the level of ihe water in the channel ; lendinii lo pio\',- i|h. eoticlusion arrived at hy the Fxperls in our answer to the ;h-d clause of the inlerlocniorv as to the said point 1' heinir I'lH-nied partly of the. /.V„v'.v washed into the tail-race hv fres'lii'ts and then cleaned out of it hy hand o!' man and thrown upon lhe>aid hank. It will not l,r out of place hereto remark cm Ihe evidence rendered hy two of tin' Del'endaiil's wiln.--e, (■• J'lxlracts No. J iind .'. ofap[iendix II continued") as to ihe formalion of the point I' one of the said witnesses Ij;nai'e .M.iieney says that ihe point 1' is '•»,„■ c,«/„,-, i/, ,ii"r,„ /1,',7'cc .s overhearin;,' and repealini; the words of another. The Dclendani in his remaiks lo us, and in a remark made hy him in Martin's or .Moreiicy's evidence tries to explain awav the' uall or iiulwark alluded to hy his witiiesM.^ hy s;,yin.,/|hat the said wall had existed hiit iiad heen most materially altered since its formation imforlunati'ly however (a circiimstaneb to which the Delendant did not Jiay snllicii'iil atlenliou) his man .Moi'encv says " /,,■ iniir ilmit j\ii j,:::-!^ critic ,irl,ull,n:,-nt, j' !'oi' to ciilitv , iii'iu'lit tli< o;itMt to I'ks llllOV" IIH'll lily of wliiii'vi'S ml llic wliiirvfs cc, unci y-i'iii'iiil freely ailinil llie Hell on iicconiit ler tlic circiiin- 'tit to liiiii lis it •y ill tho (Mil let lis (lullc Mini is I (IdUii ill suid We eiiiiiiot liel|i ildlleeil liy tlic : l.'l' let 'it lit; I'liii when the eihe (extnii^t H ■■ I'lnii of till. April. lS,",;i.'- iiew oC the lo- t |iiir|iortei| to vreet iiiiiiiiiiieh : while it i-i in e 11 lileusure in niek iit coining- I'll feet nt the illli of thu iiivh '~. KK'tclier nil 1 ey wouhl have ■'I' ill • fact on 'leteiier'^ |ilai| lii)w that I he I 'lain till' ean-'eil it to ln' Imi It for the cxi iress ]iiir|iose ofilrivini;' tlio enrrenl aL'ainst liis wharf so as to iinileriiiinL' it anil jrive it the a|i|'eaivnec whicii il I'ealy has at present of liaviiii; ein'roacheil ii| the present channel. What wc deny is that tiio stones are in aiiv way iirraiiL''e'l in the manner of a wall asstaleil liy Morcncy anil Martin. They appear on the contrary to have merely heeii thrown there from the tail race without any attempl at special arraiiL'emeiit. The man came down mid when asked to point out tin! wall the oxistelice of which he had spoken ofa few days liet'oro asofa fact lie had witnessed the verv same day that lie had u'iveii his evideiieu he iioiuted everywhere and iiowluMV) to the wall and to ilio 40 feet inlcnuth thereof in utter disci inliliire. We shall have lo allude aplin to the^e two wilncs-cs in coiineilion with snnie evidence rendcreil liy them on another snlijecl. To iiiallieweil it eoncavo when if should heconvexi ihar no more rdiaiee can he placed on the lower part of the said tail-race, and no proof cliciicd a- to ii- haxim:' lieeii clian:^ci| within the lew years [last. F.iarthly. — I)cl'i's !',\hiliit lit'ieen is a iicrc lojiy of that made liy Ware (I'.xhihil .\' i l'"il'llily. — l)ett'> Mxhiliil twelve is also Imt a mere copy of Fletcher's [dan and therefore calls for no remarks. • Sixthly. — Defciiilaut's Kxhihit, II. i- a loii.jti copy of .\iHlin's plan, made at 'he reiple»t of the Did'cndant. to ^liow not al all conei'dy hat rallier in away to thro\v as III ich discredit as possihle on the I'hiinliirs wilncsscs, the dilferent channels testified to, Iiv tliein or moiv correctly the dilfcr nl directions as>ii;ned liy the witnesses for thi' Mi[iposcil eastern eliannel. Scvi.'iifhly. — riainlilf's exhihit 11. 1\ ; l.irae ha- Iransferred toliis plan the channeis and liii;li tide lines ol' McCarthy s plan ol' IT'.'J. The transl'er is not correctly made as it shews that part ot'th ■ cicinnel of 17:12 which is in ti liii" with the south side of the distillery huildin;; to he ahoiit twenty feet nearer to the I ) 'I'diihin;'- -ide than it should he. TIh> said transfer ifcnrreetly laid down would also -lew the ,\. H. conu'r of the stone store to encroach alioiit o {'r'^ up m what the west en i dianicl of .McCarthy's [dan then was, iis may lie -ceil liy rtd'crrin;f to our plans \o. 2 and li a'i'ie\i d t i this report. The tail-raeo as shewn on this exhihit was evidently sketcln'd in a vciy careless way a> it hears no rosemhlancij in point ol shape iior ill |ioint of dilinnisions to what it really is. The bank of stones and lilliie.; in lietwe(;n tin; iioints 15 and X and around throuy-h li as shewn on this exhiliit, as well as oil Fletcher's and .Austin's plans has evidently lieeii advanced iioat'of towiirds X tiiid even several leet past that |ioilil since those plans were made. Eiijlitlily. — Flaintilf's exhihit II. copy of a jilan made in 17'.'2 hy .reivniiali Mi-(.'arth\ surveyor. 'I'liis plan will he more fully notice I in couiiection with .Vos. - and ti of tlu' plans annexed to this report. The pencil lines in'e oars and were used liy us in tranferrine' the idaii on an enlaru-cd scale lo a plan of the locality as it at prescnl exists, with a view ol' coliipariiii;' the pre-ent wharves and liiiildiii:rs with the channels and hij;li tide lines etc., of that period. Xinthly. — ICxhiliits \o. Id, tiled hy Juhn Ilaccy Fsj., in siijiport of his evidcic e on pan of the Defendant. This plan has also been Iran-I'erri d liy lis to another plan of the |ireinises as ihey nowareand will he more fully iioliccd anon. Tenthly. — .\s to tlieold jilaii of IT^o (Fxhihit 1 of jlel'endant ) it is mid imrpdrts to he Imt a mere sketch drawn on the itroiind without iiistriiinents of any kind mid is useless except as a. mere approxiiuation. I'rocced we now to the eoiisideralion and deseri|itii)n of the plans annexed to and formiiiir (lart of this report. I'lau Xo. 1 is that of llio premises as they now areaiid were at the time of the survey thereof diiriiii; the sumiiit rs of IS.'m and Is.'iS. The smiuMetttU's have been used on all our plans to denote the same parts mid they arc also the same as those on the plans of record, the several exhibits above (ieserihed. The wharf .V. "N'. /i. is the wharf built ill 1X52 by the Defendant and t'orms tho basis of the in- stiUitioii of the lu'osont aetimi, A 1!. is an old wliarl' on the Defendants sido built aluuit -:'> years a:;d. I>. Q. X. is a bank of slimes Icrmiiiatin:;; tlu,' niade-jrl'ound Oli tho Dcl'cndaiit's side (see oxtraets 7 and K appmidix I'.) All the i;round in roar of tho Defendant's wharves I'roni the bridge of the tiirnpiki! road doun to .\ and tlienoe down- 12 r. wanln i^ iiiiiiio-i;niiiii(l, iiiul in wi'ittoii ilowii in .-iirl of tlio Jiliiil Xo. 1 iiroviMiiiil. Till' spiici^ I'ovcii'd liy I ti) Imvi' lucii Im'iii'Ii oi' low iiiul iiiai-sliy liiml lu'cvioim to il iiliovo lui^iitioiu'it ami I'oiivi'rti'd as it now iri into araliK; laii.l I ill tlir scviTai sc'ctioliH III' iiiailo-;;roiiiii| is .xlicwii s liiiviiijr lii'cii lilloil ill as Tin' I'viiU'iici' of siicli low t;roilM(l or lioacli liaviiii; I'xisli'il is ilisliiictiv |ioiiiti'il out in McCarlliy's plan ol' ITl'i, ami on HoiK'lu'tli's (Uaci'V's) |ilan of l^'M ami tiio llonoralili^ .Iiiilj;vs will iniimMliali'ly set' li\ a glamo at tlic liiiili tiilc liiii's of tlio>o two piaiH as transfcri'il to oiir |ilans N'os. 'i iiinl il, wlial till' cxti'iit ot llic iiKiili>-i.'i'i'iinil is on tlio Dt'li-mlanl's siilo suo also cxlrai'ls 7 and s Aliln-'liilix 1*. — It will In; rcinai-ki'il tlial tlu' Ijiyli tide liiii's ot ItoiU'liclto ami McCartliy ai;ri'i' US iK'ai'ly as can lie iRitwitlistamlini; that foiirlci'ii years laul clalisid hctwtoii tlic two Hiirvi'vs.' Till! eviili'iue ol tin! aliove is inorc ij;iM|iliically ili'im)iistrat>.'il on ISoiii'lmllc's |i|an wlii'iv tla' >ii'iina coloiii- I'lcarly iinlicati's all the land so tinted to liave liei'ii a sort of lieiU'li tioodfd at all liijili lido~. Wliiie writiiiif "f lloiudiotle's |dan it may not he out of )ilacf lieri' to stall! that what may inlert'il li-oin the evidi'iiec of record (see Apiicnilix A) as to the f.irnior existence of a north east channel or of some low ground to the eastward of a certain island opiiosito the stone store is fully currohorated hy an ins|iectioii ot thai plan whereon is indicated a sort of cliai;nel exteiidiiii; up from when' the [loint 15 would occur on that plan to within a short distance of the turnpike road. The Defendant naturally enoiiuh, of course, has tried to prove that trees existed all along the western side of the island or |ironion- tiu'v \V on IJouchetle's ]ilan from the letter 1{ in the word river to the tnrniiike road hut his pretensions in this respect cannot ln' c(Uisidcred as correct with regard to tlie w.,y the rcjirc- Hciitalion of such trees is given on l')uuland or proinontorv W extends down now much lower than il aiipareiilly did when Ihuidietti Mirveved tiie preaiises, and must he attrihuled to alluvial action which is constantly going on more or less at all ]H)iuts in estuaries, where the meeting of the tidal and river water™ lirodiice a great diminution in the velocity of 'ho current and cause it to deposit ma- terials previously held in suspension, and carried along with the current. The species of islaiiil then fefered to may have heeii, and ]U'ohahly was ahraded and worn iivvay from ahove as the present elmiinel from the hridge down to .\' shews it to have heeii ami the detritus deposited lower down. In that way I'an lie explaiiieil the alteration which had taken place from l.SOi! to IS.',:;, iind which gradually shortened the island from ahove, and IcUirlhened it from lielow unlil it had altained ils present shapes ami position as detined hy the oulline X. ^'. /.. of the wharf which now partly encloses il. I ). ( '. ^■. is tin' wharf on'the I'lainlid's side huilt or rehuill in ls."iO. The stones heliind the stone store are shewn at T. V. S. It. is the lower ]iart of the tail-i'iico which the llefemlanf asserts to have lieen changed from its former course in the direction S. T. It is \i'ry possihie thai this mav hi' the case since the hank U is low and of alluvial and recent forination. .\ few feet hel'ow X were seen, when wu surveyed the ground, some roots of trees which we have at the Defendants' re(|uest shewn on the plan at that point. 'I'lie Defendant's pretension Iteing that those roots ]irove there to have heeii no channel at that point. At point Y there tsa tree sfrowiiig out of the wharf as seen on (Section through point ^ .) The Deli'iidant pie- temls thi'i'div lo prove that the wharf at Y docs not eneroacli on tlu' |ireseiit channel i>\' the river. It is |uetended hy the Det'cndant and asserted hy sonu of his witnesses, that Ihattrce has spruiiLT up I'roin an old stump which exi-^U'd there when the wharf was huilt. We have hccii told, ihouiih il does not appear in evidence that the tree wasiilanted there since the hiiilding of the whiirf, and it lo ,Ks rather like it. It matti'i's little however how il came there, and the Defemlant mav as w ell he entitleil to the heiielit of the doiihl. The .-mall hridge ahove the same dam is tlial alluded lo in the testimony of those of the Defendant's witnesses on account id' sotnething that had occurreil on ihe ll'lh march last and to which we shall refer aiimi. The survev is carried up to a point ahoiit the mill dam where the channel is shewn to he only IT I'e'et ill wiillh, and it is even narrower higher up, Ihe pretension of the Defendant heiiig that if such a narrow channel i.ssullicieiil at that point one of greater dimensions at V must ho 80 (i/iiftinri. The Learned . I uilges will take notice however that the channel at the narrow point ilhove nuntioned is hut three I'eet deep, and that the adjoining land is more or less llooded during freshets. 'l"he several huildings on the plan speak for Ihemselves. The feint I'ed lines are merely imaginary liiu's made use of in surveying the premises. They indieiite all the measures taken, lines ol'ilireetion lU' direct rices, lines of .section etc. The several sec, ions also speak for theiiiseiven iiml the rnicsorsei-lion have lellel's ai their exU'eiiotie.-. ciu'respoml- ingwith those through which the sections purport to have heen taken. The scale to wiiich the ground plan ir- drawn is (orly feet i'^nglish to one Knglish inch and the scetions ai'o nil fuciir (•II llial ly i'iioiiv:li. of ml or |ii'(iiiioii~ K road liiit lii< \v.(y llic i-c|iiH'- ■ li clcliinii's or cl' vc^cialioH ars and l'I'ow iirli tide tVoiii iiitly Hot I'nily lollljll I'llC illl\' I walcr lower N'. K. cljaiilK-l •(• ill ils w holt' 'I'hr i>luii(l or icii limicliottc isiaiitly tfoinu' 1 river \vat(Jl-i o deposit ina- Tlie species d uiMii awiiy s it to liave tliu alteration e island iVoiii id |io~ilion as >. C. ^■. is ihe one sidi'e are sserts 1(1 have possihle tliat iitioii. A lew liieli We have it's ]ire(ciision |ioiiit N' there llelendant pre- ■iit eliannid tA' •s.that liialtree We have heeii 'e (lio linildiiiy; there, and the dl^e ill)o\i' Ihe -ses on aeeonnl ill refer anon. shown to lie die Derenilant iiiu'iisions at Y ' narrow point ir less llooded The feint red oy indieate all several sec ions les correspond' .scale to which cetiohrt arc nil drawn to an er.larixed scale of eifj;ht feet lo an iiudi to rcnd'T lln' iletails more sen-ihlc. 'I'lii. in !;iicd pier or wharf at '•section" lliroUL'li point Z-liow, ilicpi.-ent |iosilion ol'llie u half of 1"*"'- al lliai point anil the iipri'^hi pier lichlnd il i- u hi. I ihe po>iti(ni of the wharf ill Ihe same point is supposed to have hceii at the luiie il was siirviweil \,y Ware in I>».".:1. The lines shaded hliK' have ^-allied i;r(iiiii(| tidiii the hridiic down lo the poiiil ^■. and to ha\( lost irronnd from \' down to O aid in the same proportion iiearly. Hi- liavinj;' ;;tiine(l i;-ronn(l fnini the hridee down to \ is pidlialilvattrilir.tahle to ihearch iiiKlerthe lirid:re ol' iIk^ tiinipike road liavili;; lieeii rclciilt »iiiee 17 '.'J nioi'c to the east unrd than il w;i, hef .re, .N'o particular cause can he a--iL:ih d f. .i his having |o>t i^roiind from N' l.i i ) ,.i i.. i ih.iii l he npeiMi ion i if natural c;niii.li as iIk attrition and dee'radiition of tliciivir li.mk^ i aii-ed liy the citrrent il-elf at -"lue p,,ii,t~ and the depo-il ol'allnviitni al oilier points. |t will heoli-ervcil that I he stone store on this plan app'-avs 1,1 have heeii partly Imiit iiilothe then we-tern chaiimd o|' the river, hut Met 'arllivV ciianncls may not have lieeii >ui'Ve\cd \villi iiiindi acciira.'y and they lieilij^ draun to a m r\ ininnle scale il is poxilile that it may lie a mere ilel'cct in the plan which ciiic s the ^nnie -nn-c to appear to have lieeii huill into the clianuel. It may he howeViU' that the clianiKd had ahi'.idy mo\'ei| lo the eastward ui'c lie -tone --tore had lieen liiiilt. The e;reat dill'erence lietween the positiiinsdf the prc-eiii channel aid that of 17'.'2, hetwceii V and () make it |iroli,ilile that lielween those two point- the I'laintiir has really lost miieh eroimd ; say ulioiit lill\' feet al () and ahoiil thirty fe. i ai ( '. (.i- r.iihiu' al midway hetweeti N' and (). .\ccordini; lo this plan then the I'laintilf's w hurl'. ■ .iiiiiol he c.ni-idcred an encroai htinuit hut iiilile (he eon- irary.— it uill '"■ dh-iuv.d that the \\liait' of 1 s.",J. ,uls complel. !\ a.ro-s .McCarthy's three chiiniieU and cldp- out on the opp.i-ile -i.le. The whai t' .\ l'> appears to partake some w li.it of the t;eneral directii'ii m|'\|,-i '.uihy^ . haniiel, ami niiudil to a certain extent he looked iipiiii as a proof of the chaiiiicl lia\iii'..; iioiii l> I i .V hceii more lo the eastward in former time- than it i- al prex nl. il 1101-1 not he ioi;:.illeii leitlhr that iiccor.liiiL;- to the title- the saw mill ,h('^vii on McCarlhy's plan and -iie on which it i- creeled I ehniLjed to the I'lainlilVs .Xntenrs in 17'.'-. and that ordim/ to the same titles lhe\ had a I'iiilil to any -aw mill tlie\ iii'jht eieel nn the same siLilit and lo the site il-elf ■• ,;' /'"'/""'■ riaii \o. i|' llii- report indieate- the relative p.i-ilion- df tl (dianiiels of I7'.'i' and 1M"1, hy \(hii h it appiars tiial the riaiiitilf throimli hi- an- teiirs had hcirnii to L'aiii L:'rouid from the hridu'c down to V, and to loose Ln'oiiid in alioiit the same piopoilion I'liUii ^ ddwn lo I ». |!v this plan al-o it i- cviijeiii that till' riaintiirs wharf iii-t.:id ef eiei-, ,,iehilii;' on th" idianncl is Mpeiated t'rolii il hy an a\-erat_'-c of ahwiit twenty feet. It i- inueli to he reerelled that there exists no plan of the premises of more reeinil date whcrewilh I'P compare tli(> sitiialioti of the iire.-eni wharves, mill hnildin^'s. ri.m No. I di,." repori iiiiiieatc- the relative iio-itions of the channel of IMt'i anl tlic pre-cni elianiicl, an i needs no further remarks llian tlio.-e already made with reirard to plan Nil. d. I'lau No. .'i of our report is a mere copy of No. I with llie addition of the lines if hi;;'ii water a- liny existed ii. iMIil. lly i.U'ciine' Id jvxlraii No. Ill .Xppeiidix C", it will he M'(Ui that .lohii i{accy l'",si|. iwiiii'-- for I'laiiiiill' hut ap[paii iitl\ with an ill humour ae'aiiisl him for lakiiii; some of the ^d.nes ,ii' hi- di-iillevy lo Mil his jilie i 'laintiH'.-) whaif witlu see i'Alract lit .\ppeiidix U, make- an a>serrioii which is erroneou- aid ah>nrd. He -ax> thai jnduiiiLr fnuii liouchetles plan ol l.s(i:' (the very plan filed hy him in >iippoit nl his lestiinotiy) the i'laiiitill"s w halt' eieidaelies iVniii the wooileli ^lorc lo ihe -idnc -tdre. — Now it i- evideiil from a mere ijlaiiie al plan No. -'i oi'oiir repori whereon that of iMiii i- trans- ferred, and laid ddvvii thai lli'-re is a -liuhl eiieroacliinenl at (' iiierely heyond the line cif hiu'li -pi'iiie; tides or heyiuid the lop ol' I he hank as ir was at that time and that from (' down loiiear U the I'laiiilill 's wharf is sever.il teel u ithin the top of the liaiik or liiiili tide line. So iiuicli lor such uiifoutuled asserliiuis as that. Tie: i'lainrttl's wiiarf al (> ellcfoaelies or projects as a-serlcd hy several witnesses alioiil I I I'eet lieyond llie line of liieli spriiii; lilies lint is still very f.ir from inlerferritiu' in any way with the ( liannel ol' the river as it was in l"iiil al ilii- moment, (iaiiriel (.irenier, one of the llefeii- daiit's witnesses al ■' I'lxtract No. s ol ,\pp,iidix (' coiiiinued " makes a mo>t iinfoiinded blaleinelil and ifihe iplidityiue- remark nnder lii> name in the liiarein he road, some idea \\ \r, '"•'>■ I"' "•l.niU'.i ol ihr iliil'.il-IUh.'f 1.1 lie illllll'illMl III lii.M ;l.ssiTlinlM. lie 1.11VH "7c «)i rlui'iit'i lioiil li }ilii.t .1,1 ,„;//„ „._Smi'1i nil iisscrtiiiM us tliis nm^t 1 .viiliiiiuMl. ulicii Ihc miuii lliiit iiiiikc^s it, is not iiM iiliol. Iiiit (Pii Iho iMiMirarv u ivs|M'i'talili' iiiiiii iM (ii'cnirr, mtiiis in he in i'vitv rcBtu'ct. U'l' tliiiik iM'tturoI'liiiinaii iiiiliiio tliaii In alli'iiipMn (iinl ji iicrjnry wlii'ii tlu'i-c 'luav liiivc lii'iMi not thr Ifast iiit.'iiliiiii on llid witiics-cs part to iMiininil u'nc." ami shall iMidcavoiir to r\|ilain uiiili'i- what circiiinstaiui's {ii'ciiicr iniiy liavo vicwcil tin- |iirini:<-.('» prc'vioiis to niakiiii;- an assortinn .-f tlic kiinl. When «■,■ ' hack ol'lhi' slonc store, it mn-t he .■oiit'es^cil that tlip I'lainlill 's whaii'lias an iiirly Inilyiin; out a|.peinvm-<.. nhi.h inii;hl alinosi Icii.l on., to miv that it wi'ivaii I'lui'oa.hiiK'iil : hill snp|.osi. il lollows ih,. nalniTl lun.l <>\ tin' \\\f\\ wliiil is to he sail..ppe(lil..wii troni the t.ip Iheiv,,!' i,. ihee.l-v oMhe ehann. I i.. i..u. ami that the hiL'h rnle.- ro>f on Ihi'haiik (wliieh of course lhe_\ mnst nalnralK ha\c .|.in. ami woiilil .l.islill if the saiil wharf wctv not theivi. \„u- .slippose (;r,.|ii,.r' >|,.ii!.l hav.' socii tin- premi-se^ at liie;li ti.le invvi.nis lo l,><.".ll lal whi.'h time ihc I'laintills wharf was hiiiltj w.iiilil n.it sii.h false appcai-cii.-c> hav.' ilccivcl him or any oiher wi|n.-s, (, 1,,, I,,,,} ^ccii the river nml..r ■.ii.'h .■ii'cnnistaiici's. It i- Irn.' (ir.iii,>r .Iocs I'di viv the uImiI' pn.ie. n l„.v.Mnl the line ot hiirh ti.lc hut im,. ih,. , hanm 1 ami ih.' .a. mis,, ah'.. v.. L'i\eii f.r liis cvi.K'ii.'c woiil.l fall 1. 1 111.' ,<;i-.>iiml as worllilcss iini.-ss u.. suppos.. thai hciim- an illil.'r.ii.. man, h.' may hav.' iisi'.l ih.' w.ir.l channel lor the whol.' Ii.'.l .ii' iji.' riv.'r fr..iii lie |..p ..f ih.- hank .m .>n.' si.le to the ^aiii.' ..ii Ihe otii.'r -i.h'. Amillcr ino^t .■xli'a..nlininv a^.rli.ni ami cspcciallv for ainan ofclii.Mlion. ami ii -iirv.'vor willi all is that mail.' I.\' ( l.^rahl Dnnl.'vic I'ls.p, anotln'rof ihc Ki'Lll- wiliic>>es (;,.e Kxlr.nt No, W .\pp,.nili.\' C . ..nlinn.'.i i who savs •• won' it n.)t for I'lainlitr's wliarfthi' iiv.r \\..nl.| Ih.w nciv 1.. ih.' ,.,iiil|.v\,,-t heliiml ■• ih.' wooih.n st.iro. I think then' is an cn.-roa.hnicnt hy I 'lainlill' for liflv Ic.'t np holiin.l •• lii" wooili'ii -toro '/.i;.(((yi ill;/ rl,,,.), /i.ir.r ,;.,il,l. „.,! j, is) .il t',.:,l „t' „-l,.irl' ii-:il,,.(l ,i; t/iiiti A.v •■ /,.„,/, " — At that rate all the wharvi'> in tic Lower Town wonl.l h.' I'm'ina.hments, ii's Mr. Hiinlevio's .■liain h.-arcr wonl.l .•.■riainly wel his h.iots if iie pass...! al.iiiLT the fool of most of Ihciii even at K)W ti.lc — When Mr.'Diinl.'vi.' -lali.l llnil ilth,' I'laintilf's wharf wcr.' n.il Ih.'i-i', the river woilhl ll.nv iicrc l.i th.' >..iii|,.w.-t, ii i. aMoni^hin.^ ii .li.| mil oi'iMir 1.. Iiim that if till' wharf were reino\-. '.I. llciv miL'hl h.' foiin.l -n, h a thiic,.- a- a hank hi'himl it, vvhi.-h if it als.) were reimivc.l in c.nijnmii.rti willi tic \y\r.\\l, mi-iil pr...liii'i. the .lie. i stale.l hythe leanicil (.ienth'inan. Till' lasi r.'inark w.' hav.' i.. mak.' as ;.. nn .'ncroa.lim.'iil ol'lh.' riaintill"> u harf is on what i-. a>scrl.'.| hy KtieniU' l,iini:.'vin, KMr.cl ,N,). Ill Appemlix I' onliniie.j. This witness states that l'laintiH"> wharf " . //i/",Vi ll' ,/ ].". /i.V,/,v ,/„„..■ /,/ ,„■;.',•. ,„•, /„,,»„// /,. n,iirhall n.,t he .piile so ih'iieal.' as ri';r„r.is LaiiLr.'vin ahoiit limjini;- an .'X.ii-e for u state- in. 'iit iih'.'a.ly pi'.iv.'.l t.> he li.lienl.ins ami lais... We >h;ill m.'i-.'lv >av that it appears Lan-win afl.'i- w.irkinir at the I'laiiilill' s wharf lor some liine was ..ii^te.l 'f..r -.nnethini: ho «''issii-| Id lo hav.' taken fntiii tic mill, am! hence his r.'Vciiircfiil asM'iiioiis. While writinir of the I'laintilf's wharf in M'.-li.ni wiih ..nr ivinarks '.n inir pLiii \... :>. it max h.' well to repeat what has alri'a.ly I n hinted at in a t'.'rm.r pai i ..f this r.'p..ii: i/,) tliiit the top of th.' natural hank is -till to he s...n in-i.h' ihc I'lainiitf s wharf iiml at a ilistaiu'i' of ahont nine Ici't from the !..• .■.m-i.l.'iv.l in the pr.'seni .■as,., Xl,,. Dcfemlanl slatcillo ns (,n the >ixtli of May of this y.'ar while siamliiiL' with him on his ^i.i,. .•f the river, at tic p.iiiit 1! thai even ifhis wharf A 1! w.'iean ci.croachm.'iil of aiiv kind it was not to he in any way lak.'ii inl.i .■on-i.leralioii as il ha. I h.i.'i Imili i'') years aifo." tliat is previous to the I'laintil!' h.'inj; in po-M>sion of the iiiill. A.-.-..r.liinr t.') that sta'icim'nt th.'i'cf.ir.' iiratnitimsly ma.h- hy ilc 1 icf.ielaiil any cicroa.'hiii.'nl al :1m- -l.iiio stor.', is iioi f,,r a inoni.'iil t.i he coiisi.ler.il. ri.ui N'... 7 .'I. air i. 'port ha- aliva.ly h.'cii allii.lc.i t.i in our answ.'r t.i paragraph .">, ci.ia-.' Ii i.l iiil.'il.ii'iil.iy, ami -h.'Ws as 1- Her.' sialci ami as i! pnrp..rts to d.) tlie" appear- an.'.: .if Ih.' riv.'r dnrinir an onlinary hi-h ti.lc. This plan in e.niiie.'ti.in with the seeti.iiis on I'lan N... I whi.'h imli.al.' Ilc.l.'pth of w.ilcr .liiriiiL;- lii^di Ihl.'s eovcrimr the hcacli (M- l.iw S-rouiid n.iw parily en. I..-..! hv ih.' I >.fen.|aiit' wharf of 1«.",-J will furnish a rather "ral.hi.' illn-lrati.in of Ih,' way in whi.-h Ihe iiavic-ali.ni oflhe river i- imi,..,l,',| a.i ass.'rtod" I'ly w) in.iiiv wilnoss.'^ c.xtracis from whose .'vi.lem'.- ai.' ^iv.'ii in appcmli.v K. ir> wiivi ".A' iiiis tijili hiiiil 1 1 /iln.i iniikrs it, 18 not I'vi'i'v rcHpect. iiTi' luiiy rmve I fijcli'avour tij !'•* |il'rvioU« to iilc, liildvv tlio issi'il tliiit tlie Irii'l line to Biiv a' riviT, what nly. ( Jiviiiur'H !i>I.M'i(iiT way. , 111' .>ti.") (Jiijry inii 111' ri'liiiilil- l"». mill that l"\\. :iiiil that >Mi mill woiilil llllVI' M'l'll tll(( liiirf was liiiilt) 1 li;ii| sci'ii till- iI'djiM Is licyiiliil I' lii-i rviik'lii-f ti'iiilc man, lie I' llii' liaiik on I anil csin'cially lliiiili'vic Ks(|., ic'il) «li(> sayj llUl-t l)cllilll| '■'■{ ii|i lii'liiinl W /(■.//-„,/ /„v liiiirnu, as Mr. ■ I'llnl of IMIiSt vliarl'uci'i' lint I oiTur til liiiii Ilk lii'liiiiil it, IWr ll 111'. I - \v liarf i-i nil Tliis witiK'Ss i.V 'r niiirillll." '■ liir a state- lilt it ii|i|ii'ars -miK'tliiiiir lio liiiiM. W'liili' Vn. .'), it may ■"It : l'() tliiit <:ii'l' ami at a wliirli k'aviiijj ('.\|ilaim'il ill illiof (if tlllTf |Hii-|Mirts til (1(1, lines of l~U2. 1 lliut ri'tiioli' iwevcr an iii- 1!1 I'llM-. 'I'llC Ml (HI liis side (if any kind ii's ajxd, tliat is liat statement me, is lint tiir |iani,i;rii|ili .i, > the a|i|ieai-- le stH'ticiris iMi lieai'li or low iMtlirr j;raphie sserlod by tio liero Aiisinr 1,1 ./.iii.si Xr II ,,/• Iiilul'icitl'irj/ Tlie I'A|ierts as it is stated at tlie lie''] ,,„ ,, , , ■ . iMiiiim-.il till, repiirt did emniiiv will, all thai is I..O lU ed to hoduiK. |,revi(i„sl(i |iin, ..eduiir. ll remains however to make Mime remarks |..ieKa,,i,ete ,el( l,ythel.X|,erlsatMr. liaillarpV, „,|i„, „„ ,„.. .ulijeel of the to i- W,^ I'l " I'l'" "V' l":;)-'""^''.'»"- "Itvi'the ereeiioM (if tj,.. Delendanls's uliarldf is.-.'j tl a I, V 'I';' :: I'l '"" "■'' ir'V'.^'''-l'""l'l 'l-.v .vad over the ..vide,,,.,, taken l.v the! x per.: hattiies aipareMllvex.iiede,ltli,.irp,iwe,.sl,y takin.;'so„u,. evideneo i-a.her ioVei-n to the ",""''" "•.';"•!' the [nte,;loe„lo,-yai,lliorisedlli,.,n to aihliiee evide,,,.... The H , .,U ,.aii ,. Iv ; ?' ';;' " ",r '!"!--;I.K-.to avoid it. I, will he mahist I in emmeetio, vi I, t e' s . Mi^.iothe null wheel.. hat Hat any time p,..vhins t„ ,|„. u-|,a,-f of 1,«.-,- iha, wheel ha,. \.t(,|u,ih iej:a,vlto.heh,;.'h.„h.-;suel, a cii-eMmMan.'.. w.iiild of eo,i,se have In he ^"\ ' ■-"'-■■'••'■^>'io,i ,„ ea!ei,lali,,4 the diireren,.,. i„ (h,. lim,. of s,„,,,,a.r„ pi^evidu and snl.se,p„ml ,o ,|,e wharf of ISn:: m„l he ,1,,. „..,.,.,,i,v .„• the ipieMio, J , 7 to he i nes ! "n .liosepon„s. |, will aUo h.. ,.,,n,.,.d,.,| ,ha, ,f in to,.,,,,;,-' .inies i,' was , n'tom-UT lo il i, lln. Ilnw U~llal I' ... ...1 .111 . . ' '' '" i"iiin I iiiin-> was r >u»ni;irv in M.k the wheel ev,. ,er „ was s ,..,.,vd to a ivrtaia d-p.h. and if 1, i, m„ m'w I'Mial Olio visiirh a ciivnmslan.e dim, Id lie taken into eon,l,U.ratio„ in eimipulin- I liMir,,,,.. asse,te,lt,iex„, inihe pre„.ii, s.npp,,..,, „f |l,e mill-wheel as eompa,, ,1 will, iw ~ln,,,,a..v ..yv,o,,s.otl,ewha,;.ons.^-aiidlie a^ain ,he neeesM.y of ,lL ,,i.es,ions „i, ,!,' C ■ ,T ""• ^ 'l'^"-al!ve s.oppi,-,. nf ,h,. tuo , ,,,„ds l,.,n,v and ai.ertlie wharf nl Is.-,j. U was ,lii!iei,|, tn'dn so wi , taki,,.^ in.n oiM. Km ..,o„ tne ,-ela.,ye ..lUs,. nf ,„.ii s.nppa.-,.. For in>.anee if a witness „f hi^iwii '"•" ' ""■"""^■'■' ^\" '.'I"' stoppa^r,. nicmioned any wliai'f as heini; the eaii-e .lieivof i became ,i..eessa,-.v to ask him wha. wharf an,l if li,. aiisweivd •■ A ,,h.^ .,,.; tZrJl!- '.V„V,'' m, exp|.,.ss,„„ vvhleh ..(■ei„.s s,.v„,.,l ,1„„,. i„ ,|„. evidence) it was still ne.'essarv so We .hnn.'hl toaMv,.,am pr,.eis,.|y wlii,.|i wharf , lie witness mean.. If H,,. witnes,w,.n, t.,t,. .- /, ,;;,',:'; .■■",■• A ,./, ,../. /.,..■. „la,l„„, <.„:/,. I ./. /;/.•• ii,|„.„ |,„,,„ae m.,es-a,-v to a-l. ••■.,„, / .1.,..,/- and sn„ „ u,„,l w,. we,v ,n ivalify lead awav fmm the pni,„ m isM.e. \Ve ...iisider -d it li-di. "in How thepm-tiesioask any ,p,estmns as .„ nl,s,r,„,,„„. ,„ ,|„, „,„,|,i,„.. „, „„. ,„-,|| ^ , '';!"^ ■"iy,p„.st, ear,,,- diive.ly „„ ihal s.n,,,,,..,. The |.,.|e„dant e,. 'r n i\ stones hell,,,,! the sHilie stol'e and the point I' etc. The riaintiirvel-i p,-nperly olijeeled, a, he had a re^l,, m dn. tn -nin.-intn -.,,1, ueiUcr ns there was ,„. k,,,,.,,., ,vli,.n il,e Kiep.ete wnnld end if snch a Jonr^. wue ■,■,! d ' , hsol,|,,,.,,nnsw,lll,e In.ind. slamdinthe ma,-in in manv palN „f i|„. .vi,|,,J '-,' nam 1, s Kvp,.,., ,ho,,.h,. t wni.ld ,inr he ai-lin^ will, that impartialilv o he -l , , .d ,. , eMi.'nihM,i:,i,i,a,m.dtlielNa,m,ll >,,l,ie,.,inns,n any ,p,es,i!„is as Vn .,. Jl„.L,| , 1 t Yl -ll' '■'|'^";'-'"i > hiv.nn., ,,f,|.,. mil ,„,. ,„„, Ki,„.a.ioii ..i- ,i„. ,,.„m I' hi|i 111,1. have elie,,,.da,,Mu.r-nnpaland,|etn, he s;,i,|l.|,i,,,i,nmd fnr.hat .vasai mot (■ . uTilvT''" ''•'"";' r''-":''- '" 'l"\"M""'-'.sso,.aise,l, The ,lllli,.,il,;,.s n 1 It ; K- , V\ 'V'''''''''"''''";^ .viii..„.i.,.ivd Iha, ,l„. Oefandant hin.s,.||. a„d w ,,.^.: :, ;;'^v, ''r*'''','^' ""•,"""•' -'"ij-'lul l,,, Kn.pmte ami exan.ined ,1„ Mill ,s,.s, „n as a 1 expei't woiil,, hav,. ,|n,.,.. Ii,i, MS lawvor nvnei'alU ,lo,.,,,hat is „„ ,.,,.,.,■ P;'!n lav,i,.dile.l,.|i,.sv,ew,ifth(.m,es,ioiiandi.nfav,,,.alih..,itha.,ifi;is,-,pp,,,c t 1,. \ .■■, ■- r' ^"'.''"■■'•'■;'' ^'■— .1""->1^'IH.,| hy M,-. liaillarire " wlii,ii the 1). -mla,. always eaased , , |,, „i-e,„,|, when M,.. liailla,-,-. exa„>i.,e,l his witimsse. lu whieh he took e.-i.-e „nl lo have i,is,.riod when he examined the I'laiiititl's wi.nesses. The IX.f,.i„lant had p,-evi„i|s|y sel fiHh as the p,-ineiple ,,t a.tin,, nf ,u, ixpe,'! iwimh „r .ou,>ethoKx|,e,-ts„(.,vwelawa,-e,.f, thatanl.:xpe.-,u,!likealawver was „n ,,, ,,se :h:,:,Cm:''':'''l''''''^''^"'^^ ''''''■• -'-'l — '|ncs.innin^ae,.o..din^,n.lil'l..i:r,m "."In, an,,... lli,- ..xanimin,. ,.l a u,„„-- i„ a way to niake him omlradiet his evi- ■ in.l,i..|, iMi! was..iippns,.,|,,iask any ami all ,p„.sii,i,„ ,u.,.(.ssa,-v to ai'rive at the tli.and ,l.:„ l,.,,,^ a,lmi.„.d. whi,. ' ,..„i,.,e was li^,.,.,,,! to it was unml,.:sarl t.i La' e im .xpe-M,,n •■,r,.-s , ..„i„,,„.d ' ,.ni,.r,.,| m ||„. evidem'e. The nil,. lii,-,ui..'l,n,it th,. ■m,'^...^ lie 'T "■•'^"1"".''' ""■ """,.ss..s „.stead oflhe DeHmdant himself 'uioht not e n a . '; ;; hT'''l-V'' ■'■';"'l"e,tio,iiii^tli,. |-|ainlilfs witnesses. The principle ll ,.| V, ''"• ".';I'''"I^',"V'' ah.iv.. -.,a!,.,l, ,f n-n,„|, shonhl hav,. Iieen ,„a,l,. o appiv V, rsw ; ^■"'^;;^''''; ' I'vMr. \\ailace was Icl^ ci, in !,i, ,.xa,iii,iatio,i of the I'is' h^„, ■ ^.^''.\""i"l""l'ynelei„lanfs r,.,p„.sl those wo,.,|s t,i be ente,v,l ? s . I . m.e.l a,i,l emmen lawyer an,| a ,leep man. with tluent ami polished spoeeh. nav ; .1, el,, ,enee:i-w,iys,-eady,,ipe,-.s,m,lo one of the traih of his aiserlions. \Vhv the. l^ei^'i 't ''!''r '"'"' '.'^'"'1 ;^^-^-:l •» -"'-k l>"th waysv 11, „„„t have i, a ■' "'"■, ,^l;';"'"'V^'^'l"'i'"M'eal,.yis of liuie or no importance ue em.eeive • Inn i • W :,■.,■ p"'''",~!>'"^, l^'vonihh. to him to nuike it ap,,ear to the llono.'able (■on,T tliul .Ml. l..ul,a,,i:el,a.laet,.diiitlie en.piete iiol a. an Kxp,.,., nn^dit tn a,'!, hut .'atlier as u |;nvv>'i a^Uiii- ii.Mir l.ui ..:,.■ -i.l.'l .in.-li.u,-. Ifi M ■, r.iillarL."' Ill' i,,.._,.4 i,i ,n-,'i.iiiii ill I hut r.il'. Vi'lV lill- IV"!!! I y III III 11" «„v , .■ilniii. i""ii"l '''V .'"''V ,„ i,, , L, ;, ,, 1„,1 111- Ivr.iiJ.. ,,,,:,,,,,,„,, I,,. lj,,.,,«.....™v^^^^^ i, ,,. ;i::s;;srr;;;;;:Ts:i;;;;;:'«;:';v/,-;^;: :;:-;;? ,- - ,-; -;!r;j;;;;;;::™:s::.^;z::r' ■b, r;: 5 ; :V,,n^^^ ..„i.r>. n.ak. l.i. wUik-... Mpi.sir to lia >• v'lu. l i. . . ' , :i:i;:;;;;:;;:V';;::i;;;'":r:s:j;;,l"n;:T,:l:::':r; ."■■«:- -^^^ 1 ■!;' S. -u ni,, i,„,,,,|,,i i;-;;;;- ;;;;■■;■;;;:;; :;;r; ;;:";; ;■;,,,^';;;;,;!:;'k,,■|.' "I W>. l„.lTrivi-.l il V.T.VllialU.M ti'U.lyiirv nil lla. IM.im.MII I, leu.lcMirv iihraclv ulliiiU-il t.> ill tlii- i'<'l Kalv ill lii> I'viili'iiri' lii'l'mv ii' >ji'ilt..i„. ,l..ic. will''!! Kalv ill in- I'VMlrll.M' iM'InlV II- >Ji.iM ', , , , l l„ ,1,,. ,,.,,,,1, ,val Ikmii." ,.M,;v..i.,„ tho IVt.iiilaiit imii...liat.l.v tiaii-laf . nr i,.|.la. ..I u "•'"'. „.„.-, ' ,, „„ ' •„ nut II ll ill I'll nt sinUirLrlril in l.y a -iiiiilai' |in lint sinuiriri.'il :ii I'X a MiiNi.u I'M". -- ... ;ii:::;*i:-,;:"^;:;;i":::;:i^:?'i.'";;.^-S: > .li.l ,„„ avail liiii,-.'ir.'V.-. pt III a V.',. l.u niMaiu-,'^ . 1 1, . m - ^^^. ^^_^^ ili.l -..lia.lt.) li.M'li. '.'!<. 'lU'i'iilii „iullv ,m a."'..uiit ..fa ralli.T naliu'al U'li'l.'ii.'v ..n tlu' I'ai-l nl oj.,' ,li,l...l,a.lt..ll.M'll.'.'l<.;.l.'' iniiiMan.y.. |, . |,1„. I ...iVii'l'llit ili. .-.■ thrnl.-.illl ill.' |';x|..'i't'^ w.'ii' iH'.'M'iit at th.' null l"i' tin' I'liU'"-' "1 iimkih.- i.jlli.' -t..|'l.a".' ..rill.' mill iluriiii-'tliat .lay. Ti '.w-i iu,.'i„i.,,i "i-ti," iM.n.i-. •;;, •j;!;'::;::: ;;-,;;:: i::';;':.. n;,',;;;,,';:;;' i" .,,,,,otn.U..rini«anantal,l.'.u.an-l.a.ll.,'.'iM'iili ^Y•1 ' ' • ' . ■ ■- ,■ „„„ ,„ ,..i,U.a,l 11. ami n.ak,' .iiatt.'.- •'l!!"-,, "';■.,; ,,. 1' lia' Li'l^'ialai.t. uill l.l„i,niHMav,.i'. llK'-; a>M'i'li,'ii. -lioMii tl,.,v ''_,„. ,-„.,,, x„„ ,;,. ,i , ^'i">:.' •"•-■:' ;;:",!'>■ ^'.i^;!'!:rx. t ::::-::::\::::l ;. -r.-^.' ^ ^^ . -" - i:, .if Aj.ii.'ii'lix .'rii.iu.^li lil.lll' I' a|>|..':ll> t .1 1..' ,.,,....,.,. ;■ , . ,. ,.. 1 .■.• ,,,,,,„',,./. •"■■■ l< /<./"''//./."/■,■■ tlii'ii auaiii l„r-.,tl.'n that la' a.liiiil- liiiii-'.'ll. li.' i- '" "" . , .|| , , ,-,„.,_.,;,U'„ ,„ ,iv,'. ill .,11.' ,.f.i,,. i>'i-'i^"" ^'"":r■ -.",';'.:l'::;'-':,.!;:::„::;;i "-,.; uk. naiutiif. wiiai-r aii.l tli..iiL;li la-t 11 .1 .1,., .,i'!,. ..V 'ill.,-.' wli" ma. I.' th" il.li.'iil.m- >lat.'iii.'iit a- t • • ' m. : 1, 1 V :.'t iilt., tl h.ian.'l. a tlii,:, I'm-a f h-, utt.i'lv la^.o an, ^-;:V:";;- u, M'aviK'y ,,i.v ,..'n.a,.u, .,,i hi- -;;;;;;:;':;;;;;;.,,::;;,.:i; ■';,:■ ;'\,:: 'm!:;.;; : ;:h:: a/;;,'.' sullio'U.-lK'whowliis .'vi.l.' . -,.. I ^^ , ' W I |..'i;.,i,lant. th,. Kxtrat N„. P tin,,' I,.' -av.' hi- c'vi.h'm-.' u,ik..t l,\ i . ,i.i> Tin . .■vi.h'ii.-.' A,,,„.n.lix r lr.,m Uitiu'.--- -lawi-" ;;,';;:":,.-;!",;:. ,' ,..:" ,;l,-ahn',l as i-.-la„ii^ ;:;-!;,:;i-n: 'i-r ,;i:f 1^^^^^ !:;-;i:'^.::,-,:;a:;;l''Ma;.l':::a::^^^^ 'v h, ■,ii-.'U--in,l.l.iil th,' I'l.t ,,rtl..' -at,.- having at tin' tlin,' ",'"'"; 'ni . .'i I, ' 'n,,i-'htl, l),'l-,ii.l.int.uiMa--.-a,,.ay tliatth^^ ^' ff/ ,/ .'■u.,.n'tl,:''.' lUiav,!,,.--,','! ihalil ua-n- -nil th.nj^. «.,...>' jjatc was Ir i : mC ,,1U X'l.; th.'tim;.w..w.„, ,,..|,.w th-mill. n. n ,s i, ilonioil in an, way I'aiM.l ui|,i,,ul>t, .11; ah.' i: ili-i'l;uiii III vi'iy I'ui Ifiii Ic li riiiili-iirv he D.'I'i'ImI:!!!! ||l> |)('l'i'lllM'cillllv jiiiniiM'. Niiw Uilll till' l*i- Inwii /-■- ll"ll inr uiillM I'l' ■,■ (if llU'll I'l' l;ir, mill riiH- I ;i-i lii'^ I'Wii nil ilniu' : liiit lllli'llrc'l:ntll'll I'liiiiititl"^ wliiirf mill i;r(iiiiiilK'>>. iM ,'/'(• '.-,'.7.. " will ii'liii wild 111 till' Kxini'l N". I''' I. Tlii . ,'\i.|i'iii'i' ,|, iTil ii-; i-.'Iiiiiiii;- vh 1,1-1 1111.1 111.' 'Iio ;i--' rli'iii- III' liV ll,..-i' III' 111.' , III, IT .ll'- Wi' nt tlic tiiim I'i'i'ii ,'l iiriiiliii'i'il ii|"iii iiiilllu' dpi'iiiiVL' "f IS •• Inflll.-nil/l /i/k- ^^.llln' u'liU' "US iiiiil ill liny way liy tlio I'lrtiiititl'tliii I'lfi'i't pniiliii'i'il Iwiiiir llial nt ii "/i.Wi iifml.-, il'mn" as sotiin nf tin- \\ilni's-ii'-( Hiiy. It I'.UHi'il 11 Hiiiiill strt'iiiii (if wiili'i', iiliiiiil llii'iM' iiii-|ii"4 ill ilciitli, to How ovor tliii iri', tlii'ti ill till' cliuniicl mill liii'l im |icr.'('|ilili|i. I'llirt in iiii!,'iiii'iiliii!,' tin' llii'ii ili'lMli , if not lU'olmlili' llmt in tlii'ii' zi'iil liir iii-' cuii-n', tlu'i'i' may liavii Ihtii an i.li'ii ofiiiiiri'iivatiiii; iimtfi's on tliiil ilay, liy snim'tliiiiLC of a trick, wliirli Imw. vrr. if inli'mli'il ii-i such la ti ■lament wo lliinU not at all liorni" out) jiroiliiccil no I'c-ult w.uih iiicntioiiiiii.r. 'I'lui Idiiniralilc .IiiiIl,'c,s will fcniarlv Ihiil (ircnicr liiiiHcIf saV'), Ih.it iil the tiiuu the ..'atc-i wcro raiii'd. tlujro wiin riix inclics i|i'i'|i of water |ia-iiii;; over tliciii, ami I'lii'tlicr on, lliiit /' iciy' yi.ci .*'/'// A. iijkii. lln ./,il,'M. Mareoux says ihal hail tli" irales rcmaiiicil cIhm'iI. his laiiil Woiilil Imvo lieeii lliioileil, 11 circiimstaiiee which would liavercnilcieil ihe I'laintlir liahle In pay iliinuiires to Marciiiix for any harm ilone liy lliewiiler, In coii'iiliiii'iitinii of our iis-ertion us to the hetenihuil's wish to make it ii|ipi'ar, ihal the mill may have heeii on some occasions purposely sliippeil liy the I'laiiililf or liy hi- men. to I'aiisi. uppcareiici's to he in liis favour, we take the hlierty to retur to a ipu'ulion hy the lleliiiilaiit, in the examiiiutioii of Kilwanl llemlerson. AVe iieeil not say any thiiii; more on this suliject, than, that on every occasion that we oliserveil the sloppuixe nl tic mill, we timk ..riioil eare not to ;;i) hy hoar siiy hut measured the water ourselves tliiiii on ti.euhei'l, so llmt there iniilil he reasoniilile doul'it at the conclusions wu arrived at. It is hiie iiice-sary to alhnle to a protest hy the Ilelciulant iiv'ainsl .\lr. Stavely for trointc out to llie mill to iinike ohsci'vations iiimeeiin'ipanii'd hy the otiii'r Kxiierts and in the aliseiice ofilii' parties. — 1| is only icipii-iie to say tliiil the I'lspert- wereaiid are still of opinion that eii' h and every one ot' il i separately or eoiijoiiiliy had 11 peril ct lilii'i'ty to i{o out to the luiil mi ili.ir nun a.'i miiil to inform ihemsclve- on any particular point and Iherchy lulp to maki' up their minds iiiid eolne to a judicious eon- elusion on the points at issue. Alter hiiviuir answered, to the liest of our i'a|iaeity every, one of the separate ipiestions, pariiLrraphs and clauses of the Interlocutory, mid notwilhsiaiidiiiu'' the l.'iii;lli thi- report lias alreii'ly attained, il is still necessary to oiler several remarks corrohoraiinn' or in anv way atreiliii:; the eoiicliisions we have come to on the niMiieroin ipieslions. v.e have hail the honor to answer as contained in the said lnterloiiii.ii\ . \\'.. have thiiughl il lit to corrohorate our opinions as much as |iii-silile hy Ihe a-sertion- olthc uitnesses cxaiiiiiied in this ease. To have referred in each ieslaiice to Ihe particular pii'^e or [uiices, wherein WeU' to he found any rei|uired asserliou. Would have heeii an almost endless iiialter illld verv unsa- tisfactory lolhe llonoi'ahle .li|i|ec-oii iiccoiiiit oflheii' haviiijr to seek out in eilcli ease the |iarlicular evideiii'i' referred to. We have, therefore, our-elves in miiiii; over the evidence selected, and elassilied the whole I't'lhe evidence eoiitaiiicd ill the voluminous reeord. W't; have arramred it under the sexcral head-, iillectiuir the many points at issue as contained in the ilecliiration " Kxception" and Interloculory .ludLrmenl, and have condensed and liroiii,'lit ihe whole toijethi'r in the form of .Appendices A to li inclusively annexed to our report. We have also ill the two last appendices n'i\eu niiscellaneous extiai-t's Irom evidence, titles and iiiithors, etc.— Ill 11 word we have wished to present u report coiiiplele in itself and , .'coiii- lianied hy a tlioroiii;li synopsis of Ihe whole record to save Ihe Ih rahle .liidees, the trouhle and time of referring; in any way lo ihe -aid record. N'nw as to Ihe eom[iiisitioii of nianv of the extracts it in neeessaiy to say that a iihrase or paruLrraiili luis ofienln'en made mi ofsuveriil jihrases or parairraphs of the witnesses evidence. For exaliij'le when a witness slates his liaviuicohserveii any parliciilar occurrence, williout at the same time, suyinj^ when, and where he made his ohservation and when in a siihseipieiit part of his evidence ho is iiiiide to eomiileto his pri'vioiis statement hy -ayini; when and where. The whole is put together in the extract in away to make aeomplcte mid compiehensihle statement. J [ad wo acted otlier- wis(> the appendices must have atlaiiicd lo at I'.'iist twice their lu'eseiit dimensions. Also when 11 witness inentions, '• the Itefeinlants wharf" ir " thewliarf of l>s.'):i,"or '• the wharf that crosses the river" '-or the wharf that cuts oil' the easlern ehaniiel," and when there 0.111 lie no reasiinahle doiilil as to llie witnesses memiinir, we have in I'verv ease trmislated the witnesses words hy " the wharf liiiilt hy the j) 'feiiiiaut in IS'i:; ' or"simiily the wharf of IfS.')-.'." for had we donoolherwiso the lloiu rahle .liulges in rcferiiiL; lo the evidonce, miiiht not have always undersl.iod what |iarlieularwliiirt the witness meant. We lia\e replaced" also the letters (1 C! used hy many witnesses in their evideiioo hy the letters X V which on Ware'splaii (I'hiintill's oxhihit \| are placed oxaclly at the saiiiu points. So thai most of the expressions ; as to there ever haviiijr heeii a ohaniiel hetween C and C we havo translated hy eipiivalent expressions as to the existence of ii chiinnel hetween .\ mid V that the learned . I ud.LTOs may not suppose that diirerent points mi the plan or jrrouiid are iiiomil when ill reality tho soli' same poiuls aie ncmit in every ca-e. Opposite all the extracts we have taken eare to cuter in the margin the (|iialilViiii;- st.atementiuiide by the witiu'ssos themselves or other slatemeiits known to ourselves to he true, tondiiig tn ati'oct in any way the veiacily of Ihe witness's assertions ; such for instauco as the witness being at tho time of iriving liii< ovidoneo in the employ of the party for whom lie i- '.'H ihu' ■ V I'l' I" ■ "1 "I ll> III; III II li"il-r lii'lull'^'illi,' In lliill pldlV nl i>l liH llcilll{ nil llll'l tcriM-' uilli lli.il I'lirly or \i\-. iuIvi'IniiI'v iiimI i-o lorlli. \Vi' now |ii' llii' ••I'ViTiil AplM'iiillc'cN iimpcvcd to tlii'* i'i'|H)i'l.- -'I'lii' s_viio|i>i-< lit till' cikI (if cncli ,\]'iit'iiilix H II r*|ii( ii-i (liiiiiiilv/.iilidii of itrti'll'. 'I'lio "VMoii-is to A|i|ii'iiilix A lit tir«t xiirlil hIiowm a iiillicr toimiihilili' iirniv of witm'HHi-< ;n,';iili«t Ilir I'xi^ti'lici' III iili\ tinio of ii Imi'lli i-u^l iliiiiilU'l. 'I'lir o|i|mi- iom niiilis, liovvfVi'l' iiri' loiiJ-iilcnilily tliiiiiu'ii liy ^liikiin; out tlio-i' wlio only I'liy tliiit I'loni pn "in ii|'|"ariini't's tlicii' iii'Vcf wiif II rliiinnol lictwi'i'ii \ mill V. Tliry n'lVf no oiiinion in tlii'\ >v> re iml n-ikfil to do Hit, if llicii' limy liiivc Im'cii ii rliiinncl iiliovc X, .loscpli i'iciu'd is |iiit down in tlu' Hyiio|wi-i 11?* otic of lliosi' wild i* ii'jriiinst tin' oNi^tiini' of a foiimi- iliiinind : and yd in lii^ viTv t'vidi'iici' tluTi" o I'lir-i an ixi'ii'Mxioii wliiidi would imply mhih' ^ll^ll tliiiiL''. He niiyn. •' // 1/ tirail iihi juH/iili' rii)/i rint'i' iiiiiiiiliU'iiil /iiir Ii' ijiiiii ilii lli'l'imldir," Wlnii' llnTi' in an islund W'l! I'Ollci'ivi' llu'lV liilist also 111' Milllinnrl on liotli side-*. Mlilirii'C Miiliolix tlloiii;|i III! Iic;;iiis liv fitiiliiiL' tln'ic iu'V( 1' wii'< anotlicf clianni'l, is put iinioni; tlic wilncri.-n'* fop on iircoiiiit nf hi?* cxpfi'ssioii tliiil " l>iiiis Ii 1 i/i'u.iMi,t iifiij', I'niii fi'juiiiil jiiiili'iil 1 1 141 sii'il iiii.t fi niiir.i ill' III ri'rii'n," liirnii-'i' it i?i not Hoiii:lit to cstiiMi-h in liivur of tin- I'liiiiiliU' lliiit tlii'i'c llll^ii>t >onn' low iri'oinid over wliidi fiolnl whUt iimmI to llow. Tliotiiiis (irciru'i- is iiUo cliis-i'il iinioni; tlir \vitni"i-'iM for or iicvMiinl of the i'Xpri"liin'i'-> niidcr wliiili tln'y iniiy liuvc vicwod tin' pri'iiiisi'-i. it Ihh iilr^'iidy lici'ii >iiid lliiit in wintiTiiiid -niiiiin'r lln'ii" wii- ;;ciii'nilly only i'iioiii;|i water for the mill (nor cmild llii'i'i! ill tliis rc-'piTt luiM' hiTii any diU'c'riii'i' ]iri'vioiis to is;.:.'! whidi of roiir^i' H cnilil liiivi' all parsed out tlinnnrh tin- mill-iiii'o and down tin' pri'.-cnt clianiicl niid at all f^iuli linii's till' lit'd of tin' N. !']. rliiiiinci would liiivc Iktii (■oinpariilivi'ly dry. It i« proliiilili' lliat no water oxei^pt frohet water (mid a fii-liel is not a lliiiiL' of freipient oeelirem el passed tlll'iMlirll tlie supposed .V. I'], eliilllliel lit lea>l siiiee a iiiimlier of \ eai'H pii-t, and only to ihosi- who had seen the river under .siieh eiii'Min^lnnees, would there have iippeiired to he 11 ehiiniiel, as at all o'.lnM' limes it liiiist hiivi' heeii dry frroiiiid. 'i'lie Defen- iliinl appealeil In lis to fi el ipiite L'hirioiis iihoiit the evideiiee of .John l'"eri;Msoii, who thoiiuh he eaine to Canada, only in l.H.'iJ. that is two years after the whiirf wiis hiiilt speaks of the X. ]■]. idiannel whleh ol' eoiirse ho never eoiild have seen ii.s he hinisi'lf admits, as haviiiir heeii cut oU' hy the Del'endaiit's wliio'f of H'li. 'I'lie Di'feiidant theieiii openly .slali'd in presenile ot' the Mxpert.s, that it wii- his avowed intention to [irove. KeriTiison to he a //'. )' iliiil a /I' <;,'"i( r and to do the Mime of iiio>l of tlu' I'liiiiitilf's witnesses. This is so Irile thai a suit has lately heeii instituted hy {•'eriril'on iiL'iiinst the Uefeiidiint for tin' ex- pres-ii.iis he made iiseof. Now we are not at all dispos.Ml to think so had of liiiniiiii nature as we have already said, as to think a iiiiin eapahle iindiT all eireiinistunees, of tellint;- a wilful lie, — We have endeavoured loalisolve (ii'i'iiirr oi f ihi' Defendant's witnesses from liiivinir asserted a wiltiil ah.-iirdity and l:i!-eh I, and will now do so for (>iie of the riiiintilf's witnesses. We have already .said that theri'iire natiii-al traees tlioUi;li .sliuht ones ol' the tornier existeiiee of a X, K. elianml, and who knows hut those triiees niiiv have a|ipi'ai'ed nineli nioie jflaiinirto Keriruson, than they dir>-J, to have cut otf a channel which he never saw. Ill (loint of fad hotli men made their a—.'rtions from olisiu'vatioiis of the locality lis it now stands. If one of them therefore was u Ijnr the other must he so (acconliii'/ to Ihe Defendant's showinir :i hut we had rather he more eharitahic and sav that neither of them deserve to he called hy sui-li a name, in rci^ard to j\|ipendi\ I! it is only rc ill' III rii'ii'ri," wiiliitrly wiw u itllW. TIlOlllllM ii< " ill rriri'i- lis I'nilly filU'lllviiii; (•liiiniii'l owiiiix ri'iiiiT-i. It Inn li wiitiT for tlic iN-VJi wlii.li (if r|illlllli-l niid III vi'lv (liy. It i« iiiL' of fr('(|iii'iit iiiiilicr of M-arr* iiiilil there hiivi! il._ Till) D.ffii- l"''.'ri;iH()ii, will I liis liiiilt >|i(':ik^ ll-icif lllllllitH, IIS I'iciiiioii opciily . Ki'i'irnsoii In IlL'SSC'S. Tills is limit for the cN- f liniiiiiii luttiii'c CCS, of ti'lliiii;- 11 i witlicssi's iVciiii for one of the Miirli ^liirlii ones Iriiee.s iiiiiy have le liliiile-eiirlli iit iiH it dill when to Liinie's ami V), liiiiy he not vatioti of the lo- ci there. Alas iiilant ill this -sloii t'roiii the |iur|ios(j as he witnesses. The liaii to ask him ' tail-race point re at lilierty to N'o. 7 .Vppemlix channel " ami hetore him, nilil 1 never seen any iiiinel which he •rvalions of the tier must lie so lie ainl say that ilix I! it is only ix.'i:^, is an eii- iml lieyomi the vnopsis that till' int contniilicti'il ly tlies to prove lf> hy his wilnesses, that his wliart does not eiieroadi lic_\om| the natural hunk, not of iho river, hnl ol the i-lami, low !,'roiiiiil or In ;nh in the river. This .Vppeiidiv may he eotisidered tlieie|',,re as |iroviiijf two diUcrenl pointy 1st.— That the wharf of IH.'.J (|i„.s not eiieroi'cl Iliii iireseiit eliaiiiiel. ;.'iii|. 'I'liiit it does eiieriuieh on the l-cal heil of the river, as thai hed has heeii -iiiee iHilii and earli( r tlian that. We need oiler no further remarkson appendix (', than has hceii done in tiio hodv of the Kepurl hy which we hiive tiiilv deiiioii.lrateil that the I'laintitr's wharf in no way eiicroaelies on lhi. '■'i" lof the river, as It is now or has ever heen hefire. The only Hsserlioii hv the witnesses as to eiicroachineiils haviiiir heen made hy llic I'hiinliU; whlcli'eau he considered as eiifivct are those of l.ariie and Wiekstead as t,, li sliyht encKiachnient at C of ahoiit four feet heyond the top of ihe hank or lii','li Miriiij; lidc line, ami of another of ahoiit four feel at O heyond the same line of hivh tide hut not iiit(rferini; in any way with the heil of the river Ol rse ol the water or cliatinel. The aiipemlix 1) a'ml synopsis thereto speak for themselves ami prove that the river Itcauport is lonkcil upon hv eviu'v one of the wilnesses on holh sides as a mivis^ahhi river durini,' ail hii;li tides (',f ihn' Ut ami :lri| ipiarlersof the iiiooii. The navi'.'ahleliess of the river appendix K Jiroves hv :>.■, witnesses that the wharf of I"<.'.:i is an ohstru-tioii to llie wurkite^' of the mill. App Ii'x !•' asserts hy IJ witnesses coiitradicfed only hy two that the wharf of ["(."ij is an ohslruetiiiii to the work- ilnrofthe mill. There appears hy the synopsis to this esidence to he Ijye witnesses ^vho eolilradict theilssiulions oflhe other ij.') witnesses, hut sUch is not the ease. Tlmse live witnesses merely assert what is In m. way denied hy the I'lainliirthat the said wharf is m, ohMriietioii 111 the iLw of the w.ii.i' iiiehr ..nliiiarv ciivnin-taiico, or in the imrnial stale of the river. .\ppcmli\ (i.--.\- t.ilhc ,t,ilie, hehillil the -lone -tole. Read I he -Miopsis. .\plicndi\ II a, loll d.ly al I' and nhslnieihiiis in the tail I'lleo, etc. IJcad ihe synopsis. Apliemlix I : Appendix K : Appcii.li\ L.-'I'lie e;i,l,.|,c,' in thc~e nppendices ivariU llielormcrsi/,c ol llicimll wh.cl, the diM; Iielweeii it and ihe ir|-,,i||„| ,,r its licii;ht a'!.oy(. '".-'' i"''' l''\'"'l' "ii'l 'li" depth to which it was usual to allow it'to he suhmcr.'oifprevious to supplier it. ' ' Appendix M i- a' tip the time the wheel u-ed I'ornielv to slop iliiriiiif hich tides. 'I'l,,. ayera;,'e time „fstoppa;;e in tormcr line's is certainly les^ than what it is a? present from our own ohservations The tin f sioppaiic al present i. iV ahont one to live hours ,ir »a\ thivehoiiison an avera-e, whcva. it appear, ii„iu the evidence lo have fnnnerlv heen, not more llian two hours mi an avcra'/e. We cannot however arrive at the conchisi.in that tic wharf of \^r.-2 is at least t,i aiiv sens, I, I,, rvi,.,,, ,|„. ,,,,,,., ,|-,|„. ,lili;.|viice in Hi i lime .if -toppa-e under ordinary eircuiii"- slaiiees tlial is ,|iiriii- In^h tide, unaeeonipanieil hy freshets ,ir jams of ieo. Wohelievoit hashecn eusloniary ,.f lale m.t to drive the wheel when suhmer-e,l heyond a lew inches, wlierc..,_ ii .ippcvs hy Appendix 1. that lornierly the whe.'l was worked someliiiies. even when It was suliiuerj,'ed to the exlei ' two feet dr niore.—N'ow as llie lido rises ,ir lalls ahout Ihtve feet an hour diirine- hiir|, tides, if wo supiioso that the wheel IS now- made t.. stop when >„hii,ci-e,| six inches, and thaf if was lonuelv allowed' to -o until It was suhmer-eil two Icet. it will he underst.iod that Ihe dillereiic'o of ti.no w,Mi,|heeipialtothatr(ipure,|hytlietii|einrisin-an,l liilli,,..' Iho extra ei-liteeii inches Ihatdillcreueo would. |ust he ahout an hour, and in this way. can the dilierenee hetween pivseiit and tornier s,„,,|u,,,, 1,,, a,.eouiited for. If a-ain we suppose the diameter of the mil whe.'l, .. havo h.rniely heen t, i s,.veut..en to tweiifv feet as stated hy some of the witnesses, while Its pivs.'nl .liainelcr i^twcnty one feet, and if wo, at the sanio'tim.', suppose the sliatt or axle oltho wh.'cl t,, I,,, in Iho same position as it always wa.<. i wil ho understood iha, the hoftoiu ol the wheel under such cireuiiistaucos,' must liuvo l.eot' elevac.lloriu.'lyahovetl,eti,le,tnini six to twenty four iiiclu's m..re than it is at lirosoiit and that cireumslane.' again \yo,i Id account for the .liir.'ren..e hetween present and foriiior stoppa-e lo m-eount lor the dincrence in any otii.'r manner is iiiipossihle. unless we suppose which IS ralh.'r unlike ly, that tides rise hiu'her now a days, thaii they .Ihl fornu'lv Ol that thoiy has iH.eii some (h'pivsHon in the land to he a.'c.'iunted for, on ireolo-ica |U map OS. Ila.l Ih,. I.e.l o| ,he rivor, near the tnill, heen very lar,,ro in former timet, so alio cause the space to forma kind of duck or Imsin of -real size, and tlio inlet from tlio H o Ti:'','"; ""'■' "";' '•> ^•'""l'^'r"^''ly t" ».l'"'^i>^« "I'tl.o said hasin, it will ho understood hat sii, a space would have tak..|i some tune t.. till and that ero it had hoou tilled to the h'vel ., the h t hawr..nc.>, the tide ,nii,^lit have alr.'ady U.&n to fall a-ain hy which process the water iti the liasin would never have a.'.p.ire.l the same surface level, as the tid e waUr II, the M. la.w-reiice. Th.' si/.e .if the hasii, however in IT'.i^ or 180.) Cvas not sutl eon ..iinparatiy,ytoth.'s,.c,,ona! urea of the i t, M euusc any poivoptihle oilcct, s i ' L s that uhovo do.scrihod. ami much less can anv such etroci he caused at prosoiit I \n 211 \Vi iiiii-nlirivlorc' loii-iiil'T 111" riiiiiiiiil - |.ri'tv!iftiiiii* with ri'x|»'<'l t<> tli<> unni i\\{\'v- n'lif.. 111! .'.11111.1 ''"* "'■ '' i^v '.n |.iv...'iit nil. I iWiMi.'r H|i.p|.iiir.' "t' tlir mill «li.'i.| I.y tl .• wlmti of \-* ilill'.'i.'M.'.' ill 111., liiii.. i.r -l.>i.|.ii'.'.' lit .'11. Ii li.l.'. Til.' jfii'iil liitl.i.'iii'" iii"'V>> Hlllti'il l..'nvi'.'il III.' tillio lli.MVll.'.l .•.l..|.'. II. nv. Illl.l III.' Illil.' it IHCI l.» •.fn|i Wll.'tl ..111. I', llll.l llu' mill iiiu^t III' H.'.. mill. .1 I'll', iH »'• liiiv.' iilr.'ii.lv hmi'I. I.v .-.mi.' .IiII.'K'h.''' .uIi.t 111 I hi HI/,., of til.' "'i-"l or III.' .iMiati.-.' ii.'hv.'.'ii til" wli.'.'l nil. I til.' L'r.mii.l In'u.'iiili it 01' by llu' ililK'r.'ii.'.' .It 111.' il.'pili, I" whi.'li 111.' wli.'.'l ii ii.iw iiIIm.v.'.I i.. I..' ■.iil.iu.'i'^'.'.l I i.iro M.ippiiiu; it, iw I'oiiii'ari'.l with wliiit tliiit !*iilimi'rKi.m iHi'.l I'.i mutIs , l.. 1.. . Aiip.'ii.liv N' riiii-t li.' .■..ii»i.l.iv.l li)|ii'.i\.« (If l>ii»t iHf.ii-iH niii Im' iIom.' h.v I'vi.l.ii.'f vt,.r tliiM'oiitnii'v .Miiii.it I'.' .I.'iii"i.^inu."l I'V Hi 'vi, ili.it |ii'.'vi..iM t.. il r.'.'ii.ui ol tlio wlmi'f of K.-','tli.' I'l.iimilf'H iiiiU ii.^v.';' •\■<[>^: I ' • u .my oili t • > I I' I I 111'' lii.i-'li ti.K'!<. A|Mi.'ii.li\ i> *li.'vv. .'v.-ii if lli.'.vi.j.'ii.'.' vv.'i'.' I1..I ...rr .li'.iMl. 1 I'.v .mr ..\mi ..!.-^"i'v.iliiiiiit, tliiil-iii... ill.' I'l lioiL.f til.' wluirf .if lO'iJ, III" null "li""l liiH l'""ii ^l"l'|'"'l li"i" '""-'"< otli.T tlum til.' Iiiitli ti.l.'i. Il i-. ii.'.'.'i^iirv I., ii.-tiiv li.'i'.' nil iippiifiit ili-.i.paii.y m tli.- ovi.l"! .f KI'V.ir.l II.M|.i.'i-..)ii .'Mra.'t N'... |:! Appii'liN K. Ii -p.'.iUm,'"! It.t.'H'iiitit -» wliiirf of IS.'.li. uitli n'::.ir.l t.iiti.'ir.'"t .111 lli" iiiiti In' --iiy - ■■ th. .Il.'.t ..I lli.' wlmii h to tlii'ow liitik wali'i' on til.' wl.".'l " umltlnii " i ilo not kniw ilii.i ••• .iim'.l " 1..' il tl."ii niii.l" to Hiiv ill til" Kiim.' K.\ini"t. " I l.;iv.' miv.i.il liiii"* """ii Hi" H'lH st.H.po.l l>v li.l.'k w.il.T from iW^li.'t-i niii".' tli.- vvhiiit of l-.VJ. ' Thu liii.'r.'p.im.v ".■ic.'h to "Xi:*t wh.'ii it is .'oiiii.!.l'".l thai III" tilM .ilnti.ill i^ 1 .11 fn'Oi lU'li'liT-oli ■< "Vi.l.'li." iTIVfll iitCoinl -"V.'iiil V"ai'H iijfo, iiii.l not I.Hi'.Mifl.'i' 111.' I.iiil.liiii .-f Hi" wliaif ol l^'-'. mi'l Hmt til.' \tM .■K.ili.iii U lr..iii lii« .vi.U'i .L'iv.'n li.-foro lli.' I'Ap Us in l-.V,t, tli" iiit.'ival liaviiit; "viii.'iitlv fiinii-.li.'.l liim with opiiiirtniiiti"^ I'tc l.'ariiiiin that of wli'.. Ii li" w.i- lii'-»l i;.,'H.iraiit. ill App.'mli.v I' will 11.' f.iiin.l mi-..'.'lluii".>ii- .Alnu't* i'l'oiu I'vi.U'ii..' I'.f.'i'iv.l t.i in tli.? rcp.ii't. Til" Ht'v.'cal app"ii.li.'"H Ills.) ...iiiaiii iiiiiin' .'\iia.t-< i...t .lir.'.'tly r.'liTiv.l t.> 111 lli" ri-p.ift Imt \vlii"li will lio foiiii.l import.iiii ill ..Hr,)l..ii'..;'..ii ..I' Hi.' .■oii"ltisii)i..'5 cam" lo l-y tl"' I'Ap'iH- InnjipL'iiiiixti w.' riii.I in cxtiiK't N'o. A. •• I i-.'ir'Ui' h.< ii:t.uvwlriiei (Ihhit.l.iiii'.-: 'I'lliiti-s) >• ./.('//.. /.. n,ii'ii.i'ui,i run ... /', 1,1 •/, i„ ,1,1. ,•/.'.■/•. 'A >.(' .""■•' ii'iiiiiil, " iil.'«i "■". r('-',ri;iiil Ilh '• ,i;t, ,■:•■:,'>■<■ -inr^ ,,i ,/,U,„ii;„y /.■ <■.<'()•.« i)'ilw,l rl .s-n," in'/r.i- l,s ,l;h ./,'./'Mc. ./i',* (I'lamtift h " aiil.'iii's) ,1, (,,(,■ r,h,,-l,-, ,/■ T/--'«-v"/' '/"-- A' ./.'/. (■.>.■.■.■.." N'.iw in.l.'p.'inl.'iitly of tli.T.' "Voi- liaviiii,' "xisti'il a norlli .'a t .'liaiiii.'l wlii.'li mav liavo In'.'ii .nt. olf l.y '.ho It.l.'iuliinl s "li'ii't- It will I"' "oii'i'l.Ti'.l l.y 111" l.'.inii'.l .lii.lir"s w'li.'tlii'i'ii iV.sli.'l is a iiatiiril or an iiilih.ia lliimr. mnl if u iiiitiinii plii'iiomciio Mofi-.".'iilai- ami prio.li.al o.'.'iirr.'m-.'. il"' rn'.-i' -lioiiM ii.it il" left opi'ii 1. 1 allow it a fivu pa.sa^'.' iii-.t.a.l of loi'.'iii'^ it into an iiiiiiaiiiral iliivtioii liv any wluii-f or .illi.'rolistru.-ti.ni. App.-n.li.'v li I'onliiins anion',' oilier )liini;s ih.' lil'ili..! tli.' parties pr.'k'iisi.iiH as I'.inlalin'.l in the il.'.'laniti.m ami .■ .'.'plioii. I'lxira.'ts '1, It, ID, II, of this Appin.li.x i.'ive sum.' inlorniatioii as 1.1 tin' fr."iii.'ii.'y ami cxti'iit of I'l.'sh.'ts 111 the river Heailport. Many fre-liels are llierciii im'iitione.l as haviiii,' li".ii I'Xt.'iisiv.' enoil5,'li t.> li.io.l all III.' Ian. U ill til" vieinity ami .'Viii till' main roa.l hflwe.'ii lli.' .lam ami lli" mill. N.iw it is inip.irlant to siy iliat fr.im th,' iiii| il.ility of h.'iin; on lli.' irr.niml at anv parti. 'iilar imnm'tit or from other caiisi's we n.-v.'r liapp.'ii.'.l to witn.'ss a li'.'>li.'t ..l^ , u.' .li.l m.l tli.'r.-for.' m'.- tli.' riveron any ."•.■ii«ion ill its wor-^t e.iiiililinn-, with r.'irar.l lo it- ii.'tion on th.' iiilll wli.'.'l -o that il may Im' inlcrr.'.l ihiit our .•'Mi.'lii-ions ill fav.ir of th.' I'laintilf are on lli.'] -ale >i.l.'. App.'ii.lix U .(mliiiu"* imii.irtaiil .'Xtra.'islVoni l).iir.-irl, I,,!,',;; ,/. !•( I'i'i,'l„<. (>,;l,„,ii,„,s Mir:t,ni,s ,i liWl, //(.•;,/..'■•., — l)"liiiini,'th" l.•u^lllll"allill^' of a liavi-al.le river ami th.' p.'iiallh's of oh-! met 111,1; it X.;. In e.iiine.Mioii with thoMi e.^ctracts rea.l exlra.:t N.I. ^i, of Ap|"'mlix I'. We ha.l nearlv omitte.l to statu hefore .'.in.'ln.lim,' our ivm.irk* thai ihei'.! .'\is|s unniis. takal.h'eviil.'iieeof the intention the Delemlaiil ha.l whil.Hniii.liii^' hi-» uharfof \<>y to .ontiniu^ that of 1«.")J in th.' >aiiie ,-trai;.'lit .lir.'.'li.m .l.nvii to lli.' p'.lnt A .'ii ..ur |.lanNo 1. Koverul of the ll.lemlanl'M vviln.'.-.ses employe. 1 h\ him in ere'"iiii; tin; -sni'l ^^ h'U'l. '''"'n I'V their expressi'Hi- H.aMii.'y 'Xp.'.'t.'.l il to II" eoniimi.'.l ill a. strai.iiht liiu' wiili thai "I l"*.il ami as an iino.|Miv'M'ai pr... f of this int.'n:iiin, on til" li.femhiiits pari, tie'-' exists uilhin the wharf of ls,v; a ! .4 .f liiilier ext.'iri"i'.' .lowii s.nm' twenty liv.. le.'l in lli.' Kiii.l .lire.'- tioii. Why. ■ :. a l- . i.i :.; 'nthm was n.-v.'r .-arrii.'. I .mt, w.' eaiinot pr.'leml l.isay, nnlesi to ho sure it was thwai'teil liy the I'laiiitiU's in-ot.'st a',Miiisl tli" wharf ..f isrd \vhi"li may have imlispusuil the Defemlanl I., s.mi.' .vl.iit towar.ls ih.' I'iaintilt ami . .iii->'.l him t" "ii- L'lo.so the whole of ih.- I.iw ^^roiiml or l.ea.h to uhi.-li h.' [ii-.U'iiil- lie is .'iiiitl.-.l. ^m 1' «lnil ililK'- liy t) (• whiut' 111' llii.ii iViim r, Tfiii'i' iiliiivt) 'h iiilii'i'> liiiil (itlllT ill tlio 1 it or liv till' I'.im H|o|'t|iitii,' GDi'^rcLTjsiom liy fviiliiii'K iM'liiiii i«r till' lail lli<; lii;,'li I iili'ii>rvittiiiiiii, I tVnlil cllllxi'H ,.|iiiiii V in llu' i| l)r|i'lli|illlt'n II' wluil'l' \* to tliiin; liiii Of. Ki'iMi tli<^ mill i.lMi'V rru-ii'it to I'Viilflll'i' jU'ivi'll IM.VJ, iinil liiat iiti'iv^ii liaviii); lir|Mirt Imt , th'' l^xpiiH. iiiilunl'.'iii'ifiiir.t) ' .<(' ;'(•«)'(•'(/(' ll,t l.y !(.■ Ii/, V 'I: III .(,•,« (I'lMilllirt"H y 111' tliiTi' I'Vt'i' '.|iiliiiir-i wimrl'. II' nil lulilii'iitl II' livi'i' 'limiM iliinil iliniliiiii •* ill!' lil'ili "I'dii' N ti, !', 1", 11, I'll'llu'tH ill till' isivi' Olioll'.'li to iih'l ill" mill. L'lumnl :it iiiiv U't, 111' sllllii'iflU 111. 'l'lioU!j;li wi' on iiiiy ocruHiiiii iiiny 111' iiili'iiTtl (lix k rdllluillH ■:t.:,hs ,1. \'''^l, •■i Droli-Miuliiij; \Vi! iiiii«t liDjic tliiit ri'imrt will uIiIh' Inli'rloi'iilnl'y .Iii'Il'iih'iiI ilivi .■]i:ii'Mli' i|iii'»tioii-. mill ii l.llTi'll it ijlU' t I'oli- 'I iliil.Mi1-,..i-.' ,111 iir, .,,11111: 111' till' intcrc-'t^ tit ' my \vitiii'^ V'"' "• ' ' I'll'., I'or nil i'X|ilaii:itiiiii III !.-' n.i-iii. in- ;ii,ir nn lln'ii'liiri' «!■ liaM' ri'iiiiirki'ii -o I'llit^ om uII thi' |i,iiiit,.? ii lis iiiH^ililc Willi all tli'' 1 ■' ' ' ' : I '' ' liiiiiiolo'4'atioii ol'iiiir ici.i'i I, .N'ofliiilti! ill oiii' ri'|iort fan Ic ■ .■ini,|i'n',l roin|ili'ti i it-n-'ll'm, IntrrloiMlliiry lU'i' witlioiil all 'h.' |.^. ■ liinraii.l -i|li-ii''iii''iit ,-hilisi'~, I'fir llioroii'^lilv ri'\ii.'uiii^' ili. li"!.- ,n'il. \Vr aUo liii|ii' liir our im liail tlii'i'iiM' 111 our liainl I ' i^i .■ lli.in two yi'iirs, tin' lloininil,! it too iniirli lo ili'V'iii ,1 . . \y\t iliivM to til'' rcijital ul . Ml- r till" I'lHi' hint ■ ,1- if lliry liilil ■l.'ii. , ami' litlr- iii'C : ami it i • Ivaliri' U!t (III; ii ■ill,. 1,. of ll„. ,,.,,.,.||y 111 liaviiiif i mil di'i'in (Siniu'• f.\i.~tn vvitliiii till! .Hiiiil iliivf- lo say, nnli'^i to <.'il wliii'li may I'll liiiii t'l L'li- vF^mmm i. lytntcls /'nun Ij-'hU'iho (uUlnvcd hfi I'ldiiiliJI' on lite c.ris- Icncc of (I \orlli-i:amv •■"'""•"" I,,. (Kuii iU> ix.VJ liunv |.'l"''' 'l"'"''! 'Ill ^'- '^^'- '■' i'"i''''i'""' !■' I"''"'' '''' 'I" '' >' "'•'" will) l>.'t«'in]- 1 mil Ki'vontiiu ilulis hi nvii'|-f. uZ7v.. i;,T.,lKvt in M,V Katlirr's tiiar ;, >ui;.ll i-lan.l. S„q,lus wat.r^ thw, llouv.l on ,;„ h Oulun,'--. ,i,i,, ,],,,,,. i,v loriuiMirlu.. chiiinicls. W f..!' \X:-,i iMiih m wlml^ wii. Ini.nrly a [.oitin,, „l tlic I'liaMUoruii.l now piv-^i-iit- tlif wat.T> llouiiiir to tli.. rust sido ot the islaii.l. An.n„M,. Wharf of IS.-.J iui.l l.N-.l lavviit waf.T from H..win- tlimuirh the who],, of tl,.^ nv>.i''s >'""^'''' ■'• aitlVTont rliinHU'ls. l'n.vi..n- t.. ,-oHstiMU-tion of uharvc-, waLT llour,l ov..|- ll„; wliolc lu^ac'li. Kiwr, now .•outiufil to our -mall clainntl. V,i .,„„.. 1. l>o not n.nu.nilK.r tl,o 'wlana. \)r\u'y. l.,.fo,v w!,arl •>( Kd wa. Imill th.'iv whorr luo rl.anii.'U.'Xfnain-ashort .litamr l.-low ih,' v^\\\. '1 !..• wati'iN may liav |.;.-.M n,o,-,. tl.au th.'V now ,lo on llu' llof.'n.lanfs >\.nkTnu- e.ttr ■llu.l;i Miit ii^.. |(an> K> in.'is i'.au .!>■ la nvii'i'o (lar^^ail il.-- :lru\ .ol,-. dr ri'llf ilo. Willi U.lVii.l- mil 1- ji'ii" ajlii ttllti it'nt lil.s '• n'ijthtfi- 1,1, III. I.,.iii< llll- , „,,,,„;„.,; .raiconnalssanivifunriH'litoil.' uui i-t mamti'nant ivnI.Tnuv par I,. .|ua, ilo in.... H:i.! 1111.1 i.i.t 1)„„. K..,r|,,ss..s iMiix. it iiuaii.l la nuT .Mait lia-r, il V avait.nn liclil rlHrnal .|ni pa-a.t an »-"""■'"' nor.K-tdo nlo. !.!■ il.inal iln nohi .■>!, n'c^xi-ti' |.his iHanl liam' par Ic i|nai do iNi-. ;';,'';'h;'"L. I/.l.-n,.paraitphH maint.nant pa,vi..,uaii,v. Ic quai flit, il a rte .•liamiu^ nn. ,p,antno a^;iiii-t iuiu. 1)0 mon tmnps il V avail daiw !a livi.-nv nno P''!'"'' i'''- l/.au pa^-ait drs drnx .•ot.;. deootloiU-. (iiian.l IVau olail Lini -ro.- ra pa-ail par di-ns 1 ilo ot la pin- loiU; p^"''"-' ,le Tuau pa^siit an noid c-l. !,.■ iuai vinp.'i It loaii do ^'oooulor ail iiord o\v I'oan pastor dans nno liai-iair. i-oniino n.aiuoro d un potit olioiial .>.iii,,i.'.li'io. .„i X |.-',i,. pjl.'.. L,. I.inu' 'l. 'H'. ,, .\,„.,.rl.i 1,1. ,,uai .lo l-.VJ r t fait .lans loi.junal du iioid-o-l : V' > avail nno pilito ilo .[ui -.' ■ fliiaaiir, ,,,,„,,. Hiainl.nai.l r.-M. rinoo parl.'.piai do l.s.",:i. Lo liol.iMlonr a oonpo lo l.ras oil lo i iv """■■■• ,lo lurivii'-n. I'.ir ..m .piai .!.■ |s,-,2, ot .piaiol il a fail lo .piai .lo l^.il, i,a roininoiirail a -onor. I I, |.„r. \vaiil lao.in-tniolion dii -piai do ls.-,-J. il y avail donx i honaiix dan> la rivii'iv. II > 'n.n.l 11 111 ;,vait nno do maiiilonaiit onv.loppoo par I.' .piai. Avant lo .piai. la rivioro avail d.' Miixani.. l'i,.iii,uii»^...- .-j ,.,,,,, ,vi,|.,i pi, .lis do lai-./onr vis-avi- 1.. •• slono ,loiv." t^iaml I ,.an , -1.111 -i,,.—-, li • n '''"•■ pa.sait aulani par lo N. K. .pio pa'- I.. S, i K d,- lilo, l,o l.oiil >\n .piai .pa l.oinlio lo |,ra. .|. iariviiro, Ilw f.ris- 'iKj of Ihc I liii'h l):irrri' • i|iril y av;iil nUi'll nil Cillll iy a |inrii(.ii nl' ) of till! rivi'r's i-ci' llio wIkiIo I'lv wliorr Iwn ■ |i:i-~i-il iii.ir.- .rlilVi'iiU' ii-tti' .|n;ii .li' 1S.",:J. (|iii [las-iiiit iiu i{iliii ik' lS.'):i. V NIK,' <|iiaiilili' Irs ili'iix rotrn In- I'nrti' [laiiie K'. liuuml It's rsijiH! Ifs caiix uiilii'lit fhi'iial ir, !■ rtait jiliH ■ ■|iiai la jiai'i'i'- llc'xlsU-'Ilt |illH, (111 M' rrpaiiiln' MH II avoiis pa> 1. // 7 •i'-ii!f nil. ■•tite ill' i|ui s,' Imis nil Ic I'lPiir- in'iii.-ait a iii'iicr. la rivirii'. II > vait il>' Miixaiiii' il ^r.i:,-.', il . n mini 11' lirasili M, Sii.ti I-.'. P.oHri.n i;; Clrrk ill riiiiiitiir-i I'ln- l.Il.Vllllhi- lirni' ill' uiivi' lii.s i;viiJi'Ui-'i'. I). Iliiiis II. .1. I!. I-..lliii o. iiisKi't ii;. J. KiTtrnssun 17. Miller in riiiintiir.H.'iii- pli'y was nut ill ( aiiiida |iii-- vi.Mis I . th,. Iiiiiklin^ lit whiii'f nor lor tivo yt'ar.1 iiltor. K.hMinl lliii- .li 1,1.11 1- ['•laiii'iii^ .\a- • Iran 1,1 Law li lilt; Mr Ki MUa ','11. C. liiiiiui -.1. Hattiu'o iiiid 2 (•liaiiiU'U. ("Iiamicl i-aii ffdiii point X to llio .\. K. nf uliai-f nf lf<')2. Am iiliiiiist sm-e till' .V. !•:. rlianiu'l wa-i lln' ili'i']ii'i.t nf tliu two. Wliai-t' of iHiVJ, Imilt ai'iiiiini a ^iiiall i^laiul. Tliori' wvw two iliamuls tliat is uiu' fliaiiiicl am! tli.,- mill rai'O. (iii'ali'>t .jiiantily of\\ali'r tln'ii pa«,.i| in present .'lianin'l, ami a poi'iioii of II to tin -til I'asi of i-land .V. H. lIuiiiiii'I Liit nU liy wliarvcs of U:,l ami Is.V lint I'spi'ciiilly by lliat of 1>:.M. "' (Jiiai liatiilans li' niiliiii i|i. la riviT'i'i. rt nnnni' plus, Ir Drfmili'iir par -I's rpiai a '; Il''- la rivii-'t'o. Avaiii Ir .jnal I.' plus fmi ili's I'aii.v , ouraitan .V. K. vlts raiirini .iiiai 1! .Iu l>i'li'iiili'ni'. l-i'ipiaia rotri'i.'tiliT.iii.liiir..r,.aii iji' la livii'iT ail laiial ilu inouliii ft nl coniplt'te- iiR'iit cliangi' lo lit ilf I.I rivii'i'f. SpniiiilVi'slii'tn ivi'iit li-lit ai'oiiii.l 111,' small i,h,,„| lietwrou tin.' ili-,liariri' of tliu mill race ami the X. H. oniiaiii iliaiinel of tlu' l'.i':iii[ii;iit I'iver. _ The wharf of 18.-,2 that is Imilt aeross tlie rivi'i'. .Vfi,.|'a IVi'slii't nnm's ihmn iiistoail ot takiii,!; Its pniper stniiirht roiii',i' the current is tiininl hv the wharf. If a Jioi'tion of the wharl ol 18.i2 were cut away anil Ihe lln,„l water maih' t'o pass tlii-oi|.r|, that opcnino- m, ohstrni'tmn would oeenr. If the water were not thei.' the walrr woul-l How ihriinoh its natural ehaniiel. Wharf of l.^^.'i-.', liiiili arr.iss natural channel of rivrr licauport. I.e ijiiai ih' |s."i-J .|iii ii-avei'se en pailie la rivii''re. Walrr fi'oni milural eliannel now ixoes with that of tail race. 1.1- ipiai ih' l.^.'iL' .pii e-i il,. travel's ilans la riviere et emiiiehe I'eaii ile ileseemlre a hi I'. M.a-iii I, \V. .\llstill ','. l.aiiilily :l (ilrllii'r I Nalvi/A a. Cnutinnrd. E.iii,i(is I mm > ri,I<>,irr whluaul /-y Ihleiiilan/ on the i'.risteiici' of a t^ortli Ei/st Chatini-I of the h'ii; /■ /l,,i,i/ior{ o;a^i/e //„■ S/on<- Ston: previous to the hitildinti oj the ir/iii/ 1 of \Hy2. Je n'ai vu toieiine trai'eih' ileii\ clii'iiaii.\ ilatis la riviere Ueaiiport. Saw no trace of another channel or of an i'-lainl. The stmni'S of trees from X to Y prove there is no olhri' eliannel ln'twi'i'ii llmsi' poinls. My iiiipi'i's-ion is that previous to Ihc c.'cistenc" ol the wliarl' uf L>."i2 the river took a slraiu'lil course. ■ le n'ai Jamais I'l'iiiarqiic plus, I'lin eheual ihiiis |a rivien' ISi'aiiport. J'v ai eanote line liarlic lie tons 1,'s J, nil's ././„.- /„l.,ll ■.,,„. JK'rricre les arhres il v avail line /«(.■.-.>, ./)■ par oil I'cau inoiitait an has ilujiirilin ile nmii pi''i'e. J/cmlroit ipii no se'couvrait pas il'oau fai.sail nncespeee (11! petite ile iliiraiit Ics -ramies mers. Dans Ics phis lortcs m'ers I'ile so eou- vrait, e'est .surlilc .pictaicnt les arlires ilont je parle. ^^ Aprcs le i|uai r.-au '■..iilail comme avaiil -a eoiistriii'tion. (.)u n'a pas ari'ele I'cau cu faisanl le 'piai ni rhaiuc le iheiial, d a |ilus forle r.ii-on on iic I'a pas liomhe, ,/. ,„ ,,.„„.ii'.s- .yd'.v /ws I, ,/„„., I ./, A, ,■,,'.■,•,•, ,i,;i,i/ d'un^'r Or trar.iilj.- ,o> ■pbi',. ,/, ,,'./,• y„,s ,,/ /,, ^,/,,, , ,/,^,,„;.. .I'ai exainiiii'' le lerrain particiili(''reiiieiit avant hi batisse du dit ipiai. et siiis ecrt.iiu qu'il n'y avail, jias ilen.\ ehciiaux. On n jim' I, i/n.i: /,i{,l juur-- '//icAv hi Tuit.^.'-viiit. Xever stiw luori' than one rhaiiiicl below mill. A ma eoniiai-sam'e la rivieie n a Jamais I'li iiu'iiii scul clienal. |),'pi,!s |., j,,..,t :'i thsceiidii' all llcuve, hi rivjci'c n'a Jamais c-u a ma i'.)!iiuiissanL'e plus d un eheiial drpuis ll alls ,|ik. J,, naviii'iic. .N. (iivuur 111. .le siiis iirlaiii .|iril ny ajaiiiai.- eii |iln- dun ehciuil a parlirdu [lout en descciidiuit. Miiiiri. .■ Mill- roiiv n. .l„.,.|.l, V\i:U'\ I-.'. l:'.. l-'r II. PiiTH' (1:111- vri-iiii !*'■ il.ir II.. ti.liriiiiir It. .1,- «uW .11 iimiivai' a,i.„M;n-..i .rMii. ,l,„„al. I>'..s /,.v ,/r'...«.'v.'"0-. /•"'" '■'■/"'"■' /'■"•'■■'"• •'"'■-"' /■"■ " '■' ''' '" '■"■'"■'• (i„;,n.l ..n ;M.'.,mH..M,M-. !.• .|iku .11 IS.".! ,. .^v /.A ".'"•■ il n'v iivall i|ini„ .lirnal. J.' u'ai i.as ,-..111111 li' .■iiur> ilr I'. mm iiviiul U' <\n-M (U- l^^.i!. S iw 11.1 tiMiv ..f anv i-laml ..r rliaiiiH'l, saw river Cr IIil fuxt liti... in IS.",:!. Trr.'s coiilil ,u,l liavr irrnwii tlR.ro iiail iIkto lnvi, a siroaii, nf .■.in.lanll.v nninni- water. 'jaiiiai-^ vil iiil'ilii s.'ul rli.'iial. el ji' ii ai pas vii il ili'. l-as,|,.tiM.vil'in, a.mv i-li ,1 ,ii .run il.'. .I.' .lis |..wi,iv..,n...-.V, A.' y M"''l n-yAi^< im, .I,' .-li-nal ,../■■. ■- J.u.r rn,nh ,l,.,i„is tJ a I.i aiis. oliau.l Tai visit,. I,.s li.-u.x [..-ur la i,iv,i,i,-.r,. Inis !.■ M-iai .!,■ l^il .'•lait l.r,-.,iu' lait. ,)nl{a,.,.v-s,,hu>tl„.r,.,V,. ■/./.„//./.,/ .,..,'/,. AW /A. /,... w, ..-AW. . ■\u. ■•Hain that lor ti'ii vears'thi'iv ,...iil.l liavr lr..,Mi » . rl..,m,.h'l •'/.,./ /'■""' Mmm J "»./ ) . .|,.'suisn,-. s„r .V ,iui Inrtne tuaiiitotiaiit ,.arli...|.. la tertv ,li. IV.tV.ti,l,.itr. .!.• lU-Iaiv ,|i.,. i.,„-,li,„„isv„,,i,UM..heMal./.',w.,./,,iir luMi.isMliI,. that within till, last Ki v.'ars thnv ,-aii have lioen u rW.mur] wli-.f,; ~tum,.< .il' ln.,.s w,r,' .'^lwil,.4/..'.^..-. .V ■".■! ). I'i.l ii,.l kn..>^ i,iviiHs,.s |,ivvi,.ils t,. whart ,.t l--- ,|;ui,ai^vi, ,r,h- „i .ha.x ilu.-iaMN. .1,. .l,'Hi...HV a in„. li.^ur 'U- hi. -K' 1- aurais vi.s ,la„s lo <',iiirs il,- 10 luis, s'il y en avail I'li. Km is,-,:!, JVi traViiiUc lunir le Defemleur. .le nai jamais vu .leiix .lieiiauK .,.',:■ .1 ,/ ). Wil!i:,iii Ml. MVJI. iKliii.-,- M,. n-uci "J*. Si,i,.elhav,.kn.,wiitli,.,.r,.nn-..s,„ 1^>. tl,..,v la. li.'en Mt. .Hie ehannel, ami m- i,iaiiil />./;,.. A, „//„-.,.■./, >./.", ,„./,„-.-.,../.-'"•''■""• .,.. „-ai,ia,uais -■oniiu ile ehetial iln ente ,lii helemhar ; d,. surte .,ue le .,nai u. W hnu, he lias. syyoi'sis 0/ Eridenrc n, Ar,»vd,.r A ..to the rs,.>enc,ol a N.rtl, Eusf C/.uu,./ o,..,somr Un. .nound lo'hc EaMmnd of island answrrnn: as a ,hun„rl n, Insh. I tun, . K.iu. 1 Fraue.iis \'alli''e. ■J Daniel ,M,.('alluiii, o An;j:ii~ .M.'D.muM. 1 Kilwar.l .1,111,'-. .1 rieir,' S,'ii;Miii. 11 i.iinis 1 Jii'iiier, I V. \. lliniii.s. s |,..iiis .\iil;,1'. ..1 .1. \\. I!,.rlian,l, 111 .\li,-iiael S.-iitt, II I'alrii'k Dlilieii. \i lieniainin I'llais, v\ .1. 1!. Ki.rlin, w ( ;, 111':.',' riisset, !•'. ,),.lii, Fer;riissciii, Hi 111 17 Lawieiice .MLKeniia, A, I.M.N Hi. I .lii-i'iih I'iearil, ■1 l'i,ari' .\l,)rin, ' :l Wiiliani Austin, ' t Xan'issi. Fan, 'her * .■) Fraii,;.iiH (.'ri'pean. (I Fih\ar,l Kneket, 7 AiitDiii,' I'.arbeaii. H Daviildinm.N, '.» Xai'eiss,' Ori'iiief, lit William Wiiksteiul ' II I'iiir,. (iauvri.an ' \1 C'l-ahl DuuUvie, ' 1:'. l-'.lieline L,anL,'evili, 1 I I'ii'i're Filiati, ).", William Murray. III JLi'iiai'e Miirenei, 17 Friitii;ois (.iiiL'tinii. iiKil- ' n '|ii nil III clll-lKll. Ji' ;',. TlTrs Cdlllil •iiiliMir ct n'v iii riv'u'ii- ; }<• u':u • r ili-s soiu'lu's IN IJ a 1 ") iuis. lit. II crrUlill llllll .1.' iliM-hiri' i|\i(' • •• ^|llll^• store." lu'l'i' >tlllllji-t 111' Imrf ..f IS.". J. ;iiirui> viis ihiii-i II X n.'ir .V^i y. iiiiiiu'l, and ii'i lUii 111' Ir liiiUrlic or iif soini- loir (7 /(///(. 25 FuK 18 ('iiptaiii Liiiiilily, lit 'I'lioiiias (irciiicr, 21) Maiiiiri! .MaivDUX, 21 K. T. Fl.'tchor, 2:2 (iabric'l Giriiicr, AUAINST. (Signed. .\. n. Wiliii'sscs rnarkcil tlnirt * talk iiioroly as to proseiil apiiearaiiccs. (MS. r,\ILLVK(JFr KDW. STAVIMA. 1/*/*/:A7>/A />'. Eiudence adduced by I'hi I lit iff mi fiicrnnchmciit nf u-liarf hiii/t in 1852 /'// Difi-ndanl- t'i'l''- '■■"",■ Wliarl' (if 1S.')2 liuili imt .m I li'lriiilaiil's ouii |irM|»'i'ty Iml on ]iiilp|i.' prdpiTtx . I'sod to liuTly llni'" lioat ii|) river licailpoi'l to uiiliin si'^ln of mill to sit thai tlir river was not olistructoil m liiiur .Miisli r jn'rl'iinililliri irilh m'l i/ill'l. Ill tJUllii'O Aiiirnf Me- .loilnlil '.'. 1 state this •• all llic u'liin\ es on the 1 )eteiehuil's side ol' tie' rivi>r are enerDaclinients on (1 have known the premises siiec l^lOor ^o| the river and prevent the water from flowing thioiiLrh the whole of its dilferi'iit ehannels. Wharf of ls,')2 is an eiieroailiment ou river I'leauport. r. S.'tinln :i. I,e (piai de ix.'i-, e-t h'iti dans la riviere lleanport, je ne (lis pas daii.s lo clional. l.s. (ir.'iiiiT4. A line place h- '[iiiii de IS.'iiiest etendil a pen pres sept ]iieds dans la riviere nu point X et an-dessiis. K. X. (iir.Mn .le triiuve le ijiiai de ls.",j tout ,'i-l'ail dans le milieu de la riviere, paree (pie eomnie je lo •"'■ eompreiids, la riviere allait dii •• s|, me ^tol■e " jii.-.pran ipiai I! dii I let'endeiir. el en allant en bateau. i'alhiis parloiit. II \ a a des places dciix pieds il'i-aii le loiiir du >|uai (111 I )i''fen(leiir et le loni;de ee(|nai 1!, le eoiiranl de la livii're de^ceiidait anssi toil (pie dans le iiiilieii de la rivii^'fe. A.l. l,;irii(!i;. It is ni}' opinion that the xvliarf ot' is.". J is an (■neroachmcnt to the ext.^nt of one liUiulrcd s.iivcjur. and twenty six I'eel at spriiiLT tide-. Iioiiois,.,. w luii ii-e Ihe wharf is to Defemlant sincu the water Van holh si.lc- of it. Wliail' ol' \^i2. ..I.^triicts western or [.resent ehannol. .1. ric.ir.l ;. J'ai lifiti le (piai (111 |)('>fendeiir le lout;' di^ la riviere, iioii pas dans la riviere, pour (III D.struiH. ,.|„.|,,|.o le terrein dii lli'l'eiidenr. II pent y avoir de Jiti.i- li 2 sceins lo me a complete encroachment (.n the river. — It is altoj^ether .!. II. l!,r Indi'l :•. Ill I'l.'lilllill'n cnilili.y. II. in the river. It appear.- to me lliat llie said wharf was liuilt for Ihe express [uirpose of aiino\inir the I'laiiititl'aiid to any person eiii,'a,i;-e(l in the navie;atioii of the river. I ean .see no ol'hei"earlhly reason lor il. il(.l)ef.) - I advise y<,-,:!,(/„ ,/,.-7./,ev /.(/(/../, //..('■/■•":»' v''^^"''- "'/""("/" l''Ti..», ' /. ilj'iitir iioliis. Hclolcrsitn disliki* th(^ IMVh.lnl.l, (i ^-,. Kissot Wharf of lS.".-_', Imill on what u.-ed to he the chamiel of the river. Alway« thought '-• Widow (ireiiier's lot lijriiied part ofeluiiiuel ol liver. It. ninin !;■ la rivii'ic. 26 lo lHr,-J, luiti iImh^ Io milliru i\v l:i tivii'ii'. |,c PrU'iKli'iir par SI'S i)iuiis :V Ixpiu'li''- lli.ni.l M>' Cii:iiiiii II, L'. Ililiur 1.". John lVrj:u>. ?ori h'. F, Niulinu n. .Ii« llimly !■'. 'I'lu' lioaili !>> Ill'" .(jvi'ivil \'\ wliarfof Ib.iii. I,f uiKii (If l.-^'--, nui est ilu IniviTs ilaiis la rivirrc Wharlol' Is.VJ. thai i- Imilt uitoss tin' rivi'i'. 1,0 (luai lali .'ii l^'"'-. M'l' "-iivi'is.' fii piirfu' la rivliTO. (VMiiuii s,. U'ouvr situr. Hu'il trav.'i-so la rivi.''iv cm parlio. E.c/mc(s from rviili'na adduced hi/ I III/ l)fl't'!id(in' (III till: iiicroitclimi'iU of wliarf limit hi/ him in \Ki-l. 11 o^^t ]iro!iali1o (luo la piirfu' V dii .I'l:'' ''^' '. Muriii I. Survcyr. mni> irAvill, i|llalHl If.- f Is.VJ -f tr(>\ivai t (lai 111 (If la nvifi'f, an m m\ siiiil tji'i'-'-f-- \V. Aiisli" ' Wliarl'df I^.VJ d'lt''* ""'' '" ' lif Ifasi fiifniacli ui")ii llif fliami.'l. Tlifro was ui of a lout (it'watfiat pon liiit luit ill it. t Y, wlifu 1 iiifasiiiiHl It, 111 .liiiif l«.->3. It /i at fili'o (if watfi- T. (irenierll. N. r.nu'licr -1. i.t Qiichu- I'a mis I'll (.Jiiai (If l^"i- l':"'t' =^'"' ''^ ''''■'■'' '""' ^''" Quai (If 1^">- iroiniiii'lf jias siir U It Ifs ai'liri'-'. Ic fhf iial liK'Hif. i.-a Icilaiis. On a coui'c lii li/iiTf il'arlirf s ft laispf l(i cliotial plus lari,a', oar on lifiti If ipiai ;\ a plaop. On n'etait pas CiiriH iittT lidliiOl.. liililil JlitVli- Toau niiaiul on ii pi>sf Ifs prftnifi-f llolifsilu u'lai (If ".'_', (^>fptOIl .•!■). iliinl's wlmrf. Fr.'(n(;«>: Cxi- On A \ ilaof If ipiiii (If l'^"'-- '•'H' ''■ tfi'i'iiiii ( 111 |)i'rfiiilfiir, ft (in a irlariri If difiial (If pcaii ; CdIc, Aiipu^tin St. J'ai a: do a I'aiiv If 'lit H"'" ' If 1 8.VJ. 11 est (111 liiinrilii linr.l ilf la livifi'i Hihir.c. (Iniiiifr a In rivii'fc ( If (lix-liiiit a viiiirl |iiiUffs ) (li> lartrfiiii'i' t. .If siiis pos' Nuns aviiiis ilil' (iii'aii pniiil X il V avail tiois k (luati'f pifds ft tro la rivi("'rf ft If ipiai. N. Ci-ciii.' 7. M. Miicou.\ H. J(i3. ricaril !). IsW est sur If lionl df : ft ii"i' I'^i- ''^n-' '•' n\''T*-'- l^.'i-J nCiiipiftf pas If laoiiulrfMifiit Le (piai (If jjf ipiai (If J'ai travaill('' a l.i liraisso du (piai. 11 fsl li;iti If III' If flif iial do la riviere. 1,111" do la riviorc et noii pas dans la riviorf. Frani^ois On- Ciiuii 111. (iiiai iV 1S.VJ lifili sur I'l'^cars. II n'c iiipi(''tf jias sur la riviiuv. C.M- vri'uu 1 1 . I'ositil' (pif If 'I'liii de l^.'i2 n'fiiiiiif If 1 II II I'fan a >' iiiiand ,1 '" ^'' site lo iiiiai. (.////" / inll, llii ,,. i.l avail pro.si|UO pas il fan a ^ n / ll.hdc Phiiiliff's irhiirf his uiUrtal l,„ini,l «l' r>rn-l''il tint of Jj< I'lluhiiih in ic "■".'/• KtU'iini- Lull- Rinn 1,0 (iiiai do IS.VJ onipiolo tin ji M dans la rivif iv, luais (.a.- I'.mt lairo (l(iiiiniai;f. W. Miirniv lit Ill'fciMllillt w hart' mT I'^'i- (Iff- ni'l oiiornafli. (iroc lirr'l I my jiri'Mcnt ai- tiiatiuu. sYAorsis Of Evi(k>ici- III Alijiriidi.i li 11.1 to tmcri rhiiir/it of ii-harf ,o Kiniflior, i, Fiaiu.iiisl'ii^pfii", li .Xiiu'iistin Si. Ililaire, 7 \ar( i-si- (ilf llif r, s Maiirifo .Marcdiix, '.I Kiaiii.oi.-- (iatriiDn, Iiliiis -X I)iiiii'li6 w/iiirf, liiiilt 1)1/ ill' 111 rivii'i'o, nil ITI! WIH upwiirils lit ihIi'c oiwati'i' plus lai'tii', i!ur oil '. Oil n'etiiit jiiis iit). r'l \r clictial lit' son JTc. Nous inoii-^ lio-ilil' na'au iMiiiil LTO. , null (iiiff ilaiis la rt il'i'an ii "N' 'luaiiil irluirf his ..//;.•/,,/ loiiiiiiairi'. n852, 27 10 I'Mwanl Ilonilovsoii. I 1 ( IPOliTl' |{i^ii, 111 Krain'OH Xailcuu, 17 .liHopli Ifanly, |H I'itM-rc Moriir, (SiiilKMl ) I Tlioso wittu'HaoH do not ncoossarily i'dm- Itrndiit till' otlii'is, ^^^nla1ly ot'tlif.' fnriiH r deny 'an cnri-oai'liiiiciif on tliu I'liaiiiifl wliili' most, of llR'lattfr(tiii'.)^lii'ak ol'tlic wluii'I'as oiiri-nai:1i- iiii; (111 the lirurli uiid a.s licinj< an ciK-rouidi- 'lueiit at lii;;!! tido. CMS. BAII.LAlKili:. EDW. STWKLV. I'r-. Villi.-.. 1. llii.l ;i -nit «itli ll.t.i..! ant I* \ fills lipi ll,.|rn.|. am ^i.lil hi- ll. .II-.'. I,flnirn\ 'J. i;.l. .I..n.s ::. Al. 1..IIII.' I. .1 I'i.ar.l :.. I.-. Aii^'.r Ii. i/*/v;a7>/a <\ Extracts from evidence iuloiiiaiidciii- sc iniiivc dans la vi\\i-vc on cinpitHi' siir la rivii'TC 11 I'-t loiiinii.' il i^tail aiiciL'iiiU'iiicnt ipiaiid.i'y rcstai.-. travaillr an ipiai ilii l>riiiaiiilL'nr drpu'w k' rdninu'iiceiiiciil jiisijii tin. II . Iln croai'li on All lUiT I'liil a sin.ill I'oi-iii till (J on litK'l'V Ian r o|' riaitililf's wliart cnci'iiiti'lK's li.'xonil llic line ul liii;li^ ■liin.'ht aiionl till' ri'iilri' of its lon^'tii, of irri' IS also an I'lin-oa' t four feet, licyond llu^ liij;li lidf line on Kacrys plan. Kn faisant W ipiai do ]S-"il..i'ai vn fairi-' ct-'lni dn I >rmaiuli'nr, ipii innpiL'to sur la riviiro. a jii'ii pros do I ('[laissoiir il uiio lloll. 1,0 Domaiidonr a tait son qiiai pour ompi^dior roH'ot dos irrossos oanx siir son jardin ii;t di ii.v on viinrl trois ans o.iardindn Domandonr otait pins laru'o. I.a riviore an a iiiaiiiri' li^ jardin ot I'a n;'tr(''('i. .1. II. n.'i'ti'.'iii'l T. .Vns.rvi.il .III llt'intiii- ,1. iir. M. .Si.tt, r. K.l\vjir.l Hi'it- .l.TSnii '.I. ilait alors pins an \. K. Dopnis ca I'l i;'ost nioi iiui ai fait lo iinai dn Domandonr ol jo snis ]iositfiiu'aiuniio parlio no oo i| . 1 . . .. * .. •■ • _. ! i .. .. .'.:. t *'...-....♦ ,...! .'i no so Iroiivo dans la rivii'i'o. 11 v avait nii vionx (piai, ot on a fait lo noiif oxii.'tonionl a hi plaoo oxoopti'' ipio par plaoos on a fail lo ipnii phis ohoz lo Doinandonr. Doiit ooiinais nil ipiai ipii a ('Ic c nil anparavant. . /,' dn cote ilu 1) eioaiHleui'. •ais qii'il y on aval Win. Ain-liii I I'l.n,. .M..iin'J Extracts /rm evidence luLlnrid li;/ De/t/idan/ nni ncivachnunt ofl'lilinti// ',v icharl. When 1 siirveved the picmisc-, the I'lainlilfs uharfdid not encroach upon the rivci. IJiiai dn l>cm.' par plan lU' I'.oncheile i liaccv s plan! empi.'te snr hiriyierc. a I e.^treiiiilo tSiid Ksl, derriero Ic " WiMnlcn sloro nuns n eitipeclie [las lo ( i iirs (ic ia riviini. pas ilires'il ('nipii''lc sur Ic coin's do la nvi.Ti '2» Ig V.ilUrn ;i Qiiiii (111 Dorn. I'liiiiitMc on i-nrtnnt 11 dix liiiit \<'u;U.. II y iiviiit ilf la ,i;lii.>' .|iiiimi.ii' I'lii viiK. .lo li'iii pii^* vn iTtiiiliii-ii il cinliuto inaisjo Hiiis iiii'il fiii|ii<'lo. Nnr.druiiUrl .I'iii vil i|lU' leu IkUIIIIK'S S( riolit Iiii-i a I'ciill ]iiiiir I'lliir li' ijiKli illl DoIiiillnU'l'.r, iiia'H ,'n> lie fliis jiiis si ci' i|ii;ii ciiiliii'd' >ill' U' iliriiiil. .M.Mnuoux,.-. F,i' ciuui (111 I K'liiiiinlciir piir !<■ luH ciiiiiii'd' dc dix ;'i ilnu/.i' \**l'iil, iiji J'i-i>iii Inland truDilm fl.,,; I.,r.iils, ii"l rl.ihii Ihiirn- niiltil IH,I ji-lss ill /•«,! ,,f ilhilrl' ir'ithiiill irUhhliJ Ins limits. K. l.an^'i\iii. C"est moi (jiiia hati le 'inai (111 l>eniandeiir. II est dans la rivit'-re oil passait ie eoiiraiil. "'• Le qiiai empieto soit de I'- a l"i picils. l.l.-;i;„„ll J'lii vti les homines un .i(nir Iravailler an ipiai dii Hcmandeiir dans I'eau jiis.pi'aiix trenonx. Ce (pii'i emliit'le 7 a S pieds (plus loin).|iiatre a iii'(| picds qdjis l()in.) Tonjonrs (pio CO soit]ilils on moins jesnis por-ilill (|iic(;a einpiclc. .le pr('lciids(iii'il y a (piarante an- liirirn'irruulif'l li A.;/'/ (A ^' /.',/,/, //...>,,//./,/,„ ,1,1 i .Maiirict^ Marcdiix. 7 FraiH.'ois (iagiion, ,H ( iahrici (ireiiier, H (Icrald Diinlevie, lit Ktieiine I.anL'cvin. 1 1 rierrc Filiaii, I'J William Mnrrav. 1 Fraiii;ois \'all(''e, 'J Antoine Lemieiix, :! I.ouis Aiii,'cr, I d. 1!. Ilertrand. "i Michael Sii.tl, II I'Mward llendersoii, 7 iscph Hardy, >< W illiani Austin, ;• I'icrre Morin, 1(1 NarcisMi ( irenicr, 11 William Wi.hslead. This eviiUncc is not all a>nti(iilii/oi >/, one. ]>art of iinolher suicv soini' spatk oj posilni incroiichmcntf (nol nlhrrs vfencroachmenlt ciixonlitii: (o ilacvy's plan. (Si/.\ I). .■nuiiiilorr, iiiiiM jc rtur hi riviiTc I'li siiico noiirln'tlf'n le. .\'i inirliiiii nf KitstiT" I'Kiiii;!' is shewn ii^ lii'ini; rlidsso I'eau ►'111' !>' '■( ijiiin:! till!'. Jo 'iiliii;i' ill' iiiiTro dii II Hllll Olll-'St. Li- 1 la livit're I'litriiil *!i lai'f^ciir (iiuit i'l iii-isnil 11' ciniiaiil. IS rcaii jiisi|n'aiix IS li)iii.) Toiijiiiirs I yi\ iinaranto ans rnllt'rt hi llli'itir ifiG rlv IIi:mi is ri'|irf- aiiiiiil lir los lliau Ani;ii> Ml' \:.uM I. VA. I.s. (in^iii.r I. K.rlriicts from fviilrhir iiililiicnl In/ I'/aiiilijI ok niirii>ii/>/i hisso/ Jdrer Jii'diijiorf. V'ossL'l.s I ri'collof't rmild cniiu' ii|i to iIh' viit mill ilnni'. Il was iHTl'iTlly poisiliin tiir t>> il isiliaiLCo 1,'niiii at stoin; store ami it is my imiiressinn tlieydiil. At low tiilo. tlie lu'aeh iri'ls lif Natural rliaiiiiel not iiiivi iMe. li i\iT iiavi L'liM.' at lertaiii r-la','cs of I he tide as tar 1 have III) ilmilit halean coidd al liiLrh tide ^o In the mill. 'I'ldnk I haxc sei Kehociiiors at wiiodeii store. Uivi6ri' iiavii;alih' en lias des ijiiais de IS.'iL', el iiisi|irail moillili, dans les g ramies mers avee pellts liateanx. al VII lllViTliel- 1 le- lialeaiixa relidroit dil i|iiai ile ISol |)|| teiiips lie M. MeCalliim, J'ai VII m.iiiler el eharLrer illi iielil hateail a ras le liloiilill. lie mini temps la rivieie a ele iia\ i,;;ali|e ilaii s les glalldes lilers illS(|ll'ail lIllMllill pour IN. .Voiis eliaigioii^ a hrasilu moidiii aiix hateaiix. C'etail des haleaiix tiraiil eiiii| A six pieds d'eail. 1 111 tiiiip~ de M. Mri'alliim, le> hateaiix veiiaieiit ihari^er au moidiu eimi a six fois par aiime. Dans les i^raiides met- on peiii allerjiis.pi'a vis-a-vis le iiioiiliii avee ile.s liateaiix liniiit i.'f.ii.l.iiit iMiatre pieils d'eaii. Conime je le eompivmiis, la riviere allait parhnit ilepnis le ipiai lid !■". X. (iiniiix !>. I \v;i,H l;i» \i'r Del'einleiir.iil-prail ••slone ~liin ai eliar;.;e d la pierre au oiiai a liiveriie iles Ir-lr.l fl.v I'lainlilli .1. H. It.'i I.I ,-..u- lialeaiix lie 17 [iit'ds an N. I'l a liollte il i\iere iiaviiralilejiis'in an pres iii 1 I. iiiliii, dans le> Ltrandes mer:-. .Pai vu nno iruoletto :t eiiii| alls ileeharLrer an haiigaid de hois. .I'ai vii hivei'Her des haleaux vers le point Z. Il.ive Ni'en liateaiix taken up as I'ar as the mill. — I eoii>>iiler thi' river lieaiiport iiavinahle, ir nil as lirid:.;e. l/n; .«. . ;i ci'as. Av ri/nnri'! und hiiili on JJih uiiuitt's siilc mh IiHii'Ii-kI. j\i( A" l.ir np as hriil /„/.,//■ ///■/'.///I, Iwriil;/ Ihi-n //o'/'N ";/■• I', Miniir 111. Kiviere iiavi^'alde. de I'ai miviiinee moi-mC-me depnis ipiiiize a sei/,e ans, avec i .V.muiil.ur. ],,|,j,,,|,^ lii-ailt six pieils d'eaii. !•. Dllrini II Kiver lia\ igahle lip to mill at lii;.di tides. I'll II. .1. Hii.vv 1 1. KiviM- iiaviLCahle lo mill, have M'en lialeaiix ir.niiic up as tar as the hriilge. River has heeii used to convey grain loainl from the mill. hie lor small erall. -n.h as hateanx as I'ar as mill at higli tides. 1 nivself Kiver iiaviga have hi'oiight hateanx np a-- I'ar ilhin til'tv leet of mil avif seen hateanx a~ far up a^ ^-ar.len, a.ljoinimr >loiie ■>t..re. In exirctae high tide iniLrhl e-o nil hiudier. .■'^aiil haleanx eiiganed in lakuig grain to mill and eoiiveyanee ul I M lor .Mr. I» iielie>miv. W. Wurc l.'i. Kiver iiavlgahle to high water mark. Tides does not rise heyoinl ureh at turnpike II. lllaU III. iiiiUliir. Itiviere iiavigahle iiif-'inaii ehemiii dil Uoi, jnsiin'ail pout. J'ai iiavigiie la riviere larlont, en haul el en ha<, depnis viiigl trois an-;, avee les liatoanx ihari,res, tirant si.x pieils d'ean idiargeant de la pi. Tie el .In gram, jiis.pi en sei/o, ipiator/e eldix hiiit ple.U de larg.'iir. lS."il. ai ell lies haleanx do .1. II. I'.iiiin Riviere navigalile, el dans les gr.m, les m.'i'--, les hateanx veiiaieiil toiil pres dn nuuilin. lii-iciuliMir. On pent iluil'ger an inoidin. J'ai en le minilin douze a Irei/.e ans Arri:M)l\ l>. Cinilinncd. E.rtnii/s I nun rrulrnce adilucid by Dtkndiiiif on naviiitihlernxs of river. \\ 'ir .ijiaik o/ pusiltii vy's phut. Caiii.I.iinil.ly The river I'.eanporl is a small river hiil is navigalde al high water, to near the mill I. I'..nii.ily (',„. lialeanx, small schooners and so forth. It resemhios iho river !St. Charles in that respect m!11'i','',''' ,.i' only the last is much more roomy. ym-l..-.'. r. (iriMii.r-,'. Haleanx a 111, I . ..iinai>~ahee moulai.Mil in.-.iu'an houl den ha.- de remplacemenl de luou pere [\u\ ar(iciil pin ha- .|ne le ponll N 30 (Ml |];itc'iiilX .iiMilM'ilil iriiiulill. ,, ,iir„ux 1 Dmiis Irtiit iirtiiiil .li' liMivitMviiii lal.'iiii \'v»\ iiiuliliT .jir'(|il all (Kiiil liioii Imlfiiii ii lii\ .Tiio plus liu.H line A miiis .m |.cmniit iiisi'iinMl iillcr plus hunt, il y iiviiit lio 1 i^mi niitliHann'iil |.(>ui' ci'lil. Duns Ics ^'nniilc^ iniTS on [n'lit ninntiT in--'|U an |ii>iit. >].(''ri' ill' lialiniiMils inoiitcr JMsi|n'an P. Kili.iuT W Murrnv (SiijiUMl.) CMS. li\ILI.AK(ii:. i:i)\v. si'AN i;i,Y. I I Jliiiiri.i' Mar- cmix Tt. . . ,To n'aii.iinais vu ill' L'l'i'K'tli-iiin lialranMinaniMini , , ■ i - (/i.'lnTi.'i liari!.'aril il,' I'l.Tn' i" stoiu' sloiv") i f .l.'iliai.ir.'r un |.i.ni' i-liarLici-. Kivu'Co I!.'aii|ioit i.aii.- iiM'^' iiiivi'i-alili' iM'nilanl li's ui'anili's inc'i's. Mni-nniin' j'ai nmnli'' mim liati'un .insi|n a im mi- l.,.iii-iir>i.i.r ,,|,„,,',|„,„, vis-a-vis .liriiiiinliii. 11 \ a •-'•: mi J:! litis nil.' ..'ct'lrll.' a ,li'' ji'l.V par la liantu •■'mt''!l'u \K iM.'i-ilans li'.ianlin ilii D.inainliiir. ' I'lmlaiil IS ans j'ai imii-nirni.' ini.lite uiiu viiii,'tuino cl.' /.■ii.l.iir, jmr- ,,,,,.,]l.s ik' liiiis fii (aicU-V liniiil iliii-s pii'il^ cl linil |miihi.'s ircali. .,i|u.- J.- |iin- HIliH lllll-ll' I'l- liiHiitli'iir ilc- viiil |i» riln* ce l.riiri'H. ,lc n'lii jaiiiais vn ilc liatcaiix nn iincunc iintrc i-pri'i' ili' lialiiiu'iits vcnir an moilin pmir ; (It'cliari.'i'i-iiinliar',"'''- Dans li.> i^nmiU's ini'is nn Imlraii pnnrait y nioiitcr. j IJiviT naviiiiililisU liiL'li tiili-^, vt-si'ls Willi InaiU vriniTally taki' a I'ull ilay to iinloml aiul :| ■ "'•'''''■'■'".V ''"' luivi.-alilo piiriio-i's. [,.„,, iiatfuuK surh a;t arc u-cil lor ^'lain cannot now l'ci up [last the point /,. r,.i. iioti'i.T ' " ""'"■ Width of river used to ho sixtv to seventy (eel imd is now fontni.led hy wharf of Is'^'. (). lie-Mt'.i wiijii-f is hiiill where vessels used to lie. If two halcaiix came one would have to wail li the other had passed, \ haul ^u avaiit Ic ipiai ilc Is.V-' llllllll 1 Calliiin M. 1. Aii|-'ii« ilolialit M. (lui;ii.iii i:i. (itri.ux 1. U. tllais II. La ri'coudc du iiuai I'sL I'ati ilai le iiiillicii (!<■ la riviere. I,c .piai de \^:>-l houvlie I'cuU-c'v lies li,ilcaii.\ et ties haliim.'ui.- - Navi.iiatioli p.is-ifadle ;n llliinti'' (III ftTMU , moil Imti'iiii II ' I'l'iiii siilli^aMii'iit ■I iiiiiiitt'r.|ii>'i|ii all Uivirii^ l!('aii|M uiiu viiii'tuiiiP ill' II' an iiK' il'ii |i(iiir lav to iiiiloail unit .1. II. F.irtiu 1,1' Dcrcinli'iii a \in* iiii tiors di' laiivit'iv, II a lioucliu hi rivirif pftr xon qiiiii lo '-'■ ilmii!{iimuiit It I'uti't'ci lit livii-ro il'iin iumn. {.>■ '|iiai tji^iii', <,u iloit j^Guor. I I Al'l*i:\l>i\ /;. ConliiHinl. EvUknce adilucfd hif Ifefendant on /uk u-hiir/of'l(i!'}2 lieing an obstruction lo mmgahk- n<:.is of riirr. n (iirous I. .Ii' iliH (|iiL'iliiii.'* I'l'lat iii'tiu'l ill' la riviiTo iiii liaiiau ]mmiI niofitiT Jiihiiu'iiii iiont. On no iii'iil pas virer nil liiitcaii daiw lo limit il'i'ii liaiit liatraiix. ]<■■* viriT, los iIchiciiiIiv, Ic.h liivcriior roinnii' aiipanivatit. sy\(H\sis ' liiali tides. Of Eriiliiicr ill iijijiiiiili.r II ii lo itririgahknesn of I hi: rinr Hi (tii/nii/. ]-\,n. AilAINST. WHiK. i;i.v. iihslnirtiiin lo llit l'f,'roiiiiil or hifhli river iisfions I'ni !■ c'rs; irop srITc rivii'i'c M' tioir I Dailiil MrCalhllii. •_' l.llllin (iaLTMOII, ;! !•'. X. ciiioiix, 4 liOMH AiiiriT, ■| .1. H. Iti'itian.l. II Miriiai'l S"(ilt. 7 KilwanI jloii'ln-i'ii H (l.'.irirr l!i,"cl, !l Williiiiii W'ai-r, 10 ISciiianiiii l'>hii~. 11 .\iis:iH M.'l»"ii:iM. IJ .1. I'., Foitiii. (Siixii(*«l. 1 jlavid tiii-iiiix, ■J Maiii'iri' Marniux. Vl\S. I',AILL\K(JK. i:i)\v. stam:i.y. M'i'i:\i)ix i\ atouiix. piiiiil 'A. Uy wliarf of iNfl I iiavr lo uiiii Ii i hal piirpoMi'. Ill If ipiai 2 would have tin.: I'IK'ct of prevcntiiif,' till' fri'i' disi'han:!' of the' riv.'r and >lop or retard tlio mills hy havU water iii the case of Hoods. Wharf of l>i">- has ixreallv reduced the value of the property as a mill. DefoiulanI'.-' w harf lif I'^.'i'J a.-i a iicc-e.;.^arv iniisenilen ei- would rotaid ri'tlnv of lido mill niav hav heeii r.'l.irdt d i>s|„rially when tide is recedini;. I' ^.el[Ml I. ,|f jiiiisi' inii' If I'l liiiili'iir, |iiif cnii 1)11111 ili' l"'.'iJ, i> liiit lin't ail I)i'iiiiiiiili'iir: I'l |iiir •| ;'''""" I'"" |{\|i|Miit A l'i'mliiiiii'lmr<' ill' hi ri\iiT(' i|iii !*(' ii'diivi' lni|i rtroili', Irn I'lnix iiiitlciit lM'aiuuii|i 'iVI. I'V'ilr i'i lilll* ill' Iflll|iH A ili-'ri'llilli' III rivilTi', |illl' III HIH-iliti' rilll-ir. (,'ll lldlt liter ill' la Vllli'lir nil I \ ilJiiii. ii ,\|iiiiliii. ill' III' tloniu'iai-' jiiis If iiK'iiir jiiix (lonr Ir inniilin n iiirsi'iit. 1.1' |)i'iiiaiiili'iir a i HI I'.T.Iu ini'ii 1,111, (i;,,.),!,,, i|(iiiiipiairt'^ pm nii'imii iiiiv I'li ix vnum! '!■■ la riiiiTf ili'aiiinirl i| imr iiii'innt cUililm I irii III I till ailX I'llllX ill-' lliairr». I,.. (imiliT,-.. II iiDiii-rail HI- liiii'i' i|iii> Ii' i|iiiii I'lti |iiii' k- Ui'li'inliiii' iii l^c'. auiail I'l'tli't, |ii'iiiliiiil Irs liMii. .Ian- jj|',M.,i'M I'ailX, ill' rlillssi'l' li's railX -111' Ii' (/• >liiinr sli il'i' "). I hiii^ h: ['his ,'lriiH, ,l''l' linilir fl'.r \7ri"iid"'\r'^'ii unlj' liiiil.-> ijiiiilr, l'nil''i'< ■>■• ri;i(,/', la r'uii'rr v'u'tii rrii|i|ii'i' li' I'lin ihi '|iiiii ili' I'^.'rJ I't Tail ri ImiiIi'I' I'l'ini '""'" ' liii immliii I't ivIiii'iK'i' K' Miciiiliii. i,i' i|iiai lait tm-l an iiicHiliii. lii'aii ili' la 1 Initli' (ili' la rivii'i'i'i I'laiil la iilii-i lnrli' v'u'iit tnMiln'i' ilaii'* li- raiial ilii iiiniilin i'l ilaii^ li"< irraiuli'i iiii'i-* i,'ii I'l'luiili' I'raii iliiiiH li' raiiiil iln iii.iiiliii. .li' iir iluiiiu'rai-' pa^ Iv iiii'iiir iiri\ i|H iiii|iaiM\ ant |iiiiii' li' tiiniiliii. |iarii'i)m' I'l'iiu ili' la rliiili' iiiiil tiMp. ,. j^ (;,r„„v ('nlllllli' la I'nirl'i', A 111 ^nl'lii' lilt ral'allln I llill, -I' trilllVl' l''(l'i>ill', jo |li'll.^i,' i|t|i' ;■■■ "" li' iiiiai ill' 1"<-'|J l"iil a\iiir Irll'.'! ill' I'iiirr I'liinii'l' I'l ir'HitliT I'l'iill ila'i-i li' raiiiil ilil liiniirni. .Ir |ii'iisri|iu' ilaii- la liaiit.ur ili'^ ran'v i.a iioiiiTail ilimt la rniie ilii iimiiliii. .1. lli«lriii-- /,, Diimllrlilll' lll''l llil III l>*."lll, 7''i .M ;/'.//i Initio 'ii'll.i mi ■/'"li li I'l Iflrnlt ,1,- rjili 1/1' Is,",:.', iinii-.n. ilil ,.,l f, r'I'l •li'liuil'liir d .-IH llllilltill. I'lllll'l -. ' •' 1 • I 1 <• , .„,„„ii />(/,v /,.,■ ,/)',).v,».VJ, rt ill. ■iimir ilii ,'ii I'll I'rlli'l ill' lairi' aiTi'Ui' |i' iiiniiliii, i;a tail tn'iii|M'r la rmii' ilaiH I I'liii. ilaii.s li'^ ltumhi'-i l>,ii,;iii.l'in. ,'.„|x, , 'I iiii.ili'i-i' Ir 11.1,1 '.111 iiiiiiiriii. I>aii-. K'- lia— I's I'liii:;, Ic .|imi ilr l^/i-J nr tail aui'iin iiiiil. I I, ,,_|, 1,1' iiuai lU' Is.'i fait iinViThi i-mn' 'laii^ I', an it I'liiin'i'ln' ili' travailliT li' linmliii. ',,■,,,, I i.',, !,,. ii|,,iirni a an-i'li'- [.Ir.- -."n.iil il.|.iii> .|ii.' Ir .|iiai il.' |s,",J ol lifiti. ('0 i|iiai I'aiiHi: ilr- Miihll.'iiiiiil- il'i'aii. Wliai'l'si'i'iu-i 111 liavr liii-ii Imill I'T tin' .xi'i'.'-- |.iir|iiisi' nf aiiiinviiiL.' tin' I'laiiitill'. W'liail' 111' l>''i'- i-ail-ii's liiii'k wati'T nil uli.'.l. 'I'liink iiiill iimv «.,illi trniii //V, l^iiuilrnl I" ,„„ llr.ii-iiiil i'""ml.< !'.■«, //■■in I:/;; ,r/,'iri''i' l^-'.J -'" ■ A"". I , NVIiarl'ol' is.'ij faii-n'i a ri... of vvaiiT in -'r.ain tVniii iiiill-niri' llip.iuiii',' ivatiT Ka.'k lOihi'i'li's'' aii'l liiilliiii,' \\iii'il ill wali'i'. I w. mill 11. it imu ..:iv,. -11 Ii t'.ii'lln' mill as luloiv wliaif ':'''''*• was iiiiilt. i,V|, iii'l' (if is'iJ /."■- '/'iri- ■'■.'''/"'/"■""''"'"/■'' /",'/'' /''.''iT "!»'■ /Vrv/»/',v it iiiiist tlii'iiw Km k !|V,'..ri;r' wati'i iilii'ii till! uali'l' will, 1. 1 i|.i ii'il kii.nv that '>n.Ii a tliilii; lias ii.'i'iiri'il. Tin; I'liiTi'iil miw is 1. 11! llii' -anil', as it lia.l a -j '■ "\' Imnili'i'.l l.'i'l In rim ovi'i', l.i'foi'i' llm wliarf wa- Imiit. 1 liavi' s.'Vi'ral liinos sciii mill -l.i|.i...l li lia.k waliT liy fri'slii'ts siiici! wluirf ,.|ls,-,J. I |. |.„^,;„ ,r,. ,T,,i- ,|i|,. j.arlr 'ina. ill' [-.".^Irau l..'nl Ln'l liirii avoir ransi; iln iliiiiiiiia;ri', II ,. ......,■.., ^ , ,^, I'll.' f.'i-. il \ a iitialri' .111- .|n.'j'ai vi !,■ in mini arri't.'. ,| 111 |n'ii'.i' ijiU' r i'l:iil lo .inai i|. ■• I ■ 1*.",J .|ni '.'I'liail la ilrlinil'ln-'. I .^ ,, S'lTs Mar^ l^"'^,i'ai \ni- iiih' .i.-.i. '!• ^i.i. ■ ■■• !■' i"''"it '^. ''H'l''' ">' '' '^' H'" fai-a:! ,.,.,ii,,,it.i' I'l'.in an iiiiMilin. .Ii' >nis i.n-.nu' ii'i'tain ijiir Iran itail j lii- lianu' an ili'ssiis .jiijui ili'ss'ins iln I'lliit / par la illiTin' ili' irlari'. Waliriii Wi'-tiTii rliaiiiii'l of MrC'arlliy's i.iTs.'iil iliaiini-'l I'anii.it llnv as it iliil in IT'.'-' M. >...!! 11 .\\. Liirui- IT it 111' wiiai I'lil Is.VJ. ) K.Tni<„ii \Vliarfofl>^.'i- linill iirniss till' rivi'r turn- inrrmt, ami il passi'- uvi'i- tlir mill ran' an. 1 ■|-, vZTuiU k.i'i- liark-wali'r npiiiitlu' wlii'i'l. Amillu'r nli-lrni'li.ni inridi'iit on cxi-tciu'e of wharf i- i„iil.riiiiiv..l ,||,,, j, ,.,,im,.s ,',,,,1, „;' „'r. 'riii'i'i' wonhl In' no 1 ihsl mil ion at all to tin' Wiirkiiij; ot'tlii' inili. vi'-ir-'iaWtlir' if I'lii' rivor iliii not I'ross ovrr I'haiiiii'l of ihi' lailrare. I'or iiislani'i' if a portion of tin' wharf i.uiMiuif ..f of 1S."'2 WL'fi' riit away ami till' llooil wali'r from rivi'r ll.'anporl niaili- to pass tliroii.u'li thai 111.- «liiur uf „|,i-ninir no oh-tnii'tion woiilil oi-riir. .lainsnf i.i' lan-nl rivrr to lir like a ratial with '"""• l,.,k-, i^u'h. jam ki'i'pin,'; till' wati'r hark. Wati-r was nin.'li liiichrr at fool of tail-rart: mi ,(.-..,.//.' ■■I'juiiif III' ii'e ; llinii tiiluirlln nlmrl' ii/l^-'<'2. l.|,.r,,. i;„|,;. .1,. n'ai pus (.oniiaissuiiri' ipu' ih' nion temps la riviere avani le .|iiai ile \^i'i2 ait jainai- liiill.- I'J. I'te Lieiii'i' par la •j:\m ( '. HltllDt '.'II. j,i ,'aiial est Imp p tit el e es I le .iiiai 'le 1- oil I'tn pi'^clie lie (losepiiilre lean a 1.1 ;:i 'iiiiiinli'Mr: rt |iiir m ,1 Wall. r«"ii Jlrltl'llt lic'IIUl(lll|l .'1 ■ 1I41 III Vlllrlir 111! iif |)i'liiiitiilriir ii t ort it [iiii' l:ip|iiMt i t.. MrK'IIIIrl ■"iK't, IH'llilllIlt Irs ■nil, j'lii hiiiiii' ili.r i 1- Kr x'l. •11. rill.', iliiii" l( jiliiM st'oiidro. .1. Iliirl\ '.'1. liiit ri'l'iHili'i' I'l'iiii • la rlilltl.' (ill' l;i Ic's i.'raiiili'-i liM'i'-" ri\ i|iriiil|i:iiM\ ant id', JO |ii'ii!-i,' i|i|i' i-aiiul liii liiiiiiliii. V ,/, .•,/,// ./, i>.-,j, i|imi ill- l^.c", I'l ilaiiH li'.-i vrru^Mi's luiiii^ 'vat.'i' liaiU ill as lirl'iiif uliail' : must tliniw liarU rcij. Tin,' 1,'iirri'iit IV tin- \\liiirt' \va- slu'ls siiico wliail' umaj;i'. .'(•'('■tail li.' '|uai il'' (1 'A (|ui lai-a.; ilU' all ijiru'i \- a-^ it iliil ill IT'.'J the mill ran' an'l ti'iii'i.' Ill' wliai-t' i- ii'UiiiL' dl' lilt-' mill. nl'tiiMI of tlic ulaiil pass tlirc)Ut;)i tlia! like a caiiiii wiili III ol' tail-niro on (' ISoJ ail iaiiiai- iilrc li'aii a 1.1 Iri' WHS jallim. •! 'HI" II 1^ I il|i, ami iitiiscil VMili'i- III III. ike ~i, |. .«»/.(■ Ilii ,ilfiirl'i'/\x'r2 Hh i./w/./.y, '/'•'' ■■i-- < a. ml nliii'li I'liiisi's tin; wiiti'i' to fisM wliirli iln'v > tloW OVCf. Il'l' inllis alioM' llirlltiiilH'il Nli'l'i' ol. olMiuili iN.-.it, ■ I'li'vioiis t.> tlii'«liail'..l I'>.'i'.', wall ilia. I ' 'It and iiUcwlKri' fiiiiliiT il M mill ttiii'i'l. / K./o f'lri'Difii'i iij' ll'i chill) I III II liii-vfrr h|mi « !■:. T- Kl.i til. 1- :.. ■ (i. |luilli'%ii'l villi: till' I'laiiililt'. H ■om fire hiiiiili-iil 1" U I Woiki il al makimr Imlis in tin' in' to asnitaiii win ii' uuti r whs Htoinu'il tliiil wiMit liaik ii|ioii llii' wiiti'i' wlii'i'l tliiiiiii.'li tin' iiii'aiis of thai wlmrftliat is I'l'os'iiiiu' tlm I'iviT. l!y mraiis ot'tliat wliarf watir ll.ivv- ovrr into t.iil fan' iiinl llii'oWi lun'k watir ii|iiim tlm wlnil. l.('i|ii.u il.' IN.'J -otioiisi' 'ilin'', i|ii'il I'foisi' lafi\ii'ro rii laiftii' I't l'i'ik' |iar U' ri'tfi'ii- Mliirlil ijil |ia--ai;r ili I rail. .(/'/'/; V/>/.\ /. Ciniliuncil. E.rtriiils I'orin irii/iiirr itililiirnl hif Ih limli i/f, iis li> his irlmrl' nj \K\'l hiiin' tin ulixlnic- I hill III till- ii'iiikiirj^ lit llir null. Wliaifiif H.'iii il.'i - Hot olistiint llow of wiiti'i-, ami i- m'iM's>ai'y to |irolrrt hi- |.i-o|ii rty. I,i' i|ii,ii ilr l"«iJ n'a iiiilli imiii ii'lr.'.i In rlnaial ilr la 1 i\ ii'ii' an puiiit Z. .Ii; m^ siiis {.a- |>oiii' li' h'.iil I'i'i.i, I'i'i'i rrj'ii' I ji:irl''il (V in .■'ilii y»f/.- A I'liif.i ili: In ra'irii. 'I'lin wliarf ol' l""''! J lias no I'tfi'i't nitli mj-arl to tiil.'s ami is lii'iiclli'ial. if any ihiiii; : l.iii I il.iiil sii'i :i 11;, III./ 1,1 .«.i /(■///, i-i;/'ii;l 1.1 fri-l.i . Ii i- |.o-,'ih|.' ihal iliii-unj fri.-hh.- uliarf mav iliui'k ami ifuiit natural riini'iit ol Wain. It a|.|ii'ai> 111 mr lh.it u h.u I' ol' ls."rj I'liiinot ii'tanl I'lh of li.lr. Il.i not lliink llial u hai'f of Is.V.' laii lot -loiins or tri'avi'l up miil-fan'. .s) AO/'.s/.s U) criilt'iirr in Apprnilii F us to irlinil ni XS'i'J I'rum lUi ulinliuctivn lu flic worhiiii; III llii null. 1 Daiiii'l.Mi alliim. •J Anvils M.Konalil. :! I'lilwaril .loin-. I I'inni' Si'irnin, •"> liOiiis (ill-nil T, li Louis (iairnoii. 7 K. X. Uiioiix. H .losi'ph I'n-alil, II Louis AiiLTiT, 10 .1. I!. Ui'itraml, 11 Mi.'harl Sioli. \X I'aliiik O'ltiicn, lo I'Mwanl llrlnli'isoii, 14 .1. I!. Koniii, 1"> .\iiilii- Matliii'ii, III l''raiu:ois Naikaii, 17 Ailolplin iairiio. 15 .lohii Fi'l'tcnssoii, I'.t I'iorri' Koliilailli.'. •JK ('lis. Kit HIT, 1\ .loliii Waliisoii, ■I'l Lawri'ini' McKi'iiiia. ■Jo I'alrii'k Ki'oiiirh. ■J I Josipli llaiily, •J."> Maiiiiei.' Maivoil.\. AiiAlNsT. 1 William Aii-liii. •J I laviil I iiioiix, :l William Wiikstoud, I K. T. Klrtilmr, .") (ii'i'ahl l>iiiik'vii', Tin' I'viilcmi" •• for" is mostly to tlio I'f- I'l'il iiat tin' wharf of 1S.')» is an obstrui'tioii, not al low wati'raml in llm onlinary state of tlio rivnr hnt linrini; liigli liilis ami fn.'sln'ts. 'I'hn I'viiloiice ''aiiaiiist" ilocs not contrailirt the sliiU'iia'tits of tlm witiiossfs " For" Init mi'i't'ly talk of wharf of ls,">J with mtjaril to its I'll'i'i'l 01. iliL' onlinary tlowof llio river ami il.s olistriietioii to tlio clili of the tide. Maiiriee .Mareoiiv onn of the witiicssos adihn id by Uefi'iidaiit IS entered in the list. " For" us liom what he says (see extraet) it may bo iiilerreii that in freshet time if wharf were not there water would How on unob.slruel e.l. (Sij^uod.) f ( HAS. nA!LS.AK/\ f. liinel I'"'" 1' E.iliiicls ftt'iii fiiiiiini iiilihind hi/ I'liliuhfl an In ulniiis hihinil Stmii tiloir.iiinl t liiiil i>f J'/iiiii/iffK irliiiij itiiil iiM to iilis/nirfinti nl lurrr (itdu/it/rt, iiuiiUnl Ih, t,. Auir-r I. Ml iihH r .")J. |'i out i>l6 miitv« III iiMiiit III! lip 1 /*/'/; \7>/.\ a. ('i>iiiiiiti(i ji iiiliilil nil llu ihjirl. \\ Aii-iiii I, I ri'Miiukril 11 i(miiitily I'l iimiiriiil -imn' In (liaiiiii'l nl {■i\'ii' o|i|mi,ii.' | if I'l.iiiilill > wliail. A |Hiilinii I M'liii il'u liiiiriiiiil l.illi'ii I. ) till' Im-i' llii-i'ii'f. I'll, llll'jill llilVi' im'illil'i I'liiiii lii'l i.iiit \ aiiil .ii \M'i h litllliil - I', II.' I'ji l'*l."i line |iiirlif ilii xii'iix mill' llu liiiiiL'iir ili' jiiiiir ii cli' ilriiinjii' il ri-li.ilii-. In'- vii|lllli;i''' I'll Dill rti''ii'li'i'- nil pil'il- ihl mill" .'l in-' IrnlU'l rnlllllit IllnV" hi livii'Tr. i'r" pil'll'i'- i'llll-"'4 la mi ii's a inli'Vi'i"'. >l ai Ira II iiiur II III ri'lialii'. .Il' 11 HI pa- VII liiiiilii'i' li's \ iilaii.i.'1's i'l lie mi'w jia« mII v iiviiil ii rrmli'iiil nil rlli'-i lint tiiiiil ill' la I'lTi' -.'"111'. .A Id, rrii'H iii'riiil il'iirin!' , {I,' Ini- ^,llr (»ii rliiii-i--.iiit |.ariiii Ir- Miliiii!,'r,s la iiii illi'iiii' pirrii' puiir ril.alir li' miii-. rai'tii' llu null' llu siiiiii. sliiii' il I'll' ilriiidlii' i I I'.'laiti'. .1.' I 11' i-.i|ilial- pas Ir Irl'l'rlli an pi. lis llu iiiiii'. .Il' III' 1 avais pii* vii aval it il avnii- I'll' V Iravaillri'. ,/■. Il, III, III ni ,;.ill,i l,r I- I,., iffl'imi,.^. On (I'lail Irs rl.aii. Iiim - ilu liaiii.Mi.1 ilr ].'nTir all lias ilii 11,111'. I. 1 li. I >l.- pi. Ill - r~l ill' i.liM'WT I'l all llu I .'Ir ilii P. I. ml nil. II ili'iimli-sant paili.'ilii Mriix mur .lu I. - viilan'.,'i's tnmli unit an pin ir. II V a I'll ."ii) pi. 'lis ill' I. III'.; ili- mui' ih' ilrlmilii' siir ilmi/.i' piiils ilc liaiit.'iii' rl II' 111' sais |.as .pii'llr liaiilrlir Illl lariri'Ui' lie viilanijis il v a\ail. iiix I'l ili'iiiii' il I'pai.ssnii' iiriifti lit /I'll I' Il riiimii/, ,/ .irnil ,1,1, I 1,1, il.^l, Ifli'l inli I iilll in I till l.lil '•U'ji i"',ir '/■'"■ .■Ii; ,I„ /"" /" Ir.iiiniil iiliis I mil i/iii !', Il' Sills (111 I il a I'll' illl' ili-s viil lll^'r- il'llli'l'.' I.' •■ st'illi' stcir Inn..; llu liaii','ai' ili- pini'i'. .!.■ iir (lis pas ipio i;a I'.iisait n'la il.ins .'- lia-M'r- i\iri.' .'111. lit (III I'aiix ma:- .plan. I li's caiix I'-liiinit ;;i'iis.-i's. I.cs vnlanu'i's I'mpi'.liinl I riiu lii- tuuilin' nil mur ft jrllnii 1 .ail sill- la pi'iipiii'li'' llu I'.' Illl. In II'. .Ii' iii' rniinais lini ili's lii'iix .Irpiiis :;i aiis. 's pii'i'i.'s (Inline Ic liaii'j-ar i|i' plri'i'i' t''tai.'nl In avaiil L' I. nips ,lii | i.'ii.iin.l.'i.r. Kll.-- it I'li'ji'tic- la p. I l.-s Imiiiii.-- ipii rrp.iiai.iil !.• Ii.iii.rai'.li' pi.'iT. llu t. mp Mr. (;.,r.l. .II. .illl-. fU rii;(MViii*<- I'll- All i.is llu •• st'illi' -I. Ill .site ill- la ii|i''s. lit.' Iiati l.t Ipll'Ipll's 111 111 - il I l.s pi.'ii'i - lint ill' J. In-s prnii'iiant il iiii an.i.'ii -iil,i'.;i' ii-ipi.' If I >niiaiiiliui' a a.iiuis la pi'.i|iiii'l.'' it nmui ur I.' I y in.iii pas (!.■ p la. I. 1 pri'iiiii'i'i' luis i|ii il y I'll I I, IU,.ICI. 111. .1 It Itir Inui.i a. In ri.iiiilifT'-. Ill- |.l..\ ,11 ih.' II. i;ui. I. ,\.l. l.iini.' iviiiiiii.li-iir. loi's.pii' 11' mur llu liaiij;ai' ill' piiiii' a ilrli'iiili'', il pnil y av.iir ipiatm/.i' nil ipiin/i' ans i|,. Il' -iipl Iiii'ii ipic |i' ilil mur in.iii I'll' mini' par Trail, llini i-iTlain .pii' - il v Mp i,,\i K hkh'.i 1l' Ml. avail pas .1.' pii'iri aiirii'iiliniii'iil. II y a.l.' ."iillait I. Ills I I.' I. .11- .III I laiiLTar .1.' l.'h: li.'iri' I'l'au i-..iilnail k' Imiu' il.' Iiaii','ai' .'..mm. t a\aiii 'III ii'.'s itii lian 11' II ai pa- \ ' pi.UI la ai.iiit ai.'iit rt.' nil I.' n.'ii -,- la r. liil'liiii.iilV- .In a.'iplis 1.' iii.iiilin. Avail! riii-.pii-ilinn ilii 1 inn.in.lnir l.-au .lii canal ijii mniilin .'niilail p. mi 'II nil.' pal lii' !.• \,,{fj: llu li,im;ar ilc pi. ri.'. ,ivr kmiun pr.iiii-.- I'lir ni"ii' than lu.-nly i.ai-. W'li.ii lil'-l I -aw tin' pi, ami I'll a l;'i man\ i cars alln'u anl- M.it.r li..iii null i.i,' ll.iu.'.l al.inn- illl' ri ar wall ..i si,.n.' -l.ir.-. Within lliri'i' y.ars, -Inn.'- liai.' I ii put .iml ailili.'ially in ram:, il li.'liin.l Iniii' -till'.', ami lr..iii lim.' tn tin iinlill ai-'piiri .1 p, Tl II' -all! -li.n, ilnvi' ualir tn liilinilaiii - -illl' aiul .•l.-lrml llnw ..|' Mali'r rnuii tail rai'i', .\rrniilinj;- i" mv iili-n'Villi.jlis ul' till' Inr.llili, I li.ilil llial llir -tniii' slnro is itsrlf all I'licl'i.ai'liliii'lil uii III'' I sM-r. '//. -/"IK ■■/■, I;, I, l.ii.U hf. J. I , r, III, mill ■■ Uii .■/,'■ Ill' ll,i /,!■ HUM ^ jifi rii)ii< I,, II,, 1,11, 1, 1:,, ■! 'All..;/. I il.i lint lliiiili iluii til, II' was mn naliii.il hank li.'liiiiil till' .-Inin.' -li Ur nil wliii.'li tin- slum- wi'ii' plar.il. ■iiu/ior/, iHi iiliiit Htl'l'f) I'! IIOIH |ioui' ^iiiilinrcr li' IC ell' pirllr, .■ |p.l-i i\f |illh '■. Ui'lilllMili'lir I'l ill' ,1 :i\ aiit nil ii|H . I iitnrt t»ni» I" 111 Mr. .Mr( 'alliiin 4 titni', wiiliT ri"m iiiillriH I! riMi (joiti' cIoko Id tlm rear wall ni tho iitonn dtiiri'. Witliiri tliri'i' vi'in'", u ■ iiri Inml of two ot -luiic-. Imvi' Imcm (iliui iI Im'IhikI llic' -tiiiii' *tii|i' ciiii^iiij; ill"' wiiirr Id run ililli'ri'iitlv iVuiii wlmt it iljil lu'lnii'. 'I'ln' sioiict I iillililr Id, iiri' In'twciii uii|i) (ihfriif- lliiii luiiisi'd lliinlnj itr. 'I'lir \\illll'-^> -1 nil liolll ^-illC"* li;jri ' ;< !■ l.ihc. lillV ill',' liiTIl -irll In Inn. I -Imii "liiri'. Till' I'lVi'c'i lii'iiiir iiiM'iirilliit; to («ini ilimw il.i' rivi'r uvrr lo iln' 1 1, ii'inl.u:!' ■ -i'li' iir iiilirni|il lln' Mow "f walir Iroiii tailriici'. fSii:n<<|. V |Miinl ^' mill .i' I liclwi'ili liliilirl- • il rrl.iili.'. l-i- ('•IT. Cl'.- |iil'll' jl'VI'l'-l. J'ili li i 111* H'il y in- nil .1 './ il'llfuif I I:' ' rcli.'ilir 11' iiiur. 'il-i li' Irrriiii ;ii| lit nit III III rill//, )' /•; |iirl'l(' nil \t,is ilil iil>:iirnt nil {ijriU U cK' llillllrlir rl 1miii.'i'< il y aviiil. I r,"". i\ in - ■ ■ ' ij , I'ilUN lii.i; - <|il:ll>i| II llillr ct j.llrlil I llll'-. li'lllMD'li'l.r. j'iiir- iil.' Mr. i;..r.|,>M. ii'H -.il,i-.;i' Mir 11' Ir rl llli llir |.nl|| \ 1 11 ;i III I'l-l II iiniii/c ;in^ ill' IM-Illill 'lUi' ^ il \ ■ • li;llllJMr riiiillllr I/' llli-r- I'l I'l .1 ■ l'.iii:nii|iMir n,' Miliii I'l'iiliiil I'oiir -au till' |iii r •■ ;■ I III' ri'ur uiill ni :ii iiiiiuiil lu'hiiiil 'I'hi- .■^iiiil >l.iiif. I. .\rc-oriliiiL'' I" nil ('iirrNv. si.w i:m:v i/'/7;.v/>/.\ //. i'.riili IHI iiililiiiiil III/ I'litUilitiiiii (il'iliiiilioiis riiiisiil III liiil-rtiri' iiiii/ nii llii luniMtiiin 1)1 Ihi' jiiiiitl I' hilifirn llii rhiiiniilof nnr iiikI Imnr i ml i'l liiil-nirr. A/sii "lin- II IhllllltllS I lilll III I'. II. I i/.i |.i,iiir,i,i -ii r.iiiv .|ii.i !,■ i|ii.ii ■!•' !■■'■- •• i,ii' ■ ,iii-.' 'ii|i' iIjih I.'- i^i'miiiIc- i';iii\ .'lli'-i > .i'iii|i;ni-iil rr,i|i|irr .■'iir li' ■' Mmu' -imi . I \„, . , ■.'. 1,1' ijiiiii ill' I'^.'i^ r;iil-i- iiii i-i'iiin'l :ri I p. ml ill .■ iiial ilii in mini. • i raiii;i--i' Ir -a Mr rl Irs ^' '" L'ravoi>.. I I. Illlllliti Ml. .1 II lut I a j.lliKli-* I'll i'l il"'i.'larr lo rillial (III lli.iillin. Iillli> on a ilrL'illi'i' li' rnlirt ilr la roilr ",;""'■'■, '" (llir 'liali 1. I,r i|iiai ilr l''*.VJ a riinsr im rriiioii an limit (111 lanal dii nioiiliii rt a raiim.-sc i'i'i"'v'!!i''ili"'' '" "alilr cl irraviii^. |,rs i;n.<-r~ r.inx I'aiHairiit rrinprir dr \iilanL.'r-( cl ilr v'ravirr Ir canal dii I." !■ ■-■I'l- iiioiiliii, iiiciiir avant 1 iistriirlioii ilil i|iiai, iiiai~ ili'l'iii' |r i|uai |i' inoiinlrr |ii'lit colli) ,i I HI ijiii \i hail riii|ili-,rn Ir raiial ilu lu.iillili. |, m ,, I I.,. ,|i|;,i ,lr l-^.V.' rriiv.iyr Trail i|ni malice Ir- Imv- dii • "ir liu 1 ), in.imlriir. ^1 ,,,,,,,;, Klinv 111' water ill (liaiiiirl oliiiir(' wliarl'rl' l>i"i'J i< iMt al.lr to How ^trai;j'hl on a- il 'li'l lu'lmv. take- a null riiuiid and llirn ^'or- -lrai'.:!it, dou n. 1'. K.,„i..li 111 .Vrriirdiiii; to my lvniiulrd:;r it \\ .i- ip-mi ir. ■ -- iiy I" ■ nl au .ly tin- i r I'lMm tail rarr .,| liil'liiiiiiiiv - ill ,|ivii|i^r. 'I'lir jlrrrndanl iirvrr -au 111'- lakr -Inn. , lii.ni 111- -i'lr and ihrnw tlirln on ilu- 1 1 Mnii'y\l.."i'.'i!' I'i.iintiir- sill.'. I wi.rlv.'.lat I'oi.t ot tail 'arc !•.■ i-Mi- "i' tic arriininlaHon nl iniM-and I ilun'iiii 11.1 u'l-avrl, raii-rd l._\ tli.' wiiai'l' .'l' 1>.''_'. ■' l' \. ,„,„.„„ 'I'ail rarr lia- not lirrii i liaiii^rd ill any way. Mill rarr l.y .an-a' ol wl.aii .d l-.VJ lirromr- 4 'I'liiii'i'ii'iT" lillrd np, Irvrl with lo|i olliaiik and lliavlwoikrd ill llirlail rarr to clean (^nil -and ami ;| '■ ' "■ Mi-av.-l raiiM'd l>y trr-li.'t-. No .-l.iiir-' u< rr ever init al tli" liollom ol'tlir poinl I'. .1 /'/*/; V/>/.\ // Coiiliiincd. Eriiltnai iiiUwid l«i il" !>■ I'lii/niii. H.. nol think whail "I !''•'- 'an i 'i' .■ i"i. ill iiiiii I. r .H(! r. MnltilH' -. .1-' lra\iull"' A III itiurtit'f pour li- 1*1^ tVli"lt'iir. ,l,iu.t I Inly :i. n'lu-\ .'t. l.ivtt ill one kI" In trri(]aiitH liDii (f. (■IfllUT, h, ,)l^ Kui:4 i-Il n^rtllvai^^■ tii- ti-nto uvfi- If Itriiiatiil'Mr - ](i-li\t'-ii<' ..f DctViiJalits h.'iiiiin|ii.'' 'iiio I'l'iui s'.Mi vii siiii- !>■ iiii:ii ilii Di'loinliMir. ("r>t i|Ui' r'f-l tmii haul ilu fi'iti'' ilu DcMiiimli'iir a caiiHO il.s irH'iTo. .If i-nii- 'Hie It's pirnvH siirlr point 1' out iMi'' iiii-^f la 1^1- main iriiomiiio ]ionr fiivovi'i' I'lMii il'i •■iiti' (111 Di'^'i'inloiii-. l/i'uii ii'aurait jias jmi iiii'ttivci's (icnv- la inimiii'ji! Irs iM viii'". I am mit pn-iiivi' ulictlior the pniiit iit'laiul 1' li.'Uvcoii tin' l and th.' mill r.ir.' uas asloiii: -Ji' M'ai'saL'oas il i> now, but I am p.-i-itivr a poinl i'xi-t^'ton,'> pla.iMl artitiriallv an.l iliair iH.v iM^hind stoiv (-npposnl lo mi'MU point I') ^i) a" to lii-ivi' till' wati'i- ai;ain-t the Di'f.'mlanl'.-i \vliarl'ant sid.> oftlu' imint I", nor iln I ivrolK'ct how tin' watri' usi' to How thnv. La iioint.' I' I'si plus lomrm' iprrlli; n'l'Mait ailtivfoi^ il'inic (|uaranlaim.' d.' pii'ds <■.• ipi domii- jilusdo iiTi'ain an Dfniamlciir. i;n i'ti- alonirr a I'oivf iK' jcti'i- (!<■ la pim-c snr h' I I. Cilli' picn-c est ai-ran:,'!'' on maniiTo lU' wir in imn-i .v-"i7/.dii cote'' sait jdns hant viT.s oil liniss.Mit Ifs aihirs. torn- hait dans 1,. oanal '"' ''' '""''"./'"' ■-'"'•-■ /'"•«■';'• ^ il n''o>l '."'H^'o g six lois (I nn^mo phis do voir dos hommo^ an scrviro i\i\ I'omandonr tra\aillo dans la nvioro ^ ot prondiv dospioiTos dn ooto dn Dolondoiir pour losjotordn oOlo dn Domandonr. lis nu i '" taiont oos picrros an bas dn lian.ijar do pionv du outo du ijuai dn lU'inandonr. !,ors do rao(|iiisilion dn monlin j-.arlo Itoinandi'nr la rivioro dans la partio do son ])aro(inrs dopnis lo pout ius.in'an point N oonlait |dns an -ml oiiost iin'idlo no liiit anjonrdhni, ot lo Domamloiira pour ooia idii^ do torrain ipi'll on avail autrotois ot lo J)ol'oiidonr on a luoiiis. N).VO/*.S7.S iioh.ii' Of iriiktin ill Aji/ioitli.r H. From all this ovidonoo it mav ho intorrod thai the point 1' is mostly oomposcd ol Ih. r-tono,-, ixravol and sand, oloarod out of tho tail raeo and lormod hy tho notion of tlio ri\ rr it-rU'durimr froshots. (SiiTiiod.) (IIS. li\II.LAK/>/ A /. Eriflence adduced I'!/ I'/nintil/ on /ormi'r s/:r of mi/,,- irhcl. In 1><:II and ls:!:ilho diamotor ol llio mill whoidmay havo hron from ninotoon t.> twonlv iVrl t'rom tho fact of tho llnnio iiavinu' hoon rai-od. I inirr that Ihowhool must havo iio,.n .■idarirod in diaiiiotor or that tlo> shaft mnst havo h,.,.|i raisod. Kn ls;it la rouodu monlin poiivait avoir dix hnit jiiods do diamotro plus on moins./', /.■ nct'iiijniii'ii-i inisnrfi. .rooroi^.iuodo mon tonip^larono olait do di\-o|it a dixdmit pioils. ./. ,>r I'ui Jmmif mesiitu'c. Ithiiik that oiL'htoon yoar.s ai:otho>i/o of tho mill wh.rl wa- Iwonlyfoot. In isj.') to l^IiH the wliool \va> aliont Iwonly tort. li. Uruuii:!, 1. Adduced hy Defindunt .-.« !l:i xmiii: suhjtr/. .Jo«ui-iiiiloi-son uiul IVi.sset conolioniti'il by that ot'K'i'oiigli, Ix'iii- iiioiu I'L'liabK; lli'iii tluUot the utliof witiiosHcs who only ^ipcak up- [ii'cixiinati'ly. (S1i' r adduo'd lis /o span' henealh mill wheel liefore Plaintiff's time. ,;,, iirn.l.,. In IH:11 Jii'l is:',2 till' di-tanee beneath tliewhoil may liiive been t'l'onu'ii^Iitoeu to twenty ►"II '■ t'mir iiiebe.-. IV Ui.hiiiiill.i Ell lH:!tl I,'e-paee sous la roue nuuvait iivoif ele ile se|'t a liuit ponces. ,7i,'ui |)ny:i. l''ii I**-'' il y ''^'''i' 'i''''^i' i"i '1""''"'^'' I"'!"'*'^ il'espaeo sous la rone. (.|„. „i,„,r 1 I), I temp- lie M. M.Callnm il pmivail y avoir de iiiiin/e :'iilix bnit Jiouees d'espaoo nous la rone. l- K,.„ii^-li :. 1 think that ei-lil' <'ii .M'iirs airo the spaee beneath the wheel was thirteen inulion. 1.-, Au).'.r(;. II V a vinj,'t neulaiis il ponvait y avoir alms ,1,. don/e 11 (|uin/.e jioiicos d'espai'c souri hi rone. (, ,(;,„,, 7, In b><:!,'. Ill l-s.is as mar as I ean reniember. the space boiioath the wheel must have been nine to twelve inches. I did not measure it but -.'.7 s,, /,o;ti(.i. It iifist Inirc IjCliI .^v. SYXOI'SIS Ol ir/di'iiir ni iiji/iiridir K. heaviii'out IheeMrenieollwenty four iuelies and addiii.e- all the other spaeoH and dividinir Ik "ihennniber thereof we obtain thirteen inehes nearly for the probable .space bo Heath the "heel previous to I'laiiilill 's time. rlierl. 1 from nineteen to lat the wheel liiu>l (Siii'iu'd. (lis. UAILLAR(JE. 1:1 )\v. stavi:li:v. plus on luoins ji !■■ «. Je VI' I tii jiiiiinii IV feet. .irri:Ni)i\ l in l)i luaiideni. /■:ridiice uddiiced ,is /o depth of wafer Mowed on irheel previous lo stopping il. . A„.,r I Uiuuid hi rone (reinpe irois pouees dans I'eau on s'apper.'oii ipu- ^a lati-ne les monvo- ^\^:S:^h ,,^^,,Ji'''X,'ndi!v a neuf pouees' dVan dans lessrodels ibiieketsi ,1 laut arretcr pour pa. ''""""'™'- lirisor les niouveiueut>. fins I'eau luoiile snr la roue plus il laul niellre d eau pur en luiul \I011 r eoinpensor la i.erte- do force ct ca ubiine lout ct moud uial. 38 (ii" Iiir; Imt Wf li'l tin' wlii'i'l u'li lis IiiMj; iis sill' woiilil, liy uililiiii^ iiiKi'i' water iVdiu aliovc, if wti liail ^J liny. We iliil ii.)t Irl ii y.i until it sto|i|iril ot' it-ilf Iml -l.mprd if, wiieii it ln'iraii to lajr. Wlii'n tlii'i-c was [lii'iity i>l' watiT li'cini iiliovc »•!> iiiiL'lil li.ivc let tlio wlici'l l>i' sultnn'i'j,''''! i a liiol, uioro (ir Uvss. liuliirc \\v stii|i|iril ii. 1 mraii a (not Inini tin> umliT vili^c nl' tin' j iMK'kets. J. Fi'ririisnn :i linint'iiiately tlio water ton<'ln's llio rim I'i' tin' wlii'd. [ ahvays sto]i tin' mill niy^.^lf Milk""" " in faso (>r daniriT. Snnu' tiini- ai."> an a.'.-i,|,nl urcin'ril liv wh'.i'li wc Im'l^i' ^imir nf the L'tiijs oC tin' iiinidn uln'i'l, tlic Mrain iiicmu'ciI liuni Kavin'^- wurkfd tin- mill while tlieio was IiaiU waliT dii it. r.Rciliii.iii!.. I j-ji l>:li; mills lais-idus nnintrr six u Iniil |miucc'- d'ean en di'ilans dr la scinclK' de la null' avant de raririei'. Cli,-'. liiiii.r.'i. ()rdinaii'cnn'nl on ni' d.iil pas laisser ni.int.T d'raii Mir I'- jiinds i inside rim m' -uln de la mile avant ile rai'ieter. 1.. Mi'KiiHiin'. Wheel used to stii]) 111' iieecs^ity when there wer.' iw.itntw.i and a hall' I'ert of wati-r (III it. I'-'l _ ll'ii'i'i Wheel laiisi shiji whenlht-re are I'iirh.een in.hr^ to hv.i I'ei'l ix poiiees d'oau siir la seliiille" (>l Kvitll lice ill Ajilirmli.v L The avcrairo oxiicsiirc, friiiii the evidenee, Wdiild he almiit lit'teen imhe- Irnm the init'r cdL-'e 111' the ImeUets, nhiained hy adiliiii;- ihe in. Ik s ;:iven hy all ihe w iliic---'-. and dividiliir ihe >iini li\ the niiinhcr cil' .-rpaiale depl lis. (Sijiiicd.) (IIS. iiAiLLAi{(;r; i:i>NV. S'lAVKLKV \rri:M)i\ m. I), McOllllMll I. !.> (liitriitiii 'J. MuhalSrulia l.t'iiis AuL'. r i (Ir.j. KUmI r,. F..1. TIliiI.i- KUll 0. 1' l(..l.itaill.' i',. I tract. < from icii/cncc aifi/i/ccr! />i/ J'tuiii/i// on iliinilioii ol' .itoppage of mill-irheil jireriuit.i to the coiislruclioii o/' Dc/hiilmit'.s irfiur/ of IHa'i. .\l \ 1 ry hii;h liiles, mill u-ed 1,1 ^l(i|. a 1 el lain linn' : dining my time, il"«ln;. I>e ni'iii temps, il y a dl' rrla vini.'l ipialre an-, les i^iandes imrs laiMdclit arieter le mmilin, au iiieillciir de ina eonnai-same de 1.1 a I; heuii's an plus. i,e muulin arrelail pen daiil liinle> les i;-rande- mer-. Ill my time (hveiily three years aL'ui I havi' .-eeii the hiirh tide siiinetiiiies step the mill, hir two lioiirs Imt very seldi)iii, it was j^eiierally liir iilnnit an hmir and (inlv diiriiie very hii,di tides and very seldom. II y 11 viiii;t iieiit' ans, j'ai mem'' le moniin inoi-inenie. Nous arrelions im heme el (h'ini a deux heiires. j.a rone aelilelle e.-l la iiK'me .pi il y avail an Inonliii ipiaiid Jy -ni- eiilre. la -e.Mimle I'ois avani le 'piai de l^<,"):i. Nous ariotions alor.s de dell.x a deux henres el demi. (jt duns le.s plus tjrande.s iners tiuis lieures. In 1S:!.'> t.) ls:'i>i the mill u-ed |.i -lop rr.imlwo ami a hall' to three and three and a halrhour-, and al extr.-me lii;;-lj li.les l.iiir hours. In l^-'il and \>'■\■^ ill my time the wheel only slopped diiriiij; ,-prini; tides (ilspriniij aiel Tail. I'siially aliont two In two hours and a hall', and diirin^r very hi;j;li tides, driven li\ a -Iron;; easterly wind as iiiueh il" tliree hniirs. Mil l.H.'i'i/fai rest('' ipiatre ans ail moniin du temps .1,. Hisset. he inoiilin arivlait alm- (laiis lis i.rram|es iiier.s (In prinlem['s et ipiehpie I'ois dans raiitomiie el seiileiiieiil dans le- gi'os vents de N'ord l')st. .lamal- le nioidiii ii'e-t arr("'l('' I'liiver par les halites iiiers le iiioillin arretait trois ft iplelipie I'ois .pialrejonrs de suite dans les L^raiide iiiers, de troi- lieUlVS A tr.ii- lieiil-es rr di-niie, (it .pl.l.pl.' I'.ii- .platre hellle.- [i.ir Inalee. Ce n'e-l ipie dail- ies Ljrunde iiiers de .Mai ipie le moniin arretait aiiisi ipiatic heui'(- 3!t sill's tlio ]i<)\vi'r; Ji-nii Di'ry H, II y ii vinijt ciiiq i."'' I" '"o"':;; ,ini"'l:iil iLiii-^ tdUti's Iim irrnndc^ mcM do I't'l nil llllOVl', if \Vl^ llll lioii it lii'iTiUi to liijr. lici'l lie siililiii'i'iri'il llllikT cilni: dl' till' ix an-:. I.i imiii,' arirlail ilans los ixramli'S invi'.'* llll )ii'iiit('iii|H t;t ill' raiitiiiium ilf ili'U\ lii'iur- a ili'iix lii'iiri'.s ot lui ijiiarl. tiiit'l'|iiriiiis mii.' la liiiiiti: iiii-i'- n'linrait ro^tiM' ijiii' ih'iix liniri's siir la foiu', clli' y n'slail truis hciiros par nil i;iiw vt'iit ill' N'. v.. I'll trm|i^ ilu homamli'iir, itvaiit lo i|iiai ilo I.S."j:i la rmii' arrtHait coiiimo llll li'iiips ill' M. MiCalliiiii, rt ii'la iirmlaiit -opt a liiiit aii.s iipri's quo lo Doiiiaiiilunr ost osoliil prnpl'lrtailo. Ml K..MI1II I" tiitlio \vlini't'orix."iJ, it ua-; usual I'nr mill to stop at lii;;li tiih' sin-iiii,' ami tiiU I'lnm olio, til olio ami it halt', to two hours, or a littlo iiiori' porhiqis as tho wiml hio II. li.riiiiii'I J'ai oti'' qiiatro ans I'l ih'mi ihius Irmploi ilii lli'inamlriir avaiil h' .piai ih- 1> II. Miuiiiir nioiiliii alors arr^'lait r.( aiis li- priuti'iiips ri ilai.- i auiumm'. .piaiol il \rii lail fort Xort K^ suit ilo lii'iix a trois hi'uros ft ipiaiol 11 arrotail aiiisi lroi> hoiiros, rolait dans li- irros \oiits N. H. ot dans 1 OS L'ramli's mrr- M;i r.KioiiL'li I-. Thr loiigost timo I ovor kmu thr min t.i st.ip Is yrm-^ ;|._.-o was two honi'.s and a-lialf. Arri:M>l\ M. Cmfiinicd. K.rtiac/s l'i(»)> evi(li:niT adilnicd lnj pijinihiiit ii» (liinitinii of nfnjipdnc a/' iiiill wheel I'll IIhIii- Irolil Ihi; II ihi' uiliir"i •■ and M.AR(ii: avi;m:v uiiiis:e iif mill-wheil X'ors ls:10 Jai travaillo dan- h' iiioni in six a sept ans, hi ivht arritait alors lo nioiiliu ' 11 do pi'iiilaiit mil' a mil' lii'un' I'l ili'ini a rha'pio iiiaroo. .1 rii sins cortuin poiir I avoir vii do inos yi'iix. Avaiit lo qiiai do IH.'iii j'ai ooiiiiaissam'o ipio lo nionliii arri^tait doiix a trois lioiiro-i, pas .U tr titi'i '/"' I'l iihr iicml' lif'iiiro'iji iifi'ii /..nit,- (i I'n's, 1,1 ijii','1 •/ 11 llll, ij,(iii:,hin iCninu, 'I'l'VMii- to wliar loi' 1- il ll-r 1 to -till, f p liMiii olio all 1 a hair to two hours and at •rv hii;li liih's, moro. I niiirhi ^a\- rmi- h on-. I lnlir\r I havo >rrn it niialilo to work liir as iinioli as loiir lioiir- 'I'o ihi' I.I -I kn.i»|,.d-i' I h aM' SITU from Olio and a hall to two hours, r m- I In till' lion- of tho lidi-. I h tho mill .stoppoil ivr iiovor si'on tho mill stoppi'il four hours diii-iinr till' s.mo' tido. To tho In'stol'my knowlodgo, I havo soon tho mill -toppi'd four hours diirini;- tlo' day. nil-, ilslii . fai>aii'iit arrotrr Ir inonlin arrotail iirii somi'tiinos stop iho iiir and oiilv diirim.; oils nil liiMiii II' I'l don i|iiaiid ly sills oiiliv. ili'iix hi'iiros ot domi. iroo ami lliri'o and a n: lidos of spring ami i;li tidos, drivon liv a Ol eriilenre in Apjietiili.v M i/.v /n iiution nt' sfojijxiije af mill wheel dur in i: high lides jiierioii.i til irtiiiii oj 185'J 1 I, >ni:- (iaijiioii •J Mill lai'l ^^olt l.onis .Ainror. ■I (u'liriri' .) I'.ilwaril llonilorsoi lioliitalllo .loan l>i' S Charh's liilmr ',1 Lawi'i'iii'i' MrKrnna. 10 .1. I!. I'.orlraml 11 I'atriok Ki'oiigh \1 .losoph Fllian |:1 (ialiiiol (ironior 11 William .Miiirav 1.'; 1.', h. 1} hoii- inonlin arrolait alm- sonloiiionl dans lo- los haul nios mors null' iiirr-, I lo tr II r.-l ipll' (hill .\vorago oi|nal ti Avonitto of avora (Sio-ncd.) \\ to '!>, ens. HA!LLA!{(a: i:i)\v. stavi:m:v. 40 i/v'/;v/>/.v v, E.i/nic!f from en, •knee, addmrd I'!/ J'/i'inflJI l ,,,,,..,1 l.y ^|. riv-li.'t-, ii.'illior wliin I 111' l^;i aili IMll ;|',\M1T tl,;,t tlic. iiiHl.WstoltiMl l,y i,-,. jaiiis 111 [hv ^\ N,.r I iiiii dw.iy I' il„. mill rv.r haviii- li'-.-ii .-lop]. liii.j-, <'iiiisiiij( tliu wiitiT ..I'lii iiiv liiiii'' iiy fipiin.!,' liT,-.|i' I.-. Au r. K.i.iiii .1. Di" .ir II ;ii .|.i (lilai. I .fc ii'iii 1'; luiiw coniiiiissiiiuH' iiViiii |i- 1:1 rivi.'Ti' t !,■ (|ii;ii lU' 1^"'- 'r»v(iii- yii !lli..it. (,';! no liiV'^l .i;ilii:li^ iirrivr a nvlcr li' numliii i Illnl-llll'llH' llVilll I W ail iiiiniissaiii'i- i|ili' 11' nuHi llli ;ii| jamais ari'i'lr 1'^ ,.s ^i',)-*:i'l .laiis Iv- ) s Iv^ liluii'w I'l lr..'cl,-s ilii i.iiiilcliil- avail! !'• i|lia is.'i::. 1' n'ai pas niiiiia issaiiiM' (|in' jamais Ir mmiliii ail arn !•> l.'|■l)ss^■■^ I,, la riM.-Tc l!..aiip"i'i. ■''■."'■ ""' "•'l'.l"''>' I'''- 'I'"' J'""'" 111(111 ti'nips par I jl Mill vciiii nil ri'limlis il'raii par la \:\ llli ait Tail ani'tii- K; iin'iirm ( 11.. liiiii.i r. I,. Ml Ki'Miu .1. II. liii- tiaiul -. 1'. Ki-uiij:l. ,1c n'ai pas I'nnnuissaiK'e i|ii(' jamais liiit anrtiT U' mi'iiliii ilrliai'U's ill' L'laci'. |'ri".i^ pas (|il(' .laliiais I ^l.il. li\ li'c^llrls. .!(_■ n'ai (ills ('(iiinaissiiiu'c ip •anx de la rivioic Itcaupurt. ic dc 111(111 Iclup a I'lHic iln iiidU liii ail iirivlt'i.' par Ics i^n At tliiit tiiiu' (I'iLditi'Oii y ■ars ai:*!) tlicii' was tv ilhiiiir l.iit iIr' lido that causiMl tlic mill I ID stop. 1 UL'Vi'r knew it !•. stop Ircin "/W sYSorsis or Arri:M)i\ v. ll is a-scrU'd liy niiii' wilncsMS at (I iKil (■(.iilradi'tid liy any nil in tlic Pi'l'i'lidiints sidi llial pri'S Kins lo nil' ci' nstr'.itii'n i ih.. wharl'df Is.'iiitlic mill n<-\vi dill', I'itlu'r !iv Iroslu-ts ol lln' river beau (SiiTiu'd rl (.]■ Iiv Jams nl -|(lp].i(l |(1 till' WlllK' llic spriiiir. (MS. liAILKAUca: i:i)\v. SI am:h:v. lirtnirls Horn .irri:M>i\ <>■ ,.nd.'nnadMrlh. l!i|h and 21st ol' .March 1., M(K. .1. 11. 11. Iiaii.l:l. 1'. K. ..iii:li I. t'lu. liUiiii ■' Ihal ll 1 wharf el' ;,. la~t ill I'lain'itl'semplov allerwhai IJ.I 111 fire and it -t.ipl"'d al-o hv Iri fi.fU ill at thai lime ii-ed to stop lom/rr ivhicli did le aire aiis el deiiii ( ls,"i."il one j'ai (|1K>I • le !>•">■- le miiiilinarrelai 11 y a ipi ie re.-liiis la al lait. Hans le l.-mp- .ine.'fai laisMe l';."i""l'",^^';, iiliisii'iirs liii? hiissc le mouliu el siir le- i ■rcvioiis to tl IcriiiercH iiliiit'i'S ipic rrosst's can mil till xdc la i-iv'i're Heaiipoit avi't'taiciii t plus liiiiuleiiips i|ii avaiit ipie le (\ le mi.. dill.' l.e miiilliiia arrele pin- smiveii t depnis ipie le ipiai ilc l.x.l .all. la'iiiiai fail des iron 'i'his vear 1 llemi'lils d"eail el fail in'V r la r..U( dan- I'l ail. h,. hi^h tide to slop four or live hours i" tide, the loll'-'csl lime i ever km it to sto|i 'hcforc the wharf was huiil hciii,- t wo lioiii's ami a ill'. In March last mill ,1 fi'.iiii Ih" I'.»th t nhmer.'cd ;ist. No .urii lin.rwas done diiriii.ir thai lime ihe water w heel 111 kcil Tit imikin/lloles in the ice lo ascertain where wa tcr was stoppi tluU Weill hack upon the mill \\ I jlepuis le ipiai de 1«.VJ. Iesi:r. 1--C.- eaux on iiial'ee. iiie hiii-i ti'oiivi ail iiiiiillin line lois .|Ue I tail arri'lcr lemnnliii imlcpeiidciiiinen . !a e-i anive. Kn Aviil l^-i^. h' n 1 d.' iiiclc pciidaiit .piatre .I'lUr ii-.ii- Hilar t a trois heiires d iiii iiuarl p. :i n.-f.-ii, 1,111! 41 i}>})e(t pierious to ivti'c liar Ics lci'h^- ,1, II I'.Tiiiii.. I,,, iMiiiirm (loil tMl-f iirii-lr |.lii--< rlmrini'iuoiilrt il(t la I'ivit'l'i' pllf li' ilUlli lie I'^.'ilJ. I,'. An-, rT. 1| \ ;, ,|,.|,x ailH .'l lit till lie Kl'VIMiT. j'lli Ml U- lunlllill ini.'ll'V IllM' JiMllllrC Olltic''IV v\. UllO unit, (■■'(■liiil Ic viiiirt ilfiix nil villi;! Ir.>l-'ilr l-'cvrin- on !.• vin','1 .luaHr. iliiii^ Irs Im-is imn-H, a mil' .M'liwioii i|iii' la iivii''i('(-^l ilfVi'iiUi' !.'ri>— c A Mailu.ii - rii,. r..i< il V u ■|iiahv .•iii>(l^."i.'i| vii'~ la till il'' -'iiin on Ir i iiihiim'11''ciiioiiI ilo Juillot a Imil (Ml iii'iil'lic'iiivsdii matin la in. r rl'll I'a-ir alm.s. liCan (U'siTiiilail ilaii-i la rivii'MV lai^ail nil liMirt'l rciiKMitail duns I, ■ i-ana! di' la n>ni' dn innii!in. l,ciinmlin A <''lf iirn-ti'- uim lu'ill-iM'tdciniL' i\ -J liiili-.'s |.i'iiilaiil.|iu',i'ai i'('' la, rt mi lii'ii dit (|il'il I'tait dt'.ii'i aiTi'lii do(iiiirt dciix licnrts. ,1 K.^'M.— n Till' mill now >lo|i-i from ('..iir to live and a .|nai'ti-r liour-ilniiiifr -^iiriiii; tidos. It also sfo|iM '•' liv till' Cri'sln'ts ol'tlii' riviT l'.can|"Tt. KvriT tivdicl stops llir mill. For tln'sr lonr yoai's |iast il liiis hi'i'ti tlic saiiH' and miiM liav.' Iiucn tin' sunn! sim-o tin' wliaif \vii> Imilt in 1>^.V.'. Tliisyiar (lM,V,t| the wlicrl was immri'siil in watir on tin' iMli Maivli and was not cli'iir till lln' -JUt at li.'twccn II and I J A. M. A,!Jtaili on iln' :'.l-l Maivh mill sloi>|.r.| for niihj hours owiin,' to fivsli.'l. I-'I ll.ii'I'i- 1 liavi'scvi'i'al times si^i'H mill -lo]iiird liylia.k wati'V from firshct tiino simr wliaif of "'" isrii iiin'onin'fti'd with tidi' watrr. i;<. Niichiiu V'lTs la tin df Fi-vri.'i- ,miI.> conim.'ni'iMniMit d.> Mai-s 1>.'.'<. ilniMiil nii t.'mii> 'inc K's ('anx II ctaii'iil I'XliTiniMm'iit L'i'o".'- il |iaiai"aii vci's /, ,-iiHv \ I'l /, inc .iiirih' do vilai'i' iini faisail rcnioiiiiT Iran ;iii nioiiliii. dai alors nir~niv i|iio la rour Irrmi'ail- trois pinis ilaiis I'l'au. .\l.,s.Mii I.', W'liarl ot Is.VJ (■aii-...,i.;i,k wali-r on tlio mill wliool and apprais to havo licun Imilt for tin: c'xinrss [mrposi' of aiiiioyiii'j; tiic I'laintiH'. niusod tlio mill i:\ IDEM i: Ai/dund In/ Ih U iiitaiit on the sniiiii suhjicl. (!, (ir.'Miir 1. 11 V a di's i^ramlis ni.'i- ipii' 1<' nionlin anvti' liiii) a six Join's, c'c-t pari-il a inrsciit •I.' suis "1 ,.|iinnn'"avaiit i|iU' Ic '|iiai di' l'*o- fnt Iril'. I,i' iiioulin arn If pai-i'il. La iiior lie iiionti; l!^ni'.'''nv.i''l'' liipliis 111 nioiiis a |nvs,.nl .HI.' dan- lo i. nips p;i-s(. j/„ /,,-,< lir.si ,,■„!, „,;■ h, g.ii/s) ,lo troiivo liiiiiiih.lvMi ,|ii,. hi niri' monti' lioaiiroiip moiiis a pi-.'s,.nl .piil y a i|iiiiizi' ans passn-s. SY\<>I*SIS (_>l cvidiiirc in Appendix O It i> liiTi- asserlrd liv Iwotvo witiKs.fs, coiitfadirtrd liy none, id' tlic I leffiidaiit's witiifssi's, tliat siiicT the i:iv,tion of tin' u'liarf ..f l^.c', tlco mill lias lii'fii stoppi'd by tVi'slicts and jams of i('>' ill il,.' -priiiir. whi.-li ii is ;is-rii. d in .Vpprmlix N iiuvor oocurcd pivvioiisto tlio i-oiistnu'tioh of 111.' -.i'd wliar'f (Siiiiii'd.) CI IS. liAiLLAmar. i:nv. s'rAM:ij:v. .iri'i:M>i\ /'. Miscvlliiuemis e.rtiar.tsfrmn eriiUnice on dillennt siih/ect.s. r. i;,.>k,ii 1. Lived with Dofciidanl ton yars as laninT. Di'feiidaiit was in iiosscs-siuu of beach of St. J.awiviicL- and St. ('haii.'s riviTs as lie iisimI to nit the ttrass th.nv. , A. Karltrr.ii •-'. 11,1, ll.lllllls J,o Didi'iidoiii- passi" pour ('In- proinir'tairi! do la gii-vc St. Charles jus, pi'ii la liassc iiicr. r.i|.t 1, anii.lv Dont think anv (u'litk'iiian ''an tako possession bolow high water mark herauso it he ;^'""''' looged to the Killer. Ilarliour Mii?- IIT. 42 A- McD.innl.l ( Viii-iili'i' >aliiiMii i-iiliiiii' Mil l»;ii'i'v'-< tihiii lo lir ih. lii'iu !i iil'rivi'r Ui'iiiiirin. .|. IMiiinliir,- l^itll" ."•''■ A. I'lir.ril ... I>lli'llr-llll\ llVilil hi pii>-r~-i.lll illSi|U"i ' ,l-~r mil'. li.l'.i,.|..iin\ «illl«SS. ,,{ iinrLcaii 1'. •''-' "'''^ 'I'"' '^' l'i'l''!i'li'Ul' piir^-^t'dL' iiisi|ir:'i lu l>a- -i nni Dfti'li'lalil s !■ [.-ili,,,,; C'l'st iliiii.s ri'tc lii' H."):! ([lie J'lii tnwiiilli'' |i.iiir Ir hcrcuili'iir a im llri,' ;lc-< v'hiiuijri-'.i i\'- H 11 X. .I'iii finplovi' iIlmi.x clii'vciiiix, I't \l:ir."ii\ an, duriiMt iiiu'|iai(ii' i|.' I'l^t.' .Icniifr d dr I'lil' (tlri'(''i|i'lit. W. Miirr.-iv ^ Ui'li'iiihiiil'-* I'oa-'Oil hiyiiii;' -loiii'.; at I'irnilar liiu' 'ntui'i'ii 1> ami .\. iii'i.'ii.l.iiit \V. Wnrr'.i 'Wlii'ii I mad.' ill.' pl.iii il'iaiiilill - .■xlilliit .\ i '/■• .- . /'.././ //..' I,il ih, /■.,,,> 'riic riiiihhii \ -iir\i'\ \\.i~iiiad'' .111 ill.' ^iv.iilli .\|.ril. ' I kinnv llial liidiiiiil 1 i.'lrmlaiir,-^ wliarl it u:-rd t • !'.■ a ^waliiji, Imt lu' |ia.i lilU'd it in '■■n;.;;;;i^r- («iK,rrnns,-,ii. wi>iiuj>.*. I,. Aii'ir II. \iMis iiiMis .-iiiiuiuM ii|ii'ri;ii^ di"-~ la luviiiit-ri' aiinri' .|'H' l.i |'r.'iiiii'iv |'arlic du i|iiai ilii riiiimiiV s l>rli'ndi>ur, loll.' Latic (.'i; l."-.".l, uoii^ L'l'iiail. l,',i di' i.:iadail l.i liTi.! .lu iin.iilin .[iii u-t i\v iviin. ^„•^.. 1 a'.llrt.'cuti.'. Ill Ilio i;.irclcii. IMri.'l lr..in 'I'll.' ■ .M u liail' . if wliirli Maixi' s|i..I<.ii a-liaviii;:' lii.ii Imiltiii iii\ tiiii.', Wa.-i .-^o Imilt .yi.l.Ti.v I-.', ill l.s;',J f. I-^;!^. Ill IliV liliir IIm.' liiu'll lid.- !..-.■ liiM.i, l!ir . !.■, ..nil. doi'..' ill liii ;:i\.li Ipy '.. * ' ' lli".:i ill', -i^i' -r..'. ..I (iii;:v vs. III..,!..'. n. (Jriiii.r i;i (.''r-t iivaiit ipii' !.■ i|iiai dn I'cinaml.iir I'lit i.."iii. ,, , i:.:ii a iiivcrm' dans Ic .f« Mil- .11 j|,|-din .111 hcmandfiir. I>aii^ v>- !.'Im|.s la li'janliii allaii .n |...nlc i-ii lini~-ant li ricri ;\ lu . iit..iit'-^!iv..,- I'ivi.'rr. Avaiil U' .|iiai a.liirl .hi 1 >rmaii.|.'iii-. il ay .i\ail |i,i-i d.' .|uai la. II |iourail v I., li.'ih.iu.l. ur CM uv.iir oil nil i|Ui' Ji' m.' laiirai-i |ias \ u. Li- .""anicli 1'.' \\:\\- dirni.'V. Ir |)rlclidi'lir mil l.n. .4 111 Mil., jjjj ,1^, |'.,i,,,, adi'iilioii ai-'.' iini >..' ha-^i'i-.iii an in.iiilin, .|>i.' !>••• I'A|r|-|- .dlai.ail vt'iiir. I.,rs luilli'^ (.1 til.! U.-tl^ll. . . 1' ■ - 1 I' . - . ' . ,. . -»' » II ' .l.iiii H 11 .iisis, c|ia avanl I amvi'o d.w h.^piTls ofairiil I.tiiii'i'.^, mil ctf .iin.'il.s |.ai'.\u^. i- .( i'crirui'.-ini. Mriinirrs ihi l>i^man.U'iir. dii tn.nii.'nl .|iii' Irs Kxprrl.-* mmiI ilrs.i.mlu an has dn niDiiliii. Avaiil rida ,\iii.'.'i-. FtTiiii.-.m rl Iv'.ii.'r' Kruwii. jrlai.-iil .|.' la ijla. .■ .mi lia-; d.' la cliaiisri', .jnil-i idl.iii'iit rln'1-i'li.i' plu^ lianl .|iri:- iTavMii'iii . uiiinim' do lairr rl l.nii crla avail rctli'l df liiii'i' [laraiti'i' aiix Hx|H'rt- |.ius d'.'.iii ft d.' ^lan' dan- l.i livi.'r.' .[iiil n'v lai aiiruit en -iiiis rcla. .11 I'tnii iii'cii.-^iiii'i il'fiin-'ri /..-/../A.< tl, hi •litni-,', ^ ,/ ,ir,i.i j.ln A, ,;,(,■, .,,y, ,/ l,i ririi'n ,'l.lil •. . / /. Itnijl.-I flilil hi, I) :li,il.i . A I' III/ il'i.illl-:,'' h - /•/'... // /i((,v r( ,' . ./<.y yj .y..C iii,ll,;'.\ ll'lilll /.iirili.-'ii.-!. Vallt'O ost Vfiiii Vfiidredi K' HMars. vin-^ .|iiatic ,'i i|iialii' lii-nii-' rt (k'lni dc I a|iivs Miidi, avt'iulu lilr i.ioni' lain' liinndii' an mmilin. ri i! a rriii|i..iii'' -a lariiii' ly Irmlr- niiiiii, .Ic ii'ai pas onu'iidii inan'InM- If in.miiii. la rlinl. < .■ imir la. rai>ait Irop dt' lirnit [Miiir iM'la. I \l..i-.',i.-v M .^ay till! .sanu! tliiiiij iis N.i. l.'i as in op. niii'. ..f 'j-at.- ami ll.r. i\\ ini;- d.iun i.-,., (■(,■. .).■ .1. 1.I..1I1.. Saliifdi lo r.i Mars olalt nii nin-- cunp .lo plni. .1 d.- .l.-.j.'!, I,.-^ li-..ii-. .|iii' !.• I i.niaiid.'iir ''"!'"",'''■" avail fail Cairo .lan,~ la 'jlai-.' on mo , .:: > . h.ii 1 omi .'■.lii-r do llnltor lu.ii-i.iH .111 . 1 • ll.lll..li I.111-. !■ Miriii, I,-, rjuy saiiiuas Nil-, l^ and 11 a- !■. .■! > i .oj i i; ,. i ;,,i,-,,i! |:.:1, .Manli and lIu-.iuiiiLr 1 1. 1. II. Ill, I iof iivo!' Tails, olo. lU allaii.'lil i lo i. hoi .!.• l.i L;ia. .■. iioM !..■ -.i\ - 1 J.- or miJ- [ .i- oo uii'ii- ■an. m- "'^"'""'"^'^ allaiont olioi'i'lior. t/a I'ait paiaill'o au\ l\\p.i I- . .immo >"ii \ aiail In am imp pins ,|'o; .i.'uii' l.v il'.'. I.os liMi:s laits par I.I I 'oiiiandeiir dans l.i ul.u o p..inaiiiit a\iiii- lai lollot nn pen do To porhordo lliillot. '1 • II uiilil Iho .Mnnila\ .lav I.. Ml K.'iiMH ' 'I'lio ll.iii.l i;'al.'- u.i'.- i.iiono.l mi llif I'.Ml. .iiol r.'liiaiii I.;, I'lMu.uit- t,,|l,,wiiiv'. witiii-...*. .I'ai i-'l.u los avorlii' ail noiiiliii lo |s M.n- .ui -..ir .I'.nu lii , i. - )i. llos avaioni \|. Mur V . . , IT. I'liiiiiiiil - olo li.Tinoos (;a aurail iiimido inmi I.TlMin. i\ iiii.>?i V. Ciitui-.. I- (Jtiand nn ost aiTi'ivo an iiimiiiii lis don.v polios dn nimilin n. on p.iiiis aii-;.i l,.i;ilos ol Mr. li.iiil.irL" Diivorlos ipio (puuid oil il rotoiirnt' vnir pins lafd. cjirt.-T. I'l.iiu- tilT ivitni'S!!. <;. MitiKr ill Marliii iNo. 1.')) uradoluamlo si .■■.lail vraio nuo los polios iivaionl oli'. 1. rmeos avaiil I'luiiiiiiV ml'. Tarrivoo do.s K.\|ioi-Isot il a dii .[III' 1.' li. I'l mh nr I'lulnil lio Hlri lUi-i ,;l.i, \\y^ miiif a di.\ m«. lionro's dn matin il v avail .liiix polio- .I'.iia orto. I. , .lon.v an!). - iif I'. ii|i . i , ji v.t.s li-ni:- .i . iiuttlto liouriH. I,. Ant-r Jli. i'i...iiiiir\ iiiiii. 1' IMiiMl \... I 'III I'liliihl. Ill' I) li.f. ii.lain'.i .■vli.l.ll'.'. I7ili Ml. Ji;-:i, „, .l.'iiiili.'ii piir (.ill.ir.l .1 llii. ^'1 .|j.-nii.v .1 ;iull.-.' Il.t.li.lillll s lOjliil.it N... I hi. .l.-.l I)... ol 1. ii.i.ii.l 111 lai 1,1 .|ilrl.-. 'nti.. ..1 :ili A|iril, i;7i. |i.f.ii.laiil'< IMiil.ii .N... y, :i. uli.lai Km- .|.i.ii 1.. 'fill,. '■'' .1 '."I Mar. h 111 ':-•' /,' hi ill r.ii. lain < IM.il.ll N... I .■. iM.-.lal i;ii'.|.i,.r... 'I'i. pa II.' II .Mav. ta I7:t'.'. ,, •ti 111 do ('.iii,..-.i,.ii.|. I.I. I.. |.ar .\i. I.llll.l .lll.-ll. rail Da.li. .,. II. ,\ .1 .1.11 .■|.".|- a .M.\r. .■"i I-'razcr, iin .liii.i...', .Ii.l.ii |,,j l.'iiiii.'. It , 111..... (iluiil. 'lu iilil.llis illl ,/,v ll.-lliali.liatr . 11 rt'ttii cailR.' V,i,.l.,r-» re ^'l' >.r\...lall Vil i.IliirriKlitu ,i„, a,v..r.li,i^ ,0 ^^,,j l(iLl.I..|'way y" I'.'i l'laiiiiiir.< ioi: ■nil. iir». |i.ir ,. , iirr.' Il |,ar .-au, Itiirhl iiivL'li '..I'iainlilVs iiil.'urs t.i UHr 111. r t..r lui- ii;;:il.t. |.iir. 4.H - viiliiiitrvH ill' I' ili'llliiTi'l lie %Ui'n!itT'f • ■'"^■'''^, l«^''', !'■','■"* |..;ll,sl,. \-,.,„|lv,|; -..i, ,•! ,.'l.'. oMMv.t.-'.M navrrt.s i,Hc|„'au Manli ,„.|i,,. smviiiit. .>iimo.li .laii- lu|,ivs iMi.h v.i>ii.,i,,Mi ,,iiulio hcuivs jui M.rti ipour uchcvor du li'Vi;r_ iiiif iirllcpiuvtMiu.' 1 r.m lu. i,i inri. l'\.| mi,,.,ou n'Olail pas avuc iiioi. .1.. ^xxU poHitit ,|iu. l.eri,'iu's,.ii ii'a pa-''i' i'voii' pri-^ ,!,• m,,. l„.iire a mir livnrv ct ilciiii puiir in.ni.liv la rliari;i' id' \ allri'. (Sillied. ( (II AS. l5AILI.AR(;i:. I i:i>ui). SI A\ i;li:^. 13 lilifd it iii, ii' ilij ipiai ilii Tin i|in i-i lie h', «as so liiiill llio i.'ardeii. Venn'' ilaiis 111 ant ii lien :\ In II imni-aif y ic'l'iiidi'ur ni'iv ■nir. Li'spiillcs <-t l'"ciL'ni's(in, IS dii nidiilin. ilr la vliaiist'c, ■ia avail Ictrct • rn aiirail cii '//' 1 1 III rii'ii'n ^t.i: jmiiri.^ il'iiiH lis ci di'ini lU' ariiii' |i.. li'Milt'- di- liniit pour loWII 111', i-t,'. Ii' I'rInalldi'UI li'T dr Holt,!'. 1 and llmiwiiii; i" pas IX' ipriis 'Up phis d'l'aii. I pi'ii dii I'l'Mi- I llic Miiiida\ I" Ills avairni ImIIIi'S cI .\rri:M)i\ o. Extniils Irani ht/(x und irlil'^its etc. ikjlmn'^ possesawn.i uml liuiindnrii's of ji'irtirs. I^';'''i' ^"' I ■• " f"'- 'litii ti'ii-.' (Si.iirin'Mfic di_' Rcitnpnrfl hni'H(''o d'llli i-ott' ih\ la dill' livi.' IV d,. Xnti ■I" I ''■'""I""- Daiiii' ill' llraiipoi't I'f di'laillr.' d- l.i ri\iri.' ilnSiidi dr \l,.iitii|..ivii.-v." 1,'i'aiil urnviiaiida halt li-a-- i. . n| ,.\ii:i .I'ptii di'la rivii'i'i' di' X,>ii-,- lijiurdi' Jioaii[i'ii't dii '1. Si'iijiu'iiiii,' lie I'hi' ad'htioiial r'''"r\ I.', I'.r Sinn' till.'." IU,nii'i. |lc I'l llil'lMI'.s i-,i! 'I'l;' n'-a •. "■ \:"''s-'"'"!"^ '';• l'''^"d""'' |-if.-ol.sl,anr. - . ,„ ,„ i„i.,i. ,- i,„n ;,„-,; ,p„, i,, ,.,ut apparti'- 'l,'a'i,.M ,,;,; ".■"■•'" '''!■ ''•" ""■'"' '•'■ l"-i"l'"ii parladonatioii .pii liii avail .•l.-' fail,' par I'l'u Hohort (iilliird i.iii.u.l ii iHi- vivant Scii^'Mi'iir ihi dii I'm Mnp III. ,1,. MUIV .1 iLlihillllit s .> !• »t 1 Kil.il.it V... I •'■ '■■' •^'•. l>il~'hi siKiv I I iiiMii iht Sahd'.rrv d.inii.' , i . ..iilinui' k- dhiit, .h- piirh,. ,.i ,1,. lylr.lni 1),.. i-has^i' ail X d its liahitan!- >iir h.-ui drM-n! luv -niv ml !.- am i.n- titri-^. ■•' !.■ ,h,.ii di' iiirttri' '""'■'"' "'I'" siir la ''it'Vi' kairs auiniaux. .|ui'i.>. Till.' -^ Hi Till April, i:;i. |i.iVii.li,ni;s J. ■• 1,1's irnis pMiii,,n-d.' li^iiiv, iiiv-:i!., ill- .■..;,,!. , ' ui- ail plan ill- la ti'rri'dcs :i iv]''!lmr„. ^■'•ii<'""i-S '■> >;i'daii,.p„' ].- p.n h,., ,, a /, . ■ „ ,, ,/,,,%>.„■ /, . A, „x , |.' plan ampii'l il ust ii'i ■I'li'i.i.. Till,, ivli'i'i'i'sti'i'liii I'xliihii I ,l'' I', (■•nd,"ii- li!^' a I i_'ii.|ii,-iri ,11 ;iti,Mi.lanl .pa,' h' tout suit IIl'-iiiv • I -ja .M;ir, Ii iiii'siiri''i'Xa,-t,'nii'nl -i h, -.'in ■ -t. ' ■• i. . ., ifii l.i ,/,' /.,•<■. ,,./•.',•, /.,.//.■.„..;>/,,• w-//-, A; r!n ,1,: '•-'■ ll:'hlll,irl,l/l/:(irf,lrll,f.llll'U,l,l..i, /)' I, ^,'.l'l S, n/IH ■II' ■•': II, ■I'/p.irt , ,1 XHIi ,l}ll lis ,../l«,i„V,;.* ,/, /" rilirli." Ill h ii.lant u.ii.ii : nil. I M '>■ •'Coiisi>iant m ,■,■ .pii -. ii -i . ■ d p.: ■ !,i 1 1\ .■ -ml nii, -i ,U- la rivh iv ,lr l!,'aiip,.rt ipii ■'" • dnis^'ra loiijiiiir- 1,'s dit- "l.. ' —I,.'- ,|ii- SI. m- , t Hani,, i i.|,li,-|i:iv unit, 'tit ,l siihr,,::,.!,! liii'ini'i''. 'I'i- jiarci-'s ]>ri'si'iitrs I,, dits Si pifiii iir- .1, a.-.pn'ri'iirs vu h'lir lii-nx ,(' pla,-,' en loiil ct avaii- ti.- n .M,iy, liiiji's, prcro;j:atoiivs,.t aiilr,..q'ivn.n!'.,i'.^ a..|iii-,-^par !.' 'lita.-t,'. i .\,ti' dil -".• .Mars ITS;",) i-Mii','.-i,iii,l,- '''"''"''' '''■* di'iix li, IS .1,- .pi.ii-, li.iii..;ai'. I'lah!.' ,■! antr'- h itiini'iils .■nn-tniits sur W terrain, r.'i',i.''|,",r"A'„'- s"il^l" li'iif. •■I' 'in,' d.'-sa.,,.n,,.,l,. ri \,ai.|ii, li.'ii r r\-..r. ni ,.\,.,pii'r ,.n |U<;,)ii ipi,'li-on,pn;.'' I..I1W .lii.-li,- •• IjCs dit Ml, niiin- a I'ariii. ■,,/./,.■/, , liaiiLjar- ,piai-. p.nir h'^ av.ii;- tail rrtahlir I'l roiistniirt' m','v',.i''.''.'i!'''''' '''*-'" '''/""''■■ ''"'""■' ITS.",.-' •• A la ,-liar._',' par h's ,lit> acpn' ivin- .!.■ laiiv .'ti'iitri'ti'iiir a toiijour.-), ,ii"ii.. 11 MM. tmiti'S li's I'lntiir.'S ln''.-.'<-air,'s p,,nr cnLniriv I,',lil Icrrain ,l,-. ,.|.'., ./■ ,n.ini,'r, " p, nuillr, ,iu.r Niii.'ii b'r,w,.r. 'iiiiiiiiin.rd'illlrrh,':!',' ■■ .-,■ r,'~, r, .i ii' I,, -iicur lli|.|i,-nay I. 'ii> ailln-s ilroits ct,'," cli Vi'rlii ,U's \"'m''. ','(''"' '"''^''" '"I''''" •'" '■•'"'■ pr'nin, ■•" ■■ I.,'- nn.iiliiia larin,' ,-t a s,i,- ,'1 Iclirs ilrp,.mlaii,'0 Ili'.s.'i'iiiiiii, dc I'lisaa;,' I't limits, Ir I'.mii p-.m- !,•- ,11!- in'mliii-, ipiais, haiiLrar. ct iiiitn's ili'-pcinlaiu'i's ivrn'm,! ''" '''■' '■':'"""■■'' /""■'"■"''"' /"'■' '"■■ '' /■•■'■ ■ '" 't d'. i.'iili' Ics .■onuiioiiilcs cl il,'.pcn,lan,-cs ■.i''i'M'!'™'i.,! ''"^''^ ''''■'^ iiioiilins, s.int a"! , •IK'Uhiit ,t iipp. rti,.iiii,'iit aux ilits |,ri'iiciii-i, l),Min,nt \.u.l..r\ r,- ^'" ""'I''-' l^'" "I''-' \,.,i.l.-.i!-i aiix .lit., prciu.iirs ;'i lavcnir a |,orpL'tiiitc, poii- -'i,..l.,ii v,.ir iV hhrrlr .1. ' -.■',■,,■ .I'l:,. I., ,1.1, ,-'n.'i: ,1. ll,,iiii„.ri jus.pi.-.hi ,111 'i'I'".'r.i'i'M''."'' '"""'"' !<•■■' I"itiiii.i, I- ',, ,, ,/■,,,,/ ,„/ .'.I'l..!.,- il li:\l'.ii,;- >■'(•/.(■ /i','ir l.,iry li:ii,s/i,ir/.s; ;"„',"""*"''" t'mli.iC'iihiiiiiils cl ,l,'l,;i-i',. ::: .' . y,~ ,,..,,:i-r ,„ ,'i,v ,i,iji,--i..'^:'' '• L,'- ,lils v,'iidi'iirs sc ivsor- HiJit..i,v,iy vaiit ilu sc ruscrs ir lie hi dil,. ri\ici-,- ,-,iniiii,. i'i-,|,.vanl ,■! aiilr,'s ,|i,,il i.T I'hiiiiiir.s ict'llu." I),',-I,ii;u,l I. aiii.i.is. pur ,:oar.^„,iliinl,il.:..(,: I, IT,. ,•! p,ir ' •lunciiriaiix ilaiis 1' rnii'us iivani r. mint' a di.\ II vi'i-.s trnis •> ■ Hi^lit Kiv,.ii I.. I'liiiiiiiir > Itllt'lir.., 1,1 lisr li,, r I.T li«- ^ijl'il't' pur- 41 U\gll i.tMn- ili.i- 1.11 ■.11- ^umi iiiiy mill. ii.-. niiliMiit 111 liny \\i>\ clitihifiii^^ till- imliinilc.'ursi' nil hi- wiilrr. 1). r.ii.l,iiir> r.viiii'ii ii It l> il at r.i ^l■ rt^crvinil If- llili VcniK'llO 111 lilirl'lr ill' ((ill^lniili.' iiiniirni> -111 li ilili' ri\it'r« II lilll'i' nil tiT< ii-iiiii.'-i lir 111 (litu rivit'i-f ,1,1. ,h;iii,rt III': ,1, I, ,11- l.hn-l,-, ,1, h;,i. ,■/,/„... I., ,1.1. ,1,1, ,11111,1 I, ,,iiir-' ii,itiii;l • I.-. r I, Tl iii|iort 1- :i -III ill I \ II' ll\ . rilL'illl,' ll'iHIl -IV IvM'K,' l.i'l ill wi'llli. Ill iir I'll' III III ll .ll|l\ l"*."!! tlll'll' C'llllll' 111! l'\ .'lu'l' lilllll I ilUVr cVi'l' \VII> tlllll'll III li'iiiirirni:ii-\ lii'iny I'iii'i ulii.li run-' i| ii Iit-IicI iiihI tin- riviT kiiiiwii ii 111 III'. All till' liiiiiN iiilJiMiiiiiir di'' I'iviT Mciiii- if iioi't rniiii my inill ilmvii lullir Mini wi'i'i' iiioi r iti'il. 'I'll!' wiili'i'- imsscil liver "'■'"'■'■- il Piirl oCtlii' prniiirtv nl'lln' I'hiiiiliiri MiirinuM. I Imvc iil-" Uiiuwlnlu.' llml tin' stiiil |ii'o " ,M:ini'il\ 11. Iliinill Nil ■|:I7. I inuit (' 1. I'ri.i.li.fs.'vi' ml liv«hi Is. KJii'iviiiir till' i\iiiit 111* ll rrt''«lirt in .l.'lilli. Ih-tVtiiljiiit .TlV /"'" I, t, , II .ii'i rti'.ii' ih.irul On .M i;i;il iu;ii I" I., is.-ii. t; ,t' uriliiiiirv III' illl nt llll' nviT oiiiiii>iti' iiiv nil 1 is about six 111' si'Vi'ii iiirlii'^. ,;.//i//;./. Till' r IVl'l' Oli]iOSI ll,C lliillil ill '/ll. -'"'Il '■' (■•■- / /li'lll. iil""il tl' til iiiv mill i-i iiliiiiit Iwilvr li'i. I ■li'iiiM I'lill tivi' fi'i'l ili'ptli olwiiiii ill till' mill |iiiiiil Mil I'xlniiinluiiii'y til I, 11 i-iiiir, vii h•l^ (livi'r-<('M iiu'i ill' ■ll. ('. .\. C •Ir . I I ilt'i'lliri' I'Miil.iit No imiiii'iilili' iilU'i-ti'' iM fliiirui' I'livi'i's If ilit i.|iiiii-iiiil (tiiiuy) iiiOiiiiiiih'i I ill' I'l I'lilri'li'iiii' a 'J lii'il III ni.|iii'li' 'Jl.lh I'l 'I |ii'r|ii'lilili'' tiiiiti'^ li'S rlotiil'i'^ iiri'i'SMiiil'i's, m i'( i|ir/.'.//i.-' I'lriliii'i'S (ii'i'niit iilii,;n ■•'III' III rii t li's iliiiiiiiiiii'^ili' Iti'Miii" It llll ilil iiiimi'iilili ul-,,ll.>l ,1, I'l ,'ri- lilllll, iii. \i\'[\H' It' I'l. l-.''l. (rii|ii'i's ll' ilit iii'li' iliiit ilivisi'i'ii toiijniir.^ U-> ilits lu''i'itii?:i's, ft^i'ioiil ili-ipiiM'os do liiimici'i' ;i I'l' i|iu' li's iiiiiiiiiiiiv llll ilit i)]i|iiHiiiili I'ti' |iiii-.-ii'iil I'lii' I'liiiir'i'lii-i, ni iliri'i'ti'iiii-'iil, iii iiiili- ri'i'li'iiii'iil, il'alii'i' liiiii'ii ail linnl ili' In riviri'i'. I'liiiiii;-.' ill' I'l'iiiiiliu'riiiriii ill' I iri'iiiiM'. . 'iiii|'iir t ill ./ i.iiii.n.i ,;,iii-iri, inir III iiiiir, li.d r\riril t'lilir Ici'l ill llrl'.'lll llli'V lll'i Mari'll ls.,1. Kii.l.iii'i- 111' On mil' ni'i'asiiin I ri'iiii'i uIm'I' alMlH' liiwiT izrnuiiil- III r.iaii|".|l lirili^' lliioiliil liy a iH- lii-la't. I l.iniliiili I I. -Mii'.lini 111- I. h Inula :iii||i riiiit llir rii'i'r I Irti'llilllllt'll riuit riiiiniiir riiiiiiiiit 1,1"! Itruwii III. I'oiiliiiii"! t< Al'iri' liia\ v rain- ni' a lliaw of snuw in llir .-|.iiii ;r //„ „.//,/,-,/ I.,, I ,,/ ll., II ill, .il III Ii. I'.; I'.li.l. iirt If iri'fiit iiiiilv if watfl', wllii'li iCi'llflallv rnlilf.s iluUli tin' l ivi-r nil i-lli'li oi'i'il.^ioiis On oiif oifa-iiiii tliiiii;,'li'tlif slnii'f irati's Wfi'f mi, llif llat lamU in the \ iiinily. Wf I'l „/,. 1,1 llll , I, nil ■ill ll ami llif watii' |ia>.sfi l\7i. II tl„ ./.ll, < .in ,1, .11-11 ll.i ii-.iler iiiii^l /'ll.-' "'"'".'/ /"■"/' i- mill lull I nil l)ftwffii tho mill anil llif I'laintill^- iiMiifrty. 1 /.,> ./, /""" //i(//l ll, l'..r,- 'll ,;iii lliii.il ll., I iiiiitiniii li,/, I 111 mil -imi «liin I li.i'l 111-' mill lln' wati'i' I'linliiiiifil to ri-f in ll, llimr_'li llll' ',;ali'- Uflf ii| Wi i|„-lr ll -J. r. .\[. ami tlif watii'- I 1,1 a lalf limir iif till' lii-lil allir " liifii tin v u'linlnallv Milnliiiil. i:vliil.lt At till' liiiif 1 wi'iil 111 till' ilaiii lliiii wa.s a fmit nl wali'i' mi tlif rnail, hi'twi'i'i. llif mi! II. i:,iuiii'l (lain anil tlif mil ,i,,iii« ij.i ■'1. I'liiiiililf- K' \V1 hill. .\. r.' I'l..- a. wliarl imu fXi-tin ('. .\. OiiLi'V, i- alimit 111 ruii-li'iirl a uliiii'l'iii aiMilimi to or |ir. ilmiiralimi ,.\ tin.' uhiili f.Mi'iition saiil (iiiu'v iiilf inlt- In Iniilil inln tlif flianiifl ot'riv.i 'aii|im'l ami ii|imi llif lifil tlii-i'i'iil' .11 as 111 iiiiiifilf III' ia.--airf 11 I' sflinilllfl's mill o tli.'i l^liaml IVmn tin' Inill ami In iiilfi'lfrf willi llf wmkin'/tlif I'fi't'. Ami wlifi'fa- tliiit ififi will uIhiiiI Iu ImiM. I'liiilitiir i\ liiliii N'.i i:i. tl Ihf .-laiil wliarl' i- an I'lii'i'iiai'liiiif lit mi llif ilianni ll llif -a ill ii\f I' a- it aluavsi'xisli 'la;. Allri'.i.rv Dnil ll imi'i'lia-frs -liall sulniiil ami f.inl'.iriii tnwanl- I'.. <'. A. Oiii;y. l''.-i|iiii'f. |ii'ii|ii'if tm laiii 111' llni Sfiirnimy ill' I'lfaiipni'l a- lifiiiLT ill 111 ' '' ''' ' ' ''' riii'lils 111' llif lalf Aiiliiiiif .liu'lifrfaii if-iiav. Ins lifir- ami as.-m'iis ill tlif si'i'vilin ll'M'I'VfS, . .1.111 |l. f, u i.'iiiu :iiiili (1.1. l-.v,». riiHl I III- riMT i* II iiavn.'.i'i!.' ■/■/"'/ I In .■',11,1 rii; r ftfinj,,;-! . < ' - /, iiuil ii-" -iirli liat nniil lli'' ij-i-ii'viiiuM' Iuto- iiml'lrr iiiiii|ilaiiu'cl hI'. Im'cii iiiiviit'.il'i'' Irniii lli.' ^.liil iiiilU In rlii' rivi'i- Si. I.iiw iciirr iiinl liiilli lircri M..'i| ami cnidviil in \\w <\\\,\ I'lainiill'iiuil lii- |iicilri'i'-i-.ciis, in llii' llniilliii;- i)[ lncti'iiiix mill dlJii'i' vc-^M'Js (■iii|i|u\ril li\ llniu iiM oiivi'V ill'.,' -'I'l'iii- ll'in ami iiIIht illi-ri. In uml tVniii ill.' -.liil mill. , I I ilr.'iaii' !,■ ilil lifi' rl I'lilri'li'iiirii I ill) ilii iiiiiiii'iilili' /7, lui[iU'IK' I 'I-,,' 1 1 n llri'/lll IIk'V lll'i Tli.il ih" ^\ linri' ill i|ii. •(it'll 11. 'ai \\ lr;ii.'i'.» till' liitr nil. I llltlT:« till' '■."llf..! ..(■ itlL. iviiItT'* I'Iml III" riv.r it il.'Klrii.vi'.l I'.ir iiitviifdi.lc piirjii.'"''., Ii.'l.'ii.liint.i ixi-.'l.li.'ii i:.. Ill I'ltiiiilitl' iliitlnrutiiiii. 'I'l.iit riiiiniiiV lll.T.i.'li'llr.l t„Hi* |irfvi.>in- Jv JUi.l hi'l'.ii- limit li^i'l til l.iiilil Ilil Hli.'irf III |H-'lll'l't 111* |'r,'i"rt> .Mli.i.iMl ..r I'liiititilV l.l.'l I.I Muiili |i. I.ll.'lllfs iitli'laill. I'i.'l''.| \'\ Itli.lMl H(:;iili'il (Jll|5V. IIL'llill'.t IliH l.llli.lllll.' liiH «linr!..l l-.M Tllill llic siliil Drii'lliluill iliil I'lTrt. nil nr llliiilll tlic llitll ill' Oilnlicr IS.V.', il:„/ ',11 ilinl "/"i« til, mini rll-if /l,,lll/„,)'t ,1 ,;i-l.i:,i ,rl;l,l. ,rl,„l, I, ,,1,1,/ li-lllir^ ■ ll; lli„,l, ,,l' ll„ S'lnl /-.I . C .//../ (/7'"7l mill ifl.iirl' iii'il, ri'ill,/ ,ili, i-' tl; ii,iliii;il ,■,„(,■■, ,./ il„ .sihil r,,; r 'ii„l ii'irii,ir' Ihi ihiinul ,■/ ll„ -iim, .-n (/(i/.7i, lliiit il ii iiinv <|uiti' im|in^-ili|i' ini- iln' I'liiiiititr In llnul ii|i liiiti'iiiix ami nlln'i' vc^hcIm tVdlu the saiil river ."^l. I.avvri'iii'f in IIh' -.liil mill ii- licrctnrnii' aii( rrmlanl lialli li_v liii'liiiH iifllic saiil wliarl' [iri'Vi'iili'il till' Willi i> rmiii riiiininir ilnvii lln' miliiral rliaiiiii'l (if till' fiiiil river ami ,i,i,lii„s ll„ .I,,,.,,. ' ' ,,.'',,/ ,, t'l, lh„t ;„ j); .l.,i i:,,,, tlir wnt. r i- thnnvii liai'k ii|iiiii tilt' iiiill, til'. Thill llu! wlinrt' iiiiii|.laim'il nl in lln- ili'i'hiialiitii is wlinll\ I'li'i'lfil nu llii' Di'l'i'iiiluiit'!! irmiiml iiiiil lines mil iriivi i'm' nr iiinjei't inlu the river. ''<"/ 'A"' H; ,1,1., .v. ,;'i.7, ./ /../ ih, .-niil Uih ii,liii)l Ims II,, II fdixiil I'm- tt„ jiiirjiin,- III' jirirriifiiiil ll,i i iiii'iniiliiin i,l nj tin «*»/ ri/'ic i//in» hix liiiiil mill Ilil ])il', mliiiil Miilli Ih'il liiiiij jii;riiiiis III tin in •■linn nl' tin- >aiil ilike li;l tin •■iiiil J)i- I'liiiliiiil, lie, till' saiil I'laililiir liail eie.leil a pier nr « liarl' ll|iiiii llie n|i|i()site .^iile nl tlie saiil river, wliieli Huiilwliarl' exleii.le.l a ureal ili-laiiee iiiln ihet-aul river aiiil I'liieil llie uatcrs anil elirrelil In llie I lereliilaiil's ^iile, U lielel'nre il li.'iaiiie liei T.-.-ai V' I'nr I lel'i mhilil In erei't >»aiil ilvke tin' liis nun in'oleeiion. Iti. 'I'lial ihi-- ile| lit .Inl h.'l|il.iie aii\,:-lnhi- .il.iii'^ III. -I.'iii -I'.ir aiel llial il was iinl 111 ^siiry I'nr llel'iinlant tn Imilil liis wliail. IT. Mill ii~.''l In ~ln|i I'niir Imiir-/'. r .Aw |.reviiiiis in ihe liuil.line- nl'llie uliarl'nl' l^"iJ. I"<. W'lii.li w liarrili.il ..r l"^'"il I -ail I i iui^.v in I em I- in I mi I.I in In llie eliaiinel nlihe ^ai.l river l!i'aii|iiirl ami ii|i.iii lln- I. .'.I nl'llie sai.l riverami \\liereas ili.' ^ai.l uliarl i> an em'rna.'liinent II I II III llie el la nil el a- llie ~ame lia^ aU\ a\ ^ e\i-lei| ami e.Meii.U l.ir lieynml tlie I mil mis nl' llie |.ri>|'erly nl'llie -a" I l iiiL;\ ami i~ lal'-iilaleil -erinil>iy In injure llie sanl lirnwii. (Siiincd. (IIS. li.VILL\li(Ji:. i:i)>v. stavi:m:v. Ari'i:M)i\ Ii. |l.lU/:|itl..|M. T. |. illi.l. .;:til.i.- '.I' ClaiiM \;ii. Cl.ii-. ■i\ li.ivi.lili, r"1ir.s .r.jiii p. '111. I'lIP' I". IV t'' Extnii'l^ Irani iii/l/m/s on rirer'.i. 1. Del'eiiM- a l"Ule~ [.er-nniie- ile lair.' nil niilles ei|iliee> nil enil'eelicniel:ls nilisililes ail eoiirs lie lean ilan- I.- II.um'- nil riviere- naviiraliles, llnllal.le- el meiiie .|'x jeler et". Defense a tmil.- i.er...iim'-- ile ilelniinier I'ean iles rivieres naviual'les nil il'eii HH'aililir nil allerer le emir.^ ele. II est lln line iii'leianiie all |iini.rietaire nil rermier il'iiii iiinnlin snr nne riviere iiavi- ,,Mlilenii llnllalile l.niirl.' U'lnl's 'ine le iiinulin a ele eini't'-clie ile tnuriier. •J. Cnniiue aiee-nire- ile- rivieres navie-aliles U's i.ras iiuMuo imn navi.u'alile .|iii eiulei.en- ilPiil soul ejciileliieiit iniii|iris ilaii.s la iloniaiiie pulilie. I.e eniiii-le il'iirirenl ileniamliiil <|m' I'oii ileelaral naviiralile les eonrs d'eaii i|iii l.orloiit lialeaii.\ nil rai|eail\ pemlanl illi lmii> an liininsilan> le eniiraiil ile I'aniiee. l.es rivi.'re iiavi.'aliles, la nier el les -reves .pi'i'lle eniure lial.ililelleineiit sont liors ilu ediiiiiieree paree.in'nn ne eom.uil pa> hiio leiir eonseeratioii aiix ii.sagoh geiioraux puiHseul en aiii'Uii temps eer-ser. •in l",i^.,. li. 1,1' Icnaiii i|Ur liM iMi'\ luiivi, -iiiiH ilulionlfhu'li' cMriioiiliiiiiiic (•«!. rctriirtli't H(iih mil ilotitc ilil l.ctilivic lii- ill I'liiiic'iiiiiuMiiiii' riiiiir i •f, ijmi iilinn.-^^hnniii lliinmi tiiiiliiiif, I't lu luisii' ili'i li;uili'.i I'liiiv ii:ivii.'iiliU'iiiilii(iii'i' hi '■n-. nil linit li' (Idiiiiiini' |iiililii' clciii roiiiiiit'tii'i" la |)i'()|irirli'- ilis riviTiiin^. I,ii loiir tie Iadii ii (losc in iiiiiitc a la iijj^iii' ilii ]iiiH liaiiti'H i-aiix llavipllll^'^^. I,a I'l'i'li'ii'tidM ill.' la liiiiitr ilii llnivi' mix ui- Ir li'i'i'ain. La jiiii'-|aiiilrin r niliiiiiii-lralivi' I'st iTMtro I'oiiliiriiii' aiix iui:* lioiuaiiii's .1 aii\ iiin ii'ii- |ii'iiiriiir-i ilii ilrnit Fraiii'ais allt'sti'' iiiir Li'lVlivrr ilc la I'lamln'. I >riliiiumnrr'( iiutriliiiicK tti' Klfl liivitTos iiavi' aip|i< Jii-ijii'an uraml llni i\f .Nhiiv. (SijifiuMl. (MIS. P. \ILLAK(ir;. i:i)\v. si'avi:li:v. \l!r.lTI!ATl()N i:\Pi;\SHS. Ml{. llMI.LAH(;i;s A( roiNT. < Mil- liiiii'lli'il ami liriy-lliri'i' ihi\-< rmplci; I'll, ^iiar tin- l^*lli nl April ls.")7 to ilii' I'liil iiI'Mav If*."!'.', liriiiir uli'iiit J.")A niciitlis in luini; s^oni in, Mir vi'viiiir till' pi'i'iiiisi'.-, ji'Vi'lliiiLr, iili'i'iviiii; lln' liilrs, ami >li)ppaLri' ul llir iiiill at all .-lasniw. prrpaiiiiir plan-* ami siTtiinm, takiiij; cviiloiii'i', ln'aiiiii; till' I'ai'lii'-, ifailiiiuniml aiialvsini; tin' rci-oril, ilcliln'ratiiitc ami piipariiiir till' i-i'piirt, at Irii ilollai^ iSli'i piT ilav ^1-'>'M (in Cliaiii lirarrr.-i, rlcrU's liiiiir I'liiploviil at |'laii-, im—'aLCrs, ,\;r.. \i'., "It ilay-. "H 0" Kxpi'ii-i's iiu'luiliii'.' carriaiji' hiri' lur twi-iiiv-iiinr liipi tn UraiipDi't, tnlls. !-taliiiiiarv, Milipu'iia^, i'*;i- "I '■'■''i 111 I'opv i.fn-i.oit,47,nilit wiiriN at 10 i Is 17 W III I'Viiii'lIll' talii'll liv Kxpi'l-ts. •JO.iMMi L'll ill) fsi'i't'olliic anil liiH.' pnior.-alo till- tuu U'arsat 8.VI 100 00 Aiinmnl iliir to Mr. liaillarL'i:' #1H.15 f-ar\ In ri'liiark llial tlm rliaix'i' inaili' li_v tin' I'lxprrt-i i> in roality ripial In iii>l inmli'ni'iri.' tlian half till' aiiiiiiinl : sinro Mr. I!aillari;-i'' liir inshinri' ua> rinpliwi'il \\ix ilays 'il'l'min Im A. M. In Iniir I'.M. Nrillirr mu-' it 111! forirotlrn that tln' rase wa-i um' that pn-i-nli' I pi'iiiliar ilillirnlliis. ami ihat llu- I'liaii;' ; - it i-*, is III) niiii'i' than halfnrwhat ( lovrrnnn'nt ailnus |-ji'.;iiiiM'r.-. I'nr >inillai si'rviri's. MK. STAVKLMV'S ACCOlM. ScvLMity-thrco (lays i'inplii\'-'l as incntioiioil in Mr. Uaiilarirr's actDunt, iiol ini'lililiiiii: plans, si'rliniis ;iml ol' ri'pinl. al ??10 •':57''>o un Kxpfiisi's. ill! hnliiiL; larriaL''!' hill- :'>'■'< "" S7s:i 111' 47 i:i:Mii:i Mi'l'i'iiiliiiit ■< l'\|n'il liin not Hiilncrilpcil liU iidiiii' tn IImm ri|Mirt, lull liiw i>iTli'i'n'i| til si'ii.l in a -f|'iiiiiti' iinc. Nni tliat \i]n vU'Wh ilitU'r \.>iy imitiu'- iall\ liiiiii niiiN cm iiii>->i 111' tliii riiiirlu-ioii-i iiiiiii' tip in aii-iwiT to I III' Ni'verii! cluiHt'-* of tlio Jmlu'ini'iil, IpiiI iivowi'ijly nil urf.iiiiit (pl'ipiir liiiviiiu'. iircoiiliiii; tip liiin, fxi I'cilfil uui' iliitii's |p\ ri|iiii'tiiii; ii|iiiii till' svliait' III H."iJ in ii'latimi In it-* intinn mi llu' iii- hC tins riviT iliiiitii; till' ^lll•inl^ IVi'^lirt^, ami mi ai-ruiinl nl'mif liavini; in any way liinti'il at tlm rmnii'f rxi^li-iiri! ipfii S'ipi'lli Ka^l rtianinl ln'Xiinil llu' liinit- \ N' iinnlimiiil in tin' jiiil!;iMi'iil. NdI' wcriMVo in aiiv wiiv lalliil n|imi aiinniiiii.' to llu' liili'inlant- llsiH'it'* to |irr|iiiri'. llu' lovi'l'iil nil I'li'iliri'-i aiiiii'Xril In on. i'i|iiiii. ■••ii all liii-r |Mrinr \!i. \\'.ilhui' may ln' rij;lit hut wo tliink iiiil. 'I'll'' Jiii|i:ini'nl ralli'il ii|ioii iln- i;\|i.it- to i Naiuinc ainl fi'imrt niimi tin- inilnfil ni'il ,irliji'"il "li^lnirl.n,,^ to till' tl'ivv lit till- u.itir. Tl \[ illlfii'tiiv 111 till' I'lillrl mill it- j"iilir,il,ir •,i,i.i,-. ANo uliitliri' a ri-ti' ol' tlir water is caHHi'il |py (In' i'IphIiiii timi-. Till' niiiU'1-jii.'iii'il i'mi''iil''i'i'il ll"' natiii-al ainl artitirial iil.-tinrlimi^ to inrliiili' tlio-r nl' I'Vi'iy ill -n'ruilion wlirllnif ot' u iiirinani'iit or imii ly nl' a ti'iii|poiiiiy iliaiarlii'. Tiny I'lin^iili'i'i'il till' iri' lo 111' anion vr tin' /"O/. !''".■• i"i/,-.,« aliovi- all mini to .I'nl liii|ii' to In- lioini' out li\ till' Couil 111 llnir iiilir|'i''l:ili'in ol' l!ii' /jiiilijiiniii At'tiT i-oniini; to tin' roiiilu-ion lliat no i-liannrl (mil i'\i-iiil in l'>-"ij, lu'twri'ii \ ami N', till' r',\|iril~ ili'iini'il it i'X|iri|ii'iit in vii'>v ot'all tin' I'viilrin'n mi tin' -iiliirit to otl'vi' .imiic .AlTlanatioii. iH to wlii'ii' till' >ii|i|ii'-ii il iliaiiiu'l iniiilil liiivf lircii, ami iw lo tin- ii|i|n'iiiriii'S anil iiri'oin|iaiiyinLr ^ynoini-, vm- iliil not i?mi'>iil(i' tin' iihto lai'l of llirir |iri'-ilinuMi| ulntlirv Mr. Walla, r - irUi-ai lo riiilor-r mil vu'W-. 7:1 nil II-. il '.1.1.', IT w' I'O llll lUO Ull SiiiiuMl. (IIS. liAIM,AI{(ii: 1:1 »V. SIAVLLLV ADDITIONS TO Hxri'itTs mm [^(1 lljc '^anofrtdli; v0^tt^l1cs. ol' ilic >J^ti]'fCviov V^out-i. At till' I'lul orilii' l!r|n>rt siiit ill In Mr. W'uilih-i' tliii-i; ii|.|"Mr' n ii'iiiaiU |iiii|i(iiliiiL; li. I iifiH'il liv Mr. HailNiriti'. Tin- I'l'iiiail \* In till' 1 li;.t lliiil Mr. I! iiidcii'-c-i ,Mr. Will lii>'. llin> ivil liv Mc,->r-* liaillai'H'-' mill Slavi'ii'v ami -ii;inil liv iIh'iii. v'u'H'* I'.M I'ptiiiir ill «> liir II'' ilu'vari' iiiciililii'il contauiril in llari'|>nl't yw- 111' llirrr HxiiiTl-* lliav in rralitv in' -\ niir >aiil l'<'|Hii't. lluit till' |>nini nn wliirli liin-I inatrri.illv ilitt'iT rrnin Mr. \V illiu-i' i-. in rralily tlii'nnl\ iin|inrlaiit |Hiiiii ni i,.|i 'I'hr siiliji'it nl iiini|ilaint as sit I'mtli in llir l'l.iinliH"s iK'i'laralinn i- tin' wliarl' I'l'ritiil In ll lli'l'i'inlanl 111 l>*.'i'.'. aii'l Mi'ssps. l!aillari;i' ami St.iv<'li'\ liy tlirircc|«irl lu'nvi.' lliiit wliarl'ln l.i i li-allU all nli-lrUrllnll wllii'll sjinlllil lie ri'limvi'd. 'i'lial is ihc niilv iiiati rial pnint nn »lii a il.i- Expects diiSngreo. il will tlll'IOlnri ■ nsiik-rt'd liv tin' iJnnnraliU' .linl-'i- llml Mr. i>iiillai';;i'''s naiiio ui 11 ■ I.Mr. \Viill.ni''s ri'|inrl ainiuinls In liilU' or iiniliinu' u illi niranl in his n|iiiiii till iiil\ inii"'itaiit print at i-suc. It liiis just ni'i'iii-i'il In tin' liinli'l'siLtiifil that tin' n (.rrvinils tn lililiu' il llu'V llni ■Inir liiir tin l|( iMi'.h ilali' nl'llii'ir l'i'|iiirt liasinit lii/i'ii lilliil « ill I'liiisiilnr till' ilali' "I till < nmniiiiinatinii a lilli'il ill in'i'nriliiijily. s lii'inj; llial nl tlic .-ani irpnit aii'l Inlrl \ iUillmri/i' tlic .-an 1 ilatr l'> l> W'v mils! alsn iv|Ui-t that tiii- cninimiiin alinn hf anni'.Xi'il in ( tiir l>r|Mirl ami i Inriuiiig a |>art tlnn of. (Sioii,.(l,j (IIS. r,AILLAUiriiiziiiici' of nil nllidiivit liy tlw KftViHliilit ill tliiHcii-'': iiMiU.rtw.. (.ilniullhlii.ii- niH' liv Ml'. Wiilhi.i- 111.' Idi.niliiiif^ Kx|.(Tt llu' ..tli.T liv Mr llnlwfll ii .1. lis ill Mr. Walhin's oll'lr,, ill rihOi of wlij.h ar.' t.. 1..' li'iiii'l H.vrnil iiii- tiiitliiiiiiil ivllrr!i..ii-.i,i arliiiiM.ii'riiiJniiiiii't i'> lK>' iiiiil.T.-it'iir.l : iliiiik it tli;'ii- ilniy li>;n'iii li, «ii,tii ( iilli lliat 111! siirli ii«M'riii'ii-' ii* iiiiilaiiu'il in tlici-..' iilliilavii:* aiv ^uUl^ iimliriiiiiH, iiiijii-it, uiiil wiiliiiiit ruiiiiilaiiiHi. Till' l).'ri'M'liiiit ill hii altl'lavif r.iiilinii.'- th,. |MiliiT nli-'Tvnl Ky him lliniiiv'lMiut^tlii'* pro. Iiii'ti'il -iiil'-tliat iiflryiiii; \» di-ti'a.t iilli'iili.iii ri'i'iu'tln' wliiirf I'liili dy liiiii in is.VJ iiii|l mi )(i-tlv .••>iii|ilaiiii'il ul'iii till' ilrilai'alic'ii, li> llu' roii-itl. ■ration (il'lhi' liaiik i.|%liiiii'^ lii'liiinl llii; '■• HiuMi' -(iMi'.'" tin' piiiiil of luml l.i'tw.'i'ii till' 1 liaiiiirl mill tail lar,' ami llio lii'i' lit r I 1 iiiiili.llii'i'iii-iiriiilii'anl olii.'rl- wliirh ll n.|ii'-iL:iii'i| liavi' il.'.lai'.'.l in tin ir I'l'l'mt to lii'ai'iio I'l'hitivi' iiii|u.riaii.-.' t.illi.'' sii.l wliailiH n'L'iinl- tlu' nli-lnirU'il .-tati' nt' the rivrr liranpoi'l in iVi'-iic't liiiii' ami wlii. h a", Tlion lli^y ii,.w imwt I'liipliatirallv rrp.'at tli al llnni miiy Ih' no iloiilil a-> to llii'ir liaviiii_' iiirant what in reality tln-y saiil in tlii'ir ii|iorl. 'ri,i' l». Ii'liilant -i.i'ak- ol'oiu'i.ailialitv in Cu our ollli.' I'liiiiitlll'. aii.l li..w to n liili' tl.at ,-|,;ii'ii,., w.' ll t know, h i.r.Mii', to 11, 'that wlim an l'"..\|»'ll "V iv. n a .Iml-'i' lias ari'ivcil at a "oiK-lu-ion t'.ivoiuaM'' lo on.' ..i lli.' parii.', in any suit ami wi^li' - to -i|li-laiiliat>' lii-j opinion. Ill' is ■■I'lK'il upon l.i ui,.' all lln' l"-t it., -on, he can liml in lavoiir ,.| that (.arty, ami iint.ivoiii'aliK' loliis oppoii.-iiii ami lli>' v. i \ f.i.i an.l a. I olMoin-' -o iiiiiM iiin'^sarily lor tlio limi' li.'iiM' -iv.' him ..11 an ..| p;n i i-iliU '•. hnl ii do,- m,| loll, iw thai tin' .■..lirliisioli til'st aliiv.'.l al hash.'.'ii liaM,|..ii .ih\ p.i n.il' . . mM.hiation. \V.' th.r.'l'or.' opi'iily ai.-.'laiin ami il.'iiy 1.11 oiT la.miiH' and on ,,nr oalh llial "'hav.' I.i'.ti inllilt'm'.'.l in oiir d.'.'isions in any ..iIm'I' w • than h,\ our own oh-.'rv..iioiis a' i a lull ami impartial .■.■iisi.loiati, in nl'tli.,' wholi' i'ii-,inl. l- .w, "iiiu tl aHida\il- A,- mil 111-' ,li-.p,.-.' ,.l' that ol .Mr. Ilolu.-ll and tiu'ii Ml.'- ,,"i\,lv ...h-i.l.r Ih.il .'iMi. \\\illai'.'. and that .'I th.' I ',li'lulaiil him-rlf. Wilh iv-.ii'.l to 111.' lir-i. 1- t,al',-ly m'.'.-siry to ivmark that ih.i.- is .vhl.'m'." .'Iioiil'Ii in 111.' r.-'i'or.l to r.'ii.l.r ii-.l. any I'nrih. r as-.-ilnni as M tin' l,.nm'r .xi-t.'m ,■ of a N..|'tli K.i-l .■hanin'l a sill. j.'. I lnll\ .li-.'u' I iii.iiir r.|".rl in all its p.i-sil,l.> h.arin^s. Mr. Ilolwi'll ill his /..'al lor lli.' Ii.l.'mlani ih.i'.hy thinking to s.rv.' his liia^lcr, Mr. Walla.'.', has nia,|.' an as-, nion a- , ..IninnioUs a- it is iiiali, i..iis ami niili'ii.-. 11.' slal.'s Uiat •■ it is aN.) i.alpahh' ami nlaili thai in th.' liii" ..f ,-r.'rioii llii-,.in;li poliil V. tlu' ■;i'.iilii.l ..ll •• Im.iIi si.l.'s 1:, iiii-i, pri-fiil.'.l ill pl.in ol MM. I!.iill.ii,i;<' ami Stiivi'ly, ami th,' liv.' is not •• f.iirlv -Iu'Wii. hii! most iiiilairlv -h,» n." Iti-mo-t iinlorliinat.' tor .Mr. li..!u.ll ihat th.' I'ii'.nn'istain'i' -limiM liav.' .■>, ap'i'.l him, ollh,' pl.ni h,- allmh'-to h.-in,i; siiiiKd l.y -Mr. \S allac' liim-.'lt wiio tlKToby a. kii..\\ li'il^ct its ai-i'iira. y. What Mr. II.-lw.H ui.'ans l,\ !h w.ir.ls "nnlairls sh.uii' u.' in,' at a l.ws to t'.im'.'ivc, iinh-- it h.' that .'N. lA hi'.iii.-h ami I, :.l',.r th,' li'.'.' ai.''iiot cxa.'tly imln'at..'d t.. a pi'i>l.i'r .s.alt.' a-ih,N '.vould h. Ill a pholou'raphi.' r,'pi.-.'nlali,.n. In ..ih.'r r.'^p.'.'ls w.' ass,.it and tniisl iiiaimi.o,, until th, ...nlr.iiy is .lo iMi.ii,,l hy -,.im' ,.ii,' .-i-' than a nu'i'.' s„,r..,„i-^ ,■/,/■/,, liiai ,,111 plan i~ ...n.'.'t in.-M'ix pailhnlar h.aiiii'.;' in any u,i,\ .,n tli.' .a-.' al i-sii.'. Air. ll,,lu.'ll ..' • -lal.'sin his alii, l.i'vii that •• h,' .•.niviii,'.,! hiiii-.df that ih.' tr.'.' ;it I'.'ml 1 .rs a •• natnrai ,,•-■ ;;i'..wiii.r ori-im.lU ,,ii ih.' h.ink ..riaml." Oiir r.'port m m. «ay .hiii.'s llii->as .V.' .Ii.l mil Ihiiik lit 1.1 iii.-iii'aii\ .Ap.'ii-' t,> as.vi'lain s,, nnimp'irtaiit a partii'iilar i sin.'.' as sLil.'.l ill our r.'p.irl, lli.' hi.-t ol'th.' wharf at V .•ii.'r,.a.'liiiii;' orm.t on th.' pr.'setit .'liaiiml ol 111.. I'ivi-i lull'.' m. ivIaliM' imp..rl.im-.' t.. that .,f its mi.-r,.a.'liim'iil on llic wlmh' spa.'..' . ihiat.'d h,.!w,.i'n ilii'pl'.'s.iit .-11111111. 'I ami that s,ipp,i.,,,l I.. Iiav.' f.rnially .'Msl.'.l |..\var.ls m,- Njirlli Ka-i. Wi' slal.'il that Ih.' tr.'.' in ,pi.-li,.n l,..,k.'.l ralh.'r lik.' ..ik' that lia,| h.'.'ii plain. '.I tli.'i'.' ami ran p.'i'.-.'i\.' m. r.-ason y.'l Un i lilyin^' our opinion in that r.'-p.'.t. ., ■!.,'.■. 11 '.'. ill: tl.','- of ih,' r-a 11 !■' si„ . i.'-. il is I'vi.li'iit that tlios.. Wh.'ii a hank. ,f html i- o al tin.' foot of III.' hank . aniiol •li,ir h.'a.ls lis hiirh as thosr urouinu' on llif top ot llio fid liiiiik ; wlioii ii" in iIi'h cii^' we Iniil ■[ liiiil .iiiito till' (■(iMlnirv In (ilitairi : >*i iic(' tlic livout V irniwinir t\u 11,'iriMl tV(im tlic l.nv.'iiii.-t !.;ii-l of tin' l.iiiik coti'-idi.niMv ov,Tl.>ps tlmsr to W f.iii unit ot'llic Iniiil. l:i\ III'' now .ii- pos Mr. ll..l\v. llnlll • l.'il Lis-rllinil-i wo \i\-ovi' imI to .ti; r ii li'W ks iii7.Mr. \ViillMcc'~:illi'i;ivil wiru'li iilso .•(inl;iiii-i a-siTlion-i akin In IImim' (il'lii-< clerk. inn nil wliiiii till' I'laiiititl'ri'iinMi'nti'il lluit llii Mr. Willi lU-i HWriir- iliat nn I'verv nri'ii' mill vvns -|n|ip ,1 liv l.ark w iiliT tin' Kxiii'rts (iiinvilliii; rlv, in ihuiini: ■liiiiisi'irnf I'oiir.-'c) he tart tn Ik Mlinril I niiixlit nnt have en -.1 Wlllinl It, vrsnrtiniT to any ('X|iiMlicnt to ascertain « licthcr tlu' mill ntiii, (.hI to uiiik t'nr any. or what li'iiirili ol'limc Now the error of tin stiitemeiit I'nnsits in the nmlcnni lile I'iict that Mr. Wallace can knnw nothim; of llie e.\- iieilient resorte.l to hv the niMlcrsi^'iie.i m tc-i wlu iher tiio mill mi-ht have contiiiiie.l to iro or ' - I .* M .. I \1.. \V'.,ll..,..i «■■!.: !i)>^i.iit tV.tiii the itreliilses 1 the not, sine on alnin^l ai 1 Slid I orrit^i'Mt" .Ml. W ihsclil from the iili'miscs ; tin -iirvev ami oii icrvalmn ol thi' ri^e a ml fall of the tide having' stioii. ami with 1 it almo>t ciitirciv carried on hy .Mcs~r-. liaillai lit Mr. Wi 1! 'fl hen le iimlersn.'ne I mii>t Ihciefoiv ■-trenuoiisly "re|.iiiliate the char:.'.' made hy sr and Stavidev. Mr. Wallace ami lare that IhiV ma consKlereil liece- le all M|idiex|ierinient- and I'r ^orlcd to all siichexpedicnt a- tlic> ,,, (,..,.<. .!>•,.< I'ldlv as tn the time and caii'-e of sln|iliai:e of tin' mill .'v to intnrm ti'm-s at least spot, and tniich ot'temr il'they renniii as meiitinncd in their ie|iMii to >ec for then hal or a- II lieini; slions the Ivvpcrts took care lis (ilten on intaim d they did not allow tin' truth nt'any ol' d ill hi.-- do. laralinii t'idenomlsnn aiiiiht. the I'laintilf 's as>ertioiis either vi'iha hilt their own personal ohservations ; a course of uctum prcci>cly similar liaviiiLT also .h.,. lids the llefeiidaiil. T, re cnloiirinir tn the ahovc citation from .Mr. Wallace- aHida\ it he adds, " iiinro particularly as t he Dclcndaiit suspected that tli iflln I miv'ht he .loscd hy artificial mJaii-." Now what we could have had to do will the jlcfendant's sii-picions when we wi'le on ihe premi>es with tli tail-raeo or canal hid'oru its , open wv' cinin t cniceive and d" not think it worth our whih' to make any remar III -mil tutilc and chi Idi-I I a—crtions. .Mr. Wallace next alhnles to an ix| riimeiit whicli tlie [■rts liad dccidi It cm In iforiii iiitr lo a-ierlain tlieti t .Ml lleolstoppa^ thi' mill wheel and which they failed to perforin hcciiuse, a> he will have it .Mr. ^itaveley rd dl 1 -ii;n a n rlain doiiimcnt pri'parcd hy lln' I'hiintill rh tir tn hold themselves re>pon>ililo lor any ilamai," that miirlil have hccii con- sei|uenl on the said experiment. The iimlof-iLniod areata loss how t.. dc^ai with su. h an enniimms statement as the •ns-ilde ilnil Mr. Walhiceeiin already have Inrirotleii that on the oc- iihovc : for It IS hardly l sion in iiuestmii tin' Inle water ilid not even reach the wheel, a circiim^taiice wlindj ol < rs put Ihocx periment nut ot'ipiestion, ami uas tlic iu;ly it' il not Im luformod a ivcdnpoii nor did the I'laintilf nll^r the lea-t nppo-itinii to our perUn'minj; the experiment 1 hell he undi r-tond the luiturc nt il. The riainlill'at lir-t Ihouirht thai the Kxpeils ini.ndcd to work the wheel thr.niL'li hacl uitoriinlil it ^tnp|u..| (ditselt;' which he very ualiirally ol.j i| straining am I hiejkin- th.' wheel an accident whic-li ir lui-m have ivipinvd wc.k-to icp.iir hicted t I h. o on iiccoui 1 oflhe ,1; I Hire r ind which mii;lil have proved a ,-oiin-o ni ^'ical damaL; to the I'laintilf; hut when he iiiider- tnndour intciilicn lo he thai of working;- the wheel only until i rind eMicicntly he was per fecilv n'/iicahlc that wi' .-hoiild perform tlu' experiment and then I should l.-iir ton much to th fefl the mill with (U-dcrstn liis n'liller to d,, anylliluL,' the Kxperts re.|uired. Nnthin.ir was d however, im lli.il o,,:i-iou in the w.iy nf cxperimentilii: i n the wheel -iiice as aho\ e ohserved th.' tide w did not cMui fi-ac It Ih.i! evcniii Had lie h. n anv ai> scdut. Ilecessitv fu-lh.'aforesiiid experiment it c.mid certainly hav,' hcui pciMormed on a sih-e.pient . ■a-imi, Init we loiiml ihal tin' re.piired inform.ilioii cnii Id he ohtained ' a ditl> rent wav. that is hvoh-crvina the time Ihe tide took lo li-.- and lail a-am Ihroiiui, „ jrivcii jicitrht il We olitaini-d it accordiiilv 'I'liciwo iMIowiiej- par.iLi-raphs in .Mr. W lilac s a llidavit as to .Mr. .-^tav elev liavinj line occa-ion o-,,||,. iMiMo the mill withoiii hi- c,iiiciirrem-c, ami as to a -uddeii ril-li ot i and water on the niiict. en no fiirliicr remark. Mr. Wallaci' linall\ -ui .il th of .March la-l lijllv cii eiilcd oil ill our rep. III. and need - Ih.ll he di.l II. It It to th. il note inade hv Ml Ilar"-c in tin- i-vidi'tiee of (iahricl (.inuiier. Mil I'.al if the iimler-iL'ncd, he Would have perceiMi ihiil .Mr. Wall.i.'.' attiuitively lead the rep.ut llial th. Ilml been tn a- havim; heen in-erted I -ilhh lal nolo III (picsti. d " 111. lo ami lie woiifil |iav<. ■pa led the trouhh' nf referriliu' In t d hy Mr. liaillaiL'c aloin le-uhje.'t in his atlidavit. Wo have now to deal with the alii. Ia\lt ma.le li\ tin- |l..femlanl liiiu--ir. -.uin if till' a--ertioii- in w hicdi we ari' siu'iv li. ■av ale al \ari..|i.e with .nir comlii-ion- a |., Iliela.l-, CaloiTorii allv In taK 11- ami i.lul.' all llie >tatcinent- contained iulhis\,.|ii minnus allidavil nf the Defemlanl. would !■ m. icK linim ir l'ep
    -iTlinlls hoWfV.'r wllii'll llhlM nut, l)U pil^-^iMl nv.T ill >ilrlKT, IKlt Oil lU'.'nllllt f .■oliiuriiiM- L'iviii t.> (ln'in liy tin' hcreiiilillit. ■Voriinliii"- lo lln' D.'IrinlMiit^ -Innviim' mir iv|Hirl i- ..■uliiiiiiiioiis iiml lilii-'lloiH ; wo have ilriilniiiiii-llv'iii.l.'^lK'Wii piirtiiilitv lor tlii' Phiintill Iktuiiso tnrx.olli uv biive lic'cn tuivcl liv r,.iiiiiinr\"suiisu to urrivi' at .vilaiii .■oii.|u-i.ni^ iih.iv lavmal.! to liim tiiaii to Ins o'pi.o.aiit. D.'IriHlaiit •■faiinot ivlVaiii iVoKi (•\i.iv--iii..' Ii'h ■^iir|.ii~f," '• lia. iciiiarkiM with siin-n-o ■mil pain •" ••.■all.'.l our ailciition in tlif ii.M~t cariu'st iiiaiiiior ;" - rxpivs,-.-, In, ]irotouiiil ivivf" "tia' most li-ivial alU'i."'rr. The falseliooil lai.lat om-dom'.'must ivluuind upon the .lonop. Tin.' Defendant's all'eeted expixvsions ot surpi-isis reirr.'t, and pain, bis faUe iiidi,L'nation iind Mi>pi«-ions and bis hujiiuHl lament inu-l L'ive wav to real -eiitiineiit- of the ,-ame kind on our part. \Vi' may apl'ear io wax warm upon the ^ulijeet : but where is the iiKin who wouhl not do -o. when' he lell as we ,1,. hi- iee,,,iir and inle-rity at >lake. The fir-t pa^e and a half of lie' Defendant's atlidavit are devoi.'d t i tlio tree at point ^• The D.-femlaiil here -tat.- that what the iimlersiirned as-ert in their report a- having' been lolil Ihein with le^Mid to the |,|antiiiir of the tree sinee the bnildi •: of tlie wharf is an ••atroei.uis falselHH.d." We ha.l no ivar-on to siispei-t the veraeily of our mhuniaiits who avowed th.Mii-elve.- readv to -tale the same on oath, but we bail no power to take .vi.leiiee on the sub'i.'et, and iVwe had we -hmild have ivfraine.l frcun u-iiii,' that (.ower, -inee a< our report' --oe-. thi' matter is ,>f no imp.U'tanec whatev.'r notwitb-tandinir the repeated altemp!- .U' tie/ Dcn.aidiiicl to I'oree upon our iioliee, a- a matter of ,!i;reat moment. The Deteiidaiit leM -wear-llial a- "Mr. I'.aillafL'e aeknowleilired to him both the site " of the riaiiilill"- wli.olaid li.r hoik on whieli the Defendant'^ wharf is ereeted Weiv set . ,l,,wn .Ml ill.' piaii lil.-d l.v th.' line.' Kxp.rl-, mil hv aetiial -luv.w ami .•xamination alter •■ th.' r.au .sal of ih.' .ihl u !„nv.-. hat hv iiea-.' sii|.|.o-ili..n. II.' tli.'U a.hls that kn..winix the •• pivitii-.- le' 1- .'iiaM. d to -w.'ar and .l.i.'s >wear. that in tii.'-e parti. 'ular- tbel'e is err"!', and " .rr'T '.vl.e h .. ejiii to I.e ami .■oiil.ll..' .".rr.'.l.'.l willeuit mu.'h tnuihle or expense by any sur- " vevor ol av.'i.i'!;-.' al.iliii- not .li-po-i'.l to mak.' uiiivas,. liable eharu'.-." 'Tin' ab.ive .hari.'.' is' in .'v.-rv pirlh-ulai' iintrii..-; that on the eontrary evrv . I. 'tail l..'ariuir ill anv wiiv on tie' -uhj.'.-i at i-'u.' was .-an't'iilly Mirv.'Ve.l ami m.'a-^ured, ami lahl .iown with p. a till a.'.' lira. y ..ii th.' phi.i in .|iii-tion. Ti, ' D.'f.'ii'laii: .ill'.:- t . wi-h ihal -.lu • ..ileT -iiiv.'vor -hoiiM he -,.iit ..ut t.i tin' premises t,, ,',.riv.'l th.' .'rror ail."/.'.l I'l l.a\e l...'ii . ..mmilti .1 i.y n- in .'ur -iiivey of the loealitv. Notbin.'eoiil.l I..' m..i.' -.ui-fiel,.rvt.) ii- than siieh a pro.'ee.liiiLr, a-^ tb.'C.mrl w.uil.l then b.' .'■..iiviinaMl hv a.l.litional .'vid-'ii.'.'"..! the .'xa.'tilii.le ..f.iur survey. Our nnivasonahle .' iai\::es ■iro n.'Xt hinl."i at bv lb.' Defemlanl wh.. pi'. hal.lv .'..nii.aiv.l them with tlnwe ma.le by Ins ,.wii Kxpi'ri. Mr. Walla.'.', f..r-.'tlii.Li le.w.v.'r that .Mr. Walla.-es .««il l'..r le^ral day:, Iroiii 10 \ .M 'to I r. M. ami I.'-, i- even iir.'.it.r in pr..p..rti..n than our ."^ln for .lays of wlii.'h a I'reat'numh.'i' k.'i'l ii-...'.-iipi..l fn.m •". ami li in the morniiie' to '.i ami lU at riglil wat.-bing 'Ui.' I'lb'.'ts .il till' moinii and eMiiiiiL' till. 's ami Mirveyiii'i the pr.'ini-.'-. On tin' thii'.l pa'.;v i his alli.lavit the Def.n.lant .'.miplain-, "With profound r. iTivt that w.' -h.ml.l bav.' eall.'.l thiiiir^ l.\ th.'ir ri'rht nam.- and not make tlio bank of stones T. \ . t.> 1,,' I lai'.-.'r ..b-ta.l.' than the w'harft.i tin' th-w ..f lb.' liv.'r lieaupoi't. W o presume that the rxpert-'them-.'lv.'-. aii.l m.l ll,.' parti. 'S were t.. be tie' .1 lali;.'- ofihe relative iinportair'e otihe -everal .ih-ta.le^ e'.inplaiiie.l of hv the Defemlanl as alU'.'tini;' the ibnv of the river in Iresh.'t, time • -in.e it i- a.lmill.'.l in onr r.'p.ut that iimler ..r.linary eireiini'^taiie.'s. the wliarl ot lx..-J, i- ii,.'ob-ta.l.' to th.' mill ami tleuiu'li r.'peate.lly .-all. '.I t.) our att.-inion by the Deteiidaiit, we .'.ml.l not <''.iiie to the eon.'lii-ion that lie' hank ol -t'.n.'s was any ob-trueimn. .\-. to the so .iilU.l " . har'i.' " ma.h' bv us a'j.'aiii-t tiabri.'l (ireni.'rtii liviiii,' in one of the I'l.'l.'iidanl'- h'.ii-.-. wh,. h lb.' DeU'iidaiit swears to be untrue we will admit, that our infonnanl- mav po-ihlv lia\e h.en in error and that the interest whieli ihe Defendant has ill the -ai.lh..ii'-.-mav lie ..llu-r than that of a proi.rielor : but to>peakof the mistake ll it is on,', a-ol a '.ir.iv.' .ri'..!- i- nu'i. ly an atl.'inpl I" witli.lraw att.nlion from.llu' important points ..I the ea-.' t'l oth.i- ..fa im.-l Ir.vial natiii.'. Till' C. lilt will not fiilbipereeivelbal emitrary to what isalh'.-.'.l by the Defendant there w m..h'siie t.p imp.'aeh (ireiii.'r's evideiiee but lUily to sliow that In' mi-lit have been .li- itly interested in the evi.leme f.,r the D.'femlaiil in re-ard to the trnk wliieh the Dolohdiint % . i-he.l to pIMVi i he l''aini;ii''.;alhN ^•.> I"' peiie.l on the nimleeiilb .hi;. .•! m.n. h lar-t to .'leat.' a n i-b •.'( i.'i' ami w.iti'f on that f)'.' ail 1 tliiMvliv Icail the Kxperts to ivpdrt (iivoi-iilily \'«r tin' I'ljiiititr-. :i riiv\Mii-t;niii' wliidi tli.> KxiuTls li;i'vc ihvi'il 111! Ill -niiio loH^'tli ill lln'ir ivpurt. ■|'1m' point of laml Ipi'lw. Til 1 lie l.-iil nice iiiid cliiiiiiu'l of ilu' livor U iii>xt talicii ii|i \■> ilrlirirnt ill liK'IiliilT iirt to liavc loru'nltoii to I'e.c.iil ill lin'ir rrj.orl entaiii ailliiissions wlii. li lie pretcmls tliciii tn liavc niaile a-^lo 111.' sioiu's at W. I'. Iiuviii.;:' tlie appeaiaiui' of luiii^' an'an.ir.ii imrjiosely hy tlio JMaiiitill to I'oi iii.l.sifnctioii. 'riii~ i- ra~v ora|>i'irlnn-ioii. 'I'lir I ,iilir~ woulil V. ly iial 11 rally, try lo draw lis diil, ami olitaiii s.'iiK' cxi'ivs-ioii of opinion iVoinns in aihancc of our ivporl. t'f rourso wi' were (mHimI upon to see tliintrs just as they appfand in llu' intiM-fslcd oyc ol tin' pally so pointinu: llii'in out; l.iit Kccaiiso wl' iiiay liavi- iin-Wi'ird thai wo iiotii'.'il thr^lonrs -,i pointnl out Ions, it cannot liu conslnKMl tlicivlVo'iii that wu adinitU'il any parlii'iilar ariaiiu^'in^'nt of the >tuius in ipi(--lion. Drl^ndaiil savs ln> indiu'iiatioiiand >n>pi.it.n-u.iv lArili'd hy th.' fart of our havin.!,' one ilav afU'i- Mr.' Walla, r's departure n'.pli'>l.'d .Mor.'iiry to indi.atr lo lis on the pl'cinis.'S ,,f ll,rl'...Mlioii of Ih.' ilrv sloiH' wall lu' hail spokni of in hi- l.-liiiioiiv. To this it is siiii- I U iv.pii^il.' to aiiswir that tin' iindri-iL;ii.-d win' In want of n'rtain inl'onnation lo .■ilalij.' iIk-iii to discover tli.' wh"r.al Is .if tin- uall in 'pn'-tioii. Mr. Wallar.' i-n the .'oii- ll-arv had.'Xaniiiii'd li.'siid wall pr.'\ious to IravinL' lli.' pn niiM's. and had assi'i-tcd in ihii jK'li'iidanl's pn'-.'iii'i' and li.'ariii'.; that it was pcrfrcily visiiilc to him thoiijrii our pi'ivcplivo lai'ilili.'s w.'iv too dull to tiiid il out wilhoiil th.' help .'f tin' unidr. and with llio irnidu's as- sistain-o wi'i-u still iiiiaMi' to di-rov.'r il. Another error wi'.'oininitli'd, a.vordin.u' to Hef.'iidaiit. is that of mil havini,^ cmliodicd in iiiir report tin' hn-l of F.'rirnson livimj; in one of th.' riaintitl > Iioiim-. r-p.'cially as we elioso to make a similar a-serlion in reirard to ( !r.'ni''r. 'I'liis was allo..',.tlier iinealird for. as in eoiniir'.' lo a d.'.i-ion mi the sevi'ial points at i~-ne. w.' in no way hased any of tliein tn Fer- H'llsoii's lestimoiicv. Iiavins:- l.fl him out of .oii-id.'ralioii a llo'jeiher on aeeoiint of tlie p.issihlc rnt(r.'>l whiili he'mi'ihl hav.' Hit from ih.' f.u t thai he mil only liv.diii one of the Mainlill''s hoii-, s. hut was al-o in the I'lainlilfs employ, a eirenni-l.im.' ei.'.eied a- a mar-imd iioie in .iiir extrai-ts from his eviilenie. Thesiibie.'t of the D.l'eiidanrs prol.'st ae-aiiist Mr. Slavily for one day vi-iliiii; the mill ill theah-ene.'of liis hl'other Kxperl- and tin: D. feiidaiil i- fully diseii.-ed in our ivporl. and w.' iiiii>l here repeat, amldo |io-ilively swear, that Mr. Wall -.i iii-e.'d in our (ipinion that we had an nmlouhl.'d ri'jht I'ith.'r individually or .•ollee'' M-il the pr.'inises and when we thou-hl til to intonn iiur.-el\ e> ,.n any parlieul.ir. The Kxperl- had informed the parlies on more than in. ■ .era-imi that they uonhl he readv lo vi^it the premi-es at the lihldin',' of i-itlier of ihem whenever thereunto reipiired for the purpose ol havinir anvlhiii',' pointed out to them and of li-li nimr to any .•\planation. Th.'vdid so and it happ.'n'ed so'm.linies that lln' H, feiidanl was pr.-eiit in the ali-.'iie,' of th.' I'lai'nlilf : lit othei-s, that ihe I'laintitf wa- piv-. m in i h.' ah-.uie,. ,.f ihe Defendant, and iren.'rally that th. y were hoth ah-eui. It will he understood that when a fle-hel leid |.i he willie-^-ed Ihe Kxperls r.Mpiir.'d to lie pre-eiil on llie verv ni.-k of time. Now on the oeeaMoi, ailnded to in lli.' said protest the I'lainlilVeallod in a hnrrv u|ioii Mr. {'..lillaie-.'- to r.'.pie-t the KxperN to vi^^it th.' mill imin.- dial.-lv for 111.' purpos,. .I'foii-ervine; the .-Ih'et of the iee on the fiv-hel water then eoniimr down' the riv. r. Mr. liaillar'.'.' .-onld iml po-,ilily ^^.^ JiiM at that ii lit and siie^'esti'd lo I'laintitf that it would Im' as well tor Mr. Siavely ;,- Tier fXperl a:id iheivhy supposed to h,' it' p,.s,i\ih. h-s iniere-leil ihaii Ihe parties Kxperls lo pr..eeed almie to the premi-e.. and r.'port his .ih-ervatioiis M MM. Walla.e and llaillarv'.'' on a .-ul.M'.pi.'iil o. en-i.ui. Il.ue then i- the who!.' mv-lerv. iind il tin' Hefendant has no other ^Iraw lo eat.li at to prov.' mir partiality for th.' llaint'itl'w.' do not anlieipate that thefoiirl will v.'i'y se\ er.'ly nprimaml Us for a .■oui>e , if action uhieh vs e deemed honi-l aiel eiiu-i-lanl aer,.idim_Mo uur \ iew> and l.'u'al. Til.' I)el'.-ndant on ihi' ahov.^ mehimied orea-i..u ma,\ m'liia\e hcui appii-.'d of .Mr. istavelys intended \i~iMo il.e mill, l.i.l mu-l m l >upp,.-e ihai ih.n; euuhl have h.'eii any .h'sir.''to exilnde him from a p.miripaiiou in ih.- I'.vpeiN' oh-ervaiions oii that o.'ea-ion mure than on anv other oe.aMou. Tieie u.i- i .e.iMon for ihe pre-.' f the pani.'s on the Jiremi-es cvi'i-y time the Fxpeiis \i-ili.l the lo,alit\ and aee,,r.linu;Jy ihey k.pt away thoii'di repeateiilv advi-.'d of our inl.'lid.'d vi-ils and adjoin nni.'iil-. rndir the-.- eir. iiin- i-taniM- the nndersiiined hunihly suhmil thai tin' fael oi one ..f ih,. p.niie, |.,,i haviinr I n nolilieil on on.' of the niimerou'- oeea-ions .ni whieh ili.\ \i-iied lie- mill must rather he look.'d upon a-^ an oversiirht than a^ an inl.'ntional aet and d.'alt with iieeoidiiie-ly, «'>pe.ially when it iseon-idered that th.' Kxpei l- eould >ee ihiiej- tlirou;rli their own eyes without th.' I,eee--iu ot' luaiie.;- . v.iy I hilrj: poked al I hem li\ ihe p.n li.>. At pa'^'.'^i'iL'hl and niie- .te. of hi- alli.hu ;l llejeiidaul -wear- that a- a pro. if i if our leaniiiL' iir partialirv in tavor ot' the I'lainliiriie v\,.uld eiie iiiir • ililei-m- i,f tie' ii-tineuiy uf ||, .\ The room in I n.'l. Tie liality hy I'onipar.'i This l"erLru.-so 5;j ,hn\i-i V.-^n.. uIki lis Di'l'tMidiiiit iiiosi sdlciiiiily iIcmImii-; is n pcrl'i'ct cliiinn Icr well ktinwn as u 111:111 orilli>wclvilii; I'cetitililo ki\ W'c iclliiiiily lire fully ilis|i,iM'il lo iicliiiil nil lliis, I'vcii witlidut till' •• scilcianily" ol'llu' iissiTtidii iiiii- liiil wimmt ildiilil lli,. iii'i'nnicy of tlic I'urlriii- liir.", lull uliiit it liiis lit all tn dd vvitli tin' (■(Uirliisiiiiis luiivnl at liv us in oiir icpiul \vr are at a loss I,, t,.||. Tlir' ciuirt upon I'l'uiliiii; uiir ivpoft u liifli al'lcr 1111 iitli.lavil i.l'sui'li a swoi'iiini; I'liaraotor 11^ lliat uiiw iiinlri- riMil ciiriic^lly liru' nt' llic Cniirt to ilo, will [n'l-ciuvc that llicri' is no sii.-li lliini; as a rriticisni of Mr. .loncs' cvidcnci' Unit lui tin- conlniiy it was only I'l'liTrcil to ami coihinicccl to willi luu'linns of KiuLrnsson's oviilciicc to cxiilain tlio ap- |iiircul anoiniily o| liolh the wilnrsscs in tlicir ii",.|'lions of lliiuL's lUi wliifji tlify couM iiavo liiiil luit an opinion. Tliis .sulijcct is fully ili'alt willi in our rrpoil in nil its possilil.. lirariiiL's and the Ifiuior- al.lr.lud^-1-.iii pfi-iisiii.^rii will not lirslou- lo privriv,. ihal lli.' Drfcndant's atlidavif lias cvidont- ly litcn pi-rpiiird Willi llic viow ol' niiikini,' il appeal- lliat oiii- report oiiiilH to explain many lliin-s wliieji in reality will lie found fully explained llieivin ; luit \vliieli mi^dit liavo lioeli i>iiiitled willioui in any «:iy aHi'dinir our eiuulii ions. 'I'ln^ jtefendaiit Mow rej.'ivls or all'eels to (j.) so, tliattlie Ivxports slioiild not liave found room in tlier voluminous repiut for siune of FerirMssiui's assertions as the North K.ist Clian- nel. The ,indersiu;ned Iminlily siihniit that on tin ntrary they have shown their inipai'- lialily hy ex'.-lildiiiir that cvideiiee iVoni the appendiees it lieiiii; o|' lillle or no value wliiUi eoinpared with luo-t ot'tlie evideiiee on ihe >iilpjeit. 'I'liis ,iiv!nii..tanee will indirale rl,-;irly (h;il eonirary to whal ihe |)efeiidanl surmises. l'"iTi;u-soir,-. e\ iijeiiee hail 110 weiL;iil with llie lv\peil~ imr any intlueiiee in their decisimis. 'I'lie Defendant eontinues to remark on the iiii|ioitanee we may have attached to llii^ and that evidence in comim; to the conclusions arrived at in our report. W'c coiiceivo it to lie I'lilher impos>ili|e I'or him as it Would lie for any one else, to say wlierc we attaclieil iin- poitanee and wlnu'c we did not ; and that thi're may he no doiilit iif the correctness of our eiHicUi^ions independantiy ol' any inlliience which the evidence of dimes, l-'criiussoii, lliiii- levic, (ilcnicr, .Moieiicy, and MeKcnna, Xc, couhl liinc had in our dccisimis we will incrclv ^ay : put all >uch evidence aside ami mir cnii,lu-ion~ remain iiualtefcd they liein;^ in no waV founded on the a-s,.iti,in.-. ot llio^c wilnc~-c>. It is dillicull says tiic Defendant to r-peak with patii'iiee ot' .Mr. I >a ilia lire who appears to have liilsilicd the record liy niakini; a maieinal note in the evidence ol (iahriel (irenier \c. Il has already hcim said that .Mr. I'lai'larLre made, and siLrncd lint marijinal note in ipU'stionas fully explained in the rc|ioi't : and if Ihe Defendant liiids it dilliciilt to speak with patience of .\|r. I(,iiilar:;c tor hi- remark in llic niari,'in iiiipalatalile as it niii>t ticces- sarilv he to the l)cfciidaiit lo lia\c >ueli an unpleasciil Irulh promiilijaied ; Mr. liaillarye t'ecls much le-s patienci' when lie recalls the uuscrupiiloiis iiniiincr in which the Defendant dietalcd to the clerk the words which from the snlij,.,! ol" the maiirinal note in ipiestion and which Mr. I!.iilla-Lrc declares ,,11 his ,,aili to lia\c never liceii uttered hy tiie wilnoss. The Delcndaiit after caii-iii',' Ihe words ■•;,/■//■, " a- a^ciihcd to (inaiicr, to li,' entered in liie evidence and remaining; unchecked after the lir-i altcnipl which .Mr. I!aillari;c attriliiiled to >oine inattention on his pari immedi.iicly tried the cxpei'imcnt ai,Miii hut was mado aw. lie hy the {■Ixpiil- that the tiick h.id lii'cn percei\ed and would liol he allowinl lepiiiiioii. We do not ill oiir report lerii-c ihc Dclcndant as he faU. ly states of liavinif siiiiiLj'.'led similar expressions into thec\idciice taken in Coiirl hut merely Mirmise wliclher the ••/. /((!■,' to he fouiid ill scvcial -iiic--i\e paragraphs of some of tlie evidence adduced hy the Dcfciirlanl w,i- not -iiiUL''u'led in liy the piore-- ahove alluded to. \Vc are next hioa.dit to ta-k hy the Defendant in tin' D'.lh piuc of his allidax it for -ayiiii;- We •• I -ideied" lh:il he -hoilld havc every pos>ihh' chance ol' di-|iroviiiir the I'lainlilfs chare;!'- as >i'l I'oitli in the declaration. It is well known that sueli citalions as the ahove from any wrileii or verhal statement may appear to wear i[uite a dilfereiit ineaiiinL; when the Words immediately preceedimr and lollowin^ are Icit out as seiuiis to have heeii purposely ihuie in this case. Let our report he allciitively read and it will he seen that vvc have uiveii the very Uesl rea-ous f,,r makiiii.' the remark wilii whicli wo are cliari;ed hy the Defciidanl. The interioi iiiory, it will he reiiieiiihered. dcharred Us from the riicht of hcarins; any other evnlenee Ihaii that immediately and directly eonnccU'd with llio -loppae-y of the mill wheel. Now il w.is wiih tin' iitmo-t circiimspeclion and with the irreatcst dilliiailty that we could prevent the partic- Iroiii L'oiii:,' hcyoiid the hounds allowed hy iho iuilL'iOeiit. n..t Ij.cvcver a!t. ..(h.^- prevent it 11s fnUy . xpl Hi 'tir rop'-irt and as -.oil lo llie for the i|iie.-lioiis which w e allowed the llcfcndant to put to llio wiliio.sses with " ve ai'cuscd of hv stone hehiiid the sti the Dcfeiidanl that wi • con-iiieri me sioii' a .!■■ he lid that at 1' Wi d ha\c cMrv iio 'am as alio •jihic ilu lice ol disproviiii] ill till' rhiililill '> IlllcL'Mtiiiii^. It i-^ riiil till) uiilcli III sii\ ill :i uniil lliat nil llic iinil^iiliuiw Ipi'il lljinM 1I-; I'V till' hrliMiiliiiil ill Ills iilKnIavil, iiiI iiM'lii-miis \vi' IlilM' lUIIV il iit, iiiiloiii;' us :i|i|ii'iii' I illliiil ti iiti'ar\ iiiiiiri's-iini mi tlir Cnurt. ili'llllltril il-i rxphlilHi' li_v IIS til "1 'I'lu' hi't'cmlaiit lii'Xl iriirs nil to siiv tluil iis ti. till' la.t III' ,1 II' coiitrartiiiii an •xiiaiisioii of iri' III' iliil'i till' ill' liituri'li Till' Ciiiiit 's til rniitrailirt llio Ivxiu'i'ts ami that r.mtrarv In mil- |ii>iiiiiniis ami clalmrali' tln'iiry till laiiilill s iiiii I ll.'li liilalit s u l.aiA'i rr will olisri'vi' thai it is nut at all iVniii tl liiis lisi' ami liill with I'vcrv tii ii'iirv \vc liavi' I'l'porti'il ihc ii'c t •iiiaiii siatiiiiiiii'v iliii'liiL'' liait ul'llu' winter lnlui'iii tin' Inn whaiM's hiil Irnni arliial ul imt- vatinii- havi nu nil si'\ iTa I'l-llMnlls M wairr tn its I'nnni'i'tion with the lixnl ii i' a lillh' hi'^hi'i' ill I'll the llnatiiiir h'C at Z (li|i|iilii,' i.'iailiially luliiiitli ihi' Di'l, mlaiit iirnri'i'i ; 111 sav that till' in till' linll- a- a |irr-niial Uimw n l-i'.iftli' if Ml-. I!ai!lar::i'' niinii tin' ilav nii'iilinniil hv Mr. Wall; nil' nltlii' I'hiin- ll'l' ill Ills sl'illllll fl'|iOlt. Anil sn ha\i' tip' umli'isiuiii'il a lirl-niial klinu I Mr. I!aillarui''s liniisi' on tin- vi'i\ s:'iiir, ilay .iiitl /pi-I alunil tin- liiiu' tin il'_'i'iir till' |iri'sini'r nl' thi' Di'li'iiilant .'Its h; 111 sii;n till' ri'|init ami |ilaiis, i^r Till- riainlill hail ili'il Mr. I'.aill ii'LTi' In maU'c .siiiin' i>m|iii s|ii'rlini; the t mil' nl ifiviiii; ill till' i'i'|init ami ihr I li'li'inlanl ua- a|'|'ari'iitly aii\ini|s in tin' -ami' |iiiint. 'I'lii' I'arl is that linlli ni tln'iii liail sunii' vriv ii.iliiial i ill insiiy In ijiialily ami il i~ mil ihrir laujl il'tlii'V wiiit away iiiiinrnniHil. Till' ni'Xt anil last a' rii-atinn iiiaili' hy llin i)i'ri'mlaiif a'^aiiist llu' MxprrN i> that nl' lia\ iin; iiiaiU' an allrralinii m lln' ii'|inrl al'ti'i' il was soul inin ihn ('niirt ami |inlili«lii'il. 'I'ln' altrra- tinii alli'iTi'il In havi' hi'i'ii |ii'irnniii'(l is thai nl' i-haiiirin,;; " ;!u " In lil'ty ami Ihr lart nl' lln' mar- illai'i liaiiil wriiiii'.' is inninii'iili initial mill' lu'iiiir in Mr. Ilai linn. Till' lli't'i'iiilant aUn s; \vi' lln lint kiinw unless III' I'l'iiil lln' ri'|iiirl I'livimis |n its lieinj; sent in m hiih ease .Mr. W'al- IVs lie IS enn\ inei'll lie nliee r reail :!0. Mnw as a iiinol'iil the alteia- iiilii have r.ail ;iil hiee the Kxiiert iiir I'l'pini Inr a lew Mays in Ins |in~si's~inii |ireviniis In niir sii^niii'z it must have allnweil him In |ii'tilse it after it lieiliij well iiliilerstnnil hy llu- liilee I'lxperls that slieli a Ihilli: shnlllil lint lie ilniie. irany alleratinii I'mm '■'•'> In ,"iil has lueii maile we here ileelare on niiroalli that it iinnle iireviniis to mir -iifniiij; the re|iinl ami lilinir it at a lime when weui liter as we llll'nnLlll t lit. The fact nf the iiiaii^inal in ile 11' re -lill at liheilv tl ilii> III .Ml', liaiilaii^i lla ' liami ' amniiiits In nnlhiiiLr siiiee there iiro sever.il other eoiieelion-, ami iiiaririnal imtes in the-ame of Wlilin^r In ~^iy llotllimC some nf jhe hlsl pact's nf the re|inrt \\ hirll havellein elilil'i'lv lien liy .\li'. Jiaillarue, It (leelirs In the unilevsiiriteil that the " .Vl " liml I tn lie ivplaeeil liy the wrilteii wnril " tifl_\ leeii iliserteil 111 li;;nii' as |irn|ii'r shniilil liy ilnm il Ih (Siiiiu'd.) (IIS. I5AILL\|{(;I i:i)>V. SPAN KLi:^ Sworn holiire me, at (.iiieliee, the .'inl iliiv iifdetnlii r. 1^.".'.', (Siirneii.i .1. I'., i;. i)ri''i;i:.'sM';, Ciilii. S. i.' Ji lUnU |)lfSriUS Aiilnine.luehereaii Diiehesiiay. eeiiiei'. .Si-'i^-noiirilo Heanpiirt, Saini Knell e| aiilris lii'iix. ileiiieiirant ell sun nianoir Seitrnen'rial I'l I'leaiipurl. et Daiiie Catlierim llilpie, ,1111 epnnse, llu ilit iSieiir son inari iluiiient iiulori-ee pmir led'et lies pirscnles, li-- nni'ls nut par eo.s piv.sonto.seoiieeile en rntiiie a tine ih' , , n- .■! perpetiii'lle el, noil lai lieliilile el prnmetteiil liiirejniiir all ilit litre i| jmirs el veinlii, eeile, ipiiii,'., i|elais-e et ile s,.i-j,,.|||-|;,](. lorir; les inainlenanl el a Imi duliilairc elilreeux snus lus re iliamlniinc il"s iiiainteiianl el a tniijniirs avec uaianli iinmialinn- n ipii-es ei ile ilmii ilr tmi, irnul'ile,, ,|nn-. .hniaii. - Mi jiciir )iiirti;i! to ■hilioiiili' iliiMirv with IMTV lilK'. lllV iH'lll'illll (III' <■(■ 111' till' I'Liiii- ■■• in liis MTDiid t'lllf DrtcllllllMl iiij; llic tiiiu' i<\' llil llMVf liild looiir Hii^mii'j: it ill tllilt il WilS Sll lill iit liliiTly 111 !•'.< Iiilliil Wlilili;;' 1' liciii riilii'ilv MIllMil't, Sllllll lcUri;llL- ll'tlrliT, ili'llillil I'l u I.m; (Iclti'-i. liyiii>tlii"'<|i|i'^, rvicdiiii-^, iilii'iiiiliniH, siili~liliiliiiiH ct tons nut ri's ('Iiiim"'cIiciihmis •.'•'■I!'"'- lali'iiivMl i|iicli'oiii|iu'< il Mi'ssii'iii-s .loliii N'oniiic, Siiiioii Fnisfr, Junior, I'f 'I'lioniin (iiiinl. iiiiM', Ions li-ois ii'inion r I'msoI', Ills Sii'iil's .loliii ^■ollll:,' I't 'riioniiis (iniiit, liiiit poiir I'lix i| lie iioiii' Ic I • Iniiior, alisi'iit ■III' |ii'oviiiri', ani|U(.'[ lits Sii'ii.s Jolin ^^lllllv■• it I (il'Ill it proiiii'tlinit I'l s'oliliiri'iir Mirnhiiri'iiiriit liiiro iiccciitci', !ij,'ri''i'i' ct viitiliiM' |llVSCIlll's I iinii'to rii Itoiiiii' el duo I'ornio uussiiot ijiril scni iiriivo on cflto \\n iTtli' iinni'c, smon il iiis lo roni's i| iin ii 111' ill' I'o Join- siuis i|iu' iii'iin il luoiiis 11' di''l:iiil ill' I'liliririilion linns iniiuii ili-^ li'i'iiu's riik'ssns Hxrs imissi'iit I'li iiiU'iini' iniiiiii'ii' inviiruirr ni oinpi'i'lu'l' roM'i'iitioii do- llil'- I'lvsi'liti's, ("'i'st II siivoir los di'ilX tiiTs iln tola! dii liTiiiin Mtn,. I rt ^^•l'Jnl•lll•l l!i'iiii|ioi't. I'll ia ri'iisivo d'ii'i'lli', consi-laiil on Ironvo 'li'|Miis la ii\o -id-oni'-i .lo la fivii'To i\f l!oan|ioi't i|iii divisora ii toii.ioiir- h- dil- .-iiiir il Danio Diiolii'snay ot los dii- Sioiirs prcnrnrs ot ao'|iH'i'oiii's rl li'iii-r. I'l'iirosonlanl- iv-j.oi-tils a ravonii- do la on iiioiitani ju-i|Uos a la olian-si'i' (ii'dlo ooniprisi' ooniiiio il sora dii i\ a|iii'.-) ilu iii'Milin '|iii toiinio liar la dilo rivirri' do Uoaiiliort, oonstriiit snrlo liord d'ioollo ol oy aini'S vi'iiilii, loi|uol lorriiiii on total o-l liorno an siidonost inirtio aiix dits sionrs i.ronoiiis ot aii|i iiiinio iiyaiit ai'<|iiis ili il I iiiiias |{oilioloaii dil liospcranoo ot rram.ois t F aioiil, par ailo li'vanl .Nlr. hiioln'snoaiix, I'lin dos notairos soiissiirnoH, ipii on a tiardo inlniilo, ol -on ilron Kooll .'t Fi ml do ixionir mars dornior, ot partir an rosto do la torn' drs dits 'I'lioi 'aronl, I'o inio dossns vondii I'onimiif doiix liors dii toirain ipio lo dit .sii'iir .liiolioroau lliii'liosnav ot I'otor Stowarl, ooiiior, imssi voiidoiir ov apros noniii ml ao lis on socioto ilos di Is Tlioinas 1 ioi'lii'loai 1 ot Fraiii;i)is I'aroiit par ai'to portant oiii-oro iiiiln iiivontions, jiasso dovaiit Mailro I'aint. ipii on a jtai'do ininnlo, ol -oi ntVoro ijolaiii vin','t-nonr mars mil sopt oont i|iialri'-vinL''l-''iiii|> siiivant lo |ilan y aiinoxo ol iipprouvo di-s parties, ot poiir |iliis irniiido si'iroto los dits Siour ot Daiiio Dinlu'siniy moltonl ol siilirojfoiit par 11'^ prosontos lo- dits sionrs pronour- I'l ar'piori'Urs on lours lion ol plac o, on tons los droits. iroioiialivo ot aiilros proti'iilioiis aoipii 'ar lo ilu acto an dit Moiir Diioh' I- lioirs I'l ayaiils oaiiso, a i'avonir ot a porpotiulo, ol iiioiiu' ooinmo si lo du. into out oto pa- ri lo nditions V rlolaillt's oiissont oto ooiivunns I'lilro Its dits Sioiir 'I'lion I I'l l'"iani;ois i'ari'iit ot los dits .'^ioiir aoipioronrs auxiiiiols ost I'ait |iar los pro- ontis Iran- pol I i'l doloL'alion oiilion I'lolili^alioii? I'l ill ilils droits ot pri'lonlions ao piis par lo dil nolo avoo loiitos Ir: iiiiinai.'osil ml li'.s dits Sionrs I Inclii'-iiav I'l St nail soiit i-liar ;os elisors les ilils iioelieloiiu et I'aront el par lo 'lil aolo sans aiionne restriotion ni oNeoplioii a eel oiran Miiilelll ell ol lire le dil- Sieiir 1 I I >anu' ['lie e-I aelilollollU'llt, ot iMli ll'aver- Dllel dill ii'siiiiv les del IX tiers lie la oliaiissoi' dans li'ial rniore il sieiirs ai'ipi tonlol'oi-- i| noro'irs do roeonstriiiro iei Modi' la III iiiporl, avee p iiivoir anx ilils iierean do la ilile eliaiissoe reeonstrnile m i|ii il- le tronxeioiil a propo-. I oi nivre on ii iiioinl .Ins, 11 dil Sieur l>iieliosnay i|ni' ei-dovanl, et poiirron I les dits Si, loiirs aoipioronrs, lours lioirs el a\ ant eaii ihr-ian on -e Haul il' la siir r, nlr oli'Ver oil oxliaii--i'r la dill' I'haii-soo ell indeinnisant lo dil Sieiir l)ii- ■ repro.soiilaiils p< I e\li ■oiir le- domniaiios ipi loiirra oeea.-ioiiiior rinondalion prove- i'lovatlon on exhaii-seii'i'iil /'. „ /,-,/. 7 .- /:, 1 III .'ihn II II la dile I'liaii—o :ir le 11 T I II' )U Ian ''I'-, -e- loni .lani- iiioiu ,'iii 'iii- ri an '!■•■- ilepi'in lone lili an lerrain du dil Sieor I imln' di'-ii;iii' I'liiinai ee- nil molilll.li rraiii ei iie— ii- d'ierl'li, eiieore le- ileilx Mel- i|.- ipi.ii-. Iimiil;'.! r.|. ilalilos el aulres lialiiiieiil- eon-lrilll- siii !e dil tei'iain miiis i\t' lout lUeliimipie •r d. inro.ji' rl \ 1 11,111 l,s,l.'ljl„i •■/" 'Il In. rien ii-erver in exii'| iter en laooii 'li-'hl siir la dlle riMi'l'o de I! aiipoi I, da rl autre- depoildonees ipiele pie il ni'liii, lei ipie le- I'i'de el M'liilu el dos dil- inonliii ii rarine, //m///./' i; >■ deiix lii'i- du dil terrain ei-de ill ai'luelk'iiieiit, ipiais Dii ill laiiiiard, olalile /. . I ,l,-,,n„l,, opeinlelioe telle ipi il- 'I'll' ivoir le li'rr.iin p'Oir I a\ o,!- a.ipiis oonliointineiit avee K I'llos sunt apl'ailienlionl an dit siour it .■>ii'iii' I'oter Stuart Uoel.i'lean rl I', /'. laiiu'aril, 'piaie- p.mr le- /' ■ 1 ,1,1, l.ill.- , I I, .V ,l,Ls s ni','il'ii ,i I'lf'i" , I If i\.iirlail II laMii el r.iii-li'uiie I'lnjointiiienl avee le dil -lour I'l ler Miiarl depni- I .iiiine mil -epi real ipialre-viii:;l'iiiip Cilte lire-elite ioiii'i'--ioii aiii-i l'.iil''.'i la eliari;e par le- dil- Sii iirs |ireiieiirs leiir- lioii's ol a\aiit- eaiise ii I'avonir ot a perpelnili' de payi'r lo oii/.o Nov. do eliaipie aiinoo a eoniiiieiieer le Nov. proeliain ot iiiii,-i oiiiillnuor d'annoe I'li iiniioo ii porpetiiito an lit Sr. J. Diiolii - lioirs ol avanise.iii-e a raveiiir, seiirneiir de la partie de la soi^iieiirie do Ilea upon ap- irlenant aotnelleiiieiit an dit Sr. I )uelH'snay. an iiianoir prineipa I do la dite soi'.;nourii' de lloai I" lie laiplolle le terrain siis veiidi il I'l Irelite sols arireiit louinoi-, di- rule I'oneioro perpeln •iL'^iieiiriaii' el lion rai'lii lalile. le dit eons portant lot- el veiites, do laut, sai-ieot nmeiiilo, snivani la eoiiiiinie do ee pays. So reserve leilitSr. l)iieliesiiay, ponr li liarlieile la seiijiienriodo lioauporl.ipii liii appall ieiit ai I lie" -.". Iimrs ot ayaiits eaiiso, pour la [ inenUlo droit a perpi tiiito do reiilror par rot rait eoiiventionnel simple el sans ol re Ion u ii aiiouni! tunialite do ri'^'iieiir dans l;i propi te lies dits iloiix tiers, mi total dos dits lerrailisde la 'liaiis lioit do I'ean, lie- iiionliii- a rariiiei/./ , lies h.-iiiirars, ipiais et lollies lours dopom r!e plo 111 Ilia! ion par vent eon anlro aele on oont rat eipii polenta reiile de toil ton do ehaipie par- lie, de- dits deux tier- eii rem 1 10111-01110111 par le llil Sr. Duehesiiay iirs et a\aiilsoaii:-o. ■ pi ir le pri\ prineipa!. le- Irai.-.et lo\aiix ■ onte- de -on ai-'pi'-ilion dan- le doliii de ipue 56 I'liutc jonrs ciitiiT.-i ft ciiiisiHMilifs, Ti coiiipti r ilii JDur que li' (■(iiitiiil lU' vciitc nii ;miIi'i' rdiilnit, nil iirti' iiinii|icil('Mt ,'\ vciili' mini ('-ti' siufiiilii' piir vent on laissO en nuMiriiiniiMlioii iivrc ollirs (liM ilroil.-t ill' li'ts ft vi'iiti's, SI' ivsci'vaiit cii mitrc !>■ clit Kiciir Iliiilii'iniiv |"mr liii, cr-i ilils lioirs I't uviiTit caiisr, tuns aiilivs dciils scii.'iiciii'iuiix unil |ii'iil iivuii- !•! pivlciidio Hiir m en cctli' |ii'(iviiiri' coiiiiin' si'i'.'in'iii' ilii lii'ii. (Vlti> |. VIV-I ClIlllN ll irsi'lll,' Vi'Mll' lilllo I'll nlltr<> |i(iui' el liicivi ll ll' iirix ll mini' ill' ili'iix mull' li- lliilll',i\ i'';;;ili' 11 i|iiiiriiiili' liiiil milli' livi-i's ili' viliui -nIs ilniit milli' livri"< ciiiir.s (T I lull I'll \ |iniii' ll' lii'i'-i i|iii' mini I III Sii'iir Dnrhc-iiiiiv iiolitriiii ilii ilil Sii'ur IV'ii'r Slinii't |iiiiii- smi (Iriiil ill' liioillill, ri V it'll', I't rilliriiiiiii'i'iniiism'i' rl li'suntii's liiilli' IImts |iiiii|- li' siii'iiliisilm' i|iH! ci ili'ssusvcMiln, 111 i|iii'lli' ilili' sniniiii'ili'ili'iix milli' liviTs, Irsilits Sii'iir.liihii ^'llllln; rl 'riiom is (il'aiil |ii'iiiiii'lli III '■! iiiri' soiniiii ri'iiii'iii riili-i' I'us' I'l |niiir ll' lilt Nii'iii' Miiiiiii lavfi- I't liailli'i- iMi\ clils Sii'iir I'l |)aini' l»iii-lii'siiav nil niilri' savnir. Cii Kim •I'l', jniiinr, illlulila\ ll liiii I'll nil an nil |iiiiii'tnnli' |ii'i'li\inii I'l "ilclai a ii'lti- csrarri' I'l Ics ijnii I ri'lils I.ivii's ■nlirs iiii's illlalitax iX'siaiit il'lini I'li ^■\l IMS imiir tniiti' |p|i'llMnli rt ili'lai av I'l' ll'S III dito soiiinio Intiilo ili' ilciix millc livroi cnni's illlalitax ;\ six i r ri'iit arlii ttTftS I'M I'l' tto I' Its 1 \1V, trli'ls. ill' la li''ijal ill's iii- nviiii'ii a rnMi|iti'r ili' I'l' ,|niir |iisi|iii's a |iailiilt |iavmriit, li'si|ni'l iiili'i runt |iii_\alili' ill' six Minis I'M six innis nil ilit Sii'iii' Diirlii'sniiy, mi niilri' ilmil li' pn'M lavini'iil I'l'lii'i'i'a i'l m' I'it lit .\, Vi'inln'r |iriirliaiii el aliisi rnnliiiiii'r iK' six iiinls I'li slx,|ll'•• ^[lll's a pai'lait [piivi'ini'iil, I'l Irs ilits intrn^ts ili'iiiiiiiiinnt siiiMiiiI I'li |'rii|'nrtiiin ili s jiiivmriits tails sill' 111 ilite sniniiH' <."a|iitalt', Iti'tii los ilits Sit'iir Aiitniiii' .lin'lioi'i'iiii I'lnli.sMay, J-iriiiiT, it la liilr |)i ilit Sii'iii- SUM iiiai'i anlnrisri' rnintiK' ilil I'st mil |iai' ii'~ nii'iiii' |iii mil' snil r|innsi mri'di' 11 titrr .III I'l'Ms I'l I'l'iih's si'iiriu'iiiial I'niii'it'i'i', |u'r|M'tiii'l|i' ni nnii I'arlii'talili' |ii'niMi'lli'iil sous In iliti' soliilitr liiiri'.iniiii- an ilit titn' i't nut vi'inln, I't'ili'', niiitli'', ili'laissi' I'l aliaiiilniiiii'S ilcs iiiniii^ fuiiaiil ct 11 tnii|nii|-s aviT |i|-niiH'ssi' ill' irarantir sniis la iliti' snliiliti' i|i' Imis tl'oillili's ([iii'l- i'nin|iii's aiix (lit Sii'iii- Simnii Krasi'i-, jiininr, Jnlin 'I'nniiLr i't 'rimmas ( Iraiit [iri'iii'lirs i't iir- i|iu''l't'iii's I'niijniMti'iin'iit I't oil sniii'ti'- I'Mti'i' I'lix i'l |Miur riix liiii~ Imirs, rt iiyiin' I'uiisi' a I'avi'iiii'ri', a i'i:i,'|itaiit, I'limiiii' ri di'ssiis, ]<■< illtsSiriir .Inll iii'si'iits, I' t'«t li savnir nil ti'i'i'.iiii i i|iri's ll I'Sli^nr sltlli' I'll la rrli-IM tlnlnas (il'llllt, U la dill' Si'iiriiL'n n|iiii'l I'l in-i'iidi'i' rl Imi'iii' par ili'\aiit an sml a In clntnr.' I'vi-iiint art in'lli'ini'iit, d'nn pi'tit rins nil pari' dt'stinir a inilti'i' piiraji'l- ili' pi'lit iiiiiinanx, par iliiriri'i' pii' I'l'ail ilrvi' di' la ditf I'lians-i'i' allaiil li' Inn;;' di' I'l'iiil dn la dite i'l ' ' \, 1> \r imll liti's parlii's lint planir' I'lli's-iiicmi's d'ai'i'nid d'liii rn 4"'. la ihti' riiaiissi'i' allaiit vits In noi'd In Idiil;- di; la nlntiiri' d Ir nil -ihl ^1 a 111! pi "ii'~l a I aili! iini'il i a nil i-ni'lior mi rail I pan Ili sci'vira ill' lini'iin. Ln dii caillniix plan- v lis mi'iitiniiin; ,|nsi|ii's 'is-a-vis nil pnmirr a pniMi'tli's ot ai'iiviinii I'liit linipuiiili' liiiit pii'ils ill' la dill' iliails>i''i' dnipinl rn-hiT mi niil- 'inix si'i'a tii'i' iiMi' liijiH' di-iiili' an piipint i ■ dr-~ns mi'iiliniiin' rpii I'llnplanti' pn'ds dn la ilitn I'liailssno aiiisi ipir lilt U iipii's ipii' li's ilits paitii's rmil liinitn I'lli's-mt'ini's snr k's li tri'inn a I'liviinn nrlit nam nsl n ilrssns dm-it. i-t ilrsii,'iir n.'i'i'iii's k'lirs liiiirs I'tavaiit Ui'idi lilts sii'iii' ar- il I'liviMiir |inill'l'mit pas-i'i' mi liiiiv passni' rin'i'ini'iit a nil pan I a la . !i. III lilt ."sil'lll' u'" pi pii'd on I'll Vnitni-o In Imii; dn la diln ilianssni' siii' In lini'd dn pntil Itiinlmsiiay dnpiiis In i.-lii'liiili dn Iniy Jiisipms an ti'irain i;i i|i's>iis vniid ilits iSit'lll-.- lU'niii'i-i'iii-s nt Iniir ri'|n'i'sniitaMt dn faii-n t'.iiin nt nnti'nii'iiir ,-'i Imijmirs a U-iir- IV I'l dnpulis Iniit 's Ins I'lotni-ns nninssairns nt snlidn pmii' I'Mt'ini'i'i- li,' dil liini'ii li dn— vi'iidil, sans ipm Indit siniir Diii'linsiiay mi nns I'npi'nsnntants u lavniiii' pnis^n nlin Iniins i inaiiii'i-n ;i lairn mi a t'aiin laim aiii'iiiin parlin dis i|ii,.s ilniiiii's suns .pii'li|iii's pii In, ipm ni; pnissu L'trn nt lin poili'nint Ins dits .Sinni's ampini I's nlmn nil liiirn nlniv In dit ilininiii 11 pa.ssan-n ni dnssiis inniitiminn dn manini'u i'l t'airn nliipOilinl', dii'i'i'ti'innlit nn indii'i'ntniiiniii nnlii'siiay lirrain ni di'.— ns Insaiiimanx ipii snrmit dans In pntit paro on panairn ipii appailinimn an dit Simii' l» nl Ipii dans lu paitin dn slid minst nst niitrn In nlminiii dn Unv nl vi'lidns d'allnl' iiiiil'i' an Imril iln la illtn nvim-n mi nliaiis-nn ni'di'iil nt al k's dits .Sinnrsnl Itainn llimlinsnay aiix dits Siniirs anipii'i'i'iirs In lilicn nsai; ilialiilmiin ipii dnii'i-mil. taut ipin In dit pi niiit I inii^tniit an mrinn nndi-nil diiii ll^lll■l' Inrrain, "silnn snsditn sni'Minniin dn iimiliM a siin I'xistnra mi Imit aiilri' inmilma nt ll. |iai- ll I'll mill'n I'l iniii>sannn ■ in In I'l'iii- liian nvant ail iimd an nliniiiin ilii l\iiy, liar dnn ii'rn an slid par iiiin liL'im dniiti pii snia tire dn raisin ipm fail la nlntnin dn dit fsi,.in- | )nnlinsi;av d'nM I la livii'in linanpml nt di,' I'antin noln an nmd n-l par la nlnt niitrn In tnrrain vniidii i |iai' I'n- ili'sniilns (.| c'i'li llin ipii null' an sinl mn-si snlis-i^tn anlni'lli'innlil it Inrrain nst antnnllninniil a la nlian.'n par lavi'Mii' dn tiiirn nt nnlrntniiir a t< liiln nnnnssaii'os iio nrniitmirnr In dil t li in-lanl an dit Sinnr I lii"lii'siiay, aiii.-i i|iin dits Mi'iirsanipininins nt Imirs rnlirnsi'iilaiils l.i'Miis ,'i Inuis IVais I'l dnpiii-lmiln ilolni'n limiiin nt 1 'iiaili nil tmiln sn- larli lu'snav Ml SI'S rnprnsniilants a I avniiir jiiiis lits ip; dil sinnr tairn mi nntri'tniiir aiinnnn partin dn ~nnl janiais nn annimn maniniv nl ('Irn tnliils d I'lntnils siuis ipli'l pin pinlnxtn ipin in plli-s Cntln pri' .'lit n i'iiii('i's>imi Iln lirrani nmir i-liarLi'n lull' I In. N'i'Miln nl iln-iiiiir nn ia ■.niilinlnn |ia"n dn ni' ns lilts fsinni's prniiniirs r| ji. .pinrniii's. Inni's dits Imirs nl iivant mm-. \ t'iivniiir ll a pnrpiliiitr' dn paynr In mi/a' .Vin'nmlirn pi'ipnliain, nl ainsi nmiiinnnr d'aiiiii lUiiinn 11 pnrpnlnitn a dil Simir .liu'lini'nan l> " inlmsii.iv, I'l-i linr, sn, I Kills nt iiMinls vniiir, Si'iL:iinnr dn hi piirlindn la .^ni-nnnrii' dn I'.nanpnrl. appirimaii' in rimlliinniit an dn Sinnr 1*11 Inrrain ni Inrralii, I' i'lr la I tniti' dn iriimir ill nliil'pln I I'liil.pln I nitra la ilitnpa I'M mili'i' Ins dits S run St. liiirtn d ini'lit nl , limis (1111 linn I In ralilli nm)ii'nlii- ni-ilnsslM sitiin Sll; dilsSii I lord linrii' li.M'll ^mivniiti • 'OMl'l'nrn iiimnxn (>t "iirnl I't pill III a U.inlirl, inm-pii 1,- nliar d.ms imnts n Uainj'aril dn 111' Im.' Ill illlllC I'llllflllt ition iivi'C ollVis mi' hii, Kos ilils iiiiic Hiir (u: i|in' llf livi'iM cdiirs Sdiarl |iiiiil' sun I 1' iMscr, junior, W/.i' cents I, vies iiitrit"'|s, ill' hi linns I'll >ix Ills. on riioiisi' (III 111 sons III ilili' ilViMi' callsi' 11 111' SoiiTiionrir H'llcnicnt il'iin itioniu! jiis(|'ics !lll )MI|llil'l' II I CIIVIIOIl Cl'lll lilts slolll' llr- ilii ilit fsc ^ cl iivan! can-. Ilcinciit an ilit Siciir I'liilicsiiiiv an inaiioir |iriiic'i|i ll lie 1,1 111 If sciiriiciiric (lout rdcvc la ijilc partic i|c terrain ci lIlMSIIS eoiiecil •I veni n nc. - ll .1' cell, ai'ueiit loiimnirs |ionr la ililc pai lie lie terrain, le lilt cells |Mirliiiit lots cl \ cnl.'- ilcliill saisiiie, cl anienile .-.iilvant la itiiine i '' ' nr Ini -cs lioirs ct avants cmis ■c pays, sc reserve pareilli'ineni le ilit .>>icur |)i|clie.^nav, j'onr Ini .-cs In.irs iir ia |i irlie i[ ' la S -i'^'n'Mire il • U • inp n- , ipii Ini app.irlicnt actnellcineni ilroil tnite lie reiitrer I'ar I'etrait. cinAcuMoiK I ,iiiip!c ci sms eire teiin a an frneiir ilaiis la propriele lie la ilili ■line lorn .iliti rrpi chaijile inn tatioii par veiili ii'plc pailli sa ilite I ai'lii p M 'le iiiilrc lie I, le il ii-.iin -ns-vci I le nil • nlillal i'i| nines, ct lie Icnrs ilcpcnilances II le iln lont on ile ch II iiilio'ir-anl par nipoleiit a \cn Il iht 1)1 lelie-nav. lirs el aviinl.s can-e a I aeipicicnr !■■ pii'^ principa lrai~ el lovanx ecu- ni iic.ini-i coiitrat ll laisse 1 chesnay p lion ilin- le ilelai ile .pi iranle j en liei - el . oii-ecnlil-, a conipli rilu .imir ipie le I'-te ~iu'iillic ji.ir eeril on Ire le ilil Sielir |)ii- \ ell 111 autre ail' lilHll. hi I Vilile alllil n coniinniiieaiioii av. illr |.i|, el ,r\eni ell on iiir Ini, -e. ilit^ lioir- d avant ciil-e, loil-'au li.-.||..ii.. I iliti p riie ■!■• lerraii |iie ell V. rin pi It in oir ct pn tcln intre )ionr e' niovciin ml le pi'i\ ' les ilils Sieiirs el It. line I )nc|iese|ii avoir rciii a leiir - iii-lai lion r- il.iiil •luiil.ii eeiivcr. I i I" 111 lies invres a | el e^'anl, el II liii-iant est ileSa Majeste oinparu en iiers'iiiin lie^ iliN >len-r 'cicr ,'>inarl. ili..iliet lie IJneliee, re-iilelit en cetlcville Injur , ,■- prcseiiie \..iii|:i, . 1 ill'. i|iiitti''. i|e|ai-^e, ct nliaiMloniie cl liaii^ rte lies iiiaiiilenaiit ei a l.iiii..nrs. el proinei- ■_ I'Miitir lie tmis ironMcs ilons i;. naires .let St. I'ierre, le.pn 1 Vpoi ll.'.. pies, evict ions e lie nation-, ^illw; ll nl l l Ions miiUv enipc helieli I ^r,',|i,'.|.j||.iiit.||| ipiel- ciMiipie ail\ llient el .11 - laiiis line poll its .■siiiion j-'i-.-iscr. junior, .loliii S'onii s c! 'I'li.nnas ( iraiil. acipicr.-iirs conjointi •icte, ciiti'c eiix el ponrciix Idirs lioirs et ay ml laii-e ii'-pcdil':- iilav ciiir, ee aceep I les ilit> ^ieiirs .lolin N'onii:,' cl 'rinnnas (liaiil taut imnr cnx inline lilt est el .lee p r le ilit Siciii'Siiiioii Kr.iscr. junior, aliseiil ile eelie p ^'oiiiiir et 'riiiiinas (ii-.iiil ecs preselites pur llcte d .|lciil et >'iililii;'ciit soliilaireinciit liiire ■I Ics^lits Siciirs .lolin ■pier, iiirreci'el ratiticr 1. I'l line I'or . ll arrivi celle aiiliei Ian. .^inoii .1.11 ni.' aii--il..i .pi'il 'era ile rdonr en cette province. ■ le e.' joii r s.iiis ipie ni'annio;ii, Ic ileiant le ratiliciilion ilans .oicnn ll..- ll line- d-l ■III- ipcellcr I'execlllion ile< ililc- |ire>elll I'll aiiciiiic iiianierc nivaliiler ni Ic |i.»n.- lixe ("est a .-avoir, iiii tiers forinart avec li^silcnx ini ri-ilcssns veii-i iii-ililc Ins par le ilit Siciir .Inclicrcan Oiieliesnay i t I 'anie mhi cpi use le total i In terrain piiroi.- el ell la eelisivcllc la l lite Seieninrie ile lieanporl. con-istaiit le ilit total 111 -e iroiive ilennls la Iim ee .| ilits Sicnrs iicipiercnr ll il'onest lie la riviere ile li.'aiiporl ipii iliviseiaa tonji sil ilil Sidir Dncln ravdiir. ll.' I.i llalil |il-.pl iirs cl iiyaiit caii^c rc.-pcetil> a imprise coininc -era ilit apie-i, ilii liionlin hor.l ll i.cll. IJo.^l, ,1,^111,1. II tonine par l.i ilile r.vier.- ilc It.^anp.nt eoii-lrnil -nr |i nln, leiiiicl terrain . ii total c-t it I'anlr.. tier- \:i etr. ne-i p: ilit- apic a ■.inereiiis a\anl aciini.- n- r.ir.^iil ]:>v .1 \1 ■-iicanx i 111. I 111 ell II i;*ar. \ iiiiTl il.'U ■ l.n .|.. 1 I icrri' lies ilil- iier- iiii terrain ipn ■ll ■an el !■ raiicm. r lis N,, i.^r li panic an r. -I. iln i; inidil nil . les iliN ineti i (Ills L'litioiis I'oiicerMcnt leilil terrain. Sieiirs ,1 ii.li..reaii I tilclie-iniy ct rdcrSlnarl ciiini- mil a.ipiis Uoclielcaii cl Francois I'areiit, par aete porlaiit encore aiitres I'a-se ilevniit M. I'liiid ipii en a pirile liiinnte et son ilil ■nnrreie .\ i ilairc- Ic viiie-l iienr \lai-, mil -pi cent .piaire vin.,'t eiiii| et >ilivant le plan iniieve an ilil acle cl approve Oi- pailie- \ i.oninice- el pour pln.s L'l'ainl ei lairi'is-eineiit 1 -nl.iou''' ies ilil- Sieiirs ac.(in^i'eiirs cti sun lien pi.'i-i'/ ilive- c- a.ilii s prelenlion- ae.piises par I'arenl a Ini ilil I'eter Stiiarl et 1.. iii.'ni.. el coinee' si le (lit aete - ilits 'i'lioinas :.t 1.1.1 ila >icnr I ch'i' Miiai I ne i les ilroil-, avaiilair - •'• le illl a.^le aM |.. -lilts 'riionia- K.iilielean d l'iaiii..n ililsl loir- el a\ .oil e:ll V: Ml etc pasM- d il'.li a p.^ri riiet.iile. niMiins aM loiclicleail et Kraiii^-oi- rardil d li - .lil- -i.nr- acipierdir- anxiiiiel est Tails par cs pre.-eliU ■I prelciilions acpiis par le .lit acle avec tonli ll cliar;;( traii-p irl it ilelei;ati..l IS cnlicii- Ic- eliarircs, olilie'ati.nis et iloiniii.i..'c- il.nil le- ilil- >n divers i..- ilils Uoclicleaii d I'arenl .-aiis an.^niic re-lii.li..ii ni cx.^e I iiiclic-nav el M.iarl ptlon a 1 .1 ctraii ilit Sieiir IV'tcr Stnail ilil- ^nnr- in ipn re. IS le tier- lie la elii .il.llls letal t'elle ipielle c-l ad nelldnenl i el .pil ll.l\il-e la illle rivicre lie l.canporl. i\\;x p.iiivoir luix ilil- Sieiiis ae |iieie.irs ct leiir ri^pre-ienlant- .-'i I'avehii' d I'l per|.clnite il.^ ri 1 -iriiirc ICC Ile. /'. Ill \.^nil I I alianiloniie le tiers dii inoiiiiii a f.irine eon-lrnil -nr le terrain I's.-ns (Ic-iLine .In, ll inrnanl .i .inaire nioii lis ct lie tonic- Ic- ilcpeiiil laiiiT cs lie -e- toninanl- \ iranl. nnnivi elleis annexe- iliil laires ll iiclni lids ili.s ipnii ■ll-, clalil ilii loni pn ill) iiiiiiiliii a ■■« .- el tollli Hires liarnneiits con-lrnil -nr le .i.i i.ir.iin -n-vcmlii >aiis i|e.-ns vemln li'ii re-ervez in i'Xce|ilcr cli I iiiin . inc.. on. pi /,'. Ill lu tlei .' -iir la il','.^ rn ler. |.. Ilea ip. .11 ilal'.'- ll a. Hi.'- ilepcnildiccs ipnl- ipies ilieelni, cnriii rie et le llcfs an total tier- lie I'll lies elieinins ■I iir.. II lie I' I.- llilS III ■\ \: nine d irlicnriers par Icrre d par can ct i|e toiitc- les coiniin liitcs el ilcpcinli a lariiie et a scii' iiioiilins, ipiaJM lie- liil- iiio-.iliii- lii el aiii.M .pic le lid.- ir lenr ilciieiiil t'l liaii>;a I" ar. d ill- ■liail- iai;e cl ilroil ile Kcaii pour les ili autre- ilepeinleiices, iles clieinin- parlieiilici's par lerre et pur cMinjiiiiitcliii'iit iivn IHu'Ik K ililt iiinirli[iji '•I'lii ii.iiu'llc'iiii'iil it rl'I'.lill |inlll' r.lMlir ilri|Hi.S Wiriiirt ilc.1 'li^ ■ ll. 'in IM lll'ICIIII I I l''l I'lUTiil |iur I'lK'tn ■'iH trii'tiiiiiiinr ilii >- iiurl miil M^r- iinl -•i' III i|iiati'i MlltllllCI ,1. .!.■ r iHiijii' I'l limit ill' I run |iaili'rii' I't |iar I'lii ■I ill- Imitf'* Il villi:! riiii| ( ITn.'iI I'l i|. •■ 'iiMii, liaiii;iir rl aiilii« lin iliti iiinlllili, ihili^ II' i-lirliilli-' |illl lirilliiT iilili'M !•! ilv|iriiili'iii-i's ill- ilil!< liuiilliii:< laiil |iai' |- ii'i|iii->iliiiii'* i|ii n fail iiu ilil Sii'iir llui'lii'^iiii V snivaiil Iriii ii.li> rt iiiiivniliiiii-' ifi'liriii III- in III a ^'imli' iiiuiil II ili'lliiiTi' iiilirlr il'irilui [A'M- ili'Viiiil M. ralii'l Nntaiir i| .liii.viiT mil -ii'Ii* I'liit '|iialci' \iiii.'l i-ir,i| iiiK' ri'iiiiiu' ayaiil lail • 'ii^li 11 I'ariiii' i-t u -lii- i|iiai, liaiiu'ai'. pai'li lit' la ilili' iliaii-.-i' If II' vilint ^ it liniii' It'i ilil-i iiiiiiirnt<« I't aiili'i"' liiiliiiniil- a I'lai-^ rniiiiiiiins avi T III ilit Sii'iir |iiirlii'-iiav ill' A I'ti' I'liiivi'iiii i|iu' I'arlii' li'-i ilii> iliiix ai'li :i| ilii ilil :i"ti' : ili's~ii liitli'"< rl Iiii'liliiiiilii'. f .III ilit j"in-, viiiirt ~i'|'f .liiiivi mil ."I'lit I'l'Mt i(iiaIi'i'-Mii::l-iiii'|. par li'i( li'iiii.l- il I'-i ilil III iiliii a riiM sllliirc ajnl'-i r I iiiii-triiil ili'iiiii-i la liaiiiial I'l aiiiiiM'i di' lli'aii|iiirr ii|i|iai'li'iiaiil artiu'lli'iiiriil an ilit Sii'iii DlH'll' ■i|ia\ ..111' l.iill illti'llll illl lilt lll'lirli' st'i'iiliil lU'Vii'iil il a linijiiiirs mil ii I i L'aiil 111.'. >H'iii's iiri|i'iirt'Mi> Imiisi't avaiil rau-i'ii 1 avrinr i I a |iiriirliiili"|iii ii'ainniil ain'iii ilmil iliri'di' ni iiiiliri'i'l iimiiii' -I ra 1. Ill- an lonir iiiMvi'iiu I't ili''i'laii' ry ii|iii',-i liaiHialilt' pi nil- 11' liit iiiiiiiliii a I'arii aliiiiiiliiiinaiil cii mili'i' li' ilil Sinir I'l'ti r Sliiail aii\ ilil- Sii'iii' iii'iiiU'l'i'iil' iiiri* liim- I'l a\ lint fans aviiiii' fl a |n'i'|n'lilili' I'lil 11' m'll Fmiii.'iiiH I'ai'i'iit, ilr ^I'silcniiiT, I'li .•iiii-i'.{ii si'pt .IiiMvii'i- mil -I'l'l I'l'iil ipiiili-i'-viiiLrl iiii'|. -an-' i|iii' ii.aiiiiiinii ill :. llil> 'I'lll'lllilS Hill 111 Itiin ( t ■iiiiilrraili.il' tiiii-ii'iiii' iln 'lit ai'li' an viiij;t III a\.'ir 111. (IN s.iil ml iiiii-'ii lli'-llliv I'.illlllii' >i'IL''lirni' ( li' llciinport iloiit I'Vi'r lt> lilt li'rraiii mih-\ .'iiilii ..ii a irt'iit. iii'irint touriimi. ilil -..■- li..ii - I'l iiyaiiN nlaiit lot- I'l V rut'. pii'l riii'iiiili' nil -III ill' ci'iis 111- ililii.il (I ami'iiili' fiuvaiit ■I Irml. Ics Inls I'll tnl'i'i' illlll'* ri' pay llllrlli' liinrirl'i' pi'rpi'l lli'lli' I I't a pi'i'iiolniio. .-iTiint pari'illi'iiu'iit pi'r|ii'iiiili' snji'l.- I't Miniiiii nivrr I" aii--i aiuriil l.iiiriii'i- ili' m iilr >i'i,i;in'nriiiili', an- 1 null I'lirlii'tal'li'. payalili' li' liiiit -.'pli mini' ili' rliiunnn aiiiii Ills sii'iir- ai'.p lil ^iiiir r.'iii- li'iir- ilit- Imiis rl avaiiln iiii|i.-iia\ il.- II. iir-i I'l avaiil I'lin-c a iH'Inilo ilii limit lii' ri'trail I'lniAi'iiliinii'l I'li . a- ili' vi'iiii' in I'Hl im luinii' ili' ii' i|iH' lii'—i I . . i . 111-..:.. .. I... .1',!., W 11. iln t'l ilaiii |i- ti'riiii''* il iiiy it Sliiarl par K I'ipi. 'niii'i' ai'lirli > ilil r 'M-.m .1 I'll' 1 iiiMi' II'- ilil-< Sii'iii's |ln- ■iir ilil .ii'ii' ilii vii'::! ,1 .1 iiivii'r mil I'pt ri'llt 4iiiiiri'-viiii.'l 1 iii'i anlaiit ipii'lli'i in' -oni |i..iiil aiiiinllri'- i"! 'pi ii n y I'-t p^imit ili'mi;!' \ pri'-i'iiti"*, I'll initri' an\ ' ' " i ■ ^ ■ ■ laii-i'-, iTi'in'i". t li's i|it„ >ii'iir- ai'ipiorriirs ly nj.ii'- lU'iailli'. Cill" \riili' t.nli' 1 III- Sii'iii- l»,irlii'>iiu\ I't Smart I'l'li'r iSdiiirt, ar II' iSii'iir t II' prix It' -..iiiiii.- ill' luilli' Inir- .'.nil- illlalila.x i|iii' l.'s t-ii'lirs .loliii piiiir I't moy ''111111111 ii' | Yinini;i't 'rinima.i (Irani -uliilaii.iii.'iil I'liliv i ii.\ il -..riil.iir.iiMiil a\ I'" 111 Su'iir Siiiiiiii iiniiM', jian.s ilivi-iiiiiri -..ii- l.'s r.'ii.ni. laii.'H r. .|iii .- i'! .Iv ili'..it pnniu'lU'iil^ ol -n- lil iiri'ii t pavi'r I'l liaillor an 111 >liMl' rt ill ml I'll - 1 .\ an-, p..iir t.iiili' iirr'tixmn rt I'liii a\i'i' llilcri't, il irt'ili' -.Miiiii.' I'.lal I" 1,1 l;ill 11. 111. I .1. - inlrlCI" I'll CI III' ]■ a I'Dinpii'r i|i' n' ralimi ilc I'liai'iiin! iiiim'i I'l.iir -ni'i'li' iln pay I'lm-i |inir jn-ipn- an pal lail pay i iiii'ii I 1. - ilil- iiilrirl.- p; I'Npi- I ill' la iliti' snmiiii' ill' ili'iix milli- livri' 1 colli':- li llalil'ax ihioaii ilit IVil. par II' pli :'iil a. il', I'l I I'llc ill' inillc livii'- I'l.iil's il'llaiirax ilnc an ilit 111' Mniirl I rl i.ar li plc-i'i| I aiii' li il.-- mil ii'l- .pn .-n pi''-^ i.'i .I1..1.I pavi'iiii'iil, cnniiiii' ans-i pour la >iirc II' ill- I ilii. Ill i|.- .'h; ,|ii-.pii'- an paiiait liliiiii, laiit ci ili'vani ipii'cv apii'-^ iin'iiliiiiiin- Imil ci.' .pic i|i"<-ns vimln .-an- m ncii rr-incr, ni cxicpU'r cii liii-.m ipicli'.i'n.pii', ili'iiiinri'i'oiil ilc c jmir aHi'i'lcs, nlili'.'c- ct li\ |i".lli<'"pi.- par privilc^'c en tii- ■■ ■ ' . ■• • '^^||;||•| I'.iniincli.iill.'ni- ill' r.'n.lcliacnii en II'. I.-- ilii- >ii'iir- .In.lii rcaii Ihiilii'-iiav t I'l'IC Ic a I'avi'iiir limit -'li, I'.niiinc aii--i Ic-i ailililii'ii- d aniiTn'i'iUi.Mi-i i|iii y -. I'.nil lail. -1 1 I . ..i.-lrni cl iiiircc'i lucnu's prc-i'iitc- ],■< iHn Sii'iir-. acpii'ii'iir-y 1 volniiiairciniii airi'i'li'-. oMiiji'' ci livp..llii''.|ni'' 11- fcri-ain ipiil- .ml mipiis ilc- ilil- 'riininas li.Mliclran d Franc, .i- rarcni, ain 'I' il I -t ill -i'.'iM I'lii'lc ill' M'lili' iln vin-l ili'iix mar- il.'riiicr. I'lunii' Ics iimrlioi'iiiiimi ipii 11 r.iil.s I I I'linstrnili's a I avinii, ciiliir Lni- !.ni'- aulrc- Lidi- mcnlilcs ct iiniiicnlilcs |ii'csi-ii|s ri a avciiir -an- ainiin ic-cr\c in ix.-cp r 111 lai'.iii .pii Kt a clcili'i ilns nivcmi ciiU'c II 's iliN .'^icnrs.l iii'licicaii lllli'lc .1 Di imc Mill I'pinisi' I'l I'ctor ."''Inart cl Ics dits Sicnr:! .lolni Voniiir d 'riiiiinas ( Iraiit lai-ani l.iiil pmir cnx ipic pniir II' ilil .•^ii'iir .'^iin.iii I' rasi'r.inni.ir. aril.' Miialrcviii iliiniii'i! ai plHipU"* 111 I'r. iiiicrcini'iil. — f.os dit.s Sicnrs ac'iiii'iciir- ni Icnr,- Icir- ..11 ay am . ausc-'i 1 im nil cl a per- il iiiiiiidrc, I'airc iinniilri dii anci'iii liicii nil II 1-; autre- jiiain- lii 'liiilc III' p.iiirrni -I 111 Mi 1 11 iiiiimlii' -I iciiilncnl haliita an till mniiliii iinH ."-ciiTiK uric (ic iiciinport ip its lialiltanis sunt Icnn.s dc liiirc inoudrc au mniilin liiiimal dc la ilili Siiiiriiouric scion Ics loix dc cctlc prnvi peine dc loll- di'[.eiis lioiniiiaircH ct iiitvl'Ostrt ciiitiiiniri" irlLlioiiiu''. ^fltjlli'iinc II lll'lllVl'll! IS I'l ii\ lint nil' iiiiiiiM', lilt I'liiiM' a \ el Miiiiit ii'iirs .liiliii li'iir .Siiinm ilclllll'llll I'll iii'i'iit, iiiii~i M'ati |i lfriir li'iit ii^iii.'"'^ ik' tniiiHiu.i't rt |!.'iiii|inrl. iiiiiii i|iii- ilii 'I leliin-'iu.'ini'iit (|ii('liniM|ii.' 11 hiiiiai:.'.' |>iii' k-' ilit- Su'iir-* iici|iii'i'iMirh il .'iilri i'l I'liiiiil ill' I'liitr^ ri'ipaiiil'n'ii- i|i|i'|i'''ii'|ii I'M'I |i|l li'iiir k'N ilit'< i|inii i Iniiiiiiiiiri'* raii'«''» par trill' pci'Minni' i|iii llll'iMlt rails 1 en allaiii '"i it ilii (lit Siciii- i>iii' n'l I Mill! ill's ilits i|iiiiis ct I'liiial I'lil' la |M'rtiiissiiiii I't rinisciit ■t -.'s ri'in'i'si'iiliiiits I iilir iisair'' 'I'"' I"""' I'' 'litSiciir Dii taiiis, |i(iiimnit niOnn' k'.s ilits iii''|iirn'Mi''» li'iirs liit^ IihiI'h oM iiyiint IS,' tiiii'f i'lai",'ii' iV ilit I'.iiial .'iniiiin' iU k' .iii','i'n>iit a |.i'.)jm>-. ii la I'liai'u"' park's ilits Siciii'H i'l'iilri'ti'iiir 11 k'lir si'iils iVai-' I't ik'pciis k's iIiIh iiipii'i'i'iii's, li'iii's ilit.s li'iirs I't iiyaiit caii-t' i niais I'l canal i|c tiiiitcs rcpariitinns ipi iilcr I cs iliiiiiina iiipu's it (Ic rclcnir lc> liTic-. I't IcH caiix lie niHiiii'i'd .,'i>s ipic'li' ilit cana'l pmii rail caiisi'r an terrain ilii ilit Mciir I •iiclnsiniy 't rc- narer les ildiniiiiis'es iini poiirrau'iit clre ciiii>es '.. . , . ' 1 '. 1 '. _ . . • . 1. '. A par rilariris-eiiiciil ilii ilit caiiiil ct sans |irc|il- iliiicr nil clii iliiiiin'i' aiix mill lies lialiitants (pii i ilnit ;\ lu irreve, kien chleinln ipic la pn ;\ I'l ' elite likcrti •Ic „ , .,„., ,|its Siciirsac'ineri'iii-s pniir eiix Icnis linirs el a\aiil cause il 1 avcnir tie se suvir 111 ilit ciiniil ct i|nais pmir Iciirs Irnnspnrt. cinkaiipicineiit el ik''kari|neiiicnt ne s'etcnil aiicnr icte rci'lle I iiieiit a la pnipr clii'siiav sc rcservciit iilisulnincnt pin- ci - pic t ilrcils n-au'' - lie- ilils canal » I ipiai .pn Ics ilil'- Sicin- ct ilali jiii- Trnisii'ini'incnt. — |)cs lit'- Sr. el l>aiiii ■lltcs. |)iiclii'.nav p.hircn \ k'lii's liiiirsi.t avaiit caiisca I'li- ii'ii pcrpclnilc ilonncnl parccs pr ill's piMivuirci liliciic aiix ilils f^ieiir.s acpieri knir- el avant cause a I aveiiii ct a perpt'tniir' ik; I'aire cntrer iliins lailitc livii insipies an ilit nioilliii 'i'l //<('/'i/e "'• "" ■iiitris nulnri.t il mil <:ii niinu- mi /,.-■ fu iirs ii'iirs Hcauiiiiil I'ir lit I" I, i/)'.« triiii.ii'iir> -11- ilii terrain .|Ui 1,1 ilii.' .liaii--. .' in.iiiilcra coinme il lai: c iiiveiin ciilr. Ini ilit Siciir |)iir|ic-na\ 1 j.' ilit .'sicnr I'der Mu.iii par liiir .lit a. le iki \ in;.'! M'l it.laiivicr, mill knil c.'iil .pialr.'-vin- .iii.i Arli.lc e .piatiiciii ■ lit liiarl aMinlcte ci ili'vaiil ai prc-ciit a.li Si. Ill- I'cler Smart ctait iciiii n III le iroi-iciiie III irai'licli r^er lie t'l'iirnir pari'ils ili.x picil- ipic le ilit la rivi'siiil i.iii'-i lie la ilile rivieie siiivant I'ar- /(/.. In ilii a.li'ilu \in^l -.pi .lah\ kr ii.iU In. it cent .plalre-\ n...'t-ciii.|. Sixii'niein.'nt. — >i'r.iii I iciiiis |. ". ilil- '-iriii- ac'incicnrs Icnrs ilil- koii- cl iiyaiil cause .nrorinei ik- | lint en p'.iiil aux | ii. lecs vcrlieai X lie .lean Kcnaiiil iciiii r. \ovt!r le District (le Ijiiclne en ilalc lin ilix -. pt inai. iLni/c .1 II ct ilix liiiil Aoiit mil sept It i|iiatre-vini;t-ciiii| ciiiiecriian li oliieiic an ('oii-eil -iiuaiil loi'ilre iln ti'cnte cl nn (pi.ilrc-viiiL:! em I ilc- t ie- I'licmiiis ct poiils inciitionncs aiix iiroei's vcrlicanx I nn Aon.-I ile la ilile aiince mill sept cciil li.nnoloiralion Icliirc I'l ile laile aiix iliks n.iccs \erli.'aiix el Menr- acipli .Inrlicrean l>iii'lic-nay rcnr- k-pi. i- en out rcpii- .'o| illc hiiiiliccs, lie '|i I Tclcr Slnail, kiirs ilil- lioirs cl ay.ihl eair- k's ilil- Sicnrs lav ciiir ell sunt ik' IT Jonr cl en -ennit l..iij.in!- . .'Ill Si'liliclni'iii '111. — I '..n\ ii'iilieiil ilil- .inmc Scigncnr ir ' vcntc It, le- lol- 1 I Miili -icnr- a.'ipii'i'i'nr- in t.a\.i am lit-; icnr- 1 >ncln'snav I.I -online il.' mil livri - i olll's i rilalita.x lie- i|n ili I'ler Sliiai I. Uci oiiiiai-Minl aiissi Il s iliis Su;ni>ac niiercnrs avoir aeiinis lesilits t"i'raiii, cliaiis-cc ' . .'....... 11 .1 .1... nioiilins, liaiiuaril. cl al^|•l'.'^ inpcniicm i .■ I'lnlii-, Id ipl ' tont i'?t actnciu mciit iloiit iUik'clareiit ctre Kati.sliiil> d lonlcnl pi f,0 aviHi- !•■ tuiil vu i-l viiitf, I'l en iivoir pri^ pi ^ioii (liM [iiiiili ildiiiir li' M'|.| ilii iirt'HCiit UK) art Hfii c'lMitoiiililiilion ilii |irri"i'iit iiiti Ituilii'iiK'iiiciil. — .V t'ti- iiiiiiniin.'iitiniiviiiM ■ t iivm ic-li's si'jiarii's li ili'!"^!!-' tVnit '^ foiivi'iitiiiiiH il.M \,.\vUv^ I't JH iiiiiir i>lii-i unii. . , , , ruililniu'iil l.^olmili iv.|.L'.lifs il.'s piiitK-^ eii r>-« I"''"''"'''';' ';f,.l tllllltM Iiiiiu-1'H, (1. I;(illi> el ii'iiv.iiiH pi ■ lixir L't di't. V.\ ciiliii pii'Vi'iiir runner iiivii- .lidiciillt'i'w. Ml 1111 iiioyt'ti ili'^ rliiiriri's, < Imi Sii'iir TcU'i' Sliiiirl iliiniiu im ln.it juiiir litii'i' 1 rt iivaiit rail-i' t"ll^ t lIlMpi I'll Ionic IlliliollS Ct ICHI'I'VIH lilll'^'SllH MUMl- Slriii" it I'aiiiL' MnrliisiiiiN ft li' 'lit iili;ii:.|niiiioiil iiiix ilil'* Siciir>< unpit' , ri il.',«-iiH vfiiiliis jimii' par i-iix I'll I'iritH.' a lii'i-l'i'lilitr. .1 pour i'.'Xrciltioli ill- pirsi'titr^ Irs I'M prcKi'iitcf* n, liiiii-po liaiil lilts Mi'i lis iii'iiii'i-LMii'.- out clu li'ur ' l't YollMLC ''ll Cliltl-' vi l'> • min.ili' uTivoi'a iSii'urs r r.iscr vn luiir iiiaiioir S.'iirin-iirmlo a l>i'iui| hie en ill ilcllU'lUV ilitiU'ili' i t Uaiiii' l> liH ilits ■ Saint I'ivrrcft \r> ilils M.iir» e iiclic>iia\ .rt .■! lit Mini I'l'lcr Smart lii sa ili nnnri' in Ini'lli It villi' rue Saint I'ifire aii.Mpii'lU's lieiix ile.. iioii'.li-:.inl el l.rtiinellent ele. reintneeiit ele, tail l't pa-:'!' a lini" t 'ar ain:il ile. ililiirent et ■n 1 ein. •lie liialire sotairen mni.-smiies I iiiili. n mil >ept eeiil iplaire vini:! "lonze ilesel i|Uatin'/lelne J' ie>heaiix I nn lies Mai allien 11 on I les parlies preselites simile ipi rliire lail' .11 (JlKltKAi; DI'CIIKSXAY, mriu-r kiciiksnav. I'KTKIi lAur .IAS KliASi:U\ SKI. I' .KilIN Vol Nti. TlloNI.VS (iUAN'l". .Ill li.AN'I'K-. I, jiKSCllKSNKAUX. I'OUI ■Dpi nitoriiie a la niinnle lionve .laii- iMmle lie Ten iiiai tre I., lleseliesiicniix Kdtlliru pour ei'tle part la I' ijil I'aiiaila. ei-ileva'il iipp I'll' l!iis ('aiiaila, ile dans \reliives lie ee Hi^triel liiliineeet eolloealioiinees par iioiis snns-iu'lie-'. franllens i'lle< el I'rotonalaires ile la I'onr Siiperieiire pi ir le Has < 'ana. la, u (Jllt'li. le trei jonr ilii iiioisi le Kevrier mil luiileenl ein.piaiiii 11 Uli'il ' •\\> ^ KISKT. 1'. C. BIBLIOTHEQUK DK lA villi: di: montri-al COLLECTION GAGNON ;U44l / -gs>-