L e. 12,:'1 i ,1'\ I be.~+ ccd-.:v\ '" L c 5 , - -- \<.. q <381 c,~ \ Catholics and the International Labor Organization CJ3 ' ,If Albert Le Roy, S.J. '<91ie International Labor t9ffice Printed for the SOCIAL ACTION DEPARTMENT N ATIONAL CATHOLIC WELFARE CONFERENCE THE PAULIST PRE S S 40 I West 59th Street New York Nihil Obstat: Imprimatur: ARTHUR J. SCANLAN, S.T.D., Censor IAbrorum. + FRANCIS J. SPELLMAN, Archbishop of New York. New York, August 16, 1939. PRINTED AND 'PUBLISHED IN THE U. S. A. BY THE PAULIST PRESS, NEW YORK, N. Y. THE INTERNATIONAL LABOR ORGANIZATION BUILDING, GENEVA (See page 23) FOREWORD THE word "catholic" means "universal." The universal and international Church is interested in and sympathetic with the just aspirations of labor in all countries. The International Labor Organization represents a systematic and comprehensive endeavor to improve the working condi- tions of the toiling masses in every part of the world. To the great majority of American Catholics the part taken by their European brethren in the foundation of the 1. L. O. is entirely unknown. As far back as 1884, the Fri- bourg Union, under the chairmanship of Cardinal Mermillod and containing representatives from several countries, was exemplifying international Catholic Action for the study of the social question and the improvement of the condition of labor; as early as 1887, another great Swiss, Caspar Decurtins, was endeavoring to induce the legislature of his country to "take the initiative in convening an international conference to prepare a basis for uniform labor legislation throughout the world"; in 1890, such a conference was held in Berlin, at which Bishop Kopp, of Breslau, represented the Holy See; in 1893, Pope Leo XIII approved a proposal to bring about an international agreement for labor legis- lation, pointing out that uniformity in this field was essen- tial to protect high standards in one country against injury through competition by countries having lower standards. The Holy See was officially represented from the beginning at the sessions of the International Association for Labor Legislation, established in 1900. After the Great War, the Christian trade unions gave enthusiastic support to the project of setting up an International Labor Organization at Geneva. Father Leroy's pamphlet gives us an interesting and sufficiently comprehensive account of the origins, principles, structure, spirit and achievements of the 1. L. O. As he points out, there are two facts underlying the scope and work of the Organization: conditions of labor involving injustice; and the necessity of international agreement to provide a remedy. The guiding principles of the institu- tion, he shows, are in close conformity with Catholic prin- iii iv FOREWORD ciples, even in the matter of their phrasing. The most strik- ing illustration of this resemblance he finds in the Bishops' Program of Social Reconstruction, issued by the Adminis- trative Committee of the National Catholic War Council in February, 1919, and recently reprinted in a Twentieth Anni- versary Edition. A much older instance is found in the regulations adopted by the Jesuits for the protection of the Indians in the Paraguay Missions. These regulations in- cluded "all the features of modern social legislation." The summary of them given in this pamphlet will probably come as a pleasant surprise to the great majority of the readers. Perhaps the most striking testimony to the affinity be- tween Catholic social principles and those of the I. L. O. was that offered by M. Albert Thomas, the first head of the Organization, a few years ago, when he declared that "the principles and even the forms of words" in the Labor Charter are practically identical with some of the proposi- tions in Rerum N ovarum. The latter half of Father Leroy's pamphlet describes the structure, authority, functions and results of the I. L. O. The description is adequate for all practical purposes. The last· chapter is entitled: "The Collaboration of Catholics." In it the author summarizes the co-operation of Catholics in various countries with the I. L. O. and its work. Here he gives generous, though brief, recognition to the activities of the National Catholic Welfare Conference and the Catho- lic Conference on Industrial Problems. Father Leroy has done a good job in producing this pamphlet. Nowhere should it be more welcome or more useful than in the United States. American Catholics have not yet become adequately conscious of their international obligations and opportunities. But they are making prog- ress in this respect. Father Leroy's pamphlet is well calcu- lated to accelerate that progress in the great field of labor 'conditions and labor legislation. Washington, D. C. July 25, 19.'19. JOHN A. RYAN, Director, Department of Social Action, National Catholic Welfare Conference. PREFACE A VISITOR who crosses the entrance hall of the Inter- national Labor Office and climbs the first few steps of the main staircase, invariably stops to admire a mural painting presented by the Christian Trade Unions. This work of the French artist Maurice Denis would not be out of place in a church in one of our industrial cities. The central figure is that of Christ in all the grace and beauty of His eighteen years. The time is the evening of a working day in Nazareth. Near Him is Joseph, leaning on his carpenter's bench, and, a little farther away, the Virgin, holding her distaff. Seated at the feet of Christ are His Galilean compatriots, wearing the costume of the period-workers who, under the same skies and tilling the same soil, earned, like Him, their daily bread by the sweat of their brows and lived on the same fruits of the earth. Beyond them are workers from modern factories: a metal worker, naked to the waist, other workers in caps, an engineer, an artist and an apprentice. Behind them, coming from the fields, are peasants returning from their daily toil. One of them, with his scythe over his shoulder, has come close to the Master. Seated in a corner, in an atti- tude of contemplation, are Serrarens, Secretary-General of the International Federation of Christian Trade Unions, and Gaston Tessier, Secretary-General of the French Con- federation of Christian Workers. All are listening atten- tively to the words spoken on the evening of a hard day's work by the young Carpenter of Nazareth, who did His share in the toil of men. The artist's purpose is clear. These words, so simple and so sublime that they must penetrate every heart, for "never did man speak like this man," were not spoken merely for the listeners of one day ; they are for every age and every country. They were addressed equally to the humble craftsmen of Nazareth and to the peasants, miners and metal workers of the twentieth century. They are still the source to which thousands of men, whether manual workers or brain workers, constantly return in their search for a remedy for the evils of this age and for a solution of its social problems. v vi PREFACE This fresco explains more clearly than any lengthy speec;h could do the close and cordial relationship which has grown up on the basis of mutual respect between Catho- lics and the International Labor Organization. Catholics recognize in the Geneva institution a powerful force which can bring a little more justice into this world. The Inter- national Labor Office, which is sincerely anxious to be uni- versal in its activities and to exclude no one who is pre- pared to collaborate in its work of social progress, has al- ways shown itself willing to give Catholics their full share in its activities. A brief survey of the origins, principles, structure and achievements of the International Labor Organization will show more fully the part Catholics play in its work and the great opportunities of collaboration which are open to them. TABLE OF CONTENTS FOREWORD, by Rt. Rev. John A. Ryan, D.D. ......... iii PREFACE ....................................... v CHAPTER I ORIGINS 9 CHAPTER II PRINCIPLES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 13 CHAPTER III STRUCTURE CHAPTER IV RESULTS CHAPTER V THE COLLABORATION OF CATHOLICS ApPENDIX A ApPENDIX B vii 23 30 42 48 51 ILLUSTRATIONS INTERNATIONAL LABOR ORGANIZATION, GENEVA- (Frontispiece) JOHN G. WINANT, DIRECTOR OF THE I. L. O. . . • . . • .• 29 THE DIGNITY OF WORK ••.....•.••.•••••.•••••• (Center) viii Catholics and the International Labor Organization By ALBERT LE Roy, S.J., The International Labor Office CHAPTER I ORIGINS A. Before the War THE International Labor Organization came into being just after the World War; but the idea was an old one, which had been stirring in men's minds for many years earlier. From the outset, Catholics took up the idea with sympathy. The unbridled competition that existed in the nineteenth century inevitably led men to the conclusion that it was only by breaking down the barriers of national fron- tiers and seeking an international solution for the social problem that remedies could be found for the undeserved sufferings of the working classes. It was to meet this need that the Fribourg Union was founded in 1884 under the chairmanship of Monsignor Mermillod. It was an association of leading persons from various countries in Europe, who met once a year to study the questions of the moment together and thus provide a certain unity for the Christian movement. In 1887, a Swiss, Decurtins, who belonged to the Catho- lic social movement, requested the Federal Council of his country to take the initiative in convening an international conference to prepare a basis for uniform labor legislation throughout the world. This idea bore fruit in 1890, when the Berlin Conference was held, at which Monsignor Kopp, Prince Bishop of Breslau, was present as representative of the Holy See. There was no more enthusiastic supporter of the work than Cardinal Manning who considered that it 9 10 CATHOLICS AND THE INTERNATIONAL LABOR ORGANIZATION was a point of honor for his country to give effect to the con- clusions of that conference concerning weekly rest, the em- ployment of women and children, and safety in mines. The year 1891 saw the appearance of the Encyclical Rerum N ovarum. This Encyclical, addressed to the Church Universal, and providing it with a uniform social doctrine, brought out still more strongly the trend of opinion in favor of international solutions. In 1893, Decurtins, at the Workers' Assembly in Bienne, again was the protagonist of the idea of an international conference. He persuaded the Assembly to convene a con- gress of workers' delegates without distinction of national- ity, religious belief, or political opinions, to seek an agree- ment on protective labor legislation. Leo XIII unreservedly approved this proposal. "It is clear," he wrote, "that the protection given to workers in their employment would be quite inadequate if it took the form of different laws drawn up by each nation independently. The various commodities from different countries compete with each other on the same market, and therefore the differences between the regulations un- der which workers are employed in different lands would enable the products of the industry of one nation to flour- ish at the expense of another." It is not therefore surprising that when the Interna- tional Association for Labor Legislation was established in 1900, the Holy See decided to be officially represented, to pay a regular contribution, and to send a delegate to its meetings. This association was really the International Labor Organization in embryo. It had a permanent office in Basle which collected information and centralized the work of research. The procedure was a dual one: a tech- nical conference first met to prepare drafts and make pro- posals; this was followed by a second, diplomatic confer- ence, at which the representatives had full powers from their Governments, and this conference took decisions. In this way Conventions were adopted concerning the em- ployment of women at night and the prohibition of the use of white phosphorous in the manufacture of matches. These were proposed by the technical conference at Berne in 1905 and ratified by the conference of plenipotentiaries ORIGINS 11 in the same city in 1906. In 1913 another technical con- ference prepared draft Conventions restricting the hours of work of women and young persons and prohibiting the employment of children at night. The outbreak of war in 1914, however, prevented their ratification. B. Since the War Shocked by the horrors of war, and inspired by the hope that out of so much suffering and ruin a world of greater justice would be born, the workers of all the allied and neutral countries had several times demanded that the terms of peace should "safeguard the working class of all countries from the attacks of international capitalist competition and assure it a minimum guarantee of moral and material order as regards labor legislation, trade union rights, migration, social insurance, hours of work, and in- dustrial hygiene and safety." The Christian Trade Unions,! ,far from disapproving or ignoring these proposals, gave them their fullest support, for they were in close harmony with their own desires and their own doctrine. In June, 1918, at Le Havre, the Chris- tian Trade Unions urged: "That the Treaty of Peace, following the example of various international conventions, and taking account more particularly of the results obtained by the Berne Confer- ences, should contain clauses embodying the fundamental points of a system of protective labor legislation or at least the principle of such legislation; "That the representatives of the various trade union associations should be invited to take part in drafting this agreement; "That the Convention adopted should follow the dic- tates of humanity and of Christian morality, more especially as recapitulated in the Encyclical of Pope Leo XIII on the conditions of life of the workers." When hostilities ceased, their demands became more pressing, and they prepared an outline of an organization 1 Christian trade unions, comprising Catholics and Protestants, were f ormed on Christ ian principles in m an y count ries of Europe the latter part of the last century in order to offset Socialist t eachmgs and to give a Christian philosophy t o the labor movement. They ar e inter nat ionally united in the International F ederat ion of Christian Tra de Union s, with headquar ter s in Utrecht, Holland. 12 CATHOLICS AND THE INTERNATIONAL LABOR ORGANIZATION which was not unlike that actually established. The Con- gress of Christian Trade Unions in Paris in March, 1919, demanded: "(1) The establishment of an international labor insti- tute, to be responsible for drafting and promoting labor legislation with which the various national laws should be brought into harmony, and to supervise the application of that legislation through an international inspectorate; "(2) That each nation should be represented in that institute by two Government delegates, two delegates of the workers' organizations and two delegates of employers' organizations, so as to insure the due representation of - the various industrial, commercial and agricultural organi- zations, irrespective of the trend of opinion to which they belong." After long years of preparation, therefore, the time had come for the creation of an international labor organi- zation. Catholics were all the more ready to welcome this step because they felt that their repeated efforts in favor of a cherished idea were at last being rewarded. No more striking tribute to this fact has been paid than that from Albert Thomas himself, the first Director of the Interna- tional Labor Office, who publicly recognized the part played by Catholics in an official message which was read at Rome on the occasion of the festivities commemorating the fortieth anniversary of Rerum N ovarum and welcoming the promulgation of Quadragesimo Anno: "The International Labor Organization, in which the peoples put their trust immediately after the world dis- aster, entrusting to it the establishment of really humane labor conditions as part of the effort to secure peace and world harmony, has set about this immense task with great confidence and enthusiasm. It realizes that it is not a spontaneous creation, the result of a sudden burst of en- thusiasm, but rather the consummation of prolonged ef- fort and of close and active collaboration between all men of good will and all who are striving after ideals. The seed fell on good ground, which had been carefully prepared over many years by workers who were anxious to secure the reign of social justice, and among them by those who based their convictions on the Encyclical Rerum Novarum." CHAPTER II PRINCIPLES A. The Starting Point THE International Labor Organization was established just after the war by a special commission presided over by Samuel Gompers of the American Federation of Labor. Its constitution was included in the treaties of peace which put an end to the War-as Part XIII of the Treaties of Ver- sailles, St: Germain and Trianon and Part XII of the Treaty of Neuilly. In reality it is entirely independent of the Treaties arid forms a separate entity. Its relations with the League of Nations do not in any way affect its complete autonomy. Countries that belong to the League of Nations are required to be Members of the International Labor Organization, but the reverse is not the case. Germany and Austria, which had to wait several years after the War before being admitted to the League, were Members of the International Labor Organization from the outset. 2 Japan 3 and Brazil when they withdrew from the former, remained very ac- tive Members of the latter. The United States, which never ratified the Treaty of Versailles or belonged to the League of Nations, became a Member of the International Labor Organization in 1934 when President Roosevelt, act- ing under authority of a Joint Resolution of Congress, ac- cepted the invitation to membership. At present the Or- ganization has fifty-five States Members, including all the important industrial Powers, with the exception of Ger- many, Japan and Italy.4 In fact the International Labor Organization stands upon its own field of activity in which all can find a com- mon meeting ground. The problems with which it deals are 2 Germany resigned from the two organization s in 1933. 3 Japan, following the Munich pact, notified the Organization that she would cease to collaborate with the t echnical services of the League of Nations and with the International Labor Organization by the end of 1938. 4 In December, 1937, Italy withdrew from the League of Nations and the Inter- national Labor Organization. This decision will become effective after a period of two years, in December, 1939. 13 14 CATHOLICS AND THE INTERNATIONAL LABOR ORGANIZATION not ephemeral; they are eternally important. They are problems not of local but of universal interest. They are the most important questions in the everyday life of the people of the nations. They have nothing to do with dif- ferences of opinion between two countries, or with changes in boundaries; they concern the fate of humanity as a whole. The question at issue is whether, throughout the whole world, from Japan to England and from America to France, men are to be able to earn in peace their daily bread or their bowl of rice; to provide for the subsistence of their wives and families; to be saved from poverty, both them and their families, when overtaken by sickness; and, after a lifetime of labor, to enjoy a few years of rest and peace before their days on earth are ended. The Organization stands above political discussions. It also stands above doctrinaire discussions and differences of ideology. It was set up, not to elaborate theories, but to remedy crying abuses and to insure a little more happiness for everyone. In the world today human beings are suf- fering and struggling, because their legal conditions of labor are not sufficiently humane. The task of the Or- ganization is to bring them help. That is the starting point from which the extent and limits of the work can be defined. There are only two facts which must be recognized and all the rest follows: the first is that conditions of labor exist which involve in- justice; and the second is that these conditions can be remedied only by international agreement. The Preamble justifying the creation of the International Labor Organi. zation reads as follows: " ... Whereas conditions of labor exist involving such . injustice, hardship and privation to large numbers of people as to produce unrest so great that the peace and harmony of the world are imperiled; and an improvement of those conditions is urgently required: as, for example, by the regulation of the hours of work, including the estab- lishment of a maximum working Clay and week, the regu- lation of the labor supply, the prevention of unemploy- ment, the provision of an adequate living wage, the pro- tection of the worker against sickness, disease and injury arising out of his employment, the protection of children, PRINCIPLES 15 young persons and women, provision for old age and in- jury, protection of the interests of workers when em- ployed in countries other than their own, recognition of the principle of freedom of association, the organization of vocational and technical education and other measures; "Whereas also the failure of any nation to adopt humane conditions of labor is an obstacle in the way of other nations which desire to improve the conditions in their own coun- tries; "The HIGH CONTRACTING PARTIES, moved by senti- ments of justice and humanity as well as by the desire to secure the permanent peace of the world, agree to the following: "A permanent organization is hereby established for the promotion of the objects set forth in the Preamble." B. The International Labor Charter The aspirations expressed in this Preamble, although they do not cover the whole field of Catholic social endeavor, at least form an integral part of it and have always been shared by the supporters of that movement. When the guiding principles of the Organization, now . everywhere known as the International Labor Charter, are . examined, the resemblances will be seen to be equally striking. Catholics can unreservedly accept all these prin- ciples since the very phrases are familiar to them. This will be clear from a mere reading of the text: "The High Contracting Parties, recognizing that the well-being, physical, moral and intellectual, of industrial wage-earners is of supreme international importance, have framed, in order to further this great end, the permanent machinery provided for in Section 1. . . . . "They recognize that differences of climate,habits and customs, of economic opportunity and industrial tradition, make strict uniformity in the conditions of labor difficult of immediate attainment. But, holding as they do that labor should not be regarded merely as an article of com- merce, they think that there are methods and principles for regulating labor conditions which all industrial com- munities should endeavor to apply, so far as their special circumstances will permit. 16 CATHOLICS AND THE INTERNATIONAL LABOR ORGANIZATION "Among these methods and principles, the following seem to the High Contracting Parties to be of special and urgent importance: "Firs.t: The guiding principle (above enunciated) that labor should not be regarded merely as a com- modity or article of commerce. "Second: The right of association for all lawful purposes by the employed as well as by the employers. "Third: The payment to the employed of a wage adequate to maintain a reasonable standard of life as this is understood in their time and country. "Fourth: The adoption of an eight hours' day or a forty-eight hours' week as the standard to be aimed at where it has not already been attained. 5 "Fifth: The adoption of a weekly rest of at least twenty-four hours, which should include Sunday wherever practicable. "Sixth: The abolition of child labor and the im- position of such limitations on the labor of young persons as shall permit the continuation of their edu- cation and assure their proper physical development. "Seventh: The principle that men and women should receive equal remuneration for work of equal value.6 "Eighth: The standard set by law in each country with respect to the conditions of labor should have due regard to the equitable economic treatment of all workers lawfully resident therein. "Ninth: Each State should make provision for a system of inspection in which women should take part, in order to ensure the enforcement of the laws and regulations for the protection of the employed. 5 N ew economic and social circumstance~. the most important of which was the depression and the widespread unemployment which accompanied It. have now brought us beyond the stage of the 8-hour day; the Question of the moment is the 40-hour week. 6 It should be noted that this principle is intended merely to remedy the ob- vious injustice of paying a woman a lower wage than a man for the same work merely because she is a woman. Such a practice means exploiting female labor and also tends to bring down rates of wages for m en . Justice demands that when a woman performs the same work as a man she shouid be paid the same amount. The paragraph was not intended to refer to Questions of family wages or compensa- tion for family responsibilities-a matter that is dealt with in practice by means of family allowances. PRINCIPLES 17 "Without claiming that these methods and principles are either complete or final, the High Contracting Parties are of opinion that they are well fitted to guide the policy of the League of Nations; and that, if adopted by the in- dustrial communities who are Members of the League, and safeguarded in practice by an adequate system of such in- spection, they will confer lasting benefits upon the wage- earners of the world." Anyone who has even a slight acquaintance with Chris- tian social doctrine will immediately realize that Catholics not only can but ought to subscribe to all these principles. It is their own program, a program based on the need for justice which they have maintained for many years. It was laid down in the Papal Encyclicals and has constantly been put forward by the leaders of the Church in every country, . such as Cardinal Gibbons when defending the Knights of Labor, by Monsignor Ketteler, Bishop of Mainz, in his famous speech of 1869 on the trends of the working- class movement, and by Cardinal Manning, the great Chris- tian leader, who was so popular in London that his funeral brought together representatives of Queen Victoria and the Prince of Wales walking side by side with represent- atives of the trade unions and of the dockers. Read once again the following pages from the message which Car- dinal Manning sent in 1890 to the President of the Liege Congress; it might be mistaken for a preliminary draft of the International Labor Charter: "Political economy is not a matter of values and ex- changes; or of free contracts only, but of human life in all its social needs and welfare. It is impossible to discuss how many hours a day a man or a woman shall work, until we have first laid down how many hours in the day are needed that a man may live a human life, or how much time in the day is needed that a woman may fulfill the duties of domestic life. "In mines and other severe labors a day of eight hours is reasonable and just; in lighter labors a day of ten hours may safely be admitted. 1 1 It should not be forgotten that these lines were written in 1890 and the de- mand. they contain represented considerable progress in the light of the practice of that period. One may safely presume that Cardinal Manning would have been prepared today to accept the idea of a