key: cord-1056230-aj6vvshl
authors: Pu, Jing; Mei, He; Lei, Li; Li, Daiwen; Zhao, Jiekun; Li, Bin; Wang, Haiyan; Ma, Ying; Du, Xiao Bo
title: Knowledge of medical professionals, their practices, and their attitudes toward traditional Chinese medicine for the prevention and treatment of coronavirus disease 2019: A survey in Sichuan, China
date: 2021-03-16
journal: PLoS One
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0234855
sha: b17ab3aad18a51bf048088d29d35fb1fb6ea29cf
doc_id: 1056230
cord_uid: aj6vvshl

This study aimed to investigate the knowledge, practices, and attitudes of medical professionals toward Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) for the prevention and treatment of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). All 401 medical professionals were surveyed using an anonymous with an investigator using the Questionnaire star APP. The participants answered 14 questions; of the 401 participants, 55.2% agreed with the statement “TCM can be used for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19,” 40.4% remained neutral, and 4.4% disagreed. Moreover, 75.3% agreed with the statement “There is no specific drug for COVID-19,” 67% agreed with the statement “TCM can develop immunity to COVID-19” and 62.1% agreed with “TCM can alleviate the symptoms of patients with COVID-19.” Meanwhile, 69.1% were aware that TCM has been recommended for COVID-19 by the National Health Commission of the People’s Republic of China. Regarding the selection of sources of knowledge on whether “TCM can be used for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19,” There were 277, 123, 82, 369, and 17 participants selected sources from “Hospital training,” “Academic journals,” “Academic Conferences,” “Social media platforms (such as WeChat)” and “Others,” respectively. Further, 358 participants will take TCM for the prevention of COVID-19. Multiple logistic regression analysis showed that age, major and received TCM treatment within the last five years were independent factors affecting the participants’ attitudes. In the absence of specific drugs for COVID-19, more than half of the participants agreed that TCM could be used for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19 and most participants are willing to take TCM to prevent COVID-19, although unsure about its effectiveness. The main information sources on TCM for the treatment and prevention of COVID-19 were social platforms and hospital training.

a1111111111 a1111111111 a1111111111 a1111111111 a1111111111

In December 2019, coronavirus disease 2019 was discovered in Wuhan, later spreading throughout China [1, 2] . The complications of COVID-19 included acute respiratory distress syndrome, RNAaemia, acute cardiac injury, and secondary infections. Thirty-two percent of the patients were admitted to an intensive care unit and 15% of them died [3] . The treatment of COVID-19 remains unclear and no antiviral treatment has been proven to be effective [4] . Preclinical evidence demonstrated the potent efficacy of remdesivir to treat severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus and Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus infections [5, 6] . Thus, a randomized controlled trial has been quickly initiated to assess the efficacy and safety of the combined use of lopinavir and ritonavir in patients hospitalized with COVID-19. Although corticosteroids were used frequently for the treatment of severely ill patients, there is no evidence that systematic corticosteroid treatment is beneficial or harmful for patients infected with COVID- 19 .

Although there are no effective therapeutic drugs for COVID-19, the National Health Commission of the people's Republic of China recommended, in the Guideline of Diagnosis and Treatment Plan for COVID-19 (5 th edition), that lopinavir and ritonavir can be used [7] , and that Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) can also be used for different phases of COVID-19. However, there is no evidence to prove that TCM is beneficial for patients with COVID-19. Whether TCM can be used for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19 remains unclear, and the attitudes of medical professionals with regard to this need are to be examined as well.

The purpose of this study was to investigate the knowledge of Chinese medical professionals, their practices, and their attitudes toward TCM for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19 and then assess factors influencing their decisions.

This study was conducted between February 7 and 10, 2020. All 401 medical professionals who worked in the 10 hospitals in Sichuan province were surveyed using an anonymous questionnaire that was sent from an investigator using the Questionnaire star APP, a professional online questionnaire survey, evaluation, and voting platform. This study was approved by the Medical Ethics Committee of Mianyang Central Hospital (No: P2020005). Because the medical professionals completed the survey questionnaire anonymously, and data were also analyzed anonymously, informed consent was not obtained from the participants.

Based on a previous survey, which was used to investigate the attitudes of radiation oncologists toward percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy in patients with head and neck cancer and eating difficulties [8] , a self-reported questionnaire was developed by one of our investigators. When the preliminary design of our questionnaire was completed, it was reviewed by two different parties. The first group included those that were familiar with our topic, and who could evaluate whether our questions successfully captured the topic. The second review was conducted by a question construction expert, who ensured that the survey did not contain common errors such as leading, confusing, or double-barreled questions. Then, we conducted a pilot test with a sample of 20 medical professionals (doctors and nurses). Afterwards, we collected the responses into a spreadsheet to clean the data, performed the principal components analysis, and checked for internal consistency. According to the results of the principal components and internal consistency, we modified the questionnaire and performed another pilot test and analyzed the data again. The Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy was 0.658, the p value of the Bartlett Test of Sphericity was <0.003 and Cronbach's Alpha was 0.726, and based on these validations, we finally started our formal survey. The questionnaire was in Chinese and comprised four parts (S1 Questionnaire) with 14 questions. First, the participants were asked to provide their demographic data (e.g., gender and age). The were also asked whether they had received TCM treatment in the recent 5 years. Second, the participants were asked about their attitudes toward TCM for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19. The answers were recorded using a five-point Likert scale that ranged from "very much agree" to "very much disagree." Third, the participants were asked about their awareness of COVID-19 treatment with TCM. Fourth, the participants were asked whether they will take TCM for the prevention of COVID-19. All questionnaires were exported and used in the analysis (100% response rate).

Results were analyzed statistically using SPSS 22.0. Standard descriptive statistics were reported, the χ2-test was used to assess associations between demographic variables and attitudes of Chinese medical professionals toward TCM for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19. Multiple logistic regression was carried out to examine whether attitudes correlated with other factors. A two-sided analysis was used and a p-value <0.05 was considered to indicate statistical significance. Table 1 shows the characteristics of the participants. The 401 participants consisted of 161 doctors and 240 nurses.

The knowledge of the participants, their practices, and attitudes toward TCM for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19 are shown in Table 2 , and we performed a subgroup analysis to understand the impact of occupations on the survey. For the statement "Attitudes toward TCM for prevention and treatment of COVID-19," a larger percentage of doctors opted for the "very much agreed" (31.1% vs. 15.4%) option. In the case of the statement, "There is no specific drug for COVID-19," more doctors selected the "very much agreed" (54.7% vs. 35%) option, while more nurses selected the "Neutral" (28.8% vs. 9.9%) option. Furthermore, in the response to the query "TCM can develop immunity to COVID-19," more doctors opted for the "very much agreed" (31.1% vs. 18.3%) option, while more nurses selected the "Neutral" (32.9% vs. 22.4%) option. Further, in response to the statement "TCM can alleviate the symptoms of COVID-19 patients," more doctors selected the "very much agreed" (34.2% vs. 17.1%) option, whereas more nurses selected the "Neutral" (44.4% vs. 25.5%) option. Moreover, it must be emphasized that a higher number of doctors were aware that TCM had been recommended for COVID-19 (85.1% vs. 58.3%). Furthermore, there was no difference in the response between the doctors and the nurses for the statement "Eat TCM for prevention of COVID-19, which is provided by their hospital."

Up to 55.2% of the participants agreed with the statement "TCM can be used for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19," 40.4% responded neutrally, and 4.4% disagreed with the statement.

With regard to the source of information on "TCM used for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19," There were 100, 184, 68, 47, and 2 participants selected single, two, three, four, and five sources, respectively. Further, there were 277,123, 82, 369, and 17 participants stated that their sources came from "Hospital training," "Academic journals," "Academic Conferences," "Social media platforms (such as WeChat)" and "Others," respectively.

Three-hundred-and-fifty-eight participants will take TCM for the prevention of COVID-19, and 62.8% of them considered it unharmful and worth a try. Forty-three participants were unwilling to take TCM, 53.5% of them considered it ineffective, and 46.5% considered it harmful. 

Sex, age, major, occupation and received TCM treatment in the last five years affected participants' attitudes toward TCM for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19 (Table 3) . Multiple logistic regression analysis showed that age, major and received TCM treatment in the last five years were the independent factors affecting participants' attitudes (Table 4 ).

At the time the survey was conducted no clinical study had indicated that there is a specific drug for the treatment of COVID-19. Cao et al. reported there were no differences in mortality among patients with COVID-19 who did or did not receive antimicrobial [9, 10] . Wang et al.

reported that remdesivir was not associated with significant clinical benefits for severe COVID-19 [11] . Therefore, more than 70% participants agreed with the statement "There is no specific drug for COVID-19." So far, there is no strong evidence supporting TCM use for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19 [12] . However, 55.2% of participants agreed with the statement "TCM can be used for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19," and up to 89.3% of the participants were willing to consider TCM to prevent COVID-19. Third, more than 60% of the participants agreed that TCM can improve immune function and alleviate symptoms in patients. Fourth, 56.2% participants thought that TCM is unharmful and should be worked with. The results of this survey are consistent with those of the previous survey on nursing students' attitudes toward TCM [13] . Forty-five percent of 263 Chinese nursing students reported a positive attitude towards TCM use, 52% were neutral, and only 3% were negative. In another study, the attitude towards TCM was positive in 41%, neutral in 52% and negative in only 6% [14] . Subgroup analysis showed that there was significant difference in the knowledge and attitudes between doctors and nurses. The difference in attitudes between the doctors and nurses toward TCM could be majorly attributed to the following: First, doctors and nurses had different concerns while treating and attending to patients. Therefore, despite their different attitudes towards TCM, doctors and nurses reach a consensus while discharging their duties toward their patients. Our result show that nearly 90% medical professionals willing to eat TCM for the prevention of COVID-19. Major and age and received TCM treatment were the factors affecting participants' attitudes. Older participants tended to agree more with "TCM can be for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19," with 79.3% of participants selecting "very much agree and somewhat agree" in the age group of >51 years, whereas only 47.7% in the age group between 21 and 30 years did. The same result was seen in a survey of attitudes toward TCM among Western-trained doctors. The reason for these results could be that older doctors have more training in TCM than younger doctors [15] . Participants with major of TCM tended to agree more with "TCM can be for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19," with 74.4% of participants selecting "very much agree and somewhat agree" in TCM group, whereas only 41.2% in West Medicine group did. The results can be easily explained: participants' responses were dictated by their experience. There were 59.4% of participants who had received TCM treatment, consistent with the previous survey on the application of TCM in residents of Beijing [16] , and 56.8% (1937/3410) of residents had used herbal decoction. Among the participants who had received TCM treatment, 67.2% of them selected "very much agree and somewhat agree;" however, only 37.4% of the participants had not received TCM treatment. This was because they believed in the effectiveness of TCM and had received TCM treatment in the past, it is reasonable that they selected "very much agree and somewhat agree."

Concerning the information sources on "TCM used for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19," 75% of participants selected more than two sources. The first source selected was social media platforms (such as WeChat), which have been used in different fields, including medicine [17] [18] [19] . In China, many medical subscription accounts and official accounts can be found on social media platforms. As information on social media platforms is timely and easily accessible [20, 21] , it has become the main channel for medical professionals [22, 23] . After February 20, all academic meetings had been canceled and social media platforms became the first choice for obtaining professional knowledge [24] . As many hospitals have executed allemployee training on the Guideline of Diagnosis and Treatment Plan for COVID-19 (5th), the second source is "Hospital training." There is a need for more training on TCM prevention and treatment of COVID-19 for medical professionals because of all the employees, only 69.1% of the participants knew that TCM was recommended for use in the treatment of different phases of COVID-19 by the National Health Commission of the People's Republic of China. The reason is that few participants participated took part in this study, as they focused on the prevention and triage while ignoring treatment which is one limitation of this study. Studies on COVID-19 were few and academic conferences had been canceled. Thus, very little information could be obtained from "Academic journals" and "Academic Conferences."

Up to 89.3% of the participants were willing to take TCM to prevent COVID-19. However, out of them, 62.8% thought that TCM was unharmful and should be tried, although they were not sure about its effectiveness. This result is in line with the current situation; there is no evidence to show that TCM is effective in the treatment of COVID-19 [12] . To determine the efficacy in TCM for the treatment and prevention of COVID-19, it is necessary to provide sufficient evidence from clinical trials. In all participants, only 33.16% thought that TCM was effective, lower than the results of a previous survey of Beijing residents [16] in which 80.7% (2753/3410) of the residents believed that TCM herbal therapy was effective for disease treatment. The reason could be that the medical professionals surveyed in the current study had professional knowledge, causing them to make objective judgments. Only 5% of participants thought that TCM was harmful, and only 4.4% of participants who disagreed that TCM could be used for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19.

The limitations of this study are as follows: First, whether or not they participated in the treatment of COVID-19 patients was not designed as a question in the survey, which may have affected their response. Second, the TCM includes Chinese herbal medicine, Chinese patent medicine, Traditional Chinese medicine injection, acupuncture, and other treatments, but we did not specify these types in our questionnaire, which may have confused the participants, thereby affecting their response. Third, we only performed a subgroup analysis to understand the impact of occupations (doctors and the nurses) on the survey, we did not evaluate the impact of varied specialties (Chinese medicine and West medicine) of the doctors or nurses.

In the absence of specific drug for COVID-19, over half of the participants agreed that TCM can be used for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19 and most participants were willing to take TCM to prevent COVID-19, although unsure about its effectiveness. The main information sources on TCM for the treatment and prevention of COVID-19 were social media platforms and hospital training. 

A Novel Coronavirus From Patients With Pneumonia in China

Early Transmission Dynamics in Wuhan, China, of Novel Coronavirus-Infected Pneumonia

Clinical Features of Patients Infected With 2019 Novel Coronavirus in Wuhan

Role of lopinavir/ritonavir in the treatment of SARS: initial virological and clinical findings

Broad-spectrum antiviral GS-5734 inhibits both epidemic and zoonotic coronaviruses

Comparative therapeutic efficacy of remdesivir and combination lopinavir, ritonavir, and interferon beta against MERS-CoV

National Health Commission of the People's Republic of China. Notice on printing and distributing the diagnosis and treatment plan of pneumonia with new coronavirus infection

Attitudes of radiation oncologists to percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy in patients with head and neck cancer and eating difficulties: a survey in china

Clinical Features and Shortterm Outcomes of 18 Patients with Corona Virus Disease 2019 in Intensive Care Unit

Clinical Features and Short-term Outcomes of 102 Patients with Corona Virus Disease 2019 in Wuhan, China. Clinical Infectious Diseases

Remdesivir in adults with severe COVID-19: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, multicentre trial. Lancet

Can Chinese Medicine Be Used for Prevention of Corona Virus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)? A Review of Historical Classics, Research Evidence and Current Prevention Programs

Chinese nursing students' attitudes toward traditional Chinese medicine

A Survey of Attitudes to Traditional Chinese Medicine Among Chinese Medical Students

Attitudes to Traditional Chinese Medicine Amongst Western Trained Doctors in the People's Republic of China

Application of Traditional Chinese Medicine in medical practice: a survey of community residents in Beijing

The Multipurpose Application WeChat: A Review on Recent Research

The usability of WeChat as a mobile and interactive medium in student-centered medical teaching

Understanding the Function Constitution and Influence Factors on Communication for the WeChat Official Account of Top Tertiary Hospitals in China: Cross-Sectional Study

Social Media Landscape of the Tertiary Referral Hospitals in China: Observational Descriptive Study

How the public uses social media wechat to obtain health information in china: a survey study

Social media usage and online professionalism among registered nurses: A cross-sectional survey

Evolving use of social media among Chinese urologists: Opportunity or challenge? PLoS One

Notice on postponement of academic meeting of Chinese Medical Association from February to April