key: cord-1052040-1e46x3sh
authors: El Hayek, Samer; Nofal, Marwa; Abdelrahman, Doaa; Adra, Ali; Al Harthi, Mansour; Al Shamli, Siham; AlNuaimi, Nawaf; Bensid, Lynda; Cheaito, Mohamad Ali; Emberish, Alkhansa Mahdi; Larnaout, Amine; Radwan, Ahmed; Slaih, Mohammad; Kobeissy, Firas; Bizri, Maya
title: Telepsychiatry in the Arab World: A Viewpoint Before and During COVID-19
date: 2020-11-19
journal: Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat
DOI: 10.2147/ndt.s277224
sha: 5e4c700c7efda7ba9812e2f6a192f15b958f4c2e
doc_id: 1052040
cord_uid: 1e46x3sh

PURPOSE: Telepsychiatry, a subset of telemedicine, has been increasingly studied to meet the growing demands for psychiatric care. The utility of telepsychiatry is relevant now more than ever as the world endures the COVID-19 global pandemic. This paper describes the prior state and the changes that the COVID-19 outbreak brought to telepsychiatry in a selected group of Arab countries of the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We invited twelve early-career psychiatrists from different Arab nations to share information related to telepsychiatry in their respective countries before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. The information was collected using a semi-structured guide. This was complemented by a search for relevant articles in five search engines using terms such as “COVID-19,” “telepsychiatry,” and “Arab world”. RESULTS: Before the pandemic, digital mental health services were provided in several Arab countries, mainly through hotlines and messaging services. The COVID-19 pandemic has marked a major shift in digital psychiatric services in the Arab MENA world, through the transformation of many clinics and some hospitals into digital mental health systems. Many non-governmental organizations also started remote initiatives for psychological support and psychiatric counseling. Three main barriers of patient-related, healthcare-related, and system-related hurdles of using telepsychiatry emanated from the analysis. CONCLUSION: The use of digital mental health services varies between different Arab countries. Even though some nations have laws that regulate the provision of such services, most struggle with multifactorial barriers. As affordable and attainable solutions cannot only rely on training and recruiting more psychiatrists, telepsychiatry would help meet the exceeding demands in the Arab world, particularly after the COVID-19 outbreak.

Telepsychiatry, a subset of telemedicine, has been increasingly studied to meet the growing demands for psychiatric care. 1 It provides a range of services, including psychiatric evaluation, medication management, therapy, and patient counseling. The most predominantly used communication platforms in telepsychiatry are synchronous technologies, mainly via videoconferencing. 1 Asynchronous technology through messaging services has also been used. 2 Telepsychiatry has introduced several benefits, such as decreased cost, reduced stigma, and better continuity of care. Moreover, it has helped remove multiple barriers to accessing psychiatric care, particularly the scarcity of resources, shortage in mental health professionals, inaccessible geographic locations, and fragmented care. 1, [3] [4] [5] The utility of telepsychiatry is relevant now more than ever as the world endures the COVID-19 global pandemic. [6] [7] [8] This outbreak has presented the medical community with a sweeping number of challenges. Many mental healthcare systems did not have the infrastructural resources required to adequately cope with the exponentially evolving impact of COVID-19. 9 The pandemic has negatively impacted mental health around the globe by elevating rates of depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder, and negative societal behaviors. [10] [11] [12] Additionally, the adverse effects of COVID-19 on the mental health of affected communities, including healthcare workers, quickly started to compromise the general medical response. [13] [14] [15] With physical distancing, increased patients' reluctance to present to healthcare settings, and decreased staffing levels due to necessary self-isolation, telepsychiatry arose to meet the demand for mental health services. 3, 16, 17 Governments, organizations, and scientists urged for the advancement of psychiatric care during the outbreak. 18, 19 However, in many affected countries, the availability of mental health professionals does not meet the continuous growth in demand. 20 For instance, in the Arab world, mental health expenditure as a percentage of total health expenditure is not available for most countries. Six out of 20 countries do not have mental health legislation, whereas two do not have a mental health policy. Alternatively, seven countries (Iraq, Libya, Morocco, Somalia, Sudan, Syria, and Yemen) have less than 0.5 psychiatrists per 100,000 population. 21 Keeping this in mind, and in the context of growing healthcare demands and a need to maintain physical distance, an assessment of the status of telepsychiatry in this part of the world becomes necessary. Hence, in this study, we review the state of telepsychiatry in a selected group of Arab countries of the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region. We discuss the evolution of digital mental health before and during the COVID-19 pandemic and highlight the hurdles encountered during the process.

We invited twelve early-career psychiatrists from different Arab countries of the MENA region to share information related to telepsychiatry in their respective nations before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. We elected for earlycareer rather than mid-career or late-career psychiatrists as the former tend to be the most informed and updated about modern technology and remote medical care. 22 Besides, early-career psychiatrists, as torchbearers of the future of the field, 23 would provide a fresh perspective about the use of telepsychiatry in this part of the world.

Each author provided data about telepsychiatry services available in their countries, with emphasis on the evolution of these services, if applicable, during the pandemic. For the sake of this study, telepsychiatry services of interest encompassed synchronous and asynchronous technologies, including video-based services, phone call options, and electronic messaging services. The information was collected using a semi-structured guide (Supplementary Appendix). All team members carried out their search using the governmental ministry of health websites of their respective nations, along with local, regional, and international electronic newspapers, magazines, and social media outlets discussing the topic of telepsychiatry.

To complement this search, the authors checked different search engines (PubMed, Medline, Scopus, Embase, and PsycInfo), from inception until June 16, 2020, for references about telepsychiatry and telemental health in the Arab countries of the MENA region. Particular focus was directed towards articles addressing the use and impact of digital mental health during the COVID-19 pandemic. Terms used in the search included "COVID-19", "coronavirus", "SARS-COV-2", "telepsychiatry", "telemental", "digital mental health", "Arab world", and "Middle East and North Africa region". We reviewed relevant references for the articles of interest and only included those published in English.

Discussion between the authors of the manuscript occurred via email. Ethical permission was not sought as there was no direct involvement of human participants, and data used were already available in the public domain.

Telepsychiatry services have been present prior to the COVID-19 pandemic in most Arab countries of interest (Table 1) . [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] The services, available via governmental, non-governmental, or private institutions, mainly involve phoneline call centers and messaging services. Less frequently, hotlines designed for mental health and video conferences have been established. Shezlong, an Egyptianbased platform, started to offer online therapy in the MENA region via video visits since 2014. 41 Only two submit your manuscript | www.dovepress.com

Neuropsychiatric Disease and Treatment 2020:16 countries, the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA), have telepsychiatry legislation. In the UAE, the Health Authority Abu Dhabi implemented a general telemedicine regime in Abu Dhabi as early as 2013. 42 Alternatively, KSA is the only country where online training courses in digital mental health are provided for healthcare workers.

Despite being available and used, the field of telepsychiatry in the Arab countries of the MENA region has been struggling with many challenges. Three mains themes of patient-related, healthcare-related, and systemrelated barriers emanated from our analysis. First of all, patients commonly find consultations without seeing a doctor as a challenging concept. Some countries suffer from a high level of illiteracy, such as in Sudan where it reached 60.7% in 2018, 43 limiting the ability to implement telepsychiatry. Those who are educated and comfortable with digital care might still suffer from technological illiteracy, with limited knowledge about the use of different platforms or unfamiliarity with payment processes. Many also would be concerned about their privacy and confidentiality while using online resources, limiting their acceptance of this method of healthcare. In terms of healthcare-related barriers, one common pitfall is digital illiteracy and the lack of appropriate training for the use of digital mental health. Another barrier is the general lack and limited access to mental health services. 21, 44, 45 Lastly, system-related limitations include bureaucratic and organizational difficulties. For instance, in countries that have fallen within political and socioeconomic turmoil, such as Lebanon, Libya, Sudan, and Syria, telepsychiatry has been hindered by poor infrastructure, including the lack of stable electricity and the absence of accessible internet. These limitations are more commonly observed in remote and rural areas. This comes on top of a lack of adequate sustainable funding and adequate financial resources in the Arab healthcare system to implement, operate, and maintain telemedicine in general.

Since the COVID-19 outbreak, the concept of telepsychiatry has become more familiar and accessible in the Arab world (Table 2) . 33, [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] For instance, in KSA, most clinics switched to virtual visits, either via phone consultations or video conferencing. Similarly, in Jordan, digital mental health has evolved so rapidly that it became the preferred method of consultation to confirm with social distancing rules. As one private clinic shifted all their services into online ones, the largest private psychiatric hospital in the country launched a promotional campaign encouraging the transition to digital platforms. 52 In addition, the Jordanian Psychiatrists Association initiated a phone-based hotline for psychological support during the quarantine that served more than 270 cases within one month. 53 Likewise, a psychiatry department at a tertiary care center in Lebanon became a leading model for telepsychiatry in the country. 54 The "Syndicat National Algerien Des Psychologues", alternatively, announced the release of a new hotline for psychological support during the pandemic, and many services, including psychiatry, switched to online platforms. 55, 56 In Egypt, telepsychiatry services expanded to include the private sector, non-governmental organizations such as the Egyptian Red Crescent, and governmental organizations, through the General Secretariat of Mental Health and Addiction Treatment. The latter has been offering digital mental health services via social media booths, online training, and a dedicated 24-hour hotline. 57 In addition, the Shezlong platform has raised new investments to expand its services. 58 Alternatively, besides the UAE and KSA, only Egypt started to offer telepsychiatry training for healthcare workers. Despite that, a wide majority of interventions has been offered, mostly to psychiatric patients. Fewer targeted the general population, COVID-19 patients, healthcare workers, and vulnerable subgroups. These services were easily accepted among patients and mostly received positive feedback, despite the re-emergence of the previously described pitfalls.

The role of telepsychiatry is now more important than it ever was. 7, 8 The evidence to support the effectiveness of telepsychiatry is fairly diverse, especially for depression, anxiety, and trauma-related disorders. [59] [60] [61] Different forms of digital mental health platforms were found to be effective for the delivery of services, including videoconferencing, smartphone applications, text messaging, electronic mails, and online forums. [62] [63] [64] [65] [66] After the COVID-19 pandemic, a drastic shift from outpatient activities and liaison psychiatry to telepsychiatry has occurred, and a call for the implementation of digital mental health has been widely encouraged. 9, 20, 67 China led this movement as the nation started to actively provide telepsychiatry services for the general population and those at risk of exposure to COVID-19. 68 Along the same lines, the Australian Neuropsychiatric Disease and Treatment 2020:16 submit your manuscript | www.dovepress.com

Government has responded to the pandemic by increasing the funding for telepsychiatry services, including telehealth consultations with general practitioners and specialists. 69 The same has been applied, to a much-limited extent, in the Arab world, with many pitfalls that have been dragging for a while, even prior to the pandemic. For instance, psychiatric services, previously confined to few large mental health hospitals, have been gradually replaced by inpatient and outpatient facilities in general hospitals. 21 Training programs in mental health at the primary healthcare level have also started in many of the Arab countries. 70 Despite this movement towards the integration of mental health in the general care delivery system, the implementation remains limited and the mental health infrastructure and services grossly insufficient. 21 When it comes to telepsychiatry in the Arab world, the field seems to be in its early phases of development. 71 Even though some Arab countries have a more advanced telemedicine profile, others still fail to meet basic healthcare requirements. In the first pitch of nations, KSA has been employing health telematics as early as of 1993, with a remarkable success that persuaded the Ministry of Health to create a national electronic healthcare system which links more than 25 hospitals in major cities and vital rural areas. 72 Telehealth has also been successfully implemented in KSA during the COVID-19 outbreak. 73 In the opposite pitch, the healthcare system in Iraq has been struggling with an increased burden on resources, which frequently impedes patients' access to healthcare. Electronic information sharing among hospitals remains, as such, very limited. 74 Even though Oman has some telemedicine services and a prototype for remote healthcare monitoring was recently suggested, these services remain limited to a few hospitals and specialties and do not adequately tackle telepsychiatry. 75 In Syria, poor technological infrastructure remains the main problem in the application of telemedicine in general, and telepsychiatry more specifically. Indeed, Syria has the poorest network infrastructure among the Eastern Mediterranean countries, along with a high cost of internet access and poor internet security. 74 Despite these limitations, telepsychiatry has been proposed as a potential modality to help bridge the mental health needs gap in Syria. 76 The use of telepsychiatry as a temporary and cost-effective service for the growing mental healthcare needs of Syrians was proposed amidst the rising challenges 29 and different platforms have been offered and provided, along with clinical training to healthcare providers in the Syrian humanitarian conflict setting. 77 Lastly, a recent systematic review on the feasibility of electronic mental health applications among Syrian refugees and other vulnerable Arab populations noted a positive impact of these applications on the access to services and treatment outcomes. It also revealed a paucity of literature about the topic in the Arab region. 78 Our results also pinpoint many limits for telepsychiatry that seem multifactorial in nature. Jefee-Bahloul discusses four similar barriers to implement telemental health in the Middle East: cultural (both patient-and healthcarerelated), and technical, financial, and regulatory (systemrelated). 79 On patient-and healthcare-related barriers, a recent systematic review of 134 studies about telepsychiatry identified that patients and providers are generally satisfied with digital mental health services. The evidence also suggests that telepsychiatry is at least comparable to face-to-face services in terms of reliability of clinical assessments and treatment outcomes. 4 A remote interdisciplinary approach that involves psychiatrists, psychologists, and social workers, is the most effective in preventing undesirable outcomes. 80 An important element to keep in mind is the cultural facet of the Arab world, where religion and gender considerations may play a substantial role in the delivery of digital services. 79 However, the limited data in this part of the world seems to be worthwhile. In a sample of Syrian refugees suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder, about half were open to receive telepsychiatry care. 81 In another study, attitudes toward telemental health were assessed in a group of Syrian healthcare providers. Even though the majority had no experience with telepsychiatry, half believed that mental healthcare can be provided through digital platforms. 82 Overcoming sociocultural barriers requires a comprehensive strategy that targets both receiving ends, with appropriate training for providers and suitable exposure for patients. For mental health professionals with limited technological literacy, the American Psychiatric Association provides a telepsychiatry toolkit for guidance. 83 On the other hand, system-related barriers, as Jefee-Bahloul described, encompass a combination of technical, legal, and financial challenges. 79 Tackling these components requires the combined efforts of multiple stakeholders, including local governments and investors, while keeping in mind that telepsychiatry is more cost-effective than face-to-face delivery of mental health services. 4 Inpatient and outpatient clinics should explore repurposing existing workstations to become more friendly for the usage of digital platforms. 84 Alternatively, healthcare systems and policymakers have to set up programs based on the existing and effective remote collaborative care models. 85 Finally, one significant challenge that arose in the rapid need for tele-deployment during the pandemic has been prescribing practices. In Lebanon, with the Neuropsychiatric Disease and Treatment 2020:16 submit your manuscript | www.dovepress.com absence of a centralized electronic healthcare system, both the Lebanese Orders of Physicians and Pharmacists issued a temporary circular urging providers and covering parties to use and accept electronic modalities for prescriptions during the outbreak, although concerns about potential lack of regulation have been plenty. 86 Taking these challenges into consideration, Table 3 provides a list of recommendations to improve telepsychiatry DovePress services in the Arab world. These recommendations, derived from the identified barriers, try to tackle the different patient, healthcare, and system-related deficiencies. As early-career psychiatrists, our role is of relevance. 22, 87 With our adequate exposure to technology and our level of comfort with digital platforms, we have a duty to vouch for telepsychiatry services and always offer them, whenever applicable, as a treatment option. 22 Our study has several limitations. First, data about telepsychiatry services in the different Arab countries was collected qualitatively via a semi-structured interview. Some nations were also not represented in the analysis. However, the heterogeneity between the countries from which the Arab early-career psychiatrists came strengthened the value of the collected information and would allow its applicability to the MENA region in general. Alternatively, cultural barriers of telepsychiatry that might include gender sensitivity, religion, and other societal norms of the Arab society were not fully assessed. Further studies would benefit from structured crosssectional surveys that explore the perceptions and attitudes of patients and mental health professionals towards implementing telepsychiatry while taking into consideration socio-cultural challenges, among others.

Critical shortfalls in mental health services in the Arab countries of the MENA region present a challenge for mental healthcare during the COVID-19 pandemic. The increasing demands on already overburdened psychiatric services might risk creating a public mental health crisis. As efficient, affordable, and attainable solutions cannot only rely on training and recruiting more psychiatrists, telepsychiatry would help meet the exceeding demands. This would, nevertheless, require the joint efforts of a range of stakeholders, including policymakers as, to our knowledge, no specific telemental health guidelines have been previously developed in the Arab world. Advocacy for digital mental health should also extend to mental health professionals and the general body of medicine. As the world moves through this crisis, the Arab nations should do their best to implement the much-needed telepsychiatry interventions and maintain these services into the future. More studies are also required to understand the socio-cultural barriers limiting the use of digital mental health in this part of the world.

The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work. Table 3 List of Recommendations to Improve Telepsychiatry Services in the Arab World

Raising awareness and educating the public about the availability, importance, and efficacy of telepsychiatry services.

Providing basic training for candidate patients about the use of different digital platforms when seeking professional help.

Establishing regulations and protocols that ensure privacy, confidentiality, and legal responsibility towards patients.

Healthcarerelated Ensuring appropriate training for mental health professionals about the use and application of telepsychiatry services.

Providing a telepsychiatry course as part of every psychiatry residency training program.

Recognizing the role of early-career psychiatrists in advocating for telepsychiatry and in organizing training sessions to facilitate the implementation of services.

System-related Allocating specific funding for telemental health, directed towards improving infrastructure, particularly in terms of availability of fast and efficient internet and appropriate cellular network coverage.

Establishing a national legislation for telepsychiatry services that caters for the needs and rights of both patients and professionals.

Creating audits and quality improvement projects to improve services, tackle challenges, and optimize cost-effectiveness.

submit your manuscript | www.dovepress.com

Neuropsychiatric Disease and Treatment 2020:16

Telepsychiatry in integrated care settings

Review of use of asynchronous technologies incorporated in mental health care

Considerations for telepsychiatry service implementation in the era of covid-19

Review of key telepsychiatry outcomes

Telepsychiatry and other technologies for integrated care: evidence base, best practice models and competencies

Covid-19 and telepsychiatry: development of evidence-based guidance for clinicians

The use of telepsychiatry during covid-19 and beyond

Telepsychiatry and healthcare access inequities during the covid-19 pandemic

Public responses to the novel 2019 coronavirus (2019-ncov) in japan: mental health consequences and target populations

Covid-19 pandemic and mental health consequences: systematic review of the current evidence

Mental health outcomes of the covid-19 pandemic

Concern over dramatic fall in emergency hospital admissions

Factors associated with mental health outcomes among health care workers exposed to coronavirus disease 2019

Prevalence of depression, anxiety, and insomnia among healthcare workers during the covid-19 pandemic: a systematic review and meta-analysis

A viewpoint from paris on the covid-19 pandemic: a necessary turn to telepsychiatry

The use of telepsychiatry during covid-19 and beyond

Timely mental health care for the 2019 novel coronavirus outbreak is urgently needed

The outbreak of covid-19 coronavirus and its impact on global mental health

Impact of human disasters and covid-19 pandemic on mental health: potential of digital psychiatry

Mental health services in the arab world

Brain health innovation diplomacy: a model binding diverse disciplines to manage the promise and perils of technological innovation

Relevance of early career psychiatrist associations

The world bank

Vaidya S Oman sets up first telemedicine centre

Libyan national health services the need to move to management-by-objectives

Telepsychiatry for post-traumatic stress disorder: a call for action in the syrian conflict

Police launches suicide hotline as numbers rise

Khartoum: Sudan WHO and Ministry of Health

The first online psychological clinic in Arabic for adults, children, and adolescents

Qariboun -We are close

Telemedicine in developing countries; case of tunisia

Chapter 12 -the egyptian-african telemedicine network: the treat and teach comprehensive model

Standards for telehealth services

15+) literacy rate

A call for emergency action: telepsychiatry for trauma treatment among syrian refugees

Barriers and challenges in adopting saudi telemedicine network: the perceptions of decision makers of healthcare facilities in saudi arabia

A hotline and a team of specialists in Qatar to provide psychological support during the Corona pandemic

16 submit your manuscript | www

19 boosts the uptake of tele health/medicine in uaewhat are the legal implications?

Duraid Hussein Hospital launches a remote psychological support and listening cell

Aburawi M Fighting covid using telehealth in libya

This "virtual clinic" platform is offering two free e-check ups to patients in egypt & middle east

Covid-19: telehealth businesses set to grow during pandemic

Al rashid hospital center psychiatry and addiction

You are not alone, we are with you: Campaign to support mental health in Jordan

«la téléconsultation suscite l'engouement des citoyens»; 2020

Lancement d'un réseau national d'écoute et de soutien psychologique

Egypt offers psychological help amid social isolation

Alaa El-Din M Shezlong increases investments to expand mental health operations

Telemedicine for depression: a systematic review

A systematic review of videoconference-delivered psychological treatment for anxiety disorders

Systematic review of lessons learned from delivering tele-therapy to veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder

Videoconferencing psychotherapy and depression: a systematic review

Videoconferencing psychotherapy: a systematic review

The effectiveness of email-based exercises in promoting psychological wellbeing and healthy lifestyle: a two-year follow-up study

Smartphone applications for depression: a systematic literature review and a survey of health care professionals' attitudes towards their use in clinical practice

Telepsychiatry as a public health imperative: slowing covid-19

Mental health service platform provides around-the-clock psychological support during covid-19 outbreak

The role of telehealth in reducing the mental health burden from covid-19

World Health Organization ROftEM. Mental health in the eastern mediterranean region: reaching the unreached

Developing a digital mental health platform for the arab world: from research to action

National Profile of the Information Society in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. United Nations. 25

Current status of telehealth in saudi arabia during covid-19

A review of adoption of telemedicine in middle east countries: toward building iraqi telemedicine framework

Telemedicine requirements for treatment network in oman

Telepsychiatry and Mental Health Care for Syrian Refugees in Turkey

Using a store-and-forward system to provide global telemental health supervision and training: a case from syria

Utilization of mobile mental health services among syrian refugees and other vulnerable arab populations-a systematic review

Telemental health in the middle east: overcoming the barriers. Front Public Health

Efficacy of synchronous telepsychology interventions for people with anxiety, depression, posttraumatic stress disorder, and adjustment disorder: a rapid evidence assessment

Pilot assessment and survey of syrian refugees' psychological stress and openness to referral for telepsychiatry (passport study)

Attitudes towards implementation of store-and-forward telemental health in humanitarian settings: survey of syrian healthcare providers

Telepsychiatry toolkit

Mobilization of telepsychiatry in response to covid-19-moving toward 21(st) century access to care

Circular for doctors to approve using phones and applications for inspection and provision of prescriptions

Telepsychiatry during the covid-19 pandemic: development of a protocol for telemental health care

This journal is indexed on PubMed Central, the 'PsycINFO' database and CAS, and is the official journal of The International Neuropsychiatric Association (INA). The manuscript management system is completely online and includes a very quick and fair peer-review system

neuropsychiatric-disease-and-treatment-journal Neuropsychiatric Disease and Treatment 2020:16 submit your manuscript | www