key: cord-1044742-r8d81b28
authors: Lin, Steven; Sattler, Amelia; Smith, Margaret
title: Retooling Primary Care in the COVID-19 Era
date: 2020-07-23
journal: Mayo Clin Proc
DOI: 10.1016/j.mayocp.2020.06.050
sha: f7fcc3c7bae84f633089543aee8610baf6e8cc19
doc_id: 1044742
cord_uid: r8d81b28

ABSTRACT The COVID-19 pandemic exposed numerous deficiencies of the U.S. primary care infrastructure. The system is overstretched with little to no surge capacity to deal with crisis situations, its reach restrained due to overreliance on brick and mortar clinics, and its behavior overwhelmingly more reactive than preventive. As delivery systems reorganize on the fly to fight COVID-19, many are turning to tools like telemedicine, pre-visit planning, and centralized population health programs. We propose how these rapid transformations happening across the country, born out of necessity, present a silver lining opportunity to fix primary care. We describe how integrating telemedicine, patient-generated data, and preventive care into a retooled intake and care optimization process is achievable through an approach powered by humans and augmentable with artificial intelligence. Primary care must retool to meet the challenge of COVID-19 and emerge in the post-crisis world better equipped to care for a wounded nation. Our collective willingness to invest in primary care teams, relaxation of rules around telemedicine reimbursement and patient-generated data sharing, workforce training, and movement to value-based payments are necessary to achieve this vision.

The COVID-19 pandemic exposed numerous deficiencies of the U.S. primary care infrastructure.

The system is overstretched with little to no surge capacity to deal with crisis situations, its reach restrained due to overreliance on brick and mortar clinics, and its behavior overwhelmingly more reactive than preventive. As delivery systems reorganize on the fly to fight COVID-19, many are turning to tools like telemedicine, pre-visit planning, and centralized population health programs.

We propose how these rapid transformations happening across the country, born out of necessity, present a silver lining opportunity to fix primary care. We describe how integrating telemedicine, patient-generated data, and preventive care into a retooled intake and care optimization process is achievable through an approach powered by humans and augmentable with artificial intelligence.

Primary care must retool to meet the challenge of COVID-19 and emerge in the post-crisis world better equipped to care for a wounded nation. Our collective willingness to invest in primary care teams, relaxation of rules around telemedicine reimbursement and patient-generated data sharing, workforce training, and movement to value-based payments are necessary to achieve this vision. 3 

The COVID-19 pandemic exposed numerous deficiencies of the U.S. primary care infrastructure.

The system is overstretched with little to no surge capacity to deal with crisis situations, its reach restrained due to overreliance on brick and mortar clinics, and its behavior overwhelmingly more reactive than preventive. Even before the outbreak, U.S. primary care physicians faced excessive patient panel sizes in an environment of a workforce shortage. [1] [2] Without enough time to provide all the necessary acute, chronic and preventive care for their patients, primary care physicians are forced to prioritize acute care; not surprisingly, patients receive only half of all the recommended chronic and preventive care services. 3 On top of these, stunning disparities in access, quality, and affordability of primary care persist, especially in rural and vulnerable populations where doctors are in short supply. 4 These system failures -however damaging during normal times -have been magnified exponentially by the unprecedented challenge of COVID-19.

As primary care systems reorganize on the fly to fight COVID-19, many are turning to tools such as telemedicine, pre-visit planning, and centralized population health management. Telemedicine has been indispensable in delivering care to patients sheltered at home, while minimizing risks to providers. Prior to COVID-19, only 28% of U.S. physicians were using telemedicine; 5 today it is the preferred, if not dominant, method of delivering care. 6 Pre-visit planning strategies like clinic schedule sweeping, pre-visit screening of patients, and triaging visit priorities -once regarded as "nice-to-have" protocols -have been adopted as "must-haves," quickly and widely. Systems that have been flirting with centralizing their population health services to improve care quality have accelerated their transitions to free up primary care physicians to handle the surge of COVID-19 4 patients. These rapid transformations happening in health systems across the country, born out of necessity, present an opportunity -a silver lining -to fix primary care.

When all is done, the COVID-19 pandemic will likely be seen as a tipping point for telemedicine in the U.S. -the point when it was no longer considered a niche service, but an essential piece of care delivery. At one institution -Stanford University -the volume of telehealth and video visits leaped from 400 per day to 3,000 in a period of just two weeks when the pandemic hit California.

Nationally, widespread telemedicine adoption was powered by the loosening of payer restrictions by Medicare and some private insurances. 7 The longer COVID-19 lasts, the more it will push the envelope on the breadth, depth, and comprehensiveness of care that can be accomplished through virtual visits. What we need now is a national telemedicine curriculum to be taught in residencies and medical schools, 8 and for Congress to make coverage for telemedicine visits permanent.

Since COVID-19, nurses have held the primary care front lines. Nurses assess, advise, and direct patients to the most appropriate level of care, conserving access to physicians for those who need them most. They follow-up and monitor COVID-19 patients for clinical deterioration. Nurses are a scarce resource. Tools such as Apple's COVID-19 screening app, created with the CDC, gather patient-generated data and help patients contextualize their symptoms and determine if they need to see a clinician. 9 This general approach of using patient-generated data to connect patients with the right level of care when, where, and how they need it should be broadened to all primary care intake processes. Integration of technology-assisted tools including symptom checker apps, web-based screeners, and wearable devices into health systems' electronic health records (EHR) holds promise to make the most of every precious encounter between patients and physicians.

The COVID-19 pandemic led to a dramatic shift in operational priorities from improving general population health and chronic disease management to identifying patients with and at risk for the virus. Nearly all preventive care have been postponed and chronic disease management programs scaled back or put on hold. These inter-visit efforts require significant time and resources that are not currently available. Before COVID-19, systems were slow to adopt centralized strategies that leverage team-based care and technology, despite demonstrated benefits on quality of care. 10 The post-COVID-19 era presents a crucial opportunity to overcome the hurdles of culture change in a time when systems are pressured to reimagine nearly all aspects of daily work. The alternative to prioritizing and centralizing preventive care is to exhaust our already overextended teams, asking them to catch up for lost time once systems emerge from this pandemic.

Integrating telemedicine, patient-generated data, and preventive care into a retooled primary care intake and care optimization process is achievable (Figure) . Such an approach would be powered by humans and augmentable by artificial intelligence. 11 Up until the recent loosing of restrictions on virtual care, the primary barriers to telemedicine adoption were payer coverage and regulatory limitations. Looking to the future, the lack of reimbursement for pre-visit planning and inter-visit care management activities will be a key driver of change. Human and technical challenges exist:

for patients, convenience, privacy, and data security are chief concerns; for providers, fears about 6 data overload, technology/EHR interoperability, and workflow integration are paramount. Health systems' willingness to invest in primary care teams, relaxation of rules around patient-generated data use, workforce training, and advancement to value-based payments are necessary to achieve this vision.

Primary care must retool to meet the challenge of COVID-19 and emerge in the post-crisis world better equipped to care for a wounded nation, and possibly millions of patients who have delayed usual care for months on end. Although issues of over-empaneled providers, workforce shortage, and disparities in access, quality and affordability of care will not disappear after COVID-19, we can use tools like telemedicine, pre-visit planning, and population health management -powered by humans and AI -to expand primary care's reach in all communities, increase system capacity and visit efficiency, and prioritize prevention to keep patients healthy. The COVID-19 pandemic taught us valuable lessons. Let us not squander this opportunity to make primary care better.

Estimating a reasonable patient panel size for primary care physicians with team-based task delegation

Association of American Medical Colleges. The Complexities of Physician Supply and Demand: Projections from

The quality of health care delivered to adults in the United States

Physicians' motivations and requirements for adopting digital health: adoption and attitudinal shifts from

Telemedicine is essential amid the COVID-19 crisis and after it. The Economist

Medicare Telemedicine Health Care Provider Fact Sheet

AMA encourages telemedicine training for medical students

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. CDC Statement on COVID-19 Apple App

Chronic disease outcomes from primary care population health program implementation

Ten ways artificial intelligence will transform primary care

Funders: None.Prior presentations: None.

None of the authors have financial interests to declare. 8