key: cord-1040128-bwmsp2ct
authors: Sui, Yongjun; Bekele, Yonas; Berzofsky, Jay A.
title: Potential SARS-CoV-2 Immune Correlates of Protection in Infection and Vaccine Immunization
date: 2021-01-30
journal: Pathogens
DOI: 10.3390/pathogens10020138
sha: 5059bc3a7319c3ff83f3af8e0734732b86844bdc
doc_id: 1040128
cord_uid: bwmsp2ct

Both SARS-CoV-2 infections and vaccines induce robust immune responses. Current data suggested that high neutralizing antibody titers with sustained Th1 responses might correlate with protection against viral transmission and disease development and severity. In addition, genetic and innate immune factors, including higher levels of type I interferons, as well as the induction of trained immunity and local mucosal immunity also contribute to lower risk of infection and amelioration of disease severity. The identification of immune correlates of protection will facilitate the development of effective vaccines and therapeutics strategies.

After crossing the species barrier, most likely from bats, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) has recently emerged to infect humans and cause severe public health problems. Since the outbreak in late December 2019, more than 85.9 million cases and 1.86 million deaths have been reported worldwide as of 5 January 2021. Effective SARS-CoV-2 vaccines and therapeutic strategies are urgently needed. While some vaccines and monoclonal antibodies have been approved for clinical use, understanding their mechanism of protection can facilitate improvements that may become necessary as long-term efficacy data become available over the next few years.

SARS-CoV-2 infects target cells via angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2) as the primary receptor and transmembrane protease serine 2 (TMPRSS2) as an activating protease [1, 2] . In the respiratory system, since ACE2 and TMPRSS2 are expressed primarily in type II pneumocytes and a fraction of secretory cells [2] [3] [4] , SARS-CoV-2 virus productively infects these target cells in the upper and lower respiratory tracts [5, 6] . The virus also can infect endothelial cells of multiple organs such as lung, gut, liver and kidneys and result in damaging blood clots in multiple organs [1, 2, 7, 8] . In humans, the infected patients displayed various COVID-19 disease symptoms, ranging from mild to severe pneumonia, and in some cases acute respiratory distress syndrome and lethal pulmonary failure [9] [10] [11] . Other COVID19-related pathological manifestations in gut, heart, and brain were also observed, and led to fatalities as well as some long-term debilitating sequelae in a fraction of survivors. The mechanisms determining the variable outcomes remain elusive.

SARS-CoV-2 viral infections and vaccines induce robust immune responses, including innate and adaptive immune responses. However, the immune responses that can provide long-lasting protective immunity have yet to be fully determined. Here, we review the literature on what is currently known about the immune responses induced by SARS-CoV-2 infection and vaccines and focus on studies identifying potential immune correlates that predict protection. This is critical for development of vaccine and therapeutic strategies targeting SARS-CoV-2.

disease, more studies are needed to elucidate whether virus-specific CD8 + T cells are pathogenic or protective in SARS-CoV-2 infections [23, 31, 33] .

To identify the immune correlates of protection, though information from SARS-CoV-2 infections and vaccines are both valuable, extra caution is needed. Interpretation of the immune correlates from SARS-CoV-2-infected persons can be complicated and sometimes misleading. Like other viral infectious diseases, viral loads are a major driver of induced immune responses. Usually, patients with severe disease have high viral loads, which lead to high innate, and humoral/cellular immune responses, while the asymptomatic patients with lower viral loads induce lower immune responses. This is also true for SARS-Cov-2 infected patients. For example, vast numbers of studies have been carried out to characterize the humoral immune responses in COVID-19 acute or convalescent patients and most found that higher titers of neutralizing antibodies were induced in COVID-19 patients with severe disease than in those with mild disease [26] . The antibody responses also lasted longer in the patients with severe disease. Consistent with this, asymptomatic individuals manifested much weaker immune responses to SARS-CoV-2 infections than symptomatic ones [34] . Furthermore, in the early convalescent phase, IgG and neutralizing antibody levels in asymptomatic individuals declined much more quickly than those in the symptomatic patients [34] . However, these inverse correlations between disease severity and the magnitude of immune responses most likely indicate that severe disease, with high viral burden, leads to more robust immune responses, rather than the other way around.

There are no fully licensed SARS-CoV-2 vaccines available so far. Multiple vaccine strategies, including adenovirus-vectored, inactivated virus, DNA-, mRNA-based platforms, and recombinant viral subunits/protein, have been utilized for SARS-CoV-2 vaccine development. So far, three vaccines (from Pfizer/BioNTech, Moderna, and AstraZeneca) have finished interim Phase III clinical trials, and obtained Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) in multiple countries. The immune responses have been measured and the vaccine efficacy has been tested in animal models and human clinical trials [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] . Most vaccine strategies induced humoral and cellular immune responses including virus-specific binding antibodies, neutralizing antibodies and virus-specific T-cell responses, in vaccinated macaques and human vaccinees [38, [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] . Detailed information on the phase I-III clinical trials and the immune responses induced by these vaccines have been extensively reviewed [48] [49] [50] . Since most of studies have only immunogenicity data, the immune correlations that can be used to predict the outcome of viral infection and disease severity will not be ascertainable from these studies. Here we summarize the data from non-human primate (NHP) studies that had both immunogenicity and SARS-CoV-2 viral challenge outcomes presented (Table 1 ), in the hope to glean some clues on the immune correlates of protections. Among these NHP studies, several of them identified immune parameters that were inversely correlated with viral loads and disease severity. Consistent with the fact that neutralizing antibody titer has been linked to protection against other pathogens and is considered a surrogate marker to predict viral clearance, two vaccine efficacy studies, one using DNA and another using Ad26 as delivery vectors, have demonstrated that vaccineelicited neutralizing antibody titer correlated with protective efficacy, and thus suggested neutralizing antibody as an immune correlate of protection [36, 39] . In the DNA vaccine study, Yu et al. found that besides neutralizing antibody, Spike-and receptor-binding domain (RBD)-specific antibody-dependent complement deposition (ADCD) responses inversely correlated with viral loads [39] . Specifically, RBD-specific FcγR2a-1 binding antibody mediating ADCD responses and neutralizing antibody (Nab) titers of IgG2 antibodies improve the correlation in two nonlinear regression analysis models [39] . In SARS-CoV-2 infection, antibodies against viral protein, especially the RBD of the spike protein, can neutralize the virus by preventing the virus from binding to the ACE2 receptor on susceptible cells, and thus block viral entry, transmission and infections [52] . In another study using Ad26 as the vaccine platform, Mercado et al. found that virus-specific serum antibody titers, including ELISA titers, pseudovirus neutralization titers and live virus neutralization titer, inversely correlated with peak viral load in bronchoalveolar lavage and nasal swabs [36] . Other antibody features such as FcγR2a-3 or IgM-mediated ADCD responses increased the correlation with protective efficacy, suggesting that in addition to neutralizing antibodies, other binding and functional antibodies may play roles as well [36] . Moreover, neutralization activity in the serum of the mRNA-1273 vaccinated macaques was associated with quick clearance of the input virus in the nasal secretions [38] . Indeed, in the Phase 3 clinical studies of ChAdOx1 [53, 54] , BNT162b2 [55] , and mRNA-1273 [56] , where high titers of neutralizing antibody responses were induced, 70-95% of protective efficacy was achieved, suggesting neutralizing antibody titer as a correlation marker. Further confirmation studies are needed to compare the immune responses in the viral infected vs. uninfected vaccinees to answer the questions whether neutralizing antibody responses alone are sufficient, or whether another biomarker will also predict protection.

In both DNA and adeno26-vectored studies, virus-specific CD4 + T cell and CD8 + T cell responses in blood were detectable; however, neither of them correlated with protection [36, 39] . Another mouse study conducted by Yang et al. showed that a spike subunit vaccine mediated protection against SARS-CoV-2 infection [57] . When adoptive transfer of immune sera vs. splenic T cells from the vaccinated mice was conducted, adoptive transfer of splenic T cells (CD4 + and CD8 + cells) did not protect the human ACE2-transgenic mice from SARS-CoV-2 challenge, whereas transfer of sera from the immunized mice did [57] . However, a recent CD8 depletion study in the macaque model clearly demonstrated that cellular immunity, especially CD8 + T cell responses, played a pivotal role in protecting against viral rechallenge with SARS-CoV-2 in convalescent macaques with waning antibody titers [58] . In this study, the authors also found that adoptive transfer of relatively low titer purified polyclonal IgG from convalescent macaques could protect naïve macaques against SARS-CoV-2 rechallenge. Using logistic regression models, pseudovirus NAb titers of 50, RBD ELISA titers of 100, and S ELISA titers of 400, were determined to be the antibody titer thresholds required for protection.

Even if no direct association with protection has been identified, virus-specific T cell responses, especially Th1 and T follicular helper (TFH) responses, are pivotal for the induction, and more importantly, the functionality, the isotype, and the maintenance of antibody responses. Indeed, data suggested that protective immunity was associated with coordinated virus-specific adaptive immune responses, including neutralizing antibody responses, and CD4 + and CD8 + T cells [59] . Future animal studies with specific depletion of certain arms of immune responses will facilitate the elucidation of the protective mechanisms.

Two recent studies demonstrated that inborn genetic mutations of type I interferon and autoantibodies blocking type I interferon are associated with severe COVID-19 disease, suggesting that type I interferons are key protective factors to prevent severe disease [60, 61] . These findings also provide a potential explanation for the wide variety of clinical disease phenotypes. The fact that these two types of flawed interferon responses underlie 14% of COVID-19 severe cases demonstrates the important contribution of innate immunity in preventing COVID-19 disease [62] . Conversely, overproduction of inflammatory cytokines, which may be coupled with low type I IFN response, has been found to exacerbate SARS-Cov-2 disease. Laing et al. have characterized an innate immune signature that could be used to guide clinical care and treatment. The signature includes interleukin-10 and interleukin-6, which could anticipate subsequent clinical progression [63] . In severe COVID-19 patients, a systemic pro-inflammatory signature, including elevated plasma IL-6 and C-reactive protein (CRP) levels, was associated with clinical worsening and 2-month mortality [64] .

A recent genome-wide association study identified several host genes that showed significant associations with severe COVID-19 disease [65] . Low expression of interferon receptor gene IFNAR2, and high expression of tyrosine kinase 2, were found to be linked to life-threatening disease. High expression of the monocyte/macrophage chemotactic receptor CCR2 is also associated with severe COVID-19. Moreover, gene cluster/gene encoding antiviral restriction enzyme activators (OAS1, OAS2, OAS3), and dipeptidyl peptidase 9 (DPP9) also were linked to disease severity and might be involved in affecting the disease outcome. Brunchez et al. found that major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II transactivator (CIITA) and CD74 can inhibit SARS-CoV-2 viral entry by blocking the cathepsin pathway [66] .

Trained immunity, first suggested by Netea, refers to enhanced responsiveness by myeloid cells and natural killer cells when they reencounter pathogens [67] . In the era of COVID-19, studies found that in countries where Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccination is widely given, a lower infection rate and COVID-19-related mortality rate were observed [68, 69] . Thus, the hypothesis that some pathogens or vaccines such as BCG might confer protection against SARS-CoV-2 was proposed. Though some studies did not find evidence that BCG protects against SARS-CoV-2 infection and COVID19 disease [70, 71] , others did. Escoba et al. conducted an epidemiological study to assess whether BCG vaccination was associated with COVID-19 mortality. After mitigating multiple confounding factors, they observed that every 10% increase in the BCG vaccination prevalence led to a 10.4% reduction in COVID-19 mortality [72] . Another study from a diverse cohort of health care workers found that decreased SARS-CoV-2 IgG-positive rates and reduced COVID-19-related clinical symptoms were associated with BCG vaccination [73] . While a prospective clinical trial on BCG vaccination for prevention and amelioration of COVID-19 severity (NCT04534803) is ongoing, the mechanism by which BCG vaccination affects the severity of COVID-19 has yet to be determined.

Mucosal immunity is important for COVID-19 because the virus infects and is transmitted primarily through the upper and lower respiratory tracts, where the ACE2 receptors for the virus are present. By inducing mucosal antibody and T cell immunity, mucosal vaccines and therapeutic strategies are expected to be able to abort infection locally at an earlier stage at the site of transmission before the virus disseminates systemically.

A recent study using a human ACE2-expressing mouse model showed that an intranasal ChAd-SARS-CoV-2 vaccine induced high levels of neutralizing antibodies and promoted systemic and mucosal IgA and T cell responses, which led to almost full protection against viral transmission at the upper and lower respiratory tract. The fact that the intranasal vaccine was better than the intramuscular counterpart in preventing upper and lower respiratory tract infection demonstrated the importance of mucosal immunity in mediating protection against SARS-CoV-2 infections [74] . Indeed, systemic vaccines such as mRNA and adenovirus vaccines provided only limited protection against input viral clearance and resulted in persistent viral presence in nasal swabs [36, 38, 43] . Prospectively, mucosal vaccines were proposed to be better at clearing the virus in the airways, and thus preventing virus transmission [50, 75, 76] . A mucosal vaccine which is in development in our lab showed more effective clearance of nasal input virus than a systemic vaccine (unpublished data).

Overall, as summarized in Table 2 , the current view of an optimal immune response usually consists of high titers of neutralizing antibodies with durable Th1-biased T cells. Antibody repertoire, especially the functionality of IgG, including Fc receptor binding, Fc effector activity, and complement-fixation activity, played an important role in mediating protection. Favorable innate immunity, trained immunity, and mucosal immunity also contribute substantially to optimal protection against SARS-CoV-2 viral transmission and severe COVID19 disease development. Conversely, it is possible that different vaccine platforms may have different protective mechanisms, and therefore have different immune correlates of protection. As current vaccines may require additional boosts to maintain long-term immunity, a better understanding of which immune responses are most effective at preventing transmission and controlling infection to prevent severe disease may be critical to design the best boosts and adjuvants that can determine the type of response. For example, mucosal boosts may be more effective at reducing virus in the nasal cavity and thus in reducing transmission to others [50] (Sui et al., manuscript submitted). Moreover, adjuvants can skew the isotype of antibodies induced, as well as the cytokine profile of T cells elicited [77] [78] [79] . With the release of more data on phase III clinical trials from different vaccines, more immune correlates of protections will be identified in the future. Table 2 . Immune biomarkers that predict the outcome of SARS-CoV-2 infections.

Humoral immunity

Neutralizing antibodies S-, RBD-binding antibodies Correlated with protective efficacy [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] 36, 39] Antibody repertoire: subtypes, Fc receptor binding, Fc effector activity, complement-fixation activity Contribute to protection [15, 36, 39] Cellular immunity CD4+T helper cells Effective induction and long-term maintenance of antibody responses [13, 22, 23, 26] CD8+T cell responses Higher frequency associated with milder disease; partially participating in viral control [23, 31, 33, 58] Innate immunity Type I IFNs Key protective factors to prevent severe disease [60, 61] Pro-inflammatory cytokines Exacerbate COVID-19 diseases [63, 64] Host genes: OAS1, OAS2, OAS3 Antiviral restriction enzyme activators [65] Low expression of IFNAR2, and high expression of TYK2 Causal link to life-threatening disease [65] High expression of CCR2 Associated with severe Covid-19 [65] (MHC) class II transactivator (CIITA) and CD74 Block cathepsin pathway to inhibit SARS-CoV-2 viral entry [66] Trained immunity BCG vaccination Decreased SARS-CoV-2 IgG-positive rates and reduced COVID-19-related clinical symptoms [72, 73] BCG vaccination No correlations [70, 71] Mucosal immunity Intranasal vaccine Better than the intramuscular counterpart in preventing upper and lower respiratory tract infections [74] RBD: receptor-binding receptor; MHC: major histocompatibility complex; BCG: Bacillus Calmette-Guérin. 

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

Angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 deficiency in whole body or bone marrow-derived cells increases atherosclerosis in low

SARS-CoV-2 Cell Entry Depends on ACE2 and TMPRSS2 and Is Blocked by a Clinically Proven Protease Inhibitor

SARS-CoV-2 Receptor ACE2 Is an Interferon-Stimulated Gene in Human Airway Epithelial Cells and Is Detected in Specific Cell Subsets across Tissues

SARS-CoV-2 receptor ACE2 and TMPRSS2 are primarily expressed in bronchial transient secretory cells

Virological assessment of hospitalized patients with COVID-2019

Respiratory disease in rhesus macaques inoculated with SARS-CoV-2

The SARS-CoV-2 receptor, ACE-2, is expressed on many different cell types: Implications for ACE-inhibitor-and angiotensin II receptor blocker-based cardiovascular therapies

Platelet functions and activities as potential hematologic parameters related to Coronavirus Disease 2019 (Covid-19)

Risk factors associated with disease progression in a cohort of patients infected with the 2019 novel coronavirus. Ann

Pathological findings of COVID-19 associated with acute respiratory distress syndrome

Clinical Characteristics of Coronavirus Disease 2019 in China

Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2-Specific Antibody Responses in Coronavirus Disease

Detection of SARS-CoV-2-Specific Humoral and Cellular Immunity in COVID-19 Convalescent Individuals

IgA-Ab response to spike glycoprotein of SARS-CoV-2 in patients with COVID-19: A longitudinal study

Compromised Humoral Functional Evolution Tracks with SARS-CoV-2 Mortality

Convalescent plasma treatment of severe COVID-19: A propensity score-matched control study

Treatment of Coronavirus Disease 2019 Patients with Convalescent Plasma Reveals a Signal of Significantly Decreased Mortality

Potent neutralizing antibodies against multiple epitopes on SARS-CoV-2 spike

Ultrapotent human antibodies protect against SARS-CoV-2 challenge via multiple mechanisms

REGN-COV2 antibodies prevent and treat SARS-CoV-2 infection in rhesus macaques and hamsters

A Randomized Trial of Convalescent Plasma in Covid-19 Severe Pneumonia

Targets of T Cell Responses to SARS-CoV-2 Coronavirus in Humans with COVID-19 Disease and Unexposed Individuals

Broad and strong memory CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells induced by SARS-CoV-2 in UK convalescent individuals following COVID-19

SARS-CoV-2-specific T cells exhibit phenotypic features of robust helper function, lack of terminal differentiation, and high proliferative potential

What are the roles of antibodies versus a durable, high quality T-cell response in protective immunity against SARS-CoV-2? Vaccine X 2020, 6, 100076

Kinetics of viral load and antibody response in relation to COVID-19 severity

Immunological memory to SARS-CoV-2 assessed for up to 8 months after infection

SARS-CoV-2-specific T cell immunity in cases of COVID-19 and SARS, and uninfected controls

SARS-CoV-2-reactive T cells in healthy donors and patients with COVID-19

Preexisting and de novo humoral immunity to SARS-CoV-2 in humans

Robust T Cell Immunity in Convalescent Individuals with Asymptomatic or Mild COVID-19

Intrafamilial Exposure to SARS-CoV-2 Induces Cellular Immune Response without Seroconversion

Characterization of pre-existing and induced SARS-CoV-2-specific CD8(+) T cells

Clinical and immunological assessment of asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infections

Development of an inactivated vaccine candidate for SARS-CoV-2

Single-shot Ad26 vaccine protects against SARS-CoV-2 in rhesus macaques

Safety and immunogenicity of the ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 vaccine against SARS-CoV-2: A preliminary report of a phase 1/2, single-blind, randomised controlled trial

Evaluation of the mRNA-1273 Vaccine against SARS-CoV-2 in Nonhuman Primates

DNA vaccine protection against SARS-CoV-2 in rhesus macaques

Phase I/II study of COVID-19 RNA vaccine BNT162b1 in adults

Phase 1-2 Trial of a SARS-CoV-2 Recombinant Spike Protein Nanoparticle Vaccine

Safety, tolerability, and immunogenicity of a recombinant adenovirus type-5 vectored COVID-19 vaccine: A dose-escalation, open-label, non-randomised, first-in-human trial

ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 vaccine prevents SARS-CoV-2 pneumonia in rhesus macaques

COVID-19 vaccine BNT162b1 elicits human antibody and TH1 T cell responses

Durability of Responses after SARS-CoV-2 mRNA-1273 Vaccination

An mRNA Vaccine against SARS-CoV-2-Preliminary Report

Safety and Immunogenicity of SARS-CoV-2 mRNA-1273 Vaccine in Older Adults

COVID-19 vaccine development pipeline gears up

Promise and challenges in the development of COVID-19 vaccines. Hum. Vaccines Immunother

SARS-CoV-2 vaccines in development

Development of an Inactivated Vaccine Candidate, BBIBP-CorV, with Potent Protection against SARS-CoV-2

Characterization of the receptor-binding domain (RBD) of 2019 novel coronavirus: Implication for development of RBD protein as a viral attachment inhibitor and vaccine

Immune responses in COVID-19 and potential vaccines: Lessons learned from SARS and MERS epidemic. Asian Pac

Safety and efficacy of the ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 vaccine (AZD1222) against SARS-CoV-2: An interim analysis of four randomised controlled trials in Brazil, South Africa, and the UK

Safety and Efficacy of the BNT162b2 mRNA Covid-19 Vaccine

Efficacy and Safety of the mRNA-1273 SARS-CoV-2 Vaccine

A vaccine targeting the RBD of the S protein of SARS-CoV-2 induces protective immunity

Correlates of protection against SARS-CoV-2 in rhesus macaques

Antigen-Specific Adaptive Immunity to SARS-CoV-2 in Acute COVID-19 and Associations with Age and Disease Severity

Inborn errors of type I IFN immunity in patients with life-threatening COVID-19

Autoantibodies against type I IFNs in patients with life-threatening COVID-19

Flawed interferon response spurs severe illness

A dynamic COVID-19 immune signature includes associations with poor prognosis

Elevated plasma IL-6 and CRP levels are associated with adverse clinical outcomes and death in critically ill SARS-CoV-2 patients: Inflammatory response of SARS-CoV-2 patients

Genetic mechanisms of critical illness in Covid-19

MHC class II transactivator CIITA induces cell resistance to Ebola virus and SARS-like coronaviruses

Trained immunity: A program of innate immune memory in health and disease

BCG-induced trained immunity: Can it offer protection against COVID-19?

Could BCG Vaccination Induce Protective Trained Immunity for SARS-CoV-2? Front

Lack of evidence for BCG vaccine protection from severe COVID-19

Protection against SARS-CoV-2 by BCG vaccination is not supported by epidemiological analyses

Barillas-Mury, C. BCG vaccine protection from severe coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19)

BCG vaccination history associates with decreased SARS-CoV-2 seroprevalence across a diverse cohort of healthcare workers

A Single-Dose Intranasal ChAd Vaccine Protects Upper and Lower Respiratory Tracts against SARS-CoV-2

Development of SARS-CoV-2 vaccines: Should we focus on mucosal immunity? Expert Opin

Prospects for mucosal vaccine: Shutting the door on SARS-CoV-2. Hum. Vaccines Immunother

Cytokine-in-adjuvant steering of the immune response phenotype to HIV-1 vaccine constructs: Granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor and TNF-alpha synergize with IL-12 to enhance induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes

IL-1 enhances expansion, effector function, tissue localization, and memory response of antigen-specific CD8 T cells

Role of CD4 T cell helper subsets in immune response and deviation of CD8 T cells in mice