key: cord-1039232-bnlhhha6 authors: Murase, Jenny E.; Murrell, Dedee F. title: Embracing diversity in dermatology: Creation of a culture of inclusion in dermatologic publishing date: 2021-08-05 journal: Int J Womens Dermatol DOI: 10.1016/j.ijwd.2021.08.001 sha: ac472284c36263f8c107592b29dad12af000e7ee doc_id: 1039232 cord_uid: bnlhhha6 nan Diversity in publishing is, in and of itself, a diverse concept. To be truly inclusive and embrace diversity in our dermatologic literature, it is critical that the chief editors and the editorial board of the journal examine how they are actively creating a culture of inclusion within and for their publication. Indeed, the concept of diversity includes issues regarding gender, race, and transgender/ gender minority/sexual minority issues and extends beyond the medical content of what is published within the journal. With regard to the International Journal of Women's Dermatology (IJWD), we have taken an all-encompassing look at how to champion diversity and inclusion in our publication. Gender and racial diversity are not only limited to issues specific to women's health or care of patients with skin of color, but also include diversity in authorship as well as our editorial team, and the professional development of our female and male dermatology colleagues of different transgender/gender minority/sexual minority backgrounds. We have embraced diversity in our authorship, diversity in our colleagues, diversity in the literature, and diversity in our patients and the issues that they face regarding their dermatologic health, creating a model that can be emulated in journals throughout different fields of medicine. The editorial board of the IJWD consists of two co-editors in chief, one deputy editor, and 32 associate editors. In terms of female representation on our editorial board, we have a higher percentage of female associate editors compared with the editorial boards of all other dermatology journals. In their article, "Representation of Women as Editors in Dermatology Journals: A Comprehensive Review," Lobl et al. (2019) demonstrated that women make up 18% of editors in chief and 22% of editorial board members. This built on previously published work in our journal regarding the low percentage of female editors-in-chief of dermatology journals . This is in stark contrast to the editorial board of the IJWD, in which both of our editors-in-chief are female, 83% of our editorial board is female (29 of 35 members), and 86% of our advisory board is female (12 of 14 members). In terms of international presence, we have 11 editors from countries outside of the United States (31% of the editorial board), including Argentina, Australia, Denmark, France, Germany, Greece, India, Iran, and Switzerland. On our advisory board, 4 of 14 members are from countries outside of the United States (29% of the advisory board), including Brazil, Germany, Israel, and the Philippines. In terms of ethnicity, we have 24 editors of Caucasian descent (67% of the editorial board), 2 editors of Black descent (6%), 2 editors of Middle Eastern descent (6%), 2 editors of Latin American descent (6%), and 5 editors of East Asian descent (14%). Finally, our advisory board also has physicians specializing in internal medicine, obstetrics and gynecology, psychiatry, and ophthalmology, providing input from within the house of medicine and guide the development of the journal so that our publications are germane to physicians within various fields of medicine who care for patients in conjunction with our dermatology colleagues. As editors, we appreciate the importance of including first names in medical journals and congress publishing as a tool for assessing gender diversity in the medical literature. For many years, medicine was the prerogative of men, and physicians used titles and surnames to address each other more formally. Articles were published using surnames and initials, which makes it difficult to ascertain academic output of women. It becomes almost impossible to assess whether journals and congresses are providing sufficient opportunities for women without the use of full names. Another reason to include full names is the number of similar names in countries where there are limited surnames, such as China or Korea. Since its inception in 2015, the IJWD has been including the first names of authors to highlight the contribution of women to the articles we publish. Table 1 outlines the number of articles published per issue and the percentage of articles published with at least one female author. The impact of the IJWD on female professional colleague development is apparent in that we have published a total of 544 peer-reviewed articles to date, and an impressive 96% (522 articles) have at least one female author. A key initiative of both the Women's Dermatologic Society (WDS), as well as the IJWD, is to support professional female dermatologists through mentorship, leadership opportunities, and guidance regarding personal and professional development. In January 2020, Dr. Michi Shinohara, a special-issue editor for the IJWD, 1 14 14 100 1 2 12 12 100 1 3 10 10 100 1 4 11 10 91 2016 2 1 10 10 100 2 2 10 10 100 2 3 9 6 67 2 4 10 9 90 2017 3 1 29 27 93 3 2 10 10 100 3 3 16 14 88 3 4 12 12 developed a gender gap special issue modeled after her course for the American Academy of Dermatology . A total of 61 articles from this special issue and over the lifetime of the journal (listed in Table 2 ) provide examples of publications elicited by the IJWD editors to promote female colleagues' personal and professional development. To further this initiative, both founding co-editors in chief and current co-editors in chief, Drs. Jane Grant-Kels, Dedee Murrell, and Jenny Murase, assessed the impact of gender on mentee-mentor success through the WDS Mentorship Survey, which is now published in this September 2021 issue . The WDS and the IJWD value diversity and inclusion in our field. To this end, we have published an array of articles specific to fostering the personal and professional development of our colleagues with skin of color within dermatology. In this September 2021 issue of the IJWD, Desai et al. (2021) discuss what it means to create a culture of equity and inclusion in dermatologic societies, mirroring our description of how to create a culture of inclusion within dermatologic publishing. The American Academy of Dermatology, WDS, American Society for Dermatologic Surgery, Association for Professors in Dermatology, American Society of Dermatopathology, American Contact Dermatitis Society, and Skin of Color Society have all taken initiatives to address the inequities in our field. It is also encouraging to see how much the twin pandemic of racism has had a positive impact on diversifying our field the past two years Feaster and McMichael, 2021 ; Lester and Taylor, 2021 ; Sekyere et al., 2021 ) . Table 3 outlines 14 articles we elicited in support of the personal and professional development of our colleagues with skin of color within dermatology. As co-editors in chief, we have embarked on initiatives to both increase the skin-of-color content of our publication and create a baseline metric for how dermatology journal skin-of-color content can be tracked over time. These two strategic initiatives were performed with the intention of promoting a culture of inclusion within our publication. The March 2021 issue of the IJWD featured 24 invited publications written on topics ranging from diversity within dermatology, allyship and advocacy, and diseases directly related to pigmentation and high hair curl type prevalent in skinof-color populations . In this September 2021 issue, we feature a study in which we developed a two-tier criterion to assess skin-of-color content for 52 dermatologic publications and ranked each of the dermatologic publications by their skin-of-color content, analyzing the most common categorizations and differences based on Scopus score, international versus noninternational, and scientific versus clinical publications ( Wilson et al., 2021a ; 2021b ) . These initiatives sent a clear message to our authorship, our readership, and our editorial board that we are interested in publishing articles on skin of color and diversity issues (52 articles are provided as examples in Table 4 ), which further helps to build a culture of inclusion, both within the editorial board and for the public facing aspects of our journal. The focus of the IJWD is on the dermatologic health of women and their families. This range of topics includes but is not limited to the role of hormones in the development of acne and alopecia; the skin manifestation of metabolic syndrome and polycystic ovarian syndrome; skin cancer risk specific to women; clinical considerations when managing chronic dermatologic conditions (e.g., atopic dermatitis, psoriasis, and cutaneous lupus in women); Table 2 Articles published in support of the personal and professional development of our female colleagues within dermatology the safety profile of dermatologic medical and cosmetic therapy in pregnant and breastfeeding women; the impact of esthetic procedures on body image and body dysmorphic disorders; chemotherapeutic concerns in dermatologic skin care in women with cancer; skin disease specific to women who are aging in menopause, pregnant, or breastfeeding; skin disease of the vulva and vaginal area; vaginal rejuvenation; and ethical issues when caring for dermatologic issues of women and their families. But importantly it also includes issues for our colleagues and patients with issues regarding gender minority and transgender dermatology, as well as gender minority and sexual orientation bias in the workplace. We have published articles related to transgender and gender minority patients ( Table 5 ) , and this area in particular is one that we wish to focus our attention on moving forward and to purposefully recruit articles to further our strategic initiative as we strive to develop a culture of inclusion in dermatologic publishing. Ultimately, we believe editors, editorial boards, and publishers should be encouraged to critically examine diversity in their publications, including an annual assessment with metrics indicating how effectively a culture of inclusion has been fostered. Currently, journal success is evaluated through bibliometric milestones, such as Scopus scores, number of submissions and citations, and impact factors, but the culture of inclusion that the journal has built should also be factored into an evaluation of a journal's impact on its subspecialty and the importance of that journal in the field of medicine and within society. We encourage evaluation metrics that 1) Examine editorial board and advisory board make up, including race, gender, ethnic background, and country of origin, the latter particularly pertaining to international journals. 2) Examine how the publication supports professionals from different backgrounds. 3) Examine the gender, race, and ethnic background of its authorship. 4) Examine topics published to foster knowledge of gender differences, skin of color content, sexual minority, gender minority and transgender issues, when appropriate. It is ultimately the development of a culture of inclusion, a strategic initiative that is purposefully and thoughtfully executed by editors and editorial board members, that brings change to our society. Editors have a great responsibility in deciding what information is disseminated to medical professionals and the public in Table 3 Articles published in support of the personal and professional development of our skin of color colleagues within dermatology a peer-reviewed platform, where potentially more weight is placed on the validity of the findings published due to the rigorous review process for the published articles. It is easy to state that the inequity in our literature is not being addressed by the stream of articles submitted to the journal, but what if, as editors, we take the initiative to invite publications that directly address this inequity in our literature? Or to encourage research that would address these inequities? Or to welcome voices that would otherwise be unheard? The best counter action to discrimination against populations that have been marginalized in the past is to be intentional in preventing that discrimination from continuing. The onus is on us as journal editors to create a welcoming and inclusive environment that embraces our differences and is enriched by the knowledge and insight that results when these differences are identified, classified, analyzed, and studied. Diversity is important, but the development of a culture of inclusion on our editorial boards, in our authorship, and within our publication is the key to unlocking new material that benefits both the majority and the minority, the male and the female, the mainstream and the marginalized. Encouraging the voices of the marginalized is the essence of what allows for the creation of this culture. Therefore, fostering a culture of inclusion is vital to gaining access to the benefits of diversity. Let the marginalized of the past be heard for all of us to reap the benefits of inclusion. Dr Dedee Murrell identifies as female. She has served as founding co-editor in chief of the IJWD since 2014 and is the author of some of the cited articles. Dr Jenny Murase identifies as female. She has served as co-editor in chief of IJWD since early 2018 and is the author of some of the cited articles. None. Gender Differences in Dermatologist Practice Locations in the U.S.: A Cross-Sectional Analysis of Current Gender Gaps The women behind the names: Dermatology eponyms named after women The Women's Dermatology Society: Physicians, Leaders, Mentors A survey study of dermatologists' experiences of sexual harassment Leading ladies: Why leadership programs are so valuable to female physicians Mentoring and the U.K. Medical Women's Federation The role of women as past and present advocates for vaccinations: Relevance in the COVID-19 setting Professor Rona MacKie, Scottish dermatologist and melanoma authority A commentary on gender bias in dermatology and its perceived impact on career development among women dermatologists Reply to: Gender and rank salary trends among academic dermatologists Wilma Fowler Bergfeld: A woman of substance, role model, and founder of the Women's Dermatologic Society Making the most of your mentorship: Viewpoints from a mentor and mentee Personal productivity and the two-career household: The AIR method Maternity Leave for Residents and Young Attendings History of Women in Dermatology series Sexism in medicine The most important decision of your life is… Can men mentor women in the #MeToo era? Does gender impact publication opportunities? Lean in or out: It is a tough balancing act, or my 10 best pieces of advice for women physicians Too many female doctors are part-time or stop working!? Thoughts on dermatology residents who are new parents Please take your feet off my neck Commentary on: Sexual misconduct in academic medicine Maternity and medical leave during residency: Time to standardize? Supporting successful women in dermatology A study of the number of female editors-in-chief of dermatology journals Grant-Kels The Impact of Gender on Mentee-Mentor Success: Results from the Women's Dermatologic Society Mentorship Survey Representation of women as editors in dermatology journals: A comprehensive review From aggressive to assertive Mentorship: A key mission of the Women's Dermatologic Society Academic dermatology leadership in the United States -Addressing the gender gap Sexual harassment from patient to provider The female pioneers in Mohs micrographic surgery Work-life balance among female dermatologists The history of dermatology at the Woman's Medical College of Pennsylvania Striving for balance: A review of female dermatologists' perspective on managing a dual-career household Reply to commentary to: Gender and rank salary trends among academic dermatologists Career satisfaction of leaders in academic dermatology: Results from a national survey Burnout of the female dermatologist: How traditional burnout reduction strategies have failed women Gender Gaps in National Institutes of Health Dermatology Grant Recipients The gender gap in academic dermatology and dermatology leadership: Supporting successful women dermatologists Understanding individual and gender differences in conflict resolution: A critical leadership skill What will keep women practicing dermatology? The proportion of male and female editors in women's health journals: A critical analysis and review of the sex gap A world-renowned dermatologist and researcher, a great mentor, an educator, former president of the Society for Investigative Dermatology, editor-in-chief of The Journal of Investigative Dermatology, and a devoted friend Successful mentoring of women A ten-year comparison of women authorship in U.S. dermatology literature Prioritizing equity and inclusion in global health dermatology Responding to the moment: Dermatology, health inequity, and a call for introspection-driven activism Embracing Diversity in Dermatology: Creation of a Culture of Equity and Inclusion in Dermatology Allyship in dermatology Taking a "step" toward diversity in dermatology: De-emphasizing USMLE Step 1 scores in residency applications Two pandemics: Opportunities for diversity, equity and inclusion in dermatology Heralding change within dermatology: Response of the International Journal of Women's Dermatology (IJWD) to the twin pandemic of racism Supporting underrepresented minority women in academic dermatology Assessing the impact of an intervention to increase minority representation in dermatology If you want to be it, it helps to see it: Examining the need for diversity in dermatology Skin of color lacks representation in medical student resources: A cross-sectional study Turning the Tide: How the Women's Dermatologic Society Leads in Diversifying Dermatology Gender and race trends in academic rank of dermatologists at top U.S. institutions: A cross-sectional study Community engagement matters: A call for greater advocacy in dermatology Association of ethnicity, Fitzpatrick skin type, and hirsutism: A retrospective cross-sectional study of women with polycystic ovarian syndrome Camouflaging techniques for patients with central centrifugal cicatricial alopecia Impact of leishmaniasis in women: a practical review with an update on my ISD-supported initiative to combat leishmaniasis in Yemen (ELYP) Mohammad Shahidi-Dadras. Considerable variation among Iranian dermatologists in the knowledge and attitudes regarding the use of biologic agents to manage psoriasis Knowledge, attitude, and practices toward sun exposure and use of sun protection among non-medical, female, university students in Saudi Arabia: A cross-sectional study Skin-lightening patterns among female students: A cross-sectional study in Saudi Arabia Hospital-based prospective study of the clinical and epidemiologic profile of adult female acne in Lagos, Nigeria The importance of dermoscopy in subclinical lichen planus in skin of color Association of type 2 diabetes with central-scalp hair loss in a large cohort study of African American women Skin cancer in women of color: Epidemiology, pathogenesis and clinical manifestations Prevalence of pigmentary disorders: A cross-sectional study in public hospitals in Durban, South Africa A red-orange rash in a patient with skin of color Psychosocial determinants of the practice of skin bleaching in young adult female undergraduates in Anambra State Motivations and characteristics of patients seeking minimally invasive cosmetic procedures in 2 Iranian dermatology centers Dermoscopic features of neoplasms in skin of color: A review Family impact of pemphigus disease in an Iranian population using the Family Dermatology Life Quality Index Updates in the understanding and treatments of skin and hair disorders in women of color Vitiligo: Patient stories, self-esteem, and the psychological burden of disease New oral and topical approaches for the treatment of melasma Utility of international store-and-forward teledermatopathology among a cohort of mostly female patients at a tertiary referral center in Afghanistan Dermatologic conditions in patients of color who are pregnant Differences in dermatology training abroad: A comparative analysis of dermatology training in the United States and in India The effect of melasma on self-esteem: A pilot study The impact of acne treatment on quality of life and self-esteem: a prospective cohort study from Lebanon Longitudinal melanonychia in an Iranian population: a study of 96 patients Successful treatment of basal cell carcinoma on face and scalp by photodynamic therapy in Indian patients with dermoscopic diagnoses and serial follow-up Representation of Sex, Race and Ethnicity in Pivotal Clinical Trials for Dermatologic Drugs Patient and practitioner satisfaction with tele-dermatology including Australia's indigenous population: A systematic review of the literature Ketoconazole shampoo-induced hair discoloration Bone mineral density is lower in male than female patients with plaque-type psoriasis in Iran Updates in the understanding and treatments of skin & hair disorders in women of color Dermatoses and traditions: Fissured plantar keratoderma, a discriminating factor in bantu society in the Congo Brazzaville Analysis of Skin Color in the American Academy of Dermatology Basic Dermatology Curriculum The art of prevention: It's too tight-Loosen up and let your hair down Current and emerging treatment strategies for hair loss in women of color #BlackGirlMagic: Impact of the social media movement on Black women's self esteem Assessing the impact of an intervention to increase minority representation in dermatology Pityriasis rubra pilaris in skin of color The dark side of skin lightening: An international collaboration and review of a public health issue affecting dermatology Clinical recognition and management of alopecia in women of color A survey evaluating knowledge, perception and use of skin lightening products among South African students A dark lesion on an Indian Woman's vulva Trends in sessions in diversity at the American Academy of Dermatology Annual Meetings Anil Kumar Das. White ambition leading to topical corticosteroid misuse -A beauty myth in skin of color Sunscreen recommendations for patients with skin of color in the popular press and in the dermatology clinic Autoimmune Bullous Disease Quality of Life (ABQoL) questionnaire: Validation of the translated Persian version in pemphigus vulgaris A pilot study examining skin cancer education in an underserved population at a free skin cancer screening Bridging racial differences in the clinical encounter: How implicit bias and stereotype threat contribute to health care disparities in the dermatology clinic Assessment of skin of color and diversity and inclusion content of dermatologic published literature: An analysis and call to action Direct-to-consumer dermatology-related advertising differs in magazines targeted to women of color: A cross-sectional analysis of top-circulating consumer magazines Cutaneous myiasis in an elderly woman in Somaliland Skin lightening practices, beliefs, and self-reported adverse effects among female health science students in Borama, Somaliland: A cross-sectional survey Dermatologic care of the transgender patient Unforeseen ethical challenges for isotretinoin treatment in transgender patients Medical dermatologic conditions in transgender women Representation of women as editors in dermatology journals: A comprehensive review A study of the number of female editors-in-chief of dermatology journals The gender gap in academic dermatology and dermatology leadership: Supporting successful women dermatologists The impact of gender on mentee-mentor success: Results from the Women's Dermatologic Society mentorship survey Embracing diversity in dermatology: Creation of a culture of equity and inclusion in dermatology Responding to the moment: Dermatology, health inequity, and a call for introspection-driven activism Allyship in dermatology Two pandemics: Opportunities for diversity, equity and inclusion in dermatology Turning the tide: How the Women's Dermatologic Society leads in diversifying dermatology Heralding change within dermatology: Response of the International Journal of Women's Dermatology ( IJWD ) to the twin pandemic of racism Purposeful inclusion of skin of color in published literature for improved dermatology education: A call to action Assessment of skin of color and diversity and inclusion content of dermatologic published literature: An analysis and call to action