key: cord-1032167-bv8jjwtt
authors: Crea, Antonio; Grimod, Gianluca; Scalia, Gianluca; Verlotta, Mariarosaria; Mazzeo, Lucio; Rossi, Giorgio; Mattavelli, Davide; Rampinelli, Vittorio; Luzzi, Sabino; Spena, Giannantonio
title: Fronto-orbito-ethmoidal intradiploic meningiomas: A case study with systematic review
date: 2021-09-30
journal: Surg Neurol Int
DOI: 10.25259/sni_386_2021
sha: 3403029e175f172e53eba513ec21aef70bee68f9
doc_id: 1032167
cord_uid: bv8jjwtt

BACKGROUND: Primary intradiploic meningiomas, extra-axial tumors arising primarily in the skull, are rare. The authors reported a complex case of intradiploic intraosseous metaplastic meningioma of the left medial wall and orbital roof with the left frontal sinus invasion and left ethmoidal body bone substitution. The authors also conducted a systematic review concerning diagnosis and management of patients affected by purely calvarial intradiploic meningiomas along with a focus on fronto-orbito-ethmoidal ones. METHODS: A literature search was conducted using PubMed and Scopus databases according to preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analysis statement and with the following Mesh terms: Intradiploic, intraosseous, calvarial, and meningioma. Eligibility criteria were limited by the nature of existing literature on intradiploic meningiomas, consisting of only case series, and case reports. RESULTS: A total of 128 published studies were identified through our search. 41 studies were included in this systematic review, 59 patients with a female/male ratio of 1.2/1. The mean age of the patients is of 47.69 years (range 3–84 years). Only seven out of 59 patients (11.9%) presented a complex intradiploic meningioma located in fronto-orbito-ethmoidal region like our case. In almost all patients, a gross-total resection was performed (96.6%) and only in two patients (3.4%) a subtotal resection was achieved. CONCLUSION: The authors shared this successfully treated case to add to the overall clinical experience in the management of this rare subtype tumor, with the hope that more studies are conducted to further address the mechanism of intradiploic meningiomas development.

Meningiomas are one of the most common benign brain/intracranial tumors with an incidence rate of 15-20%. [12] Parasagittal and convexity location are the most frequent accounting all together for almost 45% of the cases. e most common extradural localizations are the paranasal sinuses, nasal cavity, skin, neck, glands, and intraosseous space. [3] Primary intraosseous lesions are rare accounting for <1% of intracranial meningiomas. [39] Intradiploic meningioma is an extremely rare type of extradural meningioma and is generally localized in the frontoparietal and orbital regions. Due to their low incidence and lack of adequate preoperative diagnostic imaging, intradiploic meningiomas are generally mistaken for primary calvarial bone tumors, en plaque meningiomas, and fibrous dysplasia. It is postulated that they could arise from arachnoid cell remnants captured at inappropriate sites during embryonic development or implantation of these cells by some mechanical insult such as trauma or dural tear. [23] eir origin can also be attributed to cellular dedifferentiation within the diploic space or cranial nerve sheath cells during their course through diploe. [37] ese tumors are observed mostly within the first two decades of life and histologically are usually of psammomatous type. From a surgical perspective, when located onto the convexity surgical excision is feasible. Often, the complex reconstruction of the anterior skull base can represent a limit in the case of gross total resection (GTR) of large meningiomas involving also ethmoid and sphenoid bones.

e authors collected clinical, radiological, intraoperative, postoperative, and histological features of a patient harboring a rare case of left intradiploic fronto-orbito-ethmoidal meningioma. We also performed a systematic review in accordance with preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analysis guidelines [ Figure 1 ]. A literature search was conducted using PubMed and Scopus databases from 1955 (first reported paper) to 2021. References of the included studies were searched for additional relevant studies. is search was limited to studies in English language. MeSH terms utilized were as follows: (intradiploic OR intraosseous OR calvarial) AND meningioma. Eligibility criteria were limited by the nature of existing literature on intradiploic meningiomas, consisting of only case series and case reports. Data items collected included the following: authors and year of the study, number of patients, sex, signs and/or symptoms, intradiploic meningioma location, treatment modality, histological examination, and clinical outcome. In brief, 128 articles were found after database searching and removal of duplicates. After full-text review, 87 articles were excluded, leaving 41 included studies.

A 47-year-old female patient was admitted to our department, following the progressive onset of left eye proptosis lasting for 4 years associated with occasional mild to moderate headache. She did not complain visual acuity decrease nor diplopia in any gaze direction. At the time of her first medical consultation (at another Institution), she was advised to perform an endoscopic trans-nasal biopsy; this procedure was then performed but the histology was not helpful (no more information about this surgical procedure is available). After this, she decided to have a second opinion with the aim of definitively cure her illness.

On physical examination, there was axial proptosis on the left side, diplopia, with a restriction of the extraocular movements in the superior and medial side. e patient also presented hyposmia. She suffered from an amblyopia dating back to the adolescence in the contralateral eye (visual acuity: 7/10); in the left eye acuity was 8/10. No visual fields defect was detected, and the fundus oculi examination was normal. Rest of the neurological examination was normal. Routine hematological and biochemical tests were normal.

A brain computerized tomography (CT) scan with thin cuts of the orbit and 3D-reconstruction showed a roughly ovoidal lesion centered at the left medial wall and roof of the orbit and invading the left frontal sinus and left ethmoidal body bone. e lesion's maximal diameter was about 5 cm, and it was surrounded by a heterogeneous bone shell filled internally by hypodense tissue with multiple sepimentations [ Figure 2 ]. is lesion compressed and elevated the frontal lobe while, inferolaterally, the ocular bulb was dislocation with evident proptosis. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) showed that the mass was T1-weighted iso-intense and T2-weighted heterogeneously hyperintense with an intense postgadolinium enhancement. Medial and superior rectus and superior oblique muscles were compressed and dislocated [ Figure 3 ]. A total body CT scan was negative for other neoplastic localization.

Neuronavigation was installed. A sterile surgical field was prepared at the level of the fascia lata to harvest a graft. A bicoronal skin incision with subcutaneous twolayer dissection (to save a vascularized pericranial flap) was performed. A bilateral fronto-basal transfrontal sinus craniotomy was done to expose the tumor. Tumor was found to be completely extra-axial destroying the orbital roof and the orbital medial wall and eroding the ethmoid. Bilateral frontal sinus was invaded by the lesion (especially in the left side). e dura of the left anterior skull base was massively elevated together with the frontal lobe and totally substituted by a thin layer of fibrous tissue. e lesion presented a hard consistence due to an external hyperostotic bone shell. At the inside there was a cavity filled with numerous sepimentations and blood clots. e periorbita was intact during the microsurgical dissection with a good cleavage plan. e tumor was removed through a piecemeal technique. Peripheral hyperostotic bone was drilled away to obtain a good control of the bleeding and an efficient removal. Frontal skull base dura was removed and reconstructed with watertight technique with a synthetic patch. Left olfactory nerve was encased in the mass and was not possible to be spared. e tumor was completely removed obtaining a Simpson I resection. Frontal and ethmoidal sinus was closed by free temporal muscle fragments, gel foam, and fibrin glue. en, orbital roof, medial orbital wall, and ethmoid were reconstructed using the split internal cortical bone of the frontal flaps, to avoid any postoperative pulsatile proptosis. is reconstruction was then covered with fascia lata and fibrin glue. Finally, the whole anterior skull-base until the planum sphenoidale was covered and sealed up with a vascularized pericranial layer. e bony defects of the frontal craniotomy were corrected using a methylmethacrylate paste. A lumbar drain was placed to prevent any cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak (for a total of 8 days).

e histological analysis reported a metaplastic meningioma (the World Health Organization [WHO] Grade I) with extensive ossification with a bone angioectasia infiltration (immunostaining showed Epithelial Membrane Antigen +, Vimentine +, S100-, CKpool -, CD4-, Progesterone -) [ Figure 4 ].

At the recovery from the general anesthesia, the patient was drowsy and strongly apathetic. CT scan demonstrated a contusion and reactive edema at the basal frontal lobe. Intensive care stay was prolonged, and patient gradually recovered to a satisfying state of consciousness after eight days. Postoperative CT scan showed a total removal of the lesion, with an optimal reconstruction of the medial wall and the roof of the left orbit, in the absence of complications [ Figure 5 ]. At the discharge, patient was neurologically intact and after 3 months got back to her job. Cosmetic outcome was particularly good, and the proptosis showed an evident reduction.

About 3 months from the previous CT scan control, the patient presented to the local emergency room for acute recurrence of rhinoliquorrhea. According to the COVID-19 re-organization model adopted by the Lombardy region, the patient was transferred to the neurosurgical reference hub in the area. When she arrived at the Neurosurgical department of the "Spedali Civili" Hospital in Brescia, the patient underwent a brain CT and MRI that showed the presence of pneumocephalus with a small defect in the posterior ethmoidal plane close to the spheno-ethmoidal suture with pneumocephalus [ Figure 6 ]. After examining the radiological images, we decided to perform a combined transcranial and transsphenoidal approach. Such approach, in our experience, yields to a higher successful rate. Under balanced general anesthesia, the previous bicoronal surgical incision was opened. After removing the bone flaps, no evident extradural CSF collection was found. e bone flaps and all the reconstruction materials (i.e., methyl methacrylate and orbital roof titanium mash) were removed and after meticulous exploration a defect at the margin of the duroplasty with the dura mater was found. e synthetic patch was completely removed, and the underlying subdural space was filled with a graft of abdominal fat tissue (paraumbilical incision). e dura was reconstructed with a free pericranium (taken from the calvarium posterior to the craniotomy) with a watertight technique and reinforced with fibrin glue. e reconstruction of the anterior skull base appeared intact except in its posterior ethmoidal portion. A 5 mm gap/defect was found at the level of the left ethmosphenoidal suture. e adjacent pericranium was detached to adequately expose the defect and the surrounding bone. e posterior ethmoidal space, after thorough cleaning, was filled with free fatty tissue (till the intact periorbital plane) laterally and medially to the mucosal graft and sealed with one layer of free pericranium. e margins of pericranial layer (positioned in the previous intervention) dehiscent have been incised and removed. e margins were slightly detached from the bone plane for about 3 mm; a first patch of free pericranium was placed, in contact with the free bone margin and to cover the fat layer. e pedicled pericranium was then repositioned to cover the whole floor of the left anterior cranial fossa and a second patch of free pericranium was applied to it by superimposing it on the vital pericranium (with multilayer wafer technique). e whole construct was then sealed with fibrin glue. e epidural space was filled with free fatty abdominal tissue. rough an endoscopic transnasal approach the free abdominal flap fat in the sphenoethmoidal suture is easily identified. e nasal mucosa bordering the defect was removed and vital bone tissue exposed. A pedicled naso-septal flap, previously harvested, was then used to further seal and support the reconstruction. Silicone coated pads were positioned to make the flap adhere better to hold the construct (the endonasal swabs will then be removed 4 days after surgery). e frontal bone operculum was positioned and fixed with plates and screw (Synthes Matrix). Postoperative course was uneventful. A control head CT scan showed good surgical results and resolution of the pneumocephalus. An endoscopic exploration showed good vitality and adhesion of the mucosal flap. After prophylactic therapy (vancomycin + cephalosporin for 10 days), the patient was discharged at home neurologically intact. e 3-month postoperative MRI showed no residual or recurrent disease [ Figure 7 ].

A total of 128 published studies were identified through our detailed searches from 1955 to 2021. After a detailed examination of the titles, abstracts, and contents of these studies, 87 were rejected from our systematic review because they were not in English language, not purely intradiploic calvarial meningiomas, or did not include accurate data. Our case was not included in this systematic review. A summary of patients' characteristics in selected papers are reported in [ Table 1 ]. A total of 41 studies were selected, including 59 patients, 32 females (54.2%), 26 males (44%), and one patient of unknown sex, with a female/male ratio of 1.2/1. 7%) , while in ten out of 59 patients (16.9%) the subtype was not specified. A total of 48 out of 59 patients presented a good recovery after surgery (81.3%), one patient showed only persistent exophthalmos, one patient developed a wound infection with CSF leak, one patient underwent reoperation due to meningioma recurrence, and another one patient presented a persisting gait disturbance, with an overall postoperative complication rate of 1.7%.

A localization of meningiomatous tissue at the level of the orbita, it is most often due to secondary invasion of the orbit or of the orbital walls by a tumor starting from the meninges enveloping the brain, especially at the level of the anterior cranial fossa or of the sphenoid lesser wing. [31] Winkler in 1904 first described a meningioma originating from extradural location and extradural meningioma arising in the skull is usually referred as calvarial, intraosseous, or intradiploic location. Intraosseous meningioma denotes a subset of extradural meningioma arising in bone and accounts for about two-third of extradural meningioma. According to the literature, frontoparietal and orbital regions are the most common intraosseous meningioma locations. [37] Lang et al. [21] classified primary extradural meningioma (PEM) into three types: Type 1 (purely extracalvarial), Type 2 (purely calvarial), and Type 3 (calvarial with extracalvarial extension). Types 2 and 3 can be subclassified as B (convexity) and C (skull base). According to the above-mentioned classification, our case can be classified as Type 2 C. Cirak et al. [7] reported that psammomatous variety is the most common histological subtype, but the results of our systematic review showed that the most frequent histology is the meningothelial subtype. At our knowledge, the current is the first case of intradiploic metaplastic meningioma. ere are different theories as to the origin of intradiploic meningiomas. On the one 

Signs and/or symptoms hand, it is thought that they arise from arachnoid cell rests inappropriately laid down during embryonal life or deposited in unusual sites by trauma and dural tears. On the the other hand, they may arise from the sheath cell of cranial nerves as they course through the diploic space or their origin may be due to cellular dedifferentiation within the diploe; a similar mechanism is proposed for the equally uncommon cutaneous meningioma. [7] e common age of presentation was in the early second decade of life and although intraosseous meningiomas commonly involve the calvarial bone, they rarely occur in the orbital roof and sphenoid bone. [1, 10] Intradiploic meningiomas of the orbital roof are more frequent in males and in young people. [29] ese tumors may be considered as a subgroup of intraosseous meningiomas and it does not fit any of the intraorbital meningiomas described by Craig and Gogela. [8] PEM grows slowly over time and produces signs and symptoms due to compression of adjacent neural structures, especially exophthalmos is the predominant symptom. [22] In addition, intraosseous PEMs appear on tomography scans as expansile masses or provoking osteolytic lesions that mimic metastatic disease. [9] X-ray, head CT, and brain MRI are methods of radiological screening in diagnosing intradiploic meningioma. Radiologically intradiploic meningiomas are typically either osteoplastic or osteolytic, and although the majority are osteoblastic, extremely rarely are osteolytic or very extremely have a mixed pattern. ese can present with opacity of the orbital roof on X-ray skull study. e osteolytic subtype of intradiploic meningiomas is more likely to be malignant than the osteoblastic subtype. Intradiploic meningiomas should be considered in the differential diagnosis of patients presenting with osteoblastic or osteolytic skull lesions. [37] e differential diagnosis of the osteoclastic lesion should include chondroma, chondrosarcoma, hemangioma, epidermal cyst, eosinophilic granuloma, metastasis, and fibrous dysplasia, whereas the radiological differential diagnosis of osteoblastic lesions should include metabolic diseases including osteoma, hyperparathyroidism, metastasis and A and D hypervitaminosis. Head CT scan can be used to best define the margins of meningiomas in the bone algorithm and brain MRI can be used to identify adherent tissue involvement. [3] Particularly, MRI is helpful to evaluate the extraosseous extension and the soft tissue component. It is like the primary intradural meningiomas except for the dural tail sign, which could not be seen in intradiploic meningiomas. [43] Furthermore, scintigraphy and positron emission tomography CT (PET-CT) can be used for the differential diagnosis, with bone scintigraphy that shows an increased metabolic activity of the specific bone region when positive. [3] Tumor excision with wide surgical resection and meticulous bony reconstruction is the primary choice for treatment in symptomatic patients [22] and in this kind of tumor surgery, if the shell of the tumor facing the dura mater is not intact, the most important rule is to prevent postoperative CSF leakage. [7] is holds especially true for our case, given that the large dimension and the infiltration of multiple compartments (namely the roof and medial wall of the orbit, the ethmoid, and the frontal sinus) set a particularly high risk of CSF fistula. More, the absence of a dura sheet between the tumor and the basal frontal brain provoked a superficial damage to fronto-basal cortex. Nevertheless, these factors did not prevent us to accomplish a Simpson I resection and avoid CSF leak. Although most intradiploic meningiomas are benign, they could present malignant growth, which might lead to erosion of the skull. erefore, in most cases, total resection of lesions seems to be impossible, and the residual tumor should be treated with radiation therapy and chemotherapy, especially for the patients who had malignant or atypical features on histological examination. e present chemotherapeutic agents mainly include molecule-targeted drugs (imatinib, sunitinib, and vatalanib), cytotoxic chemotherapeutics (hydroxyurea, irinotecan, and temozolomide), hormonal inhibitors (targeting estrogen and progesterone), and other drugs. Hence, postoperative imaging will become vital for monitoring tumor recurrence or progress and prolonged follow-up of patients will be necessary. [43] CONCLUSION Primary intradiploic meningiomas are rare tumors, which are used to describe the subset of extradural meningiomas that arise in the skull. To the best of our knowledge, only seven cases of complex intradiploic fronto-orbito-ethmoidal meningioma were reported in the literature. Regular monitoring is essential in the management of intradiploic meningioma and surgical treatment with wide incision of the lesion is the goal of the primary therapy. We share this successfully treated case to add to the overall clinical experience in the management of this rare subtype tumor, with the hope that more studies are conducted to further address the mechanism of intradiploic meningiomas development.

Primary calvarial meningioma. Case reports

Diffuse calvarial meningioma

Primary intraosseous meningioma mimicking osteosarcoma: Case report

Fronto-orbital intradiploic transitional meningioma

Intra-osseous meningioma of the orbit: An unusual presentation

A primary intraosseous cystic meningioma: Case report

Fronto-Orbitonasal intradiploic meningioma in a child

Meningioma of the optic foramen as a cause of slowly progressive blindness: Report of three cases

Hyperplastic intradiploic meningiothelial tissue in the orbital roof mimicking metastatic disease

Intradiploic meningioma of the orbit: A case report

Intraosseous meningioma mimicking osteosarcoma in an adolescent: A case report

Intracranial meningiomas of the first two decades of life

Intraosseous calvarial meningioma of the skull presenting as a solitary osteolytic skull lesion: Case report and review of the literature

Intradiploic meningiomas. A radiological study of two cases confirmed histologically

Surgical resection of osteolytic calvarial lesions: clinicopathological features

Primary intra-diploic meningioma in a child

Primary extradural meningioma presenting as frontal sinusitis with extensive bony changes: Case report

Intradiploic orbital roof meningioma with pneumosinus dilatans in a child: A case report and review of the literature

Primary calvarial ectopic meningiomas

Multiple extracranial metastases from intradiploic meningioma

Primary extradural meningiomas: A report on nine cases and review of the literature from the era of computerized tomography scanning

Primary giant spheno temporal intradiploic meningioma

Intradiploic meningioma of the skull: Case report and review of the literature

Temporary bilateral external carotid artery clamping to reduce blood loss during removal of calvarial meningioma: A technical note

Primary calvarial meningiomas

Diffuse calvarial meningioma: A case report

Multiple growths of primary calvarial meningiomas

Primary calvarial meningiomas

Intradiploic meningioma of the orbital roof

Primary intraosseous calvarial meningioma

An intradiploic meningioma of the orbital roof: Case report

Primary intradiploic meningioma in the pediatric age-group

Primary extradural meningioma of posterior fossa associated with acquired chiari malformation: A short review

Removal of giant intraosseous meningioma followed by cranioplasty using a custom-made bioceramic implant: Case report

Case report 680

Microcystic meningioma of the calvarium: A series of 9 cases and review of the literature

Orbital roof intradiploic meningioma in a 16-year-old girl

Calvarial ectopic meningothelial meningioma

Primary intraosseous meningioma: An osteosclerotic bone tumour mimicking malignancy

Intradiploic meningioma mimicking calvarial metastasis: Case report

Primary osteolytic intraosseous meningioma of the frontal bone

Primary osteolytic intraosseous atypical meningioma with soft tissue and dural invasion: Report of a case and review of literatures

Frontal intradiploic meningioma with progressive intracranial invasion

Fronto-orbito-ethmoidal intradiploic meningiomas: A case study with systematic review

e authors thank Professor Francesco Doglietto for the surgical management and supervision of the clinical case.

Age (Years)

Signs and/or symptoms All procedures in studies involving human participants were in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional and/or national research committee and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards.

e authors certify that they have obtained all appropriate patient consent.

Nil.

ere are no conflicts of interest.