key: cord-1001126-zith4v45 authors: Monjezi, Mojdeh; Jamaati, Hamidreza title: The effects of face mask specifications on work of breathing and particle filtration efficiency date: 2021-10-06 journal: Med Eng Phys DOI: 10.1016/j.medengphy.2021.10.004 sha: 2c4e708f30722da65b3b5d12619c8fd05973d2ad doc_id: 1001126 cord_uid: zith4v45 The outbreak of the ongoing coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has led to the recommended routine use of face masks to reduce exposure risk. In this study, the increase in work of breathing (WOB) imposed by face masks is theoretically studied for both normals and patients with obstructive and restrictive lung diseases at different levels of activity. The results show a significant increase in WOB due to face masks, which is more severe in higher activity levels. The added WOB is considerable during physical activity and may be intolerable for patients with preexisting lung disease and may contribute to inspiratory muscle fatigue and dyspnea. Moreover, in this study, the effects of the physical properties of a fibrous medium, including thickness, porosity, and fiber diameter, are analyzed on the particle filtration efficiency (PFE) and the added WOB. The relations between the physical properties of the fibrous medium and the added WOB and the PFE are shown on some contour plots as a quick and simple tool to select the desired physical properties for a single layer filter to ensure that the added WOB is comfortable while the PFE is sufficiently high. Since the emergence of the ongoing coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, the routine use of respiratory protective devices (RPDs) has been recommended to reduce exposure risk. Furthermore, the most recent recommendations of the World Health Organization include the wearing of face masks by the general public for mitigating the risk and impact of COVID-19. The most used RPDs among healthcare workers and the general population are surgical face masks (SMs) and filtering facepiece respirators (FFRs), especially N95 FFRs. The continual wearing of RPDs is crucial for personal protection from exposure to contaminated particles or the risk of respiratory infections. Although RPDs are mandatory and highly recommended for areas most affected by the COVID-19 pandemic, significant difficulties have been observed in RPD wearers because of physical symptoms and discomfort. Major experimental studies have been performed on PRDs comfortability. Some researchers used automated breathing and metabolic simulators [1, 2] , while others tested the masks comfortability on human subjects [3, 4] . Potential reasons for discomfort with masks include a high temperature in the mask cavity leading to thermal discomfort [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] , CO2 accumulation, decreased oxygen causing headaches while wearing N95 FFRs [1, 6, 9] , and mechanical factors 6 such as increased breathing resistance [2, 4, 6] . A recent study has shown that panic-prone individuals may be at higher risk of mask-related respiratory discomfort [10] . An increase in breathing resistance up to approximately 300% for N95 FFRs was previously reported [4] . The increased breathing resistance, in association with CO2 rebreathing while wearing masks, may amplify respiratory fatigue and impair physical work capacity [11] . However, no indications of increased respiratory effort at a low workload for a relatively brief period were observed by Roberge et al. [12] . Fikenzer et al. reported that the pulmonary function and cardiopulmonary exercise capacity highly impaired by N95 FFRs in healthy individuals [13] . Later, Hopkins et al. found some flaws in their work which took the validity of the study into question [13] . The authors discussed that since there were no significant different results for arterial blood gases, heart rate, cardiac output and blood pressure between masked and unmasked conditions, in no way should it serve as a recommendation for avoiding mask use during exercise. These different results suggest the use of a mathematical model to investigate the effect of workload level on the increased work of breathing (WOB). There are various experimental researches in the context of particle filtration efficiency (PFE) of face masks [14] [15] [16] . Well-fitted respirators are required to achieve >95% aerosol filtration under standard conditions. PFE depends on the filter material [17, 18] , the properties of the fibers, including structure, diameter and electrostatic charges [17, [19] [20] [21] , the number of layers [22] , shape (surgical style, conical, or duckbill), and facial fit [17, 23, 24] . Moreover, a considerable reduction in PFE during a cyclic coughing incident has been observed. [25] . Although the main mechanisms for aerosol penetration through the masks are well studied [26] , the combined 7 effects of physical properties of the fibrous medium (including fiber diameter, porosity, and thickness) and the wearer's level of activity on PFE are not reported. This study computes the increase in WOB imposed by masks through a porous media model. Then, the effects of physical properties of the fibrous medium and the wearer's level of activity are investigated on the added WOB and the PFE. The filter medium, made up of randomly-oriented fibers, was defined as a porous media to simulate its resistance to flow. Assuming an adequate fit condition, almost all inhaling air passes through the filter medium without leakage. In laminar flow through porous media, the pressure drop is proportional to velocity according to Darcy's law [27] : Pv k     (1) In this equation, v is the face velocity, k is the permeability coefficient of the medium, and µ is the dynamic viscosity of the fluid (1.8e-5 Pa.s), and P  is the pressure gradient in the thickness of the medium, L. The face velocity is the fluid velocity and is related to the fluid flow rate, f, through the Eq. (2). in which, A is the surface area of the filter medium. According to detailed physical properties found in the literature for classical surgical masks [28] , we have found the solidity of surgical masks using Eq. (3). where ρ SF is the surface density and ρ is the available density of the polypropylene [29] . So, the assumed porosity of the surgical mask, ε =1-α, is 0.71. in which α is the solidity or packing density of the fiber medium. So, the permeability of each layer of the N95 FFR can be computed by Eq. (5). The modified form of Darcy's equation is Forchheimer's equation that also considers the inertial effects (Eq. (6)) [33] . where F is a dimensionless number called Forchheimer coefficient. Ergun suggested another form of Eq. (1) for granular materials expressed by Eq. (7)[34]. (7) in which g and d, are gravitational acceleration and fibers diameters, respectively. According to Eq. (7), F can be expressed by Eq. (8). 3/2 F 0.045/  (8) in which ε is the porosity of the fibrous medium. The fibrous masks have multiple layers of randomly nonwoven fibers that are not similar in shape to granular materials. However, there is a good agreement between the F coefficient of Ergun's equation and the numerical data on fibrous structures [34] . So, we have used Eq. (8) for the F coefficient. In this study, four level of minute ventilation (15, 30, 60 , and 85 l/min) were tested which covered the breathing flow rate range of an adult under different activities (rest, light, moderate and heavy activity). Assuming a sinusoidal profile for the inspiratory flow rate, In which p  is the pressure drop due to the mask substituted from the Eq. (6) and t i , and V T are the inspiration time and tidal volume, respectively. We have increased the respiratory rate, RR, by increasing the level of activity while I:E=1:1.1 according to We have computed the basic WOB of the respiratory system by the following equation: (10) in which R rs , f, and C rs are the respiratory resistance, inspiratory flow rate, and respiratory compliance. The first term of Eq. (10) is the resistive work required to overcome the frictional resistance to airflow during breathing that occurs due to the resistance of different compartments of the respiratory system, i.e. lung airways, and pulmonary and chest wall tissue resistances. We have compared the values of WOB for three types of lung mechanics, namely healthy, resistive, and obstructive. The compliance values for healthy and obstructive are considered to be 0.1 lit/cmH2O, while it is assumed 0.05 lit/cmH2O for restrictive lung mechanics. We have followed the previous approach to find respiratory resistance [36] . In this approach, some experimental constants were used for healthy and COPD individuals. The reported constants for COPD individuals are used for obstructive while the constants for both healthy and restrictive lung mechanics are the same. The porosity and fiber diameter are two parameters that controls both breathability and PFE of the fibrous medium. Increasing the porosity of the fiber medium increase the breathability while could lower the PFE hence it is a double-edged sword. The PFE may be predicted based on the following formula [37] . where η f is the single fiber efficiency due to inertial impaction, η I , interception, η R , diffusion, η D, and adhesion, η A given in Eq. (12) . In Table 3 , the relations for computing these filtration efficiencies by different mechanisms are expressed. In addition to three main filtration mechanisms, inertial impaction, interception, and diffusion, we could take particle-fiber interaction into account, i.e., the particle rebound and reentrainment. Eq. (12) calculate the single fiber efficiency based on collision efficiency (sum of collection efficiencies due to impaction, interception, and diffusion) multiplied by the collection efficiency due to adhesion effects [38, 39] . According to the formulation of η A , it is near unity for micron particles in breathing flow rates. The effect of electrostatic charge of fibers on the filtration efficiency has not been considered in this study. However, the PFE of electret fibers is significantly higher than mechanical ones. In order to consider the leakage flow through the face mask we assume that there is a small gap between mask and face ( Fig. 1 ) [44] . Assuming Darcy's law through the filter material of mask f P v Lk   (13) Where vf is the face velocity of the filter. Flow through the gap can be described with Bernoulli's equation (neglecting the gravitation), with 15 2 g v P 0 2    (14) Where vg is gap air velocity. Combining Eqs. (13) and (14) the relationship between vf and vg can be found, with The inspiratory flow rate, f, is equal to the volumetric flow rate through the filter, ff, and the gap, where Af and Ag are the surface area of the filter medium and gap. Substituting Eq. (15) into Eq. (16) yields Therefore, vg can be found as below It should be noted that this equation has two solutions but only the solution with positive sign is acceptable. Defining a gap factor, σ=Ag/Af, one can find the leakage flow ratio, LR, as below The normal gap area varies between 0 and 5% of the mask area [44] . We can assume that σ=0.05 for SMs with large gap and σ=0.02 for N95 FFRs with small gap. The inspiratory flow rate, f, substituted in Eq. (8), should be multiplied by (1-LR) to consider the leak flow. For the PFE calculation, we should also modify the previous PFE, η, as the following equation [44]  (20) The ratio of the second to the first term in the right-hand side of Eq. (6) is shown in Fig. 2 . According to Fig. 2 , the ratio of the inertial to viscous pressure drop is not significant, even by increasing the flow rate or level of activity in the studied masks. The error caused by ignoring the F coefficient in estimating the pressure drop of the both types of masks is smaller than 1%. This study computes pressure drop, additional resistance, and WOB imposed on a healthy subject wearing both an SM and an N95 FFR, as shown in Table 4 . 19 Assuming that σ=0.05 for SMs with large gap and σ=0.02 for N95 FFRs with small gap, the leakage ratio, pressure drop, added resistance and WOB are expressed in the Table 5 for different level of activity. As shown n in Table 5 , the leakage ratio decreases by increasing inspiratory flow rate consistent with the results of previous research [45] . The comparison of the results in Table 4 and 5 shows a maximum of 8% decrease in pressure drop and 15% decrease in added WOB under the leakage condition. According to Table 5 At rest condition, the added resistance is about 25.68% and 76.37% of the healthy lung and the added WOB is about 3.87% and 11.53% of the healthy lung for SMs and N95 FFRs, respectively. The previously reported range for the added inspiratory resistance of N95 FFRs is up to approximately 300% [4, 46] . Therefore, our simulation results are within the reasonable range. In According to Figs. 5 and 6, to achieve the PFE of mechanical filters above 80% for MPPS, the red region above the line with a determined level of the added WOB is acceptable. As porosity increases, a smaller fiber diameter should be used to obtain the desired level of the PFE and the 26 added WOB. Increasing fiber diameter in a fixed porosity lowers both the added WOB and the PFE. Similarly, increasing porosity in a fixed fiber diameter leads to higher breathability but lower PFE. Increasing the fibrous medium thickness leads to better PFE but lower breathability. According to Fig. 6 , increasing the activity level reduces the PFE while increases the added WOB. For simplicity, this study assumes that air flows uniformly through the whole surface of the face mask, and there is a uniform pressure in the space between face and mask. However, it is not accurate because the maximum flow is generated just in front of the nose. Therefore, a fluid dynamic analysis for breathing through a face mask covering a human face is suggested as an improvement. Moreover, we have not computed the increase of pressure drop due to the clogging occurred by continuous usage of the face masks. This issue could also increase the added WOB of the wearers in the long durations. According to Figs. 5 and 6, it is impossible to lower the added WOB while improving the PFE of a face mask by changing the fiber diameter, porosity, and the fibrous medium thickness. So, it is suggested to improve the PFE of the fibrous medium by other techniques such as electrical charging of the fibers. This study examined the effects of face masks on the added resistive WOB of mask wearers at four different levels of physical activity. The added WOB at rest condition was about 3.5% and 11.6% of the healthy lung for SMs and N95 FFRs, respectively. While the body of literature reports that this issue is not significant for healthy individuals, the present study results suggested that face masks may increase WOB, even in healthy individuals during physical activity. Patients with preexisting lung diseases are more likely than healthy individuals to experience increased dyspnea while wearing a face mask due to the increased WOB above their tolerating threshold. This study estimated that using face masks for an extended period of time may increase pressure drop due to clogging. The simultaneous effects of porosity, fiber diameter, and fibrous medium thickness of a fibrous medium were investigated theoretically on the added WOB and the PFE. Both porosity and fiber diameter can change the added WOB and PFE of face masks. By assuming a constant fiber diameter, a dilute filter with higher porosity has lower added WOB and PFE than a dense filter with lower porosity. Moreover, by assuming a constant porosity, an increase in fiber diameter results in lower added WOB and PFE. Changing the fibrous medium thickness is also a doubleedged sword. Thicker filters have better PFE but higher added WOB. We presented these nonlinear relations in some contour plots as a quick and simple tool to select the desired values of porosity and fiber diameter in the fibrous medium to ensure that the added WOB is comfortable while the PFE is sufficiently high. Evaluation of N95 respirator use with a surgical mask cover: effects on breathing resistance and inhaled carbon dioxide Effect of exhaled moisture on breathing resistance of N95 filtering facepiece respirators The effect on heart rate and facial skin temperature of wearing respiratory protection at work. Annals of occupational hygiene Objective assessment of increase in breathing resistance of N95 respirators on human subjects N95 filtering facepiece respirator deadspace temperature and humidity Headaches and the N95 face-mask amongst healthcare providers Effects of wearing N95 and surgical facemasks on heart rate, thermal stress and subjective sensations. International archives of occupational environmental health Thermal burden of N95 filtering facepiece respirators Physiological impact of the N95 filtering facepiece respirator on healthcare workers Impact of respiratory protective devices on respiration: implications for panic vulnerability during the COVID-19 pandemic Carbon dioxide rebreathing in respiratory protective devices: influence of speech and work rate in full-face masks Physiological impact of the N95 filtering facepiece respirator on healthcare workers Effects of surgical and FFP2/N95 face masks on cardiopulmonary exercise capacity: the numbers do not add up Inward and outward effectiveness of cloth masks, a surgical mask, and a face shield Non-woven materials for cloth-based face masks inserts: relationship between material properties and sub-micron aerosol filtration Measurement of filtration efficiencies of healthcare and consumer materials using modified respirator fit tester setup Filtration Efficiencies of Nanoscale Aerosol by Cloth Mask Materials Used to Slow the Spread of SARS-CoV-2 Household Materials Selection for Homemade Cloth Face Coverings and Their Filtration Efficiency Enhancement with Triboelectric Charging Aerosol Filtration Efficiency of Common Fabrics Used in Respiratory Cloth Masks Evaluation of decontamination methods for commercial and alternative respirator and mask materials -view from filtration aspect Application of nanofibers to improve the filtration efficiency of the most penetrating aerosol particles in fibrous filters Aerosol filtration efficiency of household materials for homemade face masks: Influence of material properties, particle size, particle electrical charge, face velocity, and leaks Performance of an N95 filtering facepiece particulate respirator and a surgical mask during human breathing: two pathways for particle penetration Comparison of filtration efficiency and pressure drop in anti-yellow sand masks, quarantine masks, medical masks, general masks, and handkerchiefs On respiratory droplets and face masks An overview of filtration efficiency through the masks: Mechanisms of the aerosols penetration Flow in porous media I: A theoretical derivation of Darcy's law. Transport in porous media The relationship of fabric properties and bacterial filtration efficiency for selected surgical face masks Manikin-Based Performance Evaluation of N95 Filtering-Facepiece Respirators Challenged with Nanoparticles. The Annals of Occupational Hygiene The effect of simulated air conditions on N95 filtering facepiece respirators performance Filtration Performance of FDA-Cleared Surgical Masks Model for predicting pressure drop and filtration efficiency in fibrous media An analysis of high-velocity gas flow through porous media Micro/macroscopic fluid flow in open cell fibrous structures and porous media: Simon Fraser University The pattern and timing of breathing during incremental exercise: a normative study The effects of pressure-versus volume-controlled ventilation on ventilator work of breathing Numerical Comparison of Prediction Models for Aerosol Filtration Efficiency Applied on a Hollow-Fiber Membrane Pore Structure Air-borne particle capture by fibrous filter media under collision effect: A CFD-based approach The collection efficiency of a particle-loaded single filter fiber Inertial impaction-dominated fibrous filtration with rectangular or cylindrical fibers Fundamentals of Aerosol Science: The Theory of Aerosol Filtration with Fibrous Filters Studies on Fibrous Aerosol Filters-IV Calculation of Aerosol Deposition in Model Filters in the Range of Maximum Penetration. The Annals of Occupational Hygiene Theoretical-experimental aerosol filtration model for fibrous filters at intermediate Reynolds numbers The critical importance of mask seals on respirator performance: An analytical and simulation approach Simulation and evaluation of respirator faceseal leaks using computational fluid dynamics and infrared imaging Investigation of the flow-field in the upper respiratory system when wearing N95 filtering facepiece respirator Respiratory protective devices; final rules and notice