key: cord-0999098-45kaqhwl authors: Hu, Guangyu; Qiu, Wuqi title: From guidance to practice: Promoting risk communication and community engagement for prevention and control of coronavirus disease (COVID‐19) outbreak in China date: 2020-05-22 journal: J Evid Based Med DOI: 10.1111/jebm.12387 sha: 38507bc4d3aa16227b8d6408fd56446dc6432e25 doc_id: 999098 cord_uid: 45kaqhwl Integrating risk communication and community engagement into the national public health emergency response is crucial. Considering the difficulties and challenges faced by China in the prevention and control of coronavirus disease (COVID‐19) and based on interim guidelines from the World Health Organization, this article makes several recommendations addressing the outbreak in China. These include improvements in the internal governmental risk communication systems, enhancing the coordination between internal and partner governmental emergency management, and promoting public communication in response to societal concerns. Regarding these recommendations, we emphasize community engagement in joint prevention and control, confronting uncertainty and countering rumors effectively, and strengthening international cooperation and evidence‐based decision making for prevention and control measures. communication systems should shift from being locally based to a high-level centrally led initiative that includes RCCE in a national response agency. Special working groups should be established at central and provincial levels with clearly delineated tasks and responsibilities. A unified, authoritative, timely, and efficient information release process that includes principal activities and timetables should be established and continuously improved. As far as possible, agencies should not conduct their risk communication strategies. Instead, a central working group should develop unified and clear working specifications for essential information, such as the timing of releasing the disease statistics and the format of recommendations for disease prevention and control, whereas provincial working groups should supervise regional implementation. However, the systems in China were not active and well organized within the first few weeks, and the reasons are not yet clear. Containment measures for the outbreak should be legally based. Considering the inclusion of COVID-19 among class B infectious diseases and the implementation of disease prevention and control measures for class A infectious diseases in China, 12 the media and public should pay attention to the disease surveillance and reporting systems strictly implemented according to the law. Additionally, the WHO's guidance provides general recommendations. However, in the context of this outbreak becoming a public health emergency of international concern, 13 how China can establish a risk communication and response system that leverages the dominant social and ideological systems unique to China remains to be answered. Public health emergency is widely interrelated with economic and social development, and outbreaks have affected the survival and growth of various industries. Adequate preparation for RCCE not only emphasizes stronger coordination among government agencies but also accentuates coordination with external partners. During the early stage of COVID-19 regional transmission epidemic in Wuhan City, local government agencies introduced public policies that were contradictory to the local outbreak. 14 Unfortunately, the policies unintentionally increased the risk of spreading disease and social instability. Effective coordination between government agencies would have helped avoid this situation. Infectious diseases have an extremely strong externality. Therefore, cooperation and coordination of emergency management between internal and partner governmental agencies is an important cornerstone for containment measures. The inclusion of relevant societal interests (including governmental agencies, NGOs, and businesses) into the RCCE response and ensuring its effective and timely communication is essential for the success of joint containment measures. Guidance from the WHO recommends the formulation and adoption of standard operation procedures (SOPs) in implementing the roles and responsibilities of various parties in the RCCE response. We agree with the recommendation and recognize SOPs as essential in effectively improving the coordination of onsite outbreak control, especially in the early stage of community outbreak. On 23 January 2020, public transportation in Wuhan City was locked down, and the airport and outbound rail stations were temporarily closed. 15 Many local hospitals faced the challenge of inadequate basic protective equipment and relied primarily on donations from various NGOs. Concurrently, there was a lack of efficient logistic channels for a large number of third-party aid supplies. This case highlights the urgency and necessity of having a unified plan for a coordinated RCCE response. The panic caused by an infectious disease outbreak among the public has profound economic and social consequences. 16 The timely disclosure of the information is the top priority in infectious disease prevention and control. Panic among the public, including health care personnel, results from the fear of unknown and uncertain risks. The general public can obtain information from the diverse channels available for information dissemination. Compared to China's official epidemic reporting and news briefing channels on the national and local levels, third party's social media-based news briefing services are featured for rapid, highly dynamic, and interactive as supplement information release channels with distinguished performance. Moreover, key opinion leaders in domestic and international social media platforms have the advantage of high community engagement, strong community mobilization, and widespread social influence. Governmental agencies should take the initiative to strengthen their communication and cooperation with the parties mentioned above further to improve the effectiveness of risk communication with the public. Several other affected cities in China's Hubei Province also announced the implementation of public transport outages and road closure measures since traffic closure was implemented in Wuhan. 17 The WHO's guidance on the RCCE in response to the COVID-19 outbreak 6 COVID-19 is a novel coronavirus strain that has not been found in humans before. To understand this, it will require extensive basic and clinical medical research, which will be a gradual and in-depth process. Leaving the response to chance is not an effective strategy. Instead, an initiative must be taken to communicate and explain uncertainty in time. Thus, the central government in China engaged senior experts to develop our understanding of the virus in order to enhance COVID-19 containment and made press releases in the early stage of the outbreak. Meanwhile, the state council provided hotline and web-based channels to help the general public to respond to requests for help. These measures contributed to addressing uncertainty and rumors. Nevertheless, the participation of public health experts in the release and interpretation of epidemic information was limited, so the government was unable to meet the public's expectation regarding information disclosure fully. Public perception of the limitations and gaps in drugs and vaccine development could be underestimated. Public education and risk communication considering these uncertainties require more attention. We also noticed that, due to the lack of effective monitoring tools and mechanisms, the domestic authorities at the regional or city level had difficulty determining the issues that might be causing rumors. We recognized that the insufficient preparedness needed to be addressed, and lessons could be learned from China. Rumors are usual features during outbreaks and spread of diseases; therefore, we must not only rely on the open and transparent disclosure of information to effectively counter rumors and misunderstandings but also seek ways to make the information more accessible and comprehensible. As the basis of risk communication, establishing an official and unified information dissemination channel on the national level in China is necessary, as well as for countries where one or more COVID-19 cases have been identified. For the local authorities implementing containment measures, we suggest that they should not only establish synchronous monitoring, verification, and response mechanisms for rumors and misunderstandings but should also establish timely and effective channels for understanding the risk perception and knowledge of different groups. In the collective sensemaking process that occurs on social media platforms, using expressed uncertainty to detect rumors has been proven to be possible 18 ; using "official" accounts on the social media platforms, they should participate in the propagation and correction of online rumors, and it would also benefit in improving and implementing RCCE strategy. 19 Information on COVID-19 cases in China was reported daily to the WHO from 3 January 2020. Subsequently, the full genome sequences of the new virus were shared with the international community after the pathogen was identified on 7 January 2020. 5 We must recognize that international information sharing and interregional cooperation would be of utmost importance in addressing and controlling the pandemic. For the RCCE readiness and initial response, the disease control These experiences from different countries remind us that enhancing international exchange and cooperation promptly, as well as sharing the response and preparedness measures with the international community, would be beneficial in addressing critical gaps in knowledge on COVID-19 and promoting evidence-based decision making for effective risk communication. 23 It has been 17 years since the SARS outbreak. The origin of the SARS coronavirus was not confirmed until 2017, and to date, no effective targeted drugs exist. However, we believe that China's public health and healthcare system has the ability to control the COVID-19 epidemic. China's command-and-control political economy and its containment efforts are unique. However, we should be aware of and identify barriers to engaging in RCCE practices in different countries with diverse political affairs. China's experience provides valuable lessons for other countries. The strategies, including ensuring the organization and accountability of public health system and healthcare system, respecting science, universal rules and common practices of the pandemic countermeasures, resolutely implementing effective and comprehensive public health intervention, and emphasizing RCCE, will finally help us to constrain the COVID-19 pandemic. Risk communication as a core public health competence in infectious disease management: development of the ECDC training curriculum and programme World Health Organization. Risk Communication and Community Engagement (RCCE) Considerations: Ebola Response in the Democratic Republic of the Congo A novel coronavirus outbreak of global health concern National Health Commission of the People's Republic of China. Proactive Prevention and Control of Novel Coronavirus Pneumonia by the National Health Commission Novel Coronavirus (2019-nCoV) Situation Reports Risk Communication and Community Engagement Readiness and Initial Response for Novel Coronaviruses (nCoV) Development and experience of health risk communication in China Risk communication of public health emergency. People's Medical Publishing House Application of WHO risk communication principles in prevention and control of the first imported Middle East respiratory syndrome case in China Application of risk communication in prevention and control of human infection by H7N9 bird flu in China Do our best in the prevention and control of disease as well as the treatment of patients, resolutely fight against the epidemic National Health Commission of the People's Republic of China Public Bulletin Emergency Committee Regarding the Outbreak of Novel Coronavirus (2019-nCoV) Wuhan Mayor: Why is the Wanjia Banquet Still Happening and 15 Medical Personnel General Office of Hubei Provincial People's Government. Wuhan City Novel Coronavirus Infection Prevention and Control Headquarters Bulletin Another Decade, Another Coronavirus Public Transport Suspended in 18 Cities and Counties during the Hubei City Lockdown Could this be true? I think so! Expressed uncertainty in online rumoring Keeping up with the Tweetdashians: the impact of 'official' accounts on online rumoring Estimating the Potential Total Number of Novel Coronavirus Cases in Wuhan City Pneumonia of unknown aetiology in Wuhan, China: potential for international spread via commercial air travel Concept and inspiration of risk communication in the Singapore and Philippines health fields. China Health Ind From guidance to practice: Promoting risk communication and community engagement for prevention and control of coronavirus disease (COVID-19) outbreak in China