key: cord-0994158-6ekyccsh authors: Itiki, Rodney; Chowdhury, Prithwiraj Roy title: Fast deployment of COVID-19 disinfectant from common ethanol of gas stations in Brazil date: 2020-07-24 journal: Health Policy Technol DOI: 10.1016/j.hlpt.2020.07.002 sha: 5f94db9becde3926f088aaf23cfe21a36c9b287d doc_id: 994158 cord_uid: 6ekyccsh OBJECTIVES: Coronavirus COVID-19 is spreading very fast in Brazil, requiring innovative strategies for the fast deployment of disinfectants. Panic in population triggered by COVID-19 has caused a shortage of alcohol-based hand sanitizers and disinfectants in many cities of Brazil. Despite the governmental reaction against the outbreak, a risk of shortage of disinfectants still exists. The objective of this research is to investigate an alternative method for the fast deployment of alcohol-based disinfectants to protect the population against COVID-19. METHODS AND RESULTS: This research highlights the feasibility of disinfectant production from common ethanol available in Brazilian gas stations, as a last resort. A four-by-one (4:1) ratio of common alcohol diluted in water meets the minimum requirements set by health agencies for the alcoholic concentration of disinfectants. Risks factors on alcohol dilution process are associated with corresponding measures of risk mitigation for public health and safety. CONCLUSIONS AND PERSPECTIVES: This research proposes a process for the production and deployment of ethanol-based disinfectant from gas stations. However, the implementation is not timely possible for the COVID-19 pandemic due to complexities in the productive process. For the post-COVID-19 period, the authors give three perspectives: (a) future investigation of human dermal toxicity of common ethanol, (b) establishment of a program for the ethanol decontamination, and (c) countries such as the US, Sweden, Thailand, and Colombia to rethink their energy policy for the adoption of biofuel E100 (ethanol and water) instead of E85 (blend of ethanol, gasoline, and water), as part of their biodefense strategy. The first steps to contain the outbreak of COVID-19 in Brazil started during the first semester of 2020. Many health organizations instruct the public to wash hands with soap and water or making use of hand sanitizers with alcohol content [1] [2] [3] [4] . Alcohol-based hand sanitizers are helpful in reducing the frequency of illness [5] [6] . However, a panic of the public due to the coronavirus outbreak, reported in the news, caused a shortage of alcoholbased hand sanitizers in Brazil. The COVID-19 outbreak is spreading globally, including Latin America [7] [8] [9] . The author of this paper takes an out-of-box perspective of the COVID-19 pandemic by proposing a process for the shortage of alcohol-based disinfectants in Brazil as last resort solution for the scarcity of COVID-19 disinfectants, presenting the timeline of facts of regulatory agency decisions concerning alcohol in parallel with the fast speed of COVID-19 outbreak in Brazil, and define health and safety policy for alcohol-based disinfectant deployment as a last resort. In 1975, the Brazilian federal government introduced the National Alcohol Program (Proalcool) to increment the consumption of ethanol by mixing it with gasoline to propel common gasoline vehicles [10] [11] . In the period of 1979 to 1985, during the second oil shock, the Proalcool program incentivized the construction of alcohol distilleries. The automotive sector, at the same time, focused on the manufacturing of cars powered exclusively by ethanol [12] . In 2018, the total production of ethanol was 33.1 million of cubicle meters, being 23.7 million of hydrous ethanol [13] . Decades of experience in the production, storage, and distribution of ethanol for vehicles have also led to a currently vast and well-established infrastructure of gas stations throughout Brazilian territory [13] . In 2018, the total number of gas stations in Brazil was 40,021 [13] . Most of the gas stations in Brazil are currently equipped with fuel dispensers to pump ethanol fuel into vehicles [13] . Despite the vast availability of ethanol in gas stations in Brazil, only one type of ethanol-based product has a potential for the production of COVID-19 disinfectant. Common ethanol shows potential for use as COVID-19 disinfectant due to the absence of additive and gasoline. However, the concentration of ethyl alcohol is above 92.6%. This concentration is not usual in the common practice of disinfection in the technical literature [18] [19] . An adjustment of concentration would turn common ethanol into a regular and effective disinfectant to COVID-19. The three largest ethanol-producing countries are the US (56%), Brazil (28%), and the European Union (5%) [20] . Most of the ethanol refineries in the US are in the Mid-West region [20] . The US has around 4,500 gas stations offering E85 and other flex fuels [20] . The American flex vehicle runs with a seasonal-dependent blend of ethanol and gasoline [20] . Gas stations pump two types of mixture: E85 Summer (74% ethanol and 26% gasoline) and E85 Winter (82% of ethanol and 18% gasoline) [21] . E85, despite the existing distribution infrastructure, cannot be used as a disinfectant. In Europe, Sweden is the leading country in the ethanol-fuel consumption with 1,695 gas stations for E85 [22] . In India, despite the great potential for ethanol production, a huge demand by its internal market make unfeasible, in the short term (2020), the blending of ethanol in the gasoline for concentration above E50 [25] . During the COVID-19 pandemic, India implemented repurposing of the existing industrial capacity of private liquor companies for the production of ethanol-based sanitizers. However, such repurposing was unlikely quick enough because the supply chains become affected in the pandemic [26] [27] . Similarly, repurposing of breweries for ethanol-based sanitizers has proceeded in the US, Canada, European Union, and the United Kingdom [28] . Thailand is expanding the utilization of ethanol fuel E85 for transportation [29] . Colombia is planning to introduce E85 in its markets in 2030 [30] [31] . The literature review shows that some countries, such as the US, Sweden, Thailand, and Colombia, have the infrastructure and plans for the production and distribution of ethanol fuel E85. One of the significant barriers for E100 distribution infrastructure was that a flex-vehicle required a small independent tank for the injection of gasoline into the motor engine during the start of a vehicle on E100 [32] . A new technology of injectors provides preheating of the E100 for the cold start of the vehicle, allowing start without gasoline injection system [32] . Such new technology opens new opportunities for the widespread adoption of ethanol fuel E100 in these countries. Health agencies around the world diverge on the minimum ethyl alcohol concentration. Brazilian Federal Ministry of Health recommends the same as the World Health Organization, i.e., 70% concentration of ethyl alcohol [4] . Table 2 presents different minimum ethyl alcohol concentrations recommended by health agencies. After May 15, 2020, proceed surface cleaning followed by 70% -90% ethanol [34] Brazilian Federal Ministry of Health It may (not must) be 70% alcohol concentration [4] It may (not must) be 70% alcohol concentration [4] Brazilian Federal Counsel of Chemistry minimum 60% and a maximum 80% are also effective, according to some studies. [35] minimum 60% and a maximum 80% are also effective, according to some studies. [35] ANVISA It is illegal commercialization of liquid ethyl alcohol one-liter bottle for the public in supermarkets and drug stores if the concentration is above 54%, except for 70%. [36] It is illegal commercialization of liquid ethyl alcohol one-liter bottle for the public in supermarkets and drug stores if the concentration is above 54%, except for 70%. [36] . After May 26, 2020, proceed cleaning with 70% alcohol or neutral detergent cleaning, followed by 60% to 90% alcohol [37] . Assuming that the alcohol-based disinfectant must meet the requirements of the Brazilian Federal Ministry of Health, the process of disinfectant production must result in a possible 70% of alcohol concentration [4] . This percentage number suggests that the ratio of 4:1 would closely meet the recommendations of the Brazilian Federal Ministry of Health, leading to a concentration calculation of: According to the material safety data sheet (MSDS) of the common ethanol, there is a tolerance of 92.6 % to 94.6% in the composition of ethyl alcohol in the common ethanol product [14] [15]. The common ethanol can reach up to 94.6% maximum concentration due to tolerance of the productive process. In this case, the dilution process would result in 75.68% maximum concentration, assuming the evaporation of ethyl alcohol negligible in the dilution process. The resulting concentration of the 4:1 dilution process is 74.1%. For ANVISA, commercialization of 74.1% ethanol for the public is illegal because it exceeds 70% [36] . However, 74.1% ethanol concentration is within the 60% -90% range, also recommended by ANVISA for surface cleaning [37] . The 74.1% ethanol concentration is also within the 60% to 80% effective range of the Brazilian Federal Council of Chemistry [35] . It is also close to 78.2% and 80% ethanol concentration for disinfection reported in the technical literature [18] [19] [5] . In June 2020, a literature review shows that SARS-CoV-2 is efficiently inactivated by ethanol concentrations ranging from 60% to 95% (v/v) or from 70% and 91.3% (v/v) [38] . SARS-CoV-2, the pathogen of COVID-19 pandemic, is not a bacteria. Concentrations not exceeding 80% for high contact time necessary to achieve an efficient bactericidal activity are disregarded by the Federal Drugs Administration [38] . The 4:1 dilution of common ethanol in water for COVID-19 disinfection brings some risks for the population. The handling of common ethanol by non-qualified public brings risks to their health and safety. Table 3 indicates some of them. Over usage of alcohol-based disinfectant on large areas [40] Formation of an explosive atmosphere classified area [14] . On March 17, 2020, the total number of COVID-19 cases confirmed in Brazil was 234 [42] . Despite helping to improve the supply of COVID-19 disinfectants and antiseptics, it is questionable if such measures are too late and too short against the fast COVID-19 outbreak. The compound pharmacies in Brazil, after the ANVISA resolution, still have to start up the production process to make 70% alcohol available to the customers. The progression of the COVID-19 outbreak over time is a constraint to the success of all levels of public governance to minimize the impact on the health system. Some aspects of the ANVISA resolution 347 [41] , particularly to the ethyl alcohol 70% in 50 ml bottles, seem in harsh contrast to products available in online sales in the US. Table 4 shows the differences in bottle volume. [37] . Table 5 summarizes the ANVISA recommendations for disinfectants of surfaces and objects for COVID-19. ANVISA informed that the virus is inactivated by alcohol 70% and chlorine [37] . Table 5 . ANVISA recommendations for the disinfection of surfaces and objects. April 23, 2020 [45] May 26, 2020 [37] Ethanol 70% Neutral detergent cleaning followed by alcohol: 60% to 90% in water solution v/v Sodium hypochlorite at 0.5% Neutral detergent cleaning followed by inorganic active chlorine-releasing compounds (e.g., sodium, calcium and lithium hypochlorites): 0.02% to 1.0%; Bleaches containing hypochlorite (sodium, calcium) at 2-3.9% Neutral detergent cleaning followed by inorganic active chlorine-releasing compounds (e.g., sodium, calcium and lithium hypochlorites): 0.02% to 1.0%; However, not all people in the world has an abundant supply of clean water, paper towel, and washing stations. People living in precarious shelters (slums) may not have adequate sanitary installations. Sharing cloth towels can facilitate virus spreading. Washing stations with automatic water faucet and motorized dispensers for contactless paper towel release are not commonplace in the developing countries. Soap cleaning may require scrub sponge for rinsing and rubbing, gloves for hand protection, and more paper for drying. Water spillover during the cleaning may cause mold proliferation. On the other hand, ethanol spares water, sponge, and a large quantity of paper towel supply because it mostly selfdissipate from the surface by volatility and evaporation. It may not be just a matter of convenience but the only practical solution for the most impoverished strata of the society. Also, ethanol from gas stations is available in an outdoor environment, as opposed to soap, sponge, gloves, and paper towels, which usually are in indoor sales point, exposing consumers to community spread of COVID-19. The COVID-19 pandemic caused an extra peak demand for all types of personal protective equipment and cleaning products [26] . Panic about the unknown life threat caused widespread hoarding disorder. The consumer may not have a choice between soap and accessories (water, sponge, paper towel) or ethanol-based disinfectant since all types of cleaning products become scarce in the sales points during a pandemic. This research aims at an alternative method for peak extra-supply of ethanol-based disinfectant. The last resort strategy happens when it is better to choose a non-perfect but acceptable alternative than doing nothing. An example of last resort strategy is exemplified by the CDC decision for optimization of supply of facemasks for health care professionals (HCP) under crisis management [26] . Unavailability of facemasks urges CDC to recommend HCP to use homemade masks (e.g., bandana, scarf) for the care of patients with COVID-19 as a last resort [50] . The COVID-19 pandemic caused a fast shortage of personal protective equipment [26] [51] . The disinfectant supply suffered the same shortcomings. However, the ethanol fuel E100 currently has risks of toxic contaminants, according to the Brazilian National Oil Regulatory Agency [48] . The risk of toxic methanol in the common ethanol composition is easily eliminated by thorough quality auditing on gas stations by the Brazilian Oil Regulatory Agency, and proper punishment for violation of conformity. The Brazilian Oil Regulatory Agency prohibits the addition of methanol on fuel since 2018 [39] . The assessment of compliance of ethanol fuel in gas stations is monthly reported by the Brazilian Oil Regulatory Agency [52] . Very few cases of methanol in E100 fuel were reported in recent months. In May 2020, for instance, just one non-conformity related to methanol content exceeding 0.5% was detected out of 1,558 samples from different gas stations in Brazil [52] . The elimination of other contaminants, described by Talita and colleagues in [21] , may require major intervention on the production process, which would not be timely possible in this COVID-19 pandemic. The author of this paper proposes a process for the production of 74.1% alcohol-based disinfectant obtained by a 4:1 ratio dilution of common ethanol of gas stations in Brazil in water. However, the proposal is not timely possible due to the complexities of the ethanol production, transportation, and storage process. It seems unfeasible in a short period to eliminate all risks of toxicity from contaminants pointed out by the Brazilian Oil Regulatory Agency. For this reason, three relevant perspective recommendations emerge from the post-COVID-19 period. Firstly, the scientific community is urged to investigate the human toxicity potential by dermal exposure to the ethanol fuel E100 from gas stations. The National Regulatory Oil Agency are urged to investigate the risks, challenges, and the economic feasibility of improving the quality of ethanol fuel E100 within the parameters of acceptable dermal toxicity. Secondly, the fast deployment of ethanol-based disinfectants from gas stations may be one course of action of a national biodefense strategy against pandemics and biological attacks. A program for decontamination of ethanol E100, if proved technically and economically feasible, should involve the participation of the health regulatory agency, and the oil regulatory agency, in the context of a national biodefense strategy. Finally, the perspective of future pandemics like COVID-19 or biological war can make other governments in the world to rethink about ethanol fuel E100 as a new standard for dual-use fuel, instead of E85. Countries like the US, Sweden, Thailand, and possibly in Colombia, major ethanol consumers or producers, may improve their biodefense strategy by adopting the ethanol E100 as their biofuel standard. .. None. None declared. Not required. World Health Organization, Key Messages and Actions for COVID-19 Prevention and Control in Schools World Health Organization, Infection prevention and control during health care when novel coronavirus (nCoV) infection is suspected, Interim guidance CDC Statement for Healthcare Personnel on Hand Hygiene during the Response to the International Emergence of COVID-19 Protocolo de tratamento do novo coronavirus (2019-nCoV). Brazilian Ministry of Health Effectiveness of alcohol-based hand disinfectants in a public administration: Impact on health and work performance related to acute respiratory symptoms and diarrhoea Washing our hands of the problem The race to unravel the biggest coronavirus outbreak in the United States Clinical, laboratory and imaging features of COVID-19: A systematic review and meta-analysis The next big threat to global health? The policymaking process for creating competitive assets for the use of biomass energy: the Brazilian alcohol programme Analyses and perspectives for Brazilian low carbon technological development in the energy sector Genesis and consolidation of the Brazilian bioethanol: A review of policies and incentive mechanisms Ministry of Mining and Energy of the Brazilian National Agency of Petroleum Anuario Estatistico Brasileiro do Petroleo MOD=AJPERES&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVI D=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQ FV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID =mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV&CVID=mKJNQFV Official Diary of the Union MOD=AJPERES&CVID=mN9MYKR&CVID=mN9MYKR&CVID=mN9MYKR&CVID=mN9MYKR& CVID=mN9MYKR&CVID=mN9MYKR&CVID=mN9MYKR&CVID=mN9MYKR&CVID=mN9MYKR&CVID= mN9MYKR&CVID=mN9MYKR&CVID=mN9MYKR&CVID=mN9MYKR MOD=AJPERES&CVID=mKJNteK&CVID=mKJNteK&CVID=mKJNteK&CVID=mKJNteK&CVID=m KJNteK&CVID=mKJNteK&CVID=mKJNteK&CVID=mKJNteK&CVID=mKJNteK&CVID=mKJNteK&CVID= mKJNteK&CVID=mKJNteK&CVID=mKJNteK Surgical hand disinfection using alcohol: the effects of alcohol type, mode and duration of application Effect of a 1 min hand wash on the bactericidal efficacy of consecutive surgical hand disinfection with standard alcohols and on skin hydration Renewable Fuels Association Secondary particles formed from the exhaust of vehicles using ethanol-gasoline blends increase the production of pulmonary and cardiac reactive oxygen species and induce pulmonary inflammation Biofuels for road transport: Analysing evolving supply chains in Sweden from an energy security perspective Emissions of particulate associated oxygenated and native polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons from vehicles powered by ethanol/gasoline fuel blends Effect of glycerol ethoxylate as an ignition improver on injection and combustion characteristics of hydrous ethanol under CI engine condition Indian scenario of ethanol fuel and its utilization in automotive transportation sector Addressing the shortage of personal protective equipment during the COVID-19 pandemic in India-A public health perspective Restructured society and environment: A review on potential technological strategies to control the COVID-19 pandemic Bullied, Production of Ethanol-Based Hand Sanitizer in Breweries During the COVID-19 Crisis Final and B molasses for fuel ethanol production and some market implications Combining an accelerated deployment of bioenergy and land use strategies: Review and insights for a post-conflict scenario in Colombia Development of a technology roadmap for bioenergy exploitation including biofuels, waste-to-energy and power generation & CHP 3 -Using alternative and renewable liquid fuels to improve the environmental performance of internal combustion engines: key challenges and blending technologies Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Interim Infection Prevention and Control Recommendations for Healthcare Personnel During the Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) Pandemic, Update World Health Organization, Cleaning and disinfection of environmental surfaces in the context of COVID-19 Nota Oficial (atualizada) esclarecimentos sobre álcool gel caseiro, limpeza de eletrônicos e outros Hand sanitisers amid CoViD-19: A critical review of alcohol-based products on the market and formulation approaches to respond to increasing demand Union Official Diary Taking the right measures to control COVID-19. The Lancet Infectious Diseases Resolution of the Collegiate Directory number 347 of March 17; 2020. Union Official Diary World Health Organization The liquid alcohol in Brazilian current context. Burns, 33, Issue 1, Supplement, pp. S19 COVID-19) Situation Report -62 -Data as reported by national authorities by World Health Organization World Health Organization Agencia Nacional do Petroleo, Gas Natural e Biocombustiveis, Coronavírus: riscos dos usos inadequados de etanol combustível COVID-19) Situation Report -120 Strategies for Optimizing the Supply of Facemasks. CDC; 2020, USA Health policy and technology challenges in responding to the COVID-19 pandemic Agencia Nacional do Petroleo, Gas Natural e Biocombustiveis, Boletim de Monitoramento da Qualidade dos Combustíveis