key: cord-0992343-f1xz0n3t
authors: Pezeshki, Mohammad Zakaria; Janati, Ali; Arab-Zozani, Morteza
title: Medical Overuse in the Iranian Healthcare System: A Systematic Scoping Review and Practical Recommendations for Decreasing Medical Overuse During Unexpected COVID-19 Pandemic Opportunity
date: 2020-08-11
journal: Risk Manag Healthc Policy
DOI: 10.2147/rmhp.s262908
sha: 65a986a7d909d658a49b11bceca9d0ab74415b74
doc_id: 992343
cord_uid: f1xz0n3t

PURPOSE: To perform an inclusive search for original studies that report medical overuse in the Iranian healthcare system and discovering the area of overuse. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A systematic search of the literature is conducted in bibliographic databases including PubMed, Embase, Scopus, Web of Sciences, Cochrane and Scientific Information Database using a comprehensive search strategy without time limit until the end of 2018, updated by 1 July 2020, accomplished by reference tracking, author contacting and expert consultation to identify studies on the overuse of medical care. RESULTS: We reviewed 4124 published articles based on predetermined inclusion criteria. The author’s consensus included a total of 41 articles. Of these, 32 were in English and 9 in Farsi, published between 1975–2019. The result categorized into two distinct clinical areas: treatment (18 articles) and diagnostic (23 articles) services. Almost all of the studies only described the magnitude of unnecessary overuse. Unnecessary overuse of antibiotics, MRI, and CT-scan were the most reported topics. The ranges of their overuse proportion were as follows: antibiotic (31 to 97%); MRI (33 to 88%), and CT-scan (19 to 50%). CONCLUSION: Our review showed, even so, the magnitude of unnecessary overuse of medical services is high but there are only a few interventional studies in clinical and administrative level for finding effective methods for decreasing these unnecessary services. Researchers should be encouraged to conducting interventional studies. We suggest the ministry of health to use the golden opportunity of COVID-19 epidemic for designing Iran national policy and action plan for controlling and preventing unnecessary healthcare services and including a section for “Interventional Research” in the action plan.

Medical overuse means services that are more harmful than beneficial, does not seem to increase the quality and quantity of life, impose excessive cost on the patients and their healthcare system, has low quality and if the patient has enough information, he or she will not ask for it. 1, 2 Overuse can take place in different areas including medication, test, or procedure. 3 Recent studies have shown that overuse of tests and treatments can lead to serious consequences on patients in six domains including physical, psychological, social, financial, treatment burden, and dissatisfaction with healthcare. 4 Medical overuse can delay access to the goals of health systems-improved health, responsiveness, financial risk protection, and efficiency-by increasing cost and decreasing the quality of medical care. 5 Given the fact that medical overuse is one of the problems that can make system performances problematic, its identification is of great importance for a health system. 6 Also, overuse in medical care is one of the obstacles to achieving universal health coverage (UHC). 7 If we want to achieve better UHC, we need to be able to manage costs, and one of the most important tasks in this direction is to reduce overuse in medical services. 8, 9 Over the years, many efforts have been made to identify overuse in medical care across health systems around the world. 10, 11 In Iran, as in many other countries, there is little evidence about the amount of medical overuse in the healthcare system. 1 So, the identification of medical overuse is an essential issue for the Iranian healthcare system and also helps health policymakers, health and medical managers, researchers, general practitioners, patients, and their families to cope with harms, costs, and quality of services. Ultimately, identifying the overuse of medical care can bring our health system to balance in the right use of services. Thus, the objectives of this systematic scoping review were 1) to review the literature on the overuse of medical care, (2) to identify the areas in which the overuse of medical care take placed (3) to determine the rate of overuse of medical care in the Iranian healthcare system and its drivers and (4) to identify the interventional studies in clinical and administrative level for decreasing the rate of overuse.

We conducted a systematic scoping review on medical overuse following the PRISMA-ScR checklist (supplementary material) and the five stages outlined in the Arksey and O'Malley framework. 12 The review protocol was registered in PROSPERO before starting our study (registration no. CRD42017075481) and published in BMJ Open journal. 1

The following questions guided this scoping review of medical overuse in the Iranian healthcare system: How much literatures have dealt with this issue in the Iranian healthcare system? Which area does medical overuse occur? What is the rate of medical overuse in the Iranian healthcare system?

All original articles that investigated the overuse in medical care were included in the study. Of these, only studies were included those have addressed overuse in the Iranian healthcare system. All the included studies were limited in English and Farsi languages. Articles were excluded if the researchers did not have access to the Full-text.

We searched six databases including PubMed, Web of Science, Embase, Scopus, Cochrane and Scientific Information Database (SID) without a time limit until the end of 2018 (31 December 2018). We also contacted the authors of included studies and use reference tracks to get the articles we probably did not find in the search. We used a set of Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) terms and free terms to maximize the sensitivity of the search. For more information on search strategy, see study protocol at: https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/8/4/e020355#ref-17. 1 After the article was finished and before the article was published, we searched the PubMed database again and updated our results until July 1, 2020. Details about search strategy are provided in the supplementary material.

After the search was completed, duplicate records were removed. Then, two reviewers screened the records based on the title, abstract and full text, and extracted the data about authors, publication year, type of study, study population, type of service, clinical area, and overuse rate or range. All potential disagreements in each level of study were resolved by consensus with a third researcher.

We categorized the results of the included studies based on publication year, clinical area, type of service (treatment and diagnostic area), and range or rate of overuse.

Initially, a total of 4179 records were screened. After removing duplicates, 3023 records were considered for eligibility. Of these, 41 studies were included. The study selection process is outlined in the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analysis (PRISMA) diagram ( Figure 1 ).

Most studies were published in English (78.04%). Included studies published between 1975 and 2019. Most studies were published in 2014 (25%), 2012 (15%) and 2011 (12.5%). Also, in terms of design, 38 were crosssectional, and three RCT studies. The summary characteristics of the included studies are shown in Table 1 .

The result categorized into two distinct clinical areas: treatment (18 articles), and diagnostic (23 articles) area. Unnecessary overuse of Antibiotics, MRI, and CT-scan were the most reported topics. The ranges of their overuse proportion were as follows; Antibiotic (31 to 97%); MRI (33 to 88%), and CT-scan (19 to 50%). Among the studies in the area of treatment, the most studied were antibiotics (7 studies, 38.8%), and three studies (16.6%) did not compare the results with any other standard. Also, among the studies in the area of diagnosis, the most studied were related to MRI (4 studies, 17.3%), and CT (4 studies, 17.3%), and three studies (13%) did not compare the results with any other standard. For more details see Tables 2 and 3 .

This systematic scoping review aimed to perform an inclusive search for original studies that report medical overuse in the Iranian healthcare system. Finally, 41 original studies were included in our study, of which 18 articles related to the treatment area and 23 articles related to the diagnostic area. Antibiotics and MRI were the most reported issues in each category where overuse has been reported. Tables 2 and 3 shows the majority of studies only have focused on the magnitude of unnecessary diagnostic and treatment services. There are only a few interventional DovePress studies regarding diagnostic and treatment services. Also, there is not any study regarding unnecessary clinical preventive services like unnecessary check-ups and also unnecessary public health services. Unfortunately, as the Tables show there is not any study at the regional or national level that clarifies the drivers of unnecessary services in Iran and how to address them. To address the shortage of study regarding the interventions for decreasing the overuse rate in Iran we already conducted qualitative research at the national level to clarify the drivers of overuse and strategies for controlling these drivers in Iran. In this qualitative study, we interviewed 21 well respected old hand policymakers and researchers of Iran. After analyzing the interview, our study showed that the main drivers of unnecessary overuse in the Iranian healthcare system are physician, patient, organizational, socio-cultural, market, and mass media factors. Also, a Policy Delphi analysis as part of our national study and based on the key informant's opinion, 54, 55 showed that the main interventions for decreasing unnecessary overuse of medical services include; implementing strategic purchasing, active engaging of insurance companies, promoting payment system, use of clinical practice guideline in decision making, and increasing political commitment and reducing conflicts of interest. We are going to publish the results of our study in detail. COVID-19 pandemic has created a golden opportunity for addressing the drivers of unnecessary overuse of medical services by countries because of the three main reasons: 1) There is a shortage of healthcare resources for controlling COVID-19 pandemic and unnecessary services waste the resources 2) Overuses of healthcare services unnecessarily expose the patients and healthy individuals to the virus in outpatient clinics and hospitals, 3) Overuse of medications may suppress the immune response and predispose people to COVID-19 infection. Our preliminary search shows that the COVID-19 pandemic has decreased the use of several clinical interventions in countries 56,57 for example screening tests, 58 admission and hospitalization, 59 and elective surgeries. 60, 61 Considerable proportions of these clinical interventions are unnecessary. We suggest the Iranian ministry of health to use the golden opportunity of COVOD-19 pandemic to develop national policy and action plans for controlling and preventing unnecessary healthcare services in Iran. These policies will facilitate the controlling of the COVID-19 epidemic and preventing underuse of necessary services during the COVID-19 epidemic and after the end of the epidemic. Since this study was the first study in this field in Iran, there have been some limitations in conducting the study. One of the limitations has been related to the search strategy and how to search, which has made it difficult to research in this area due to the wide range of keywords. Researchers have tried to cover this limitation as much as possible by selecting multiple keywords, searching multiple databases, and using reference tracking and author contacting. Another limitation is the lack of evidence for some of the purposes of the study. For example, there has been no study on interventions to prevent medical overuse at the regional or national level, and we have limited 

Our systematic review shows even so the magnitude of unnecessary overuse of medical services is high but there are only a few interventional studies at the clinical and administrative levels for finding effective methods for decreasing these unnecessary services. Researchers should be encouraged for conducting such researches. It is necessary to be included a section for "Interventional Research" in the action plans we suggest to the ministry of health for controlling and preventing unnecessary healthcare services in Iran. 

The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work. 

Medical overuse in the Iranian healthcare system: a systematic review protocol

Evidence for overuse of medical services around the world

2017 update on medical overuse: a systematic review

Development of a conceptual map of negative consequences for patients of overuse of medical tests and treatments

Overuse of health care services in the United States: an understudied problem. Arch internal med

A practical framework for understanding and reducing medical overuse: conceptualizing overuse through the patient-clinician interaction

From universal health coverage to right care for health

Avoiding overuse-the next quality frontier

Levers for addressing medical underuse and overuse: achieving high-value health care

Early trends among seven recommendations from the Choosing Wisely campaign

Using the electronic health record to understand and minimize overuse

Scoping studies: towards a methodological framework

Polypharmacy among older adults in Tehran

Study of drug-drug interactions in prescriptions of general practitioners and specialists in Iran

Antibiotic use and abuse among physicians in private practice in Shiraz

Antibiotics use patterns for surgical prophylaxis site infection in different surgical wards of a teaching hospital in Ahvaz, Iran

Bacterial sepsis: challenges of diagnosis and treatment in a teaching hospital Southwest of Iran

Unnecessary blood and blood products transfusion to patients admitted to Ardabil Dr Fatemi Hospital

Impact of intravenous acetaminophen therapy on the necessity of cervical spine imaging in patients with cervical spine trauma

Predictors of local venous complications resulting from electrophysiological procedures

Are older women likely to use medicines than older men? (Results from AHAP study)

Economic burden of inappropriate antibiotic use for prophylactic purpose in

Unnecessary antibiotic therapy in children with diarrhea may cause antibiotic resistance

IS PRESCRIPTION OF KNEE MRI ACCORDING TO STANDARD CLINICAL GUIDELINE?

Prevalence of polypharmacy and correlations with sex, age and drug regimen in insurance prescription

Overuse or underuse of MRI scanners in private radiology centers in Tehran

Survey of Appropriate Use of Magnetic Resonance Imaging Services Provided in Shahid Chamran Hospital of Shiraz

Antibiotic usage in intensive care units of Tabriz Imam Reza hospital

The extent of inappropriate use of magnetic resonance imaging in low back pain and its contributory factors

Evaluation of prophylactic antibiotic administration at the surgical ward of a major referral hospital, Islamic republic of Iran

Clinical assessment of dizzy patients: the necessity and role of diagnostic tests

Association of clinical symptoms and laboratory results in diagnoses of Candida vaginitis

The correlation between preoperative erythrocyte sedimentation rate and postoperative outcome in adult cardiac surgery

Inappropriate use of urinary catheters and its common complications in different hospital wards. Saudi j Kidney Dis Transplant

Importance of diagnostic laboratory methods of beta hemolytic streptococcus group A in comparison with clinical findings in the diagnosis of streptococcal sore throat and unnecessary antibacterial therapy

Utility of lower-extremity duplex sonography in patients with venous thromboembolism

Clinical decision rule to prevent unnecessary chest X-ray in patients with blunt multiple traumas

General practitioners' prescribing patterns for the elderly in a province of Iran

Role of cervical spine radiography in the initial evaluation of stable high-energy blunt trauma patients

Study of Positive and Negative Consequences of Using GnRH Antagonist in Intrauterine Insemination Cycles

Indications and Overuse of Computed Tomography in Minor Head Trauma

Routine Chest Computed Tomography and Patient Outcome in Blunt Trauma

The use of head CT scanning in mild head injury

Assessing the appropriate utilization of CT scan in triage units

A review on laboratory tests' utilization: A trigger for cutting costs and quality improvement in health care settings

Overuse of psychotropic medications among children and adolescents with autism spectrum disorders: perspective from a developing country

Unnecessary paraclinical tests before elective surgeries

Appropriateness of physicians' lumbosacral MRI requests in private and public centers in Tehran, Iran

Venous thromboembolism risk assessment, prophylaxis practices and interventions for its improvement (AVAIL-ME Extension Project, Iran)

Preoperative medical evaluation in elective surgery versus standard criteria

Overuse and underuse of pulmonary CT angiography in patients with suspected pulmonary embolism

Prevalence and associated factors of potentially inappropriate medications among Iranian older adults

Policy package for preventing overuse and underuse of health care services in the Iranian health care system: A study protocol

Khodayari-zarnaq R. 6 Medical overuse: how to define, detect and prevent?

Be the Year That Medicine Was Saved? The New York Times

Covid-19: exposing the lack of evidence-based practice in medicine

Things should never be the same again in the screening world

Inappropriate rate of admission and hospitalization in the iranian hospitals: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Value Health Reg Issues

Hospitals have stopped unnecessary elective surgeries -and shouldn't restart them after the pandemic. Conversation

An Unexpected Opportunity Presented by the COVID-19 Pandemic. Clear Health

Examining the amount of unnecessary knee MRI prescription in the MRI center of bushehr university of medical sciences in 2018. Evidence Based Health Policy Manage Econ