key: cord-0991103-cc208i88
authors: Sajan, Abin; Hakmi, Hazim; Griepp, Daniel W.; Sohail, Amir H.; Liu, Helen; Halpern, David
title: Herniation Through Defects in the Broad Ligament
date: 2021
journal: JSLS
DOI: 10.4293/jsls.2020.00112
sha: b7405eaf0a43a0c23892e5f45a5668b1d08f363f
doc_id: 991103
cord_uid: cc208i88

BACKGROUND: We sought to assess hernia characteristics and classification through comprehensive review of the literature involving broad ligament herniation. METHODS: A literature search via MEDLINE and Embase databases was conducted to identify and select broad ligament herniation studies published between January 1, 2000 and September 30, 2020. Extracted data included previous surgical history, previous obstetric history, diagnostic imaging, herniated organ, hernia classification, and repair performed. The reported data has been compared to a unique case of broad ligament herniation that presented to our institution. RESULTS: A total of 44 articles with 49 cases were identified for the study. Eighteen (36.7%) patients had a history of previous abdominal surgery while 29 (59.2%) had a history of previous childbirth. Type I (51.0%) and Type II (18.4%) defects were most commonly reported with most patients reporting only one defect (85.7%) using the Cilley classification. Twenty-nine patients underwent primary laparoscopic repair of the defect while 19 patients underwent exploratory laparotomy. CONCLUSIONS: The analysis of previously reported cases adds to the limited literature on broad ligament hernias and highlights the surgical management of this uncommon pathology. It also highlights the need for a broad differential diagnosis when female patients present with pelvic pain or symptoms of small bowel obstruction. The broad ligament should be fully inspected when mesenteric defects are suspected as multiple defects can be present as evidenced by the attached case study.

Internal hernias are defined as a protrusion of intra-abdominal viscera through a mesenteric defect. Herniation through the broad ligament is rarely reported and constitutes only 4% of all internal hernias. 1, 2 Patients with a broad ligament hernia present with a wide spectrum of symptoms, ranging from none to acute small bowel obstruction. The diagnosis is challenging given the nonspecific clinical and radiographic findings. While small bowel is the most commonly reported herniated organ, rare cases of adnexal and sigmoid colon herniation have also been reported. 3 We present a surgical review of the 44 reported studies on broad ligament hernias over the past 20 years and include a case of small bowel obstruction secondary to small bowel herniation through multiple defects in the broad ligament that had undergone laparoscopic repair.

A literature search via MEDLINE and Embase databases was conducted to identify broad herniation studies published between January 1, 2000 and September 30, 2020. All articles that reported on broad ligament herniation were included using the "OR" Boolean operator. Our search string was as follows: broad hernia OR broad herniation OR Allen Masters OR internal broad hernia. We only included studies that were limited to case series or case report articles and where patients had confirmed cases of broad ligament herniation. References of each included study were reviewed so that additional eligible case reports could be identified and included. Cases of Allen-Masters syndrome were also reviewed to identify cases of broad ligament herniation. We excluded cases reporting on internal hernias that did not involve the broad ligament and cases that described bowel obstruction due to ambiguous pelvic herniation without definitive or suggestive diagnosis. Literature on basic sciences, randomized control trials, and animal or cadaver studies were excluded. We also excluded studies that reported on the same patient cohort as another study but with shorter duration of follow-up.

Two authors independently entered the search string in each respective database. The search was performed in September of 2020. Initial search terms yielded a total of 529 articles. Study titles and abstracts were copied into a single electronic database to screen for duplicates which eliminated 484 articles and resulted in 45 unique articles. Of these 45, one article was only listed in Chinese with no available texts in English and thus, was excluded to maintain the efficiency of our study. The remaining 44 articles were wholly analyzed, and, after applying the exclusion criteria detailed above, the 44 studies were confirmed to have valid reported cases of broad ligament herniation. Forty studies reported case series articles, with three studies reporting two cases, and one study reporting three cases, yielding a total of 49 reported patient cases.

A 51-year-old female with no significant past medical or surgical history with five previous spontaneous vaginal deliveries presented with one-day history of nausea, multiple episodes of nonbloody, nonbilious vomiting, and diffuse abdominal pain. She had two bowel movements the day before presentation and her examination was positive for diffuse abdominal tenderness without guarding or rebound tenderness. Vitals were within normal limits and initial blood work-up revealed a white blood cell count of 100.1 with a left shift of 86%. Computed tomography (CT) of the abdomen/pelvis was significant for a coiled loop of small bowel with transition from the dilated proximal small bowel to collapsed distal small bowel along the left pelvic sidewall (Figure 1 ). The patient was initially treated with nasogastric decompression and intravenous hydration. Her obstruction resolved within 24 hours. Subsequent joint review of the CT images by the operating surgeon and a second radiologist raised the suspicion of an internal hernia. For this reason, coupled with the fact that the patient had no previous surgical history or alternative explanation for bowel obstruction, the patient was counseled to undergo a diagnostic laparoscopy. At laparoscopy, the small bowel was carefully examined from the ligament of Treitz to the ileocecal valve. There were no small bowel abnormalities or intraabdominal adhesions. Focused evaluation of the site of radiographic small bowel transition in the left pelvis revealed two defects in the broad ligament, each measuring approximately 2 cm x 2 cm and a sciatic hernia along with pelvic venous congestion. The broad ligament defects were consistent with types I, and II respectively. Both defects in the broad ligament along with the sciatic hernia defect were closed with polyglycolic acid sutures, and the broad ligament was thoroughly examined for any additional defects ( Figure 2) . Additionally, there were two infarcted epiploic appendages of the sigmoid colon that were presumed to have herniated through the left sided defect and spontaneously reduced with the small bowel. These were resected. The patient recovered well after the procedure and was discharged within 24 hours after tolerating a regular diet with bowel function. Patient was evaluated two years postoperatively and reported no recurrent symptoms.

Forty studies reported case series articles, with three studies reporting two cases, and one study reporting three cases, yielding a total of 49 reported patient cases. The average patient age was 44.71/-13.2 (mean1/standard deviation). Only 35 (71.4%) cases reported the type of observed defect using the Cilley classification. Of the 35 cases, 25 reported a type I defect, with only 7 studies reporting a type II defect, and 3 studies reporting a type III defect. Nine studies reported bilateral herniation, 19 studies reported left hernias, 19 studies reported right hernias and two studies did not specify whether hernia was bilateral, right, or left sided. Twenty (40.8%) patients had a history of previous abdominal surgery while 33 (67.3%) had a history of previous childbirth, pregnancy, or endometriosis. Ten (20.4%) patients lacked any pregnancy history and 6 (12.2%) patients lacked both pregnancy and previous surgical history.

Forty-five patients underwent emergent surgery for bowel obstruction secondary to broad ligament herniation. Four patients underwent elective surgery for chronic pelvic pain. One was found to have herniation of the sigmoid colon through the broad ligament without signs/symptoms of bowel obstruction. One patient was found to have bilateral large broad ligament defects without organ herniation. Two were found to have ovarian herniation.

Five patients were found intra-operatively to have a contralateral asymptomatic broad ligament hernia.

79.6% of reported patients with broad ligament hernia had small bowel herniating through the broad ligament, making it the most commonly herniating organ, followed by large bowel 12% and ovaries 6%.

An extensive summary of the literature review findings is shown in Tables 1, 2, and 3. Further results of imaging modality along with operative approach and intra-operative findings are reviewed in the discussion section below.

Internal hernias are rare, with a reported incidence of 00.2 -00.9% and classified by Ghahremani and Meyers according to the location of the hernia orifice. 3 Some of the common internal hernias include paraduodenal, foramen of Winslow, intersigmoid, pericecal, transmesenteric, and transomental hernias. 1-3 Although difficult to ascertain, paraduodenal hernia and transmesenteric hernia are the most prevalent internal hernia types. Broad ligament hernia accounts for only 4% -7% of all internal hernias. 1, 2, 4 The broad ligament is a double layer of peritoneum that envelops the female pelvic organs during the fusion of mullerian ducts in-utero. 5 This protective layer of mesentery attaches the lateral portions of the uterus to the lateral pelvic sidewall and includes the mesometrium, mesosalpinx, and mesovarium. 5 The broad ligament is an important intra-operative landmark as it plays a key role in forming the rectouterine pouch and is a common site for endometriosis. 6 The earliest reported case of a broad ligament traces back to 1861 during an autopsy study by Quain et al. [7] [8] [9] Almost 70 years later, Gray et al. was the first to describe the operative repair of a broad ligament hernia in 1933. 10 The etiology of the defect can be congenital or acquired. Congenital causes are secondary to the spontaneous rupture of congenital cystic structures, which are related to developmental abnormalities in the pelvic peritoneum. 11, 12 Acquired defects are secondary to operative trauma, pregnancy, birth trauma, inflammatory pelvic disease, or disease processes like endometriosis causing significant damage to the mesentery. 11, 13 Allen-Masters syndrome, originally introduced in 1955, describes a clinical syndrome which may result from defects in the broad ligament as well as the cul-de-sac or uterosacral ligament. 14-16 Development of this syndrome has been attributed to traumatic obstetric tears or chronic endometriosis which may induce scarring and weaking of tissues. 16 Thus, this syndrome was also included in our search to identify possible cases of herniation through the broad ligament.

The traditional teaching is that broad ligament hernia is associated with multiparity. In the present case, the patient had a history of five previous spontaneous vaginal deliveries. The obstetric history in the 49 previously reported cases of broad ligament hernia were analyzed and summarized in Table 2 , along with additional significant patient history. It is notable that 18.4% of patients lacked any pregnancy or previous surgical history. This suggest that almost 20% of the reported cases may be congenital or develop de novo as primary broad ligament hernias. The pregnancy history of the oldest patient (94 years old) in the analysis was unknown but she had previous abdominal surgery while the youngest patient (24 years old) did not have prior pregnancies or surgical history. 17, 18 Interestingly, three patients younger than 30 years were included in the analysis, two of whom had no previous pregnancies or surgical history. Although the analysis is incomplete given limited patient history, the reporting of such hernias in younger patients did not depend on a previous history of surgery or pregnancy.

It is interesting to note that the majority, but not all visceral herniation, led to acute/chronic pain or bowel obstruction. There were only two reports of isolated ovarian herniation through a broad ligament defect. Both patients had a history of endometriosis and had chronic pelvic pain.

Hernias through the broad ligament can be classified by the degree of peritoneal defect or the location of the defect. Hunt et al. classified defect intro two main categories: fenestra and pouch. Fenestra type involves a defect in both the peritoneal layers while the pouch type only involves a defect in one of the two layers. The anatomical classification by Cilley includes three types of variants. Type I is caudal to the round ligament of the uterus while type II is above the round ligament, including suspensory ligament of the ovary, mesosalpinx or mesovarium. Lastly, type III defect is in the two-layered surface of the round ligament and mesometrium ( Figure 3) . 13, 20 An analysis on the classification types is limited given only 35 (71.4%) cases reported the type of observed defect using the Cilley classification. Of the 35 cases, 25 reported a type I defect with only 7 studies reporting a type II defect and 3 studies reporting a type III defect. This is consistent with the trend observed in Cilley's original paper published in 1986 where type I defects were the most common. 13, 20 The observed defect type, herniated organ, and hernia characteristics of cases reported from the literature are further summarized in Table 3 .

In the present case, three separate defects were observed in the mesentery: one between the round ligament and ovarian ligament (type 1), one above the fallopian tube (type 2), and lastly one located in the distal inferior portion of the uterus (sciatic hernia). Although the majority CT imaging can diagnose a broad ligament hernia when mesenteric vessels of herniated intestine are seen penetrating a defect in the broad ligament. Another reported diagnostic finding is enlargement of the distance between the uterus and ovary, causing deviation in opposite directions. 1, 17, 18 Ultrasound is useful in assessing the position and vascular supply of the ovaries. 19 As summarized in Table 1 , multimodal imaging (CT, ultrasound, and plain radiograph) is often employed for patients presenting with bowel obstruction or pelvic pain. CT scanning was used for evaluation in 70% of cases. When used, a pre-operative CT diagnosis of broad ligament hernia was made 36% of the time. Ultrasound was used in 20% of cases either as an adjunct or primary imaging modality. It was also used for pre-operative assessment of sites for trocar entry. 19 When used as a solitary imaging modality, it was not helpful in diagnosing broad ligament herniation. In one case report, it was used as an adjunct to CT scan and demonstrated small bowel herniation through a broad ligament defect. Plain radiograph was employed in 37% of cases. As expected, there were no specific findings on plain radiograph that led to the pre-operative diagnosis of broad Patients presenting with small bowel obstruction secondary to an internal hernia should undergo exploratory surgery to identify the cause of obstruction and prevent recurrent episodes.

The surgical management of broad ligament hernias were first described through an open approach, but laparoscopic advancements in surgery have led to minimally invasive repair. As referenced in Table 3 , 59% of patient who presented with broad ligament herniation were successfully managed via a laparoscopic approach. Laparoscopy can afford improved visualization of the pelvic structures and is often associated with decreased use of postoperative analgesics, decreased rate of wound complications, and decreased hospital length of stay. 22 The threshold for minimally invasive management should be low in patients presenting with symptoms of small bowel obstruction, asymptomatic patients with a visible transition point on imaging in the pelvic cavity, endometriosis, and patients with previous childbirths. The fact that several patients were found to have incidental broad ligament herniation at the time of elective laparoscopy for pelvic pain demonstrates the utility of laparoscopy for diagnosis of broad ligament hernias.

Mesenteric defects are mainly closed primarily, but omental patches and/or a fenestration procedure, whereby the round ligament and the peritoneal fold are divided, can be considered in cases with larger defects, eliminating the possibility of herniation. Our literature review did not demonstrate superiority of any particular technique. We therefore suggest that the choice of procedure be based on the operative anatomy and surgeon's technical ability.

Broad ligament herniation is a difficult diagnosis given the nonspecific clinical symptoms and the limited utility of radiographic studies. Patients can present with a broad spectrum of symptoms, ranging from acute to chronic complaints making the diagnosis more challenging. Contrary to traditional teaching, one should be aware that 20% of patients with broad ligament herniation will have no prior surgical or obstetrical history. The present case highlights the need for a broad differential diagnosis when female patients present with pelvic pain or symptoms of small bowel obstruction. CT scan is a valuable diagnostic tool for broad ligament hernias. The case also calls attention to the probability of multiple defects and thus, emphasizes the importance of fully inspecting the broad ligament intra-operatively to effectively treat herniations and avoid recurrent symptoms. Laparoscopic intervention should be considered as a means of repair.

Internal hernias in the era of multidetector CT: correlation of imaging and surgical findings

Internal hernia: clinical and imaging findings in 17 patients with emphasis on CT criteria

Internal abdominal hernias

Intestinal obstruction

The broad ligament: a review of its anatomy and development in different species and hormonal environments

Comparison of Laparoscopic Hysterectomy in Patients with Endometriosis with and without an Obliterated Cul-de-sac

Case of internal strangulation of a large portion of the ileum

Strangulated hernia through a defect of the broad ligament and mobile cecum: a case report

Broad ligament hernia-associated bowel obstruction

Figure 3. Variations of defects through the broad ligament. UT, Uterus; O, Ovary; RL, Round Ligament

Hernia of the ovary and fallopian tube into the broad ligament

Incarcerated internal hernia of the small intestine through a breach of the broad ligament: two cases and a literature review

Small bowel obstruction by broad ligament hernia: three case reports, management and outcomes

Herniation through the broad ligament

Complicated Allen-Masters syndrome

Acute abdominal pain due to internal herniation of the sigmoid colon, fallopian tube and left ovary, a rare presentation of Allen Masters syndrome

Pelvic peritoneal defects and endometriosis: Allen-Masters syndrome revisited

Internal hernia of the broad ligament: CT diagnosis for laparoscopic management

Small bowel obstruction secondary to internal hernia through a defect of the broad ligament: preoperative multi-detector CT diagnosis

Use of transabdominal ultrasound to identify intraabdominal adhesions prior to laparoscopy: a prospective blinded study

Defects of the broad ligament of the uterus

Unexpected findings at diagnostic laparoscopy: caecal incarceration with concurrent appendicitis in a patient with bilateral broad ligament defects

Laparoscopy in small bowel obstruction -current status -review. Wideochirurgia I Inne Tech Maloinwazyjne

Jejunal obstruction and perforation resulting from herniation through broad ligament

Strangulated herniation through a defect in the broad ligament

Incarceration of small bowel herniation through a defect of the broad ligament of the uterus: report of a case

Small bowel incarceration in a broad ligament defect

Internal herniation through a defect of the broad ligament of the uterus

Internal hernia through the broad ligament presenting with acute on chronic intestinal obstruction: a case report

Defects of the broad ligament of the uterus

Utility of multi-detector CT for pre-operative diagnosis of internal hernia through a defect in the broad ligament (2007: 1b)

Laparoscopic management of small bowel incarceration caused by a broad ligament defect: report of a case

Small bowel obstruction due to broad ligament hernia successfully treated by laparoscopy

Concurrent sigmoid volvulus and herniation through broad ligament defect during pregnancy: case report and literature review

Internal herniation of adnexa through a defect of the broad ligament: case report and literature review

Laparoscopic treatment of incarcerated hernia through right broad ligament in patients with bilateral parametrium defects

Small bowel obstruction due to an internal herniation through a defect of the broad ligament

Internal hernia through the mesosalpinx: a lesson to learn

Herniation Through Defects in the Broad Ligament

Small bowel obstruction due to broad ligament hernia: computed tomography findings

Bilateral herniation of the ovaries into the anterior compartment of the pelvis

Laparoscopic management of internal hernia of small intestine through a broad ligament defect

Strangulated hernia through a defect in the broad ligament: a sheep in wolf's clothing

Internal hernia through a defect in the broad ligament

Internal herniation through a broad ligament defect found at laparoscopy

Laparoscopically treated small bowel obstruction due to internal herniation through the broad ligament

Broad ligament hernia successfully treated by laparoscopy: case report and review of literature

The complicated Allen-Masters syndrome: small bowel herniation through a broad ligament defect

Asymptomatic internal hernia through a defect of broad ligament: a surprising finding in a laparoscopic surgery to recover a lost levonorgestrel-releasing intrauterine system

Richter's hernia through the broad ligament: Role of computed tomography and ultrasonography in facilitating diagnosis and rapid operative repair

Bowel obstruction and peritoneal dialysis: a case report of a patient with complications from a broad ligament hernia

Broad ligament hernia successfully repaired by single-incision laparoscopy: a case report

Bowel obstruction caused by broad ligament hernia sucessfully repaired by laparoscopy

Broad-ligament hernia: a rare cause of small bowel obstruction

Less invasive treatment for broad ligament hernia: a case report

Mesosalpinx hernia of the sigmoid colon: a cause of lower abdominal pain in women

Needlescopic surgery for broad ligament hernia: a case report

COVID norelated surgical emergencies during COVID-19 time. Case report: broad ligament internal hernia with associated small bowel necrosis