key: cord-0980289-b2tgqtu7 authors: McMillian-Bohler, Jacquelyn; Bell, Lacrecia M. title: Considerations and Recommendations for Care of Black Pregnant Patients During COVID 19 date: 2022-05-05 journal: Nurs Clin North Am DOI: 10.1016/j.cnur.2022.04.010 sha: 72e30e81a1fbbaf17e05f45fa8705d8374882dee doc_id: 980289 cord_uid: b2tgqtu7 Black pregnant patients experience perinatal morbidity and mortality rates greater than other ethnic groups. These health disparities exist primarily due to systemic racism, bias, and discriminatory acts within the healthcare system. The COVID 19 pandemic has reinforced health disparities experienced by all vulnerable populations in the United States, including Black pregnant patients. This paper highlights some of the factors that may impact the experience of Black people as they navigate the COVD-19 pandemic and presents strategies that every provider can implement to minimize the detrimental effects of this devastating virus during pregnancy. On January 9th, 2020, the World Health Organization(WHO) announced suspicions of a flu-like virus in Wuhan, China, potentially linked to the Coronavirus. 1 As of January 2022, more than 70.2 million Americans have contracted Coronavirus (SARS Cov-2), and more than 800,000 Americans have died of COVID-19 2 . Although the pandemic has affected nearly every community in the United States, Black, Latino, and Indigenous people remain overrepresented in positive cases and death rate reports. 3 Health disparities among the minority populations in the United States predate the devastating effects of COVID-19. However, as explained by Volkan Bozkir, former president of the United Nations General Assembly, "this pandemic has laid bare the existing vulnerabilities facing the most marginalized and disadvantaged groups." Black pregnant patients are a marginalized and disadvantaged population. It is well documented that Black pregnant patients are more likely than patients from other ethnic identities to experience perinatal complications such as depression, preterm labor, hypertensive disorders, cardiovascular disorders, and postpartum bleeding. 4, 5 The most disturbing statistic is that Black pregnant patients are three times more likely to die in childbirth than White patients 6 . Black patients also experience greater incidences "nearmisses" called severe maternal morbidity (SMM). 7 In the case of an SMM, a complication occurs and the patient nearly dies. One study reported that Black women are 2.1 times more likely to experience an SMM than White women 8 . These maternal disparities exist regardless of the education and socioeconomic status of the mother. The root of these health disparities are systemic racism, and discrimination and bias within the healthcare system 9 . Given the disparities in COVID-19 related health outcomes for Black persons and the pre-existing health disparities for Black birthing persons, it is essential to explore the impact of COVID-19 on Black pregnant persons. Education and data about the management of COVID-19 continue to evolve. As a result, information about the impact of COVID-19 on induvial populations is also limited. It is, however, possible for healthcare providers to make changes in their practice that can improve maternal outcomes for Black pregnant patients. The purpose of this paper is to describe factors that may contribute to the differences in Covid 19 related health outcomes for Black people and then present a list of recommendations for healthcare providers to integrate into their clinical practice. Black people make up only 15% of the US population; however, in 2020, they accounted for 25% of the positive COVID-19 tests and 39% of the recorded COVID-19 related deaths. 10 As of October 2021, the disparity in death rates for Black people has narrowed to 17% but remains disproportionate to the overall American population. Factors such as vaccine hesitancy, lack of culturally appropriate education about COVID-19, and general medical mistrust have impacted COVID-related health outcomes. 8 Additionally, social determinates of health (defined as where one lives, works, plays, and worships) also appear to play a significant role in the increased rates of SARS CoV-2 exposure and viral transmission. 11 Several factors may increase the opportunity for SARS CoV-2 exposure for Black persons including occupational exposure and challenges related to protective equipment. First, Black Americans are more likely to work in industries with a high potential for exposure to SARS CoV-2. 12 These jobs include work within home healthcare, medical aide services, manufacturing, housekeeping, and retail industries. These jobs are considered essential, yet the workers often report feeling undervalued 13 and protection against Covid-19 exposure J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f inconsistent. Once exposed to SARS-CoV-2, workers can unintentionally spread the virus to their families. Minority populations are more likely to live in densely populated settings and multigenerational housing. Therefore, occupational exposure can not only impact an entire family but an entire community. Secondly, aside from challenges everyone faced obtaining personal protective equipment, utilizing protection against SARS CoV-2 has not been race-neutral. According to a Pew study taken at the beginning of the pandemic, 42% of Black Americans were concerned about the most basic protection--wearing a mask. In addition, a University of North Carolina coronavirus project conducted to explore attitudes and behaviors related to the Covid 19 pandemic found that participants viewed Black men wearing a cloth mask or as less trustworthy and threatening 14 . With the murder of George Floyd, Ahmad Avery, Brianna Taylor, and countless other victims on the minds of many Black Americans, any hesitancy to participate in a recommendation that may lead to an increase in suspicion is justifiable. Examples of poor treatment of Black people by the medical community are legion. Black patients often report feeling dismissed or unheard by providers. 10 Even during this pandemic, Black people seeking health care for symptoms of COVID-19 reported feeling ignored and were denied testing. 11 There are reports of providers dismissing complaints by Black patients who eventually passed away due to complications of the disease. For example, A video of Dr. Moore, who died of complications of Covid 19 after sharing her story of being mistreated in the hospital, went viral. This type of media further sews seeds of mistrust within a community, whether wholly accurate or not. There are also historical events that illustrate the research community's longstanding mistreatment of Black people. In the Tuskegee study, which lasted over 40 years, researchers did J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f not consent the Black men to participate in a study. The researchers then withheld treatments for syphilis 15 resulting in permanent disability or death for some participants. This research study did not end until 1972within the lifetime of today's Black patient population. In the case of Henrietta Lax, researchers collected a sample of her cervical cells without her knowledge or consent. Those cells were later used to cultivate a cell bank for research and genetic studies. Neither Henrietta nor her family was ever compensated. Finally, Dr. Marion Sims-the "father of gynecology," performed brutal experiments on Black enslaved bodies without anesthesia. He believed that Black people did not experience pain the same as White people 4 . As the stories of the horrific events circulate within the Black community, commingle with present day experiences of bias and discrimination, feeling of mistrust may persevere. A 2020 survey by the Kaiser Family Foundation and ESPN called "The Undefeated" found that "seven out of 10 Black adults still believe that race-based discrimination in health care happens somewhat often, and one in five say they have personally experienced it in the past year." 3 Considering the legacy of discriminatory treatment of Black people in the name of science, it is understandable that when the Covid-19 vaccine became available in December of 2020, some Black people may have had doubts about vaccine's safety and were hesitant to sign up for vaccinations. The results of a Pew study collected in 2020 before the availability of the Covid vaccine revealed that while 60% of Americans reported that they would get the vaccine--only 42% of Black people surveyed would do so. 16 Reasons for low participation in COVD vaccinations may be general medical mistrust and concerns about the how the vaccine was created. Unfortunately, racial disparity in clinical trial participants persisted in the Moderna and Pfizer-BioTech studies as the COVID vaccine was developed. For example, although 12.5 percent of the US population is Black, only 9% of the participants in both studies were Black. 17 Failure to include a representative sample in clinical trials may negatively impact the confidence that Black people and other people have about the safety and efficacy of the vaccine. In addition, some people were concerned that the vaccine production speed also meant that the vaccine was not well tested, and unanswered questions may have delayed vaccinations. As of January 2022, only 64% of Americans are fully vaccinated. 18 Of those vaccinated, it is estimated that only 10% are Black which is well below the 12% representation in the whole US population. 19 As broad vaccination of the population is a critical factor in ending this pandemic 20 , recognizing and addressing the underlying barriers for vaccine hesitancy is vital. Testing is another strategy to contain COVID-19; however, access to COVID testing for some Black people is yet another challenge. In some communities, testing is readily available, or if persons have insurance, they can receive testing at a multitude of settings. 11 In other communities, testing may be free, but the lines for testing may be long. For the client with any symptoms of COVID 19, it may be difficult to find a test location that will take a patient. Data about the impact of COVID 19 and pregnancy continues to evolve; however, it appears that the susceptibility rates to SARS CoV-2 during pregnancy mirrors the general population. Because SARS CoV-2 is overrepresented in the general population, however, it is overrepresented in the Black pregnant population. 21 For pregnant persons who contract COVID 19 during pregnancy, rates of pregnancy complications and unfavorable maternal outcomes are increased. 2 Pregnancy complications may include stillbirth, preterm birth, admission to ICU, and, J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f ventilatory support 22 although this finding is inconsistent between studies. 23 What is consistent in the literature is that pregnant patients, like non-pregnant patients, with co-morbidities such as obesity, diabetes, or hypertensive disorders are at greater risk for poor outcomes 22 should they contract Covid-19 during pregnancy. Adverse neonatal effects can be associated with maternal SARS-CoV2 infection 23 . Although the rates of vertical transmission from the birth person to the fetus is reported to be low, the transmission may occur. 24 The inflammatory response caused by SARS-CoV-2 may elicit an inflammatory response on the placenta, decreasing maternal-fetal blood flow. More studies are needed to understand COVID 19 on a pregnancy fully. However, it is noteworthy that the risk of a newborn contracting COVID 19 from the birthing person may be significantly reduced when the birthing person wears a mask and practices hand hygiene. 25 Black pregnant patients reported a higher rate of mental health diagnoses, including anxiety and stress, than White or Latino people 26 during pregnancy. Reasons for the increased anxiety and stress include exposure to racism and discrimination, concerns about the COVID 19 pandemic and the potential effects of COVID 19 on the fetus. In addition, a high level of anxiety and stress during pregnancy is associated with higher mortality. 26 Vaccination is the best defense again the SARS CoV-2 virus, however, pregnant patients have concerns, reported that pregnant and breastfeeding women were less likely than the general population to accept the COVID vaccine. 27 Concern over the impact of the vaccine was often cited as the reason for the hesitation. With the knowledge that the effects of COVID-19 will continue within the healthcare system for years to come, we offer recommendations ( Table 1) It is essential to provide clear, concise information about COVID 19 and transmission risks for vaccinated and unvaccinated. 28 Black women have frequently reported feeling unseen or unheard as they write concerning symptoms to their providers. Discuss the prenatal visit schedule and offer telehealth visits if possible. 29 Black women had the lowest completion of prenatal visits compared to Hispanic and white counterparts during covid. When pregnant women do not receive antepartum care, there is a greater risk of poor health outcomes for the birthing person and the fetus. Some Birthing Black persons may be working in the service industry, frontline workers, or caring for other family members, including small children. With the frequent surges of COVID-19, patients may miss appointments due to at-home care needs related to covid. Making telehealth visits available for patients when patients miss or need to cancel in-person visits provides ongoing provider communication and assessment. Ask if the client has any needed equipment at home, including urine dipsticks, a scale, or a blood pressure cuff. Offer the COVID vaccine at each visit, even if the vaccine has been refused in the past. 28 Discuss specific concerns about the vaccine if clients are hesitant. 27, 28 Given the current low vaccination rates for Black birthing persons, and Black persons living in the United States, it is essential to continue to offer the COVID-19 vaccine 28 Historical harms to the Black population may have propagated distrust, and patients may be hesitant about the efficacy and safety of the COVID-19 vaccine. The pregnant client may also be concerned about the effect of the vaccine on the fetus. 27, 28 Screen for postpartum depression. 26 When symptoms of anxiety and depression do present, patients should be referred for appropriate psychological services. Once those referrals are made, maternity care providers should follow up with the referral and patient. 26 Given the increased rates of anxiety and depression for Black birthing patients, providers should screen patients for depression early and often and make referrals when needed. Many of the concerns that patients share include worries about the birthing experience, the presence of the designated support person(s), and financial burdens. 30 Before the Pandemic, rates of depression in Black birthing persons were increased. The direct and indirect effects of Covid increased black pregnant patients vulnerable to COVID 19. Often, patients presenting with anxiety and depression fall in the gap of care to obtain psychological services. Black birthing patients need to be frequently screened informally or formally. 5 Preexisting comorbidities such as diabetes, hypertension, autoimmune disorders, or obesity increase the risk of severe Covid 19disease, and Black women are at increased risk for this disease. 22 Patients with pre-existing conditions like obesity, diabetes, and hypertension should be counseled about continued health maintenance of pre-existing conditions. Black pregnant clients are at increased risk for poor health outcomes during pregnancy and may need more frequent visits. 26 Consideration should be given for getting to in-person visits. Time away from work, transportation, or lack of childcare may make it challenging to attend visits. Internet access may not be reliable; therefore, it is essential to ensure the patient has access before setting up telehealth visits. Providers must self-educate on the harm that individual patients or families experienced when engaging the health care community. Providers should refrain from shame and bullying and partner with patients to address their concerns and barriers. Black women reported the lowest confidence in their care. 22 Encourage prenatal and postpartum doula services. 31 Continuous labor support has been shown to decrease the rate of cesarean birth and increase birth experience satisfaction. 31 Data points to the benefit and positive health outcomes when doulas are present for prenatal support, the birth experience, and postpartum care. Maternity care providers can encourage doulas and liaise with Black doulas to refer their patients. 31 Discuss support person for labor. Providers may recommend connecting with friends and family over zoom or more frequent phone calls. 32 There may be a limitation to the number of support persons allowed on the unit. Lower levels of social support are associated with higher levels of depression and anxiety during pregnancy. 32 Birth outcomes are improved with continuous labor support. Discussing the options beforehand allows the patient to decide who they want present. In some cases, a doula does not count in the visitor count. 31 There is no evidence to support that Covid is spread through breastmilk 22 If the birthing person delays breastfeeding initiation, there may be difficulties in milk production. Black people continue to experience a disproportionate burden of COVID 19. Despite the scientific knowledge that herd immunity may eradicate this deadly virus, the Black population remains significantly under-vaccinated. Lack of culturally appropriate education and a history of mistreatment but the healthcare community may contribute to vaccine hesitancy. Black pregnant women are already considered a vulnerable population because of the increased risk of morbidity and mortality in pregnancy are impacted to a greater extent during this pandemic. Pre-existing J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f morbidity and mortality rates and rates of depression, which were disproportionate before COVID are likely more prevalent now. Special considerations and additional screenings are warranted to ensure that this vulnerable population receives adequate and supportive care. Adopting these recommendations may improve perinatal for Black pregnant patients; however, each recommendation should be adopted for care for all pregnant patients long after this pandemic has passed. J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f A Tale of Two Crises: Addressing Covid-19 Vaccine Hesitancy as Promoting Racial Justice Black Workers Face Two of the Most Lethal Preexisting Conditions for Coronavirus-Racism and Economic Inequality Black-white differences in severe maternal morbidity and site of care Characteristics of Women of Reproductive Age with Laboratory-Confirmed SARS-CoV-2 Infection by Pregnancy Status -United States Continuous support for women during childbirth COVID-19 and Health Equity-A New Kind of "Herd Immunity COVID-19 Cases and Deaths by Race/Ethnicity: Current Data and Changes Over Time. Kaiser Family Foundation 2022 COVID-19 vaccination hesitancy in Hispanics and African-Americans: A review and recommendations for practice. Brain, Behavior, & Immunity -Health COVID-19 vaccine acceptance among pregnant, breastfeeding, and nonpregnant reproductive-aged women COVID-19: neonatal-perinatal perspectives Diverse patient perspectives on respect in healthcare: A qualitative study. Patient Education and Counseling Evaluation of rapid telehealth implementation for prenatal and postpartum care visits during the COVID -19 pandemic in an academic clinic in Factors Associated With Racial/Ethnic Group-Based Medical Mistrust and Perspectives on COVID-19 Vaccine Trial Participation and Vaccine Uptake in the US Failing Another National Stress Test on Health Disparities Fear That Masks Will Invite Racial Profiling Giving birth under lockdown during the COVID-19 epidemic Health Equity Considerations and Racial and Ethnic Minority Groups. Center for Diease Control Intent to Get a COVID-19 Vaccine Rise to 60% as Confidence in Research and Devlopment Process Increases. Pew Research Center Loneliness and Depressive Symptoms among Pregnant Black Women during the COVID-19 Pandemic Pregnancy and neonatal outcomes of COVID -19: coreporting of common outcomes from PAN-COVID and AAP-SONPM registries Pregnancy and Postpartum Challenges During COVID-19 for African-African Women Pregnancy Outcomes Among Women With and Without Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 Infection Race and Ethnic Disparities in Fetal Mortality, Preterm Birth, and Infant Mortality in the United States: An Overview Health, and COVID 19: The Views and Experiences of Black America. Key Findings from Eth KFF/Undefeated Survey on Race and Health Racial and ethnic disparities in severe maternal morbidity prevalence and trends Racial disparities in health among nonpoor African Americans and Hispanics: The role of acute and chronic discrimination Rethinking Bias to Achieve Maternal Health Equity: Changing Organizations Risk for Stillbirth Among Women With and Without COVID-19 at Delivery Hospitalization -United States Stress and coping among pregnant black women during the COVID-19 pandemic The Disproportionate Burden of the COVID-19 Pandemic Among Pregnant Black Women USA FACTS FDA Briefing Document Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine. Pfizer and BioNTech WHO Statement regarding cluster of pneumonia cases in Wuhan, China