key: cord-0969568-wdhp18th
authors: Løset, Ida Heitmann; Lægreid, Torgils; Rodakowska, Ewa
title: Dental Students’ Experiences during the COVID-19 Pandemic—A Cross-Sectional Study from Norway
date: 2022-03-06
journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health
DOI: 10.3390/ijerph19053102
sha: f28cd84dc953dbb2a0d57ecc2fa52d27737ca97c
doc_id: 969568
cord_uid: wdhp18th

The purpose of this cross-sectional study was to map dental students’ experience of the study situation throughout the pandemic. All clinical dental students (year 3 to 5) at the Faculty of Medicine, Department of Clinical Dentistry (IKO), University of Bergen (UiB), Norway, were invited. Participation was anonymous and voluntary, and the response rate was 63%. Questions regarding stress-related factors were divided into three categories. In the category «Stressors/learning», a statistically significant difference was observed between both the genders (p = 0.001) and years of study (p = 0.028). Statistically significant differences between the genders were also observed in the category «Stressors/infection» (p = 0.008). Women were significantly more stressed due to lack of clinical skills (p = 0.048), not receiving as good theoretical teaching as before the pandemic (p = 0.016), and uncertain issues around the exams (p = 0.000). Fourth year students were significantly more stressed due to lack of clinical skills (p = 0.012), for not passing the clinic/skills courses due to lack of study progression (p = 0.005), and worries about not being a good enough dentist after graduation (p = 0.002). In conclusion, the pandemic had a major impact on dental students. The most prominent stressors in relation to the study situation were experienced by students from the fourth year and female students. Clinical and theoretical learning outcomes among students were regarded as worse than before the pandemic. The students preferred in presence lectures, but experienced digital asynchronous video lectures as a good alternative. The pandemic negatively affected the students’ social life. Dental schools should be aware that students have been exposed to increased distress and burden through the pandemic and should provide support for those in need.

In the beginning of March 2020, the World Health Organization (WHO) declared the outbreak of COVID-19 as a pandemic [1] . Nobody expected that our professional and private life would change so significantly. The first applied restrictions in many countries aimed to slow down the spread of infection and to avoid overloading the capacity of the health care system. Universities, among other institutions and businesses, were closed down, and all traditional teaching had to be quickly converted into digital education.

Dental education is demanding, with a major part of practical training in addition to theoretical teaching. The dental students spend each year a lot of time with face-to-face teaching and hands-on practice to develop their manual dexterity and clinical skills. Dental students in Norway are among those students who spend the most time on their studies under normal circumstances (an average of 47-48 h per week) [2] . With the COVID-19 pandemic and the limitations entailed, the dental students lost a lot of time in the clinic and thus much hands-on training. Patient treatment was partially replaced by digital clinical seminars and assignments. Lectures were conducted on digital platforms, and there were changes in exam forms. To carry out scheduled activities, some semesters were extended at the expense of holidays.

At the beginning of the pandemic, a special infection control committee was established at the Department of Clinical Dentistry at the University of Bergen (UiB) to introduce reinforced infection control measures. These measures were continuously adjusted during the pandemic based on changes in the pandemic situation in Norway and the at any time applicable national guidelines. Reinforced infection control measures included no tolerance for attendance in the clinic with symptoms of respiratory infection for all patients, students, and staff. There was a general requirement for the use of face masks in all the department's premises and good hand hygiene, in addition to the use of extra infection control equipment during patient treatment.

Studies show that dental students in a normal setting experience much stress throughout their education [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] . The main sources of stress include workload, clinical requirements, assessments, and grades [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] . In the clinical part of the education, students need to perform treatment of patients to achieve good clinical skills and necessary study progression. At the dental educations in Norway, there are minimum clinical requirements that the students must meet to pass the clinical service. These stressors and demands can affect dental students' academic performance, psychological well-being, and physical health [3, 9] . Many studies published globally before the pandemic, showed a high incidence of depression, anxiety, and stress among dental students [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] .

The purpose of this study was to map dental students' experience of the study situation throughout the pandemic. We wanted to take a closer look at stressors present in the study situation during the pandemic and the students' learning experience to be better prepared for similar situations and draw conclusions for the future.

This was a cross-sectional study carried out between 17 March and 12 April in 2021. It was approved by the Regional Committee for Medical and Health Research Ethics (REK) (reference number 230726) in conformity with the Helsinki Declaration guidelines. All dental students at the Faculty of Medicine, Department of Clinical Dentistry (IKO), University of Bergen (UiB), Norway, who had started their clinical training (year 3 to 5) were invited to participate in the study (n = 134). Participation was both anonymous and voluntary. All the participants signed an informed consent prior to the access to the questionnaire. On the 17th of March 2021, an invitation was distributed via the digital learning platform MittUiB (Canvas) with a link to the questionnaire. It assured anonymity of all data.

The questionnaire was designed specifically for this study. It contained questions about gender and year of study, as well as sixteen questions that dealt with stress-related factors, six questions about learning experience, two questions about consequences, and two questions about social factors. Altogether, the questionnaire consisted of 28 questions, including 14 sub-questions. They were closed-ended in the form of multiple choice or Likert scale. The respondent could not proceed with the questionnaire until these questions had been answered. One question was open-ended and voluntary to answer. Our questionnaire was organized electronically with the use of the software SurveyXAct (Rambøll Management Consulting, Oslo, Norway). As a pilot, the questionnaire was tested on a group of volunteer students (n = 25). The participants were asked to give feedback on the questionnaire and after minor corrections, we prepared the final version. The answers to the open-ended question were presented graphically with the "Pro Word Cloud" (Orpheus Technology Ltd.: London, UK) extension in Microsoft ® Word.

The statistical analysis was performed using the IBM SPSS Statistics, Version 26.0 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA). A two-group t-test was used to examine mean differences between women and men, whereas a one-way ANOVA test was used to examine mean differences among third, fourth and fifth year students. Residuals were inspected to see if these followed a bell-shape in order that the mean value was sufficiently robust estimated. The significance level was set at 5% (p < 0.05).

The response rate was 63%. More women participated in the study and fourth year students were most represented. The demographic characteristics are presented in Table 1 . Table 2 presents questions regarding stress-related factors. Over 80% of the students reported that they had perceived more stress due to the study situation during the pandemic than before, but there were no significant differences between the genders or the years of study. Questions were divided into the following categories: «Stressors/learning», «Stressors/infection» and «Stressors/consequences». The sum score in the category "Stressors/learning" showed significant differences between both the genders (p = 0.001) and the years of study (p = 0.028). Moreover, significant difference between the genders was observed in the category «Stressors/infection» (p = 0.008). Women were significantly more stressed due to lack of clinical skills (p = 0.048), not receiving as good theoretical teaching as before the pandemic (p = 0.016) and uncertain issues around the exams (p = 0.000). In addition, women reported significantly more stress affecting their concentration (p = 0.019). Students in the fourth year were significantly more stressed due to lack of clinical skills (p = 0.012), for not passing the clinic/skills courses due to lack of study progression (p = 0.005), and worries about not being a good enough dentist after graduation (p = 0.002).

Another finding in this study was that most of the students preferred to go back to in presence (physical) lectures when the pandemic is over (Figure 1 ), followed by digital asynchronous video lectures.

Learning experience through the pandemic are presented in Table 3 . 60% of the students reported that the theoretical learning outcomes had been either worse or much worse during the pandemic, but there was no significant difference between the genders or the years of study. The male students in the fourth and fifth years experienced significantly poorer clinical learning outcomes than the females in the fourth and fifth years (p = 0.027). Another finding in this study was that most of the students preferred to go back to in presence(physical) lectures when the pandemic is over (Figure 1 ), followed by digital asynchronous video lectures. Learning experience through the pandemic are presented in Table 3 . 60% of the students reported that the theoretical learning outcomes had been either worse or much worse during the pandemic, but there was no significant difference between the genders or the years of study. The male students in the fourth and fifth years experienced significantly poorer clinical learning outcomes than the females in the fourth and fifth years (p = 0.027). The pandemic has negatively affected the students' social life, but there was no significant difference between the genders or the years of study. One in five students had considered quitting or applying for leave from their studies due to reasons related to the pandemic, or already did. The reasons mentioned by the students were uncertainty and stress because of the pandemic, little clinical training, a lot of absence due to quarantine/isolation, lack of social contact, and mental health. Figure 2 presents a word cloud for all comments on the open question. The word cloud is an overview of all keywords in the answers. All single words in the students' answers were summarized, and the most repetitive words are presented with the largest font size. Factors related to the clinical teaching were the most prominent stressors among the students. 

Medical, dental, and healthcare education are in general regarded as emotionally and academically demanding, and the prevalence of anxiety and depression is higher than in 

Medical, dental, and healthcare education are in general regarded as emotionally and academically demanding, and the prevalence of anxiety and depression is higher than in the general population [3, [9] [10] [11] . According to a meta-analysis of Quek et al., the prevalence of anxiety among medical students was 33.8%, whereas in the general population, did not exceed 25% depending on different surveys [10, 12, 13] . Moreover, Guse et al. showed that dental students were even more distressed than medical students during the pandemic [9] . Many factors influence this situation, among others the workload. The COVID-19 pandemic had a significant impact on our private and professional life, including education. Moreover, the pandemic situation was an additional stressor for the students. To our knowledge, this was the first study in Norway during the pandemic that focused on dental students' experiences of stressors related to the demanding study situation. The main findings of our study are the impact of the pandemic on fourth-year students and female students.

The strength of this study is the relatively high response rate, especially to the openended question (77%). This may indicate a clear engagement in the topic, and that it was important for the respondents to share thoughts. Another strength was that the questionnaire was produced specifically for this study. A frequently used questionnaire in other studies on dental students is the Dental Environmental Stress (DES) Questionnaire [3, 4, 14] . In our opinion, this questionnaire did not fit into the purpose of our study. On the other hand, this can cause a limitation because the findings are unique only for this sample and cannot be generalized to all dental schools and dental educations.

Most students in the present study had experienced more distress and burden during the pandemic, and this was mostly related to clinical teaching. Patient care is essential for developing technical skills required in the dental profession and this kind of teaching is difficult to digitize since it involves treatment of patients. In addition, the development of communicative abilities and empathy is another crucial part of the education that cannot easily be replaced by digital aids. Although there is a potential in the use of digital tools in dental/medical education, students are not always satisfied with this kind of teaching [15, 16] . Even if students highly accept remote teaching their manual dexterity is not developing [17] , and digital devices must be considered as a supplement [18, 19] .

The fourth year students experienced the most burdening learning situation. They were more concerned about lack of clinical skills compared with students in the third and fifth year. Students of the fourth year usually receive a considerable amount of clinical training during the academic year, but the pandemic situation affected this significantly. However, results from other dental educations in Europe showed no significant differences in terms of clinical factors between students in the clinical years [20, 21] . On the other hand, according to Zarzecka et al., fifth year students experienced significantly more stress than the second to fourth year students regarding «academic work» [21] . In general, it appears that students in the clinical part of the education experience more stress than students in the preclinical years [4, 20, 22] . Moreover, fourth year students were also concerned about proper study progression. Lack of study progression may have financial consequences.

Retaking one year can lead to lost income and increased student loans. Furthermore, students from the fourth year were worried about their professional future. They were worried about not being sufficiently trained as dentists when they graduate. This may be related to the fact that they had limited access to treat patients and, due to the pandemic, patients were cancelling their appointments.

Studies show that men and women respond differently to the experience of stress [23] [24] [25] [26] . Females often respond more emotionally to stress, whereas men tend to respond with aggression to severe stress [23, [27] [28] [29] . Moreover, cultural norms may influence the experience of stress [27, 28] . According to the literature, women are generally more prone to stress, anxiety, and depression than men [28, 30] . In the Students' Health and Well-being Survey (SHoT) [31] from 2021, 46% of the students on a national basis stated that they experienced stress as a health problem. The same survey also showed a significant increase in mental illness since the previous survey in 2018 (45% vs. 32%). The increase was most pronounced among female students [31] . Mekhemar et al. showed that dental students experienced up to mild anxiety, stress, and depression during the pandemic, and women were significantly more affected than men [32] . Nevertheless, there are studies showing that male students were affected significantly more by stressors [33] , whereas others are showing no statistical significance between gender regarding changes of mental health and worries about study situation and motivation [9] .

Additionally, our study showed that women were more stressed than men regarding stressors in the learning situation. This was consistent with Agius et al. [20] , who showed that female dental students experienced more concerns about exam changes and loss of manual skills than the male students during the pandemic. Other studies point out the loss of manual skills as the most prominent stressor among dental students [20, 34] . Furthermore, exam-related stress is also among the biggest stressors under normal circumstances [4] .

Most students in the present study wanted to return to in presence lectures after the pandemic. At the same time, a large proportion of the students thought that asynchronous video lectures were a good alternative to traditional lectures. On the other hand, synchronous lectures on., e.g., Zoom were less desirable among the students, and were consistent with results from another survey [35] . A noteworthy finding was that almost two out of three students were disappointed with the theoretical learning outcome compared with before the pandemic. This is in contrast to the results from Bunaes et al. earlier in the pandemic [36] . Digital teaching seems to be less engaging, and the students miss the contact with their fellow students [31] . This finding could also be related to impaired communication with the school [2, 21, 24] .

At the same time, students' social life was negatively affected during the pandemic due to distance requirements, closed social meeting places, and gyms. Uncertainty and insecurity related to pandemic may be the reasons for quitting or applying for leave from studies.

The pandemic had a major impact on dental students. The most pronounced stressors in relation to the study situation were experienced by students from the fourth year and female students. Clinical and theoretical learning outcomes among students were regarded as worse than before the pandemic. The students preferred in presence lectures, but experienced digital asynchronous video lectures as a good alternative. The pandemic negatively affected the students' social life. Dental schools should be aware that students have been exposed to increased distress and burden through the pandemic and should provide support for those who are in need. Acknowledgments: Many thanks to Stein Atle Lie for statistical advice, Sissel Vågenes for administrative support, and to all the students who participated in our survey.

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

World Health Organization. WHO Director-General's Opening Remarks at the Media Briefing on COVID-19-11

A systematic review of stress in dental students

Stress amongst dental students: A systematic review

Depression, anxiety and stress in a cohort of Australian dentistry students

Alhassan, A. Depression, anxiety and stress in dental students

Stress, burnout and health in the clinical period of dental education

Psychological Functioning of Patients Undergoing Oral Surgery Procedures during the Regime Related with SARS-CoV-2 Pandemic

Mental burden and perception of the study situation among undergraduate students during the COVID-19 pandemic: A cross-sectional study and comparison of dental and medical students

The Global Prevalence of Anxiety Among Medical Students: A Meta-Analysis

Evaluation of Effectiveness of Digital Technologies During Anatomy Learning in Nursing School

The short-form version of the Depression Anxiety Stress Scales (DASS-21): Construct validity and normative data in a large non-clinical sample

Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HAD): Some psychometric data for a Swedish sample

Sources of stress in the dental school environment

Dental Education Challenges during the COVID-19 Pandemic Period in Italy: Undergraduate Student Feedback, Future Perspectives, and the Needs of Teaching Strategies for Professional Development

Distance learning in clinical medical education amid COVID-19 pandemic in Jordan: Current situation, challenges, and perspectives

Remote Teaching in a Preclinical Phantom Course in Operative Dentistry During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Observational Case Study

Digital Undergraduate Education in Dentistry: A Systematic Review

Virtuelle virkelighetssimulatorer som pedagogisk hjelpemiddel i odontologisk utdanning. Nor

Self-reported dental student stressors and experiences during the COVID-19 pandemic

Dental environmental stress during the COVID 19 pandemic at the Jagiellonian University Medical College

Psychological stress and health in undergraduate dental students: Fifth year outcomes compared with first year baseline results from five European dental schools

Biobehavioral responses to stress in females: Tend-and-befriend, not fight-or-flight

Evolving Knowledge of Sex Differences in Brain Structure, Function, and Chemistry

Why sex matters for neuroscience

Sex differences in anxiety and depression clinical perspectives

The Influence of Gender and Year of Study on Stress Levels and Coping Strategies among Polish Dental

The Effect of Gender on Stress Factors: An Exploratory Study among University Students

Effects of masculine identity and gender role stress on aggression in men

Sex differences in HPA axis responses to stress: A review

Studentenes Helse-og Trivselsundersøkelse (SHoT)

Dental Students in Germany throughout the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Psychological Assessment and Cross-Sectional Survey

Perceived sources and levels of stress, general self-efficacy and coping strategies in preclinical dental students

Impact of COVID-19 on dental education in Europe: The students' perspective

Et Akademisk Annerledesår: Konsekvenser og Håndtering av Koronapandemien ved Norske Universiteter og Høgskoler; NIFU-Rapport 2021:9; Nordisk Institutt for Studier av Innovasjon

Fra fysisk til digital undervisning