key: cord-0967675-9gwojf2b
authors: Ayanlade, Ayansina; Nwayor, Isioma J.; Sergi, Consolato; Ayanlade, Oluwatoyin S.; Di Carlo, Paola; Jeje, Olajumoke D.; Jegede, Margaret O.
title: Early warning climate indices for malaria and meningitis in tropical ecological zones
date: 2020-08-31
journal: Sci Rep
DOI: 10.1038/s41598-020-71094-8
sha: 3f25c054ce5c53d5e9a546f226aa9dc5d7a2eadf
doc_id: 967675
cord_uid: 9gwojf2b

This study aims at assessing the impacts of climate indices on the spatiotemporal distribution of malaria and meningitis in Nigeria. The primary focus of the research is to develop an Early Warning System (EWS) for assessing climate variability implications on malaria and meningitis spread in the study area. Both climate and health data were used in the study to determine the relationship between climate variability and the occurrence of malaria and meningitis. The assessment was based on variations in different ecological zones in Nigeria. Two specific sample locations were randomly selected in each ecological zone for the analysis. The climatic data used in this study are dekadal precipitation, minimum and maximum temperature between 2000 and 2018, monthly aerosol optical depth between 2000 and 2018. The results show that temperature is relatively high throughout the year because the country is located in a tropical region. The significant findings of this study are that rainfall has much influence on the occurrence of malaria, while temperature and aerosol have more impact on meningitis. We found the degree of relationship between precipitation and malaria, there is a correlation coefficient R(2) ≥ 70.0 in Rainforest, Freshwater, and Mangrove ecological zones. The relationship between temperature and meningitis is accompanied by R(2) ≥ 72.0 in both Sahel and Sudan, while aerosol and meningitis harbour R(2) = 77.33 in the Sahel. The assessment of this initial data seems to support the finding that the occurrences of meningitis are higher in the northern region, especially the Sahel and Sudan. In contrast, malaria occurrence is higher in the southern part of the study area. In all, the multiple linear regression results revealed that rainfall was directly associated with malaria with β = 0.64, p = 0.001 but aerosol was directly associated with meningitis with β = 0.59, p < 0.001. The study concludes that variability in climatic elements such as low precipitation, high temperature, and aerosol may be the major drivers of meningitis occurrence.

www.nature.com/scientificreports/ in many Sub-Saharan African countries is the periodic epidemics of malaria, which is common in the area with poorly developed immunity to malaria. Malaria is a significant public health problem in many Sub-Saharan African countries, with nearly 200 million clinical episodes and almost one million deaths occurring annually 26, 29 . Meningitis occurs mostly during the warmer months between February and April, with its significant effect on a large number of people in cycles of 8 to 12 years 30 . Besides, studies have reported that hot deserts storm increases the risk of meningitis in Africa, especially in the Sahel region of West Africa which is immediately after the Sahara desert 31, 32 . Many of the recent studies have reported the need for climate information, as an interdisciplinary approach, for better public health action [33] [34] [35] . The health decision-makers gradually search for a better understanding of the climate as it relates to public health [36] [37] [38] [39] . Consequently, understanding variability and changes in climatic indices are essential for a proper evaluation of their impacts on human health. The relationship between climatic indices and the epidemics remain inconclusively investigated [40] [41] [42] . The change in the MM epidemics over different ecology ecological is a significant gap. For this reason, this study aims at examining the relationship between variability in climatic indices: (precipitation, temperature, and aerosol) and the occurrences of malaria and meningitis across tropical ecological zones in Nigeria. The study is based upon the assumption that climate does not only define the seasonal and spatial distribution of MM, but it also influences the inter-annual variability of MM epidemics and their long term trends 15, [43] [44] [45] . As a consequence, climate variability is now an issue of concern for health policy in many countries because the total number of people at risk, the age structures of the population and the density of the settlement are essential variables in determining the socio-economic development at any country 46-48 . Materials and methods the study area. This study involves different ecological zones in Nigeria (Fig. 1 ). Nigeria is a tropical country located approximately between 4°N and 14°N latitudes and 3°E and 14°E longitudes in West Africa, covering a total area of about 923,768 sq. Km. Cameroon, Niger Republic, and Republic of Benin border the country in the East, North, and West, respectively (Fig. 1) , while Nigeria is surrounded by the Gulf of Guinea (Atlantic Ocean) in the south 49 . The study area experiences abundant rainfall accompanied by convectional storms, having annual precipitation of about 15,000 mm and a mean minimum temperature between 18 °C and 36 °C. In the north, the mean temperature is higher compared to the west and south, where the temperature is curbed by the influence of rainfall, which reduces northward over the country. The seasonality of climate is influenced by the variability of the Inter-Tropical Convergence Zones (ITCZ) across the country. The ITCZ is formed by the actions of the north-easterly and south-westerly air masses 50 . The study sites are the six typical ecological zones in this country, transiting in the north-south direction from the fringe of Sahel savannah to the Atlantic coast. These are the Sahel Savannah, Sudan Savannah, Guinea Savannah, Rainforest, Freshwater, and the Mangrove swamp. Rainfall per annum varies in these ecological zones, from as high as 3000 mm in the Mangrove swamp to about 500 mm in the Sahel savannah.

Data acquisition. Satellite climatology data was used in this study. The climatic data used in this study were retrieved satellite observation, including precipitation, minimum and maximum temperature from January 2000 to December 2018, and aerosol optical depth from January 2000 to December 2018. These data were used to Two locations were purposefully sampled per ecological zone as in the red points. The figure was generated using ArcGIS 10.5 software (https ://www.esri.com/). develop climate indices for the early warning system for MM in Nigeria. Satellite climatology dataset acquired from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) while the International Research Institute for Climate and Society (IRI), New York provides the initial training on satellite data acquisition and climate data analysis. Both kinds of satellites are necessary for providing a complete global weather monitoring system. A different set of data used includes the Moderate Radiometer Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS-Terra and Aqua) and dekadal (10-day) precipitation estimates from the Climate Prediction Center. The data were made freely available on the IRI web. The data for each climate variable were downloaded from IRI web. https ://iridl .ldeo.colum bia.edu/mapro om/Healt h/Regio nal/Afric a/Malar ia/Syste m.html. MODIS, an imaging instrument that flies on two satellites in NASA's (National Aeronautics and Space Administration) Earth Observing System. Some of the characteristics of MODIS are; Spatial resolution: 250 m (bands 1-2), 500 m (bands 3-7), 1000 m (bands 8-36), temporal resolution: 1 to 2 days in 36 discrete spectral bands. NOAA has the following abilities that are essential for early warning system: Improved short-term warning and forecasting services, forecasting climate trends and changes. The major benefit of these datasets is that satellite observation data can be used for global analysis beyond the study area; it also provides a good spatial and temporal resolution across Nigeria.

For practical evaluation, both climatic data and epidemic (malaria and meningitis) were analysed. Data from MODIS databases were assessed. The analysis of climate indices was carried out using dekadal precipitation and precipitation estimate percentages. The MM data covers the period 2000 to 2018 such as climate data. The MM cases were summed over two age groups (under and over 5 years). Some of the datasets were updated with the dataset from the Nigerian National Bureau of Statistics (NBS), with monthly MM data and regional informations. The NBS generates all set of statistics for the country on a continuous and sustainable basis. Each ecological zone is a vast area covering more than two states. Thus two locations were purposefully sampled per environmental zone. Since the data is used for research only and involving no human participants, permission to use the data was granted by NBS.

In this study, other climatic variables such as relative humidity and wind speed were applied. The principal climate variables usually considered are concerning rainfall, temperature, aerosol, wind speed, and humidity 52 . The specific rainfall indices which were used in this present study are primarily based on the work by Nigussie and Altunkaynak 53 and Muluneh, et al. 54 . 7 days were adopted, which have highest adequate precipitation during a consecutive 14-days period, and highest adequate precipitation during the following 30-days period. In the present study, we categorized a "rain-day" as a period of twenty-four hours with total rainfall equal to or greater than the minimum measurable amount and a "dry-day" as a period of twenty-four hours with no rainfall. The critical temperature indices used in this study were based on Rahimi and Hejabi 55 . The temperature indices used included daily mean temperature, mean daily maximum temperature, mean daily minimum temperature, maximum consecutive days with daily maximum temperature above 15 °C in days, and warm/hot nights frequency: percentage of days when daily minimum temperature (TN) 90th percentile. Calculation of percentage occurrence of climate conditions suitable for the transmission of MM was initiated based on climate indices. Descriptive statistical techniques were adopted; maps and charts were developed to show the estimate and trend of climatic indices, which includes precipitation, aerosols optical depth, and maximum and minimum temperature. The pattern of these climatic indices was compared with MM dataset to show the relationship between the diseases and climatic indices. An Early Warning System (EWS) model was developed to project the possibility of MM occurring at specific periods of climatic extremes. Numerous climate indices had been projected for climate change, and it impacts on health 51 . The annual cases of MM from health facilities in sampled local government areas of Nigeria were used in a novel stratification process. The aerosols-optical depth suspended in the atmosphere influenced by the action of wind and precipitation/ITCZ in Nigeria was estimated. Studies have provided threshold that specific indices are estimated on the outbreak and prevalence of MM at a particular location. Concerning malaria, limits are assumed as average precipitation more significant than 80 mm, temperature ranging from 18 °C and 32 °C, and relative humidity (RH > 60%) 56 . Meningitis, on the other hand, seems to prevail with high temperature, high aerosol, and a threshold of dryness reaching 40% 20,57 . In the present study, the probability of the occurrence of MM concerning climate variability was further estimated as the "early warning system". Probability analysis was based on observations of meningitis events, the Meningitis Forecasting for Africa Project (MFAP), as presented in IRI web https ://iridl .ldeo.colum bia.edu/SOURC ES/. LSTM/.MFAP/.moles worth _etal_2003/searc hes.html?bbox=bb%3A0.250%3A2.361%3A14.849%3A14.291%3 Abb . MFAP is an investigate model meningitis events or probability that leads forecast of meningitis occurrence. Details information about MFAP were reported by Molesworth et al. 58 . MFAP demonstrates the probability of meningitis occurrence and changes as climatic indicators changes over different ecological zones. The model present the probability rates of meningitis epidemic experience for each ecological zones.

To assess the relationship between climatic indices and the epidemic of infectious diseases understudy, a correlation analysis was performed. Spearman correlation coefficient (R 2 ) was used to estimate the relationship between precipitation, and aerosol with MM in the six major points from each ecological zones. Multivariable regression was carried out to investigate the relationship between the MM and each climatic variable. The choice of the multivariate regression analysis was started by examining the nature of the variables used in the study, using Quantile-Quantile (Q-Q) plots. It is clear from the Q-Q plots that the outcome is continuous and follows a normal distribution with a positive slope. Since the Q-Q plots indicated that the outcome variable followed a normal distribution, a multiple linear regression model was therefore used. The multiple linear regression models were based on Eq. (1): www.nature.com/scientificreports/ where y is the malaria/meningitis, x is the climatic variables (x 1 = rainfall, x 2 = temperature , x 3 = aerosol), and β is the coefficient for each climatic variables respectively. During multivariate regression analysis, the interrelationships among all climatic variables were also taken into account to assess the significant impacts of each climatic variable on MM. The R Squared was used as the proportion of variability in the MM which can be explained by the climatic variables in the model.

The result from this research shows three significant findings: (1) occurrence of Climatic Indices vary across ecological zones; (2) the Climatic Index with the most considerable influence on the appearance and spread of malaria is precipitation; and (3) with regard to meningitis, temperature and aerosol are the most significant climate indices. Although during initial analysis, we applied other climatic variables such as relative humidity, wind speed, we find out their relationship is very weak, but the initial test revealed rainfall, temperature, and aerosol were significantly associated with MM (p < 0.01). Variations in climatic indices in the ecological zone are noticeable from dry to wet seasons (Table 1 ). In general, the mean monthly temperature ranges from 29 °C to 42 °C in all ecological zones, but much more high in the Sahel and Sudan (Fig. 2) . The temperature is at its highest (≥ 30 °C) during the dry seasons (Table 1) , which are the months from January to March in all the ecological zones (Fig. 2) . Most of the months of the year, in both Sahel and Sudan, are hot and dry with maximal temperatures rising as high as 40 °C (Fig. 2B ) especially during the month of the dry season (Table 1) . During the peak of dry season, especially the months of February and March, the mean monthly temperature ranges between 36 °C and 42 °C in both Sahel and Sudan. The average low temperatures are observed during the months of June, July and August with temperature ranges from 25 to 31 °C (Fig. 2B ) in both Sahel and Sudan, however, lower mean monthly temperatures are observed in other ecological zones, about 3 to 5 °C lower (Table 1 ). In all ecological zones, precipitation varies from season to season, but it is more pronounced in the Sahel zone with the lowest rainfall (Table 1 and Fig. 2) . However, the precipitation appears much more in Rainforest, Freshwater, and Mangrove zones with the peaks in June, July, and August ( Fig. 2A) . The Sahel zone is a dry land in the Northern part of the study area, with a short rainy season months ( Fig. 2A ) compared to the Southern region (Rainforest, Freshwater and Mangrove zones), where rainfall is abundant (> 200 mean monthly value) due to the influence of the Atlantic Ocean bordering Nigeria at the south that increases the moisture of the air and causes rain to fall. In both Sahel and Sudan ecological zones, the mean monthly rainfall is very low compared to other zones, with annual rainfall ranges between 100 and 300 mm, and mostly rains during three to six months ( Fig. 2A) , while the other months may be very dry < 50 mm and some time nor rainfall at all. Generally, the mean monthly rainfall are higher Rainforest, Freshwater and Mangrove zone compared Sahel and Sudan (Table 1 and Fig. 2A ) .

The mean monthly amount of aerosol optical depth (AOD) varies from one ecological zone to the others (Fig. 2C) . Monthly distribution of aerosol in Sahel savannah is at peak in February and extends to April, 0.40 ≤ AOD ≥ 0.5 (Fig. 2C) . Likewise, Sudan Savannah shows a similar trend with Sahel Savannah 0.40 ≤ AOD ≥ 0.5. The disparity with Guinea Savannah and the Sudan Savannah begins (wet season) in April, there is a slight increase in AOD, while May to December experience a more considerable variation than Sahel and Sudan savannah (Table 1 and Fig. 2 ). In the Rainforest zone, the highest AOD is in April followed by February, while the lowest amount is in the wet season (Table 1) , during the month of June to August with 0.1 ≥ AOD ≥ 0.3 (Fig. 2C) . The Freshwater ecological zones share a similar occurrence of AOD with the Rainforest ecological zone. The monthly and seasonal distribution of atmospheric aerosols varied over the different ecological zones 59 . It is obvious that the distributions of atmospheric aerosols reflect the climate seasonality. Largely, the observed variations in climatic indices reveal high rainfall during the wet season, with relatively low temperature and low aerosol, whereas there appear to be inverse values during the dry season (Table 1) .

Climate indices and their influences on malaria and meningitis (prevalence/incidence) in different ecological zones. The results of this study reveal that the distribution patterns of temperature occurrences across the ecological zones in Nigeria are distinct (Fig. 3) . In Sahel savanna, the temperature decreases from April to June, while the other months display a quite variable temperature amount (Fig. 3A) . Sudan savanna indicates a slight dissimilarity in temperature when compared to Sahel savanna and the temperature is www.nature.com/scientificreports/ relatively high and stable throughout the year with a slight decrease in April (Fig. 3B) . The temperature distribution appears the same across the other ecological zones: Guinea savanna, Rainforest, Freshwater, and Mangrove, with a 100% occurrence throughout the year (Fig. 3C-F) . The reason for this scenario is apparent. The ecological zones are within the tropical region of the world with little variation in temperature over the year. On the other hand, the precipitation appears more variable across ecological zones with a few anomalies (Figs. 3, 4) . Mangrove and Freshwater ecological zones represent the location with much precipitation with rainfall periods spread from May to October. Despite the high precipitation in these regions, November to March exhibit the lowest amount of rainfall (Fig. 3E,F) . In the Sahel Savannah precipitation occurs only from May to September, while the other months experience little or no rain (Fig. 4A) . Though the Sudan falls directly below the Sahel savannah, precipitation occurrence is relatively higher than in the Sahel savannah, and precipitation occurs from May to October (Fig. 4B) . The Guinea savanna experiences a significant amount of variation in the distribution of climate indices, and the ITCZ falls within this region before it is pushed southwards by the north-easterly wind. Precipitation occurrence in the Guinea savannah starts in March and ends in October with the highest amount occurring in June and September (Fig. 4D) . The results (Figs. 3D, 4D) shows the rate of precipitation in Rainforest, rainfall is predominant from February to December, the early and late months of the year which are the dry seasons of Nigeria from November to February are the months with the lowest amount of precipitation. The percent occurrences of climate conditions suitable for malaria transmission compare the rate of precipitation, and the corresponding amount of rainfall in each ecological zone are presented in Fig. 4 . Each ecological zone shows a distinct rate of malaria transmission. Precipitation is higher in the southern region of Nigeria than in the north, and this is due to the movement of moisture-laden air mass generated from the Atlantic Ocean in the south. For the first three ecological zones in the north: Sahel Savannah, Sudan Savannah and Guinea Savannah, the percent occurrence of climates conditions suitable for malaria transmission is relatively lower (Fig. 4A-C) than the southern part of Nigeria: Rainforest, Freshwater and Mangrove (Fig. 4D-F) . The results of the climate indicator and suitable for malaria transmission also revealed variations for each location (Fig. 5) . The pattern of malaria transmission in Fig. 4 shows disparity throughout the ecological zones, the months suitable for malaria transmission are more in the south than in the north (Fig. 5) . In Sahel savannah down to Guinea savannah, the months ideal for the transmission of malaria ranges between 1 to 5 months. The case in southern Nigeria is quite different as the months ideal for malaria transmission range between 5 to 9 months (Fig. 5) . The reasons for this variation are obvious in each ecological zones, there is variation in the distribution of climatic indices for each season. Different ecological zones have a varied amount of temperature and precipitation (Table 1 ). Generally, Table 2 . What is evident from the results is that malaria exhibits the strongest correlation with precipitation. The results imply that as precipitation increases, the breeding ground for adult mosquitos' expand 5 . Meningitis is most affected by dust (aerosol). The influence of temperature on meningitis is most prominent in the Sahel with a Spearman correlation coefficient R 2 = 78. 45 . The influence of temperature on malaria is indeed relatively prominent in Sudan with a correlation co-efficient R 2 = 34.88, and this means that the temperature has a stronger impact www.nature.com/scientificreports/ on meningitis than malaria, i.e., the higher the temperature, the more the prevalence of meningitis (Table 2) . There is a strong positive relationship between rainfall and malaria, with a correlation coefficient R 2 = 71.34 and 73.56 in Mangrove swamp and Freshwater respectively in the south and a moderate association in the north (R 2 = 67.45). There is a weak positive relationship between rainfall and meningitis in all ecological zones, with the highest and lowest correlation coefficient R 2 of 24.32 and 10.32 in Sudan and Mangrove swamp respectively. Thus this data means that the rainfall does not have a significant influence on meningitis transmission. The relationship between malaria and temperature is positively weak, with the highest and lowest correlation coefficient R 2 = 34.88 and 21.88 in Sudan and Mangrove, respectively. In the Sahel, Sudan and Guinea, meningitis has a strong correlation with temperature R 2 = 78.45, 73.23 and 65.01 respectively ( Table 2 ). The temperature in the north is always higher than the south, the north-easterly originating from the Sahara desert blows diagonally over these ecological zones. Table 2 , the dust has a strong correlation with meningitis: Sahel, Sudan, and Guinea indicate a correlation coefficient R 2 = 77.33, 62.11, and 53.89, respectively. In comparing the impacts of climate indices on malaria and meningitis, it was found that rainfall was directly associated (Table 3) with malaria (p = 0.001) and aerosol directly associated with meningitis (p < 0.001). The www.nature.com/scientificreports/ results presented in Table 3 imply that rainfall has the strongest impact on malaria occurrence in the study area while aerosol has the strongest impact on meningitis. In contrast, rainfall has the least impact on meningitis. It is obvious that there is a significant linear relationship between climatic indices and malaria/meningitis. Rainfall is significantly and positively related to malaria (p < 0.01), while temperature (p < 0.01) and aerosol (p < 0.01) are significantly and positively related to meningitis ( Table 3 ). The results further revealed that the response variable fits the criteria with the R 2 = 0.695 (Table 3 ). This implies that climatic factors explain about 70% of variations in malaria/meningitis occurrence in different ecological zones. This is the percentage of variation in the response that is explained by the model, thus the response variable fits the criteria. However, comparing the impacts of climatic variables, the coefficients reveal that rainfall has the strongest impact on malaria prevalence while temperature and aerosol have the strongest impacts on meningitis incidence but low impacts on malaria incidence ( Table 3 ). The reasons for this scenario is very clear, the malaria parasites develop only within a certain temperature range, where the minimum temperature for parasite development lies between 14.5 °C and 15 °C in the cases of P. vivax and between 16 °C and 19 °C for P. falciparum, while the proportion of parasites surviving decreases rapidly at temperatures over 32-34 °C 28,60,61 . However, aerosol has the least impact on malaria prevalence with p < 0.10, similarly temperature has strongest impact on malaria prevalence with p < 0.01 (Table 3 ). The results imply that the amount of aerosol couple with the intensity of temperature in a particular ecological zone influences the transmission of meningitis 21, 57 . Table 4 further illustrates the probability rates of meningitis epidemic experience for each ecological zones. (Table 4 ). Likewise, aerosol shows many relationships with meningitis, especially in the northern ecological compared to other zones. The result implies that meningitis is likely to occur in the months with high dust, while for the months with the lowest distribution of aerosol, meningitis will be at the lowest. These data stressed the comment of Mueller, who hypothesizes that low www.nature.com/scientificreports/ air humidity and high aerosol load influenced nasopharyngeal colonization and the number of asymptomatic Neisseria meningitidis, often commonly referred to as meningococcus, carriers 24 . In general, the epidemic of meningitis depends on the prevalence of carriage in the population. Therefore, climate change via the route of transmission influenced the trend of meningitis. Earlier Studies revealed that variations in temperature and aerosols have significant impacts on the meningitis occurrences 57, 62, 63 . The study revealed that the cases of meningitis would increase by 6 and 9 for every increase of 1 °C in temperature 63 . The present study, accordingly, revealed that meningitis occur during the dry season with the high temperature 21, 64 , and the presence of dust (aerosols) also affect the probability of meningitis occurring 57 . This is obvious as meningitis is a transmittable disease with bacteria that are readily transferred from one person to the other 65 . It is thus thought the seasonality of meningitis is related to increased invasiveness of the pathogen rather than from person to person transmission and the invasiveness of this pathogen is widely determined by climate, which includes dust, extreme dryness and host's mucosal defences 62, 66 .

Limitations of the present study are apparent. Besides the nature of the analysis, in terms of simple correlation analysis, there is high likelihood of other confounding factors that may affect MM. The factors affecting MM epidemics or distribution cannot be limited to climate alone. There are non-climatic factors, whether directly or indirectly, that have a significant relationship with the occurrence of these epidemics. These factors that affect malaria include irrigation, agricultural practices and other land use practices 1, 67 . According to Lindblade et al. 67 , the impacts of land use change on malaria transmission in the south-western highlands of Uganda, and that increased temperatures are responsible for elevated malaria transmission risk in cultivated areas. The migration of non-immune people creates an environment for the epidemic. These areas are unplanned, and poor people live in unsanitary condition. This creates the right environment for getting malaria. Urbanization increases both malaria and meningitis, the overpopulation in urban centres which causes a rapid transmission of the diseases, aerosols are generated more in urban centres, and there is a higher probability of having water-logging areas especially in unplanned urban centres that increase the breeding of mosquitoes 68, 69 . Also, Irrigation can increase the transmission season of malaria. Irrigation is created by building large numbers of dams and canals which often cause seepages from carnal and the rise in the water table, thus creating a source of still water in which malaria vectors can breed 70, 71 . Dry regions require moisture to carry out agricultural practices, so pipes and drains are created to move water to the farm-sites. Leaks in the pipes and tubes rupture create artificial water bodies which serve as a breeding ground for mosquitoes, and this seems to be contradictory to meningitis occurrence, because meningitis is predominant in dry regions due to the presence of aerosols. This present study concluded that accessibility to climate information 33, 72 , healthcare facilities with adequate health provision is a fundamental determinate for better health care at instance of climate change and prevalence of the outbreaks will be minimal.

The seasonal prevalence of malaria and meningitis in different ecological zones of Nigeria were examined in this study. The major findings of this study is that the climatic indices have significant influence on the event and spread of MM. Because of the nature of it variability or rainfall in amount and intensity in different ecological zones, rainfall is considered to be one of the significant factors influencing variability in malaria transmission, only because it provides a breeding site for mosquitoes (malaria vector) to lay their eggs and ensure a suitable humid condition to prolong the mosquito survival. Temperature determines the ability of mosquitoes to survive as they cannot survive under extreme temperature conditions. Aerosols, which consist of dust, gases, water vapor determines meningitis prevalence to no small extent. The climatic variable that has the most substantial influence on meningitis is aerosol. But, the prevalence of malaria is higher in the south than in the north; the reason for this is that there is more precipitation in the south than in the north of Nigeria.

The influence of several climatic variables on worldwide droplets-transmitted diseases such as meningitis are discussed in multiple geographical areas such as African area 40, 57, 73 . Still, Wang et al 74 have outlined as wind speed and changes in tails of the distribution are crucial for understanding the winds' influence on dust emission. In the present study, we showed as meningitis transmission is significantly influenced by dust (aerosol) but not always by rainfall. Recently, the comparison between Italian city with low and high wind speed as coast city that are exposed to consistent winds suggesting as the air pollution and meteorological condition have influenced SARS-CoV-2 transmission and among these variables also wind speed should be considered 75 . In a not yet peerreviewed paper, Coccia delineates that the accelerate and vast diffusion of COVID-19 in Northern Italy has a high association with air pollution and hinterland cities have average days of exceeding the limits set for PM10 equal to 80 days, while coastal cities have days of exceeding the limits set for PM10 equal to 60 days. Remarkably, the average number of COVID-19 infections was more than 2,000 individuals as of April 1st, 2020 in the hinterland cities, while the average number of these infections was about 700 in the coastal cities 75,76 . Coccia's 75 data further point to two key mechanisms including the air pollution-to-human transmission and the humanto-human transmission to explain his data. He suggests that to minimize future epidemic similar to COVID-19, the max number of days per year in which cities can exceed the limits set for PM10 or for ozone should be less than 50 days. Therefore, we suggest that precipitation, temperature and aerosol are significant climatic drivers that must be considered in predicting the occurrence and migration of human disease such as malaria and meningitis.

Malaria risk and temperature: influences from global climate change and local land use practices

Adequacy of TRMM satellite rainfall data in driving the SWAT modeling of Tiaoxi catchment

IEEE International Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium

Investigating flash floods potential areas using ASCAT and TRMM satellites in the Western Cape Province, South Africa

Pregnancy outcomes in women with or without placental malaria infection

Impact of climate change on global malaria distribution

An empirical perspective for understanding climate change impacts in Switzerland

Evaluation of five satellite products for estimation of rainfall over Uganda/Evaluation de cinq produits satellitaires pour l' estimation des précipitations en Ouganda

A review of merged high-resolution satellite precipitation product accuracy during the Tropical Rainfall Measuring Mission (TRMM) era

Accuracy of TRMM precipitation data in the southwest monsoon region of China

Assessment of TRMM rainfall data (2001-2015) over the Indian region

Tuberculosis evolution and climate change: how much work is ahead?

Seasonal variation of malaria parasite density in paediatric population of north eastern Nigeria

Intra-annual climate variability and malaria transmission in Nigeria

Seasonal Forecasts, Climatic Change and Human Health

Preparing for the health impacts of climate change in Indigenous communities: the role of community-based adaptation

Climate change and the resurgence of malaria in the East African highlands

Climate change and malaria: analysis of the SRES climate and socioeconomic scenarios

Perceptions and Management of Cerebro-spinal Meningitis in the Kassena-Nankana East and West Districts

A geo-informatics technique for the management of meningitis epidemic distributions in northern Nigeria

Temperature triggers immune evasion by Neisseria meningitidis

Temperature, relative humidity and sunshine may be the effective predictors for occurrence of malaria in

Hydrological simulation using TRMM and CHIRPS precipitation estimates in the lower Lancang-Mekong river basin

Evaluating precipitation estimates from Eta, TRMM and CHRIPS data in the south-southeast region of Minas Gerais State-Brazil

Gaps in the childhood malaria burden in Africa: cerebral malaria, neurological sequelae, anemia, respiratory distress, hypoglycemia, and complications of pregnancy

An online operational rainfall-monitoring resource for epidemic malaria early warning systems in Africa

Climate change unlikely to increase malaria burden in West Africa

Raised temperatures over the Kericho tea estates: revisiting the climate in the East African highlands malaria debate

The global distribution of clinical episodes of Plasmodium falciparum malaria

Meningitis (Twenty-First Century Books

Desert dust impacts on human health: an alarming worldwide reality and a need for studies in West Africa

Climate information for public health action: an interdisciplinary approach

Sub-Seasonal to Seasonal Prediction

Effects of climate change on malaria morbidity and mortality in Taraba State

Use of rainfall and sea surface temperature monitoring for malaria early warning in Botswana

Childhood malaria case incidence in Malawi between 2004 and 2017: spatio-temporal modelling of climate and non-climate factors

Climate and health damages from global concrete production

Preventing and mitigating health risks of climate change

Climate drives the meningitis epidemics onset in West Africa

Relationships between climate and year-to-year variability in meningitis outbreaks: a case study in Burkina Faso and Niger

Malaria early warnings based on seasonal climate forecasts from multi-model ensembles

The association between temperature, rainfall and humidity with common climate-sensitive infectious diseases in Bangladesh

Review of climate change and health in Ethiopia: status and gap analysis

Satellite earth observation data in epidemiological modeling of malaria, dengue and West Nile virus: a scoping review

Global climate projections. Climate change 2007: the physical science basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment

A human health perspective on climate change: a report outlining the research needs on the human health effects of climate change

Health implications of climate change: a review of the literature about the perception of the public and health professionals

Variability in atmospheric aerosols and effects of humidity, wind and InterTropical discontinuity over different ecological zones in Nigeria

Rainfall variability and drought characteristics in two agro-climatic zones: an assessment of climate change challenges in Africa

Energy, poverty, and health in climate change: a comprehensive review of an emerging literature. Front

Climate change and forest disturbances: climate change can affect forests by altering the frequency, intensity, duration, and timing of fire, drought, introduced species, insect and pathogen outbreaks, hurricanes, windstorms, ice storms, or landslides

Impacts of climate change on the trends of extreme rainfall indices and values of maximum precipitation at Olimpiyat Station, Istanbul

Searching for evidence of changes in extreme rainfall indices in the Central Rift Valley of Ethiopia

Spatial and temporal analysis of trends in extreme temperature indices in Iran over the period 1960-2014

Web-based climate information resources for malaria control in Africa

Seasonality of meningitis in Africa and climate forcing: aerosols stand out

Environmental risk and meningitis epidemics in Africa

Spatial and seasonal variations in atmospheric aerosols over Nigeria: assessment of influence of intertropical discontinuity movement

Malaria in southern Europe: resurgence from the past

Influence of climate on malaria transmission depends on daily temperature variation

Temperature variability and outbreak of meningitis and measles in Zaria, northern Nigeria Res

Cryptococcus meningitis (torulosis) treated with a new antibiotic

The role of weather in meningitis outbreaks in Navrongo, Ghana: a generalized additive modeling approach

Acute bacterial meningitis after transrectal needle biopsy of the prostate: a case report

Seasonal Forecasts, Climatic Change and Human Health

Land use change alters malaria transmission parameters by modifying temperature in a highland area of Uganda

Urbanization and tropical health-then and now

Urbanization in sub-saharan Africa and implication for malaria control

The impact of a small-scale irrigation scheme on malaria transmission in Ziway area

Does irrigated urban agriculture influence the transmission of malaria in the city of Kumasi, Ghana?

Africa needs climate data to fight disease

Climate influences on meningitis incidence in northwest Nigeria

On the decadal scale correlation between African dust and Sahel rainfall: the role of Saharan heat low-forced winds

Two mechanisms for accelerated diffusion of COVID-19 outbreaks in regions with high intensity of population and polluting industrialization: the air pollution-to-human and human-to-human transmission dynamics

Diffusion of COVID-19 Outbreaks: The Interaction between Air Pollution-to-Human and Human-to-Human Transmission Dynamics in Hinterland Regions with Cold Weather and Low Average Wind Speed

The authors declare no competing interests.