key: cord-0943528-mscdx7cd
authors: Medina Fernández, Isai Arturo; Carreño Moreno, Sonia; Chaparro Díaz, Lorena; Gallegos-Torres, Ruth Magdalena; Medina Fernández, Josué Arturo; Hernández Martínez, Eva Kerena
title: Fear, Stress, and Knowledge regarding COVID-19 in Nursing Students and Recent Graduates in Mexico
date: 2021-03-05
journal: Invest Educ Enferm
DOI: 10.17533/udea.iee.v39n1e05
sha: c592a8d7d4030b71c0535ad3b420a1cb0511932c
doc_id: 943528
cord_uid: mscdx7cd

OBJECTIVE. The study sought to correlate fear, stress, knowledge regarding COVID-19 in Nursing students and recent graduates in Mexico. METHODS. Correlational design, sample comprising 912 nursing students and graduates during the last 18 months from public and private universities of Mexico. To measure the variables, the study applied the instrument Fear of COVID-19 Scale, knowledge subscale of the scale Knowledge, attitudes, and practices towards COVID-19, and the instrument COVID Stress Scale. RESULTS. Relationship was found of the age variable with fear, danger of contamination, traumatic stress, knowledge and minor socioeconomic consequences (p<0.05). Likewise, relationship was observed of fear with stress regarding COVID-19, danger of contamination, socioeconomic consequences, xenophobia, traumatic stress, and compulsive checking (p<0.05). Stress and knowledge explain the presence of fear regarding COVID-19 in 50.3%, and fear and knowledge explain stress regarding COVID-19 in 50.4%. CONCLUSION. Nursing students and recent graduates have high levels of stress and fear, besides low level of knowledge. The presence of high stress and low knowledge predict fear regarding COVID-19. Interventions are required on knowledge, stress, and fear regarding COVID-19 in the population studied.

compulsive checking (p<0.05). Stress and knowledge explain the presence of fear regarding COVID-19 in 50.3%, and fear and knowledge explain stress regarding COVID-19 in 50.4%. Conclusion. Nursing students and recent graduates have high levels of stress and fear, besides low level of knowledge. The presence of high stress and low knowledge predict fear regarding Interventions are required on knowledge, stress, and fear regarding COVID-19 in the population studied.

Descriptors: fear; stress, psychological; knowledge; students, nursing; nurses; coronavirus infections; pandemics.

Temor, estrés y conocimientos ante el covid-19 en estudiantes y recién egresados de enfermería en México Resumen Objetivo. Correlacionar el temor, estrés, conocimientos frente al COVID-19 en estudiantes y recién egresados de enfermería en México. Métodos. Diseño correlacional, muestra constituida por 912 estudiantes de enfermería y egresados en los últimos 18 meses de universidades públicas y privadas de México. Para medir las variables se aplicó el instrumento Fear of COVID-19 Scale, subescala de conocimientos de la escala Knowledge, attitudes, and practices towards COVID-19, y el instrumento COVID Stress Scale. Resultados. Se encontró relación de la variable edad con temor, peligro de contaminación, estrés traumático, conocimientos y menores consecuencias socioeconómicas (p<0.05). De igual forma, se observó relación del temor con estrés ante el COVID-19, peligro de contaminación, consecuencias socioeconómicas, xenofobia, estrés traumático, y comprobación compulsiva (p<0.05). El estrés y los conocimientos explican la presencia del temor ante el COVID-19 en un 50.3 %, así como el temor y conocimiento explican el estrés ante el COVID-19 en un 50.4 %. Conclusión. Los estudiantes y recién egresados de enfermería tienen altos niveles de estrés y temor, además de bajo nivel de conocimientos. La presencia de alto estrés y bajos conocimientos predicen Introduction T he SARS-CoV-2 infection evolved into a pandemic of unforeseen dimensions due to its rate of spread, lack of knowledge of its mechanisms of infection and survival, besides the lack of global habits with respect to social distancing. In Mexico, the SARS-CoV-2 infection began with a case imported from Italy in February 2020, a situation upon which the Government of Mexico decreed the health emergency and its consequential measures of containment and mitigation of the spread of the virus. Since the confirmation of the first case and documentation of the first death due to COVID-19 in March 2020, the Mexican population in general began to fear upon this infection, developing behaviors of panic, such as excessive purchases and looting, which, together with the confinement order issued by the National Government, triggered different impacts, among them, affectation and fall of the economy. (1) However, fear regarding COVID-19 is not exclusive of the general population, given that it is a fact that one of the populations most vulnerable to the infection are health professionals, particularly those spending more time in the patient's environment. According to this, Mexico has reported high affectation of health professionals due to COVID-19, with over 2000 infected by 09 May 2020. Added to the figures of infection through COVID-19, complaints are known from staff working in health institutions, which expose the weakened, disorganized, and saturated Mexican health system, as well as the lack of personal preparation to address the pandemic and the lack of access to personal protection elements. (2) Given the novelty of SARS-CoV-2, the scant information the world still has about its spread, control, and treatment, health professionals in general have situations of fear and stress regarding COVID-19. Fear, as an unpleasant mental state produced by the perception of danger, has been documented in situations of pandemic; particularly in COVID-19, related suicide attempts have been documented. (3) However, in spite of the unpleasantness of the sensation, fear can be a protective factor, given that it moves humans toward prevention behaviors. (4) In turn, stress regarding COVID-19 has been reported in health workers, especially in physicians and nurses of first line of care. Severe stress conditions with repercussion in mental symptoms were reported in a sample of health workers in Europe, observing as associated factors prior mental symptoms and the proximity with infected patients. (5) The principal causes of stress related with COVID-19 is the sense of danger, the possibility of self-inoculation of the virus, concern for the possibility of infecting relatives, and sleep alterations. (6) Specifically in Nursing, a study conducted in Wuhan, China reported high levels of stress and anxiety, upon which nurses reported as cause, that of having to leave their children alone and the high work load. Said study concluded about the importance of adding evidence in this area, seeking to develop better strategies of emotional containment and support. (7) Given the critical situation regarding COVID-19, it is imperative to modify knowledge, attitudes, and practices in this context. In this respect, studies of this type have been carried out in health professionals, students and general population. In health professionals, lack of staff training is highlighted regarding the approach and prevention of COVID-19, (8) besides the need to increase knowledge, given that inadequate knowledge was reported by 10% of the professionals studied; attitudes of fear toward the virus, and the need to strengthen infection prevention measures. (9) With respect to students from health sciences, adequate knowledge was reported by 85%, prevention behaviors by 94%, and a perception of moderate risk. (10) Together with the concerns and uncertainty of the disease, presence of anxiety and fear of contracting COVID-19, epidemiological change still not under control, nursing students have equal concerns on the ambiguity regarding these new roles that can limit the learning opportunities, given the need to consolidate the abilities and skills necessary to permit a transition. (11) According with the aforementioned, the need is observed to enhance evidence available on COVID-19 not only in terms of its genetics, replication, spread and control, but also in terms of matters related with the population confronting it and its consequences on mental health. The purpose of this study was to correlate fear, stress, knowledge with regards to COVID-19 in Nursing students and recent graduates in Mexico.

This was a correlational, predictive, crosssectional study conducted during May and June 2020 in Mexico. It used convenience sampling with 912 participants, which corresponded to undergraduate students (n = 711) and recent graduates from the Nursing program within a maximum period of 18 months (n = 201), being 18 years of age or more.

The study was carried out in the southeast, northeast, and central regions of Mexico. The characterization and measurement instruments were delivered via E-mail or shared through social media through Google forms; the average response time for the package of instruments was 30 minutes. The study was approved by the Bioethics Committee of the Faculty of Nursing at Universidad Autónoma de Coahuila with registry number CBFEUSUADEC-IEM2, respecting anonymity and confidentiality by applying the electronic informed consent.

The variables were analyzed with a participant characterization file and three instruments were applied. Permission was obtained from the authors to use the instruments. The instruments were translated into Spanish by an official translator and, thereafter, were adjusted in semantics by the authors to be used within the Mexican context: (i) Fear of COVID-19 Scale, this scale is made up of ten items, with one-dimensional behavior in the construct validity, which reported factor loads from 0.66 and above and an item-total correlation > 0.4. In its original version, it reports a Cronbach's alpha of 0.82 and an interclass correlation coefficient of 0.72, which is adequate for its stability. It has a five-point Likert-type response scale, from never to always. The scale was designed to be self or hetero administered and the results indicated that a higher score means greater fear regarding COVID-19; (12) (ii) COVID Stress Scale, which measures five dimensions established through confirmatory factor analysis; these being danger regarding COVID-19 and contamination, economic consequences, xenophobia, traumatic stress, and compulsive behavior. Cronbach's Alpha internal consistency was > 0.8 in total and in all dimensions, (13) where a higher score meant greater stress regarding COVID-19; and (iii) Knowledge, attitudes, and practices towards COVID-19, which is constituted by 12 questions of which four refer to the clinical aspects of the disease, three are about the transmission mechanisms, and five are about prevention and control mechanisms. The questions have response options of false, true, and don't know. Likewise, the score of the scale goes up to 12 points, where each question has a value of one point, the result indicates that a higher score means greater knowledge. In its original version, the scale has a Cronbach's alpha of 0.71, (14) however, this study only applied the knowledge subscale.

Moreover, the description of the sample and analysis of the central variables of the study used absolute and relative frequencies for the discrete variables, besides central tendency measurements, dispersion and 95% confidence intervals for continuous variables. Correlations were explored among the continuous variables from Pearson's statistics, with prior compliance of normality requirements. Additionally, the Mann Whitney U was used to identify difference of measurements of stress, fear, and knowledge between groups. The variables included in the regression models were those reporting correlations and those the literature showed as relevant in the analysis.

The study obtained 956 surveys from subjects of which 44 were discarded because they were under age. The sample showed that 78% (n = 711) of the participants were currently studying in the Nursing career and 22% (n = 201) had recently graduated, who were in the social service or had already finished (15.2%) or were within a year from having concluded their studies without having received their title (6.8%). Of all the participants, 33.7% live in Yucatán (southern Mexico), 32.1% of the students live in the state of Coahuila (northern Mexico), 15.2% live in Zacatecas (central Mexico), and the rest is distributed in the rest of the states of the Mexican Republic.

A total of 77.7% of the participants were women and 22.3% were men. The mean age was 21 ±2.25 years. Regarding involvement with COVID-19, only 4.7% of the participants were currently working in an area that cares for these patients and 66.1% of the subjects has taken some course related with prevention, diagnosis and/or treatment of the pathology.

Notably, 92.4% of the students indicated not having manifested symptoms, like coughing, sore throat, fever, or general discomfort in the last 14 days; 14.8% had been in contact with someone classified as suspected of having the disease and 6.6% with someone identified as positive case. With respect to whether the students live with someone considered at risk, it is highlighted that 57.6% indicated living with someone enduring a chronic disease and 35.6% with an elderly adult; 15.4% of the participants reported living with someone who Works directly in a health institution.

In addition, Table 1 Note: M = median, SD = Standard deviation, Min = minimum value, Max = maximum value, 95%CI = Confidence interval at 95%, LL = lower limit, UL = upper limit. It was found that fear and stress are different according to sex, being higher in women (p <0.05); with respect to being a student or recent graduate, stress and knowledge were significantly different (p <0.001), with stress being higher in students and recent graduates having greater knowledge. Likewise, it was found that being in contact with a case suspected of COVID-19 has greater knowledge with respect to those who have not has said contact (p <0.05). Similarly, the group of individuals who have taken a course related with COVID-19 has less fear and stress, as well as greater knowledge about the disease (p <0.05). Table 2 shows the relationships among age,  fear, stress, and knowledge regarding COVID-19 and their subscales. Furthermore, it was found that stress and knowledge are predictors of fear regarding COVID-19, as well as fear and knowledge about stress regarding COVID -19 and stress, fear, having been in contact with someone, as well as having taken some course related with the disease are predictors for knowledge regarding COVID-19 (Table 3) . Two models contribute to the explained variance of stress and fear regarding COVID-19 with over 50%, and knowledge regarding COVID-19 was explained by 5.1%. (15) and Sakib et al., (16) with a median of 2.75 and M = 18.3, respectively. That fear was greater in contrast with the literature; it could have been generated by uncertainty for students with anguish due to social isolation, anguish due to fear of contracting the disease, and moral anguish as a consequence of seeing death at large scale. (11) However, although the nursing students have knowledge about the disease, fear may be related with the uncertainty of future close contact with patients, lack of knowledge of real settings, and discomfort caused by special protection, upon the suffering and death of critical patients and fear of infecting the family. (17) Stress regarding COVID-19 obtained a median of 98.2, which is higher than that reported by Asmundson et al., (18) with a median of 41.7 and 67.7 in the study by Lakaran et al. (19) Presence of a higher median may be related with the sense of security of people in each country, as well as the uncertainty of not having answers about the end of the pandemic, constant exposure to a flow of information on COVID-19 and its effects, and its dissemination in social relations and constant repetition of recommendations and prohibitions, all of which can affect negatively the mental health of the individuals. (18) Regarding knowledge of COVID-19, the median in this study was 8.24, which is lower than that reported by Zhong et al., (14) Azlan with a median of 10.5 (20) , and Begum (21) with a median of 10.8. The median was below that of various Asian countries; this indicates the possibility that students do not have appropriate practices to prevent COVID-19, which suggests that programs on health education must improve knowledge on the disease to help to promote an optimistic attitude and maintain safe practices. (22) With respect to the relation of knowledge and stress in our study, no relation was found; this was represented to the contrary by Maarefvand et al., (23) where stress levels were related with preventive knowledge for COVID-19. Likewise, Zhi et al., (24) suggested that stress levels are inversely proportional to knowledge in effective ways of managing the pandemic.

Our study found no relation between fear and knowledge on COVID-19, which was similar to the study by Ali et al. (25) In contrast, Hossain et al., (26) reported that with greater knowledge, fear regarding COVID-19 is lower, which could support the hypothesis that lack of knowledge on a specific area could facilitate the construction or ingrained beliefs of myths of such. Thus, knowledge on COVID-19 is a prior requisite to establish prevention beliefs, form positive attitudes, and promote positive behaviors and cognition and the attitudes of people toward the disease affect the effectiveness of their coping strategies and behaviors to a certain extent. (27) Together with the aforementioned, this study found that fear is a predictor of stress regarding COVID-19; these results were similar to those by Bakioğlu (28) and Begum et al. (29) This may explain that fear is a strong emotion that affects physical responses, cognitive abilities, and mood of individuals, generating greater concern and further worsening the severity of the situation lived by the person, besides the impact on the mental health of Nursing students and professionals could be severe, given that they experience constant psychological affectation, caused by their work in the first line or worry for an uncertain future in the work environment.

In conclusion, higher scores are noted in the sample in this study than those reported by studies in other countries for fear and stress regarding COVID-19; as well as lower level of knowledge. Low knowledge and high stress predict high levels of fear regarding COVID-19. Likewise, the high percentage of influence over the variables indicates the need for up-to-date interventions on the pathology and follow up and care of the mental health of students and recent graduates in Mexico.

El desafío de la enfermedad del coronavirus (COVID-19) en México: una reflexión crítica y forzada como individuos y sociedad. Frente a la Salud Pública

La pandemia golpea a casi 2.000 profesionales de la salud en México

The fear of COVID-19 and its role in preventive behaviors

Functional Fear Predicts Public Health Compliance in the COVID-19 Pandemic

COVID-19 Pandemic: Stress Experience of Healthcare Workers -A Short Current Review

Psychological stress of medical staffs during outbreak of COVID-19 and adjustment strategy

Work stress among Chinese nurses to support Wuhan in fighting against COVID-19 epidemic

Dentists' Awareness, Perception, and Attitude Regarding COVID-19 and Infection Control: Cross-Sectional Study Among Jordanian Dentists

2019-novel coronavirus survey: Knowledge and attitudes of hospital staff of a large Italian teaching hospital

COVID-19 and Iranian Medical Students; A Survey on Their Related-Knowledge, Preventive Behaviors and Risk Perception

COVID 19: Disruptive impacts and transformative opportunities in undergraduate nurse education

The Fear of COVID-19 Scale: Development and Initial Validation

Development and initial validation of the COVID Stress Scales

Knowledge, attitudes, and practices towards COVID-19 among Chinese residents during the rapid rise period of the COVID-19 outbreak: a quick online cross-sectional survey

Evaluation of the English Version of the Fear of COVID-19 Scale and Its Relationship with Behavior Change and Political Beliefs

Psychometric Validation of the Bangla Fear of COVID-19 Scale: Confirmatory Factor Analysis and Rasch Analysis

Emotional responses and coping strategies of nurses and nursing college students during COVID-19 outbreak

Covid stress predicts depression, anxiety and stress symptoms of Filipino respondents Renz

Do pre-existing anxietyrelated and mood disorders differentially impact COVID-19 stress responses and coping?

Public knowledge, attitudes and practices towards COVID-19: A cross-sectional study in Malaysia

Nursing Students in Selected Nursing Institution in Saudi Arabia during COVID-19 Outbreak: An Online Survey Knowledge, Attitudes, and Practices towards COVID-19 among B.Sc

Community-Based Assessment of Knowledge, Attitude, Practices and Risk Factors Regarding COVID-19 Among Pakistanis Residents During a Recent Outbreak: A Cross-Sectional Survey

Coronavirus outbreak and stress in iranians

Investigation and analysis of psychological stress and professional identity of nursing students during COVID-19 pandemic

Knowledge, attitude, practice and fear of COVID-19: A cross-cultural study

Attitudes, and Fear of COVID-19 during the Rapid Rise Period in Bangladesh

Meta-Analysis of the Reasoned Action Approach (RAA) to Understanding Health Behaviors

Fear of COVID-19 and Positivity: Mediating Role of Intolerance of Uncertainty, Depression, Anxiety, and Stress

Feelings, Stress, and Adaptation Strategies of Nurses against COVID-19 in Guayaquil