key: cord-0942341-bcraqemn authors: nan title: Age and frailty are independently associated with increased COVID-19 mortality and increased care needs in survivors: results of an international multi-centre study date: 2021-02-05 journal: Age Ageing DOI: 10.1093/ageing/afab026 sha: bde01a69b25da4dfa5192bb0de88d0d5a930d341 doc_id: 942341 cord_uid: bcraqemn INTRODUCTION: Increased mortality has been demonstrated in older adults with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19), but the effect of frailty has been unclear. METHODS: This multi-centre cohort study involved patients aged 18 years and older hospitalised with COVID-19, using routinely collected data. We used Cox regression analysis to assess the impact of age, frailty and delirium on the risk of inpatient mortality, adjusting for sex, illness severity, inflammation and co-morbidities. We used ordinal logistic regression analysis to assess the impact of age, Clinical Frailty Scale (CFS) and delirium on risk of increased care requirements on discharge, adjusting for the same variables. RESULTS: Data from 5,711 patients from 55 hospitals in 12 countries were included (median age 74, interquartile range [IQR] 54–83; 55.2% male). The risk of death increased independently with increasing age (>80 versus 18–49: hazard ratio [HR] 3.57, confidence interval [CI] 2.54–5.02), frailty (CFS 8 versus 1–3: HR 3.03, CI 2.29–4.00) inflammation, renal disease, cardiovascular disease and cancer, but not delirium. Age, frailty (CFS 7 versus 1–3: odds ratio 7.00, CI 5.27–9.32), delirium, dementia and mental health diagnoses were all associated with increased risk of higher care needs on discharge. The likelihood of adverse outcomes increased across all grades of CFS from 4 to 9. CONCLUSION: Age and frailty are independently associated with adverse outcomes in COVID-19. Risk of increased care needs was also increased in survivors of COVID-19 with frailty or older age. outcomes (1) (2) (3) (4) . The clinical frailty scale (CFS) (5, 6) featured in critical care escalation guidelines in UK and Canada (7) . Early evidence of impact of frailty produced mixed findings; studies suggested frailty was (8) , and was not (9, 10) associated with increased mortality with COVID- 19. Our collaborative previously demonstrated in other conditions that delirium is common and associated with adverse outcomes, especially in frail older adults (11) . Two distinct cohorts identified that delirium is more common in frail older adults with COVID-19 (12) . Thus, a need for research on delirium and frailty with COVID-19 was recognised (13) . Additionally, prolonged recovery has been reported in survivors (14) , although the impact of COVID-19 upon transitions of care needs with age and frailty has not been previously studied. To evaluate the association of age, frailty and delirium with adverse outcomes including mortality and secondary outcomes to include critical care admission, incident delirium and transitions of care needs in survivors in hospitalised patients with COVID-19. We included unscheduled hospital admissions of adults aged ≥ 18 years old with COVID-19 infection in this observational study. Emergency department discharges and nosocomial COVID-19 were excluded. Prospective data upload upon clinical suspicion was encouraged; clinicians identified patients during medical clerking, or ward transfer. Retrospective identification was dependent on local COVID-19 coding processes, involving medical records, informatics or microbiology. Investigation was led through the Geriatric Medicine Research Collaborative (GeMRC) (15, 16) . The protocol was openly available on GeMRC, British Geriatrics Society and University of Birmingham REDCap webpages, and disseminated via emails and social media. Sites were required to obtain local, regional and national approvals, and declare these were in place when registering. Data sharing agreements were arranged where required. Sites were provided REDCap data upload logins; secure encrypted web-based data management software. Sites uploaded anonymised patient-level data onto REDCap. Independent data managers ensured quality control. Suspected COVID-19 infection was diagnosed clinically considering symptoms, radiology and laboratory tests. Laboratory confirmation was conducted according to local policies and World Health Organization guidance; identification of SARS-CoV-2 from reverse transciptase polymerase chain reaction from oropharyngeal or high nasal swabs (RdRp gene assay), or antibodies against SARS-CoV-2 in serum samples ≥ 14 days after symptom onset. Patients were included if there was strong clinical suspicion but no laboratory confirmation. Data were extracted from routinely collected clinical information; variables are outlined in the online supplement (Supplementary Table S1 ). Screening with the 4 'A's Test (4AT) (17) on admission was recommended; ≥4 was suggestive of prevalent delirium. Incident delirium was defined as documented emergent delirium during admission. Frailty was derived based on function 2 weeks before admission using the 9-point CFS (6), by prospective clinical assessment or retrospectively from medical records. Primary end point was death during index admission. Secondary end points were critical care admission, incident delirium and increased care requirements at discharge (as defined below). Data analysis was performed using STATA SE version 16 (StataCorp LLC, Texas, USA) by an independent statistician (KO). Descriptive variables were expressed as median and interquartile range (IQR), and counts; chi-squared and Mann-Whitney U tests were applied for statistical significance of mortality differences. We used Cox proportional survival analysis to assess impact of delirium and frailty upon inpatient mortality. Univariable and multivariable analyses were conducted as follows: • Model 1: variables previously associated with COVID-19 adverse outcomes; age (3, 18) , sex (3, 18) , C-reactive protein (CRP) (3), Ferritin (19, 20) , body mass index (BMI) (21) , Alanine aminotransferase ( , co-morbidities coded individually (3, 18) and illness severity (3) by admission national early warning score (NEWS) (23). • Model 2: variables above with CFS; CFS 1-3 was the comparison group, and CFS 9 and missing CFS were separate discrete groups (6) . Additional analyses were conducted with age and frailty (excluding CFS 9) as continuous variables. • Model 3: variables in Models 1 and 2 and delirium (prevalent/incident). We performed Wald and Likelihood Ratio tests for model fit for age and frailty individually and together as predictors in all models. In addition, we assessed for multiplicative interactions between age and frailty upon the primary outcome of mortality censored at the point of discharge. Frailty was grouped with the exclusion of CFS 9 in these models (CFS 1-3, CFS 4-6, CFS 7-8, CFS missing). We performed sensitivity analyses on models for the primary outcome: 1. Excluding patients aged < 65 years old. 2. Excluding patients admitted to hospitals outside the UK. We used binary logistic regression to assess impact of variables on critical care admission and incident delirium (excluding prevalent delirium), and ordinal logistic regression to assess impact upon care requirements at discharge. Incident delirium was considered as any new diagnosis of delirium by a healthcare professional at any time during admission, where this was not present at admission. Increased care was defined as transitions across three care levels: living at home without formal care, living at home with formal care or living in a 24-h long-term care facility. The study includes data from 5,711 individuals with COVID-19 admitted to 55 hospitals in 12 countries. Supplementary Figure S1 shows reasons for data exclusion. Supplementary Table S2 demonstrates participating site locations. Median age was 74 and 55.2% were male. Table 1 shows full baseline patient characteristics. Risk of death increased independently with age and frailty in univariable and multivariable analyses ( online (Supplementary Table S4 ). Age and frailty together and not individually as predictor variables improved model of fit (LR χ 2 (7) = 91.3, P < 0.001; Wald χ 2 (10) = 207.9, P < 0.001). Additionally, mortality risk increased with age and frailty together in multiplicative interactions (Supplementary Table S5 and Supplementary Figure S2 ). Delirium was predictive of mortality in univariable but not multivariable analysis. Risk of death increased with higher CRP or ferritin, more severe renal disease and cancer. Mortality did not differ across BMI cut-offs; risk of death was increased with missing BMI. Figure 1 demonstrates Kaplan-Meier curves for risk of death for frailty and delirium. Results were not affected by sensitivity analyses for ≥65 years old, or UK data only (Supplementary Tables S6 and S7 ). Critical care admissions were more likely with greater illness severity, CRP, or ferritin or BMI < 18.5 or ≥30 (Table 3) Table S8 ). Delirium incidence was 9.6%. Incident delirium odds increased with age but not frailty ( Table S9 ). Increased care risk increased with age, frailty, delirium, dementia and mental health problems ( Table S10 ). Age and frailty were independently associated with COVID-19 mortality. This is consistent with risk exhibited for nearly all other illnesses, and does not represent relative risk for COVID-19 compared with other illnesses; risk of dying increases with age and frailty (6) within 'normal' risk (24) . However, increases in absolute mortality risk will be most pronounced in these groups, even if relative risk is equivalent to young or robust individuals. It is important to consider the results of likelihood testing, which demonstrated that age and frailty as individual predictors improved the model of fit. Risk continued to increase with increasing age and with increasing frailty. Therefore, the greatest risk will have been exhibited by the oldest and most frail patients. Underlying mechanisms for increased mortality with age and frailty with COVID-19 may include endothelial dysfunction leading to vasoconstriction and organ dysfunction (25, 26) , heightened inflammation (27) and pro-coagulant state (25, 26, 28) , dysregulated angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 activity promoting viral uptake (28) (29) (30) and immunesenescence (28) . Immunesenescence is associated with immune system changes that are age-related (31, 32), frailty-related (33), or inactivity-related (34, 35) . Delirium was not independently predictive of mortality, but was associated with critical care admission; delirium itself is an illness severity marker. This may relate to exclusion of prevalent delirium cases, or represent different delirium pathophysiology with COVID-19 compared with other conditions. We demonstrated novel results that frailty, age, delirium, dementia and mental health diagnoses were independently associated with transitions of care in survivors i.e. adverse functional outcomes. Quality of life is individual and subjective, but increased dependency will have been hugely significant for many individuals. Transitions of care are also likely to have been associated with state-funded health and social care system costs, during a time of international economic recession, which has wider health impacts (36) . Previous studies assessing COVID-19 mortality with frailty showed mixed results. These have been predominantly small single site studies (9, 10, 37) . Our results are consistent with another study including 1,410 UK-hospital and 154 Italianhospital patients; sub-categorised CFS and age were independently associated with mortality (8) . A second UK single site study involving 677 patients demonstrated increased mortality in CFS ≥ 6 (38). A small Italian study demonstrated that a Frailty Index was also predictive of mortality (37) , even after removing co-morbidities from the index (39) . However, a small UK study showed that age but not continuous CFS was predictive of mortality in univariable analysis; CFS was not included in multivariable analysis (40) . Similar results were shown in another UK study (9) . Differences may relate to under-powering in smaller studies, or how CFS was recorded or extracted from clinical records. In our study, few patients had missing CFS (11% versus 32% in the latter study) (9) . However, these studies also assessed mortality following discharge, whereas we report mortality during index admission. Whilst this is important to distinguish, we do not consider this explanatory for differences; it is unlikely robust patients were more likely to have been discharged to die outside of hospital. As our data were censored at hospital discharge, this has also been accounted for. Consistent with results elsewhere, male sex, inflammation and cancer were associated with mortality (18) . However, BMI was not independently predictive of death, which is contrary to previous research (21) , although high and low BMI were associated with critical care admission. Studies previously adjusted for age, sex and co-morbidities, but this is the first study to adjust for frailty. Both being underweight and obese have been associated with frailty (41) . Previous research demonstrated that delirium is a common COVID-19 presentation (12, 18) . It is surprising that delirium did not predict mortality in our study. Delirium has been consistently associated with mortality in hospitalised patients with other illnesses (11, 42) . A single-site Italian study demonstrated that delirium, diagnosed against reference criteria by geriatricians, was associated with 4-fold increased COVID-19 mortality risk (43) . Under-recognition is unlikely to fully explain differences as prevalence was high in our study. Delirium was associated with critical care admission, which is consistent with a Brazilian study (44) . Frailty has been associated with prevalent delirium in COVID-19 (12) and other conditions (11) . Incident delirium was not associated with frailty in this study. Additionally, dementia, a classical delirium risk factor, was not associated with risk. Higher risk was demonstrated with cardiovascular disease and illness severity. These differences in patient groups affected may explain differences in COVID-19 mortality with delirium compared with other conditions. Severely ill robust patients may have been as likely to develop delirium as frail patients, but less likely to die. We are not aware of other studies reporting transitions of care in patients with COVID-19. Studies outside of COVID-19 have shown that frailty and cognitive spectrum disorders are associated with increased risk of new discharge to a care home (45, 46) . A major strength of our study is that it was large and multi-centre. This is the largest study to date evaluating how frailty and delirium relate to outcomes in hospitalised patients with COVID-19. Data collectors were not involved in analysis; statistical analysis was conducted by an independent statistician. We included large numbers of variables in multivariable analyses, which had been previously associated with adverse outcomes with COVID-19. We did not collect ethnicity data. Previous research identified that Black African or Caribbean and Bangladeshi individuals are at increased risk of adverse outcomes from COVID-19, although this also relates to socioeconomic status (47, 48) . This personal information requires stricter safeguards (49) , and is not internationally standardised. Data collectors were provided delirium and frailty diagnosis guidance. Prospective data collection was encouraged and diagnoses were made by clinicians. Results provide predictive value of real-world delirium and frailty diagnoses. Given the high overall delirium prevalence, we consider it unlikely that under-diagnosis of delirium significantly impacted upon our overall results. Retrospectively identified data may be vulnerable to documentation errors, and we cannot rule out possibility of data entry errors via REDCap. To counteract this, data managers performed quality control checks on uploaded data, and contacted sites where data were missing or outlying values recorded. Overall, missing data rates were low; discrete missing categories were included to account for those that were. The highest missing data rates related to BMI (height and weight). This could explain why obesity was not predictive of mortality; missing BMI was associated with mortality. It may have been most likely to be missing in most unwell or possibly most obese patients. Higher odds of mortality were demonstrated with missing CFS, which is consistent with previous studies (50) . Multiple imputation has shown consistent effect of frailty on mortality in other populations (50) . Inclusion of hospitalised patients only is a limitation. The majority of people with COVID-19 had mild symptoms (51) , particularly those who were young and robust; inclusion of community cases may have amplified association of frailty with mortality. Conversely, frail individuals may have died unexpectedly, or advance care planning decisions may have been made to avoid admission. Internationally, significant numbers of people who died from COVID-19 died in 24-h long-term care facilities (52, 53) . We also recognise that our sample may not be internationally representative. As dissemination was via GeMRC (15, 16) , more older adults may have been identified if clinicians were working on geriatric medicine wards. This in itself should not have affected main results; data collection was not biased towards outcomes. Healthcare policy should recognise heightened vulnerability in older adults, particularly those living with frailty. Caution should be exhibited to ensure older adults with frailty are shielded from high risk COVID-19 exposure, such as ensuring isolation procedures during elective surgery admissions. Older and/or frail patients admitted with COVID-19 should undergo holistic assessment, ensuring treatment is proportionate and in accordance with their wishes. Research identifying underlying mechanisms of adverse outcomes with age and frailty may enable novel intervention development. It is vital older adults with frailty are adequately represented in all COVID-19 research. Vaccines and COVID-19 treatments may have different responsiveness with age or frailty. Considering high odds of increased care in patients with frailty, urgent funding is needed to enhance community and hospital rehabilitation services (54) . At present, longerterm consequences of COVID-19 are unknown. Chronic symptoms of fatigue and systemic upset have been reported even in community-dwelling previously robust adults (14) . Further research should focus on understanding mechanisms and adverse recovery predictors, particularly in patients who developed acute sarcopenia (55, 56) or induced frailty (57) . In this international multi-centre study, age, frailty and morbidity were independently associated with adverse outcomes with COVID-19. Patients who were older or more severely frail were more likely to die, less likely to be admitted to critical care, and more likely to require higher care levels on discharge in survivors. Increased awareness of importance of measuring frailty alongside age and co-morbidities in hospitalised patients will assist clinicians making holistic decisions involving treatment of reversible pathology, prevention of unwanted or burdensome treatment and early rehabilitation. Supplementary Data: Supplementary data mentioned in the text are available to subscribers in Age and Ageing online. Coronavirus disease 2019 in elderly patients: characteristics and prognostic factors based on 4-week follow-up Case-fatality rate and characteristics of patients dying in relation to COVID-19 in Italy Clinical characteristics of coronavirus disease 2019 in China Preexisting comorbidities predicting COVID-19 and mortality in the UK biobank community cohort A global clinical measure of fitness and frailty in elderly people The role of illness acuity on the association between frailty and mortality in emergency department patients referred to internal medicine COVID-19 Rapid Guideline: Critical Care in Adults. In: National Institute for Health and Care Excellence The effect of frailty on survival in patients with COVID-19 (COPE): a multicentre, European, observational cohort study Comparing associations between frailty and mortality in hospitalised older adults with or without COVID-19 infection: a retrospective observational study using electronic health records Outcomes from COVID-19 across the range of frailty: excess mortality in fitter older people Delirium is prevalent in older hospital inpatients and associated with adverse outcomes: results of a prospective multi-centre study on world delirium awareness day Probable delirium is a presenting symptom of COVID-19 in frail, older adults: a cohort study of 322 hospitalised and 535 community-based older adults Delirium: a missing piece in the COVID-19 pandemic puzzle Management of post-acute covid-19 in primary care Geriatric medicine research collaborative. Growing research in geriatric medicine: a trainee perspective Using social media and web-based networking in collaborative research: protocol for the geriatric medicine research collaborative Validation of the 4AT, a new instrument for rapid delirium screening: a study in 234 hospitalised older people Features of 20 133 UK patients in hospital with covid-19 using the ISARIC WHO clinical characterisation protocol: prospective observational cohort study Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99 cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan, China: a descriptive study COVID-19: consider cytokine storm syndromes and immunosuppression Excess Weight and COVID-19 Using standardized serum creatinine values in the modification of diet in renal disease study equation for estimating glomerular filtration rate Featherstone PI. The ability of the National Early Warning Score (NEWS) to discriminate patients at risk of early cardiac arrest, unanticipated intensive care unit admission, and death Use of "normal" risk to improve understanding of dangers of covid-19 Endothelial cell infection and endotheliitis in COVID-19 Endothelial barrier integrity in COVID-19-dependent hyperinflammation: does the protective facet of platelet function matter? Age-dependent differences in pulmonary host responses in ARDS: a prospective observational cohort study Why does COVID-19 disproportionately affect older people? ACE2 expression is increased in the lungs of patients with comorbidities associated with severe COVID-19 Polymorphisms of ACE2 gene are associated with essential hypertension and antihypertensive effects of captopril in women Pulmonary infections in the elderly lead to impaired neutrophil targeting, which is improved by Simvastatin Impaired neutrophil extracellular trap formation: a novel defect in the innate immune system of aged individuals Frailty is associated with neutrophil dysfunction which is correctable with phosphoinositol-3-kinase inhibitors. The journals of gerontology series a, biological sciences and medical Moderate physical activity associated with a higher naïve/memory T-cell ratio in healthy old individuals: potential role of IL15 Habitual physical activity is associated with the maintenance of neutrophil migratory dynamics in healthy older adults Recessions and health: the long-term health consequences of responses to the coronavirus. Institute for Fiscal Studies Frailty index predicts poor outcome in COVID-19 patients Association of Frailty with mortality in older inpatients with Covid-19: a cohort study The role of frailty in COVID-19 patients Presenting features of COVID-19 in older people: relationships with frailty, inflammation and mortality Frailty, body mass index, and abdominal obesity in older people Observational, longitudinal study of delirium in consecutive unselected acute medical admissions: age-specific rates and associated factors, mortality and re-admission The impact of delirium on outcomes for older adults hospitalised with COVID-19 Delirium and adverse outcomes in hospitalized patients with COVID-19 Living at home after emergency hospital admission: prospective cohort study in older adults with and without cognitive spectrum disorder The Association of Geriatric Syndromes with hospital outcomes Ethnicity and risk of death in patients hospitalised for COVID-19 infection in the UK: an observational cohort study in an urban catchment area Disparities in the risk and outcomes of COVID-19 Information Commissioner's Office. Special category data Clinical frailty adds to acute illness severity in predicting mortality in hospitalized older adults: an observational study Characteristics of and important lessons from the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) outbreak in China: summary of a report of 72 314 cases from the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention COVID-19 Mortality and Long-Term Care: a UK Comparison. International long term care policy network Mortality Associated with COVID-19 Outbreaks in Care Homes: Early International Evidence ten Hove R. The COVID-19 rehabilitation pandemic Acute sarcopenia secondary to hospitalisation-an emerging condition affecting older adults COVID-19 and acute sarcopenia Sepsis pathophysiology, chronic critical illness, and persistent inflammationimmunosuppression and catabolism syndrome