key: cord-0939940-2vw1qmso
authors: Yengo-Kahn, Aaron M; Kelly, Patrick D; Liles, David C; McKeithan, Lydia J; Grisham, Candace J; Khan, Muhammad Saad; Lee, Timothy; Kuhn, Andrew W; Bonfield, Christopher M; Zuckerman, Scott L
title: The cost of a single concussion in American high school football: a retrospective cohort study
date: 2020-10-28
journal: Concussion
DOI: 10.2217/cnc-2020-0012
sha: cefa76d26135cab99aed2f4a9f1fd2ea7d6741ad
doc_id: 939940
cord_uid: 2vw1qmso

AIM: The potential financial burden of American football-related concussions (FRC) is unknown. Our objective was to describe the healthcare costs associated with an FRC and determine factors associated with increased costs. METHODOLOGY/RESULTS: A retrospective cohort study of concussed high school football players presenting between November 2017 and March 2020 was undertaken; 144 male high school football players were included. Total costs were about $115,000, for an average direct healthcare cost of $800.10/concussion. Visiting the emergency department (β = 502.29, 95% CI: 105.79–898.61; p = 0.01), the initial post-concussion symptom scale score (β = 0.39, 95% CI: 0.11–0.66; p = 0.01) and a post-concussion syndrome diagnosis (β = 670.37, 95% CI: 98.96–1241.79; p = 0.02) were each independently associated with total costs. CONCLUSION: A granular understanding of cost-driving factors associated with FRC is the first step in understanding the cost–effectiveness of prevention and treatment methods.

occurs by the biomechanical transfer of linear and predominantly rotational accelerations [10] , experienced by the head, to the brain, helmets are engineered to reduce this acceleration transfer by distributing impact energy to the various components of the helmet [11] . Depending on the ability to reduce the accelerations experienced by the brain, football helmets can offer different levels of protection [12] . Although these differences may be relatively minor, prices can vary considerably [13] , and may be cost-prohibitive in certain communities. An economically sound purchasing decision requires both clinical effectiveness data and the marginal cost of a concussion.

Given the high incidence of football-related concussion (FRC), a granular understanding of the healthcare costs associated with FRC is the first step to ensuring equal prevention and treatment practices for all. The objectives of the present study are to: describe the healthcare costs associated with an FRC, and determine what clinical factors are most associated with increased costs. We hypothesized the development of post-concussion syndrome (PCS) would be particularly associated with higher costs.

A retrospective cohort study was undertaken between November 2017 and March 2020 for concussed American high school football players. All patients were evaluated and received the majority of their FRC care at a sport concussion center located in the Southeast United States. The study was determined exempt by the Institutional Review Board (IRB #192033) based on minimal risk designation (45 CFR 46 .104(d) (4) ) and the need for patient consent was waived accordingly following IRB review.

All patients seen at the regional sport concussion center during the study period with visit-associated ICD-10 billing codes for concussion (F07.81, S06.0X**) were queried. Patient selection is summarized, and exclusion criteria are detailed in Figure 1 . Inclusion criteria were: SRC suffered during high school football game or practice while helmeted, presentation to the concussion clinic within 10 days of injury and this was the first concussion suffered during the study period. Athletes with a history of concussion prior to the study period were eligible for inclusion. These criteria were chosen to limit the inclusion of those who may have received substantial care elsewhere, which would lead to vastly underestimated costs. All variables were extracted by manual chart review using the study institution's electronic health record and stored within a secure database.

Relevant pre-injury clinical variables, including demographics and medical/family history as well as injury characteristics (loss of consciousness, antero-or retrograde-amnesia) were chosen based on published literature demonstrating importance of these variables in predicting prolonged recovery [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] . Initial symptoms and severity upon presentation to sports concussion clinic were documented using the commonly used and validated post-concussion symptom scale (PCSS) [19, 20] , which contains 22 symptoms rated on a Likert scale from 0 to 6 (least to most severe), yielding a maximum score of 132 [20] .

The dates of each concussion-related healthcare system contact were collected. Time (days) from injury to initial evaluation by each type of healthcare provider, as well as the number of visits to each type of provider, were calculated. Emergency department (ED) and urgent care visits were collapsed into a single variable due to an overall low count of urgent care visits and the two provide a similar service involving the initial assessment and diagnosis of SRC. Imaging was identified by radiology reports and imaging studies were verified to be SRC-related by reviewing temporally associated provider notes. The presence of outside facility imaging studies, urgent care or ED use was determined by close review of the initial concussion clinic consultation note, as these variables are systematically documented as part of our institution's initial clinic evaluation.

A concussion episode was defined as time from initial injury to discharge from the clinic, which typically occurred when the athlete was cleared for return to play or became asymptomatic as athletes typically return to school prior to discharge from clinic. Four clinical outcomes, including three time-to-recovery variables, were chosen a-priori as end points. Return-to-learn: days from injury to return to school (part or full time); return-to-play: days from injury to full clearance for return to practice and/or games; symptom resolution: days from injury to when PCSS was 0 or the treating clinician stated the athlete had 'recovered' from his concussion; and PCS: whether or not the athlete developed PCS, defined as >1 symptom continuing over 1 month (28 days) post-injury [21] . If an athlete was released from the clinic into the care of their athletic trainer prior to reaching an end point, it was inferred the athlete did not develop PCS.

The direct cost of the concussion episode was the primary outcome. Each patient's cost data was derived by matching visit and imaging dates with study institution inflation-adjusted cost data. Notably, costs were used instead of charges, which can fluctuate greatly by region/hospital [22, 23] . Costs were inflation-adjusted to December 2017 dollars using the Bureau of Labor Statistics Producer Price Index for Outpatient Hospital Care at General Medical or Surgical Hospitals [24] . Costs were set at December 2017 dollars rather than April 2020 levels due to SARS-CoV-2 pandemic-related disruption of the inflation cost curve [25] . Cost data were presented in two forms similar to prior studies [8] . To obtain the primary outcome of direct cost per SRC episode, total costs were divided by total SRCs. Secondarily, the cost per resource utilization represents the total cost of a given healthcare resource divided by the number of patients who utilized it (e.g., the average costs associated with that resource).

Descriptive statistics were performed, with continuous variables represented as median with IQR and categorical variables as N (%). Sample size was determined by the number of available records, and thus no sample size or power calculation was performed. Missing data were imputed using mean value imputation. Three patients -two with non-contrasted head CTs (CTH), one with a cervical spine (c-spine) MRI -underwent in-system imaging related to their concussions, for which cost data were missing, and these costs were imputed by averaging inflation-adjusted costs for CTH and c-spine MRI collected from other patients. For patients receiving outside imaging and/or outside ED care, the costs were imputed utilizing the mean in-system cost of these services. Wilcoxon rank-sum tests were used to compare the initial symptom burden and total costs incurred by those who did and did not develop PCS given non-normally distributed data.

A multivariable linear regression model identified clinical factors associated with the total cost of concussion care. In-system ED visits were included as a covariate to mitigate the confounding influence of this variable. Based on the anticipated relationship between PCSS and cost, a nonlinear quadratic term for this variable (PCSS 2 ) was included in the regression model.

The threshold for statistical significance was set a priori as p < 0.05. No sensitivity analyses were performed. All statistical analyses were performed in Stata/IC version 16.1. (StataCorp LLC, TX, USA).

Demographics, clinical characteristics and outcomes of the 144 concussed high school football players are presented in Table 1 . At least one of the three, time-to-recovery, end points was able to be ascertained for 138 (95.8%) patients. Six patients (4.2%), were instructed to only return to the clinic as needed after the initial visit and therefore no further outcome data were obtained. PCS status was able to be determined or inferred based on management for all patients.

Costs & healthcare system utilization Complete healthcare system utilization and costs per concussion and costs per resource utilization are presented in Table 2 . The total cost of concussion care in the study population was $115,214.40, resulting in an average cost of $800.10 per concussion. The ED or an urgent care clinic was utilized by over a quarter of the cohort (27.8%) at $687.86 per use, and 80.5% of these visits occurred within 1 day of the initial injury. Imaging was performed for 12.9%, 1 patient received a repeat CTH (0.7%). Both occupational therapy and psychiatry had substantial associated costs, in excess of $1000 per athlete referral, related to multiple visits (medians 11.5 and 3.5, respectively) despite only being utilized by 1.4% of the cohort. 

Multivariable linear regression revealed that presenting to any ED or urgent care was independently associated with total cost (β = 502.20, 95% CI: 105.79-898.61; p = 0.01). Additionally, there was a statistically significant association between the squared PCSS and total cost (β = 0.39, 95% CI: 0.11-0.66; p = 0.01), indicating a quadratic relationship (Figure 2) . Accordingly, being diagnosed with PCS was also independently associated with higher cost (β = 670.37, 95% CI: 98.96-1241.79; p = 0.02) ( Table 3) . Athletes who developed PCS had higher initial symptom burdens (Wilcoxon rank-sum; p < 0.01) and incurred a greater average cost of $2579.70 compared with $608.45 for those without PCS (Wilcoxon rank-sum; p < 0.001).

We sought to determine the average direct cost to the healthcare system of an FRC among US high school athletes. Over $115,000 was spent across 144 football SRCs for an average cost of $800 per concussion. Our initial hypothesis was supported, as a diagnosis of PCS was independently associated with higher costs and athletes. Additionally, we found that both visiting the ED and a higher initial symptom burden were independently associated with increased costs. These results represent one initial attempt to quantify the direct costs of SRC, and describe the relationship between symptom burden, prolonged recovery and direct healthcare costs for male, high school athletes who suffer a concussion playing football. 

Many investigations have quantified costs associated with mTBI [6, 8, 26, 27] . However, most studies include only inpatient and ED costs, which make them not applicable to SRC since very few, if any, patients are admitted to the hospital [5, 26, 28] . In pediatric patients with general mTBI, Taylor et al. [8] found a slightly less expensive cost of $608 than our $800 per injury, after inflation adjustment [24] . This difference may be related to our football specific, all-male cohort with an older age range, as increasing age is associated with increased costs in the 1 year post-mTBI [6] . Alternatively, this discrepancy may be related to continuous exponential growth of healthcare spending [29] . Furthermore, the Taylor et al. [8] study reported costs to the payer (i.e., reimbursement), which is more susceptible to outside forces (negotiating power of hospital vs insurer) than provider costs, and may represent declining reimbursement rather than more efficient care [4, 12, 30] .

Emergency room evaluation was independently associated with a higher cost per concussion episode. The indication for an ED visit was not standardized nor documented, but red flags symptoms (intractable nausea, altered mental status) may have been present, warranting the visit. Improving the efficiency of ED utilization represents a potential method to reduce costs. For example, limiting CTH to evidence-based indications [31] , improving ED discharge instructions to emphasize the low yield of standard imaging [32] and early specialty referrals may improve cost. Early specialty concussion clinic referral has been associated with faster recovery time [33] , therefore prompt concussion clinic referral, in lieu of an ED visit, may reduce costs without sacrificing care. Initial symptom burden was strongly associated with costs. Though initial symptom score has been associated with protracted recovery [17, 30] , to our knowledge this is the first instance where highly symptomatic (PCSS >20) athletes and those with PCS were associated with increased costs of concussion care. Interventions to prevent PCS may reduce overall costs. Recent trials have demonstrated that early subthreshold aerobic exercise was associated with a 10% absolute risk reduction for delayed recovery (i.e. PCS) [9] . Quantifying the cost of concussions is the first step in evaluating the cost-effectiveness of other treatment interventions.

Cost-effectiveness of football helmets Over the last decade, helmet research has shifted toward concussion prevention and risk reduction [34] [35] [36] . Despite robust engineering analyses [35, 37, 38] , little attention has been directed toward the costs to achieve these reductions. Like any healthcare intervention, protective equipment should be subject to cost-effectiveness analysis and transparency regarding the cost per incremental improvement.

Consider the hypothetical $525 upgrade from the Riddell Speedflex (MSRP $425 [39] ) to the VICIS Zero 1 (MSRP $950 [40] ). Early reports suggest that the absolute risk reduction by making this change was 3.3% [41] , and therefore 30 helmet upgrades are needed to prevent one concussion. Thus, societal costs to prevent one concussion equates to $15,909. However, the direct healthcare cost of an FRC appears to be only $800. This equation oversimplifies a complex relationship that includes indirect costs of missed school/work and long-term cognitive outcomes. Although simple, this example illustrates the economic disparity between prevention and treatment. Scientific progress cannot move forward without economic awareness and, at present, $15,000 spent to upgrade helmets is likely not the best use of financial resources. Funding may be better spent on hiring full-time athletic trainers focused on improving post-concussion care and mitigating PCS risk [42, 43] . Furthermore, strategies aimed at preventing concussion by limited contact practices or changing gameplay rules (i.e., advancing the kickoff position) represent cost-free interventions that may considerably reduce concussion burdens [44, 45] .

The primary strength of this study is providing an initial attempt to provide a granular accounting of the direct costs associated with FRC. Compared with other 'cost' studies, a major strength of this study lies in the use of hospital cost data rather than billing charges or reimbursement. Charges can greatly overestimate direct costs and cannot be compared across multiple hospital systems while reimbursement can similarly change due to insurer, hospital market share and an individual's ability to pay [22, 23, 46] . Therefore, true hospital cost is likely the most objective method to gauge total costs related to concussion. The ability to precisely review line-item costs on a patient-by-patient basis maximizes the granularity of our cost estimates compared with studies utilizing insurance claims data, for instance. Furthermore we were able to record clinical outcomes for the majority of athletes to demonstrate their recovery trajectories were similar to those previously published [33, 47, 48] .

Despite these strengths, there are important limitations to this study in addition to regional care differences that may limit generalizability. First, direct costs of concussion care reflect those incurred by the health system and these results do not account for costs attributable to FRC that occur outside our health system. Imputed imaging and ED costs mitigate this limitation and inclusion criteria were deliberately set to include athletes who would have received the vast majority of their care within our hospital system. Second, we decided to focus on direct costs rather than providing estimates of indirect costs. Specifically, we did not include the costs of health-related quality-of-life (HRQOL) detriments due inconsistent effect of sports-related concussion on HRQOL among studies ranging from no difference [49] to substantial declines that resolve at the time of symptom resolution [50] . Additionally, a conservative estimate of indirect costs suggested these represent 4% ($32 = 36 x 20 x [16/365]) or less of total costs, calculated using a substantial decline of about 20 QOL points [50] lasting until symptom resolution at 16 days (75th percentile) and an assumption of $36 per year per HRQOL point [51] . Therefore, given our current poor understanding of the costs associated with transient declines in HRQOL, we decided to focus on direct costs exclusively.

Similarly, our study reflects the relatively acute or initial costs associated with FRC. There is emerging evidence of psychological maladies associated with FRC that may lead to higher longitudinal healthcare costs [52, 53] . Yet, as young athletes accumulate life experience following their concussions, drawing a link between a remote FRC and the new development of psychological issues requiring treatment becomes increasingly difficult. Future longitudinal studies may better elucidate what constitutes the delayed costs associated with FRC.

Finally, we focused on a single sport for this initial investigation given the high incidence of FRC and the expenses associated with injury prevention specific to this sport. Future investigations can expand to understand differential healthcare utilization across sports and decision-tree analyses may determine the cost-effectiveness of rehabilitation-based versus equipment-based interventions.

The average cost of a concussion suffered playing high school American Football in the Southeastern USA is approximately $800. Costs are independently associated with the initial symptom burden, ED utilization and/or development of PCS. A granular understanding of the costs and cost-driving factors associated with concussions is a critical first step to study the cost-effectiveness of prevention and treatment methods. We encourage further investigations of the cost-effectiveness of SRC-related interventions in order to make sound economic and scientifically based decisions.

As the prevention and treatment of SRC continues to advance technologically and scientifically, the potential costs to athletes, teams, society and the healthcare system have the potential to expand indefinitely. As these costs mount, attention must be placed on the costs per unit benefit. Stakeholders will demand that these rising costs are matched with benefits in the form of markedly reduced recovery time, reduced risk of any long-term effects of SRC or improved primary protection from SRC. Simple advances that achieve meaningful improvements with near negligible costs will be preferred to significant technological advancements accompanied by disproportionate costs that yield only minor improvements over existing products, methods and treatment standards.

• American high school football-related concussions (FRC) are exceedingly common.

• The healthcare costs of these injuries and what factors drive greater costs have not been previously described. Participants • A total of 144 American high school football players who suffered an FRC were included. • All players received care through a regional, multidisciplinary concussion clinic. Direct healthcare costs • The direct healthcare cost per concussion was about $800. • These costs reflect the direct cost of care to the healthcare system, providing an objective cost measure.

• These costs are objective, reproducible and more generalizable to other health systems, unlike costs/charges as assessed by the insurance company or experienced by patients as these others costs/charges are highly variable across carriers and patients. Cost drivers • Visiting the emergency department, higher initial symptom burden and developing post-concussion syndrome each independently drove higher healthcare costs.

• This provides a calculation of the direct healthcare costs of a sport-related concussion (SRC) in any sport as well as demonstrates the association between symptom burden and costs for the first time. • Understanding the costs associated with SRC provides the groundwork for demonstrating cost-effectiveness of interventions -both preventative and treatment -in the future.

Consensus statement on concussion in sport-the 5th international conference on concussion in sport

Self-reported concussions from playing a sport or being physically active among high school students -United States

Lifetime prevalence of self-reported concussion among adolescents involved in competitive sports: a national U.S. study

Prevalence of concussion among US adolescents and correlated factors

The impact of tackle football injuries on the American healthcare system with a neurological focus

Mild traumatic brain injury in the United States: demographics, brain imaging procedures, health-care utilization and costs

• Provides an excellent accounting of the costs associated with mild traumatic brain injury stratified by age groups

Establishment of a multidisciplinary concussion program: impact of standardization on patient care and resource utilization: clinical article

Trends in Ambulatory Care for Children with Concussion and Minor Head Injury from Eastern Massachusetts between 2007 and 2013

• A similar study to ours that provides the costs and healthcare utilization of a single minor injury in children

Early subthreshold aerobic exercise for sports-related concussion: a randomized clinical trial

• A well-designed trial demonstrated that early aerobic exercise is associated with a 4-day decrease in recovery time and about 10% risk reduction in delayed recovery

Rotational head kinematics in football impacts: an injury risk function for concussion

Validation of a football helmet finite element model and quantification of impact energy distribution

Helmet Laboratory Testing Performance Results

Varsity Football Helmet Ratings

Preinjury migraine history as a risk factor for prolonged return to school and sports following concussion

Predictors of clinical recovery from concussion: a systematic review

• An excellent review of the extensive literature on predictors of recovery in sports-related concussion with extensive references

The role of family and personal psychiatric history in postconcussion syndrome following sport-related concussion: a story of compounding risk

Prognostic factors in pediatric sport-related concussion

Clinical risk score for persistent postconcussion symptoms among children with acute concussion in the ED

Self-report scales/checklists for the measurement of concussion symptoms: a systematic review

Measurement of symptoms following sports-related concussion: reliability and normative data for the post-concussion scale

How long is too long? The lack of consensus regarding the post-concussion syndrome diagnosis

The pricing of U.S. hospital services: chaos behind a veil of secrecy

• Although nearly 40 years old, a critical read for those looking to better understand the distinctions between charges and costs when interpreting economic analyses

Producer price index by commodity: health care services: hospital outpatient care, general medical and surgical hospitals

Adjusting health expenditures for inflation: a review of measures for health services research in the United States

Health & economic burden of traumatic brain injury in the emergency department. Can

Medical costs of mild to moderate traumatic brain injury in children

Hospitalisations for sport-related concussions in US children aged 5 to 18 years during

www.cms.gov/Research-Statistics-Data-and-Systems/Statistics-Trends-and-Reports/NationalHealthExpendData/NHE-Fact-Sheet

Early symptom burden predicts recovery after sport-related concussion

Identification of children at very low risk of clinically-important brain injuries after head trauma: a prospective cohort study

Post-concussion syndrome (PCS) in a youth population: defining the diagnostic value and cost-utility of brain imaging

Association of time since injury to the first clinic visit with recovery following concussion

Birth and evolution of the football helmet

Examining concussion rates and return to play in high school football players wearing newer helmet technology: a three-year prospective cohort study

Concussion characteristics in high school football by helmet age/recondition status, manufacturer, and model: 2008-2009 through 2012-2013 academic years in the United States

Development of the STAR evaluation system for football helmets: integrating player head impact exposure and risk of concussion

Can helmet design reduce the risk of concussion in football?

Helmet Catalog

Helmet Catalog

Coaches Survey of VICIS ZERO1 helmet use in high school football

High school football injury rates and services by athletic trainer employment status

Disparities in athletic trainer staffing in secondary school sport: implications for concussion identification

Effect of a new rule limiting full contact practice on the incidence of sport-related concussion in high school football players

Association between the experimental kickoff rule and concussion rates in Ivy League football

Extreme markup: the fifty US hospitals with the highest charge-to-cost ratios

Natural progression of symptom change and recovery from concussion in a pediatric population

• A landmark study of the natural history of symptoms following concussion. Provides plots of symptoms over time stratified by gender and age group

Acute effects and recovery time following concussion in collegiate football players: the NCAA Concussion Study

The effect of sport-related concussion injuries on concussion symptoms and health-related quality of life in male and female adolescent athletes: a prospective study

Health-related quality of life following adolescent sports-related concussion or fracture: a prospective cohort study

Linking improvements in health-related quality of life to reductions in Medicaid costs among students who use school-based health centers

A review of psychological issues that may be associated with a sport-related concussion in youth and collegiate athletes

Sport-related concussion and risk for suicide in athletes

The authors have no relevant affiliations or financial involvement with any organization or entity with a financial interest in or financial conflict with the subject matter or materials discussed in the manuscript. This includes employment, consultancies, honoraria, stock ownership or options, expert testimony, grants or patents received or pending, or royalties.No writing assistance was utilized in the production of this manuscript.

The authors state that they have obtained appropriate institutional review board approval or have followed the principles outlined in the Declaration of Helsinki for all human or animal experimental investigations.

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/