key: cord-0937373-r25bdie0
authors: De Foo, Chuan; Grépin, Karen A; Cook, Alex R; Hsu, Li Yang; Bartos, Michael; Singh, Sudhvir; Asgari, Nima; Teo, Yik Ying; Heymann, David L; Legido-Quigley, Helena
title: Navigating from SARS-CoV-2 elimination to endemicity in Australia, Hong Kong, New Zealand, and Singapore
date: 2021-10-04
journal: Lancet
DOI: 10.1016/s0140-6736(21)02186-3
sha: deaac09c5b151361b2a1db94a119bb4cfde82dad
doc_id: 937373
cord_uid: r25bdie0

nan

Elimination of COVID-19, broadly defined as no local SARS-CoV-2 transmission for more than 28 days, has been a target considered by Australia, Hong Kong, New Zealand, and Singapore since early in the pandemic. Their elimination strategies are based on earlier successes in interrupting SARS-CoV-2 transmission by using a mix of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) such as forced physical distancing (lockdowns), contact tracing and isolation, testing and quarantine at borders, travel restrictions, and mandatory use of face masks. 1 Elimination strategies have been reported to have contained the virus without severe economic fallout during the first year of the pandemic. 2 Despite their benefits, elimination strategies forestall the development of population immunity among populations with low risk of severe outcomes of infections through natural infection. 3, 4 Initially, elimination strategies were intended to provide time to develop COVID-19 therapies and vaccines, strengthen health systems, and for informed decision making, but some locations continue to adopt them as a long-term response. 5, 6 Yet there are concerns about the sustainability of such strategies and the need to transition away from SARS-CoV-2 elimination. 7 The current status and approaches of these four elimination locations (appendix) as of late September, 2021, are instructive for policy makers and researchers as the world navigates towards an endemic future.

In July, 2021, the Singapore Government declared its intention to move away from a near elimination strategy towards endemicity. 8 A central feature of this shift is the sustained deployment of first-year NPIs while new NPIs, such as distribution of SARS-CoV-2 self-test kits to households to facilitate early case detection, are undertaken to instil a common sense of social responsibility. Concomitantly and throughout the pandemic, the Singapore Government had earmarked about S$100 billion through five budgets to provide targeted and universal relief, of which $53·7 billion was drawn from its national reserves. 9,10 On Sept 1, 2021, with more than 80% of the population fully vaccinated 11 and a strengthened health system with augmented contact tracing, testing, isolation, and treatment resources, Singapore adopted a middle course by increasing liberty of movement while remaining ready to tighten NPIs when needed. 12 In August, 2021, Singapore entered the first of its four-phase reopening roadmap. 13 In this Preparatory Phase, selected NPIs are relaxed while others are expanded to permit increased social and economic activities, including international travel, albeit with a corresponding expectation of increased imported SARS-CoV-2 infections. 14 Under this roadmap, differentiated measures are anticipated, whereby vaccinated individuals enjoy additional liberties and home-based recovery for fully vaccinated individuals with mild or no symptoms and no severe comorbidities is promoted to free up hospital resources. The second and third phases-Transition Stages A and B-foresee a further increase in personal liberties while minimising COVID-19 deaths and the risk of overwhelming Singapore's health system. The strength of NPIs and the rate of transition to these phases will depend on the number of severe COVID-19 cases, SARS-CoV-2 transmission trajectory, vaccination coverage, effectiveness of NPIs, and occupancy of Singapore's 1000 intensive care unit (ICU) bed capacity. A cautious stepwise approach with doorstep interventions for halting sudden spikes in infections ready at every stage is expected to serve as Singapore's guiding principle.

Australia has employed stringent quarantine for incoming international travellers and subnational (state) border closures to contain local outbreaks while retaining first-year NPIs. A national four-stage plan for reopening when vaccination coverage reaches 70-80% of the population was adopted in August, 2021. 15 However, this plan has been hampered by vaccination coverage that is one of the lowest among countries in the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, with mRNA COVID-19 vaccines in short supply until September, 2021. 16 The incursion of the SARS-CoV-2 delta variant highlighted the vulnerabilities of fairly low population vaccination coverage, prompting stricter NPIs such as extended or renewed lockdowns in various jurisdictions, including the Australian Capital Territory, which had held a zerotransmission status for more than a year. 17 Although Australia has the ability to increase ICU bed capacity, there are concerns of a potential shortfall of trained ICU personnel and the country's hospital capacities will be monitored closely. 18, 19 ICU capacity partly guides the strength of NPIs. In a federation where states have constitutional responsibility for health and determine lockdown policies, there has been political tension in relation to abandoning elimination or maintaining zero transmission. For a country whose gross domestic product largely relies on economic income from education, tourism, and trade, reopening only after reaching high vaccination coverage is generally seen as the most practical exit strategy. 20 This approach has driven COVID-19 vaccine swap deals to overcome bottlenecks in vaccine supplies. In September, 2021, Australia was embarking on Phase A of its four-stage reopening roadmap, during which NPIs including lockdowns are enforced in outbreak areas while vaccination is accelerated. By Sept 28, 2021, 53% of people older than 16 years in Australia had been fully vaccinated. 21 In anticipation of the 80% vaccine coverage for the population older than 16 years by the end of November, Australia announced the end of an 18-month travel ban and is working on a framework of testing and home quarantine upon arrival for returning fully vaccinated and unvaccinated Australians as it continues to widen its list of approved vaccines to prepare for increased international travel. 22 The remaining phases of Australia's roadmap will be implemented as vaccine coverage increases.

New Zealand continues its elimination strategy guided by four Health Response Pillars: Keeping it Out, Preparing for it, Stamping it Out, and Managing the Impact. 23 This strategy is achieved by strengthening NPIs and targeted lockdowns while reinforcing New Zealand's historically under-capacitated intensive care operations, 24 to prevent overwhelming the health system. Furthermore, COVID-19 has had a disproportionate impact among already disadvantaged Māori and Pacific populations, prompting an equity motivation to sustaining elimination. 25 To that end, New Zealand uses a four-level Alert System that triggered a nationwide lockdown (Alert Level 4) in August, 2021, after a single case was detected in Auckland, a first community infection identified in 6 months. 26 Vaccination coverage below 20% in August, 2021, 27 and the fast-spreading SARS-CoV-2 delta variant motivated the country to hasten its vaccinations during the lockdowns, including by securing additional COVID-19 vaccine doses from Spain and Denmark. Despite these measures, Auckland's lockdown was extended repeatedly in August and September as new SARS-CoV-2 infections emerged, only to have its Alert Level 4 status reduced on Sept 21 while other jurisdictions moved down to lower Alert levels even before that. 28, 29 If local vaccination is maximised by early 2022, New Zealand envisages a risk-based entry system to the country that subjects travellers to three entry pathways on the basis of vaccination status and country of departure. 30 The success of pilot programmes 30 such as home isolation and high vaccination coverage serve as key prerequisites for more domestic freedoms in New Zealand and reconnection with the world.

Hong Kong responded effectively to its four COVID-19 waves with decisive and strict NPIs without implementing lockdowns coupled with high levels of public compliance. 31 The government disbursed four rounds of aid and a relief package from the Anti-epidemic Fund to individuals and businesses to support them through the prolonged NPIs. 32 However, increasing vaccination coverage is currently a challenge in Hong Kong. There are adequate supplies of COVID-19 vaccines in Hong Kong but vaccine uptake has been slow. Vaccine hesitancy in Hong Kong is a concern, especially among the oldest age groups. 33, 34 In late September, 2021, about 62% of the eligible population in Hong Kong was fully vaccinated, but among those older than 80 years coverage drops to only 14%. 34 To incentivise vaccination, Hong Kong has implemented a set of policies, including differentiated measures such as a vaccine bubble in food and beverage establishments, which regulates the number of patrons and opening hours based on the vaccination statuses of staff and customers. In September, 2021, Hong Kong reiterated its commitment to its elimination strategy with the explicit aim of reopening its borders with mainland China, which mandates zero tolerance towards the virus. 35 Hence, strict NPIs are expected to persist for the foreseeable future, despite increasing criticism from the international business community that the strict quarantine policies are hampering Hong Kong's position as a global business hub. 36 However, a daily quota of Hong Kong residents and other travellers are permitted to return from mainland China under its Return2hk and Come2hk schemes. 37, 38 Lessons from these four locations, consistent with a growing body of medical literature, 39, 40 suggest that the social and economic stressors on populations as a result of elimination strategies that were feasible during the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic might not be sustainable in the future. Although elimination strategies averted a high COVID-19 death toll, especially among those with risk factors for serious illness after SARS-CoV-2 infection, nations that were successful in implementing these strategies develop low population immunity from natural infection and must now increase vaccination coverage to avoid high mortality and other consequences associated with the establishment of SARS-CoV-2 endemicity. To transition safely, we propose four key tenets. First, nations need to retain flexible and short-term NPIs based on the changing epidemiology and hospital capacities and be steadfast in implementing NPIs even when there is a rise in infections from reopening. Second, nations need to ensure maximum vaccination coverage while taking into account risk prioritisation, vaccine dose sparing, and equity principles. Third, the disparate impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic have highlighted the need for more targeted and commensurate relief, to shield to an extent industries and vulnerable groups from the unintended consequences resulting from sustained NPIs. Fourth, nations need to foster extensive surveillance and stronger community social responsibility to detect and isolate COVID-19 cases quickly through more self-testing and home-based isolation while transferring risk assessment skills from institutions to individuals through codesigned risk communication and community engagement strategies, so communities can understand and mitigate their own risks. As places that were successful in early elimination come to terms with integrating into a world where SARS-CoV-2 is endemic, researchers and decision makers need to identify every opportunity to strengthen health system capacities, reduce inequities, and reinforce lasting pandemic preparedness.

NA is Director of the Asia Pacific Observatory on Health Systems and Policies at the WHO Regional Office for South-East Asia and is funded by WHO in this role. The other authors declare no competing interests. The views expressed in this Comment are the authors alone and they do not necessarily represent the decisions or policies of WHO.

Health systems resilience in managing the COVID-19 pandemic: lessons from 28 countries

SARS-CoV-2 elimination, not mitigation, creates best outcomes for health, the economy, and civil liberties

The Lancet Infectious Diseases. The COVID-19 exit strategy-why we need to aim low

Pathways to COVID-19 "community protection

Lessons learnt from easing COVID-19 restrictions: an analysis of countries and regions in Asia Pacific and Europe

Elimination could be the optimal response strategy for covid-19 and other emerging pandemic diseases

A way forward: considering the sustainability, equity and unintended effects of social control measures as a response to the COVID-19 crisis

News Highlights. Endemic COVID-19

Ministry of Finance Singapore. Budget speech for Budget 2021

Budget 2021: expected deficit of S$11 billion; government to draw on reserves for 2nd straight year. CNA

Update on local COVID-19 situation and vaccination progress

Preparing for our transition towards COVID resilience

Singapore must be prepared for more Covid-19 infections, deaths with reopening: Ong Ye Kung. The Straits Times

COVID-19 phase advisory

What's gone wrong with Australia's vaccine rollout? BBC News

COVID-19 statement: ACT to enter seven day lockdown

Concerned" intensive care doctors warn Australia faces surge demand in coming months

We're seeing more COVID patients in ICU as case numbers rise. That affects the whole hospital. The Conversation

The Australian economy in 2020-21: the COVID-19 pandemic and prospects for economic recovery

Australian Government Department of Health

Australia set to restart international travel in November, Scott Morrison says. The Guardian

Ministry of Health New Zealand. COVID-19: elimination strategy for Aotearoa New Zealand

Potential health impacts from the COVID-19 pandemic for New Zealand if eradication fails: report to the NZ Ministry of Health

How Aotearoa New Zealand rapidly revised its Covid-19 response strategy: lessons for the next pandemic plan

About the Alert System

Covid-19: Australian outbreak surges as New Zealand sees first domestic cases in six months

Covid-19 live: Auckland remains in alert level 4, rest of NZ at level 2 for another week, Prime Minister confirms. Stuff

Unite against COVID-19

Government sets out plan to reconnect New Zealanders to the world. The Beehive

Impact assessment of nonpharmaceutical interventions against coronavirus disease 2019 and influenza in Hong Kong: an observational study

COVID-19 thematic website, Together, We Fight the Virus, Anti-epidemic Fund

Vaccine hesitancy and COVID-19 vaccination in Hong Kong

Government of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. Hong Kong vaccination dashboard

Lam lobbies Beijing for border reopening, seeks medical expert dialogue. South China Morning Post

Businesses in Hong Kong slam tightened covid travel curbs. Bloomberg

Information Services Department Government of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. Return2hk Scheme to resume

Government of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. Government announces arrangements for Come2hk Scheme

A literature review of the economics of COVID-19

The socio-economic implications of the coronavirus pandemic (COVID-19): a review