key: cord-0931038-wdidzum8
authors: Citoni, Barbara; Figliuzzi, Ilaria; Presta, Vivianne; Volpe, Massimo; Tocci, Giuliano
title: Home Blood Pressure and Telemedicine: A Modern Approach for Managing Hypertension During and After COVID-19 Pandemic
date: 2021-12-02
journal: High Blood Press Cardiovasc Prev
DOI: 10.1007/s40292-021-00492-4
sha: 3f96f16114790c1224508bab084898924201671d
doc_id: 931038
cord_uid: wdidzum8

Hypertension is the most common cardiovascular risk factor for acute cardiovascular outcomes, including acute coronary disease, stroke, chronic kidney disease and congestive heart failure. Despite the fact that it represents the most prevalent risk factor in the general population, mostly in elderly individuals, its awareness is still relatively low, being about one third of patients living with undiagnosed hypertension and high risk of experiencing acute cardiovascular events. In addition, though recent improvement in pharmacological and non-pharmacological therapeutic options, hypertension is largely uncontrolled, with about 35–40% of treated hypertensive patients achieving the recommended therapeutic targets. Among different modern interventions proposed for improving blood pressure control in treated hypertensive patients, a systematic adoption of home BP monitoring has demonstrated to be one of the most effective. Indeed, it improves patients’ awareness of the disease and adherence to prescribed medications and allows tailoring and personalizing BP lowering therapies. Home BP monitoring is particularly suitable for telemedicine and mobile-health solutions. Indeed, in specific conditions, when face-to-face interactions between patients and physicians are not allowed or even suspended, as in case of COVID-19 pandemic, telemedicine may ensure effective management of hypertension, as well as other cardiovascular and non-cardiovascular comorbidities. This review will summarize strengths and limitations of telemedicine in the clinical management of hypertension with a particular focus on the lessons learned during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Hypertension is still the most common cardiovascular risk factor, being associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular morbidity and mortality at global level. It affects almost one third of adult population and about two thirds of elderly patients in Western Countries [1] , counting for more than 1 billion people worldwide [2] . In spite of the impressive progress in the development of new, effective and safe pharmacological and non-pharmacological therapies, hypertension still remains poorly controlled in the real world practice. Indeed, less than 50% of treated hypertensive patients achieve the recommended blood pressure (BP) therapeutic targets [3, 4] , and even lower proportions of BP control are achieved in high or very high risk categories of patients with hypertension [5] [6] [7] .

There are multiple reasons underlying the poor BP control reported in treated hypertensive patients, though the most relevant items are the low adherence to prescribed medications, as well as the poor awareness of hypertension's consequences [8] . In order to overcome these points, recent hypertension guidelines have proposed two synergistic approaches [9] . The first one is based on a more extended use of fixed (single-pill) combination therapies with two or three antihypertensive drug classes in one pill, to be adopted as first-line strategy in the vast majority of patients with hypertension [9] . Similar approach has been proposed by the Italian Society of Hypertension [10] . This article is aimed at critically discussing the potential clinical advantages offered by telemedicine and M-health solutions, for ensuring home BP monitoring and effective clinical management of hypertension, also during COVID-19 pandemic disease.

Telemedicine originated in the United States in the late 1960s with the aim of monitoring health status of astronauts during space missions. At that time, electrocardiograms were firstly transmitted between the Logan International Airport Medical Station and the Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston. After this pioneering experience, several definitions and potential clinical applications have been proposed, though the idea behind the concept has been substantially unchanged over the years: it is not the patient who moves to health care providers, yet healthcare tools and supports directly get to the patients at their home or work. In 1997 the World Health Organization (WHO) proposed the following unifying definition of telemedicine: "The delivery of health care services, where distance is a critical factor, by all health care professionals using information and communication technologies for the exchange of valid information for diagnosis, treatment and prevention of disease and injuries, research and evaluation, and for the continuing education of health care providers, all in the interests of advancing the health of individuals and their communities". Over the last decades, the progressive improvement in both technical devices and software availabilities allowed rapid transmissions of high-quality data between individual patients and referring physicians even through distant states or countries. This novel approach has been adopted with benefits in the clinical management of different cardiovascular diseases, including hypertension [22, 23] , coronary artery disease and heart failure [24, 25] , cardiac arrhythmias and sudden cardiac death [26] , and, more recently, atrial fibrillation and stroke prevention [27] .

In particular, the daily management of hypertension has been progressively and markedly modified by telemedicine, mostly throughout the use of validated, automated BP devices for measuring out-of-office BP levels. These devices have been recommended for improving awareness of the disease, personalizing antihypertensive therapies, ameliorating BP control and reducing incidence of major cardiovascular events [9] . Indeed, the integration of out-of-office BP measurement approach with office BP measurement has several potential advantages, such as a control of white-coat effect, little or limited cost (related to the acquisition of the BP measuring device), and the The second one is founded on the widespread diffusion of automated and semi-automated devices for measuring BP levels at home [9] . This latter point has particular relevance, since the recent availability of web-based supports and mobile health (M-health) solutions for sharing out-ofoffice information, such as home BP measurements, with treating physicians might be viewed as highly effective way to improve hypertension awareness and control in the modern era [11] .

In this view, the lessons learned during the outbreak of the infection of the Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2), also called COVID-19 [12, 13] , should be now implemented in daily clinical practice for ameliorating the out-of-office, self-management of BP monitoring at home and, thus, reducing the incidence of hypertension-related cardiovascular diseases.

At the beginning of 2020, almost all countries in the world were hit by the COVID-19 pandemic and healthcare systems around the globe were put under an enormous and unexpected pressure [14, 15] . An indirect stunning and threatening consequence of the COVID-19 pandemic was the impact on the daily management of many other acute and chronic non-communicable diseases, including cardiovascular, neoplastic, degenerative and psychological disorders, which have heavily down-sided due to the overwhelming impact of COVID-19 on health care systems.

Restrictive measures progressively adopted by national governments all over the world forced many patients with chronic cardiovascular diseases, including hypertension, at home. In many hospitals, in fact, outpatient visits were suspended or delayed, and there were major difficulties for patients to reach doctors or hospitals during national or local lock-down. Preventive programs, planned visits or interventions, and even access to the emergency rooms were rapidly reduced, and in most cases stopped. Among the patients who suffered a long interruption of their clinical management, also because they were forced to stay at home, those with essential hypertension represented the vast majority [16] . In addition, hypertension represents the most common comorbidity in patients suffering from COVID-19 pulmonary infection [17] . This critical situation was temporarily aggravated by initial reports claiming that hypertension "per se" was a risk factor both for COIVD-19 infection and for more severe course of the pulmonary disease. Besides, some antihypertensive drug classes (mostly ACE inhibitors) were suspected to facilitate the entrance of virus in the human cells, these initial hypotheses were subsequently mitigated or denied by more solid evidence [18] [19] [20] . These evidence were also reinforced by international scientific societies, which clearly stated the not to interrupt antihypertensive medications, including ACE inhibitors, during COVID-19 pandemic [21] . availability of numerous BP data in different settings (home, work, holidays), time periods (morning, afternoon, night) and seasons, health status, and positions (supine, sitting, standing) [28, 29] . In addition, the possibility to have repeated BP measurements and personalized BP diaries on the basis of individual characteristics, job-related attitudes and antihypertensive therapies, represents an important advantage with respect to office BP measurement [28, 29] . More recently, the automated transmission of stored BP data from hypertensive patients to their treating physicians introduced a novel clinical advantage for the clinical management of hypertension, by limiting the potential bias introduced by patients' manipulation of the BP diary, as well as the white-coat phenomenon. A schematic representation of Telemedicine applied for the clinical management of hypertension is illustrated in Fig. 1 [30] .

All these facilities have been recently busted during COVID-19 pandemic, due to the need of maintaining adequate levels of health care in chronic, non-communicable Fig. 1 Schematic representation of an integrated system of telemedicine and Home BP telemonitoring service. In the figure: BP blood pressure, ABPM ambulatory blood pressure monitoring, HBPM home blood pressure monitoring, PDA personal digital assistant, S-FTP secure file transfer protocol, S-HTTP secure hypertext transfer protocol. Derived from reference num [30] conditions, such as hypertension and other cardiovascular diseases, and reducing the need of hospitalizations and access to outpatient clinics for routine or follow-up visits. In this view, telemedicine applied to hypertension represented the best option for maintaining the connections between patients and care providers, also in case of home isolation [31] .

Over the last decades, home BP measurement has gained increasing importance for the clinical management of hypertension. The latest guidelines on hypertension encouraged a more extensive adoption of home BP measurements for improving awareness and control of hypertension in treated patients, and proposed-for the first time-this approach as an useful complement to clinical BP readings performed by treating physicians [32] . Indeed, available evidence suggests that incorporating self-management behaviours, such as home BP monitoring, in educational interventions may be an effective approach for ameliorating BP control, as an example by promoting physical activity and weight loss [33] . In this way, an extended use of home BP measurements might be a cost-effective approach for improving BP control in general population, particularly in those categories of high risk patients with hypertension, such as frail elderly, diabetic, and individuals with comorbidities.

Compared to the previous European guidelines on hypertension [34] , the 2018 ESC/ESH guidelines added in class IA the use of home BP measurements for the diagnosis of arterial hypertension [9] . Out-of-office BP measurement is specifically recommended for a number of clinical indications, such as white-coat and masked hypertension, quantifying the effects of treatment and identifying possible causes of side effects [9] . Indeed, evidence are available demonstrating that HBPM is as reliable as 24-h ambulatory BP monitoring in predicting hypertension-mediated organ damage, and it is even superior to office BP measurements [35] . Given the demonstrated importance of HBPM, the interest in telemonitoring of BP levels at home is growing. Telemedicine, in fact, can reinforce and empower the physicianpatient relationship, and even individualize this relationship, thus further ameliorating BP control and reduced the risk of major cardiovascular outcomes.

In line with these purposes, several cohort clinical studies [36] [37] [38] [39] and randomized controlled clinical trials [40] [41] [42] [43] have been conducted so far in different populations. General characteristics of these studies are reported in Table 1 .

The Japan Morning Surge-Home blood pressure (J-HOP) study included 4310 participants with at least one cardiovascular risk factor and demonstrated that BP measurements taken at home in the morning are associated with increased risk of cardiovascular disease, mostly stroke [36, 37] . Similarly, the ongoing HBPM-iCloud study is an open prospective, multicenter cohort study among participants recruited from three participating health check-up centers in southern China. This study will help to determine the best way to implement telemedicine technology in BP control for better prevention and treatment of hypertension [44] .

In 2015 a group of Koreans researchers performed a randomized clinical trial aimed to assess the effectiveness of remote patient monitoring and physician care in reducing office BP [40] . They randomized 374 hypertensive patients in three groups: in the first group patients received usual clinical care with HBPM; in the second group, the patients were remotely monitored and received office follow-up; and in the third group the patients received remote monitoring without physician office care using the remote monitoring device. For each group, in-office followup care was scheduled every 8 weeks for 24 weeks. The primary endpoint was the difference in sitting systolic BP at the 24-week follow-up. No differences among the three groups were observed. They assessed that remote monitoring alone or remote monitoring coupled with remote physician care was as efficacious as the usual office care for reducing BP with comparable safety and efficacy in hypertensive patients.

In a recent meta-analysis, Omboni and his group collected data from 7037 hypertensive patients enrolled in 23 selected high quality randomized controlled studies [45] . Overall, regular BP telemonitoring at home was associated with a significantly larger reduction in both office and ambulatory BP as compared to usual care. In fact, the mean office systolic and diastolic BP reductions were 4.7 and 2.5 mmHg larger in the BP telemonitoring group. Moreover, a significantly (p < 0.001) larger proportion of patients achieved office BP normalization (< 140/90 mmHg for non-diabetic and < 130/80 mmHg for diabetic patients) in the intervention group.

After COVID-19 pandemic onset and diffusion, the rapid involvement of millions of people worldwide forced local and national healthcare systems to adopt telemedicine for ensuring baseline and, in some selected cases, advanced healthcare supports. This was the case for several chronic progressive cardiovascular diseases, such as pulmonary hypertension [46] , congestive heart failure [47] [48] [49] and chronic kidney disease [50] , but also for non-cardiovascular diseases, mostly onco-hematologic diseases [51, 52] . Among these conditions, essential hypertension represents an ideal target for telemedicine, since: (1) it affects In addition, participants with inadequate BP control at recruitment might gain more benefits with mHealth intervention [63] millions of people across all age, gender, and ethnic groups almost in all countries all over the world; (2) it requires periodic assessment of both vital signs (i.e., BP levels) and adherence to prescribed interventions (life-style changes and/or drug therapies); it is highly affected and positively influenced by frequent interactions between patients and health care providers from both educational and therapeutic point of views. High levels of compliance and effectiveness of telemedicine in hypertension have been demonstrated in several interventional studies performed in Italy [41, 53, 54] , United Kingdom [42, 55] , Scotland [56, 57] , and Canada [58] . Unfortunately, none of these studies were conducted during the COVID-19 pandemic and, mostly, they often involved relatively small sample of treated/untreated hypertensive patients and/or highly selected general practitioners or specialized physicians, who were trained and compliant with modern facilities of telemedicine. What we have observed during the first months of the COVID-19 pandemic was the extremely heterogenous methodology adopted by physicians for contrasting this unconventional and exceptional condition. In a very short period, almost all doctors were forced to simultaneously use telemedicine, not within the assistance of a given protocol, but in the setting of real-life practice. Most of these physicians who had to use telemedicine for monitoring their patients during the COVID-19 pandemic, did not have proper training or education, did not adopted uniform protocols for patients' interactions (synchronized or asynchronized interventions), used different devices (smartphones, tablets, computers), facilities (phone contacts, text messages, e-mails, video-interviews, vocal messages), and medical programs. In addition, most of these devices were not validated and did not ensure proper level of privacy and confidentiality for patients' clinical data.

As expected, all these aspects further generated confusion and, potentially, improper medical decisions, thus negatively affecting hypertension control and, possibly, further promoting anxiety and concern by the patients. In line with these considerations, a recent international expert position paper has been published for providing evidence and recommendations on the use of telemedicine for the clinical management of hypertension also in case of home isolation and limited access to health care points [31] . Similar recommendations have been also provided by the Hypertension Cardiovascular Outcome Prevention, Evidence in Asia (HOPE Asia) Network [59] .

In line with these recommendations, some interventions might be proposed for a more extended use of telemedicine for the clinical management of hypertension, when direct (face-to-face) interactions are not allowed or in case of home isolation, physical inabilities or geographical limitations. First of all, extensive upgrading towards high speed internet connections is an urgent and mandatory element for allowing the use of telemedicine in daily clinical practice, particularly in low-income countries or in specific regional areas of highincome countries. Secondly, the systematic adoption of a validated protocol for measuring BP levels at home, such as those promoted by the Italian Society of Hypertension or other international hypertension societies, will render clinical BP information more easy to interpret and less affected by individual characteristics or conditions. Thirdly, clear identification of which physical parameters (age, gender, ethnicity, height, weight) and vital signs (BP, heart rate, oxygen saturation) should be transmitted to treating physicians, as well as guidance on how to interpret these information would help doctors in ameliorating clinical interventions in hypertension and avoiding legal consequences.

Diagnostic and therapeutic algorithms based on artificial intelligence and machine learning have been recently proposed for helping physicians with large amount of clinical data, thought the clinical effectiveness of this approach should be confirmed in large clinical studies.

Some potential limitations should be acknowledged. First of all, there is still large heterogeneity in internet connections across different countries, particularly in low-income countries, which render the transmission of high quality data particularly difficult in some selected areas or regions. In addition, socio-economic considerations should be made for those users who have limited access to modern devices and high quality technologies, which represent mandatory aspects for sharing clinical data throughout the clouds. Some other considerations can be made, regarding several psychological aspects of telemedicine, such as low empathy between patients and doctors, absence of physical interaction and impossibility to perform proper physical examination, cultural or emotional barriers for using telemedicine instead of conventional medical consultation.

Hypertension is the major driven for the increased risk of acute cardiovascular events, worldwide. Despite the availability of safe and effective drug therapies, the percentage of treated patients with adequate clinic BP control remains low. E-health solutions, specifically telemedicine, may help to establish and build an enduring and long-term relationship between patients and their treating doctors, particularly in case of hypertension, a lifetime condition needing continuous medical supervision and frequent patient-doctor interactions or clinical consultations.

The COVID-19 pandemic forced doctors to use telemedicine for monitoring and treating a large spectrum of chronic clinical conditions, among which hypertension represented the most frequent one. Despite the large heterogeneity reported by physicians in the protocols and attitudes for managing hypertension during this dramatic period, a common conclusion was the high patients' compliance and the relatively good rate of acceptance of this novel approach, also by elderly individuals.

More studies and recommendations are needed to improve the systematic adoption of telemedicine in the daily clinical practice of hypertension, also in "COVID-free" future periods.

Funding None.

Global burden of cardiovascular diseases and risk factors, 1990-2019: update from the GBD 2019 study

Global burden of hypertension: analysis of worldwide data

Prevalence and control of hypertension in the general practice in Italy: updated analysis of a large database

Blood pressure levels and control in Italy: comprehensive analysis of clinical data from

Blood Pressure Targets Achievement According to 2018 ESC/ESH Guidelines in Three European Excellence Centers for Hypertension

Blood pressure target achievement under monotheraphy: a real-life appraisal

Group SSILsVdI-AnS. Blood pressure control according to new guidelines targets in low-to high-risk hypertensives managed in specialist practice

Why in 2016 are patients with hypertension not 100% controlled? A call to action

ESC/ESH Guidelines for the management of arterial hypertension

2012 consensus document of the Italian Society of Hypertension (SIIA): strategies to improve blood pressure control in Italy: from global cardiovascular risk stratification to combination therapy

Does home blood pressure monitoring improve patient outcomes? A systematic review comparing home and ambulatory blood pressure monitoring on blood pressure control and patient outcomes

Clinical characteristics of coronavirus disease 2019 in China

A novel coronavirus from patients with pneumonia in China

Comorbidity and its impact on 1590 patients with COVID-19 in China: a nationwide analysis

Clinical characteristics of non-critically ill patients with novel coronavirus infection (COVID-19) in a Fangcang Hospital

Trends in outpatient emergency department visits during the COVID-19 pandemic at a large, urban, academic hospital system

Prevalence of co-morbidities and their association with mortality in patients with COVID-19: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Reninangiotensin-aldosterone system blockers and the risk of Covid-19

Renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system inhibitors and risk of Covid-19

A retrospective study from 2 centers in china on the effects of continued use of angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors and angiotensin II receptor blockers in patients with hypertension and COVID-19

Renin-angiotensin system inhibition in cardiovascular patients at the time of COVID19: much ado for nothing? A statement of activity from the directors of the board and the scientific directors of the italian society of hypertension

The role of telemedicine in hypertension management: focus on blood pressure telemonitoring

E-health in hypertension management: an insight into the current and future role of blood pressure telemonitoring

Telerehabilitation in heart failure patients: the evidence and the pitfalls

Telemedical Interventional Management in Heart Failure II (TIM-HF2), a randomised, controlled trial investigating the impact of telemedicine on unplanned cardiovascular hospitalisations and mortality in heart failure patients: study design and description of the intervention

Potential role of home monitoring to reduce inappropriate shocks in implantable cardioverter-defibrillator patients due to lead failure

Large-scale assessment of a smartwatch to identify atrial fibrillation

Italian society of hypertension guidelines for conventional and automated blood pressure measurement in the office, at home and over 24 hours

European Society of Hypertension practice guidelines for home blood pressure monitoring

Telemedicine and M-health in hypertension management: technologies, applications and clinical evidence

Evidence and recommendations on the use of telemedicine for the management of arterial hypertension: an international expert position paper

Value of home blood pressures as predictor of target organ damage in mild arterial hypertension

Using mHealth technology to enhance self-monitoring for weight loss: a randomized trial

ESH/ESC guidelines for the management of arterial hypertension: the Task Force for the Management of Arterial Hypertension of the European Society of Hypertension (ESH) and of the European Society of Cardiology (ESC)

Home blood pressure is as reliable as ambulatory blood pressure in predicting target-organ damage in hypertension

Morning and evening home blood pressure and risks of incident stroke and coronary artery disease in the Japanese general practice population: the japan morning surge-home blood pressure study

Day-by-day variability of home blood pressure and incident cardiovascular disease in clinical practice: the J-HOP Study (Japan Morning Surge-Home Blood Pressure)

Home blood pressure monitoring and e-Health: investigation of patients' experience with the Hy-Result system

A prospective cohort study of home blood pressure monitoring based on an intelligent cloud platform (the HBPM-iCloud study): rationale and design

Randomized clinical trial to assess the effectiveness of remote patient monitoring and physician care in reducing office blood pressure

Home blood pressure telemonitoring improves hypertension control in general practice. The TeleBPCare study

Telemonitoring and self-management in the control of hypertension (TASMINH2): a randomised controlled trial

The effectiveness of home blood pressure on 24-hour blood pressure control: a randomized controlled trial

Direct comparison of home versus ambulatory defined nocturnal hypertension for predicting cardiovascular events: the Japan morning surge-home blood pressure (J-HOP) study

Clinical usefulness and cost effectiveness of home blood pressure telemonitoring: meta-analysis of randomized controlled studies

How COVID-19 affected the introduction of telemedicine and patient reported outcomes among patients with pulmonary hypertension

Telemedicine in heart failure during COVID-19: a step into the future

Heart failure management during the COVID-19 outbreak in Italy: a telemedicine experience from a heart failure university tertiary referral centre

Feasibility and accuracy of teleechocardiography, with examinations by nurses and interpretation by an expert via telemedicine, in an outpatient heart failure clinic

Home run-results of a chronic kidney disease Telemedicine Patient Education Study

COVID-19 emergency and post-emergency in italian cancer patients: how can patients be assisted?

Reorganization tips from a sarcoma unit at time of the COVID-19 pandemic in Italy: early experience from a regional referral oncologic center

Blood pressure control and treatment adherence in hypertensive patients with metabolic syndrome: protocol of a randomized controlled study based on home blood pressure telemonitoring vs. conventional management and assessment of psychological determinants of adherence (TELEBPMET Study)

Telemonitoring of 24-hour blood pressure in local pharmacies and blood pressure control in the community: the templar project

Telemonitoring and self-management in the control of hypertension (TASMINH2): a cost-effectiveness analysis

Telemonitoring based service redesign for the management of uncontrolled hypertension: multicentre randomised controlled trial

Telemonitoring-based service redesign for the management of uncontrolled hypertension (HITS): cost and cost-effectiveness analysis of a randomised controlled trial

The impact of a multidisciplinary information technologysupported program on blood pressure control in primary care

COVID-19 and hypertension-evidence and practical management: Guidance from the HOPE Asia Network

Impact of clinical pharmacist services delivered via telemedicine in the outpatient or ambulatory care setting: a systematic review

Self-monitoring of blood pressure in hypertension: a systematic review and individual patient data meta-analysis

Digital interventions to promote self-management in adults with hypertension: protocol for systematic review and meta-analysis

Interactive mobile health intervention and blood pressure management in adults. Hypertension