key: cord-0916253-x0e390jx
authors: Melo, Paulo; Manarte-Monteiro, Patricia; Veiga, Nélio; de Almeida, André Brandão; Mesquita, Pedro
title: COVID-19 Management in Clinical Dental Care Part III: Patients and the Dental Office
date: 2020-12-26
journal: Int Dent J
DOI: 10.1016/j.identj.2020.12.028
sha: 3f04bc964bf9c5576afb113d9cf6deb181c498e1
doc_id: 916253
cord_uid: x0e390jx

The COVID-19 pandemic dramatically changed all aspects of life. In the context of clinical dental care, a significant number of new recommendations have been implemented in order to comply with public health policies, ensuring the safety of dental care professionals, staff, and patients, and preventing further spread of the virus. This paper is the 3rd in a series of three on the management of COVID-19 in clinical dental care and presents a set of recommendations and standards to be implemented in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. These include remote contact with all patients for triage and guidance before scheduling a clinical visit to know if they have COVID symptoms or are COVID positive, if they belong to a risk group, and if there is a suggestion that aerosol-generating procedures (AGP) will be required during their visit. It also reviews additional precautionary measures in the waiting room and reception area, where the environment is reorganized in order to protect patients and clinical staff, avoiding situations that could result in cross contamination. The dental office operate under a strict set of guidelines, namely, use of personal protective equipment by professionals, contact with patients, a strategy to avoid AGP, as well as disinfection procedures for the dental office before, during, and after each patient visit. The implementation of these protocols to mitigate cross-infection and spread of SARS-CoV-2 in the dental office will help improve safety and restore the confidence required to provide dental care to patients during the COVID-19 pandemic.

The COVID-19 pandemic has dramatically changed the routines in all aspects of life contexts. In the context of clinical dental care, where preventive measures to avoid cross-contamination were already in place, a significant number of new recommendations have been implemented in order to comply with public health policies, ensuring the safety of dental care professionals, staff, and patients, and thus, preventing further spread of the virus. [1] This paper is the 3rd in a series of three on the management of COVID-19 in clinical dental care. As previously stated, although it might occur in some medical procedures there is no evidence of SARS-CoV-2 transmission through aerosol-generating procedures (AGP) in a dental care setting. [2] Considering the possibility of interactions of people in the dental office with others in the environment, collective diligence is essential (COVID-Management in Clinical Dental Care. Part I). [2] The recommendations regarding clinical dental care in the era of COVID-19 focus on prevention and safety. [3] Such recommendations should be adjusted to the epidemiological setting (prevalence of infection in the area at the time when care is delivered), the patient's individual characteristics, and the type of procedures to be performed, together with access to personal protective equipment (PPE) (COVID-Management in Clinical Dental Care. Part II). Protocols for cleaning, disinfection, and sterilization of the dental care environment, as well as equipment, to mitigate cross-infection also need to be adjusted.

Every dental office should implement a set of basic standards, preferably in writing, for patients, dental care professionals, and staff to follow, with consideration of the level of risk.

The entire team (both clinical and administrative personnel) should be well-educated about the disease and the modes of transmission to identify high-risk individuals and adopt appropriate preventive measures. [4] Dental care professionals should continuously evaluate the rationale for the adopted measures, including the cost-benefit ratio, without ever placing any of the involved individuals, or the public, at risk. This 3rd paper aims to present a set of recommendations that includes triage and guidance to all patients before scheduling a dental appointment, guidance on personnel preventive measures and healthy literacy, additional precautionary measures for the waiting room, reception area and dental operatory, as well as disinfection procedures before, during, and after each patient visit.

The COVID-19 pandemic requires several changes to dental practice that should be considered, namely, how the dentist and staff deal with the patient before, during, and after a dental visit so as to improve the safety of all participants and minimize the risk of transmission.

It is recognized that many COVID-positive patients are asymptomatic and, therefore, all patients seen in the dental office should ideally be evaluated (by a diagnostic test) to verify that they are not infected with SARS-CoV-2. [5] However, , the utility and sensitivity of diagnostic tests are still unclear, even though nasal swab tests have offered high reliability (COVID-Management in Clinical Dental Care. Part I). On the other hand, neither the antigen (virus) nor the immunological (antibody) tests can at present accurately define current/previous infection with SARS-CoV-2. [5] As stated before, it is not now possible to accurately determine who is infected with SARS-CoV-2 and, thus, every patient should be considered as potentially infected at all times while in the dental office. Of course, the epidemiologic setting should also be taken into account because the risk of actually being infected depends largely on the prevalence of the disease in that location.

Therefore, the first step to prepare for a dental visit is to remotely contact (by phone or electronically) all patients scheduled to visit the dental office for an appointment in order to obtain current information about the patient's status and allow an accurate assessment at the time of the visit. The scheduling of visits, specifically their duration and the intervals between appointments, should be adjusted during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Remote triage should help determine if the patient has been, is, or is at risk of being COVID-19positive. It is also important to know if the patient belongs to any of the high-risk groups and if AGP is expected during their visit. This information will allow identifying COVID-19 positive patients or those t high-risk as well as the need for procedures that require additional precautions. Patients should be asked specifically whether they have acute respiratory signs or symptoms compatible with COVID-19 (Table 1) , [4, 6, 7] a positive diagnosis for COVID -19, or have had unprotected contact with a confirmed or suspected COVID-19 case. If a positive response is elicited, ask if the patient is still in isolation or the quarantine period. If symptoms suggestive of COVID-19 are present, the patient should be instructed to contact the local or national health public authorities and follow the appropriate guidelines.

For patients identified as cases or potential cases of COVID-19, the first option should be to try to resolve or mitigate the patient's problem remotely and postpone or reschedule the visit so that the patients can comply with the mandatory quarantine/isolation period. When the situation is urgent or cannot be postponed, and rescheduling is not an option, the patient should be considered at high-risk, and the visit scheduled. Urgent situations include severe pain (not manageable with analgesic therapy), severe infection (affecting the fasciae and deep tissues of the head and neck, fever, trismus, general malaise), dental or orofacial trauma, and uncontrolled hemorrhage. [4] According to the region or country, the treatment of patients identified as cases or potential cases of COVID-19 can have at least three different paths. The first consists of scheduling the appointment at the dental office at a specific time, which should preferably be the last appointment in the morning or the afternoon. This will prevent the patient from having contact with other patients in the waiting room and will allow time for air recirculation after the visit. [4, 6] The second path is referring the patient to a dental office dedicated to COVID cases where the patient will schedule the appointment. The third path is referring the patient to a government dental clinic or hospital dedicated to COVID cases, which may be a local emergency department, a public health clinic, or a dental school, where the patient will schedule a visit.

In cases where low risk is identified by remote triage, the test for infection is negative, or the patient has already recovered from COVID-19 (presumably now immune), the patient can be scheduled for a regular dental visit. [6] Information regarding the patients' age and health status should also be obtained to understand the patient's health risk. Patients older than 65 years of age, pregnant, or with comorbidities must be considered as high-risk, as described previously (COVID-Management in Clinical Dental Care. Part I). These patients should have visits scheduled for the first time slot in the morning or afternoon.

Visits where AGP are required should also be considered as high-risk. Visits without AGP should be scheduled for the first time slots in the morning or the afternoon, while visits with AGP should be scheduled for the last slot of the morning or afternoon. However, it is not always possible to foresee whether the dental treatment will include AGP, and therefore some flexibility must be built into the schedule.

After the remote triage, patients with scheduled visits should be informed of the infection control procedures (Table 1 ). This information should include all procedures from when the patient enters the dental office until they leave. Beforehand, patients should also be informed that they are required to wear a face mask during the entire time they are in the dental office, except when care is delivered, and to avoid bringing unnecessary clothing or accessories. [6] They must be asked to arrive alone and on time to minimize the time spent in the waiting room. Additional precautions could be taken, advising patients to wait outside the office, in the car or elsewhere, and call them when it is time to enter. In justified situations -if the patient is a minor or has a motor or cognitive disability, they may be accompanied by no more than one person, who should also follow the infection control measures described for patients (Table 1) . Patients should preferably pay the bill by credit/debit card using the contactless option or another method that avoids the exchange of cash.

To guarantee the safety of all participants and minimize the risk of transmission, a set of basic standards should be implemented in all dental offices, covering all aspects of contact with patients ( Table 2) .

In order for safety procedures to be properly implemented, information should be provided to the before the visit. This begins with entry of the patient into the office. There should be a dispenser with an alcohol-based antiseptic solution (ABAS) for patients to disinfect their hands upon arrival, body temperature should be measured via pyrometry and patients must return home and stay under observation if the temperature is ≥ 38.0°C. A surgical mask should be provided if the patient is not wearing one, social distancing should be respected, and the patient should be reminded of the protection and safety measures currently in force in the dental office (Table 1) . [6, 8] Furthermore, there may be a mat soaked in a disinfectant solution at the entrance to the dental office for the patient to disinfect their shoes, or shoe covers may be provided.

Upon arrival at the dental office, it is important to again ask if the patient has developed any signs and symptoms compatible with COVID-19 since the last contact (Table 1 ). If the patient denies having these symptoms but demonstrates them while in the waiting room or before the visit begins, they should be informed that they are considered a potential COVID-19 case and will have to reschedule the visit. If in the presence of an urgent situation, one of the paths described above for urgent situations, with patients identified as cases or potential cases of COVID-19, must be taken.

Changes should be implemented in the reception area, waiting room, and common areas of the dental office, as described in Table 2 . It is important to clearly post pictograms developed by local or national health entities regarding handwashing and hand hygiene. The number of patients in the waiting room must be limited, and long periods in the waiting room should be avoided. Moreover, common areas should be cleaned and disinfected (Table 2) every 1 to 2 hours, including floors, light switches, door handles and knobs, reception desks, acrylic barriers, and support tables. [6, 9, 10] All newspapers, magazines, and other unnecessary items must be removed from the waiting room. Frequent air renewal in the waiting room, preferably by opening the windows, is advised. [11] In the dental operatory

The dental procedures in the dental operatory should also be adjusted during the COVID-19 pandemic ( Table 3 ).

The number of professionals inside the dental operatory should be limited to the minimum required, and unnecessary movement in and out of the office should be avoided. During treatment, the office door should stay closed for the duration of the appointment (Table 3) . [12, 13] Phones and cellphones should not be used inside the operatory.

Professionals should carefully wash their hands before and after treatment and after every contact with potentially contaminated surfaces or equipment. The guidelines for donning and doffing the recommended PPE should be carefully followed, as previously described (COVID-Management in Clinical Dental Care. Part II), and PPE should be worn when the patient enters the operatory. [14] Patients should disinfect their hands before entering the dental operatory. After seating and before dental treatment begins, the patient should remove their mask and rinse with a 1% hydrogen peroxide solution for 30 seconds, as SARS-CoV-2 is sensitive to oxidation, or with 0.2% iodopovidone, except if the patient is allergic to iodine. [8, 15] Once dental treatment is completed, the patient should put the mask on again and leave the dental office directly to go to the reception, where they should schedule their next appointment, if required. Some procedures during dental treatment might mitigate AGP. Dental treatment should be performed together with a chairside assistant (four-handed dentistry), and high-speed suction should be used. The use of spray-generating equipment, such as three-way air/water spray, ultrasonic scaler, and high-or low-speed handpieces, should be avoided if possible. In some procedures, the water stream from those instruments may be reduced, and they should be positioned in a way that the generated spray stays mainly within the patient's oral cavity.

Whenever possible, the three-way air/water spray can be used for irrigation, followed by drying without spray, and low-speed handpieces should replace high-speed handpieces.

Different AGP may generate different amounts of aerosol and proper evacuation is needed.

During removal of caries or restorative procedures, manual instrumentation or chemomechanical approaches such as Carisolv® should be used when possible to minimize AGP. [16] [17] [18] Preventive interventions or minimally invasive treatments are preferred. The treatment approach should be effective and pragmatic. The duration of each visit should be adjusted to the specific needs of each patient and treatment complexity. Whenever possible, multiple procedures should be performed at the same visit to reduce the number of patient visits. [6] For surgical procedures, resorbable sutures should be used to avoid a visit for suture removal. [8, 15] 

After each dental visit (Table 3) , air should be renewed for at least 10-15 minutes with air from outside the building, whenever possible, and the dental office should ideally be naturally ventilated by regularly opening windows. However, natural ventilation varies in different locations; it may be limited by natural climate conditions, such as the wind flow, or differences in temperature and humidity between the outside and inside air, particularly when high airflow is required. Moreover, natural ventilation can be limited when outside temperatures are extreme. [19] Alternatively, mechanical ventilation systems that allow air renewal without air recirculation may be used. [6, 12, 20] Nevertheless, airflow in the wrong direction may help disseminate an infection and therefore outflow must always be directed to areas where there are no people, or directly to the outside. [6, 12, 13, 16] The maximum ventilation rate (above which the risk of infection does not decrease) is unknown. [10, 16, 17] If an air conditioning system is used, it should be in the air extraction mode and never in the air recirculation mode.

The system must be properly maintained, including disinfection by an approved method. [16] The use of portable air filtration devices with high-efficiency particulate air (HEPA) filters, although apparently advantageous, may have some disadvantages because it is difficult to effectively control the flow of droplets in the direction of the filter, the filtering capacity is limited, the filter must be leak-proof to be efficient, and the in-flow and out-flow of air are generally close to each other on these units, thus reducing filter effectiveness. [10, 16, 21] The use of other systems, such as ultraviolet or other wavelengths with germicidal irradiation, photocatalytic oxidation, (e.g photohydroionisation), or ozone-generating air purifiers, is controversial as their effectiveness against SARS-CoV-2 and other coronaviruses has not been evaluated in the dental environment. Further, they may pose risks of occupational exposure when improperly calibrated. Consequently, there are no definitive recommendations regarding the use of these systems. [16, 22] 

The dental operatory should be cleaned and disinfected by individuals wearing PPE. The interval between visits must allow time for cleaning and disinfection, organization of the operatory room, and change of PPE. The cleaning, disinfection, and protection of surfaces and the cleaning and disinfection of floors between appointments (Table 4 ) should never be conducted before air renewal. Vacuum cleaners or brooms should not be used. [19, 23] Disposable barriers made of plastic, cellophane, or aluminum protecting the hoses of the equipment and the surfaces that are most exposed to hand contact (e.g., light and tray handles, rotary instruments, curing light) [15] (Table 3) should be replaced after each visit (Table 4 ). Thorough cleaning and disinfection of every surface and area of contact with the patient (e.g., armrests and headrest, spittoon, suction instrument, tray, lights, switches/buttons, surfaces, and chair), [8, 24] including door handles and knobs, should be performed between dental visits.

Cleaning and disinfection (Table 2, Table 3 , and Table 4 ) should be conducted using ordinary domestic detergents and disinfectants (e.g., 0.1-0.5% sodium hypochlorite for 1 minute for non-metallic surfaces; or 70% alcohol for at least 1 minute; or 0.5-1% hydrogen peroxide for at least 10 minutes). [3] Small surfaces may be washed and disinfected with alcohol-based or bleach-based disinfectant wipes or other disinfectant products. A fog disinfection system might be used.

The floor should be disinfected between visits with a ready-to-use solution containing sodium hypochlorite at a 0.5% concentration or 70% alcohol for metal or other surfaces that are not compatible with sodium hypochlorite. Other virucidal cleaning and disinfectant products may be used for the floor and surfaces, including chloride tablets to dilute in water at the time of use and detergent solutions containing a disinfectant in spray, liquid or other forms. [23] Regarding the collection, separation, handling, and decontamination of products and medical devices removed from their package but not used, the protocols currently in force for the disinfection and sterilization procedures remain valid in the context of COVID-19. [25] All packaged products and materials exposed during the clinical procedures and not used should be thoroughly cleaned and disinfected before being stored again in drawers or closets.

Management of residues and contaminated material should preferably be accomplished wearing thick rubber gloves and a waterproof apron or gown (COVID-Management in Clinical Dental Care. Part II). Waste, including PPE, should be handled in accordance with healthcare facility policies and local regulations.

Dental care providers have a civic and professional responsibility to ensure the safety of their staff, patients, the public, and themselves. When dental care professionals and staff arrive at their workplace, they should adopt a sequence of preventive procedures even before donning PPE. First, body temperature should be measured via pyrometry; if the temperature is ≥ 38.0°C, they should be told to return home and stay under observation. Dental care professionals and staff should remove every accessory, such as rings, bracelets, necklaces, earrings, watches, and other personal items, and store them in a personal locker, and should preferably not take a cellphone into the dental operatory. Disinfect the cellphone with a disposable towel/paper soaked in 70% alcohol whenever it is used. Hands, face, and neck should be washed with water and soap (40 to 60 seconds) or with an alcohol solution (20 seconds) before donning and after doffing the PPE, especially when the workday is over and before going home. Every dental care professional and staff should keep their fingernails short and clean, and artificial nails or other nail extensions are contraindicated, as is nail polish and other similar products.

Considering the frequent use of and contact with detergent and disinfectant biocide products to clean and disinfect the dental office, the handling, dilution, and use of these products should be done carefully, following occupational safety recommendations. Good ventilation of the areas where these procedures are used is mandatory. [23] The labeling and safety information about these products should be read and understood before their use, and training and educational monitoring policies should be in place.

Every recommendation presented above should be adapted to the local setting and the context of each dental office.

As the population acquires immunity (group or herd immunity) and/or an effective treatment or vaccine for SARS-CoV-2 is found, the threat level is expected to be reduced. Until then, dental care professionals have the duty to help limit the spread of this disease, including helping to educate and inform patients and the public of prevention and safety procedures.

The best way to prevent COVID-19 is to avoid being exposed to SARS-CoV-2, by maintaining social distancing, washing hands, routinely cleaning and disinfecting touched surfaces, and wearing a face mask. [26] All staff working in dental offices should be informed and have regular refresher training on prevention, safety, and spread of SARS-CoV-2 infection. [27] The experience acquired during this pandemic will reinforce and strengthen dental office infection prevention.

The implementation of these recommendations to mitigate cross-infection and the spread of SARS-CoV-2 in the dental office will improve the safety and restore the confidence required to provide dental care to the population during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Dental care professionals should regularly evaluate the rationale for the indicated recommendations, including the cost-benefit ratio, without ever placing any of the involved individuals, or the public, at risk.

These recommendations are not meant to supersede, but to complement, the information issued by national and international health authorities, including the World Health Organization. [1] 6. Pay the bill by credit/debit card, preferably using the contactless option.

7. Respect a 2-meter distance from other patients in the waiting room. Table 2 -Precautionary measures and cleaning and disinfection procedures for common areas of the dental clinic (reception, waiting room, and bathroom). Table 3 -Measures for the dental office before, during, and after patient clinical dental care.

Before dental care During dental care After dental care

Considerations for the provision of essential oral health services in the context of COVID-19

Clinical evidence based review and recommendations of aerosol generating medical procedures in otolaryngology -head and neck surgery during the COVID-19 pandemic

COVID-19 Transmission in Dental Practice: Brief Review of Preventive Measures in Italy

SFSCMFCO, Practitioners specialized in oral health and coronavirus disease 2019: Professional guidelines from the French society of stomatology, maxillofacial surgery and oral surgery, to form a common front against the infectious risk. 2020: French Society of Stomatology, Maxillo-Facial Surgery

Measures for diagnosing and treating infections by a novel coronavirus responsible for a pneumonia outbreak originating in Wuhan, China. Microbes and infection

Transmission routes of 2019-nCoV and controls in dental practice

The epidemiological characteristics of an outbreak of 2019 novel coronavirus diseases (COVID-19) in China. 2020, Epidemiology Working Group for NCIP Epidemic Response

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19): Emerging and Future Challenges for Dental and Oral Medicine

Possible aerosol transmission of COVID-19 and special precautions in dentistry

Natural ventilation for infection control in health-care settings. WHO guidelines

Quantitative microbial monitoring in a dental office

Outbreak: An Overview on Dentistry

Guidance for wearing and removing personal protective equipment in healthcare settings for the care of patients with suspected or confirmed COVID-19

Recommendations from the Guidelines for Infection Control in Dental Health-Care Settings

Severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) and the GDP. Part II: implications for GDPs

Effectiveness evaluation of different suction systems

COVID-19): Implications for Clinical Dental Care

WHO, -: interim guidance

A pilot study of bioaerosol reduction using an air cleaning system during dental procedures

Prevention of exposure to and spread of COVID-19 using air purifiers: challenges and concerns. Epidemiol Health

Enforcement Policy for Sterilizers, Disinfectant Devices, and Air Purifiers During the Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19). Public Health Emergency Guidance for Industry and Food and Drug Administration Staff

Aerosol and Surface Distribution of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 in Hospital Wards

The Business Research Company

Protect Yourself. 2020

COVID-19 infection prevention and control for primary care, including general practitioner practices, dental clinics and pharmacy settings

Install an acrylic barrier at the reception desk or a sign advising a distance of at least 1.5 meters

Keep the reception area clean, with the minimum necessary office material on the reception desk

Keep a dispenser with an alcohol-based antiseptic solution in the reception area

Remove from the waiting room all decorative objects, magazines, water dispensers, and any other nonessential items that could be handled by multiple persons

Store TV and air-conditioner remote controls away from patients

Remove from the waiting room all furniture and other items with upholstery that may be difficult to clean and disinfect

Post a pictogram in all bathrooms with instructions about how to hand wash. Do not brush teeth in the bathroom

Ventilate, preferably naturally, common areas

Clean and disinfect door and window knobs, banisters, handrails, blinds, light switches, tables, chairs, and desks

Clean and disinfect the reception area and reception desk

Clean and disinfect the working table

Clean and disinfect the telephone, cellphone, computer keyboard and monitor, and printer

Clean and disinfect bathrooms, including their floor