key: cord-0916067-81u0s572
authors: Baenas, Isabel; Etxandi, Mikel; Munguía, Lucero; Granero, Roser; Mestre-Bach, Gemma; Sánchez, Isabel; Ortega, Emilio; Andreu, Alba; Moize, Violeta L.; Fernández-Real, Jose-Manuel; Tinahones, Francisco J.; Diéguez, Carlos; Frühbeck, Gema; Le Grange, Daniel; Tchanturia, Kate; Karwautz, Andreas; Zeiler, Michael; Imgart, Hartmut; Zanko, Annika; Favaro, Angela; Claes, Laurence; Shekriladze, Ia; Serrano-Troncoso, Eduardo; Cecilia-Costa, Raquel; Rangil, Teresa; Loran-Meler, Maria Eulalia; Soriano-Pacheco, José; Carceller-Sindreu, Mar; Navarrete, Rosa; Lozano, Meritxell; Linares, Raquel; Gudiol, Carlota; Carratala, Jordi; Plana, Maria T.; Graell, Montserrat; González-Parra, David; Gómez-del Barrio, José A.; Sepúlveda, Ana R.; Sánchez-González, Jéssica; Machado, Paulo P. P.; Håkansson, Anders; Túry, Ferenc; Pászthy, Bea; Stein, Daniel; Papezová, Hana; Gricova, Jana; Bax, Brigita; Borisenkov, Mikhail F.; Popov, Sergey V.; Gubin, Denis G.; Petrov, Ivan M.; Isakova, Dilara; Mustafina, Svetlana V.; Kim, Youl-Ri; Nakazato, Michiko; Godart, Nathalie; van Voren, Robert; Ilnytska, Tetiana; Chen, Jue; Rowlands, Katie; Voderholzer, Ulrich; Monteleone, Alessio M.; Treasure, Janet; Jiménez-Murcia, Susana; Fernández-Aranda, Fernando
title: Impact of COVID-19 Lockdown in Eating Disorders: A Multicentre Collaborative International Study
date: 2021-12-27
journal: Nutrients
DOI: 10.3390/nu14010100
sha: 200f9769b8cafac716e787825d5f52bbf386c4c6
doc_id: 916067
cord_uid: 81u0s572

Background. The COVID-19 lockdown has had a significant impact on mental health. Patients with eating disorders (ED) have been particularly vulnerable. Aims. (1) To explore changes in eating-related symptoms and general psychopathology during lockdown in patients with an ED from various European and Asian countries; and (2) to assess differences related to diagnostic ED subtypes, age, and geography. Methods. The sample comprised 829 participants, diagnosed with an ED according to DSM-5 criteria from specialized ED units in Europe and Asia. Participants were assessed using the COVID-19 Isolation Scale (CIES). Results. Patients with binge eating disorder (BED) experienced the highest impact on weight and ED symptoms in comparison with other ED subtypes during lockdown, whereas individuals with other specified feeding and eating disorders (OFSED) had greater deterioration in general psychological functioning than subjects with other ED subtypes. Finally, Asian and younger individuals appeared to be more resilient. Conclusions. The psychopathological changes in ED patients during the COVID-19 lockdown varied by cultural context and individual variation in age and ED diagnosis. Clinical services may need to target preventive measures and adapt therapeutic approaches for the most vulnerable patients.

The COVID-19 pandemic has been a challenge for governments and health care professionals. The lockdown has been a worldwide response to control the spread of the disease. Although the measures taken have been effective in reducing the transmission of the infection, health professionals have expressed concerns about the mental health consequences that can result from social isolation and restrictions to daily life [1] [2] [3] .

The psychological impact of lockdown in history and in the current context has been considered [4] . Higher levels of negative emotions such as anxiety, depression, anger, guilt or even posttraumatic stress symptoms have been reported [4, 5] . A more profound impact has been observed in individuals with chronic diseases and mental illness [1, 6, 7] . Patients with eating disorders (ED) have been found to be at risk of adverse psychological consequences in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic [8, 9] .

Several studies have highlighted the emotional distress due to lockdown in patients with an ED, reporting high levels of anxiety, depression, and post-stress traumatic symptoms that may persist after lockdown [10] [11] [12] . Social distancing might obstruct adaptive strategies to deal with psychological distress [3, 9, 13] and maladaptive coping strategies, such as engaging in substance abuse and potentially addictive behaviors (e.g., gaming), may be adopted [14, 15] .

Changes in eating behaviors, exercise and weight/body mass index (BMI) have been detected both in the general population and in patients with an ED [16, 17] . Emotional disturbances secondary to environmental changes and "food insecurity" have been considered as some possible explanatory factors [17] [18] [19] . Reduced social support, low self-direction, childhood trauma, and insecure attachment or difficulties in emotion regulation are vulnerability factors leading to psychological distress in lockdown, which can be associated with disturbed eating patterns [11, [20] [21] [22] [23] .

Increased dietary restriction and physical activity in patients with anorexia nervosa (AN) or higher frequency of binge episodes among patients with bulimia nervosa (BN) and binge eating disorder (BED) have been reported during lockdown [10, 11, 21, 24, 25] . However, there are few studies focusing on the evolution of ED symptoms after lockdown and these have yielded mixed results [10, 11] . A differential impact on eating and general psychopathology has been assessed in patients with an ED when compared with the general population [11, 16] . This may vary with the ED subtype [26] . Moreover, age may be a possible factor to consider when evaluating clinical changes in the context of lockdown. In this line, younger age [1, 7] , together with cultural and socio-demographic factors may modulate them [27, 28] .

In order to assess the global effect of lockdown due to the COVID-19 pandemic in patients with a current diagnosis of ED, an international group of clinical and research experts developed the COVID Isolation Eating Scale (CIES), which has been translated in nineteen languages [26] . The study by Fernandez-Aranda, Munguía et al. [26] provided evidence of the psychometric robustness of the Spanish version of the CIES, with an adequate goodness-of-fit for the confirmatory factor analysis and good to excellent Cronbach alpha values. Preliminary data suggested that the effects of lockdown differed between ED subtypes, whereby patients with other specified feeding and eating disorders (OSFED) reported the highest global impairment [26] .

To the best of our knowledge, this is the first observational study to analyze clinical changes in patients with ED longitudinally during lockdown, from a multicenter and international perspective. Both child/adolescent and adult populations were assessed using the CIES. The aims of the present study were: (1) to explore eating symptoms and behavioral changes, as well as other psychopathological features in the context of lockdown, and (2) to examine whether ED subtypes, age and geography moderated this effect.

The sample comprised N = 829 participants, from European (Spain, n = 300; Austria, n = 43; Germany, n = 103; Russia, n = 119; Portugal, n = 28; Lithuania, n = 23; Czech Republic, n = 50; Ukraine, n = 10) and Asian (China, n = 92; Korea, n = 50; Japan, n = 11) private and public ED units. Participants were diagnosed according to DSM-5 criteria [29] by expert clinical psychologists and psychiatrists using a semi-structured clinical interview (SCID-5) [30] .

The COVID Isolation Eating Scale (CIES) [26] is a self-report questionnaire that assesses the impact of lockdown on patients with ED and/or obesity and has been translated in 19 languages [26] . Supplementary Material contains the English version of the scale. It is composed of 4 subscales:

Circumstances of the lockdown (eight items). II. Effects of the lockdown on eating symptoms (thirteen items): it evaluates symptomatology of AN, BN, BED and OSFED, according with the DSM-5. Comorbidity with other psychiatric disorders or diabetes is assessed. III. Reaction to the lockdown (34 items): it evaluates the effects of the confinement on eating behaviors, attitudes and habits, anxious-depressive symptoms, emotion dysregulation, and other symptomatology associated with substance use disorders and behavioral addictions. IV. The evaluation of remote interventions (thirteen items) assesses acceptance, general satisfaction, and motivation for virtual interventions.

The last three subscales are answered in a five-point Likert scale. Sections 2 and 3 consider two moments of time, before confinement and the current moment of time.

According to the factorial analysis [26] , five factors were identified. Factor 1 was defined by the items measuring eating related symptoms; Factor 2 by the items measuring the effects of lockdown on the eating-related style; Factor 3 by the items assessing anxiety and depressive symptoms; Factor 4 was defined by the items related to emotion regulation; and Factor 5 by those that evaluate telemedicine.

Only the subscales I, II and III (that correspond to the factor 1, 2, 3 and 4) were used in this study. Therefore, no results referring to the acceptance of virtual are reported (subscale 4, factor 5).

Socio-demographic and clinical information (i.e., age, ED subtype, and variables related to COVID-19 and lockdown) were also obtained through the CIES questionnaire.

All the participants were already involved in outpatient ED treatment in specialized units of the different countries. The subjects were asked by therapists from each center to voluntarily complete the study questionnaire (i.e., CIES), translated into participants' languages [26] . Data collection took place retrospectively between August 2020 and January 2021.

The study was approved by the Clinical Research Ethics Committee of the leading University Hospital (Bellvitge University Hospital) (PR239/20), and informed written consent was obtained from all participants.

Statistical analysis was performed with Stata17 for Windows [31] . The assessment of the pre-post changes in the quantitative measures was carried out through repeated measures analysis of variance (repeated-ANOVA), while the McNemar test was used for paired nominal data.

Additionally, the differences post-pre values were generated for the scores registered in the CIES, and for the weight (kg) and the BMI (kg/m 2 ) (values equal to zero in these new variables indicate absence of change; negative values indicate a decreasing pre-post change; and positive values indicate an increasing pre-post change). Next, ANOVA procedures compared the mean differences between the diagnostic subtypes, the groups of age, and the continent.

In this study, the statistical analyses were adjusted by the sociodemographic sex and age, due to the differences between the groups (defined by the diagnostic subtypes and the origin of the samples).The effect size was estimated with Cohen's-h coefficient for the differences between the proportions and with Cohen's-d for the differences between the means (null effect size was considered for |h| < 0.20 or |d| < 0.20, low-poor for |h| > 0.20 or |d| > 0.20, moderate-medium for |h| > 0.50 or |d| > 0.50 and large-high for |h| > 0.80 or |d| > 0.80) [32, 33] . Finner's method controlled the increase in the Type-I error due the use of multiple significance tests [34] .

Table S1 (Supplementary Material) displays sociodemographic and clinical characteristic of the sample during the lockdown, as well as the comparison between the diagnostic types, the age groups, and the different continents. For the total sample, the mean age was 27.9 years old (SD = 12.3). Most participants were women (70.4%), lived with other people during the lockdown (78.9%), did not have to take care of others (73.8%), were not infected with COVID-19 (92.8%), did not know anyone close to them who was infected with COVID-19 (84.8%), were working (53.8%), and reported a minimal financial loss (73.5%). Table 1 contains the changes in the CIES subscales scores between the pre-and postlockdown within each diagnostic subtype. After adjusting by sex and age, patients with AN reported a significant worsening in eating style and alcohol use. Patients with BN had an increase in weight, and a decrease in ED symptoms, but emotion dysregulation and alcohol use were increased. Individuals with BED reported increased weight, an impaired eating style and had an increase in anxiety-depression symptoms. The group with OSFED reported an increase in anxiety-depression symptoms and emotion dysregulation. Table 2 shows the comparison between the diagnostic ED subtypes for post-pre changes (defined as the difference between the measures at the end of the follow-up and the post lockdown versus the pre lockdown). The first line-plot displayed in Figure 1 also contains the mean changes within each measure (mean values close to the horizontal line at value 0 represent absence of pre-post changes). After adjusting by sex and age, compared with other groups, patients with BED were characterized by the highest increase in weight, BMI, and the CIES-F1 ED symptoms. For the CIES-F2 eating style, BED and BN achieved statistically equal changes, which represented a higher decrease compared with AN, and OSFED. For CIES-F3 anxiety-depression and CIES-F4 emotional dysregulation, OSFED registered the highest increase compared with the other diagnostic conditions. Table 3 contains the results of the repeated-ANOVA assessing the changes between the pre-and post-lockdown within each age group (young/adolescents versus adults). These analyses were adjusted by the ED subtype and sex. Among young/adolescents, a significant decrease was observed for the CIES-F2 eating style. Adult patients reported Table 3 contains the results of the repeated-ANOVA assessing the changes between the pre-and post-lockdown within each age group (young/adolescents versus adults). These analyses were adjusted by the ED subtype and sex. Among young/adolescents, a significant decrease was observed for the CIES-F2 eating style. Adult patients reported increased weight, BMI and CIES-F3 anxiety-depression symptoms, decreased CIES-F2 eating style, and the likelihood of alcohol and other illegal drug use. The results of the ANOVA procedures comparing between the age group the differences generated between the values measured at post-and pre-lockdown are shown in Table 4 (ANOVA procedures adjusted by the ED subtype and sex) (see also the second line-plot of Figure 1 ). Statistical differences were achieved by comparing the mean changes in the CIES-F2 eating style and the CIES-F3 anxiety-depression symptoms. Table 5 contains the results of the repeated-ANOVA (adjusted by the ED subtype, sex, and age) assessing the changes between the pre-and post-lockdown in the weight, the BMI and the CIES scores. Separated/stratified analyses have been performed within each continent (Europe and Asia). Among the European patients, a significant increase was observed in weight, BMI and the CIES-F3 anxiety-depression symptoms. Besides, a significant decrease in the CIES-F2 eating style and in the likelihood of alcohol and other illegal drug use was reported. In Asian patients, while an increase in weight and BMI was obtained, a decrease in the CIES-F1 ED symptoms was found. Finally, the results of the ANOVA comparing the differences post-and pre-lockdown between the geographical area are shown in Table 6 (results adjusted by the ED subtype, sex, and age) (see also the third line-plot of Figure 1 ). Statistical differences were achieved comparing the mean changes in the CIES-F1 ED symptoms (higher decrease for Asian patients). 

The aim of this study was to compare the psychopathological effects in the context of lockdown due to the COVID-19 pandemic in patients with ED from different continents (i.e., Europe and Asia). Secondly, we examined if these differences pre/post lockdown varied by ED subtype, age, and continental provenance.

In line with previous studies [26] the findings highlight a differential psychopathological impact during lockdown according to the ED diagnosis. Patients diagnosed with BN and BED reported weight gain after lockdown, the BED group experiencing the greatest weight changes when comparing by ED subtypes. It is possible that a sedentary lifestyle favored by "stay-at-home" measures and mobility restrictions during lockdown [35] may play a pivotal role in these weight changes [36, 37] . Some of the increased eating behaviors related to "food insecurity" or boredom, such as snacking [35] , could also lead to weight gain [16, 17] . In this line, individuals with BED and BN showed a higher impairment in their eating style in comparison with the other ED subtypes. Moreover, previous studies have recognized an increased vulnerability to weight gain in individuals with overweight and obesity [38] , conditions that are usually presented in individuals with BN and BED [39, 40] .

Eating behaviors have been described as maladaptive strategies to cope with emotional distress [13, 18, 22] . However, ED symptoms and emotion dysregulation were reduced in BN, which aligns with other findings [10, 41] . The continued presence of other people at home and maintaining daily routines [4] are two significant socio-demographic features that characterized our sample, and may have allowed patients with BN to reduce binge episodes and purging. Moreover, the observed decrease in other maladaptive behaviors after lockdown (i.e., alcohol consumption) has been previously described in an international non-clinical study [35] .

Individuals with BED reported the highest impact on ED symptoms when comparing ED subtype groups, although no significant changes in ED symptoms pre-and postlockdown were individually reported in this group. A greater illness perception among these patients together with a higher motivation for change [42] , and the weight gain during lockdown, could encourage them to improve their eating style (e.g., non abuse of certain palatable foods).

Changes in eating style have also been described in patients with AN, which may suggest an increased control over food intake during lockdown. Changes in diet habits have been observed both in general and clinical populations during lockdown [16] , the restricting pattern being commonly mentioned [24] . Surprisingly, and in contrast to other studies [12, 43] , they did not report significant modification in weight/BMI, ED symptoms nor other psychological features. Furthermore, a reduction in alcohol use was described in this ED subtype after lockdown.

Regarding OSFED group, both psychopathology and emotion regulation worsened during lockdown. This aligns with previous research which found that individuals with OSFED deteriorated in adverse situations [44, 45] . Not only they did experience a greater psychological impairment than subjects from other ED groups but this impairment also persisted after lockdown [10, 11, 23] .

Overall young/adolescent patients had a significant improvement in eating habits in comparison to older individuals. The adult group reported significant weight/BMI changes and higher psychological impact than the former one. These results differed from those described in the general population in which younger people had a poorer adjustment to lockdown [1, 7] . One possible explanation for our results could be that older age is linked to patients with BED, who in our study reported a greater psychopathological impact than other ED subtypes. Besides, younger people may be supervised and accompanied more frequently by others, constituting a possible protective factor [4] . Furthermore, young people are usually more familiar with the use of social media, which might imply a better adaptation to the online modality, promoting therapeutic adherence and the maintenance of academic/work routines, as well as social contact [4, 13] .

Both European and Asian patients experienced weight gain during lockdown, as has been described in clinical and general populations [36, 37, 46] , without significant differences between groups. In comparison with European patients, participants from Asia reported an improvement of their ED symptoms. These findings were not in line with other studies exploring the impact of lockdown on the Asian population [46] . Individual differences in personality and coping features have been reported between countries [27, 28] which might lead to a differential adjustment to stress such as the COVID-19 pandemic [47] .

The large sample size with international participation using a validated and homogeneous method of evaluation is a strength of this study. Moreover, the analysis related to age and provenance were adjusted for the ED subtype. However, the observational design of the study and the voluntary nature of participation in it could be some of the limitations of the present work. Furthermore, the presence of memory bias due to the retrospective nature of the assessment and the heterogeneity of the sample must be mentioned. Even though initial evidence regarding clinical changes in ED patients during lockdown has been measured by the CIES, future studies should consider involving other ED severity questionnaires.

In this international study of the adjustment of patients with an ED during lockdown, we observed differences that varied according to ED subtype, age, and provenance. Individuals with BED showed higher worsening of eating symptoms and change in weight during lockdown than those from other ED subtypes. The greatest psychological impairment was described in the OSFED group. Finally, young and Asian patients appeared to be more resilient. These findings may enhance preventive and therapeutic approaches in similar future circumstances.

Supplementary Materials: The following supporting information can be downloaded at: https://www. mdpi.com/article/10.3390/nu14010100/s1, Table S1. Descriptive for the age, sex, and the confinement context/ Covid Isolation Eating Scale (CIES)-English version.

Mental health consequences during the initial stage of the 2020 Coronavirus pandemic (COVID-19) in Spain

Immediate Psychological Responses and Associated Factors during the Initial Stage of the 2019 Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19) Epidemic among the General Population in China

The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on eating disorder risk and symptoms

Narrative synthesis of psychological and coping responses towards emerging infectious disease outbreaks in the general population: Practical considerations for the COVID-19 pandemic

The psychological impact of the COVID-19 epidemic on college students in China

Mental Health in the Coronavirus Disease 2019 Emergency-The Italian Response

Idoiaga-Mondragon, N. Stress, Anxiety, and Depression Levels in the Initial Stage of the COVID-19 Outbreak in a Population Sample in the Northern Spain

Eating disorders and obesity (ED&O) in the COVID-19 storm

Exploring the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and UK lockdown on individuals with experience of eating disorders

The psychological impact of COVID-19-related lockdown measures among a sample of Italian patients with eating disorders: A preliminary longitudinal study

The impact of COVID-19 epidemic on eating disorders: A longitudinal observation of pre versus post psychopathological features in a sample of patients with eating disorders and a group of healthy controls

Early impact of COVID-19 on individuals with self-reported eating disorders: A survey of~1000 individuals in the United States and the Netherlands

COVID-19 and implications for eating disorders

Gambling During the COVID-19 Crisis -A Cause for Concern

Problematic online gaming and the COVID-19 pandemic

Eating and exercise behaviors in eating disorders and the general population during the COVID -19 pandemic in Australia: Initial results from the COLLATE project

Food insecurity associated with elevated eating disorder symptoms, impairment, and eating disorder diagnoses in an American University student sample before and during the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic

Eating disorders in the time of COVID-19

Access to evidence-based care for eating disorders during the COVID-19 crisis

COVID -19 and eating disorders during confinement: Analysis of factors associated with resilience and aggravation of symptoms

Impact of COVID-19 lockdown measures on a cohort of eating disorders patients

The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on individuals with eating disorders: The role of emotion regulation and exploration of online treatment experiences

Risk and resilience factors for specific and general psychopathology worsening in people with Eating Disorders during COVID-19 pandemic: A retrospective Italian multicentre study

Eating disorders in times of the COVID-19 pandemic-Results from an online survey of patients with anorexia nervosa

Bulimia nervosa in times of the COVID -19 pandemic-Results from an online survey of former inpatients

Analysis of the impact of confinement in eating disorders and obesity-A collaborative international study

Cultural differences in response styles: The role of dialectical thinking

Culture and self-concept stability: Consistency across and within contexts among Asian Americans and European Americans

Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-5 Disorders

Stata-Corp Stata Statistical Software: Release 17; Statacorp: College Station

Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences

On effect size

On the false discovery rate and expecte type I errors

Effects of COVID-19 Home Confinement on Eating Behaviour and Physical Activity: Results of the ECLB-COVID19 International Online Survey

Leading Factors for Weight Gain during COVID-19 Lockdown in a Spanish Population: A Cross-Sectional Study

COVID-19-Related Home Confinement in Adults: Weight Gain Risks and Opportunities

Effects of exercise during the holiday season on changes in body weight, body composition and blood pressure

A review of binge eating disorder and obesity

Lifetime Obesity in Patients with Eating Disorders: Increasing Prevalence, Clinical and Personality Correlates

The impact of COVID-19 lockdown and of the following "re-opening" period on specific and general psychopathology in people with Eating Disorders: The emergent role of internalizing symptoms

Illness perception in patients with eating disorders: Clinical, personality, and food addiction correlates

Exploring the ways in which COVID-19 and lockdown has affected the lives of adult patients with anorexia nervosa and their carers

Identity statuses in prebariatric patients with obesity: Associations with eating disorder symptoms, psychological complaints, and coping behaviour?

Other Specified Feeding or Eating Disorders (OSFED): Clinical heterogeneity and cognitive-behavioral therapy outcome

Changes in Body Weight, Physical Activity, and Lifestyle During the Semi-lockdown Period After the Outbreak of COVID-19 in China: An Online Survey

COVID-19 and mental health: A review of the existing literature

We thank CERCA Programme/Generalitat de Catalunya for institutional support. This manuscript and research was supported by grants from the Department of Health of the Generalitat de Catalunya by the call Pla estratègic de recerca i innovació en salut (PERIS, SLT006/17/00077), the Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad (PSI201568701R), Fondo de Investigación Sanitario (FIS) (INT19/00046, PI17/01167, PI20/132), CIBERINFEC (CB21/13/00009) and co-funded by FEDER funds /European Regional Development Fund (ERDF), a way to build Europe 

Data Availability Statement: Individuals may inquire with Fernández-Aranda regarding availability of the data as there is ongoing studies using the data. To avoid overlapping research efforts, Fernández-Aranda will consider a request on a case-by-case basis.