key: cord-0887144-0cx1lc4o
authors: Smith, David P.; Francis, Nigel J.
title: Engagement with video content in the blended classroom
date: 2022-04-29
journal: Essays Biochem
DOI: 10.1042/ebc20210055
sha: 60f31b8b6cbf8501bc2fa2af177392bf20ed734f
doc_id: 887144
cord_uid: 0cx1lc4o

Blended learning is becoming the expected norm for core content delivery in many institutions. Pre-recorded videos in the form of screencasts are the primary delivery method, with students being asked to engage with the content in this medium. Usage is only likely to increase into the future as delivery moves away from traditional lectures and seminars. In this perspective, we look at the use of video material as a means of content delivery and how to help students engage with it. Theoretical literature around cognitive loading and active learning, alongside personal experience of delivery, is drawn on to give a framework for creating engaging recordings and learning activities.

perspective, blended learning is set within the context of the bioscience as an approach by which complex threshold concepts are delivered through digital videos distributed through a virtual learning environment. Well-designed videos both support and supplement learning, bridging the digital and physical spaces and challenging the dominance of text-based materials [11] . They act as a precursor to active learning within the classroom [12] or laboratory environment [13] [14] [15] , as an additional means of consolidating prior learning [16] , a supplement to taught material [17] , and a means of personalising assessment and feedback [18, 19] . A recent study by Mustafa et al. (2021) , investigating the use of videos to teach anatomical dissections, highlighted students favour a blended approach and would not want videos to replace face-to-face instruction [20] . The potential of blended learning as a flexible, accessible, and digitally enabled model has created a wave of activity amongst higher education institutions (HEIs), resulting in a broad range of practices.

The use of videos as a learning tool does have a sound theoretical basis. In 1969, Paivio presented his dual coding theory, proposing that our brains have distinct but linked regions for processing visual and auditory information [21] . Dual coding suggests that the maximal cognitive learning benefits occur when complementary information is presented simultaneously to both systems, as occurs in well-designed videos and teaching sessions [21, 22] . As well as potentially helping students learn the material more efficiently, video lectures offer additional benefits to students, which centre around control over their learning. The ability to pause and rewind videos, unlike live sessions, allows students to manage their cognitive load, specifically the intrinsic load of the task [23] , which is defined as the load placed on the working memory inherent to the task itself [24] . There are several alternative benefits to the use of videos as the primary means of core content delivery; commuter students, those with part-time work or caring responsibilities unable to attend a live session, can still be part of the learning experience. The ability to work at one's own pace and review material later helps develop self-directed learning strategies. Well-structured videos also allow for a reduction in extraneous load [25] , which is where the working memory becomes 'distracted' by content that is not inherent to the learning outcome [24] . Through editing, academic staff can limit these extraneous details that could otherwise overload the working memory capacity and reduce the ability of the students to remember new material [24] . Brame (2016) provides an in-depth look at effective ways of managing cognitive load and maximising video effectiveness as an instructional tool [26] .

Although the material can be presented in any format, it is commonplace for the core content to be in the form of a video and in many institutions, these have taken the place of large group teaching lectures. There are areas of caution, however, as distant learning environments have been linked to waning subject interest and motivation among students due to feelings of isolation online [27] . Traditional video lectures can be a very linear learning experience, and many students will not be actively engaged whilst watching a video recording, with the level of student learning being proportional to the degree of interactivity in the resource [28] . Interactivity is more easily facilitated in environments where students can work together in small groups, but asynchronous videos are different. To gain engagement, students must want to watch the videos; linking to their course and the application of the core content is critical. In our experience of using videos in teaching:

• Audio is key: The first thing students will notice about your screencast video is not the video itself but how clear the audio is. Investing in a good quality microphone will ensure your audio is not muffled or unclear. • Planning: Creating an outline for your video, especially for instructional material, enables you to organise your thoughts and design a 'roadmap' for your screencast. Students will quickly lose interest if the content jumps back and forth between thoughts. • Open your screencast by specifying the learning objectives, then deliver your content and give a summary. Recap your key points and tell your viewers what they have learned. • Video length: Duration is negatively correlated with engagement. There is a reason TikTok is addictive [29] . The optimum length has been quoted at approximately 10-20 min for educational material [25, 30] . If you have a lot of content, consider breaking it up into separate, more focused segments (but do be aware of the total run time).

Five 10-min videos are often more effective than one 50-min video [25] . This chunking also has the advantage that when the time comes to replace or re-record the video, it can be done in sections. • Production: There is no need for a video to be highly produced. Students currently do not expect Hollywood levels of production. Evidence in the literature suggests that the rougher nature of screencasts can make them feel like a one-on-one tutorial, increasing connection with the student [25] . Eight common styles of video have been identified as frequently used in HE -see Choe et al. (2019) for a more in-depth discussion about the pros and cons of each and their impact on learner outcome [31] . • Accessibility: It is crucial to consider accessibility and provide captions or transcripts so you can support students who might struggle with accessing videos; indeed, this is a legal requirement for HEIs in the United Kingdom under the Public Sector Bodies (Websites and Mobile Applications) Accessibility Regulations 2018. Alongside the screencast, PowerPoint slides or notes that replicate the information can also be provided, presenting the material in a range of formats. Be considerate of the amount of text on the screen; many students engage via mobile devices where text-heavy slides cannot be easily read.

The act of watching a video is a passive experience [28] , and watching does not mean learning has occurred, in the same manner, that passively listening to lectures does not mean one understands the content. Engagement can come through active learning, which is an instructional strategy that encourages students to participate in the learning process rather than passively receiving instruction [5, 32, 33] and can be as simple as embedding concept checking questions in the video to encourage cognitive activity [26, 34] . Active learning is student-centred and requires individuals to take ownership of their own learning experiences [35] , with numerous studies demonstrating the benefits [36] . These range from reduced failure rates [37] , grade improvement [38] , and increased knowledge retention [39] .

In relation to video delivery, several strategies have been employed to increase engagement [40] .

• Release in stages: Releasing all the content at once to students can be overwhelming. An alternative strategy is to release content on a week-by-week basis with clear instructions on what to do at each stage with links to supporting materials. • Workbooks: In the traditional lecture, active learning components would have been added in, such as quizzes to test understanding and tasks or activities to consolidate learning [17, [41] [42] [43] . Physical or digital workbooks can be produced that give the students tasks to do while watching the videos that are centred on the key learning points. Here short, chunked videos can be utilised with each page or section of a workbook being linked to a video. Software such as Panopto or Google forms allows self-marking questions to be embedded, giving instant student feedback and the tutor the option of monitoring engagement and understanding [44] . • Assessment-linked consolidation tasks: A consolidation task takes the learning of the videos and asks the students to engage with it through analysis, evaluation and creativity. Like it or not, assessment can be a significant driver for engagement. Consolidation tasks that prepare the students for later assessment give a reason to engage in the material. These tasks can be problem-based, analysis of information/data or simply a direction to the key learning points to consolidate and apply. • Asynchronous support: With students accessing videos at a time of their choosing, tutor support can become asynchronous and having clear lines of communication with the tutor is key. This can be achieved via discussion boards, tools like Padlet, e-mail communications and ad-hoc drop-in sessions.

Given core knowledge is held and delivered in the digital realm, in-class time can be dedicated to exploring topics in greater depth and creating meaningful learning [5, 32, 33] . One of the most well-utilised forms of active learning is flipped learning, in which the traditional view of lecture or seminar learning is inverted [12, 45] . In this model, students are introduced to the learning material, often through video prior to a session, with face-to-face time being used to conduct problem-solving activities designed to deepen understanding through discussion and application [1, [45] [46] [47] and has been shown to increase critical thinking skills [48] . Many students have reported to the authors, however, that the volume of material to be watched prior to a session(s) can be overwhelming due to cognitive overloading, and care should be taken to manage this cognitive load [23] . These personal observations are echoed in the literature, with students reporting that they would rather not attend than arrive having not engaged or do not find videos an effective way to learn [49] . Nevertheless, flipped learning is an effective tool, and a recent study by Fakhoury et al. (2021) demonstrated that students seem to prefer the flipped approach to learning [50] . As an alternative in-class time can be spent on the core learning points with the video material to be watched later, adding depth and breadth.

In-class activities are then open to the full range of active learning methods [33] . Peer interaction and individual attention here is key; the aim of these sessions is not to repeat the learning in the videos, instead allow the knowledge to be introduced, used, or applied and to build social interactions between students.

Effective active learning tasks are linked to the real-world application of the material and, if needed, to the summative assessment tasks. Consolidation activities from the workbooks perform well here as a focus to explore and apply learning. Student response systems allow the tutor to probe the level of knowledge, revealing any misunderstandings which can then be addressed in real-time [42, 51, 52] . Collaborative working through shared documents gives a focus to the session and can also be used in the hybrid environment with remote and physically located students working together [53] . The tutor conducts sense checking of this work to correct any misconceptions. One clear benefit of online live delivery is the use of the chat function, with back-channel conversations increasing popular during physical and digital delivery. What is key is for students is the option to use text response systems in class as a means of asking questions either openly or anonymously [54] .

Blended learning and the use of recorded material can equally be expanded to the practical delivery of the laboratory experience [13] [14] [15] . Many of the lessons learned around effective engagement in taught sessions hold true for the practical experience. In the same way that recorded material can be used to prepare students for active learning, videos have been shown to be a highly effective tool to introduce students to key laboratory concepts, including health and safety and the use of equipment. These videos are often used as a means of introducing students to laboratory equipment and their practical use and are embedded into pre-sessional materials [13, 14] . Using tools like EdPuzzle allows for interactivity to be embedded in these resources with real-time feedback to students [55] . Simulations can generate unique datasets allowing the students to problem solve quickly in a consequence-free environment prior to the laboratory session [56] . A wide range of innovations has been shared through the #DryLabsRealScience network and materials made available on the lectureremotly.com website. What is clear is that blended learning models extend to the point of student preparation and support for the laboratory; what cannot be replaced digitally, however, is the psychomotor skills that are developed through the physical act of laboratory work [57] .

The use of video as a primary means of delivering content, explanation or consolidation is now firmly embedded in teaching practices. Although the technology around recording and delivery is likely to improve and adapt with time, the fundamental medium as a means of communication will remain. It is up to us as educators how we use this medium to engage and teach our students.

The authors declare that there are no competing interests associated with the manuscript.

Open access for this article was enabled by the participation of Cardiff University in an all-inclusive Read & Publish agreement with Portland Press and the Biochemical Society under a transformative agreement with JISC.

HEI, higher education institution; HE, higher education.

Adopting a flipped classroom approach for teaching molar calculations to biochemistry and genetics students

The meanings of student engagement: implications for policies and practices

Staff perceptions of student engagement. The Student Engagement Handbook

Relationships between student engagement and academic achievement: a meta-analysis

Student engagement in online learning: what works and why

Radical flexibility and relationality as responses to education in times of crisis

Reshaping education. Part 1: practical thinking in a pandemic

Coronavirus: universities are shifting classes online-but it's not as easy as it sounds. The Conversation 9

Blended learning: the new normal and emerging technologies

Blended Learning in Higher Education: Framework, Principles, and Guidelines

The flipped classroom strategy: what is it and how can it best be used? Distance Learn

Online prelaboratory videos improve student performance in the general chemistry laboratory

Developing pre-laboratory videos for enhancing student preparedness

Professional science education videos improve student performance in nonmajor and intermediate biology laboratory courses

Show and tell: student and instructor perceptions of screencast assessment

Using pre-lecture activities to enhance learner engagement in a large group setting. Active Learn. Higher Educ

The impact of text versus video communication on instructor feedback in blended courses

The use of video technology for providing feedback to students: can it enhance the feedback experience for staff and students?

Teaching Musculoskeletal Module using dissection videos: feedback from medical students

Mental imagery in associative learning and memory

Applying the science of learning: evidence-based principles for the design of multimedia instruction

Cognitive Theory of Multimedia Learning. In The Cambridge handbook of multimedia learning

Cognitive load theory and complex learning: recent developments and future directions

2020) Five ways to increase the effectiveness of instructional video

Effective educational videos: principles and guidelines for maximizing student learning from video content

Learning with invisible others: perceptions of online presence and their relationship to cognitive and affective learning

The ICAP framework: linking cognitive engagement to active learning outcomes

Social media short video-sharing TikTok application and ethics: data privacy and addiction issues. Multidisciplinary Approaches to Ethics in the Digital Era Anonymous

Screencasts: how effective are they and how do students engage with them? Active Learn

Student satisfaction and learning outcomes in asynchronous online lecture videos

Active learning: creating excitement in the classroom

Engaging Ideas: The Professor's Guide to Integrating Writing, Critical Thinking, and Active Learning in the Classroom

Overcoming overconfidence in learning from video-recorded lectures: Implications of interpolated testing for online education

Constructivism, instructional design, and technology: implications for transforming distance learning

Examining the benefits associated with implementing an active learning classroom among undergraduate students

Active learning increases student performance in science, engineering, and mathematics

The implications of a robust curriculum in introductory mechanics

Strategies to address common challenges when teaching in an active learning classroom

Five tips for moving teaching online as COVID-19 takes hold

2021) A sandwich-model experiment with personal response systems on epigenetics: insights into learning gain, student engagement and satisfaction

Incorporating clickers into an enzymology course improves student performance

Animal experimentation in transgenesis: evaluating course design in large classrooms

Evaluating the impact of a quiz question within an educational video

Flipped learning in higher education chemistry: emerging trends and potential directions

Student learning in an accelerated introductory biology course is significantly enhanced by a flipped-learning environment

A partial flip classroom exercise in a large introductory general biology course increases performance at multiple levels

Active learning in flipped life science courses promotes development of critical thinking skills

Student exam performance in flipped classroom sections is similar to that in active learning sections, and satisfaction with the flipped classroom hinges on attitudes toward learning from videos

Flipping a biochemistry class within a medical curriculum: impacts on perception, engagement, and attainment

Assessment of the effects of student response systems on student learning and attitudes over a broad range of biology courses

A systematic review of audience response systems for teaching and learning in higher education: the student experience

Promoting interaction in online distance education: designing, implementing and supporting collaborative learning

Who goes where? The importance of peer groups on attainment and the student use of the lecture theatre teaching space

Using Edpuzzle to improve student experience and performance in the biochemistry laboratory

Perceptions of a program approach to virtual laboratory provision for analytical and bioanalytical sciences

Reimagining laboratory-based immunology education in the time of COVID-19