key: cord-0884340-lptct9uw
authors: Eyimaya, Aslihan Ozturk; Irmak, Aylin Yalçin
title: Relationship between parenting practices and children's screen time during the COVID-19 Pandemic
date: 2020-10-05
journal: J Pediatr Nurs
DOI: 10.1016/j.pedn.2020.10.002
sha: 9503af303e1ffda0437a4d16614b2bb5b9f4b085
doc_id: 884340
cord_uid: lptct9uw

PURPOSE: This study investigates the relationship between parenting practices and children's screen time following the COVID-19 outbreak. DESIGN AND METHODS: The population of the present cross-sectional study was the parents of children studying in three randomly-selected schools in the western, eastern and central regions of Turkey. The study data were collected between May 15 and 31, 2020, using a descriptive questionnaire form and the Parenting Practices Scale applied to 1115 parents of children between 6 and 13 years of age. The data were analyzed using the SPSS 21.0 software package, and with descriptive, correlation and multiple regression analyses. RESULTS: It was noted that 68% of the mothers did not work, and 40.2% of the fathers had shifted to a flexible work arrangement as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. The study revealed that 89.6% of the families had established ground rules related to screen time, and that the screen time of the children of 71.7% of the families had seen an increase, amounting to 6.42 ± 3.07 h/day. Gender, age, household income, mother's employment status, family's rules about screen time, and inconsistent parenting practices were defined as significant predictors in the children's screen time model created for the study. CONCLUSIONS: A vast majority of the participants stated that their children's screen time had increased during the COVID-19 pandemic. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: Screen time should be monitored, the necessary support should be provided to children, and parents should set ground rules for their children's screen times.

. Healthy communication with children and good parenting practices are key factors in the identification of physical and psychological problems in the early period, and in helping children relax during long-term isolation (National Health Commission of the People's Republic of China, 2020) . Good parenting practices in particular gain significance during the lockdown of children in the home (Wang, Zhang, Zhao, Zhang, & Jiang, 2020) . The term "parenting practices" refers to the observable behaviors of parents toward their children that support children in social activities and in reaching certain targets (Baydar et al., 2012; Kahraman et al., 2017) . Negative parenting practices, on the other hand, such as criticism and violence, increase the likelihood of such behavioral problems as dissonance, disobedience and aggression emerging in children (Raya, Ruiz-Olivares, Pino, & Herruzo, 2013; Kahraman et al., 2017) . Mass quarantine at home may serve as an opportunity to improve the interaction between parents and children, to include children in family activities and to develop their selfsufficiency skills. Proper parenting approaches may help strengthen family ties and satisfy children's psychological needs (Perrin, Leslie, & Boat, 2016; Wang, Zhang, Zhao, Zhang, & Jiang, 2020) , however living conditions in the home have been changed suddenly and profoundly by the COVID-19 outbreak, causing such problems as food shortages, suspended work, either paid or unpaid, mandatory lockdown, the need to home educate and an inability to cover expenses (Vessey & Betz, 2020) . Though the more time spent at home during the COVID-19 pandemic means spending more time with family members, it also places a burden on parents' shoulders (Spinelli, Lionetti, Pastore, & Fasolo, 2020) . The present study investigates the screen time of children aged 6-13 years, and the relationship between the parenting practices of families and the screen time of children during the pandemic. Identification of the screen time of and its negative effects on children, i.e. the vulnerable group, will serve as a reference for family-based practices in the event of possible pandemics in the future. The research questions investigated in this study included: During the COVID-19 pandemic,

The present cross-sectional design study focuses on the parents of children attending three different schools studying in grades 1-8, aged between 6 and 13 years. Since all public primary schools in Turkey receive the same amount of funding from the government, no socio-economic categorization was made between the schools. Therefore, the schools located in the western, eastern and central regions of Turkey were listed individually, and the three schools were selected randomly. The selected schools had 305 (western region), 526 (eastern region) and 713 (central region) students, and parent participation rates were 70.49%, 71.04% and 70.12%, respectively. All three schools that participated in the study were state schools.

The data were collected using a descriptive questionnaire form and the Parenting Practices Scale. The descriptive questionnaire form included questions on socio-demographic characteristics, the COVID-19 pandemic and screen time, and was created by the researchers based on a literature review (Hu, Johnson, & Wu, 2018; Kahraman, et al., 2017; King, Koster, & Billieux, 2019; King, Delfabbro, Billieux, & Potenza, 2020) .

The Parenting Practices Scale (PPS), on the other hand, is a 4-point Likert-type scale (never=1, occasionally=2, frequently=3, always=4) involving 52 items and six subdimensions, which was developed by Kahraman et al. (2017) for the assessment of the positive and negative practices of parents toward primary school children (Kahraman, Yilmaz Irmak, & Basokcu, 2017) . The Positive problem-solving sub-dimension assesses the communication style used by parents while talking with their children, and their effective problem-solving methods, which usually involve effective listening, warm and open communication, empathy, and adopting a behavior that meets their level while teaching them certain skills. The Negative problem-solving sub-dimension assesses the ineffective problemsolving methods applied by parents, such as behaving aggressively, in a critical or accusing manner, or making things difficult for others. The Over-reactive sub-dimension includes items to assess the over-reactions of parents, such as physical violence towards children and preventing their autonomy. The items in the Inconsistent sub-dimension assess whether the rules defined for children are applied consistently. The Functional family sub-dimension J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f assesses family members and the continuity of family functions, which include obeying family rules and maintaining a favorable atmosphere among family members. The Interactive sub-dimension involves questions evaluating parent-children activities. The range of possible scores from this scale is 52-208, with higher sub-dimension and total scores indicating better parenting practices. The Cronbach's Alpha value of the scale is 0.91 (Kahraman, Yilmaz Irmak, & Basokcu, 2017) , while the Cronbach's Alpha value of the present study was found to be 0.88.

The online questionnaire was shared with the parents of children aged 6-13 years for a limited period of time between May 15 and 31, 2020, approximately 45 days after the lockdown of children had been announced. The study topic was explained to the school administration and teachers before the collection of data. The teachers of the three schools participating in the study were reached through school administrators. The administrators and teachers were asked to forward our online data collection form to the social communication forums of the parents, and the parents were invited to participate in the study. In cases where the parents had more than one child, they were asked to fill the form for only one of them.

They were also informed that it would take approximately 15 minutes to fill out the form. For the questions on screen time, the parents were asked to ignore the time their children spent on academic studies, including the time spent doing homework and online classes.

A Research Permit was obtained from the Republic of Turkey Ministry of Health, and the Namık Kemal University Faculty of Medicine Non-invasive Clinical Trials Ethics Committee provided ethical committee approval. An Informed Consent form was included as the first page of the online data collection form. The parents filled out the data collection form after reading the consent form and agreeing to participate in the study voluntarily.

The data were analyzed using the SPSS 21.0 (Statistical Package for Social Sciences) package program. Skewness and kurtosis were examined to determine the normality of the data. The numerical variables in the study were expressed as mean, standard deviation, minimum and maximum, while categorical and nominal variables were expressed as J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f frequencies and percentages. Correlations between the predictor variables were analyzed to identify any collinearity problems with the data. A decision was then made on which items to drop from the multiple regression model, based on the level of correlation and theoretical considerations. Multiple regression models were generated for the dependent variable.

Independent sample t-tests (not reported) were used to identify the group creating the difference in significant relationships. In the calculations, the statistical significance level was accepted as 5%. The results were analyzed based on a 95% confidence interval and a p<0.05 significance level. Table 1 presents the findings related to the families' and children's characteristics during the COVID-19 home isolation, based on 1,115 questionnaire forms filled out by the families. As can be understood, 53.4% of the children were female, and the mean age of the sample was 9.03±1.95 (min: 6; max: 13); 43.1% of the families reported an income of 2001-4000 Turkish Liras; 68% of the mothers stated that they did not work, and 40.2% of the fathers said that they had shifted to a flexible working arrangement as a result of the COVID-19 outbreak. Of the families, 89.6% stated that they laid down ground rules for their children's screen time (television, computer, tablet, mobile phone, play station etc.) during the COVID-19 outbreak, while 71.7% said that their children's screen time had increased in this period, reaching a daily average of 6.42±3.07 (min: 0; max: 15) hours. J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f A multiple regression analysis was conducted for children's screen time, as a dependent variable (Table 3) . The model explaining the screen time of children between the ages of 6 and 13 years during home isolation amid the COVID-19 pandemic (R 2 = .132, p = .000) was found to be significant. For the screen time model, the child's gender (being male) (β=.067, p≤ .05), child's age (β=.249, p≤.001), household income (low) (β=-.104, p≤.001), mother's employment status during COVID-19 pandemic (mothers who have shifted to a flexible work arrangement, and those who continue to work at their usual workplaces during the mass COVID-19 quarantine) (β=.101, p≤ .001), house rules regarding screen time (no rule) (β=-.142, p≤ .001) and inconsistent parenting practices (β=-.157, p≤ .001) were significant predictors, explaining 13% of the variance.

Screen time is a significant problem, especially among children who are under longterm mass quarantine. The present study is the first to investigate the relationship between parenting practices and children's screen time during the COVID-19 pandemic. The results of the study can be considered worthy of note, as the sample number is high, and the data were collected in the final days of a long lockdown period, with the aim being to identify the cumulative effect of the lockdown in a clearer manner.

Of the parents, 71.7% stated that their children's screen time had increased during the COVID-19 pandemic, reaching approximately 6.42 hours/day, which is one of the most striking findings of the study. There have been previous studies in literature suggesting that the daily screen time of children had increased with the onset of pandemic, from approximately 3 hours to 6 hours (Parents Together, 2020). Using creative and educational screen media options that are appropriate for the child's age, in a controlled manner and with certain limitations, may be a part of a lifestyle that may even provide some developmental benefits to the child (Barr, Lauricella, Zack, & Calvert, 2010; De Decker et al., 2012; Hill et al., 2016; Hu, Johnson, & Wu, 2018; Sweetser, Johnson, Ozdowska, & Wyeth, 2012) . That The present study identified a correlation between screen time during the COVID-19 pandemic and negative problem solving, family functioning, and over-reactive, inconsistent and interactive parenting practices. A regression model was created to identify the multifactorial effect of the studied independent variables on children's screen time. Within the model, the child's gender (being male), child's age, household income (low), mother's employment status during the COVID-19 pandemic (mothers who have shifted to a flexible working arrangement, and those who continue to work at their usual workplaces during COVID-19 home isolation), house rules about screen time (no rules) and inconsistent parenting practices were defined as significant predictors. In a study by Hu et al. (2018) , a significant relationship was identified between screen time and the child's age, the parents' socio-economic status and presence of rules about screen time, which is consistent with the findings of the present study. The authors suggested that socio-economic status was negatively correlated with the screen time of children (Hu, Johnson, & Wu, 2018) . On the other hand, Bleakley, Jordan, & Hennessy (2013) found a correlation between the child's gender and age, the parents' income and employment status and the child's screen time. In their study, Carson and Janssen (2012) noted a correlation between the child's age and gender, family income and screen time, and argued that the attitude of the parents was positively associated with children's high screen time.

In the present study, the age and gender of the children were significant determinants of screen time. Similar to our study, Lloyd, Lubans, Plotnikoff, Collins, & Morgan (2014) argued that the child's age and gender (male) were significant predictors of screen exposure.

In their study involving 1,218 children between the ages of 6 and 11 years, Fakhouri, Hughes, Brody, Kit, & Ogden, (2013) found that the daily ≤2 hours of screen time was exceeded more by children between 9 and 11 years of age when compared to the 6-8 age group. They noted J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f further that 47.3% of male and 45.7% of female children exceeded the 2-hour screen time limit. Sisson et al. (2009) found in their study that 35% of children aged between 2 and 5 years exceeded the 2-hour screen time limit, with rates of 49% and 56% among the 6-11 and 12-15 age groups, respectively. In their study involving 3,141 children between the ages of 7 and 11 years, Hawi & Rupert (2015) found that the average screen time was 2.43 hours and 2.66 hours per day for girls and boys, respectively. Of the study participants, 61.8% of the girls and 70.0% of the boys exceeded the AAP's screen time recommendation. These results may be attributed to inability of children to control their curiosity for technology as they age.

Furthermore, the fact that boys spend more time on screen than girls may be attributed to society's traditional gender roles.

Screen activities are so absorbing that most children and adolescents lack the insight and discipline to limit their own screen time effectively (American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 2020). When parents stop limiting their children's screen time and setting rules, screen habits rapidly take over the lives of many adolescents, and may even replace significant daily activities (American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 2020). Another variable that has had an effect on screen time during the COVID-19 pandemic is the screen time rules. There have been many studies identifying the setting of house rules as an effective method of reducing screen time among children (Barr-Anderson et al., 2011; Birken et al., 2011; Gingold, Simon, & Schoendorf, 2014; Hawi & Rupert, 2015; Hu, Johnson, & Wu, 2018; Xu, Wen, & Rissel, 2015) . In their study, Hawi and Rupert (2015) found that parents used screen time as a disciplinary tool. A study by Barr-Anderson et al. (2011) involving 431 children with a mean age of 5.8 found a link between the rules set by parents to limit the time spent watching TV and reduced screen times among children. In their study, Birkend et al. (2011) reported that screen time rules decreased the weekend screen time of children by 30 minutes per day. Of the participants of the present study, 89.6% stated that they had set up screen time rules for their children who spent their time at home during the COVID-19 pandemic, while 71.7% said that their children's screen times had increased in this period. In a children's screen time model created in line with this paradox, another significant variable was inconsistent parenting practices, i.e. the inconsistent application of the rules set up for the children. In their study of 4,770 parents with children between the ages of 6 and 11 years, Samaha and Hawi (2017) identified higher daily screen times among the children of parents who used screen media inconsistently to reward, punish and silence their children.

It is important for families to develop balanced and effective approaches towards screen use to support their physical and psychological well-being during the pandemic (King, Delfabbro, Billieux, & Potenza, 2020) . The role of parents has become more important than ever for their children during the COVID-19 pandemic. For many parents, it is hard to keep their children busy at home and to spend quality time with them, and the struggle is even greater for larger low-income families. Most fail to fulfill their responsibilities to both their daily tasks and the supervision of their children throughout the day. In the applied model, low income and mother's employment status were found to be significant predictors of the screen time of children. The children of parents with a higher socio-economic status spend less time on screen than those of parents with a lower socio-economic status (Bleakley, Jordan, & Hennessy, 2013; Carson & Janssen, 2012) . Accordingly, a higher socio-economic status is associated with larger spaces, providing children with greater freedom, while parents with a lower socio-economic status encourage their children to spend more time in closed areas, leading to greater times spent on screen. Socio-economic status may also be associated with the education level of the parents and their choices of screen time.

Long-term social isolation and longer periods spent on screen may lead to an unhealthy lifestyle, with the potential to lead to possible adaptation problems after the COVID-19 pandemic (King, Koster, & Billieux, 2019; King, Delfabbro, Billieux, & Potenza, 2020 

This study involves some significant limitations that are worthy of note. First of all, the recorded children's daily average screen times were as reported by the families. Secondly, studies involving larger sample sizes will be required to define the relationship between screen time and parenting practices. Finally, the findings of the study cannot be generalized for all parents in Turkey.

The present study investigates the relationship between parenting practices and children's screen time during the COVID-19 pandemic. A vast majority of the parents stated that their children's screen time had increased during the COVID-19 pandemic, reaching an average of 6.42±3.07 hours/day. Such predictors as the child's age and gender, socioeconomic status, the mother's employment status, the application of screen time rules and inconsistent parenting practices were defined as being influential on screen time. J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f Table 2 Bivariate correlations between some of the descriptive characteristics of parents and children, and parenting practices and children's screen time (n=1115). 

Infant and early childhood exposure to adult-directed and child-directed television programming: Relations with cognitive skills at age four

Associations of American Indian children's screen-time behavior with parental television behavior, parental perceptions of children's screen time, and mediarelated resources in the home

Environment, socioeconomic dependence and parenthood

Parental factors associated with screen time in pre-school children in primary-care practice: a TARGet Kids! study

The relationship between parents' and children's television viewing

Associations between factors within the home setting and screen time among children aged 0-5 years: a cross-sectional study

Influencing factors of screen time in preschool children: An exploration of parents' perceptions through focus groups in six European countries

Physical activity and screen-time viewing among elementary school-aged children in the United States from

Excess screen time in US children: association with family rules and alternative activities

Impact of e-Discipline on children's screen time

Media and young minds

Screen time relationship of Chinese parents and their children

Behavioral and emotional disorders in children during the COVID-19 epidemic. The journal of Pediatrics

Parenting Practices Scale: Its validity and reliability for parents of school-aged children

Problematic online gaming and the COVID-19 pandemic

Study what makes games addictive

Maternal and paternal parenting practices and their influence on children's adiposity, screen-time, diet and physical activity

Using nature and outdoor activity to improve children's health. Current problems in pediatric and adolescent health care

The internet and children's psychological wellbeing

National Health Commission of the People's Republic of China, Guideline for psychological crisis intervention during

Survey shows parents alarmed as kids' screen time skyrockets during COVID-19 crisis

Parenting as primary prevention

Fostering resilience in children: the essential role of healthcare professionals and families

Parenting style and parenting practices in disabled children and its relationship with academic competence and behaviour problems

Associations between media use and health in US children

Associations between screen media parenting practices and children's screen time in Lebanon

Profiles of sedentary behavior in children and adolescents: the US National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey

Parents and Children Facing the COVID-19 Outbreak in Italy

Active versus passive screen time for young children

Screen-related parenting practices in lowincome Mexican American families

Everything old is new again: COVID-19 and public health

Mitigate the effects of home confinement on children during the COVID-19 outbreak

Online gaming surge: steam breaks concurrent user record amid socail distancing mandates

WHO Director General's opening remarks at the media briefing on COVID-19 -11

Associations of parental influences with physical activity and screen time among young children: a systematic review

We are grateful to all the families who participated at the study.

Dr. Research Assistant, Ankara University, Nursing Faculty, Department of Nursing Adress: Aktaş Mahallesi Plevne Caddesi No:5 PK: 06080 Altındağ / ANKARA /TURKEY Phone Number: +9005066844484 Fax: +9003123197016 e-mail: asliozturk@ankara.edu.tr

 Table 1 Descriptive characteristics of parents and children (n = 1115). What effects has the COVID-19 pandemic had on your J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f