key: cord-0875876-y6mq3wuo
authors: Tanaka, Melissa Lucero; Marentes Ruiz, Carolyn Jennifer; Malhotra, Sanchi; Turner, Lauren; Peralta, Ariana; Lee, Yesun; Jumarang, Jaycee; Perez, Stephanie E.; Navarro, Jocelyn; Dien Bard, Jennifer; Gordon, Aubree; Allen, E. Kaitlynn; Thomas, Paul G.; Pannaraj, Pia S.
title: SARS-CoV-2 Transmission Dynamics in Households With Children, Los Angeles, California
date: 2022-01-05
journal: Front Pediatr
DOI: 10.3389/fped.2021.752993
sha: 64a7a5fe0ced5e587e5d1ab9f926b34cc4331110
doc_id: 875876
cord_uid: y6mq3wuo

Objectives: Studies of household transmission of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2) focused on households with children are limited. We investigated household secondary attack rate (SAR), transmission dynamics, and contributing factors in households with children. Materials and Methods: In this prospective case-ascertained study in Los Angeles County, California, all households members were enrolled if ≥1 member tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 by polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Nasopharyngeal PCRs, serology, and symptom data were obtained over multiple visits. Results: A total of 489 individuals in 105 households were enrolled from June to December 2020. The majority (77.3%) reported a household annual income of <$50,000, and most (92.9%) were of Hispanic/Latinx ethnicity. Children <18 years old accounted for 46.9% index cases, of whom 45.3% were asymptomatic. Household index cases were predominantly children during low community transmission and adults during the high community transmission period (χ(2) = 7.647, p = 0.0036. The mean household SAR was 77.0% (95% CI: 69.4–84.6%). Child and adult index cases both efficiently transmitted SARS-CoV-2 within households [81.9%, (95% CI: 72.1–91.9%) vs. 72.4% (95% CI: 59.8–85.1%), p = 0.23]. Household income and pets were significantly associated with higher SAR in the multivariable analysis of household factors (p = 0.0013 and 0.004, respectively). Conclusions: The SAR in households with children in an urban setting with a large ethnic minority population is much higher than previously described. Children play important roles as index cases. SAR was disproportionately impacted by household income. Vaccination and public health efforts need special focus on children and vulnerable communities to help mitigate SARS-CoV-2 spread.

Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2) has continued to spread rapidly worldwide, leading to over 4.2 million deaths globally (1) . Although travel and work exposure dominated initial SARS-CoV-2 spread, household exposure quickly became the principal source of transmission (2, 3) . Households are high-risk settings for the spread of SARS-CoV-2 via respiratory droplets, aerosols, and fomites due to sustained close contact in enclosed indoor settings (4, 5) . Published studies show a household attack rate of 47% and a secondary attack rate (SAR) ranging from 6 to 53 percent among household contacts (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) , with a mean SAR of 16.6% on a meta-analysis of 44 studies by Madewell et al. (5) . Previous studies suggest that children under 18 years old are unlikely to be index cases and result in a lower attack rate, that secondary attack rates are higher in adults than children, and that asymptomatic index cases have a limited role in household transmission (5, (15) (16) (17) (18) . The number of Coronavirus disease 2019 cases in children, however, has been on the rise since summer 2020, paralleling trends among adults (19) .

Many household studies are limited by evaluation of only a few members of the household, focusing primarily on adults in the household, using a cross-sectional or retrospective approach, studying a short period of time, or lacking serologic data. Here we describe a prospective, case-ascertained study of household SARS-CoV-2 transmission in Los Angeles, California. This is the largest household study in North America to our knowledge, the first to report findings over multiple phases of the pandemic, and one of few studies to focus primarily on households with children in an urban setting. Los Angeles County has been a hot spot of disease burden during this pandemic, with the highest COVID-19 positivity rate and the most daily new cases per 100,000 residents nationwide for most of the winter. Understanding transmission and characteristics of urban households, especially among ethnic minority populations disproportionately affected by COVID-19, will help in the development of COVID-19 prevention and mitigation measures.

Households in Los Angeles County, California were prospectively enrolled into the Household Exposure and Respiratory Virus Transmission and Immunity Study (HEARTS) if at least one household member tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 within 2 weeks prior to enrollment and at least two members living in the household agreed to participate. We recruited households of patients who tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 at Children's Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA) using a convenience recruitment strategy. These individuals had presented for testing due to COVID-19 symptoms, known exposure, or in preparation for a routine procedure or hospital admission. Recruitment fliers were also posted at CHLA and at community testing sites near the hospital. We defined a household as all people who occupy a housing unit; the household may include related family members and unrelated individuals (20) .

At enrollment, a designated household representative responded to a questionnaire detailing household information including the number of household members, type of housing, number of bedrooms and bathrooms, pets, smokers, and household income in the last year. In addition, each consented household member answered an individual questionnaire that included demographic information, co-morbidities, and exposure history. Co-morbidities included pre-existing lung, heart, renal, liver, or neurologic disease, diabetes, cancer or other immunosuppression. Participants logged illness symptoms in a daily symptom diary for 28 days. Parents recorded symptoms for their children. COVID-19 associated symptoms were defined as at least one of the following: fever, chills, headache, runny nose, congestion, cough, sore throat, shortness of breath, wheeze, altered smell or taste, muscle aches, or gastrointestinal symptoms. Data was recorded in the Research Electronic Data Capture (REDCap Consortium, Vanderbilt, Tennessee, USA).

Participants presented to our drive-thru respiratory testing center for nasopharyngeal (NP) swabs performed by trained study staff every 3-7 days for up to 4 weeks or until two consecutive negative SARS-CoV-2 real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) results were produced. Blood was collected at the enrollment visit and a convalescent visit after 4 weeks from resolution of the last symptomatic household member. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board at Children's Hospital Los Angeles.

We tested for SARS-Cov-2 using the CDC protocol that was approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for emergency use authorization (EUA) (21) . RT-PCR was performed using primers and probes that targeted the N1, N2, and RnaseP (RNP, internal control) genes (Integrated DNA Technologies, Coralville, IW). A positive result was defined as cycle threshold (CT) value <40 for both N1 and N2. A valid result for SARS-CoV-2 detection was determined by RNP using a cutoff of CT value < 32. An inconclusive result was defined as either N1 or N2 gene detected only with RNP detection.

Serum SARS-CoV-2 receptor binding domain (RBD) and spike IgG antibody was measured using an ELISA, as previously described (22) . A positive cut-off OD 490 value of 0.2 was used for RBD based on the published protocol and the mean of the negative control values plus 3 standard deviations (SD) from 20 blood samples collected between 2017 and 2019. IgG against the spike protein was used to confirm RBD IgG positivity.

The attack rate of individuals per household was defined as the number of COVID-19 positive cases during the testing time period divided by the total number of household members. SAR in each household was defined as the number of new cases divided by the total number of at-risk members after subtracting out the index case. We used the earliest date between symptom onset and first positive RT-PCR result for each individual to determine the order of infection within a household. The index case was defined as the individual with the earliest onset date for symptoms or positive test in the household. If two members had the same earliest date for symptoms or positive test, they were considered co-index cases. If infection order could not be determined (e.g., asymptomatic case determined by acute/convalescent serology) for any household member, that household was excluded from the SAR analyses. ) of the subjects who tested positive reported COVID-19 associated symptoms; 160 (72.7%) tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 after presenting with symptoms, 21 (9.2%) tested positive on the same day of illness onset, and 48 (21.0%) tested positive before developing symptoms. The majority of patients managed their symptoms at home, but two participants required hospitalization for COVID-19, and three participants were hospitalized for unrelated reasons. Fewer children were Individual characteristics of all household participants, 113 index cases, and 214 secondary cases are shown in Table 2 . Hispanic/Latinx ethnicity was associated with a higher individual SAR compared to non-Hispanic/Latinx ethnicity (80.0 vs. 47.4%, p = 0.002). This analysis excluded 18 households with 26 asymptomatic cases detected by positive SARS-CoV-2 serology only for whom infection order could not be determined.

Overall, children under 18 years of age accounted for 53 (46.9%) index cases, of whom 24 (45.3%) were asymptomatic. Children index cases were associated with periods of lower community case rates while adult index cases were associated with periods of high community transmission and rapid incidence rise of COVID-19 cases (p = 0.006, Figure 1 and Supplementary and varying incubation periods (24), we performed additional analyses after reclassifying cases within 1-5 days of the index case as a sensitivity analysis (Supplementary Table 2 ). The SAR remained high above 63%, even with reclassification. In a univariate analysis including all households, income, ethnicity, having multiple index cases, and pets were possible predictors (p ≤ 0.10) of a higher household SAR. In the multivariable analysis, only household income and pets remained significant factors associated with higher household SAR ( Table 3) . The mean attack rate in all households was 83.9 (95% CI: 79.4-88.3%). The number of bedrooms, bathrooms, household income, multiple index cases, and Hispanic/Latinx ethnicity were each associated with a higher attack rate in univariate analyses ( Table 4 ). However, in the multivariable analysis after removing variables with multicollinearity, only the number of bedrooms was found to be a significant predictor of higher attack rates in the household.

This study focused on a high predominance of low-income Hispanic/Latinx households with children in an urban setting, a vulnerable group disproportionately affected by the pandemic in the United States. We report the highest recorded mean attack rate of 83.9% within our households and SAR of 77.0% compared with previous household studies (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) . Only a few studies have found household SAR over 50% (25, 26) . All members tested positive in 60.4% of our households, showing intense clustering of SARS-CoV-2 infections within households during periods of low and high community transmission. The number of bedrooms was a significant factor in predicting the overall household attack rate in the multivariable analysis. Fewer bedrooms likely decreased the ability to properly quarantine within the living space. Indeed, most participants reported daily face-to-face contact with a known COVID-19 positive household member, supporting decreased ability to isolate from other household members. Medical sheltering facilities or temporary housing using hotels and motels may be useful for COVID-19 positive patients for the purpose of isolation to decrease household clusters of infection (27, 28) .

Lower household income was significant in the multivariable analysis to predict a higher household SAR. This is most plausibly a reflection of the combination of challenges faced by households with low socioeconomic status such as decreased access to care, an obligation to work and interact with the community, different housing patterns, neighborhood interactions, and neighborhood childcare which we did not capture in our study. Although presence of pets were also associated with higher household SAR and it seems theoretically possible that pets could briefly carry the virus and spread it throughout the household, most studies to-date do not show evidence of pet-to-human transmission (29, 30) . Hispanic/Latinx ethnicity was associated with higher individual SAR. This may be due to the large Hispanic/Latinx cohort in our study. Ethnic minority populations are currently at the highest risk of infection, hospitalization, and death from COVID-19 (31, 32) . Multiple data sources have shown a disproportionately high case rate amongst the Hispanic/Latinx population, with a death rate 2.3 times higher than the non-Hispanic/Latinx White population (31, 33) . The higher attack rates in these communities reinforces the need for vaccination efforts specifically focused on the lower income and disproportionately affected ethnic minority populations to overcome this large disparity (34, 35) . By following our patients over the pandemic, we found that both adults and children are responsible for bringing SARS-CoV-2 to the household as the index case. A recent populationbased cohort study in Canada also found that younger children were more likely to transmit SARS-CoV-2 infection compared with older children (36) . During the period with lower case numbers in the community (23), we observed that the index cases were most frequently children, despite public school closures.

We did not ask households about adherence to community restrictions or childcare practices during school closure, but it is possible that public health measures were not followed as strictly when children were not in school in our study population (37) . A study in Spain found that children were less likely to be index cases, but higher SAR occurred when children were out of school (25) . Further studies are needed to determine if children will be important drivers of transmission similar to influenza (38) during periods without community restrictions. So far, school reopenings have not been associated with a significant increase in COVID-19 community transmission (39, 40) ; risk must be weighed against the significant benefit of in-person schooling (41) . During the largest peak of COVID-19 cases when community restrictions intensified in Los Angeles, adults 18-54 years of age comprised the highest proportion of index cases. Los Angeles County restriction orders at this time included no inperson dining, decreased capacity for essential and non-essential establishments, and no private or public gathering. Adults in that age group were the most mobile individuals within the household and at the highest risk to acquire SARS-CoV-2 from work or social contacts outside of the family.

Substantial secondary transmission occurred from both child and adult index cases in our households. Other studies have shown a significantly lower SAR when the index case is a child (16, 42) ; fewer studies have found a higher SAR from child index cases compared with adults (42) . Almost a third of our index cases were asymptomatic overall. Of the child index cases, almost half were asymptomatic. Unlike previous studies (5, 11, 42, 43) , we found that asymptomatic index cases were important transmitters of SARS-CoV-2 similarly to symptomatic index cases. Individuals who are asymptomatic or have only mild symptoms generally remain active and are thus in greater contact with others, increasing the possibility of transmission to the household and community (44, 45) .

Strengths of the study include capturing and testing entire households including all children, prospectively and repeatedly performing PCR testing on NP swabs over multiple visits to identify cases, and incorporating serologic data into the analysis to catch asymptomatic individuals who may have missed the PCR positivity window. However, the findings are subject to limitations. The convenience sampling strategy, especially during the pandemic, may cause selection bias. We were unable to determine the infection order in 26 (5.5%) participants who were serologically positive but asymptomatic, which may underestimate the number of asymptomatic index cases. Misclassification of index cases is a challenge for SARS-CoV-2 transmission studies, due to the possibility of different incubation time periods and asymptomatic presentation (24) . We did not perform contact tracing outside of the household to capture the source of infection outside of the household. Only half of the participants returned for convalescent serology; therefore, we may have missed individuals who developed COVID-19 immediately before enrollment or during the follow-up period and missed by the NP swab. We could not definitively differentiate second cases from subsequent cases in the households; all were included in the SAR definition. Almost all patients who were enrolled only had mild illness, and this may underestimate the SAR in households where the index patient was more severely symptomatic. A possibility exists that some of the subsequent household cases were actually acquired outside the household rather than from household transmission, the SAR did not increase during the period of increased community transmission. Viral sequencing was not performed. Cultural practices may play a role in the transmission dynamics for which we did not assess.

Households with children in low income, urban communities have an extremely high household SAR. Strategies to decrease household transmission, particularly in ethnic minority communities and low socioeconomic settings, remains crucial to controlling the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic. It is imperative to increase access to resources to make infection prevention, COVID-19 testing, and following quarantine guidelines possible and less challenging for these populations. Children, both symptomatic and asymptomatic, are important contributors to household spread. Children could be drivers of continued low level community SARS-CoV-2 circulation in vulnerable populations without vaccination. Future vaccination efforts must include special focus on children and ethnic minority populations, including the households with low income who are disproportionately affected.

The raw data supporting the conclusions of this article will be made available by the authors upon request, without undue reservation.

The studies involving human participants were reviewed and approved by Children's Hospital Los Angeles Institutional Review Board. Written informed consent to participate in this study was provided by the participants' legal guardian/next of kin.

PP conceptualized and designed the study, analyzed the data, and reviewed and revised the manuscript. MT and CM collected data, carried out the initial analyses, and drafted the initial manuscript. SM helped carry out the initial analysis and draft the initial manuscript. LT and AP designed the data collection instruments, collected data, and reviewed and revised the manuscript. JN helped design the data collection instruments and reviewed and revised the manuscript. YL, PT, and AG helped design the study and reviewed and revised the manuscript. JJ and SP collected data and reviewed and revised the manuscript. EA and JD reviewed and revised the manuscript. All authors approved the final manuscript as submitted and agree to be accountable for all aspects of the work. 

We wish to thank the dedicated participants who contributed to this study. We would like to thank Florian Krammer and Ali Ellebedy for sharing constructs SARS-CoV-2 antigen and antibody constructs and Janet Smith, Melanie Ohi, Clay Brown, Jennifer Meagher, Brad Carlson, and Rebecca Tutino for providing the antibodies and antigens used in the ELISAs.

The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fped. 2021.752993/full#supplementary-material

World Health Organization. WHO Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19) Dashboard. (2021)

Spread of SARS-CoV-2 in the Icelandic Population

Household transmission of SARS-CoV-2

Scientific Brief: SARS-CoV-2 and Potential Airborne Transmission

Household transmission of SARS-CoV-2: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Household transmission of SARS-CoV-2 in the United States

Household secondary attack rate of COVID-19 and associated determinants in Guangzhou, China: a retrospective cohort study

Susceptibility to SARS-CoV-2 infection among children and adolescents compared with adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Household transmission of SARS-CoV-2

Transmission of SARS-COV-2 infections in households -Tennessee and Wisconsin

The household secondary attack rate of SARS-CoV-2: a rapid review

Attack rates amongst household members of outpatients with confirmed COVID-19 in

Secondary household transmission of SARS

SARS-CoV-2 seroprevalence and transmission risk factors among high-risk close contacts: a retrospective cohort study

Role of children in household transmission of COVID-19

COVID-19 in children and the dynamics of infection in families

The role of children in the transmission of SARS-CoV2: updated rapid review

SARS-CoV-2 infection dynamics in children and household contacts in a slum in Rio de Janeiro

Sauber-Schatz EK. COVID-19 trends among persons aged 0-24 years -United States

Available online at

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. CDC 2019-Novel Coronavirus (2019-nCoV) Real-Time RT-PCR Diagnostic Panel

SARS-CoV-2 seroconversion in humans: a detailed protocol for a serological assay, antigen production, and test setup

Los Angeles County Department of Public Health. LA County COVID-19 Surveillance Dashboard

How to detect and reduce potential sources of biases in studies of SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19

Household severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 transmission and children: a network prospective study

Seroprevalence of anti-SARS-CoV-2 IgG antibodies in children with household exposure to adults with COVID-19: preliminary findings

Fangcang shelter hospitals: a novel concept for responding to public health emergencies

The Interferon-induced transmembrane protein 3 gene (IFITM3) rs12252 C variant is associated with COVID-19

Do dogs and cats passively carry SARS-CoV-2 on hair and pads? Viruses

Current state of knowledge about role of pets in zoonotic transmission of SARS-CoV-2

Racial and ethnic health disparities related to COVID-19

COVID-19 pandemic, unemployment, and civil unrest: underlying deep racial and socioeconomic divides

Risk for COVID-19 Infection, Hospitalization, and Death By Race/Ethnicity

Demographic characteristics of persons vaccinated during the first month of the COVID-19 vaccination program -United States

The advisory committee on immunization practices' ethical principles for allocating initial supplies of COVID-19 vaccine -United States

Association of age and pediatric household transmission of SARS-CoV-2 infection

Young people's views on their role in the COVID-19 pandemic and society's recovery from it

Fine-scale family structure shapes influenza transmission risk in households: Insights from primary schools in Matsumoto city

Comparison of COVID-19 incidence rates before and after school reopening in Israel

COVID-19 cases and transmission in 17 K-12 Schools -Wood County

Schools closures during the COVID-19 pandemic: a catastrophic global situation

A meta-analysis on the role of children in SARS-CoV-2 in household transmission clusters

Household transmission of SARS-CoV-2 and risk factors for susceptibility and infectivity in Wuhan: a retrospective observational study

Viral shedding and transmission potential of asymptomatic and paucisymptomatic influenza virus infections in the community

SARS-CoV-2 transmission from people without COVID-19 symptoms

Seqirus and also receives research funding from AstraZeneca and Pfizer for unrelated studies. AG has received consultant fees from Janssen.The remaining authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.Publisher's Note: All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Tanaka, Marentes Ruiz, Malhotra, Turner, Peralta, Lee, Jumarang, Perez, Navarro, Dien Bard, Gordon, Allen, Thomas and Pannaraj. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.