key: cord-0872007-9ji9u4tr authors: Gao, Xudong; Li, Haiyan; He, Wenjie; Zeng, Wen title: COVID-19 Vaccine Hesitancy Among Medical Students: The Next COVID-19 Challenge in Wuhan, China date: 2021-09-09 journal: Disaster medicine and public health preparedness DOI: 10.1017/dmp.2021.291 sha: 446d4d3c8355ebbbb08c17d62bfea2e5c0f5a7a3 doc_id: 872007 cord_uid: 9ji9u4tr OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to explore the level of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) vaccine hesitancy among medical students in Wuhan, China, and to identify the factors and barriers associated with their vaccination decision. METHODS: A cross-sectional survey was launched with 612 medical students recruited by convenience sampling from 6 universities. Data collection measures mainly included a demographic questionnaire, COVID-19 vaccine knowledge questionnaire, and the vaccine hesitancy scale. RESULTS: A total of 58.2% of medical students reported vaccine hesitancy. The most common reasons for this were worrying about the side effects of vaccines (44.4%), uncertainty about vaccine safety (40.4%), and underestimating the risk of exposure to COVID-19 (27.9%). The main factors associated with COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among participants were their knowledge about COVID-19 vaccine, training related to COVID-19 vaccines, family address, and education level (P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: The government, health department and universities in China need to work together and actively communicate with vaccine-hesitant students, establish a standardized COVID-19 vaccine course, and provide on-campus vaccination services. have been no studies of COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among medical students in China, therefore, our study aimed to fill this gap by exploring the level of COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among Chinese medical students and identifying the factors and barriers associated with decision to vaccinate. We conducted a cross-sectional survey using an online questionnaire. Medical students from 6 universities in Wuhan were selected to participate through convenience sampling. We chose a teacher from each university as a liaison for our study. Questionnaires were distributed to students' cell phones through the liaisons. Prior to the study, the liaisons provided them with an electronic informed consent form. All students received information about the study purpose, and they were told that participation was voluntary and anonymous. This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board at [blinded for review]. Inclusion criteria were participants who, (a) were medical undergraduates or postgraduates in Wuhan, (b) were eligible for COVID-19 vaccines, and (c) had volunteered to participate in this study. Exclusion criteria were participants who, (a) were infected with COVID-19, (b) were pregnant or breastfeeding women, and (c) were diagnosed with diseases that prevented them from receiving the COVID-19 vaccines. In total, 711 medical students completed our questionnaire from February to March 2021. The government of Wuhan has been providing COVID-19 vaccines for college students since April 2021. Thus, none of the participants in this study have received COVID-19 vaccines. In total, 99 incomplete questionnaires were excluded, and finally 612 questionnaires were analyzed. The survey questionnaire contained 3 parts, and it took the students approximately 6 minutes to complete the survey. Medical students' demographic characteristics were collected, these included gender (male, female), nation (non-minority, minority), monthly household income (less than $780, $780 -$1561, more than $1561), family address (in Wuhan, not in Wuhan), education level (undergraduate, postgraduate), training related to COVID-19 vaccines (trained, untrained), college (clinical medicine, nursing, preventive medicine, pharmacy, basic medicine), history of respiratory diseases in the past year (yes, no), history of influenza vaccination (vaccinated, unvaccinated), religious belief (non-religious, religious). Household income in our questionnaire was recorded in Chinese currency (less than 5000 RMB, 5000 -10000 RMB, more than 10000 RMB) and converted to U.S. dollars for reporting purposes. Knowledge about COVID-19 vaccine A self-design, 14-item questionnaire was employed to evaluate the medical students' knowledge about COVID-19 vaccine (e.g., types of vaccines, vaccination eligibility, common side effects, and precautions after vaccination). The questionnaire was developed through a literature review and group discussion. After 2 rounds of expert consultation, the pre-test questionnaire was developed. A total of 126 medical students were pilot tested. The results show that the Cronbach's α coefficient was 0.743. The content validity index was 0.961, and the reliability index was 0.788. When a question was answered correctly, the student received 1 point while incorrect answers were not scored. The scores on all questions were summed to obtain the total score. Higher total scores indicate a Vaccine hesitancy scale Zhang established the Vaccine Hesitancy Scale (VHS) in 2020. 38 Participants were asked to answer 8 questions related to their vaccine hesitancy on a 5-point Likert scale (1 = strongly disagree, 2 = disagree, 3 = neither agree nor disagree, 4 = agree, 5 = strongly agree). The scores on the 8 questions were summed to obtain the total score; higher total scores indicated higher vaccine hesitancy. The Cronbach's α coefficient of the scale was 0.705. The content validity index was 0.830, and the reliability index was 0.696. Furthermore, the reasons hindering COVID-19 vaccination among medical students were also investigated (e.g., side effects of vaccine, vaccine safety, convenience, vaccine efficacy, and underestimating the risk of exposure to COVID-19). We used IBM SPSS Statistics 26.0 (IBM Corp., Armonk, New York) for statistical analysis. The Kolmogorov Smirnov analysis was applied, and the result showed that VHS was normal distribution. 39, 40 Multicollinearity was measured by the variance inflation factor (VIF). After testing, values of VIF were all lower than 10, so there is no multicollinearity. The correlation between COVID-19 vaccine knowledge and VHS was analyzed using Pearson correlation analysis. The comparison of different demographic medical students' COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy was analyzed by univariate analysis. Multiple-factor analysis of VHS was analyzed using multiple regression analysis. The value of P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. The average VHS score among medical students was 22.81 ± 5.91, and the mean score rate was 57.0%. The maximum score of VHS was 36, and the minimum was 12. A total of 58.2% of medical students scored at least 24 points on the VHS. As shown in Figure 1 , only 15% of students agreed that 'COVID-19 vaccines are not important for my health' (Question 1). More than half of the students reported concern regarding the adverse effects of COVID-19 vaccines (Question 2). Moreover, 47.1% of the students agreed with the statement that 'I am uncomfortable getting a vaccine that was rushed into production' (Question 4). About 50% of the students agreed with the statement that 'I do not need vaccines because COVID-19 is no longer widespread locally' (Question 7). For all questions, "neither agree nor disagree" is not the most selected option. The average COVID-19 vaccine knowledge score among medical students was 9.82 ± 2.83, with an average accuracy rate of 70.1%. The maximum score of COVID-19 vaccine knowledge was 14, and the minimum was 6. The COVID-19 vaccine knowledge score was negatively correlated with VHS score (P < 0.01). As shown in Table 1 , medical students' primary sources of knowledge about COVID-19 vaccine were the Internet (67.3%), campus publicity (36.4%), and medical staff (29.7%). Medical students' demographic characteristics associated with COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy As shown in Table 2 , COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among medical students in Wuhan were significantly associated with their family address, education level, training related to COVID-19 vaccines, and history of influenza vaccination (P < 0.05). Multiple-factor analysis of COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among medical students As shown in Table 3 , the main factors associated with medical students' COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy were their knowledge about COVID-19 vaccine, training related to COVID-19 vaccines, family address, and education level. Therefore, the negative factors were lack of knowledge about COVID-19 vaccine, lack of related training, not living in Wuhan, and lower education level. As shown in Table 4 , the most common reasons hindering COVID-19 vaccination among medical students in Wuhan were worrying about the side effects of vaccines (44.4%), uncertainty about the safety of vaccines (40.4%), and underestimating the risk of exposure to COVID-19 (27.9%). Vaccination is an effective way to prevent and control COVID-19. However, there are still many people in some countries who continue to refuse or delay vaccination. 24 Medical students are often ignored in the promotion of COVID-19 vaccines, hence to the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to investigate COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among medical students in China. Typically, a VHS score of 24 or higher indicates vaccine hesitancy. 38 In our survey, 58.2% of the medical students scored at least 24 points on the VHS, indicating that a large proportion of Chinese medical students are hesitant to receive COVID-19 vaccines. We inferred 4 reasons that may explain this phenomenon. First, it is possible that some medical students underestimated the risk of the COVID-19 pandemic. Since January 2020, China has adopted a series of effective prevention and control measures and successfully controlled the spread of the epidemic. 41 Apart from some imported cases of COVID-19, there have been very few domestic infections in China since May 2020. 26 Furthermore, to protect the safety of students, almost all universities in Wuhan implemented closed management, whereby outsiders were prohibited from entering campuses without special permission. Therefore, many medical students believed that their probability of being infected with COVID-19 was very low. Second, several vaccine incidents might affect medical students' trust in Chinese vaccines. In recent 42, 43 In the DPT vaccine incident that occurred in 2017, the Wuhan Institute of Biological Products did not follow the production regulation and produced a batch of invalid DPT vaccines. These invalid vaccines were administered to approximately 144000 people. The Wuhan Institute of Biological Products is also 1 of the 3 leading manufacturers of COVID-19 vaccines in China. 44 As medical students are usually familiar with these vaccine incidents. It is likely that this negative information influenced their unwillingness to be vaccinated. Third, vaccination is not convenient for most medical students. In China, most vaccination services are provided by community health centers. 45 However, community health centers are mainly located in urban areas, while most universities in Wuhan are in suburb areas, which have fewer community health centers. Consequently, access to vaccines was not very convenient for many medical students. Finally, 1 year after the COVID-19 outbreak, China's research institutions and enterprises have been developing and producing COVID-19 vaccines on a large scale. 44 Unlike the typical duration for producing traditional vaccines, COVID-19 vaccines were developed in the shortest period. Therefore, many medical students were worried about the safety, side effects, and effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines. Although medical students understood the importance of being vaccinated, some students planned to wait for a while to observe the effectiveness of the vaccines on others. Our study demonstrated that the main factors associated with medical students' COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy were their knowledge about 46 Since the target group of this survey was medical students, we expected that they would have better knowledge of vaccines. However, participants' average accuracy of COVID-19 vaccine knowledge in this study was merely 70.1%, indicating that knowledge about COVID-19 vaccine is not provided in the current medical curriculum. Second, we found that medical students who had received relevant training were more willing to receive COVID-19 vaccines. Previous studies have also demonstrated that relevant training can improve students' adherence, attitude, and knowledge about vaccinations. [47] [48] [49] Nevertheless, in our survey, only 32.2% of the students had received relevant training. Training related to COVID-19 vaccines should be offered to medical students as soon as possible. Third, medical students who lived in Wuhan were more willing to receive COVID-19 vaccines compared to those who were not living in Wuhan. This is likely because Wuhan residents experienced the rapid spread of COVID-19 in the first quarter of 2020. Thus, their awareness of epidemic prevention was generally high. Finally, we found that undergraduate students were more likely than postgraduate students to hesitate about vaccination. This may be because postgraduates have more medical knowledge than undergraduates, so they understand the importance of COVID-19 vaccines better. Moreover, according to the graduation requirements of universities in China, medical postgraduates are generally required to complete 1 year or more in professional practice in hospitals, center for disease control and prevention, or other medical institutions. Postgraduates know that they are at a higher risk of exposure to COVID-19 and are, thus, more likely to receive the vaccine. This study has several limitations. First, considering the limited number of universities that participated in this study, our sample was relatively small. Thus, our findings must be further verified using a larger sample size. Second, the VHS uses standardized questions and a Likert scoring format, which make it easy to analyze data. However, it masks the heterogeneity of the students. Future study should employ other methods, such as interviews, that can explore potential motivations in greater depth. Third, as a cross-sectional survey, our study only evaluated the status of COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy at a specific time point without conducting a follow-up observation of the medical students. Finally, in addition to the factors included in this study, there may also be other factors associated with medical students' COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy. Considering these findings, we suggest the following to improve medical students' intention to vaccinate. First, prior to conducting vaccine training or awareness campaigns, health department should conduct surveys on students' intention to vaccinate against the COVID-19. Universities should actively communicate with vaccine-hesitant students, and identify the reasons hindering their intent to vaccinate, based on which targeted measures should be taken. Second, given that the COVID-19 pandemic will last for a long time, medical students' hesitation about vaccines may also continue. Thus, universities should establish and promote a standardized COVID-19 vaccine course. This course can also be disseminated via TikTok, Twitter, and online public classes. Third, governments should supply on-campus vaccination services to improve students' accessibility to COVID-19 vaccines. In the past year, there have been very few COVID-19 infections in China, which has resulted in gross underestimation of infection risk among Chinese people. 27 Our study is the first to focus on COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among medical students in China. More than half of the medical students reported COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy, and the main factors associated with vaccine hesitancy were knowledge about COVID-19 vaccine, training related to COVID-19 vaccines, family address, and education level. Once most countries achieve herd immunity and resume trade and tourism, many vaccine-hesitant medical students in China may be exposed to a greater risk for infection. The government, health department, and universities in China need to work together and actively communicate with vaccine-hesitant students, establish a standardized COVID-19 vaccine course, and provide vaccination services on campus. COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy and resistance: Correlates in a nationally representative longitudinal survey of the Australian population Cross-sectional survey to assess health-care workers' grief counseling for bereaved families of covid-19 victims in Wuhan, China Nurses' grief counseling for bereaved family members of covid-19 patients in Wuhan, China: A cross-sectional survey Management of a nursing unit in a temporary covid-19 specialized hospital in Wuhan, China World Health Organization. WHO Coronavirus (COVID-19) Dashboard Research and development of COVID-19 vaccines in China Inequitable COVID-19 vaccine distribution and its effects COVID-19 vaccines and treatments nationalism: Challenges for low-income countries and the attainment of the SDGs COVID-19 vaccines for low-and middle-income countries Vaccine hesitancy in low-and middle-income countries: Potential implications for the COVID-19 response Production capacity of COVID-19 vaccine in China Understanding COVID-19 vaccine demand and hesitancy: A nationwide online survey in China Analysis of China's COVID-19 twitter data Survey on knowledge and attitude of COVID-19 vaccine among residents in East China Real-time big data reporting on COVID-19 Understanding vaccine hesitancy in COVID-19 Willingness to get the COVID-19 vaccine with and without emergency use authorization Intention to receive a COVID-19 vaccine: Results from a population-based survey in Canada Attitudes towards COVID-19 vaccination, vaccine hesitancy and intention to take the vaccine Vaccine hesitancy and anti-vaccination in the time of COVID-19: A Google trends analysis High rates of COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy and its association with conspiracy beliefs: A study in Jordan and Kuwait among other Arab countries. Vaccines (Basel) Measuring vaccine hesitancy: The development of a survey tool Valli165-4175.tancy: The et al. Psychological characteristics associated with COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy and resistance in Ireland and the United Kingdom A global survey of potential acceptance of a COVID-19 vaccine potential acceptance of a COVID-19 vaccine [published Expert Rev Vaccines Prevention and control of COVID-19 epidemic risk at border ports in China A survey on the attitudes towards COVID-19 vaccination and its' sociological and psychological influencing factors Willingness to receive SARS-CoV-2 vaccination and associated factors among Chinese adults: A cross sectional survey Intention to get vaccinations against COVID-19 in French healthcare workers during the first pandemic wave: A cross-sectional survey Editor's Choice: Influenza vaccine uptake, COVID-19 vaccination intention and vaccine hesitancy among nurses: A survey Hesitancy of Arab healthcare workers towards COVID-19 vaccination: A large-scale multinational study. Vaccines (Basel) Medical experimentation and the roots of COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among indigenous peoples in Canada Targeting COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy in minority populations in the US: Implications for herd immunity Vaccines and vitriol: An anthropological commentary on vaccine hesitancy, decision-making and interventionism among religious minorities COVID-19 related medical mistrust, health impacts, and potential vaccine hesitancy among black Americans living with HIV Addressing justified vaccine hesitancy in the black community COVID-19 vaccine intentions and mistrust in a national sample of black Americans Development and application of the vaccine hesitancy scale Application of normal distribution in daily life Common test methods of normal distribution COVID-19 pandemic: Experiences in China and implications for its prevention and treatment worldwide Analysis of public health emergencies based on network public opinion: Taking Changsheng vaccine incident as an example Analysis on the role of information system of illegal vaccine accidents in Shandong province COVID-19 vaccine produced by Wuhan institute of biological products is expected to be available in next year Age-appropriate vaccination coverage and its determinants for the polio containing vaccine 1-3 and measles-containing vaccine doses in Zhejiang province, China: A community-based cross-sectional study The persistence of vaccine hesitancy: COVID-19 vaccination intention in New Zealand Vaccine hesitancy' among university students in Italy during the COVID-19 pandemic Improvement in attitudes toward influenza vaccination in medical students following an integrated curricular intervention Improvement in vaccination knowledge among health students following an integrated extra curricular intervention, an explorative study in the University of Palermo Conflict(s) of interests. The authors declare no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.Ethical standards. Ethical approval was granted from the Institutional Review Board of Wuhan Polytechnic University.